Maybe we're all here just figuring it out based on curiosity and piquancy. I could have been an NBA star but chose to be a writer instead. You could have been a model but got sidetracked tinkering with mechanical engineering. Orrrrr: Maybe we all have callings. Maybe there are things we are supposed to do in life. And maybe God designed us for them. And that's what we have to figure out. In this fifth episode of season four, an "excast," Chris and Kyle turn their heads and hearts toward vocation, discernment, and how to trust your conscience in such a clamorous and confused age. Yet this ain't no ivory tower pageantry of pontification. They give real sticky advice. Like pay attention to your dreams, register your attractions and aversions, and don't be too quick to race past your mistakes. + + Welcome to another episode of Two Pour Spirits! Where signature cocktails meet spirited conversations for the sake of the Church and the common good. + + Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor ecumenically educates, equips, and empowers the Church to image her Creator and love all creatures, including her enemies, in public places with particular practices. From soil to sky, crib to casket. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Rev. Dr. Kyle David Bennett and Dr. Christopher Cimorelli. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Krista Morelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the church and for the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the Catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically oriented, and practically minded. We hope that you enjoy the conversation and camaraderie of two poor spirits, and make no apologies for the background noises that mark our fellowship, the clinking of ice and sloshing of liquid among them.
SPEAKER_01Let's build up together.
SPEAKER_00Visit projectneighbor.org to learn more seeing you in all the old familiar places.
SPEAKER_01As you prepare to enjoy season four of Two Poor Spirits, we just want to note that this episode was recorded off-site using wireless lav mics, which accounts for any discrepancies with our normal sound. Many thanks, dear listeners.
SPEAKER_02Welcome back to another episode of Two Poor Spirits. We are in the midst of our fourth season in which we've been talking about common grace and communion in culture. As we look at various cultural artifacts, we're exploring what truth, goodness, and beauty that we can point out. Might we find Christ and his church being promoted in these artifacts more than what's being prescribed? It has been particularly spectacular, but we thought we'd take an episode off, so to speak, so that we can discuss a region of topics that are vital today, like discernment, vocation, and conscientious living.
SPEAKER_02How do you know what you're supposed to do in life? Like really know? How exactly do you figure that out? And how do you hear and trust your conscience in such a clamorous and confused age? Chris, it's a magnificent moment to always be hanging with you and deliberating. We are not downing a cocktail this week. Unfortunately, but unfortunately, there's no Jesus juice involved this week. Um, he's in our hearts and our brains, but uh we're sipping on some Buffalo Trace bourbon.
SPEAKER_01Which is pretty pretty good.
SPEAKER_02It's it's a good go-to. But I I wanted to publicly thank you for all of the cocktails that you have concocted this season. You've got it. Uh they have been marvelous and magnificent, and I think we've got some real classics that you've put together. So thank you for all of the drinks that you have made in the past four seasons.
SPEAKER_01You're welcome, brother, and it's a pleasure to be casting once again and taking a break.
SPEAKER_02All right, well, let's let's get into the weeds and let's talk a little bit about uh discernment. I think the the background to this topic, it seems like it's come up in rudimentary ways over a number of episodes that we've done. Uh how do you know what your vocation or calling is? And and we've kind of been thinking about it in our in our cultural moment in which it's very noisy, it's very clamorous, there's a lot of voices, there's a lot of opinions.
SPEAKER_02Everybody is, I mean, on the one hand, we we are living in a cultural moment in which it seems like anybody can be or do anything. And so the sky's the limit as to what you can do or what you can be, and I think we'll have to talk a little bit about that as a Christian and understanding what discernment and and vocation means. But but also not just what's possible, but also there's so many voices telling you to do this or to be this.
SPEAKER_02And so, what what do you do? What can you do? How how can you have a concept of vocation in a world and in a society like this? And what does it even mean to discern when there's a cacophony of voices and everything's well, literally, everything's on speed dial, everything is, you know, full steam ahead, don't have time to discern, and do we even have time?
SPEAKER_02You know, think do we even have time for our conscience to kick in, so to speak? Like these are the conditions in which we find ourselves. Um, and so within the Christian tradition, vocation has been uh you know a central concept for us as individuals. What has God called me to? What has God called us to? And discernment has been a spiritual practice. How do you how do you discern what's right and wrong? And how do you discern things in your own life?
SPEAKER_02And of course, you'll have much to say about the conscience, you know, central concept, central activity in in the Christian's life in order to have a conscience and to use it in your everyday living. So it seems like we find ourselves in a in a cultural moment in a society in which there's a breakdown of vocation, inability to discern, and perhaps some people don't even want to use their conscience.
SPEAKER_02I don't know how you want to tackle it, but let's just tackle some of this.
SPEAKER_01Um yeah, just I think that's a nice setup, and I think that we have quite a challenge before us, but it's a good challenge, a creative challenge, because you know, on the one hand, you can have, for example, a conversation about Christian discernment, vocation, and conscience. You can have that just at any time. You can you can have a conversation from a Christian perspective, but then you add in the layer that you did, on the other hand, with um with the noisy culture, right?
SPEAKER_01Right. So then there's there's the question of Christian vocation and discernment and conscientiousness, conscience, and all this, but then doing that within a noisy culture is also another layer to consider. So I think we should definitely get into it. And I have certainly some thoughts, not least about conscience, but I think again, these are central kind of categories for the Christian, for the believer. Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_02Why don't we start with vocation and then discernment and then conscience? Do do Christians believe that we have a vocation? Do do we believe that we are called by God, not just to God, but called by God to a He's gifted us with talents, he's gifted us with interests, uh, he's made us in our mother's womb in a particular way to be a particular kind of person. It seems to me that vocation is something that's indisputable for the Christian, that you do have a calling.
SPEAKER_02And we're lit, we're living in a culture in which it's almost as if calling is disparaged. Don't be beholden to something. Don't let God tell you what to be, right? You be what you want to be, right? No, I I I think there's there's a rejection that we have to that we have to have of that mindset that uh we are called. God did make us a particular way and with a particular skill set, and he does call us to that.
SPEAKER_02Now, I think you also you also heighten the setup too. It's like, how do you hear someone, you know, so how do you hear someone call your name when everybody's shouting? You know, and that is that is that that coupled with discernment and the inability to take the time to hear God's voice in your life. We're we're in a moment in which it's very noisy and people don't necessarily believe that we have vocations, right?
SPEAKER_02Right? So I I think I think we are running, we are running against the wave, the crowd, the wall, and we do have to, we do have some ascending to do and and retrieval of God has made you for a particular reason at a particular time, in a particular place to do particular things, and you have to discern what that is and hear his voice and listen to that calling because that is how he has made you.
SPEAKER_01Thoughts? Plenty of thoughts. Um, there's there's something so fascinating. Like we think about vocation as I think for some people like spiritual calling could be a way to do it. Um, but it's fascinating because it it in Latin, at least, like what vocare, it's like to call, but when you when you make it vocation, it's actually passive. So we're being called, and like to you, uh to your point, that is actually one of the maybe controversial or difficult things for people today is that you know your life is not your own.
SPEAKER_01You are called by your maker, by your creator to, in some sense, to discern your gifts, yeah. And so there is a this wonderful connection between the concepts that we we have here. You are called to not only realize what your gifts are and to realize them in the world, but to to kind of offer them up not only for yourself, for the church, for the building up of the world. So there's something fundamentally relational about it because again, from the creator, from our maker, the Lord has given us our lives and our gifts, and they're meant to be used in a way that is, you know, we would say thoroughly Christian, neighborly, and relational.
SPEAKER_01So um, I actually I love that, and then this whole whole idea of calling for people that might be, you know, wondering about, I mean, it's from the very beginning of scripture. Yeah, God calls God's people, right? And God's word is active, and that word, we are images of the God who creates through God's word. So um, it's certainly in in in the New Testament, um, it's everywhere as well. So we have this idea of uh the Greek word is clesis, and that comes from Kaleo, which is also a really good band.
SPEAKER_01Uh oh, I've never heard of them. Yeah, I like I like that's another band we could talk about. So they're contemporary, yeah. Oh, interesting. Yeah, they're they're they're good. Um, but yeah, these these gifts are given and they're meant to be used in in a way that is in correspondence to the God who is love and who has revealed so much to us.
SPEAKER_02There's something there too, I think you're absolutely right in in the emphasizing the relational element to it, and not just relational between us and God, that He has called, He is the one who has called us. But I think the relation, the relational element is not only external in that sense, God and me, it's also internal in the sense that even though the culture and the world, the world is noisy and the culture is telling me I can do anything and be anybody, there is an internal conflict within me that I know that I wasn't made to do particular things.
SPEAKER_02Because when I pick them up and I fail at them, and nobody affirms me in them, and I like I know that I'm not doing what I'm supposed to be doing, right? You know, so it's almost like I I mean, I think the relational the relational conflict is so deep. It's like well, on the one hand, the relational con the relational conflict is so deep on both sides.
SPEAKER_02It's God isn't just calling you to something, like, hey, I think you'd be really good at this. It's almost like a command. This is who you are, do this. I made you to do this, I orchestrated everything.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02This is you, flourish, go do your thing, you know? And so it's more of like it's more of a command than it is just a mere call, right?
SPEAKER_01That's fascinating, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Can I can we pin it for just one? But but I also think the internal, the internal strife and conflict is I I deep down know that. And that's why when I fail at things, I I'm completely unsettled. Or when I don't figure out, is this really me? Am I supposed to do this? It's an I it's an identity issue. It's not just, you know, you've been called to fly planes. It's not a checklist item that you could just say, oh yeah, here I am, and I'm flying planes.
SPEAKER_02It's your entire personality and who you are. And it's either, you know, fulfilling because that's how God made you, or you know, it's not your calling because it's not fulfilling. And that's that conflict is just gonna keep coming up until I'm doing the thing that I know this is what he made me for, and I'm doing it, and that's why I'm so fulfilled in doing it, you know. So I think that the relational is so deep on both sides.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. The and I think that kind of already indicates the importance of ongoing discernment when it when it comes to what what we're called to do. Because there are times, and I think we've probably both had them in our lives, where there might be some failures at the outset, but yet there are some affirmations or signs that you know what I have some support here, I might have failed at this, but there might be something else.
SPEAKER_01Like, it's not me trying to make you know go to the NBA.
SPEAKER_02Right, yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01It's like a 40-year-old, 40, 42-year-old.
SPEAKER_02Or you or you feel called to like journalism and you start out on that, and there's some affirmations, but you're like, no, I'm I'm in the completely wrong place.
SPEAKER_01I need to go play professional basketball, you know, like yeah, so that that's where it's like I'm in complete agreement. And this idea of potentially the experience of a command or I I actually think that's provocative because I think of like Thomas Merton as just an example because Merton was highly intellectual throughout his life, but as a young man, this played a part with Vice, you know, his ego and his literary capabilities and the kinds of people he was associating with.
SPEAKER_01And when he he was really good at writing, right? And he kind of gave that up when he became a monk, yeah. And as a Trappist, you know, he's going through all this training, silence, and but after after years, you know, his uh the abbot brings him in, is like, you're gonna write, and so something that he thought was yeah, like he had given up and I moved away from it, and it's no longer my thing. It's like, well, actually, now it is your thing again because you've gone through this process, and and so sometimes the gifts that we have, yeah, if we even if we try to misuse them or mismanage them, or it's not the right time in our life, there's a way the journey of faith can kind of bring the gifts back into focus.
SPEAKER_01And they might be used to build. And obviously, he's one of the great spiritual masters of the 20th century, so it's inspired millions of people around the world. So it's a good thing that he was given the command to write.
SPEAKER_02Discment, because I guess what I'm trying to wrap my mind around is once you get some kind of hint or clue as to what you're called to, who you are, and what you were made to do, which is gonna take different manifestations and it's gonna unfold differently throughout your life. Ideally, it would be I've got, you know, when I'm 12 years old, I want to be a fireman.
SPEAKER_02And then over the years, things start to unfurl and unfold, and and I know that I'm gonna be a I know I was made to be a fireman, right? But I think you can also take missteps or you can make mistakes, but still, in the course of all of that, there's gonna be some kind of clue or hint or vestige of this is part of your your calling. You know, what exact you're you're a good writer?
SPEAKER_02Well, okay. Uh I learned that I was a good writer when I was a teenager, but then I tried my hand at academics, I tried my hand at poetry, I tried my hand at newspaper articles, you know, and but and all along you know that writing is part of your calling, but what what exactly that looks like and where it is and who your audience is, this is a discernment process, right? So I think like you're always, insofar as you're discerning what exactly your your calling is, you're gonna get bits and pieces of it.
SPEAKER_02And you might get more greater understanding as time unfolds. Uh, but it also might take a different turn or a different manifestation, and that does require discernment, yeah. You know, just moving into discernment, like it requires taking time to reflect on where have I been? I felt really fulfilled in writing in those spaces and whatnot. But here I am now, and I'm not in that space anymore with that audience.
SPEAKER_02So, what space am I in now? Who's my audience, and how should I write? Should I have a different style of writing, you know? And so that that invokes discernment, taking that time to uh gain insight into what's my context now, and again, speaking to our speaking to the condition and the cultural moments, like we're we're in a moment in which people don't even reflect, period. Right, with all of the media and all of the information and the the fast-paced lifestyle, there hardly is any time to discern.
SPEAKER_02And then we we have this this cultural problem where people don't know who they are and what they're supposed to do, right? Right, and and it's anxiety reigns, and we don't know what to do with our hands, like uh what's the space on Talladega nights? You know, I don't even know what to do with my hands, but you know, I I am thinking like we we're we're walk we're um running uphill backwards, trying to emphasize that vocation is a category for the Christian.
SPEAKER_02We're also doing the same with oh, and you should practice discernment because people don't have time for it and people don't know how to do it, and people may not even see the need to do it, right? You know, but we do need that time of reflection.
SPEAKER_01We do. It's you you use the word insight right away, and I think that's a good one, like getting to the heart of a matter, um some sort of perception into it, like separating out things, yeah, and that takes time and it takes work, and I think numerous Christian leaders and pastors have pointed this out for a long time, which is that you need to take time to reflect, to step back. If you're gonna live wisely and live well, you need to take that time, but we don't do it.
SPEAKER_01And a lot of times, too, like let's say a natural moment might be at the end of the day when you no longer have any obligations that are at the forefront of your mind. But a lot of times we we'll we'll sit in our phones and we'll doom scroll. And you know, this this actually the first two categories here vocation and discernment, it really reminds me of like. You know, I'll I'll use Newman for a second. And Newman said, uh, in terms of like this idea of vocation, which again, it's not career, it's not a career that I choose, it's about being called by God.
SPEAKER_01And he said that we're all called to some particular task that is ours and ours alone. And part of our life is to figure out and to discern what that is. But even Newman in his own time lamented how much information was out there, how fast the news worked. And he he he mentioned something like called like the vibration all around. And and then you think about you know that's a rich image. Yeah, like 170 years later, with you want to talk about vibration all around or like frequencies all around, or that which can kind of interrupt um and prevent like what we're what we're talking about here with developing insight and getting to the heart of a matter, which again takes time and effort and sifting, right?
SPEAKER_01And that's even a concept that's with littered throughout scripture, you know. Even the idea of like separating out and seeing things, like you can go to Genesis 1 with with God creating and this separating things and calling it good, but then the concept really comes out um through the history of salvation, you know, Hebrew scriptures to New Testament. So I absolutely think we we are challenged, we are deeply challenged now to be you know discerning Christians, and yet what how do we get there?
SPEAKER_01How do we resist the onslaught of information? Some people tell our generation, for example, that when we were growing up in the 80s, that you know, nowadays kids are taking in 80% more information, but they have no greater ability to process that information. As a matter of fact, it creates almost a sense of like paralysis because you don't know what to do with it, so you just keep scrolling, right? But how how do you receive, discern, and and find your way forward to live out your vocation?
SPEAKER_01And I think that's a great challenge for us.
SPEAKER_02That's interesting. This is total nerding out philosophically, but you know, it is it what that just elicited for me is there is this hope, perhaps, that the more information you take in, and not on a conscientious level or register, but the more information you take in, kind of like learning a sport or a craft, you'll absorb it.
SPEAKER_02Now, on the one hand, I would say that's not not that that's a different kind of knowledge, absorption, but like we're not talking about scientific, you're not gonna learn scientifically about things just by absorbing, right? That's a different conversation that you know that's a different epistemological conversation. But the what what that just elicited for me is like it's it's it's almost as if the way that we are learning how to process information is antithetical to the practice of discernment.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02Because if you're absorbing things all of the time, you're not separating them. And the more and more you absorb, the less and less time, and the less and less proclivity, and the less and less capability you're gonna have to be able to say, no, wait a second, I don't need that, and wait a second, I should you know, you know, and and it's not like you can absorb six days, and on the seventh day, all of a sudden be able to practice discernment and sift through all of it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know what I mean? Like so that it there's something there that is deeply problematic. That we're it's not only the case that people don't discern anymore, maybe they can't even do it because of how we're learning. Because of how media is is mediating information, and our uptake and consumption of it is deteriorating any faculties or skills for discerning.
SPEAKER_02We don't it's not that we just don't have the time, we don't even know where to begin, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you got any thoughts? Yeah, I mean there there are so many thoughts. Um again, like now I don't think these are necessarily etymologically completely related, but again, the idea of setting apart or sifting, like there might be some connection there to even how we kind of identify holiness, right? But in this case, how how do I I'm like struck by what you said about not having the time like absorbing for all these days, and then is it possible to kind of do something on that seventh day, like a kind of flipped version of the of the Sabbath?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know. Um, I think that would be incredibly difficult, if not impossible, um, because you know, discernment is supposed to be ongoing or at least, you know, I think integrated into our lives in a very kind of healthy way. Each and every day, you know, how are we discerning what we're called to do, how we are to be a Christian, where God is, you know, where we're encountering God through others and our neighbor, like this is something that needs to be habitual, but yet if we're just going through the motions and and receiving an onslaught, and you know, I'm not sure how we collect ourselves right um within all of that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Let's uh let's move maybe a little bit. Uh I mean, this has been totally stimulating, but let's move it a little bit more of a constructive practice. Like, I have some thoughts about how do you so for the person that says, okay, I recognize that I am called by God and I am an individual and a person, and He has this, he has this plan for me, He has this mission for me, and I want to know what it is. What are what are some signposts or some clues to know what it is?
SPEAKER_02I would break it down, I think for me, I would break it down into different aspects. Like, I think, for example, I think the things that we are curious about, that we daydream about, that we envision ourselves in in kind of an intriguing way, like I think that clues us in a little bit to the desires of our heart that God has given us, right?
SPEAKER_02That we find something fascinating about this occupation, but we find this one banal and dis you know dismissive. And we we I don't I don't care about plumbing, you know, but I do care about electricity, right? And so um, so I think like what occupies our minds, or like what we think about, daydream about, what we're curious about. I also think I was initially thinking of two ways in which this comes out, but like how we're emotional about things related to that.
SPEAKER_02Like, do you get really passionate when you hear somebody talking about being an electrician and putting wires together and all like you get excited, you get passionate about it, and you're like, yes, yes, yes, this is a good occupation, people should be electricians more, you know, almost like a moral grabbing of it. I also think there's an aesthetic aspect to it, too. Like, I find feces disgusting, so I don't want to be a plumber. Right, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_02Like, so so your feelings about aesthetics and tastes and uh aversions, like that should tell you something about how God has made you and designed you. Now, sometimes that can be fickle, and it's just like one stage of your life, you hate that, and then you find yourself in another stage of your life and you may not hate that. But I do think that consistently, like the things that you're passionate about, the things that that either attract you to them consistently over time and in different ways, or you know, propel you away and say, I don't want to have nothing to do that.
SPEAKER_02Like those would be just simple signposts. What do you spend your time doing thinking about? Uh, what do you get excited about? And uh, you know, what do you find repulsive and you just want to get rid of? You know, like those should be clues or signposts uh as a start for what what how God has made you and what he's called you to.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I I mean, I think there's kind of a natural segue into conscience here. I don't know if you want to.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, go for it, go for it.
SPEAKER_01Um, so when we do when we think about conscience, I think there's there are opportunities for daily practices. So I want to I want to like unpack conscience a little bit, but I first I want to attend to what you said because we were talking about the practical. You know, there are opportunities each day to take a little bit of time. So this gets into what we talked about with discernment as well, to do short exercises. You know, in the Catholic tradition, there's like the Ignatian examin, which actually is used all over by very different folks, uh, even abbreviated forms of the exam, where you know, where in your day did you have you know really positive feelings, really negative feelings?
SPEAKER_01Where did you feel God's presence? Um, where are there opportunities where you might have, well, that didn't sit well with me? Why didn't it sit well with me? What might I do different next time? And that's the type of thing where if you can incorporate that on a daily basis, a little bit of time to think about it, some of those signposts I think might actually become more clear. Sure, yeah. Because then you're saying, like each day, you're more conditioned to be on the lookout for those types of things and to think in a different way and see in a different way.
SPEAKER_01So um, I do think that's the type of practice, obviously, prayer, right? Like daily prayer or you know, prayer as needed, also, you know, if you if you find yourself struggling or asking God, what did you make me for?
SPEAKER_02What am I supposed to be doing? Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I think like maybe when we get to the end, I'll want to treat this because I think Jesus, in terms of his time in the desert at the beginning of his ministry, but also in the Garden of Gethsemane, I think these are two, you know, classic, provocative, rich examples for every Christian to consider, every person of goodwill to consider about the nexus of like conscience, vocation, discernment, right? Because you you know you have quite the mission ahead of Jesus and also the culmination of that mission and the difficulties that he faces along the way.
SPEAKER_01So I think I think those are two examples I'd love to talk about if we if we have time in this episode, of course.
SPEAKER_02Can I ask let's go there because um and you're referring to let this cut pass if like there's a more there's a moral wrestling in that or spiritual wrestling?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I just don't know if we have to define conscience at the time. I was just about to ask you.
SPEAKER_02I mean, you've done extensive work on conscience and and Newman. How would you distinguish between the conscience strikes me as a faculty, a thing? Discernment strikes me as, or discerning strikes me as an activity.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Is that right? Is how would how would you differentiate between discernment or being discerning and the conscience and what the conscience does?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so when I when I teach conscience, there there are many aspects to it or many dimensions to it, you might say. So linguistically, of course, it comes to us as a noun, but very often I think our experience of it is as a verb, right? And that's where it kind of connects, I think, to discernment, the way that you've described it. Now, conscience itself, if we break it down into like etymology, we have you know, conciencia with knowledge, with knowing. Um, and so it's not just this thing that is equivalent to personal opinion or like just how I feel in the moment, right?
SPEAKER_01Sure, yeah. It implies a process of doing something with knowing and with knowledge. Um, so there's this seeking that has to do with the activity of conscience, right? So this is a is a faculty. This is uh for Christians, I believe this is um kind of part of the constitution of our being, is that we are beings of conscience. And one of the reasons for that is because, you know, despite any technical or etymological definitions of conscience, many Christians will describe it in phenomenological experiential terms, in which it's the voice of God or the echo of God's voice within us, that we are born with a moral faculty, a moral sense, right?
SPEAKER_01Where we understand that as we live and act, there are certain things that we we do that we feel good about, or we we we think, wait a minute, I should, I shouldn't have done that, I ought not have done that. Like, um, and so for someone like John Henry Newman, he very much puts in place the power of conscience as this experiential thing where we're connected to God through it. This reality of being connected to God. And this reality, when you start to look at it, shows us a couple of things that there is right and wrong, that we are responsible before a lawgiver, and that we are called to listen to conscience in concrete situations.
SPEAKER_01Like that I need to up, like in this moment, I have a decision to make. So you know that there's right and wrong, you know there's a lawgiver, and you need to live it. Right? So these are some dimensions of conscience, but even for someone like Newman, conscience itself is a signpost that shows us that we need more. Because, of course, as great as conscience is, we struggle, and sometimes we're not completely sure, and we need guidance.
SPEAKER_01And all it's already a faculty that implies we need to learn and know more. And so for him, whatever image of God we might get from the experience of conscience, it's it's kind of like asking and begging for God to reveal himself. And so for Newman, the natural the natural like experience of conscience that every person has is conditioning us to be ready to receive revelation, right? So it's like the this natural, wonderful thing we have wants God to reveal so that we can have an even clearer image, and that's what God does.
SPEAKER_01God prepares us through history, God cultivates a people out of Israel, and then God extends to everyone through the revelation of Jesus Christ. So now this is where like Newman's understanding of consciousness is completely bound up with history and with experience. To bring it back to where we've been, right? This noun is actually something that needs to be activated. And I think that's where, in its activation and kind of perpetual working, is where it really is connected to discernment.
SPEAKER_01And for the purposes of living out our vocation, right? So responding to God's call, God's voice, so that could be vocation, the call, conscience is the faculty by which you kind of experience that call and you discern the response to it. I think there's some sort of like rich nexus of all three.
SPEAKER_02That's right, too. I was just gonna ask you, um, it does seem like the way that you framed lawgiver, right and wrong application, that the conscience would be involved if it is a noun in the moment or just in this scenario I'm setting up. That conscience is conscience employs discernment, conscience engages in discernment. Okay, there this is tricky here. I know what's right and what's wrong.
SPEAKER_02That's a good, yeah, I like that. But but how do I do that right here? So is that fair to say that conscience precipitates discernment?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, right, yeah, right.
SPEAKER_02And I like the I mean that that's a great way of thinking about it is hearing God's voice from from within. Again, connected to vocation and a call. I don't remember if you said this uh before we transition to the last part here. I don't remember if you said this, or I heard this somewhere, but did Newman believe that you could lose your conscience or significantly dull it or something?
SPEAKER_02Like, yeah, I don't remember if it's like framed in terms of like what Aquinas called like not blindness of senses, but something like the dullness of your discernment, the dullness of right and wrong, because you don't cultivate it and you don't listen.
SPEAKER_01Am I trying to you're yeah, exactly you're on point because um, and this again part of the broader Christian tradition too, but for for Newman, right, the the experience of conscience kind of generates an image of God, and that image, I think, even at the best of what we get naturally just from being alive and being part of whatever you know social traditions we're a part of, the image would always be the equivalent of like walking around in twilight.
SPEAKER_01And for Newman, you know, when you respond to the voice of conscience and to the lawgiver and you do what's right, and when you do something wrong, you you realize that wrong because it really seers you and hurts you. If you respond well and like learn from it, now the image becomes a little bit more luminous. But even at its best, it's like twilight, right? And so that's why he thinks it's kind of anticipating or calling for a clearer revelation to come. And that's where like something like the light of Christ or the light of revelation over time, that's where all of a sudden now you're starting to get back into daytime at or even at the fullness of it, the brilliance of the noonday sun.
SPEAKER_01And so for Newman, like, but if you choose not, if you start to ignore conscience, we're habitual beings, like our our actions matter, our day-to-day uh activities matter. So if you start to ignore the voice, the image will become dimmer and duller, and it might get to a point where now you're no longer perceiving the voice. It's covered over too much, you know.
SPEAKER_02And that I think the voices of others or yourself, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I'm sure that connects really well with Aquinas and also with the church fathers in some ways. Um, so yeah, like you need to kind of take care with yourself and to cultivate that. And if you find yourself down a bad path and you've got to try to claw your way back with God's help, of course, you know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. All right, well, let's let's conclude this. This has been uh once again stimulating. Let's conclude this with just some prescriptions and suggestions, recommendations, uh summing it all up. Um, you know, you mentioned prayer and taking time, like let's get nitty-gritty, concrete. What do we need to do to be able to reinstitute vocation, practice discernment, and take seriously the conscience?
SPEAKER_02I I have a couple thoughts.
SPEAKER_01Go for it.
SPEAKER_02We need to talk more about vocation, yeah. Like just instruction in the Christian tradition as to what does this mean? Like, we need to educate people more in terms of vocation because we are we are competing with a culture that says everything just happened, nothing is put here, you know, nothing is put here that's been determined. It's all in flux. Just do the best you can.
SPEAKER_02And I think we need to reintroduce providence, we need to reintroduce sovereignty, we need to reintroduce his created order, and it's it's all meant to be orchestrated together and work together and flourish, just like the common good, and you know, just like our conversation about society. So people have estates and stations, and people have places and callings. So re educate our re reeducate the church, educate our children, and talk more about vocation.
SPEAKER_02Uh, I think there's a lot to be said for practicing discernment and piggybacking on the Ignatian examine. Like, hey, one time to practice discernment was Would be go to bed early 30 minutes before you usually do and just be quiet and discern and pray and ponder your day and kind of in that examined way. You know, whether whether you're fresh out of college trying to figure out what to do, or you're making a career shift, or you've lost your job, just take time every night for foreseeable.
SPEAKER_02I mean, maybe your whole life, but also just in those moments in which you're trying to discern what your vocation is. Something simple as, you know, go to bed 30 minutes early, pray, discern, think through things. You could cut things out of your life like eating breakfast if that's going to be your time to discern. You might be on the go. Don't listen to music, or you know, practice some silence and um and engage in discernment.
SPEAKER_02And I would say the conscience, I I would, I want to ask you, like, what would be some helpful books or a helpful literature for the everyday person to like, here's the theology of conscience. You should take it seriously. Because I think that's immediately where my head goes is I think people need people need the category. What is conscience? You've defined it for us, great. But like, what's the theology of the conscience?
SPEAKER_02And how do I how do I come to terms with that so I can take it more seriously?
SPEAKER_01You know, it's so fascinating that you you you pose it that way because I realize this is probably a problem I have, which is I've talked about conscience with you know people discerning whether or not they're gonna be Christians, or you know, they're gonna convert to Catholicism and doing catechesis. And almost all of the things that I read are like academic, dense types of literature. So I don't think they're like necessarily appropriate for someone who's just trying to like think about it.
SPEAKER_02Well, maybe your calling is to write one.
SPEAKER_01Maybe. I mean, I would almost recommend to someone to take a look at like the Ignatian exam, because there are there are so many spiritual books about that, like popular, more popular spiritual literature. Because you mentioned like taking that time each day, and I think that's essential. I think taking a little bit of time to look back at the day to recollect before the end is really important.
SPEAKER_01Um, I like what you said about talking more about vocation. Maybe we don't do it enough, and maybe we're too, maybe we're too quick sometimes to allow people to talk about careers and not to talk about well, you know, a career is something that I like seems more about me, right? Yeah, right. And and a vocation is something that's relational, yeah. So I do think we need to talk about it more. I would say that to I think this really aligns with what you said as well.
SPEAKER_01We've talked about sacramentality before, we've talked about Project Neighbor being integral, it's it's through everything. And I heard in a documentary recently about um Pope Francis, I heard about this line about the the the veil between heaven and earth is gossamer thin. And and I think that's a really important thing that that in an Augustinian line that God is closer to us than we are to ourselves.
SPEAKER_02Say it for me one more time.
SPEAKER_01Which one? The veil, yeah the veil between heaven and earth is gossamer thin. And that the uh and again that God is closer to us than we are to ourselves, which is something that conscience, I think, brings home.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01So I would say to to the the Christian, like really to anyone who's willing to examine their conscience, like, please engage, you know, enter the fray, ask the tough questions, see where God might be speaking to you, see where things might have gone wrong. It's worth it because just by cultivating that, you're actually cultivating a much deeper relationship, something that um can really move us.
SPEAKER_01And by by just asking those questions each day and taking a little bit of time, you're actually engaging in discernment, you're responding to conscience, and you might maybe discover your vocation, and that's where again I would point people to to the our Lord and our savior. At the beginning of his ministry, he goes into the desert, and this is a person possessed of all power as we can understand it, and eventually is tempted and has to discern what is being offered with what he already has in plenitude to determine no, this is not what's right.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and I'm gonna rely upon the things that I've learned in scripture to answer the devil and and defeat the devil, right? And then you you fast forward and you go to the Garden of Gethsemane, and again, Jesus doesn't want to die, it's not his goal, but what am I called to do to give witness to this kingdom and to put his life on the line for love, right? And and you see him struggling, but he took the time, and he was always trying to take the time to pray, even though people kept hounding him or falling asleep or not listening to him.
SPEAKER_01Yep, he took the time to pray and to try to figure out what was what was called for in that moment. So, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, as always, Chris, this has been absolutely fascinating and spectacular as uh we engage this topic. I think we've got one more, at least schedule Xcast in the queue on repentance, remorse that uh that we've been wanting to do for a while. But I think after this episode we'll catch back up into our series on the cultural artifacts. Thanks as always for listening to Two Poor Spirits.
A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...
Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...
Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...
Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...
You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...