
Is Programming Still Fun?
Ben asks a question that violates Betteridge's law. Matt rediscovers the joy of coding like a caveman on a plane with no WiFi.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Ben asks a question that violates Betteridge's law. Matt rediscovers the joy of coding like a caveman on a plane with no WiFi.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Matt GodboltHey, Ben.
Ben RadyHey Matt.
Matt GodboltHow are you today?
Ben RadyI'm doing alright.
Matt GodboltExcellent. Excellent.
Ben RadyThank you.
Matt GodboltWell, we... we surprisingly have a topic today. In fact, we went out for drinks last night.
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt GodboltAnd we discussed many things, some of which we wish we had a microphone for so that we could have just recorded it and put it out to our good audience here. Much of it... was absolutely unbroadcastable for a variety of reasons, usually around intellectual property and or just...
Ben RadyYes, right.
Matt Godboltinappropriateness.
Ben RadyToo many drinks, that's...
Matt GodboltToo many drinks, yeah.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltHa ha. But one of the things that you brought up, which I thought was really interesting... Well, I'm gonna let you say it. What is your topic for today, Ben?
Ben RadyIs programming still fun?
Matt GodboltIs programming still fun? And is this...
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltDo you mean... Have you gotten bored of programming? You know, now you're... ancient and old. You'll never be as old as me, but... Yeah, ancient and old, and you've gotten tired of it. Yeah, you just want to do, I don't know, weaving or...
Ben RadyI don't... You know, it's sort of the, you know, the cliche breakup line is it's not you, it's me. It's the opposite of that.
Matt GodboltHa ha! Ha ha.
Ben RadyIt's not me. It's you, comma, Claude.
Matt GodboltOh. Oh.
Ben RadySo I am posing this question specifically in the context of these modern, powerful tools that we have.
Matt GodboltYep.
Ben RadyWhich I'm certainly not suggesting that we give them up. But is a side effect of this that programming is no longer fun? Or... You know, and I... I don't think that there is an obvious answer to this question. This is not like a super leading question. It also may be in flagrant violation of Betteridge's law of headlines, which is the answer is not obviously no.
Matt GodboltInteresting.
Ben RadyThe answer is not also obviously yes. So it's like, I think it's worth a podcast to talk about.
Matt GodboltYeah, worth a podcast episode. So yeah, I mean, you and I obviously, we spoke about this
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltlast night a little bit. And I think... As we've alluded to in other episodes, we've both... been on a journey of discovery through this process, as have many people in our position, where, you know, first of all, we're in the luxurious position of we have established careers, and so we can look at it from that point of view. And there's a whole bunch of topics that go in the direction of like, but what does this mean for the next generation? I don't propose we talk about that today. But from a very selfish, individualistic point of view, has the advent of coding assistants of all sorts, has that taken away the thing that we actually enjoy about
Matt Godboltprogramming? So let me start with this.
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt GodboltOkay, so back in the day, I would edit code in black and white with no syntax highlighting.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltIn a vi terminal or in an editor, a very straightforward editor. And it was hard work. Right? It was hard work to hold what I needed to hold in my head.
Ben RadyMm-hmm. Yeah.
Matt GodboltI sort of squinted to be able to understand the code that I was working on. And the first... improvement in my life as a developer was syntax highlighting and or colorization of what I was working on, I think.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltStrongED was the name of the editor that I was using. And it was like an absolute step change in my ability to look at a page of code and kind of get the gist of it straight away. And that was... unambiguously an improvement. Then... Time ticked on. And the first sort of next, rather, the next stop point, I think, where like tooling came along and changed the way we program was IntelliSense. And that materially changed the way... I didn't have to remember all of the documentation or forever go hunting for it.
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt GodboltI would type object name dot and then hit control space, and I'd get a list of all the things that that object could do.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltAnd I remember people at that time saying, oh, this is... You don't really know it anymore. You're just kind of feeling your way through the problem. Right. And that means that you're not thinking about it holistically.
Ben RadyUh-huh.
Matt GodboltYou don't really understand it. You're just kind of auto-completing your way into a solution, right?
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltAnd that's another step change in the way that we do things. And then maybe we could say refactoring tools have a similar feel, but I could argue that maybe they're more freeing, I don't know. And then obviously we get to the point now where I, rather than thinking about something myself, I say,
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt GodboltHey, agent, can you refactor this thing for me? And then I go away and make a cup of tea, or more likely I have four or five of them going and I'm doing something kind of different.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltAnd maybe that's the thing. What do you think about that?
Ben RadyOne of the observations that we had last night is that I certainly find, and I think other people have found this as well, that it is very difficult to be in a flow state while programming with agents.
Matt GodboltYes.
Ben RadyI think I've had some moments where it sort of comes back a little bit and it feels a little bit like a video game in the sense of like, you know, you're interacting in like a frequent enough
Matt GodboltYes.
Ben Radyway to where you get a little bit of it. But it is definitely not the same feeling of, you know, putting on a pair of headphones with the, you know... Tron soundtrack on.
Matt GodboltOh, excellent choice, sir.
Ben RadyAnd... you know, sitting down with the editor or IDE of your choice and solving a problem and being in flow state the entire time. And, you know, especially like some of the practices that I had built up in my career around, you know, test driven development and continuous testing and running tests
Matt GodboltRight.
Ben Radyon a continuous basis and getting that feedback loop, where you have like the constant feedback loop of like take a very small step, get feedback on that step, take another very small step. That can very quickly put you into a flow state.
Matt GodboltMm-hmm.
Ben RadyWhich many people, including myself, find the flow state to be very enjoyable. That is half the reason I play video games is because... they put you into that state and it's fun. It's just fun to be in that state.
Matt GodboltA friend of mine referred... This is in the context of playing video games, usually on the Game Boy, which tells me exactly how long ago this was.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltBut at the time I was commuting a very long distance on the train, and my friend pointed out that it's okay because you have a time travel device, which is that you have a Game Boy in your hands. You put on Pokemon and then before you know it, you're about to miss your stop an hour later, right? And I think that's true. That's what that flow state is. It's like...
Ben RadyYeah. Right. Right. Yeah.
Matt GodboltYeah, I definitely feel you on the flow state. And in particular, when I am managing multiple sessions at once, the context switching overhead is just decimatory
Ben RadyYeah. Yeah.
Matt Godboltto flow.
Ben RadyYes.
Matt GodboltI think the times where I get into flow where I'm working with agents is when I have the screen split in half, and I have my IDE up and I'm still reading the code, and maybe I'm even commenting the code, I'm looking at the code, while meanwhile I have more of a pair programmer, but a pair programmer that I can alt-tab to rather than have to like speak to. And that's like the nearest thing. But then
Ben RadyYeah. Yeah. Right.
Matt Godboltthat feels like it's not as efficient, if efficiency is what you're looking for, as working on five things at once and getting, you know, progress on multiple fronts. So it feels like maybe I'm not doing it right, you know? I'm still doing the old school programming, it's just I've got Claude to help me, you know, and like, oh, can you fix this, make that test pass, now actually I've now changed the code, that feel. And then it's kind of back and forth. I don't know. Is...
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltIs that close to your experience when you said you could get into a flow state, or are you thinking of something else?
Ben RadyYeah, that is close to my experiences when you start doing that sort of more, almost pair programming type approach. And in my day job, a couple of weeks ago I actually did a presentation at work because we've had a lot of folks that, you know, have lots of questions about like, you know, how should we be using agents at work and, you know, other things like that. And I did a presentation that I called Agentic Patterns. And it was like, these things, you know, like we've talked a bunch of times about programming patterns and, you know, software development patterns. Like you've got, you know, architectural patterns like the singleton and the flyweight and all of those other kinds of things, but you've also got patterns that are essentially practices, you know, test driven development, refactoring, continuous integration, continuous deployment, pair programming. These things are all kinds of patterns really.
Ben RadyAnd so, you know, I tried to sit down and like, with lots and lots of caveats and asterisks, saying like, these are some things that kind of seem to work for me right now, given the current technology, but all of this is going to be different.
Matt GodboltMm-hmm.
Ben RadyAnd I have no idea what the long-term ramifications of this is.
Matt GodboltRight, I suppose unlike like Gang of Four...
Ben RadyYes.
Matt Godboltstyle patterns and practices, whatever, all these things change week on week, let alone maybe, if not day on day.
Ben RadyRight. Yes. Ah yes. I am making no claims whatsoever that these are the patterns or that even that these are good patterns for everybody. They just happen to work for me in certain contexts. And so I wanted to at least start a conversation about like sharing them and maybe giving them some names, right?
Matt GodboltRight.
Ben RadyAnd so this sort of pattern of like when you are essentially pair programming with the agent, right? Like there's one agent running, you're reviewing the code fairly closely. You're doing things like adding TODO comments into the code and saying like, hey, fix this, fix this, fix this. You're very much focused on like method and class signatures and function signatures as a way to drive the direction of the agent rather than strictly just using English.
Matt GodboltRight.
Ben RadyYou know, like that kind of interaction, I definitely have had situations like that where it feels like pair programming in a lot of ways, and you definitely can get into a flow. But those are... That's not the everyday, right? Like that's a situational type of thing where you're like, it's really important that I get this right, or I'm trying to understand this, or I'm trying to like
Matt GodboltYeah. Yeah.
Ben Radyfix a problem or something like that. That's not the normal default mode, at least that I have when I'm doing agentic programming. And so most of the time, that means these days I'm not in that flow state. Right. Which is very different than it was two years ago.
Matt GodboltRight. Right. And I mean, especially, I mean, I'm seeing more of a push towards sort of the software factory approach where, you know, you have Slack integration or...
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltor whatever, and you kind of, you're kind of like doing one shot, like, hey, just fix this comment, right, to a thing that then makes a pull request to your repo or whatever, and then some other bot reviews it, and then you once over and go, yeah, that's about right, and then you check it in. And all that, the software factory of, like, almost like a Kanban board of, here's all the tickets that are in progress, and I'm just basically the ticket
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt Godboltadministrator stroke
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt Godboltlast sign-off part of the process. And it feels... like that is not, yeah, I'm... I'm a mediocre product, a project manager
Ben RadyYeah, yeah, yeah.
Matt Godboltat best, and I'm an adequate code reviewer.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltIn fact, I like to think... I'm better than adequate code reviewer, but... The thing that I like about reviewing code is the ability, first of all, to learn something new, which maybe I can do still with agentic
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt Godboltcode. Maybe. But also the ability to mentor and shape and help others become better. So like it's a two-way thing. I learn something, they learn something. And especially, you know...
Ben RadyYeah. Yeah.
Matt GodboltAnd that just doesn't happen. That side of it doesn't happen. No matter how many times I implore an agent to stop writing ludicrous comments that explain the things that I told it not to do rather than the thing that it is actually doing.
Ben RadyYes, right. Uh huh.
Matt GodboltIt's not going to learn that. And that is unsatisfying from a human point of view.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltAnd I know that's nothing to do with flow necessarily, but it's like if we're looking for what makes
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltour job, rather than programming per se,
Ben RadyRight.
Matt Godboltrewarding and fun. Then... I don't mind a good back and forth with a human, knowing that we can go for a drink afterwards and kind of have a chat about that silly thing that we discovered in the blah blah blah blah. That's cool.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltBut I won't have that with my army of agents. That's not the same experience. And so if I'm trying to rationalize my new role as a middle manager of a bunch of robots, then maybe I don't get even the benefit of that out of it.
Ben RadyRight. Yeah.
Matt GodboltSo.
Ben RadyYeah, well, and that is another dimension. Like of all the things that makes programming fun, what are some things? Well, flow is one thing. The ability to mentor and teach through sort of like the craft of software development is another one. You know, I think there's definitely something, I don't exactly know how to describe this, but there's definitely something about like just tickling that part of your brain when you understand a complex thing. And you still get some of that, but you don't get it at the same level that you got it before. Right.
Ben RadyLike... You've always had to understand the architecture.
Matt GodboltThere is... You know,
Ben RadyBut you also had to understand the code underneath that architecture. And quite often if you had to choose between the two, you kind of started from the bottom and worked your way up, because that's... kind of like the only way to really get it. And now it seems like, yeah, you don't really. In many cases, not all cases, but in many cases you can be very ignorant of how the code actually works and still produce working software. Right?
Matt GodboltYeah. Right.
Ben RadyWhich is weird.
Matt GodboltAnd I think that's... It is weird and... One of the things that... I received feedback recently about the fact that there were some parts of the code that I clearly didn't know as well as I perhaps should have done. And it was because while I'd reviewed it, I had... It was not the same, you know? Like, yeah, people
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltjoke about, you know, writing stuff down. You know, I've got... pads of paper around me right now. I write post-it notes and stick them to the screen, even though I have a Jira system to do ticketing in, which is far more convenient because it follows me around, unlike the piece of paper that's stuck to my computer back in the office, right?
Ben RadyRight. Yeah.
Matt GodboltBut there's something visceral about having done it yourself, even if it's as mechanical as writing it down.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltBut there's also, if you typed it yourself, I'm sure that's another layer of it. And even moreover, if you thought about it yourself, you thought about it in a different way, you experienced it, you went through it, you are more...
Ben RadyYep. Right.
Matt Godboltsimpatico with it. And then... We've said this before. It's like managing, right? Like when I've managed a small team before now, I know what my individual reports are doing. I've reviewed their code. But if I go into a meeting with a bunch of other middle manager people and we talk about the project, they go, well, how exactly does X work? I'll be like, we're going to have to go and ask.
Ben RadyYeah, the people who actually know.
Matt GodboltOf, you know.
Ben RadyYeah, right.
Matt GodboltYeah, I don't know it well enough to teach it. And yet I don't, I can't go and ask, at least the exact agent, the one I worked with. And obviously, I can go and ask an agent.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltIt's unsatisfying and I feel fraudulent, honestly.
Ben RadyYeah. Yeah, yeah yeah.
Matt GodboltIf that's the right... phrase. Now I've just, and this is becoming new, new experience coming to me as I'm talking to you. I think... I'm worried that... if I... don't use the agents, I won't be as productive as I could be, and I will be measured, but by myself mainly, no one's asking me to be, but as being not as good as I could be. And certainly you and I have in our wider friend group some amazing engineers who are doing some incredible things with AI technology writ large, right?
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt GodboltBut... I feel fraudulent for like passing off someone else's work as mine, even though I have spent ages... reading it, crafting it,
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltand explaining back and forth and ideating and going, that's rubbish. No, we're going to have to try again. I still feel like it's not mine. And then when I do represent it, even though I could, I feel confident in what I've done. And I don't know how to square that circle because maybe I... Maybe it is enjoyable. Sometimes it is enjoyable to be doing a little bit of that iterating. Yeah, but has the fun come out of it? Because it's not mine.
Ben RadyYeah, I mean, so there is... there's a powerful... element there. You know, and I could, I think.
Matt GodboltA powerful elephant?
Ben RadyA powerful elephant, right?
Matt GodboltWow.
Ben RadyThere's an elephant in the room and we're all trying to feel the different parts of the elephant.
Matt GodboltI've... and I've definitely...
Ben RadyAnd it feels very powerful.
Matt GodboltI've definitely got, like, there's the elephant with an extra I in it, E-L-E-P-H-A-I-N-T, right, for the AI in the room. I think there's something in there. I've got a slide somewhere that's... anyway, never mind. Carry on.
Ben RadyUh huh, right. Yes. There's a... I forget where this came from, but there was a poster or something that's been popping back in my mind of the Octophant, which is an elephant on top and an octopus on bottom. And it's carrying a little flag that says, I should not be.
Matt GodboltWhoa. Whoa.
Ben RadyI forget where that's from.
Matt GodboltWell, I...
Ben RadyWhere is the Octophant from?
Matt GodboltThere was a little post-it note on someone's desk when I went to Google, and it was just a little... caricature of an elephant, and underneath it it said, anything that's not about elephants is irrelevant. It just tickled me.
Ben RadyYeah. I like that.
Matt GodboltAnd I still think about it. Anyway, the elephant in the room.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltWhere were we with this?
Ben RadyNo, the thing that I have to wonder is...
Matt GodboltThere was some point we were having.
Ben RadyI've gone back and forth on this over the last few decades of my career of... There are lots of people that I have worked with that are very good at their jobs that do not code in their free time. It is strictly a profession for them, right? Like they use it to, you know, pay their rent, and it's like, they go home and they do other things.
Matt GodboltRight. Hmm?
Ben RadyBut I have worked with a lot of people who are very good. And also... you would have to pay them not to code.
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben RadyRight? Like, they just do it all the time. I think, right, a good chunk of the open source software that modern society rests on comes from these types of people, where they're just like, I am interested in solving problems and I will do it for free.
Matt GodboltIt's...
Ben RadyAnd it's kind of cool that I get paid for it, but I will do it for free because I find it to be so much fun.
Matt GodboltRight. This, like, these... It just comes from them.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltIt's like artists that have to express themselves through art.
Ben RadyYes.
Matt GodboltIt's like I have to express myself through code. That's kind of, I mean... Yeah, I feel that way, but the people you're talking about
Ben RadyExactly.
Matt Godboltseem to act that way too. And then, yeah, society sort of takes advantage of their better nature
Ben RadyRight, 100%.
Matt Godboltby saying, thank you so much for your compression library.
Ben RadyLike... What are all these LLMs trained on? It's trained on all of that, you know, despite what people may claim.
Matt GodboltOh, God, yeah.
Ben RadyI mean, it pretty obviously is.
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben RadyAnd so I think a strong argument can be made that this phenomena that we're experiencing here is essentially the... the death of open source in the way that it has been, because it does two things. One is it removes the fun element of creating these things. And two, it makes the actual efficient way to create solutions like this very expensive in the form of tokens, which it wasn't before.
Matt GodboltMm hmm. Ah.
Ben RadyAnother thing we were talking about in the pub last night is... Our profession has had this amazing, wonderful property. And I think we maybe have talked about this on a separate episode, of you can just kind of get like a laptop. And that's it. And now you've paid this one fixed cost and yeah, you get some open source tools and you can build a lot of things with just that.
Matt GodboltI mean... Heck, you can get a $20... or $40, like, Raspberry Pi, plug a monitor into it, and you've got a good enough development kit to be able to get on with... Yeah, it's... yeah, yeah. Yeah.
Ben RadyRight. Right.
Matt GodboltYeah, the barrier to entry is... is fairly low.
Ben RadyYeah. Yeah, compared to a lot of other...
Matt GodboltThere are even, apparently, websites you can use that do this. You know, as long as you've got internet access, you don't even need a computer as such.
Ben RadyAll right.
Matt GodboltYou know, you can do it, albeit badly, on your phone.
Ben RadyExactly.
Matt GodboltI'm sorry, everybody who tries to use my site on the phone. Anyway, but yeah, so the barrier to entry has been...
Ben RadyYes.
Matt Godboltvery low for a long time.
Ben RadyQuite low. And I...
Matt GodboltIn fact, lower than perhaps it was when we were growing up, right?
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltWhen I was...
Ben RadyI think so.
Matt GodboltWhen I was, you know, single digit years old and I got a computer, I was incredibly fortunate
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltthat I was in a position where my parents could afford, and did, and that's, you know, so life... life-changingly, path-settingly, but you know, that was a privilege. And... Yeah. Anyway.
Ben RadyYeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And now I have to wonder if all of the forces that created the open source ecosystem that everything now rests on are being removed, because you no longer have the sort of fun element that people get when they're like, oh, I'm going to go solve this problem and I'm going to build this open source library and it's going to be really fun. I'm going to enjoy it. And oh, I guess maybe someone else will use it. I don't even care if anyone else uses it. I want to build this for me.
Matt GodboltYeah. Yeah.
Ben RadyCombined with, well, the actual way that people build software in the modern world is you use an LLM and that costs a bunch of money and, you know, there's all these dependencies.
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben RadyI think we talked about that in the last episode. And so...
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben RadyI think there's a lot of kind of elements of funness that could be getting removed through efficiency. Right? And...
Matt GodboltYeah. Well, let me tell you what, let's, one sort of counter to that, if I may.
Ben RadyOkay, yeah.
Matt GodboltAnd that is... lumber mills or CNC machines or whatever you... Insert your big technology that came and changed the whole industry around type thing. 3D printers. There's another example of like, here is a transformative thing that means that nobody needs to do like whittling things down.
Ben RadyHmm?
Matt GodboltThey don't, you know, you don't have to machine it from like parts and send it off to whatever. Those have come. But if you enjoy that kind of stuff, I mean, I sit and watch loads of YouTube videos on people who sit and machine these beautiful little parts because they enjoy the making of it. You know, there are people who make watches from scratch out of little tiny pieces, and how do you do this? It's like, you could just go into a shop and buy something that's been hand, you know, not handmade, machine made, for like
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt Godboltnothing.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltBut you enjoy the process. And so you choose to do it that way. And I respect that. There are people who crochet stuff.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltI mean, there are people who knit stuff, even though knitting machines are a thing.
Ben RadyYes.
Matt GodboltAnd, you know, and it's almost ridiculous.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltYou're paying for the privilege of spending hours and hours to make a garment that you could wear yourself.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltRight.
Ben RadyYes.
Matt GodboltPeople do this because they love it, right? And I think...
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltThis is something else we touched on, I think, last night when we talked about like how maybe specifically for programmers, this is different from other uses of this kind of technology. In as much as like we still have a job out of this, right? We're still able to at least, you know, again, in our privileged position. Whereas... you know, and I don't know, hobby knitters will never become... I don't know. Maybe I don't know where I'm going with this, but there feels like there's a difference between folks who have done all right out of the technology and folks who... now have been having their jobs totally taken away.
Matt GodboltAnd maybe I'm naive and ours will go and that will be the end of it. I'm not sure.
Ben RadyWell, yeah, my concern is that handcrafted code, which I almost am reluctant to use that phrase, but I don't know a better way to describe it, is going to become a hobby. That's not something that anyone would ever do professionally, except in very rare circumstances. That's my worry. Because that's been my experience for like the last
Matt GodboltRight.
Ben Radyyear, nine months, where, you know, 90 to 95% of the code that is being created, both by me and the programmers around me, is being created by agents and not in this sort of handcrafted hobbyist way. Right. Whereas before there was no real distinction between the hobby and the profession.
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben RadyRight. Like you loved building software. You did that by writing code. That's exactly what you would do in your day job. It's the same thing.
Matt GodboltRight. If you, yeah, if you were a master craftsman and you spent all day building chairs with beautiful dovetail joints and whatever, and you still loved it, you went home, you'd do the same thing at home. But now you work in the IKEA factory and you're feeding the machines that build the flat pack, and then you go home and then you do something completely different that sort of only overlaps in the Venn diagram by 10% of what you do.
Ben RadyRight. Right. Right, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Right. Right. Maybe you could break even on your costs by selling your chairs at the local...
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben Radyart fair. But it's not a profession, not really.
Matt GodboltYeah. And maybe, I mean, maybe there will be a market. I mean, I've seen a bit of, you know, there's obviously backlashes against AI usage in many, many places.
Ben RadyMm-hmm.
Matt GodboltAnd there may be some, you know, certified 100% organic free range code, right?
Ben RadyRight? Yes.
Matt GodboltThat's been written by real...
Ben RadyArtisanally crafted from the finest ones and zeros, you know?
Matt GodboltAbsolutely. Yeah, exactly.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltYeah. Not these... Yeah, maybe there will be a market for that. But yeah, unlike many other things, I think, because the output is... Well, I guess that's a debate is whether the output is better or not. You know, this is...
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltWho knows? I mean, we're in a period of discovery, but, you know, we're also in a period of where it changes week on week on week. So...
Ben RadyYeah. Well, you know, the interesting thing is a little sidebar, but it's like you talked about knitting, and then like one of the ways that you can spot a hand knitted sweater is there are tiny imperfections, and there's this sort of weird,
Matt GodboltSo, you know, I mean, like... Yeah.
Ben RadyI don't know, almost uncanny valley type thing where it's like, as a, like, you don't want it to be absolutely perfect. You never would be really able to make it absolutely perfect like a machine would, but you want to like limit the imperfections, but you still want the little thing of like, you knit that yourself, didn't you? It's like, yeah, I did. It's like, oh, that looks really good, you know?
Matt GodboltI'm... Yeah, two sort of observations. I was like watching my son reply to an email about college admission-y type stuff. And like he made a typo and he said, oh, I'm going to leave that in because then they know it's not AI. And I'm like, oh, my God. I mean, you're not wrong.
Ben RadyYou're not wrong. Yeah.
Matt GodboltHonestly.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltAnd then, so secondly, you know, like when they built, these master craftsmen of old would build these great temples to their gods, they would always make one deliberate mistake somewhere so they could show that they... they weren't perfect, unlike the god they would want to, like, be. And I'm like that... But the fact that you chose to not be perfect when you could have been kind of undermines the whole thing.
Ben RadyOh yeah. Yes. Yes.
Matt GodboltBut that's a whole other debate.
Ben RadyWell, you know, that was the backwards justification for why they made the mistake, right? Like, that's... They didn't do that on purpose.
Matt GodboltYeah. Right.
Ben RadyThey're like, oh, well, no, of course, we put that in there. because
Matt GodboltCrap, we've put the bottom... block of the pyramids is upside down.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltWe meant to do it.
Ben RadyYes, exactly right. Exactly right.
Matt GodboltOtherwise, you know, the god would be annoyed at us having done it perfectly. Right. Okay, invoice is in the post.
Ben RadyYeah. Right. Right. Well, okay, so... This, you know, the first part of this episode is a little bit of a downer in the sense of like, oh, I don't have fun at my job anymore. But there are actually some really good things about this stuff. And the part of the struggle for me, and part of the reason why I think this is an interesting question, is because being able to use these tools does... unlock a lot of really cool things. And I don't want to give those things up either, because the ability to like speak words into my phone and have working software come out the other side is kind of amazing. And I don't want to give that up.
Matt GodboltRight.
Ben RadyIt's... it's, you know, the problem is it doesn't take very long, right? If I could spend my whole day doing that, maybe I wouldn't hate it quite so much. But it's, this, a lot more of like, as you say, you wind up... If you want to actually do this all day long, it's a lot of context switching. It's a lot of like spinning multiple plates at the same time.
Matt GodboltIt's...
Ben RadyIt's not focusing on a single problem and seeing it from beginning to end, which is what I want.
Matt Godboltexhausting. It's exhausting in a different way that focused time
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltis, for two reasons. I think one is the massive amount of context switching that you're doing in order to sort of feel like, while you're waiting for one thing to reply and it's off grepping the code base looking for whatever, you get another one up and you make a new work tree and you're doing something different or whatever.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltThe... But that also, the way that you're programming is by... engaging the social part of your brain, which, you know, for many of us
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltin this profession is... not as developed
Ben RadyTaxing. Yeah, it's taxing.
Matt Godboltas maybe other people, or at least takes up energy that we keep in reserve for actual human
Ben RadyYeah. Right.
Matt Godboltcon... And, you know, there are outliers amongst us. But...
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltFor the majority of people, I can't help but think that like, if you've been arguing for 25 minutes with an AI on and off, that has drained a battery that doesn't replenish quite as quickly as the, I sat down and solved the logic puzzle for 25 minutes.
Ben RadyRight. Right, right. Yeah. The whole, like, you know, I have no basis in sort of like psychology or anything to say whether the whole, like, introvert extrovert model of like, you know, introverts, you know, spend their energy on social interactions and extroverts recharge their body on, or their battery on, social interactions. I have no idea if that's like a real thing. But definitely seems appropriate for me and a lot of the other people that I know.
Matt GodboltI...
Ben RadyWhere it's like, it's not that I don't enjoy social interaction. It's just that it's taxing. Right.
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben RadyAnd I can only do it for so long before I just need to go sit and like, you know, again, listen to Daft Punk, write some code, or play Factorio, as I've been doing a lot more recently, right? So.
Matt GodboltOh, you're that Tron soundtrack. Oh, you see, I mean, that's a great one too, but like the Nine Inch Nails one is
Ben RadyYes.
Matt Godboltpretty darn awesome as well.
Ben RadyYou know, I think I've only listened to that like a couple of times, like the new Tron movie.
Matt GodboltOh, shame. I haven't actually watched the movie.
Ben RadyYes.
Matt GodboltPeople have told me it's...
Ben RadyI am.
Matt Godboltnot great, but I would watch it just to listen to the soundtrack. There's a number of... The number of movies that I've got like that in my head, I'm like, yeah, the soundtrack is what makes this movie great.
Ben RadyNot great. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Matt GodboltAll right.
Ben RadyBut yeah, there are a lot of things that make... using these tools to build things fun. But I think a lot of it just comes from the building, right? It's like, in the same way that like, you know, putting together a little Arduino circuit is fun, or like cooking even is fun. It's like, you know, I get to make something that people enjoy and I enjoy, and it's cool and I like that. Right?
Matt GodboltSo... Let me take that, because that was definitely something that I was... going to... bring up is that, you know, and we've mentioned this before, there are people who like the craft of building something and they enjoy the edifice that they've made, not the outcome. And there are people who just want the outcome and they're excited about that. I think everyone's a... there's a mixed, you have a mixture of that. And I think probably where it's for me is like, I've got a thing.
Ben RadyRight. Yeah. Yeah.
Matt GodboltI can make a thing. I can almost call a thing into being now by just naming it, almost, which is like an amazing
Ben RadyOkay.
Matt Godboltmagician ability that we've all gained, or for those who can afford the tokens can gain. And that's great. But then I didn't make the thing.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltAnd so anything that I still, this comes back to this fraudulent feeling, is that
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltI don't feel like that is worth as much, right?
Ben RadyYeah, yeah.
Matt GodboltAnd I mean, if it ticks boxes for me, like if it's, I think we talked about this before, if it's a scraper of YouTube that goes and finds unanswered comments on other people's videos that include me, I don't feel like I need to ever look at that code. I want the outcome, and that's really what I'm measuring myself by, is can I get a list of those, can I look them up, can I do what I need to do with them. That's one thing.
Ben RadyRight. Right.
Matt GodboltBut if it's like... a fun hobby project like thing where it's like, hey, wouldn't it be cool if X. I get X. And I only get like 70% of the satisfaction of X because I have X now. But I don't feel like I made it. And some people maybe don't care about that. I mean, one of our good friends I alluded to earlier, I'm sure, is just like, I have my X, I'm happy. Hooray. And dances off and makes it, uses it to make more, and it compounds, and it's brilliant. But I think, like, I go, oh, that's... it would have been... oh, maybe I should have done that. You know, I told you, like, I had this like silly idea of making a spoof game for somebody, and I gave it
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godbolta one paragraph description to a Claude and set it off with an emulator and an old computer system. And I said, just make it. It's almost like just a stupid pun on somebody's name and something in the news. And it did it. And I was like, this is so cool. And then I played it for 10 minutes. I don't know that it's cool anymore. I don't know. I don't feel good about this now.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltI don't like it, you know. It's... Yeah.
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltIt's proved its point, I suppose. It's really, I mean, it's an incredible achievement that that has been able to happen. I just leave something going and I come back to it. But, you know. And it's a similar thing with, you know, like say...
Ben RadyRight.
Matt Godboltthe artwork. You think of a funny joke and you're like, well, I can't draw, but I can ask the AI to make an X and a Y with a hat on like a Z, and it looks like, and you send it, and you're like, I still feel hollow that, you know... It would have been nicer if I had got that.
Ben RadyYeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Matt GodboltBut on the other hand, would I have paid someone to make that? Would I have drawn it myself? It would have the pun... I don't know. I don't know.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltI'm so conflicted, Ben.
Ben RadyYeah. Well, I think there's a lot of us out there.
Matt GodboltYou know, well, what value comes out of it, you know? And so, you know, I think I said last night, right? There's a... conference talk I'm preparing for in October, and I need some code for it. And I already have a project and I'm working on it, and I did a lot of work on it, and I then sort of asked for some fill in the gap stuff with the AI. And it really has been a two-way thing, with me setting it off and then coming back and look at it and everything. But on the plane, it was a beautiful experience flying back from New York where I had no internet connection because the stupid
Matt Godboltplane thing didn't work. But first of all, isn't it bonkers that I'm actually relying 100% on the fact that I can get decent internet access, better than I had as even like a 20 year old,
Ben RadyRight. Yeah yeah yeah.
Matt Godbolton a plane, flying through the air.
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltBut it wasn't there. So I just opened up my laptop and I was looking at the code like a caveman in an IDE with no, nothing to help me. And I had a great old time just reading through it. And... I learned a lot about what I built. And, you know, it was familiar. It wasn't surprising to me, but it was great. And I was putting comments about where things were I wanted to change or whatever. And I'll look forward to like making good on this. But that was a moment of like, oh gosh, maybe I should do this more often. And... I don't know if I have the self-control to do that unless I literally have no internet access.
Ben RadyYeah. One of my concerns with all of this, and this has been true with every technological innovation ever, is that you have to accept the fact that like certain practices, and so the skills associated with those practices, are going to atrophy. Right? Like, the things that we did to accomplish goals that were effective, that were... you know, well-worn. This is a, you know, Repair Shop. We've talked about Repair Shop a million times. The whole...
Matt GodboltYep. Okay, if we haven't, then yeah, everyone should go and watch Repair Shop. It's great.
Ben RadyRight. Can you give like a brief summary of Repair Shop for the folks? I feel like you're the most qualified of the two of us to explain Repair Shop.
Matt GodboltIt is Antiques Roadshow meets Makers kind of paradise. Somebody brings in some heirloom that's broken of theirs into a hut, everyone like looks at it, and they tell the sob story about why it was so important to them, why it's so special. And then one of them, an army of experts come along, and they will then spend, you know, 20 minutes of TV carefully crafting and fixing up the thing, followed by inviting the person back and the reveal of this beautifully restored, by craftspeople, item. And so, you know, you've got all of the heartwarming part of it, you've got the maker type stuff and the intricate, like, you know, there's the clock maker person who comes in and, like, you know, you see him filing down and building new things with his tiny tiny little lathe, and you see, you know, the saddler making some leather straps for this beautiful thing. And then you get it back to the person who then inevitably will cry, which, you know... And so it's got something for everybody. It's got something for me, it's got something for my wife. It's, you know, it's brilliant. I love it.
Ben RadyMm-hmm. Yes. Yes. It's a fantastic show. If you like making things and you're like doom scrolling and you're like, I need to feel good about the world, you should go find a Repair Shop and watch it, because it will make you feel good.
Matt GodboltYes. Yes, I think it's on YouTube.
Ben RadyYeah, it is. I think I have a YouTube channel.
Matt GodboltThere are other places to find it, I know, but there are...
Ben RadyYes. But yeah, one of the points they make on that show is that they make a point of using sort of traditional techniques for restoring these things. Right? Like, we're going to go fix this clock the way that a clockmaker would have done it in the 19th century.
Matt GodboltRight. There's no 3D printing or, you know, we're sending off to PCBWay to get this part sorted.
Ben RadyRight. Yes. Yep. Right. Right, right. I'm going to get out a file and I'm going to start filing these, you know,
Matt GodboltAnd that's a file, not like a computer file.
Ben Radythings.
Matt GodboltThat is like a rasp.
Ben RadyRight. Yes. Yeah, right. Exactly, a metal file. And I wonder if there's some, you know, future like This Old Codebase, a show on PBS where it's like,
Matt GodboltMaybe.
Ben Radyyou know, we go in and we hand edit this code. One of the things that I said in the presentation that I did, like I was talking about, is that I think at this point I can make the claim, and others have made this claim too, and I don't think I'm alone here, I can make the claim that TDD is for humans, not robots. I have tried many, many times to build software using test-driven development with agents, and you can make them do it. I don't think it makes the code any better. I don't think it... Because the, why do we even do TDD? What was the point of TDD? Well, like, it was lots of things, but one of the...
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben Radygoals was to make sure that you didn't wind up with untestable software. Right? Like, because the problem with automated testing, oftentimes people are like, well, it's really hard to write the tests because...
Matt GodboltRight.
Ben RadyIt just doesn't work. And it's like, yeah, because you didn't design it.
Matt GodboltEverything's just a big old, yeah.
Ben RadyYou didn't design it to be tested, right? So the cure for that is, well, write the test first, and then you can't help but design it to be tested, because that's the only... I think that's the first and most important constraint is, can I exercise this through my test?
Matt GodboltRight.
Ben RadyI don't think that TDD... TDD is a human process. It's not an agentic process. And so it's... the kind of thing where it's like, 20 years from now, how many people are going to be able to like test drive out a code base? I don't know, not very many. Maybe they'll have a show on, you know, BBC One where they're like, all right, I'm gonna
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben Radycrack open my old editor here and we're going to go write some tests for this code base, and...
Matt GodboltI mean... You're joking about this, but you do... I mean, like, you can see... Well, you can't see, actually. The camera's not pointed down here. But, like, I am surrounded by computers from the 1980s and 1990s that many people enjoy for exactly the reason that you're describing. It's like, partly it's nostalgia, partly it's keeping something alive and understanding what's going on, but partly it's just,
Ben RadyRight.
Matt GodboltI can explain everything that's going on in here. And I kind of like that.
Ben RadyYeah. Yeah.
Matt GodboltYeah, we were talking again, we're talking about this down the pub, you know, like the age of complexity where no one human can fit things in their head has kind of gone past. It's only going to get worse if we've got like agentically diverse things where I can set one... Yeah. But it's a happy place to be when I can edit some code and I can count cycles and I know exactly what colors are going to appear on the screen. I know exactly how that's going to...
Ben RadyRight. All right.
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben RadyRight. Yeah, no, I'm not saying they're going to go away. I'm saying they're going to be relegated to the world of hobbyists
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben Radyand historians and preservationists and people who want to...
Matt GodboltAnd. But a career, maybe... not so much, or...
Ben RadyYeah, I don't think that...
Matt GodboltBut...
Ben Radyyou know, TDD, for example, is going to be an essential part of your career in 10 years.
Matt GodboltRight. No, maybe not.
Ben RadyOr maybe even now.
Matt GodboltNo.
Ben RadyI'm not really sure.
Matt GodboltI'm not sure. Again, I mean, again, the cost of these things, if the real cost comes out, maybe there'll be some resurgence and this pendulum will swing back a little bit.
Ben RadyRight. Yeah, like that could happen.
Matt GodboltI don't know. I mean... Yeah, well... Given that we've explored so much space in quite a lot of time, surprisingly, I think we probably need to come back to the original question and just finish it off
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltwith us thinking about what it means now. So, again, the question was... Is programming fun?
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltAnd maybe... I can tell you with truth, if I restrict myself to actually being me doing it, and I give myself a hobby framework, yes, I love it still. I still really enjoy it. If I use an agent, do I enjoy it? Yeah. But... But this is slightly tainted with a, I didn't really make it myself. And it's of a different
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt Godboltlevel and quality from, say, the difference of like 18-year-old me poo-pooing C compilers because, you know, you should be writing it in assembly. Now you're just letting the computer write the assembly for you kind of thing. And I know people have made those analogies and whatever, but like I feel like this is both quantitatively and qualitatively different than that. Sorry. I feel fortunate, but...
Ben RadyYeah.
Matt GodboltYeah, so what is your... answer? What do you feel after this conversation?
Ben RadyI feel like if we want to answer this question in a professional sense, right? And I've made the claim on this show many times that it's like, I love my job. And I enjoy it and I want to do it for as long as I possibly can. So in a professional sense, is programming fun? I think I have to say not as fun as it used to be.
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben RadyAnd... I think that this phenomenon has sort of bled into my hobbyist programming, where I... The actual amount of time that I spend on hobby projects is way shorter than it used to be. Because I'm able to be so much more effective in such a short period of time. So it's like, if you're looking for a pastime, if you're looking for something to pass the time, it's not as good at that.
Ben RadyBecause... I only have so many ideas for kind of like
Matt GodboltYeah.
Ben Radyactually interesting hobby side projects. And they don't take nearly as long.
Matt GodboltBefore you have to go back to Factorio.
Ben RadyRight. And the set of them that are interesting, I think, also got smaller
Matt GodboltRight.
Ben Radyas a result. Because... there's more constraints around what's going to make it fun for me. So I think I have to say that it is less fun than it used to be, in pretty much every dimension, which is not to say that it's not fun,
Matt GodboltBut it is...
Ben Radybut it is less fun.
Matt GodboltFewer.
Ben RadyFewer fun.
Matt GodboltFewer funs.
Ben RadyMm hmm.
Matt GodboltOkay, well, that's awful. Grammar-incorrect pun joke, whatever.
Ben RadyYeah. Yeah.
Matt GodboltI think we have to leave it there for now, and I will see you next time.
Ben RadyNext time.
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
Ben brings a 1976 letter from Bill Gates, and Matt brings the after-effects of last night's pub. The hat gets out of the rabbit, a squirrel is briefly involved, and nobody downloads a computer.
Ben gives his house to an AI named after GLaDOS, and Matt makes the compiler build a Z80. A dying USB dock threatens to end it all.
Ben's friend is locked out of their AWS account and Matt's AI has decided he's a hacker. The escape route runs through a cheap computer, a mesh network, and Neal Stephenson.
Matt records from the wrong continent and explains how he taught his computer to be a 1950s television. Ben guesses his way to the secret of the colo(u?)r burst and wins today's podcast.
Ben sets out to learn Rust by only reading it, while Matt wonders if you can learn to land a plane from a book. Also: is snark a portmanteau?