folks, we are back with another mailbag because we are behind on patron questions. this time, we talk about everything from donkeys to postal services, gendered work to seasoning pans, Hungary to myths and folklore, and even a whole block of questions about peasants running away to the cities and obtaining their freedom by staying for a year and a day. enjoy! cover image: frontispiece from Gustave Dore's illustrations of The Holy Bible showing people clinging to rocks during the biblical Flood, entitled "The Deluge"
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1I'm here.
Speaker 2Did you put the full video for as a kick the ball into the goal?
Speaker 1I did? I did. It was delightful.
Speaker 2It was very exciting because I remembered that yesterday. He said he was dropping it at ten am today and I was drinking coffee and I was like, wait a minute, and I was like fully in the YouTube queue but like nice seven other people being like hell yeah nice. I love to have a niche internet thing. It's beautiful. Yeah, yeah, good time.
Speaker 3I like, you know, I like it when gay guys are really gay into sports, either because they like sports, are they just like looking at guys. Either one is fine. I don't really care, but I just it's so fun. Like he like, I want to put sun cream on Thomas Toucle's head. I was like, I was fucking doubled over laughing at that ship as Semple is like his
Speaker 3head is like all skull. It's just like someone pulled skin like straight over his skull, like skeletor like a skeletor kind of thing.
Speaker 2It's true, And I'm just like.
Speaker 1Yeah, he doesn't.
Speaker 3He doesn't need sun cream on his head.
Speaker 2Get it. Maybe maybe a sensible sun hat, but that's that loses the ironic charge. That loses the ironic charge.
Speaker 3Yeah, give him one of those like woven like peasants hats, yeah, big and everything. Yeah hell yeah, oh man, yeah, uh that is uh, that is fun again. The cultural exchange of the World Cup is great. Like it's just everything is uh, you know, so much fun. Oh here's what I found. Uh it was a Brazilian fuck hold on,
Speaker 3uh this person, this is Portuguese and it was written in Portuguese and it says somebody says, uh, Brazilians have such a way with words. And the translated tweet is Neymar needs to die on the field to motivate the players. It's sad, but it's the only.
Speaker 2Oh my god, oh shit, okay.
Speaker 1I love this stuff is just so great. It's just so much fun to uh.
Speaker 3Like to see that other people have the same just utter disdain for their for their teams that I do.
Speaker 2It's it's so important, like right. One of the things that I thought was beautiful this week is did you see the story about how these Scotland fans like drank Boston out of beer? Hell yeah, yeah, they're like in the first place, there were some places in Boston that had tenants, which is confusing. They drank all of it except for like this one Irish pub was like we still have some, and then they're like the distributor doesn't have enough tenants. They're like interviewing these fucking like Scottish guys and they're like, yeah, the only thing they got left is bud light. That's not beer, that's pitch and
Speaker 2all this stuff. And I'm like, the American mind cannot comprehend British drinking culture. Like the American mind is actually.
Speaker 3Not right outside of Wisconsin.
Speaker 2Yeah, Wisconsin, it would they would, they would not have a problem in Wisconsin, but like apparently these guys like drank the Sam Adams tap room out of Boston Lagger, which is beer. It's a ship beer. But listen, Scottish people, I'm really sorry, but like tenants isn't very good either. It's fine, you know, I'm not mad at it, but it's like, listen, my pub, my pub did had bubbar
Speaker 2on but then they decided to just like slight me personally, like fuck my culture, I guess, fuck my beautiful Czech culture, Fuck our beautiful state owned beer company. I guess. Hate to have a socialized perfect logger on, but they got rid of it and they put tenants on. And it's really annoying because it's always like the richest motherfuckers drinking tenants in there and they're like, oh yeah, like I'm actually a man of the people, and it's like it makes me want to die. Like there were these guys the other week. I was sitting next to them and
Speaker 2they were arguing really loudly and they were like essentially like bankers of some kind who were like betting on the Nigerian economy.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, yeah, commodity, like commodity.
Speaker 2Trading and like arguing about like the Nigerian economy and then like but only drinking tenants. And I was like, I went and complained to the staff. I was like, do you guys know what these guys are yelling about? Some homies with staff and they're like, I'm presuming football. I was like, incorrect, I wish Nigerian commodities training and like a like a couple like I'll like their next time up there, Like I'm sorry, guys, I think you've had enough. This is your last round.
Speaker 1That's so funny.
Speaker 3Yeah, god, so is there. I mean I think we talked about this before, but like, so this is this is definitely a logger.
Speaker 1Like is would you say that's like the like most.
Speaker 3Thing that people drink there, because like I mean here, like if you if you say to me, go pick up some beer, I'm gonna go pick up something that I would normally drink, which is a very high alcohol by volume thing, because I would rather drink one or two of those and feel a buzz than have to drink four or five or six of whatever and then I just feel.
Speaker 1Bloated in water logs.
Speaker 3So like my question is, like I understand you want the tenets, but like is it is it one of those things where like if someone was like, here is a high ABV thing, they'd be like, I don't want that shit. Like not that they couldn't handle it. I'm not saying that about the Scottish. They could out drink me every day. I'm just wondering if, like if there's a a like just a different hang up here.
Speaker 2So one of the things that you're going to see a difference on in terms of high ABV is you are going to see a higher price point on it. And so like it's usually down the pub that's going to be priced differently, so it's very common here. For example, if you have something with a really high ABV, for example, if you've got like Belgians on right, or if I go like, uh, if you've got like an Imperial stout, which I love, or like if you've got like a DipPA something like that, Like I'm a fucking sucker for a DipPA. You know, they'll be like, we're selling it
Speaker 2at the half or we're selling two thirds of it because it's just going to be more expensive.
Speaker 3I think one of the I guess because I don't ever buy I don't buy beer that often or whatever, I don't think about that. But no, yeah, I totally you know, rather get why you'd rather have a twenty four pack than a sixer. You know that makes a lot of sense for most people.
Speaker 2Yeah, And I guess that's like what I'm drinking in the house. I tend to drink higher abb because I will be drinking like I'll usually have, Yeah, specifically, I'll have like Belgians in right, So I'm just gonna like nail a couple of shoes real quick and then that'll be good to go. Whereas I think that I would say probably the most common beer drunk in pubs generally is lagger of some description. You know, that's a huge umbrella. There's a lot of really shit logger on here. There's a lot of good lagger blah blah blah. But fundamentally,
Speaker 2I guess the difference is here. When you go to the pub, you are more often looking at what we would refer to as the session. So you're gonna you're in you're in it for You're in it for four to seven pints, right, yeah, and like and like imperial pints and so like if you're me, for example, or like what a lot of people do is you very specifically keep an eye on what the ABV is. So because I know I'm gonna like drink like five pints, right, So I can't be like, Okay, well I'm gonna have
Speaker 2like if I if there is something that I want to have that is like a seven point four for example, like a really good side or something, I'll have a half of that, and then I just have to make sure that I drink it slowly and in the same time that my friends were drinking a pint are having it. But if you drink a lot of ale like, I drink a lot of ale that usually has a lower ABV, and on top of that, we have a couple of lower ABV options in general, so like you will have oftentimes they will specifically call it session ale and it'll
Speaker 2have like a lower ABV somewhere like around the three.
Speaker 1But that's what.
Speaker 2You're gonna drink a lot of it. And then in terms of beer, the equivalent is tape bull beer. Ah okay, So the end the table beer is also going to be lower, and that's usually a good one to keep an eye on because it's like, I mean, I'm gonna be so real with you, I'm absolutely nailing some pints that are like five point eight percent. But I will often refer to that as like the big Boy round. Yeah, you gotta keep an eye on the big Boy round, right, got it? Who was there was a someone had this beer that was so fucking incredible this one winter. The
Speaker 2one lock had it on all the time, and it was called the Mariana Trench, and I think the Mariana Trench, which was fucking delicious. I believe it was something like a five point nine, possibly a six point two, and unfortunately it was so fucking good and like we started off being like, okay, well just have one first. That's your big boy round. It's out of the way. We can't be going around but having a six point two all the time. But then it was so delicious, It was so delicious that you would go back for another one.
Speaker 2And I don't know, Mariana Trench fucked my life up one winter in a very delicious way. This has been beer Corner with Eleanor.
Speaker 3Yeah, I would uh yeah if I went there, like I would have to like I guess, I get I guess I would just have to like, uh like superpace it and like people be like, why does he keep going in the bathroom so much?
Speaker 1I'm like, when I drink.
Speaker 3Beer, I have to pee ale beer logger, when I drink alcoholic beverages, yep, it's yeah. And I'm just like I gotta you know, I gotta go. And then you can be like does he have a problem, Like no, this is just what happens. This is this and sweet Tea does it too, So.
Speaker 1There you go.
Speaker 3Yeah that's what everyone cared about. Uh yeah, all right, well let's.
Speaker 1Talk about the other thing.
Speaker 3Uh. Now that we've had our World Cup mandated cross cultural dialogue here at the beginning, beautiful, we can get back to hating each other for our differences, which are that you live in a different country even though we're from the same one. Oh but uh, I hate people from Washington.
Speaker 1Stay.
Speaker 2Yeah, everybody, everybody's mad because we spoke too loud.
Speaker 1And our status different.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's that's what they said. Idaho is like, come on, man, what the fuck?
Speaker 2And we'll like, shut the fuck up Idaho.
Speaker 3Like, shut the fuck up Idaho and most of eastern Washington listen.
Speaker 2I don't even want to hear it from Washington.
Speaker 3No, no, no, all right, here we go. Hello, welcome
Speaker 3back to We're Not So Different podcast about how we don't want to hear it from Eastern Washington. I'm Luke and that's doctor Eleanor and we are back with more mail mail call time. If you want to ask us questions like these, please do subscribe to Patreon, Patreon, dot com, sash, w nsdpod five bucks a month get your access to well over two hundred and fifty add for regular episodes,
Speaker 3over one hundred and ten bonus episodes, and yeah, check it out join our discord.
Speaker 1Yeah we are.
Speaker 3Wait, hold on, I think we're like ten combined episodes away from being at three or four. Un I don't anyway, it doesn't wow, Okay, or it would be four hundred anyway. Yeah, cool regardless, Let's get to the main show, folks. We're back with more mailbag style content because we've got a ton of patron questions and it's just too damn hot out, too high. We are working on some upcoming series, like one on medieval disability, but need a bit more time to put it all together. Also, we have numerous other obligations. Anyway,
Speaker 3this time we're talking about horney and or cowardly bards donkeys. Postal services is seasoning pans, a whole block of questions about puzzles, peasants running away for a year and a day and more. First up, we got one from Miles B who says, going postal What were postal services like in medieval Europe before the Nashville developments? In early in early modern Europe, small scale favors by neighbors or families to get something over to a village. Did institutions like guilds,
Speaker 3market town authorities or at the largest scale, the church have their own internal services or did they rely on some sort of private contractor or merchant.
Speaker 2Yeah, so large scale institutions will start at the top. The church just they will send people all right, like they're.
Speaker 3Just like they're like here's our errand boy go err and boy go.
Speaker 2One hundred percent where they'll just be like, well off egos. And since when you're the church there are people moving around all the time, that's like really easy. Sometimes you don't have to send an errand boy. There's going to be like a church guy going that way anyway, and things are going to move back and forth fairly quickly, and the church has a pretty easy time of getting through because like you're still not going to attack like a cleric on the road. Right.
Speaker 3Yeah, they were always sitting paper, was always sending legates out to be like hey stop fighting with each other or hey let's smooth this, you know whatever for any various reasons, and those people can carry along messages just as easy.
Speaker 2Yeah, hundred percent. Like that's essentially what a leg is, right, is a messenger. So yeah, like they have people to do that very specifically, and even if they are not sending a legate, they have so many guys Like it's just like they got shooters, right, So like there's always gonna be some low level motherfuck who can like jump on a donkey or whatever. It's gonna be fun, right, yeah, And so that's what happens. If you are the king, you will send out uh someone also who is of
Speaker 2the nobility. So oftentimes, for example, we'll see queens send out their ladies in waiting where if they're like, if it's something very particular that they're really worried about, they will send high level people to kind of go do that. If it's like something less that you're worried about, more like oh, you want to send a chatty letter to your mom, then it'll just be like, is any delegate going past that court that kind of a thing, or you could send them out yourself. You know, you probably have enough money to do that. That's fine. Guilds, you
Speaker 2hit the nail on the head. Like with guilds, people are just moving around a lot, right, So they are gonna know business people who are trading things. They might even have whole ships that are going back and forth. And so if you need something taken from like London to Ghent, that's pretty easy. They'll they'll just do that. They're just gonna jump on a ship there, they'll have a ship going. They're gonna know a guy, right, Like, there's rather a lot of knowing a guy. And that's basically what medieval business is. More generally, what you will
Speaker 2do if you're an ordinary person and you need to get a letter over it again, is you can like literally go down to the docks and ask around. You can just like go and be like, hey, what's up? Need this done? You can ask around and then they will do you know, it's like a nominal fee. It won't be that much, right, They'll be like, I'll get if I give you this, will you do this? And people will do that, right, And you want to make sure that it does get to where it wants to go, because that's just a nice little side earner if you like,
Speaker 2if you are somebody on a ship, you will take those things on because it is not a lot of work. Do you want people to be able to trust that you were going to do these things? Like you know, that's just fine.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, we don't really have them anymore now. But people who own ships who weren't attached to larger groups would literally just sit in ports and wait for cargo that needed to go somewhere, or messages or people, and they just wait and there. They eventually became called like tramp ships, like tramp steamers, but yeah, they just they they don't adhere to schedules and they just kind of wait for stuff. And there were people who would do that back then.
Speaker 2And so you know, you would just kind of like go find those people. Then within kind of like a town thing, it's like people are moving around all the time. You could send messages and like at the very least you get to one market town and then from that market town, someone's going to be going to another market town and they can kind of stop on the way through. But also at the lower you get down in society, the fewer people can write or read, so you just don't have that much of a need for a postal service per se. Like one of the reasons that we
Speaker 2see Ton and Taxis set up their postal service in the German Lands when they do is people can read and write. Now, yeah, so they're sent in letters, right. You just couldn't send letters a lot of the time because like no one knows what the fuck that says, and they don't know how to write. Like peasants aren't sending shit, dude, Like we definitely know that rich ones like you know, uh, the land gentry, right, like the Paxtons very famously send for other a lot of fucking letters, right, But they are rich people who are almost nobility, right,
Speaker 2So that's why they're sending somebody. They know how to read and write. If you're an ordinary person, you fucking don't, and you can't send a message, but you might just send a word of mouth message. So like you know, you can say, oh, are you going to town? Yeah, okay, can you tell like Jane the chandler that I need you know, like what you know, like some kind of piece of gossip. But then you've got to like be willing for people to know your message. Right, So that's like that's the difference. So there's no privacy afforded.
Speaker 3Yeah yeah, yeah. Anything before trains was taken by a horse or by a donkey, I guess, by a very slow ox or by runners. That was how you did it. The uh, the Persians, we talked about the Royal Road. They had a they had a mail system called the chap ar Canay and that was just runners and horses
Speaker 3along the Royal Road. The Egyptians had courier systems, the Greeks had had runners who did it.
Speaker 1India Rome had.
Speaker 3The curses publicus. Like a lot of ancient societies that were empires did have these things. Because the imperial scale lends itself to needing an internal communication system, even if it's just for the nobility or the higher ups or the merchants or whoever. Like, if you don't have that, it's going to be a problem because how are you going to community if you rule Rome from Rome, how are you going to communicate with the Transoxyonia or Egypt
Speaker 3or where you know, you have to have something that can do that.
Speaker 1Yeah, in the Middle Ages it got.
Speaker 3Smaller scale in a lot of ways, but I mean then they made the same resurgence.
Speaker 2Uh.
Speaker 3You know when the Mongol Empire came. We've talked about the yam system a number of times. They they had to have that in order for it to function as it did.
Speaker 1And there you go.
Speaker 3And then in the early modern parier you get thurn in Taxis or whatever, I'm sorry, thurn und Texas in Germany, and yeah.
Speaker 1There you go.
Speaker 3It's a Maximilian the first. Yeah, so that's how you did the male. You didn't have any privacy. I mean in most countries you technically don't have a ton of privacy with your male now anyway, but we have the illusion of it.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Anyway, Miles, thank you very much for the question.
Speaker 1Next week got.
Speaker 3One from Gaffzi, who says, how did ideas of gendered work change during this transition from the Late Antique to medieval periods as well as over the course of the medieval era. Are there any surprises about what might be men's work or women's work, or any changes that you wouldn't have thought would be the case. I know Eleanor has has a number of examples before we did this. I just I wanted to include this one because I just wanted to talk about, like, we have a lot of ideas about gender working that is obviously true. There are obviously men who are like, I'm not doing that
Speaker 3because that's women's work, and there were women who were like, I can't do the same, you know, vice versus the same thing. However, when you live at the edge of a knife, when you when it's existential, uh, you do what you do if your husband is away on crusades, and you it's you and the kids. Then you are tilling the fields, you know, with and you're you're a woman, you're tilling, or you're you're figuring out something to do,
Speaker 3and you know.
Speaker 1That's how it goes. So for a lot of people.
Speaker 3Men's and women's work would have probably been somewhat amorphous blob of just things that have to get done. Now, some things might have been more coded towards women, as we might say, or men for that matter, and some things were completely off limits for like hunt not hunting, like.
Speaker 1War.
Speaker 3You know, it was very frowned upon, you know, for for a woman to go to war in most places back in the Middle Ages. But you know other things like you know, somebody, if you got to churn and your.
Speaker 1Wife is the and the doctor said that your the.
Speaker 3Physician said, your wife has on sickly or is on bed rest because she's nine and a half months pregnant or whatever, you got to churn that dog. Doesn't matter if it's women's work, you know, or you got to have a son who you can are a child who ohs, who's old enough that you can slough it onto anyway.
Speaker 1I'm sorry, eleanor go ahead.
Speaker 2Yeah, you're you're right. I suppose that the thing to understand that is, you know, it's kind of the true as is all kind of like gender discourse of whatever around work, is that it's much more likely to find women doing a quote unquote men's work than it is to find men doing quote unquote women's work. And so like a find example of this is on I believe it's the Third Crusade. Yeah, it's the Third Crusade where everybody decides that the reason every everything sucks and they're
Speaker 2all losing is because probably people are too sinful and having too much sex. So they expel all of the camp followers who are like the women who like do all the cooking and stuff like that, and they're like, except the washer women, we're not doing our own laundry.
Speaker 3Yeah, they're like, yeah, yeah, I.
Speaker 2Think they did it. I think they did. I'm yeah, yeah, you're right though, because I'm like yeah, damn. Like it's but it's like washer women are like the number one because the men are like, we'll figure out how to cook. I am not doing laundry right, Like, I'm not gonna.
Speaker 3We'll figure out how to cook we already know how to suck each other off. But I'll be goddamned if I'm doing if I'm doing fucking laundry.
Speaker 2Yeah, right, Like it's so fucking funny. Yeah, And so you do see that men, of course, I will probably take care of their children if their wife dies. It is likely you are going to try to get a female relative in to help out with that, and even more likely that you're going to remarry very quickly in order to kind of like get out of that. If you have like an old enough bunch of kids, it should be fine. But like that, that is certainly something that happens, whereas like women do like fucking everything and
Speaker 2then they've got to get back into the house. So it's more commonly. But they don't say, oh, this is women's work, that's men's work. They say this is inside work. That is outside work. And inside work is for the ladies. Outside work is for the men. Now a lot of the women's work that is inside work takes place outside, right, But like also it's just like bro during the harvest, everybody does everything. It's just all hands on deck. It's like you better get out in that fucking field. You better go, and we definitely see evidence of women working like men's what like quote unquote men's jobs and a
Speaker 2lot of places. You know, we definitely know that women are doing all the work that men are doing in guilds, and that's evidenced by the fact that when their husbands die, they're just expected to carry on the business, like you know that sort of a thing. You know, we've got records of women blacksmiths, We've got records of women guards, wet you know, we have all of these things.
Speaker 3So women blacksmith's got to be the hardest woman alive. Like everybody like, yeah, huge guns. And also like those guys are coming in there, like I'm going to take like I'm going to take this woman for a ride, and she's like listen, motherfucker. You know, just laying down the law. Yeah, because that's what you got to do.
Speaker 1Just yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah, Like I think that I believe that this bitch in question she worked at the Tower of London, so she's really cool. Hell yeah. Anyway, yeah, it is like uh, basically, you know, you're right, it's kind of like there's a lot of work to do.
Speaker 3Yeah, in general, you know, yeah, you got a lot of stuff to do.
Speaker 1You got a lot of.
Speaker 3A lot, a lot more things have to go on and get done every day than typically what what we have to do because we have a lot of machines and automation and things like that that that.
Speaker 1That make that easier.
Speaker 3But you know, it's it's the same thing as now like when uh, you know when uh, the eighties and nineties and and people you had to have families with two both parents working instead of just one parent doing it and stuff like that, and the women went out and they found jobs in the business world, which had been a male center.
Speaker 1Activity because that is what they.
Speaker 3Had to do, just like during the war, you know, during the war. You know, we all remember the stories from all over the world of you know, like women are doing this and women participated and they were soldiers and in you know, World War two, and.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean.
Speaker 3It's just the same stuff with patriarchy going all the way back, because it's like you have this thing where men are like, I'm not going to do that because it would be beneath me. And then you have some men who realize that they would rather live and be with.
Speaker 1You know, their wife or whatever.
Speaker 3Then then then die like holding onto the stupid ideal, and you know that's I mean, that's that's one of the things you get is people as the Middle Ages go on their crusades, there's more of that stuff happening. Wars, kick up, the Black Death and all that.
Speaker 1There are.
Speaker 3Fewer men around in a lot of places, and somebody has to pick up all that work.
Speaker 1It's got to get done.
Speaker 3Everybody's you know, got to have shoes made, gotta have beer brewed, gotta have money counting, you know, whatever it is, got to do it. And that's why you end up with all those female brewers in England in the later Middle Ages, or maybe even earlier than that. I can't remember specifically anyway. Yeah, some of this, like I really try, but like some of the stuff like just sort of like runs in at the end and I'm like, am I talking about England or India? Am I talking about Prague?
Speaker 3Or yeah, like Beijing, And I'm like, ah, how did I get that?
Speaker 1How did I get all that confused? In my head?
Speaker 3Those places aren't anywhere the same anyway. Yeah, Sie, thank you very much for the question. The idea of gendered work is of course foolish. All work is work. And we all have to do it to get by there are you know, some people are better some things than others because they're taller or whatever. But you know, for the most part, it's all got to be done, and you learn that book. I'm very this to me personally
Speaker 3is a thing because like I've been a stay at home dad for years now, and I mean that is first of all, because we're lucky enough. My wife makes very good money, and you know, I had to stop to take care of my daughter. She was very sick when she was born. But like, you know, you you get this stuff from men, like men finding out that I'm like a stay at home dad, instead of like being like, oh wow, you don't have to like go and like do a lot of this bullshit rat race stuff. You know that I have to do that I've been
Speaker 3complaining about this whole time, and instead it's.
Speaker 1Like, oh, you fucking pussy.
Speaker 3It's like, okay, man, cool, Like yeah, sure I was. I was gonna let my kid die, so so you wouldn't call me a pussy.
Speaker 1Good point, man, Yeah.
Speaker 3Stupid fuck yeah anyway, all right, I yeah, uh, the idea of gender work is stupid. My own personal complaints about this pale in comparison to thousands of years of patrion arkle mistreatment of women. But you know what, it's still fucking annoying anyway, and men should stop doing it and any women who also do it. But regardless, Gassie, thank you for the question. Next week got a block of questions about peasants running away, and I just noticed that we had a few, and a couple of follow
Speaker 3ups were added to them, So here we go, all right?
Speaker 1B Bailey says.
Speaker 3We often hear that runaway peasants or serfs could win their freedom if they made it to a city and live there for a year and a day without being captured by their lord's men and halt back to the manor. This sounds good and all, but how was this actually done? If I, as a peasant made it to York or Leads, for example, would I go somewhere to register to start the clock ticking? I would think that someone pursuing a runaway would thus simply have to check the town's registry to see if the target was there or did the peasant find just find lodging and employment, And you know then after a year someone vouched for them afterwards, How
Speaker 3was their new founder of freedom protected if someone found them and try to drag them back with a town of authorities intervened to stop them. You know what recourse did these freedmen have if any.
Speaker 2Yeah, so there's not gonna be records like yeah, like it's very very few places have full records of these old things. A lot of the time, if you made it to the city, you were fine. Yeah, like your lord probably doesn't have the resources to go hunting down every single peasant. Unfundamentally, they don't care that much. Like if you were one of like seven siblings who survived, they're gonna be like whatever, dog like, yeah, I do not care about this at all, you know. And so yeah,
Speaker 2basically you go find lodging in work, and then it's kind of like a vouching thing. If someone then did, in theory come and attempt to drag you off there, it would be like one of these things where you would start yelling and so it would come vouch for you. It would just be kind of like a hue and cry thing. But it is it is, you know. One of the reasons why they're like, oh, you better not do it is because it is kind of it's a well, it's kind of hard to run off because you have to like leave your family behind, right, like you can't really come back. And also you know, they catch you
Speaker 2pretty quickly most of the time. But then also like a lot of people don't want to write, like a lot of people are farmers or whatever, and like giving that up for being a manual laborer, which is kind of like the thing you can do in the city because like do you have an introduction with a guild, like you know, like we're you apprenticed anywhere? Probably fucking not. Like do you have the money for rent to set up a shop of some kind? Do you have the money set up like to get inventory? You probably don't. You're probably going to be a day laborer. And you know,
Speaker 2in places like fourteenth century prog that's great, that's going to really pay off of you for you, that's fine, But it's also quite expensive. We definitely know that from records that it's like an expensive to live in. So a lot of people aren't going to do it because they just don't have the cash. And you know, it's not like now it's not an industrialized world. It's not like like you're not just going to be able to rock up and get bar work. You know, there are no baristas, right, so it's like there aren't like low level jobs in that same way that aren't also backbreaking, right,
Speaker 2So it's not like a lot of people see a huge benefit in that, although many many people still actually, you know, cities are alluring places. People like cities. We know, for example, Paris exerts a huge draw on people. There's like lots and lots of very poor people in Paris that are like from England and shit, and they're like, oh, I just wanted to like see the big city and like they live over there, and you're like, yeah, so yeah, it's cool, cool, Yeah, it's really cool.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah so did.
Speaker 3Uh let me see, so like.
Speaker 1If they're.
Speaker 3Do we have any records of like runaway communities or like freedmen communities or I do like probably not the right word, but anything like that in any cities.
Speaker 2I mean, like the close the closest that we have is during the Black Death when everyone just leaves their plague village that is. But like also it ain't nobody like coming to.
Speaker 3Get you that nobody was counting peasants during the Black Death yeah, right, but.
Speaker 2It's like there there are definitely a lot of people who are like, Okay, fuck it, we're out, and they just like move because well, the town's no longer tenable. I'm not gonna stay here, so you and your neighbors go to whatever the closest bigger town is and you try to set up there. So certainly we do that. We do have that, you know, I guess the I mean probably the Eastern Roman lends. Once the Ottomans take over, you have big It's not just Constantinople, right, Like there's a there's a pretty big move there generally, but a
Speaker 2lot it's much more common to find city people moving into cities, like it's more common to find like burgers moving about, you know, like peasants. It's not just tied to the land because they are unfree, which they are. They're tied to the land because that's what they know, right, you know, and what they would want. I mean, if if they were going to move in an ideal world, they'd want a bigger farm, they would want more farm metals. That's the kind of thing that they would be looking for a lot more than you know, the city life where there they just don't have the wherewithal you know
Speaker 2a lot of the time.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, oh yeah, so b Bailey, Yeah, that's that's kind of the basics. Next final vowel asked about, you know, the idea of if you run away for a year and a day, you're free, And she asked, how's that counter proven? And you know, as we said, it's you know, basically someone comes out and vouches for you pretty much. But also had another question, how does one keep track
Speaker 3of peasants in practice? Because and I know this is anachronistic of me, but when I think of peasants, I think of the depictions of there are more depictions of like how slaves are treated, like with a master and stuff.
Speaker 1But like you, if you.
Speaker 3Are a lord with a large farm, do you just have men that do that and they just kind of like somebody kind of stays guard near like the peasant houses or like how does that work?
Speaker 2I guess, yeah, you have a bailiff, right, and the bailiff is usually gonna live in town. They've got like a nicer house and they're around now there. One of the things that is also true is there's usually a bit of a curfew, like usually you are, you were supposed to be in your fucking house at night because they don't want people creeping about, stealing things, getting drunk things like this. Partially the reason they don't want you doing that is because they want you working in the fields next morning.
Speaker 1M hm.
Speaker 2So that's cool. And uh So it's like they they are going to be in the town and they are going to be kind of like checking in on you to see that they know where you are, right, and so I think that like the bailiffs are kind of like the overseers in that way. Yeah right, yeah, And they're not going to beat you. They're just gonna be like, hey, John, where are you going? Yeah, you know, and then that'll be that'll be that right.
Speaker 1Like yeah.
Speaker 3So I mean like if you have records, and I mean I realized that not all lords were like extremely abusive in this way, but if you have like very abuse, if you have like a very abusive lord that like mistreats the peasants like is they're like, I mean, I assume there's not really any recourse to that at all, because like you're supposed to be there and that is what it is.
Speaker 2Yeah, Like you know it is it's harder for us. We're like, oh, well, surely they must all all wanted to run away, and like yeah, maybe, but it's like we just got to understand it's a really different world, right yeah, And like they don't really want to abandon their community, their family, everyone they've ever known a lot of the time.
Speaker 3Right, Yeah, it's different than like now, like if I like, even you know, very sheltered kids or people can have some idea of what like the big city near them is like, because if you go, like you know, if you have any kind of books or whatever or TV or anything like that, it's going to like vaguely describe it to you. But like back then, like I don't know, if you live like twenty miles from Paris, like and you're a peasant or you know, even a little further,
Speaker 3you're just like all you're gonna have is word of mouth. I mean, like, yeah, you're not probably not going to have been there very often unless you have to go to market or something, and they probably have a closer market to you.
Speaker 2Yeah exactly, And like yeah, and people like going to market, and they enjoy like going to town and stuff, and they probably like going home, you know.
Speaker 3Yeah, It's just it's a different thing because like all like I mean, now, like today, you know, we're like, oh, you know where I'm gonna, you know, gonna move. I might have to move for work, I might have to move for this or that or whatever. And like moving is pain in the ass. Don't get me wrong. I hate I hate moving more than I hate basically anything in the world. But like, we can do it, you know, a lot, a whole hell of a lot easier than they could, even even if it's still expensive. Regardless, we have a lot more ability to do it.
Speaker 2Yeah, Like, and because we've got the ability, we have the ability to think of it.
Speaker 3Right, Yeah, exactly. Yeah, Yeah, you're a mat broad Broadening your horizons is a real thing because it really it broadens the possible scope. It broadens the scope of what's possible in your head. And yeah, when when you know more about Paris or London or you know, wherever, it's a lot easier to justify going there than not.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Uh.
Speaker 3Then we had a follow up that was kind of building on the fact that they there weren't a ton of records for this stuff. Uh so, uh, Pearl Riverflow says, I've been thinking about medieval tax assessment myself. How much How did they know how much you've got to take a chunk of uh?
Speaker 2Like literally they will come a look at your shit, right. Uh, It's like they know about they know about what you're growing, they know how many cows you have and all of that shit. Because again, like that's the bailiff's job, right, Like the bailiff knows what people have. Now you by could hide it. People do, like peasants will try to like hide what they've got or like intentionally like they'll bring you like the most rubbish sheep or whatever. Yeah,
Speaker 2if they can, and that kind of a thing, Like I think you like like this is something more Sometimes like like it said that, they'll be like, oh they've got like you know, a secret spot in the loft or something where they will hide things. But yeah, yeah, as a general rule of them, again it's the bailiff. He's just around and he knows what's because that's his job is knowing things.
Speaker 3Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And then lastly, for the subtle block of questions, dog God said, related question, how did the tax rate adjust for bad harvest, natural disasters or devastation by armies and the answer is, I believe, very very slowly.
Speaker 2Yeah, Like, I mean, that's that's fundamentally right, is that you just gotta understand and nothing is happening in the way that it does now, and everything is just like molesses baby, like you. I guess that the way that things tend to work is on cycles, and it's like cyclical, right, so you'll just be like, oh, yeah, like now is the time of the taxiting or whatever the shit, Like
Speaker 2now is the time of like you know, when things are moving around, and there are times of year when things happen more quickly in times of year when things happen more slowly. It's much more likely that stuff is going to get done in May than in January. Yeah, Like, and so you have to take weather into account of everything. You've got to take into account like whether or not other people are doing other things, like do they have time to look into it? Right? And the answer is a lot of times people don't. Yeah, And like I
Speaker 2guess I guess that's the thing to sort of keep in mind. We have so much more free time right than they ever did. So it's sort of like, ugh, can someone look into it? Does that make sense? I don't know.
Speaker 3Yeah, no, no it does. It makes cito sense. Yeah, it's uh, it's like somebody, yeah, someone's like, hey, so what are we doing.
Speaker 1They're like, oh, not this again?
Speaker 3Oh no, no, I don't oh god, not text season again.
Speaker 1And the bailiffs out there.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, just a pain in the ass. It was probably spread around pretty quick like hey, the bailiffs out Hey, you're like, fuck, not again.
Speaker 1Didn't I give you a ship?
Speaker 2It's like they're like, but if they're like the bailiffs out and you're you're like out in the field with the fucking oxen, how are you gonna get back to town? Ask yourself? You know. So it's like it's one of these things that you have to just always be on guard. You gotta be on guard.
Speaker 3You gotta like be stashing mm hmmm.
Speaker 2Because like where where are you at the time? Are you compassing? Yea these things to know?
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, yeah, the answer is, uh, you know it's uh. They assessed taxes, like you know, the Supreme Court assesses pornography. You know it When you see it, you're just like, well, there's all your sheep, Okay, yeah, there it is. And if you were if you're able to hide like a really prized went back. You know, you win. If you don't, then you don't. You know, that's you know as it. I think I'll be honest, Having worked in tax law,
Speaker 3I think it's how a lot of people treat taxes today too, Like you don't you can not pay and there and there are people who do not pay taxes for a long time and and it doesn't bother them. But you know, if they find out, you have.
Speaker 1To pay the piper.
Speaker 3That's always how it is anyway, and one you have to pay them in one way or the other. Anyway, Thanks everyone for those questions. Uh, you know, it's nice to have related questions bouncing off of others.
Speaker 1Uh.
Speaker 3Next, we got one from vest and trunkless tozy, she says, looking at my cast iron pen and asking myself did medieval people season their cauldrons before using them.
Speaker 1To brew a potion or stew?
Speaker 3Did everything they cook have a slight copper slash iron slash ten taste because they didn't have access to stainless steel.
Speaker 2I mean they got one fucking pot, bruh.
Speaker 3So like that you're gonna be tasted. You can be tasting a little a little pot in it.
Speaker 2Yeah, you're gonna be tasting the pot, you know. I think, uh, like, I mean kind of, I think that Basically, it's like there's a difference with the cauldron is like that shit seasons really quickly because it's in a fucking fire. Yeah, right, like it's in a fire. And we do know that they like when they're washing things like this, a lot of the time they are like with those they'll maybe use sand to scrub them and things like that.
Speaker 3Probably they're using oh that is a good idea.
Speaker 2They'll be like scrubby scrub, scruby scrub. Yeah, they don't have steel wool. But like you know, also so for example, what I use on my iron because I'm a fucking g is I've got like a thing of mail like chain mail and.
Speaker 3Yeah yeah yeah you know wait real chain mail.
Speaker 2Yeah it works super well. It's like it's oh yeah, yeah, it's a kitchen implement, right, So they got like that's what they're using. So it's like it's not steel wooly in that same way. But also we definitely know they clean things like with kind of like you know, we would like, uh, rock your salt and things like that. If you've got it if you're like a king, that's what they'll be using.
Speaker 3But yeah, yeah, yeah, I mean, look, you know, uh, we all know that. I mean, it is better to season some pans, especially cast iron pans, before you use them. However, uh, the act of cooking things does also serve as a way to season them. It doesn't always have the same overall effect, but it can. As Eleanor is saying, they use some kind of metal implement to do that. That's definitely going to season it and get some of the excess surface material off of there so that doesn't end
Speaker 3up in you know, your perpetual.
Speaker 1Stew or whatever.
Speaker 3And yeah, that's awesome, Like that's they use sand. That's so fucking cool. Like I mean, of course they did, because somebody would be like, hey that you know, that shit's really coarse, and I can use it to you know, it's course and rough and it gets everywhere blah blah blah, and you and I can use that to you know, as effectively sandpaper essentially, and that's really cool. But I mean, of course we all do know that they then took their cast iron pans and then put them in their medieval dish dishwashers. And turn them on high, you know,
Speaker 3because that's how you're supposed to treat a cast iron pan by putting it in the dishwasher.
Speaker 2Yeah, do that immediately, everybody.
Speaker 3Yeah, my mom just beating this ship out of me with a lodge like caster, and like, what the hell is I've raised you better than like, Okay, okay, I'm sorry.
Speaker 1It's just a.
Speaker 3Joke, mom, It's a joke from like five years ago that nobody thinks it's funny anymore. Anyway, Uh hey, side note you Okay, Yeah, I'm fine.
Speaker 2Yeah, sorry, I'm like, I just having a little it's just the migraine brain.
Speaker 1No, No, it's fine. I think I think I.
Speaker 2Should probably put my sunglasses on.
Speaker 3No, you're I just I think there's a hiccup in uh the.
Speaker 2Oh it might be it might be my internet. My internet has been a little laggy today.
Speaker 3Okay, that's yeah, okay, because yeah, yeah it does. But it was like I said something and you was just like yeah, I think, and then you went and then you went, oh yeah, and I was like, did I say something wrong?
Speaker 2Yeah? No, it's probably an internet deal, bab, it's an internet deal.
Speaker 3Well I'll delete this anyway. I'm just making sure. Yeah, I asked the chunkle tozies.
Speaker 1Thank you for the question.
Speaker 3Uh, next week got one from web for Australia is a kangaboo.
Speaker 2Now, Jesus Christ, I can't get any peace around here. But also that one's really good.
Speaker 3Did medieval people themselves have a stereotype of bards being horny and cowardly or is that something that came later? And if so, how did it come about?
Speaker 2I mean like it's certainly yeah horny, yeah, oh yeah for sure. Yeah, like because they're writing horny ship, you know, like they're like this is horny shit, and like you know, they're like the rock stars of the time.
Speaker 3Yeah, your songs are all body fableau like yeah, they're and.
Speaker 2They're like going town to town almost certainly bagging bagging high hydraw ass, you know, cowardly less so cowardly less. So I mean like the there is like certainly you know, the o hoho like artistry, but it's like I mean maybe knights who have their fucking panties in a bunch because their fair ladies want to fuck this guy, right, would be like you kill. But also like there's a monopoly on violence. Right, there's a monopoly on violence by
Speaker 2the nightly class, and these guys are not necessarily drawn from the nightly class. Now, you got examples where that isn't true. So for example, sorry, Migraine, brain, I forget eleanor Vaquitaine's grandfather's name. He wrote, he.
Speaker 3Wrote William the eleventh. It's either the ninth or Eleventhitaine.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, there you go. There you go.
Speaker 1Before the ex or after one way or another.
Speaker 2Yeah, so he rights Chanson certainly. And and no, and what you're gonna go tell the duke he's a coward? Absolutely not. So I think it tends to be like that's more of our own modern crisis of masculinity and you know, being like oh the fay artsy person and they just don't have that at all, like a real night, a true night, like we have the whole books where it's like every duke or whatever has to has to bring in their own song, right, And that's how you
Speaker 2know that, like you were, a true night is because like you can also you can also sing a little song. You can you can sing a little ditty. So no less so is the answer, uh, pervert, yeah, coward, no, yep.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, yep, not not until later would they become I don't know, cowardly, probably not. You know, Uh, it takes it takes a lot of a lot of courage to uh write a song about fucking some woman in the ass and then play it in front of their husband.
Speaker 2So true.
Speaker 3Not gonna lie anyway. Yeah, we frustrating, Kanka, but thank you very much for the question. We got three more. Next is one west End robbery who says, what's up with donkeys? Was there a big market for them? Who's making them? Why would I want a donkey instead of a horse? Did they have cool designer donkey breeds?
Speaker 2Uh, they do have cool designer donkey breeds. There's all sorts of different kinds. Shout out donkeys. I love those little guys. My family had one who was a mammoth jackass who that's the big lads And his name was Edgar, and I loved him very much. And the reason you have a donkey and not a horse is you can't afford no horse, right.
Speaker 3Also, donkeys can carry different things, yeah, and move differently.
Speaker 2Yeah, donkeys move differently. So it's like when you have a donkey, you don't really ride donkeys. So much despite what I just said, which was highly amazing. You they're pack animals, right, They're like a lama or you know, they are like they're they're like an alpaca. So if you are a peasant and you've got to move some fairly heavy goods, like say you got to take like a couple sacks of oats into the next village, you throw them on the back of the donkey and you just walk over there, right you And I can't stress
Speaker 2this enough. You don't have a horse like horsies like the horses that you have, Like maybe you have a couple that pull a cart, but what if you don't have so much goods to get in the cart, but you want to just like you know, you're just like you're popping too the market town. That's what you use the donkey for. And you also use donkeys for crossbreeding with horses in order to get mules to have like a bigger one. And oftentimes it's more common that people will have mules pulling their carts than horses because again, horses are at a premium. So yeah, it's it's basically
Speaker 2like it is the hoofed animal that peasants can owned and also they're very cute and I love them very much.
Speaker 3As it was explained to me, donkeys are the middle road between the ox, which is strong and slow, and the horse, which is fast, still strong, but not as strong. And this is middle This is the middle road between them, the extremely extremely grumpy middle road when.
Speaker 1It doesn't want to do anything.
Speaker 3Yeah, and Eleanor mentioned mules. Mules are when you breed a donkey with the horse. And mules are slightly bigger than donkeys, or in some cases a decent size bigger.
Speaker 1But they are all.
Speaker 2They're all intersect they're all infertile.
Speaker 3Yeah, they're all but yeah, they're all bare and so yeah, you can't mules can't breed. What a tragic life. But yeah, it's Uh, donkeys were used for all sorts of things. They were used all over. They were domesticated six thousand ish years ago, probably Nubia. They're all descendants of the African wild horse. Yeah, I mean that's Eleanor gave you you know, the specifics of it. This is just kind of the deep background stuff. But yeah, they were, they
Speaker 3were an offshoot that we domesticated. And there are despite what you might think, there are feral donkeys. You will see them occasionally, not a ton, but you know it does happen.
Speaker 1Uh, and yeah they are they're they're they're.
Speaker 3An unheralded helper of civilization. You know, the horse and the ox did that. Well, so did the donkey. Yeah, but anyway, Western robbery, thank you for the question. Uh man, I love that you had a donkey, but I am not surprised, and I think you've told me that.
Speaker 2Yea, yeah, I love a little donkey. I love a little donkey moment, you know.
Speaker 1Yeah, do you how long did they live?
Speaker 3A long time?
Speaker 2I don't know they are but like eventually, like we were only renting the place we lived where we had the donkey, so uh, we had to get rid of him when it got sold, unfortunately. And he the one time when your family said he went to live on a farm, he did go live on a farm. You know.
Speaker 1Oh, well that's good.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, but we loved that her even though he was a fucking nuisance. I'll tell you what donkeys really they are woof.
Speaker 3They will steal your food, they will kick you.
Speaker 1Just because they aren't feeling it. That day, he was.
Speaker 2Constantly breaking out of the yard. It was like that was his whole deal. He was in love with a pony who lived down the street, like he just wanted to go see her all the time. Basically, so, yeah.
Speaker 1Feel I feel you. He's like, can we make mules together?
Speaker 3And she's like, uh no, I mean we've all been there, brother, Yeah, we've all been there.
Speaker 1Brother. All right.
Speaker 3We got one from bachan Alia lover sixty nine?
Speaker 1Who said to what?
Speaker 3To what extent did Hungary participate in what we present what we in the present day would recognize as medieval European cultural practices? Did Hungary have knights? Did they write chivalric romances and make Arthuriana? O?
Speaker 1See?
Speaker 3If so, how did these practice practices graft onto or blended to the step Nomad and Slavic traditions already present?
Speaker 2Uh yeah yeah, Like by the time you get to the late medieval period, they're just kind of like a type right, Like there are specific there's specific things going on over in Hungary, just in the way that there are specific things happening everywhere. But I mean, let us be so for fucking real, Like, you know, you have an aristocracy that is just like the same group of fucking guys, Like by the time Sigismund is on the throne for God's sake, Like that's Charles the fourth Son, right like yeah, like calm yourself, Like he's the fucking
Speaker 2holy Roman emperor, you know, and he starts out a citizen of Hungary, right, So that like it is certainly within this same cultural context by the later Middle Ages, and you know, a lot of the records are still just written in fucking sorry English, Jesus Christ. A lot of the records are still written in Latin. Like you don't you can you can just becall me yourself, you know, Like it's it's only really secondary literature that you see that's written in Hungarian. I'm sure that perhaps lords are
Speaker 2writing to each other in Hungarian, but less so. They do have more issues obviously with getting attacks from step noble nobles, from step nomen. They certainly have more issues when like the Ottomans start coming about and that sort of a thing. But they are just a type of European, right, Like they're not even fucking like orthodox bro Like they're.
Speaker 3Yeah, like those Catholics, yeah yeah, regular old Catholics. Yeah. By the late Medieval period it was fairly similar. There were some differences we talked a little bit about in the Land Management series because of when Christianity, and more specifically when like the so system that came the manorial system that came along with that, entered Hungary a bit later. But yeah, it started to Christianize around the eleventh century.
Speaker 1Now, before that, it was.
Speaker 3They had or the folkloric religion before Christianity there is said to have been like Tingrism, which is I've talked about the Mongols. They worshiped the sky god Tingri and that was very, very common for many nomadic peoples and they got this from the Avars, and I mean their religious and folklore significance was built around that. It had a lot more in common with step nomads than it
Speaker 3did with Europe. But then there was a guy called Andrew I who was a king, and he was a king in the mid eleventh century there and he was he basically went on a destruction spree and had them destroy all of the what do you call pagan idols and all that and sort of helped really christianize Hungary. But yeah, they you know, they had an Arthur of course was not Arthur, but they had Hunor and Magor who were their way of understanding their history was how
Speaker 3do we explain who the Huns are? And how do we explain who the Magyars are? And they came up with or hun Or and magor.
Speaker 1Yeah, so.
Speaker 3You know, that's that's just kind of how it is.
Speaker 1They The thing.
Speaker 3About folklore is that, ever, not everybody writes arthurianna. In fact, most of them don't. But everybody has their own version of Arthuriana. They have their own local, regional, and national myths and all that sort of stuff. Yeah, so that is Hungary.
Speaker 1It was like.
Speaker 3It was like the rest of Europe in a lot of ways. Their nights became extremely famous, especially under like King Matthias and all that Matthias Corvinus the Raven and all that sort of stuff.
Speaker 1But I believe he was, Yeah, he was told.
Speaker 3He was just just at the beginning of the early modern period regardless. Yeah, they had a history with all that.
Speaker 1So yeah, it was it did blend a lot.
Speaker 3But I'm unfortunately they when they Christianized, they did a real thorough cleansing of all of it, and you know, not a ton of it survives. But yeah, that is that's hungry back and all you lover, Thank you very much for the question. Last we got one from girl Boss Woman, who says certain modern historians these days take a rather dim view about the historicity of certain well known stories, for example, King Arthur, the Trojan War, Moses,
Speaker 3et cetera. However, conversely, we've also seen modern historians reconsider the value and transmissibility of human knowledge that is preserved through oral traditions and then are eventually written down centuries later. Are modern historians ready to reconsider and reevaluate the broader historicity of all oral traditions that even if events described are not exactly word for word true, they still are a part of a corpus of truth and aren't just wholesale, whole cloth fictional inventions. Of course, if I have this completely wrong, please let me know. However, I've recently fought
Speaker 3on line with people that disputed the existence of a Trojan War, which makes me believe that the word is not yet out about oral traditions. Yeah, I think, well, no, you go first, go Well, I was going to say, I think there are two things to look at here. I think we have to take the different stories by what they are trying to tell and think about the historicity from that. So, like you mentioned King Arthur, let's
Speaker 3just take these examples King Arthur. We have a very rich textual history of the way that the author myth, the Arthur myth has evolved from Welsh stories up to a British you know, foundation myth, to chivalric you know whatever, to what the Arthur ayanna that we have now.
Speaker 1And the thing about Arthur is that.
Speaker 3The reason no one thinks there's an Arthur is because there's no or the reason that that most historians, the consensus is that an Arthur didn't exist is because no one really nothing really fits that. And we can kind of see in this case, you can kind of see how the sausage was made because the English and the English wrote so much of this stuff down going back, you know, they have a rich tradition of literacy and writing things down going all the way back to the Romans,
Speaker 3and they beat of course and all that sort of stuff. But you know, we can see that, so we see how the sausage was made and how it went from like myth to fable to deep lore to just whatever a brand now sort of. Yeah. The Trojan War, on the other hand, most people thought it was completely mythical, But there were some people who were like, yeah, you know, maybe this place called Troy did happen. Because a lot of the stuff that's described in there in in Homer's
Speaker 3works is it has been core, it has been aligned with archaeological evidence. For example, the Boris tusk helmentt was like a big thing that was found and uh, it would have been hundreds of years before the people who were writing under the name Homer lived and so them knowing about so that that did contain some truth to it. And then we have of course found a city in Anatolia that likely was what we call Troy, and you
Speaker 3know they probably fought the uh the Mycenaeans or some other Greek Anatolian group, and that became the basis for all.
Speaker 1Of this, uh, for all of that.
Speaker 3So that has some truth to it, but is a lot of fables and and obviously like mythologic, mythological and uh you know religious uh stuff tacked onto it.
Speaker 1Moses. Uh.
Speaker 3The reason that most historians don't think that the Torah, the first five books of the of the Old Testament as we call it, are historically accurate, is because most almost none of that lines up with anything we've ever found. The Jews were not the historical Jews were not enslaved by the Egyptians to work on the pyramids. There are
Speaker 3very few, if any archaeological records outside that that say that even say that they that the Jews, that there would have been Jews who were enslaved by the Egyptians at all. That does not mean Jews were not mistreated or anything like that. That just means that, you know, the that the early part of the Bible is is you know, it's a loure, it's myths, that is what it is. And so there's there's no records for a guy named Moses or anything like that, and so you know, that's.
Speaker 1How that works.
Speaker 3But there are records for things that happened later in the Old Testament, like there's a record of of course Nebukinezer and Cyrus the Great, and these are all historical figures that we know. So you have to kind of take good with the bad. Yeah, And I mean, I think the other thing that we're seeing now with modern historians reconsidering the value of oral traditions, I think that has a lot to do with us figuring out that we should listen to what indigenous people have to stay and that their oral traditions can have the exact same
Speaker 3amount of truth in them as say the story as say, the story of the Trojan War does or you know, First Kings says about you know, the ancient Babylonians or Persians or whoever it is. And yeah, I think that is. And we've actually from from from listening to that and figuring that out and applying that to everyone instead of just the Western subjects that we'd like or think about. I think that's given us a much greater understanding, you know,
Speaker 3specifically of native peoples in the Americas and in Australia. I've talked a lot Eleanor you're a modern historian, please.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean I think that that there is a difference also in terms of our interest in non non literary sources, so oral traditions when people don't have any literary tradition it all right, So if you never fucking wrote stuff down, then probably your oral traditions are going to be where the fuck it's at, my friend right and there there are real you know, it's a really
Speaker 2respected way of giving information, learning information, retaining information. When you have a literary culture oftentimes. No, I'm not trying to do down my my homie, theery literate, which was most of everybody. But if there was like some truth quote unquote to the story of King Arthur, well we have a literary culture. It's right, Like, Babes, it is so not possible for like an entire Christian kingdom to exist,
Speaker 2like after the retreat of the Romans, and like, I mean, I think that there is a misunderstanding also on the part of you know, average people in terms of Arthurian. It's like when all this ship was supposed to be taking place, right, because it's like, Babe, the empire hasn't even christianized yet by the time the Romans leave Britain, Like, what the fuck do you mean that? Like Arthur, Like, there aren't castles, bra We like the Normans are the ones who introduced stone castles, right and if you and that, yeah,
Speaker 2right exactly, and like and you can change, like there's no concept of chivalry. There's no such thing as a motherfucking knight, right, like it's and and that's fine, Like there's nothing wrong with that, and certainly you know that's the the way it is. But also I wouldn't relate to Arthur Eanna as a in oral tradition at all, you know. And you know, I suppose certainly we do. See, Like, I mean, one thing, I will shout out the great flood myth, which is interesting in that every single culture worldwide wide is like remember that time it flooded?
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean, that's the That's the other thing about the about the first five books of the Old Testament, Like I'm not trying to be like an epic atheist here, but the number of stories that are written there that are copies or riffs or adaptations of existing story of stories that had already existed in the world in other cultures is very, very very high. The story of Moses, you know, being saved in the basket was a common story.
Speaker 1I believe it was also told about, like Sargon of.
Speaker 3A cod the flood myth as Eleanor mentioned. The Epic of Gilgam has that and that was written a long time before, you know.
Speaker 1So that's another thing.
Speaker 3It's like, how much of this is just like them borrowing, which happened everywhere. But at the same time, that doesn't make it a historical record.
Speaker 2Yeah, And I mean, I'm more likely to because we see, you know, we certainly see like worldwide global cultures talk about the Great Flood. I'm like, okay, so that probably happened, right, but probably you know, Noah didn't have anything to do with it, right, So you know, it seems like this is where we do a lot of cross checking. So you know, for example, in my part of the world, in the Pacific Northwest, right, like we have certainly found that, like I believe it's a Telinget myths, well t Linget
Speaker 2oral culture which talks about the last time there was a really big tsunami and earthquake also lines up with dendro chronological things within trees. And also we have like fossilized forests which date back to the same time that they're talking about, right, So we know we can cross reference those things. That's something that we can do like cross cross referencing and say, okay, well this oral culture is absolutely right. They're bang on right, Like we know that that is when the last big fucking earthquake happened.
Speaker 2But you cannot do that with the Bible because that shit ain't real. You cannot do that with the our theory on it because it's not real. And also what I think is kind of interesting for our our way of looking at the world is medieval people weren't like the Bible's real in that way. They were they when you look at a medieval Bible, when you look at the gloss, it's like, here's how you interpret that. That's what this means, here's how to like all of these things mean this. Here are these ways of thinking about it.
Speaker 2They're not saying this is a literal truth. The idea that it's a literal truth is like a very It's like a Protestant right, Like this idea that is like whatever is the Bible is one hundred percent correct. And you know, evil people didn't think King Arthur was real. Yeah, like he's a legend, and they understand what a legend is, right, And I think to a certain extent, we do the people of the past a disservice and and like the concept of literature and disservice, you know, like a myth,
Speaker 2for example, a myth doesn't mean a lie. Sometimes the way that we use a myth myth is we say that that that isn't true. Myth means that it's a story that has been created in order to explicate, yeah, a situation now, right, and so it's just a way of getting your head around how society is currently working. Right, So keep keep that in mind and you will have a better time with all of this. I think, yeah. But also you know, yeah, I think the oral tradition,
Speaker 2you know, it takes a different kind of training than I have. It's incredibly fucking cool. I love all of my homies who are doing it. I am not equipped to do it because I just have a good trained you know.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think yeah, I think with like, we just kind of smash everything together, not not even intentionally, but we smash all of these historical things together. And so an oral tradition becomes the same thing as a myth, which comes the same thing as folklore, which you know, in some cases becomes the same thing as religion, and and you know, it just spools out all into this stuff. But you know, like we can see how the Arthurian,
Speaker 3the myth of Arthur, We can see how that came about, and and that the people that they understood is like, Okay, I'm trying to tell this story about the history of whatever. I mean you Jeffrey of Mammoth's version was like, no, we're gonna get back to the historical truth of it. He was a Roman guy and blah blah, and you're just like, Okay, sure, man, what like he's trying to give it of the near of this. But they, I mean, I seriously, it doesn't seem like they believed that to be like a literal thing, and I mean Thomas Mallory
Speaker 3certainly didn't when he uncame his version. Yeah. The only other thing I'll say is like, I think that we have to read these things the way that they were written and the way that they were intended to be written, and then we pull out from them what we can And.
Speaker 1This is something that.
Speaker 3A lot of historians, not a lot, but some historians still don't do that well. And like, it wasn't until the early nineteen hundreds that historians in the West and specifically in England really started to understand how to look at stories from the past. And a guy who was really big on helping people with that was J. R. R. Tolkien because he, despite being the Lord of the Rings guy to us, was one of the foremost and most
Speaker 3influential medievalists to ever live, and he spent years at salons and talks and campuses telling other historians, no, you're reading Beowulf wrong, because they were reading it as and critiquing it the way that they critiqued stories in nineteen hundred or whatever year it was, and they were not reading it as having been written by someone a thousand years before or whenever exactly it was written. They were
Speaker 3reading it like, oh, well, why don't they use the same kind of iambic pentameter that we use? Why don't they do this or that? And Tolkien's going, how the fuck could they do that? You morons? They lived a millennia ago. That type of iamic pentameter was an invenental blob. And he has to do this, and there he's so frustrated and so annoyed. He's just like a he's like an exhausted guy trying to do this. And now, of course he and they did not extend the same kind of idea to every oral tradition they could for the
Speaker 3most part, probably didn't give a shit about non Western ones. But now we understand that this is the correct way to read this. And I've talked about it before, but like the seventeen hundred Cascadia earthquake, is something that we know that happened in the Pacific northwest of America, but there's no contemporaneous records of it. However, in two thousand and five, a seismologist named Ruth Ludwin just collected all of these anecdotes from First Nations groups in Canada about what happened and drew from the who I ought the Macaw,
Speaker 3the hoe, the Quillute, the Iraq, and the Duwamish, and I apologize if I fucked you need those up and you're.
Speaker 2Right well done.
Speaker 3Was able, thank you, and was able to come down on that a series of earthquakes and a short span caused a number of saltwater floods, and using other data and points in those stories, was able to land on a midpoint of basically seventeen oh one, which is what our scans and indicators say it should have happened right around seventeen hundred. So like this woman used this stuff in two thousand and five to like to come up with a historical date, an actual historical date for this
Speaker 3earthquake that we had only kind of been like, yeah, it happened around seventeen hundred. Now it's like we think pretty well that it happened in seventeen oh one or thereabouts, and it's like that's yeah, that's what you can do when you don't just throw all this stuff out and say, oh, yeah, it's all hogwash, like I mean, yeah, their story of the thunderbird in the whale. That earthquake was not caused by a thunderbird in a whale, but that's how they told the story, and it was just one of their myths or you know, or one of their.
Speaker 2Yeah, myth is the thing because the myth is explicating. It's the store that they used explicated thing that they demonstrably saw happen, right, yeah, like that's how myths.
Speaker 3Work, right yeah, yeah, yeah, so yeah that is. That's going to do it for us today. I hope you enjoyed it. If you want to ask us these types of questions, please do subscribe to the Patreon. Other than that, eleanor what's going on with you?
Speaker 2Ah yeah, great fucking question. If you haven't checked out my show that's on History hit do that I'm singing a song about and hey, that's pretty cool. I have a got I think that's pretty much the major thing that is going on. I don't know if you're in the UK, I guess the week this is coming out. I'm at Chalk Valley History Festival if you want to check that out. They're all weak. Yeah, that's the major
Speaker 2thing I'm doing right now, trying to stay sane and not have any more migraines. Yeah, that's what's up. Find me being adorable on socials at Going Medieval.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, you can find me.
Speaker 3Luca's amazing wherever you know, wherever on social media you happen to be, and you can find me. I'll show people's sistory of the Old Republic if you want to hear me yap about Star Wars anyway. Yeah, thank you all very much for listening, and we'll see you next time.
they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...
folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very...
folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!
folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...
The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...