Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Two's Complement

Two's Complement artwork

Pay Up, Nerds

Nov 14, 202638 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Ben brings a 1976 letter from Bill Gates, and Matt brings the after-effects of last night's pub. The hat gets out of the rabbit, a squirrel is briefly involved, and nobody downloads a computer.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Matt GodboltHey Ben.

Ben RadyHey Matt.

Matt GodboltWe have a plan.

Ben RadyWe do.

Matt GodboltThe plan is not...

Ben RadyIt's all of eight seconds old, but we do have a plan.

Matt GodboltYeah, no, we mentioned it last night over drinks.

Ben RadyWell, that's true. That's a good point.

Matt GodboltBut I haven't really looked into this. So this is going to be by the... shoot from the hip as always. But the plan, I think, was for us to talk about... a letter that was written a little while ago.

Ben RadyThat's right. That's right. So I'm checking my facts with... Wikipedia here, just to make sure that I get this right.

Matt GodboltAs am I, honestly. I've got it lined up there as well.

Ben RadyAnd so, you know, dear viewer, if you want to, read along with us here...

Matt GodboltBut, we, well, let's talk about what... What are we going to talk about? I'm actually going to bring it up so that I can even read it out, if we wanted to do some kind of audiobook version.

Ben RadyYeah. Yes. No, that's good. We probably... we should... there's maybe some select sections of this. So what we're going to talk about today is Bill Gates' open letter to hobbyists that he wrote in 1976, I believe.

Matt GodboltRight.

Ben RadyFebruary 3rd.

Matt GodboltFebruary 3rd. Yeah, February 3rd, 1976, before even I

Ben Rady1976. Yes.

Matt Godboltwas born, but not by much.

Ben RadyRight. Yeah, well, me too.

Matt GodboltWell, yeah, you are, but you're young.

Ben RadyYeah. Right. Spry 48.

Matt GodboltThat's right. Yeah, that's... I mean, you've got, yeah, exactly.

Ben RadyWhich is, you know, a nice round number. So... the open letter to hobbyists, I think, is really interesting. It reflects an era that I sort of lived through the very tail end of, which I would just maybe refer to generally as the pre...

Matt GodboltMhm.

Ben Radyinternet era.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltObviously, the internet was around this time, but it wasn't in the form that, you know, we all see it and know it now, is what you mean.

Ben RadySure. The commercial internet. The consumer internet.

Matt GodboltRight. Yes.

Ben RadyAs opposed to the academic internet.

Matt GodboltRight, this is AOL...

Ben RadyRight. Right.

Matt GodboltAOL, a kind of generation onwards, and the sort of democratized... yeah, yeah, yeah, CompuServe.

Ben RadyYeah, CompuServe. Yeah, right. Exactly, exactly. Because certainly when I was a kid, access to the Internet was... a thing that was possible but kind of difficult to come by, maybe expensive. Not...

Matt GodboltRight. So just as I was in the middle of high school was when some of my... more well-off friends who had all the gear and whatnot would get a modem, and, you know, 14.4k. And I, for example, I had an acoustic coupler, if you remember these things, they were like actual things you put the handset into, that I'd found, and I tried to get working. I never actually got it working, but that was, like, the level of, like, attempts to get on to any form of BBS or internet at that time. So, yeah, yeah.

Ben RadyYou know... Yeah, uh-huh. Right. We're going to come back to this. BBSes in particular is going to be...

Matt GodboltBut anyway. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Wait, we're getting distracted already because we're all just...

Ben RadyPart of this whole story arc.

Matt GodboltOld men.

Ben RadyI can tell it's going to happen already.

Matt GodboltOld men talking about their how they had it on the internet when they were kids.

Ben RadyRight. But I just wanted to start off with the qualifier of, obviously, Matt and I were not heavily involved in the software industry in 1976.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyAnd so, like, our perceptions on this are...

Matt GodboltBut a gleam.

Ben Radyare backward looking even from our younger days.

Matt GodboltAha.

Ben RadyBut with those caveats in place, I think I can make some sort of interesting arguments.

Matt GodboltEven then.

Ben Radyabout this letter and how we might want to reflect on it today.

Matt GodboltJust in case our listener is unaware, as indeed one of the podcasters is relatively unaware of the contents of this letter, other than it's written in front of me right now, I haven't really read it. What, give me your TL;DR, and, you know, as you said, we can read out little parts of it.

Ben RadyMm-hmm. Right. Yeah, so this was a letter that Bill wrote when he sort of realized that everyone was stealing his software. He had written a program for computers available at the time. And he sort of, you know, was like, hey, our sales and the usage of this thing do not match up. So people are clearly just making copies of it.

Matt GodboltRight.

Ben RadyAnd he sort of makes the argument in this letter that that's not good or sustainable. You know, maybe just to read the first paragraph of the letter. He says, to me, the most critical thing in the hobby market right now is the lack of good software courses, books, and the software itself. Without good software and an owner who understands programming, a hobby computer is wasted. Will quality software be written for the hobby market? He asks.

Ben RadyAnd the sort of implication is that unless you pay for it, the answer is no.

Matt GodboltIt's... Right.

Ben RadyRight. But so, that's the thrust of the letter.

Matt GodboltRight, not unreasonable.

Ben RadyRight. And you can go read it for yourself.

Matt GodboltAnd, you know, he says things along the lines of, you know, we've written these BASICs. You know, the value of the time that we have used exceeds $40,000, he's saying. So it's costing them.

Ben Rady$40,000. Yes. No, that's a lot. It is 1976. It is a lot of money. Yeah. Yeah.

Matt GodboltI mean, in 1976, 40K is a lot of money. And then everyone says they like their BASIC that they've written. It's been positive. But, you know, most of these, quote, users never bought it, is what they say. And they, you know, the air quotes, or not even air quotes, the actual literal quotes around users.

Ben RadyYeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Matt Godboltimplies that, you know, they think a user is someone who's paid for their software, not somebody who is just using it, although, you know...

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltYeah, the amount of royalties we have received from sales... makes the time spent on Altair BASIC worth less than two dollars an hour for the work that they've done, they're saying, which is, you know, not obviously different, even in 1976, that's not a living, but not a good wage.

Ben RadyMm hmm. Not a lot, especially for something like building software, which is, you know... Yeah.

Matt GodboltIs it fair? And so on, you know. So... This is, yeah, I would appreciate people who wants to pay up, he says, at the end, which is rather hopeful.

Ben RadyOkay.

Matt Godboltor has a suggestion or comment and gives his actual... like, address that you could write it to.

Ben RadyRight. Send me a check.

Matt GodboltYeah, send me a check.

Ben RadyYeah, right. Right.

Matt GodboltAnd Bill Gates, general partner, Micro hyphen Soft.

Ben RadyRight. Capital S.

Matt GodboltWhich is... Capital S. Yeah, really, kind of, it shows what it is.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltSo he's basically saying...

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltHey, it's great, but we can't sustain this. It's not okay to not pay for software.

Ben RadyRight. Who is going to make your software if you're not paying people to do it?

Matt GodboltRight. And it makes perfect sense. Right.

Ben RadyMm hmm.

Matt GodboltIt's not like... I mean, he even makes a point about hardware in this. Right. It's like, it's not like I don't expect to have to pay for a physical computer that I'm then going to put on my desk as a hobbyist and then play with. Right, I know that. That's why I don't just go into a shop and... You know, you wouldn't just steal a computer.

Ben RadyRight. Yes. You wouldn't just download a computer, right?

Matt GodboltRight. Right. And so, you know, yeah, it all makes sense.

Ben RadyUh-huh. Yeah.

Matt GodboltSo, kind of...

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltYeah, what's your point, Ben?

Ben RadyWell, so... Right. So I think one way to look at... let's say 1976, from when this was written, to, let's say, I don't know, 1996-ish, the mid-nineties. Let's just say the mid-nineties. And the sort of... easy access of the internet to everyone, right? Like in 1990, let's say. Internet access was possible, doable, not a super common thing.

Matt GodboltRight, but not... certainly not common.

Ben RadyYou know, it's like... yeah. It was more of a specialty thing. To 2000, 10 years later, it's like, yeah, literally everybody is connected to the internet in some way, even if it's just like dial up.

Matt GodboltMm-hmm. Literally, everyone is drowning in... computer, sorry, in America Online CDs that they've been sent through the post multiple times and use them as coasters and whatever, and yeah, we've got all the internet we could ever want.

Ben RadyRight. Exactly. Exactly. Right, right.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadySo, you know, wherever in the midpoint of... Yes.

Matt GodboltSomething happened in that decade.

Ben RadySomething happened in that range that was very important, and we're just going to call that the commercial internet.

Matt GodboltYeah. Yeah.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltMm-hmm.

Ben RadyI think that you could make an argument that basically what happened over that span of time

Matt GodboltMhm.

Ben Radyis you had hobbyists, you had people who really loved working with computers because they were fun. Right, they, like, they really enjoyed it. Maybe it's also their job.

Matt GodboltI hear... programming is fun.

Ben RadyRight. Well, and this is part of my inspiration for this is that I'm reflecting on earlier episodes.

Matt GodboltI've been told. On earlier episodes, right, right.

Ben RadyThey were doing it again. It's a letter to hobbyists.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyRight. He's saying, like, hey, guys, like, I realize you're having a great time with all this stuff, and it's fun, and I like it, and you like it, it's great. But someone's got to pay to write this software. Isn't it just come for free?

Matt GodboltYep.

Ben RadyAnd part of the reason for that, I think, part of Bill's argument here, is that, especially at that time, when you delivered software to somebody, and he makes this point of, like, manuals, courses, and the software itself, well, the software itself is also, like...

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyPhysical media!

Matt GodboltYeah, of course.

Ben RadyThat needs to be mailed to someone, or bought in a shop, or, like, you need to, like...

Matt GodboltA what?

Ben RadyA store of some kind, like, you know, a mall, perhaps.

Matt GodboltDoesn't sound right.

Ben RadyI don't know.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyMaybe that's the thing.

Matt GodboltThat's where like, yeah.

Ben RadyYeah. Right.

Matt GodboltI don't get it

Ben RadySo... he's saying, like, the people need to expend their time making this. The manuals need to be printed. You know, the training courses need to be created. The software needs to be written to disks and tapes of various kinds. And it needs to be delivered to you.

Matt Godboltwhich themselves are, you know, have a cost with it.

Ben RadyRight!

Matt GodboltAlthough, again, you know, obviously if these hobbyists are getting hold of it, they probably are getting hold of... hooky media to then, like, copy to, so there's still some physical cost to them, but just not the... not the part. So...

Ben RadyRight. Right.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyRight, right. And so he's like, there's this cost to this. And I can put myself in the shoes of somebody who's reading this letter, who is one of these hobbyists.

Matt GodboltRight.

Ben RadyWho is kind of like... grumble, grumble, grumble. Like, I don't... I don't like this. I mean, you're kind of right about some of these things, but I don't really know.

Matt GodboltListen, you can't see this, but Ben, as he's saying this, is stroking his beard.

Ben RadyRight, exactly.

Matt GodboltYeah, yeah, yeah, in a very... which, it's possibly the kind of person who was, in fact...

Ben RadyRight. Very bearded. Those folks back then.

Matt GodboltVery bitter, yeah. Yeah.

Ben RadyAnd I think I can make the argument that, like, the thing that... the hobbyists were able to refute this with, the refutation of Bill's letter

Matt GodboltMhm.

Ben Radyis open source and the internet. Because once you have... commonly available internet, then the distribution problems essentially evaporate. Or they become so diminis... diminimously small. That... as to, like... basically say, okay, Bill, like, I get that somebody needs to pay to ship this stuff, but what if we just didn't do that? What if we wrote the software for ourselves? And then just shared it.

Matt GodboltYep.

Ben RadyRight?

Matt GodboltAnd then the... The physical distribution is covered. The web, or the... or Gopher, or whatever it was back then, was our FTP sites, you know, had... you know, README.txts that would be the documentation, which, you know, I think, you know, quality documentation, as he

Ben RadyRight. Yes. Usenet. Yeah.

Matt Godboltputs it here, or quality software, that's a... that's where, that, you know, some of those things... But...

Ben RadyRight. Right.

Matt GodboltThere are people who said, no, there is another solution to this problem. This is like the kind of, you know, there's a negative solution and a positive solution to the square root kind of thing going on here.

Ben RadyMm hmm. Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Matt GodboltIt's like, hey, what if we didn't do that?

Ben RadyRight. Right, and... and I am maybe kind of making the argument here that it's like, open source is only possible because of that commercial access to the internet, whatever it is that happened between the 90s and 2000s. Like, obviously it was kind of there before, but if you...

Matt GodboltI was going to say, we can't... you know, BBSs and things had things like this. It wasn't open.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltI mean, I don't remember it being open source. There were a lot of demos going on. There were lots of, like...

Ben RadyRight.

Matt Godboltcracked copies of things for commercial games. There was... there were obviously, I mean, obviously the GNU project is older than, like, the 90s, right, and things of that nature, and the Free Software Federation Foundation.

Ben RadyYeah, yes. Right. Absolutely. Mm hmm.

Matt GodboltSo clearly there have been folks who have been thinking this way in this sort of, dare I say it, socialist...

Ben RadyRight.

Matt Godboltsoftware.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltLittle bit of politics there.

Ben RadyBut, yes. But... Fast-forwarding to the state that we are in today, where I think you can very easily make the argument that, like, a good chunk of the technology that we have rests on these open source projects, on this...

Matt GodboltMm hmm. A hundred percent.

Ben RadyLike.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadySoftware that was basically granted to the world for free. And all of the technology that we have right now, certainly all of the, you know... LLMs that we have that's writing all this code was trained on

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyMIT licensed software and probably other, not...

Matt GodboltYeah, yeah.

Ben Radysuper legally licensed software, if we're being real about it.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben Radythat was just given away by these hobbyists. And the progenitors, or the... not the progenitors, but the successors of the sort of hobbyist mentality.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben Radythat Bill was speaking to in this letter, and the reaction to it, as, like, a whole group, was, like, screw you, we'll build our own software.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyIf it's not economically viable for you to do it, then we don't need you. We'll do it ourselves. And the thing that allowed them to do that

Matt GodboltRight.

Ben Radyto the degree that we have today, is the internet and the ability to distribute the software to literally everyone in the world for basically free.

Matt GodboltAnd... I'm just sort of thinking back through, yeah, I mean, yes, absolutely. I think it's a foundational aspect, but I also think that, like, stuff like compilers being accessible. Like, so when I was growing up and I was writing stuff in assembly, the reason I didn't learn C, amongst just my... just general grumbliness, is that there wasn't a free version of a C compiler for my platform. And GCC ultimately was ported to my platform eventually. But obviously somebody somewhere said, this is... and it's that is a key unlocking, enabling technology, right at the very bottom of the stack, right, that, and, you know, maybe Linux is the other example of something that is very foundational. And then, you know, like, every academic

Matt Godboltwants to add and contribute. You know, you want to get your master's degree in something, well, how about you add a feature to GCC? How about you add something, you know, that sort of compounds from an academic sensibility? So I'm wondering if that's part of it as well, but I do think that, like, the distribution means that, like, it's taken as read that it's everywhere, right? GCC is everywhere.

Ben RadyMm hmm. Mm hmm. Yeah.

Matt GodboltYeah, I mean, again, maybe, you know, like, looking at the moment, everything is hosted through Git, or, you know, something Git derivative. Obviously there was SVN, yeah, before that was CVS, before that there's all manner of things, but, like, so... Oh, yeah, SourceForge, man.

Ben RadyYeah. SourceForge. Yeah.

Matt GodboltOh, gosh, how the mighty have fallen, right? I mean, in a way.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltBut like that also is an enabler, because, you know, like, having open software, being out, being able to collaborate. And of course, the... the collaboration tools themselves are open source, so there's a kind of bootstrappy feeling to this as well, whereas, you know, I remember using, like, Perforce, which you had to pay a per-seat license for at companies and things like that, so, you know, and Subversion came along and said, like, well, we can be Perforce but we're not Perforce, we are Subversion, we're effectively the same in many, many ways.

Ben RadyRight. Right.

Matt GodboltSo there's a whole bunch of technologies, but, like, this... Yeah, I don't know where we're going now. Where are we going with this, Ben? Where have you led me?

Ben RadyWell.

Matt GodboltI'm looking, it's going like, wow, I hadn't thought of it that way. And now...

Ben RadyBut that's... so, so what of it, right?

Matt GodboltWhy was Bill so wrong? You know, yeah.

Ben RadyRight. Well, so here's the thing is that... as we were discussing in a previous episode about programming and funness, right? So these hobbyists were doing it for fun.

Matt GodboltYep. Yeah.

Ben RadyThey were building computers for fun. They were building eventually software for fun with the open source movement.

Matt GodboltMm hmm.

Ben RadyThey were able to collaborate with other people that were doing it for fun. And then that turned into all of this foundational technology that we have. And it was essentially free to them. It's like once you pay the cost of the computer, you can write your own software. And once you can write your own software and connect that computer to the world, and now you can share the software, and you can collaborate on it. And now you basically have everything that you need to do this as a hobby for fun. Are we, perhaps, maybe now, coming full circle back with Bill, where...

Ben RadyIt's like, well, it's not as fun as it used to be.

Matt GodboltOh, I see.

Ben RadyAnd you have to pay for it, because you have to pay for tokens or you have to pay for access to LLMs.

Matt GodboltWell, that is interesting. So let's take that apart. I mean... There is a certain democratization that anyone who can pay for the tokens can potentially make software now. We've talked about this before.

Ben RadyTrue. But it's... But it's not. It's not free as in beer.

Matt GodboltIt's not free. As in beer, no. It is... You don't have to do that. No one's making people do that. You know, there's definitely, I mean, within my wider friend group, there are a lot of people we still... wait.

Ben RadyTrue. That's true.

Matt GodboltI'm wearing a demo T-shirt right now. You know, we still make demos, and there is definitely a schism opening amongst the sort of more artistic end of programming for fun, for free, where the idea of using AI is verboten.

Ben RadyMm hmm.

Matt Godboltfor good reason, for some folks, and, like, and is a huge enabler for other folks who are, like, being able to do things that have never been able to be done before, by them at least.

Ben RadyRight. Yeah, I am.

Matt GodboltAnd, you know, there's a democrat... democratizer. I mean, and... but yeah, is there a little bit of the... the Incredibles when, you know, when everybody's super, nobody's super. Is that perhaps what people fear, and that in that particular world? You know, like the folks who are incredibly talented are like, well, hey, can I say, my talent is now not as valuable as it was before because everyone else can do it too, right?

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltYou know? But... where was I going? I can't remember where I was going with it. Why are we talking about demos? Because... AI...

Ben RadyWell, it's not... it's that there are going to be people who don't use LLMs to write code.

Matt GodboltRight. You don't have to. Like, you can have people that say, like, look, this is artisanal handcrafted code.

Ben RadyYou don't have to. It's not a hard requirement that you do. Right.

Matt GodboltCome and marvel at how good I am at programming and how beautiful the code looks.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltAnd that's great. You know, again, the repair shop, you know, there is still a world in which Steve from The Repair Shop fixes clocks and doesn't just go, well, here's a Casio.

Ben RadyRight. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Matt GodboltYou know, get off you go, here's a new battery, we're done here, right?

Ben RadyRight. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Yeah.

Matt GodboltThat will always be the case. But the financial aspect of it has changed. We've kind of litigated, or... it's shifted around, and perhaps that's what you're getting at, you know, for a starting point.

Ben RadyWell, I'm kind of making the case that, like, all of these foundational open source technologies that were created by these hobbyists and given away for free were used by all of humanity to create all of this technology that we have. And maybe what's about to happen is the faucet for that is going to turn off.

Matt GodboltIs it there?

Ben RadyBecause the motivations to continue... expanding at the same rate that we have been.

Matt GodboltWell...

Ben RadyI'm not gonna say that those projects are gonna disappear.

Matt GodboltNo.

Ben RadyWell, clearly not.

Matt GodboltWell, they're certainly adapting, aren't they? I mean, like, so some obviously are just carrying on exactly as before.

Ben RadyYeah. Yeah. Right.

Matt GodboltSome... are asking the question, what do we do about well-meaning folks who have got a token budget to spend and want to help?

Ben RadyMm-hmm.

Matt GodboltWhich, you know, is another thing, right? You can get a reward from, like, not being as skilled necessarily.

Ben RadyRight? Yeah. Right.

Matt GodboltAnd not... it's not even skill, right?

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltIt's just... choosing to use a different tool to make a project.

Ben RadyYeah. Mm hmm.

Matt Godboltto advance a project's goals, in which case, you know, the token spend is real, just like effectively the electricity spend that I, you know, you're saying it's free to like sit on my computer.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltIt isn't. It's my time away from things I could be doing.

Ben RadyRight. Yeah.

Matt GodboltIt is my electricity. It's my whatever. I know, but it's de minimis, really.

Ben RadyMm-hmm

Matt GodboltBut... so those folks may get an inrush of good changes. I mean, that does not seem to be the case from what I read, but I mean, maybe there's a world in which that's okay, in which case, you know, now we've got the snowballing of this kind of... of this idea that the people are inclined to improve and make open software even more available and cool and feature-rich.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltI mean... Did you see this? I mean, this is going to date when we're recording this, but a few days ago there was a... the release of essentially a Rust clean room AI re-implementation of... every

Ben RadyI was made aware of that, yes.

Matt GodboltAdobe project. And I'm like, I don't know how I feel about this myself, right?

Ben RadyMm hmm.

Matt GodboltI mean, I certainly... have complicated feelings about Adobe over the years for all the things that they've done, but it's... you cannot say that they have not innovated in a space where... perhaps they needed to be a market leader. They're certainly a market leader for a couple of the big projects. Also, I was speaking to someone from Adobe, and they were telling me about a lot of other stuff that they do that perhaps you don't know that they do. But, like, you know, you think of Photoshop, obviously. You think of, like, PDF, Acrobat. You think of the video editing equivalent that I can't remember the name of right now.

Ben RadyOkay.

Matt GodboltAnd those kinds of things, After Effects, whatever. That's cool. All those are great.

Ben RadyMm-hmm.

Matt GodboltThey've gone to... you know, they used to be expensive to buy. They, I mean, it used to be a significant cost at, like, the game studios I used to work at. And now they've gone to a subscription model.

Ben RadyYeah, yeah

Matt GodboltAnd the first thing when I saw this and I was speaking with a friend at work, the first thing the friend said was, wow, this is really going to put... pressure on the pricing model of Adobe.

Ben RadyMm hmm.

Matt GodboltBecause if you can... just recreate it with some amount of... tokens that have admittedly probably incredibly heavily subsidized right now, and unsustainably so.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltSo we don't know what the true cost of recreating Photoshop in Rust in

Ben RadyYeah, but certainly less than all of the future discounted revenues of Adobe. Right.

Matt GodboltCorrect. Correct.

Ben Radyby a few orders of magnitude.

Matt GodboltBy, yeah, a number.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltBut, like, how is this changing the world? And is this... I'm not going to say is it better or worse. Is it... how is it changing? Yeah.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyYeah. I mean, that's another interesting dimension to it of, like, you know, getting back to Bill and his letter and the sort of premise here, it's like open source eating Adobe's business. But it's a very particular kind of open source that has been accelerated by LLMs.

Matt GodboltRight. I mean, like, the GIMP has been around forever. It is all... And, you know, Audacity has been around forever.

Ben RadyRight. Yep.

Matt GodboltAnd various... Kdenlive and other things have been around for a while.

Ben RadyYep.

Matt GodboltThere's just something about them that screams, I don't know, I'm going to say this is going to make everyone hate me, you know, it screams, this is open source, right? Which means that, like, it's...

Ben RadyRight. Right.

Matt GodboltThere's a particular feel of the software. It's like they're without a strong...

Ben RadyYeah, yeah, yeah

Matt Godboltproduct lead. And, I mean, that's not to say, like, I know that, like... Oh, I can't even... forget the bloke's name, but he's just left there. But, like, I know there was a product lead for Audacity, who worked really hard

Ben RadyMm hmm.

Matt Godboltto try and, like, steer it in the right direction and all that kind of stuff. But, you know, effectively when you're dealing with...

Ben RadyYeah. The resources a person like that is going to have is going to be de minimis in comparison to Adobe and the stupid amount of money that they have to throw at, like, all kinds of problems around product development.

Matt GodboltRight, right. Well, I mean, also, it's not the cool stuff, right?

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltIf you're a programmer doing it, you know, I don't know. Maybe there's just something about the programming mind that means that open source sounds cool and groovy and you just want to do it. And you're like, hey, I'm sharing this stuff. It's like, nobody goes, my hobby is product managing or managing small teams of developers, right?

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltThat's my hobby. I just love doing it. On my weekends, I just love to tell people what to do. I mean, maybe there are people like this, but certainly I don't.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltI don't know any, and I probably wouldn't want to hang out with somebody who thinks it's fun to tell me what to do.

Ben RadyYeah. Well, and that is actually kind of the point that I was making earlier, is that, like, where is the future where it's like, my hobby is being a meat proxy for, you know...

Matt GodboltOkay, okay. Right.

Ben RadyLLMs to write the next generation of cool open source software. Now, this is a great counterexample to that, and I almost wonder if this is almost, you know, as much of a... let's just see if we can do this to figure out if it's possible.

Matt GodboltMm-hmm

Ben RadyNot necessarily, I want to spend my time on an open source clone of Photoshop. Right? Maybe you do. Maybe that's what you want.

Matt GodboltBut... kind of the rabbit's... the rabbit's out of the bag. No, the... the... but

Ben RadyThe hat's out of the rabbit.

Matt GodboltSomething like that, yeah.

Ben RadyThe squirrel is, I don't know. I've...

Matt GodboltWhat is the thing? Oh God, I'm having a moment. The cat's out of the bag.

Ben RadyThe cat's out of the bag, yeah.

Matt GodboltOh my gosh. You know, like you can't put the genie back in a bottle here. Like once someone goes, oh, that's cool.

Ben RadyYeah, yeah, yeah.

Matt GodboltEven if Adobe shuts it down, someone else will bring it up. Or, you know, even if it's just there, it can be forked a million times.

Ben RadyRight. Yeah.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyRight. Like once, once it's proven that this is possible, it's going to be incredibly difficult to stop.

Matt GodboltSo.

Ben RadyAnd there might even be a little bit of Streisand effect here where it's like the harder Adobe tries to stop it, the more people are going to.

Matt Godboltthe more...

Ben Radyfight against it. Right.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyJust to be like, you know.

Matt GodboltVery true.

Ben RadyYou don't get to have the choice here, Adobe.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyBut, but I

Matt GodboltI mean, did you see their stock price took a, like a... Donk.

Ben RadyI did. I saw the graph.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyThat was, yeah. And I mean... maybe rightly so. Maybe rightly so.

Matt GodboltYeah. It's... It's interesting.

Ben RadySo, I don't know. I just... this sort of struck me.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyI was... you know, randomly something.

Matt GodboltSo your thesis really is, like, have we gone full circle? Are we now paying for software but in a different way?

Ben RadyYeah. Yes, we're paying in the form of tokens, and that is going to create... situations where the hobbyists now, in order to... do the same thing that they have done in the last 30 years, which is create these open source projects that are so impactful, that are so foundational, to repeat that again over the next 30 years. They're... they're kind of not going to be able to. Because in order to do it, they're going to have to pay for tokens that they didn't have to really pay for before. And your, you know, your point about, like, okay, there's electricity and there's other things.

Matt GodboltRight.

Ben RadyBut in comparison, it's just... it's going to be many orders of magnitude more expensive. It's not going to be at a hobby level at the moment.

Matt GodboltAt the moment. At the moment, right?

Ben RadyAt the moment.

Matt GodboltBecause, you know, like in the 1960s, prior to even, you know, this letter being written, there were people who would...

Ben RadyYes.

Matt Godbolttinkering with this kind of stuff, but they were beg... borrowing and stealing access to Crays, or, you know, getting... you know, going to universities and finding their way into the places to be able to, like, work on stuff that they thought was interesting, and, you know, punching cards and stuff, and then getting, you know...

Ben RadyRight. Right. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Matt GodboltSo, you know, maybe it'll change again.

Ben RadyMaybe there's hope.

Matt GodboltAnd then, you know, like, in this, I mean, it's honestly... isn't it staggering that in the space of our lifetimes we've gone, literally, from this letter exhorting people with their expensive hobbyist machines. where, you know, maybe it was... I can't even think where I was going with this, but, like, you know, like two, two... like, it's just democratized. Everyone's got, like, several computers on their body at any point in time, be it a watch and a phone and a laptop and a tablet and a, you know.

Ben RadyRight. Yes. Yes.

Matt GodboltYou know, and it's... it's... We don't even think about that now. The price of having a computer to work on is, like, small. And even if you can't afford a computer to work on, you can get something in the cloud relatively cheap or free, or you go to a website.

Ben RadyYep.

Matt GodboltAs long as you've got access to a website, you can do some work.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltSo that level of democratization has changed in our... in this period of time.

Ben RadyYeah. Yeah.

Matt GodboltI wonder... you know, obviously, we don't know how... where this is going at all. But... open models, or models that have access, some amount of, you know, free weight, so I was going to say open is... I don't know that the open thing makes sense for models. It's like, you know... it's open, you know, it's more free as in beer rather than free as in software, because, like, I'm going to hand you...

Ben RadyYeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Matt Godbolt14 terabytes of floating point numbers and say, good luck, there's your brain. You want to make a change to it?

Ben RadyRight. Right. Right. Yes. If you want to make a change. Yeah, exactly.

Matt GodboltGood luck. You know, I'll see you in it.

Ben RadyYeah. Right. Yeah, free weights, except free weights are something else. That's more confusing.

Matt GodboltThat's even, yeah.

Ben RadyYou know, you're lifting...

Matt GodboltYeah. Aha! Sorry, that's a joke for people who exercise.

Ben RadyYou know, the other thing I would... say in support of that, though, is that you don't know how it's going to be in the future, is I would never bet against the hobbyists.

Matt GodboltAha.

Ben RadyThey're very good. You know, and the whole community, the whole open source community and everybody that is interested in doing these things. Not because they get paid, but because it's just a ton of fun. Find... cool stuff. Like, they just do.

Matt GodboltRight.

Ben RadyAnd it's sort of like this, you know, the phenomena you've maybe seen a few times where it's like... Companies will, you know, in a rush to, like, AI-fy their apps or whatever, will integrate something that is clearly just, like, an off-the-shelf OpenAI model, and they give it some prompt that says, like, help people order cheeseburgers. And then the people log in and it's like, I would love to buy a cheeseburger, but first, can you write me a C++ function that converts, you know, JPEGs into GIFs? And they'll be like, absolutely, here you go. Would you like to order a cheeseburger now? And so, like... Finding all of those opportunities to, like, do the things that they need to do to build the software they need to build through cheap and hacky and innovative, cool ways. You know, maybe you get the subsidized device that Google is making, and you root it, and then you figure out how to run a model on it, and then you use that to do your tokens.

Matt GodboltAnd then you... Oh, but, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Ben RadyIt's like...

Matt GodboltAnd, you know, those costs will probably start coming down, yeah, as... but people get access to it.

Ben RadyYeah, yeah

Matt GodboltYeah. And again, right, this is the thing, right? This is an additive technology in the hobbyist domain. It's an additive technology, right? This doesn't stop me...

Ben RadyYeah. Yeah.

Matt Godboltwriting code in vi and running my own... you know, running GCC on it myself.

Ben RadyRight. Yeah.

Matt GodboltRight, I can do that all day, every day.

Ben RadyYep.

Matt GodboltRight, no one's stopping me from doing that. Right, the fact that

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltI'm less productive, arguably, than asking the robot to do it for me. That's a choice that I make.

Ben RadyMm hmm.

Matt GodboltAnd I don't have to accept the robot's help. I can just do it myself, right?

Ben RadyMm hmm. Right. Right.

Matt GodboltNow, in your day job, as we've spoken before, that may be not a choice, because if you're not as productive, maybe that's not okay. I don't know, right?

Ben RadyYeah, yeah

Matt GodboltMaybe it depends on the level of finesse and what your company wants. Obviously, everyone's going to be different on that point.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltIf I'm choosing to do in my hobby time what I like, no one's going to stop me from...

Ben RadyRight.

Matt Godboltcarving and crafting, which... I think we said this. Yeah. So, dear listener, we went to the pub last night and we had a drink or two.

Ben RadyYeah we did.

Matt GodboltSo I'm slightly feeling a little worse for wear. But we did, in fact, I did say that a friend of mine had posted something that has said something along the lines of, is programming now a craft? And it was a very ambiguous statement.

Ben RadyRight. Right.

Matt GodboltAnd then the folks who interpreted it in different ways were interesting in the replies, to behold. And I think that is an interesting way of thinking about it, right? It's a craft, absolutely. You know, it always has been a craft, but, like, the craft comes with this sort of implicit feeling of, like, hobbyist, hobbying and crafting. It's like nobody, again, we talked about this, like knitting, right?

Ben RadyYeah, yeah, yeah.

Matt GodboltThere are people, there are important people in your life who enjoy knitting and knit. Right. But, like...

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltIt's... No one's going to stop them from knitting.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltBut I'm going to go to the store and I'm going to buy one myself, if it's okay with you.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltHeh.

Ben RadyRight. Well, and I think one of the concerns that you could have about this, though, because, your point about, like, I can always just bust out vi and do this myself. Like, that's the beauty of open source, is that at this point, it's never going away. It almost can't go away. It will always be there. And that's fantastic. And it's like a wonderful thing that humanity has created, honestly. but there is a concern that one could have that the craft and the profession are going to diverge in ways that they have not. In fact, they've converged over the last 30 years, and it's like, what you would do as a software engineer in a real job and what you would do as a hobbyist working on open source software are essentially identical

Matt GodboltOh man.

Ben Radybut maybe they won't be 10 years from now.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyAnd so, like, that ability to apply the craft, because, you know, the practices and you have the tools, and it's like, literally, I do this all day long, and then I come home and I do... I do it again. It's like, no, what you're doing in your day job is now... very different from what you would do in sort of that more craft mentality, because that's what you can afford to do as your hobby.

Matt GodboltYeah. I mean, that's another way of... that's another sort of... that's another relitigation of the, where are we going to find the software engineers of the future,

Ben RadyRight.

Matt Godboltargument-ish. And, you know, and then it leads to the conclusion, potentially, or at least down that path of, like, well, we don't need them anymore. We just need... no one needs authors anymore, we only need critics, right? That's, you know, a very big difference between us. So, well, you know, the robot writes the book, and then I read it and criticize it, and that's a different skill set. It's overlapping in some ways, but it's different. And then at some point we go, but no one could do this anymore, and we go, well, that doesn't matter, because nobody's doing that. Why would we do that? You know, nobody does that. No one needs to do that, except, you know, like...

Ben RadyYeah. Hmm. Mm-hmm.

Matt GodboltWeird Tim over there.

Ben RadyHa ha. Yeah.

Matt GodboltTim loves to write it himself, you know, doing it in his way.

Ben RadyYes.

Matt GodboltAnd, you know, and everyone's going, that's lovely. What a lovely pastime that is. And that becomes genuinely a hobby, and it's utterly divorced from profession.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltI get it.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltYes.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltI've just re-derived what you said earlier because I'm a slow person.

Ben RadyWell, false, but okay.

Matt GodboltWow. Yeah. I don't know how I feel about any of the things that we've spoken about today, which has been my, honestly, it's been my lived experience for the last... six months is...

Ben RadyYeah. I know, this just sort of, like...

Matt Godboltis...

Ben Radyyou know, worry combined with, like...

Matt GodboltOn...

Ben RadyI don't know, wonder. Yeah. Yeah.

Matt GodboltSo there's an element of delight, yeah, delight and wonder at some of the things that I am able to do. A little bit of hollowness afterwards, feeling, if I've done something cool, then go, have I done it?

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltI don't know. Me? No. Yes. But like, I have a thing now. It's really cool.

Ben RadyI...

Matt GodboltAnd no one else has this thing. And that's great.

Ben RadyI heard something... I heard something a couple of weeks ago that actually was a great summary of this whole situation, which is... LLMs are a cheat code. And just as with a game, if you use a cheat code to just warp to the last level and beat the boss immediately, it's like... cool. What of it?

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyNow what? What?

Matt GodboltIt's hollow and yeah.

Ben RadyIt's like... Okay, I didn't really do anything. Right. And it's like...

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyIt gives you this power, but it takes away all of the elements that made it engaging.

Matt GodboltRight. There is a reason why I haven't Googled anything about, like, Skyward Sword, because I can enjoy it myself at the moment. I'm not cheating in any way. I'm just enjoying it for itself, and I will not... look up anything. I'm having a great time. But, yeah, like, I have also... but so, but to counter that...

Ben RadyYes. Yes.

Matt GodboltWhat did I play the other day? Oh, I played the original Legend of Zelda, which I'd never done before. You know, it's... it's perfectly tractable to beat it, but I was, like, I've got this morning.

Ben RadyMm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Matt GodboltI've never beaten it before. I just want to see the game.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltAnd so I got the guide and I enjoyed playing the thing from one end to the other.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt GodboltAnd I was like, oh, that's why this is great. And of course it would have been a... I'm going to say better, different experience to have pound it through it, but I haven't got the time, and this was my way of enjoying the game at least at some level and getting to the end, of being like, oh, there we go. Right.

Ben RadyMm hmm. Mm hmm.

Matt GodboltBrilliant.

Ben RadyMm hmm.

Matt GodboltSo, yeah, it's different. And, you know, there have been analogies about, you know, like... it's like sending the robot to the gym for you so that, you know...

Ben RadyYeah. It's different.

Matt GodboltBut, like, that implies that you want to do that thing, right?

Ben RadyYes. Yeah.

Matt GodboltOr that it's valuable to you. And maybe it isn't. But...

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltI just had to find this on my phone here. This is from... Alice Averlong, I don't know how to pronounce her name, but, like, the AI industry is full of people who would automate away playing with a kitten.

Ben RadyHmm.

Matt GodboltAnd I'm like, yeah, that's when you've gone too far. There's a point at which you've gone too far. That's the thing. It's like, oh, yeah, yeah, hey, I can... you know, you go and do the fun thing. I mean, we talked about this last night, right?

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltI'm sat here, like, that the... the computer is doing something that I would like to do, and I'm doing my tax returns. I'm like, this is exactly the wrong way around, right?

Ben RadyRight. Right. Yeah.

Matt GodboltThis is not how I want to be spending my time. But... but here we are. Yeah. So... Taking it all the way back in to try and conclude this, as I'm looking at the time and thinking... We're not very good at ending podcasts.

Ben RadyYeah, well... I mean, I think it's still an open question, all these years later, about whether Bill was right and that, you know, basically software, in order to be successful, needs to be a commercial activity. It certainly was not in the last 30 years. Right.

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyForty years, really, we... yeah, 40 years at this point.

Matt GodboltI'm... Wow.

Ben RadyGod, I'm old. But...

Matt GodboltI just turned 50. So, you know, like it's 50 years from before to this time.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltSo, I mean, you're not old yet.

Ben RadyYeah. So it certainly has not been since, like, the sort of... you know, birth of the commercial internet and the sort of booming of open source software and the communities around them. Like... it absolutely was not true. Will it be true in the next 40 years?

Matt GodboltYeah.

Ben RadyWe're going to find out.

Matt GodboltWe are going to find out one way or another.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltOr... Roko's basilisk is going to torture us all to death.

Ben RadyRight.

Matt Godboltin a very... Wow, that's a... No, we can't end there. We can't end there. I'm not even above... I know I'm too lazy to edit that out. So now we just have to turn it around and be like, well, that might not happen. It may be like, what was the opposite of it? I think Davison's weasel is the opposite of that.

Ben RadyMm hmm.

Matt GodboltAnd that would come and make everyone lovely and everything would be great.

Ben RadyWe're going to have a benevolent...

Matt GodboltBenevolent AI.

Ben RadyAI that's going to... treat us all like pets.

Matt GodboltI'm... I want the Culture AI robot. That's what I'm hoping for. You know.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltIain Banks, no. Anyway. Well, friend, before I open a whole new worm can... Food for thought.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltNo conclusion at all, which is, you know, typical of this podcast.

Ben RadyYeah. Listeners discuss amongst yourselves.

Matt Godboltamongst your... yourself.

Ben RadyYeah, right.

Matt GodboltSingular. Oh, that's... now it's getting complicated. I've... I've met... now I've... that joke is... we're wearing thin with everybody I meet now. I... I...

Ben RadyNo, there's at least two, maybe even three listeners out there, at least.

Matt GodboltSo... really?

Ben RadyWe should have a meetup.

Matt GodboltI mean, yeah, I suppose so. We could do. Yeah, that would be an interesting one. I mean, we've talked about doing a live version of this, or doing a recorded version of this, but that's far too much effort involving...

Ben RadyYes.

Matt GodboltI'd actually have to care about my appearance, which at the moment is...

Ben RadyOh my goodness.

Matt GodboltYeah, no one wants to do that.

Ben RadyWow. That seems like a lot of work.

Matt GodboltBut maybe another time. Anyway.

Ben RadyYeah.

Matt GodboltLet us know in the comments or whatever. Don't forget to like and subscribe. No, what am I supposed to say?

Ben RadyAnd I... I don't know, man.

Matt GodboltI forget now. I don't know.

Ben RadyI don't do this. This is not my jam.

Matt GodboltNo. That's not your job now. This is not a job.

Ben RadyNo.

Matt GodboltAnyway, friend, this has been fun.

Ben RadyYes.

Matt GodboltI will speak to you another time.

Ben RadyNext time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Lightning Round

    Oct 11, 202643 minAudio

    Ben gives his house to an AI named after GLaDOS, and Matt makes the compiler build a Z80. A dying USB dock threatens to end it all.

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Is Programming Still Fun?

    Sep 11, 202644 minAudio

    Ben asks a question that violates Betteridge's law. Matt rediscovers the joy of coding like a caveman on a plane with no WiFi.

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Tinfoil House

    Aug 15, 202638 minAudio

    Ben's friend is locked out of their AWS account and Matt's AI has decided he's a hacker. The escape route runs through a cheap computer, a mesh network, and Neal Stephenson.

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Never Twice the Same Color

    Jul 10, 202644 minAudio

    Matt records from the wrong continent and explains how he taught his computer to be a 1950s television. Ben guesses his way to the secret of the colo(u?)r burst and wins today's podcast.

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Programming in English

    Jun 14, 202632 minAudio

    Ben sets out to learn Rust by only reading it, while Matt wonders if you can learn to land a plane from a book. Also: is snark a portmanteau?

    Credit the people on this episode