Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Two Pour Spirits

Two Pour Spirits artwork

How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Stop Trying to Be Alone

Jun 26, 202656 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Being alone will give you vertigo. You'll get lost in your own head and your eyes will cease to cooperate with reality's demand. You'll probably start to enjoy blurriness. Like espousing the belief that living alone is the same thing as loneliness. Or "love" is just another word for "obsession." Wake up! We were not made for individualism and the infatuation it begets. In this tenth episode of season four, on common grace in culture, Chris and Kyle discuss Alfred Hitchcock’s film, Vertigo, and how it applies to hopeful neighboring. Believe in reality. Don't be gullible. Remember that the new heavens and the new earth will have to be populated, so don't idolize chastity or celibacy. Also - don't wander for too long. You have a home, and there are neighbors there. + + Welcome to another episode of Two Pour Spirits! Where signature cocktails meet spirited conversations for the sake of the Church and the common good. + + Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor ecumenically educates, equips, and empowers the Church to image her Creator and love all creatures, including her enemies, in public places with particular practices. From soil to sky, crib to casket. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Rev. Dr. Kyle David Bennett and Dr. Christopher Cimorelli. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the church and for the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the Catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically oriented, and practically minded.

SPEAKER_01We hope that you enjoy the conversation and camaraderie of two poor spirits, and make no apologies for the background noises that mark our fellowship, the clinking of ice and sloshing of liquid among them. Let's build up together. Visit projectneighor.org to learn more.

SPEAKER_03In this tenth episode of season four of Two Poor Spirits on Common Grace and Culture, Chris and I will be talking about Alfred Hitchcock's film Vertigo, a bizarre tale about deception, romance, nuns, visits to graveyards, elongated trips to the museum, and taking over the family business. Chris, it's cast day, which means we have something cast strength or more, and these here glasses.

SPEAKER_03Before we take a trip down voodoo lane in our analysis of this film, alleviate the crippling curiosity of our listeners by making them privy to this syrup that we're slurping.

SPEAKER_01Kyle, my brother, always a privilege and a pleasure to be casting. I can't believe that we are in the tenth episode.

SPEAKER_05I know it seems like yesterday.

SPEAKER_01That's pretty incredible. And uh so today we are going with a drink that we sometimes call the huge.

SPEAKER_03The yuge.

SPEAKER_01So maybe the OG. We should call it the OG. Maybe we should just kind of call this one the common life. You know, it's that powerful. So this is an original recipe for us. Uh it starts off with a large tumbler and we have a large cube in there, a few dashes of, in this case, two different kinds of bitters. We've got Agnostora Coco bitters and El Wapo Barrelates vanilla bitters. And then the base is two ounces of a strong bourbon.

SPEAKER_01We have Maker's Mark Cask Strength. Uh, one ounce of the Day of the Lord spiced cointreau that we make, our own recipe. And then an ounce of spiced cranberry juice that is also kind of a homemade recipe. More of like a holiday cranberry drink.

SPEAKER_03So would would you disclose that that recipe to our listeners for like, say, I don't know, a$500 donation or something?

SPEAKER_01That's right. Just please reach out to us if you want to support Project Neighbor. Uh, but actually, I would almost guess that the recipe varies each time I do it. But generally speaking, you take a 64-ounce regular bottle of cranberry juice, and you kind of start heating that up. I express a part of an orange peel into there and then throw the peel in, and then a variety of spices go into it. Um, cracked cinnamon stick, cardamom, nutmeg, um angel toenails.

SPEAKER_03Just all the heavenly beings.

SPEAKER_01I usually put some full, you know, cloves into the um orange peel before I throw it in there. Yeah. And so, yeah, ginger. So it's like you you put a bunch of spices in there that remind you of the holidays, and you kind of cook that on a low simmer for about 45 minutes to an hour, let it cool and bottle it up.

SPEAKER_03So, really quickly, like what what has been the I don't think I've ever asked you this, like what has been the development of the recipe over time? Like, I mean, you've perfected it, but when you started out, you didn't start out with the measurements that you're working with now, right?

SPEAKER_01It's definitely changed, but I guess I'm becoming more like my grandmother, which is when you just you know it's not exact anymore. It's it's now to the point where I, you know, I found a recipe in the beginning for like a holiday cranberry, like a spiced cranberry juice. You can find that online. Anyone can find it. And then I think from there it's just a matter of preference. And for me, now it's the point where I'll put in the spices and then I I like lean down and I sniff the as it's cooking, and I'm like, does it smell right?

SPEAKER_01That's great.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01A little bit more ginger, a little bit more cardamom, that kind of thing.

SPEAKER_03That's great.

SPEAKER_01Um, and then it cooks down and you let it cool and you bottle it, and it's great. So I recommend people that they try it because it actually is really good for mocktails, too. It's it's good in a lot of different things. Yeah. Well, thanks, brother. You got it.

SPEAKER_03All right, in this episode, we're gonna be talking about Alfred Hitchcock's film Vertigo, which has been highly acclaimed, and I never knew this, uh, and has been nominated set on several occasions for best film ever. And we were noting earlier, Chris, you know, some of his. I mean, I enjoyed this one, and we'll get to the um, I'll ask you for a synopsis here in a second, but there's I I really thought that I Confess, his film I Confess, was was like the best one that we've analyzed and viewed, but they're all very, very interesting.

SPEAKER_03And this one notwithstanding. Uh, before we jump into the uh, you know, the common grace and the cinematics and uh relationships and communion and thinking theologically about it, why don't you give our listeners just a brief synopsis of Alfred Hitchcock's Vertigo?

SPEAKER_01All right, yeah. So I don't think it's gonna take too long to give an overview of what the plot is in this movie.

SPEAKER_03Just don't spoil it.

SPEAKER_01There's there are gonna be spoilers.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, there's no way give that warning right now.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you are interested in watching this movie for the first time, maybe you know, earplugs and go watch it and then come back. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And then donate$500 for the recipe. Right. So sorry.

SPEAKER_01So uh just like Rear Window, James Stewart is in this movie. He's starring as um detective and retired detective Scotty Ferguson. You've got Kim Novak um starring as Madeline Elster, and also maybe another character, which is part of the spoiler. Um, and then you have, I'm not sure if I got this one right, Barbara Belgeddis as Midge Wood. So those are the three characters that I feel it's important to mention. But Scottie Ferguson is in the beginning a detective who's, you know, chasing a culprit on the rooftops in San Fran, I believe.

SPEAKER_01That's right. And there's kind of a tragic circumstance in which he's chasing the suspect with another cop. He ends up in a bad situation where he's hanging off of a roof, the other cop tries to help him and plummets to his death. In the wake of this tragedy, um, he develops acrophobia or a fear of heights, hence Vertigo, feeling that dizziness and being paralyzed when he's in a situation with heights. And so, in the wake of all that, he decides, like, I'm gonna retire.

SPEAKER_01Right? And he's he's sharing some of this in the with his best friend, who we find out was uh also a romantic partner before that named Midge. But it's in this situation where he's kind of trying to figure out his life that an old friend of his contacts him with a very particular situation that he's worried about the mental health and well-being of his wife, who's who he says or claims is having some sort of possession, where there's this ghost or a spirit that seems to be taking her over, and she disappears while she's present and then ends up acting strangely.

SPEAKER_01And he says, Well, you're a detective, you need something to do. Why don't you help me out? And at least just kind of watch her, see what's going on, see what you can find out. So he agrees to help his friend.

SPEAKER_05Reluctantly.

SPEAKER_01Reluctantly, certainly reluctantly, but he does so, but then as he's following this much younger woman in her, I think in her mid to late 20s, he starts to get more and more engrossed with her and more attached to her, and starts to develop an affection for her. And there's such a mystery about what's going on with her because she does seem to be disappearing at times and lost in the life of a past person uh with whom she or she might have a relationship or at least be a descendant of someone who uh she seems to know quite a bit about.

SPEAKER_01So as he gets more and more engrossed in the the work that he's doing and in the woman that he's covering and and following, yeah, the the audience is kind of feeling a bit disturbed by the way he's developing an attachment. And this is where real spoilers come in. It turns out that after saving her life once, he's unable to do so a second time. And eventually he's cleared of any wrongdoing from from this woman who basically climbed to a height a height and jumped out of the building.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01But he couldn't he couldn't help her because of his condition.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And then he's left traumatized. But then the plot thickens once again because he thinks he sees someone who looks exactly like her. So do I keep going with this or do I stop there?

SPEAKER_03Oh, I mean, any I mean, you want to tie the bow and so okay.

SPEAKER_01At the end of the day, he sees a woman that looks exactly like her, very similar to her, but you know, different color hair and and this kind of thing. And he he approaches her very kind of yeah, forcefully, or I don't know, forthrightly. Awkwardly, aggressively in a way that nobody should emulate. And uh he develops a relationship with her, but he starts to try to dress her up and get her to look just like the woman who he was attached to and and who'd passed away.

SPEAKER_01And it's that's probably the most disturbing part of the movie. Turns out that she was the woman that he had fallen in love with, and he had been set up from the start by his friend using this woman that was not the guy's original wife, who just happened to look like the guy's wife, and it was all done so that he could get his friend to be like a a witness to what happened at the end, where the friend who again hired him actually wanted to kill his wife to get the inheritance, and so on and so forth.

SPEAKER_01The way the movie ends, they ascend the same tower because he's figured it out. He confronts her, figures out the truth, and all of a sudden they're surprised by a nun. We'll get to that, but I don't understand that at all. Yeah, somebody surprises them, and the the second woman now falls from the same tower and passes away. And that's how the movie ends.

SPEAKER_03That's a great synopsis. I hope so. I mean, you spoiled it, and you have to, but I thought that was uh a uh uh conservative spoiler. Uh let's start with cinematics and common grace. I mean, I one of the things that's noticeable for me in this particular film, I don't know the sequence or chronology of the films that he's produced, and we've we've reflected on what years, but I think this one is later on than the other ones that we've reviewed.

SPEAKER_03And there's some notable camera angles that are different. I think in previous previous films we've seen kind of a panorama panoramic around the back of somebody's head. And we've noted that there's you know, typically stills and close-ups, not super close, like the whole uh profile of someone or the front of the face, but you still can see the shoulders.

SPEAKER_03And I believe when the credits are rolling, you get these very intense close-ups of a woman's lips and a woman's eye. And it's uh super uh um immense close-up. And you know, I'm just all I was already observing like this doesn't seem part of your philosophy of cinematography, like what's going on here. Suggestive in retrospect, like keep an eye on things, you know, wh watch carefully.

SPEAKER_03But that that uh appro that it that intimate and intricate approach, I you know, kind of appreciated in in sort of a common grace way, like when when you're you know, when you have a still or you have a frame of someone's face and head, there's so many things you can focus on. And with this focus on the eye or the lips, just looking at the symmetry and the way in which uh our creator has made things so beautifully and so functionally, and the way in which it seems like Alfred Hitchcock is focusing on the mouth and the words that you say, and are they truthful?

SPEAKER_03Are they deceptive and the eyeballs and perception? And are you paying attention to actually how things are? So that that was just raising aware awareness for me that um you know there's there's common grace going on here in eyeballs and mouths and different angles, and um a producer suggesting things to viewers pay attention to this um that I appreciated.

SPEAKER_03Is there anything for uh in terms of cinematics that you appreciated?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I definitely the the close-ups stood out to me as well. But I also thought to juxtapose with that would be quite interesting to think about the the distance shots as well. So there's some times where you know when he first starts to follow the woman, he's in a restaurant and she's kind of far away, yeah, but then she begins to come closer and to the point where you get a much closer shot. Yeah, and that kind of repeats later on.

SPEAKER_01Uh, and you see this multiple times where things come into focus. And is this the person? And am I looking at the right thing? And so it's like waiting, that kind of anticipation, yeah. The distance, then to the close shot. So I really like that.

SPEAKER_05That's a great point.

SPEAKER_01There there were there were also a couple of shots like in nature and on the road, where you you're almost like a first person perspective. You're looking at the the these beautiful trees, and at one point you're in the forest with the sequoias. Another time you're coming up on a Spanish mission, um, and you're seeing these shots as if you're the the people, and then all of a sudden you're in the space, and then you start to get these really close shots as well. So I thought that the juxtaposition of like closeness and distance, to me, I felt that kind of in different ways throughout the film.

SPEAKER_01But to your point with with the close-ups, especially in that most disturbing part of the movie where he's trying to be with a woman that looks just like the woman who died, even though he doesn't know it's the same woman. Yeah, but she looks a little different, yeah. And so he's looking, he's inspecting her and trying to recreate the image. Yeah. And I I think that's so fascinating in in many ways for our what we talk about on a on a weekly basis here. But um, but he's like looking at her face, like, no, the hair's not quite right, the color of your outfit isn't right, and it's like you're just sitting there like crawling in your own skin, watching somebody dress up a Barbie.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. Yeah, so that's what stood out there.

SPEAKER_03That's a brilliant observation. I mean, I didn't even think of um in in terms of the the the driving and transportation. It is quite fascinating that in some scenes you'll find yourself as the character looking from inside of the car out through the windshield.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03And then it'll shift to you're in front of the windshield watching them drive, you know, and it's just this you're in throughout the film, you're in several different spaces and places. You're looking up, you're looking down. Yeah, you're looking inside, you're looking outside. And and that also brilliant observation, the focus and how some things come into focus, and and he he really is being patient with blurriness.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. He's being patient with the blurriness of and and anticipating the viewers like, is that her? I can't tell yet. Keep coming, keep walking, keep, you know, and and there it it reels you in, it it it it brings you in. So yeah, brilliant observation.

SPEAKER_03All right, let's talk about common grace in relationships. I know in our last episode I had particular questions for particular characters. There, you're right, there's mainly three characters here. There's there's a few others, but mainly three. And if I had to identify and framing it in terms of like who's the negative neighbor, who who sucks at neighboring, and who is great at communion and communing and building community.

SPEAKER_03I think well, to your point, I think we're we both agree. Scotty is uh not disgusting, not reprehensible. He's just disturbing.

SPEAKER_01Scotty's disturbing.

SPEAKER_03Something weird's going on with this dude.

SPEAKER_01You don't knock on people's hotel rooms and be like, Can I just talk to you?

SPEAKER_03You look like somebody and like, yeah, can I come in? Can I just sit down on your couch? I forget what he says. He's like, I won't touch you, or you know, so can I just come into your apartment, sit on your couch and talk to you because you look like somebody I know?

unknownWhat?

SPEAKER_03Uh, you know, I I think of all of the characters, although we can talk about the business owner and the murder of his wife, uh, obviously negative neighboring, but you do get this image of Scotty being obsessed with this woman in such a way that it's off-putting to the viewers and it is frustrating and maddening to others. So I think there's something there with negative neighboring and being obsessive.

SPEAKER_03And you know, he's stalking her, it's couched or masqueraded in terms of investigation or you know, detective line of work. But it really is just obsession. Eventually he gets very uh affectionate and affective toward uh affected toward her um in such a way that it ceases to be investigation anymore or detection. So there's something there with Scotty being a negative neighbor, and I think I I honestly don't know.

SPEAKER_03If I would categorize Midge as the consummate neighbor, there are parts of, you know, she obviously still loves him.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, because they had been engaged for three weeks. Right. Years ago.

SPEAKER_03She broke it off.

SPEAKER_01She broke it off. We don't know why.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Um, but you know, she comes across as kind of like a loser. Like she's she she she's helpful, she's compassionate, she uh cares about him and she watches out for him and she's protective of him. But from beginning and all the way to the end, I I got a impression. It may not be the only impression, but I got a impression that she missed out.

SPEAKER_03And that that's what I mean in terms of her being a loser, not like she's a deadbeat and you know, but she she obviously loves him and she she's not doing something about it. She's she she or or expressing her regret about breaking it off. She's letting him be infatuated and obsessed with this other woman. And um, though she's involved in in some of his pursuits, it's just like you could have done more to get the guy.

SPEAKER_05Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. So I don't know if I would say she's the consummate neighbor. I don't know if she's celebrating communion. I don't know if that's the right way. I don't think so. That's the right way that she should have interacted with Scotty. But of all of the characters, it seems like she's the one who's at least building community in positive ways. What do you think about all that?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I agree. And with Scotty, it's kind of tragic, right? Because this is where Hitchcock, I think, does a really good job, because you you're watching from the beginning, and I think you have like a natural affinity for Scotty because he's trying to chase the criminal. He finds himself, you know, feeling guilty for what happened with the other cop. He has this acrophobia, and you're kind of like rooting for him to get back on his feet, and maybe through this case where he's you know following this woman, maybe he'll find meaning and feel better about himself.

SPEAKER_01But he does become obsessed. And we'll talk maybe in the theological section about this more, but you know, does some pretty, you know, immoral things and certainly awkward things and disturbing things. So um watching him become obsessed, and you realize, no, like this character that we're invested in that we want to do better, it's like this is now twisted in a way that I'm not comfortable with. And maybe you have to start being a little bit critical of Scotty and how he's going about his business.

SPEAKER_03And even uh sorry if I can interject, I mean, even at the end, that's a great point. Even at the end, when you realize he's been deceived and tricked, still, the vestiges of those scenes in which he was doing that, you're still like, no, no, no, I don't care. Like you're still culpable. That was that was uber disturbing.

SPEAKER_01Really disturbing. So, um, and then with Midge, I think, yeah, she's uh definitely one of the more interesting characters in the whole film. You don't ever get clarity about why she broke off their engagement. So that's like Hitchcock doesn't always give you the information you're desiring. So I think that's fascinating. I think she's probably like, you know, be being a great neighbor or showing or demonstrating neighboring in a positive way the most after the woman that he thinks he was in love with falls to her death, and he's kind of had a mental break, or at least he's he needs time to recover.

SPEAKER_01And Midge is just there for him.

SPEAKER_05Yeah.

SPEAKER_01She's with him, she's visiting him, she's trying to help him recover, and it's like, you know, it's not looking good, but yes, she's there.

SPEAKER_05Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And to me, it's like that that's a sign of neighboring, of love.

SPEAKER_03Sure.

SPEAKER_01Even though we still don't know why she would have broken it off, and even why she acted so strangely when he began the case, and she started to get jealous and yeah, seeming possessive in her own way.

SPEAKER_03You're absolutely right. I I think I think she is I I think she is the consummate neighbor in terms of helping him, uh, being present for him, being patient with him, generous and kind. I mean, there's fruit of the spirit here. But I suppose what I what I'm struggling with that sh she is deficient in is using your words. She could, and using your words in in a way that's noticeable in the film.

SPEAKER_03I don't think I'm I don't think I'm reading too much and interpreting uh subtle signs and making them significant. I think the viewer is left wanting her to say things like, why did you break up with him? Yeah, why did you break off the engagement? Who are you to him? You know, you you you guys used to go to college together, I think. What are you to him now? And you're engaged, and who are you engaged to? And sh so it's like she doesn't use her voice and she doesn't speak, and she's not honest, and she's not forthright.

SPEAKER_03And I think that's absent. So so even though physically she's very present and and she's not she's not obsessive, she's not overbearing and commandeering like Scotty is. Um, she's a she she's a consummate neighbor in terms of presence. But what's absent is all of the right words that she should be saying to build community in that way. Any thoughts?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I think well, I'm contemplating what you just said. I mean, she is an artist, which is fascinating too, because it's like the things that she ought to be saying, she seems to struggle with. And so she starts to like express herself in art, but it doesn't always go over the way that she hopes. That's a great observation. She even tries to like play around with one of the paintings that Madeline had been obsessed with, the character Madeline, and it doesn't go over well with the now obsessed uh Scotty, yeah Scotty.

SPEAKER_01So Midge struggles, she really struggles to uh to communicate in this, despite the fact that her affection and her care for Scotty is clear. And you know, when it comes to Scotty, if you're one of the you know audience members, I mean you don't you don't know that he's being deceived purposefully by this woman in the beginning, but you're looking at this woman, you're like, man, she's she's messed up. Yeah. And you're like, this this woman cares about you, and you're getting obsessed with a woman that it just doesn't seem like it's gonna work.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And so from Kansas.

SPEAKER_01So it's like I felt um, yeah, Midge's character definitely struggles. So I agree with you on that.

SPEAKER_03Well, let's transition to uh we're always thinking theologically and spiritually about. Are we? Some I mean, I think so, yeah. A couple of themes that jumped out at me, and they were prompted by some remarks or quotes in in the script. The the the first one that jumped out at me was when oh her name's uh Judy. Yeah, you you you come to know her as Judy, right?

SPEAKER_01This is the character that was Madeline Elster, but so Madeline is Judy. Yeah, yeah, exactly. That's the spoiler.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, that's the spoiler. But you know, in in as she's as she's conversing with Scotty, she says, one shouldn't live alone. Um, which should which raise for me a theme that has is interwoven in almost every episode we have, like individualism, isolation, and even romantically or sexually, like celibacy and chastity. It just how how do you be a good neighbor if you're not around anyone?

SPEAKER_03How do you be a good neighbor if you're in your basement all the time and you don't interact with other humans or cats or dogs or trees? You can you can certainly neighbor the Lord in your basement, but there's just something there, you know, one should never one should never l live alone, and what that is suggestive of in terms of community and neighboring. The other remark was I believe this was also from from Judy or or Madeline.

SPEAKER_03Uh, only one can wander. Because I yeah, only one can wander if there are two, they're going somewhere. Only one can wander if there are two, they are going somewhere. And I believe the context for this one was when Scotty asked uh Madeline if he could go with her to someplace. And she was saying, I go there to wander. And he said, I can, I think he said, I can wander with you. And she said, only one can wander.

SPEAKER_03If there are two, they are going somewhere. Which which raised sort of like, you know, just vo questions of vocation, questions of lifestyle. Is there a difference? I mean, wandering almost immediately elicits for me the Israelites.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Wandering in the desert, in the wilderness. They're wandering collectively, not just as individuals uh roaming about. And and you know, we're all wayfaring, we're all trying to find our way in the world and in our vocation and in our relationships and in our uh occupation and activities. We're all trying to find our way. And there's something that I don't know, just about that remark that doesn't quite fit for me.

SPEAKER_03That um wandering isn't necessarily such an individualistic enterprise. So one shouldn't live alone. Only one can wander if there are if if there are two, they are going somewhere. So this wayfaring and wandering theme and individualism and celibacy and isolation, another theme. And then finally, I'm just struck. We talked briefly about this before we hopped on the mics here.

SPEAKER_03I don't understand the symbolism of the nuns, right? This is a theme that runs throughout the film. And I had heard or read somewhere that this was Hitchcock's like most Catholic film. I don't know if that was just like a thin way of saying there's a lot of like Christian themes in it, but certainly there's something going on with the nuns in this film that just doesn't compute for me.

SPEAKER_03I don't know what the symbolism is. There's reference made to them, and then they're actually in the film, and just makes you wonder what what do they mean? What are they for? And and they're actually they don't they're they're not a prominent part of the film, no, but they are a significant part somehow. So that was another thing that jumped out at me. So we've got three themes we can, you know, jump all over the place. Anything resonate with you, anything uh per pique your interest.

SPEAKER_01I'll I'll try to attend to each of these a bit. When it comes to this idea of it's not good to be alone, yeah, I I so I was really struck by this throughout the film because then when I started to think about being alone, I was wondering if like what weren't all of the characters alone in some sort of destructive sense. Like where we understand the like ideal of Christianity to be like living in community in some sense, whether it's your domestic church or whether it's just with others who share your faith.

SPEAKER_01Um, I'm thinking about the kind of trouble you can get in when you're like an individual living alone. Right. And you have the wrong way of seeing things. And that kind of plays into the wayfaring wandering question as well. But I'm thinking about you know, the the characters like Midge and Scotty, they they live alone, they're not in any committed relationship. I'm thinking about also the character Madeline, who becomes Judy, living in her apartment alone.

SPEAKER_01But I'm thinking about um so the character Madeline, you know, Elster, her husband, I think his name's Gavin. Gavin Elster, a friend, a friend of Scotty's from the past. He's married, but they say it towards the end of the movie that his wife is always gone, living in the country. She basically lives in the country. That's right. So you get the sense that this guy who married into money has a job probably through the marriage, and his wife spends time away from him, and he's basically alone given the space and the time just to cause problems.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Wow.

SPEAKER_01And so, like, you've got all these people like uh who are in some sense alone and then kind of yeah, derailing themselves over time.

SPEAKER_03That's fascinating. And it also provokes for me, they are they are alone, they're living alone. And maybe you maybe you might want to challenge this or contest it, but I'm just gonna assert it. But none of them are lonely. Like, I don't even think Scotty is lonely, he's in love. He's he's obsessed, he's infatuated, and they're all living alone.

SPEAKER_03They're all like atoms, A-T-O-M. Yeah, like just bouncing here and there. But none of them, none of them are are are portrayed as lonely, which I think is fascinating. How is it that they don't fall into that existential realization and feel feel like there's a deficit, feel like there's an absence. There is something there, I'm thinking through it.

SPEAKER_03There is something there that they're all living alone, but you don't feel for any of them in being lonely.

SPEAKER_05Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And you know, you've got somebody like Gavin who's trying to get people out of his life. And you've got somebody like Scotty who's trying to get people into his life, and you've got people like uh Midge who wish they had uh somebody else in their life. So you you've got these atoms, and they're trying to they're they're trying to relate in different ways, but they're all still maintaining their their loneness, their aloneness, but none of them are lonely.

SPEAKER_03So it's almost like I guess I guess what I'm trying to get at is like there's also something that's inhumane or unhuman about where they are and how they're pursuing things.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I like I like that. That's provocative to me. Um so we talked about the being alone, and then I was really struck by when you talked about wayfaring and wandering, and maybe there's some sort of like deficient notion here when we look at the history of Israel and wandering together, journeying together, sojourning. Uh so I think that yeah, like the character the the kind of presuppositions or prejudices that the characters have going in about themselves as these like isolated individuals certainly plays a part in this kind of wandering.

SPEAKER_05Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So I I'm totally on board with thinking about that. What was the third one that you mentioned? Nuns. Nuns, yeah. Nuns. Yeah, I I struggled with this because I was trying to think, is there some sort of meta thing going on here where you've been trying to deny the truth, and it's like you all of a sudden at the end, when all of the revelations are are coming out and the truth is out there, and you know, Madeline Judy is trying to find a way to salvage what they have, but then all of a sudden the nun arrives.

SPEAKER_01Now, could it be yeah, like the arrival of truth, and there's no longer any way to avoid this situation and the repercussions of it? Maybe, but it's also like that when the nun appears in the top of the tower, it's like she's in darkness, and it's kind of it's creepy, yeah, and and like it's scary, yeah, if you're a person there, and obviously Judy is scared, and I don't know if she just like exits stage the wrong way or throws herself.

SPEAKER_01Did she jump or did she fall? Did she trip? Like, whoops, that's what I don't know either. But so I'm not sure what it what I'm comfortable like saying, oh, this is clearly like a Catholic theme, or the nuns represent X or Y. I I too was kind of wondering about that.

SPEAKER_03And and I I think there I I think there has to be symbolism there.

SPEAKER_05Yeah.

SPEAKER_03There has to be because it it's woven throughout the entire film, and it's ancillary, it's kind of like just a flashing light of the the nuns are around, or you know, there's something related to the nuns. And then in these pivotal moments, they step into the scene literally and figuratively. But then you have in that final scene, right?

SPEAKER_03She trips or falls or throws herself, and the nun continues to ring, I think, the mission bell. Like somebody just died, right? And you're ringing a bell, like for for you know, you know, whatever it might be, a meal, prayer time, whatever, but it's like there's another another person dead. Yeah, maybe you ring the bell every time something jumps up. Um but there, yeah, there's something.

SPEAKER_03The more and more I think about this, there's it it is bizarre. There's there's several factors and and tenets of this that are so bizarre, like even that kind of seems inhumane. Can you really carry on the liturgy, for example? Can you carry on administering the sacraments when somebody's dying in the sanctuary? Do you do you keep going or do you pause and say, Oh my gosh, let's take care of this, let's get help, or you know, there's something inhumane about it.

SPEAKER_01And yeah, I I think that's sorry to interrupt. No, that's fine, yeah. Um, but yeah, because it is fascinating, right? Because she says, Oh, I heard voices, and she was coming up, and the person's dead, but she just rings the bell. There's not like, oh no, let me look out the window and see for whom the bell tolls.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So it's definitely a strange situation.

SPEAKER_03I think if you don't mind me taking uh a step back here, just one second. I mean, I I think I don't have any other insight to the symbolism of the nuns and the ringing of the bell. I just think it's there's something there that I don't completely comprehend. But I do think there there is something to push a little further with the wandering um and the wayfaring that as you pressed it a little further, it does seem like revelation tells us that wandering is a good thing.

SPEAKER_03And wandering is divinely orchestrated, and God is sovereign over the wandering until things are prepared and then you can go in, then you can settle. But it's not done individually, it's done collectively. And I also think of John the Baptist. He has his followers and he's wandering and Jesus is wandering in the wilderness for forty days and forty nights.

SPEAKER_03There is something that's collective. About wandering. And it's almost, I guess, if this is a paradox or a contrast, we when we hear the word wayfaring, we're like, oh yeah, like everybody's trying to find their way in life. And wandering sounds like you lack a destination and you lack a vocation and people shouldn't wander. I also think of what was it, Tolkien?

SPEAKER_03Not all who wander are lost. We think of wandering in in sort of a pejorative way, but I think revelation reveals, dictates to us that wandering can actually be what God uses to prepare you for the good, the good land, the good situation and settlement that's to come. So it's almost like it's it's almost counterintuitive.

SPEAKER_03Wayfaring sounds like the beneficial thing that we all have to do. And, you know, we'll do it and we'll find our way, and everybody's finding their way. But wandering, that doesn't sound great to us. And yet, I almost think Revelation points out it's the opposite. You're not just making your way through life. There might be times in which you have to wander so that God can prepare the land. And then you settle in the promised land, the promised job, the promised relationship.

SPEAKER_03And you don't have to find, you don't have to find your way through things. He's orchestrating and he's planning and he's getting things ready for you to inherit the land and enjoy it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that's valuable, Kyle, because again, if you have the sense of wandering with in some sort of individualistic sense without purpose, that's not what we're talking about here. I mean, scripturally, even the wandering is in light of this kind of God is caring for us, God is leading us into this land, preparing it for us. So it is communal, it's relational, it's theocentric, or it should have been. A lot of times there's grumbling and complaining, but that's where things go wrong.

SPEAKER_01Right. So, and that's where I think this is definitely not original, but like, can you wander in wonder? Right? Like, is it still kind of not this kind of self-centered, individualistic, almost destructive kind of wandering? It's it's a wandering again, open to the Lord, open to direction and the working of the spirit, um, listening to God's word. So it can be thoroughly relational for a Christian, thoroughly Trinitarian. And so I think that that's really, really essential.

SPEAKER_01And I'm so I'm really happy you brought it up. Um, I have a couple other items. Yes, shoot. Can I can I bring them up? All right. So, with this, I mean, in this movie, there's like deception within deception. And it's kind of a sad portrayal of relationships. I mean, the very fact that a former friend of the detectives would would use him to try to murder his wife, and then he ends up abandoning the woman that he used, also, just so he can inherit money.

SPEAKER_01Um, this kind of use and throwing away, discarding of people, it's really tough. And the way that Madeline, in full knowledge of this, she only finds out at the end, but in full knowledge is allowing all of this to happen and furthering it.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And then she herself also cares for this person by the end and hopes that there can be some sort of salvaging of her relationship with um Scotty. So it just brings up a couple ideas, some that my wife and I talked about, and I gotta give her credit for this, but like when you have this openness and trust, and then how this leads to like a vulnerability, right? And we see how deception kind of ruins and hurts, really hurts people in this movie. And so that kind of led me to this, I guess almost like an Augustinian type of position, where the the love that is displayed in this movie, it's built on all of these lies, deceptions, and other motivations, not on communion, not on God.

SPEAKER_01And so, in a sense, it's like the characters are creating this negative space. And and then when they try to have these these things flourish in a negative space, it just can't happen. It's just built on a horrible foundation, and it's destined to fail, it seems like. And and the really the last 30 minutes of the movie kind of the audience knows what that this can't work. Despite any of the relationships or like the way that Scotty's trying to make over this woman, yeah, and it's obsessive and it's manipulative and it's creepy, right?

SPEAKER_01And you know at that at some point that it's actually that that she is the same woman and that she's trying to be with him, but she's deceived him so so much that like you have a feeling it's destined to fail. And so it just keeps like reminding me of a few things. So building love on lies and deception, how dangerous and destructive that is. And really, I was left by the end of the movie, like I was troubled because when I looked back, when you're watching the movie and you're like, oh, this detective's falling for the woman he's supposed to be following, the wife of another man, he ends up kissing her and kicking.

SPEAKER_01I'm like, I'm like, oh, violating the commandments, like you know, adultery, but it wasn't because it wasn't even the guy's wife.

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_01But he didn't know that. And so now I'm like, wait a minute. He thinks he's committed, like he would think he was committing adultery, but yet it wasn't because there's so many lies bearing false witness. So I was really struck by like the way the commandments were being violated. Interesting. Along with um building up, you know, this this elaborate fiction, and then how love develops within this deception. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03So I'm sorry, yeah, cesspool, and then it turns into like chlorine.

SPEAKER_01So I don't think we can solve all that, but I just wanted to throw it out there.

SPEAKER_03This is we're not going to be able to attend to this, but um, I I at least have to make this remark, and um if if you're if you can s succinctly uh respond, you're more than welcome to. I am struck after your comments by the fact that two things. One, did Judy get what was coming to her though? Because if you present yourself in such a way with such a deception, and somebody believes you and they're and they're um you know, they're gullible, and then they fall in love with you because of the way that you presented yourself deceptively, are they to blame if they're the ones?

SPEAKER_03Are they culpable for their gullibility that you played on in saying, This is who I am, and then you fall in love with them and you kiss them in that way, and then you you come out, you you come out and take off your mask and say, This is who I really am, and they say, put your mask back on. Who's to blame?

SPEAKER_05Right?

SPEAKER_03I think that does call into question what you're absolutely right. There's deception upon deception upon lies and misrepresentation and and so on and so forth. And I think and this is a little more cynical than that than that, but don't we do what Scotty did almost every moment of our lives in some respects? How so? You're like incredulous. Um if you if you colored your hair a different color, I think you'd look better.

SPEAKER_03If you wore this, it's it's the yes, I know he's trying to retrieve. I know he's trying to retrieve an old, he he's trying to retrieve Madeline when she's Judy. Get that. But you presented yourself, as I just noted, you presented yourself as Madeline and not Judy, right? But but isn't there, even though that scene is incredibly monstrously disturbing, don't we do that in some respects every time that we perceive any other human being?

SPEAKER_03I don't like that. I wish we're critiquing. There's something there that Scotty is participating in, yes, in a very egregious and exaggerated way. But I also get the fact that we do that all the time. We just it's not that disturbing.

SPEAKER_05Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Right? It's I don't in the principle of it is you're itching, you're itching, you're ready. The principle of it is I don't accept you the way that I perceive you. I want I want you to change so that I can accept you. And every single time that I perceive you, and you you don't present yourself the way that I want you to present yourself, I'm critiquing you.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that is that is a bit disturbing, Kyle.

SPEAKER_05Sorry.

SPEAKER_01But I think um, yeah, to to to your points that you've raised here, I think Scotty, he had fallen in love with the lie, with the deception. And at this point, Madeline, who's really Judy, is desperate for him to love her as she is, but he can't. It's not what he's falling, that's not what he loves. Right? And then in in almost like an existential sense, yeah, like what this should complicate our everyday lives because, oh, you changed your hair, or oh, like are we somewhere on the spectrum of Scotty?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, the spectrum of Scotty.

SPEAKER_05That's all I got, brother. That's great.

SPEAKER_03Well, in our next episode, we'll commence our phenomenological musing surrounding the Netflix series Slow Horses, a story about a dysfunctional team of MI5 agents and their obnoxious boss, and what that might mean for our lives. We have much in solidarity and resonance with those characters as these in Hitchcock films. Until next time, don't hide in a closet or stare at paintings for too long all day, or jump off a roof.

SPEAKER_03Overcome your fears through the Lord and with the Lord, and listen to some Mozart this week. Thanks as always for listening to two poor spirits.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Your Seams Are Showing: Loving Our Neighbors through Fashion | Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo

    Nov 13, 202654 minAudio

    A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Embrace Boredom and Boss Better

    Oct 29, 202655 minAudio

    Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Be a Better Colleague

    Oct 1, 202649 minAudio

    Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Don't Make Your Boss God and Your Kids Swag

    Sep 12, 202657 minAudio

    Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: See Your Failures as Blessings

    Aug 13, 202653 minAudio

    You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...

    Credit the people on this episode