Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

We're Not So Different

We're Not So Different artwork

March Mailbag

Mar 4, 20261 hr 17 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

folks, we had take a short break from our Medieval Land Management series due to some scheduling complications (don't worry, it will continue next week) and so we did a mailbag instead. we usually do at least one mailbag episode a month to catch up on the mountain of questions we have from patrons. if you want to ask us questions, please subscribe for just $5 a month. this time, we cover everything from cobblestone streets to cadaver synods to the Florentine Vice to Gilles de Rais, Medieval beach trips, performative masculinity maxxing, and more.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1I left my dog in Dubai, I left my heart in the gutter. You know, I'm just thinking about all the real casualties that this war with Iran. Yeah, white people's talks.

Speaker 2Oh yeah, well, I mean, you know, we finally decided to go to war was the wrong and uh yeah that's great.

Speaker 1I'm sure there's gonna be no consequences for this.

Speaker 2None as far as I know. I've been told reliably that blowback is a dead concept.

Speaker 3It's so good.

Speaker 1Uh, it's reminding me of that old onion point counterpoint. Yeah, you know this, what is it? This war will destabilize the entire Middle East region and set off a global shock weight of antim reorganism versus no, it won't. Yeah, classic classic of the genre.

Speaker 2Yeah it's uh yeah, good job, good job. I don't. I mean, I think the only thing to say is that this is going to blow up in America's face. It's going to blow up in Israel's face. It's going to blow up anyone who's anyone who supports this. They're already seeing the blowback from it. More as more Israelis have died uh in this than in any bombing campaign

Speaker 2in decades. Americans are dying. American bases all over the Mediterranean and Middle Eastern North African world are being hit, and uh yeah, it's you get, we get what we fucking deserve. Like that is like I don't I don't know anybody else to say it, Like, of course I don't want the bad things to happen to like innocent Americans or innocent Brits or anything like that, but in

Speaker 2the state. But in but by the same token, like are any of us in the imperial cores really innocent of these things? Like our everything in our lifestyle is burnished by this. It has been. And I'm not saying that like we are all like individually war criminals, but like you know this, if you're this, this is the this is the only way that imperialism can't conclude. And

Speaker 2it's like with the it's it's trying to like wipe out these enemies that we've had since like nineteen seventy nine or nineteen fifty three or whatever, because they had to kill Mosaday and then you know, there was the coup in seventy nine and and like, oh, you know, we just have this like all out vengeance idea that we're just going to get to Iran and take it down. And it's like Iran is more militarily capable than Iraq and Afghanistan were at any point combined. Like it like

Speaker 2it's I.

Speaker 1Would worry about it, Luke, I would just not worry about that.

Speaker 2I mean, it's on the one hand, like you're just like absolutely dumbfounded by it. And on the other hand, it's like, I mean no, yeah, that makes total sense, Like it makes total sense that like, uh, the like the world bestriding colossus and this remorra that's somehow helping guide our fucking foreign and domestic policy that we have

Speaker 2is our this like, oh, we can do anything we want, Like can we?

Speaker 1I mean, I mean we can, but not without consequence, I suppose is what we ought to realize. I mean, like I think that this is the thing there is there is a fundamental disconnect with our rulers where they because they don't experience consequences, they think nobody experiences consequences. Yeah, and that's what it comes down to. I mean, I would like to read a really great excerpt from the

Speaker 1Financial Times, the only newspaper I really read anymore. Would you like to hear this? I would just to go back to the desert of Dubai is being bombed, all right, yeah, okay. An executive at a large global hedge fund with a presence in Dubai said, quote, we have been exploring how to evacuate people, but it's not easy. Unquote, he added quote it's pretty scary. This is going to have implications for some of my guys. The trade was not that you were going to that you were getting exposed to geopolitics when moving to Dubai. It was not a consideration.

Speaker 1People have moved families. This element of concern is new, and that's the thing right.

Speaker 2In all of this.

Speaker 1At the core of it is this idea that the ruling elite, like whether that be Americans or you know, people who live in Dubai or whoever it is that benefits from the violent nogemity of America in the world, will not be exposed to geopolitics. So geopolitics is something that happens to other people.

Speaker 2Right, is the most like you should they should put that on the fucking book jacket for the uh the fukiyama the the end of history shit like that, like that is the most end of history shit, like how how was I supposed to know that I would be exposed to global geopolitics by moving to the city built on slaves in the middle of nowhere that is basically only kept afloat by like uh foreign oligarchs, uh slave

Speaker 2labor and uh, I don't know, let's say, the worldwide military industrial complex and oil like what what are we uh?

Speaker 1Like, what do you mean?

Speaker 2Might be the most the least self aware human being in history?

Speaker 1Whoever says it's like all of it is just the most geopolitics that anywhere can possibly be. But then being like nah, dog, I wonder who that's for.

Speaker 2The idea of going into anywhere, like anywhere in the Middle East. One thing I can always remember, even from childhood, is that anything in the Middle East is always geopolitics, always because it's where the it's where there's so much oil. And like we have we've set up all of these like insane things to like get at the oil and keep the oil and blah blah blah. And so you have like the House of Soud, and you have like I mean, clearly Israel, you have like all of these

Speaker 2uh golf monarchs, you know, and and and the rise of the Petro dollar and everything like that. And it's like, if you go to the Middle East, that is geopolitics because if America goes away, the entire region is just gonna like go like it's gonna break apart in some various ways because we keep a lot of those states and ship like we hold them up. And it's just like, yeah, I don't know, well, I mean like if America goes

Speaker 2away tomorrow, what happens to the Saudiast? Like how do they question a force? How? Like yeah, they've got bombers, they've got jets, but like who, like who's who's still funding them? Where? Like who is protecting them? Who is like keeping all of the other Golf states and and and Middle Eastern states who have vendettas against them just basically all of them, including Israel, Like what's to stop

Speaker 2them from just immediately attacking like the Saudist if we go away, Like and it's like I didn't know I'd have to face geopolitics if I went to the Middle East. You're fucking fucking brilliant man.

Speaker 1Just so good. I just love I simply love to see it. I don't think that there will be any repercussions and yeah, it's another beautiful day in the global hedgemon. What can I say?

Speaker 2Mm hmm fantastic. Um cool, Let's.

Speaker 1Let's do some questions, shall we.

Speaker 2Let's at that about that. Yeah, we have fun.

Speaker 1Look, look, it's we deserve nice things, even in the midst of horrors, that's all.

Speaker 2Yeah, A little dessert probably probably gonna cut like half of that because it's just like us trying to like cobble together like thoughts that are not like wow.

Speaker 1I mean, but it's like what I mean, it's just fucking fucking idiots. It's just a fucking stupid How am I supposed to have a thought? Other? Well?

Speaker 2Yeah, what are you?

Speaker 1What?

Speaker 2Yeah? Like, what is it? It's like we've we've we've said this all before. Imperialism is the highest form of capitalism. It is a scourge on mankind in society. And the sooner America is broken apart, the better a lot. And I mean, and when that happens, I don't know what else falls apart. But yeah, we're just all gonna.

Speaker 1Have to We're gonna have to figure it out.

Speaker 2I have to figure it out. Eighteen forty eight on steroids across I don't know uh, two thirds maybe of the planet. Let's see. Let's see. I'm excited to find out what happens when you break the eighty year old consensus and that's attached to the like three hundred year old one before that.

Speaker 3Anyway, let's go.

Speaker 2Hello and welcome back to We're Not So Different, a podcast about how was I supposed to know I would be involved in geopolitics if I went to the place that has to be defended with bombers at all times. My name is Luke and as always I'm joined by doctor Eleanor. And yeah, folks, we're doing today.

Speaker 1This is my fault, everybody. It's because I have to do a bunch of running around this week, and I made us record early, and I just want everybody to know that I personally, I'm like, I'm I'm here doing my self crit Yeah you know, yeah, yeah exactly.

Speaker 2It sounds like, yeah, it sounds like I have the like gun sights on you, like the like there's like that there's a red got side on you, like what the fuck?

Speaker 1But also we haven't done one in a while, so I.

Speaker 2Think, yeah, yeah, folks, Uh, even though we're doing a mail bag episode today. The series on medieval land management will continue next week. Uh schedules conspired to leave us with a short amount of time to record, so we're just doing the mail this time. I'm really going for info about medieval forestry. Never fear it is coming next week. Anyway, Today we're doing a mailbag episode, as is our want, and we're going to answer questions submitted by our patrons. If you want to ask us these quess here's the

Speaker 2bonus episodes, like the most recent one we did on Night of the Seven Kingdoms. Join our discord or more. Please do subscribe Patreon, dot com, slash, w nsd pod five books a month get you access to all that and it's really fun. Anyway, Today we're talking about annoying streets, medieval beach trips, the Florentine vice, cadaver, Sina's parasocial relationships, and shows of performative masculinity. Enjoy. First question we got us from Missy, who says I recently almost busted my

Speaker 2ass on a cobblestone street, which got me thinking, how were people talking about? Were they even talking about or were they even taking the time to write about city streets extensively outside of like planning documents, there any humorous accounts of people ranting about the fuck this street in particular, or while this street it's always level and clean, similar to how we complain about the one road that always has potholes in it today.

Speaker 1Okay, So my example from this you're not you're not going to be surprised to learn, is from a little place called Prague at a time called the fourteenth century, when a certain emperor, Charles the fourth was working on it. Okay, because when he takes over and he establishes the new town, which it's very funny now that like the new town was built in the thirteen fifties, but you know, hey ho.

Speaker 1You know, so when he establishes like the new town, one of the things he does is he extends the city walls, and he's like, okay, well all these bits that were little towns outside Prague are now Prague. And part of what he does to establish that this is a city is he paves everything nice. So it's like, so all the streets that were formerly dirt are now cobbled, and everyone is like, nice cobbles.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's busting your ass on cobblestones is still better than trudged through the fuck and mud.

Speaker 1Mud, yes exactly, and so like it is all swings and roundabouts, right, you know, like from our standpoint, cobbles they're very pretty. Are a real bitch, And listen, I say this to you as a cyclist, right, I enjoy looking at cobbles, but like I have a deep seated fear of them because I just like I just do not trust my bike on it. Look, I am not a professional cyclist. You're not gonna find your girl like doing the fucking Pari rubet, okay, because them cobbles they

Speaker 1give me the frights. But if you have wagons, it's real nice. And also like medieval shoes like one of the biggest problems that we have with cobbles now, Like I mean, ladies, am I right when you're wearing heels? Like okay. So I was a couple of years ago in Hunt with my sister and we were like, oh, it's girly time and we're gonna go out for a fancy dinner. But I forgot to bring my nic shoes. So I went and bought this pair of like super cunty stilettos, like they're so like, and I was all like,

Speaker 1I am so fashionable right now, check the shit out. But I kind of like neglected to think about the fact that I was in a medieval town and everything was cobbled, and I'm like walking with like one hand on my sister's shoulders, going mother fuck, like I cannot, I cannot deal with this right now. And it's like so in the my world's really collided. At that moment, I was like, I've really got to think about things in the future. But you know, medieval people wearing stilettos a lot less. You know, you're wearing kind of like

Speaker 1leather shoes with wooden clogs on the outside something like that, and you would just be like clippy clop, bitch, you know, and like that would be better than like mud. So for them, that stuff is an improvement, we know because they write about it. Now. On the other hand, who's writing about it. People who are like I.

Speaker 3Think you should come to Prague.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's really cool. But like that's the only time I've ever really seen streets mentioned in such a positive way. Like usually everyone is just saying like that street's nasty. Yeah, if if it gets like written down, yeah.

Speaker 2Strange. Yeah, every everyone was in the Roman Times everyone was big on the roads they they built. That was a real thing, like like everyone's like, wow, these roads are fucking nice, man, Like, uh, that's a real a real deal. And I mean that went on for a while. It's you know, some of those roads are still there today and they still weren't just fine. I mean as long as you don't try to take like a fucking tractor or not attract like an eighteen wheeler across them or something. Now that would fuck them up real bad.

Speaker 2But yeah, there you go. Yeah, uh you know, Uh, it's one of those things like how when something new comes out for us and uh it's really revolutionary whatever, and we just kind of take the downsides along with it because that is what it is. Anyway. Uh, it's cool that we're doing the show on the internet.

Speaker 1Right, Yeah, yeah, absolutely, I love that.

Speaker 2Absolutely zero downsides from the internet. But also, what in the world will we be doing without it? You remember the eighties when we didn't have the internet. You remember that people used.

Speaker 1To get bored people. Yeah, dude, I haven't been bored in decades.

Speaker 2I think about it. And it's not like things were better back then. But I'm just like, you remember when there wasn't you couldn't just look stuff up on your phone in your pocket, I do.

Speaker 1Do, bruh, Like you used to have to have encyclopedias and shit.

Speaker 2It was wild, Yeah, insanity, Missy. Thank you very much for the question. Next, we got one from Gaffzie, who says, I recall reading something about male male homosexuality being known as the Florentine vice. But were there any other medieval stereotypes about the horny through sexual proclivities of various people's kingdoms? Were the French always known to be like that? And I honestly don't even know what this means. Does this mean like hitting on much younger women or like just tornyaches?

Speaker 1Yeah, like I mean I think that this is a just kind of a reference to the generally perceived sexuality of Le Francis, you know, so okay, this is a good question, and I mean sort of yeah, like what is courtly love other than talking about what French? Which people are like and they're like, you know how it

Speaker 1is always trying to jack your wife off. I always trying to like like get jacked off by one of your bros. Like everyone is just always like at it. And I do think that there is there is a specific thing everywhere in general still as there is now about how cities are like the Center's advice. Yeah right, it's like anywhere you go, if it's a city, they're like, oh, I see how it is.

Speaker 2Yeah yeah, I would think yeah, I would think there was always there would always be like uh yeah, uh town, like whichever town you dislike the most, for whatever stupid reason it is. You know, you were like, oh yeah, everybody over there is fucking gay there. Whatever it was, yeah, or oh I'm sorry, they're all the anti Christ. Sorry oh yeah, like.

Speaker 1Tip Christ lamp. You know. But you see this all the time, in particular with preachers calling various cities a new Sodom. Yeah, it's like all the time. It is like into a new Sodom over and over a fucking gun and it will be like they're talking about Munich and they're like, really, where's the.

Speaker 2New Gomora, Right, here's the new Sodom. Here's the new Sodom. Where's the new Gomora?

Speaker 1Okay. There was this guy who used to do like web comic movies, and there was this one that I was obsessed with, Slash. I'm still obsessed with it's a team up called the Professor Brothers, and one of them is giving a lecture about Sodom and Gomorrah, and he's like, you know, the first city is called Sodom, named after Sodomy, and the other one was called Gomora, which was named after even freakier moves. So it's like, any time I hear Gomora in my head, immediately I'm like, even freakier moves.

Speaker 1But it's like, you know, this fucking web comic from like six or some shit.

Speaker 2When I was younger and still went to church, there was a kid. There was a guy. I mean, he's a guy now. I assume he's still alive, but uh uh. There was a kid who I was in Bible class with, who I guess through some whatever. Since Sodom was sodomy, he thought Gomorah meant being a lesbian.

Speaker 1And yeah.

Speaker 3Sometimes I was.

Speaker 2Like, I'm like, gomorahri, is that Gomorah me? Yeah?

Speaker 1I love that.

Speaker 2Yeah, when it's lesbians, it's Gomorah me. And I'm like, uh, you know what, yeah, why not? Man?

Speaker 1You know what critical support for this idea? I really like it.

Speaker 2You know, oh yeah from yeah. Uh and then we did uh we had a follow up question from Princess Sparkle Pants. He said, uh, by the fifteenth by the late fifteenth century, had sodomy come to settle on the meaning of being a of being you know, just male male sexuality or had or was it still the more like just anything that's not penis to vagina penetrative sex was okay?

Speaker 1Yeah, So this is one thing that people get wrong right quite often, okay, and they have to be super super careful about it, like even in the fifteenth century. By the time you're kind of tipping more into the early modern period, so kind of like sixteenth century seventeenth century, we do tend to see that people are using it more as like a catch all for gay stuff, but medieval people really don't. And so you have to be super careful with documents because people who aren't trained will say, oh,

Speaker 1look like these are all like a number of persecutions against gay men, and that's not what that means, right. It'll be like like a lot of times, for example, you can get in trouble if you're a married woman. You can get in trouble for sodomy real fast. If you're like the blowjob queen of your particular postal district or whatever, like that's gonna be bad for you, not.

Speaker 2That they have the post but job Queen of Alsace, Lorraine.

Speaker 1That's right, like what a you know, the throat goat.

Speaker 2There is there is a throat. There is a throat goat of a'l says Lorraine. And whoever she was, he or she was or or they were or are or are uh congrats what a good fuck?

Speaker 3Yeah?

Speaker 1Hell yeah, I love to see it, you know. So yeah, we and we have to be really careful. I talk about this all the time too. Like the the insidance that I often bring up is that we tend to see that when people are executed for sodomy, it's usually because they're actually doing peedo shit.

Speaker 2And it's like saying that.

Speaker 1Yeah, so it's like one thing to get caught given blowjobs in the Florence Duomo, which was a huge cruising spot, but it's like quite another thing to be use sexually assaulting children and they will kill you for that. It is true though, because like Princess Sparkle Pants is like, was Florence really not out or kind of yeah? I mean sort of yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2Because when those priests were describing some places in New Sodom, they were saying it's an all that orgy instead of specifically saying it's an all out gay or okay, Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1It's it's much more okay. So think about it like the Garden of Earthly Delights, like the picture, right, most of it. Most of what they're talking about is dude on dude action, which there's a lot of in the Garden of Earthly Delights. But there's chicks there too. There's chicks there too. And the thing about Florence as a hotbed and center of this is just because it's this incredibly wealthy city. Yeah, and like has been for quite some time, you know, and it's like bright, like big city. You've seen all the literature, you know, We've we've been working so much on our Patreon doing like book clubs

Speaker 1about specifically Florentine literature. Right, the The Cameron is Florentine. The fucking Divine Comedy is Florentine. And so these things are kind of circulating and everyone is like, hell, yeah, I want to get in on some of that. Yeah, this is the place to go if you are kind of artsy and or if you want to bang. Yep, right, And because it's such a big city, it is likely that you can find work and things like that. So if you are looking for some action, Florence is as good a place to go as any.

Speaker 2Yees so, and I mean, yeah, it seems. I think one thing we can say throughout history is that people are people who have lifestyles that might be considered.

Speaker 1Minority positions.

Speaker 2Yeah, my minority positions or lifestyles or things like that often do gravitate to cities because you will find more people like that there. While it probably would be much easier to hide it if you were just gay with somebody down the road, like in like far away from a city, it would probably be easier to hide it from a lot of prying eyes. It's you know, how often are you finding someone like that in your in your village of ten people or whatever, When you can

Speaker 2go down the road to a city that has ten thousand or twenty thousand people, and you're probably much more likely to find another guy there who you know, wants to do wants to do shit with you, or another girl or whatever like whatever it was. And and so that is why throughout history, you know, you see religious of all religions and all stripes. You know, they decry cities even when they live in cities, they still decry them as as sinful dens of iniquity because I mean,

Speaker 2I mean, I guess technically they are if you consider the stuff iniquitous, you know, But if you don't, then it's just a place to go to have a good time. In which case, Florence is like you read the de Cameron and tell me, like, I mean, like they got a lot of shit, like I want to fuck, I want to fuck women. I want to fuck me know, like I want to do that, Like like okay, cool, let's let's go. Yeah, Gassie and Princess Spargo Pants, thank you for the questions and the follow up.

Speaker 1Uh.

Speaker 2Next, we got one from Mike RS who says was listening to Dan Savage's Sex and Politics. It was a premium episode actually, and they had this guy, Matthew Vines making extravagant claims about the relationship between marital monogamy and the development of Western modernity. And I asked Mike what the the argument was, and he said, basically, everyone was tribally marrying their close relatives to consolidate power over generations in the Catholic Church around one thousand CE said now

Speaker 2you can't fuck your cousins anymore. So now we're able to establish trust across large groups of non related people and also get universities. I will say that Eleanor has been on Dan's podcast before. I don't know that Dan himself necessarily endorses these views, but regardless, Eleanor go off.

Speaker 1Okay, Yeah, So like in the first place, let's just assume that like Dan agrees with me because I'm right about everything. But otherwise, okay, so to think about this that why this doesn't shake out for me or work is that people were doing monogamy even when they were marrying their cousins, like in the first place, like that that's still monogamy. Like that is one huge fucking thing that Christians brought in where they were like monogamy, monogamy, monogamy. Would you like to hear some more about monogamy. That's monogamy, right, yeah,

Speaker 1And so that has been going on since you know, they gained any power at all. So let's say like from the fourth century Common era, you know, something like that. So, I mean that doesn't really wash with me. In the second place still and even a lot of times when people make these claims, they're only looking at the class. Yeah, right. And the thing is like, ordinary people aren't marrying their fucking cousins, right, Like ordinary people.

Speaker 2At least not their first or second cousins, maybe maybe a.

Speaker 1Third cousin or something like that, but you know, they're not like ordinary people who are just farming or whatever are not. And also because of the way land ownership works and un freedom works, they also don't have that same incentive. I mean, like, yeah, you do pass your land down to your family, but it doesn't work the way modern people think it works.

Speaker 2You know.

Speaker 1It's not like, oh, you own your home and then like your kids take it or whatever. Like it's not it's not the family farm in Texas, that's it. Those are two different things, and it's different ways of thinking about it. And it's not that much land. And yeah, like when you're in the village as most people are, yet just marry whoever and no one really gives a fuck, right, yeah, I mean. And the other thing that I would also like to say to this as a generalized counter point, is that the thing about monogamy is no one is like, yeah,

Speaker 1I mean it's like, sure, there are plenty of examples of whoever. You're probably more likely to find that a peasant's are monogamous because they get to marry who they want, right, Like, it's much more likely that everyone in the village is going to find it more easy to keep on with it because they can match with whomever they so choose. They're fucking again, courtly love, courtly Love one more time. That's courtly love. You know, like, if you are forced to marry some dude twenty years your senior for political

Speaker 1purposes that you don't really give a fuck about, are you going to be monogamous? Sure, there's some women who are like super super pious and they're going to do it, but a lot of them are getting jacked off by like a hedge knight. Yeah they're not called hedge knights, but whatever, I'm not over it.

Speaker 2So unfree by a knight who doesn't have land and is just trying to attach himself to a household.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, exactly, So like that doesn't really work there either, I guess. And also, like we had universities, so I don't really understand. I'm not sure what he was saying about universities, but like universities are a twelfth century invention. Yeah, and I mean.

Speaker 2And even before that you had bureaucratic exams and bureaucratic Uh, the whole bureaucratic system in China had been there for a thousand years before that. So yeah, not.

Speaker 1And I guess I don't really understand why monogamy establishes trust.

Speaker 2I don't know either, Like that's I.

Speaker 1Guess I haven't heard the argument, so I don't know, but like that is unclear to me, and I don't think that it necessarily really follows when indeed, you know, for a counterpoint, it can be that like having a bunch of sex with people can establish trust sisters systems across large groups of people of not people, right like uh, that's what fucking Bonobo's do, right, yeah, like the you know, and basically like everyone mocks the polycule quite rightly, but

Speaker 1when I do it, it's okay. But you know, one of those things is you know, you do you do develop like complex systems of trust. So for example, like the people that I refer to as my family, like include like my Metamore's husband, right yeah, so you know, and things like that because it's like, oh, yeah, well these are these are the people to whom I owe something, and like that's what my familial system is. So monogamy doesn't necessarily work to do that either. I don't really understand what that argument is. I have no idea how

Speaker 1could relate to universities, especially when universities in the eleventh century are largely dominated by male members of the clergy.

Speaker 2Yep.

Speaker 1So I don't really understand how monogamy plays into that either. I mean, people who make these sorts of claims are usually not medievalists.

Speaker 2I would say, yeah, I don't I don't understand. I don't understand the connection, because I mean, in order to have a civilization of any kind, you have to have a tit. You have to have like established trust of some kind, like the idea that like the lady who's supposed to go in and either appease or awaken the god or goddess at the temple, uh, and that's going

Speaker 2to ensure that the rainfalls and we have a good harvest this year. Like if you live in that Mesopotamian city or a cod or wherever it is a long long time ago, you have trust that the lady or the man or whoever, the priest or priestess is going to go in there and do their job, so your crops will turn out okay, Like that is a trust thing. And also there are I mean hundreds upon hundreds of examples of soilvilizations and societies where they uh, they were complex,

Speaker 2they were extremely successful in many ways, and they were ruled by uh men who were allowed, encouraged everything to be in polyamorous relationships and to be to have huge covens uh and harems or whatever word you would like to use to describe that. I mean, for to give just one example, Chinese emperors, Egyptian pharaohs, both men, I believe,

Speaker 2both the men and the women pharaohs. I couldn't say whether Empress Wu and China had her own thing. I think she's the only technical Empress of China. But regardless, that's not hearing her there. China was incredibly successful. The Inca, the Sefaka who led who led the Inca people's they were I've talked about them many times. They were in extremely polyamorous relationships with many women, some of them uh

Speaker 2younger than you know we would uh then then are appropriate in any way but like that's still a high trust society that is extremely advanced on any level of like the medieval world. So like I don't I don't understand how monogamy specifically does that. And I and I mean, I'll be honest, I think like most families and most people kind of have like someone who is like an aunt or an uncle who's not who's just a family friend. And like if I think about my family, I think

Speaker 2about people who are like that, like they're considered in it. So if they're not considered in or if if if we make that exception, like why is it so much weirder for someone to have two boyfriends two husbands? Uh? However many it is? You know, yeah, like we make fun of the polycool and that's because it like that's basically so that's basically because I mean it's a lot to make fun of, like.

Speaker 1With everything I'm allowed to you know, yeah, yeah exactly.

Speaker 2This is like the same reason people make fun of America. Why wouldn't you What the fuck is there not to make fun of here? This place is insane? Like yeah, like if you can't laugh at the thing you are, Like, I don't know, what's the point in being it, I suppose, at least to me.

Speaker 1But yeah, I looked up real quick in the interim who Matthew Vine is and he's a biblical scholar, which we'll explain why he doesn't. Ah, well, there you go, there you go.

Speaker 2Yep, Okay, Yeah, so Mike, hopefully that answers the question. Neither of us agree. We don't have this specific argument, but yeah, it seems pretty nuts and a historical to us. But yeah, thank you Mike for the question. Next we got one from Horatio Hicks, who asked us to talk a little bit about Gil Deray, who was a confidant or not a not a well it was a confident, but also a comrade in arms with Joan of Arc

Speaker 2from a noble family, and has for the last one hundred or two hundred years been the subject of a lot of historical revisionism, calling him like a serial murderer, a serial killer, a serial pedophile, serial rapist, all that sort of stuff. So, eleanor who is Gil Deray and why is he like he? He seemed to confess to a lot of things. But is do we do we believe that confession?

Speaker 1What are we listen to me? I don't believe any confessions from this period. Yeah, like, I just like I don't think that you should do that. Most of these people are being tortured, right, So, yeah, like.

Speaker 2Torture was more common in the early it became much more common in the early modern period. But let's be honest, anytime you're extracting confessions at any time from the beginning of civilization to now, there is some amount of torture going on regardless of oh completely.

Speaker 1And it's like even if it is just kind of threats thereof, and especially here we're working with our good friends Julian kind of like the fifteenth century, which is when things are getting like hmmm.

Speaker 2A yeah, you know, oh okaya, Oh you guys are really taking this, uh this, this is this budding proto nationalist thing pretty far. Huh oh yeah, oh god, you're burning a sixteen year old girl. Oh god, oh.

Speaker 1No, no no. But he's the Marshal of France because he got a lot done on the battlefield while Joan was there. Give it the hype beast treatment, which is cool. We don't really know very much about his relationship with her, just because like we don't, right.

Speaker 2They fought in he fought in battles where she was a leader in and I think that's all we know for sure.

Speaker 1And I'm like, I'm sure that they probably chatted or whatever, like, in particular in later battles when she is more instrumental in terms of things like a canon positioning. I'm sure they would have discussed at the very least, right. And the way you got to know about my boy Gill is that he first kind of comes to our attention in a bad way because his family gets pissed off at him because he's like selling off the family lands because like because he wants to live deliciously yeah, right,

Speaker 1like and is so like Homie was at the very least real loos with it all right, like my man was about wine, women and song at the very least. But his family gets mad at him because it's like, yo, you actually like can't sell off the barony, so please stop that. So then the king places him under interdict, which is funny because kings shouldn't really be able to do that. But then as a result of this, he

Speaker 1assaulted one of the local church clerics at s e which is quite funny, real good. It was just like, you know, absolutely get his ass, and then he also kind of like goes and seizes the local castle and then everyone is like wow, wow, because he's basically stolen this from John the Fifth, who is the Duke of Brittany,

Speaker 1and so everyone's like, wow, you beat up a priest and you're like starting wars with the local nobles. But he's like, well, bro, like you put me under interdict. So like I thought, well, if I'm not a if I'm not a Christian, yeah, you.

Speaker 2Put me in intern dog, Like what do you want me to do?

Speaker 1Like exactly, And it's like so he gets He then is specifically investigated by the church, so the inquisitors get to him and they're looking at him for heresy and sodomy and the murder of one hundred and forty or more children.

Speaker 2It's like.

Speaker 1Yeah, so basically like there is this thing about like him having gone for children. Now, whether or not that is true huge question mark. Listen, He's a rich guy, Yeah, so if he had been assaulting children, I wouldn't be particularly surprised. Rich guys sure do like to do that. On the other hand, the church is pissed off at him for bitch slapping their priest. The Duke of Brittany's

Speaker 1pissed off at him for stealing his castle. They've got hold of him.

Speaker 2The Burgundians were pissed off at him because he had helped Joan of arc and yeah, like everyone's pissed him off for years. Yeah. Yeah, the king of the King of France is mad at him for various things. He'd already been interdicted. As you said, it's just like who who who living in his meal U was not mad at him.

Speaker 1Right, And so basically our thing is that we think he probably did some bad shit. Yeah, And like my thing is like I'm like, well, of course he did some bad shit.

Speaker 2He's a rich guy, yeah, exactly.

Speaker 1Right, Like, so obviously that's like he's he's a bad person because like he's a fucking duke.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 1But lately, in particularly we're hearing like from the cloud Govad She's like, look, we need to kind of like slow our role here because it's like what, basically what were the inquisitors doing, Yeah, and we don't know that, we don't know what the inquizdatorial procedure is for this and if he was getting tortured, yeah, which he may have been, because it's becoming kind of the style at the time for inquisitors at the time, right, and so

Speaker 1we just have to be a little bit careful at the very least I would say about him, I don't believe that he's like killed one hundred and forty children, right like that just yea to me, it sounds like such like common medieval hyperbole that it's difficult for me to kind of like really take it very seriously. But I have no doubt at all that he was not a great guy, because none of them were.

Speaker 2So yeah, yeah, there's a as far as I can tell, it's he was a bad person. He probably did bad things in keeping with his station. But then they got really mad at him. A lot of people were really mad at him about a lot of things he had committed, some various violations that Eleanor talked about that are just going to get you in a lot of trouble regardless. But like even modern scholars who think he did a

Speaker 2lot of this stuff still kind of back away from the crazy shit that has talked about, like in in the confessions of like his assistants and and his in his confessions and like some of the like it's like this is stuff that wouldn't that like wouldn't be put down again until like centuries later. Like it like, if he was doing this and people knew about it, you would think there would be a lot more scandal about

Speaker 2it because they're talking about him, like they talk about the fucking Marquis de Sade, like.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah. And like I would say also, like one of these things is that there is a certain amount of, like I would say, kind of lurid interest in in Gildea. I think that like people who have kind of like the serial killer thing are interested in him. There are a lot of like engravings from the nineteenth century which to me kind of look like vaguely veiled porn, where

Speaker 1like people are very clearly like titillating themselves about this, which I don't think is great either. I do think that he probably was assaulting young men, and I don't think that that is great, and like, you know, fuck him as a result of that, Like, like I think Lett has written a bit about that where he really thinks that they were But I mean, you know, I just think that people get a little too hyped to find what they think is a serial killer, you know

Speaker 1what I mean. And also I'm just saying that, like like all of his his crash out came more as a result of like attacking the church because like he was spending too much money, and then suddenly it's like, oh and also he's an ounce. Yeah, I'm assuming he is an oance because he's rich.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, it's I don't know, like sure, I mean, like, did he did he kill people? Probably people probably know. We know he assaulted at least a few. That's a noble right, Yeah, it's not really doubted, but like this is yeah.

Speaker 1Uh.

Speaker 2The only problem with saying you don't think guild Gilday is guilty of all these things is that it means you're required to agree on some level with Voltaire, who also didn't buy all that shit. But yeah, anyway, that's uh, that's just a joke. I just I don't think he did all that stuff. Uh, And if he did, I think there would be a lot more about it elsewhere, Like killing one hundred and forty kids in fourteen forty, they would like you would be talked about like a

Speaker 2fucking uh like Dracula, like Vladra Cool, like the way that they talk about like Attila the hun and shit like yeah.

Speaker 1I.

Speaker 2Don't see it, but yeah, Horatio, thank you for the question. Next we got one from Colin Keith. Obviously, medieval people exploited marine resources, so it seems hard to believe that medieval people are really large groups of pre nineteenth century people wouldn't try to get recreation out of a beach with soft sand and warm water. It's hard to imagine someone in twelfth century Pulia not making a day of gathering muscles and also chilling on the sand with some wine. Other children frolicked in the surf.

Speaker 1You ain't wrong, Colin, you ainate wrong.

Speaker 2Yeah, the beach.

Speaker 1People love the beach, and like medieval people love swimming. They love to go for a swim, swim. It's one of the delights of summer.

Speaker 2Yeah, you know, and.

Speaker 1People will absolutely like travel to swim. They'll travel more, particularly for bathing, but also kind of like swimming at the seas sort of counts and like often there are kind of like famous baths near the sea as well. So yeah, they do a lot of splash splashing around and they love to swim. For them also, it's like one of their major like their Jim Bros. Swim. Yeah, they're they're like, oh yeah, you know, like instead of talking about gains, they're like swimming, and then well, I'm

Speaker 1sure they do kind of talk about gains, but then they left. They lift up big rocks for sure.

Speaker 2O the triangular weights and go hip.

Speaker 1Oh yeah, that's sort of a thing. So yeah, absolutely, and it is. It is one of those things where people just do love to have a little swim swim, you know, basically you kind of like get down to your linens and then you jump in. And it's a little easier for men to do it than women, but women still do it as well. People be swimming. Everybody likes it. You know, who wouldn't desire to eat a fishy next to the beach. I'll tell you who. Luke,

Speaker 1he doesn't care for the beach.

Speaker 2It's me. I don't want that fucking sand anywhere near Mendstand. He went to the beach before u before running water. Get this.

Speaker 1You could go to some of these god awful European beaches like in Nice. It's just these big round stones. It's so confusing. I'll tell you what. When I when I got to Nice, I was like, are you fucking kidding me? When you see the big round storms.

Speaker 2But my favorite one the Giants Causeway, just being like what the fuck is this?

Speaker 1Where is the same the Giants Causeway? No, that's a real one. But I ain't going in the water there, but where I like to go and have a dip in the metroble all of it, but but really cool. My favorite one and what you would like is near Cassi. They don't really have a beach per se. They have these things that they call klunk and it's like essentially just like the water. There's like a series of hue huge boulders and then there's the water and you just like jump off the boulders directly into deep water, and

Speaker 1then there are like ladders that help you get back out, and everyone just lays around on these like huge stones. No sand included.

Speaker 2Yeah, oh it looks like nah, I just don't like the beach.

Speaker 1I know, you're allowed to have different likes.

Speaker 2I just don't like sand. I don't like sand, and I don't like salt water sand.

Speaker 1And make you watch the sand documentary for the Simpsons.

Speaker 2Yeah oh yeah, no, no, no, I look, sand is interesting. It's cool that it turns into glass and all sorts of other stuff. I just don't want it on my body anywhere. Colin, thank you for the question. Next got one from jos the Texican, who says, I just had an insane, delightful idea, and now I need to find out do we have any reports or traditions of Saint Clair of a CC's hair color. I'm thinking about making my niece a fabric and yarn doll of Saint Clair. My niece is named after her, but they gave her the check version of Claire. Oh Clara. Yeah, And I

Speaker 2did some research on this and the only thing I can find the only images or of course her with a veil, because she is a saint. And I was just I wanted to include this one more to talk about the fact that medieval well not just medieval people, people before I don't know, let's say, the seventeen hundreds or so, really didn't describe things or people very well.

Speaker 2They weren't flowery, prosaic descriptions of people and things were not common, and you know, you just even fel like I think there are two physical descriptions of Ginghis Khan, and they both contradict each other. One of them says he has like catlike eyes and no one knows what that means, like okay, like okay, cool, Like does that mean he had?

Speaker 1Like are they green? Are they are they all in shape?

Speaker 2Can he see in the dark? Like what are we talking?

Speaker 1Like? I don't Yeah, yeah, they didn't.

Speaker 2Yeah, they didn't do a lot of descriptions. And that's not calling out Joss. Uh, it's just that we don't know a lot eleanor do.

Speaker 1You Yeah, you're you're bang on here. I went through like a lot of medieval images of Saint Clair and she's always shown wearing a habit because you know of her. Yeah, no, either is fine. And uh, what I would say is you are safe if you go with blonde, because if you ask the medieval person, they'd probably go, I don't know blonde because she is a saint, and therefore, if she is a saint, she is beautiful. And if she's beautiful,

Speaker 1she's therefore blonde. And what they would depict her as you know, like in the big parade of Saints and Martyrs in the gain altarpiece, if you go look at all of the women saints and martyrs, they are all blonde, like interchangeably.

Speaker 2So so ever noticed that my life, Yeah, so.

Speaker 1She will have probably blonde hair and gray eyes, because that's what they think is hottest. So if they were pressed, they'd be like, probably blonde and gray eyes. She was really great, but we just don't have a description other than that. It's like how we don't know what Eleanor Vocutaine looked like other than that she was hot. But for Eleanor Vacutaine, I assume that that she's probably like brown hair, brown eyes, because I think that if she had blonde hair and gray eyes, we would fucking know

Speaker 1because they'd be like, holy shit, like she's doing it. But everybody's all like, oh no, man, like she's hot, and it's like, may I know more? No, nope, gotcha.

Speaker 2It's the hottest, the hottest woman that like Europe has seen in hundreds of years, and and the descriptions of her are hot attractive, Yeah, like cool, thanks guys for that.

Speaker 3They like.

Speaker 2Uh. The the descriptions of Anne Boleyn, who is known to have been like considered one of like the hottest women like around at that time and is in the early modern period, are lacking, like it's it's just still not there. They just don't have a lot of it.

Speaker 1Yeah, like, if we didn't have the portraits, we would have nowhere to go on that, you know.

Speaker 2Yep, yep, Josh, thank you very much for the question. And I hope your niece likes the doll because that's cool.

Speaker 1I really like that.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, Nick's got one from fairy Dust who says, Pope formosis aka the cadaver synod. What the fuck? That's it? That's the question. Uh, could never synod happened in eight ninety seven? They yeah, excuse me, Pope see Stephen the sixth, They disinterred Pope formosis and they who had died about

Speaker 2eight months beforehand in eight ninety six. They dug him up, accused him of various things, including perjury and that he had risen to the to the seat illegally, and they declared his papacy nol. And I think the reason we all think about this is because we all, man, there are so many Americans that I need to dig up and put on trial. George Washington, get his fucking ass up here, Get every president. I'm doing them all in a line. I don't care bring them all up anyway

Speaker 2else could ever sign? Yeah, this is one of those things where you're just like the Middle Ages are fucking hilarious like that. That is like, and no, this is the first time this happened. This has older, it's happened before, but like it's man.

Speaker 1I mean, like listen, the reason everybody likes look to have a synod is that, like everybody longs in their heart to dig a guy up and yell at him.

Speaker 2Yeah, everybody longs in their heart to get it out, to get the Catharses out and be like this guy fucking sucks.

Speaker 1Yeah sucks.

Speaker 2He was. And also there's like an image it's by a Jean Paul Larne from eighteen seventy. Uh, it's called Pope Formosis and Stephen the sixth and the.

Speaker 1One you do you imagine yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah pointing at him while like Formosis's body is like sitting there and he's like decaying in the chair. It's just it's it's an incredible mental image that it gives you. And also just like yeah, fuck that bring me the body of Look, I'm sorry, Abraham Lincoln, you gotta go up there, man, we gotta. Alexander Johnson insanely stupid decision in addition to the uh, the indigenous genocide, but like, look, man,

Speaker 2everybody's going up there. There are no sacred cows here. I'm just dragging them all up there. Get FDRs ass in there too, let's go, let's go.

Speaker 1Cams.

Speaker 2We don't like all of them, fuck that, yeah, every even. And I expect I expect if I somehow become the leader of a rump state of America, that you'll have to dig me up and do a cadaver synod about how I was a war criminal for it too, Like just all of them. It doesn't fucking matter. Just put them all in there and I And to be honest, I think in America it would do a lot of good because of the way that we did. The like sanctity with which we treat these uh terrible, terrible people probably do a lot of good. In Britain too, man, y'all.

Speaker 2Could they could have some fucking age old ones like like h man, it.

Speaker 1Would be so good. I really think we should bring them back. Actually, you know, like less what the fuck and more what the fuck? Why haven't we done more of these exactly?

Speaker 2Uh yeah, fairy does thank you for the question. The codever synod is great, so true, and I will probably use the that picture as the header image for this because it's a great picture. Next week one for Pearl Riverflow. Who says, all right enough with the quote thousand years of stinch in quote. We know it smelled bad, But what did medieval people do to smell good? Specifically, what's in their perfumes? You know, their their potpourrise u? What herbs, spices, plants and oils did they use to get themselves to

Speaker 2smell good? Yeah? Lots?

Speaker 1So we you can see this. The trotola is an excellent place to go look for medieval recipes for soaps, deodorants, perfumes, laundry, soap, things of this nature. And the answer is like flowers and herbs, you know, like obviously you're gonna use whatever it is that grows near you. But they use a lot of rose, They use a lot of violet, They use a lot of lavender, They use a lot of jasmine, they use a lot of bay, a lot of rosemary. Basically,

Speaker 1like if you can name it, they use it. They really like to make a little melange, right, they're using a lot of tansy. Tansy's coming up all the time. I will say that.

Speaker 3But you know, if you would cook with it.

Speaker 1They'll also like give it a go for perfumes, especially for like masculine ones, for like masculine clones and things. They will also oftentimes be like, oh, to make your breath smell good, chew on some peppermint, like take that around with you. They kind of brush their.

Speaker 2Same We still do it, yeah yeah, yeah, yeah, like.

Speaker 1They we'll brush their teeth with brushes, but then like chew mint afterwards to make it smell good. So yeah, like it's obviously going to really depend on where you live, because like an Italian person is going to have like way more access to stuff like you know, jasmine or whatever than someone in Scotland. Like, you know, Scotland's going to be a little more more limited in terms of what scented plants you can use. But they put a huge price on smelling good as everybody does. They also

Speaker 1have like deodorants, so they they will kind of like make pasty versions or like salty versions of things and put them under their arms, which kind of helps. It does help. It's a good thing.

Speaker 2Yeah, that salt will dry up the sweat or some of it. Anyway. Yeah, it's going to fuck up your skin, but I mean I guessic you take it as it comes at that point, Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 1So yeah, they so basically they're using kind of like salt preparations that have like their mixed favorite mixture of herbs in them, and then you just kind of like apply that to anything else, like put it in soap, put it in whatever.

Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, they're Uh, I'm just imagining like some priest like who's like, you know, he's doing his sermon, but he has to he has to make some extra money on the side to get by, so he's like, oh, so now do over it for men, and it's just like it's it's just like perpetual stew. It smells like perpetual stew. They're like, oh, this is great. I fucking love the I fucking love to smell like stew. Yeah.

Speaker 1Oh hell yeah brother, yeah.

Speaker 2Like we we yeah. I mean they did at like, uh food, the smell of food is uh. They like I've talked about it. For Constantinople, they had a spice market and uh a bunch of like cookeries and restaurants near uh the palace because uh, those kept the the awful smells of medieval cities away because you know, everybody loves the spell of like cumin and cardamom and all

Speaker 2that cooking, and you're just like, and you don't notice that a horse took a shit sixty from you or whatever. I know, I know they put it in other places and the horses normally would it, but at the same time, it's a fucking horse.

Speaker 1They should also listen fundamentally, Basically, before the nineteen fifties, everything smelled a bunch more yeah than it does now.

Speaker 2Like we just simply could much better now.

Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, we would not be able to comprehend even like the Victorians and how much they stalk.

Speaker 2So yeah, looking back to the past, I know it's smelled crazy in there for any year before, like I don't know, nineteen sixty five or so, probably after that, but yeah, uh pro overflow thank you for the question. We got a couple more. First, one from Damien thinking about parasocial relationships in general, and specifically about some people's bizarre fascination with the lives of soelebrities they've never met and never will. Was there a medieval equivalent of this?

Speaker 2Who did medieval people obsess over like modern people do over footballers and pop stars? Saints Tournament knights, et cetera. Obviously, the concept of celebrity as a whole couldn't function exactly as it does today. But you know what took up the medieval brain that in the modern mind is occupied with the Kardashians or whoever.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, like I think, look no further than the Divine Comedy for Dante's answer to this.

Speaker 2Right, Yeah, Julius Caesar, baby, y.

Speaker 1They are obsessed with Caesar. They're obsessed with Aristotle, They're obsessed with Cicero, and they're like, and.

Speaker 3Here's my friend.

Speaker 2Yep, we hang out in my dreams.

Speaker 1Yeah yeah, dred percent they And also I think that we can make a really good argument for the Saints here.

Speaker 2True.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think like the Saints, like people have parasocial relationships with the Saints, certainly with like the Virgin Mary, Oh God, yeah, like that's everybody's fake mommy. That's like everybody's fake mommy, and like that one hundred percent is is like something that that is happening for them. I think also probably like the Pope, you know, there's a there's a certain amount of well if the Pope heard of this, then you know he would he would help me but I think that like they have, they do

Speaker 1it for people basically from the Roman era a lot, and then you know, like less so stuff like the King. No one really gives a fuck about the King, but like they do care about saints a lot, and so I would say that yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's just I mean I think there are things that don't that just don't connect as well because fame, the nature of fame was different. You know, fame was something that came down to people like usually long after their death, like in the in that time, like you know, you heard about some heroic deed that someone did, and like now, I mean you might hear about something like that now, but you hear about it and it happened like an hour and a half ago, and it happened

Speaker 2and you know, you live in London and it happened in fucking I don't know, the Cape of the Cape of Good Hope or so like it just happens like you know, a world away, and you know it's just yeah, you had an idea, no, go ahead, solid in Yeah, anybody who got a full cycle named after them, yeabsolutely, Saladin Arthur like.

Speaker 1Like that's why, that's why Richard Lineheart went over there. He was like, who's my friend?

Speaker 2We're going They tried to get him to meet up to uh to to bring about the end of the world solidly, remember, like, yeah, that's I mean, that is Yeah, that's mad. That's mashing your dolls together and saying like now fight now, can't like that's what that is, Like it's the same thing that we do nowadays, like when you know, when we're like, you know, you hear someone, you think they're cool, you think they're fun or something like that. And but it's just different for us because

Speaker 2we have so much of it in the face And I mean, like would you hear us talk? Like it's different than the way they It's different than the way that famous people to them. Even if they even if there was a famous person about the land, they wouldn't have conversations like we are having where normal people could hear them, Like you would hear that guy maybe preach, maybe do some kind of big speech in the town center maybe, But I mean other than that, how are

Speaker 2you gonna hear about it? And if you can't read or write them, or if you can't read that well, like even if they put out a circular, what do you the fuck are you gonna know? Like until the rumor millgis do you? Yeah, Damien, thank you very much for the question. Last one we've got today, one that I've been looking forward to. Okay, So Ninja Maxing says, I don't really know how to frame this question other than did medieval knights engage in pageantry and performing the masculinity?

Speaker 2If they did, what did it look like? And then they attached a an image of tweet and it's a quote tweet and one of them, it says number two ranked Chad and Dronic failed to locate the ASU frat leader by himself is now linked up with Clavicular to prepare a coordinated attack. And at Erindian quoted this and said, there's something vaguely medieval about this whole saga, Like I

Speaker 2feel as though rivaling knights would have had an instinct understanding of the peasant, the pageantry and if you're not aware, Uh, there's this new trend I guess going around where extremely uh buff and uh, I guess conventionally attractive men who basically seem like the only things they do or talk about, like working out, Uh, take a bunch of uppers do

Speaker 2some steroids and hit themselves in the chin with hammers, and uh, you see stuff like Clovicular mogged by ASU frat leader and you're just like, what the fuck is this? And I heard, uh it was Will Mincer on Chapo say uh that this reminded him of like something medieval peasants would do, like we got our biggest peasant to come out and face your biggest peasant. Which town is best, like eleanor these seem like the most peasant mindset people

Speaker 2alive to me today, your thoughts on Clovicular and fret leader Maggin.

Speaker 1Listen, It's none of my business. I don't know if this appears to be something nineteen year old boys are doing, so it's like, yeah, you know whatever, But I guess that what I would say, what I would say is what is a medieval pageant? If not like like a medieval fucking like tournament, is just a masculinity pageant? Yeah yeah, right now. Granted that's for the fancy boys, but that's what they're doing.

Speaker 2That's the same thing.

Speaker 1Yeah right, yeah. So it's like, you know, when they put on their shiny armor and they have their horse season, they have their little guy that's on top of the helmet, especially in like the late medieval period. That that's like, you know, masculinity writ large, masculinity with capital M certainly you know, having like your large peasant who is like lifting the rocks as like previously stated, Like it'll be that as well. But I think that for peasants it's

Speaker 1like oh yeah, like he's really bringing in that harvest Hell yeah, like you're gonna be harvest mogging. Yeah yeah, like you're pig mog.

Speaker 2Oh absolutely yeah. If you if your town does the best grapes or the best I don't know, sheep or whatever like that, like they're you're yeah, you're absolutely gonna uh sheep mog. Uh. The other peasants in uh who take the stuff to market in Flanders or whatever, like yeah, they're absolutely no them where that shit's coming from. Yeah, it's you know, like uh yeah peasants. They didn't they didn't compare like the strength of peasants, but like you

Speaker 2could definite like knights, oh god, yeah, like some like lord or noble. He's like, look at my array of handsome nights and everyone's just like oh so hand Like yeah, Like if you just describe the medieval pageantry of tournaments to a person randomly, they'd be like, yeah, that's the gayest shit I've ever heard of, dog, And I mean, like all of that is performative masculinity, Like sure you're doing it for like the idea that like a woman's

Speaker 2going to notice you, And I'm sure they were doing it so women notice them, Like of course they were, because we still do that today. But like, yeah, what am I trying to say. It's I mean, I don't I don't want to sound like like, oh, I'm so above at all, but like almost all masculinity is performative masculinity, like everything about it, because none of us exist in a vacuum, and you like it, does it Like however

Speaker 2you are going about it, there is some performative aspect to it that other people will see and you are aware of that to a degree, and so like yeah, like this is just like medieval nights, like with their horses prancing back and forth to see who has the prettier heraldry.

Speaker 1To me, like that's well, yeah, it's it's interesting because like when I read the question for the first time, my brain just immediately started thinking about tournaments, and I thought, that's what the question was about at first, and it was like no, my brain just went ahead of me and was like hey, co Se, you know.

Speaker 2Like yeah, like oh, like you look at it, Look at my Look at my illustrious, uh destroyer horse, look at my my beautiful armor, like like you know, like you don't you don't make haraldry and you don't make armor like that except to get noticed. There's a reason that it it does, like there's a reason that you do that, and it's because it means something to you

Speaker 2and to their people. And yeah, like yeah, these these guys are medieval nights, down to the fact that like I mean, like I don't follow this stuff closely, but I have seen like like still shots of this clovicular guy like hitting himself in the face with hammers. And this is apparently something that like doctors in various countries are having to warn like kids against because they see stuff like this, like do not like you cannot reform your jaw into like the Chad jawline, for like by

Speaker 2whacking yourself with hammers, And I mean, what is the difference between whacking yourself with hammer and having your bro do it on the tournament yard? Like if you watch The Night of the Seven Kingdoms, like that dunk mud mogged area, like it's it's the same, it's the same thing. Like they're out there like having a concussion off in the mud, Like what's the difference in these guys doing it completely?

Speaker 1Like it's just different ways of doing the same thing.

Speaker 2Yep. Yeah, well, folks, we'll leave you with uh uh chivalry logging. Uh the I'm trying to imagine what the medieval equivalent of the a s U frat leader is and like I need, I desperately need to know what is the least serious most party school imaginable? And yes, I realized that, uh you know, Florida State doesn't have much room to talk. But like.

Speaker 1Trying to think, I'm trying to think of like lesser universities in the Middle Ages. How about fucking the one in Ipswich exists. It got abolished with cardinal.

Speaker 2No yeah Ipswich, Yeah, Ipswich frat leader. Uh William the you know, William the conqueror. Uh French dogs on Ipswich. Now, I know they didn't have a college, but yeah, you get the idea. Henry Tutor comes across the CEA Mogs on Ipswich frat leader. Yeah, I don't know whatever, guys are folks, sorry about that, not guys, folks, Thank you everybody, everybody.

Speaker 2I try. I try to say guys. I know a lot of people don't care, and that's fine, but I try regardless, folks, thank you very much for listening. That is all of the questions we have for today. As I said, next week we will be back with an episode we're going to record here in a couple of days about medieval forestry, and we'll continue the medieval land management series up to the end. But yeah, eleanor what

Speaker 2you got? What's your commercials?

Speaker 1Commercials over my personal Patreon for only a quid per month, you can read my confused ramblings. But I've got a two thousand words for you on whether or not it is possible for Andrew Windsor to actually face justice in a monarchy, and what has happened as a real result that may mean that he might so he can do it. You can check that shit out. Otherwise, you know, I'm just like fucking chillin'. I don't think that I got anything else coming out recently, so yeah, yeah.

Speaker 2Cool, yeah, yeah, you can find me same old stuff. Luca is amazing. You can find me. You can find people's Sistory of the Republic if you want to hear me talk about Star Wars. But anyway, yeah, thank y' all very much for listening, and we'll see you next time. Bye.

Speaker 1I don't know why that was so loud.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 302 - Onfim and Medieval Children

    Nov 20, 202654 minAudio

    they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 301 - Enter Leviathan, or, Why the Early Modern Period Sucked

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 24 minAudio

    folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 300 - November Mailbag

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 299 - Army of Darkness Review

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 298 - Welcome to the Crusades 2.2 Mosul

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode