Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

We're Not So Different

We're Not So Different artwork

October Mailbag

Oct 8, 20251 hr 17 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Good evening, good evening, Hello the Vincent Press, and welcome you are, Menagerie of Horror.

Speaker 2I don't know.

Speaker 3I mean it's October, why not?

Speaker 1Woo youoooo.

Speaker 2It's good spooky effeminine Americans who you thought were British your entire life?

Speaker 3I did, I did. I did think he was British for a really long time.

Speaker 4Yeah, you know, but again, we need to bring back the trans Atlantic accent.

Speaker 3That's what it is.

Speaker 4I've got no business with this accent. I should be doing that. That's here for our boys and Blue or whatever. Fucking no ass accent.

Speaker 2That ship was yeah in the in the European theater. Yeah, yeah, you're just announcing newsreels before movies.

Speaker 3I would you know, that would be great. You know I could do that job. That's fine. Bring them back. We must return, specifically, just so I can get a job.

Speaker 2Thanks the old the old war correspondent announcer. Hello, and well yeah, and then they became.

Speaker 3The movie time for the news at eight.

Speaker 2And now they no longer exist. Yeah anyway, Yeah, how's it going.

Speaker 3Yeah, it's all right, it's all right.

Speaker 4I am giving myself untold psychic damage by reading this new Dan Brown book m which just shows the lengths I will go to for this podcast for the good people, if we're not so different.

Speaker 2I like I like the idea. I like that. I appreciate that you tell yourself that you wouldn't have hate read this out of I would not.

Speaker 3I've never read a Dan Brown book. I've never read it down.

Speaker 2You would not, well, I have, unfortunately read, Uh, what was Angels and Demons?

Speaker 3Which is you so that was the only one you read? You didn't read? Oh yeah, that's interesting.

Speaker 2And I only read Angels of Demons because like so many people were talking about it and I read through it at the speed that I read through like a Star Wars novel, which is say, very fast normally, and and I was like, wow, this is.

Speaker 3You can rip through about one hundred pages in like an hour.

Speaker 2Yeah this is not uh, this is not good. But but yeah no I don't. I don't have any more exposure to it. I believe I called it, uh books for stupid people to make them feel like they're smart.

Speaker 4That's exactly what I was about to say. I think that it's it's like everything is so obvious, and you know, it's that it's the fucking Garth MARENGI gift the you know I know who use subtext and they're all cowards, Like.

Speaker 2Wait a minute, is it the Illuminati again, it's the Illuminatis. Yeah, and like, uh.

Speaker 3It's just I swear to you.

Speaker 4In this one whole section is just read like Wikipedia, where it's like where he's like, Prague was home to such notable and I'm just like, shut up.

Speaker 3But it's also like it's wild because they'll be all like, oh.

Speaker 4They're like Prague is mysterious and magical and dark, and I'm just like, fucking could you please stop exoticizing us for five seconds?

Speaker 3And he's like, absolutely not.

Speaker 4And there was like this one paragraph where he's like he goes from like the court of Rudolph the Second, where like Rudolf the Second has this big alchemical.

Speaker 3Thing where he's like he was practicing in secret and I'm like, no, he wasn't.

Speaker 4It was quite in the open, but whatever, and he's like and John Dee visited and it's like uh huh. And then he's like and also Franz Kafka, I'm.

Speaker 2Like, what the fuck, what the fuck, what the fuck.

Speaker 3Are you talking about? Like a three under your gap and.

Speaker 4Then like a guy wrote modern fiction, like what it but we just all look like to him, I don't know, like it's it's cofka.

Speaker 2You know. The one thing I have to say about this is that it's kafka esk.

Speaker 3Yeah, there you go. Oh, I mean, thank you.

Speaker 4I shouldn't go too deeply into it because we needed to save it for the actual app we're going to do. But my lord, like I was like reading it around the house and like like Justin was trying to write and get actual work done, and he's got like his headphones in and I kept just like yelling at the book and he kept like taking it out and being like what And I was like, no, I'm not talking to you.

Speaker 3I'm just angry.

Speaker 4He's like, all right, okay, Well, if you could just like make a hand gesture you actually need me, I'm like, okay, m yeah, sog uh in many.

Speaker 2The last line of the book will be Progue is a city of contrast.

Speaker 4Oh, it's like a hundred percent one hundred percent, Like I mean, like Homeboy just like went on vacation once and I thought you could write about Progue and it's so you know, insulting.

Speaker 2I'll be honest. You know, vacation did once save the city of Kyoto from being nuked.

Speaker 3That is true.

Speaker 2That's true. So yeah, I.

Speaker 4Okay, so like, okay, some vacations are I'm not like, obviously, don't nuke progue if anyone who has a nuclear device and who's listening, don't do that.

Speaker 3But I just I don't know.

Speaker 4I'm like, I just got my backup when everyone is treating us like an unknowable and mysterious people, I guess when we're like pretty fucking noble.

Speaker 1Actually yeah.

Speaker 4And also it's just gonna like this is gonna spark a whole new wave of tourism of like the most insufferable people on earth who think that they are like unearthing mysteries.

Speaker 3But yeah, yeah, I don't.

Speaker 4Know, I've got I'm also just like in a bad mood about progue things because I was like, for other work, reading a book that's ostensibly vaguely academic that came out and the person writing it got a bunch of the medieval stuff just completely wrong because it was like a twentieth century person and she was like, I can do the medieval period, and it's like turns out no, nope, so yeah, I'm just like, I'm having a bad time with books about Prague right now.

Speaker 2I'm sorry.

Speaker 3I uh no one suffered.

Speaker 2That's that's it. It's a rough buddy, put yourself across.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Oh man, uh yeah that Uh I'm sorry to hear that, I really am because uh man, No, there is absolutely no chane of me of me picking that up. Oh god, and uh let's uh let's do some.

Speaker 3Male Yeah, let's do some male. Hell.

Speaker 2Yeah, let's talk about that. We can talk about Dan Brown next week. Yes, and uh whatever, his name is doctor Robert something. I always want to call him Robert muldoon, But that's the name of the game warden in Jurassic Park, which would honestly be a lot funnier now that I think about it, Like that would be more entertaining if you just had this like random Australian guy with like a big wide brim hat and he's chasing down people but he's just tranking like cardinals or whatever. See, that's

Speaker 2way more ten seconds, and it's already more entertaining than now. Now. If I could only sell I don't know, however many copies that's sold, like thirty million or whatever, anyway, folks, Hello,

Speaker 2and welcome back to We're Not So Different, a podcast about how we've always been idiots. Some of us are bigger idiots about Prague than others. Folks. It is a new month, and that means it's time for another brand new mail bag of patron questions. Today we're going all over the place. We've got modern day dark ages, parallels, the demonology of Succubai, sumptuary laws, and China rain catchments,

Speaker 2and talk about feudalism and more. Enjoy and subscribe to the Patreon if you want to answer hear us answer questions like this five dollars a month Patreon, dot com, s, w nsdpod, you get bonus episodes, You get this stuff. It is a whole lot of fun. Anyway, let's get onto it, astronaut pants. Ask. Many colleges and universities in the US have formal opening ceremonies such as convocation and

Speaker 2senior investiture that they claim come from rights at Oxford. How far back do these traditions go? And do we know how similar they are to what most schools celebrate today?

Speaker 4Yeah, so they go pretty fucking far back. And I'll tell you one thing about Oxford. Those bitches keep track of this shit. They love to They simply love to convoke, you know, like I love to tell the story. But one of my best mates, Antonia, was working at Oxford for a really long time at Saint John's and I used to go there and scam free dinner, like we go to like High Tay and it was really awesome because you could get like for free, like three courses,

Speaker 4and then if you got enough people together, you could like request that they put on this thing called second Dessert where you go into another room and then like there's like berries and chocolate and port and saturnine and snuff. And I was always doing the snuff and the people are like, people don't usually do the stuff, and I was like, I'm doing this stuff. So I'm doing I'm snorting tobacco now.

Speaker 3But the first, the first time I ever went, oh.

Speaker 4God, yeah, Clary and I are like teasing Antoni and we're like, oh, what are you gonna have to get up and say grace and Latin? And Antonia goes, well, no, usually one of the undergrads does that.

Speaker 2And we're like that was supposed to be a joke, right, I'm not here baby, yeah, and so.

Speaker 4Like I mean by so the by the nature of universities being what they are, which is, you know, large institutions of learning, and Oxford having this sort of money and prestige that it does, we have excellent records for what their fucking problem is, right because these are people who buy their very nature, write everything down and they are essentially church institutions in the medieval period, so they're keeping these things on record because they're like, this is how you do it. So it's just like it's a

Speaker 4particular arm of the church, right that's doing these things this way, and they're able to kind of like keep these libraries for years upon years upon years upon years upon years they've got unless they like sell particularized things off to collectors when they run out of money, which they don't.

Speaker 3Really do very often.

Speaker 4Then they have these like great manuscript collections and that sort of thing. So we actually have really good traces of this. There's certain things, for example, like if you join the Bodiley and Library, which you know, of course I have, Like there are these traditions like when you join the Bodiley and one of the things that you have to do is swear an oath that you won't light fires in the library.

Speaker 2Okay, yeah, I can see that.

Speaker 4Yeah yeah, And it's like and which I And it's funny because like I was like giggling while I did it, and like the library and was being like so fucking serious and I was like, okay, dude, like sorry.

Speaker 2I'm bad.

Speaker 3Yeah, I'll stop enjoying this, I guess.

Speaker 4But yeah, So we the point being that we have really good records on this because that's what universities are like, and if they're basing them off of the Oxford things, yeah, that's that it's probably correct. And this is these are things that you can go look up. You know, Oxford Oxbridge in general is a special you know, they're they're special little snow flakes and they they have this part to go thing. But you know, you'll find similar stuff, for example at Bologna, at the Sorbonne, at Queensboro in

Speaker 4uh Portugal, at Charles You know that we have really really good.

Speaker 3Records on this stuff. So yeah, it's probably right, and I think that's neat.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's cool.

Speaker 4Man.

Speaker 2An oath did not light a fire in the library. That is probably one of the few oaths you could get me to like actually swear, I'll be like fine whatever.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 3I was like, you know, fair enough.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah, astronaut Pants, thank you for the question. Next, Milesby says, I know it's repeatedly said the Dark Ages refers to the lack of written materials rather than quote decline of civilization in quote, but how does Eleanor view this piece of news in Britain in comparison to the post Roman Empire slash Early Middle Ages? And this is a story about a library that had been closed in

Speaker 2Croydon and the people who have been brought in to clear out the library did not take note of the books or how bad it would look or something like that, and they just dumped the in front of the library, just out there, like to be thrown in the trash. And of course the mayor maybe not mayor whatever it is, it was, you know, horrified, and gave a statement and

Speaker 2everything like this is not just supposed to happen. These books are supposed to be center round and everything. So yeah, I think it's a good story there, Eleanor. Yeah, yeah, it's not a good story, but it's a it depicts the Dark Ages that actually happened.

Speaker 4Yeah, and I mean this is something that one of the reasons why we often have bad records of the Middle Ages is exactly this shit happening, exactly this shit happening right here, like over and over and over again. So you have, for example, in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries in the Austro Hungarian Empire and Holy Roman Empire, you have this consolidation of the libraries that is like instituted as a modernization effort, where the Habsburgs are like, oh, yeah, well,

Speaker 4we need to like let's just put instead of having like all of these monasteries with disparate libraries, let's like just put them all together in one place.

Speaker 3And they're going don't.

Speaker 4Need that, don't need that, don't need that, and just kind of like throwing out lots of books. So we lost just so much medieval shit that way.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 4Similarly, here, Henry, the eighths dissolution of the monasteries just means that it's like a fucking like absolute bonfire of libraries. You know, some of them go down to the university and things like that, but a lot of them are just like fucking lost because people are just like, yeah, get this the fuck out of here?

Speaker 3Who gives a shit, right, and especially if you are not an expert.

Speaker 4Right, like if you're just some guy who's told clear this space out and you're like, yeah, whatever, books, I don't give a.

Speaker 3Shit, like you've got no way of knowing, and like.

Speaker 4This happens over and over and over again, like this is just willful destruction of things, and like, you know, don't get me wrong, like I don't care if like a bunch of damn brown books get out, like whatever, Like you know, nothing is lost, and you know we've got copies on record at that, like you know, the British Library.

Speaker 3It'll be fine.

Speaker 4But the point is that once these things start happening, they happen even more. And we're living through a period where in expert knowledge, especially of things like the humanities, is being systemically degraded, and we are being told over and over again by like our ruling elites that you don't need to know about things like this. We're being told that books have no function. You know, that AI is going to do everything for us, which is just like absolutely bizarre. And you know, I think that these

Speaker 4two things are linked, you know, like you don't need a physical library, when you know the government is pumping a bunch of money into AI, which will just like think for you don't need to think, right And so I think that this is a really good object lesson because it teaches us how we get these dark ages exactly exactly as you're saying. It shows us how, you know, even now when we have the benefit of hindsight, we have the benefit of knowing what happens when you start treating libraries like this, when you start treating collections like this,

Speaker 4if you stop thinking that knowledge and its accumulation and sharing is important, that stuff can get traction very very quickly, and it's something that doesn't lead anywhere good.

Speaker 3Let's just say that. So, I mean, I'm glad.

Speaker 4That there's a furior about it. That's a good thing, but it never should have fucking happened in the first place.

Speaker 3And you know.

Speaker 4Why the library is quite why the library is closing in the first place is all down to the fact that this government has stopped funding councils and is expecting all local councils to be doing basically everything like they're supposed to be finding the housing for everyone who lives there. They're supposed to be like and doing rubbish collection, potholes, libraries, gyms, you know, like every single fucking thing.

Speaker 3And they have no goddamn money. So when it's.

Speaker 4Between like are we going to get people housing or are we going to house these books? Unfortunately a lot of the time it's like the books that are going to go. But the two things are inextricably bound. I would say, you know, like a society that values its people also values the knowledge that benefits them, and uh, something's got to.

Speaker 3Give in this country. Joined the Green Party, everybody, thank you.

Speaker 2Yeah, I was the other day. I was actually thinking about this exact thing because I I had like found like a box that had some like some like books and stuff from like I don't know, like a few years ago that had just gotten put away in a corner, and so I got it out and I pulled you know, I pulled the stuff out. It was a couple of books, and you know, I dusted them off a little, put them on the shelf, and uh, there was also like

Speaker 2a couple of receipts in the bottom of it, just like you know, grocery store receipts, normal stuff, you know, And I was after I went wow, things were a lot cheaper back then. I uh uh I I'm not trying to say I I saw. I looked at it, and I thought, you know, this is one of those things that like if I had forgotten about that box,

Speaker 2you know, or something like that, and uh, you know, it's one of those things like you know that you that you hear about like a fine you know, like so someone in a thousand years some archaeologists is like dinging around here or whatever, and uh and comes across, you know, this box that haven't been preserved because stuff didn't fall on it or you know, something like that, and like, you know, it's like and I was, like, that's exactly like what we have for these people. Yeah, I mean, of course there's a lot of stuff that's

Speaker 2saved and everything like that, like the master works or you know, like these nice like bound histories and periodicals and stuff that that that we do have records of. But like the other stuff we have, you know, like when you go through like a collection of something, it'll be like, you know, like just the everyday like nick knacks that that like you keep in your pocket, you know, like here's a key, here's a button here, you know, like and we only found this stuff because it was

Speaker 2in this woman's pocket on this day and she fell into a peat boger, you know, something like that. And I just think about like that stuff, and then like reading this article, I was just I was just like god damn, Like they're doing the same thing and I'm not, like, you know, I'm not here to ding on these workers who were probably told, you know, do this as fast as possible, and you know where you lose your job or whatever. But it's one of those things where it's

Speaker 2like the books themselves, like the actual physical books do not matter, like not really, like when people are like precious about like the physical form of book, I'm like, okay, fine, But like the thing about the written word is that like when it survives, like what survives is like just a small segment of the actual history. Like even in

Speaker 2places like medieval or ancient China where they had insane record keeping and stuff like that, we still have spotty records because that stuff gets lost over time. It was written on, it was written on very degradable surfaces. You know. It's just like what survives is at random. And so like we have all this access right now to all this information and it's amazing, but like you know, we have to do we have to make conscious efforts to like keep that and like keep records of it and stuff.

Speaker 2And I mean that means not like you know, it means you know, reading books, interacting with books and stuff like that, but also you know, like keeping files on it. And if you have you know, like a you know, storage drives and stuff like that, you know that that stuff is is good because you know, I mean, anything could happen that could cause like huge loss of this stuff. But I mean even from natural disasters to man made ones to you know, I mean anything, so like, yeah, this, I mean, I think this is a perfect example of

Speaker 2how you get a dark age, Like if you lose enough stuff like this in a thousand years.

Speaker 4Yeah, it's just cumulative over time. You know, these things don't happen all at once. It's death by a thousand cuts, right, It's a cultural thing that happens slowly over time.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's a yeah, it's yeah. We we all live in the cycles of life or whatever. And I find that both comforting and also terrifying because I don't even if I don't like a lot of what's on the Internet or the way that people use it or whatever. I really don't think we should lose that because having access to this repository of information in such a way, and that it's in a lot of cases is relatively

Speaker 2unedited coming to us in terms of you know, a lot of videos that we've seen and stuff like that. Like, I think it is keeping that is like a one of the more worthwhile human endeavors there is, because we have accounts of that. And when you have accounts like that that can be spread around, it's a lot harder to fall for propaganda, which is what we're seeing right now. Yep, absolutely, yep, uh yeah, So Miles By, thank you very much for the question. Next, we got one from Zibin who says a question for Eleanor about the Kramer slash Summer's understanding

Speaker 2of succubus. If a demon can only steal semen from a human man and use this to impregnate, does the semen get some of the demon's DNA in the process? Is demon ness transferred to the child? Because that doesn't really solve the only God can create problem. And if they don't pass their demon qualities, aren't they just shuffling jigs around creating paternity confusions. Just jizz couriers, eleanor.

Speaker 3Yeah, so they are just his careers. Thank you for that. I'll be in the future. Love this. You know that they you they are just jizz couriers.

Speaker 4But the understanding of the reason why this is bad is that they're like jiz currying.

Speaker 1To decease to deceive.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 4So one of the things that Kramer's really worried about, like while he's beaten off, is that like innocent men, just normal men, normal men, innocent men, uh are their Jesus is going to get stolen and women are going to get knocked up with it, and then people are going to be all, like, why do you knock that woman up?

Speaker 3And they'll be like I didn't.

Speaker 4And so like the uh suckubisses and incubusses are are causing confusion with this. The other thing is that they're gonna take it and then they're gonna knock the witches.

Speaker 3Up with it at the unholy.

Speaker 4Sabbot slash witch orgies that they have, and then the witches are going to then give birth to these kids, suck the poor normal men slash innocent men into it, and then they will raise the babies to be witches.

Speaker 3So, uh, it's it's a secifica. They say it's nurture. You know that they don't think that it's a nature issue.

Speaker 1It's a nurture issue.

Speaker 2So, yeah, is the spawn born of this? Is it a demon or is it a human?

Speaker 3A human?

Speaker 4It's a human and you know, indeed we see this kind of going on in general with also Antichrist discourse. So you know, the the major ways that we think that Antichrist is going to be born into the world is either by an evil monk and nun who are shagging, or like a sex worker, and you know, like whoever.

Speaker 3They're varying degrees of it.

Speaker 4But the baby would be a normal baby. But it is then basically inhabited by an evil spirit that the devil sends. So the devil still can't because the devil can't create, right, so that's not possible, but the devil can possess, so you can.

Speaker 3Do it via possession instead.

Speaker 4So they don't need the nature necessarily in order for evil to occur, Like it doesn't need to.

Speaker 3Be physical, you know, like a conception of DNA.

Speaker 4They simply don't care that much about because you know, they're medieval people, so it's much more about action, right, and the action is going to be a result of nurture or indeed, in some cases just whole scale possession, So they don't you don't need their body to be weird. It'll just you know, and then like maybe your body will start looking weird because you're so evil, because you know how beauty standards work.

Speaker 3But yeah, yeah, I.

Speaker 2Love it when fantasy novels have a well defined magic system.

Speaker 1I love that.

Speaker 4It's just yeah, it's very well defined. Like I mean, the devil just can't do it. The devil has not got the juice, so that's it, you know.

Speaker 2Yeah, yep, oh, Zeven, thank you very much for the question. Next, we got one from dog spot er. Do we have any info on height slash weight for the types of people who were trained to fight in the Middle Ages, How did averages compare to someone within a standard deviation of today's average.

Speaker 4Yeah, we don't have that great records about it. We do know that, like at least in English contexts, when people are like, oh my gosh, Henry Longshanks and it's like Homeboy was like six feet tall and you're like okay.

Speaker 3Pretty good.

Speaker 4But you know, we have dietary issues obviously that we no longer suffer from, so we are now able to be much taller. And also, you know, standards of measurement are really you know, varying.

Speaker 3Across time.

Speaker 4You know, like all you got to do is consider the fact that English people still are talking about how much they weigh in stones.

Speaker 3So it's it's really it's really difficult.

Speaker 5You know.

Speaker 4It's like the one thing I really I cannot get my head around stones. I still can't remember what it is. I feel like it's fourteen pounds or something like. It's like some weird measurement.

Speaker 3No, I will not look I refuse to look it up.

Speaker 4But also, like, especially if people here are dieting, like the number one way they refer they relate to weight losses talking about stones, They're like, oh, yeah, I've lost a stone, I've lost half a stone.

Speaker 3I'm like, bitch, I don't know what that means.

Speaker 4But okay, so yeah, Unfortunately, we just don't have great records on this. Like also because we don't have like a state that would take.

Speaker 3Records like this.

Speaker 4You know, there isn't there isn't an interest in statistics in this the same way, and like unless it's like for the purposes of taxation, Like you know, no one really gives a shit about like writing down like how tall you know, tom Son of the Smith was.

Speaker 2They just say that boy big.

Speaker 4Yeah, and then you know, and if they're really big and they're noble and notable, they'll write about it. But you know, most everybody is just going to be ignored. You can kind of sometimes get an idea by looking at armor.

Speaker 3But again here we have the fact that.

Speaker 4Like armor is usually worn by rich people, so it's really only going to tell you about rich people.

Speaker 3It's not got to talk tell you about like ordinary folks unfortunate.

Speaker 4We can kind of do it, but we can sort of do it now by looking at skeletons, but yeah, I'm not really then we would need to know that the skeleton belonged to a warrior, right, So, and we don't really have a way of doing that unless we know that the skeleton is like fucked up and like there's obvious like damage in varying places.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 4But the basically there are all these things which make it difficult to get a read on it, which is why I don't have an answer to this unfortunately.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, and I mean the I think the I think the difference between like the Middle Ages and now, like in terms of high I think I've seen it as like it's like two ish inches, Like we're like two ish inch dollars inches dollar on average. But like, yeah, they didn't they didn't care about height like that. I do think in the early in the early modern period and especially about the Napoleonic period, that was something that people were starting to care about. And I think you

Speaker 2could kind of find that, uh you know, like heights and stuff like that for certain things. Uh but yeah, not not necessarily. Yeah, uh excuse me, dog spotter, Thank you very much for the question.

Speaker 5Uh.

Speaker 2Next, we got one from Luca j. H who says, obviously silk was very It was a very expensive luxury good in Europe, and I presume was further restrained by various sumptuary laws even after Europe got domestic production. But what about China. I know court officials in various dynasties had specific colors and symbols to wear depending on their rank, but were there other laws on who could wear silk like in Europe? Was it less expensive more common outside of the wealthy, wealthy elite, because silk was native and

Speaker 2I did some research on this, so basically, basically they did have sumptuary laws, and earlier on in the Medieval period it seems like they were more strictly enforced, but by the later but by the by the late Middle Ages, and even in I mean even you know, like the

Speaker 2tenth century, they didn't enforce them as strictly. And by the end of the Middle Ages, they're like, even if they had the laws, they weren't enforced because every level of like even down to smaller towns would have would typically have some kind of a silk industry, assuming it was like within the proper like you know, bands for you know, the right weather and stuff like that. So yeah,

Speaker 2and I think like there is there's like a confusion teaching on this, and it's very much about you know, well, quote, let clothing be regulated according to gradiations in rank in life. Let there be distinctions in regard to carriages and official caps, clothing and positions, stipend and salaries and fields and dwellings. And that let no one, even if worthy an honored dare wear clothing that does not befit his rank. So you have that confusion teaching, and but it wasn't strictly.

Speaker 2It became much less strictly enforced over time, and and so like even in the sixteenth century they would say, you know the dynasy this was during the ming Uh. The dynasty has clear regulations for the dress and ornaments of women from official families. As times changed and customs became more lavish, people all set the resolve on venerating riches and excesses, and as they no longer knew they were there were explicit prohibitions, instead went about trampling on them. Nowadays,

Speaker 2men dress in brocade and embroidered silks, and women ornament themselves in gold and pearls. So this person, you know, is complaining about the This is a court official complaining about the degradation of the insignificance of these silks and stuff like that, because people have you know, whatever whatever laws were in effect, they didn't care essentially and there so there there are other quotes that show the this

Speaker 2was you know this this people just went about in whatever they wanted to and as long as it didn't offend someone specifically like you, you were pretty good the men could dress and could dress in silks, and and a lot of times if they didn't have a lot of money, they would just use the silks from the local industries and they would, UH they would, and I mean women were dressed in silks as well, And there

Speaker 2are gradiations in silk. And there were certain colors that were associated with either the UH imperial the imperial house that was ruling, but also UH like certain types of silk could only be worn by individual like UH in their UH, their their bureaucracy. Basically there were different gradients and some the highest officials got to wear I believe red and then green and then blue, or blue and

Speaker 2green or reverse one of the two. And basically the basically like, as long as you didn't infringe on that, you know, you weren't trying to like appear to dress like, you know, an official or something like that, you could you could pretty much get away with it. And there's this quote that comes from this is actually from the late sixteenth century, but it talks about how at least since the Song dynasty, which was the late tenth century

Speaker 2to the late thirteenth century, people have been just like going even even commoners have been going out of their way to buy silk and in the style that became famous during the song period, which is called a song brocade. And it's quote now the youth from our town considers silk, gauze and pattern fabrics worth nothing, seeking the expensive and elegant wou silk and song brocade, cloud patterned thin satin

Speaker 2and fabrics woven with camel wool imported from far away to dress themselves. And it goes on about like how they wear all these these these extravagant colors, and uh, you know this is a yeah, yeah, this is a mockery of of you know, everything, and and uh blah blah blah. And there there's another quote about how basically, uh, if you go, it basically depends on where you go as to how strictly they enforce it. But like even

Speaker 2in places that do enforce it, it's kind of like, you know, don't wear that color of silk. You you know, you you go back, you know, you go back to uh, you go back to wearing a slightly less desirable kind of silk instead of you know, wearing the absolute fanciest because you have fit did some some No, let me just.

Speaker 3Tell you what China. China's built different.

Speaker 5But yeah, yeah, it's you know, there there are a few there are a few different quotes of these, a lot of them from civil servants complaining about you know.

Speaker 2Uh, this is from a guy named uh Luji in uh the mid sixteenth centuries. Nowadays, the majority of revenue comes from the region of wu in Ua, and the luxury life in this region is the most prominent. In Sujao and hang Zhu, there are numerous people who don't till but eat good food, and people who don't weave but wear patterned silk. This is because people love pursuing luxury and prefer commercial activities. Uh yeah, yeah, word, yeah, you're describing the consumption lifestyle there. Basically, they did have

Speaker 2sumptuary laws. They from what I can tell, they were not terribly enforced along the way. And uh yeah it and I mean there's also uh this painting of the city of nanjing Uh in the very late Middle Ages, and it is very long painting. It's it goes It's

Speaker 2like all this thing is just centimeters. Yeah, so however long that is, my American brain doesn't know. But and and it has like different sections of the city and there's like there's like a commercial district, and the commercial district has you know, like a like a silk like a silk place, and then it has like other places that are kind of less well to do but also sell clothing. So like this was it was something that was common and it went on fairly regularly. And I

Speaker 2actually found this from yeah, of course university course reading list on Uh, I guess the silk trade and silk industry. It doesn't even have a name on it. So whoever put this together and included copious notes and references, Uh, thank you. I appreciate that. I don't know who you are, but thanks. Yeah. Anyway, Luca JH. They love their silk, Uh,

Speaker 2sumptuary laws couldn't keep them down.

Speaker 3I suppose ye love me silk's me yeah, hell.

Speaker 2Yeah, thank you very much for the question. May Day says Uh. In a recent episode of Lions lit by Donkeys and Nate had a running gag referring to Italian city states by the particular cuisine the most popular for how long standing are these status items as high value luxury foods? Like with nobles in the business Empire brag about their expensive imported modin and balsamic vinegar. Would a German sausage gourmand to be eating imported Bolognis sausages?

Speaker 4Well, Shout out lions legged by donkeys, shout out nate front of.

Speaker 3The pod, et cetera.

Speaker 4So most food traditions from the Middle Ages are no longer accident. You know, Italians will kill you if you point this out. But most things that are considered traditional were brought into the Italian lexicon in the twentieth century.

Speaker 3You just have to do like very basic historical research on it. They will try to kill you if you bring it up.

Speaker 1Though.

Speaker 4There's this like one Marxist food historian and in Italy who writes about this and everybody hates him. But like, yeah, we just don't have recipes on the books for you know, Tordolini before you know, like eighteen ninety or whatever. So like they're not they're not particularly fucking old.

Speaker 2You needed the tomato, you needed, you need that in exchange.

Speaker 4Like yeah, now having said that, uh, the thing the thing you flex the most about is wine, like wine number one. Hell yeah, bringing in wine, that's definitely definitely a thing and everyone is into that. So like flexing about where your wines come from and having that wine that's going to do your thing. Spice is similar, so spiced whatever is definitely a good thing. Occasionally cheeses people

Speaker 4will get they'll be getting down talking about like whatever interesting cheese that they've got, and that kind of can move back and forth.

Speaker 3And we do have some things.

Speaker 4For particular dried sausages, yes, because those can be traded. But you know, we've got to understand that because travel is simply slower, there's a lot of food that can't really be moved back and forth, you know. Yeah, so it's hard.

Speaker 2You gotta you gotta like a hard packet and salt if you're going to get it anywhere. Like you know, yeah, so it was hard to get fish from the coast because even if you pack it in salt, if it like gets messed up at all, it's just gonna go bad.

Speaker 3Oh yeah, fucking you know.

Speaker 4Oranges, that's a huge flex, enormous flex on oranges. They often come from Spain, very particularly when they move around dates.

Speaker 3That's a flex.

Speaker 4Pineapples, Yeah, if you can get one, you know, things like this, you know, fruits, fruits that travel yep, that's that's the thing. But Yeah, it's because they don't have preservatives and food and travel is slower.

Speaker 3It's just a lot of it can't fucking happen. That's that, you know.

Speaker 2Yep, Mayde, thank you very much for the question. Uh. Next, we got one from Ali Can't, who says I was told as a kid that houses in Arabic slash Central Asian Asian regions were designed so that water collected on their roofs on the rare occasions that it rained. Is there any truth to that or is it just more orientalism? And I also look this one up and I found a really good article about this. It is the articles called Ancient water harvesting Methods in the dry Lands of

Speaker 2the Mediterranean and Western Asia. And ancient here is being used to just mean anything pre modern. But you know, we'll forgive them for that.

Speaker 1Uh.

Speaker 2And basically the the answer is, yeah, they they did it. They have been doing this since, I mean since civilization existed. The for like rain catchment on roofs, the roof would be built slightly slanted and on the on the end that was slanted down, there would be a pipe that went down and there would be a catching device like a bowl or you know, a jug or something like

Speaker 2that where they would catch it and that was typically used for the personal water for the families in places you know that were that were really dry. You know, you would have different methods like they they would have to do like extreme methods too to get this done, uh, just to get water in uh to where they're doing. And and that would include things like uh they would have hillside conduits, they would have little round things called

Speaker 2hafirs which like were slightly mounted earth that would catch water in it. They would have terracing rooftop harvesting, and then they would have they would have something called uh niagaram, which was a system of catching rain just in like various I think I think it's in like various uh not tarps, but like kind of like it seems like something like that. Like they had a lot of methods

Speaker 2for this, but one of them, one of the main ones was rooftops and it would be used by everyone because you need water to live and a lot of places in southeastern Europe and uh into this step all the way across way into Asia are insanely drive of course, including the Middle East and Levant and North Africa. So yeah, they were using this Ancient Indian Ancient Indian cultures used them,

Speaker 2including the Indus Valley civilization. So that's going back to like fucking like twenty six hundred BCE. UH, Sumerian and Mesopotamian cultures, Egyptian cultures, Syrians, Greeks, Romans. Greeks and Romans have their had their impluviums, which you know were roof catchment systems, and uh, basically anywhere over there that would have the giant cisterns that we've talked about from time to time, like the ones they had in the Byzantine

Speaker 2Empire in Constantinople, the ones they had in you know, over in parts of China, and in uh the Camere Empire over in the Ink or what in ancor tom. Yeah, so like anywhere that they have stuff like that, they're going to have a roof rain catchment as far as I can tell. And yeah, that's uh that article, where the hell did that? I forget where it was from, but yeah, they basically if it's Orientalism, uh, I don't know,

Speaker 2but it's they did it for a long time. Yeah, and that's how they.

Speaker 4Yeah, although I think it's it is good to be cautious about these things I want oh yeah, yeah, yeah, but like yeah, it turns out that shit just works, so that's cool.

Speaker 2Yeah, And that was from articles in the Journal of Ancient Studies. It was written by Brian Becker's Jonas and Burking and we get to shoot. Yeah, so that was that was pretty cool and a little fun to learn about. But yeah, Ali, thanks for the question. And as the learner said, it's good to be on the lookout for orientalisms. Yeah, but this is a case where we can look at them and be like, damn, you guys really did know how to do this. Also, I should, of course mention Indigenous Americans had this. The people who lived in the

Speaker 2Andes and in Peru, even before the INCA became like an incorporated entity, they used incredible like terraforming and terracing methods to get water because it's so dry there, irrigation methods, things like that, and they of course they have water catchment in you know, Native American societies from you know, the coast of Chile all the way up to you know, Canada and Alaska. So yeah, this is a very widely

Speaker 2practiced thing as far as I can tell you. Yeah, So Thank you very much for the question. We got a couple more first one from Gaffsei who says you sometimes hear how rulers quote unquote settled outside peoples such as Saxon's in Transylvania for specific purposes like increasing the productivity of agriculture or trade in the area. What would this have looked like on the ground level, both in terms of gathering the people from the outside and once they were in the kingdom settling them.

Speaker 4So they tend to send out messengers to wherever it is that they are attempting to attract people from.

Speaker 3So we see this.

Speaker 4A lot of the time with Burgers for example. Also like throughout Slovakia or in like mining regions in particular, we see a lot of Germans get brought in for a mining expertise across Central Europe. So that's a big way that people are brought in. And what will happen is kings will basically like send messengers over and be like here you hear you motherfucks who.

Speaker 3Wants a job? And so usually what you get offered or like a they'll be like bye, the bye. Have some minds, opening needs some guys.

Speaker 4To work it and they'll be like favorable taxation rates, usually breaks for building houses, things like that, subsidized subsidized materials for housebuilding, or you know, sometimes if you show up, kind of like cash incentives to kind of get you on your feet, and what it looks like on the ground when you get there is usually these people are going to be settled in towns or cities.

Speaker 3It's very rare.

Speaker 4That they are settled more in the countryside in particular. You know, they're usually brought in very specifically for the purposes of economic activity, for the purposes of you know, working on the minds, for the purposes of like doing some thing right.

Speaker 3Otherwise like who really wants them.

Speaker 4We also see this with Jewish people, so like Jewish people will get brought in, you know, for example, very famously in England after the conquest to be like oh Jesus Christ, we need some commerce. Somebody's got to lend some money. So again you will be offered a very favorable taxation rates. Oftentimes in all cases you will have direct access to like royal or noble or whatever courts, you know, so you don't need to worry about kind

Speaker 4of like the rinky dink stuff. If you are a Jewish or if you are a Burger, you go straight to the king with your issues, which is a pretty good deal, but it does mean that you are basically told that you have to live in particular locations. Obviously on the ground there, there's usually some light friction at the very least with whoever is already there, you know, who don't love that people are getting perks to be there,

Speaker 4And so we often see settlement pat turns that will emphasize you know, linguistic affiliations and these sorts of things. But you know, as a general rule of some of these things are just kind of like announced loudly yeah in very places. So it means you've got to hire people to go yell yeah.

Speaker 2And I mean this is of course an inherently violent practice because oh yeah, because the people being moved, you know, even if you're getting incentivized for it, you know, do you really want to move? You know, you're being you're being in some way compelled by market forces at that point. And those groups are extremely vulnerable to othering when things go bad, you know, outsider blame for crop failures, blame

Speaker 2for this, blame for that. And I mean, of course the Jews were blamed for any and everything. So yeah, it's it's something that happened, and I mean they would integrate, but it's also you know, there are a lot of repercussions for that that aren't immediately let's say that aren't immediately that they don't immediately show themselves, but end up causing extreme problems down the road. So yeah, Gaffsie, thank

Speaker 2you very much for the question. Lastly, we got one from Colin Keith who says, I feel it feels like every time I hear Eleanor and other medievalists explain it, it boils down to quote, well, it was a rare It was rare for a polity to have a neat and tidy pyramid like a textbook end quote. But couldn't the same be said of capitalism, which we currently which we most certainly live under. Many firms don't have a

Speaker 2neat and tidy corporate structure or shareholders. We have sole proprietors, partnerships, co ops, family owned businesses, et cetera. How is it the case that exceptions and multiple variations don't change the fact that we live under capitalism. How does the existence of the church, free cities aloidal fiefs, elected monarchies, and wealthy peasants negate feudalism. Aside from medieval cities. It seems like almost everywhere in medieval Europe, money, labor, goods, and military service flowed up and protection flowed down. I've been

Speaker 2taught that this is the essence of feudalism. What am I missing here? What essential elements were generally missing in medieval Europe? That makes it so that feudalism largely didn't exist in Europe.

Speaker 4Okay, so I guess one of the things that is differing here to point out is that you're right, there's all kinds of different ways of corporate entities existing under capitalism. But feudalism, the way that we're thinking about it is not, in particular just an economic model.

Speaker 3It's a model of governance. And that's the difference, right.

Speaker 4So the difference is that, yes, it is sometimes used to talk about an economic model, but really what it's doing is saying that that economic model is based on this theoretical mode of governance, not that governance happens as a result of the economic model. Now, of course that makes sense. It makes sense to kind of think of things that way around because of you know, the horrors that we currently live in under capitalism, because capitalism isn't

Speaker 4necessarily our mode of governance, but it is obviously, you know, so obviously we see this both in the States and you know, the United Kingdoms.

Speaker 3The two places where this podcast is.

Speaker 4Based, where in our governments essentially exists to do the bidding of corporations.

Speaker 1So that's cool.

Speaker 4Uh, It's different with the theory of feudalism because what happens is that you know, kings exist, the papacy exists, and the economic model exists in order to further enrich them as a part of it.

Speaker 3And now that is true under capitalism.

Speaker 4Like all right, obviously, like you know, you can see Trump getting all kinds of fucking crazy rich as a result of being president. But that's it's not the same, right, there are people with more money than he has who are kind of like outside of that.

Speaker 3Of the you know, like all the billionaires are not in governments, right.

Speaker 2And he clearly has to listen to them, otherwise we've gone to a full tariff system and crash the world economy like four months ago or whatever. So like yeah, there, there, there, there are these exterior pull factors on that. That mean he is not like supreme overlord, yeah as they as as medieval rulers were so.

Speaker 3And that's the difference, right, is that like when you.

Speaker 4Are a medieval ruler over here, the way that you create you collect taxation is going to be completely different in severe than it is in you know, London, right, And there's going to be very differing economic constraints on varying places that are much more localized. You have trade networks that work in very different ways, and so we just you can't talk about feudalism because people are trying to use it as a form of governance and and also a way of you know, and the economy just

Speaker 4doesn't work out too because there isn't really an economy, yeah, per se.

Speaker 3It's like there's commerce.

Speaker 2That yeah, and there are mixed forms of business, but they don't but there's not they it's it's not the same. It's not the same economy. It's not the same, it's not run the same. They don't they oftentimes don't have real like bureaus of standards and measures. It's like, I mean they lack even that basic economics.

Speaker 3Oh god, yeah, like.

Speaker 4You know, different places that you go are going to like, awigh, things differently, You're going to have totally different currencies you are going to you know, like everything differs place to place in a much larger sense. So, you know, that's part part of the problem that you have with attempting to place these models on the past is that, you know, it's just so modern to think that there could be a model, right because we have staturnization. Now, we have

Speaker 4these really integrated state systems which work hand in glove with the you know, with the capitalist system in order to keep these particular things propped up. The medieval period's just a lot fucking messier than that, right, Like, you just can't have systems like that, even when you have, for example, a very bureaucratized government state system like the church, which is I think that are the closest thing that we've got to like a real state in the modern sense.

Speaker 4In the medieval period, oh, there's nobody listening to them bitches, Like I mean, you know, like kings will just beef with popes all the time, They'll get excommunicated. They're like I don't give a shit, you know, like it's like it doesn't you don't have these same kind of chow points that you have in the medieval world. And yeah, it's so, it's not we don't like it as modern people. As modern people, we want to think that there are systems. As modern people, we want to think that we can

Speaker 4have grand narratives. And it's a lot of the time why people, for example, prefer studying Roman history because you could be like, ah, empire, look they've got laws, they're doing these things, right, It's.

Speaker 3Just a lot simpler.

Speaker 4But it's why I like the medieval period because they're contrary little bitches who are all doing different things and it's a fucking mess.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, it is, yeah, exactly that. I mean, that's exactly right. I think I think there are two things here. I think the first one is that feudalism is a originally is a term of art that is used to that is used for a description of vaguely how medieval society worked like in in like a in like an ebb and flow sort of way, it worked like this

Speaker 2more and certain instances and less and others. But within feudalism, I think there are three primary uh, there are three primary systems working within the superstructure working within the larger superstructure, and that is the pastoral system or the what we what we call the manorial system, where you know, you are a peasant or a s if you provide you know, up to your landlord who or your lord who provides

Speaker 2you know, in theory protection and you know, doesn't let you starve, et cetera, et cetera. And then you have the marshal, which is, you know, the king gives x land or rights down to his people in exchange for them providing military service for him. Blah blah blah blah blah. And I mean that happens occasionally in some places, like the Normans fucking love to do that. Charlemagne did a good bit of it, but like it's not like a

Speaker 2universal thing, and none of it is so neat and tidy as I just described it, even in the places that did it. And then the third thing is the like the overlay of this thing that keeps the that that keeps the system the way it is, and that is the church and state existing in like a loose melding together where they kind of where the church is there basically to be like look, God said, you stay

Speaker 2in your lane, you you know, if you're a peasant, you don't try to get above your station. You know, if you're a noble, you know, whatever they would say, and and and like that. And so you have these three factors and the only and only two of those are kind of even remotely universal. And then there are plenty of exceptions to that, and that is manorialism and the church, the church as the superstructure that reinforces like the social bonds of this system, and in Europe, those

Speaker 2are those kind of did happen everywhere, but they happened to varying degrees and in varying ways. And I'm sure me and Eleanor can think of a bunch of exceptions. I know I can right now to that. But so like it's an inarticulate way of describing like a massive system that worked on a continent, well, you know a few continents and and over a thousand year period where

Speaker 2at the beginning you're going from the collapse of the Roman Empire to the end where you started colonizing or you know, I'm sorry, to the end where you're getting close to start colonizing the quote unquote New World. And it's like taking feudalism as like the pyramid. The problem with the pyramid is it's trying to put a modern homogeneous definition on a place that was by nature, by

Speaker 2its very nature heterogeneous. Because even if you were a Norman lord and you have been given land by William the Conqueror, and he had said you have to come to my aid. If you do this, there are a thousand other factors that are pulling at that that would cause that could cause him not to go to the aid or not to go a not to give aid in certain circumstances and things like that, like real material things that change that. Whereas like now we can say

Speaker 2we don't want to live, we don't you know that there are exceptions to the market and everything like that. But you have to work and make money to live in this world now, like you have to. There is basically no exception to that. Unless you are born into wealth or you are extravagantly lucky for some other reason. You have to do that. You have to sell your services in the marketplace. There are so few people who are owners who are on that level to where they are, you know, the capitalists, the rest of us are down

Speaker 2here in some you know, mass of people, but we all have to sell our goods in the market in some way to get by. And the other thing I think is that the Middle Ages are is a process of building the modern world as we have it now from the ancient world, where things were vastly different in

Speaker 2various numbers of ways. And that is going from you know, these city states, these empires and things like that, until you start like you start coming more towards like, Okay, we are going to form an actual state, and it's not going to be just based on who I know or who my dad swore an oath to or something like that, and we're going to have these things. And once we form this state, we can do you know, more complex economic schemes and things like that. And that

Speaker 2was a long law process that took well over one thousand years to get to where we are now. But the thing about where we live today is that most countries, most states in the world made a voluntary or involuntary choice to get into capitalism. America, the United Kingdom, uh even even even China now like China made even though they were coerced by like the world system of capitalism

Speaker 2to do it, they still marketized a bit, as you know Vietnam did, and you know they did. They did that because they had to to get by. But like our governments have made a concerted effort too to adopt this capitalist system and to follow its strictures. And at first that was done kind of unknowingly, like by the Dutch when they were just forming, like the East India Company and all that stuff. And then as the English

Speaker 2took over, they did it unknowingly to a degree, and then they figured it out and once they became conscious of it, and that level of class consciousness appears, and you start having people thinking about like that and thinking about whoa wait a minute, we're in these world systems and I don't like the way this capitalism thing is going. Why is my country adopting this whole sale? Why did they care so much about it? And when Europe took over the world for better and worse, mostly worse, almost

Speaker 2certainly almost all worse. But when that happened, all of the rest of the world was suborned into this system, and suborn didto the system that we've been building over time until now that that that the Dutch started, based on all the trends from the Middle Ages, and the very early modern period that they started unwittingly that the British adopted kind of half knowingly, and then gained a class consciousness of and then the rest of us gained

Speaker 2that as well, like in due time as we figured out what was going on in political economies and socioeconomic blah blah blah blah blah. So I would say that the difference there is that the two governments that have been ruling the world as the Hedgemonds for the past fucking I don't know two hundred and fifty ish years or even before that in England's case, have they adopted this at some point willingly adopted it and said, yes, we are going to adopt this system we reject. We're

Speaker 2not going to try and evolve it beyond this. We're not going to try and do communist, socialist, any kind of collectivist system that you can think of. They purposely pushed that out and said, no, the market is God. That is what replaced the social aspects of the church. That's the market. And the Protestants and the Catholics went along with them after the fact, said you know, we make the rules. Our vision of God is what it is,

Speaker 2and you know, so we've recreated, we recreated the medieval superstructure. We have you know, the military, the martial systems now work differently, they're state based. The economic system and land systems a complete fucking miss, it's completely different. But you know we have that, and then you have the market superstructure above us. That is, as we've been told, the it's what determines who is good and evil. If you,

Speaker 2in the logic of capitalism, if you succeed in life, it's because the market smiled upon you. And if you failed in life, it's because you are of bad moral character and God doesn't love you. And by God, they mean the market.

Speaker 3And yeah, leave me the line.

Speaker 2I'm not I'm not I'm not making I'm not making light of.

Speaker 3This, but like I just think it's good, you know.

Speaker 2Yes, no, no, no, what I'm talking to to Colin who who gave us the question, I'm not making light of what you're saying. I'm saying that feudalism is a term that we in the modern period invented to describe a thousand year period spanning the over three continents, and then incorporating two others into three excuse me, three others when you incorporate the rest of Oceana, Oceania and Australia

Speaker 2incorporated into this world system that they had been building for well over a thousand years since even before the Greeks and Romans and even before imperial China was around, you know, going back to Mesopotamia and all that. It's like, we invented that term as an inarticulate way to describe a thousand year period. And the reason the pyramid doesn't work is because the pyramid is something that we invented so the modern mind could wrap their head around a system where you have the Holy Roman Empire and it's

Speaker 2it's anywhere from like a few dozen to three hundred statelets that have various degrees of of voting rights and imperial rights and rights in the in the not the lance rod, but you know, rights in the in their tributary legislative type arenas. They had hard borders, some of them with each other, despite the fact that they were

Speaker 2all in the Holy Roman Empire. They would have different currencies, different extremely different languages and things like that. And even now where we have countries that do have hard borders, like you know, a dollar for at least for now at least you know, I assumed tomorrow whenever we published this, but at least as of October seventh, twenty twenty five, that you can still spend the dollar around in most places like you came with the yuan, increasingly with China.

Speaker 2So it's like the medieval world was never that that homogeneous ever, yeah, anywhere even like and I mean I think we both joke before that, like they did the Japanese, the early modern Japanese did stumble upon an inadvertin form where they had uh where they had created feudalism based on like the like feudal practices of you know, the

Speaker 2shogun who would hand it down to his warlords underneath him, and they would hand it down to their retainers and so on and so forth. But like, I mean, even then, that was just in early modern Japan that only lasted for like it was less than two hundred years as long as the shogunate system lasted into the early modern period, and I mean it was still like, it's still vastly different. There are still extreme exceptions to it because the world was changing, and you know, once you get into the early modern period, all of a sudden you can see

Speaker 2white people coming over the horizon, and yeah, that changes everything, which I mean is the whole part of Shogun. They're dealing, you know, they're dealing. Actually, no, Shogun is a good example of that because they are dealing with being incorporated into like a burgeoning capitalist system. Even though those colonizers and evangelists for Christianity didn't understand that they were doing that. They were just like, we don't wittingly understand that we are creating whatever system comes after this, Like we know

Speaker 2that we are creating that, but we like on a day to day basis, you can't say like this is I'm doing this now to create you know, X, Y and Z, and then it's definitely gonna happen. That's not how time works, you know.

Speaker 3Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 2Yeah, basically, I just don't think, Yeah, it's just not a it's not a homogeneous system. It never was. And you know, we use terms to just this goes back to the thing we talked about with you know, the era eras and and uh, you know, trying to trying to come up with these these systems for everything, and they do. And that's good because we need to be able to describe uh times in history without going uh yeah, that period from four to seventy six b uh for

Speaker 2seventy six CE to fourteen fifty three CE. You know, in the in Europe or whatever, you just say the Middle Ages because it's easier just say Middle Ages. It's cleaner. Yeah, yeah, for sure. Anyway, Yeah, uh Colin, thank you for the question that.

Speaker 3Uh thank you.

Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, and I think it's I think it's good to like elucidate this because you know, we don't we don't we we don't elucidate feudalism near as much as we did when the show started, but it's good to do so every now and again. Uh so new people or people who have forgotten. Uh you know, we kind of level set everything there. So yeah, Colin, thank you for the question, and everyone, uh thank you for them that is going to do it for us today, eleanor what is going on with you?

Speaker 3Ah? Okay.

Speaker 4Look, if you are in the United Kingdom a week from today at the time of recording uh on Sky History, you will see that there's a show that's called The Witches of Essex. For some unknown reason, it is chaired by Ryland.

Speaker 3You won't know who that is.

Speaker 4Luke and doctor Alice Roberts lovely woman. Uh you know, and it's about the Essex wishes. I am one of the historians they've got in. Were you to watch it and uh, you know on social media, be like damn Ellen Orihonica is cool career.

Speaker 3You know, you don't even have to watch it.

Speaker 4But if you like saw things for it on social media, if you're like damn sky History, we sure like that woman, that'd be that'd be helpful for me.

Speaker 2Otherwise I'm not really your voice online be like wow, so great.

Speaker 3You Otherwise not much. I'm trying. I'm trying to get a blog post up this week. I know I haven't done that for a while.

Speaker 4I'm thinking about the overlap between AI and the GOLM. But we'll see if I can get that written. But yeah, mostly I'm just online yelling into the void.

Speaker 2Well there you go. Yeah, you can find me at the normal stuff. Lucas amazing on the places you can find Melchow People's History of the Old Republic. If you want to hear me yap about Star Wars. Hello, But anyway, that is going to do it for us today. Thank you very much for listening, and we will see you next time. Bye,

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 302 - Onfim and Medieval Children

    Nov 20, 202654 minAudio

    they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 301 - Enter Leviathan, or, Why the Early Modern Period Sucked

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 24 minAudio

    folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 300 - November Mailbag

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 299 - Army of Darkness Review

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 298 - Welcome to the Crusades 2.2 Mosul

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode