In November 1944, President Roosevelt asked one question that would reshape the 20th century: how do we turn wartime science into a national engine for peacetime progress? In this opening lecture of a three-part Friday Night Lecture series, Dr. Rick Lindroth - Vilas Distinguished Achievement Professor of Ecology Emeritus at UW-Madison and Distinguished Research Fellow at the S.L. Brown Foundation's Lumen Center - traces the origins of American science funding from Vannevar Bush's landmark report Science, the Endless Frontier, to today's federal research landscape. Lindroth lays out what actually makes something "science," why basic research matters, and why public trust in science - once among the highest of any profession - has fractured sharply along political lines since 2020. Part one of "Can Science Be Trusted?" Dr. Rick Lindroth is a Distinguished Fellow of The Lumen Center and a Distinguished Achievement Professor (emeritus) at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, where he also served as Associate Dean for Research. Dr. Lindroth was a recipient of the Hilldale Award in Biological Sciences and is an elected fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), the Ecological Society of America, and the Entomological Society of America. He served as an editor for four science journals and on advisory panels for national and international research agencies. Dr. Lindroth and his research team published ~250 scientific articles and chapters on a wide range of ecological topics. Currently, Dr. Lindroth speaks and writes to the public and faith-based groups about environmental stewardship, climate change, biodiversity, and science denialism/communication. Send us Fan Mail Upper House Commons gathers the university community for spiritual, intellectual, and vocational formation. We explore big ideas and engage in conversations that matter within arts and humanities, justice and society, leadership and vocation, science and technology, spiritual formation, and theology. Whether you are a student or faculty member at UW-Madison or beyond, working in the marketplace, or serving in the church, we see you as part of our university community. Gather with us for one of our programs - our “commons” - each a pasture for shared spiritual, intellectual, and vocational formation. Head over to our events page to see what's coming soon, or mark your calendar for these upcoming programs. Find out more slbf.org/upperhousecommons
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Tonight I have the pleasure of introducing both the topic and our speaker. The question before us tonight is can science be trusted? Science, literacy, and science denialism in a fractured world? And here to answer that question tonight is Dr. Rick Lindroth. Before he comes up, I want to say a bit about my colleague and friend. Dr. Lindroth is a Villas Distinguished Achievement Professor of Ecology Emeritus and former associate dean for research right here at the University of Wisconsin, Madison.
SPEAKER_00His research has focused on the ecology of forest ecosystems with emphases on species interactions, chemistry, and global environmental change. He has been a Fulbright Fellow, and he has been elected as a fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, the Ecological Society of America, the Entomological Society of America, and the American Scientific Affiliation. And here at the University of Wisconsin, Rick was a recipient of the Rome, Kellett, and Hildale Awards in Biology.
SPEAKER_00And with funding from the National Science Foundation, Department of Energy, and Department of Agriculture, Rick had Rick and his research group published over 250 journal articles and book chapters. That is a very big number. Rick served as an editor for several science journals and on an advisory committee for advisory committees, excuse me, for the NSF, USDA, DOE, and the Pew Foundation. He is currently a distinguished research fellow in natural sciences at the S.L.
SPEAKER_00Brown Foundation's initiative, the Lumen Center. He speaks and writes to public and faith-based groups about environmental stewardship, climate change, biodiversity, and science communication. Here's a real quick personal uh note about uh Rick he grew up in Illinois and Missouri, went to the University of Iowa and Illinois, and spent his entire academic career right here at University of Wisconsin, Madison. That is not very common these days. People bounce around quite a bit. That's quite an accomplishment as well. He and his wife Nancy have two married daughters and four grandchildren.
SPEAKER_00For recreation, they enjoy outdoor activities such as hiking, biking, and fly fishing. And here's a very optional fun fact that I hope he's okay with me saying. He has been profiled in both the Washington Post and Trout Unlimited magazine. I had to look that up. It's a real thing. Please join me in welcoming Dr. Lindroff.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Tony. And I was really impressed with the bit of the word cloud that I saw because I was fully expecting answers like boring, um, like uninteresting. And no, they weren't. In fact, the the response that was received the most was biology. And I just want to point that out to my friend Shannon Stahl, who where is this Shannon? Who's a chemistry professor here at UW Medicine? I didn't even see chemistry up there.
SPEAKER_01So anyway, thank you all for coming out on this beautiful night. Uh, I would have been tempted to do something else, and I'm sure you were as well, but thank you for coming. Um, I'm looking forward to the evening. Um, also, thanks to the staff of the Stephen Laurel Brown Foundation. Let's give it up for all the people who put everything together, including the food and everything else. So thank you. And thanks to some of my UW colleagues for showing up.
SPEAKER_01It's always a pleasure to see you. I'm usually asked within about the first sentence or two upon seeing former colleagues, what's retirement like? Well, retirement is like this. I was having breakfast with a friend a couple of weeks ago, also a retired faculty member, and he had returned from a professional conference some weeks before. He said, at the conference, a young woman came up to him all full of smiles and enthusiasm post-graduate graduate school age, and said, proceeded to say she was so excited to see him.
SPEAKER_01She had read all of his papers. His work had fundamentally transformed the trajectory of her career, and she didn't know that he was still alive. That's what retirement is like. But especially in that context, I'm indebted to my colleagues here at the Lumen Center for providing a new scholarly home to pursue some endeavors that I'm interested in.
SPEAKER_01I mostly hang out with a bunch of humanities types, and that's been a bit of a steep learning curve. It's been fun, it's been interesting, and at times challenging. A couple of months ago, we were in some kind of a discussion, and I made the mistake of saying something was just history, and was immediately chided by one of my colleagues, Rick, everything has historical context.
SPEAKER_01Ouch. And of course, he was right. November 1944. The end of World War II was almost in sight. The Allies had reached the borders of Germany on both the western and eastern fronts. They had reclaimed most of the South Pacific and were closing in on Japan. Ten months later, the war would be over. Now, when many of us consider that truly world war, we think, well, of course the Allies won.
SPEAKER_01But in the early years of the war, that was far, far from certain. What was it that just barely tipped the balance in favor of the Allies? In a word, it was science. It was American and Allied science that led to the development of radar, sonar, proximity fuses, synthetic rubber, antibiotics, and of course the atomic bomb. Not only did science win the war, but as one of our friends of Upper House and historian Kevin Walters has said, it was widely perceived and understood as having won the war.
SPEAKER_01Again, most of us would think, well, of course it was American science that led the way, but that also was not a given. Prior to the World War, prior to World War II, the U.S. was a second-rate at best science power. It lagged behind many of the countries in Europe, including France, Germany, and the UK. Robert Oppenheimer, who led the Manhattan Project, didn't get his PhD in the United States. He got it in Germany.
SPEAKER_01Prior to the war, there was no established system of federal support for science in the United States. The total amount of federal funding for science prior to World War II was about$70 million a year, a paltry sum. Most of that went to agriculture and aeronautics. There was no National Science Foundation, no National Institutes of Health, no National Aeronautic and Space Administration. There was no federal funding for universities.
SPEAKER_01What changed? In November of 1944, President Roosevelt wrote to Vinever Bush, his director of the Office of Scientific Research and Development. Recognizing the power of science to transform the world, Roosevelt charged Bush with developing a plan to transition federal support for science from wartime to peacetime efforts.
SPEAKER_02Hold on. There we go.
SPEAKER_01Eight months later, Bush delivered his report to then President Truman. It was titled Science, the Endless Frontier. And that document is considered one of the most important federal reports of the 20th century. It concludes with declaring: without scientific progress, no amount of achievement in other directions can ensure our health, prosperity, and security as a nation in the modern world.
SPEAKER_01And it included these key recommendations: create a National Science Board, which they later named National Science Foundation, provide significant sustained federal funding for research, allocate funds to universities for research and training, emphasize basic, fundamental research. Science should be led and guided by scientists, not by politicians, not by business people. And it should promote the free flow of scientific information.
SPEAKER_01Those recommendations were followed and within a very few years catapulted the U.S. to world premier dominance in science. It for the next 70 or so years was a scientific superpower. It was an absolutely extraordinary transition. Just a few years later, Harry Truman wrote this. Now and in the years ahead, we need more than anything else the honest and uncompromising common sense of science.
SPEAKER_01Science means a method of thought characterized by open-mindedness, honesty, perseverance, and above all, an unflinching passion for knowledge and the truth. Science was embraced by the American public. It became part of our national identity. We saw ourselves as a country of explorers, of risk takers, and of adventurers. We saw ourselves as smart and were proud of it.
SPEAKER_01It would be hard to overestimate the contributions of modern science to society. They've been absolutely transformational. These are just some of the major ways. It expands our knowledge about the universe, drives innovation, improves our health, protects the environment, solves problems, strengthens technology, supports education, enhances our quality of life, and helps shape the future. None of this was destined to happen. It came from a rigorous process designed to test what works and to discard what doesn't.
SPEAKER_01Now I want to highlight basic research in particular, sometimes called curiosity-diven-driven research. It's sometimes undervalued by the public. Basic research is at the heart and soul of innovation, and innovation is what drives economies and enhances the quality of life. Basic research is the foundation of applied research, which leads to multi-trillion dollar industries. Now, as an ecologist, I know full well that some science and science-based-based technologies have harmed humans in the earth that we inhabit.
SPEAKER_01I used to teach a course in environmental toxicology just across the street for almost 30 years. I know full well there are downsides to science. Throughout its history, science is caused because has caused damage because of a lack of ethical oversight and especially because of unforeseen, unanticipated consequences. So science always exists in tension with society. Some measure of skepticism and concern about science is absolutely warranted.
SPEAKER_01Don't hear me say tonight that science should be unfettered. It needs appropriate skepticism. As Reagan once said about the Soviets, trust but verify. But that is a subject of another lecture. Tonight, I want to discuss the recent and dramatic shift in public trust in science. Over the last 10 years or so, something has happened. The relationship of science to society is suffering. Science has been under attack as in no other time in modern history, as some of these headlines indicate.
SPEAKER_01This very month, the Vatican's Pontifical Academy of Sciences is hosting a meeting to address the crisis of trust in science. Science has been swept up into the culture wars and into identity politics. And the fallout from this crisis is negatively impacting all of us right now, whether we recognize it or not. And the consequences will reverberate for generations. Now, a question that some of you are probably asking about tonight is is he going to get political?
SPEAKER_01I wish not, but making sense of the growing distrust of science is simply not possible without considering politics and political ideology. In fact, the data now tell us that distrust in science is itself politically polarized. So that said, my commitment to you is to be honest, to be critical, and nonpartisan. I'll throw some daggers at both Republicans and Democrats.
SPEAKER_01But let me say this if at some point you find your emotions being triggered, take note of it. Because one of the main themes of tonight is to discuss how and why that happens, and it happens to all of us. Here's a roadmap for this evening. Three questions. The first lecture will address what is science, a primer on the American scientific enterprise. Then, why is science distrusted?
SPEAKER_01The psychology and sociology of denial. And finally, how do we address the problem? How do we re-establish trust in a polarized world? And before we get rolling, I need to provide a warning and an admission. The warning is that this evening will be content heavy. Sorry, it's the way it's going to be. You can take the professor out of the classroom, you can't take the classroom out of the professor. My goal is to not only help you understand science and the distrust of it, but to give you tools for addressing the problem.
SPEAKER_01And then an admission. As an article recently highlighted in the prestigious journal Nature Reports, scientist jokes mostly fall flat. So don't expect jokes.
SPEAKER_02That was a joke.
SPEAKER_01A primer on the American scientific enterprise. Science is the rational, systematic study of the structure and function of the natural world. It aims to understand how the world does function and to predict how it will function. It's not so much a body of facts as it is a way of discovering, a way of knowing. And it relies on this thing we call the scientific method, a cyclical process consisting, first of all, of observation, hypothesis formation, experimental modeling, experimentation and modeling, analyzing the results from those experiments and models, and then repeating the process.
SPEAKER_01This process requires creativity, ingenuity, and a commitment to discard what doesn't work and to keep after what does. The emphasis on evidence-based thinking cannot be oversight, cannot be overstated. Science is the very best way we have of understanding the true nature of the world around us, and it is based entirely on evidence-based thinking. And it's this approach toward the gathering and processing of information that separates science from so much of the rest of the world today, in which information processing is more strongly influenced by ideology or by cultural loyalty.
SPEAKER_01And evidence suggests that, sadly, the American public has a poor understanding of the scientific method and an increasingly weak capacity for evidence-based thinking. This leaves us susceptible to pseudoscience and to science denialism and the serious problems that they create. Some of the key correlates of the scientific method are that if it's not refutable, it's not science.
SPEAKER_01To be science, there has to be some way of refuting it. Science operates at the frontiers of knowledge. Perspectives will change as information accumulates. Science has self-correction, not self-protection, written into it. Science is not perfect. It gets things wrong. But the beauty of science is that it's self-correcting. When it gets something wrong, it's scientists, not politicians, not religious leaders, not business people, not social influencers that set it right.
SPEAKER_01It's scientists. Science is not policy, it's not management. Although we would like for science to inform policy, and indeed it does, many other factors do as well. For example, science tells us that wearing seatbelts and banning cigarettes will save lives and money. But society has chosen to require seatbelts and allow smoking, because other factors come into play. Science is not technology, but it contributes to it.
SPEAKER_01This last spring, Nancy, my wife, and my grandson Everett, and I made a trip to Chicago, and one of the places we stopped to visit was the Museum of Science and Industry. And on in that dome, on the bottom side of the dome, are written two phrases. If you can see them here, the first is science discerns the laws of nature. And the second is industry, or today we would say technology, applies them to the needs of man.
SPEAKER_01So science and technology are certainly coupled, they are not one in the same. Now there's one more characteristic of science that I want to mention that is generally underappreciated, especially by the public, and that is that science touches the numinous. Science is a doorway to awe and wonder, to embracing mystery and even the divine. The public has a perspective of scientists as hardened rationalists, but that's really not quite true.
SPEAKER_01A number of sociological studies have shown that over half of scientists believe in God or in some higher power. For example, take Lisa Gromlich. She is a climatologist and was recently president of the American Geophysical Union, one of the largest scientific societies in the world. She's also a graduate of UW Madison. She writes about her immersion in the activities of science, work in labs with instruments, work in the field, proposal writing, etc., etc.
SPEAKER_01But then she continues with this. But I have also stood at the edge of what we know and felt something else entirely. The places where a question opens into a larger question, where the boundary between what I understand and what I'm being asked to become starts to thin. Thin places in Celtic spiritual tradition are where the distance between the human and the holy collapses to almost nothing. I have found them in old growth forests, at the foot of receding subalpine glaciers, in the faces of students the moment something shifts.
SPEAKER_01I have found them in science, in the particular quality of attention that genuine inquiry requires, the willingness to be changed by what you find. This is not how we usually talk about science, but it is, I would argue, how science actually works at its highest register. What she's saying, and what many of my professional scientists would agree with, is that science is itself sacred work. Well, let's move on now and consider what are some of the hallmark traits of science.
SPEAKER_01Good science is transparent. In other words, it should be fully understood, understandable by people who want to read about it. It's independent. It's not funded to produce a particular result. The funding should be independent of the results obtained. It's falsifiable, it's reproducible, it's peer reviewed, it's published by reputable science publishers and organizations, and it's backed by recognized scientific organizations such as NIH or the National Science Foundation.
SPEAKER_01Note that science itself should be challenged. It's Okay, to be skeptical about science. And one of the key steps, several of the key steps in getting science published involve scrutiny by other scientific peers. At the grant proposal stage, at the submission of manuscripts, everything is very carefully scrutinized. Now, note that there are some descriptors I did not use about science.
SPEAKER_01I didn't say it's infallible, it's perfect, or that the results are pleasing or welcome. Those we would hope to be true, but oftentimes are not. Science works at the frontiers of human knowledge and will occasionally get things wrong, and sometimes science tells us things that we don't really want to hear. Let me describe where science funding comes from briefly with this set of graphics.
SPEAKER_01This is a bit old, but it's the most recent data I could come up with. Basic research is funded primarily by the U.S. federal government. This is uh funding in the United States. And that funding is highly, highly, highly competitive. Scientists are not on some type of gravy train where the government is just handing out uh grants to the scientists. I once applied for a grant with the competitive grants arm of the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
SPEAKER_01My grant proposal was ranked number five out of 99. In the top five, it was not funded. That's how competitive science can be. Note that research funded by industry oftentimes raises questions. First of all, let me go back and say the basic research, mostly funded by government, applied research, more so by business, industry, and the development, which I would actually call technology, oftentimes is largely business or industry funded.
SPEAKER_01And that raises questions of concern. Is business-funded science truly independent? It's definitely been a problem in the past, and it certainly continues today. But I want to assure you that safeguards can be put into place to put firewalls between the funding, the funders, and the results. I was a research dean here on campus. We had very, very strict firewalls established such that our faculty who received industry funding were untethered from producing particular results.
SPEAKER_01So I want to make that very clear. Industry is a major funder of science, and that can be very good science. But there can be slip-ups, and there is reason for concern about corporate influence over research. That means, though, that we need to be all the more supportive of federally funded science. Because if federally funded science goes away, as some are making it or trying to do, uh, who's going to pick up the slack?
SPEAKER_01Now, the U.S. government has historically been the largest funder of basic research in the world. And we might wonder if that research funding varies between Republican and Democratic leaderships. So, by show of hands, how many of you would think that federal funding for research is higher under a Republican versus Democratic administration? Okay. One or two or three say it would be higher under a Republican.
SPEAKER_01How many of you would say it would be higher for under a Democratic as opposed to, okay, a lot more hands going up and a lot of, I don't know. Well, actually, the data show that the funding for research fares slightly better under Republican than Democratic administrations. Here we see that there's slightly better funding for defense, quite a bit better funding for the National Institutes of Health, and so on for the rest of many uh federally funded agencies.
SPEAKER_01That shouldn't come as a surprise. Science aligns nicely with fundamental conservative values such as economic growth, tech innovation, and national security. And that support for science by Republicans played out in a major way this year, 2026, because the Trump administration requested a budget for this coming fiscal year that eviscerated science across so many different federally funded agencies.
SPEAKER_01And Congress put it back in, by and large, not fully, but mostly. And for that we can be grateful. Now, historically, science has been one of the most trusted professions in the United States, with public trust hovering around 80 to 85%. That's higher than clergy, it's higher than business leaders, it's certainly higher than attorneys. But that trust has plummeted in recent years, especially starting in the year 2020.
SPEAKER_01The overall level is still good relative to other professions, but the loss is concerning as science is so important for the well-being of individuals and society. Even more concerning, though, is that there is a growing partisan divide over the value of science. The decline in trust is comprised not entirely, but mostly of Republicans, whose the percent who said that they had a mostly positive view of the effects of science on society dropped from 70% to 47% in a span of four years.
SPEAKER_01So we're seeing an increasing partisan divide over the value of science to society. The key reason for that partisan divide is that science, like so many other aspects of society, has been swept up into the culture wars. Here are just a few examples of what's going on federally or nationally in the world of science. We're seeing massive cuts to research and slow walking of congressionally approved funding.
SPEAKER_0195,000 federal scientists have left the workforce since the middle of 2025 and into this year. We're seeing the closing of national research labs and institutes every week. Just this week, there were more closings announced. The exodus, a significant exodus of scientists to other countries, the elimination of science advisory boards, replacement of science agency directors with political operatives, the transfer of funding decisions from scientists to political appointees.
SPEAKER_01That is anathema to science in the United States. The withdrawal of the United States from international scientific networks such as the World Health Organization, and the purging and corruption of science information on federal websites. Finally, we're seeing intimidation and hostility towards scientists whose research challenges political priorities.
SPEAKER_01This crisis in trust in science is unfolding at two levels. First is the decline in trust of scientists and scientific institutions. This parallels the decline in trust in institutions of all forms. But secondly, is a decline in the trust in information itself. Decline in trust in data. As I'll talk about in the next lecture, disinformation and outright lies about science are being intentionally distributed.
SPEAKER_01Information can be easily corrupted and magnified via social media, so much so that our capacity to trust science is being eroded. And this is leading to what's known as epistemic indifference, where people become so frustrated that they lose the motivation to seek and evaluate new knowledge. They just give up. They say, there's no way we can trust this. I'm not going to even try. The distrust of science in the United States is compromising our quality of life, both now and into the future.
SPEAKER_01It's compromising our ability to build toward a healthy, sustainable, economically viable, and resilient world. In a time when global crises are escalating, think emerging diseases, climate change, food, water, and energy security. We are crippling our scientific capacity to address them. Here are two examples. Distrust of COVID vaccines led to the deaths of over 230,000 people in the United States alone, and cuts to pandemic research programs are leaving us woefully unprepared for the next one, which will surely come.
SPEAKER_01Disinformation about climate science has stymied effective action and contributed to a tenfold increase in annual billion-dollar weather disasters since 1980. And those costs are small in contrast to what climate change will be bringing in coming decades. So, what is science? Key takeaways? It's a means for understanding our world through evidence-based reasoning. Science has transformed the modern world, largely, but not always, for the better.
SPEAKER_01The United States has been the global leader in science due to broad political and public support, due to visionary leadership and federal investment. But interesting, the United States is no longer the world leader in science. China, which was a scientific backwater in the 1980s, we're talking only 40 some years ago, is now the world's leader in science. It invests more in research, it publishes more, and it has more top-sided papers. It applies for more patents.
SPEAKER_01It's eclipped, eclipsed, eclipsed, there we go, the U.S. as the world's dominant scientific superpower. U.S. science has been swept up into the ideological culture wars, leading to a crisis of trust. Trust in science remains relatively high overall, but has become politically polarized. Distrust in science is unevenly distributed across political and sociological sectors, such that the health of individuals, the economy, and the environment is being compromised.
SPEAKER_01So, in an era when global crises are increasing, we are systematically dismantling our capacity to predict and to address them. And that, folks, is the problem that confronts us tonight.
Join us for an exploration of the archaeological history of an ancient capital that became a historic Christian city. Sardis, a UNESCO World Heritage site, is known from the Bible as one of the seven cities of...
How do we really know anything - and can an AI "know" at all? In the third annual Dallas A. Willard Lecture, MIT physicist Ian Hutchinson takes on scientism, the belief that natural science is the only route to real...
If facts alone can't change minds, what can? Closing his three-part Friday Night Lecture series, Dr. Rick Lindroth shifts from diagnosis to action - offering a practical framework for restoring public trust in science...
Why do smart, good-faith people reject well-established science? In this second installment of his Friday Night Lecture series at Upper House, Dr. Rick Lindroth turns from the history of American science to the...
This was recorded live at our annual Baccalaureate Service on May 8, 2026. In his role as Campus Pastor, Evan Tinkenberg reaches out to students, faculty, and staff to encourage the integration of learning and faith. He...