Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

We're Not So Different

We're Not So Different artwork

Medieval Greenland

Jan 21, 20261 hr 22 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

folks, Greenland is in the news for fairly stupid, very American reasons, so we decided to take a look back at Greenland during the Middle Ages. how did the Norse setup a colony on Greenland and keep it going in relatively European style for so long? what were their interactions like with the indigenous American groups? what were their lives like? and what happened to cause the end of the Greenlandic Norse settlements by about 1450?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Listen.

Speaker 2Okay, just brief notes about what the fuck is going on with your girl. So she's coming in hot, right, Your girl was at the salon. That's the first part.

Speaker 3Of are we talking? Are talking at the salon?

Speaker 1They will.

Speaker 2I wish no the hair salon, but at the salon, although the way I'm doing my thing, what's the difference. At the salon, they will give you alcohol. They will give you alcohol. And now, look, my thing is if you don't take the alcohol, you're leaving money on the table.

Speaker 1Price, the price of the hairdye goes. That's true if you don't drink the alcohol.

Speaker 2Right, because every every glass of wine or beer I drink, that's like money off the cut.

Speaker 1That's that's how I see it.

Speaker 2Anyway, So I have two chill glasses of red, and I was like, and then I'm going to get home and I'm going to then pour myself another refreshing glass of red before I talked to my friends, the beautiful listeners that were not so different. Your girl apparently had a bottle of Saturn. She didn't know it, and she has opened a bottle of dessert wine. It is not red wine, but now it's open. So We're about to

Speaker 2go real Riley mode on this particular episode. Listen, it's gonna beautiful, it's gonna be big. This is I think you could agree if you look at this, this is clearly amber in color and not red. But reading the label, grow up.

Speaker 1I don't have time. I'm a busy modern woman.

Speaker 2I don't have time for things like reading labels. I just picked up the bottle and it was not see through, so I was like, well, this must be red and anyway, look, it's about.

Speaker 1To get interesting.

Speaker 3That's my point.

Speaker 1That's my point.

Speaker 3I mean, yeah.

Speaker 1Also, why is the internet like I'm not sure? There we go? That should be better? Is that better? That's better? Look?

Speaker 2What a time to be alive? What a way to podcast.

Speaker 3I For the past few days, I've been experiencing what I would call the weirdest sensation in my life, which is that I am proud, cautiously proud of Americans. Not America. I've never been proud of America, nor will I ever be proud of it as an institution. However, the people

Speaker 3of Minnesota, Hell yeah, I know some of I know some of you. Listen, Hell yes, I.

Speaker 1Like organizing, organizing.

Speaker 3Have organized themselves into impromptu neighborhood protection groups where people armed with assault rifles are standing at the entrances to neighborhoods to protect them from from people who are trying to come in. And I have a cynical, deeply, deeply, deeply cynical view of America as a place. It has never been good. Nothing about it has been good. It's a land speculation venture dressed up as fucking superpower. It's

Speaker 3it's I mean, you know, it's evil, but like people do, like people doing that is just amazing, and I mean it's like you see that, and like they these people are doing, like these random people in Minneapolis are standing up to Trump more than any European leader that I can think of, really thumbing their nose, putting things on

Speaker 3the line, thumbing thumbing their nose at him to such a degree, especially on this whole Greenland mess, which is just a debacle. But like people are brave, are braving the elements. They are braving the fear of death to protect random people they don't know, people they aren't related to, but also protecting their homes. Like I know people who live in Minneapolis who like are essentially like I mean,

Speaker 3they're like militia of like militia leaders of a sort like at this point, because they are opposing the federal government. And the fact that when this happened in an American city that people immediately jumped to this without question. They're protecting schools, they're protecting neighborhoods, to protect people and not simply property and not simply themselves, and not to shy away, because that was the assumption that all of this was

Speaker 3based on, is that everybody would just do it, everybody would go along with it, because every because everybody in America is a hollowed out fucking psychopath, like the ruling elite and like the thirty or so percent of like you know, our right wing reactionary conservative whatever, however many people that actually is. And it's not like the whole like every every everything in America, like the new the new liberal turn. All of it is based on the

Speaker 3fact that like that, that people believe that Americans would never value the lives of poor people, uh generally oppressed people, minorities, and actually not people from another from across another border who just happened to be here because they came here to make a living or they were forced here by circumstances or whatever, and it was that no one would ever do that, and they would just be able to go in and just like assail these people, and everyone would just you know, hide, and like it gives me hope,

Speaker 3a lot of hope, not false hope, not counting chickens before they're hatched, but just just hope that that we can do this if there is a window for this, because these people, like uh, I mean like these people are essentially like viewed the same way that the government views Hamas like they have formed like an illegal occupational government quote unquote government in a city that is stopping

Speaker 3like what the US wants. And they are and they're doing this because they do not have help from the cops, They do not have help from the Democratic Party of any kind. They do not have there's no opposition party, so they have to do it themselves. They are essentially viewed like come ons. And I maybe the rush to denounce Amas all the time, maybe we can learn that what do you think they're going to be doing with Minneapolis. They're gonna oh, oh well, we don't want to have

Speaker 3it happen like Minneapolis, that they're gonna do the same thing. It's the same thing, the same rush to announce everything. And it's just thank you, Minneapolis for showing the way. And I mean that as sincerely as I've ever met anything, meant anything in my life. Thank you.

Speaker 2And I think that we can all learn a lesson about getting organized and how it's possible and what it can take. I myself have been very heartened by the bravery of the good people of Minneapolis. Shout out frankly, and I mean also I realized that they were targeted because they are well organized, but all so, it just shows you what well.

Speaker 1Organized people can do.

Speaker 3That's right.

Speaker 1So yeah, it's good.

Speaker 2You know, if you've got a little bit of spare change rattling around, there's a lot of mutual aid orgs licking for support. And also I would shout out as well. I've been very impressed with the work that the Black Panthers again have been doing. And obviously, for white people such as ourselves, the only business we have with the Black Panthers is giving them money, shutting the fuck.

Speaker 1Up and going away. And yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 3So there's a good scene in the movie Malcolm X where a well intentioned white woman comes up and says, what can I do to help the Black Panther movement? And or not that I think she's talking about Malcolm X specifically, not the Black Panthers, but and he was like, nothing, because that's not our place in that specific uh things, not our place. Our places to give them money and uh work with them as a uh you know, in

Speaker 3in the in the in the practice of democratic centralism, to work with them as they need to accomplish, you know, to to to accomplish what they need. And then you know, uh, as as as it works, you know, you get in the big tent and you know, let me hash everything out and you know, but yeah, uh, all power them all, power to everyone who is opposing this here elsewhere. Don't

Speaker 3give in to people like there is this dumor thing that like everybody is like a secret fascist and the and and the Leviathan has hollowed all of us out. And it has because if people in the this in the imperial core, in this imperial core, the most imperial core that has ever existed by far, and that doesn't mean we're special, that's just technology and where we live in time, but like this is the most imperial core ever if relatively affluent, Uh people in a genteel Midwestern

Speaker 3city are taking up arms against federal and state government to protect If white people are doing that to protect Somalis or foreigners of any kind or their families, that is then that that that happened, that can happen anywhere, like he can, like the conditions for that are everywhere. That doesn't you know, I mean everyone will do it. It certainly doesn't mean that every city in America would do that, you know, exactly as Minneapolis has. However, Yeah, yeah, there's hope.

Speaker 3Fuck it. There's a window there is. It's a small one, there's, but there is. There's a fucking window. And every once in a while get too rationally uh exuberant, and I could see it for half a second, and I'm like, I could see it. I can see it, not in like a day or a week, but in like decades, but I can see something. You can fucking see it in my mind's eye, And I yeah, maybe that I don't know, Maybe it's uh, you know, maybe it's a fantasy that uh, you know, your brain cooks up or not.

Speaker 3I don't know, but I think I could. I think I could maybe see it. But anyway, Yeah, let's talk about uh, let's talk about Greenland where it's really funny that the whole thing about them calling it Greenland as a marketing slogan was actually true. This was one of those things you get taught when you're a kid and you're like there, and you grow up you're like, there's no, oh wait.

Speaker 1That is real.

Speaker 3Yea, the saga's right, like oh yeah, he he faked.

Speaker 1Yeah, imagine that.

Speaker 3So fucking mad. Oh hello, welcome back to We're Not

Speaker 3So Different, a podcast where we can see the narrow path that we must go, the golden path which we must follow, that will light the path across the galaxy, I mean the world, in order to bring the light of communism and Marxism to everyone, and we erase the borders and we are able to live good lives where uh, you know, we you know, can be in harmony with the land and stuff and and also take advantage of

Speaker 3technology and everything like that. And it's yeah, h no, definitely, Uh can see that in my mind, very very uh faintly. But anyway, today, folks, we are going to the land of always Winter. But before we get there, uh, we do have a couple of questions. So a question from Alie kan't what is your favorite origin story for a surname and how and how many can be traced back to the Middle Ages, eleanor.

Speaker 2Well, uh, not particularly many, because surname is just that, that's just not a thing. Baby like me.

Speaker 3Named Miller yep. Yeah, And it's like.

Speaker 4Surnames as like a thing.

Speaker 2I mean, so I've been doing as as is my want. I was doing a bunch of reading today obviously, And it's like even for like the big houses, they don't have last names, like even in like the eleventh century a lot of the time, Like I mean, if you're if you're looking at like, you know, Harold Godwinson for example, he's still a Godwinson, right, and his sons if he'd had and he would have been Haroldson's right.

Speaker 1So it's even in the eleventh center, you just do not fucking have it.

Speaker 2And like you know, a lot of them are just you know, names that are talking about what your occupation is, if you're lucky enough to have an occupation. The most common surname in Germany's Mueller, which is Miller, you know Smith, super common you know here, And it's like those are things that where it's just like when you get to writing down censuses, that's where that all comes from.

Speaker 3Yeah, right, like you know, that's that's when you that's when people have to start having surnames so you can you know, because you know, you can't just there can't just be thirty thirty guys named Thomas in a city with no last name exactly.

Speaker 2And it's it's one of the big things that we also have a problem with because since like surnames don't really exist, or you know, denominations are quite common or whatever. It's part of the reason why people often overestimate murder rates in naval Europe because like, five different people will report that Thomas got killed, and if you don't know what you're doing, you'll go, oh, that's five guys named Thomas who got killed. But one of them might be like, oh, you know Thomas who's from the village over, and everyone will be like word word word, and someone else will

Speaker 2be like, oh, Thomas Johnson. Yeah, someone else will be like, oh Thomas, And it can get recorded in a lot of different ways because we don't have for quite some time, any accepted way of how naming works.

Speaker 4Because like if you just kind of live in your village, it doesn't matter.

Speaker 1Everybody knows who the fuck you are.

Speaker 2And you know also like your denomination by your landlords is going to be, well, I don't know what sellians are you attached to? M hm, you know, like what what cottages do you live? And that that kind of thing. So it just it's a very modern conception, and they just don't it does exist. It tends to be a bit more bourgeois, and it's it's more of a thing for people who are high falutin and live in cities and less of a thing, you know. That's why it's still like Eleanor of Aquitaine, you know, because like that's

Speaker 2where she's from, you know.

Speaker 3And a lot of the a lot of the names, the last names that we give to people or lineages are modern or early modern historiography. Plantagenet, for example, none of them were called Plantagenet, and the names what is like supposedly only like they were like well, uh maybe maybe the very last guy in the line said it like a couple of times in his life, and and you just like, but they're called the plantat and that's

Speaker 3what we call them. Yeah, yep, there was a flower something. I don't know, maybe maybe maybe we're guessing. Yeah, it's yeah, like and I mean you think about like a lot of you know, the famous people. It's uh their names are like you know, places they lived or were from or you know, uh there uh, whatever holdings they took and in the case of England, whatever holdings they took and then lived four hundred miles away from them for some reason, which drives me fucking insane. You should have

Speaker 3to live in the place that you're It's fine, you can't. No, it's not gonna change now, but it still drives me nuts. Yeah. So, uh, they didn't have a lot of last names back then. Those are more early modern and modern thing. Of course, there are some, uh and you know we we remember them, but you know, it's not uh no, it wasn't a thing that they worried about because their worlds were a lot smaller, like you don't have to how many like

Speaker 3literally how many if you even if you live in like a town of like a decent size, like, there aren't going to be ten people named Thomas there any I mean, you know, and even if they would be like, oh, that's Thomas Johnson and that's Thomas, you know fits will you you know whatever, It's like, yeah, it's anyway.

Speaker 2Yeah, Like I mean I think that you need a last name if you're going to be like transgressing borders. Yeah right, yeah, Like I think that that that's kind of like the thing, like, you know, it's not until you need a real record of where every single person is coming and going that these things matter. And until you do need that, which is kind of like with the birth of the state and bureaucracy and these kinds of things, it just doesn't exist.

Speaker 1You know.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, yeah, thank you Ali Camp for the question. Next, we have one from Pearl Riverflow, thinking about the sack of Linda's farn. I have to wonder what are your random vikings, hoard members or other pillagers doing with church, especially books and stolen relics. Are they selling or giving them to other churches? Is it a ransom situation? Do they just pass them up to their own kings and nobles in exchange for gold or favors. I can't imagine you could just sell a Saints tooth to your local fence. And who boy, am I excited that I get to

Speaker 3tell that we get to tell you about the fact that fences in religious artifacts go back to at least Mesopotamia at least like summer, if not before. The Egyptians had a literal black market stock in trade in like old Thoronic goods stolen from tombs in pyramids. Like yeah, they they even if they didn't have a fence who specifically worked in that, they could find a merchant who

Speaker 3just dealt in whatever they found, including slaves. So like if you're dealing with slaves, like what's a tooth? You know?

Speaker 4Well, so I think.

Speaker 2That the major thing to keep in mind of when we're talking about like the relics, is they're not after the relic, babe. They're after the gold around the relic, after the relic query. M hm, the relic query. So if you don't go around doing shit like putting a saint's skull and a bunch of gold and they're just gonna be like, yeah, whatever, I don't care.

Speaker 3Yeah, tossing the skull on a pile.

Speaker 2Yeah yeah, right, It's like they're going after that sweet, sweet stuff that is around it, right, I mean maybe they could sell it off, but like you know, knowing how to barter for that stuff, is going to be like a little bit weird, like.

Speaker 1Knowing how to negotiate that. I mean yeah, like I feel that that is going to be always a little bit difficult. Books. Books are a luxury item.

Speaker 3Yeah yeah, and you can't sell those to be there there's always there's always going to be a market, like an exotic book, because like even if they don't understand it, it's from oh it's from an exotic other land and you're like, yeah it is, look at that.

Speaker 2Look I mean if it's got like really great pictures in it and stuff, no one's gonna give a shit. They're just gonna be like hell yeah, fuck yeah. And like I mean you can take that shit down to Constantineoble right now, and that's money in the bank baby, like that that's uh, they do not care. So books are like they just are a luxury good. They one hundred percent are are worth it. You know, I don't think that there is that livel a trade in like a black market relics. It's more like everyone appreciates a good book. Even if you are not a Christian. You

Speaker 2know that bibles are worth money because of you understand that that books are worth money. So like none of it really matters.

Speaker 5You know.

Speaker 2It's kind of like the you know, I don't know, like if a tweaker breaks into your car. You know, like they're gonna find a use for like whatever the ship, right, Like they just kind of know what is worth money, Like a catalytic converter ain't worth that much money, but they don't pull it, right, Yeah.

Speaker 3The catalytic converter, they're they're still in all the wire, all the copper out of it. Yeah, they're just gonna they're just gonna rummage through it and sell it to who they can. But yeah, there is an old trade in artifacts, religious and cultural and books. People have all these traded fancy books and yeah they're old. They're old tombs, like an old Egyptian like laws that are like you know, harsh punishments specifically for traders in you know, sacred relics

Speaker 3and stuff like that, and it's you know, so yeah, they you know, yeah, they'll sell them. I mean and with Linda's farn like Linda's farns at seven ninety three. So let's say you take all the you take all however many books they have, and the way from the uh from Scandinavia to the trade rout from Scandinavia to Constantinople opens in the ninth century, and that's when how you get the varranging guard down there in the first place. And so I mean like they very they're very well

Speaker 3could have been books that were stolen looted from Linda's farn that were in Constantinople a century. Yeah, like very very easily.

Speaker 1Yeah, oh completely completely.

Speaker 2And you know that's beautiful, right, like that bit, I like, I like that bit the slaving less.

Speaker 3So yeah, and the slaving and the burning of all this thing're like, I don't need this book, It's not worth it, Like no, no, it could have been a direct source for us. No anyway, Yeah, Prolo, thank you for the question. If you want to ask ask us questions like these that go all sorts of places, then please do subscribe at patreon dot com slash w nstpod. It is just five dollars a month and you get to ask us questions, you get bonus episodes, you get access to our discord. It is a whole load of fun.

Speaker 3You will like it. Anyway, onto the main show. So quote and Greenland is a barren land, a land that bears no green where there's ice and snow, and the whale fishes blow, and the daylights seldom seen brave boys, and the daylights seldom scene in quote. Though these lyrics are from a nineteen eighty three song called Greenland Whale Fisheries by the Pogues, they seem to hold firm for all of the islands recorded history and deep into prehistory.

Speaker 3Greenland is, of course massive, being the largest non continental island on Earth, yet only its thinnest edges have been habitable for many eons due to the Greenland Ice Sheet. For the past two point six million years, at least, the center of Greenland has been crushed under a mile thick piece of ice that covers roughly eighty percent of the island service area. While life can be maintained in most of the fringe coastal edges of the island, the interior of the island is totally inhospitable to flora and fauna.

Speaker 3It's not tundra. It's not even the Siberian Arctic, where hunter gatherers can and have survived for millennia, or the Western Andean coast of South America, where Inca and other peoples carved out in existence in the world's driest rain shadow. It's just a vast sheet of ice, so heavy and so thick that it is compressed to the ground beneath it, down into the upper crust. Even the animals that make their homes in the Arctic Circle cannot survive there. It's an alien world. Hell. Even the habitable zones of the

Speaker 3island provided severe problems to settlements, as they don't all remain habitable all year round and require inhabitants to greatly alter their ways of life to account for the unique terrain, or get constant supplemental assistance from a distant homeland, and even then it wouldn't be fully possible to maintain the old ways. Obviously there was no means of you know, Obviously there was no means of growing like vast plains of grain to sustain a massive population. And it lacked

Speaker 3forests except for very small trees, so that ruled out erecting shelters like that, building boats, and supplying firewood to a vast population, And most of the meat had to come from fishing or eating walruses or seals. The temperatures are of course freezing, with the warmest days barely reaching fifty degrees fahrenheit or about ten degrees celsius. And then there's the uneven pattern of the sun which doesn't fully rise in the deepest winter months and then doesn't fully

Speaker 3set during the summer months when the infamous midnight sun occurs. Sailing there from the east is just is just a massive pain in the ass, all made all the worse by the fact that you have to go around the southern Cape to settle. Until pretty recently, the European facing eastern coast of the island that is pretty close to Iceland nautically speaking, was not permanently inhabited until the early modern period and only, and even then it was only

Speaker 3by indigenous American tu Lea people And the two lead are very interesting in their own right. We'll talk about them in a little bit. But yeah, approaching from the Atlantic means dealing with the chaotic North Atlantic and Arctic seas, where shipbreaking storms and ice flows of the norm, not the exception. And yeah, and in spite of all this, human habitation of Greenland goes back to the third millennia BCE, as the Paleo Inuit groups of Northern Canada visited on a few occasions, leaving only scant remains and sparse permanent settlements. Eventually, however,

Speaker 3those hardy peoples began inhabiting the far northwest corner of Greenland, fusing several disparate predecessor cultures into what we know is the Greenlandic Dorset culture by about seven hundred BCE. Yet by around one CE, all permanent settlements seem to have disappeared for about seven hundred years until the Late Dorset people returned, setting up on Greenland just across from the Narez Strait from Canada. Since that point, Greenland has been permanently inhabited, and soon enough, in nine eighty s Europeans

Speaker 3arrived in the far south of the island as a group of Norset venturers led by Eric the Red Landed, and built permanent settlements. This was the beginning of European settlement of the island that would last until the fifteenth century. And today we are going to talk about the Norse Greenlanders their settlements. This early meeting of Old and New worlds and the hurricane of material, social, climatic and economic factors that combined to wipe out all the European settlements in Greenland, folks. Yeah, we're talking about Greenland because it's

Speaker 3in the news and we thought it would be fun to talk about it in the Middle Ages before everything was wiped out the podcast situation. The podcast position on the current situation is imperialism is the highest form of capitalism and all evil in all its forms. Under no circumstantation. The people of Greenland and Europe allow the American bully to walk all over them. It will only get worse if they do. They must stand up to Trump and resist America, even if it means the end of NATO. Incidentally, NATO is also a vestige of imperialism and explicitly anti

Speaker 3communist international organization, and therefore should be dismantled. Additionally, the people of Greenland should govern themselves, would be independent if they want. I don't know how they feel about the whole Denmark thing, but I'm saying it anyway because it's true. Just because you're not doing being as ghost as America doesn't mean it's not colonialism. Don't let anyone tell you there's some weird settler connection between Greenland and Denmark that allows them to keep the land because of what the Norse did. There's absolutely no connection between the two. Danish settlement didn't begin until the seventeen hundred centuries after our

Speaker 3story concludes. Anyway, enough of the horrifying rail road events, let's talk about medieval England and the North settlements from about nine eighty six to fourteen twenty so eleanor you know, we got Greenland. It's cold. But there are these people. You might have heard of them. They're called the Vikings. Why did they suddenly just burst out from Scandinavia and take every island in the North Atlantic that they could find?

Speaker 3Why did this happen in the eighth century?

Speaker 4Okay, so you get to Greenland, etc.

Speaker 2Because people keep leaving places where the Vikings have been consolidating power, because the power can getting consolidated. Right, So you are an earl or you're calling yourself a king of a few small islands, and then somebody stronger than you consolidates all that land and you are no longer a king. And also you need to leave real quick, right yeah, right, So that's how you make the jump from like Norway to the Orkneys or the Orkneyese to Iceland,

Speaker 2right Scotland to Iceland.

Speaker 1Whatever it is that you're going to be doing.

Speaker 2Then by the time we're nearing the end of the tenth century in Iceland again, all the land is spoken for.

Speaker 3He wait, no, we got to go somewhere else.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 2And it's like, Iceland is real good farming country because it's got that really great volcanic soil. It's super easy to run some crops through there, and it.

Speaker 1Kind of replenishes itself really easily.

Speaker 2Now, so one of the problems that we've got is that we're simply running out of land on Iceland.

Speaker 1We're running out of land on Iceland.

Speaker 2And now some people have also been blown off course near Greenland already and they see there's land there, right, and they're like, oh, we're there. Appears to be land over here, but the land that they see is like fucked covered in glaciers and there's icebergs everywhere. So they're like, oh, good to know land over here, but doesn't look very promising.

Speaker 1Enter Eric the Red Okay, Eric the Red, the sucking guy.

Speaker 2All right, So Eric the Red Mary's into in icelandic family that has a really big prominent farm up in northwest Iceland. By the time you're getting in northwest Iceland, things are already a little bit more hard scrabble over there than they are on the eastern coast. But still, you know, if you've got a big farm, you've got a big farm. Eric the Red then kills someone, you know, as you do. These are vikings, you know, and Eric

Speaker 2the Red I don't think is Christianized at this point.

Speaker 1Accounts differ. We think he is not.

Speaker 3He was, Yeah, I don't think he was. His wife was, and his sons will be. But he is, as far as I know, not yet.

Speaker 2So like who amongst us has not just like hauled off and killed someone, right, yeah, And the punishment for this at the time is banishment. So they're like, Eric, you gotta get the fuck out of here, right, And like Eric is used to a certain standard of living. He's accustomed to everyone going, Wow, what a fancy lad you are.

Speaker 1Eric, So he's not gonna.

Speaker 2Like go to Norway and like labor or anything like that. So he's like, okay, bitch, guess what I'm going west, cue the village people. So off he goes in his little body boat and he gets to Greenland, and that is you know, hmm right. They try a few different places at first, it ends up being that the places that are to live at are around on the west

Speaker 2coast of Greenland. Yes, which also makes it very annoying when you then talk about this because there are two major settlements subsequently that are set up, which are called the Eastern Settlement and the Western Settlement, but they're both on the western side.

Speaker 1Of the island.

Speaker 2And really, if it was me, i would call them the Southern Settlement and the Northern Settlement.

Speaker 1But yeah, but they did.

Speaker 3Not, and it's yeah. There if you look at the map, there is the entire western I'm sorry, the entire eastern face of Greenland is completely covered in ice. It is not habitable by people yet either because the boat it's just too dangerous to get up there. It's too cut off from everything, whatever reason. But then on the other side, at the very bottom coast there is god, I'm not

Speaker 3even going to try to pronounce it, but yeah, there's the Eastern Settlement. Then way up getting near Disco Bay is the Western Settlement, which is farther like, closer to where the indigenous peoples would be up near where it gets really close to Canada. And then there was the Middle Settlement, and that was in between the two, and yeah they are just they're like they set up these

Speaker 3these three places and they're like, yep, this this works for us. This is great. And you know, I mean they they made it work for a while, like they really did well.

Speaker 2So yeah, well a big part of what makes it work also is a little thing we called the medieval warm period.

Speaker 3Yeah, right, weird. It's weird how when it's a little bit warmer in the North Atlantic and you have longer growing seasons you can support a larger settlement in colony uh In on Greenland, and then when it gets colder that you can't. Like it's it's weird how that works, right, right, Yeah, it's weird because the whole thing's covered in.

Speaker 2Nice so yeah, it's and that's the thing, right, It's like the like, yeah, I fly over Greenland a lot, which is which is fun because like if you're going to Seattle from London.

Speaker 1You go over the pool.

Speaker 2That's awesome, which it's like it literally is, it literally is.

Speaker 4And I'm ever like sleep deprived staring out a window going.

Speaker 6Ahea, and it's fucking amazing, right, and you can see all of like the glaciers and all this stuff, and it's just I mean, it is truly on inspiring.

Speaker 4But you know, the medieval warm beery does mean that.

Speaker 2You can have these cuple of settlements where you can do agriculture, you know, and which is wild because really you shouldn't do Yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah, so yeah, is your is your think? Is your thing? Hiccupping because you're because it sounded like you stopped and then it was like and then the.

Speaker 2Think, I'm just like girls, No, I'm just like nicely wine buzzed and uh, emphasizing.

Speaker 1Weirdly for emphasis. Everything's going great.

Speaker 3Guys, that's great. Yeah. So we'll talk about like their lives and what they did in just a second. But despite this being like the edge of the world essentially to these people, and definitely the edge of the world to like Europeans at the time. Uh, there are a lot of sources about this because the Vikings were marauders and and they really looked down on people who weren't Vikings. But they did write a lot. They wrote a whole lot.

Speaker 3So I mean, there are numerous sagas, the Saga of the Greenlanders, Saga of Eric, the Red Story of the People of Floyd, the Story of Einar Skasen, story of Fox the Cunning, the story of the Oath Brothers, olof Triggvason, many more, and then of course they kept their own records on Greenland and in Iceland as well. So yeah, it's actually a fairly a fairly well documented time, although

Speaker 3of course with some of the sagas, you have to be like, oh, they encountered trolls, huh interesting? Okay, well sure, you know what, why not?

Speaker 1Cool? I like it. I prefer it that way, you.

Speaker 3Know, yeah, exactly. So, yeah, so how the people of Europe lived there, well, like, so originally they were able to begin branching out because the Vikings they had developed ships with better prowls and they had more room and more depth. So not only could more people go, they could carry more cargo over deep water and stuff like that, and that allowed them to get to Iceland and you know,

Speaker 3blah blah blah blah blah, and then Greenland and the thing about the Greenland settlements, they did adapt their ways to what they would have to do, especially later on as things became like very existential. But like at first it was We're just like we're getting supplies of the stuff that we want, the stuff that we need from Europe. That is how that's how we get that's how like

Speaker 3we get everything. Because Greenland has very little in the way of natural trees in forest. It has some short like stubby birch trees that they kept using for firewood, which is which is you know, very European because farwood is essential to European life for you know, over a thousand years and in a lot of places, not but especially Europe. Whereas the indigenous people's uh, they heated their

Speaker 3they heated their their huts and stuff by burning whale and seal blubber, which you know probably doesn't give off the most pleasant aroma, but works really well and doesn't cut down the tiny trees that you have. So yeah, they basically they just brought a piece of green of Europe to Greenland.

Speaker 5It was it was.

Speaker 3Very like thin on the edge piece. But they had they brought livestock, they had pastures for them. Archaeologists have discovered some I think it's six hundred, six hundred something, six hundred and twenty farms, the remains of six hundred and twenty total, and most of those about five hundred were at the Eastern settlement. And you know, then there were a few more at the Middle Settlement and then comparably less at the far western the Western settlement in

Speaker 3the North Man That really does throw you off. But yeah, they did farming. They they did this, and they were able to because of as Eleanor mentioned, the Medieval Warm period. Now, we haven't talked a lot about the Medieval Warm period in a while, mostly because it came up in the

Speaker 3context of the Historical Materialism series. But just for refresher, the Medieval period was a bit was a three hundred year period from about nine to fifty to twelve fifty where it got noticeably warmer in Europe, the North Atlantic. It was. There are a whole lot of like factors for this, uh that you know, a ton and it's

Speaker 3very controversial, but it was most secutely felt in Europe and the North Atlantic, but it was everywhere. And basically you had longer growing seasons and you could grow crops further up into the mountainous areas because they weren't covered with snow all the time and everything like that. And you know, this meant that part of Greenland was open for you know, to be able to put part of Europe, to turn it into a little part of Europe right there,

Speaker 3just like despite the fact that it's teen hundred kilometers almost one thousand miles from from the coast of Norway, like it's it's a long ass there.

Speaker 2Evil history is Like sometimes people will refer, for example, to the Crusader States as a form of colonialism, which I don't think it actually like, I don't think it actually works when you're talking about the Crusader States. As we said, I think that there are things that are in common Greenland that's colonialism, all right. I'm like, yes, okay, I I recognize all this shit right where they're like, no, bitch, we're bringing cows.

Speaker 1I've got to put I put the cows in the boat.

Speaker 3And we're going Like but oddly enough, this form of colonialism, the settlements they have, as far as we can tell, did not displace any one because people didn't live there. So that would be like the like the big difference between like what we think of like as now. But yeah, Eleanor's right, like these are uh, this is this is transporting you know.

Speaker 1Uh.

Speaker 3They they would have done the same thing that happened to eastern North America when we transported like you know, lawns and everything, like the Victorian ideal of like the lawn and the and the homestead and everything to eastern North America. It would have it would have happened up in Greenland if it if it could have. And it's just, uh, yeah, they just went up there and they were like, this is going to be part of Europe. And that works until it until it didn't, until it didn't. But we'll

Speaker 3get there. We'll get there in a minute. So yeah, Like the lives of these people, they I mean, these are hot. Look, you say a lot of things about the Vikings and the Norse people, but one thing, they are as hearty as fuck, Like I want to I do. Want to be clear, I've talked I've talked a lot in the past about like how in all I am of the Polynesian settlers, who who settled the outlying islands, you know, or even the closer ones, but who settled

Speaker 3all those islands and made it to to to the Americas for a little bit and left some traces and then went back. And it's like those those are some of the craziest best explorers ever. But the Vikings, like, while they exhibit a lot of the gross awful things about Europe that we hate. These are like the number two best explorers of all time, like these people like they Iceland was the third to last large island in the world to be settled by humans. It was that,

Speaker 3and then Rapuannui Easter Island, and then New Zealand. That's it, Like it is so far out there. And they made it to Greenland. They inhabited the Shetlands and I forget the Pharaoh the Pharaohe Islands, which I for my entire life thought we're in the Mediterranean because I thought it was like froh, But of course it is not. When I was a kid anyway. Yeah, so they got up there, and of course they used this as a jumping off

Speaker 3point and they went to mainland Canada for a little while. We talked about Vinland before and everything like that, and it's it's own interesting thing. But they, you know, didn't last very long because they tried to fight the locals. And you know, that's all find and good when you're on Norway or Iceland or something, but when you are two thousand miles from home, well it's not gonna work out good for you. Yeah, yeah, for a long time,

Speaker 3basically they kept during the winters, they would keep their livestock in stone barns and warm them up that way. And there are no one knows if it's facetious or not, but there are references in the sagas to them having to carry like sheep and goats out of there, out of the barns, back into the fields when when the thaw, when the thaw would happen, because their legs had been so atrophy from just sitting in and milling around this

Speaker 3tiny barn for so long. And it's like you were able to do I mean, yeah, you feel terrible for him, but like you were able to do all of this, and it's crazy. And there is no as I said, no timber. There's no iron ore on Greenland. It's it's not there's not any of that. It's the the land is all sandstone. And uh yeah. They basically relied on European shipments to get new settlers, luxury goods, iron weapons, iron.

Speaker 1I can't stress how much luxury goods here is.

Speaker 3Also like wood and salt, yes, wood it because because the water up there is not good for like you can't see salt yeah up there.

Speaker 2Yeah, And it's too, it's too far north, and like the salt basically gets extracted out of the water, so it's not very good for making salt. So and you need the salt in order to salt all the fish that they eat.

Speaker 3So yeah, yeah, yeah, And you now you might ask yourself, okay, well, these people were an overseas an overseas colony of the Norse. How did they pay for how did they pay their taxes? Why was it the Norse king sending people after them all the time? And the answer was that they were the European source of ivory for three hundred or so

Speaker 3years until the trade with Africa and elephant ivory really began in the thirteen or thirteen hundreds ish. So yeah, this is where all the all of the early ivory in Europe from And it was when the Seals, I'm sorry, the Walruses at Disco Bay where.

Speaker 1They Disco Bay. What y'all bitches know about Disco Bay?

Speaker 5Night fever?

Speaker 3Night fever?

Speaker 2What a killow Walsh, et cetera, et cetera.

Speaker 1That's what's up.

Speaker 2They're just like it's just an extracting point for Walrus ivory. That's basically it's like you have the farm to keep you ticking over. And it's like at first they're like, look, we're just like normal Scandinavian people. We have cows. And then eventually they're like, we don't have cows.

Speaker 3Hey, we had cows.

Speaker 2Had cows, all right, we had cows. But what they are doing is killing a lot of walruses, and they're just getting this ivory out, which is what everybody wants. So it's terribly important for this particular luxury good for quite some time, which explains why there's such interest in keeping this going because they're completely dependent on ships from elsewhere coming and going in order to bring these things that they need. Right, So yeah, like so what's going

Speaker 2to keep you coming and going? Because like, yeah, the only wood that they've got, like you can't build a boat out of that, those scrubby little birches. Everything else is driftwood that gets brought.

Speaker 1In by like the wag you know, the wind.

Speaker 4The current, big wind, yeah, the current, but the big one the.

Speaker 1Gulf stream there, yes, yes, all right.

Speaker 2Worth listen, she's been drinking dessert wine, folks, she can remember the word goulf stream. Uh And and so yeah, it's like you need you need someone who has enough wood to make a boat to show up and be like, hey, what's up guys.

Speaker 1Yep, you're right, that's it. Yeah.

Speaker 3And Greenland, uh, interestingly, also was a point of uh was a it was a point of trading contention because if you will recall, Norway is up around the North Sea and everything, and it's pretty close to a lot of the Hanseatic League cities. And when you know it, the Hanseatic League also loved to sail their big beautiful boats across the North Atlantic. And once they got wind

Speaker 3of the settlements in Greenland and everything, they started doing business with them to try and circumvent the ivory industry. This was made illegal by Norway. However, the Hanseatic League still sent black market ships up there for years and towards the end the Hanseatic League is going to be the last connection that they have to Europe. But yeah, we'll get there in sec anyway.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 3They built churches, they had cathedrals. There was an archbishop of Greenland until thirteen seventy or so, and then he died and the one they got to replace him was like, I'm not leaving Iceland, thanks, And they never got a new one. Yeah, yeah, I think i'd like good for him, yep, to be fair, where I wouldn't gone either. No thanks, and it's land, thank you.

Speaker 2It's quite interesting because we have like everybody knows that it's over there, right, and we do have these periodic check ins where people go over and they're like, hey, so, like I think in like fifteen forty they they see a dead body, like they find a dead body of someone and they're like, oh, this guy was fitted, like it's really fuddy.

Speaker 3Damn.

Speaker 2They're like they're like, damn this guy that this guy had that ship on. They're like they're like they record that his hood is really nice.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah they do. They're like, dude, this dude was dressed to the nines and he's dead, and.

Speaker 4It's like that's like the last Greenlander.

Speaker 2They're like Viking Greenlander that they ever report seeing and he's dead. And then after that they're like they showed back up and nobody's here anymore. And it's just kind of like one of those things where we have to kind of read between the lines yep about all of it, because Yo, these people, the Greenlanders, god bless them, like are too busy hunting walruses and also trying to raise a goat. Right now, they are not a literate people.

Speaker 2They are not writing things down. Do you think that like they can spare the goat skin for parchment.

Speaker 1They cannot. Yep, they cannot.

Speaker 2So like their priests will be illiterate, But you gotta ship their priests into them, you know.

Speaker 3That's all like, yeah, it's you know, this is all going to be well and good, even lasting past the medieval the end of the medieval Warm period in about twelve fifty, it's still going to be going pretty well. And in fact, until about thirteen fifty, the skeletal remains of Norris greens show them to be exactly or even more robustly healthy than the North Icelanders, and Greenland never

Speaker 3suffered any large communicable disease outbreaks. The thing that afflicted them most was, as you might have guessed, gout, you know, because they didn't get enough citrus, and the Black Death never made it to Greenland, but you know where it did make it to everywhere else in Europe. And in thirteen fifty things are going to take a turn for the worst. But we'll talk about that in one second, because first we need to talk about their interactions with the indigenous people of Greenland. As we said, there were

Speaker 3the Dorset and Late Dorset were there, and that's more of an archaeological culture than a people, but rarely, they rarely interacted. Maybe some violence, probably some trade, but the Dorset, not a lot is known about them. The tu Ley, on the other hand, who were incredibly interesting. They started out as a as a people and a culture and archaeological culture in like two hundred BCE on the Bearing Sea,

Speaker 3like on the Bearing Strait, and they a few times went back and forth between Siberia and North America, but eventually some of them started trickling across all of Canada until they reached Greenland by about thirteen hundred. And they are the ancestors of all Inuit peoples in Alaska and Canada and Greenland today, which is cool anyway. So, yeah,

Speaker 3the North Greenlanders interacted with the too Lee a lot. A lot of those appear to be skirmishes or battles. There were at least, you know, some positive or neutral interaction. There are I think three surviving Inuit stories of oral traditions that mentioned the North Greenlanders, and one of them is about a battle, and another of them is about one of them playing a practical joke on some of

Speaker 3the Norse and like beating on the outside of their tent, like scaring the shit out of them. And yeah, so they had some interaction. There are tu Le sites that have iron objects which had to come from European interactions because there was no iron native iron working to North America. And there are surviving Tule carvings that appear to show people with European features as opposed to the people you know that that have that have their features of more

Speaker 3of the carvings. But basically, the Vikings didn't take kindly to to people who they thought were lesser than them and probably fought with the Tule a lot. They're also near here. They were the Innu or the in O and the Bentok peoples, but they are they would have interacted more with Vinland than anything in Greenland. So you know, I would say it was a portent of things to

Speaker 3come in terms of how interactions between europe and Indigenous Americans will go. Unfortunately, unfortunately, not not great, and I mean probably could have used good relations with these people when the end comes. So yeah, let's talk about the end. So about thirteen fifty, Uh, wouldn't you know it, the shipments stop from I'm sorry, Yeah, about thirteen fifty the

Speaker 3shipments stop. And coincidentally, that is the exact time that everybody's said death starts and the Black Death when it hit Norway because Scandinavia is densely populated due to you know, not having a ton of arable or livable land. It ravaged Norway as similar to how it did with Italy, and the city of Bergen, which was the main port

Speaker 3from which everything left to the for the eastern settlement in Greenland, was decimated. Fifty to sixty percent of the city was killed by the Black Death, and that their shipments got cut badly. In thirteen sixty nine. There had been a specific ship that had gone from Bergen to Greenland since you know, since the tenth century, and it sank.

Speaker 3They didn't replace it.

Speaker 2And yeah, but like why also, like to be fair, like why would you at this point because the thing that it's for is for the wall res ivory and we have Russians.

Speaker 3Now you have Russians. The Portuges had opened up a couple of the little trading outposts and they had opened up part of like African trade in ivory uh and elephant ivrey. According to people who are experts in this, elephan ivory is much better than seal or wall rec ivory in terms of you know, shaping it, carving it, using it, et cetera. So, when things got bad in Greenland,

Speaker 3perhaps unsurprisingly, the far northern Western Settlement was the first to go in thirteen sixty or a around thirteen sixties believed was the last was when the Western Settlement was abandoned. Whether whether it was abandoned or destroyed by the Touhley in a battle is unknown. There are competing there are

Speaker 3competing ideas about that. However, the Sagas don't the way that the Sagas described it don't really make it seem like if there was a bat, like they they blame it on on the Tuley, who they called scralings. But they also don't describe a lot of bloodshed. They don't describe like a lot of like we know, there's skirmishes. There were skirmishes, they fought battles, who knows.

Speaker 2But but like also so it's one of these things, right, like a thing that that people talk about is we know something happened out at the Western settlement because for example, we found completely untouched larders full of food, yeah right.

Speaker 3And when and when the people went to see it, they still found livestock there. First of all, any attackers worth anything in that part of the world would have slaughtered the livestock because they weren't going to survive the winner and you could use the meat and hides, yeah, and bones for that matter. And uh but but the but the livestock were there. They were still there.

Speaker 2And and it's not like what we find from people too is that they're like, oh, and we found a bunch of dead bodies, Like, so we don't we actually don't know. It is a little bit of a mystery. Maybe they were killed by by the tilly.

Speaker 1We don't know. Maybe I'm like, well, maybe they fucking killed each other.

Speaker 2Maybe someone was just sick of Spend's bullshit, you know, like they're not people who are pretty chill. Let's just say that, right, So like it could be something like that. You know, we just literally do not know exactly how all of this petered out because no, like and I just think that if it was obvious that they'd been massacred, by the Tully. I think that some would have been like, oh, yeah, that's what happened, But they don't say that either, right.

Speaker 3And there's no grave or mass grave. There's no set of graves that matched that time period. There's no mass grave whatsoever. So like if they killed them, where were the bodies, because there were no bodies according to the people who found them, who had been sent by the King of Norway, because nobody had heard from the settlement in like a decade. By that point, nobody in Europe had sure the Eastern Settlement. But then again when they went to the Eastern Settlement, they were like, yeah, we hadn't heard from them in a couple of years. It's like, oh, you guys were like two hundred miles by ship, so

Speaker 3you guys didn't hang out, Like no, they're the seal guys. Where the pastor guys and uh yeah, So we have no idea what happened to the Western Settlement. They could have gone into northern Canada and tried to you know, maybe you know, find some of the old Vinland sites and you know, tried started that way. There was an old theory that they kind of assimilated into the the Tully or the indigenous people. But genetic research has never

Speaker 3borne that out, so you know, doesn't look likely unless we find something new about that. The Eastern Settlement hung on, but it was not great, and the last merchant ship left for Greenland left from Norway for Greenland in fourteen oh six. The final chronological written European record comes from

Speaker 3fourteen oh eight when a Icelandic captain married a local Greenlandish Norse woman at the Havalsi Church on the very southern tip of the island. And the ruins of the church are still there to this day. And uh yeah, after that, scattered reports the no one saw the settlement confirmed, after the Eastern Settlement, no one, no one saw it

Speaker 3in working order after fourteen twenty and I believed to have been gone by the fourteen fifties. And this is there. Well, there are a lot of reasons for it, but one of the big ones is that we get the start of the Little Ice Age, and the little ice Age is going hits the North Atlantic like a fucking new sea. Ice grows rapidly. The trip, not only the trip to Greenland,

Speaker 3trip to Iceland has become far more perilous. The storms are way worse up there. It's just not good. And the Gulf, like the you know, the various reasons for you know, the Little Ice Age, just like with the Medieval Warm period. There's a ton of them, including like you know, the Sun's warrant, that the sun lost its warrant because it was going through a slight cooling period, which does happen from time to time. And also probably

Speaker 3less carbon dioxide on the planet because of all the death from you know, the Black Death probably didn't help things either, But yeah, they were ice skating on the Thames in what was it, August June in Europe, like it was like, it's not good for it's not good for skirting the Arctic Circle, let's say, to get to to get to this far away place, which now if you're a European has no use for you because you

Speaker 3can get ivory elsewhere quite easily. It's like okay, well cool.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah, And I mean it does definitely signal a change in European habits writ large byt the time, and indeed worldwide, you have to have a lot of different crops that come in. We certainly see that animal varieties of the wild type change, so for example, kinds of hawks that are now common in Africa used to live in England and suddenly they don't know more, right yep.

Speaker 1So like it.

Speaker 2Changes, it changes rather a lot, but it definitely changes your emotional support colony where you send like weird murderous losers so that they can go get you some.

Speaker 1Some like Walrus Ivory.

Speaker 2And you know, like it's interesting because for a while, like you know, it's like five hundred years that they're there. It's it's it's not it's not nothing, right, it's longer than America's existed and uh, and go ahead, and we know from like archaeological evidence and everything that there is enough contact with Europe that like they're keeping up with fashion, Like they wear the same sort of clothing that like Norwegians would wear, for example. It's like that like nothing nothing is odd there, but it's just that it is

Speaker 2very far away, and I mean our best guesses are basically that it just becomes really uncomfortable to live there and it kind of sucks. And basically if you have a way of getting out, you get out. Yeah, Like everyone, like every strong young, strapping buck you know, with a strong back, leaves for a while, because it's like it's.

Speaker 3Where they die because they go on increasingly perilous missions to find food. I mean you should say that the Greenland Norris did eventually start adopt adopting, adopting the the the indigenous lifestyle. They turned more towards use of whale blubber for heating. Uh. They started consuming a lot more fish and and stuff like that. They started wearing seal

Speaker 3skins and furs which are much warmer than you're than typical uh, you know, fat the typical fabrics used. And so they did. And one of the people that that Eleanor mentioned earlier, the last guy that they found, he was the fine clothes that he was wearing were the fine clothes that the the Tuley people would wear. And they thought he was an indigenous American until they turned him over and they were like, oh, he's got red

Speaker 3hair like us. Huh, well that's something probably. Yeah. So they adopted to they adapted to the to that lifestyle to some degree. But you have to fully adapt, you have to fully adopt it to survive up there when it gets cold like this, and you simply can't because, like as we said, the new ivory markets opened up.

Speaker 3There were definitely some battles with the Tuley and they were probably fighting over dwindling resource, food resources and stuff like that. You couldn't grow crops anymore, absolutely not. That was that was out probably beginning, you know, in the thirteen fifties or so, and the Hanseiotic League couldn't keep up the shipments. They couldn't make it that far with everything that was going on. I mean, the Hansa cities

Speaker 3got decimated, just like Bergen and everywhere else. And then the Black Death hit Iceland in fourteen hundred and so whatever you were getting from there, you weren't getting, like there's no way to keep this up. And this is like the reason why we don't have the reason why we don't have medieval colonialism the same as we do with early with the early modern period is because in the Early Modern period they could have shipped enough people

Speaker 3and enough goods. They had the technology and the ships to ship people over there to try and help these settlements like eke out in existence for a while. In the Middle Ages, they cannot do that. They do not have they First of all, there after the Black Death, there are not enough people in Europe to spread out like that they were taking over their own land. They were re taking over the land on the continent that had been abandoned by the people who died. They're not

Speaker 3they're not enough people to go there. It's too long and treacherous of a journey to like to send people for like no return, Like there's no there's no resources to be exploited up there, now that you have an alternate avenue for ivory, like there's just not so Like, what what is the purpose of this? Like you know, once what's the people who live out there die out?

Speaker 7There's no Yeah, Like what like if it exists specifically to extract one good and you get cheaper goods more easily than fuck it?

Speaker 2Right, Like that's what it comes down to. And you can see here till you're blue in the face and say, why did it? Why did it collapse as a colony? Is it because of soil erosion? Is it because of one of the big things is drought? We think possibly? Is it because they are beefing with the till a like why why it doesn't happen? And ultimately the answer why it happened is because you're very long way from Europe and no one cares to re up your white.

Speaker 3People confluence of material factors.

Speaker 2Motherfucker, have no you mentioned this is a historical materialist podcast.

Speaker 3That's right, Yeah, they look it's not.

Speaker 1Hmm.

Speaker 3The thing about the Greenland settlements is that they are impressive. They are technically impressive. They are it's impressive you are able to make it that far. It's impressive you're able to carve out a living on that land. They are also a monument to the hubris of Europeans who think that they have to take Europe everywhere they go and and and turn everywhere into into Europe. And you know, and too the Vikings who like, I mean, they looked down on the fucking English, they look down on on

Speaker 3the French that they encountered before they turned into Normans, like they look down on all these people. So they certainly looked down on the like indigenous peoples of Greenland, you know, to a certain degree. And that show, I mean that chauvinism exists there. It doesn't, that doesn't, you know. It's not like, uh, it's it's a chauvinism of like, you know, these people are backward and we don't need them, and it's like, well, they look backward compared to you.

Speaker 3But these people have like created an existence that spans across that spans from the Pacific to the Atlantic quite literally. Like you would have no way of knowing this because you're not going to sit down and have a nice little algonquin roundtable about it with them. But like, you know, that's insanely impressive to be able to do that, to carve out land like that on you know, on ice sheets and tundras is incredible, And it's like, yeah, maybe they they did know something. Maybe if we hadn't cut

Speaker 3down on these fucking trees, you know, uh, if we stopped trying to burn firewood and just burned whale blubber that was there by the poundful, like you know.

Speaker 1Nope, yeah, no, no, thank you, but yeah, yeah.

Speaker 3The In the end, I think the Greenland Norse settlements are like a testament to like this, uh, this window that they have with the medieval warm period and and the Norse people that kind of stretching out and doing this, uh this proto version of what we of we see now as colonialism and it's and and how they did make it work until I mean there was just no

Speaker 3once the economic basis for it to exist goes away. Mainland Europe is going to stop caring. Iceland is going to stop caring because Iceland it there's a matter during the midio. I mean it does. But like when the little ice age hits Iceland, you know what, they've still got volcanic soil that is kind that like it still allows for like fields and crops and stuff, and like Greenland does not have that, Like the ice would have covered up all those little thin edge settlements. Yeah, so

Speaker 3you got you know, you you you you did this like kind of amazing thing and then you got what's coming to you for being a bunch of dumbass chauviness. So mm hmm, no, like I don't. Yeah, it's it's a very interesting Uh, it's just just it's a very interesting thing because it's this little colony and we did it and it didn't work. It could never possibly work in the long term, but you know, they made.

Speaker 1It, but it might just work for us.

Speaker 3Yeah, but it might just yeah, exactly.

Speaker 1It was so cute.

Speaker 2In like the twelfth century. It was actually like Vibey you.

Speaker 3Could go you go out there, you'd be like Greenland, that's the place with the blue eyes. Huh. They're like, yeah, come see our beautiful blue ice up.

Speaker 1You like ice?

Speaker 3I hope you like ice cows. Yeah, And you know, this is uh, this is kind of a little a little bit of a Segway episode because next week I think we're going to start a series on medieval land management, and this is a little preview of what they did because uh, they fertilized the soil here and they were able to grow crops out of the fucking permafrost. But uh man, not for long, not for long, and they

Speaker 3had to they had to like break themselves to like even get that meager bit out. So yeah, it's yeah, it's great, good job everyone. Uh this definitely would will not have repercussions for the future any sort.

Speaker 1M hmm.

Speaker 2But listen, people have been asking about it, and lord look at us responding to current events.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah. As I said earlier, leave Greenland alone. Let Greenland do what Greenland wants to do with itself. Uh, I don't know. I have no idea. I have no idea what they're gonna do, how they I have no idea how they're gonna respond. I hope they don't give the baby his bottle. But I fear that the baby will get his bottle because to not do so would mean breaking the world, and I don't think any of

Speaker 3them want to be responsible for that, so quite, But we're not gonna get out of this without breaking NATO and the dollar hegimony.

Speaker 1So well, I like that part.

Speaker 3Somebody's gonna have to somebody's gonna have to pull the last jinga block at some point, and I honestly think it's probably gonna end up being America itself, but we'll get there.

Speaker 1I love the native It's dead part, but you.

Speaker 3Know that's yeah, yeah, well, I mean that's like, I mean, that's the problem with this is like what you really want is to is for everyone to just, you know, thumb their nose a trump and be like tell them to fuck off and die. But like with the army, unless unless Paris is shooting nukes at the east coast of America. I mean, I'm not trying to be a dick, but like.

Speaker 5Mmm, like I don't I don't think I don't know, but I mean, uh, for example, today we've got a pull out of the UK that says fifty percent of people here are in favor.

Speaker 1Of getting rid of the US Army bases here. Do I think that's neat?

Speaker 3Remove all of them, get all of them out. The ghost of stop the Force, ghost of Stalin is not coming through the fall to Gap. It's not happening. Just fucking kill Nato Kelly Kelly, Yeah, yeah, anyway, Uh god man, Europe has put itself into just an insanely fine mess. Uh that hooray. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, like, look,

Speaker 3uh yeah, that's uh. I don't the only the only thing, the only redeeming quality Trump has is that he loves, uh screwing with European leaders and reminding them that they are vassals to America because they are, and if they do not want to be vassals to America, which I don't think they should be, there are ways to avoid that, and I think everybody knows what they are, namely, uh, get ready to learn a dollar to yu one conversion, buddy.

Speaker 3But you know, yeah, it's uh, it's fun. That's that's you know, that's uh, that's enough of the real world. It was fun to talk about Greenland. I have no idea that I keep himming and hauling over the end of this episode, but I do anyway, folks. As I said, next time we'll be back by. We'll be back with a bit on the medieval land management. We're gonna do a series. We're gonna talk about farming, forestry, fishing, swineherding.

Speaker 3There are other famines. Something we've never specifically talked about, but was one of the biggest drivers have changed throughout all of human history until about two hundred three hundred years ago and may very well be back in the near future. For yeah, for those of us in the Imperial Core. But hey, you know across that bridge when we come to it anyway, you guys have been asking for it. Medieval land management coming up, eleanor what what the fuck is going on?

Speaker 1What the fuck is going on?

Speaker 3Mate?

Speaker 1I don't know.

Speaker 2Been recording a lot of bibs and bobs, but I don't think any of them are out yet. So you know, I'm in one of those periods where I keep doing a bunch of things for other people, but it hasn't yet come to fruition.

Speaker 1So watch the space. Best place to find me.

Speaker 2You can find me on Instagram at doctor eleanor Yanaga. You can find me onbsky dot app at going medieval where today I've been losing my mind because I made a really obvious joke about how I like Zora and Mom Donnie, and because it's blue Sky, people have come to lecture me about how he is a good socialist, and I'm just sending lots of the Rainier wool Castle saying that's the joke to people over and over again. So it's pretty cool over there. Yeah, I'm still there.

Speaker 1What am I gonna do? K Hey, I suddenly can't hear you.

Speaker 3It's it's amazing. We've got two social media apps and both of them suck for completely different reasons. It's amazing how we were able to do that, and no one just said, here's a clone of twenty seventeen Twitter. Go nuts. Anyway, I guess you can ever go back again, huh. Anyway, Yeah, you can find me, Luca's amazing. You know, you can find my old People's history of the Old Republic if you want to hear me talk about Star Wars. But anyway, that's gonna do it for us today, and we'll see you next time.

Speaker 4Go bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 302 - Onfim and Medieval Children

    Nov 20, 202654 minAudio

    they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 301 - Enter Leviathan, or, Why the Early Modern Period Sucked

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 24 minAudio

    folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 300 - November Mailbag

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 299 - Army of Darkness Review

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 298 - Welcome to the Crusades 2.2 Mosul

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode