They dealt with Disagreeable Disagreers. Everyone gave three cheers. Disagreeable Disagreers are literally the worst. And everyone despises them. But now Chris and Kyle have to convince their own traditions and tribes that disagreement can cultivate Christian character. That it's good for the Church. The "dynamic duo" will spend the next four episodes discussing the virtues of patience, humility, courage, and honesty. In this first installment, they examine patience. If disagreement is about arriving at understanding, then we have to listen to others. And listening takes patience. Join Chris and Kyle as they explore how to get there. Even if it means losing it. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a think tank and training ground for spiritual formation and the common good. Visit Projectneighbor.org to learn more.
SPEAKER_00And we'll be starting a new series, which I've tentatively entitled Long Disagreement in the Same Direction, which is actually a play on one of Nietzsche's statements, Friedrich Nietzsche, who talked about long obedience in the same direction. But we're going to get into, in this series on long disagreement in the same direction, we're going to get into how disagreement can help us become better Christians. What ways and shapes and uh degrees can disagreement foster and facilitate Christian virtues?
SPEAKER_00And we're going to focus on at least four, I think, right? You agreed to that?
SPEAKER_03I do agree to that.
SPEAKER_00We're going to focus on patience, which we'll talk about in this episode. We'll talk about humility in another episode, courage or tenacity to stick with your convictions, and honesty. And I think to some degree these pair up with the lost tools of disagreement. You know, we talked about listening, asking, and sharing and thinking, and we discussed those in previous episodes. And I think these virtues can, they don't singularly map on to each of those uh uh tools.
SPEAKER_00I think each of them could map on to all of them, but I do think that there is something that can be, there's a strong cord between patience and listening, and there's a strong cord between humility and asking, and courage and sharing, and honesty and thinking. Um so we'll kind of begin with the essence there, but I think they do again. I think they map on uh those virtues map on to each of the tools. Before we jump into patience, though, Chris, since you concocted this cocktail, I need you to tell me what this spirit is that's poured out in my glass.
SPEAKER_03Well, it's nice to be back, Kyle. Uh love to podcast, and I really hope that we can map those connections uh for everybody here. But yes, let's talk about the cocktail. And this one had a really terrible name. So I was trying to find something that might, you know, be appealing in the summertime, being now that it's July. Um, and and there's been a lot of heat. So I was thinking, okay, maybe something spicy. And the the title of this one was Sweet and Spicy Bourbon Cocktail.
SPEAKER_00So matter of fact, like yes.
SPEAKER_03So I thought, well, let maybe let's call it sh summer shenanigans.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I like that. I like that.
SPEAKER_03Okay, so uh I'm gonna give you the numbers, all right, and I'll I'll talk about how it's made, but you can because there are two of us, you know, we had to double it, right? Makes sense. So we started out with basically, you know, fresh squeezed lime juice. Um, I was looking to get about an ounce of that, right? Half an ounce each. Um put that into uh a shaker, and then took some strawberries and sliced them quite thin, about six or seven pieces of those.
SPEAKER_03Also sliced thin the end of a jalapeno pepper, uh, probably like four or five slices of that. Uh tried to avoid too many seeds, and put that together with the lime juice. At that point, I probably should have muddled those three together, but I put in uh the bourbon, which I used a you know, high-proof uh bourbon from Larseny, and then I muddled everything together, added some ice, shook it up for 10 seconds, uh, and poured it over uh more ice in a cocktail glass.
SPEAKER_03Um, I should note that that cocktail glass, similar to a margarita, was rimmed, right? And there was a a certain spice that I hadn't heard about beforehand, uh, never heard of it. It's called tahine. And tahine is a kind of spice with chili and salt, so it's like a salty, spicy kind of mix, right? So I I rubbed the edge of the glass with um uh a freshly squeezed lime, dipped it into the tahine. Um a copious amount, I might add.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and then several ice cubes, and then poured in what was uh recently shaken, and then you finish it off with um just a few ounces of ginger beer, and we just poured until the the glass became full. Is that Q? Yes, Q ginger beer.
SPEAKER_00It's spicy, I like that.
SPEAKER_03Which was a good one. Um, so we mix that up and we're we're pretty pleased with it overall, even though at first I wasn't sure. Uh, and then we decided to just add a little bit of quantro to the mix uh to give it a little more flavor. I brought in uh a little citrus with the already the sweet and the spicy. So uh summer shenanigans.
SPEAKER_00I like it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. I mean it's a work in progress, but I like it.
SPEAKER_00Is it like causal it leads to summer shenanigans, or it it it is because we are already engaging in summer shenanigans?
SPEAKER_03Well, given the mess that I made just over there, I think that some shenanigans have already taken place. Let's hope it doesn't lead to too many more.
SPEAKER_00The mess has already been made. Excellent. Well, cheers. We hope our listeners at home can also concoct this and and enjoy the shenanigans as we are. Well, in this episode, as I mentioned earlier, this episode we're looking at how disagreement can foster patience. And patience is a Christian virtue, it is an excellent way of being a Christian, it is a fruit of the Spirit, as the Apostle Paul discusses in Galatians 5.
SPEAKER_00And I I was thinking about how we might sort of make these connections instead of just jumping in with how is patience cultivated through the process of disagreement or leaning into disagreement um or arriving at disagreement. Let's let's take some time to hash out what exactly patience is. Um and I was my my first start here was thinking etymologically that you know in the Latin patiencia and and is related to patience.
SPEAKER_00All right, listeners, don't fall asleep just yet. I'm just I swear this is really important, you know. But patience is tied to this uh notion of being a patient, and a patient is someone who is enduring suffering. Patience begins at least with words, with its word. It is something that uh involves endurance of suffering.
SPEAKER_00And um, so I was at least beginning with okay, there's something going on with patience that must end that must involve suffering, that must involve endurance, a a a uh in um a receiving or taking upon suffering that is for a duration or a length of time. Now, Chris, I know that you were looking this up biblically and and thinking about within scripture how patience is discussed.
SPEAKER_00Is this consistent with how patience is discussed in scripture? Did you uncover anything additional, furthermore?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Um, so a couple things. Like I would say that there is agreement, but also some surprising, you know, things that you come across. And the reason I I was motivated to look was because I realized that my own understanding is kind of deficient. Um, so often I I think about patience, and I just for whatever reason, right, I think about almost like passivity, right? Oh, you know, just yeah, there's the sense of like getting through something, being patient, um, but it's kind of robbed of its kind of depth, right?
SPEAKER_03And and its richness, and and so I think we we definitely want to explore that, you know. Um, and then I couldn't help but think while you were introducing the idea, is that you know, we often we have children, right? And they're I often bought I will often ask my children to like, you know, be patient. It's like, so am I asking them to suffer me? So uh yeah, and and maybe they are because the you know the expression the kid kids survive their parents, but um you're I'm I'm jumping sure, I'm I'm jumping in in here, sorry.
SPEAKER_00But I I think like for me the colloquial way of articulating that would be just deal with it, be patient, right? And so you you're saying that to to that that robs patience of something more robust and significant, at least scripturally. Um I would I would agree experientially too, you know, like when you're telling your kids to be patient, you're not just saying deal with it, right? Or you know, be patient with me.
SPEAKER_00You're not just saying just deal with it, just endure it, but it's something so much more.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, no, thank and and honestly, um, you know, I think this will be a really productive use of our time, right? Because again, a word that comes up often has a really long past. And scripture is going to show us some things that um we otherwise wouldn't have really thought of. You know, so uh one thing that came up to, I mean, when I'm looking up this word, so again, I don't want to bore anybody, but there's a verb words matter.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, there's a verb form, a related form, um macro theme, right? Theme. Um, and this is the one where you know you get the sense of like 1 Corinthians 13 4, love is patient, right? And that's how it's kind of formulated by Paul.
SPEAKER_00Um which is used at like every wedding.
SPEAKER_03Yes, it's always used. Um, often with the of course, people are not understanding the the context.
SPEAKER_00Now people who don't believe in the Bible.
SPEAKER_03Maybe, maybe. Um, but you know, it's a really powerful expression, like love, agape, which you know, scripture also attests is what God is, uh, is patient, right? But then you go to like Luke 18, chapter 18, verse 7, you know, and and it says, And the Lord, I'm actually starting verse six, and the Lord said, Hear what the unrighteous judge says, and will not God vindicate his elect who cry to him day and night?
SPEAKER_03Will he delay long over them? Delay long. All right, so the sense of length, right? The macro, and then that's the same word? Yeah. Interesting. The same word as delay long, translated patient in one context and delay long in another. So you get this sense of long suffering. Um, in other biblical contexts, the idea of you know, delaying passion or anger, right?
SPEAKER_03Um, and that's something that God does, you know, even when there would be justice in being angry.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_03So that that reveals something to us too about uh the need to imitate God, to be images of God, who is love, who's charity, who exercises patience and suffers with us and delays retribution. Um so these are just a couple of examples, and you that particular word only appears a few times in the New Testament. Um, but then of course the the macro themia uh occurs many, many, many more times.
SPEAKER_03Um, and that is patience, you know, as we understand it. And that occurs all over the uh New Testament letters, honestly. So uh very important word for the the early church, the apostles, so on and so forth. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Interesting. So one of the things that um one of the things that I think is essential to patience is that you're enduring something. So I gotta think about don't delay. I've gotta I'm gonna I'm gonna map that. But one of the things that I think is essential to patience has to do with something that is opposing or you have to receive that's negative. So like there's a difference, right?
SPEAKER_00There's a difference between patience and waiting. You know, like I could be waiting for the bus to come. But I'm listening to music, reading a book, enjoying, you know, a cocktail, no, not a cocktail, probably not, but maybe like uh maybe like um coffee or something. Ever I've got I'm comfortable. I've got there's no what I would say are adversity, difficulty, tribulation, hardship.
SPEAKER_00I'm just and I'm not late for work or you know, I'm not late to an occasion, whatever. I'm waiting for the bus. It seems to me that there's a difference with just mere waiting and patience. Right? Yeah, there's a little bit more of something wrong going on with patience than there is with waiting necessarily. Now, you mentioned long suffering, yes, and you know, I I believe that this term too, like in Galatians 5, as Paul writes about it, that it could also be translated as not patience but long suffering.
SPEAKER_03That's right.
SPEAKER_00You know, yeah, and so I I'm thinking of three words right now. I'm thinking of waiting, patience, and long suffering. And it seems to me that as I think about those things, as I've already indicated, waiting can just be innocent, innocuous. Uh, it can be neutral. You're just waiting for something, and you're comfortable and you're fine with that waiting, and you know, time is passing. With patience, there's something else going on that's changing your posture that is even though we don't want to say just deal with it, you're having to deal with something.
SPEAKER_00But it's not necessarily like totally negative in the sense of like, I think long suffering is you you really want to fix things or fight back or do something about this. You're in you're suffering for a long time before you do something about it. Yeah, you know. Maybe maybe long suffering is kind of like forbearing. You're like dealing with the struggle, the hardship, the adversity.
SPEAKER_00And like long, long suffering, as we as we under typically understand it in society, is I'm enduring something and I'm gonna burst soon. But it seems to me like patience, patience isn't as quite there, there's more going on in patience that it's not as innocuous as waiting, but it's also not as defensive as long suffering. Okay, the long-suffering person, it seems to me, is is looking, is wait, is waiting to then do something to to get to the end of this, to endure the hits or the struggle as long as they can before they either burst or they run away or they die.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But but the patient person, they're waiting for something, they're waiting for the other side of something. There's a good on the other side that they're enduring this and going through this, not trying to hasten to the end, but they're going through this because they know something good is about to come. What do you think about that?
SPEAKER_03I really like the distinction. Um, I almost wonder if if it would be helpful to think about someone who is patient, might be prepared at some point to go through long suffering. Um but but it seems to me that like that, yeah, there there is a distinction between, you know, someone who could be described as patient and then a particular context or a situation of suffering, whether it's an early church community facing persecution for their beliefs and having to, you know, exhibit long suffering.
SPEAKER_03Right? Maybe relative to say um exercising patience when you're dealing with uh a personality that is not your cup of tea, another leader in in the church community. Uh not maybe that wouldn't be long suffering, um, but but in a sense, you know, there's only so much you can control. Right. And I think the scriptures are kind of attesting to that, that you know, God isn't going to contravene or take over the will uh of a of a person, and but God has a plan and uh things are being worked through, and we're participating in this with other images of God, uh, some of whom might be responding to the spirit, some of whom might be resisting the spirit, and and there are larger stories that are taking place within which we operate.
SPEAKER_03Stories that sometimes might be helpful to us and other times might be harmful. Um, and maybe at that point, you know, whatever we understand as patience might be become long suffering. Yeah. Um, now again, I don't know uh looking at all of these instances, uh, I see uh sometimes patience and long suffering are used as cognates, depending on your translation, but maybe it's interesting to think about these distinctions. Yeah, right, because yeah, I would I would think patience and long suffering uh connote different things.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think so. Um, and we you know, we talk about with Project Neighbor spiritual formation for the common good. There's a there's a it seems to me there's a distinct and there there's a distinct difference between the the spirit or posture of patience versus long suffering. The long-suffering person is enduring and mustering strength and trying to get through something, and the end goal is to be relieved of the suffering.
SPEAKER_00They're they're just you know, I I think of like um the medieval philosopher and and uh theologian William of Av Auvern, who talked about donkey patience, just getting whipped and whipped and whipped, and you just get used to it. You know, and you're just trying to get through it. Um you're not you're not necessarily dealing with it. I mean, I think long suffering has a positive and a negative way of understanding it. Um, you know, you're just dealing with it, or you just get used to just getting battered and rammed, you know.
SPEAKER_00So your posture or your goal in long suffering for the long suffering person is I'm going to endure this to then be relieved of it. And it seems to me, and I'm not I'm not Speaking about that pejoratively, there's a time and a place for that, there's a season for that. But it is different than the patient person who I think is not enduring to be relieved, but they're enduring to encounter something beyond the suffering that they're enduring right now.
SPEAKER_00So at the very least, like call it posture, call it spirit, call it an eye there or perception of things. They're seeing things differently. The long-suffering person is seeing the end in which there's no longer suffering in this time period. And man, I can't wait to be relieved of that. I'm going to endure this, even for Christ's sake. I'm going to endure this because this is this is the time of my tribulation and suffering.
SPEAKER_00But the patient person is looking at something else. They're looking at this time, this moment of I'm being tried and tested. What good is there in this? And how is this going to grow me in the future? And it's someone, you know, the long-suffering person doesn't run away. And the patient person doesn't run away. But they run, they don't run away for different reasons. And I think the patient person doesn't run away because they have the good on the other side in focus, in perspective, and pure in purview.
SPEAKER_00There God is for you know, for example, the Lord is doing something through this for me, and this is a good thing for me. You know, and fast forward to the second part of our discussion here, but like okay, this this what seems like disagreement is getting conflictual and it's getting awkward and uncomfortable, but there is something good here.
SPEAKER_00There is honesty and there is humility and there is patience being displayed and demonstrated here. There are good things here. Let me focus on those things.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. What do you think? Well, you know, and again, I can't speak necessarily to the principles of scriptural interpretation because I'm not that's not my area. But I I really do think this is this is important. Um, you know, to to kind of think about distinctions distinctions between patience and long suffering, but the connection of patience to something beyond, uh, I really think that characterizes it differently in a good way.
SPEAKER_03Like, you know, again, this is another word that is strange to some ears, but you know, eschatology or the study of the last things, or you know, the the which really kind of points to the tension that Christians live in between past, present, and future, that you know, we have this past rich, you know, the tradition and liturgical life that nourishes us, and we're also anticipating, you know, participation in the kingdom of God and being with the Lord and this, you know, the second coming and and life with God.
SPEAKER_03But yeah, we find ourselves right where we are, right? Caught between those two, sometimes uncertain, um, but nourished by the past, anticipating the future, and not really ever uh just in one single moment or place, right? So uh we this is described often as a tension. Um and but if if you think about the patience, the endurance in in light of a goal, right?
SPEAKER_03The endurance that will lead to the type of communion that we yearn for natively, right? That that to me is a very powerful way of approaching it. And then to think about as you were mentioning, disagreement. We talked before about okay, sometimes it's difficult to just listen and to ask clarifying questions, not to interrupt, but if you're able to exercise patience with the person with whom you're speaking, right, it's in light of this greater understanding, this pursuit of truth, which comes from our source and our goal.
SPEAKER_03And and by you know, by exhibiting this patience, by practicing this patience, we are in some sense imaging God. Right. So uh I think a lot of what we've talked about over the last several weeks, previous episodes, I think it's all related to this discussion of patience. So I'm not sure that's very systematic, but I want to go back to you now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I mean that's that's great. It also makes me think of there's there's an intricate link between patience and hope. Yeah. You know, you mentioned, you know, we are way we eschaton, we are waiting for the end. Yeah. Um, and and there is patience involved in hope, in hoping, uh, and Christian hope for the end and restoration and reconciliation of all things.
SPEAKER_00Um and the Christian is uh being patient in their hope as they endure difficulty and hardship. And you know, going back to something that I hinted at earlier, um, you know, there are ways of escaping patience. You know, you can be uh you can be overcome by the adversity and the hardship and the difficulty and the tribulation. Um, and and I mean I can conceive of it at least three ways.
SPEAKER_00One is self-pity. You know, you, oh poor me. Um I should have never, you know, why is this happening to me? Uh I shouldn't have to endure this. I made those bad decisions, that's why this is happening to me. You know, self-pity is a way of being overcome by the adversity and difficulty, and you never get to experience and practice patience when you engage in self-pity.
SPEAKER_00I also think like your own, you can be overcome at, and that's an emotional way of being overcome by it, a physical way of being overcome by it, which I need to think a little bit more about, but at least initially my intuition tells me like if you die, you know, and are overcome by the hardship and adversity, then you never really get to practice patience, right? Patience, in a sense, is vanished or taken away from you, and you don't get to, if it's so overwhelming that you don't even have the time, because I think time is involved in patience, endurance, you know, duration, taking time to be patient.
SPEAKER_00Um, if it kills you, you can't be patient. Yeah, you know, so it can overcome you emotionally, it can come you overcome you physically by destroying you, and and um, or it can overcome you by causing you to run away, um, to abandon, to quit, and not be able to practice patience. Um, patience is coming face to face with the hardship, adversity, tribulation.
SPEAKER_00And the waiting person, to go back to that talk taxonomy or distinction, the the waiting person isn't in the realm of any of this. You know, they're it's neutral, it's innocuous, they're not in the realm. The patient person and the long-suffering person, uh, you know, they're not they're not escaping um adversity, difficulty, tribulation, and whatnot. But they are encountering these things in different ways.
SPEAKER_00You know, like I would say the long-suffering person isn't moving into the realm of self-pity, but they recognize the pain. You know, they're in their focus is on the pain and the relief. The patient person is focused on what is the good that's in the, you know, involved in this process and at the other end of this that I can learn and grow from, and what is God doing in my life? You know, like it's a different posture and position that I think is an important one, even if we translate these words as either patience or long suffering.
SPEAKER_00I think experience and our, you know, distinct important distinctions, characteristics, feature features of each help us understand that they're a little bit different when it comes to uh our spirit and you know, practicing a fruit of the spirit.
SPEAKER_03This kind of brings something up for me. Um, again, the the the patient person being mindful of the of the goal, you know, remaining hopeful, not despairing. If you despair or engage in in too much self-pity, yeah, you're more likely to to eventually try to seek abandon to abandon your post, so to speak. Yeah, yeah. Um, but if you can keep in view the ultimate end that's nevertheless with you, it's present to you, um, then then you can actually discern uh the spirit at work, yeah.
SPEAKER_03The relationship that you might have with the person that that could be a cause of long suffering. Um, but nevertheless, you are engaged with another person, the spirits at work, uh, and and you have not despaired. So God can be present in the midst of you and your interlocutor. And now uh I think it's essential that someone tries to remain hopeful, right? Not optimistic, like I'm not gonna sugarcoat that this could be a situation that is unpleasant, it's requiring a lot of me, it's taxing me, it's enervating me.
SPEAKER_03But at the same time, you are encountering another image of God, and you are going through something, and you're going through something together, and perhaps the way that you approach that could could lead to a transformation. I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's I I like that. And I think I was I was attuned to our spirit and posture, but you're also making us attuned to the spirit in the midst of all of that. And I I think the patient person is looking to the spirit to guide and discern and uh to work all things for our good for those who trust in the Lord. Um, and I think that's involved in the process of disagreement.
SPEAKER_00Patience is required in disagreement, but but um disagreement helps us practice patience, helps us cultivate it. Um you can't, I mean, to abandonment as one of the ways to be overcome by adversity and difficulty. You can't run away from opportunities to be patient and still end up becoming a patient person.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_00You you know, you have to find yourself or put yourself in situations in which you can practice patience. Um I think so so um moving in the direction of disagreement, moving in the direction of having a conversation. And then you start to realize, like, whoa, we might not, you know, we may we may not meet at the end of this, our minds may not meet at the end of this, that you don't abandon it necessarily, um, and you you stick it out and you're looking for the good at the end of this because disagreement can help cultivate patience, and that conflict and of adversity of opinions, of um, you know, watching them infer, make conclusions, and reason through things, is an opportunity for us to to practice patience.
SPEAKER_00Now I can think of at least uh at least three ways um that in my own life personally I've had to struggle with with practicing patience. And I mean, maybe some of it, I should probably shouldn't say this on any kind of recording, but um, you know, listening, staying focused and listening to my kids, yeah, is a way to practice patience.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. I can empathize. Uh, I don't know if we're allowed to say that out loud as Christian parents, but um, you know, it it is difficult to uh listen to my children, try to articulate their words, take 400 hours to tell an anecdote. Um, and you know, listening it requires endurance.
SPEAKER_00It requires a long time, you know, and like I wish it weren't 400 hours, but I mean the point, you know, put soberly, any conversation you're in, listening requires patience. It requires this enduring and duration, enduring of all of the words, all of the conclusions, um, and listening them for an extended amount of time.
SPEAKER_00Understanding takes time, you know, and and if that if you're if it involves listening, then that means you have to wait to take your turn, too. Um, you know, um to understand someone, we have to listen to them, and to listen to them, we have to have patience. So I think on, you know, that would be one of I I I I'll go into my second one, but you're nodding, and I don't know if you want to interject and well no, no, I I and I can empathize with this one.
SPEAKER_03I mean, and when it really I mean, when it really manifests for me is at the end of a long day, maybe a tough day, and you've really had to expend a lot of energy, but then you find yourself back with your family. And I think this also goes with you know, with spouses as well, right? Like you you want to share some things, but but listening takes your energy, you know, and and so to to exercise patience, you have to be engaged in the conversation.
SPEAKER_03That's not just that's not just a an oral thing in terms of ears, that's also like a bodily thing.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03You know, to show that you're engaged, uh, and then you have to kind of expend this energy. And I find that, you know, whether it's like 6, 7 p.m. in the evening, and you know, let's say one of my kids starts telling me a really long story, you know, if I'm sitting down, I've got to be careful that I don't start to fall asleep. And it's not because I don't want to be patient, it's that I've I've been listening most of the day, and you know, and it's just so hard because I I want to pay attention to everything.
SPEAKER_03And then even listen and to ask clarifications, right? You know, the asking, which we've talked about, and to be fully engaged takes so much. So I I certainly think of this as a virtue, patience. It's something, it's an excellence, it's something that ought to be pursued. Um, but it isn't easy, no, you know, and there are certainly times, and I and I I completely agree that you know, to to be a good family member, it it's not easy, and you need to exercise patience.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, and and maybe in um a great way to segue and thinking in terms of relationships, a great way to segue from the first um way that disagreement assists with patience in cultivating patience is to shift from the family to friends.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um you know, you have to in you have to endure listening to another and their words and their conclusions and whatnot. And and we're talking about that in terms of kids. You also have to muster the strength to pay attention. Uh, and I think of that in terms of friends, you know, like the patient person is somebody who's not only is not only receiving, but the patient person is mustering, persevering, steadfastly engaging because of the good on the other side.
SPEAKER_00And so the patient person is mustering the strength to pay attention. And I've been in many situations with friends in which we have, you know, like in having conversations in podcasting, that you know, we have been interrupted, we've been distracted, we've been disruptive, disrupted, and you have to muster up the strength to redirect back to okay, we had a good thing going.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. You know, um, and so I think that there is, you know, on the one hand, in our very um distracted, anxious, startled by loud noises and moving objects and all sorts of phenomenon that's throwing itself at us all the time, that there is um um in in trying to understand others and seeking agreement or disagreement, that it requires us to be patient in, okay, we've been interrupted.
SPEAKER_00This this line of thinking has been broken. Okay, we gotta go back to it. We gotta keep going back to it. I gotta keep mustering up the strength to pay attention and get back on track. Um, if I'm to understand this person, if we're can if we're um attempting to continue this conversation. Does that make sense?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it does. I mean, and certainly I I can conceive of this. Well, I can conceive of it with family or friends. Yeah, yeah, right. Yeah. You know. Um I was just trying to include friends. I appreciate it. But let's let's keep going.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I mean, then I don't know what other s social sphere we have for this.
SPEAKER_03Can I give you one?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03All right, sorry to interrupt. Um, once in a while I have to be the interrupter. That's fine, but yeah, I'll be the obstinate. Yeah. Well, you know, I I wasn't, you know, I I recently was attending um, you know, a work conference, and I I it was a situation that I could not have anticipated, right? Never happened before. Uh so in a session with presentations, and you know, I was active to some extent in that, and there was a a participant who you know began to ask a question and kept going.
SPEAKER_03And the the you know, I don't know if it was just stream stream of consciousness, one thought to the next, access to grind. Um I mean, we're talking minutes and minutes, and so the the organizers of the session doing their very best to exercise patience with an unexpected situation. Uh and and so to to the point where all of a sudden the the moderator had to kind of step in and just over-talk and and say, we have to move on.
SPEAKER_03And then when the session concluded, people started to filter out of the room, and I found myself alone with the person. And for the next thirty seven minutes, you know, uh I was now speaking with this person and was the qu question and commentary directed at you?
SPEAKER_00Or somebody else.
SPEAKER_03Maybe. It was more of like a just, I believe I was the occasion for the uh expression of this. But I bring it up because something happened during that 37 minutes, which was that I realized I needed to be patient. And I realized I needed to listen. Because this person desperately needed me to listen. And this person thanked me profusely for listening afterward.
SPEAKER_03And I knew that despite, you know, tent plans I might have had with other people prior to the 37 minutes passing, I just knew that in this moment I had to sit there, you know, some some remarks, some back and forth just to to you know, talk and all that. But umce I kind of embraced the situation and kept in mind that this is a fellow believer, someone who's lost people, maybe somewhat recently, and who's going through something and was sharing with me their story.
SPEAKER_03Um as uncomfortable as it might have started, uh, it was really meaningful at the end. And it required me to kind of put aside the normal expectations. And I think that could only be done with that larger horizon that we mentioned. The hope, the the end, right? The end that's nourished by the origin. Um not not an any not a case of any heroic virtue on my part, but it was more of just you know, I could have at any time ended it.
SPEAKER_03Forced my way out. But, you know, for whatever reason, I felt that I was called to sit there. You know, even though I was being kind of backed into a corner.
SPEAKER_00That's what I was saying. Yeah, yeah. So let me ask you a question. Yeah, you there was patience involved in listening.
SPEAKER_03Yes.
SPEAKER_00There was patience involved in mustering up the strength to stick around for 37 minutes.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I would say my the other thing that I think of in uh engaging patience or practicing patience through disagreement is that you have to you have to receive um or endure criticisms or conclusions that you may not like.
SPEAKER_03Yes.
SPEAKER_00Because on the other side of that is better understanding and possibly agreement or disagreement, you know. So was this individual leveling criticisms at you or conclusions that you would say that's ridiculous, or I would never believe that, or why do you believe you know, you know what I mean? Like, was there was there difficulty or hardship or adversity, broadly, you know, speaking, you know, scare quotes, broadly speaking, that you had to endure that landed you afterwards in a position in which they were profusely thanking you?
SPEAKER_03I would I would say that there were some theological conclusions, um, two quick connections between different stages of the Christian tradition, you know, and also related to modernity. So quick connections between, you know, modern scientific thinkers, Luther, Aquinas, Augustine, and it was happening so fast um that it kind of astounded me, to be honest with you.
SPEAKER_03And I I thought, okay, you know, it actually forced me to stop and to listen more because I couldn't possibly be able to master the situation and speak against all of the propositions. Like I needed to kind of take it in as a whole, then to kind of reflect on my own view, right? Because um it wasn't the kind of conversation where you could just maybe with like a really close friend, you have the banter back and forth, it's really quick, it's intuitive.
SPEAKER_03This was more like I'm in strange country. Um, but it also made me kind of reflect on my own uh positions quite a bit.
SPEAKER_00The hasty conclusions and associations and connections, I think for some people would lead them to say, Oh my gosh, this dude is so ridiculous, you know, and and and step away. But you're saying you stepped in further into that because you wanted to know, wait a second, how are you making these conclusions and associate associations and connections? I need to listen more so I can see why you're making those moves so quickly.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, is that fair to say? I think that's fair to say.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so it was definitely a an unexpected, surprising encounter. Um when it was beginning, I wasn't quite sure what to expect or make of it. Um, but by the end, I I really felt um just just consolation with having listened, you know. Um, yeah, so uh I mean I don't know how how far to go into that because it required patience and listening and and expending the energy, and um maybe some would describe it as long suffering, but uh I don't know if I necessarily would.
SPEAKER_03Um, because there was, in a sense, despite the disagreements at the level of theory, there was a connection made with another person, another believer. Um and and I think that that's precious, honestly.
SPEAKER_00Well, it sounds like your spirit and posture wasn't one of, oh, I gotta keep going through this for 37 minutes. It was, oh, okay, I gotta dig a little deeper and I've got to understand a little better. Yeah. And it seems to me like that's more uh aligned with being patient than it is with just long suffering.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and and I think so. It was it was almost like the exterior of the room and the session had been had been really kind of like a storm. You know, you think about like contemplation and silence, like the opposite of that, because not only do we have the you know, summer shenanigans of the session, but but we had um it was also kind of fleet week and there were planes buzzing the building as the session was going.
SPEAKER_03So there literally it was it was not a very calm environment, but I did notice that as I was engaged in the conversation post-session uh with this person, that um I needed to calm inside, uh, despite the fact that the room was way too warm and I was sweating, which is always a source of stress in a social situation.
SPEAKER_00Jesus woke up while the sea, while the waves were crashing on the ship, on the boat, and he was like, Calm down. But he was like, Chris, go to sleep, calm down.
SPEAKER_03Chris, here's a handkerchief.
SPEAKER_00Wipe away that sweat.
SPEAKER_03But yeah, so again, that was a work situation. I think for for people listening, like family, friends, exercises of patience are certainly uh probably come easily to mind. Yeah, you know. Um what do you think?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean that's that's great. I think my I mean concluding remarks. Um, I would say don't run away from disagreement. You know, this is this is a theme. Um and if we want the holistic satisfaction and comfort and and communion and integration that we're looking for in not just in our own lives, but as image bearers who are called to have, in the most positive sense, dominion over creation and use the power of words and the power of our minds to understand others and to uh be bound to them in the spirit, then uh we can't run away from disagreement.
SPEAKER_00We can't run away from hardship and adversity and tribulation and um uh conclusions that conflict with our worldview, or um convictions that um uh we find abhorrent and uh loathsome. Um but they're patience, it re it requires it's difficult. Don't run away from it, it's difficult, but it does require the Christian uh virtue of patience, and it is a fruit of the spirit, it comes from the spirit, but that doesn't that doesn't mean it will come to us if we never try to practice it, if we run away from conflict and tribulation and adversity.
SPEAKER_00There are many opportunities that the Lord brings into our lives in which we are able to practice these fruits of the spirit. There's opportunities to cultivate them, to strengthen them. And so when you find yourself in the midst of uh a conversation and uh bordering on a disagreement, stay strong, endure, uh see the good on the other side.
SPEAKER_03If you can recognize a gift of the Spirit, then you are so much less likely to despair to be involved in this gift, to receive the gift, to respond to the gift, facing another person, another image of God, despite how they can disagree. And disagreement can serve a great purpose if you can keep this larger horizon in view, to not forget that the spirit is with you, binding you to God.
SPEAKER_03You know, the spirit is God, you're bound to God, you're bound to the other person. We're involved in this relational pyramid, this this relational life. And so, Kyle, to what you've said, I would I would say amen. And I would hope that people can exercise patience with this larger view not to despair, to endure, and to transform the world, leading us all towards greater communion.
SPEAKER_00Well, neighbors, thanks for listening. Next time we'll continue in our series here on uh two poor spirits on the series of long disagreement in the same direction. And we'll look out, we'll look at how disagreement can cultivate the Christian virtue of humility. Till next time.
A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...
Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...
Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...
Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...
You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...