There's the reply guy who believes it’s innocuous but is totally being extra. And the baddie who accepted the promposal and made all the chaperones shake their heads. And the braggadocious Brad who was caught in 4K kicking that poor old man’s Buick, and then blamed it on the bruzz. Oh, and the neckbeard who, for a few chortles from his tribe, revels in rage-bait and ratcheting up online smoke. In this seventh episode of season four, Chris and Kyle record an "excast" on why we need more repentance in our Republic (and a lot less regret in the Church). Not the kind of repentance that just feels sorry for a wrong done or wallows in regret over sin. No - the kind of repentance that turns people from their selfish ways to their Savior. The kind that makes room for others and draws them near. + + Welcome to another episode of Two Pour Spirits! Where signature cocktails meet spirited conversations for the sake of the Church and the common good. + + Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor ecumenically educates, equips, and empowers the Church to image her Creator and love all creatures, including her enemies, in public places with particular practices. From soil to sky, crib to casket. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Rev. Dr. Kyle David Bennett and Dr. Christopher Cimorelli. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_04Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the church and for the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the Catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically oriented and practically minded.
SPEAKER_04We hope that you enjoy the conversation and camaraderie of two poor spirits, and make no apologies for the background noises that mark our fellowship, the clinking of ice and sloshing of liquid among them. Let's build up together.
SPEAKER_00Visit Projectneighbor.org to learn more many of places.
SPEAKER_03We are in the midst of season four, in which our theme and topic is uh common grace in culture and how that is good for the community. Uh we have been looking at various artifacts thus far. Uh we've looked at the I can never remember the Swedish First Aid Kit. First aid kit, yeah. Are they Swedish? Yes. Yes. Duo uh female singers and analyzed quite a few of their tracks and looked for common grace there and some existential and some spiritual questions.
SPEAKER_03And we've recorded uh one episode on Alfred Hitchcock. And uh is that rear view window? Or rear rear rear window, yeah. Every gotta remember all of these. But we are taking an abeyance, instituting instituting an abeyance, at least for one week to do another X-Cast. And it's a very relevant and poignant one in which uh we're shifting from common grace in these various artifacts to then look at just for just for one episode, the state of affairs.
SPEAKER_03And in particular, the state of affairs of our nation, our states, uh, the state of affairs in the church, the state of affairs in the world in this historical moment. And so we're doing our second Xcast here. And uh one of the themes, one of the things that Chris and I have been talking about and thinking about is this idea of repentance. And we're gonna juxtapose it and differentiate it with some things like remorse and possibly regret.
SPEAKER_03And but the heart of it right now in in this episode is whether is the Christian practice of repentance? And are we in a moment in which our nation needs to repent? And the church needs to repent, and Christians need to repent. How as Christians should we see repentance? And is this a regular and ordinary practice? So we're gonna do an Xcast here on the theme of repentance and the practice of it and uh the common grace that's uh embedded in it that exudes from it.
SPEAKER_03But before we get there, Chris, as always, my brother, it is crack a lacking to be chilling with you. Uh we're doing something simple tonight with these X-casts. We like to just uh slow it down, put our hair down, and have a sip of something. So why don't you tell our listeners what we got in this drank?
SPEAKER_04Kyle, my brother, it is always a pleasure and a privilege to be casting. And yeah, as you said, we um we are today doing something simple. So you were kind enough to give me a bottle of Penelope. It's a really nice series of bourbons. Um, the one that you got me was Penelope with orange. Um, so really uh it's like almost like orange wine casks and and flavors that kind of are infused in the Penelope.
SPEAKER_04So we wanted to go with that just as like a sipper. But we we decided to make it slightly more complicated. Uh and so what we did was we took a tumbler, well, actually a large tumbler and put a giant cube in there.
SPEAKER_03That's a huge cube.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's a huge cube. We uh used El Wapo. Uh so we used El Wapo barrel-aged vanilla bitters, a few dashes of that, and then uh a significant pore of the Penelope bourbon.
SPEAKER_03More than two ounces.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, a little more than two ounces. And then I just so happened to get these uh lime wheels, dried lime wheels scent for cocktail garnishes. And um, so we we put one of those wheels in there as well, and then swirled it around and we're sipping on it. What do you think?
SPEAKER_03I th well, so we had a sip before we came on the air here, and I I what and and we were noting, you know, how what what's it gonna taste like, what's the flavor gonna be like after it marinates? And something has changed with the lime and the vanilla bitters. There is something there, like I think when with our first sip, there was the robust bourbon of the Penelope with the orange, and it's a tail end like three seconds after you know it's literally down your throat.
SPEAKER_03Three seconds after that, you get a little hint of lime. And now it's like the lime flavor has moved forward and you get more of the vanilla now than you did before. So I think the more that the bitters have marinated in that, the vanilla and the the um the lime are coalescing, and you know, it's like they're forming some kind of coalition here, and it's it's more robust, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Um, so I think that has changed. I think it's you know, any any uh of the distillations of the Penelope are just fantastic. It's yeah in general a marvelous bourbon. Um, and I also think, you know, the aging in various casks is profound. I've had a few of them. We've had a few of them. What's the one you mentioned earlier? The toasted. Yeah, there's a toasted one.
SPEAKER_04The toasted is good.
SPEAKER_03I think there's a sherry one that we've had as well that's delicious. And this one is delectable. I mean, even without the wheel and without the bitters, we were noting beforehand, just uh sipping on it, it it does have a robust bourbon flavor to it, and yeah, and and the additional distillation or the additional age is actually very excellent and well done. What do you think?
SPEAKER_04Well, I so I agree with what you said. It has changed. Uh, and um, and I enjoy I've I enjoyed it before, I'm enjoying it now. One thing that I I think we both agree on, let me know if I'm wrong. But we kind of wish we had the um Phi Brothers Aztec chocolate bitters. And if we had had those bitters, we would have used those most likely, and then who knows, maybe I would have garnished with a cinnamon stick.
SPEAKER_04And then we would have gotten a very interesting combination of flavors that kind of connects to other drinks we've and flavors that we've done before.
SPEAKER_03I mean, bourbon and chocolate. Like what can go wrong there? Yeah, there's nothing catastrophic that can go wrong with bourbon and chocolate. Yeah, I I think I think you're absolutely correct in that the Aztec ones, especially with the orange, you know, the orange flavor of the bourbon, that would be a really, really nice mix. Definitely.
SPEAKER_03Well, let's dive right in, Chris. I mean, I I don't really have so much of a logical or consequential um sequence to this. It's just that we are in a moment in culture in which things don't look very gracious.
SPEAKER_04No, right?
SPEAKER_03We're we're you know, we're recording this in the new year of 2026. There's a lot of uh, you know, division, there's a lot of tribalism, there's a lot of violence.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And uh we're we're in the midst of this season on common grace, commonality and graciousness. And we define common grace as unmerited favor. There's not a lot of favor going on, and not a lot of unmerited favor. Prove to me you know I'm wrong, show me that you're better than there's there's so much of an antithesis here within our season that we thought it's important to take a moment and say, well, we're trying to cultivate, we're trying to put on the right spectacles to look at these things in a biblical way, in a theological way, in a spiritual way.
SPEAKER_03And yet, so much of what is going around uh around us is people are putting on other spectacles. Let me see everything that's wrong with you, let me critique everything, including your face, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_03It it's it's not a commonality, it's a division and separation and ostracization, and there's not much graciousness going on. Uh, and there's not favorableness in terms of I assume you have goodwill, right? I'm not uh there's there's not a there's not a plethora of extended grace in that way. And so we thought it would be important to pause and and reflect on our moment right now and talk about some of these things, like, is repentance a Christian practice?
SPEAKER_03Is it something that we just do when we're when we give our lives to Christ and we say, I want to be a Christian, and that's the last time you repent? Or is repentant is repentance ongoing? And is it literally a practice that we ought to engage in day in and day out? And as we initially had those rudimentary and inchoate uh conversations, I was thinking to myself, like, well, this kind of ties into remorse for me. I I I want to believe and I think that I see a lot of remorse in people.
SPEAKER_03I wish I wouldn't have done that. But but that immediately sparked for me. I'm not sure that that's actually repentance. And the more I thought about it, I could see some distinctions, some distinctive features between repentance and remorse. And so that just got me thinking: like, here we are in this cultural moment in which there's so much of pulling apart and tearing apart of society and a lack of pursuit of the common good.
SPEAKER_03And so, though we're looking at the arts, we got the problem, we've we've got this problem in the nation and the state and society that inevitably is going to trickle into the arts. So let's just take a moment and reflect upon uh you know the current milou and in moment and how do how does repentance factor into all of this? And so I don't know where you want to start, but I would I I I at least initially want to start with okay, like let's talk about this.
SPEAKER_03And second of all, it seems to me that this is not good. Where we are is not good right now, and there needs to be some unity, there needs to be some healing, there needs to be some reconciliation, and Christians ought to pursue that. Uh, we ought not seek division. God may divide, but we should seek unity and we should seek the building of society. And at least initially, it seems to me like confession and apology and the admittance of wrongdoing and these sorts of things are important to restore that and to build that.
SPEAKER_03So I I don't know, I don't know how you want to tackle this, but let's start talking about it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think thank you, Kyle, for kind of getting us into this. And I think that there are a number of ways we could go about this, but to your point, the first thing that like jumped out to me when you were talking was about the possibility of repentance being like a one-time thing and how resistant I am to that, and I think you might be to that, or at least this idea that you know, scripturally we are called to repent, we are called to believe in the good news, and then we're called to go out.
SPEAKER_04But the idea that that would just be like, hey, a one-off, yeah, good to go. Um, you know, so one thing that was like percolating in my mind as you're talking is something that, you know, I've actually, in my own tradition, uh people like Pope Paul VI and others have talked about this, but to to evangelize, to fulfill one of the fundamental charges that a Christian gets, to evangelize and preach the good news, you also need to be evangelized continuously.
SPEAKER_04And to be evangelized continuously, you need to kind of discern, examine, repent of your sins, and continue to kind of commit to Christ, who is kind of calling to us. The gospel is always challenging us and calling to us, and we fall short of the kingdom in our daily lives, and especially as we uh, you know, unfortunately succumb to sin. So I the first thing again is that it's an ongoing thing.
SPEAKER_04Right. Because even though the idea of repentance, and we'll get into this, involves kind of a reorientation and a turning and kind of committing in a new way, like we can still kind of err and we can make mistakes and get off the path. So we've got to reorient.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04And I think I think God's kind of set things up so that we have reminders and practices and rituals that help us to do so. But but it is a fundamental thing. Like, and I maybe you can get into this a little bit and we can continue the conversation. But what I'm thinking about is if you uphold the idea of like ongoing repentance, we need to keep being aware of this and turning to God, that also kind of indicates or assumes a lot about some of the activities that lead us to repent and also what we're repenting uh in view of, like instead of.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_04And of course, that we we continuously talk about communion.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Right. Uh, neighboring and realizing communion. So I think we should talk about what the opposite kind of does. And you know, so let's what do you think?
SPEAKER_03Well that that's a great uh that's a great uh propulsion. I mean, so one thing I want to note is I like how you and I know within the Catholic tradition, event being evangelized to even as a Christian to a Protestant sounds weird.
SPEAKER_04Very weird.
SPEAKER_03Like I've already accepted Christ. Yeah, you don't need to evangelize to me. But yet it is the hearing of the gospel. You need to hear the gospel all the time and be reminded of the gospel all of the time. And I think that point here in a second, which I'll connect with confession and repentance, is like a Protestant has to affirm that. Why do you go to church every Sunday and hear the word preached?
SPEAKER_03You hear the gospel preached every week, and you need to hear the gospel preached every single week.
SPEAKER_04And we can be convicted, right?
SPEAKER_03We could still be convicted, yeah. Um, and your your your orientation and your mindset and your heart are all recalibrated every week.
SPEAKER_04Oh, I like that recalibration.
SPEAKER_03And you, you know, so so you you do need to be evangelized every week. You need to hear the gospel all the time. Now, that so that being said, like I think there is there's some there's a connection there that's important that Protestants and Catholics, you know, can can see eye to eye on that. Like, we need to hear the gospel every single week, uh, because we need the gospel. We need to be recalibrated in a sense, we need to be reconverted every week.
SPEAKER_03There needs to be a metanoia, there needs to be a a recalibration and a reorientation through the gospel. Oh, right, this is what the kingdom is about, and I'm not living it. Lord, forgive me. I'm not living it. Help me to live it by your spirit. Now, related to that, I think you know, something um, and I I mean, I just want to throw it out there and think out loud about it because I haven't thought about it. In a sense, what's the difference between confession and repentance?
SPEAKER_03Uh, if repentance is a turning away from sin and the devil and death to Christ and life and the kingdom, aren't you doing that every time you confess your sins and say, I confess my sins and I'm absolved by Christ, right? Isn't every confession a repentance?
SPEAKER_03You know? And you know every every Lord's Day at my church, we get we literally get down on our knees and confess our sins. It seems to me like that is a practice of repentance. Um now there's other times in which we do it at home, I do it on my own, but like what is the difference between confession and repentance? And I think I think what what I'm trying to, I'm I'm at I'm I'm genuinely thinking out loud here about that if there if there is a difference or there's a lot in common, but I also think like I'm also kind of like I want to point, I want to point the Protestant in in their eye and say, like, every Sunday that you confess, or every time you get down on your knees and you, you know, fold your hands and put your hands against your bed late at night and you confess your sins, you're practicing repentance.
SPEAKER_03Here's all the here's the lifestyle that I've been doing this past week or this past day. Lord, help me turn from that and live into the kingdom. Help me to not not just commit those sins, not not yeah, not just to commit those sins. Lord, not just help me manage my sins. I want to live, I want to stop living in the realm of death and Satan and the world.
SPEAKER_03And I want to do the right thing and what's coming, and the you know, the the the the a Christian lifestyle. So I lay it all before your feet, get rid of it, I want to turn this. How is that not a practice of repentance every time you do that?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's that's great. Kyle, I mean, and again, I'm not I I don't want to like start a different conversation, but it just reminds me from my own tradition that you know we have this, we describe there there is the sacrament of reconciliation, but it's also called the sacrament of penance, sacrament of confession. It has like multi has so many different names, but but you're you're like homing in on something there that I think is actually quite right, which is the connect they are connections between all these facets of like if you are searching yourself, if you are aware of this kind of wrong living or wrongdoing, wrong saying, whatever it is, things that you've done or things that you failed to do, there there's this prompting, this urging of the spirit to do something about it, right?
SPEAKER_04And to whether it's in in private prayer or whether it's in um liturgy with fellow believers and some sort of public um confession, which goes all the way back to the beginning of Christianity. Um and in and in my tradition, of course, there's the the sacrament itself, the formal sacrament, but there's all of these different aspects are connected, right? Because giving voice to what we have done, the things that we feel bad about, that we know are rupturing relationships, right?
SPEAKER_04But but if you're gonna confess this, there's also this kind of sense, well, wait a minute. No, I actually, it's not enough just to say, well, I've done wrong. There is a will, a desire to try to do better and the intention not to sin again.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Right. Knowing that the sins that you commit rupture relationships, they they they offend God, who is love, they they break up uh communion within churches and families and and you know, workplaces. And so, in a sense, you you have not only again to giving voice to it and confessing it, seeking to do better, to abide by what God has has commanded us to do and and given us the spirit to help us accomplish it, and then to go out and and live it out, yeah, right in a changed way, like if you're doing something differently.
SPEAKER_04So I think the fact, like in my own tradition, that we have three names at least for the sacrament connects to what you're saying very clearly about these different ideas.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I think you're you're raising and we're hovering over a a more diff a more defined notion of repentance, even though I want to ask the question of I mean the difference between repentance and confession when it comes to practice is not all that different. And it's not the the though they're different terms, the behavior and the action is not all that different.
SPEAKER_03When you're confessing sin, you're repenting from that way of life to a different one. Yeah, yeah. Um and uh but but that is you know that is one of the you were hinting at this and we're hovering over this distinction between, which has been in my head, this distinction between repentance and remorse. I think repentance is more than just saying or feeling sorry. I'm so sorry for what I did.
SPEAKER_03And it's more than, and I think this is in the Apostle Paul, this it's more than just a change of mindset. It's not just taking hold, taking captive of your thoughts and a conversion of one's perspective. You know, metanoia is literally the whole body turning, which which implies that repentance and confession ought to result in, I don't do that anymore.
SPEAKER_03And if you don't do that anymore, you commit to not doing that anymore. And then others will also see that you don't do that anymore. So it's far more public. It's very, it's very private in the sense of it's very personal, but it's very public. People will be able to see, you know, you're we're we're not confessing our sins aloud on on the Lord's Day and saying, here's what I did. It's you know, we're confessing them to the Lord, but we will have a changed lifestyle that others will be able to say, Oh, Kyle doesn't do that anymore.
SPEAKER_03Like I haven't seen him, you know. And and and so like remorse is seems to me to be far more individualistic and private and not necessarily it doesn't necessarily lead to a change in behavior that others can witness. Now I've I'm often fast-forwarding during our episodes, but like I I don't know whether or not in this cultural moment people feel remorse anymore.
SPEAKER_03I wish I wouldn't have tweeted that. I wish I wouldn't have said that. What I don't so I don't know if that's going on. If it is, it's better than it not going on. I don't care.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03I'm in I'm indifferent to my wrongdoings, even though I know their wrongdoings, even though I know their sin. I would hope that we at least have remorse and not ignorance or indifference or dismissal of sin and wrongdoing. But I also want to state and assert that remorse is not good enough. It's insufficient. What we need is repentance. I said something I shouldn't have, I repent for it, I won't say it again.
SPEAKER_03I behaved like that in that situation, that was wrong, I won't do it again. So that's fast-forwarding, but I do think there is a significant difference between remorse and repentance, and we can't confuse, we can't confuse or conflate them.
SPEAKER_03If remorse is me dwelling on my own action and how I wish it wouldn't have, I wish I wouldn't have done that. Remorse is like dwelling in that. I oh, I wish I could go back in time and change that. And I think that forfeits or gives up certain other Christian aspects or you know, a Christian mindset of, okay, well, no, I'm a sinner, and I I came to that place, and God can use that even though I'm a sinner and that was wrong.
SPEAKER_03Remorse makes you like stick your face in it, and you can't get out of it. You don't want to get out of it. You don't, you, you, you may not get out of it. You just keep dwelling on that wrongdoing instead of Christ forgave me, I can move on from this. He's working all things for my good, he's reconciling all things unto himself. It's not about me. I made a mistake, it was wrong, and so I repent for it.
SPEAKER_03But remorse can make everything about you and that wrongdoing, and it may not lead you to repentance because you can't give up that wrongdoing. You're so focused on you and that wrongdoing, you can't turn to repent. You have any thoughts?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, no, that that's really helpful. I I'd be willing to admit or allow some sort of initial remorse if it very quickly transitioned to something else that was you know geared more constructively towards acknowledging that we are relational, that we are responsible to God and to and we're supposed to love God and love our neighbor, and to do what we can to try to bolster those relationships, the movement from remorse to repentance.
SPEAKER_03So can I interject yes? So the what the word that I was trying to the word that makes sense for me is contrition. Like it's oh it's uh of course it it's okay to feel contrition. I shouldn't have done that, but I think the Christian ought to be quick to move from contrition to repentance or in confession. And there's so many different ways that remorse can be a dwelling in the past that a Christian should not do, and it can be a way of feeling ashamed in a way that's more than yes, I ate of the fruit, I was naked, I hid from you.
SPEAKER_03You know, okay, come come out and let me clothe you. No, no, no, I can't come out. I I can't I'm I'm too ashamed, right? Like I think for in my head, like that's remorse. I cannot turn to Christ because I'm so focused on my wrongdoing and how bad it was that I can't even, and I may not even get to the point of repentance, but contrition is that was wrong. I shouldn't have done that.
SPEAKER_03I'm ashamed. Please forgive me.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think that that's helpful. And in the kind of preparation for this podcast, you know, you wrote something down about remorse almost being like a repetition of like biting.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, right. Etymologically. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Etymologically. But if you think about it, I think what what might be helpful for people to consider or contemplate is almost like biting can cause injury. Right. Uh, and if it's if it's towards something that we've done, it would almost be like opening a wound over and over again. So you're not allowing the healing process to take place because you keep biting, you keep ripping and opening up a wound that I believe the Lord would want us to try to heal.
SPEAKER_04And this is where it's interesting biblically, right? Because the word metanoia in the Greek is this we translate it for both um repentance and conversion. So in that sense, yeah, to to what you've been saying earlier on, these are connected, right? The whole movement to acknowledge what we've done, but to turn around and live differently, and that's fundamentally hopeful because God loves us and God alone who can forgive us and bring us deeper into communion.
SPEAKER_04So yeah, I I think that remorse could very well be understood as like a vice, uh, a damaging kind of really deleterious vice.
SPEAKER_03I mean, if you're wallowing in something and if if you're wallowing in something and you're wishing it were otherwise, again and again and again, how does that not lead to despair? How does that shame, how does despair not follow from that shame? And I yeah, that's that that that's a great um physical way of, I know etymologically I was thinking about like, yeah, like what is what is remorse in in that Latin etymology, like chewing over and over again.
SPEAKER_03And you know, it is biting, but I I hadn't even caught sort of the aggression and the ferocity of the biting. I was thinking in terms of like you're just chewing over and over and over again in wrongdoing. Yeah. And you can't be nourished by it because you can't swallow it. You know, and it's it's actually antithetical to the biblical notion of chewing on God's word, which is the gospel, which is life-giving, you know.
SPEAKER_03Mull it over, chew the cud, you know, like just keep mulling over the fact that that Christ has done this and saved us from our sins. And you don't have to dwell on that sin from a week ago. You can let it go, you can repent, and you can ask him for the Holy Spirit to empower you and to guide you and to comfort you as you move forward.
SPEAKER_03Now, related to that, I think, I mean, this is a footnote on a footnote, and and we don't have to get into it, but I think it's connected with regret. Like that's what we do when we we regret. I think remorse is far more emotional, and we feel far more ashamed and affectively involved in imagining I wish I wouldn't have done that. But regret is a little more detached, a little more intellectual.
SPEAKER_03And, you know, you know, when I was 15, I regret not sticking with baseball and switching to basketball, you know, like because I see over the course of my life the implications or the consequences of that. And and and you know, so regret is way over here, and it's more intellectualized and it's more detached, and it is a inhibitor to repentance, but I would say remorse, how easily we can confuse and conflate remorse with repentance.
SPEAKER_03And remorse isn't a Christian practice, it's it's not what a Christian should engage in faithfully and long in a long-term way. Um but repentance is, and repentance is something that we should do quite frequently. And I think uh as as I think about what's involved in repentance, I think you know, there's grief and there's guilt. I'm so sorry, I'm I'm emotional.
SPEAKER_03Grief, I'm I'm emotional. Uh I'm so sorry I shouldn't have done this, and I know I was wrong. And as a result of that, as we've noted, I I won't do that anymore. I'm turning from that. I don't want to grieve anymore, I don't want to feel guilty anymore. And there is an outward movement that's involved in repentance that doesn't necessarily follow from remorse.
SPEAKER_03And I think we're we're nearing the the fast-forward part, but like I think we need more of that in society. Yeah, we need more grief, we need more guilt over what we've done, and we need more of a embodied, noticeable display of he no longer does that. I've noticed over the past week, over the past few months, he doesn't do that anymore.
SPEAKER_03He, you know, therefore, we conclude or in he he has repented for that. Yeah, he is he is turned from that lifestyle and that way of dealing with things. And again, go going back to what we said earlier, like that's there's a there's a dearth of that in society, there's a lack of grief and guilt and that turning. We don't we don't see that very often.
SPEAKER_03And I can't, you know, I I I I I I can't believe that because we don't see that, it's still going on, and even if we don't see it, society will be healthy and strong. No, I think we need to see it. We need to see more grief and we need to see more guilt in order for the commonwealth to be strong.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that that's really an important point, and I think it's one we should just take a second to step back from because I feel like, you know, popularly or in culture or society, you know, Christians get a lot of flack for in some sense talking about sin. And and some of that is our own fault. I mean, there there are some groups of Christians where it's like we we use the concept of sin to like, okay, there are these people that I don't like or I don't agree with, and they're sinful.
SPEAKER_04And like, so people see us kind of you know going after those that with whom we disagree. Beating beating them with Moses' staff. That's right. So um, but but the concept is one we so desperately need. The biblical concept of sin, something that misses the mark and ruptures our relationships with the God who created us and who is love and who continues to work for our salvation and has worked through the aeons from the history of Israel, through even joining with us in our condition and and sacrificing himself for our benefit.
SPEAKER_04But I we said before this is a fundamentally hopeful picture that we're talking about with repentance, because it's all about repairing relationships that are stressed and fractured and broken and trying to repair the breach and the ruptures and that restore the streets. That's right. We we are enabled and ennobled to do this because of God's grace and God's love and God's fidelity to us who may not deserve it all the time.
SPEAKER_04So I think, you know, that this reminds me, even when I was thinking about our talk this evening, I was looking at um some old lectures by a theologian, Nicholas Lash, who wrote uh a good book, Easter and Ordinary, but I was looking at his book, Theology for Pilgrims, and he was reflecting on, you know, how could a book like The God Delusion by Dawkins be so successful when he found so many problems with it? But he said Dawkins like lamented our obsession with sin and how backwards it was.
SPEAKER_04And he's like thinking about everything that's happened in the last like 150 years, yeah, and all the war and the famine.
SPEAKER_03How could you not think about sin all the time?
SPEAKER_04Should we not be more concerned about our neighbor? Yeah, should we not be more concerned about the things that we are doing that are breaking down relationships? And to your point, in this moment, it's a fraught moment, it's a tense moment. We're not exactly sure where things are going, but we do know that we need the Lord, we need the gospel, and we need to live as if love of God and love of neighbor mean something.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Right. So I don't think it's I think some might, you know, react automatically and say, Oh, you're so to calling people to feel guilty. And no, it's not about that. It's it's that we are relational beings, we are related to God, who is our creator and our redeemer. We are always in relationship with God, with neighbor, with the natural world, and we we do things and we behave in ways that actually undermine those relationships that we need to thrive.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04And if we don't examine ourselves, if we don't see where we have fallen short, we're not gonna improve anything.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So I don't know.
SPEAKER_03That's that's where I'm and and and I would say, you know, to take take a step back theologically too philosophically and and to some degree anthropologically, okay. You don't want to talk about sin, you don't want to talk about wrongdoing. Okay. Uh, I think those are perfectly fine and human because they're revelatory, human concepts. But what what if human beings never felt grief?
SPEAKER_03Is it a human being? What if human beings never felt guilt? Are they human beings? So it's not just a utilitarian, yeah, right which I'm I'm in total agreement with you, but I want to ask that person who says. stop talking about sin stop talking about wrongdoing and to some degree stop talking about grief or guilt okay but like how do you how do you describe and understand a human being without emotion and without any sense of wrongdoing or right doing what what what is that vacuum of a piece of flesh like is that what you think a full human life is no like I think human beings experience grief and guilt and I would also say to those people you can't run from grief and you can't run from guilt you know your grief might be I have cancer I'm gonna die and you're grieving you can't run from it so even though you don't want to feel it you can't run from it and when you hurt somebody that you really really really love you feel guilty about it.
SPEAKER_03There's no denying there's no there's no human being that can ever be who can ever spill or crack or smash the glass of grief and guilt. They can't no we're we're all gonna feel grief and guilt and I believe that is because God made us in a particular way and when we don't live that fulfilled life we're gonna experience grief and guilt.
SPEAKER_04And that's a recalibration hey you're not living life the way you're supposed to be living come home yeah and I think even if you know I'm sure we'll have to move on in a second here but to kind of really focus in on this how how much well how hypocritical would we be if we tried to deny that because anytime we are wronged or slighted we we want people to recognize to realize what they have done to us and to try to make amends for it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah so to I mean you really you spoke to me right there because it's like it's kind of built into who we are.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah so and it yeah I mean how and that's a great point how hypocritical is it like okay I mean how how many times a day do you say oh what an idiot oh like I can't believe he did that and okay well like you're already buying into the whole paradigm in which someone in which a natural consequence of it is grief and guilt.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it um and and I I I'd like to conclude here with a theme that I'm I'm still I'm still pondering and ruminating and I think it's a really really good theme and we're actually be going to be going to a conference in a few weeks and um doing a roundtable discussion on you know essentially being hospitable and hosting others and there's an etymological link between hosting hospitality and hostiles and hostility how do we do this in an age of tribalism and tolerance and I know probably a handful of our listeners and a majority in society think that tolerance is a virtue.
SPEAKER_03I don't think it is I don't think tolerance really gets at the heart of the matter we can perhaps easily see how tribalism is a problem from one perspective to the other and we don't recognize that well I kind of have my own kind of tribalism even if I'm a person who affirms tolerance tolerance tolerance and anybody who isn't tolerant they're not part of my tribe right so it it seems to me like there is a real problem in society right now with those who are very affirming of tribalism and us them uh and there's nothing in between and then those who are tolerant who sort of want to diminish all difference uh not have disagreements and don't recognize that they themselves are kind of like a tribe and if you're if you're intolerant you're not part of the crew you know and I think as I'm thinking about our round roundtable discussion and thinking about I think there are two vices.
SPEAKER_03I think tribalism and I think tolerance are vices and they don't really deal with the matter and help us to excel as individuals and as society I think that they make repentance difficult in their own unique ways. I think tribalism makes repentance difficult because you're so focused on the antithesis and the antagonism and agonism that you never call into question impugn your own beliefs and perspectives and your own shortcomings and wrongdoing.
SPEAKER_03You're constantly looking at somebody else and saying they're wrong they've got a problem they're not like me and it's never any interior focus which produces arrogance uh and the arrogant person doesn't have any need to repent I didn't do anything wrong I'm right right and so I think within the culture the milieu of tribalism it it's resistant to repentance and I think one other um or at least one uh aspect of tolerance that's resistance to repentance is because tolerance doesn't take seriously you have your convictions you have your beliefs I want to take those seriously you're very assertive about those you think you're right uh you know tolerance says okay put those aside put put those beliefs and those differences aside just can we come together and uh I think there's part of that culture that leads somebody to be habituated to not act on conviction to not have a conscientious objection and to apologize for things that they may not want to apologize for.
SPEAKER_03And so it's feign if they do repent it's a feigned repentance it's not actually I shouldn't have said that I shouldn't have done that it's that I'm being told not to do that. So I'm not gonna do it anymore. And that's not true repentance you know um you're you're not being honest and truthful before God and and and before man before human beings to say this is who I am and I believe that this is right and I did the wrong thing.
SPEAKER_03So I think both of those I think both of those vices create problems for the practice of repentance and we've got to deal with that in society if we are going to repent more yeah that that's that's good Kyle I think when I first thought about this um you know the the tribalism is certainly palpable in our in our present moment as is tolerance but I wouldn't so if if I was thinking about tribalism as kind of a given if someone had asked me what's the opposite of that I don't know if I don't know if I would have said like tolerance um because then you could just as easily almost say well tribalism and then individualism like that could be that could be a juxtaposition but I like this this juxtaposition with tribalism and kind of tolerance in the sense of like some sort of soft universalism or pluralism.
SPEAKER_03Right yeah you know yeah I was gonna say you're right I don't I don't necessarily think that they're opposites but maybe the opposite of tribalism which is a form of such particular engagement that the opposite would almost be like indifferent universalism. Yeah like oh everybody's in everybody ought to be in no matter what or maybe another opposite might be some kind of like cosmopolitan escapism like I just don't even want to have the conversation at all.
SPEAKER_03I don't I don't want to take a partisan stand on anything whatsoever ever. I just want to do my own thing and like you know individualism. I just want to escape from the community and just be my own isolated person on an island.
SPEAKER_04Interesting yeah so I I'm definitely I find the juxtaposition again really thought provoking and worthy of our consideration because again in this kind of milieu where oh tolerate this and if if I say something that's kind of incorrect I mean I might not be feeling personally convicted but I I have to apologize for it. So it becomes very abstract yeah you know and again ideological and of course we're aware of of of tribalism but so I actually was thinking about this idea of repentance and I don't know if you would indulge me for a moment I was looking at um one of Newman's sermons from 1831 on Christian repentance and I thought of it here because again we seem to be in this weird space where again tribalism tolerance or universalism it's these don't seem to be like valuable pathways for us.
SPEAKER_04Yeah so I I grabbed a little thing from Newman from 1831 in his third volume of the parochial and plain sermons and it's on the prodigal son as a model. Do you have an excerpt I have I have an excerpt let's hear it so he says now I insist upon this because the conscience of a repentant sinner is often uneasy at finding religion a task to him he thinks he ought to rejoice in the Lord at once and it is true he is often told to do so he is often taught to begin by cultivating high affections.
SPEAKER_04Perhaps he is even warned against formal service. Now this is reversing the course of a Christian life the prodigal son judged better when he begged to be made one of his father's servants he knew his place. We must begin religion with what looks like a form our fault will be not in beginning it as a form but in continuing it as a form. So let's let's unpack that a bit more for it is our duty to be ever striving and praying to enter into the real spirit of our services and in proportion as we understand them and love them they will cease to be a form and a task and will be the real expression of our minds.
SPEAKER_04Thus shall we gradually be changed in heart from servants into sons of Almighty God. So that's this is the first little part and then the second one's shorter but again this idea of we want to be immediately reconciled but we also need to have the right disposition to be repentant we have to allow ourselves to be convicted and to your points before to feel contrition to seek to confess so that we might convert right and live out differently.
SPEAKER_04So then he says first we must put aside the idea of finding a remedy for our sin. Then though we feel the guilt of it yet we must set out firmly towards God not knowing for certain that we shall be forgiven. He indeed meets us on our way with the tokens of his favor and so he bears up human faith which else would sink under the apprehension of meeting the Most High God. Still for our repentance to be Christian there must be in it that generous temper of self-surrender the acknowledgement that we are unworthy to be called any more his sons the abstinence from all ambitious hopes of sitting on his right hand or his left hand and the willingness to bear the heavy yoke of bondservants if he should put it upon us that's both both of those excerpts are from the same sermon.
SPEAKER_04Same sermon. And and I just I bring it up here because when you talk about tribalism or even this soft you know tolerant universalism it's kind of removing the individual and our and our sin and our guilt from it it's almost like we're trying to sidestep this this being called and addressed by God this examination of our conscience this realization that wait a minute I've behaved I've acted in a manner that's hurting others and is disrespecting my creator I need to do something about this and you know what I don't hold anything over God.
SPEAKER_04I am fortunate to have the opportunity to confess and to repent of my sins and I better hope to be able to do something about it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah I think that that yeah that that's spot on I I think that sermon also highlights for me something I've presupposed and assumed um even in talking about these tribalism and tolerance as vices and the very nature of repentance that this is all spiritual it's all spiritual issue it's not intellectual per se but when you talk about surrender and you talk about begging as as he as as he used those terms um these are very and affect you know and form and like these these are um these are very emotional and spiritual and literally the right spirit of repentance that that I I I was just assuming and presupposing but it is it's a spiritual issue and they're both spiritual diseases tolerance and tribalism and how easily we can intellectualize them and say oh well like tribalism is essentially just like the church against the world it's it's about truth against falsehood without any spirit of humility or curiosity right or investigation or uh perhaps the spirit is speaking through you know someone in the world who is not part of the church but maybe someday might I mean we have this theme again and again and again and it's almost like um it's it's almost like a Jonah spirit tribalism is at least you know like why would you want them to repent I don't want them to repent you know I I'm I'm not gonna I'm not gonna preach the gospel to them come on you like look you know that they don't deserve it there there's at least in tribalism there is this there is this Jonah spirit this Jonah attitude of this is so holy and sacred and by the way I'm enjoying the benefits and fruits of it do you really want to give it to the Ninevites you know they don't deserve it right and it it's a very um um antithetical attitude to the gospel yeah yeah that's and and you know I don't know what the equivalent right now off the top of my head would be for tolerance but you know it it is spiritual they're both spiritual diseases that don't take seriously the fact that truth matters but but you can't claim the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth and nobody else has it can have it or will have it now and forever you know like that there there is a demonic yeah there is a demonic spirit to that tribalism and I would say there's also a demonic spirit to look none of that matters at the end of the day as long as we can get along the truth doesn't matter you know everybody if you can just please yourselves and everybody stays in their homes and doesn't do anything that stirs up trouble in the grocery store the park this will all work out and we'll all be healthy and we'll all be happy and there will be true harmony that's a demonic spirit too you know so I I mean I I appreciate some of those terms because I I think um they really tap into what we have right now in our cultural moment is not just a political issue it's not just an academic or intellectual issue this is a spiritual issue uh whether it's the church or society or our nation uh there is a spiritual disease that is resisting and rejecting and repudiating repentance and we have to confront it and we have to name it we have to name it identify it and confront it that this is not the practice of tribalism and the practice of tolerance are not are not Christian practices but a practice of repentance is a spiritual practice and we ought to be engaging in it well Chris my brother as always it is stimulating it is titillating uh the spirit is always in uh high octane force I feel like when we're deliberating and discussing until next time love the Lord your God with all your heart soul your mind and your strength and love your neighbor as yourself and next time we will resume our analysis of artifacts and the common grace therein with another film from Alfred Hitchcock thanks as always for listening to two boar spirits
A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...
Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...
Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...
Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...
You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...