How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Have Another Beer (Part 1) | Marty Tomzak
51 minAudio
As the ancient Israelites advanced toward Canaan, during the latter phase of the exodus, be'er (בְּאֵר) served as a pivotal staging point where the people rested and received divine provision. “From there they went to Beer, the well where the LORD said to Moses, ‘Gather the people together so that I may give them water’” (Numbers 21:16). Did you know that "beer" means "well?" Well, well, well. In this tenth episode of season four, Chris and Kyle do an excast and interview Marty Tomszak, Lecturer of Religious Studies at Valparaiso University. They talk beer and hospitality, how monastic practices can make us better parents, and how being in a foreign land can inform our sense of stewardship. It's a juicy convo, so make sure you have a few paper towels at hand. + + Welcome to another episode of Two Pour Spirits! Where signature cocktails meet spirited conversations for the sake of the Church and the common good. + + Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor ecumenically educates, equips, and empowers the Church to image her Creator and love all creatures, including her enemies, in public places with particular practices. From soil to sky, crib to casket. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Rev. Dr. Kyle David Bennett and Dr. Christopher Cimorelli. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the church and for the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the Catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically oriented and practically minded. We hope that you enjoy the conversation and camaraderie of two poor spirits, and make no apologies for the background noises that mark our fellowship, the clinking of ice and sloshing of liquid among them.
SPEAKER_02Let's build up together. Visit projectneighbor.org to learn more.
SPEAKER_02All right, welcome everybody to Two Poor Spirits. We are in season four, and this is an X-Cast. And we are delighted to welcome in Marty Tomzak, a professor of religious studies at Valparaiso University and author of a volume just published with Cascade under what I would call a beautiful title, Time, Silence, and Yeast. A song of appreciation for Trappist Communities and Their Beer. Marty, welcome to Two Poor Spirits.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, thank you guys so much for having me and uh for that delightful intro.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm just I don't want to cover up your name, but this is the um very beautiful volume as well. I love the cover. So um, yeah, Marty, I I just want to say I've had the pleasure of knowing you um for a number of years now, uh, through hanging out at conferences in Leuven, especially, but also I think there were a couple in the States, and now you're also connected with my colleague and friend, Kyle. So before we dive into this volume, I was wondering if you could just tell us a little bit about your work, your background, your your general interests, including theological ones if you want to mention them.
SPEAKER_02Don't don't have to get too involved, but I just wanted to see if you could give us a little information here.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Yeah, as as you said, um, we know each other from mostly the Lest conference uh over in Belgium, um, but also a few projects here um through my um who was the person who was my uh dissertation director, uh Colby Dickinson, who is another wonderful soul that you guys should have on at some point. Absolutely um yeah, so I am currently um uh lecturing professor at Valparazo um in the religious studies department, um, a transition that is new to us.
SPEAKER_03Um it was the Theo department prior prior to this year. Um, and I am our uh ethicist on staff. I did a dual program at Loyola. So my PhD was um in uh integrated studies um in both ethics and theology. Um I was on the Theo side but had enough ethics where uh I got hired on at Valpo for that. And basically, um most of my research interests uh revolve around Dorothy Day and the Catholic worker movement.
SPEAKER_03Um so my dissertation and then my first my first monograph uh were kind of looking at the intersections of the Catholic worker movement and uh contemporary um political theology uh on the on the radical side. So um that's kind of where most of my work is done, um especially on the theo side. Um I would consider myself a Dorothy Day scholar. On the ethics side, I do a lot of again radical political theology and kind of um do work that is um a direct relation for me to the Catholic worker in terms of examining um anti-fascist political theology specifically.
SPEAKER_03So um that's kind of yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, thank thank you for for going through that. And yeah, I mean, certainly um right up our alley with thinking about political theology. So we're really looking forward to this. You know, one of the things, Marty, that we like to do, so I've got like a couple more things I want to say to you, but before we we dive in, I just want to ask you, because we're sipping on something that is delectable and the product of care and time and silence and yeast.
SPEAKER_02So um I was just wondering if I'm not sure if you have a beverage there or not, but I was wondering if you could just help the two poor spirits listener, oh yeah, understand a little bit about what we're drinking. Would you mind just saying a couple words for a couple minutes here about about Shimei?
SPEAKER_03Um, no, not at all. I'd I'd uh I'd be happy to. Um so uh let me open up my version of of what you have, which is uh here for the listener or or viewer, um, is our our Chime Blue. Um and this is um a product from one of uh the abbeys, um, one of the Trappist Abbeys discussed in my book. Um I know we haven't had too much of a chance to preview the work yet, um, but basically Time Silence and Yeast is a exploration of um roughly four months spent in uh Belgium and uh the Netherlands as well.
SPEAKER_03Um I got a research grant through Kauluven um to be there for a summer. Um and uh my time at the university was broken up by uh time spent at each of the Trappist Abbeys that produces uh beer to sustain itself uh in Belgium and the Netherlands. Uh and so we're starting here with probably the most famous uh of the Trappist breweries, um, although it depends on who you ask, right?
SPEAKER_03Um uh certainly the largest, certainly the largest producer. Uh Chimay exports to over 77 countries at the moment. Uh and so what we have is a is a true global brand um in the Trappist tradition, which will be really fun to dissect and talk about later, but but for now uh we can talk about the the beer itself, the beer reserve, uh the beer itself. This is uh again Chime Blue, or um essentially that is a short form name for Grand Reserve, right?
SPEAKER_03For Grand Reserve. Um, Grand Reserve is going to be the uh on the higher alcohol side uh for uh Chime and Trappist beers generally. Um it is traditionally, right, traditionally associated with the style of a quad or a quadruple. Um, to what extent that is an accurate um label is going to be a topic for discussion later in our conversation as well, because many of the Trappist uh styles um are their own unique take uh rather than something that beer drinkers here in the States would be able to go by style guide to explain.
SPEAKER_03Um so if you have this in front of you, uh this is going to be um initially when it was first brewed um in the 19th century, the middle of the 19th century. It was initially brewed as a Christmas beer by Chimay. Um, it was uh celebratory of um the nativity season. And because of that, you're going to get a lot of Christmas um kind of flavors and uh aromatics on the notes.
SPEAKER_03So think a lot of kind of like winter spices, you're gonna get some deep chocolatey notes. Um, no chocolate addition, obviously, but um just that beautiful, beautiful roasty character. You're gonna get very nice uh head retention, um, a beautiful white head on the beer that is going to last and kind of hold up, uh, particularly for Chime, which is a unique characteristic of really their entire profile.
SPEAKER_03Um, and of course, you're gonna get the beautiful fruity esters that are associated with the Chimae yeast generally. Okay. Um, very, very unique in terms of each Trappist producer um having vibrant yeast that expresses itself differently from any of the other producers that are uh discussed and included in the book. So you guys start picked picked a good one to start with.
SPEAKER_02Thanks so much, Mark. Amen. So a couple of things. So I I have some preliminary thoughts I just wanted to share with you. So with with Project Neighbor, we look really closely at all things neighboring and how we paradoxically might draw near while making space, all in imitation of and in view of communion with God, who is charitable love.
SPEAKER_02So, in that sense, we tend to talk about uh things like hospitality, stewardship, and practices silence, prayer, listening. Um, Kyle and I are also quite interested in Benedict's rule and the idea of a rule in general, not merely for formal religious communities, but also for individuals and families understood as a domestic church. So we we've had some discussions about this as well. So, given all this, it's not surprising that a number of lines from your book like really stood out and kind of, for lack of a better phrase, smacked us in the face.
SPEAKER_02So, for example, a couple I want to bring up here. Um, listening is tied to welcoming, and hosting is tied to creating space rather than oversight. Okay, that's early on. And then the Cistercian pursual of silence and the cultivation of listening must be sought by all if we are truly to love ourselves and others. And then what's more, you talk about all the legitimate Trappist Abbeys that produce beer share the notion that time, silence, and yeast are foundational to the product itself.
SPEAKER_02And that you can proof the stilte taste the silence. Really provocative language, um, language that for us just kind of goes to the core of Project Neighbor. So we do want to get into the three themes that I've mentioned here of hospitality, stewardship, and practices. And I think Kyle's got a few questions lined up for that. But before we do that, I just want to ask you, can you give us a sense of how this project began?
SPEAKER_02Like what what what made it happen and and how was it carried out?
SPEAKER_03Um, yeah, so I'm I'm really excited to get into all three of those themes because they really get at the heart of not the book project, um, although that is well, but really um the Trappist ethos, as I like to call it, um, from throughout throughout the work. Um, so I kind of mentioned a little bit getting getting the research grant, but um basically to to round out our conversation with regards to perhaps what qualified me to do this.
SPEAKER_03Um so obviously, with discussion of Dorothy Day and the Catholic worker movement, uh hospitality and the discussion of neighborliness, as you guys perhaps more approachingly put it, um, is is central to a lot of my work. Um and beyond that, uh hospitality in the contemporary sense oftentimes is associated with the hospitality industry. Um, and so that is something that I have extensive knowledge of as well.
SPEAKER_03That's kind of the other piece of the puzzle going into this book, and that is the fact that I have spent um more time in the beer industry than I have in academics, um, at least at the professional level. So um I was I was the the first member of my family to go to um a bachelor um university to get a bachelor's degree. And um that being um true because I am a first-generation migrant from Poland.
SPEAKER_03And so when I was going through both undergrad and then my master's program and finally the PhD program, um I was fortunate enough to get assistance along the way through various scholarships and other things, but I always supplemented that income with working in the hospitality industry. Um and so very early on during the craft beer kind of bubble that arose here in the early to mid-2000s, um, in and here by here I mean the US, but Chicago specifically.
SPEAKER_03Um Chicago is has always been a beer beer town, right? Um, whether that's you know um migrant production of lagers and pilsners in in the 19th and 20th centuries, or or like I said, the burgeoning craft beer industry. Uh, and so as I was quite literally working on my MA um at Wheaton College in in patristics, um in in monastic spirituality via St. Basil, etc., uh, I was simultaneously working at craft beer bars and doing my Cicerone certifications.
SPEAKER_03Cicerone is essentially the beer equivalent of a Somalier. Um, and so kind of side by side, um, I was I was doing both. I was doing both. So I was managing at at craft beer bars uh out in the suburbs, actually, during during my MA. And that transitioned into uh working for a couple of of the kind of premier craft breweries here in Chicago, which which included Metropolitan, which is no longer um no longer operating, unfortunately.
SPEAKER_03Um they closed in in 2023. Um, but it was the premier loger house uh in Chicago and arguably in the country. Um and so I learned not just about great beer and great service uh in terms of the hospitality industry, but made made a lot a lot of long-lasting connections and friendships. Um I've also worked at off-color brewing here in Chicago, um, and I occasionally still, even while while teaching, pick up shifts there. So, for example, I'll be I'll be behind the bar at Off Color um tomorrow, and that's where the launch party for the book is happening in a couple weeks.
SPEAKER_03So I'm still very much ingrained in in the beer industry. I have a lot of friends across breweries here in Chicago. Uh, and so that was that was kind of the other piece. That was the other piece, is that I had um more more than a toe dipped into to the beer world here. Um, and so for this grant, essentially um I was able to marry my two passions quite literally. Um, and that is to have the background knowledge of uh the Benedictine tradition.
SPEAKER_03Uh my undergraduate degree was from Benedictine University here in Chicago or the Chicago area. And my first teaching position, as I was discerning the academic vocation, um, my alma mater gave me a teaching gig where I taught courses on the Benedictine tradition. Um so just kind of this this inner interwoven uh nature of both the Catholic theological tradition and and monasticism specifically, um, while also having having the beer knowledge.
SPEAKER_03And, you know, people would uh ask me in various spheres about my two passions. I my my co-workers in the beer industry always found it fascinating that you know I taught theology and that I could talk about you know uh monastic spirituality. And a lot of my colleagues in the academic sphere really, you know, who doesn't enjoy asking and drinking beer, right? Asking questions about beer and drinking beer. For sure. Um, and so really the project was kind of an amalgamation, a quite natural amalgamation of of my two my two interests.
SPEAKER_03Great.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, thank you for sharing that. And I mean, just just also for some background, you know, Kyle did uh did a dissertation with uh Jamie Smith at uh Fuller on uh John Cashin and fasting. Is that right? Yep, yeah, and um phenomenology of fasting. Even even though my dissertation was on Newman, I also spent a lot of time with the um early church fathers and I did a master's on on Gregory of Nyssa and the apathetic theology. So um there's a lot here that is we're we're speaking the same language and we're very excited to hear more about this project.
SPEAKER_02So I actually want to maybe turn it over to Kyle for for a second here because um we want to get into these three themes because we really feel like as we explore these themes, the heart of the book will kind of um you know be apparent to people. And I really do recommend that anybody who's listening and who who has a love for beer and the connection between theology and good beer is willing to go out there and purchase this book. Uh, I'm enjoying it, I'm going through it presently and have found it to be so valuable.
SPEAKER_02So, Kyle, you want to get us started with some thoughts on on and questions on hospitality?
SPEAKER_01We've got a couple questions. Um Thanks for joining us, by the way, Marty. Thank you, Kyle. Um I it's simplistic, but I suppose I I would like to hear from your perspective how you would define hospitality. And so a couple of things that constantly roam in my head is one is an awareness of etymologically, hospitality, hosting, uh hostiles, they're all linked.
SPEAKER_01And like I'm trying to come to terms in my own head of what what what is what is the essence of hospitality? And maybe you could speak to that from your own perspective. But also I don't know much about Dorothy Day. Um if there's something there to introduce here. I'd be curious how you would define hospitality and make sense of those etymological links and if you know that sheds light on how we ought to define it.
SPEAKER_01And then secondarily, I am very interested in monastic practices. And um I haven't spent a ton of time in monasteries, like it seems like you have. And so related to that, I would be curious like what what are some monastic expressions or features of hospitality that you experience that you shed light on your own life of hosting friends and family and whatnot?
SPEAKER_01Like, what is something that can be uh translated or transpositioned that we could learn from monastic hospitality?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Um wow, a great, great series of questions. I'll see uh see how much of that I can tackle. Um no, I mean I I think it's I think it's important that you um brought up the etymological uh roots of hospitality and of hostis, both, you know, in terms of extending um kind of this open invitation, but also etymological roots for, as you pointed out, the enemy, right? Um and and it's not accidental that those things um are related because part of a huge part of of hospitality, at least in the Catholic worker tradition, uh as well as the monastic tradition, is that part of hospitality is is vulnerability, right?
SPEAKER_03And with with vulnerability, you have uh you always have the option of um potentially coming in into harm's way, right? And so that that etymological relationship is is key to point out. And uh it's something that I deal with a little bit um in this book. I do bring up those etymological roots, um, but is something that I extensively deal with in my um work on Dorothy Day. Um, because fundamentally the Catholic worker movement is about um performing.
SPEAKER_03Works of mercy, uh, one of which is uh hospitality, right? One of the central facets of the Catholic worker movement uh are houses of hospitality, right? Um, and the approach of Dorothy and Peter Mauren were um very much in the field of looking at the gospel message as a whole and the gospel narrative specifically, um, and this uh discussion of the coming kingdom of God um as manifestations of radical hospitality, right?
SPEAKER_03The extending of this vulnerability of meeting people where they're at, of providing for both spiritual and physical needs, right? Um, that works of mercy entailed both yes, physical feeding, clothing, right, um, giving drink to the thirsty, etc. But also, right, included um the spiritual works of mercy in terms of um working through relationships with people, right?
SPEAKER_03In terms of giving space for listening, for healing, um, not in a just a physical sense, right? Um, so I have done a lot of work on on hospitality, um, specifically radical hospitality, and uh a lot of a lot of that work um was directly for me at least influenced by Emanuel Levinas, right? Um because you know, you do need to discuss early 20th century um philosophy of the other and Levinas's notion that um hospitality is fundamentally being challenged by the face of the other before us, um, and approaching it with no preconceived notions and a complete kind of blank slate of allowing the other and their needs to shape us, right?
SPEAKER_03So that's kind of where I start in terms of at least the theoretical underpinnings of hospitality. And that's kind of a really rosy way to paint it, because as anyone that has any interactions with the Catholic worker or any other um radical community based in hospitality, the world can be an ugly place, right? And and so this sounds like you know, hospitality is just like, oh, the other is there to challenge me and and shape me and change me. But sometimes the other in in our vulnerability um is difficult.
SPEAKER_03The other is, you know, ugly, dirty, mean, right? You only have to read the long, the long yeah, you only have to read Dorothy Day's The Long Loneliness to get a sense of you know, hospitality is not easy, right? Um, and I think that is a central lesson of the kingdom of God as well, right? This this notion of you know, Christ's message that, you know, even even enemies, you know, even our enemies love their own inner circles, right?
SPEAKER_03What makes us different from them is that we love everyone unconditionally, equally, etc. Right? That is that is the central tie-in of hospitality. Um, so I'll start there in terms of just a general overview.
SPEAKER_01Can I can I piggyback some some questions here and may maybe rope Chris in too? I mean, I so uh that's great. Thank you. Um I'm uh I'm let's take it home in terms of uh you've you've intimated a few of these trajectories of attitudes and behavior in our current culture, like tribalism, like cancel culture. And I guess very just to ask, just jump right to the practical question, like a couple times we've we've talked about the Good Samaritan and we've reflected and meditated on the Good Samaritan.
SPEAKER_01And um, you know, I think there's a lot of Christians that I would say buy into the Good Samaritan if I find my enemy, my unholy enemy, on the you know, in a ditch, I will help them. But I think um more specific and precise to our day and age right now, we hope that we find we may hope that we find them in a ditch, but we're not going to look for them to be hospitable to them.
SPEAKER_01And and I I guess like I just want to I just want to throw that out there. Like we live in a culture in which you know there's canceling and there there's tribalism. Should we be the kind of Christians who seek out our enemies to have conversations with them and to make space for them? Um I'm thinking on the one hand online, but also there's many Christians who hide and just wait for their enemy or a stranger to show up.
SPEAKER_01And then they'll feel convicted and do something about it. Like, is there anything there with your own experience, the monks and Dorothy Day, that you're actively pursuing enemies in order to be hospitable instead of just waiting for divine orchestration or happenstance to occur and then, okay, sure, I'll do this.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, I think I think that's certainly a really a really loaded question in in a number of ways. Um one, I'll be I'll be pretty honest about uh the almost non-existence of my internet online social profile. Um, so in terms of the these kind of silos of ideologies and and um some of the aspects of of our current sphere, um, I'm I'm not as attuned to. Um because again, as as part of the the Catholic worker, um yes, roundtable discussion and being open to challenging one another ideologically is certainly uh a part of what Peter Marin wanted from the Catholic worker.
SPEAKER_03Um, but by and large, radical hospitality from within the Catholic worker revolves around um what I would see as actually an early manifestation of the option for the poor and vulnerable um within the Catholic Church. Uh I don't think it's accidental that there were a number of liberation theologians that were very fond of what um Dorothy was doing. Um so it in that sense, um this notion of having ideological enemies uh doesn't really resonate with me as much as the fact that um combating conditions of inhumanity and poverty um are much more worth my time.
SPEAKER_03I I don't I don't know if that that might be a cop-out for you, but um I I do think that um, you know, unfortunately American Christianity um is kind of distant, at least in my experiences of it, kind of distant from um the liberationist radical ethics that I study and and and teach on, if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_02Marty, uh just picking up on that, um, I'm wondering, and this this gets to the book a little bit as well, there's something about the monks as you describe them. It seems like they have this I mean they're they're fully committed to their beliefs and they have this quiet confidence about their Christianity, but yet that's that's completely interwoven with their hospitality. Like to to welcome anyone, whether it's uh a Buddhist or um so I was just wondering if you could like maybe talk about that in terms of hospitality, like the way that they're not trying to like control and manage every aspect of the encounters.
SPEAKER_02They're happy to welcome you you into their space and you can participate in their rhythms. Um, and they're they're confident in that, it seems. At least that's what I got from it. So maybe you could speak to that a little bit here.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I think that that answers a portion of Kyle's question as well, in terms of what can we garner from them, myself included, right? Is um the Trappist the Trappist tradition is unique in the sense that um any any aspect of the Benedictine tradition, um, whether that's you know the contemporary order of Saint Benedict or the Trappist order, is slightly different than other monastic traditions, uh, because they are cloistered um and because they are a contemplative order, right?
SPEAKER_03And so oftentimes we don't think of them as doing, right? We think of them as thinking, right? The cont the contemplating orders uh work on spirituality, or at least that's that's the assumption. And yet, radical hospitality is part and parcel of the rule of Saint Benedict. And by doing that, um, by opening themselves up uh quite literally as a place of refuge, um, they do indeed have that mixture that you touched on of both um certainty in in the rhythms of monastic life, um, but also opening themselves up to the possibility of of being changed by those that um that visit, right?
SPEAKER_03Um and you know, each community is is different and unique. So um, for example, as as part of the book discusses, um the the house, uh the guest house at Orval, for example, which I think we'll be sampling later, um, is absolutely massive. Absolutely massive. It's not even run by the monks anymore. Um, it's run by the local parish. Um and on the day I was leaving, I was there for quite a bit of time. But on the day I was leaving, um, I distinctly remember there were 42 guests uh at lunch, right?
SPEAKER_03And there were only six of us going to um any of the liturgy or any of the mass, right? Because there is no there is no expectation of we are here to shape our guests. No, that's that's not present there, right? Or Val is a beautiful, beautiful place. The grounds are absolutely magnificent, it's on the crossroads of a number of bike paths, so they have people that go there for retreat, rest, recuperation outside of any sort of spiritual value or spiritual assumption, right?
SPEAKER_03Um, and so the monks really, you know, really are a beacon of having no expectations and yet taking care of all of the needs of those that visit the guest houses, right? So I think I think Chris touched on this a little bit. Um I met so many different people on retreat across my my four months there. Uh, everything from uh a Buddhist monk that was just you know fascinated by Thomas Merton's association with uh both the Trappist tradition as well as as the Eastern, um, the Buddhist monastic tradition.
SPEAKER_03Uh, and so he was there just there hanging out on retreat for a couple days. Um the number of Protestants, when I stayed at Zundert, for example, um, far outnumbered right the guests that were that were Catholic. Um, there were you know plenty of atheists. Um there was an AA retreat at one of these beer-producing trappist communities, right? Yeah. So so like actually that was that was super unique as well. Um, I touch on it a little bit in the chapter on Zoom Dirt, but they were hosting an AA meeting, and so for that particular um evening or two evenings that we overlapped, the monks actually, you know, they asked me, they said, could you not drink in the shared common space?
SPEAKER_03Um, we will bring you your bottles to your room um so that you can do Lecture Divina or or read, you know, um read the rule of Saint Benedict uh with your beer in your room instead of the commonplace, because we realize that this is a potential pitfall for our other guests. Um it was just it incredible, incredible in terms of yes, fully committed to the monastic life, and yet just you know, open to to everyone's curiosity, um, with no expectation, no expectation of change.
SPEAKER_03Um, you know, or Val when I spoke with with Brother Xavier, who's now abbot there, um, one of the quotes that stuck out to me when when talking with him is he was like, you know, we don't we do not expect any sort of spiritual progress, revelation, growth from our guests. We hope that they feel comfortable and invited to take part in the liturgy, and that they uh realize the kind of syncratic nature of our surroundings and what it is that we do in the cloister, right?
SPEAKER_03Um, and that's it, right, as far as expectations go, that they feel comfortable enough to know that they can come and participate with no expectation. Um so in that sense, you know, the experience was was humbling in many ways.
SPEAKER_01There is, I'm I'm just pondering, using the the um the formative aspect and uh actual development and discipleship and just merely making space. Not I mean there there is a hospitality to just making space, not you know, not using your hands necessarily to shape something, but just creating space so that convention and visitation can happen.
SPEAKER_01And it's just no formative, you know. Um so I'm I'm I'm I'm pondering that. I'm also you know, I mean we're we're sipping beer, we're talking about monks, we're talking about beer, and it's like what what's what's popping in my head is like there's gotta be some kind of connection here with, and I'm I'm ignorant in trying to connect it, but I at least am I at least grasping that there's some kind of connection with fermentation and hospitality.
SPEAKER_01Like there there has to be, or like, I mean I know more about distillation, but when it comes to fermentation, correct me if I'm wrong and extrapolate and and carry on as you see fit, but there it does seem to me like fermentation requires various virtues that are necessary for hospitality. Time, patience, kindness in in in the sense of of taking care of the materials and ingredients which you're bringing together.
SPEAKER_01Like, is there in your head, is there is there some connection between the process of fermentation and hospitality? And like, do monks think about that?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, another another great question. Um to answer briefly on the last part, do monks think about that? I I want to make it clear that each and every one of these communities has a very different approach to their vocation, to the beer. So, for example, there are those Trappist communities in Belgium um and and the Netherlands that only the monks are brewing, right?
SPEAKER_03So, for example, um it has since unfortunately closed, uh, which I did make a note um in time for the book to go to print. But at Zundert, um the brewing operations were run entirely by monks. There was no lay staff, right? Um there was help from an outside brewmaster at a consulting level and at the kind of CEO management level, but the day-to-day brewing operations were entirely handled by the monks.
SPEAKER_03And so they would think of that question in a different way than, for example, what we're sipping on here with Shemey, the monks do not have a hands-on uh experience in the brew house, right? The abbot, for anything to be called a Trappist product, it needs direct oversight by the abbot um and um the brothers by extension, right? It needs to be made on or near uh the the monastery grounds, and it cannot be used for profit, right? Those are the three markers for an authentic Trappist product, which is an official designation, right?
SPEAKER_03But for Chemei, right, having oversight over a huge industrial plant does not mean that the monks are taking part in the brewing process in a quite literal way, right? So those are the two sides of the spectrum, and then you have everything in between. So for example, West Fletteran, which is probably you know the most sought after, most famous in terms of uh being people's kind of white whale, right? Uh West Fletteran does uh a one-to-one where there is a monk and a layperson um for each of the processes in the brew house, uh cellar, bottling line, etc.
SPEAKER_03Right. So again, it's a spectrum. So when we talk about how do the monks think about these things, um, we need to be honest about the fact that it's not a simple answer because each community is going to look at these things differently, right? Um, with that being said, um a number of the approaches that you'll see uh is that some of the monks, um, so I interviewed an abbot, um, or uh for the most part it was an abbot, but I interviewed at least one monk from uh each of the places that I stayed.
SPEAKER_03And then for most of them, I also interviewed someone on the lay brewing side. Um, and so getting insight on this question in particular was very important, right? It was in every interview. What do you think about the relationship between beer and theology, specifically beer and your vocation of hospitality, outreach, and sustainability, right? So it was definitely something that I was curious about and came up and uh and came up in in all the interviews. Um, but it is also something that had answers all over the place, right?
SPEAKER_03I was I was thinking like, oh man, this is gonna be great. Clearly, theology and beer are intertwined. This is gonna be a masterpiece, and I found that, you know, really some of the mugs don't care, right? They're like, yeah, right. Um the beer's good. That's that's enough. Well, or the beer's good, and now we're suffering because of it, right? So, one of one of the things that you'll come across in the West Fletteran chapter is they really don't like the fame that they've gotten, right? This notion that they blew up as the number one beer for like 20 years in a row, um, the best beer in the world, was a huge uh vocational stumbling block for them, right?
SPEAKER_03They're like, we're we're monks. Um, we have you know uh our spiritual vocation and we have our vocation of hospitality. And the fact that we sustain ourselves by brewing beer um literally puts a roof over our head, uh, but that's it, right? Um, and and so they had huge issues with um when West Fletteran blew up into this kind of um mythical status, right? Um but then others, right, others very much see an integration between the two of them.
SPEAKER_03West Mala, for example, right? Um Westmala, I think does a great job of allowing right their their spiritual vocation to come through in the beer. Or Letrap, right? Um Chris read it earlier um as a blurb from the book, right? Proof to still taste the silence. It's it's their their beer motto. Um, so again, differing levels of interaction. Um, and I I do try to cover that extensively uh in the book, right?
SPEAKER_03Um ultimately for me, there is a connection. There is a connection. Um, I don't think it accidental that the the created order around us has such beautiful right um products like thousands of varietals of hops, thousands of possibilities of of malt mixture, right? These little critters that were put on the earth known as yeast. Um so I you know, again, I might be biased, but I do think there is a direct connection between fermentation and hospitality and um by extension between fermentation and and theology.
SPEAKER_01Do you I mean I I wanna if if I can press a little further. I I just is there something about is there something about fermentation that can shed light on hospitality? Is it is there something about that process that we can say this is unique to this process. And you know most often when people think about when put people think about for example hosting it's within so I'm speculating you know fermentation requires a lot of time and you know creating the conditions for things to come together.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so there's something there with hospitality that we often think just get somebody in you know in in your dining room for two hours and you're hosting them, you know, but there's more involved in the preparation or there's you know hospitality in terms of fermentation would require six hours, not just two. You know, I guess you know I'm wondering about that. Like is there something for you to you that fermentation here here is something about fermentation that can shed light or challenge or critique our understanding of hospitality.
SPEAKER_03Or two weeks instead of yeah yeah yeah yeah um I think you know a good way for me to think about it is um you do not get the process of fermentation without yeast right um and yeast as a culture uh is unique right is it's unique you can have a general understanding or idea of what a particular yeast strain is going to do um and you can be more and more predictable pr predictable about the outcomes um but you can never be 100% on it.
SPEAKER_03And so if we're touching back on our conversation about vulnerability right uh at the end of the day the yeast the these these four encritters are what drives the fermentation process. And at each of these these Trappist uh breweries um again not only is the yeast unique but you have to allow it to drive the process right so I I do think there's there's certainly crossover there. Um I think patience as both of you brought up in in the question itself um this notion of you cannot rush these things is is another important lesson right um and you know the fact that these producers um and again if I'm getting too technical I'm happy to explain further these producers all use ale yeast right ale yeast is classically uh a quicker fermenter right in terms of the strain versus something like a lager yeast which is used in you know um what's called cold fermentation beers or um lager beers for for short right that it uh works slower right and it takes its time now the interesting thing about Trappist products is they use ale yeast but they put it in lagering tanks almost all of the producers will put the beer in lagering tanks at a certain point to allow it the time and the space to condition and continue doing its thing right so whereas here in the US the idea or not just the US but macroproducers around the world the idea is you pump out as much beer as as humanly possible as quickly as possible and you let you know the the ale yeast ferment out in um you know max six days maybe seven days if you're stretching it right uh and the monks make it a point to say no there are you know various flavor nuances even with ale yeast that will become more prominent uh and more accentuated um that might have been masked otherwise if you rush the process uh and so in that sense just allowing as you said earlier the space for flourishing right um and you know some people might just say oh well it's just beer you know um no I I do think that there is that crossover of um everything from from the ingredients going into it to to the process as the Trappists exhibit it um is is worth looking at um and and certainly there is a translation there for me as an outside observer okay uh frequently over the course of of my time spent in community with the monks a lot of them reiterate time and time again we are a monastery that brews in order to sustain ourselves we are not a brewery with a monastery attached or you know any any variation on that um and so they they do try to separate the two um as much as possible but at the end of the day and this again this is my argument this is not directly from the monks at the end of the day I don't think you can entirely separate the two vocations and I do see the translation of um the Trappist ethos and everything that hospitality um manual labor precision right all of these aspects of the rule of Saint Benedict I do see them coming through in the beer right I do see them coming through in the beer listeners given that our conversation with Marty would go on for a little longer Kyle and I felt it would be a good idea to break up our conversation into two episodes now that we've finished discussing a little bit about Trappist Beer, Marty's book and the theme of hospitality, we'll continue with the theme of stewardship in the next part of our conversation and the following episode.
SPEAKER_02So please be sure to listen to that and thanks as always for listening to Two Poor Spirits.
A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...
Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...
Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...
Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...
You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...