Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Two Pour Spirits

Two Pour Spirits artwork

Sex for the Common Good

Mar 2, 202552 minAudio

What hath the Spirit and the Son to do with sex and society? It's a question that will make the pious cringe, but will make the private quarters of the home thrive and the public square flourish. Sex is good. Say it out loud: "Sex is good." But how, when, where, why, who, what? That matters. OnlyFans, Pornhub, incelism, and the "impurity spiral" ain't going to get us there. In this episode of Two Pour Spirits, Chris and Kyle talk about what you do in the bedroom trickles into the classroom and (possibly) into the White House. The private will always make splashes in the public. The connection and communion that transitions from a rib can make or break a republic. Sex has a purpose. Do it in the right way. Do it for the common good. Welcome to Two Pour Spirits. +++ Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor is a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the Church and the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically-oriented, and practically-minded. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Kyle David Bennett and Christopher Cimorelli. https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor | +++ Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a think tank and training ground for spiritual formation and the common good. Visit Projectneighbor.org to learn more.

SPEAKER_04We are in our second episode of season two of Two Poor Spirits. Welcome, everyone. We are excited. I hope you're excited. I hope you've been on the edge of your seat, dripping with patience, waiting for this next episode to be recorded and dropped. In this season two, we're focusing on the family and the common good. What relationship does the family have to the common good? How is the family a public good, anything good? In last episode, we discussed the nature and purpose of marriage, and specifically how, from a Christian perspective, it is a covenant and not a custom or a contract.

SPEAKER_04And we tease that out. We'll probably get into that a little more as well in this episode. And upholding the notion that uh it's good for society. In this episode, however, we're going to talk about something far more controversial. Something that makes the pietist cringe. And in their vocabulary, it is a four-letter word. In this episode, we are going to talk about sex.

SPEAKER_04Oh, I'm already getting uncomfortable. I don't know what to do with my hands. Uh, but we will be looking at uh how sex is good, how it is uh beneficial and profitable for the common good. What relationship does the privacy of the home have for the public square? But Chris, my brother, it's been a minute since we've been together, and I'm excited to be recording this. And I'm also excited to be sipping on this concoction that you have brought together into one glass, almost like a male and a female into one flesh.

SPEAKER_01What is this bad boy that you have created? Well, thank you very much, Kyle. It's good to be back together. Uh and yeah, I'm already feeling very awkward just based upon that transition.

SPEAKER_04Did you see what I did there with the setup for the cocktail too?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I uh well aware. Um, you know, I'll encourage people as I go through the cocktail here to be careful because there is a stimulant in the cocktail. So um we're not getting too excited, but we're excited for the episode.

SPEAKER_04We should make everything plain for our audience. Yeah, very much. Make sure they they understand the references and the figures.

SPEAKER_01That's right. So um there there is a an espresso cocktail uh called the carahillo, and what what we've produced tonight is a version of that. And I'll I'll tell you what's in our glasses, but then we also have a recommendation uh for for the people listening. So in this modified carajillo, we have two ounces of liquor 43, which is a Spanish kind of digestive.

SPEAKER_01Uh, we have two ounces of cold brew espresso, uh, an ounce of spiced cointreau, which we feature in a lot of drinks.

SPEAKER_04It's been a couple weeks. What do we refer? How do how do we refer to that? Is that called the Jesus juice? Oh, yes, it is.

SPEAKER_01The Jesus juice. And and every time I I laugh and I feel also uncomfortable. We're gonna be all about discomfort. Yes. Uh so an ounce of that, and then in this drink, we decided to add a splash of bourbon. Now, all of that goes into a cocktail shaker. It kind of filled it up uh so with some ice, and and so I used a a spoon to kind of stir it up and then pour it out into um tumblers with a large cocktail cube and uh garnished with a cinnamon stick.

SPEAKER_01So that's what we did, and it's pretty nice, I think. Yep. Uh, but what I would recommend is that in a in a future edition of this drink, then instead of using the two ounces of the liquor 43, which has a little sweetness to it, uh probably drop that down uh to one ounce, and then from there decide whether or not that splash of bourbon increases or not. Um most of the the catahios, they don't really have bourbon at all.

SPEAKER_01Uh so you could end up dropping that and just going with uh the other elements that we've got. What's the bourbon you used? I used uh Maker's 46, which is it's a pretty good. I mean, it's it's solid, especially in drinks like this. Yeah.

SPEAKER_04I'm trying to envision or imagine. Um I recently was mixing with wild turkey bourbon.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. Which is is that the rare breed or the regular one? The regular one.

SPEAKER_04Okay. Um, and I'm just, yeah, I'm I'm thinking of that in some cocktails that I made this past week, and it's it's a lot more smoky, but I think this blends really well with on the one hand, you have a citrus flavor on the front end. Uh and it's it's a little malty.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04I'd say a little malty, and it's almost like honey. There's a layer of honey to uh maybe that's the 43. Is that the 43 or the 47?

SPEAKER_0143.

SPEAKER_0443. Uh, but I also I mean the spice on the tail end of the palette is pretty remarkable. I mean, both the cinnamon and that cointreau with the uh peppers, yes, uh that remarkable.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and just in hindsight, because the original cocktail calls for kind of two ounces of the cold brew with two ounces of the liquor 43, if we basically subbed in instead of the two ounces, the the one ounce of the liquor 43 and one ounce of the spiced cointreau, that might achieve kind of the the delicious combination that we're we're talking about here. The bourbon's a nice addition just because of our preferences.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, well that that is a really great bourbon. Yeah, I'm I'm I'm imagining and in envisioning like wild turkey, but also like a bullet.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Like I think the I think the makers is the right choice. But just because I've had uh some other coffee drinks with wild turkey or uh bullet, they're they're very different. They are like even even just a splash, you know. I mean, we tasted we tasted it without the bourbon.

SPEAKER_01That's right.

SPEAKER_04And then put a splash in there, and it's almost like half the drink changed.

SPEAKER_01It did.

SPEAKER_04It was just a half it was just a splash, you know. Well, speaking of splash, let's splash into our topic tonight. Sex. Let's talk about sex, baby. But let's not talk about you and me.

SPEAKER_04Um, Chris, sex and the common good. We're we're in this theme of the family and the household and marriage, and inevitably we have to talk about sex and at least inquire. Sex is a very private matter. Uh, it's a very, as we'll get to, a very intimate activity. And yet, I think a foundational belief that we have as Christians is that it's a good thing, and Christians ought to be able to talk about it. Um, and we want to inquire in what sense is sex, just like family and parenting and all of the other uh uh family topics that we will discuss, is that does sex have any indirect or direct or periphery or uh ripple repercussions down the line benefit to the common good?

SPEAKER_04Um does it have any bearing in what you know it's done in the secrecy of a room in a home. Is there any way, again, directly or indirectly, that it has bearing on the public? And so let's start with just exploring that topic. What does sex have to do with the common good? I think um I I would just start by saying, well, very philosophically, very fundamentally, you you don't you don't get society without sex.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. You don't you don't get a place in which a good could be common, or uh you could have a society in which the common good could be prized without the preservation and promotion of society, which comes through sex. And so I mean, just very, very basic, obvious um connection. Sex has to relate to the common good because you wouldn't have the arena or the area or the community to seek the common good or to have any common goods without sex building that community in that society.

SPEAKER_01That's right.

SPEAKER_04So I would start by saying, you know, sex is related to the common good because it promotes and preserves and uh um conceives society. I would also say it's a gift from God. And um it's a gift from God that um you know is a unique intimacy and companionship between Adam and Eve, you know, we were talking about Adam and Eve last episode, uh, between a husband and a wife and this covenantal relationship.

SPEAKER_04And so it's it's something I I mean I I'll wait for you to offer some initial thoughts, I but but I want to connect it to within scripture later on, the apostle Paul, he really takes hold of marriage and connects it to the church and a mystical union. There is a mystical union to sexual intercourse within the context of a covenantal marriage. And um I would say that in some sense, and we could tease this out in a little bit, in some sense, it's a commandment when God says to Adam and Eve, be fruitful and multiply.

SPEAKER_04It is a commandment to build society, and it's a commandment between a husband and a wife within this covenantal relationship to build society. And so I think at the outset, I would just say, you know, you have this design by God for uh for sex to be something that brings two people together, which is public. It moves from private to public.

SPEAKER_04If private is just the individual, if if that's like the if that's the depth or or the uh reduction of privacy to the individual, that's the most private. Then even the household and even the bedroom is a little more public than just the private. So already, with a husband and wife coming together in a covenantal marriage and having sex in their bedroom, that's more public than just you yourself.

SPEAKER_04And the purpose is to build a household and uh build uh who you you know, you then have kids who then marry others and build another household. And you have this building of society. So I would say, you know, on the one hand, the the uh the nature of sex itself is public in that you're having sex with another person, and that's that's more public than the privacy of just yourself.

SPEAKER_04Uh, but it also builds a public, it builds the space and arena for there to be a common good. So that would be my initial uh uh assertion or connection with sex, you know, what what uh bearing does sex have on the common good?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I think that's a great lead-in. And you know, anytime you're you're dealing with you know covenantal logic and and the biblical narratives, you're dealing with a relational view of reality. And there's nothing that's uh purely individual because even even the the deepest personal experiences of God are then lived out, you know, in community. So this is um yeah, consistent. Be fruitful and multiply, as you mentioned, right? Um in a sense, you're kind of carrying forward what we see in Genesis with God establishing order in creation, and yet it's it's these couples coming together, um uniting and building, right?

SPEAKER_01And and leading to ever greater, you know, societies. But it starts with this kind of small unit, the um the husband and wife, and all of a sudden, you know, this builds, it leads to something greater, and that leads to something greater. So I think it's very much connected to the common good, those conditions which enable people to flourish. Um, whether you're thinking more individually about what constitutes kind of a full human life, um, sexuality is clearly a part of that, yeah, right?

SPEAKER_01Even if it's not um the vocation of every person, but it certainly is a part of full, authentic human living. But at the same time, it brings the person beyond the self and it leads to kind of social consequences. Um, and so the idea then is that it like the way the Lord orders creation, these types of relationships can help to build creation and order it correctly and establish and kind of manifest that covenant that God's already kind of provided for.

SPEAKER_04So if you don't mind me interrupting, what do you mean by consequences? You're just using that very generally to ripples and rip repercussions.

SPEAKER_01Right, yeah, yeah. Nothing, nothing like nefarious or right, got it. Yep. Yeah. So again, like I'm I'm very the way that you introduced it, I think, is very helpful. You know, in my own tradition, we have uh we have this sense of of the family as a domestic church, the place where the stories of of faith and salvation history first kind of manifest, but in the family unit, which starts to build and grow and it's fecund, and you know, it kind of leads to kind of greater and greater riches from it.

SPEAKER_01And then the family is the first place, and then as you kind of exist in the family, which again is a consequence of sex in some ways, right? Which now then translates to greater and greater levels of participation in society, but it all starts with uh the uniting of the couple, uh, and and and kind of the openness to life and and producing life.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. I can't help but think, and this I I don't think this gets us far off track, but one of, I mean, one of our arguments in Project Neighbor is that communic communion always precedes us. And I you intimated at that, if not indicated a moment ago. You know, Adam and Eve, or you just the origin of all things had to come from somewhere and someone. You know, and in a second, in a sense, I'm not, I'm not, I'm not, I'm using this very, very loosely, and I'm not trying to be heretical at all, but you know, in a sense, God gives birth to creation.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_04There there is an inner Trinitarian relationship in which they all work to create. And from the beginning to the end, it's all about communion and community. And I would like to, as you noted, you know, the apostle Paul makes some except some exceptions with respect to marriage in 1 Corinthians as, you know, that not all are going to get married. Right. Not all are going to have sex, uh, some are going to abstain, but but we are we were all made for communion, and we were all made for community.

SPEAKER_04And there's different layers and levels of intensity, of, of intimacy and companionship. Um and so though we're talking, though we're talking about sex as a physical activity, there's also a parallel conception or um, you know, uh an imaginative example in which you should think of your life in terms of building like a household by being um, you know, in the right sense of the word, and in your walk of life, being intimate, intimate and a companion with others in greater intensity.

SPEAKER_04So no one is excluded from this, even though we're talking about sex in a very specific term, there is this much broader understanding of, you know, communion precedes us, and we were made for community. And it doesn't matter if you're a monk or you're an ascetic or you're someone in isolation, there is still communion that precedes you and will succeed you. And uh we were created to be individuals who uh drive towards relationship and community.

SPEAKER_04And so I think that's important to remember, as you know, we are talking specifically about sex, but sex has to be seen within this larger divine project of pulling all things together, knitting them together, greater and greater community and intensity with one another, fellowship, partnership, companionship. I think we have to see sex. We can't we can't lose sight of that in specifically talking about this physical activity.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, and and I think there's a really good biblical precedent for this. I mean, we we we see already that Adam and Eve, in terms of theological anthropology, the understanding of the person, you know, they're intimately connected already through their bodies. Yeah, right, uh, the rib and so on and so forth. So there's that. I mean, and then I'm thinking about you know, Mark chapter 10, um, when Jesus kind of seems a little bit more demanding when it comes to the divorce law and saying, no, no, like the the you know, man leaves his father and mother and joins with a woman to become one flesh.

SPEAKER_01And like Moses only made exceptions because of the hardness of your hearts. To me, this really kind of doesn't just focus on the the the procreative ability of a marriage, but the fact that it's the uniting, the coming together of of man, man and woman, and kind of uh a manifestation of of the biblical image, right? Yeah, that we get from the very beginning. So it's very bodily, it's very connected. Um, so that comes to my mind. I think about the song of songs, and I think about the there's so much erotic.

SPEAKER_04Well you will you recite some of that for our listeners?

SPEAKER_01Uh I will pass on that as much as the cells and mountains and no, no, I'll I'll I'll spare our listeners. Um, but I will say this that it's meaningful to the reader, even though you're being being drawn out of the literal and you're being kind of immersed into the allegorical, the deeper spiritual meanings. Uh it's it's using erotic imagery precisely because it is so evocative and it and it it captures a really important uh fundament well fundamental experience of humanity, right?

SPEAKER_04So, yeah, that's what I'm and it yeah, I mean and a desire, a transcendental desire and drive within us. Yes. Um, you know, the the sexual impulse is not merely physical, it's spiritual. And it is uh, you know, I I think I believe God has designed us in such a way that even through that we're yearning to be in touch with Him. Um and it's not just something that's pleasurable, it's that that's what that's why it's not merely. Merely pres pleasurable, but it touches us in a deep, deep way of being known and and uh knowing.

SPEAKER_04Um something else that you said that I I just want to put my finger on, and I'm not sure how I would articulate it or tease it out, but you know, you're talking about the rib taken out of Adam. It's also interesting, I wouldn't call it marriage, but as we're talking about communion preceding you, uh, you know, Adam comes from the dust.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_04Adam comes from the ground, and then God breathes ruach, breathes breath into him. It's like you don't get a man without dirt and God's breath, and you don't get a woman without a man's rib, and you don't get kids without a man and a woman, and you don't get a society without kids who grow up and build and build and build and build, you know. All the way down, it is uh communion and community, and it proceeds and succeeds you.

SPEAKER_04Um, and God has designed history and nature to unfold this way, and and sex is a part of that, it's a gift. I would note too that it it it benefits, there's so many things that we could say specifically that um benefits the whole of society.

SPEAKER_04So it not it not only creates, it not only promotes and preserves society, but like it's good, and it's good in different ways. And I would just broadly uh uh broadly pinpointing some things, I would say that the goods that it has for particular people is also beneficial for society and how they live in society. Now, I think the most obvious one is the husband and the wife are pleased by it, it's enjoyable.

SPEAKER_04They leave that activity feeling refreshed and good, and they're happy. Right. It's it's a relief, it's pleasurable. Um, and and so uh physically it it it is a relief and and it's enjoyable. I would say also spiritually or um uh yeah, I mean spiritually, it it is a it is a mystical union, it is it is a a connecting that is so satisfying, not just not on a pleasurable level, not on a sensory level, but but you feel known and you know, and you're safe and secure and stable in that.

SPEAKER_04Like this person knows me. And uh in and that is that is good for you, and it's good for you as you interact with other people out in society. You know, so I think on a very, very basic level, like this is good, this is good for your, and I'm not trying to make it utilitarian, but it's it's good for your it's good for your attitude, it's good for your mindset, it's also good for your emotions, and it's good for how you approach and interact with others.

SPEAKER_04I would also say, you know, if if it's kind of us, God and neighbor as the sort of the uh the trifecta of aspects of society or or um agents in society, if you will, uh, that's that's how it's good for us and our spouse. I think it's also, I think it also benefits God in the sense that it places emphasis on this marvelous aspect of the created order, that sex is a gift.

SPEAKER_04And we show our obedience to him by using our bodies to glorify him. Uh we could be running off with others, you know, maybe we'll get to this here in a little bit. We could we could do sex so many different ways, but by doing it the right way that God has ordained and prescribed, we honor and glorify him. And we we also we in by because he has designed the created order in such a way that there could be a society and there could be a pursuit of the common good, insofar as we honor and serve him and do it that way, it inevitably has benefits for society and how we interact with others.

SPEAKER_04And so we're, and this gets me to the third one, our neighbor. You know, it points our neighbor to the right way to engage in this activity. That God has given this as a gift to preserve and promote society and to bring about a very, very unique union between a husband and a wife. And this is good news. This is how things ought to be done. Um, and so it testifies to and speaks to the world, to our neighbors, that this you were made a sexual being.

SPEAKER_04And uh, in whatever whatever level or layer you know that is, and this is a good thing, and you should pursue this, and this is how you pursue it. And um, one thing that I constantly come back to, I was joking earlier about pietism, but and that that that's not really um I think I think it's funny to joke about that, but actually I think a real problem in society and in the church is you know, latent Manichaeanism, like this um, oh, you know, like God didn't really, you know, God doesn't like matter as much as he likes spirit.

SPEAKER_04God doesn't like the physical as much as he likes the transcendental and getting out of here and living in heaven and being a spirit without an body. That's that's her, you know, that that's that's wrong. That's that's not an orthodox position in the in in the Christian church. And I think that there are some Christians who are like pseudo or or um latent Manichaeans who are like uh sex like so dirty, and you know, right? And and also you have some Christians who are ascetics who uh you know uh don't see sex as a gift.

SPEAKER_04Um and and they try to prevent engaging in that with their spouse as much as they can because they don't want to get addicted to it, or you know, whatever reason it might be, but they pull away. Both the Manichaean and the ascetic, they pull away, and they're I would say they're afraid to enjoy the gift, or they have some reservations about the gift of sex and its person and its purpose within the Christian's life, Christian life.

SPEAKER_04One more thing, and then I know you got a ton to say. On the other side, I think you have, which I hinted at a moment ago, you have those who, Christian or not, are promiscuous. Yeah, they don't they do not see sex as a gift within the context of marriage. And so they'll sleep around and they'll, you know, they'll date and and and do all of the things, and they don't fully understand the gift and the place of the gift.

SPEAKER_04And so it's important for the church, for the Christian to practice the right ordinance and prescription of this is a really, really good thing, but you're doing it incorrectly. It needs to be here in this place. I don't know what you think about that, but those would just be some principles of how we see sex playing out for the common good, as well as different postures and practices that I think the Christian ought to be at least yeah, witnessing to how this ought to be done to the world.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I mean you've you've brought up a great deal, uh, and I have a lot of thoughts, so we'll see how I can try to organize them coherently. Um just recite Song of Psalms. That's right. We're gonna begin. No. So the first thing is, you know, you've mentioned the gift, right? So and gift logic, relational logic, these are these are hallmarks and characteristics of of the biblical narrative, right? So a gift is something that it it establishes an obligation.

SPEAKER_01You know, it's a good thing, it's given, but it's from a giver, right? And and for the recipients of the gift, um they they are now now bound in some sense to uh reciprocate uh and to live well in response to that gift. So that that's number one that I that I would point to. And I would even intensify what you mentioned earlier a bit more, because you know, yeah, we we irreducibly were individuals, but we also fall into a trap of our own making, of thinking of ourselves as a separate individual, right?

SPEAKER_01And I think God doesn't just have relationships in the Trinity, God is Trinitarian relationship, right? And we are the image of the Trinitarian God, we also are relational fundamentally, and we have you know the self, we have God, we've got our neighbor, but there's also the natural world in there, right? And we relate to all these elements, and then when we fall from grace, there are ruptures in all of these different elements, right? So I would think one of the problems that we face is kind of disconnecting sex from this relational view, uh privatizing it, um, keeping it completely you know separate from from all of this.

SPEAKER_01Whereas if we actually can connect this gift and part of our fundamental human being, um we we now have an opportunity to actually respond to God and use this gift well. So there's a chance to actually engage virtuously with the gift instead of just hiding it away, privatizing it. It's it's for me and my spouse. Nobody like doesn't have anything else to do with anybody, right? So now because I will say, right, let's let's shift for a second, maybe a bit more negative, right?

SPEAKER_01Because I think anybody who's been in intimate, close relationships knows that there are good approaches to intimacy and bad approaches to intimacy. And you know, we need to learn to respect this the subject, the the the God-created, you know, good goodness of our spouse as a being loved by God and with whom we are fortunate to be um married and and together, right?

SPEAKER_01To respect that person, right, not to objectify them, not to use them for self-gratification, right? Uh to to kind of be in a healthy, robust, uh intimate relationship that honors God, right? And is part of the praise of God that all creation is is involved with. So these are some of my initial thoughts. And then I guess just to look back at tradition, I think I don't know about the east, but I know we in the west sometimes we have difficulties with sex, uh, because we tend to, for whatever reason, associate it with the fall.

SPEAKER_01Right? Oh, if we hadn't fallen, maybe we wouldn't have to deal with all this, you know. And to your point, like, you know, escape hatch to the to the kingdom of heaven, um you know, spirit greater than matter. Uh, but you know, there are other other possibilities in tradition. There are certain eastern fathers who have theories of double creation and that you know, God all along knew what was gonna happen, and you know, we we we have this capacity which enabled the history of salvation to go to the incarnation, which is the greatest possible thing that could be imagined.

SPEAKER_01Yep. Right. So um now, even if you know, we've talked about virgin birth and all that, but to even get to the point of the incarnation, yeah, you're talking about a whole history before that, and God's slowly leading humanity to understand what it means to love God and love neighbor. Right. So I think these are really important things, and we can't just silo sex away from uh the covenants and that logic, yeah, and how we are to live uh as full, you know, social beings.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah, I think that's rich. And um the connection that I'm making in my head is you do have covenant is the basis for this relation that God intends to have all throughout scripture in being present in the garden and the tent in the tabernacle and the temple. And there is this development of becoming more and more uh intensely present within the created order that culminates in the incarnation and the sending of the spirit, and the spirit being in us, and uh one day God being so present to the to the new city that there's no need for the sun because he will be the light.

SPEAKER_04I think that's really, really rich, and that's the basis for what we're saying here with sexual activity that there is a there's a connection with sex and the relationship with our creator who made us as sexual beings, and there's this intimacy and fullness and connection that he has designed, uh, and it surely is a gift. And I can't keep I can't help but continue to think of just how the apostle Paul connects it so mystically that uh sex totally has a communal and community aspect to it.

SPEAKER_04Um in the same way as he talks about in uh I think it's 1 Corinthians, uh, in the same way he talks about um the bodies of the uh marriage couples becoming one flesh, it's similar to the bride of Christ and uh the bridegroom. There is this sense of being in, we are in Christ, and you know, the the two become one and they become one thing, and it's it's public, it's it's something greater than one or two individuals.

SPEAKER_04It's it's something much, much bigger. And I was also struck in First Thessalonians, uh, Paul continues to talk about uh you know having sexual immorality and having sex apart from one spouse is a transgress and wrong to your neighbor. Um if we don't do sex correctly, then we're harming others and we're hurting others. And that's an issue within the common good and and doing good by the public, you know.

SPEAKER_04So whether it's um, you know, you could think of all of the different things that one could do, you know, um, you know, fornication or you know, just sleeping around and and whatnot. This we we think it's innocent, so to speak, insofar as it's consensual. But I think Paul would push back on that and say you're harming them in some way because you're not in a covenantal relationship with them, and we're not entirely sure that you will be in a covenantal relationship with them, there's harm being done.

SPEAKER_04And um maybe even as basic, going back to what we've talked about a few moments ago, maybe it's as basic as witnessing to others this is okay. It's okay to have sex outside of marriage. It's okay to sleep around. It's normal, it's custom.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_04You know, marriage is a custom, and having sex with others and sleeping around is just a custom. Uh, and that's doing harm. That's doing harm to the design and God's gift of no, this is meant to be within this context because it's so powerful, because it's so valuable and important, because it's so divine. And so the harm may be done just simply as witnessing to the world that this is okay, and that, you know, that that's harmful. But I would imagine also that those relationships don't typically last the the long haul, and people are end up people end up hurt and broken, and they've given themselves to another that they're not in a covenantal relationship with, and that's harmful, and that's hurtful, and many people have been hurt by sex outside of marriage, and but I can't keep yeah, I mean there's so many connections here that I'm making, but but I guess it it is so it's such a powerful thing, and it's such a it it not a public thing.

SPEAKER_04Don't have sex in public, yeah. Um it but it but it has such a public dimension to it, right? And we cannot overlook that. It is done in private, but it is incredibly public.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it it it's it's something that it's an experience that is unlike any other, and it it has an impact, a deep impact on people. And I think it comes down or go goes back to this idea of gift. You know, yeah, if if if society or culture doesn't recognize that there is a gift, then yeah, the logic doesn't make sense. But for those of us that that kind of exist within the gift logic, right, you see it fundamentally differently.

SPEAKER_01But there's so much brokenness and damage from the you know non-virtuous engagement uh and and types of sexual activity that exploit others or objectify them, you know, treating somebody as a commodity that is enjoyed, and then you move on from right now. Does that characterize every interaction? No, but but just you know, you're dealing with individuals who come together and engage in an activity that is supposed to participate in a covenantal type of logic, and that's how powerful it is because covenants aren't just contracts, they go to our very being, our identities, and they're not individual, they're social, right?

SPEAKER_01So uh when you play with that, or you're playing with fire, yeah, yep, yep, you know, and it's it's to be taken very, very seriously. Um, and so I think that's kind of a a disconnect between uh maybe believers and those who who are you know in different systems or maybe no systems at all, but that's what you're playing with. You're playing with a deep fundamental part of being human that stems from our creator, you know, so I think you gotta be careful.

SPEAKER_04Maybe we conclude with this other angle to the question. You know, what has what does sex have to do with the common good? And we've taken the positive and um flesh that out. Um, but there's also a negative reason, if you will, or or um um set sex has to do with the common good because the world is infatuated with it.

SPEAKER_04Um and uh I can think of uh in and sort of you know, in it so so it it forces us to talk about it because the world is talking about, the public is talking about it. And I think I think sex is relevant to to the common good because it can be so disruptive and dangerous for the common good. Um, and it goes to this uh custom and uh normal uh trajectory that we just mentioned that sex can go wrong in so many different ways adultery, fornication.

SPEAKER_04Um I mean, we're even reading news stories of bestiality, and and it it's just these things are becoming more and more normal and per maybe not acceptable, but um they have to be attended to and they have to be. Become a subject or a topic for the Christian to discuss and see the importance of uh many people don't know how to, not just how to have sex, but they don't know how to do sex within a covenantal relationship.

SPEAKER_04And they need to be instructed, but they also need examples. Um, and so I think the world calls the world calls us to say something about sex for the common good because all of these abnormal and aberrant ways of having sex are become increasingly more prevalent and and more possible. And so I think um that can disrupt the common good insofar as we're looking for stability, insofar as we're looking for covenantal uh relationships, and uh teaching society how to stay together instead of being individuals who run about, run amok, and do whatever they want, and families and generations aren't being built.

SPEAKER_04So I think on the one hand, the world calls us to say something about the public nature of sex. I also think, and mostly I'm thinking of Hollywood and movies, and just how it sex is just so central, if not essential, to a Hollywood film movie. Um, and it's raising all sorts of possibilities and notions and questions about sex, and that's shaping society's anticipations or understandings or expectations of sex.

SPEAKER_04It's in literature and uh pictures and and poetry and all the kind of artifacts of culture are shaping people's beliefs about what sex is and what's normal and what they should expect when they get into a relationship with someone and what's possible and and what's to what's to be expected and whatnot. So I I think that you know we've outlined the positive side of the Christian perspective, but that Christian perspective then needs to be translated and disseminated out in the world.

SPEAKER_04The world is calling into question what is sex and what is it for? And I think if we're going to maintain the common good, if we're going to do something to promote and preserve society, we have to talk about the place in which sex is rightly ordered and placed.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think that's right. And I think part of part of the job of a Christian is to witness, uh, to evangelize, to encounter the other. You know, and I and I I think one of my I guess I don't want to say regrets, but one of the things that I find unfortunate um is is when Christians condemn others, but it's also important for us to make known the the logic of the gift and the connection of these intimate acts with the common good.

SPEAKER_01Because it's not, I don't know if it's kind of um just apparent to everyone, yeah. Abundantly apparent. So it's kind of it gives us a challenge, kind of a creative challenge to say, all right, we need to do a better job of talking about covenants and the gift and this beautiful aspect of human being, right? Um and then to bring up you you talked about some of the negative aspects, and I think we have to talk about them because now I I would say off the bat, right? There there are distinctions, certainly there are big distinctions between um some of these acts, like for example, something uh obviously grotesque like bestiality.

SPEAKER_01Um but then of course we also have you know extreme or excessive self-gratification, right? Um now on the surface you might say, oh, one's really natural and and is prevalent and and one is you know disgusting. But at the same time, like if self-gratification involves habitual objectification and the use of pornography, uh that's destructive of relationships.

SPEAKER_04Uh that's they're both disordered sexuality. So that's it.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, when when you're dealing with the idea of covenants and and what God has established, you're dealing with order. And so if something has that disorder built into it, we need to kind of attend to that. Yeah, absolutely. But but instead of like taking a condemnatory kind of tone, I would say more of all right, we we have to shine a light on on the nature of this gift, uh, because it is so powerful. Uh so I mean that would be more of my approach, uh, and then to kind of help people see that yeah, objectification, exploitation, disorder, these are these are problems that that can really, really upend and undermine any possibility of the common good.

SPEAKER_01And as a matter of fact, you go back to Genesis, you go back to the fall, and the power differential between men and women, um the the fractures between people, right? These are marks of the fall, and we need to try to to to live as if the kingdom of God is with us.

SPEAKER_04Right, you know, as if he's reconciling all things unto himself, including, you know, our marriages and families and households. And um I'm thinking, yeah, yes, obvious obviously our sexual activity and how we engage in that. I'm also thinking, too, about parenting. And you know, I I I think as I think about Hollywood and I think about and we we we're gonna have a couple a couple episodes on parenting, and we certainly will talk about this, but it's also uh I'm also uh connecting it to what we're talking about here that um what I what I let my kids watch and read is shaping their and and forming them with particular anticipations and uh hopes and desires for relationships and when they're old enough for sexual activity and uh a marriage and in a covenantal relationship.

SPEAKER_04And it's so that there's something there too, like you know, there is as a Christian father, I have to not only um I have to engage that with my children and know when to say, no, this isn't good for you to watch. And uh yeah, we're watching this, but uh I just want to let you know this is not how we understand the right and appropriate way to do this. Um and so yeah, just thinking about the next generation, as we think about the common good, uh, and we think about um what sex is for and how it benefits society and the common good, there's also preparing the next generation to be a good society that seeks the common good.

SPEAKER_04And you know, we're we're we gotta do that too. Well, this has been fantastic. We've been talking about sex for like what 45 minutes? Great. Um next episode. Thank you everyone for joining us. Next episode will continue in our family life and the common good series by focusing on parenting. How are we supposed to parent?

SPEAKER_04What is a Christian parent? What's a Christian household? What should we uh discern to do and determine not to do? So join us next time. Thanks for listening to Two Poor Spirits.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Your Seams Are Showing: Loving Our Neighbors through Fashion | Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo

    Nov 13, 202654 minAudio

    A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Embrace Boredom and Boss Better

    Oct 29, 202655 minAudio

    Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Be a Better Colleague

    Oct 1, 202649 minAudio

    Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: Don't Make Your Boss God and Your Kids Swag

    Sep 12, 202657 minAudio

    Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How to Be a More Hopeful Neighbor: See Your Failures as Blessings

    Aug 13, 202653 minAudio

    You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...

    Credit the people on this episode