Wouldn't it be ideal and idyllic to live in a society in which we don't have any secrets? Any and all information would just float out there in the ether for the taking - even by apes, angels, and aliens. Silly mistakes could hang on drying racks for the whole world to see. Everyone would know your business, and there would be no judgment. No shame. No pity. In this eight episode of season four, on common grace in culture, Chris and Kyle continue their mini-series on Alfred Hitchcock films. This episode they analyze Hitchcock's film, I Confess. Christians have to tell the truth - because Christ is the Truth (John 14:6). But the whole truth? And quickly? Perhaps there's room to be forthright and precise without spilling your guts. Which might actually bring hope to a community. + + Welcome to another episode of Two Pour Spirits! Where signature cocktails meet spirited conversations for the sake of the Church and the common good. + + Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor ecumenically educates, equips, and empowers the Church to image her Creator and love all creatures, including her enemies, in public places with particular practices. From soil to sky, crib to casket. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Rev. Dr. Kyle David Bennett and Dr. Christopher Cimorelli. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_05Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the church and for the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the Catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically oriented, and practically minded.
SPEAKER_05We hope that you enjoy the conversation and camaraderie of two poor spirits, and make no apologies for the background noises that mark our fellowship, the clinking of ice and sloshing of liquid among them. Let's build up together. Visit projectneighor.org to learn more.
SPEAKER_00Do many of us have a predilection to hate refugees? Do pastors have an obligation to respect confidentiality? What does a business suit tell you about someone's desire? In this eighth episode of season four on Common Grace in Culture, Chris and I will be talking about Alfred Hitchcock's film, I Confess. A story about love, sacred vows, forgiveness, and justice.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to another episode of Two Poor Spirits. Chris, as always, it is scrum trillescent to be podcasting and fellowshipping. We've got some liquid nectar here in our hands. Why don't you tell our listeners our little secret as to what we're sipping on?
SPEAKER_05Kyle, my brother, it is always a pleasure to be casting. I don't know what word you mentioned.
SPEAKER_00Okay, you got it. I think it's Will Farrell.
SPEAKER_05All right, that makes sense. Um, so today we have a riff on a cocktail. The the original cocktail is called a pan am, but this particular one we are calling Catholicity.
SPEAKER_03Love it.
SPEAKER_05So what's in this? Well, it's got um equal parts of mezcal and bourbon, so an ounce each of mezcal and bourbon. Uh so and also we've decided to use a half ounce of Day of the Lord, our specially spiced cointreau. And I must admit that this batch of spiced cointreau is a bit spicier than normal because, in addition to the regular uh chili pepper flakes, I used some Thai chili pepper flakes.
SPEAKER_00We should just double it every week until we can't stand it anymore, until our mouths are burning in hell.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so we got between the mezcal and the day of the Lord, pretty smoky and spicy. So the the ounce of mezcal, ounce of bourbon, and half ounce of Day of the Lourdes go into a cocktail shaker that's halfway filled with ice, stirred that up a bit, uh, and then in a tumbler with a large cube, I put some dashes of Agnostura cocoa bitters, and then poured in the mixture from the shaker, and then finished it off with a little bit of juice and a cocktail uh cherry.
SPEAKER_00Love it. Yeah. So as I said to you when we took we when we took the uh first sip, uh it was biblical. You you said you you initially said it's complicated, and I said, Yeah, but it's also biblical because that's right. That's right. Immediately I was thinking it was uh not bifurcated, but very well compartmentalized. Like you get you get the mezcal, and then you get just a deluge of spice, and it reminded me of the parting of the Red Sea.
SPEAKER_00Hence the it's biblical. Um, but uh this is my third sip, and I feel like it's getting more complicated. Right. Maybe, maybe, maybe with the salvation of the Gentiles, it's getting more biblical, but everything is coming coming together, like it really is smoothing out. Um, and I'm not getting a ton of layering. I'm uh it it is coalescing and coming together really well, and it's actually tempering the spice a little bit.
SPEAKER_00I think uh I I don't know if you have I agree. Yeah, yeah. It it went from but the first sips were different, right? They were extremely spicy, yeah, uh, which I enjoyed. But as as a whole, like the drink is coalescing and coming together uh really, really well. And I think, you know, we were we were considering a torched orange peel. And I think the maraschino cherry with a little bit of the syrup is a sweet spot.
SPEAKER_05Yes, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I think that is what makes it liquid gold.
SPEAKER_05Well, thank you, brother. I I agree that the first couple of sips, man, there were stages, distinct stages, and the spice really came in um strong.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05But I actually think it, like you said, coalescing, I think is the right word. It's coming together very nicely. I actually, you know, we have some cocktails that that are favorites of ours, but like I would have another one of these because I actually really like it.
SPEAKER_00And I think just because I dropped um we dropped uh season three, episode, what is it, 13, I think this week.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I had congratulated you on be thanking you for all of the drinks that you've made, all of the concoctions that you've come up with, and thanked you for all of these drinks and said, like you're the mastermind of of cocktails and mixes that you can have in any season of the year. I feel like I'm not I'm not just um tooting that horn, but I feel like this as well could be consumed or imbibed in the summer as well as by the fireside in the winter.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_05I I agree, and it's kind of important because the way that Project Neighbor and Two Poor Spirits works is that we're we're meeting right now and it is terribly cold. Like we're we're recording here in January. Tomorrow's gonna be negative eight. Negative eight degrees. And you know, this episode might very well drop in like the summer. So I actually really like that the drinks we have could be used in different seasons because otherwise it would be right not so good.
SPEAKER_00It also aligns, I mean, that that whole theme or scheme schema, it it all aligns with the fact that you have to come up with drinks that you can drink all year round, and you have to become the kind of neighbor who's a neighbor all year round.
SPEAKER_05Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00And on that note, let's transition.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it.
SPEAKER_00So we are um, I would say uh, you know, we're we're in the series of in season four, we're in the series of uh Common Grace in Culture. We've looked at First Aid Kit, a folk band, and analyzed some of their songs. We're looking at Alfred Hitchcock and looking at some of his films, and uh we've begun to kind of have a particular kind of analysis from last uh episode in which we analyzed Rear Window by Hitchcock, and in this episode, we're gonna look at his film I Confess.
SPEAKER_00And I think you noted earlier this wasn't one of his more successful, prominent, celebrated, celebrated film, but I found it to be very, very um provocative, inspiring, even, interesting to for us to discuss. I'm looking forward to hashing out some things that we haven't even thought of. But before we jump into some of the themes that we want to tackle and thinking about them, can you give us a synopsis of this film?
SPEAKER_00Uh just something brief for our listeners.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I'll I'll do what I can. Um, so you have this again, the movies I Confess 1953. So, yeah, pretty early on in in Hitchcock's uh career, he would film other movies much later. But we have uh set kind of in in Quebec. Uh, we have you know French-speaking Canada, we have the setting, and we have um that the protagonist is this relatively young priest, but kind of veteran of the war, uh, World War II, um, Father Logan.
SPEAKER_05And we see this priest, well, the movie starts out with seeing what looks like a priest leaving a building. Right. Yeah. We find out later that the that a murder's been committed there. But we see a cassock leaving a building. Uh, fast forward a bit, we have this Father Logan, and he's in a church, and he sees someone there named Otto, who who works in and around the church, and he wants to confess. He wants to go uh the sacrament of confession. So Father Logan he you know listens to his confession and he confesses to murder um of a lawyer, uh Monsieur Villette.
SPEAKER_05Right? Uh, and so we we hear about this murder to acquire money, which at the time$2,000, about$25,000 today, because he wants this man Otto wanted his wife Alma to live a better life, supposedly. So then the priest hears this confession, and we find out later that he recommends that he returns the money. This kind of a thing. So this murder happens and it shakes the town in which it occurs.
SPEAKER_05And Father Logan goes the next morning when the police are at the scene, and he kind of enters the scene and makes himself known, which the inspector, right, Inspector LaRue finds kind of interesting right off the bat. And very quickly, we start to see that Father Logan, along with a past love of his, whose name is Ruth, who's a socialite of high society. That's biblical too.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. So Father Logan and Ruth are both becoming kind of suspected in some sense, but Father Logan especially is becoming suspected of maybe doing something nefarious. Why is he at the scene? Why is he asking questions? Um, somebody saw a witnesses come forth and say they saw somebody with a cassock leaving the building. And so Inspector LaRue starts to really suspect Father Logan. The way the movie plays out, to try to keep it somewhat succinct, is that Father Logan takes the priesthood and the sacrament of confession quite seriously, and he will not uh violate um the the it's escaping me at the moment.
SPEAKER_05Confidentiality or conscience. He will he will not um violate the seal of the confessional, right? That is sacrosanct uh for Catholic priests, that's not something that you can violate. You can risk excommunication if you do it from the church. And so even though he becomes implicated in it and has the information and the knowledge about what's going on, he will not do anything to take the suspicion off himself and to put it on Otto, who actually did commit the crime. And through all this, there are different dynamics.
SPEAKER_05We learn more about the relationship between Father Logan and Ruth. Father Logan's not helping himself. Ruth tries to help Father Logan by saying somewhat scandalously that they were together the night of the murder murder, but the timeline doesn't quite work out where it actually clears Father Logan. So it only makes him more complicit because it is, as it turns out, the lawyer, Monsieur Villette, was blackmailing Ruth, and Ruth and Father Logan are kind of connected, and now all of a sudden he's blackmailing her, and then he's he's dead.
SPEAKER_05And so the actually Ruth's attempts to clear Father Logan only increase the suspicions in the end, and the movie kind of drives forward from there to a climax in which um I don't know, should I I don't know if I should ruin it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I was just about to say we should preface this episode with spoiler alert. Yeah. Might might as well go for it.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. So spoiler alert for everybody there. We recommend you watch the movie. But the point is, without ever breaking the seal of the confessional, by the end of the movie, we somehow get to a place where Otto inadvertently kind of confesses, thinking that that Father Logan has tattled on him, and he ends up um paying the price and getting shot by the police. But there's a lot of drama in there, a lot of surprises.
SPEAKER_00Important details in between there, yes.
SPEAKER_05So I don't want but the whole thing is though, like I confess the title of the film. It it involves this idea of sacramental confession, but also like self-preservation, implicating others. So it involves like, yeah, neighboring, all of these things that we we deal with constantly. They're like they're implicated in the film. We see a lot of crowds. So there's a lot to talk about here and to break down. And I just um is that okay?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, that that that's great, besides all of the spoiler alerts, but that's fine.
SPEAKER_05I should have prefaced it.
SPEAKER_00We totally got it. We'll put it on the description, we'll put it in the intro. Um, all right. So we're our our theme here with common grace is common grace in culture. And um, let's start with common grace in the cinematics. Let's start with the affection, the aesthetics. The Lord that we serve is the God of beauty, and there's ways in which this film um uses beauty and is beautiful and how it presents things.
SPEAKER_00And we should appreciate that, we should value that, and we should praise the Lord for that. I think one of the things uh that jumped out to me, and I don't know a ton about Alfred Hitchcock, his philosophy. This is the second movie of his that I've seen, and I've only watched one interview with him. I in that one interview I thought was quite brilliant. Um, but I it it doesn't really apply to this. Um, but one of the things, if I'm analyzing analyzing it phenomenologically, one of the things that I've grasped already in watching these two films, uh Rear Window and I Confess, is most of his shots are straight on front uh face in in order to show what seems to me, in order to show emotion.
SPEAKER_00This is intimate, this is emotional, and whether whether the shot is slightly angled and upward or it's straight on, there's a couple shots of Ruth in this in this movie, in which she's tearing up. And so it's I can't remember if there's a zoom there or but it but it's a full-on front shot in order to grip the audience to see the emotion. And I think in most of in most of the scenes in this film in which there is some kind of play or pivot or shift in the storytelling, there's there's a focus on the face.
SPEAKER_00But there's two scenes in the film in which it's a pivotal moment and you get this kind of uh panoramic uh uh outline of the back of someone's head from the perspective of someone else. I can't remember the second one, but the first one is when Alma knows something, Otto's wife, she knows something, and Father Logan is seated at the breakfast table, I think.
SPEAKER_00And she's wondering if he's going to disclose something. And I think she's serving coffee or some kind of beverage. And she it goes from left to right. She's behind him, and the camera scene, the only thing that's in that scene is the back of his head from ear to ear. And it's unlike all of the other scenes and all of the other shots.
SPEAKER_00And which first of all makes it noticeable what is happening here? Why this shot? I'm not used to this, it's not normal. And then there's like eerie music. And I, you know, I don't know what she's experiencing because I don't see her face. You just have the back of Father Logan's head, but it it seems like kind of a guilt gaze. Like, is he gonna tell them what he knows? Because she knows she knows what happened, she knows what happened, and she knows that he knows.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And so I think there's something interesting there with with not seeing not seeing both of their faces and not knowing I mean you get a sense of like a guilt gaze. Like, I know he knows and I'm wondering if he's gonna tell anybody. But you know, you really tell you can really tell if if somebody's guilty by their face, right?
SPEAKER_00But it's almost as if Hitchcock in this moment aesthetically tells you she feels guilt from her perspective without even showing her face just by the way that the camera moves and the background music, or the bac you know, the soundtrack. So I was I was struck by that. I think it happens twice, and I think the other time it's somebody else perceiving Ruth and she's also seated at a table.
SPEAKER_00I think it's the inspector's table. And so I find that really, really fascinating, beautifully done. Like, how do you show guilt? How do you show guilt without a face? And it seems to me like Hitchcock has done that with those two scenes. So that jumped out at me. I don't know if anything jumped out at you. What or what jumped out at you?
SPEAKER_05Well, yeah, I mean, I'm I'm really grateful that you pointed that out.
SPEAKER_00Something should have jumped out at you.
SPEAKER_05No, a couple things did, and I think it's it's great to highlight that scene with Alma because what an interesting character. So one thing that I I probably should have mentioned, but Otto and Alma are kind of refugees from Germany. And this is following the war. And the the the church where uh Father Logan is has been very kind and Father Logan himself has been very kind to them, setting them up with work and uh a life, right?
SPEAKER_05Which kind of raises the stakes a bit because Alma is aware of the guilt of her husband, but then begins to see this person who's been so generous with them become suspicious. She's also wondering, well, he is he gonna is he gonna spill this? Is he gonna say something? But she also feels bad. Yeah, right. So an interesting character to kind of do some um camera work with. Right. Yeah, that's a good point. So I'm I'm grateful you pointed that out. Um, you know, some for me again, you said so many shots were close.
SPEAKER_05So I also paid attention to some of the cinematography. I'm thinking more towards the end of the film when um Father Logan is taking this long walk.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_05The inspector and the police they don't know his whereabouts. So they're kind of assuming is he in the wind? Is he trying to flee? But actually, he's taking this like long, discerning walk. He'll eventually end up at the inspector, the police station, right? But there's one shot from a church, the architecture of a church from really far out, and and the shot goes through this kind of sculpture. of Christ carrying his cross. And you see, and then you see the um the priest walking in the distance.
SPEAKER_05And so you get this kind of sense of his yeah, the connection to Christ and the seriousness of of what he's dealing with. And that even though it's there's such injustice here, um, because of his kind of loyalty and fidelity and his beliefs, he's going to continue on this journey towards his own demise. Yeah. In a sense. So I thought that was a really, really cool scene.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there is I to to keep on to keep on this um aesthetical angle before we move on to maybe my a more moral analysis there is something there is something beautiful and valuable about how Hitchcock uses the camera to paint a face. I mean what what you have in the scene that I've described is it's a back of a head but he but there's a face there he's he's you know it's still a face I guess because it's close up and you you you see the back of Father Logan's head and his neck and it's just there's no face there but there is a face there is there is a a front that's revealing something and in the the scene that you've described right Christ's face and and the Romans and the Roman soldiers are facing the other way too and Father Logan down on the ground on the sidewalk is not facing he's walking like nobody's face is facing the camera but yet having having the cross there and Christ carrying the cross is a face to see Father Logan and what he's doing in that moment.
SPEAKER_00I think there's something theological and something phenomenological there but aesthetically I just like that's really really brilliant how you can captivate a viewer by not showing a face and giving a face like that's pretty remarkable. And I was also thinking too I think I I can't remember if rear window is I believe it's in color I I can't recall. I believe it's in color now the the I confess that I watched was in black and white and a smaller screen.
SPEAKER_00Yeah yeah now that also introduces complications to a viewer it's a smaller screen it's not the full TV screen uh widescreen but my attention was so captivated because all of the shots are close up including the ones of a back of a head and a back of a cross that Christ is carrying like that that's pretty remarkable that he can he can use the camera aesthetically in that in in such a way to captivate viewers in that way so we've talked about common grace in cinematics and aesthetics um but let's transition to common grace in relationships and I thought w one of the ways that we could frame this is to identify negative neighboring and celebrating communion two characters that immediately jumped out to me um and maybe we could maybe we could put them on both sides of the equation if you will Otto seems to me to be a negative neighbor or or he engages in negative neighboring.
SPEAKER_00And you know if Otto is vicious father Logan seems to be seems to me to be virtuous let's talk about some of the ways in which they are Otto is negative is negative in a neighboring and maybe there are there are parts or or scenes or aspects in which Father Logan might not be the best neighbor uh I don't know I I want to think out loud about that um as well as Father Logan being the most virtuous and celebrating communion and cultivating communion but also there are some things that I question like I'm not sure I would handle it that way.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00Do you have any initial thoughts about that? Like is Otto the most vicious character and is Father Logan the most virtuous character Yeah I mean Otto to me is certainly vicious and I want to I'd like to talk part of me things yeah but no I I'd like to talk about Otto for sure.
SPEAKER_05Yeah but I'm really interested in well let's talk about Otto first and then maybe we can dive into Father Logan because it's a very intriguing character to me. Even with what they allow you to think might be possible but then they pull it back. So um with Otto couple things really stand out to me. And again thinking about like the Catholic sacrament of of reconciliation or confession repentance um there's something about Otto that is diabolical nefarious and I don't use that word lightly but like nefarious um he is being manipulative.
SPEAKER_05Yeah that that would be the word that I just through through the whole thing he he's murdered a person he's worn a cassock leaving the scene his explanation for that is that well it would I wouldn't attract notice if I was wearing a cassock. But what exactly are you conveying by doing that? Right?
SPEAKER_00Um to set up somebody else later on he's literally manipulating the office of the priesthood.
SPEAKER_05But to then enter the confessional with what we find out to be his disposition and attitude it shows that true contrition is not has not happened. So as a matter of fact maybe the the confession was rushed but if Father Michael or Father Logan had done more digging in the confessional maybe he ought not have dispensed or or maybe he should have withheld you know the mercy of the confessional and the forgiveness because this was not authentic contrition and repentance.
SPEAKER_05This was someone yeah I feel bad about what I did I'm looking to be able to unload this on someone who I know cannot say anything about it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05And I can get my forgiveness and now I've got this person caught and the way that this kind of speaks to me I don't know if you caught this but his body and his positioning Otto is always like approaching people aggressively he's kind of on top of them needling like you're not can you be that good? I'm not that good. And are you going to say anything? You can't say anything. And he's just like digging and digging and digging and needling and this is a person who you came to forgiveness which again doesn't come from him it's it's supposed to come from God from Jesus through the minister but he is just manipulating and and abusing this relationship and the seal of the confessional and he does this all the time and he's even aggressive with his wife the way that he he grabs her around his arms I was going to mention that.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_05So I mean please do speak to that um but there are two situations with Father Logan where he his this has this kind of like aggressive posturing and reminding him of the seal of the confessional and you better not mess with that and are you really that good? Because I'm not that good but you seem to be that good and so I was like I was disturbed by his character. And then yeah what do you think?
SPEAKER_00Yeah I mean that would be the word that I would use and it it it caught on to me it did not I did not catch that in the confessional and I would actually say that this I think this might move into more the the thinking theologically that we can get to here in a second I'm not convinced that even in the confessional he had he he had thoroughly experienced contrition the the way that I would phrase it is I believe that he confessed to a crime not a sin.
SPEAKER_00Yeah yeah he needed to unload the guilt of the crime not seek forgiveness for the sin. Now we we can get to that here in a second. But but um so I in the in the confessional I did not get the sense that he was being manipulative only in retrospect. Yeah I agree with that yeah so so up to that point I didn't see him being manipulative now which I think this follows the first time follows that scene the first time I thought he was manipulative is when he put when he's confessing to his wife and puts his head into her chest I forget what she says he understands that she's not receiving his manipulation at that point and you see his hands grab her arms and squeeze.
SPEAKER_00And at that point you know this this is your spouse this is your wife and at that point things started to make sense for me like oh yeah like did he confess to a crime or did he confess to a sin and you know you you you manipulated the office of the priesthood by putting on the garb you know and so then the narrative and it it's it's woven throughout he manipulates and one of one of the theological themes I'd like to talk about uh here here in a little bit is one of the ways that he manipulates I think four four times in this film someone says the word pity yeah and at least once he says to Father Logan will you not pity me he and and and that is a form in that moment and with that question is a form of manipulation.
SPEAKER_00You know assuage my fears absolve me of my guilt but but all throughout the movie you don't get the impression that he has confessed to the sin. He does you don't at least I didn't get the impression this is someone who has experienced contrition he's he's he's making moves with everybody's attitude and everybody's conscience and uh seeking his own welfare not the cities if you will um and so I would say Otto is I Otto is diabolical yeah right yeah and and and to your point and to sharpen that point oh just a little further like Jesus being tempted in the wilderness Otto knows the right things to say is it not said have pity on me why aren't you having pity on me right I'm not good enough there's no one who's good save the Father you know like he's diabolical in that sense in the sense that he twists revelation he twists the priesthood he twists the sacraments in the life of the church and uses it for his own benefit about that no I mean I I I I love the way you've brought several elements together in terms of how Otto twists reality and connecting it to you know what Satan does in the wilderness I think is is really fascinating.
SPEAKER_05Love to talk to Hitchcock about that. Yeah right um but he is like the more I think about it like the more disturbed it is um and again also keeping in mind the the like the mercy and the the love that Father Logan and the church has shown to provide for this family that might be maligned just given the fact that they're Germans uh trying to reside in Canada post-war and thinking about the the history or what's in implied about the history of those relationships uh and and what's done uh here to undermine and and kind of diminish communion so yeah that that's what's I just want to say I agree with you there.
SPEAKER_05I am I do want to kind of think about Father Logan as as a virtuous character. You said something before that that stood out to me and I agree. Like you mentioned that he seems to be someone who kind of builds up and and brings people together and supports communion he seems to take his ministry and his duties very seriously throughout and I I did pay attention early on to like when he's with his other priests in their residence.
SPEAKER_05Right? So he is um I I love the dynamics between the priests and you know living together the banter the joking about the one priest who brings his bike bicycle inside and it's just like community life. Yeah and there's something life giving about that with all of the the foibles and the ticks that everybody has and you see Father Logan just thoroughly a part of that which I think is like really nice to include in the film. But then you know Hitchcock does introduce like at least a few elements that like bring you oh should I doubt him a little father Logan?
SPEAKER_05Father Logan you know because like what well we we understand that he was once in love or had a relationship with this woman Ruth and then oh wait a minute he was with her the night before the night when the crime occurred before he went to the crime scene the next the next day and you you start to wonder well wait a minute is this priest um violating the discipline of celibacy is he is he committed to his vows um at least I I was concerned about that right but then through progressive revelations in this in this movie you realize no actually he he he stuck to his vows yeah and when he you know even when he returned they did some flashbacks even when he returns from the war he's changed he obviously is on the road towards ministry yeah and and you know ordination and his life has changed based upon facing death in the war but yeah there there was uh when he comes back there is this like directionality to his life and this commitment which has to be kind of carried out and he doesn't stray from it and he doesn't violate his vows and he um and when it comes to the confessional the seal of it is sacrosanct to him and it's it's kind of it it's surprising now to me it's like you kind of grow up with this idea of the seal of the confessional and maybe we'll talk about it in the theological portion.
SPEAKER_05But it's um it's just astonishing to see someone so committed while Hitchcock is also having you kind of consider suspicions and doubts certainly through the the the police inspector um the the prosecutor as well uh I think even I think even Ruth might have wondered about it if indeed the crime could have occurred after she dropped him off. Yeah that half an hour or whatever right yep there's doubt and I love that the interest that but he himself does seem to be the virtuous person the person pr building up communion with and amid suspicion.
SPEAKER_00I think I think if we had to categorize um or or thematize like what it what is the one vice that auto displays it's manipulation and what is the one virtue and and so manipulation is a is of is a vice of that leads to negative neighboring and a virtue that Father Logan displays and I don't I don't think unsatisfactorily I think we haven't really dived into this but commitment and vow are that is a virtue for celebrating communion and cultivating community.
SPEAKER_01A covenant like we've talked about that in previous episodes like that deep commitment and vow is redemptive it is restorative it it fosters trust and and commitment reciprocally and I think we see that displayed in the character of Father Logan that he doesn't manipulate he takes the trust of others and is beholden to it let's transition to thinking theologically about some of these things I think we're already leaning into that.
SPEAKER_00Yes we are I don't know what you want to start with I there there were two themes for me that jumped out at me and that was which one of which I've already mentioned pity is mentioned at least four times in the film and for me it elicited quotes that I remember from teaching philosophy from Friedrich Nietzsche about pity. And I think most of them come from his book The Antichrist where pity is not something now obviously it's it's problematic you know his his his overman you know like that's that's the problem that he has with pity is when you pity someone you bring them low instead of carrying everyone higher we need people who can surmount all of their difficulties and challenges and not suffer.
SPEAKER_00Just do away with suffering uh be a man be be be be strong be a god um and so pity is something that promotes and encourages suffering and so you ought not pity somebody but it also made me think of like I I don't I I I might agree with Nietzsche like I think pity is problematic but pity is not the same thing as compassion so I think a Christian is called to hospitality compassion not necessarily just pity for somebody right and so there's there's this distinction in my head between thinking theologically about pity versus compassion and thinking theologically about truth telling as you noted earlier I think Father Logan is such a multi layered manifold character with precision though because I think he is a truth teller and I think there are there are circumstances And scenes in which he responds truthfully.
SPEAKER_00And you might say he tells the truth, the whole truth, but not all the truth. But he also doesn't reveal the whole truth. And you know that and you see it on his face that he could say more, but he doesn't. And then there's also times in which he refrains from truth telling.
SPEAKER_00Um like for example, when he tries to withhold information when he when he discourages Ruth from giving more information about their previous relationship. Because it's not pertinent, it's not pertinent. And so you have I I would almost say like he's a truth teller, but he's a he's like a precise truth teller. I'm I'm gonna find a way to not tell you that I have Jews underneath my floor, right?
SPEAKER_00If a Nazi comes knocking. You know, is is that all? Yes, that's all based on the question you just asked me. But there's more information I could disclose and reveal, but I'm not going to do that voluntarily, you know. So like it raised for me the question of like, what exactly is truth telling? Is truth telling telling the truth all the time in all the ways with all of the truth?
SPEAKER_00Or is Father Logan is he virtuous in his truth telling? That he does it in all of the right ways with the right means and the right attitude and so forth. And so I don't know which one you want to tackle. I don't know how much more Yeah.
SPEAKER_05No, no, thank thanks for that. Like I'll I'll speak quickly to the first part and then a little bit more on the second part. Um, I think you're right to kind of problematize pity with this idea of compassion. You know, when you think about pity and what Otto says, he invokes pity, but compassion means to like suffer with someone. Right. And so it reminds me of the gospel where Jesus encounters those who are suffering, and and the way the the scriptures kind of bring it to your mind is that Jesus, like he feels it inside, he's moved, his very guts are moved by the plight of this person, but out of love and out of what their life should be as God's creature.
SPEAKER_05And he's moved to heal them, but these people come to him in faith and openness to the gospel and the kingdom. That's very different from Otto, who does not who's not really concerned about those things. Right. Um, and yeah, so think about the idea of suffering with out of love versus I pity you because you're pitiful.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_05It's a very different connotation. So I agree with what you've what you've raised there. Now, I I love the way you you you kind of triangulated this with Father Logan, because the more that I think about it, the more I have respect for him. Because as the as the audience, you are concerned for Father Logan. Because you're like, this is unjust. Like he knows that this guy is manipulating him, he's gonna get away with it. Father Logan's gonna take the fall, it's not right, we like him, he he all of that.
SPEAKER_05But that's not his primary motivation. His primary it's not taking care of Father Logan. His primary motivation, I think to use the language that you mentioned before, has to do with covenants and vows.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. Right.
SPEAKER_05And what am I supposed to do? Wait a minute, Inspector. I'm not gonna answer that because you don't need to know it. And not it's not pertinent, but actually, strangely enough, uh a converse to that is your question is impertinent.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_05You don't have a right to know that. Right. And I don't want to offer it to you because it's not right, even if it's now going to undermine me.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_05And so this kind of like self-abandonment in retrospect is really coming out to the fore. Yeah. Uh how he could escape these clutches very quickly. But he doesn't. Right. And don't answer that question, Ruth, even though you're married and I didn't know it for a while. Uh that's earlier in the film. But, you know, the the those dynamics are quite fascinating in this film. So um I like that. Like it's really coming out now for me how his what's primary for him in his vows, his duties as a priest, as someone who's heard a confession, as someone who uh has responsibilities to his community and and to those that he knows.
SPEAKER_05So yeah, that's what that's where I'm at.
SPEAKER_00I agree. I think he I think he tells the truth ver he tells the truth excellently, virtuously. Um in those circumstances when the inspector is asking Ruth questions just around a table, not in a courtroom, he is willing to push back and say, you don't need to answer that. That's not pertinent to the case. And also, this isn't a formal juridical examination.
SPEAKER_00We're not in court right now. But when he's in court, is that all? Yes, that's all. He's a matter of fact. And so he plays, I don't want to say he plays the game of the circumstances, but he does that excellently uh and he does it faithfully to those methods and to those places. When you're on the stand and a prosecutor asks you a question, you give them the answer that they ask you.
SPEAKER_00But you don't have to spill your beans, spill your guts. And when they're collecting information around a table, what's your dog's name? And it has nothing to do with the case or the accusation or whatever. You don't have to tell the truth in that way. And I think there is something here that we can learn about truth telling in the Christian life, that it is there are places and spaces in which it's appropriate to tell the truth this way and inappropriate to tell the truth this way.
SPEAKER_00Just if I may jump back here for just one second. It it is so fascinating to me as we as we kind of paper mache this thing is how much Father Logan is like a Christ figure. And and not just a savior who's willing to take the fall as we see through the cross in him on the other side of the road, but as a mediator who brings together a community in various ways through his silent suffering.
SPEAKER_00Right, right. Right? So so there's a mediatorial Christ-like figure in Father Logan, and as we've already noted, a diabolical figure in Otto. Right? And how one is breaking apart an entire community through manipulation, which ultimately results in, I mean, we've already spoiled the entire ultimately results in a covenantal breaking of community.
SPEAKER_00Uh a tragic covenantal breaking of community. But you have someone like Father Logan who will silently suffer based on his vows, based on his commitment, based on his covenant to go to the cross, so to speak, not just as a savior, but as a mediator who brings together community all throughout this film.
SPEAKER_00And I can't I'm I'm just piecing that together now, and I think that's quite fascinating.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, this is something that that's been on my mind since I was watching the film. And you're talking about his kind of as mediator, a Christ-like figure. And I'm thinking about Jesus being questioned and not really offering very much. Yes. Even though it's gonna h hurt him.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_05And the power that he has could be used to secure his own life.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_05The infantry. Are you the king of the Jews? Right. And Father Logan has has the power, should he choose to exercise it, but it would violate the kingdom, it would violate the love, the covenant, the vow. So that stands out to me. What also stands out to me is the power of truth and also how dangerous it is when we only have pieces of it. And and maybe that like that openness to the fullness of truth might be really important here because not many people, I mean, the audience has it.
SPEAKER_05Like you have as the audience person, like you, you know it's happening. You're not waiting for the reveal. Right? There are some aspects of like the background story and whether or not he was with this woman that you don't know. But you you basically know from the outset that he was not this person. So as an audience figure, you're you're sitting there and your emotions are being played with by Hitchcock through this the story. But I'm I'm always reminded of like, wow, if you only have a piece of the truth and you're making all these judgments, how dangerous it is.
SPEAKER_05And you can read that throughout Christian history in a number of ways.
SPEAKER_00Well, I see it seems like you're making an allusion to journalism and social media, and we'll have to tackle that in another episode. You don't want to do that now? No, no, we'll we'll do another episode. Well, Chris, my brother, as always, titillating and stimulating and uh edifying.
SPEAKER_00Um and uh a form of discipleship as we discuss and deliberate. Thanks for all of your comments and remarks. And thank you, listeners, for listening. In our next episode, we will continue our exegetical analysis of Alfred Hitchcock's filmography. I think we're gonna look at his film Strangers on a Train or Birds, uh, something along those lines. Until next time. Always tell the truth in the right way. Love your spouse. Give the kids some cookies, and praise God from whom all blessings flow.
SPEAKER_04Thanks as always for listening to two poor spirits.
A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...
Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...
Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...
Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...
You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...