Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

We're Not So Different

We're Not So Different artwork

Medieval Warfare 1: Size Queens

Oct 7, 202659 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts

folks, we don't talk about military history all that much on the show except as an aspect of the overall narratives and histories we tell. however, we do sometimes have to talk about it specifically because it is both interesting and necessary to understanding things. it's not the end-all, be-all, most important thing ever as it is sometimes portrayed but, ya know, you can't fully enforce your politics from the throne, now can you? that monopoly of violence is there for a reason. anyway, we start a two-part series talking about the evolutions of Medieval armies in Afroeurasia. this time, we talk about why the size of European armies dropped so drastically following the fall of Western Rome (while Eastern Rome and Asia did not), how was military training accomplished on a macro level, why the Crusades acted as a kickstarter to future European military endeavors, and more! next time: gunpowder! enjoy. cover image is part of an illuminated manuscript by Jean Froissart about the Battle of Crecy

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2So listen, let's get into it because both you and I are burnt the fuck out. That's right. But we're here to bring the good content to the people nonetheless.

Speaker 1Nonetheless. Yep.

Speaker 2Yep.

Speaker 1All right, folks. So on this show, we are dedicated to discussing the history of the Middle Ages, no matter the cost to ourselves. Oh, sure. We might play it cool and act like this is all A big, fun time where two friends are just cutting loose and yapping about our shared hyperfixation on the medieval era. But that's just the placid surface, masking something far more horrific. For the most part, our sources are conventional. You know, historical studies, historiographical trends, reviews of archaeological finds, things of that nature.

Speaker 1These suffice for most of the topics we cover within the realms of culture, economic, political... Social, religious, or general history. This stuff is our meat and potatoes here on We're Not So Different Pod, and we usually stick to it. But every once in a great while, we're forced to call upon far darker arts to present the Middle Ages to you. Sources so malevolent and vile that they stain the soul of any and all who gaze upon them,

Speaker 1no matter how long they look. no one, not even the most hardened and grizzled veterans of abyssal historical analysis, can hope to come away unscathed. The dark chasm of this knowledge spares none who glance upon it, corrupting the minds of some of the greatest students and enlightened academics to ever grace the field. I speak, of course, of the darkest and most perverse art in the historian's toolkit, military history. Yes, yes, I know, I can hear your audible gas from here, even as I write this intro.

Speaker 1They filter back to me through the mists of time, little screams into the void as you seek to reject such heresy. And believe me, I understand your concern. The siren song of military history has doomed many a vessel attempting to pilot the rough seas of historical knowledge. However, unbeknownst to most, I have spent decades training to withstand the darkness that is military history. Oh, there have been times when I came close to giving in to the madness and Nights from the Cacophony of the Abyss came to me with pleasing tones and honeyed words enticing me

Speaker 1to the dark side, telling me to read just one more article on Mongol battle tactics and make their overwhelming military dominance the key factor to any discussion of their empire. But I, I stood my ground, armed as I was with the war hammer of autistic special interest, which in my case doesn't really include military history outside of a couple of battles here and there, and the shield of historical materialism. which is emblazoned with its typical heraldry, an image of Marx and Engels kissing on a red circle

Speaker 1amidst a field of red and yellow alternating chevrons. Regardless, man, I wrote this like a week ago. Regardless, I returned once again from the dark chasm of military history, bruised and bloodied from the ordeal, but defiantly unbroken and with a short series on the evolution of old world medieval militaries. Why am I polluting our pure, wholesome podcast with such taboo topics? Well, the first and most obvious reason is that while military actions aren't the primary movers of history

Speaker 1that many claim them to be, they are incredibly important. At some point, you know, the political gives way to the marshal as a means of enforcing whatever ideology is going to win. After all, the threat of imminent Military invasion or the existential terror attended to war are two of the most acute material pressures in human history. So where the fuck, why ain't my mouse working? There we go. Sorry. So we can't really swear it off entirely, but also we've never really covered it in too much depth on

Speaker 1the show. And there are important questions to be answered about how and why medieval militaries changes they did in Afro Eurasia. For example, Why did the size of non-Byzantine European militaries plummet for about a millennia following the collapse of the Western Roman Empire, while the Chinese armies that duked it out in the wake of the collapse of the Han Dynasty were still putting positively massive armies in the field? Despite their martial prowess, why did military training, strategy, and logistics seemingly disappear from European armies for so long?

Speaker 1why did it take so long for gunpowder to spread? And why didn't the Chinese state expand even further in all directions in line with its highly advanced military tech? They had gunpowder for a solid 400 years before anyone else. What the fuck? Were the Mongols really the accidental impetus that kickstarted the military revolution that swept Europe in the 13th and 14th centuries? Well, we're going to talk about that over the next couple of episodes. So yeah, folks, um, Just going to do a short series here. Here's how

Speaker 1we're going to do it. This week, we're going to discuss the changes that occurred within Europe, why the sizes of armies dropped, the methods used for training such large irregular armies, the slow march towards modern combined arms, the Crusades as a catalyst for military buildup in Europe, and new technologies of the era. Basically, everything that doesn't have to do with gunpowder, Chinese military evolution, and how the Mongols changed everything. Which we're going to talk about next time.

Speaker 1If my stupid computer will fucking work properly.

Speaker 2Why are both of our computers, like, trying to take the day off?

Speaker 1I ask you. I have no idea, Eleanor. I have no idea. But I'm glad, you know, sheltering here on the rock. I'm glad I'm here with you at the end of all things as the eagles fly down and shoot at us with machine guns. Quite so. Fuckers. Yeah. So, yeah, folks, listen, I know for a fact that military history is not the favorite of everyone who listens here. And I get that. However,

Speaker 1I mean.

Speaker 2Look, we do gender history on this podcast. OK, and this is gender history because men also have a gender. And so like that's that's.

Speaker 1You know. I was going to go with something. Okay, no, that's good. That's fine. There you go. Look, I do think it is important because we make the joke all the time. It's like 55 guys fighting in a field to improve one man's land by half an acre.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And, like, that was a battle. And some of those battles were and have been incredibly important to world history because of, you know, a bunch of stuff. But, like, I mean, the Song Dynasty military in 1041 had 1.25 million people. 1.25 million. That is... It's a flex. That is way... That is... three times the size of the

Speaker 1largest medieval city when constant noble had like 500 000 people like that is fucking yeah it so so why um and uh you know i went through and i was looking uh looking through a couple things and i and and i i just wanted to talk about like uh how these did change so drastically. Oh, Hey cabbage. It's a cabbage.

Speaker 2She had to get onto the counter.

Speaker 1Uh, big cab. She's trying to be, Oh yeah.

Speaker 2You're going to touch the microphone.

Speaker 1Oh, big.

Speaker 2Oh, there you go. Okay.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Okay.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Goodbye.

Speaker 1Bye. Yeah. So, um, you know, they were big, uh, clearly under the Roman, the Greeks and the Romans, the militaries are very big. Uh, and then after that they got, uh, precipitously smaller. Now, Eleanor, I know military history is at your forte in this. However... Lord knows I've taught it, though. Yeah. I do understand you are very familiar. What is the typical... Like, what is the typical reasoning given? Because I do want

Speaker 1to be very clear. Like, while these other militaries are more advanced, more technologically advanced, it's not like... And I love to make fun of Europe as much as possible, but it's not like Europe was getting... getting thrown off the field every time they fought a military outside of it. They did sometimes, but not every time. Yeah.

Speaker 2And I think one of the major differences that we are seeing here is just centralization of power. You know, listen, it's a historical materialist podcast. I hope you want to hear about material causation, right? Because fundamentally, when we are talking about the Roman Empire, whether that is old school and then Western and then it doesn't exist anymore. Or the Eastern Roman Empire, which is still using the old gambit, you know, that the empire was using. The issue is

Speaker 2that you have really high taxation there. And, you know, essentially one of the things that we see that like precipitates the onset. of the Middle Ages is, you know, the age of migrations when we have all these people coming off of the steppe and into Europe. And eventually the Romans are like, we literally can't do anything about this, right? Like there's absolutely no possible way that we can continue even like despite our massive armies, right? We cannot in

Speaker 2any way, shape or form just keep fighting this many people. It's not going to be a possibility. And so as a result, they end up, Making deals with them. You know, barbarians are allowed, their words, not mine. That's what they call them. Barbarians are allowed into the army. Barbarians gain huge positions within the Roman army. But then like out on the frontiers, out on the edges and peripheries of the empire, eventually like the large landowners get a bit annoyed by all of this. They're like, why am I even paying taxes to Rome that goes like all the

Speaker 2way down into Rome in order to deal with this? And there's still a bunch of barbarians in my backyard. Right. Like what, like what's, what's in it for me, the taxpayer, what I could do if what we're doing is we're just conciliating and that's all we care about is I could just do that myself. And for a smaller price, I can pay off the local warlords, have them work for me, and then we'll just do it that way. So increasingly we see fewer and fewer people actually paying into the state. And it is absolutely crucial that you

Speaker 2have a strong centralized state with a huge taxation structure. In order to have a standing army like that, like that's what we're seeing in China, right? Like we're seeing a well-regulated state structure, which is why like people are so like, is it medieval? Like what are we looking at when we talk about China? Because if what we're talking about is modernity as a series of things existing, well,

Speaker 2they've got it. Over in China, right? They got all that shit. They're like, they ain't worried about that. They've got the tax structure. They've got the standing army, like as you have well.

Speaker 1Noted, right?

Speaker 2Now, the thing about Europe within the successor states is that they do not have a taxation structure like this any longer. And essentially what you see is the people who were rising through the armies being like, yeah, okay, look at me. Like, look at me. Now I'm the captain, right? Um, and so they're saying, all right, well, look again, cut out the middleman. Now I'm just the king, right? And the difference between a king and an emperor is that you don't have a state system, right? Like there is no, we have secular authority, but not a state. And I

Speaker 2think that that's a really important thing for us to consider because I think a lot of the time when we are chatting about what we mean, we sometimes kind of use the word state, but that's, that's, you know, fundamentally incorrect because they're, they ain't giving you nothing, right? Like this is, this is a hundred percent, a bunch of stuff that is happening. Like when you get taxed, you're not getting anything in return, right? Like basically what you're doing is you're paying off the guys who are considered to be your social betters. You're just paying off the nobility, right? So we have this change, like, and

Speaker 2essentially the way that society works is that what they're saying is that there is a group of people, the nobility who, who now have a monopoly on violence, on listed violence, right? And what they are going to do is, in theory, wield that in such a way that it is not your problem so much. They're going to point it at other places, and in return for that, you, like, pay all their bills, right? And so it's kind of like, okay,

Speaker 2there's an army that's going to protect you if, like, some other rich guy comes in. Right. You are going to want someone to fight them of some way, shape or form. But it is also kind of like a protection racket. Right.

Speaker 1Oh, yeah.

Speaker 2Let's be sober fucking real. Right. It's kind of like, oh, yeah, like nice crops you got here. Shame if someone came and trampled on them. Right.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And I mean, I know if you're if you're very familiar with, you know, Chinese history, you might be thinking, OK, well, like. The Chinese state after the Han, which was the one that was analogous to the Achaemenid or partially the Achaemenids and the Romans, after it split up, you know, why was China still doing this? Even though when Rome essentially blew up, like, you know,

Speaker 1they were not having these huge armies. And the answer is that China's had a bureaucratic state.

Speaker 2Mm-hmm.

Speaker 1Since before jesus was born i mean like it's just like you can like it's not it's not like i you know as i said earlier i don't want to get into this thing where like people are naturally better because of where they're from or anything like that but when you have a bureaucratic state structure like that in place and it's been there for by the time the han broke up it's been there for eight six to 800 years like i mean you know you just can't

Speaker 1there's nothing to compare with that like think about uh 600 years before rome broke up that was you know like that was you know like the 200s like rome was important but rome it only like started to solidify and centralize itself in like I believe it was like the like late 200s BCE. And I mean, like we're talking about solidified self coming from the Greeks and the Greeks were not centralized fucking at all. Even after like,

Speaker 1Oh God, no, no. Yeah. And, and so when China splits apart, like it's like, okay, but yeah, we've still like, we still have all these bureaucrats coming in and they could talk about, you know, this is how, you know, we're supposed to do this and this. And like, you can, When you have like a system of like generals in place like this, where they are trained and they do have military academies of a sort, they're clearly not that advanced, but they're way more advanced than any other military training

Speaker 1apparatus in the world at the time. You know, you're going to be able to hold your armies together better. And also, I mean, there are just way, way, way, way, way more people in China than there are in Europe. Yeah. There's so many more people in China than Europe.

Speaker 2And a part of this has to do with, you know, the fact that they just kind of have an agricultural system that is taking over a bit better and a bit, you know, more regularly. They are really well set up in order to kind of have the crops just kind of coming in regardless, you know. That that's certainly happening in a way that, you know, for example, because I think the fractiousness, the fractiousness of European society and the

Speaker 2way that it works and the way that it's like privileging these smaller parcels of power. One of the things that happens as a result of that is when you do wage war, you're fucking up the agriculture so hard wherever it is you're going.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2Like when the I don't know, like the Hundred Years War happens and it's like, I was interviewing someone for work the other day and she was like, oh, you know, the Hundred Years' War, some English people would decide they're going to go to France and ride around. It's like, get their asses.

Speaker 1No, that is.

Speaker 2That's like a hundred percent true.

Speaker 1It was towards the end. That's what they did right before Joan of Arc came around. They were just like, all right, time to go on Chevalier across central and northern France. And they didn't have the power to actually completely annex all of it. But the French crown was like, I don't know, man. I like the Ile de France, I guess. This is nice. Paris is nice. I don't know what you guys are doing.

Speaker 2Well, that's crazy. Like 100% right. So that's sort of what's happening within the European context, within the Chinese context, because they've conquered so much land. Even if, say, you know, you have a Mongol incursion, right? Something like that. And obviously they do. And sometimes the Mongols take over. Obviously that also happens. But one of the big differences is fundamentally that you have such a large empire that even if you have, like, the food impacted in one place,

Speaker 2it's not going to impact everybody, right? And also you can kind of move food around a little bit better. Like, it's possible for you to go, okay, yeah, I see what's happening over there. Let's, you know, we need to get some food up there. Like, let's go. Let's move this stuff. Whereas like in Europe, because that's a whole other ass kingdom. Yeah. That's just not going to happen.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2So it is this, this fractious nature. And I suppose that like, you know, the, the issue is to an extent, like the petty bourgeoisie, let's call lower nobility, petty bourgeoisie. I'm doing it like, right. Like this is before we have them in the States, but it's like, they're like, this is mine. This is what I'm choosing to have control over. And I would rather this sort of chaos, right? And I mean, I suppose that doesn't necessarily hold true if what we're talking about is the Eastern Roman Empire. But the trouble that the Eastern Roman Empire have is

Speaker 2they're attempting to still be the Roman Empire, but they've lost their taxation base of Egypt, right?

Speaker 1Yeah which is like.

Speaker 2The thing that they need um and that this happens as a result of the fact that within a desert environment uh guerrilla warfare is much smarter than uh you know large armies which i don't know i don't know that's crazy i don't know if we could learn anything about that possibly um in the 21st century doesn't doesn't seem relevant.

Speaker 1I don't know yeah and i mean um so like just looking at like the pure numbers of some of these um so if we i just wanted to compare a little bit just just just to just to give everyone a flavor so the battle of issus which was uh in i think it was like 220 223 something like that bce alexander versus darius the third um it was their first battle and uh at These are using all modern estimates. It's Alexander's army had 37,000. Darius had 60,000.

Speaker 1And of course, Alexander I at Cannae, which was the largest battle, the largest army the Romans ever fielded, which was 86,000. They faced 50,000 Carthaginians and Carthaginian allies. So we're talking about almost 140,000 people on the field there. The Teutoburg Forest, which was in 9 CE, was 22,000

Speaker 1versus 20,000. So you're looking at about 40 there. Adrianople, which was a couple hundred years later and was one of those huge, just devastating losses towards the end, was about 15,000 versus 15,000. And so, like, you're seeing how, like, Rome has, as it started to fracture, as the edges have broken away, as everything's pulled apart under the contradictions,

Speaker 1their ability to bring in that many people to fight these battles is no longer there. Because while Italy is one of the more densely populated places on the planet and has been for a very long time, it's... Population density is not because they have like underground caverns where babies are just flung out of them. It's population density is because there's a lot of people in a lot of city states on a small amount of land.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And you cannot keep reaching in for that. Because remember, we're talking about Cannae, 86,000, an 86,000 person army, 95% of that army was destroyed. completely, utterly fucking annihilated off the field. Like, I mean, we're talking about sold into slavery, killed, unaccounted for, like, just the whole, everything. So, like, and I mean, again, you know, to Rome's credit, in this case, like, they did survive Cannae, like, and you, there are very, very,

Speaker 1very few empires that have ever survived, like, the worst loss in their history and still, like, you know, and still kept going for another 600 years you know it's uh yeah yeah it's a big deal and then it um so after you get out of that after you're after rome like finally does break apart uh one of the first big battles in europe that we think of is the battle of tours and i mean for the time it was big it's about 15 000 versus 20 000 or so and that's huge and you're like holy

Speaker 1shit you know so they should be able to get everything but no if you remember tours like while it is a big propaganda thing, they were pulling every ally that they had all the way from Italy, France, Christians in Iberia. They were pulling everyone they could to get that because Charlemagne was fighting like, Charlemagne considered an amazing general. He was fighting battles that had like 4,000 people in them total. Like, you know, it's just like, this, like

Speaker 1at tours is the big thing. And then, Lechfeld, which is, I don't think we've ever actually talked about it by name, but it is one of the most important battles in European history because it solidified the Ottonian hold over what would become the Holy Roman Empire. At Lechfeld, there were 8,000 versus 7,000. There were 15,000 total people on the field for one of the most important battles in history at Crecy. Uh, 1346,

Speaker 1there were only 30,000, but I mean, that is bigger. And then at Grunwald, which is 1410, uh, there were, it was 25,000 versus 20,000. So you start to see it expand. But again, that's how, what Eleanor was talking about, because that's when the state centralization happens, you know, as, as, uh, Constantinople as its state structure is being pulled apart by all the other factors and being in the middle of all these things. uh europe was able to just kind

Speaker 1of you know fight amongst itself for a while and um and yeah and i mean so at this time uh the byzantines um in 628 at nineveh they uh which was the end of the uh final byzantine assassinated war they brought 40 000 to the field at yarmouk In 636, they brought 30,000 to face the Muslims and lost. And that, as Eleanor mentioned, that was the battle where

Speaker 1they then lost Egypt. And even at Manzikert in 1071, they had 40,000. Now, you know, about 20,000 of those were allies. But, you know, still, you are able to call that many people out and they come out. Yeah, it's something. Yeah. And so like, that's, you know, that's kind of what you're looking at. But I mean, the size disparity basically is like, there are fewer people generally in Europe at that time. Obviously not now. There are

Speaker 1so many gigantic cities in Europe, but like at the time, yes. And then they just didn't have states. Like, you know, the Rome, the state structure of Rome just didn't hold on after that. Not very well anyway. Right.

Speaker 2No, because fundamentally you have to have, like, I mean, the entire point of Rome and how it works as, like, a conceit is that it has to be ever-expanding, right? You know, it's got to kind of be moving into places at all times because, you know, that's what empires do, right? It's all about, like, where are we going next? And that kind of expansion is part of this understanding that there's going to be something extractive that's going to happen at the end that is going to be able to continue to fund... Whatever the fuck it is, you know,

Speaker 2that we're attempting to do here, right? Like, take a pick, you know? And if there's, like, no business opportunities, then they can't command these same levels of taxation. And it's like, you see, I'm closing it in, like, pretty fast. Like, to be honest, you know, like, yeah, the way that it's structured when it's at its height, sure, like, it's pretty impressive. Yeah, like, I'm not saying that it isn't. But also at the same time, it's like they're pretty much like, yeah, I'm going to get the fuck out of like Britain pretty quick.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2Because it becomes clear that it's not particularly paying after a while. And, you know, you've got all these other problems with the Goths and Vandals. It's like, I don't need to be like fighting the Celts up here, too. This is a little bit, like, above my pay grade. And so, you know, it starts falling in. You know, they're always going to be more interested. I think it's interesting because there's this kind of, like, Eurocentric way of thinking about the Roman Empire. It's like, they're more interested in Egypt, bro. Like, you know, like, Hadrian is like,

Speaker 2that's enough of England. Anyway, I'm going to go do a genocide against Jewish people right now. And I'm going to, like, make a fucking... And I'm going to make an Egyptian city for my twink, right? And that tells you everything you need to know about where their priorities lay, right? Rightly or wrongly, and I would probably say wrongly, but that is kind of like where their attention is. It's always going to be more over in those particularized trade centers. So that's also going to bring in these larger population areas, right?

Speaker 2Because there just are higher population areas over there. So when you lose the ability to call on these populations, and, you know, also when you lose things like, oh, the ability to do mass slavery, since, like, Christianity is, like, I'm afraid I'm going to need you to put a stop to that later on, that really curtails the ability to, like, get a bunch of money in the hands of the right people so that they can pay taxes so that you can have a standing army, right? Like, it just changes things a bit.

Speaker 1They were also just, I mean, they were surpassed by, like, as, as those migrations that we talked about like a hundred times, you know, the, as, as the step tribes really started moving down into Europe and you got the Huns and then you got the Avars and then, and you just, you get all of these, you get the, and, and then you get like others, you get like Vandals and Goths and Visigoths. And these aren't even like step tribes. They're just people who were trying to get out of

Speaker 1the way of those that had been somewhere else. And now they're, they're here and now there's the germani and there's the bell guy and you're just like what the you know like where the fuck did all of these people come from and it's like well they came from outside they came from they came from outside they came from west asia they came from the steppe. And from Eastern Europe now. And it's just like you can't handle

Speaker 1that kind of influx. Let me try to say this. Excuse me. I'm still getting over being sick. So if you have that influx at, let's say, In like a hundred BCE or something like when Rome, a time when Rome is still Rome and it is huge and it's doing very well, their ability to deflect stuff like that is going to be like so much better because as we said, they deflected Cannae. They like, like being able

Speaker 1to absorb a 75 to 80,000 troop loss is insane. I mean, it's really impressive. Like, I'm sorry. Like, I love the shit on Rome, but, like, it's incredibly impressive. Yeah, and we do. But, like, if, you know, if the Vandals or the Visigoths or, you know, whoever are coming down and you are still Rome and, you know, you haven't adopted Christianity yet, you haven't adopted Constantinople yet, like...

Speaker 1And you, you know, because once you adopt, the other thing is once you adopt Constantinople and that becomes like super important, Rome as a thing, like Western Rome as a thing becomes periphery. Like everything else had been periphery to them and now they were periphery and they're like.

Speaker 2Uh, wait, I don't like it. What do you mean?

Speaker 1I don't like this one bit. Like, why aren't you guys going to, uh, why, why aren't the, you know, why aren't the Huns going to attack, uh, Constantinople? And the answer was because Constantinople, and the person's had enough money to pay him to go somewhere.

Speaker 2Else like go away just which is a it's a good wheeze you know and again that is like that is it was ever thus right like if you can afford fuck off now money like people will do for the most part like that's a completely available thing right yeah um just it doesn't always happen.

Speaker 1Yeah yeah exactly yeah um So that's enough about size. We've been size queens for long enough today. Let's talk a little bit about some other things. So like military training. So one thing we never talk about really on the show is military training. And that is because outside of China... it didn't really take the form that we think of military training does now. Military training now, or even let's say like, you know, modern period military training is, you know,

Speaker 1like the Prussians walking out there with their, you know, oh, oh, and like somebody's like, you know, whip them if they get out of line. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Or like, you know, you're out there doing war games, you're fighting, you know, doing all these different sorts of things and it's these huge battlefield maneuvers with all these combined arms and, Infantry, cavalry, and artillery are working seamlessly with the logistics corps and blah, blah, blah. That's not how it was. No, no, not at all.

Speaker 1Your military training came in various forms. My favorite personally is the steppe tribes and then the Mongols because– they didn't use, they didn't do military training. Like they, it was their custom to sit all their kids on like sheep and goats and stuff like that, as we've talked about, and teach them how to ride and shoot with a bow like that. But that was not like a regimented thing, you know, like Timmy Jin's not out there being, you know, like put, you know, two-year-olds go, three-year, you know, that's stupid,

Speaker 1as stupid as it sounds. No, what they did is once you became old enough to participate and, you know, be a man or come of age or whatever, um, in their words, um, they would, they use large, very coordinated animal hunts as military training for their war. And this is using the same tactics that they would do, uh, against people. And like they're like, uh, like the, the feigned retreats that they would do are so like, That

Speaker 1was so easy because that's like, okay, we're fanning out in front of this deer and we're going to get just far enough away that it thinks we're gone and these deer are going to follow and then come behind. And they called it what, I don't remember what their word for it is, but they essentially called it a noose. You know, like you catch the deer in between those two things. And that's how they were able to do these large scale coordinated like troop movements where they have like, you know, 40 000 horse you know uh archers on

Speaker 1horses turning at the same time and like firing and just obliterated people and i mean that was because that's how they had learned to catch that's how you have to catch animals on the step you have to tire them out you have to like you know they're fast they're evolved to be fast and and you know and and smart out there and you gotta you gotta figure out a way.

Speaker 2And like the thing is, it's an incredibly useful way of doing it because you're doing something that needs to be done anyway, which is everybody's getting fed.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2It's not like an auxiliary thing. It's not something on top of what you would be doing anyway. It's like, oh, yeah, this is like an actual chore. Right. And so you're not taking anyone off. Of duties that they ought to be doing in order to do this. Right. It's not the same as like when you see the king in England to tell peasants they all have to learn how to use a longbow. And that's like now this is what is happening on your Sunday afternoon. You don't get Sunday afternoon off. You you got to do archery.

Speaker 1You can't be one of those weird British people who's into the NFL now. Put that Buffalo Bills gear away. If I see you pick up an Atlanta Falcons jersey, I swear to God.

Speaker 2I swear to God. A, it's weird, and B, it's happening again. It used to just be one game a year, and now I think it's like three. In the first place, I spend so much time trying to be like, Americans, we're not all like that. Then they all show up. and they're behaving like that and it's also encouraging the fucking weirdos here who have like Americophilia you know or whatever and it's like they want to shag the corpse of empire and I'm just like grow up you have

Speaker 2your own football I don't want to talk about this like why don't you worry about why don't you worry about Man City why don't you worry about that fucking stop talking to me about.

Speaker 1This bullshit we have to figure out a way out of this where Man City is properly punished but Arsenal does not benefit in any single way we cannot have that happening good luck right their minds will be their egos will be too big uh no i'm just kidding that's uh you know i don't i don't i don't care about arsenal um man city should uh look if they don't i mean if they don't get thrown down and and have points deductions and everything then what the fuck is the point in having a league i mean really.

Speaker 2I'm genuinely serious that is like the most important thing that is going on right now here is it's just like um everyone is losing they goddamn mind about it um and like i don't know like i was down getting groceries before we recorded and over at my uh fruit and veg place there's this guy talking to the dude behind the counter and he's like yeah you know the problem is it's kind of like there's a whole part of manchester that's gonna be really fucked up by this oh yeah because it's like it's completely dependent on it so we have to also like find some way of like making it like like.

Speaker 1Oh yeah it's analyzing.

Speaker 2A part of the city it's bad dude.

Speaker 1Uh I mean, it's really bad. Like, yeah, the, yeah, we're, we're not here to talk about this, but like if the premier league doesn't finesse this, it like, look, you don't want a world where Spanish La Liga is the, like the, the highest league on the planet. That's not something you want because Barcelona and Madrid, it's like this man city stuff is cute and all, but like, uh, they, they fought wars over that shit. Like, you know, it's, uh, I'm not, and I, and you know, um, Anyway.

Speaker 2That's a lot like military.

Speaker 1That's a lot like military training. It is.

Speaker 2It is.

Speaker 1So, yeah. So, you had the steppe tribes. They did their hunts. Then you had some places like the Greeks, the Macedonians, and the Arab Muslims where they had all kind of been isolated onto a peninsula. And they were fighting amongst one another. And they really fucking hated each other. And then... And then something from outside or someone galvanized them and they were like, oh, okay, cool. Oh yeah, by the way, we're one of the most powerful fighting forces on the planet. And, you know, that's how the

Speaker 1Greeks were able to stave off the Achaemenids. That's how Alexander the Great was able to create his, you know, what was at the time the largest land empire ever. And that's how the Arab Muslims doubled him up. Like it's, you know, sometimes you just, You just get lucky in geography and everything. I mean, you know, clearly that didn't happen every time because there are a lot of places where people just fought and fought and fought amongst themselves and killed themselves off. But every once in a while, you do get to break out of that and just,

Speaker 1you know, control the world for a time.

Speaker 2Yeah. No kidding. No fucking kidding.

Speaker 1The Byzantines, they trained in the same methods that the Romans had used, although they're Their resources kept getting smaller and smaller over time. And yeah, it was... they had to reorganize themselves several times to deal with this. But, you know, we've talked about it, Manzikert. We've talked about that a few times. And like after Manzikert, they just couldn't field anything. Yeah. And then, as we talked about

Speaker 1a few times, military training in Europe was mostly done on a micro level with knights. There was some like training of peasant soldiers on like a very small limited basis. And that was not like at a army or state level at all. And it, and like, it's, I mean, it's just really weird because like, I mean, they, the Europeans, you know, I mean, they, they did win, you know,

Speaker 1the first crusade. So like, you know, How do you do that if you have no military training? And the answer is, well, the Muslims were in literal disarray and it was, you know, they weren't having a fun time there. But yeah, during the Second Crusade was when they first really started getting like actual training because they realized the Templars had been in the Levant for a while and kind of knew what they were talking about. and uh

Speaker 1yeah instead you get um you know and yeah i mean they eventually picked it up but yeah there was just is that i've i've never seen anything about like large-scale military training uh other than like the nightly level in europe and the like the training with the longbow stuff didn't happen until later that was.

Speaker 2A yeah medieval It absolutely is. It absolutely is. And it's like, first we got to invent longbow, right? And then we also have to invent three field system and like invent population level sufficient for all of these things. So there's like a lot, there are a lot of steps that need to happen in order to make that work out for sure. For sure. You know, it's, it's not that easy.

Speaker 1Yeah. And I mean, when you don't have military training, it's really hard to have, um, we call combined arms, which is integrating, um, The three main thrust of an army, the infantry, the cavalry, and the artillery together. Artillery was in its infancy, like, I don't know, pre, it was prenatal almost until like into the middle ages. We'll talk about how gunpowder came along next time, but yeah. And

Speaker 1I mean, attempts to integrate infantry and cavalry were iffy because like the greeks and the romans and i mean the other like classical or ancient armies they definitely would use both but for the most part horse uh cavalry was used for like mop-up duty like special like uh pencer type operations and like harrying like the backs or

Speaker 1the the rear or the mid of a of a caravan not for like uh doing huge combined efforts. Now I know Alexander did some and the Romans did as well, but like the, I mean, when the Mongols start, they don't have a ton of infantry, like that gets integrated along and along and along. And I mean, you know, like you have the two, it takes a while for those two sides to mesh. And I mean, uh, artillery is, that that won't even be a mathematical science until after napoleon dies.

Speaker 2So yeah so it's like like that's that's kind of like uh it's but a twinkle in the mailman's eye you know like at this point in time so yeah like it we are really kind of striving with what we've got here and i mean i I think that one of the things that is certainly true about sort of like European use of cavalry is it's just like, it's also, you know, part of what we're talking about here is, you know, and we talk about it all the time, this really different relationship to what war is for.

Speaker 2And because in Europe we have this emphasis on it being a means of, showing who gets to have the monopoly on listlet violence. Stop me if you've heard this one before, but that's what it's for, right? It's for saying, okay, well, here's the people who get to profit from war, right? The way that cavalry works is you're just kind of going to use it to try to, I mean, you're going to kill some peasants, it's going to be fine, and then you're going to try to get in there, you're going to try to kidnap another noble person so

Speaker 2that you can make some cash, because otherwise, why am I even here, right? There are all of these really interesting kind of interpersonal things at play within this and so they're not they're just not going also to be worrying about this interplay between like varying forms of fighting because you know peasants are hardly people to them right they're like what do you mean i'm gonna fucking train my peasants so you need to talk and also think about it if the way That you have control over

Speaker 2your peasants is because you're like, you threaten them with violence. Are you going to train them to fight? No.

Speaker 1That's why it was illegal to own a sword. Yeah. If you weren't a certain station. 100%.

Speaker 2100%. And so it's like, there is this specific thing where they're like, we don't want to be training these people. Because if they do... know how to fight, then they may take up arms against us, their oppressors, right? And they know that, right? Like, they're very aware of that fine line that they are treading. Yeah.

Speaker 1And I mean, it's like, you know, the Mongols, like, or the steppe tribes, like, you, even though a lot of those people probably would know how to ride in formation and do these things because they have been trained since they were little, like, if you were someone who was like farming and like, that was what you did, you stayed on the farm. They didn't like bring, they, they weren't like bringing people out. It's just that they had such large groups of, of horses and everything like that,

Speaker 1that they had the, they had these huge armies. And I mean, like, um, you know, you're not going to train the people that you're lording over. When we did the Iran series, you know, like, um, the Arab Muslims, when they came, you know, when, when they came in and they attacked and then when the Mongols came in and they attacked 600 years later, like they both went straight for the cities and left the, the hinterlands to their own devices. And they weren't like, come with me peasants,

Speaker 1let's do an uprising because that was the number one way to like, then have, you know, yourself also decimated, even though people did do that out of their own, um, Volition. And I mean, I have read that humorously enough, Europe did have a decent integration of cavalry and infantry just because of like how they ended up fighting. That wasn't, it wasn't like they didn't do it. Like it wasn't like an active genius or anything, but they like, you know,

Speaker 1sometimes you just kind of fall ass backwards.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Like I feel as though also it's just sort of like, I don't know. It's a little bit of hindsight where we're like, oh, well, if you just did this, then everything would work out. It's like, I mean, sort of, but it's just kind of like not the way that we're thinking about war. You know, we've got real differing ideas about what the goals are here, right? Like, I think that's important to just kind of like.

Speaker 1Flag up. Yeah, and that's a great segue into talking about the thing that kick-started like these bigger armies in Europe, and that is The Crusades. Because the First Crusade is the largest military movement on Europe since Cannae. At one point, they probably had technically more soldiers because it was about 250,000 total people. And then, you know, 100,000 to 120,000 were soldiers of some variety. And... the, the, the state level

Speaker 1entity that does that is not Franz is not whatever it's, it's the fucking church because the church had like a weird relation, a much different relationship than other places than, you know, like even, even, you know, when the Umayyad Caliphate was in force, they didn't have the same, like, you know, they just, they just didn't have that same level of, of control that the Catholic church did over Europe. And yeah.

Speaker 2And it's interesting because like you can also see that it's very, you know, I would and have argued, I think very calculated on the part of the church. I think that part of what's going on for them is they're like, oh, well, look, we did it, gang. We've got this power now. And it's like, oh, well, what do you do with power? Oh, you wield illicit violence.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 2And so they're like, oh, cool. Like, well, so what can we go fight? Right. You know, like that's that's kind of the point of it. And so they're like, oh, yeah, well, and then a good thing. Surely it's got to be something about God. We can't just go around attacking people, can we? Yeah, okay. So, you know, it's also a really useful thing to do if you've got like too many fucking Normans around and you gotta send them somewhere so yeah yeah it works out really well you know it's cynical but true you know it.

Speaker 1Doubles up as like okay we got too many Normans and then when it's time for the second crusade you're like oh we need more people over there and that's when you start seeing letters to merchants being like hey you should fund the crusade see how far your money will go you know like it's like You know, what's a.

Speaker 2Lot like being a member of the nobility is funding.

Speaker 1Yeah. It's like, it's like, why don't you, you know, why don't you fund this? And like, I mean, there are surviving letters. Bernard Clairvaux wrote to the merchants where he's like, think how far your money will go. Like it's a fucking infomercial. Like it's, it's hitting, it's hitting the same hallmarks. Aren't you tired of the bumbling church of yesterday? They drop everything. There has to be a better way.

Speaker 2This man will never stop being the enemy of the pod.

Speaker 1No, no, no, no, no, no. He sucks so fucking much. He's awful. Yeah. Um, lastly, the last thing we're going to talk about in this, uh, hodgepodge is just like, you know, um, your armor and, and military technology of the time, it, you know, it changed as well. And, um, As that changes, you're going to be able to do more things, you know, you're not just wearing quilted armor anymore. And,

Speaker 1you know, and the quilted armor that we kind of laugh at is, you know, because that was like something that was, that was what like, you know, peasants and nobodies wore. uh according to most tests that was far stronger than either uh than bronze or or.

Speaker 2Yeah yeah like go ahead and laugh yeah like but listen if you're facing the persian hordes though you know that's you're gonna be wishing you had some padding on you know.

Speaker 1Yeah you're gonna wish you had some of that george r martin boiled leather because hey boiled leather uh was actually really good.

Speaker 2It was actually pretty good yeah.

Speaker 1I mean unless you were getting unless somebody was about to hit you with something that was going to cleave you in twain um yeah it would it would help a lot i hate when i.

Speaker 2Get cleaved in twain man.

Speaker 1Fucking hate it when i'm just hanging out and a guy and a guy with a sword three times his own height just decides he's gonna like show he's gonna he's gonna pick me out and show like what the sword can do like couldn't you like Why me? Like, what about a tree? Why didn't you just cut a tree in half?

Speaker 2Yeah, like, what's going on? You didn't have to test this out on me, brah. I'm just trying to enjoy a nice time at this ale hospital-y.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. And then you get chain mail, which is, you know, that's the chain. And it goes, it's usually a halberd, and there are little interlinked rings of metal. And remember, even though plate armor is... more protective chain mail is it's pretty good expensive it's it's good it's insanely expensive because of how like the little like tiny like washer size like rings that make it up or just.

Speaker 2Someone has to do that with their hands you know it's like it bears repeating that this is like a not an industrialized world like someone is sitting there and doing that right that's it's a very difficult job.

Speaker 1Yep Yeah, it was incredibly expensive. There's scale armor, which is like overlapping plates. And then there's, of course, plate armor, which is the one we know and love from like all the stories and movies and, you know, all that. That was the late 14th century. I think the first existing, like fully existing or extant piece of it is like from like the 1440s or something like that. Oh, cool.

Speaker 1But yeah, it's, you know, plate armor is plate armor. If you watch Game of Thrones, if you watch, you know, a lot of stuff, it's just, that's what you're going to see.

Speaker 2It's sick as hell, is the thing. And like, that's partially, part of the reason you're going to see it is because it's sick as hell and we all like looking at it.

Speaker 1Right. You know, I mean, there is something to be said for like how many of the records like talk about people wearing chain mail or plate armor and they're like, holy shit, these guys are like walking like, you know, they describe them like you would describe like firing a bow and arrow at like a robot or something. And just like it bounces right off of them. I've never seen anything, you know, and it's like, you know, you just yeah, that's a good shit. it's good shit. Like it's beautiful. Like there's a reason we look at it and go, damn, that's cool as hell. Um, you know, horses, uh,

Speaker 1the arch saddle, though that was mostly for, uh, tourney stuff with lances. Um, yeah. Uh, and, and was later used for shock cavalry, uh, spurs, which, uh, about the 11th century and, the stirrup, which was the sixth century in Europe and like the fourth century in China. Um, You know, it's, uh, you know, we, I think we, we did a, we did an episode on the steer controversy a long, long time ago, but yeah. Um, they,

Speaker 1I mean, they had them, uh, early on. That was not like a flex from later. Yeah. Um, and then we've talked about mechanical, uh, uh, trebuchets and artillery before, uh, that came around, uh, in the 10th to 12th centuries. Um, when you get like the counterweight trebuchet and everything, they stop using torsion as much. And that's when artillery starts to become a real thing. Um, but yeah, uh, you know, we've been bouncing around a lot today, but, uh, that is a lot on, um, on the, uh, fuck, I

Speaker 1can't even talk. That's a lot on just the military history of, um. of the middle ages in Europe and, and part of West Asia. And next time we're going to, we're going to finish this short series up. We're going to talk about China and the step, uh, groups. And of course, uh, we're going to trace gunpowder because, um, yeah, it's, uh, you know, not.

Speaker 2The step group. They're just the group that stepped up.

Speaker 1Exactly. Yeah. Um, we're going to talk about how early gunpowder was essentially useless for like what we think of it now. Um, uh, as in like, probably wasn't even strong enough to it what it definitely wasn't strong enough to make an explosion that would kill you it might catch you on fire but you definitely yeah.

Speaker 2Listen i mean he wouldn't like it but it's also not like a weapon in the way you think it is.

Speaker 1Yeah exactly yeah um but yeah that uh a little bit uh all over the place today uh we didn't do any questions at the start of this one because uh we uh Look, we're burnt out.

Speaker 2Okay.

Speaker 1We're burnt out. We had some technical issues. It's okay. Everything's good. We're trying our best.

Speaker 2Everything is copacetic.

Speaker 1Yeah. We'll be back. We're probably going to do a bonus at some point. We're going to talk about other stuff, like what the fuck... princess die listen people like what why are they arguing about stuff even though she's been dead for a lot like you know what what why why is this coming back into the news it.

Speaker 2Is so important to just get an update on britishism and gossip i think uh yeah but also like if you're going to behave like medieval people i'm going to talk about you like that's that's what that's what i'm allowed to do so.

Speaker 1Yeah yeah but uh otherwise eleanor what do you got going.

Speaker 2On brain damage um you know everyone say good job eleanor she turned her book in yay so it is.

Speaker 1I don't know if it's getting through the pop filter but i'm clapping real.

Speaker 2Hard yay so i did it um so but obviously that kind of like took me out pretty hard.

Speaker 1Hey you did great i'm very proud of you i'm not kidding.

Speaker 2Yeah, I had to, you know, I had to take most of yesterday off to recoup. So not a whole lot, you know. Also, I had like a huge September because I thought I was going to turn the book in at the end of August and then didn't. And then I was like, yeah, I'll do all these things in September. So, you know, like to recap, if you haven't gone and listened to all my bullshit from September, you know, I was on No Gods, No Mayors. I was on Culture, Sex, Relationships. I was out and about feeling footloose and fancy free. So, you know, if you want some more from me, That's

Speaker 2the place to do it. But otherwise, I'm just chilling. I may come back to the socials at any moment now that I've got a little more room to think. Right. But yeah. And when I do, you can find me at Going Medieval.

Speaker 1There you go. Yeah, you can find me, you know, normal places, socials. Luke is amazing. I may or may not be locked depending on whatever's going on. Real talk, real talk. Yeah, you can find my old show, People's History of the Old Republic, if you want to hear me about Star Wars. But anyway, that's going to do it for us today. Thank you all very much for listening, and we will see you next time.

Speaker 2Gotta do it. Keep it sloppy.

Speaker 1Yay! Yay!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 302 - Onfim and Medieval Children

    Nov 20, 202654 minAudio

    they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 301 - Enter Leviathan, or, Why the Early Modern Period Sucked

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 24 minAudio

    folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 300 - November Mailbag

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 299 - Army of Darkness Review

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 298 - Welcome to the Crusades 2.2 Mosul

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode