Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Upper House Commons Events

Upper House Commons Events artwork

Can Good Fiction Deliver What Technology Can't? | Lecture 3

Feb 20, 202537 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Numbers are telling. On average, Americans spend nearly 5 hours a day on their phones. Research shows that 45% consider themselves addicted to their devices. Our hands naturally pick them up, open a screen, and voila, we enter another world. Yet there’s another technology that also helps us enter other worlds: a far older technology that might be considered an anecdote to our phone addiction… books. Good fiction, in particular. In this talk, Dr. Cassandra Nelson (Ph.D., Harvard) will discuss promises connected to technology and the ways technology fulfills - or fails to fulfill - those promises. She will compare the benefits of 21st century technology to the benefits of reading good fiction. And she will consider with us the question core to our scrolling and reading: What are we looking for? ABOUT THE SPEAKER Cassandra Nelson is a visiting fellow at the Lumen Center and an associate fellow at the University of Virginia’s Institute for Advanced Studies in Culture. Her scholarship centers on faith and technology in American literature and contemporary culture, and has appeared in publications such as Plough, Comment, Common Good, First Things, and The Point. Her first book, A Theology of Fiction, began as an essay of the same name for First Things and will be published in substantially expanded form by Wiseblood Books in early 2025. From 2015 to 2018, she taught literature and composition at the United States Military Academy, where she developed a profound interest in virtue ethics, character education, and effective, inspiring writing pedagogy for first-year undergraduates. Education Ph.D., English, Harvard University M.A., Editorial Studies, Boston University B.A., English, Boston University Send us Fan Mail Upper House Commons gathers the university community for spiritual, intellectual, and vocational formation. We explore big ideas and engage in conversations that matter within arts and humanities, justice and society, leadership and vocation, science and technology, spiritual formation, and theology. Whether you are a student or faculty member at UW-Madison or beyond, working in the marketplace, or serving in the church, we see you as part of our university community. Gather with us for one of our programs - our “commons” - each a pasture for shared spiritual, intellectual, and vocational formation. Head over to our events page to see what's coming soon, or mark your calendar for these upcoming programs. Find out more slbf.org/upperhousecommons

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Um, this is m more like a a kind of a case study or something in it it ended up being more about one sort of writer, but I hope it works because again, like when I went into them all the time, I was like, oh no, I'm losing them. Um but thank you, welcome back. And so now I I was hoping to like have more of a cheerful third one to reward you for hanging in there on all the the the negative topics, but I don't know that I achieved that in the end with what I actually wrote.

SPEAKER_01It's a little bit more hopeful, but it's not like soaring um cheer. Anyway, so the animating question tonight is can good fiction deliver what technology can't? And I would say if what technology promises is heaven, then no, even a really good novel can't do that. And if what we need to resist in technology really does, as I kind of, you know, maybe Milton was showing us something that is actually happening.

SPEAKER_01If what we need to resist in technology really does have a spiritual valence, then again, you're gonna want more than novels and poems to help you resist. In that case, and I I feel a little like a Sunday school teacher. I was like, do I need this whole quote? But here we go. In that case, I'd recommend Ephesians chapter six. Stand, therefore, and belt your waist with truth, and put on the breastplate of righteousness, and lace up your sandals in preparation for the gospel of peace. With all of these, take the shield of faith, with which you will be able to quench all the flaming arrows of the evil one, take the helmet of salvation and the sword of the spirit, which is the word of God.

SPEAKER_01Pray in the spirit at all times in every prayer and supplication. To that end, keep alert and always persevere in supplication for all the saints. And it was like before, I didn't want to accidentally say that we can achieve the work of salvation. Like God does that, but he invites us to sort of cooperate and play our little part in the vineyard if we choose to accept that. Um and here I don't want to say that good fiction is going to save your soul.

SPEAKER_01Like it has to be the word capital W, you know, not in this translation, but the word of God, the incarnate word. That's that's where the antidote is really going to come from. So again, if what technology promises us is salvation, then here too, the answer is no. That job belongs to Jesus and he has already won the battle. But if we shift the question slightly so that it becomes, can good fiction restore what technology has taken from us?

SPEAKER_01Then maybe the answer is yes. Because good fiction, I would argue, can play a role in helping us strengthen our will and sharpen our intellect. In other words, in helping us to get our souls back in fighting shape, as it were. In graduate school, a friend of mine once said that the work we did in terms of helping college students learn to read critically and thoughtfully and to compose clear and well-evidenced arguments in response to what they'd read was, at the deepest level, if we choose to engage with it, soul work.

SPEAKER_01And I think that she was right. I used to teach composition, like first-year writing to college students, and I could see how smart the students were in presenting their ideas out loud in class. I could also see how tangled up they got when they tried to get those same brilliant ideas out on the page. And so my job as an English professor by teaching them about such humble fair as topic sentences and how to cite books properly, was to help get those knotted thoughts and expressions untangled, smoothed out, corrected, so that I and others could see their brilliant insights more clearly.

SPEAKER_01Words are the building blocks of thought, Madeline Langle, the author of A Wrinkle in Time, has said, not the other way around. Words are the building blocks of thought, not the other way around. The more words we know, and the better, you know, kind of the order, the syntax, the organization that we can put them in, the more clearly and precisely we can think. I think a good vocabulary is maybe a little bit like clothes or silverware.

SPEAKER_01It's not flashy enough. We don't appreciate it, we take it for granted. We don't even notice when it's missing. One fiction writer who's which led to all kinds of hilarious things when I was grading, like essays, like I got a paper once about Dr. Martian Luther King Jr., one letter makes a big difference. I used to hesitate to correct, to correct them. And then I thought, no, I'm their English teacher. I have to help them, or they're gonna go through the rest of their lives, you know, mixing things up.

SPEAKER_01And there was one that was wanton the appetizer, when she meant wanton, you know, unreasonably cruel and vicious. Like, and I was like, into the breach I go. Like you need to know which one is which. They're different words. So don't, you know, don't poop the boring word, you know, thing. It actually helps you. And then I would say stuff when I gave back their essays. Did any of you use a dictionary when you wrote your essays? And somebody would say, I thought about it.

SPEAKER_01And they were at West Point and they also had military grades. So then it'd be like, well, what happens if you like need to improve in your like, you know, blah, blah, fitness tests? Like, you know, did you go to the gym? I thought about it. Like, did you get any better? Like, no, you didn't. You have to actually do the work. One fiction writer who's very good about the use of simple vocabulary to combat sort of modern-day intrusions into the soul is the novelist Don DeLillo. I quoted from his manuscripts earlier: Underworld is a hulking doorstop of a novel.

SPEAKER_01I read it the spring semester of my senior year of college, and the last pages of the Nussle had the effect of making me incredibly angry. After 830 some pages, I was so mad about how the book concluded. But for whatever reason, what I did with Fenhanger, which makes no sense on the face of it, was to spend the following summer buying up all the other books by Don DeLillo that I could find at used bookstores in Boston.

SPEAKER_01I read Cosmopolis Next and I hated that DeLillo book even more. But then I read White Noise, and I actually kind of liked that one. And I kept going like that, which sounds strange even to me now that I'm two decades removed from that scene. I won't give away the ending of Underworld here, but I will say that it foreshadows exactly the kind of transcendence through technology that I've been trying to unmask and debunk tonight. And the book was published in 1997. If you are old enough to remember what the internet was like in 1997, you will appreciate fiction's prophetic power.

SPEAKER_01It was dial-up modems. It was AOL instant messenger. It was really hard to read text against zany patterned backgrounds. And yet, yeah, you but thank you. You remember. And yet, in that awkward infancy of the World Wide Web, Delilo saw clearly the dangers of where we are now. Except that in Underworld, Delilo is not a pedantic no-it-all, like I've had to be tonight or I've chosen to be tonight. As they say in MFA programs, the fiction writer's job is to show, not to tell.

SPEAKER_01And so in the novel, he shows the hollowness of technology's promises, but he never really explains to the reader why it's wrong or even suggests overtly that it is. And so for me, that was like the grit in the oyster shell. Like at 22, I was off to the races and I didn't stop until, you know, worked for four years, went back to grad school, wrote a whole dissertation on screens in American fiction to get to the bottom of why that page bothered me so much. And so, because I'm standing on the shoulders of giants here, like I don't think I can see that clearly, but I can kind of see what the writers that I live are doing.

SPEAKER_01I'm going to share with you parts of a different um essay or review essay that I wrote for First Things magazine in 2016. And specifically the part in that essay about how DeLillo presents language and perception as weapons that we can bring to the fight against technology's empty promises. In 2016, DeLillo published a novel called Zero K. I don't think I did. Yeah, I didn't do that. Okay, I didn't do the cover. Uh, you can look it up. The protagonist of that book is Jeffrey Lockhart, a 34-year-old New Yorker who travels to a remote site in Kazakhstan, where his father, Ross Lockhart, a self-made billionaire, and his stepmother Artis, are going to try and achieve eternal life through cryogenics.

SPEAKER_01The company that opened up shop there holds out to them, quote, the salvation of the body until the year, the decade, the day, when it might safely be permitted to reawaken. Artis is terminally ill. Ross isn't sick at all, but he ends up deciding that he'll follow his wife into the cryogenic heaven anyway. So basically the plot of the novel is a lot like what Dmitry, Itskov, and Brian Johnson are doing or trying to do in real life. When Jeffrey arrives at the Convergence, which is the name of the place in Kazakhstan, he finds that everything about it is unnervingly vague.

SPEAKER_01Meals are taken in something, quote, called a food unit, and this is what it was: a component, a module. The food itself is edible, but not always nameable. If you look up Brian Johnson, I feel like he's kind of living, he's kind of living that uh now. The room Jeffrey is assigned to sleep in is, quote, small and featureless. It was generic to the point of being a thing with walls. These passages in the novels are feats of description. Delilo manages to grasp with words these deliberately indistinct and ungraspable spaces.

SPEAKER_01Quote, we entered a passageway that dead-ended in what appeared to be a solid surface. And if you want like a different image for the standardization and the way that there's like a boring featurelessness, like again, I've checked out of uh pop culture, but I used to watch a lot of like HGTV and every house, right? It's like the greyge, like they turn it all. She she watches HGTV, she sees it. Um, and it just turns into the same thing everywhere that doesn't even fit with the cabinets at the time.

SPEAKER_01Anyway, look at Zillow. People try to do it, they try to do half of it and they ignore that the rest of the house like doesn't go with that. But it's this pressure toward the most banal, forgettable, hard to describe aesthetic, um, or even like the surface of a, you know, apple product or whatever. The vagueness of this of the surroundings unnerves Jeffrey. The purpose of the convergence and convergence's design, DeLillo suggests, is to dull the client's perception and lure them into the kind of forgetfulness and compliance needed to participate in what is essentially assisted suicide.

SPEAKER_01Jeffrey recoils at the compound's quote, aesthetic of seclusion and concealment. He describes its leaders as bland in appearance, demonologists in spirit. Again, like I thought this was going to be the cheer-upper, but it's not. Um, after listening to Ross and artists describe her planned entrance into cryogenic preservation in upbeat, sanitized, and pseudoscientific terms, Jeffrey is furious. He imagines what will actually happen to her.

SPEAKER_01Quote, they would come and take her. They would wheel her into an elevator and take her down to one of the so-called numbered levels. She would die chemically prompted in a sub-zero vault in a highly precise medical procedure guided by mass delusion, by superstition and arrogance and self-deception. Jeffrey's even more outraged when his father decides to go with artist, despite having no health problems himself. There's a special unit, Ross explains, in language as indistinct as the compound's walls.

SPEAKER_01Zero K. It's predicated on the subject's willingness to make a certain kind of transition to the next level. When Jeffrey sneaks into the basement of the compound to see 0K for himself, what he finds behind and beneath the bland decor of the convergence confirms his suspicions about its sinister motives and fraudulent ways. The clients are alone in small carols, strapped down to padded benches in varying states of unconsciousness. They don't look like patients to him.

SPEAKER_01They look like subjects, submissive and unstirring. Jeffrey says, I stood before a sedated woman wearing eyeshadow. I did not see peace, comfort, and dignity. Only a person under the authority of others. Jeffrey shakes off the scene, the bleak scene, as only a Delilo protagonist would, and here's where we come to the utility of old-fashioned language and vocabulary. Jeffrey goes to his room and names every object in it brush, table, chair.

SPEAKER_01He looks in the mirror and says his own name out loud. It's a hard to overestimate the power of naming in Delilo's fiction, and of language's ability to help an individual develop both consciousness and a conscience. In Underworld, the book that was so important for me, there is a pivotal scene in which a Jesuit priest sits down with the protagonist, Nick Shay, when Nick is a young man, and he asks Nick to name all the parts of a shoe the cuff, the counter, the welt, the vamp, the aglet, the grommet.

SPEAKER_01And I quote, Everyday things represent the most overlooked knowledge, Father Paulus tells Nick. These names are vital to your progress, quotidian things. If they weren't important, we wouldn't use such a glorious Latinate word. Say it, he said. After this vocabulary lesson, the priest asks more or less rhetorically whether Nick has recently signed a petition in support of Senator Joseph McCarthy. Ashamed, Nick admits that he did, but only because the others with him were signing it too.

SPEAKER_01The priest indicates his disappointment. He says, So you signed. The others were shitting father, so I shed. But Father Paulus refrains from any further advice. To do so would be superfluous. The seeds for Nick's progress have already been sown, and if he's gonna work out the difference between right and wrong in any kind of meaningful and lasting way, he has to do it on his own. Nick leaves eager to look up words. I'm gonna skip the swear word this time.

SPEAKER_01I've put enough quarters into the swear jar today. Uh quote, I wanted to look up valaity and quotidian and memorize the words for all time, spell them, learn them, pronounce them syllable by syllable, vocalize, phonate, utter the sounds, say the words for all they're worth. This is the only way in the world you can escape the things that made you. Language gives Nick the raw materials to begin establishing a sense of self, to learn how to differentiate his views from those of the group, and to discern and heed the call of his own individual conscience.

SPEAKER_01Jeffrey Lockhart, too, is driven to the dictionary at a formative age, not by a priest but by his parents' acrimonious marriage and divorce. Yeah, once when they were still married, my father called my mother a fishwife. This may have been a joke, but it sent me to the dictionary to look up the word. Coarse woman, a shrew. I had to look up shrew, a scold, a nag, from Old English for shrew mouse. I had to look up shrew mouse. The book sent me back to shrew, sense one. A small insect insectivorous mammal?

SPEAKER_01I had to look up insectivorous. The book said it meant feeding on insects from Latin insectus for insect, plus Latin Vora for Voris. I had to look up voris. Later, Geoffrey sets himself the challenge of making up his own definitions. He starts with a lint roller and quickly pr progresses to concepts. Define loyalty, define truth. I had to stop before it killed me. But a facility for language doesn't kill him. Instead, it provides him with a way, years later, to resist the siren song of the convergence.

SPEAKER_01Sitting in the food unit, Jeffrey realizes that in order to stay sane in Kazakhstan, quote, every act I engaged in had to be articulated at some level, had to be performed with the words intact. I could not chew or swallow without thinking of chew and swallow. Perception, like articulation, also helps Jeffrey to maintain a sense of self, sanity, and perspective of convergence. It's in a place designed to make you forget everything from your own name to the fact of your mortality.

SPEAKER_01Jeffrey is constantly searching for physical specificity and for a window, two different routes back to reality. In this way, too, Delilo quietly fosters a wonder for quotidian things. There's a beautiful passage in the book describing that eternal marvel, light on water, in the humble context of droplets slipping down a shower curtain liner. It accomplishes a goal that Delilo set for himself when living in Greece decades ago. His time in Greece, he told an interviewer in 1993, marked the beginning of a new dedication to language and a new seriousness for him as a writer.

SPEAKER_01Since then, he told the interviewer, he has, quote, worked to find a clarity of prose that might serve as an equivalent to the clear light of those Aegean islands. And he has found that if you read Zero K, you will be forced afterwards, at least once, to really pay attention the next time you shower. And you're like, oh wow, they are kind of beautiful, the droplets on the shower curtain. And I read it in 2016. So, like, do I marvel at the shower curtain with wonder now? No, I don't.

SPEAKER_01But even that it makes you see it once, I think counts for something when there are words that help you to perceive the world in a different way. Saul Bellow and his novel Sees the Day. If anyone's taken the picturing the good through recent American fiction course, he has this thing about um glass of water on a table. It it is a hoop of light, it is an angel's mouth. The sort of not the shadow, but the light that comes through. And I don't remember the shower thing, but I think of that. It is a, you know, it is a hoop of light, it is an angel's mouth every time the sun catches the light of like a bottle of water or a glass mouth.

SPEAKER_01So I think that's something that fiction can do that's really beautiful. And I don't know what the word would for that would be, but something to do with perception. DeLillo suggests in Zero K and in his other books that it is of such moments of conscious perception and appreciation that a life is made. There's one other moment in Zero K that I think is really beautiful. And I'm offering it to you now. Um, maybe like the, you know, um, either a flower or a dead mouse that the cat brings in as a present.

SPEAKER_01Um, because on days when the news is really bad, like when the headlines make me start to wonder if anywhere is still safe and if anything is still sacred, these words from Zero K have floated into my mind. And when they do, for a moment at least, I really do feel comforted. This passage comes from later in the book when Jeffrey is back in New York City and he has a new girlfriend, and they've settled into not a perfect life, but a good one. And I quote, Know the moment, feel the gliding hand, gather all the forgettable fragments, fresh towels on the racks, nice new bar of soap, clean sheets on the bed, her bed, our blue sheets.

SPEAKER_01This was all I needed to take me day to day. And I tried to think of these days and nights as the hushed countermand, ours, to the widespread belief that the future, everybody's, will be worse than the past. I actually need to go to the dictionary because I don't know what a countermand is now, and I feel very um silly about that, but she'd be I think Delil would be pleased if we all returned to the dictionary later this Valentine's Day or another day to look up the word countermand. When Jeffrey returns to New York in the second half of the novel, it feels like climbing out of a tomb and into the light.

SPEAKER_01There are pedestrians and taxi drivers, kebab carts and revolving doors, and Jeffrey revels in the low-tech humanity of it all. He wants to pay cash, turn off the TV screens and taxis, stop using his credit card entirely. And out of humble things and colorful things, new soap, fresh laundry, they build a home and a life. So that's just one example of how I think reading fiction can be soul work if we choose to engage with it. Zero K again is not going to get anyone to heaven on its own, but if the book encourages someone to look around.

SPEAKER_01With their eyes wide open and not wide open in fear, but wide open in gratitude and wonder, then that's a start. Good fiction can also achieve the same strengthening effect, I think, for readers at the level of plot by offering some wisdom, some insight into the way that the world works. Aristotle calls these lessons that should come from literary texts universals. They're lessons in probability or necessity. If X happens, then Y probably or necessarily follows from that.

SPEAKER_01A more recent critic, although not still a hundred years ago, Walter Benjamin called such wisdom and fiction counsel woven into the fabric of real life. And I guess what I mean by that, I don't have an example to mind, though I should. That there are moments of grief or love or wonder, and sometimes like a phrase from Shakespeare or something will come to mind, and I'll be like, oh, that's what he meant.

SPEAKER_01Like when life kind of knocks you over, they're words that help you find your bearings again. Um or an outcome where you're like, oh yeah, that that's why that happened. Um, and in this regard, too, novels and poems have been a great help to me personally. None of them illuminates everything like the sun. It's more like they cast about as much light as a candle, not very far around you. It flickers and then goes out. Um, but for a second, you kind of understand something about relationships, politics, like you name it, it's all in there.

SPEAKER_01The nearest thing to life is another phrase to describe literature. I'll close with a few observations, then we can end. Oh, no, we're not even slightly early, uh, and jump into the QA. I'm not sure if I'm channeling the parables here or Shakespeare's Sonnet 18, shall I compare thee to a summer's day? But here goes. I would say technology is like a mosquito bite or a Trojan horse. The mosquito is sneaky, we don't even notice when it bites us. It's only later that we understand we've been bitten, but by that point there's nothing we can do about it except wait for the itching to go away.

SPEAKER_01Evil, according to Pope St. John Paul II, works similarly. When it crashes into our lives in the form of like a cancer diagnosis or a violent crime, we see evil clearly, but when it sneaks into our own hearts, we don't even notice that it's there. Sometimes technology works like that too. We don't notice the effect that it's having on us until it's too late. Other times we do notice what tech is doing to us. In fact, we open up the gates and hack happily welcome it in like a Trojan horse, into our eyes and our ears and our hearts.

SPEAKER_01We think maybe, you know, how lucky to have been born in an age of free-flowing knowledge. Only later, after we've already let Alexa into our houses and whatever's on the internet, into our minds and hearts, do we find out that maybe it wasn't a gift after all, but a weapon, a stratagem of enemy forces. Good fiction is more like bad tasting medicine or an MMR vaccine. Maybe it doesn't suit your tastes, maybe it actually hurts to start reading, uh, reading that takes some thought and thought work and soul work after a long time out of practice.

SPEAKER_01Um, but if you have the self-discipline to overcome that initial resistance, it changes. And most of the time it's not hard. Like, I'm not making a pitch for organic chemistry, although if you are an organic chemistry professor, I have a lot of respect for what you do. But, you know, this really is the fun stuff. Um but once you get going, it just gets easier and easier. A couple more thoughts that are just more provocations than proofs. One, fiction, I would argue, is a vehicle for transferring experience, and technology is a vehicle for replacing it.

SPEAKER_01Fiction tells us how the world works, and then we turn the last page, whether it's with sadness or relief, and we go out into the world armed with wisdom. Technology, by contrast, never wants to let us go. There's no stopping point. There's just that endless scrolling. Technology promises us answers to potentially everything, but it often ends up delivering only incoherence and noise. Fiction makes the reverse move. The indeterminacy of good fiction means that we often have to start with confusion.

SPEAKER_01What does that poem mean? You know, what does that image reveal? But after some contemplation, the reader is led to wisdom and truth. And even when we reread it at different times, different truths, it changes and grows with us. And perhaps the last case that I'd make is that the work of discerning the universals contained in words, lowercase w can be good practice for spiritual discernment, too, for leading us toward the word. And this is um a passage from my book that perhaps the flickers of meaning and transcendence that we find in literature are designed to guide us patiently and at our own pace toward an encounter with Christ, the incarnate word, in whom content and form are perfectly united, and through whom all things were made.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. Those those block those block quotes really eat up time.

SPEAKER_03No, that's great. We've got a few minutes left for questions. We've got one right here. Kylie wants to do it. She's running, she's screening. Thank you, Zen.

SPEAKER_00Um, thank you so much. I so I teach high school English, so I'm as passionate about preserving the written word as anyone I know. Um, but I'm understanding, you know, my understanding of storytelling is that it has changed. Um, that technology by which we convey stories has always changed, and that the novel is one of those forms. You know, I tell my students all the time, storytelling started as a very communal affair around a campfire, oral storytelling. Now we have this more solo experience of the written novel.

SPEAKER_00And do you think that some of the things you said about literature can happen in a more intentional form of digital storytelling? I'm thinking particularly of not just movies, but video games, which I do not play. But my students, I mean, I have a passionate student in AP Lit right now that is like, I think Red Dead Red Dead Redemption Four is the most literary thing I've ever participated in. And to me, the way he talks about it almost sounds like that communal campfire storytelling experience where you're participating in this really active way.

SPEAKER_00And so do you see a difference between like the mindless, incoherent scrolling and the intentional experience of a movie or a video game like that?

SPEAKER_01I thank you for fighting the good fight. Keep doing it. Young people need like passionate English teachers. And if you've volunteered to do this on a Friday, I feel like you are in that category. Like, um that but I don't I don't know what to say. I, you know how you have a teaching persona, right? Like some people are cool. Like, I don't think I'm cool. I think I'm just enthusiastic and I hope that that sticks. Um, but so my teaching persona was also like grouchy, like old-fashioned stickler, you know?

SPEAKER_01Like, um, so I did once team teach or like not team teach, we had a cohort and everybody taught the same intro course. And so I was definitely the uncool teacher. Like some people got like the cool um captain or major, and they did read like a video game. And I was like, nope, you're reading John Dunn, like sorry. Um, and it took them 50 minutes to read one Dunn poem and realized like it's not word solid. So I I'm gonna go back to the James Hunter idea of faithful presence of like God puts us in different places for different reasons.

SPEAKER_01Like, I am not the person who's gonna connect on Red Dead Redemption 4. Like I don't know what that, I don't know what that means. But I all but the fact that I don't know what that means means that I'm not gonna say like he shouldn't do that. Like maybe there is something good there. I don't know. But the the forking nature of video games, right? Like you make a decision and you go in some ways, seems to me like the fan fiction where, you know, like you start to respond before you've figured out what the trajectory of like a narrative should look like.

SPEAKER_01You start to get into complications when maybe the old-fashioned stickler part of me would want to begin with the simpler form. A friend of mine pointed out um that young people now are like the first generation to have written or or typed or produced more words than they have read. And so part of me is like, let's just assimilate the tradition. And then from there we can branch into less canonical things or um yeah, because that's where I'm like, I'm not gonna put a I use I used to be like, no, absolutely not anything on screens.

SPEAKER_01And now I'm like, I don't know where God is at work in the world. Like he might be he he might be doing that through video games. I don't know. Um, but I would say let's start with assimilating the tradition that we have and understanding those forms, and then write me a really wonderful essay about how Red Dead Redemption for like connects to or doesn't connect to um the novel. But that's my own ignorance. But yeah, I someone else was saying who teaches high school, like um just let them read anything.

SPEAKER_01I didn't start with little women, I started with like goosebumps and like the babysitters club. And look at me now, like just start anywhere and you can, you know, you'll get into the hard stuff later. So I would say if there's enthusiasm, do it. I had a student at West Point Who, like one who loved flying, like her eyes would light up and another, and I'm like, that would scare the living daylights in me. And another kid wanted to be an astronaut more than anyone I've ever met. And I thought, you couldn't pay me a million dollars and I would never go into outer space.

SPEAKER_01That sounds like the most terrifying thing. So that's where I'm just like someone's someone's gotta do that work, and it's it's not me, but it's you. So you have to figure out where the line is. I don't know.

SPEAKER_03Great, thanks. Sorry, you saying we you don't want the gift for Christmas, red dawn, dead four, whatever it was? You do you want that or you don't want it? You don't want it. Okay. Don't end that. All right. It's we've got one over here.

SPEAKER_02Um so I've had I've had probably the same conversation about a hundred times in the last five years, which is uh somebody's basically saying something along the lines of like, I feel like my phone or the news or whatever is rotting my brain. And my response has generally been like, okay. If if you feel like that, let's figure out some kind of tangible limitation that we can put on this thing that you feel trapped by, and together I'll do it with you. We'll figure out how to create some space from that thing. And when I say that, I get to watch their facial expressions, and it's interesting because you can see them sort of wrestling with like a certain amount of hope and a certain amount of like, but I don't want to give up my freedom, and what would accountability look like, and what is my conscience telling me?

SPEAKER_02And then like 99% of the time, what rises to the surface is like this fear, and they're like exiting the conversation as quickly as they possibly can. It seems like you've sort of wrestled with this moment of like, how does my conscience and accountability and all these things interact in this space that I inhabit? Would you be willing to share a couple of anecdotes of your own personal experience of wrestling with those kinds of questions?

SPEAKER_01Um, the first thing that came to mind when you were speaking, like, I don't like I don't know if my mom might be watching this, but I think she knows this by now. Like, I used to smoke cigarettes and I loved it. It was so fun and cool. Like, and I think phones actually took the role of cigarettes because you used to be in a bar or restaurant. And if you were waiting for somebody, you were like, I have a reason to be here. Look at me. Like I'm, you know, like it was it kept you company and you had a reason to be there. And now you're just like, the phone is taking that role. And but I I tried to quit smoking a couple of times and I and you're like white knuckling it.

SPEAKER_01You're like, I'm on day 11 or whatever. And then one day I was like, oh, this is disgusting and I'm sick of it. And then it stuck. And so I think you have to hit that like, ha. Like, I don't, I don't want that bad taste in, you know, my mouth the next day after like whatever I Googled the night before, you know. Like you have to just there has to be some internal thing that I don't think is going to come from um someone else. And I think uh the accountability and the like who is facing us. Um, I think if you grow in faith, then you are kind of aware that like God is always watching.

SPEAKER_01And I don't mean punitively, I mean like lovingly encouraging us to, you know, um fill that time better. Um that that for me has been there's um, there's a prayer in the the litany of trust. I'm looking at my fellow Catholic that um about restless self-seeking in the present moment, from restless self-seeking in the present moment, deliver me Jesus. I'm like, that's phones. That's a hundred percent phones, like restless self-seeking. You just go into your own little world.

SPEAKER_01And I think so. Something is about that appetite has to change. Like you have to realize I don't want another mouthful of dust. Um, and also the recognition that maybe the face that we have to be prepared to meet is God's and not, you know, like, you know, if Devin said like knock it off with your Twitter or whatever, which he would, he wouldn't do. He's my office mate. But, you know, if somebody said that, I'd be like, leave me alone, buddy. Like I know how to manage my Twitter usage. But I think if I if I hear a voice from, you know, not like a voice, but like if I have the internal conscious conscience sense of like, you could do something better with the next five minutes.

SPEAKER_01You could, you could, you could put it down and read an actual book, or you could call a friend, or you could, you know, not because it's never two minutes. It's it's it's 10 and 20, and then you're like, how did that happen? Um I think it's realizing that there are better things and you deserve them, like not a punitive thing, and there are better things and you could do them. That there's like a a way to be a pound. That's like a deeply personal question.

SPEAKER_01I'm I hope you still respect me that I, you know.

unknownC.

SPEAKER_03S. Lewis smoke. It's okay. Yeah. Um great. Cassandra, thank you. We're out of time. It's like our speaker.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Revelation and Archaeology at Sardis

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    Join us for an exploration of the archaeological history of an ancient capital that became a historic Christian city. Sardis, a UNESCO World Heritage site, is known from the Bible as one of the seven cities of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Is "Knowing" More Than Neural Networks? Christianity, Scientism, & AI | Dr. Ian Hutchinson

    Oct 19, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    How do we really know anything - and can an AI "know" at all? In the third annual Dallas A. Willard Lecture, MIT physicist Ian Hutchinson takes on scientism, the belief that natural science is the only route to real...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Rebuilding Trust in a Polarized World | Dr. Rick Lindroth

    Sep 17, 202628 minAudio

    If facts alone can't change minds, what can? Closing his three-part Friday Night Lecture series, Dr. Rick Lindroth shifts from diagnosis to action - offering a practical framework for restoring public trust in science...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Psychology of Science Denial | Dr. Rick Lindroth

    Sep 16, 202631 minAudio

    Why do smart, good-faith people reject well-established science? In this second installment of his Friday Night Lecture series at Upper House, Dr. Rick Lindroth turns from the history of American science to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What Is Science, and Why Don't We Trust It Anymore? | Dr. Rick Lindroth

    Sep 15, 202633 minAudio

    In November 1944, President Roosevelt asked one question that would reshape the 20th century: how do we turn wartime science into a national engine for peacetime progress? In this opening lecture of a three-part Friday...

    Credit the people on this episode