Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Two Pour Spirits

Two Pour Spirits artwork

The Four Ps: Picking the Proper Place

Jan 8, 202546 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Chris and Kyle continue in their four-part series on the "Four Ps of Disagreement." In this episode, they chat about the obvious: If you can't hear people, you can't disagree with them. But also, if you have to stand for two hours. If the thermostat is turned up to eighty degrees. If the walls are painted pink. If grizzly bear sightings are a possibility. It's a no-go. Disagreement will not be achieved. Because place matters. The room has to be conducive to the heat of the argument. It has to be comfortable when things get uncomfortable. It can't be a distraction. So we have to be wise as serpents in picking where to disagree so that we can be innocent as doves when the stuffing hits the fan. Join Chris and Kyle as they discuss the most magnificent, incredibly terrible, and just plain stupid places to start, continue, and end an argument. Disagreers, take note. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a think tank and training ground for spiritual formation and the common good. Visit Projectneighbor.org to learn more.

SPEAKER_02And they all start with the letter P, because we like alliteration. We said that earlier, right? Yeah. This episode we're talking about place, the importance of place in proper and efficient and productive disagreement. Where should we disagree with people? Where shouldn't we? Should we give any consideration to that? But before we go there, Chris, this cocktail is in the only place it should be, which is my hand.

SPEAKER_02But what is it? What gift have you given this poor spirit over here?

SPEAKER_01Well, Kyle, it's a pleasure to be back together. Um the cocktail that we are enjoying at this moment is a riff on the Boulevard Deer. Um and this one begins well, we call it the ABC. And we call it the ABC because of its primary ingredients. We have Aperol, we have bourbon, and we have Cointreau. Okay, so the Aperol replaces the Campari, um, the bourbon, I guess, replaces the uh the gin that would be in a normal Negroni.

SPEAKER_01Um, and then instead of vermouth, which is something I've had a strange relationship with, I do tell.

SPEAKER_02Like there's a backstory to this.

SPEAKER_01I I I always thought I disliked Kampari because of its strength, but I think vermouth is something that I need to mix carefully. And so I think people who listen to us regularly will realize that I have an affinity for spiced cointreaux. Yes. And so that's what I decided to use in this particular cocktail in a shaker, about 10-20 seconds in there, uh, then poured over a large cube in a tumbler, uh, which I had previously put a little um Agnostora bitters into, and yeah, and then I and finished it off with a cocktail cherry and a little bit of juice.

SPEAKER_02I think that spiced cointreau is like the base, it is the secret sauce. Like, I mean, of all the flavors, I mean it it's elaborately layered. Of all the flavors, that one comes forth most most prominently.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02You know, like and not just spice, but like the spice and the Aperol are like besties and they're hugging in this drink, you know.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And as we're getting ready to talk about place, um it's really fascinating to have this this cocktail in our hands in the studio, so to speak. The dungeon. The dungeon. Um and yeah, these flavors are are kind of mixing together nicely. It's it's not something that you know it it's like a one-off, I feel like. It's it's not something I've had before. Um, but I really am enjoying it.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, me too. Yeah, thanks for making it for me. You you're right, to to run with the theme, each I would say, well, I would say that the Aperol and the Spice Quantro have found their place. I'm not sure that the the bourbon and whatever else that was, you know, has found its place on my palate, but that's okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02It's it's delicious.

SPEAKER_01Good, good.

SPEAKER_02Well, we've already noted as we transition into place, we've already noted that to reach reach disagreement, we need to use uh discretion and prudence in how we disagree with others. You know, we've talked about what's the purpose of disagreement and keeping that in mind, you know, when things get sticky and icky and frustrating, that we remember that the purpose of disagreement is understanding. And we're seeking understanding, we're seeking truth. We also discussed um a few episodes back picking the right people who we d you know disagree with and uh starting it, you know, being mindful and being um um not cautious but but cautious, um but but using discretion in the kind of people that we initially engage in to disagree with.

SPEAKER_02Um if we know them to be vi vicious and not virtuous people to uh we might, you know, that might give us pause and in disagreeing with them, that we have to pick the right people to start disagreeing with. We also have to pick the right people or know when to stop seeking disagreement because this is not, you know, this is gonna come to a stalemate or you know, this is gonna come to a call-de-sac intellectually, and we're not gonna get anywhere with this. Um, so we need we need to use discernment and discretion in continuing to disagree.

SPEAKER_02But we also have to, I mean, I think as we think about embodiment and we think holistically about disagreement, not just words coming out of people's mouths and ideas being thrown at each other's at each other's foreheads, that we have to discern that that uh and determine that there are right and wrong places to dis to disagree. There are some places that are conducive to disagreement and some places that preclude and prohibit disagreement for whatever reason.

SPEAKER_02Um you know, and facilitate, are able to facilitate understanding. Um place um matters for whether or not we are able to disagree and to what disagreement we come to. Um and so as I've been thinking about these things, if I could just throw out Chris sort of a framework in which I've been thinking about these things is that A, first of all, the place really does matter more than we think it does.

SPEAKER_02You cannot disagree, you cannot understand, you cannot even hear people in certain places. And if though if you know if those elemental um elements aren't already there, it's gonna it's gonna be incredibly difficult to come to an understanding or an or a meeting of the minds, at least. And so I can think of three aspects or attributes of places that matter for disagreement, matter for understanding, matter for hearing someone and engaging in a conversation.

SPEAKER_02One is the sound, like are you able to hear someone? That's gonna matter. You know, we talked about listening as um an important tool in disagreement. If you can't hear somebody, if you can't listen to somebody, how can you ever reach disagreement? I also think the space itself, the furniture of the room, so to speak, uh, the comfort by which you're able to listen and hear someone also matters.

SPEAKER_02If you're in an uncomfortable state, you know, you're gonna be focused on that. And thirdly, I think like, and um I'm gonna have bad things to say about um Cracker Barrel, but you know, there are places in which there's so many things and so much going on, you can't focus on the words and the ideas because there's so much going on in the room. So I think that let's dive into each of those.

SPEAKER_02I think those as much as we might be indifferent or we might say that they're uh insignificant, those things really do matter for how productive and progressive we are going to be in disagreement. Do you have any thoughts?

SPEAKER_01Well, right off the bat, I would say maybe the design is to get you focused only on the chicken fried steak. And that's why I don't go to Cracker Bowl. Yeah. Um no, but but but I think this is really important. And, you know, when we started to go back and forth getting ready for this session, you know, I really I started to think in my own mind, I don't want to be too quick to spiritualize what we're talking about, you know, because when I think about uh silence, um, you know, space and comfort and and like stuff or or the focus that we have, you know, there are all these biblical scenes that that kind of come to my mind.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, and maybe we'll get to them, you know, but but to actually think about the space that you inhabit, the place, right? Um, the place is so important. We don't even realize it sometimes how agitated a particular place gets us off the bat. It's almost like unconscious, right? And so we need to pay attention to these things if we're going to, and again, let's keep this in mind, right? Disagreement, authentic disagreement is supposed to facilitate understanding.

SPEAKER_01Understanding, which can help to lead to communion, which itself is a manifestation of God's kingdom, right? So th this is the kind of journey and the track that we've been tracing here, and um so yeah, if we don't play pay attention to to place, I think we're we're really doing a disservice.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, let's start with um let's start with sound and silence. I mean, I think um these are extreme examples, but like I mean, think about being in a club. You know, like I think a couple times in my life I've gone to a club when I was younger. Uh, you know, loud music, music pumping, you know, um dancing, you know, all sorts of things, neon lights, and you know, I mean, just it sounds like hell now.

SPEAKER_02You know, as I'm older, it's like that's probably what hell's gonna be like, you know. Um but being in a club or something ancillary or something extense extended of that, with loud music or loud noises, is going to make disagreement and understanding and listening very, very difficult. Um so we have to pay attention to you know this scenario, and it might be, you know, uh, you know, I want to meet with you and I want to have a conversation with you about such and such.

SPEAKER_02Let's meet at a club. No, definitely not, right? Um, you know, you might find yourself at a club and uh, you know, or a concert or something of this nature, and you start to get into a disagreement. It might be prudent, it it would be prudent, I think, to say, look, we should we probably shouldn't talk about this right now. Let's save this for later. I want to come back to this, but I can't hear you, and there's a lot going on. So let's just postpone this and you know, let's talk later at the after party, or you know, you know, let's go back to my place and let's chat about this.

SPEAKER_02But I also think there's an there's an other side to this too, a library. A library or a church service, a worship service. These are not venues and times in which to disagree. Uh you know, before church starts, or you know, possibly even after church. Um these are not places in which you're going to you're gonna foster and facilitate the conditions for disagreement to occur.

SPEAKER_02So there can be places in which it's too loud and you can't hear anything, or there's places in which reverence and quietude is uh emphasized that the kind of the kind of conditions necessary for for disagreement, you're not gonna find them in either of those places. You have any thoughts?

SPEAKER_01No, I mean that that really speaks to me because when I first thought about silence, or when there's or in a in places where there is too much sound, you know, I started to think immediately of a place where, as you just noted, it's not a place for really disagreement, but I started to think about liturgy only because there's a a part of the liturgy in which sound is appropriate, and there's a part of the liturgy in which silence is appropriate.

SPEAKER_01And they need each other, and and it one can't dominate the other uh too much. So that was one thing, but I like what you said about disagreement. So the the example that came to my mind right away was my home environment. And I'm just thinking about the kitchen table, which just happened to be in a room with peaked ceilings, and the the across the room was the television. And so invariably, whoever was sitting by the television, whatever they were listening to from the television was coming.

SPEAKER_01Growing up. Got it. You anybody at the table would hear exactly what was going on the television and would have difficulty hearing their own conversation. And the people at the table were always loud, and so they would speak louder, and then the person would raise the volume down on the television, and then there'd be yelling back and forth. So it was not sounds like hell. Yeah, so but it's interesting. So I became used to that as a forum for disagreement at the table with a cacophony around you.

SPEAKER_01But I'll say this it was a draining thing.

SPEAKER_02Oh, yep, I can't.

SPEAKER_01It was not uplifting, it wasn't participating necessarily in communion. Um, it was an affair that sapped you. So, and then the other thing that we would do at my house was especially my father and I, um, go out to the fire pit. Oh, nice certain late nights, and just the disparity or the distinction between conversations at the table, fighting the television, versus being outside with just this silence surrounding you, but with the crackle of the fire and then discussing, disagreeing, and how that was kind of restorative.

SPEAKER_01Charged you up, left you with chills, even if it was good enough. You know, um, so that that's where my mind went was to some ever, you know, ready examples from my own experience.

SPEAKER_02So Fire Pit example makes me think of you know a more philosophical articulation of this. We don't we enter spaces, we enter spaces thinking they're neutral. And that they're just it's open space, and then we fill it. And uh, you know, some might realize like there's a whole host of meaning, you know, that's already here.

SPEAKER_02Um you you walk you you you have the sort of perception of when you walk in a room, it's open and then you inhabit it. And there might be some who acknowledge like paintings and pictures on the walls and say, this room is loaded with meaning, right? But I I don't think even that person realizes the way that spaces, for lack of I mean, I it might be the right word, it's a definitely a provocative word, the way that spaces oppress us or impress or press down upon us.

SPEAKER_02You you know, your your kitchen, your dining room table is pushing down on you in a certain way. And I think too, when you step outside, even though it's all open space and you know you're looking at the stars and the fire, there's also something about the outdoors that's pressing down upon you, right? And it's it's doing something to the nature of what you think about and what you talk about. So even going outside, I mean, we're talking about libraries and clubs and in the kitchen, but that that's fascinating to think about too, that even outdoors in this vast open horizon, it's pushing on you, if you will.

SPEAKER_02It's impressing and pressing down on you in a way that's shaping the things that you're seeing, not just the things that you're seeing, you're not seeing a kitchen table, you're seeing a bonfire, but you're you're also um you're being forced to uh um inhabit that space in a certain way, which which leads to reflection. So I mean, even even if there's no space, if I can say that, if you know, if we're in outer space, we're still the the place and the space is still doing something to us and shaping and forming the kinds of conversations we have and how if and how we're able to have those conversations.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Um place matters. And you know, I I was just in England for a conference and one thing that struck me was going to a typical English pub that I could talk to the people I was with. There wasn't music blasting.

SPEAKER_02No football games playing?

SPEAKER_01No football games, like at least the places I went to. Now I'm sure there are some, especially if the English Premier League is on or something like that. But um the ability to have a conversation in a comfortable environment like that, uh, and we will get to comfort soon, but the absence of oppressive sound was palpable. And I was so grateful for it to be able to hear the people, not have to yell and fight the sound.

SPEAKER_01Um so that's something else that comes to my mind, but but to what you just said, yeah, even the fire pit, it's an environment, right? And and we're inhabiting it and it's affecting us in tangible ways.

SPEAKER_02I think related to that and possibly transitioning into space and comfort, the the the fire pit, you know, as I just said, the fire pit is sort of introducing ideas and topics of discussion to you by just by just appearing there and you you you know, you perceiving it. That makes me wonder as you're talking about these pubs that you're in, which I I I wasn't thinking about in particular. I was just thinking about spaces and places, right?

SPEAKER_02But lighting.

SPEAKER_01Lighting, yeah.

SPEAKER_02What was the lighting like in those pubs? You know, I've been in pubs, you know, where they're kind of like cellars and it's dark and um, you know, but I've also been in bars that or or pubs or restaurants in which the lights are radiating and they're bright and distracting, you know. So I'd be curious, like what what kind of lighting was in that space, in that place? Did you find that distracting? Did you did you find that fostering and facilitating conversation?

SPEAKER_02What was that like?

SPEAKER_01More fostering. Okay. So it wasn't it wasn't overly. Bright, um, especially as we got into the evening. Even a bit muted. It was just it was enough light, you know, um, but not glaring. So, you know, you're sitting there, several people around the table, uh, the chairs are very comfortable. Um, the lighting is not distracting in the least, you know. So I think overall the ambiance, the environment, it's very comfortable, um conducive to conversation.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So you don't you almost don't even notice it.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, that makes me think of um, I mean, more you you want to have a disagreement in your living room or or a pub like this than you do like an elevator. You you know, yeah. You want to have a disagreement in in in the on the comfort of your couch, um, and not in a congested elevator with auditors, people listening to what's going on. Like, you know, so I think those so the like the the space that you're inhabiting, the the meaning of the space, uh, the lighting, um, who's around, where you are, you know, you're talking about sitting down, right?

SPEAKER_02You're sitting. Did you have any disagreements in England when you were in the pubs or no?

SPEAKER_01There there was some political discourse, but more exploration than just sheer disagreement. Okay, yeah. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02I mean, I think if you're if you're in a pub and you're standing, um, or you're you know, you're in a bar and you're standing and there's 50 people in the room and there's nowhere to move, this is not gonna be conducive for a disagreement, you know. But if you're sitting down on a bench at a at a at a table or you're sitting down in your couch um having a conversation, it's gonna it's more likely and probable and perhaps certain that you're going to be able to disagree better than you if you were standing up at a bar with 50 people around or standing up in an elevator with a handful of people listening.

SPEAKER_02There's just conditions and and aspects of the room and the space that are shaping and making things either arduous or easy. Um and I I you know I think I don't I don't I don't I don't love talking about comfort. I don't love thinking about things in terms of comfort. Like, yes, on the one hand, the Holy Spirit is the comforter, just just to get a little theological. But also, like, I don't think as Christians, our you know, a main pursuit of ours should be to be comfortable.

SPEAKER_02Right. Um there will be suffering, there will be affliction, there will be difficulty, um there may be death. I mean um the martyr death, you know. Um so comfort shouldn't be uh a primary category for us, but I do think when we're talking about disagreement, comfort is a reality that comfort in a space is going to lend itself, is going to be conducive to proper and good disagreement.

SPEAKER_02And so if you know, if there's a lot going on in the room and you know, you're shuffling and shifting because people are bumping into you because they've got a beer in their hand, um, or there's loud music playing, um, and you're, you know, you're just feeling um, you're feeling like, oh, this is hot and sweaty and congested and I'm uncomfortable. That's where your focus, that's where your focus is gonna be. That's where you're gonna that, you know, that's where your thoughts and and your affections are gonna be.

SPEAKER_02You're not gonna be able to listen, judge, uh, have a constructive uh response. You're gonna be focused on, oh, I just feel icky and I don't want to, you know, you don't feel at home in that space. And so you're unable to really give yourself to the disagreement. I mean, and and and you know, if I guess maybe one way to frame it is if you have to give yourself to attending to the space, you're not gonna be able to give yourself to the disagreement.

SPEAKER_01That's a great way to look at it. Um a lot of things came to my mind thinking about space and comfort. You know, um what something that's ever present to me is a messy house. With the kids, you know, having young kids, the the toys everywhere, or just throwing things on the ground or not thinking of putting them away.

SPEAKER_02I just want to let you know, nobody else, not none of our listeners have that problem at all. I don't have that problem in my house, nobody else does. Sounds like sounds like a personal problem.

SPEAKER_01What discipline? Um But when when the house is messy like that, yeah, you can't actually, I feel like at least I can't pursue authentic disagreement or even understanding. Yeah, I'm just disagreeable.

SPEAKER_02So um because you're so irate, you're like looking at toys on the floor, and you're like, I can't even do this right now.

SPEAKER_01You know, here we are in this like makeshift studio in the man cave basement, you know, and it's like, but I had to do work to get the space ready. Yeah. You know, it wasn't comfortable enough to facilitate this conversation. Well, thank you for doing that. Well, there were things everywhere, yeah. So that's one thing that came to my mind. Um, and then another another was one of my best friends, still to this day, but went, you know, right after the college years, lived in a room and decided to paint it burnt orange.

SPEAKER_01And so every single one of our friends at the time would take turns just sitting in the room. And we all realized that the room itself made us angry.

SPEAKER_02Why did you take turns sitting in the room? You just mean like you found yourself in the room?

SPEAKER_01It wasn't like he said, Hey guys, come sit down and tell me what he he just he just he painted his room burnt orange, and we all started to talk to each other and we're like, when I'm in that room, I don't feel right. So we decided to test it out, and we realized, wow, that this room just makes people angry. So that so and even the paint in a room. And the paint in a room can affect you. Yeah, um, but but honestly, to think about this, comfort does matter. Yeah, you know, and I'm thinking, you know, pr prayer is an interesting example.

SPEAKER_01And if you want to engage in a sus a sustained contemplative prayer, you have to work with your body. That's one thing that comes to my mind, right? So you can't do something that immediately causes discomfort because it that will begin to be agitated and grow in your awareness to the point where it dominates the prayer. Right. So if your back starts to seize up or something like that, you need to find a position that will allow you to maintain the prayer, right?

SPEAKER_01So the space, the the approach, it all matters, right? Uh it can't be too cluttered of a room, like there, there has to be an environment conducive to to prayer. Um, so I think this stuff really matters, honestly. And and yes, as Christians, we're we're kind of called to be uncomfortable, right? Like we're we're in the world, we're not of the world, we have this dual belonging, right? We're we're part of of these societies, but we also have our eyes on the kingdom.

SPEAKER_01Um, and that's all well and good. But we're also called to manifest the kingdom. And it's very difficult to do that in certain environments, right? So, and if somebody is uncomfortable, they're gonna they're gonna become defensive, they're gonna become closed off, you know. And I you were mentioning this before, and it just totally, yeah, it struck, right? Which which was that if I'm in a room with 50 people bumping up against me or in a subway car or you know, likely I'm starting to perspire.

SPEAKER_01I'm starting to sweat. And that's all I'm thinking about is is the awkwardness of being uncomfortable surrounded by people and starting to sweat. There's there's not going to be understanding and communion based off of this. So um, yeah, I think if if you if we all take a little bit of time and reflect on our experiences of spaces, whether we're comfortable or not, we can start to see that the things that we're we're trying to talk about here, authentic disagreement towards understanding and communion, it really does matter.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So I mean, I think um I think sound, sound matters, um, and the ability to hear things and listen. Um, and so silence, you know, is a is a virtuous aspect of uh place. And as we were just discussing, space and how things are arranged, um, and uh, you know, lend lends itself that lends itself to comfort being a virtuous aspect of place too.

SPEAKER_02And I think going back to my joke earlier, but absolutely true, that the stuff of so sound space and stuff, the stuff of the place or the room uh affects our ability to focus. Um, you know, I have been in cracker barrel a couple times, and like I never got into a disagreement because I was never in a cracker barrel long enough to have a disagreement. But I do remember, you know, just being so, and I'm I'm sure I don't remember how many kids I had at this point, but you know, Andrea's talking to me, one of the other kids is talking to me, and all I can do is look up at the walls and be distracted.

SPEAKER_02There's too much stuff in there, there's too much going on, and I cannot focus. I can't hear the words coming out of their mouth because all of my all of my attention is like, what what what the heck is that? And and then it moves to why are all of the pictures and all of the memorabilia or whatever, why are they all so close together? Why did you have to jam-pack the room this way? Like there's a way in which the room not only oppresses you in its mood, but it oppresses you in its arrangement.

SPEAKER_02And maybe that, you know, maybe there's an aspect to your example too that the paint on the one hand is like it's mooding you. It's shaping your particular mood, but it also leads to another level of abstraction and attention grabbing, and you're like, why the heck would he paint it this color?

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And both both of those, both of those um affects or effects, both of those um you know, condition or prohibit your ability to focus on the conversation in order to have a disagreement, or to in order to have some understanding. You know, I think it it seems like all of this is insignificant. You know, we might we might understand sound, like, yeah, absolutely.

SPEAKER_02I can't disagree with somebody if I can't hear them. Um, and and we might be a little more wary, or um, we might dismiss um the space and comfort, like, yeah, sure, you should be able to sit on a hard wood bench or be standing next to people and still disagree. But I I I I think we certainly have to be aware. I mean, it's all it's all a um an um attentiveness to embodiment.

SPEAKER_02We have to understand that colors and light and darkness and these basic elements of creation shape uh our attention, shape our ability to pay attention. And if a room is congested with all sorts of toys or candy or pictures, it's gonna make it it's gonna make it difficult for us to listen to a human being that we see all the time, one human being in a room of 30 to 50 pictures, right?

SPEAKER_02We're going to inevitably be distracted. Um and so I would not recommend disagreeing in a cracker barrel or the one I just thought of too, is an antique shop. Yeah, you know, I've been in antique shops where like I can't even shop because there's so many items, there's so many products, I can't even see all of them individually to see if I would want this.

SPEAKER_02You know, there's just too much, it's saturated and there's too much here, and I'm overwhelmed. I think the same thing happens in the place when we're disagreeing. We become so saturated by all that's going on, we can't even we can't even grasp the individual words of some of this individual because there's so much that's overwhelming us.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I so I take the cracker barrel example. You love that place, don't you? Well, my my family loves to go there. So I'm sorry, Cimarelli. On family trips, cracker barrel is a stop. We even we even separately drove to Florida one time and ended up at the same cracker barrel from different locations in the country. So um, but that said, I take your point because yeah, there's a lot going on there and there's a lot of noise also.

SPEAKER_01So you're bringing in the sound and the stuff with this particular example. Um but but I will I will say this. Um there are a couple of things going on at the same time here because it can be objects that are in the room, but it can also be other people in the room. Yep. You know, like if depending on what age or stage of life you are, there could be other people that are drawing the attention of the of the person with whom you're speaking. Um, or they could be drawing your attention, right?

SPEAKER_01Um that there are plenty of distractions there, attachments that we might form towards other people. Uh if there's a football game on in the background, yeah. You know, like I I find this at home. Like when sports are on, I just want to veg out, and my brain just wants to just go into the game and people start talking to me, and I I have no interest in listening. But but that said, like I I think there's a couple things. So if you're in the midst of what could be a good conversation, a disagreement that might facilitate greater understanding for yourself, if you're aware of distractions, you might need to change environments.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01To become aware of like I'm being pulled in a number of directions, I don't have uh the capability to handle this conversation right now with with amid the distractions. So I gotta pull myself out, or maybe we can go somewhere else. But equally, I would say that if if we're going on what we've already talked about in past episodes, you know, you're with someone else, you're you're engaging another. If you start to notice they're being pulled in different directions, it might be worth it to say, hey, let's go, let's go outside for a second.

SPEAKER_01Like, let's get some air, let's keep this conversation going. Like um, especially if you know the other person is is engrossed or or captured by some game on television or another person in the in the pub or something like that. So I think there's introspection, but then also awareness of the other that that are can kind of go on here to say, all right, this there's too much stuff in this space that is in in these places that is stealing the focus, stealing our attention.

SPEAKER_01Let's try to shift so we can actually have this authentic disagreement. You know, I think that might be a a possible, you know, practice here.

SPEAKER_02You raise something interesting um that I I would like to at least briefly explore. T V home. Yeah. Right? Obviously, you know, whatever it is, it's a football game or it's James Bond, you know, or it's cartoons. And you can be distracted, or music playing at home. You can turn it off. It seems like the home or private places, you know, out in the woods in your home, um are are places in which you can are are more likely and probable that you will engage in constructive disagreement.

SPEAKER_02I suppose, and I I'm not I'm not proposing this sort of as a a devil's advocate, um, but I want to I really want to press is it I really want to press this question. Is it possible well not possible? Is it uh can we put hope and stake in disagreement in public places? Or are we inevitably setting ourselves up for failure?

SPEAKER_02You know, I I think you know, we go out to engage others in public places. Yeah. What you know, and and we talk about the public square as the place where ideas are meant to be shared and engaged and critiqued. I just want to take a step back and say, given what we've been talking about, are we already setting ourselves for up for failure? You know, when we go before an auditorium of people and give a lecture and we know it's hostile, are we already setting ourselves up for failure in disagreement?

SPEAKER_02Uh when we go to a protest, are we already setting ourselves up for failure? Like, does it always need to come back to a private place in order for us to engage in true, proper, constructive disagreement? Like I I legitimately wonder that given what we've been addressing here.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I I don't I'm not ready to declare on that because you know sometimes your disagreement with another person is then overheard heard by another person, a third party, and it might be meaningful for them. Plant a seed. Yeah, they might jump in or contact you afterward, or you know, maybe the the crowd was mostly hostile to what you're saying, but uh several people really enjoyed what you were saying. That's a good point. I don't know. I'm I'm that that really yeah, that's something I gotta sit with it for for a bit because you know, we we can't always control who's listening um with a legitimate disagreement.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, I I need more time to think about that.

SPEAKER_02Well yeah, no, I didn't think about the witnessing of it. It's it I mean, and and maybe that's something for us to consider too in the future, that disagreement may not necessarily be between you and the your interlocutor. I mean, or or the the um the benefit and and profitability of disagreement isn't just between you and your interlocutor. Right. But when you disagree with an interlocutor, you are witness witnessing to others around you, not just to something big like the truth, you're witnessing to a community that is observing and listening.

SPEAKER_02Um and there's benefit to that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And so when maybe maybe there's a metaphor or an analogy or a concept at work here or could be at play that you know, when you disagree in public, it's like planting seeds. Uh when you uh when you disagree in your home and in private places, it's like watering and pruning. You know, I don't I I don't know, but but I am you know I am perplexed. I I I don't know. I don't know the answer to that question.

SPEAKER_02Um but I do think given what we have enumerated and delineated about space and sound and stuff, like those things matter and and they're things to reckon with and they're significant. And so uh not to say that those things don't happen at home or aren't at home or aren't in pub uh in in private places, but we have more control over them.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02So if we're not setting ourselves up for failure and disagreeing in public places, are we think are we making things arduous and uh uh difficult to land disagreement? That that is something that I would like to think more about.

SPEAKER_01Well we'll we'll certainly have to sit with it and but yeah, this this public facet to disagreement, um, and especially if you think about you know previous episodes and you know how tactics for dealing with um a devil's advocate or or an interrupter. You know, if if you're in a public space and you're listening and you're asking questions, uh and you're you're doing some of the the virtuous specs of disagreement, um that that is that is a witness.

SPEAKER_01And other people who are witnessing it will will become appreciative of that, um, or potentially appreciative of it. So yeah, we I think that's we've we've opened up something we have to think about more without necessarily, you know, yeah, definitively answering it today.

SPEAKER_02Well, this has been a great conversation. Thanks, Chris. Uh, next time we'll conclude this series by considering the importance of the fourth P procedure. Should you continue to have a disagreement when one is entered into over the phone? Should you start a disagreement right before bed at 10 p.m.? Should you have a few drams of bourbon beforehand to get everyone loose, or is that just a bad idea? What's wrong with crossing your arms when you're disagreeing with someone?

SPEAKER_02This and more we'll discuss next time. Thanks for listening to Two Poor Spirits.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Your Seams Are Showing: Loving Our Neighbors through Fashion | Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo

    Nov 13, 202654 minAudio

    A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Embrace Boredom and Boss Better

    Oct 29, 202655 minAudio

    Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Be a Better Colleague

    Oct 1, 202649 minAudio

    Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Don't Make Your Boss God and Your Kids Swag

    Sep 12, 202657 minAudio

    Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: See Your Failures as Blessings

    Aug 13, 202653 minAudio

    You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...

    Credit the people on this episode