How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: See Your Failures as Blessings
53 minAudio
You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an egregious error a "failure" if it can become an opportunity for growth? Or if God uses it to bless others? After all, it is only through misfortune that we can stand out as models, as Seneca eloquently put it. In this episode of season four, on common grace in culture, Chris and Kyle discuss the British spy TV series, Slow Horses - an amusing story of a dysfunctional team of MI5 agents and their obnoxious boss. They discuss taking risks at work, believing that the Lord has a particular purpose for you, and why aura farming with holes in your socks is impossible. Neighbor better. + + Welcome to another episode of Two Pour Spirits! Where signature cocktails meet spirited conversations for the sake of the Church and the common good. + + Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor ecumenically educates, equips, and empowers the Church to image her Creator and love all creatures, including her enemies, in public places with particular practices. From soil to sky, crib to casket. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Rev. Dr. Kyle David Bennett and Dr. Christopher Cimorelli. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the church and for the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the Catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically oriented, and practically minded.
SPEAKER_01We hope that you enjoy the conversation and camaraderie of two poor spirits, and make no apologies for the background noises that mark our fellowship, the clinking of ice and sloshing of liquid among them. Let's build up together.
SPEAKER_00Visit Projectneighbor.org to learn more many of places all day.
SPEAKER_05Did you have any moments in which everyone was sneering at you? Have you ever been disappointed with yourself? Are you still trying to prove your worth to your boss? How is it that you cope with the dull, routine tasks at work? In this twelfth episode of season four on Common Grace and Culture, Chris and I will be talking about the British spy TV series Slow Horses.
SPEAKER_05It's an amusing story of a dysfunctional team of MI5 agents and their obnoxious boss. Chris, this is the day that the Lord has made, and we're going to rejoice by casting in it. But before we get into the rules of disgrace and failure, let's throw a party recipe in the back pockets of our listeners. What do we got here in our adult sippy cups?
SPEAKER_01Kyle man, always a pleasure, my brother, to be casting with you. We have something new today. So this is a joint operation. We were just outside.
SPEAKER_04Spitballing it.
SPEAKER_01Spitballing it. And we came up with are we going with four horsemen of the apocalypse?
SPEAKER_05The four horsemen. The four slow horsemen. There you go.
SPEAKER_01The four slow horsemen. Yeah, so this is different, something new. We were playing around with. So let's get into it. We decided to go with equ well, first thing we did was we got a large cocktail tumbler with a large cube. And instead of your kind of standard bitters, we decided to use ancho reyes verde, a type of liquor flavored with uh, I think chili peppers, right? Am I correct on that? Yep, yep. So ancho reyes, the the regular is really good.
SPEAKER_01The verde is also good. So several drops of ancho um verde serving as bitters in that glass. And then it's up to you if you want to use like um a shaker or something like that. We just poured it into the glass and then stirred it, but it's up to the listener how they want to do it. We did equal parts of mezcal, uh one and a half ounces of that per glass, also one and a half ounces of our Day of the Lord spiced and smoked cointreau.
SPEAKER_01So those two elements brought in something uh spicy and smoky. And then we decided to do something that we haven't done before, which is to use both um ginger beer and club soda. And so I can't say exactly how much we used, but we basically took equal parts of ginger beer and club soda and kind of topped off the cocktail tumbler that had a large cube and these other elements in it, filled up the glass, and then we decided to finish it off with some garnish of an Italian cocktail cherry with a little bit of the juice, stirred it.
SPEAKER_05I would say the club soda and the ginger beer was approximately like three to four ounces each.
SPEAKER_01That that sounds right. Yeah. So that's what we have. We've got, again, one and a half ounces each of mezcal and day of the Lord spice smoke cointreau. Um, previously there had been the the bitters of the ancho um reyes verdes, and then topped off with club soda and ginger beer. What do you what do you think?
SPEAKER_05I think it's fantastic. I'm pleasantly surprised by I mean, there multiple aspects of it. One is the color, right? It is this fine blend of dark and and light, of translucence and um occlusion. What's the word I'm looking for? Opacity? Opacity, yes, that but all so color, also flavor.
SPEAKER_05It I said to you when I took the first sip, it's kind of like a citrusy IPA, but but like ten times thinner, more than half, ten times thinner, and then you get a hint of the spice, but uh you know it it it goes down your palate, and about three seconds later I feel like I have to cough.
SPEAKER_01The burn. The burn hits you.
SPEAKER_05Well, it it's actually, I mean, it it doesn't burn, but it is spicy. But yeah, but yeah. I think it's quite refreshing. And you, you know, I know we're thinking about drinks that can, you know, you can have throughout the year. I think I would drink this throughout the year, but probably only three out of four seasons would I say uh this is something that you could have. I wouldn't drink this when it's snowing outside by the fire.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_05This is more like summer, spring, and autumn, fall type drink. Not necessarily, I mean, it'll warm you up, it'll warm your chest up and your throat up. Um but it's a little on the thin side for the winter and it's not as strong. I mean, that last that third second or the fourth second after the fourth slow horseman has crawled down your throat is when you want to cough, but it isn't really kind of like uh exuding warmth.
SPEAKER_05Um but that's not a complaint, that's not a deficiency, it's just I think it's a delicious drink, but probably three out of four seasons I would drink this. What do you think?
SPEAKER_01I mean, for the for the most part, I agree. Um, so I mean, I would describe it as a little bit of a burn or like a hefty tingle, but it's only in the back half of my tongue and kind of at the top of my palate, a little bit down the throat, where it's like I I take the drink and it's surprisingly refreshing, like you said. And I almost, you know, I don't want to say like a lightly carbonated soft drink, but a thin, yeah, there's something about that, but it's better because it's not overly sugary, which I which I really appreciate.
SPEAKER_01Um but then yeah, as it kind of finishes off, I get a little bit of that spice and that warmth and that feeling in the back of my mouth. So um I really I really do like it. I've never mixed club soda and ginger beer before. Neither I. Yep. So this is new for us. Um yeah, I think I think I I would make this again.
SPEAKER_05So what do you think that last spice is? Is that the conquest, the war, the famine, or death? Which of the horsemen is that? I don't think it's death.
SPEAKER_01No, maybe it's conquest.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, maybe it's conquest. Well, let's jump into common grace in cinematics and um characters.
SPEAKER_05We've combined these in the in our couple of episodes in which we uh discussed Alfred Hitchcock films, we distinguished between or we focused on cinematics as one category and then went into characters or uh relationships. But I think with this show, Slowhorses, let's combine the two of them in terms of like what did we find that was beautiful regarding cinematics? What did we find that was beautiful in this TV show?
SPEAKER_05We've watched uh up to this date, we've watched all all of the all of the series or um all of the episodes and seasons. Um, but there are some uh seasons forthcoming. What did we find beautiful in the cinematics and what did we find good in the characters? Now, I don't have much to say about the cinematics. I have a couple of foci in the in the characters. I don't know if we need to introduce some kind of synopsis to this.
SPEAKER_05Would that be helpful if if we did that?
SPEAKER_01Are you able to do that? Maybe bare bones. So just to kind of give people a footing if they haven't seen it. I think it's an Apple TV.
SPEAKER_05It is Apple Plus, yep.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Apple Plus. Um, this is kind of an amazing show, in my humble opinion. But yeah, so you have kind of this beginning of the show where you're introduced to a character named River Cartwright, an aspiring and very talented MI5 agent, so British spy. But the yeah, absolute, potentially career-ending mistake made by River Cartwright to start the series off. What happens to some of these people that aren't directly fired and ended, but yet they're not able to kind of be put in the spotlight anymore?
SPEAKER_05They're like worse than demoted.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So what do you do with these people? So there's this kind of space where they're sent called Slaughhouse, um, which is where all of the derelict agents that have made mistakes and their careers have gone off the path. So they go to this house where they're kind of given, you know, for lack of a better term, busy work, uh, grunt work, nothing that's quite serious or sexy like they would want being an MI5 agent, with no prospects of really rising back up and and achieving the next.
SPEAKER_01But this show kind of tracks this community of derelict agents. But at the same time, many of them are earnest and well-intentioned, and they stumble upon something that appears to be, uh, at least in the first season, a plot that is complicated. It seems to be something related to terrorism, but actually might involve an inside job. And you start to follow their relationships as they are both coming to grips with like their failed prospects, but at the same time trying to do right.
SPEAKER_01And you're dealing with all these interpersonal relationships, um, themes of failure, while they kind of continue to do the work that they believe they're they're called to do. So each season is different. There's the different plot for each season. I I can't possibly um boil those down now, but season one certainly involves this idea of an inside job with the veneer of some sort of like terrorist plot. So that's a great intro. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Uh which I want to come back to some things because it provoked for me, like it's almost like for me, it raises the question: are they demoted to like a hell or is it like purgatory?
SPEAKER_01Purgatory, probably.
SPEAKER_05Like they're they're these demoted, you know, fallen angels who find themselves in a dungeon, but it's not quite hell. But I we'll we'll get back there. Was there anything in the cinematics for you that you appreciated? I mean, I think it's very well done, not just the narrative, the story, the script. There's some fascinating fight scenes that are very well orchestrated and written. I mean, there's nothing that's jumping out to me right now.
SPEAKER_05I have more uh more thoughts about just starting to analyze the characters and their development throughout the seasons. Is there anything about the cinematics that struck you?
SPEAKER_01Well, I I would say a couple just a couple of things, and then we'll move on. In Slaughhouse, where they're kind of exiled, for lack of it's like a it's again, just like their careers are you know falling and and there's no longer a star in the sky for what they're hoping to do. Um, they're sent to a building that is derelict. It is dilapidated, it's in many ways falling apart, they don't have the resources that a typical MI5 agent would have.
SPEAKER_01I mean, even to get into the building, you've got to like throw your shoulder into it. Um, and so you're constantly aware of this like lack of resources, this terrible setting. And anytime they go back to like the mothership where most MI5 agents are based, you see this like cutting edge, beautiful, like even though it's modern, but like this this like building that's tricked out and has everything that you could possibly imagine. So there's that juxtaposition of the setting of where these agents do their work.
SPEAKER_01Otherwise, I would say it's shot extremely well. Like you see these characters all around England and London, especially, um, and they themselves represent something in the show, and and they're kind of then plopped into different places um in England that are well known. You know, we'll get into this character, Jackson Lamb, yeah, played by the the great Gary Oldman. Yes. Um, he is the kind of head of this Slauhouse.
SPEAKER_01Um, you don't really know exactly why he's he's in charge of this unit, but he is just uh kind of a gross uh individual. We'll we'll get into him, yeah. But he's the leader, and um he himself becomes kind of like I feel like he changes every setting he's in. So in terms of cinematography, uh it's almost like you know, if all if it's a beautiful setting and he's sitting there, it changes it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Right. So I would just say again, juxtaposition of where they do their work with the agents that are still in good standing, and then also the characters kind of dispersed around.
SPEAKER_05There is a symbolism, I don't know if we'll get to it in this episode. There is a symbolism with respect to Slough House that has to do with the dungeon, the fallen angels, as as I've already mentioned, purgatory, is it hell or not? Um, there's symbolism there. But as you noted, and I was thinking about just as you started talking, there is symbolism in the front door of Sloughhouse.
SPEAKER_03Yes, yep.
SPEAKER_05It's like it's a it's a broken, sticking door that you can't get through, and you have the symbolism of they they can never break through to get where they want to be and redeem themselves, you know, like there's a symbolism there. So maybe that'll come up in subsequent episodes. But let's talk about two characters that immediately struck um, you know, my uh sort of character, my virtuous and vicious radar.
SPEAKER_05The first is as is is who you already mentioned, Jackson Lamb. Uh he's the boss.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05He oversees and supervises Slough House, and he is this unkept. He can't even control his body, flatuations, and you know, he's rude, he's profane, he's vulgar, he's demeaning, he tears down.
SPEAKER_01Unwashed.
SPEAKER_05Like he smokes a ton. Uh, he drinks frequently. In some in some respects, though, if I'm if I'm looking at what he's trying to do with the agents, it's almost like he's a character of Diogenes of Sinnoh, which I I can talk about later. But he just it seems like he's trying to dis he's trying to inspire them to be honest and truthful in who they are, which is virtuous.
SPEAKER_05But for the most part, I would say he doesn't he doesn't uh repair the breach of relationships, he tears them down. Uh he makes people feel like they want to run away or you know, commit suicide, or they're never ever going to find redemption in their life. They're losers. Um, and so I would, I would, I would say, at least initially, he's a negative neighbor. Another character is Catherine Standish. Um, and and she has had some brokenness in her life, and she's had some transition in her life uh with her previous boss, and she's trying to deal with Jackson, but but you see her character, at least initially, at least superficially, as someone, she feels guilty about how she's broken down community.
SPEAKER_05She feels guilty about how she's failed in certain areas. And so this is the impetus for her to guard and protect these young agents who are coming into Slough House. And she respects, uh, I mean, she's very forthright with Jackson, but she also respects him and helps him and does things for him. So you see her interacting, uh, at least superficially, interacting well with her superior and interacting well with her inferiors, and she has respect for both.
SPEAKER_05And you see her trying to pull and bring this thing together. So we have a negative neighbor, and we have a character who's trying to build community and build communion. Do you have any thoughts about those characters?
SPEAKER_01I have I have a lot of thoughts. I don't know if I'm going to be able to get them all in here, but um, I'm just so fascinated by Jackson Lamb as a character. Because, as you said, and I think it's clear, like if we're thinking about what we've been, you know, tracing over the last couple of years, you know, Jackson Lamb is clearly a negative neighbor. He he berates people, he demeans them, he's yeah, just he's got holes in his socks all the time.
SPEAKER_01You know, so there's nothing about him that like there's no social grace, like nothing like that at all.
SPEAKER_05Um But the guy takes off his shoes in the office, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, I do think there's something, yeah, there's there is a complexity to him that I want to I want to get to.
SPEAKER_05Yep.
SPEAKER_01In that sense, so I'll get right back to that in a second. But with Catherine Standish, she is like a virtuous person and employee. She seems to be, you know, following the will of Jackson Lamb, or at least he's the boss, I'm gonna do my job, but I'm gonna stand up to him, especially when he's berating and demeaning people. I'm gonna be a better person. Like now you get the sense, and and different seasons bear this out, which is that um her guilt over what happened to one of her past bosses actually relates very much to what Jackson Lamb was doing prior to being the head of this dysfunctional unit.
SPEAKER_01So everybody's kind of interconnected and interrelated in this show. But Jackson Lamb, um I'm I'm just it's I'm I'm I don't know how to describe this. Like I'm I'm so fascinated by him because on the one hand, yes, negative neighbor, but he does seem in some distorted sense to have the well-being of the mission and his people in mind. Now, I want to clarify that real quick, qualify it, because they don't know that all the time because he's so mean to them, and the things he says is just it's so funny if you're watching it as a as a viewer, but if you were an employee, it'd be difficult to work with a man like that.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But when it comes to anybody from the outside who's coming after his people, he's fiercely loyal and defending of them and protecting their work. And so I was thinking about this, Kyle, as like he almost he removes all of the social graces and all the things that we might want to. Say to ourselves. And he basically presents to his people a couple of choices. Either give up and get out or do your job. Which I find to be such a stark thing to like present.
SPEAKER_01Cut through the fog, and but there's nothing else for him. He won't compliment you when you've done it well. Just do your job. Um, and that's where you get the sense, like, there's a kind of a mystery generated from the show. Why is Jackson Lamb here? Because he's really capable and knows what he's about, and he seems to be a really remarkable agent despite all of the problems. I mean, I was thinking about him, and I thought, like, to your point with Diogenes, you know, this kind of like figure of wisdom, and you might have to explain that more to for our audience.
SPEAKER_01But like, in terms of Jesus, I was thinking he's almost like a slightly grotesque parable. Like a parable is something that interrupts you wherever you are, whatever your normal expectation is of life. It stops you and kind of smacks you in the face and resets things, and is like, now go from here. And he kind of does that to these people. Like, this is what a workplace should be. Oh, my life's been I made a mistake, but you know, I'll pick up the pieces. But he's like, he cuts through everything that is expected, and it's just like, no.
SPEAKER_05Get over yourself.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I find him to be fascinating, endlessly a fascinating character. And Standish herself, like, is a foil in some respects, but together they function to the betterment of their people. At least I I think that. So that's where I'll stop there.
SPEAKER_05I think that's absolutely right. They both do that. And I think what I what I what I think Jackson does is actually, it is very similar to Diogenes, and I'll explain that in a second. The way that they present is deliberate. The way that they present themselves is very deliberate to cultivate a certain kind of person. So he presents himself with no decorum, holes in socks, smoking, you know, farts.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, like he he there, there's no social ethic, so to speak, or etiquette. But that's deliberate to get them to care about the right kind of things. And that's where I see the connection with Diogenes. Diogenes of Sinnoh, you know, I don't have enough time to explain his history and story, but he would deliberately do things in public that would make people uncomfortable so that they would raise the question, why don't I do that?
SPEAKER_05Or why do I feel offended that he does that? Like, for example, he would be walking in in Greece and pull down his pants and just defecate in public. And people would be like, What are you doing? And he would get them to raise to ask the question, is it unnatural to go into a bathroom, so to speak, or is it more natural to just do this out wherever I am? Like, what's natural and what's unnatural? And one other uh um instance is Alexander the Great had heard so much about him that he came to visit him.
SPEAKER_05And uh, I forget exactly what Alexander asked him, but Diogenes dismissed him by saying, Could you please step two feet to the right or or something like that, because you're blocking the sun and their shade while I'm sunbathing. And it raised for Alexander the Great, like, who am I? Am I more important than the sun? You know, uh, is that is is it natural for a human being to be more important than the sun? And I think Jackson Lamb does a similar thing.
SPEAKER_05Wham wham wam, stop crying, do your job. This service, what we're doing, is far more important than your failure and your mistake and what you think is your career, and being ambitious about rising to the top. That's not what this is about. And so, I mean, I do think there, if he were more forthright and he were he and he if he were more explanatory in what exactly he's doing, he might not necessarily be a negative neighbor.
SPEAKER_05If he communicated better. I'm, you know, like a coach who yells at you and then pulls you aside and says, I'm trying to motivate you, I'm trying to inspire you. If he did more of that, I don't think he would be a negative neighbor. Right. But he definitely comes across, his character comes across as a negative neighbor. Um, and as you noted, I I think Standish, um, I think that she is trying to cultivate harmony and she's trying to pull things together and knit things together, but she's got a lot of baggage.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05And she's got a lot of brokenness that she is unwilling to deal with. And you could, you, one could argue that that's not good for the community. That because she hasn't dealt with that, because she's also so focused on her own hurt and her own brokenness that she can't actually be a good neighbor to others on a deeper level, that both of them are in a very similar spot.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and to Jackson Lamb's credit, though, he doesn't seem to be like he's not fooled, like there's nothing that's there's no BS.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_01Right? Like, he is what he is, and he's just gonna say exactly what he sees. And that's very hard for people to deal with who are you know thinking or expecting common social graces. And to your point, Standish is not willing to deal with what happened with her former boss who died tragically, and you know, she herself suffered from substance abuse, and you know, is just kind of like holding on tightly to this life that she's carved out out of that.
SPEAKER_01But you almost get the sense with with someone like Jackson Lamb, and this this plays out with every character, and this is why the show is so brilliant. And maybe I'll I'll I'll save some of this for our theological portion, but it's like every single character is broken in some way. Now, with Jackson Lamb, you're not sure exactly what that is, or or you know, is he actually broken the same way the other people are? Because he doesn't have any illusions about himself. So he does have this kind of wisdom in this grotesque sense.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Um and it works, and it works, but everybody's broken. But it's like, well, wait a minute, you know, get get out get beyond yourself. Like there's a job to do. Are you gonna do it or am I gonna get somebody else to do it? Like, and to me, there's something so Christian about this that people are broken, they've the world has deemed them a failure. But is that the end of the story? Or is there a possibility here for doing something out of that?
SPEAKER_05Well, let's jump into thinking theologically and spiritually about some of these things. Uh, in this episode, we're focusing on failure and career-ending mistakes. I mean, this is kind of the premise of the uh the show, and at least for the first season, this is accentuated all throughout that there are failures and people are meeting other people who have failed, and they're uh they're uh despondent and despairing because of what they have done, and they think that their career is at an end.
SPEAKER_05So let's talk about failure and let's talk about career. I think this show raises for the Christian the question of how we should look at our mistakes. Are failures really failures if they can be opportunities for growth? Now, I'm thinking of that in sort of like a secular, even a pagan, non-Christian way, like the Stoics. Like somebody like Seneca saw like misfortunes as opportunities for people to rise to nobility.
SPEAKER_05Don't look at mistakes and don't look at uh fate and fortune, whatever might come, don't look at it as something that's meant to tear you down and as something that you should regret. It's something to build you. And so it's almost it's almost the case that there is no such thing as a mistake, because um these are all opportunities for you to grow and be and find nobility and honor.
SPEAKER_05But I think as a Christian, if we believe that God's providential, if we believe that God is sovereign, then what do we mean by failure? What do we mean by mistakes? If God can take everything that we do and use it, and if God, if we trust in Him and God can use everything for the good of our salvation, how should we think about failures and mistakes?
SPEAKER_05I think it also raises the question of career. How should we think about our work? These characters in this show are looking at their careers, what they do, as something that they can totally ruin. And I think it raises the question: what's the difference between a career and a vocation? And should Christians have a career mindset or should they have a vocation mindset? God has called you to something, and you might fail, and you might lose your quote-unquote career.
SPEAKER_05But that doesn't mean that you necessarily lose your vocation, given that that is something that God has called you to. So I don't know how you want to jump into this, Chris, uh, but I do think that there are these are two very prominent themes in at least this first season, if not the entire show, of how does a Christian make sense of failure? And how does a Christian make sense of career?
SPEAKER_01I mean, th those are just phenomenal, enduring questions. And I think we are, we should be or we ought to be so prepared for this question. There's something amazing about Christianity in this regard, and I wanna I want to tease out a couple of things and try to address what you've raised. So, on the one hand, you have to think about like, I think for a Christian, we we're so like thoroughly influenced by the success of Christianity that we forget its origins.
SPEAKER_01And what I mean by this is Jesus is the Messiah, he is the Christ, he is the savior of Israel. But most Israelites were expecting a military leader, a political figure, someone to conquer, expunge or expel the Romans, reestablish the monarchy the way it was supposed to be, and he was put to death on a cross, the most dishonorable form of Roman execution at the behest of his own people.
SPEAKER_05As a criminal.
SPEAKER_01As a criminal. And the this is why you know the cross is sometimes referred to as a scandal. And how how can you how can this be victory? And this is why Christians needed the resurrection, because we didn't realize how God was working to take human failure and bring something so joyous and beautiful and unexpected and undeserved out of it. So that's that's one thing.
SPEAKER_01But but Jesus himself, you know, he didn't fail personally or morally, his judgment was was secure. So that's one sense of like God working through human failure and our sin. But then if you just look at the Gospels, look at Peter. I mean, I'm just so fascinated by Peter as a character. The the leader of the first Christians row failed. I mean, the cock crowed three multiple times. He denied Jesus.
SPEAKER_01At one point, he tried to bind Jesus by by you know telling him he was wrong about the prediction of the passion. And Jesus says to him, Get behind me, Satan. Um, and and then the guy who then you know subsequently abandons him and and runs away and is not there when his friend and master is crucified. And yet, out of I mean, how can you even quantify or qualify that failure from the standpoint of humanity?
SPEAKER_01Like, and yet he is the one through whom Jesus works and acts of the apostles attest this, you know, to kind of bring people and and build, you know, spread the gospel and be a leader for the early church. So to me, it's like if you if you're a reader of scripture, you're exposed to human failure. But you're also exposed to God working with humans in their failure, in their finitude, in their weakness.
SPEAKER_01And God can bring something good out of that, especially if you're committed to it. So, in this sense, to what you've said, someone like River Cartwright, yeah, maybe he's so concerned with his career at first, and he makes this terrible mistake, or maybe it's a mistake, or maybe somebody, maybe there's some inside story going on there. We don't know. But he's earnest and he's trying, but he's very career-driven and he's trying to get back what was lost. But I think what what Slauhaus does for him, and what Jackson Lamb does, and his community of people in this place of failure, is try to continually remind him of the importance of like attending to the duty and the job that you have to do right in that moment.
SPEAKER_01And if you commit to that, good can happen out of it. Maybe contrary to what the world thinks of as success or not. Now, that's my initial kind of thought there. I would say I'm completely in agreement. And I used to talk to students about this as well. Like, well, what is the difference between a career and one's vocation? Because career always seems very to me individualistic. It's like, oh, what am I, what do I feel like I want to do or choose to do? Whereas vocation, like Latin vocare, it involves being called.
SPEAKER_01And if you're being called, it's you're being called by a higher authority that is intent upon you discerning your gifts and somehow using them and living them out for the betterment of all. I mean, certainly for the community of faith. And so it's a much more communal uh notion, or it can be, whereas a career just seems to be much more of like a secular or worldly kind of category, whereas Volkari is, you know, it has a divine kind of connection along with a communal connection.
SPEAKER_01So um these people in Slawhouse are some of them, not all of them, maybe, but some of them are indeed called and have these gifts, even though their career is shot.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So that's that's where I'm I think the Peter example is is marvelous, brilliant.
SPEAKER_05I think it's provocative. And it it prompted for me the thought that there's also a shadow to this. You know, in many respects, Peter thought he was I mean, he f he failed and in many respects, in some respects, knew he failed. Contrast that with the Apostle Paul, who uh before the road to Damascus thought he was succeeding for the Lord, right?
SPEAKER_05Uh, but actually was failing. Uh and I would say in some respects he was he was very career oriented to kill off the Christians. That's my job. But that's not necessarily how he saw his calling. And then when he is visited by the Lord on the on the road to Damascus, he realizes that he has a mission, a calling to do something.
SPEAKER_05And I think you're right about Cartwright. Like there is this realization, once he fails, once he sees his career has been sacked, there is this build-up of I'm more concerned about the truth and what's right than I am about me being perceived as doing the right thing. And I think that is that goes much deeper into vocation and calling than it does career.
SPEAKER_05Like we find we find ourselves in our career. This is who I am, and that's us, that that derives from us. I am meant to kill off the Christians, as the apostle Paul saw himself. But then I am called to preach the gospel to the Gentiles. Cartwright, I am my my job is to do these particular things, and now I failed and my career shot.
SPEAKER_05But I'm called to find out the truth and to do the right thing. And and and the calling is given by God. Now I don't recall any religious epiphanies for for Cartwright, but you know, I I think it stands both with Paul and Cartwright. There's this realization of a higher power, a higher significance, transcendence from just themselves as individuals.
SPEAKER_05And I think for me in my head, like that's the difference between career and vocation. Career is something in which I find purpose and I think I'm good at this, and I think I'm doing the right thing and all of these sorts of things. And it derives from me. But vocation is God given, and I know it's much bigger than me. And even though I might lose my career and I might fail, I know that my vocation is much bigger and much longer than just my career.
SPEAKER_05And so in your vocation, there's more liberation and freedom to fail because you know God's given given this to me. And even though I don't always see my purpose in it, I know He who is in control of all things has given it to me. And so those moments in which I don't find purpose, and those moments in which I grieve over my mistakes and failures, I know it's not over. I know I'm not in Sloughhouse or Purgatory or hell or whatever it might be.
SPEAKER_05I know I'm not there because I've been called to this, and he's told me I've been called to this. So I think there's a lot more security and there's a lot more uh trust and freedom in this sense of vocation than there is in career and me finding my purpose and what I'm doing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I and I think like in this show, River Cartwright, he comes from, you know, there's like a family connection, right? His his um, I want to say his grandfather is one of like the great agents in history. And he is supremely talented, but he but there's a mess up, right? And and it's almost like he has this talent, he has these gifts, and he knows it to some to some extent, but then what what what happens?
SPEAKER_01This is why I think like the career vocation discussion is so fascinating, because if it was just his career and just you know, river cartwright as an individual, it's not very hopeful. But when it comes to River Cartwright as someone like with these gifts called to the truth, called to, you know, and I think season one does this, Kyle, where he's he's like caught up in what's going on, and if he's gonna figure out what is actually the truth. There could even be a bigger price to pay because of the people that are involved in that truth.
SPEAKER_01So even while he's trying to salvage his career, he has to make choices about whether or not he's going to commit to this mission. And I think, like, to your point, like we have, you know, vocation is much more relational. It involves, it's it's related to God, it involves the gifts that we have and how they might be used for the betterment of all. So I totally think like season one, River Cartwright, and it continues through the other seasons as well. But um, that to me, it really, really stands out.
SPEAKER_05So, in our remaining few minutes, if I could just introduce, I mean, go back to here, go back to failure here for a second. If I could introduce just a topic for a few minutes, let's talk about a spirituality of failure. How is a Christian supposed to make sense of failure? And I am thinking of someone like Seneca, like a Stoic, who he's not a Christian, but he really has no sense of failure because he believes in some kind of providence.
SPEAKER_05There's fate and there's providence, and he believes in that. So even a pagan, even someone who doesn't believe in Christ or the triune God, still believes that there's no such thing as failure. I think there's many listeners out there, there's many believers out there who believe that they fail. And I think it's a little bit of encouragement to know that there are pagans out there who don't believe in failure, but even more so as Christians, if we believe that God is providential and we believe that God is sovereign and He's in control of all things, then it reorients and recalibrates our sense of failure.
SPEAKER_05And I I'm thinking, at least initially, that there is a difference between making a mistake and understanding what we typically understand as a failure, as a mistake, versus understanding a mistake as a failure. And I think it's okay for us to think that we've made a mistake because biblically and theologically there is a category for mistakes.
SPEAKER_05You know, Hamartzia, missing the mark, you sin, you miss the mark, you've made a mistake. And I think there's a category for you miss the mark, you made a mistake. But I don't know of a biblical or a theological notion of failure. And I don't know if there's a biblical or theological term. The only one I can think of is if failure means that there's nothing in it or that comes out of it, then the best association that I would have would be nihilo, nothingness.
SPEAKER_05And I don't think as Christians we have a category for nothingness, right? God created out of nothing, but ever since God created, there is no nothingness. There is no complete, utter annihilation of anything. Even Satan is not being annihilated, even hell is not being, even the worst of evil is not nothingness, but it's always used for the good.
SPEAKER_05And so I think I think as on a very, very practical level, I think as Christians, we ought to be thinking in terms of I didn't fail, I made a mistake, and I won't make that mistake again. And I've learned my lesson, but also I know that God is going to use that mistake for his good and for my good. Do you have any thoughts?
SPEAKER_01I mean, not too many. I think I'm I'm thinking about the way that you've described this in terms of having the category biblically of a mistake, which is apparent. When it comes to failure, you know, I mentioned before, and I would almost say like coming from the standpoint of the world or pre-existing expectations, like you could describe the cross as a failure from a very limited perspective because you didn't know what was going to come out of it.
SPEAKER_05Right.
SPEAKER_01Despite the fact that there is no failure or even mistake in Jesus.
SPEAKER_05You perceived it as a failure, but it wasn't a failure. But it wasn't.
SPEAKER_01Now, what did Peter think when he denied him and ran away? What did Paul think when he reflected on the persecution of Christians after his experience and vision, and then had to bring himself before the community that he persecuted and try to convince them that he was legit? Those are those are tough tough questions. Or like, how do you think about mistakes and failure there?
SPEAKER_01But but even so, like it transcends our normal categories because whether it's Paul or Peter, like they couldn't help but like continue on because like they were commissioned and called to do something.
SPEAKER_05Right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's where vocation goes beyond this kind of worldly sense of of career and failure. They kept going and they were driven to keep going. And it doesn't deny what they did that was erroneous and wrong. Like that it was just part of their story. And I think it in a sense, like those struggles made their conversion and their response to the vocation like much more compelling to others. And that's why, like, I know it's not the best written or most complete gospel, but it's why the gospel of Mark has always been the one that speaks to me the most.
SPEAKER_01Because when you read that gospel and you realize it starts off and it gives you the, it gives you the the the answer at the beginning. Like Jesus Christ, the good news of Jesus Christ, the Son of God. You know, so it's like he's the Christ, he's the Son of God. But then you go through the whole gospel and it's like nobody understands what that means or what it what it requires. Not even those that were the closest to him. And they all struggle with it. And then it's like, man, if they struggled with it, I might struggle with it too.
SPEAKER_04Yep.
SPEAKER_01But I that doesn't absolve me of like, I have to keep going. Read it again, do it again, keep going. And I think that I think that's really powerful. And then in this show, they've got to keep going. And they've got some of these characters that are trying to motivate them, whether it's the negative neighbor of Jackson Lamb or the seemingly very optimistic neighbor in Catherine Standish, but they have to keep going. Amen.
SPEAKER_05We'll look at the sneaky sin of ambition and the pursuit of family legacy. Until next time, don't be afraid to take risks or make mistakes. Believe that the Lord has got a purpose for you. But also don't wear socks with holes in them. Keep your flatulence to yourself. Thanks as always for listening.
A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...
Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...
Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...
Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...
As the monks tend their barley fields and ferment their yeast, they remind us that stewardship is not abstract theology but a daily, delectable act of worship - bringing creation (and a good grains) to its joyful,...