folks, we're back to our series on Medieval Land Management with part 5 on forestry. we talk the Medieval obsession with beavers, coppicing, more coppicing, the staggering amount of land dedicated to producing firewood/charcoal in Eurasia, fire maintenance, controlled forest burnings, and an intensive study on forest management in Moravia. enjoy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hello, how's it going.
Speaker 2Oh, I'm like lightly hungover and you know, doing my best out here, which is why I needed a cup of tea and was slightly late. So that's what's up. That's what's up. So I was at like some castle drinking until too late last night, which is fine and nice, but I'm also I really don't feel like I should have to face the consequences of my actions, actually because I'm God's most perfect warrior. But here we are, yeah,
Speaker 2here we are. Here, we are so and that even worse. I forgot that I told a friend I would go out with her to the pub tonight, and I'm like, no, I really.
Speaker 1Don't want to. What if we just stayed in and hung out, had a nice night.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, I'm giving it that one. Like she's not biting.
Speaker 1Yeah, but.
Speaker 2Anyway, so pray for Mojo. That's what's going on over here. Like it's uh, it's hard out here. It's all right out here.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, Well I'm definitely not hungover.
Speaker 2Congratulations. I love that for you, you know, like, really you shouldn't be, I would say.
Speaker 1I just think it's a natural consequence of the thing. You know. It's fine.
Speaker 2Yeah, I was talking at this guy the other week and he was like, no, I don't believe in hangovers. And I was like, that's interesting, and he's like, yeah, Like, you know, I used to bar attend at a cocktail bar. I think you're all just making it up. And I was like, maybe I should just be approaching it this way.
Speaker 1I mean, you could like I don't even get hungover, and I believe in them because I mean, your body dries out. That's alcohol does that. It dries out. It soaks up all the calories and all the all the carbohydrates that you had been eating. And uh, you know, you wake up because you have a headache because your body's been processing shit. You know. It's just some people don't get them because of you know whatever we like, I have no idea why I really don't get them,
Speaker 1but you know, it is what it is.
Speaker 2Yeah, Like, I think this is probably the first time, you know, that anyone's ever suffered like this. And I'm so surprised that I'm regretting too pint snow dinner.
Speaker 1Oh you surely listen, you.
Speaker 2Surely won't regret to pint snow dinner. But basically everything just got totally out of my control. Yesterday, I was like supposed to get to this castle meet up with a Front of the podcast Kate Lister. We were going to go have dinner and then we were gonna go to this thing, and instead Front of the Podcast Kate Lister was stuck in her car on the M one for five hours because there was a car fire. I can't tell if it was in her lane or the other rain and they were just sitting there, not moving
Speaker 2for five fucking hours. So she was supposed to get into town around four, and she turned around and went back to Leeds at like seven, which is when the thing started. So then now I had nobody to eat with, I wasn't sure where I was going, and like the whole thing, you know, it got out of control from there.
Speaker 1So yeah, so that the only time I've ever the only times I've ever been hungover have been because I didn't need enough, like as long as I could just stuff my face and drink enough water like and you know, and pee a bunch ruck before I go to bed. She's like, yeah, you know, it processes like if I didn't eat dinner, yeah, I'd wake up and just be like ah, yeah.
Speaker 2Like it's not even that bad because I just like downed so much water. But it's just the the sleeping situation. It was not the one. That's what I would say.
Speaker 1And the reason everybody has their own hangover cure is because just whatever you like that like feel like it, Like I love to eat like cold Chinese food and drink like and drink like like a cold like an extremely cold like like soda or whatever, and it like I love I love doing that. So yeah, that's my hangover here is doing eating something I already like eating.
Speaker 2Yeah, I do think that like okay, in an ideal world, right where for example, you don't have to get a train the next day and it's also not a workday. I actually think hangovers can be kind of enjoyable. I think that if what you do is you're like we are about to consume for thousand calories and like not move very much and like watch the same movie that I've seen eight million times. I'm like, hell yeah, brother, like I love to do that, and hangover set you out,
Speaker 2like up really well to consume four thousand calories, right, They're like this is this is the thing that needs to happen now, and uh, you know a hangover here that I think actually probably the number one I that I like is I really like phuugh, just big old bull fufyeh. It helps I think. You know, I'm a I'm a child of the Pacific Northwest after all. But here in the United Kingdom brought m and s lasagnia that they say is for two people? What about that?
Speaker 2What about that? Which is like also such quitter talk, like it's such talk to people. Fuck out of here. It's it's like the size of a loaf of bread and you're telling me that's for two people. Like face, I don't need that kind of hatefulness in my life. But well, I do, you know, just eating the.
Speaker 1Whole judged by food box.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'll tell you when I've had enough, you know, And then by that I mean I'm going to eat this entire thing out of the tin. Oh god, yeah, I'll tell you one time, ma'am, like the number of times entire amma Slazannia has saved my fucking life.
Speaker 1Yeah, good stuff. Yeah, eating eating an entire loaf of bread will usually soak it all up and you're just like, oh wow, I feel much better now, Like yeah, of course, yeah, yeah, you have you have calories in your body for your body to use instead of like everything going into overdrive to clear it out and your liver straining under the weight, and you just and you sleep for like a bunch of hours and you get dehydrated because it dehydrates you, which is usually why you have a headache. You know. It's just like yeah, of course.
Speaker 2Like, yeah, I always have like non specific hangover. It's like I didn't sleep well and everything's weird. But you know, still I shouldn't have to face that because I'm actually.
Speaker 1Exactly exactly they should. They should make an alcohol that doesn't get you hung over.
Speaker 2Mm hmm, just like they should make a cigarette that isn't bad for you, you know.
Speaker 1Like cigret that is it bad for you? It's just weed.
Speaker 2I know, I know. But the trouble with that is that like, yeah, I know, you know, you can't. I never smoked even but like I think we can all be smoking as cool and sexy.
Speaker 1But yeah, I've never smoked a cigarette in my life.
Speaker 2Yeah yeah, but it's cool and sexy, right oh yeah yeah yeah, but it like smells bad, it tastes bad, and we'll give you cancer. But it is cool. And sexy, and I think that like the cool thing about smoking too is, like I guess, especially before we had phones that used to like give you something to do while you're waiting for people. Yes, yeah, and you can't just have a j You can't just have like a fat jay where you're like.
Speaker 1Wait and the cop he's like really, You're like what, well, I'm waiting here, I'm hey, hey, I'm waiting.
Speaker 2They I mean, I couldn't just drastically alter my life and start doing it, you know.
Speaker 1But yeah, yeah, no, no, don't do it. Cigarettes are bad, very bad.
Speaker 2They are.
Speaker 1Don't smoke, don't do it. Don't do that. Ship. It's not good for you, very bad. But yeah, it is cool as fun, Like that's the thing, like you there's no there's no way around that. Like everybody knows it looks cool as fuck. There's just something about it.
Speaker 2Well, I was really interested because I thought that now that cigarettes are eight million quid to smoke, and I thought that like we were just going to see basically the user tobacco die. No, but because because vapes are not cool or sexy, I guess, but like everybody seems to really enjoy them. And I was like, well, it goes to show what I know, Like yeah, I.
Speaker 1Think, you know, I think people just take the tiny hit they can. It's one of those you know, I don't know I rationalize drinking a bunch of coke zero, but being like this is the thing, Like this is like my little treat, I like my stupid little treat, Like this is my thing, and I work hard, I do all this stuff, so I'm just gonna have it. And you know, I mean I assume that's just what people do with cigarettes. They're just like, yeah, that's my thing. It's fine.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah. I gotta say, like, look that's me and all the alcohol I consume. My answer is like shut up.
Speaker 1My answer is, hey, fuck you.
Speaker 2I really it doesn't as.
Speaker 1Long as it doesn't really interfere with anything. Like the problem with smoking is that like you can have a drink every day not be an alcoholic and the fine and you can't like and you can. I mean the Harrison Ford ha smoked weed every day for since he was twenty years old, and I mean, like he's he can't fly playing very well, but neither came most people. So you probably shouldn't be doing that when you're eight hundred. But you know it's like you can do that, but
Speaker 1like smoking cigarettes, like you know, it's just you got the cancer thing. Yeah, it's fine.
Speaker 2There are not enough upsides. I mean, looking cool and sexy isn't enough of an upside.
Speaker 1No, it's not. Personally, so yeah, I'm never it's never going to take me into the zone where I'm actually cool. And yeah, uh me and my wife feel the same way about cigarettes.
Speaker 2So yeah, yeah, I definitely definitely don't want to be fucking with that one. I hear.
Speaker 1I've smoked cigars like twice and I hated it because I like the first time I accidentally inhaled and I fucking pooked everywhere.
Speaker 2It was so gross.
Speaker 1The second time I didn't, and I was like, well, this fucking sucks, This is stupid. What is the point of this. I don't like it?
Speaker 2Oh? Asses, Oh yeah, I love it.
Speaker 1Okay, you know, good for the cigar chompers or whatever, but like I just oh, don't inhale, Like, Okay, what the fuck?
Speaker 2What are we doing here?
Speaker 3People?
Speaker 2What are we doing here? People?
Speaker 1Yeah? Anyway, yeah, let's let's talk about uh yeah, let's talk about trees. Hell yeah, brother, Hello, welcome back to
Speaker 1We're Not So Different podcast about how when you think about it, smoking weed is a kind of controlled burn. My name is Luke, and as always I'm joining Eleanor and uh if folks. We're here to talk about We're here to talk about the lorax. We're gonna talk about the trees. Uh, gonna talk about woods, uh, medieval land management, things of that nature. Before we do, we have a
Speaker 1question from west Bank Robbery, who says, what are some of the cool things going on in medieval northern Siberia.
Speaker 2Tiger talk, tiger, tiger, tiger. Listen.
Speaker 1There was.
Speaker 2Let's see uh Jengis Khan.
Speaker 1Yeah, for a little while they did. They were, I mean up there it was it was it was all nomadic tribes up there, and it was until like I mean they did. I don't think the Russians completed the conquest of Cyber the Russian Empire and complete the conquest of Siberia until like the seventeen thirties or something. I think something like that. All right, yeah, it and I mean they didn't even begin until the fifteen really begin until the fifteen hundreds. It's like it was nomadic tribes up there. Sometimes they were assimilated into other groups. You know,
Speaker 1some trading. Yep, yeah, they they would have done trading. There were some the I think the only place that would have been permanently inhabited for any stretch of time in Siberia at this point would have been on the Kimchek Ca peninsula. I think, because there because you could survive. You could survive like fishing and stuff like that. And
Speaker 1it is from what I'm told, it's more humid, uh slightly warmer there than a lot of the rest of Siberia. I mean, there wasn't a lot going. This is one of those places where, like I mean, there aren't a ton of people there now and there were far there would have been far less back then because even during the medieval warm period, you still can't grow anything.
Speaker 2On can't be cropping up there.
Speaker 1There's not a lot of crops that we had. You either have to survive on like rivers or like on the coast, as we said, or you just or you do nomadic You do nomadic pastoralism, and you just like you you you take your horses all across the Tiger. You let them eat the ground down to down to to the to the tundra, and then you you move along and you pick up your oats or whatever you
Speaker 1planted further south, and you come back and you hunt the city, you know, like how how nomadic tribes did. But I mean, there's just not a lot out there there there Now there are more forests in Siberia than there are on most of the rest of the step. Yeah, but it's still hard to grow anything like grains or cereal grains out there.
Speaker 2What I know about this area is actually largely from we had this story book when I was a kid that was called the Folk Tales of the Amor that was all like the traditional folk tales of like the people who live up there. And yeah, there's a lot of hunting. There's tigers in that forest. I know that they do some trading back and forth with the Native Alaskans. So for example, you will find dentalia shells up there
Speaker 2which have been traded from the Pacific northwest up to the Alaskans and then over So there there is like a fairly lively cross specific trade with guys up there. But everyone just kind of ignores it because it's not like because since it isn't like industrial scale or something like that no one really cares about it.
Speaker 1It's very sparse, and it doesn't appear that there was that it was anything other than trade, Like it doesn't seem like there is any attempt to like do that. We could tell that there's any attempt to do like cultural mixing or you know, anything like that up there.
Speaker 2I mean, so yeah, yeah, Like as a result, I mean, there's they're trading a lot down with the Chinese, as one does, because you know things like, you know, the Chinese have rather a lot of money, don't they. So it is a pretty sweet way to make a lot of quick buck. You take like a lot of furs things like that down to the Chinese. Said, and then they're like Chinese people are fucking crazy, and then they leave again.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah, I mean, And a big thing that happened was nomadic tribes and groups would spring up there, and for one reason or another, they would migrate south to some degree, they would go south and west, south and east you know where, like but they would do that because it's just really hard even when you're a nomad, it's hard to live up there at all times because you can't it's very hard to grow a lot of
Speaker 1stuff or anything. And I mean, yeah, like the the Ugric people who came about I think it was about twenty five hundred BCE. I mean they started along migration and after you know, almost thirty five hundred years that migration ended with the Magyars going into Hungary and the tong Goose people fled from the Mongols. They fled out of northern Siberia and into Russia and Eastern Europe, and
Speaker 1you know, you it's hard to it's hard to live up there, even for some of the hardiest people that you know, that are ever seen. So it's just like, you know, and then you've got the tundra, like you just kind of stare out into the Abyss and you know, there's it's rolling and it's rolling, and there's not.
Speaker 2And you're still rolling.
Speaker 1Yeah, if you're if you're like even Quasi to the west a little bit, there's not any trees there, like.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's just yeah. So like I think that it's it's quite an interesting one because like even like in terms of like in terms of permanent settlement, you kind of don't get it until the Russians show up in the eighteenth century. And even then I used to have to teach this. Even then, like the Russians are like, this is so fucked up, Oh my god, Like it goes very badly huge attrition rates of the people who live there, because it's just like you're not really humans
Speaker 2are not really supposed to do permanent settlement in those conditions. We're just not good at it. It's it's not for us, you know, and unless.
Speaker 1You have modern uh not even convenience, it's just modern tools and materials, like yeah, for sure, we don't think about it now, but like the like the coats and things that we wear likes so much better than where than just having like heavy wool or like even like seal skins. Not that seal skins.
Speaker 2Were bad, but like you would you would rather.
Speaker 1Wait, you'd rather have a fucking waterproof gortex jacket, like you just would.
Speaker 3You know.
Speaker 1It's just it is what it is. Yeah, So, uh, not a lot going on up there, but I mean there was life. It was uh occasionally used you know, seasonally by by the tribes, and then they would be like, well, this sucks time to go, uh because it's too cold up here and we can't like uh during little ice age. Uh. Yeah, it's a it's a lot. It's real fucking cold there. Yeah,
Speaker 1West Bank, Robert, thank you for the question. Uh you want to ask us? Yeah, if you want to ask us questions like these, please do subscribe to Patreon Patreon dot com, slash w nsd pod. It is five dollars a month. You get bonus episodes. All these episodes add free ask a question, join the discord. It is a lot of fun. Anyway, onto the main show. So we'll have another question later. Anyway, So consider the beaver. Yes, yes, yes,
Speaker 1go ahead and laugh. Let's all get it out of the way now. Yep, we all know the beaver. We all love the beaver. Everybody loves it. We love it. It's great. Okay. Now, really, let's do as our medieval forebears did and consider the beaver. Despite being a simple semi aquatic rodent, the beaver has an extremely outsized importance to the world despite their diminutive size relatively low numbers. This makes them a key stone species just like us humans, and also one that teaches us much. Teaches us much
Speaker 1both about ourselves and land management. While all animals, terrestrial or aquatic, change and transform their habitats as a byproduct, of normal everyday activities. This is often viewed as entirely unintentional. African elephants are known to fell small trees by ramming them to get it prize foliage, and the heaviest dinosaurs quite literally created the future conditions for marshy jungles and swamp lands by crushing the ground into a muddy mess under their enormous frames. Yet these are unintentional in the purest sense of the term. The elephant did not intend to manage the tree line or shade in search of
Speaker 1the tasties leaves, any more than the stegosaurus mapped out the field before trampling it underfoot. They simply go about sustaining themselves as their nature dictates, and any outcomes outside of that are largely beyond the creature's purview. This old is true for the habitat and land management that almost all living things do. Almost then there's the beaver, who is not alone in intentional land management by fauna, but is our focus. Some weird, little furry combination of architect, landscaper, builder, site manager, finicky artists, and perfectionists. You see beavers build
Speaker 1lodges and dams and rivers and streams, and they do so because they not only create homes for themselves, but also to form ponds to play in and share with other beavers. Both the North American and European varieties of beaver seem to favor the same things when planning their watery homes, wide slow moving streams with very shallow downward grades, usually less than two percent in areas that are not prone to flooding. The main materials for these structures are nearby trees which the beavers fell or coppice by chewing
Speaker 1through the wood using their larger front teeth, which are reinforced with iron as an evolutionary mechanism, and much like our blood is reinforced with iron to receive and hold oxygen, which keeps us alive. Which is also how you know that thing about your blood being blue and your body and then turning red when it's exposed to the outside world as bullshit, because your bo your blood is literally full of oxygen, or you would be dead anyway. They chew through the wood with their front teeth carry them
Speaker 1back to the water by dragging them along behind themselves, intentionally creating ruts they can later use for easier transports. Before smacking the logs into place with their wide, flat tails. The log enclosures of them filled with heavy rocks for ballast and structural integrity. And doing so, we see the beavers use both its own body as a tool and also an intentional also an intentional use of a piece of wood as a tool to create a faster pathway. It's also simultaneous managing multiple habitats that wants compassing replenishes old and dying trees with new growth. The land turned
Speaker 1over by their logs creates new patches for plants to grow, and the local water table is improved by their ponds. They've even been known to create canals between two water sources, which are then used to float logs and other essentials between ponds and speed up construction. While though their creatures do some of these same things, beavers show a level of artistry and particularity about the look and layout of their lodges, but also the water in the pond. They are fastidious about dam upkeep constantly listening for the sound of leaks, and fussily repositioning logs when they are disturbed.
Speaker 1They will even uproot themselves and their families and create new ponds if unstoppable flooding becomes a problem or water changes drastically. Though we humans often find these dams to be a nuisance, studies have shown that their land management methods provide numerous unintentional benefits to the local environment. Once returned to areas they previously inhabited, beaver's o up more than at one hundred and fifty percent more fresh water than before during droughts. They also resort in a result in higher water tables in low lying areas, and their
Speaker 1creations often result in less flooding in the same areas. And if that wasn't enough, they've been shown to dramatically increase biodiversity of plants, animals, fish, and birds around their ponds. I could go on, but you get the idea. In a very real way, beavers help clean up, or at least partially ameliorate, some of humanity's worst ecological disasters. These fascinating creatures have been president in North America, Europe, and a few spots in East Asia for millennia, and they've both inspired and puzzled humans the whole time. It's not
Speaker 1really here and her there. I just really wanted to talk about beavers because I like them. As we discuss forestry today, we would be wise to remember our little friend in intentional land management, the beaver folks, the beaver, the beaver, the beaver, the beaver.
Speaker 2We've we've just reintroduced them here.
Speaker 1It's exciting, yeah, doing so. They're awesome. They're they're they got a job. Hilarious little like uh.
Speaker 2When videos of them like in houses and they're like, I'm gonna build a damn out of stuffies, shit kills me.
Speaker 1Yeah. Like it's one of those things that makes you that makes you consider, at least for a moment, whether Protestant work ethic is it evolutionary mechanisms? Like they're like sitting there, They're like, fuck, I gotta do something. Fuck I gotta do I gotta I gotta be working, I gotta I gotta check my email, like the boss might have called me, I gotta look at my phone.
Speaker 2I love them. They're just little co rats. It's like all they're all working together for no profit incentive.
Speaker 1Mm Hmmmmmmy medieval people thought they were like, uh, they were obsessed with like their testicles or something. It was. Yeah, there's a lot of art about it because they leave some kind of like secretion on things. I don't know.
Speaker 2There's a lot of things happening.
Speaker 1Yeah, there's a lot of weird shit going on. They didn't. They also eat beavers a lot because yeah, excuse get around for uh yeah, or not lent, but for no fish on Friday or whatever it was.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's like that. That is that is a thing. And also I guess they were delicious. But if you look up in the bestiaries, so we have the general attributes. The beaver is hunted for its testicles, which are valued for making medicine. When the beaver sees that it cannot escape from the hunter, it bites off its testicles and throws them to the hunter, who stops pursuing the beaver. If another hunter chases the beaver, it shows the hunter that it's already lost its testicles, and so is spared.
Speaker 2Here's the allegory and moral from it. If a man wishes to live chastely, he must cut off all vices and throw them from him in the face of the devil. The devil, seeing that the man has nothing belonging to him, will leave the man alone. So in the medical, magical and alchemical ones, the testicles of the beaver are highly valued for medicine. A medicine called castorium is made of beaver testicles. Is good for treating many sicknesses. It helps those who have the falling sickness that's epilepsy or cold evils of the head. It carries palsy of the tongue and resource speech if placed under the tongue. If mixed
Speaker 2in wine and herbs and sage, it relieves general palsy of the body. Taken with food or drink, it comforts the brain. It could wake a man from the sleeping evil by making him sneeze. Anointing his head with it promotes sleep. It helps against the venom of scorpions and steaks. Bile that it vomits up is useful for many medicines. Its rennet provides relief from the decaying disease. Maybe that's leprosy, we don't know. Beaverfer It contains a liquid that is beneficial to people suffering spasms and trembling of the limbs. A person who is paralyzed could be helped by having wine boiled with beaver flesh kept close. The smell of
Speaker 2the beaver itself is also used for full prolaralysis fat as very useful in ointments, and Hildegard of Bingen says, if a person ails in his spleen, he should often eat cooked beaver tongue and his spleen will be cured. Or he should reduce that tongue to a powder, put the powder in honey and eat the honey. His spleen will be better. One who has fever should try the beaver liver and reduce it to a powder. He should put a bit of it in warm wine and drink it off, and he will be better. There you go,
Speaker 2that's the best earies to take on on our friends. I don't think you should pass the beaver.
Speaker 1But yeah, and I and I don't think you should force the beaver to uh to castrate itself to.
Speaker 2I'm just like, bra let that guy alone, come on.
Speaker 1Uh. Yeah, So so that was weird. Yeah, No, that's actually it's I know, it's amazing because like there are those stories from history. You'll occasionally find where like there's a revolt against the eunuchs in like a place, and the soldiers will go about killing the eunuchs, and you'll have like guys like pulling up there like tunic or whatever and be like no, no, no, no, I have balls. I'm good, you know. Yeah, so it reminds me of that,
Speaker 1like the beaver's like look I already had it. Yeah, oh man, uh yeah, real quick. I did want to mention when we were doing the farming, we didn't talk about farming in uh pre colonial Australia, and that is because we don't know. There is still great scholarly debate about to what extent agriculture existed in Australia before before colonialism.
Speaker 1That is not to say they didn't do pneumadic pastoralism, they did, uh, but it is to say that we don't have extant evidence of them having large scale agriculture before that. Yes, you know. Yeah, so that because they didn't need it, Bro.
Speaker 2They were they were doing interesting land management with like controlled burning and things of that nature.
Speaker 1But yeah, for sure, and they were avoiding the center of the island.
Speaker 2Yeah. I mean I'm avoiding it right now. Bro.
Speaker 1They even called out back back in they.
Speaker 2Were like absolutely not.
Speaker 1Oh man, all right. Well, we had a question from Pearl Riverflow and she said are they He said, I'm sorry, I would love to know more about medieval forestry management beyond. Yeah, they did compass compassing. Thanks beavers. Well you're in luck, but you're also kind of not in luck because they did a lot of compassing and we're going to talk about it in a little while, but you were going to be shocked by how much they needed to compass just to live anyway. Uh So, forrest, they seem in
Speaker 1the past, they seem to have occupied a much different idea than they do to us today. We see forests as you know, places of wild nature and you know, places we might want to keep Christine. They have good biodiversity. You know, we love the beauty that they provide. We love, you know, the trees and everything like that. But there aren't a ton of people nowadays who just live off
Speaker 1of the forest or in the forest. And in the past, i mean even until like the eighteen or nineteen hundreds, you the forest was a place where like a few people would live, like people who just didn't want to be away from society and couldn't be and no one could bother to like bring them back in or didn't care to or whatever. They would live. But also it was just a place where people, especially like peasants, could
Speaker 1go when things got bad, and they could try to scrounch up some food. They could try to scrounch up you know, berries, You could find some animals that stay in there that you know, rabbits and things like that that you could hunt. And so they were like a place of last resort for a lot of people. And in fact, one of the first writings that Karl Marx had was in a I believe it was a German magazine.
Speaker 1Shit what was it called? Fuck? I had it, Well, I can't figure it out now, but it was in eighteen forty two he wrote, and it was about a new law that was going to criminalize coppicing, would and make it a felony theft to like steal the wood, make it you know, you the fines were exorbitant. They were far more than the cost of wood and everything like that. And and to Marx this was in a bridge,
Speaker 1and you know, we both obviously think is correct. This is an abridgment of like the natural law, because these people are like, you know, this is like okay, I'm gonna go like cut off a few shoots so I can have firewood so me and my family don't freeze this this winter. And now you can be thrown in jail. And this is prizing like property rights and class interest above like the needs of people, and you can you can really start to see like his materialism in it. But like I but even into the eighteen forties and
Speaker 1and even after that, like this is how forests were seen. They're not just like kind of scary places or cool nature places. They are a place where just has a ton of resources, like there's a ton of stuff in there. So like eleanor can you talk a little bit about like this view of the forest and you know this is kind of not kind of this is why like people took such a fence to the like, oh, the
Speaker 1king has the right to hunt in this place. It's like what the fuck man, It's just like like I'm supposed to pick berries here? Fuck off?
Speaker 2Yeah, And I mean that's exactly it, right, And I think we've talked a lot before about the generalized medieval view of the forest as kind of a place of limbo, right, like it might be vaguely magic, certainly it contains outlaws, right and that kind of thing, but we haven't really talked before about what it actually affords. And so, yeah, firewood is the big one. And it's really easy for
Speaker 2us to forget about this because we don't you know, for us now, fires are largely a luxury good in the global North. It's like, you know, if you have a fire, it's like ooh, yeah, I'm having a little fire. I fancy you know, and in the medial period totally different. You need those to live, you need those to eat, right, Like that's how you cook is by burning wood, and so that means that you have to be constantly managing them, and as a general rule of thumb, you need to
Speaker 2be living really closely to them. So you know, for example, one of the big records that we have in Prague, and there's kind of like a there's a good record of this kind of for the fourteenth century, is that one of the things that poor people really struggle with is affordable firewood. Yes, very particularly like affordable firewood is at a premium in Prague. And also one of the typical things that happens is, you know, because the bourgeois can afford to buy large volumes of things, they get
Speaker 2it for cheaper, so poor people were paying a lot more money for it. So obviously you really need to be bringing things in from forests all the time, and they don't share the conservative view of forests that we have now, because what do you mean, right, Like it's in the first place that we have an industrially limited the forest. Now. It is true that by the early modern period we lacked like old growth that was like
Speaker 2big enough to make for example, large ships here, which is part of like why the colonial expansion into the Americas is seen as a good thing. But that doesn't mean that they don't have lots of other trees that are you know, smaller and being used constantly for compassing. But we're not talking about compassing yet. So there is the firewood aspect that's obvious. Another one of the big things is, well, a lot of stuff grows in there, doesn't it. So up mushrooms for example, funguses which are
Speaker 2integral to the medieval diet, grow in forest, right, It's the Czech national pastime to this day mushroom hunting. And there are a lot of forests in Bohemia. If you go with Van Moravia as well, you go walking around and like everybody's out there looking for mushies, you know, and the medieval people are just the same. They are also a really important source of hunting. No, you can't hunt large game in forests because kings are bastards, But they are a place where a lot of people do
Speaker 2kind of subsistence hunting for things like rabbits, and it is in particular a place that people will use to hunt with hawks. So hawks can hunt within a forest, whereas falcons et cetera, they need wider areas of grass plains, and so as a result, hawks are seen as lower class.
Speaker 1Insane. They they missed that one so bad. It is so like huge hawks can hunt that they can hunt in like tiny confined spaces and just fly caught. Like, no, that's so fucking cool. Sorry, guys, you fucked this one up.
Speaker 2Yeah, like so wrong. But also like at least at least, uh, the working people of the world got to have a really cool bird. And indeed it also it's hilarious because part of the classed nature of the falcon versus hunt versus hawk debit is that hawks do bring home more prey. Yeah, and they're like, what are you gonna do? Eat it? Like you're not just killing me? Oh yeah, peasant, I bet you're gonna eat that, aren't you. And then they're like, yeah, I am.
Speaker 1Of course, I am. Yes, that's a good one. It's delicious. I want to survive.
Speaker 2Yes, But then also of forests are a really invaluable place for sending your pigs. Yes, And that's the labor of the month for November is sending the pigs into the forest.
Speaker 1They love to root out ruffles. If you are in a region that has truffles and you have the types of pigs that can do that, they love yep. They love the pasturage on like just inside the tree line before it gets two dents because they can't the same way that deer love to to to kind of eat right there. They love the nuts, they love the acorns, they love the berries that grow on the ground. I don't know that deer like mushrooms, but they might.
Speaker 2I can't really say for sure, but I cannot speak to deer preference for mushrooms.
Speaker 1But you can you can, as we talked about with when we did the episode when we talked about Italy and Silvo pastoralism, you can. You can have livestock that are predominantly living right on the edge of the forest and you can pasture them as long as you manage the area. Effectively and the grass grows fast enough and you don't you know, kill it. You know you can do that. It's just I mean, there's the other stuff
Speaker 1that that the forest h provide. Like we talked about fire, wooll, we talked about food, Timber, like actual just like large scale timber used for buildings, ships, like any any large anything that needs to be made of wood that is larger than like I don't know, like a larger than like a cylinder or something is going to need to come from timber in some way. And so you have
Speaker 1to you have that pitch. It was a huge pitch and bitch and huge because that was used to put together ships and carts and you know, it was a you know, it was a sticky substance. We've all heard the stuff about pitch and all that, but that that is where you get it. You get it from from trees and yeah, like and then you know the last real thing we did talk about it, but like the
Speaker 1forest does provide shelter, like it just does. It provides you shelter from large prey, I mean from large predators that you know, it's theorized that humans initially survived like in the edges of forests and stuff because you know, they hadn't we hadn't put together like everything yet, and we stayed there and eventually we started coming out, we started hunting more in groups and stuff like that. But
Speaker 1it's also just like it's shelter because it's a place where you can It's one of the few places in the medieval world where like, even if it's nearby to where you live, you can technically get lost in a forest. Very Yeah, people can't find you, Like, yeah, if you go if you go deep enough into a forest that is like several you know, kilometer kilometer squared or you know whatever. It is, like, yeah, if you don't want to be found.
Speaker 2Obviously it's early modern, but consider Hansel and Gretel. Yeah, you know, and it's just like, you know, you can just if you need your kids to die because you got too many miles to feed to get to send them on in there to be fine, wouldn't worry about it, you know.
Speaker 1Yeah, there's a and I mean there's a reason like when we talk about the heretical groups in Europe, we talk about them going to the edge of the forest, because a lot of them did. They were banished there or they went there because they were less likely to be bothered, and yeah, that was something that you could do, and it was a a place of refuge for the peasants for a very long time, just a place where you could kind of live. And enclosure fucked that up. However,
Speaker 1the big thing that comes with like the forest, the push and pull of like forest and larger populations, is that we've essentially been deforesting the earth for ten thousand year twenty like we as the as the population of humans has grown, we've just constantly been deforesting. We've deforestation is rampant since the Neolithic. Even where we've regrown forest,
Speaker 1it's still far smaller than it was, you know, let's say ten thousand BCE or something like that. Some big ones deforestation of the late Western Roman Empire as it got big, as they needed more ships, as they had so many people. Rome, you know, at various times had a million people in it. That many people need. You got to have firewood when it's cold. You got to have firewood to turn into charcoal. You have to make ships.
Speaker 1Even if your houses are made of marble or stone or brick, you still need a wood for framing, for a lot of those, unless you're just in a completely different part of the world. China, the Han dynasty went through the same thing. They went through planting phases, and a lot of the imperial dynasties throughout the years are going to keep like they're going to put they're going to put a premium on reforesting, especially for timber, because
Speaker 1you can't because I mean they didn't start building with stone in most places until seventeen eighteen hundreds.
Speaker 2Like, yeah, yeah, the primary, the primary building material is almost always going to be wood unless you can't have it because you're somewhere like the middle of a desert, or if you are building one you mental structures.
Speaker 1Yeah right, yeah, yeah, yeah. And then uh there at the end the Late Middle Ages, there was what was known as the Timber Famine, and this was when things were really really really cut down. They had even less so than they are in a lot of places today. And that is you just there's just so many people. Once you achieve like this mass of humanity on a place,
Speaker 1and you and the primary way to warm yourself in a on a continence that that's pretty cold at least four to five months out of the year, it.
Speaker 2Just got a lot colder.
Speaker 1Also got a lot colder. Yeah, you got your ice skating on the Thames in fucking September or whatever like, and then you start building these huge ships and you just have this huge just you're just bereft of timber like you can't when you have to hear.
Speaker 2It's such a good phrase, mate, Yeah, I love that.
Speaker 1You just have to, like you compassing. Even if you do compassing very well, it still takes like seven to twenty years for it to reappear. And you know, forest take a while to grow, and it's just a vicious cycle of relying on firewood and charcoal because you know, well, I guess we'll talk about it in a second, because we're gonna because you can't talk about wood without talking about fire. But before you get there, let's just talk about what compasing is because we talk about it a lot.
Speaker 1But you know what is that? And it's basically where you take an old growth tree and it's dying or dead, and you chop it down to the stump or the stool or even the roots in some cases, and you just let it regrow for a while and it will do it will do this thing. The trees do called sprouting where they just shoot up these little shoots and
Speaker 1they it'll it'll start, after you know, a little bit, it'll start, the stump will start to look like a bush or like a shrub. You get like a lot, you get like a lot of shrublands from this, and they just keep growing and keep growing, keep growing, and and I mean eventually, if you let them grow for long enough, they will often, uh, you know, regrow into you know, an actual tree.
Speaker 3And uh.
Speaker 1The reason that you do this is because compassing is just like, look, compassing is easy, like compared to what these people had to talk. Think about how hard the farming stuff. We've talked about, how hard it is to carry water, how hard it would be to to raised a family. At this point, like just like this sheer difficulty of doing the stuff you need to do to keep everyone alive. Compassing is you go chop down a tree, You chop up whatever you have, and use that wood for whatever you need, and then you just let it
Speaker 1go and then you go back and in a certain number of years you harvest it and you use that for firewood. Because the shoots from compass trees are fucking great firewood. Apparently, and everybody they they knew this, like they you know, compassing appears to have been practiced pretty much everywhere that for us exists. So the people knew somehow, you know, maybe they'd all watched the beavers. I don't know, it's yeah, yep, yeah, that's pretty much compassing. Uh. There's
Speaker 1also uh grafting, which is where you put complimentary species of trees onto one another. And a big thing about compassing. If you were going to compass and then take the shoots for firewood, but then you needed to to grow timber there, you could take a part from a similar tree grafted on there, onto the stump or the stool, and let it grow from there into a large piece of that you're gonna be used for timber. And grafting
Speaker 1does occur naturally. Plants will do it sometimes, but we are really good at it. We you know, you could put there. There's like a there's a very famous like kind of example of this where some guy made a tree that produces like thirty fruits and like thirty different kinds of flowers peasant excellence bro actually and and like you you know, I mean that's really advanced. But like you know, you could still do grafting back in the day. It was not they knew how to do it. It
Speaker 1wasn't uncommon or anything. But yeah, you know that's in terms of like what they're going to do with managing it. They're going to chop it down, They copp us, they graft, They turn the wood into various different things, whether it's you know, big pieces of wood for a ship, or turn it into charcoal or firewood or whatever. But the thing about firewood and forest is that there's fire and
Speaker 1we as humans we're scared of fire because fire hot, fire, indeed hot, and you you don't touch fire like everybody. You don't touch the hot stove, you don't touch the hot you don't touch the boiling pot. You don't get you don't you warm with your hands a little away from the fire. You don't touch it. You know, you don't get in there on top of it. But the thing about it is is that the story of Prometheus is that way for a reason, because we wouldn't be
Speaker 1us without fire, like it's I mean, it was the earliest tool we had, we've we've the oldest evidence for control burning is a million years old by human predecessors in a cave in South Africa. It's like and there may be and there's some stuff that may be as old as two million years old. We have been doing this for such a long fucking time. And uh yeah, it's our history with fire is It basically made us
Speaker 1who we are. It allowed us to stay up later at night, It allowed more social cohesion, it allowed uh, it allowed the flourishing of art because you could now do ceramics, you could meld stuff into different forms. It's the tools weapons. Cooking meat. Cooked meat is far better for you than raw meat. Anybody who does that like raw meat bullshit. If they're still doing that, Like if you brought your your ancestors forward into the future and
Speaker 1they saw you, uh not cooking your meat, they would beat you to death with their They would ungu bungo you to death with their clubs for for for for spurning Prometheus like that. Put the fucking meat over a over a fire, gut damage. It's delicious and even even in unlocks more nutrients in plants too. You cook plants, they can can break them down, so you can your body can you know, deal with them better. It's just that's behavioral modernity. But the thing we're here for is
Speaker 1land management because while uh much of the old world uh didn't believe this. Forests are supposed to catch fire every now and again. They are like, it's not we don't like that because like it's a big forest fire and it's scary and it and it impacts like where we live. But I mean there's something called the fire cycle. You're supposed to you're supposed to go through through fires, and it's it increases soil fertility, it eliminates like it
Speaker 1it stops wider fires in the future because all of the brush and bramble and shrubbage and everything that just gets on the ground under a forest, if it piles up for a while and then a fire comes through after one hasn't been through in a while, it's going to be like one of those raging forest fires you have like nowadays in the American West where it's just like, you know, three states are on fire or whatever like.
Speaker 1And I mean that is one of the reasons we have these issues with wildfires is because we don't do properly uh proper fire maintenance. And you know, it's uh you can see why though, because it's like, but it's scary. It's gonna burn all my firewood and and and my uh the place for my hawk the hunt come on brow.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's it's interesting because I do think that part of our new relationship with forests is you know, it is notable right that now we have like this total approach of conservation, which like you know, like don't get me wrong, like yeah, absolutely, we we kind of used too much of them up. We should not do that. But it also I think it oftentimes overlooked, especially in places where you know, there still were old growth forests
Speaker 2when white people decided to show up. It overlooks the amount of management that native people were doing. You know, controlled burns were super super common for Native Americans, for Native Australians, things like that, and uh so yeah it uh it's interesting in Australia they still have to do controlled burns all the time. Yeah, like because otherwise boy howdye? Yeah, yeah, there are some problems. So it's a really common thing, but you know, we see, for example, in California, there's a lack of it that you know, people don't do
Speaker 2it as much as they should, and there's resultant terrible things so yeah, it is of interest that in our kind of push to make everything private and also then to conserve, we've sort of forgotten how much humans were doing with forrest. That is possibly good.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, Now we should note that like controlled burns of fields, it was incredibly common in the Old World. It's incredibly common across the world. We of course talked about the Milpas system when we talked about meso America and how they would burn to replenish their fields. There is evidence all all over Europe of you know, the occasional burn to like uh to to to replenish uh
Speaker 1soil fertility, especially places. Poland did it fairly frequently. We didn't talk about it when we when we were doing that, but they there is a lot of evidence for it there. Uh, there's evidence for it in South Africa, they did it in China. But control burning a forest was not something the Old World. And this is not just Europe, it's Europe and Asia and I think Africa as far as I know. If if I'm wrong about Africa, then I apologize.
Speaker 1But uh, I mean, you can see why they would be scared of it, because that if that if that if that fire comes through and burns down all my firewood, How am I going to stay warm in the winter. And even in places where they didn't specifically use firewood for warmth, like in China where they use more charcoal, Charcoal is firewood that has been burned at temperatures in
Speaker 1an anoxic or oxygen low environment, and so you need even if you don't do coppasing specifically for firewood, you still need the wood from the forest generally in order to make the charcoal to warm your house. So you can see why these people be like, I'm fucking burning a forest. Why the fuck would I do that? However, it is good the places we know that did control burning a forest. Eastern North America, the Eastern North American
Speaker 1tribes did a lot of it. Not everywhere, of course, but they did it. It's likely the Western North American tribes did due to a lot of factors, including climate change and how badly we've overturn overturned the land and everything. We can't say for sure that they did it because without you know, written records, it's hard to tell when when the burn that we see whether that was natural or they did that'll so they did it, of course
Speaker 1in Meso America, as we talked about, they did it in some parts of South America, including various parts of the Amazon, at various times that those were controlled always or they tried to anyway. And then, as Eleanor mentioned, Australia because they don't have a ton of forests there, but the one that they do will just go up, like you know, go up like a fucking Roman candle or whatever at the slightest hint of anything, just like it does in the American West, like where it dries out,
Speaker 1that the thing gets incredibly dry, and yeah, it's it's just fucking it's a fucking mess.
Speaker 2Can I go wildly off piece for just one moment, Well, of course.
Speaker 1It wouldn't be the show if we didn't listen.
Speaker 2Have I ever talked to you about the television show Grand Designs that is on over here?
Speaker 3Yeah?
Speaker 1Yeah, once or twice. Yeah. The people who are like, they have outrageous ideas for what they want, they get in over their head with a remodel and then have breakdowns and then they.
Speaker 2Yeah, and they get and they get pregnant while they're living in a caravan on site and things like that. Yeah, yeah, Okay, the only good episode of Grand Designs Are One of the few good episodes is about this guy who has given permission to build a house in a forest here in England, which you ordinarily are not allowed to do, but he's allowed to because he's a woodsman, and so he is there all the time, like removing dead growth and he makes charcoal like.
Speaker 3He he old fashioned way, and so he got permission to build a house there and he builds this amazing echo.
Speaker 2House basically just like with the help of hippie who are like Abra show up and like I build houses. And it's like they're using medieval methods. There's almost no big machinery because you can't bring it into the forest, so they like they're making a it's called like a cruck house. So they put these big wood pillars up and then they just kind of like pull it up. It's all insulated with with hay and it's like so heartwarming because it's just like normal people building this really cool house. And the government was like, yeah, you can
Speaker 2absolutely do this because it's like this is your job. Yeah, and you're allowed to pass this house onto your kids, but you can never sell it. Yeah, Like the conditions are such that it's like, yeah, you're allowed to be here, you're allowed to have this house, but you can't be doing it to make a profit. And he's like, yeah, I don't give a shit, Like I live here, I work here, this is what I do. And anyway, it's terribly fucking heartwarming and I love the whole thing. And also the weird Boujia guy who anchors it says it's his favorite house too, so it's really cool.
Speaker 1Yeah's heartwarming, that's awesome. Yeah. The way that you make charcoal is actually you you take a bunch of wood, you pile it up. In the center of it, you put like a small little area that serves as a flu, and then you pile leaves and other debris and stuff on top of it so you get most of the oxygen out. You drop a fire down the flu. You
Speaker 1let it go for like five days, and then you put the fire out and you just let that smolder into charcoal and that can be used for, you know, everything that charcoal is used for. And that's how you make it. That's how you know if you didn't use firewood or you know, I don't know what the fuck else.
Speaker 1And dun dune was used in a lot of places, which I mean, you know, most of us, because we'd be like, oh, that smells terrible. But there are certain kinds of dung that don't smell that bad. Like apparently goat kind of smells more like wood when it burnt. Goat dung smells more like wood when it burns, So you can ameliorate that to some extent. But yeah, that's how you make charcoal. But you know, the star of the show here for Europe anyway, is compassing. So we're
Speaker 1going to talk about a study before we go that will just kind of put into perspective how widespread this was and how just how much woodland land they needed to get by. And this is from twenty fifteen. It's about intensive woodland management in the Late Middle Ages in Moravia. And we've talked about Moravia a bunch, but if you look at a map of the Czech Republic, Moravia is
Speaker 1the eastern basically the eastern half of the country. Uh, you will notice that it doesn't have a ton of large population centers. Those are all in uh what was the Bohemian part. You know, Prague is over there, and so Moravia is the uh, the the less the less people urban.
Speaker 2It's less urban. You got you got your Olo Motes, you got your Bruneau, but they it's not as big as Progue, you know.
Speaker 1Yeah, and uh, just the extent that they had to go to to do this is kind of mind blowing. So you know, for the Middle Ages, for hundreds of years even before that, composing was the main way that you got that you got firewood. And now this can be done either as like okay, there's like a there certain trees we know we can compass over there, and we're gonna go do it, and that's just what the
Speaker 1local people use and it's just a small little area and that's fine. Or you can have big, huge like tracts of land too that that are that are cordoned off for the purpose. Now, the problem with a lot of that in Europe is that almost everywhere in Europe came instead of coming, was not centralized very early on when it started to form into into nation states. You know, they had to be formed over time, and they weren't
Speaker 1highly centralized, and that power had to be pulled away from the nobles and every Bloh, but we all know, blog you. Yeah, but that means that it was harder for it was harder for them to have these like huge the huge managed forest of just that that were like completely uh uh squared away. And you have one part that was for timber, one part that was from exuse, one part was for compassing. However, in as we've talked
Speaker 1about before, in Central Europe, in Bohemia, Moravia and Poland and Hungary to a lesser extent, they were able to centralize a little earlier because of when because that was the first like central authority they'd come into a lot of those places and really united them fully when the Church did that. And yeah, so in a place like Moravia, the reason it was chosen for this study is that
Speaker 1it was centralized in this regard earlier, so it's easier to see exactly what was used for compassing versus exactly what was used for timber or vice versa, due to these charters that these these land charters that they had, these are basically like you can use this land for X, y or z reason, or you have it for you know, it's passed you and what they call fee simple, which just means you own it outright and there's feet tale and it don't worry about all that ship it doesn't matter, but not for this anyway. Good. So yeah, so we
Speaker 1get a look at that. But one thing about compassing is that you can't you can only coppas. Uh fuck, I forget what that. You can only cop coppas trees that flower. You cannot compass conifers except for you certain you woods and ash trees. So in the north, in the north of the continent where you know Scandinavia and all that and Russia. Uh, they didn't compass very much at all because they couldn't. There was no there's no
Speaker 1there's no reason to because none of the because none of those trees would go back. They just Yeah. So they they did a different things, you know, they they they used more charcoal and stuff like that. But also so interestingly, one way they did use for us to protect themselves was they would put up these things. They're not called avalanche for us, but that's what I call them. But they basically at the foot of a mountain, they would plant like a few rows of you know, like four or five or six rows of trees or something
Speaker 1like that, and it would prevent avalanche they that goes a long way to preventing avalanches from hitting your town when you can just have like a wall of trees there. But anyway, yeah, compassing in Moravia. So this study is mostly the thirteen hundred to about fifteen hundred, you know, a little on either side. But they are you know, they are careful to note that like this system continued up to the nineteenth century, like oh yeah, God, the
Speaker 1importance of compassing did, and they understood that they had to limit it to some degree. They couldn't keep doing it. But much like we talked about, we they would cut corners when they could, so you would instead of letting it. Instead of letting the coppas go for seven years, you might have to cut it after three or four or five, whatever the case may be, because you need firewood to you know, live, and so yeah, basically they reviewed more
Speaker 1than twenty five thousand charters from sometime in the tenth century to about fifteen sixty six, most of these, as I said, between thirteen and fifteen hundred, and the results were kind of staggering. So it was at any point in like the thirteen hundreds or so, the distribution of
Speaker 1coppas forest was likely about fifty percent of all what was present or fifty percent of all forests in all the parishes of Moravia, and over time that probably equals out to about thirty five percent total. Because you have their parts where you just can't compass, Like there are a bunch of mountains and large rocky places where you could where only you know, temper trees or even trees that you just can't even really get to grow. But another thing about this is, and this is true for everywhere,
Speaker 1it is incredibly incredibly expensive to move wood, firewood, timber, anything. If you cannot float it down a river or you know, do use water in some way, it's expensive. A study from London in the fourteenth century said that paying someone to transport firewood more than twenty kilometers meant that it was prohibitively expensive for even the most even the wealthiest
Speaker 1people who are trying to run, Like timber concerns you, like you couldn't that twenty kilometers, that's like fifteen miles, Like it's like you know, like you you drive that to like go pick up your kids or like go to your job or whatever, and like it was prohibitively expensive for even like the wealthy people in London to get fired, Like so it's too heavy, we couldn't do it. Like yeah, if you can't float it, you're kind of you gotta find something local. That's it.
Speaker 2It's like you need like a small batch artismal would you know that's what you gotta have, Bud, I'm afraid that's right.
Speaker 1See. Yeah, they crunched the numbers here and uh they they they through through some different measurements. They said that like the average person needed about one point one point three to five meters cubed of firewood per year, and your average land would produce about three meters to the third per hectare. They produced that much wood per year,
Speaker 1and so the area needed to compass for everyone in Moravia was twenty percent of the entire land mass of the state. Like of the area they needed twenty percent for Moravia, not for Bohemia where Prague is, not for Paris, not for London or Constantinople or wherever. For a small
Speaker 1relatively lowly populated had it's like twenty percent. So like when we talk about compassing and we say, like, yeah, they compass, it's it's not a brush off. This is what they did to survive for ever since civilization's formed in this part of the world. This is basically in these parts of the world, this is basically what they've done to survive. Like if it's cold and you have to warm yourself, you have to have a heat source.
Speaker 1If you're too far inland to get you can't get like a whale blubber inland. Clearly, if you don't have the right kind of dung, you don't. I mean, who wants to smell burning human shit all the way?
Speaker 2Yeah, you can't. It just can't. Like it's uh and you know they would certainly also know and consider it to be a health hazard. Right, So it's just like you're just not going to happen for them.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, you don't. You don't want to do that, and so this but this twenty percent is just compassing for us. It doesn't include multi use for us. It doesn't include just for us that they didn't even really have records for at the time because and to like the fifteenth the late fifteen sixteen hundreds, when they started doing censuses, they were not as thorough and that doesn't include timbers. So I mean, you are talking about twenty percent of the entire state of Moravia needing to be
Speaker 1on this seven to twenty year cycle repeatedly of coppicing in order to get enough firewood just for these people, like you know, when burneaut would have you know, I don't maybe it would be had five or ten thousand, like maybe at the most.
Speaker 2I would say five maps maps.
Speaker 1So that's I mean, the I skipped over this earlier. The where did my fuck? Oh? The like the land area there were probably about between the average they think is probably about nine hundred thousand to a million people in all of Moravia between this period. That's of course going to fluctuate, and I mean like when you have you know, a black death, or you have like any you know, famine or something like that, it's going to go up and down. But the average seems to be
Speaker 1about nine hundred thousand to a million people, and that number of people needed twenty percent of the land to be compassed. So like, imagine how much England near London. Imagine how much of that had to be compassing land because of how many people London would have had and how expensive it was, as we said, to move forwood, like if it wasn't coming down the Thames. You're kind of fucked. I mean, there are other rivers there, but you know it's it's not we we don't understand the
Speaker 1world like this because like even now, like we just we just have you know, we we can drive a long way. We like you could you could go rent a truck from the home deepot or whatever and move like a ton of wood like from a lumber place to your house in like a couple of hours. You know, like you can do that. But every but like, oh, another thing about these coppas woods is that most coppice woods need to be in lowland areas because they need
Speaker 1to be closer to the people who are going to use them, so they wouldn't coppae in the mountain and hilly regions that much. So basically, like all of the lowlands were intentionally managed with compassing from the dawn of civilization in these parts of the world until the nineteen hundreds, like because even after they started using coal for like factories and ships and everything like that, people still got
Speaker 1their warmth from firewood until I mean.
Speaker 2Even in places where coal was used more regularly, like England, yep, people are still using a ton of wood. And you know, not everybody has coal mines, you know, so you're not going to be bringing that in for heating when you could be compassing.
Speaker 1When you could be compassing, and you just like all.
Speaker 2Day fucking compassing only get a few money.
Speaker 1Yeah, I recompass zero money. I wish I had three money. Yeah, it's uh, you know, like uh, it was important. And as I said, like in China they had tree growth regimes to replace timber, which they needed for palaces, ships, buildings generally, and as I said, charcoal. So like the compassing thing, it was more intensive in Europe, but this is probably the most intensive thing that they had going on,
Speaker 1either this or wheat. Like it's right up there, the two of them. And they're basically as integral because you can't if you can't eat, you you know, you die, and if you get too cold, you die, like you know. Yeah, these these are like akin to you know, like having water and air to breathe. It's you know, you got to do it or you can't live in this part of the world. So yeah, that is a lot of medieval forest management. I would love how learn more about
Speaker 1exactly how it went in the Americas, but that is much more difficult and the subject of many, many competing studies. Yeah, without record, without records, it's very very hard, even when you have oral traditions, because the oral traditions typically aren't being like and then we you know, we burned the x amount of you know, we burned these acres cubed or squared or whatever for you know, for this it's it's a it's a tail. It's not a it's not
Speaker 1a record. It's not a detailed record of you know, it's not a spreadsheet or whatever. But yeah, that is is uh, forest management and medieval land management. Next time we are going to talk about, uh, probably water management, and uh, you know, water management is big because that includes everything from irrigation to wells, to rivers to dams
Speaker 1to you know, fishing. We get we're gonna we get talking about bill weirs, we do. We we get to talk about you know, we get to talk about all that stuff and and how transporting things on water was the fastest way to do so until the invention of the railroad. You know, Yeah, it's uh, it's just a different world. This is a way that they're very different from us. And it's that transportation and travel was just
Speaker 1an insane difficulty back then.
Speaker 2Kids today know all about craft beer, but they don't know about eel wear. How about that?
Speaker 1Do you remember? Yeah, do you remember that Adam Corolla tweet where he's like, kids nowadays are more interested in ear rings than they are in stew. And it's like really like it's one.
Speaker 4Of those like, oh yeah, none of the kids are None of the kids want to talk to me about a nice a nice can of dnty moor stew than top the top on from like what.
Speaker 1None of these kids want to compass anymore. They don't they don't understand. Uh. And I actually had to do some compassing the other day because there's a little, uh kind of area behind our house. It's like a communal area, and they're trying to redoce some stuff and unfortunately, the way that it was set up, uh, water drains right into it, and so most of these trees are dead in the back. So we were taking down some of the smaller ones to be regrown, and then uh, they were going to come in and have you know, actual
Speaker 1like professionals take down the big ones. So you know, we don't crush our houses, but you know, yeah, it was kind of fun, like it was just out there, like you know, and I imagine that was kind of like what you had to do back in the day, Like you got like we made a huge pile of like brush and everything that people would have you know, picked out firewood and and and everything from and you know, yeah, it's uh, it's clearly not the same because some giant truck came and lifted it all away and took it to a place to be recycled. But like, I don't know,
Speaker 1it's still pretty cool that, you know, you still do that, you still do that shit like that. Like the forestry people we were talking to, they you know, they still manage lands and forests like that today. It's cool anyway. Uh yeah, folks, that's going to do it for uh for forest, medieval foresty, forestry eleanor h what what commercials do you have?
Speaker 5Oh, great question. I don't think I have any this week. I think if you check out my blue Sky when I'm not like cyber bullying the political editors of.
Speaker 2Papers, I think I did end up digging out the the interview that I did for the French Network about uh the French versus English commemoration of Joan of arc, so you can find it over there. Uh yeah, I think that is the major thing. Yeah, yeah, I think so.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah cool. Yeah, and you can you know, you guys know where to find me. I am on the socials, probably mad about something or another. Uh the endless well of anger. Uh nose nose, no no bounds. But yeah, uh, you guys know you can find me. People, Sister of the Old Republic if you want to hear me talk about Star Wars. Uh yeah, I guess uh you could you know, well, you can't come and help me cop us, but you could have if I had told you about it beforehand. But yeah, anyway, uh, thank you, thank you
Speaker 1everyone for listening. Uh and we'll see you next time.
they say that children should be seen but not heard but for most of history, they have been rarely seen and never heard. before the mass expansion of literacy in the Modern era, we almost never got information on the...
folks, we are back to talk about the Early Modern Period and why it was such an awful time to be alive unless you were in the absolute highest upper strata--and even then it wasn't great. we discuss it a lot in very...
folks, we're back from Halloween with a new mailbag! this time, we answer questions about haircuts, 1066 and all that, the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse as humoral theory, new money, pet peeves, and more. enjoy!
folks, it's time for us to review Sam Raimi's 1992 cult classic Army of Darkness, starring Bruce Campbell. never has a movie that takes place exclusively in the Middle Ages cared so little about the setting but still...
The hosts of American Prestige and We’re Not So Different join forces to examine one of the seminal events in world history: the Crusades. Season 2 focuses on the Second Crusade, oft overlooked among the first four...