Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Two Pour Spirits

Two Pour Spirits artwork

Friendship for the Common Good

Apr 4, 202553 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

You have to know their middle name. And maybe not what they ate for dinner last night, but definitely what makes them tick and irks them. And their birthday. And the names of their kids, if they have any. And a willingness to say, “I can’t do this on my own. I need your help.” You earnestly want to read their book and you would willingly lay down your life for them. In this episode, Chris and Kyle ruminate on friendship, and reflect on their decade+ of friendship. It’s a friendship of familiarity, trust, reliability, and relatability. They say, the face of a friend will make your cheeks stretch and their voice will make your neck turn. You’ll even give them the garage code to check on the plants while you’re away. You kinda love them. Welcome to another episode of Two Pour Spirits. +++ Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor is a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the Church and the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically-oriented, and practically-minded. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Kyle David Bennett and Christopher Cimorelli. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a think tank and training ground for spiritual formation and the common good. Visit Projectneighbor.org to learn more.

SPEAKER_03We are in season two, talking about the family and the common good, and exploring and examining how the family as an institution is good for society, how it builds up other communities, is beneficial and edifying to our neighbors. In previous episodes, we looked, we've we have looked at marriage, we've looked at parenting, we've even looked at sex.

SPEAKER_03And um our neighbors and what it means to be a neighbor and how we ought to neighbor others. This episode we're gonna talk to something, we're gonna talk about something that doesn't seem like it directly relates to uh family and the common good, but it does. Uh we're gonna be talking about friendship. But before we dive into that abstract concept and notion, Chris, I want to get really friendly with this cocktail that you have riffed and mixed.

SPEAKER_03It is my friend. And could you tell me exactly what my friend is made of?

SPEAKER_04Thank you, Kyle. Always a pleasure to be podcasting. And this particular cocktail, this beverage, was inspired by recent trip to a restaurant, and they had a cocktail on the menu, and I liked it, but I was like, oh, I I want to make it differently. So I'm calling this the fall retreat. And in I'm using both senses of the word.

SPEAKER_03Like you think of like a retreat, a time, you know, a space to kind of I thought you were gonna say fall into senses, like the original fall into sin as well as the season.

SPEAKER_04I hadn't thought of that, but that's that's another another thing we might kind of cause you to fall into sin. Yeah, very likely. And um, I was thinking of retreat in multiple senses. So retreat as in you know, a time of refreshment, restoration, uh spiritual growth, this type of a thing, but also fall retreat in that it seems like winter's really quickly approaching. You know, we've had this cold snap. We're gonna wake up tomorrow, the real feel is gonna be negative one. Um I think it's snowing right now, it's probably snowing.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, so retreat and get back to the flavor profile from earlier in the year. So let's talk about this. Um, we have a base of mezcal, so smoky, right? Um, two ounces of mezcal. We have an ounce of the pom, it's Pama pomegranate liqueur. Okay, um, so two ounces of mezcal, one ounce of the Pama liqueur, a half an ounce of our spiced cointreau, and then we have juice from a couple of limes, uh, freshly squeezed into there, and kind of shook that all up, poured it over a large cocktail uh into a large cocktail tumbler with a cube, uh, and then torched an orange peel that had been expressed and you know uh put into the drink.

SPEAKER_04And and yeah, that's what we did. So uh overall, what do you think?

SPEAKER_03Well, I this one is like tang forward. Like it's got some citrus and tang. Um, and I I would say the mezcal comes in the smokiness of both the mezcal and the orange peel comes after. Yeah, you get this rush, this deluge of of citrus and tang, and then it it it mildly ends with the the smoke is not the smokiness is not acute, it's it's not breathtaking, it's actually pretty smooth on the palate, and I would say they blend pretty well.

SPEAKER_03I I would say you probably get more of the citrus and tang than you do of the smoke. Yeah, but they do they do after a few swallows, they do blend well. It's very refreshing. Yeah, I would say that for sure. Um, very refreshing, um, interesting color, you know. I wouldn't have a salmon color. I don't know what it was. Yeah, yeah, it is. Um, which I wouldn't have expected from the pomegranate liqueur. Um, but it's also competing against the Jesus juice in the mezcal, so it's two against one and it's losing.

SPEAKER_04Right. And I also in a perfect world, I would have liked to increase the spiced ponchot to one ounce in full. Uh, but I didn't want it to be too boozy either. So uh there was always that kind of yeah, I'm trying to achieve a balance here. Um, I like it, and I I do like the profile quite a bit. Um, and I and the smoke at the end is a nice yeah, that is nice.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean it I don't know if uh a cinnamon stick would would be the right touch, but it does seem like it would blend pretty well with some some spice like that. Yeah, the smoky after um aftertaste might blend with that well.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, and pop pomegranate. Um I'm excited to have some of this pomela liqueur because we can definitely use that in a couple of different cocktails.

SPEAKER_03You could I mean bourbon.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think that would be the way to go. Yeah, see how it works.

SPEAKER_03Awesome. Well, this is I am amenable to this drink. It is my friend, and you are my friend, and I appreciate you making it for me, so thank you.

SPEAKER_04You got it.

SPEAKER_03As I was thinking through this, uh, let's let's do two things in this podcast. One is let's let's chisel the sculpture of what a friend is and try to identify some of the features of a friend and friendship. And then let's do a um we might need binoculars for this. Like what relevance and significance does friendship have for the common good?

SPEAKER_03And why would we talk about friendship in terms of the family? What's the relationship between friendship and family? So let's start with the features of a friend. As I was thinking about this theme, I want to weave in some classical ancient philosophy that I've learned a lot from in both reading and teaching it about friendship. But also I want to identify for myself, just in sort of an experiential phenomenological way, some traits that I think constitute the essence of friendship, but maybe haven't been discussed in that literature or any literature that I've read on friendship.

SPEAKER_03And I think for me, and some of these thoughts are very inchoate. I just I'm just sort of analyzing, like for me, what what constitutes a friend for me on an experiential level without any sort of dictionary and uh ancient literature reference. So I want I kind of want to do both, throw in some quotes, but also I want to start by just identifying. It seems to me that there's four features of a friend that I would identify.

SPEAKER_03The first is that a friend is familiar. You recognize a friend's face, you know the voice of a friend. They're not a stranger, they're not some that they're not something you haven't heard before, they're not something that you haven't seen before. You can't cuss you can't call somebody thereby, you can't call somebody you've just met a friend.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_03There has to be familiarity. You have to know what their eyes look like, if they have a beard or they don't have a beard, what they sound like, their ticks, what makes them tick. You have to know something about them and who they are. Um and I I think that is often overlooked. One important and key difference between an acquaintance as a f and a friend uh might be the degree to which you are familiar with them.

SPEAKER_03Not just, you know, an acquaint an acquaintance in in your neighborhood, for example, who isn't your friend, you wouldn't say that's my friend, is somebody that you would recognize and you know their voice and and uh so forth, but you don't know how they tick or what makes them tick. You don't know what emotions they feel in in certain situations. Um you don't know much about their upbringing and where they go to church and what they do on a Friday night.

SPEAKER_03But with a friend, there's a lot of familiarity. I also think a friend is someone that you can trust, that they are trustworthy. You would you would let them watch your kids, you would let them uh into your home to water your plants. You could trust them. You could trust them with information that this terrible thing happened to me today. Now you might throw that at an acquaintance, but if it's deep-seated and it's traumatic, I don't think you're gonna do that with an acquaintance.

SPEAKER_03You're gonna do that with a friend. So I think a friend is someone who you're familiar with and someone you can trust. I also think they're reliable. An acquaintance comes and goes. An enemy never comes. You know, I'm thinking that I'm I'm thinking out loud here between trying to distinguish, trying to identify and carve out the friend in contradistinction to the family member, the acquaintance, and let's say an enemy.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_03An enemy is not trustworthy. You might be familiar with your enemy, but they're not trustworthy. Um, an acquaintance, you might be familiar with them, but you wouldn't necessarily trust them with something that's valuable and important in your life. A friend is reliable, and a family member is reliable. But a friend is reliable in a different way, it seems to me. You might tell you might tell your friend things that you wouldn't tell your family because you'd be ashamed of saying those things.

SPEAKER_03And you might not trouble your family to come water your plants while you're on vacation, but you would ask a friend. There's something there's something different going on with a family member than a friend when it comes to reliability. And finally, I think that a friend is someone who is relatable. I think um I don't know which direction I would take this in, but I'm thinking more in terms of emotionally relatable.

SPEAKER_03You get me, you understand me. Um, I've told you things, you've told me things, and we understand each other. And that's again, going back to trustworthiness and and reliability, there's something there going on with a friend that isn't quite the same as a family member. I'm I'm not afraid to say this on the air. You know, like I can relate to you in a way that I don't relate to my family.

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_03Not my nuclear family, but you know, it's just my extended family. There's there's just a different kind of relating that occurs. And I think all of these things are what, at least these four features, are what constitute a friend. In each of them, they're distinguishing and carving out what a friend is in contradistinction to a family member, an acquaintance, and an enemy.

SPEAKER_03I don't think they're comprehensive. I don't think they're airtight, but there's there are phenomena going on there that that help us chisel the face of a of a friend a little more finely. What do you think about any of that?

SPEAKER_04I mean, that that's a hell of a leading. Uh there's a lot there. Sorry, not sorry. No, yeah. And thinking about our our where we're departing from here, you know, I am I think it's great that you brought up our friendship in kind of contradistinction to, you know, typical relationships with family members. You know, it is it is different. And I think one thing that comes to my mind, and I love I love these terms, obviously familiarity, trustworthiness, reliability, relatability, I I think the these are on point.

SPEAKER_04Um, one thing that that really stands out to me is my own kind of changing understanding of friendship, because I was blessed growing up to have a good number of of what I would call best friends, deep friendships, people that I could rely upon in a tight situation, people that I trusted completely. There are still some of these people that I could call today, and I still trust that they would be there.

SPEAKER_04So certainly um that that has that's something that's in my mind, like early friendships, distinct from family. But then when I think about our friendship, it's going nearly a decade now, in which began as work colleagues, but I've had the opportunity to really kind of grow and and explore all kinds of interesting topics and realize uh you know mutual affinities and principles and things like that. So um absolutely I am understanding friendship in a different way because now I'm disconnected from all those early friends.

SPEAKER_04You know, we're all in different places and we all have families. It's like it would be very difficult to have the same sense of familiarity, right, with people that are as busy as I am, if not more. Yep. Um, so one thing I'll I'll pick up on because I don't know if I can systematically approach all of these topics at this point, but I would say, you know, you mentioned uh like this this authentic friendship, true friendship. It certainly involves, I think, a degree of empathy, um, even compassion.

SPEAKER_04So not only if you have these friendships, it helps you to understand another person's perspective, to empathize, put yourself in their shoes. And then in terms of compassion, I would say to suffer with someone, to be there as they uh are going through difficult times, as they're navigating uncertainties, and as you yourself are going through these things to be able to have people there uh to call upon, to rely upon, to get feedback. Uh, sometimes you may not hear what you want to hear, but they're friends and they will tell you maybe what you need to hear.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. So uh that empathy and compassion, even vulnerability, come to mind for me, um, which I think connects really well to other themes that we've been talking about. I know we're gonna get there in this episode, but the way in certain family situations you're vulnerable. We are vulnerable to God in a sense, right? And that's one of the difficulties of that relationship to have such a powerful other present to you and allowing yourself to be vulnerable. Friends do allow you to be vulnerable.

SPEAKER_04Uh, and I think there's a really that that's a gift, right? As we think about how friendship might might relate to family and the common good. So, yeah, I I think those are some of my initial thoughts. I'll stop there for a minute.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, no, that that's good. I I am working, this is unscripted. Um, usually our conversations are, but always not. I mean, this this is more than in uh you know being unscripted. I mean, this is just something I was reading today in Thomas Aquinas and his commentary on the Lord's Prayer. Praying is being vulnerable, yeah. In in in on several layers and stages of being vulnerable to say, I don't have what it takes to give myself what I need.

SPEAKER_03Uh, it's vulnerable in entrusting requests to somebody you can't see. And there's there's something I I don't know, you know, I don't want to say like when we when we're vulnerable with our friends, we're praying to them. I don't want to say that, right? But there's an earnestness and uh an investment in opening ourselves up to our friends that is comparable to opening up ourselves to our Lord.

SPEAKER_03And that is there's something rich and robust there when with respect to friendship. I I think as I said to you earlier before we hopped on this podcast, like I think there's a there's a different kind of affection that is um uh displayed and exhibited in friendship that's different than family. Not to denigrate either, and not to prioritize either, but I'm just what you're saying as I'm trying to grasp it is you know you have a certain relationship to the triune God, and you have a certain relationship to your family, and you have a certain relationship to friends, and all of them are part of your life, and all of them are part of the cohesion and beauty of society, of living in community.

SPEAKER_03All of them have to be part of the common good. Um and so there is there there there's some there's something so unique about friendship and what it brings out of someone, what someone gives in friendship that is irreducible to family. And I think I I don't want to um blaspheme or state heresy, but I think God has made the world in such a way that material physical friends can offer something unique that's different than even what the Lord offers now, maybe it's only historical, now as is as he's sitting uh seated at the right hand of the Father.

SPEAKER_03There's something about friendship that's unique. There's something about family that's unique, and there's something about our relationship with God that is unique and irreducible. So I you know, I'm just trying to I'm trying to um come to terms with how friendship is distinct from what what features constitute it uh that are different from our family, acquaintance, mainly family and acquaintance, not enemies.

SPEAKER_03I mean, I think we can we can carve that out uh uh pretty easily. But family and and acquaintances, and if we we want to say acquaintances are neighbors, like our physical proximate neighbors, not in terms of how we've been talking about it for two seasons, like everybody is your neighbor, right? In a sense, God is your neighbor and your parents are your neighbors, etc. etc. I'm not I'm not using neighbor in that comprehensive.

SPEAKER_03Sense. I'm using it in terms of those whose houses are proximate around you. There's something involved in those relationships that's distinct from friendship, that's distinct from family. But they all play together. They all layer each other. They all have significance for what we get from and give to society. And I think we have to acknowledge that and appreciate that.

SPEAKER_03And possibly even state that if you're someone who doesn't want friends, that's a problem. That's a problem not only for your own wealth, well-being, and health, but you're ruining society by not cultivating friendship.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, no, that this is uh it's a fascinating conversation. I I absolutely think you're you're on target here because I think about society and I think about it a lot. And I, you know, and society is much more than laws or a written document that establishes the contours of the society. Those are really important. I don't want to denigrate them, but the bonds of affection between the people that make up a society are of critical importance, right?

SPEAKER_04And I would encourage anybody out there listening who has these deep friendships, these meaningful relationships, what would life be like without them? Just extricate them, pull them out, erase them for a moment, and think about what life would be. And for those of us who are blessed to have developed friendships with our spouse, imagine life without that friendship, that companionship, right? And and how how life would lose its color.

SPEAKER_04Um, it wouldn't be scented, it would they would lose all of all of that, right? So um I think true friendship is is a gift, and and you mentioned something that really struck a chord with me. And I don't think it's heresy. I mean, I think that God has ordered ordered reality so that we can have and develop these friendships. When Lord, when the Lord became incarnate, yes, he was a teacher, you know, uh, he was the master, but he he got a group of friends together, and they were friends, they were companions, and they endured a lot of the same things and they suffered the same things, and they were honest with each other even when it was uncomfortable.

SPEAKER_04You know, Jesus yelling at Peter because he doesn't get the Messiah right, you know, the understanding.

SPEAKER_03Don't cut off his ear, man. Come on.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, so um the the Lord established a group of friends, and I mean this shows us, and and I think about um, you know, the those those kind of statements that we hear about, and I don't know, I'd have to do some research on this, and I I wasn't thinking of diving into this before the episode, but I remember people say that they they misuse that kind of blood is thicker than water uh statement. Now I'd I'd have to verify this, but people popularly say blood is thicker than water to emphasize family.

SPEAKER_04But if you say the you know the blood of the covenant is thicker than the water of the womb, um now all of a sudden the relationships and friendships that you can develop also with fellow believers uh are hugely important. And we see this in scripture again and again with the early Christians struggling in this uh culture that was against them and trying to form churches and communities and to encourage each other in times of affliction and in ways that are just different from from family relationships, oftentimes.

SPEAKER_03So um Yeah, and I mean it it's scary to to process that he came to bring the sword.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And to separate um husband and wife, and wife and child, and individuals from communities, and he's he's he is rebuilding a spiritual family that does have that does have physical consequences, and that's scary to digest, but that is the reality of the restoration of things and the renewal of things from sin. That those that that want to continue in the brokenness and the abyss and the darkness and the gloom are uh put on one side, and those who are seeking the sun and uh beauty and um purity are on another side.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, and and just if I can put if I can add in another idea here, I I think we played around with this idea before, even in a different context with a different episode, but God has ordered things in such a way that we need each other. We are meant for communion. There's not one person who is self-sufficient completely, who has it all together, who doesn't need to rely on each other. Speak for yourself. That's right, yeah. So we are intended to commune and to rely upon each other and to be a community where people have certain gifts that they can live out for the building up of their communities, the building up of society.

SPEAKER_04Uh we depend on them. We depend on them. And and friends, you know, if you explore your own experiences of the people that you would genuinely call friends, yes, they share things with you, and you're familiar, and there are probably many different things you could identify that you you share, but it's also the differences, the distinctions between us that really matter. Because friends, I don't want to say that they complete us, but they provide a different look at life or a different perception, a different experience.

SPEAKER_04And it's helpful. It's it's really helpful to us to experience those friends and to interact with them and to throw ideas against them and to you know bust each other and you know get silly and and again say things that we might not say in front of other people because we trust that we're gonna be okay and and they're not gonna come after us and and dox us or something like that.

SPEAKER_03Oh my gosh, Chris, what are you insinuating?

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_03If we could uh insert ourselves into philosophical nerdum, let's do it. I want to throw out two quotes, and then uh well, I want to throw out two quotes. I also want to think out loud about Aristotle and how he talked about friendship. Because you said complete, and Aristotle, uh Aristotle delineates three types of friends. I don't know if I like the language of friends, or I don't know if I like the language of types, but but the impulse and the phenomenon that he's trying to identify in each of those, make each of them make sense to me.

SPEAKER_03So I want to think out loud about that here for a second, and then possibly I want to throw out a quote from Seneca the Younger, and I want to throw a quote out from Friedrich Nietzsche about friendship, and then you know we can deliberate and discuss that. So let's let's let's straight up just bathe ourselves in murder right now. Aristotle made a distinction between uh friendships of pleasure, friendships of utility, and friendships of character or virtue.

SPEAKER_03Now, Aristotle claimed, I'll explain those here in a second, but Aristotle claimed that the first two friendships are incomplete. You will never be a full human person if you only have the first two friendships.

SPEAKER_04So pleasure and utility.

SPEAKER_03Pleasure and utility. But friendship of character and virtue is complete friendship and it completes you. So a friendship of pleasure is a friendship in which there's a reciprocity of giving of pleasant uh of pleasure and pleasantries. So maybe we're friends because we're comedians and we tell each other jokes and we give each other fodder for stand-up, and that's our good.

SPEAKER_03The good that we give to each other is pleasure. And Aristotle notes that it's incomplete because inevitably that good will will become absent or will go away. At some point, I will start to, over the years, I will start to anticipate what kind of jokes you're constructing. And I'll hear multiple jokes that you've said before, and they'll become normal to me, and I won't enjoy them.

SPEAKER_03I won't be pleased by them. So that good is not strong enough to maintain a relationship. And so the reciprocity of me making you laugh and you making me laugh eventually will break down. So it's an incomplete form of friendship. A friendship of utility might be uh knowledge. I think that you're a really, really smart person, and you bestowing knowledge upon me can be beneficial to me.

SPEAKER_03You're a person who has an extensive vocabulary, so I love learning from you all of these vocabulary words that I can use at Thanksgiving and Christmas or on a podcast. But eventually, again, that's gonna break down because that good is insustainable. At some point, you will have an you will have an extensive vocabulary, or you will deem yourself to have an extensive uh vocabulary.

SPEAKER_03And then the relationship breaks down because um, and this is only one way, it could be the other way that you say, man, you've you've got a minimal vocabulary, or you're not funny anyway. Right? So it goes both ways, but something is going on that's very, very different in a friendship of character in which you wish the best for another person, and there's sacrifice in that. And though Aristotle does note that there's reciprocity, there also is sacrifice in that, that even though you don't at all times want what's best for me, I want what's best for you at all times.

SPEAKER_03And so a friendship of character, and in particular, I want what's best for you. Not, you know, oh, you know, you want a home and you want this life and all of these things. Nothing superficial or material like that. I want you to be a fulfilled human being. I want you to really enjoy life and live life abundantly. So, I mean, looking at it from a Christian perspective, like I want you to be the best Christian you could be. That's what a friendship of character is.

SPEAKER_03And so, you know, as as we just came off in season one talking about disagreement, that would look different among three different friends. Yeah, that a friendship of character might say, Look, I know I'm wrong, but this is the truth. And even if you don't believe what I say, or even if you don't take this course of action that I recommend, I want what's best for you. So figure it out and do the right thing. Yeah. You know, so that would take shape in a different way, but friendships of character are um you know vital for Aristotle because they're the best kind of friendship and because they complete you as a human being.

SPEAKER_03And I think we can translate that in terms of the body of Christ, as you mentioned a few minutes ago, that ultimately the body of Christ is going to want what's best for you, that fellow believers will want you to grow up in union with Christ, and that's what they're seeking in their friendship with you. Do you have any thoughts about that before we go into Seneca and Nietzsche?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, a couple of things. So, yeah, this idea of improving virtue, these in these friendships of character, yeah, hugely important. And I think there are a number of connections that we can draw to things that we've already talked about. It it really struck me a few moments ago when we were talking about marriage earlier, you know, in previous episodes, and how maybe some marriages actually are more inclined towards pleasure and utility.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Right? Yep. But when it comes to like authentic companionship, um this idea of like the covenants of the Lord I think would relate very much very well to um character and improving virtue and building up that which is all you know good. So I'm thinking about that. That's one aspect. Um and then Yeah, no, maybe I'll stop there. So keep going. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03That that's great, actually. I mean, I think let's apply it even if it's uh uncomfortable. I mean, there are those who enter into enter into a marriage because they want a stable partner to have sex with.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_03And and that's a that you know, that that's a that's a friendship of pleasure, or somebody that they can travel the world with, or somebody that they can experience life with. That's not we're not getting close to marriage yet, right? In in a biblical and Christian sense. Or they enter into a marriage uh for financial reasons. This this woman has a great job, she comes from a family of wealth, this will be beneficial for me in the future.

SPEAKER_03I want to have kids, she can bear me kids. This is a marriage of utility. But I love you and I love what's best for you, and I want you to be the best woman of God that you can be, and I want to be there, and I want to cheer you on, and I want to encourage you, and I want to chisel you and shape you as you do that for me as a man of God. That's different.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And uh in in minor categories, it also shapes arguments. For me, there there are principles and there are areas in which, as the father and as as the husband, like I want to make assertions, but there comes a time if I have a mindset of a marriage of character, there are times in which I need to lay down my argument because it's not about me winning. What is best for you and what is best for us?

SPEAKER_03And I think you can apply friendship of pleasure, utility, and character to a marriage of pleasure, a marriage of utility and a marriage of character. So I think that's a brilliant connection that I hadn't thought about, uh, but it's it sure is directly applicable.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, and if if we kind of meditate on it, reflect on it a bit, I think the connections between friendship and the common good come out even more. Um because it's important. I I think we need to to explore it further. Yeah. Um I I honestly believe that that God has established and ordered things so that whether it's the you know, covenant of marriage or the bonds among yeah uh among people, believers, you know, they're all connected, yeah.

SPEAKER_04And we we have we are quite different from each other, you know. But even in our friendship, I'm thinking about the differences that we we have, but we also have very many reference points that orient us and guide us. And so part of friendship is this kind of empathetic reaching out, understanding, being vulnerable with the other. But then as they're sharing their story with you, you are in a sense, yeah, thinking about what's best for them.

SPEAKER_04You're imagining what it's like for them, and you're putting yourself in their shoes and saying, whoa, whoa, whoa, that the the way your boss is treating you, that's no, that's no go. That's a no-go, man. Like, um, and this is this is what I think, and but it's for the betterment of the friend. That's what the goal is. So if we're thinking about bonds and how they build up society, I think we're we're yeah, we're in the right area.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and hearkening back to some of the previous episodes, I mean, we can think of how we can think of friendship in terms of spouses and how biologically that's beneficial for our kids.

SPEAKER_04Sure.

SPEAKER_03If we have marriages of character, that's gonna do something to our kids, which is gonna do something to the next generation and the next generation, and so on and so forth. It's also gonna do something psycho sociological with those neighbors who are proximate to us. Wow, they're a really loving and caring family. Um, they inspire me and they edify me and they instruct me, and I want to be a better f better father. And we talked, we talked a little bit about hosting in one episode, you know, just displaying and witnessing that to others who might come over for dinner or to watch the Stillers game or something of that nature.

SPEAKER_03That you're witnessing a marriage of character and befriending your spouse in a way that will have benefit for society today, but also tomorrow. Um so that's great. Let me um let me offer two quotes. Sure. Tell me what you think of these. And the Seneca quote, um, the Seneca quote for me, I love Seneca.

SPEAKER_03I think he's I think he's one of the most brilliant uh Roman philosophers, but also I love how he is not esoteric, but he's profound, but also very practical. Um, and he covers different emotional movements for me in this quote. And Nietzsche, I'm I'm fascinated by by Nietzsche. I know he is for some people he's he's a terrible human being and a cynic and a skeptic and whatnot, but he's very insightful and incisive.

SPEAKER_03And so his quote for me is it does raise the question for me, to what extent with a friend, as you kind of hinted at a moment ago, like this is the truth, this is what you have to do. That Nietzsche, when when writing about friendship, focused on the tough love. Yeah, there there is there is a sense in which a friend ought to be real in a way that other people can't be real with others, but with a friend.

SPEAKER_03So Seneca's quote is the friend is someone whose conversation allays your anxiety, whose counsel promotes your plans, whose cheerfulness dissipates your gloom, and whose very appearance gives you joy. There's like a whole person benefit to the friend that I think he captures.

SPEAKER_03It's just a breath of a friend is a breath of fresh air. It's not laborious, it's not tense. There's just an aura of open fields and enjoyment and rest. So I like how Seneca, I like, I mean it's poetic, but I like how it's like tiered. There's different levels and layers of a friend, and I think he captures that.

SPEAKER_03Um here's the Nietzsche quote If you have a suffering friend, be a resting place for his suffering, but a hard bed, a field cot. Thus will you profit him best. Now I think this might tap into so it taps into challenging and chiseling your friend and and the nature of that.

SPEAKER_03But also taps into empathy and compassion, which Nietzsche had problems with with pitying people. Don't pity people because it dehumanizes them. And then when he goes to friendship, it's like, well, should you just put your arm around your friend and hug them and wait until they feel better? You know, or do you give them a little pat on the back and say, start running? You know, there is that tension there of how long are you empathetic?

SPEAKER_03How long are you compassionate? And at what point do you start to say, Come on, man, you got this. Do it. No, you can't have the crutch. Walk on your own two legs. Um, and I think there is some truth to that. Having the prudence and wisdom to know when to do that is definitely requisite. But there a friend is not someone who is always indulging others in their own state or their own condition.

SPEAKER_03If they are a friend of character and they want what's best for the other person, that might be stop doing that, get away from that, start doing this. And that might hurt their feelings. But that that's why they're not a friend of pleasure. They're not indulging their emotions and making them feel good all the time. They're doing what's best for them. Um, and again, that needs to be done with with prudence, and there is compassion and empathy involved, but but there also is uh uh if there also is pushing, if not shoving, in certain circumstances.

SPEAKER_03What do you think about either of those quotes?

SPEAKER_04I think there's you've done a good job establishing the connections between them, and I think that point of connection is certainly this friendship of character, you know, improving virtue, really pursuing the good life, excellent, excellence, right? Uh we've seen both of them talk about allaying anxiety or being a resting place for your friend who's suffering, you know, and and then to me that's really important, but there's also this constructive moment. And you know, if I'm if I'm the kind of friend who is just thinking about pleasure or utility, man, you're bringing me down.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. Uh I'd rather not be here. I'm gonna go somewhere else. But no, a friend of friendship of character is one in which you're genuinely concerned for the person. You can empathize with them enough, and to your point, having prudence in terms of assessing, okay, I've given them enough rope, and and now I've got to give some tough love. And isn't that the true mark of a friend, the person who will say something that might make you uncomfortable?

SPEAKER_04Or even to show you a little bit of what we talked about with virtuous disagreement earlier in season one. Someone willing to say the tough truths, they've listened, but they're gonna ask some follow-up questions. They're gonna challenge you because they want the best for you.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04And that's the difference because you're not meant just to suffer and wallow, like you're you're you're meant to thrive, right? So the friend is one who will suffer with you, but then they're gonna challenge you and say, Come on, let's pick yourself up. I'm with you. It's okay, let's keep going. And you know, Seneca has talked about not just anxiety uh and dissipating gloom, but promoting your plans and giving you joy. Yeah, right. So that you got these two together or these four together in that situation, and or for Nietzsche being that kind of hard bed, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03It's still a bed, right? Yes, I mean it is like to your point, it's it's a resting place. But I also think of like, okay, sometimes this is uncomfortable. Eventually you fall asleep, right? You you know, for those of you who have slept on a bed, a hard bed, eventually you fall asleep and you might be sleep deprived the next day, but you do rest, but there is discomfort involved. And if you're if you think about character as chiseling a person's traits and who they are, that's gonna be uncomfortable.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_03But if somebody's gonna do that and you're gonna entrust yourself to do that, or for somebody to do that for you, it's gotta be a friend who wants what's best for you and who is willing to is willing to take you to that place and do that. That tough love, that hard truth, that is done with prudence and is done with compassion, but it's uncomfortable nonetheless.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, and and I think that corresponds with the example of the early Christians. I'm thinking of Saint Paul, I'm thinking of these early communities that in some instances he helped to form. You foolish Galatians, yeah, and then he he follows up.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, what are you doing? Also, uh I was thinking of when you were talking, you know, Peter, you will betray me, you will deny me. Like you you called it out beforehand. Oh, that's that's hard truth. Yeah, exactly. I don't want you to do that, but you're going to do that. And um, but he was shaping his character, and as soon as he did it, he knew.

SPEAKER_04Right. And and in some sense, preparing him to be the leader that he that he became, you know, and and and this is I think a great example to us all. We we try our best, but in real friendships, it's not just easy or simple all the time. There's going to be moments of complication and darkness and gloom. And if it's a friendship of character, well, that's not the end of the story, right? So I think nowadays, and I think we can um also uh we can't get into this now, of course, because of time, but I I think about I've said this to my kids, and I've been saying it probably I don't know since 2005, since Facebook came around.

SPEAKER_04But you can have 500, a thousand friends, but are they really friends? Are they the kind of people that when you when you're struggling or you need help or you don't want to share something positive, are they gonna be there? Right. So friendship is is a real real important aspect of of life, of a full life, of a thriving life. And we we need to spend a little more time, I think, thinking about it and then cultivating it in practice.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, that does raise questions and concerns about how social media has affected personal, uh, physical friendships and what they offer. And the fact that followers are masqueraded as friends is doing something to us. And we have to keep our eyes set on this robust sense of a friend is not merely an acquaintance who can see a post and like it or dislike it or respond based on how they feel.

SPEAKER_03That's not a friend. Uh that's definitely certainly not a friendship of character. So, well, this has been stimulating and fascinating and titillating, Chris. Thank you for all of all of your remarks and this delicious uh cocktail that I have communed with and now call a friend.

SPEAKER_03Our next episode will start on a new series in our family life in the common good season by discussing homemaking. We'll talk about vacationing, decorating, and ornamenting the house, gardening and backyards, hosting, all of these things that make this home a space. And then in turn, how homemaking is is related to the family, which seems obvious, but we could we could dig a little deep into that, as well as how that is good for society.

SPEAKER_03Thanks for listening to Two Poor Spirits, till next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Your Seams Are Showing: Loving Our Neighbors through Fashion | Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo

    Nov 13, 202654 minAudio

    A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Embrace Boredom and Boss Better

    Oct 29, 202655 minAudio

    Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Be a Better Colleague

    Oct 1, 202649 minAudio

    Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Don't Make Your Boss God and Your Kids Swag

    Sep 12, 202657 minAudio

    Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: See Your Failures as Blessings

    Aug 13, 202653 minAudio

    You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...

    Credit the people on this episode