You like the taste the soap? Yea, me neither. But how do you know what soap tastes like? I bet your mother probably introduced it to your palate back when you were a young buck spitting swear words left and right. You probably also got reprimanded with a skinny finger and thrown in timeout for a hour. Oh, I bet you got spanked, too. A lot. Well, welcome to the club. In this episode, Chris and Kyle deal with disciplining children. Why do we do it? As followers of Christ, how should we do it? They first tease out the goal of discipline and why we shouldn't outsource it to grandparents, teachers, or police officers (oof). Then they offer tips and tricks from the Bennett and Cim households. Take some time out of your silent car ride to hear why timeouts are good for everybody. + + Welcome to another episode of Two Pour Spirits. + + Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor is a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the Church and the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically-oriented, and practically-minded. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Kyle David Bennett and Christopher Cimorelli. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a think tank and training ground for spiritual formation and the common good. Visit Projectneighbor.org to learn more.
SPEAKER_02Looking at how the institution of the family and its dynamics and practices bear on society. We're currently in the last leg of our season here with the theme of raising kids. And last episode, we looked at the nature of a parent, like what is a parent, and the features of parenting. And this episode, we're going to look specifically at discipline and parenting our children through discipline.
SPEAKER_02What is discipline for? Why do we do it? Um why shouldn't we pass it along to others if we don't enjoy it, like grandparents or teachers or police officers? Hopefully it never gets to that. But uh, why do we discipline for what purpose and to what end? And so we're going to explore some of those things, and Chris and I will even talk about, I believe we're going to talk about tips and tricks or just best practices in our home, what's worked for us.
SPEAKER_02Um, but before we get there, Chris, it's good as always to be hanging out, man. I love our friendship and fellowship. Uh, and always a delight to be sipping on and slurping spirits here, as we are two poor spirits, but we are being filled with the spirit. What is this spirit that you have poured into our glass, my friend?
SPEAKER_01Kyle, my friend, it is a pleasure to be together once again, and I'm excited for the topic this evening. Uh, this particular cocktail, we had to discuss it a little bit. How are we going to name it? And we came up with the fifth gospel.
SPEAKER_02I do love it. Now, just to be clear, too, it's not a Gnostic gospel. No. I mean, we might call this the gospel according to Chris, but that's not a Gnostic gospel. This is the fifth gospel.
SPEAKER_01And I'm not claiming that it's part of the canon officially.
SPEAKER_02But someday it could be. It's part of our mixology canon.
SPEAKER_01Sure. It's so let's go through it. I'll try to take you through the process of making this, which was kind of in depth. It's a little different. So not too long ago, I read about um something called a palo alto old-fashioned, which involved smoking a type of simple syrup, a cinnamon simple syrup, uh, with Palo Alto wood. So that turned out I I couldn't make the exact recipe because I didn't have all the ingredients.
SPEAKER_01So I decided let me try to think about what we've done, what we have, and what we could possibly make with that. So I thought about the drink that we've done a couple times now in the in the podcast, the old cash in, and which is kind of a riff on the old-fashioned staple cocktail, and I started to get inspiration.
SPEAKER_02The fire was lit underneath you. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01People are well aware at this point of your proclivity to say the words Jesus juice. That is correct. I just name things for what they are. So so I figured instead of using simple syrup, let me take the traditional, now I think it's traditional, Jesus juice, and experiment with that. Did you riff on Jesus juice? I did. Sacrilege. Yes. And this riff we call the day of the Lord. And God forgive us.
SPEAKER_01But we we took the original idea of Jesus juice, which again, normally it is quantro, which is an excellent orange liqueur, and which is clear in color, but when you steep it in red pepper chili or red chili pepper flakes, you get kind of this orangey uh type of liqueur. Well, because this this particular cocktail, the Palo Alto old fashion, called for cinnamon simple syrup, I figured let me not only steep the quantro in red chili pepper flakes, but also crack a cinnamon stick in there.
SPEAKER_01Nice and steep that for about half a day to a day.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_01So that's what I did. And then I put it through a fine mesh sieve a couple times and proceeded to bottle that, but then before it was complete, that's where the palo alto element came in. I have a little smoker and I shaved off pieces of Palo Alto wood into the smoker, lit it, and couldn't go above five to ten seconds smoking this quant this Jesus juice with cinnamon.
SPEAKER_02Why don't we call this the day of judgment, though? I mean, like there's so much spice. So actually, I'm sorry, I'm interrupting and oh, it's fine. But it is what what's fascinating to me is the description you're giving makes it seem so spicy and fiery, right? And hot. But the drink itself, you do get the citrus first. And the spice is so latent and absent, and yet at the tail end, like the last two seconds of the swallow is when it hits you.
SPEAKER_02It's like it's like deep throat, you know? Like it, it doesn't hit your palate initially until you've actually swallowed it. And it's almost like the spice just like a firework just springs back up and hits your palate. And I'm fascinated by that because there there do there seems to me to be three distinct flavor moments. And the first is citrus.
SPEAKER_02I'm not entirely sure what the second is. It it's it's it's moderate, it's it's massaged. But then the third is this spice, and it's strong, it's potent, and it springs back up. Like I do not I do not taste it on the back of my tongue. I taste it when it's halfway down my throat. And I'm fascinated by that. Like, how's it so clandestine? Like, you know, it's like a covert spy just popping back up and shooting, you know, a sniper into your throat.
SPEAKER_01Like, yeah, it's great. Well, I'm I'm I'm really pleased with it. I love this string, honestly, if I'm being perfectly honest with you right now. So we have this kind of again, the smoking aspect with the Palo Alto wood, you have to be really quick with it. We're talking, I did five to ten seconds in this mug, and I turned it upside down while it was smoking, then took the top off and blew the smoke out as quickly as I could so that it wouldn't become harsh.
SPEAKER_02And brought fresh aroma to your house.
SPEAKER_01That's right, and then bottled it up and incense for your church. So, how did it all come together? Well, what we did was we took a tumbler, cocktail tumbler with a large cube, used the Phi Brothers uh chocolate bitters, the Aztec kind of bitters, a bunch of dashes of that on the large cube, and then in a uh shaker we had uh small ice, uh, and then into that poured a cup. Well, for each glass, we're doing two ounces of in this case, maker's mark 46 cask strength bourbon.
SPEAKER_01So a little bit of a heftier bourbon to kind of hold up with the ice. Uh, and then we did an ounce of the Day of Judgment or Day of the Lord. This uh quantro, enhanced Jesus juice. Uh so we shook that up for about 10-15 seconds, poured it over that uh cocktail cube that had the Phi Brothers chocolate bitters, and then finished it off with an Italian cocktail cherry with a little bit of the juice, stirred it up, and that's where we are.
SPEAKER_02Oh, I love it. Well, cheers, brother. Thanks for making this for us.
SPEAKER_01It's it's I think we might have to do this one again.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I agree. Actually, as I'm thinking about it, and you mentioning the maker's mark, maybe the second flavor beat profile is the sherry oak.
SPEAKER_01Oh, that could be, right?
SPEAKER_02That it starts with the citrus from the cointreau. You get a little bit of a um a massaging sherry oak flavor that tempers the citrus and also perhaps tempers the uh uh spice so that then it takes a few mo it takes a few moments before the spice pops back up and says, Hey, I'm still here, guys, you know? Yeah, yeah. So yeah, it's delicious and very complicated and complex.
SPEAKER_02And thank you for making it. Um let's talk about parenting and discipline, right? Um why do we why do we discipline? What are we disciplining for? And I think for me, like that's the most important question. Why do we do anything? What what's it what's it for? I I can't help as I'm you know, we say we single out words. Um sometimes it's themes, sometimes it's words, but we're talking this episode about discipline.
SPEAKER_02And and before we before we ask the question of what is discipline for, I'm entertaining the I'm I I I want to understand what discipline is. And I can't help but um you know just go etymologically to what does this word mean? And it is something that is it's it's throughout scripture, right? Disciples, disciple is tied to discipline.
SPEAKER_02And I think there's something really fecund and fruitful there and and productive in our imagination and thinking about what does it mean well, first of all, to be a disciple, uh, which we've talked about in previous episodes, but how is that tied to discipline? And how does that sort of shift the shift in in our heads certain things about what it means to be disciple, uh what it means to be a disciple and who Jesus is, and is Jesus disciplining his disciples they're all tied, right?
SPEAKER_02You know. So, um, I mean, I I think the the etymology of the word or the origin of the word meaning learning and teaching is important for how we understand discipline. That discipline is is the process or the act of instruction and guidance and pointing and turning and shaping and steering to the in in the right direction to the right end.
SPEAKER_02And immediately, so from from that understanding of the word, immediately my head goes to, well, that's different than punishment. Discipline is different than punishment. When you punish someone, you make them feel pain for what for the wrongdoing that they've done. And that's the goal. The goal is to make them feel pain. Or the goal is to uh make them feel the opposite of what they've done for as long as the consequences or the implications need to be.
SPEAKER_02And that gets into like retribution and just like proving a point and so on and so forth. That's that's different, it seems to me. That's different than discipline. The goal of discipline isn't the moment. If if punishment is about moments and making them feel the pain for as many moments as they did something wrong, discipline isn't about the moment, it's about getting to the end so that they do the right thing, so that they don't do wrongdoing, but they do right doing.
SPEAKER_02So punishment and uh payment for the infraction or the wrongdoing that they've done is not really part of the equation. What orients discipline, unlike punishment, is that you're trying to move past the wrongdoing so that the wrongdoing becomes right doing. And you do what you need to do in disciplining so that you can move past, so that they learn from the wrongdoing, but they learn to do the right thing.
SPEAKER_02So you instruct them in the right doing, in the right thing, and you teach them how to do and what to do as the right thing.
SPEAKER_01Would you agree with that? I th I think that's right. I'm also thinking about the difference or the distinction between in the moment and in hindsight. And I'm wondering about the Bible and the the people of Israel, the history of Israel, and about how what might be experienced as punishment at a given time might be discipline, might in the long run, in hindsight, yeah, be understood as pun as um as discipline.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yes. So but then again, that that's a little bit I don't know if it's dangerous or not, the distinction that I'm trying to make, because it takes a long time to kind of be able to see what had happened in that light.
SPEAKER_02But you're also bringing to the surface the different perspective of the different perspectives of the one who's doing the disciplining, yeah, and the one who feels like this is punishment, which is the different, you know, might be a different perspective from the parent and the child. Right. That the parent is attempting, God is attempting, the father is attempting to discipline. But to the Israelites, it feels like punishment. Why have you brought us out into the wilderness to suffer?
SPEAKER_02We were better off in Egypt.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Right. We ate steaks, and you're making us eat manna. You know, like this feels like punishment. And so I think that is an important distinction and observation that there are there could be two conflicting perspectives from the child and the parent. Um, but also, as I noted, there could be there could be a difference in perspective in the parent that they ought to see what they're doing as discipline and not punishment.
SPEAKER_02There has to be a distinction there. Punishment is I'm angry, I'm gonna yell at you. You're inconveniencing me, I'm gonna spank you. Instead of why do you need this attention? What's what's going on from your day? How do you tick? What's going on right now so that I can help steer you back to where you need to be?
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02So there there is you're you're raising a um an important distinction uh to the surface of the perspective of the the discipliner and the disciplined.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And there's also the distinction between discipline and punishment, and there's a distinction between the motivation of each. Right? You could also you could also be very angry and discipline and it not be punishment. Now I've got to think about what that what that might look like, but but my gut tells me that you could still discipline a child angrily and it not be, it could be oriented towards the end, but it carries a little bit more anger in it than it ought to.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I think that's right. And even from personal experience, I can say anger enters into the into the equation a bit. Sometimes I feel a little bad about that. In a sense, yeah, this distinction of perspectives or between uh discipline and punishment, I think they're helpful, or at least they're helpful for considering the actions that we're already kind of engaged in. And as a parent, you kind of you feel it's your responsibility in some sense to instruct your children, to teach them so that they might learn.
SPEAKER_01And perhaps you're you get mad because they're not behaving in a way that corresponds with the Lord and that which we've been given and that which might be promised through baptism and and these types of things. And you know that they're not always necessarily ready to understand the deeper truths, but you're trying to bring them along the path, instruct them along the way. And as as that kind of path is undertaken, the responsibility increases.
SPEAKER_01Um, but anger does certainly enter into the equation.
SPEAKER_02That is like the most frequented terrain of parenting. Yeah. I mean, we don't feel sorrow, like, man, I wish my kids were like better actors. You know, like I'm I'm so sorrowful. My kids aren't where they, you know, I I expect and anticipate them to be. Anger is easily, you know, we easily slide into that. I also think it's interesting that we um I think it's interesting our expectations for our kids.
SPEAKER_02And I I I have to confess, I was gonna ask you, do you have any confessions, you know, uh about anger? Yeah. Um like how did you fail as a parent today, you know? Um, I also am struggling currently, and I'm not being disingenuous, I'm being very honest and forthright. I'm currently in the process of dealing with my expectations for my kids. And specifically, what I'm dealing with is we have taught and trained them things, like for example, what to do after dinner time.
SPEAKER_02Go take your bath, go brush your teeth, make your lunch, consider, if not prepare, for breakfast tomorrow, and lay out your clothes for tomorrow so that you're prepared in the morning when you're sleepy and groggy and all of the things, that you still have things prepared so that you can, you know, be prompt and and punctual to school.
SPEAKER_02We still struggle with that. And I'm dealing with on the one hand, like, dude, I have been teaching and training you to do this for 10 years, straight up, ten years. What's going on? Like, what the heck is wrong with you? But on the other hand, it does, I do question my expectation and my anticipation that leads to anger. Why do why do I expect them to be able to do this after 10 years?
SPEAKER_02I mean, I don't, I think they should, but it does raise the question for me, like, have I given, have I put enough time into teaching and training them? And should I expect them to be able to do that after 10 years? And given the age that they are, you know, like it just for me, it calls into question like, have I have I given enough consideration to this? I'm expecting a lot from a six-year-old, and I'm expecting a lot from a 10-year-old.
SPEAKER_02And I've only taught and trained them for maybe a half an hour window for six and ten years. I don't know what the math is on that. But like, do the hours compute? Do they add up to wow, you have done considerable training and teaching? This should be a habit, right? You know, I'm not excusing their behavior, and I'm not, I'm just I'm wondering, you know, like, are my expectations and my anticipations, do they line up with how many hours I've put in and their capability and ability to know and remember and process and do, you know?
SPEAKER_02Sometimes I think I I sometimes I don't, sometimes I think I haven't put all the work in, I guess is what I'm saying. And then that leads me to say, dude, it's been 10 years, and then I get angry, you know? Yeah. And like maybe it's not, I'm just this is my confession. Maybe that's not fair. Maybe I haven't really put in all the work of teaching and training and instructing and disciplining.
SPEAKER_02No, no, no, no, don't run around the house, okay? No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, you know. Maybe there's more work to be done. Just that is what I want to raise.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that that really speaks to me. Um, this idea of expectations for our kids. And I think about well, a couple of things come to my mind immediately, which the first I would say is that we've already spoken about in previous episodes, right? We've talked about children, we've talked about parenting, and I think there's something for us to learn here that we expect a lot of our kids and we get angry when they don't kind of conform to our view, but maybe this should throw us back on ourselves a bit and realize that we are like children before the Lord, who's been trying to instruct us from the beginning.
SPEAKER_02How dare you accuse me of being a child? So I get yep.
SPEAKER_01So I think that that might be an important moment here, just to think about the same type of patience that God might have with us. Maybe we ought to have with our kids. So maybe this might lead us to think about our intentions in disciplining our children, trying to lead them on. But to your point, like I really take that to heart. This idea of I've been trying this for a decade, and I'm expecting things, right? And I think scripture confirms this idea that we ought to discipline our children.
SPEAKER_01This is not a bad thing, this is a good thing. I'm I'm thinking also of Proverbs, and chapter 13 is one that we started to discuss before the conversation today. You know, a wise son loves correction, right? And don't spare the rod. Right. Uh now we can get into that idea in itself. Uh that might be a different conversation. But in a sense, it's instructing children, and you're instructing them with a purpose. So, what is the intention?
SPEAKER_01What are you trying to lead them into? And maybe it ought to be a difficult work, as is the case with humanity before God.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a good point.
SPEAKER_01So I don't know what do you think about that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, I think it also uh I I like the I like the linkage to our relationship with the Lord. Um, I think there's a lot to think about there. I also think it, you know, you you before you went there, you said it throws us back on ourselves. Yeah. I think it also throws me back on myself that I'm responsible. My my kids do have their own wills, and they're often selfish and self-centered and broken and fallen and sinful.
SPEAKER_02Just like mine. But I'm responsible for them, and I think it does throw me back on myself, have I, which is kind of what I was confessing and bringing to the surface. Have I done all that I could do to habituate them into doing the right thing? Looking at scripture, whether it's Joseph or it's Job, right? Uh, you're praying for your household, you're the one responsible.
SPEAKER_02You know, I think immediately of Job. Like he prays for his for his kids if any of them have offended the Lord. Ultimately, it falls upon me as the father that if my kids are not doing the right thing, I'm culpable. There was something more I could have done. Now they have their own choice, and hopefully I've raised them to be kids who and eventually adults who do the right thing.
SPEAKER_02But it it the orientation should be one in which before I get angry at them, you six-year-old, I can't believe you haven't gotten this down. You 10-year-old, seriously, like what is so deficient about you? It should throw me back on myself to say, have I done all that I could do? Am I modeling it for them? Am I an exemplar for them? Am I teaching and training them more than just 30 minutes every night when I, you know, run around the house chasing them and put them somewhere and yelling at them and telling them, go brush your teeth, go brush your teeth, go brush.
SPEAKER_02Am I actually putting in the work to take them upstairs and standing in the bathroom and maybe I read to them so they brush their brush their teeth? Maybe I sing to them so that you know, right? Like it does, it for me, it does throw me back on myself to raise the question of I'm responsible. Have I, as the parent, as the teacher, have I taught you what you need to know, and are you living it?
SPEAKER_02I think you know that that that is the the onus somehow flips and it's on the teacher. Have your learning objectives and your quizzes and your tests have they produced the kind of student who can graduate from your class. Granted, they can make choices and they can be stupid and all those, but but it does throw you back on yourself, right? As a teacher, is my pedagogy good? Is the reading and the learning objectives and all of those things? I know you got so I can see your face, like as you know, as professors, we understand this.
SPEAKER_02Like on the one hand, it it is it is a tango, right? It is the student, it is the teacher, right? And and but but we do uh if we are if we are serious about being professors, if we are serious about being teachers, some of the onus falls on us. Have we done have we done our job? And did they get it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I I'm smiling over here because I'm wondering if you are endorsing an outcomes-based assessment model of education. No, just virtue. Okay.
SPEAKER_02A virtue, efficient model.
SPEAKER_01Now, I think so, I think there's something here that we need to really emphasize. This type of exertion, this energy, this kind of commitment to teaching and instructing. I do think it's the task of the parent. It is the task of the teacher to give everything you can to try to instruct and lead. But at the very same time, you also have to understand there there's only so much that's in your control.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01And maybe that's another lesson we can take from the history of Israel and and the scriptures, that people are at varying stages of readiness to receive instruction.
SPEAKER_02And rebellion.
SPEAKER_01And rebellion.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And you'll find that individual children just respond differently to the same type of approach, which should give us a little bit of pause and also allow us to recognize our limitations in this regard. That we we need to do our very best while also not realize well, while also realizing that we don't control everything. Sure. So I don't think we can ever rest on our laurels. We can't just get laxadaisical.
SPEAKER_01We need to do this work because it is the work that we have been called to do. It is our vocation as parents, it is our vocation of people who've been tasked with the gospel and spreading the message, right? And we have our families, our little churches, and this community that we're instructing in the in the ways of the Lord. We need to do that, but it's still not perfectly within our control. So I'm kind of caught between these poles.
SPEAKER_02Which also I I think, yep, good identification, which is why I think, on the one hand, because we sense the onus and the weight of this glorious task, as well as um the frustration and the pushback and the heismen that our children give us in rebelling and not listening, is why it seems like within our culture.
SPEAKER_02So that weight and that challenge is why in our culture I think a handful of parents get fed up and just outsource their parenting to either the grandparents or school teachers or daycare workers, or I mean, even some parents who say, you know, the older, you know, you got a teenager who won't listen to you, like you're willing to allow them to get arrested.
SPEAKER_02So it we we are trying to, I mean, some of that is negligence. Uh I think we have to acknowledge that some parents are just straight up negligent. But there are other parents who are who are uh good natured and want what's best for their children, but they get fed up and frustrated that a stranger or somebody else is the person who's really gonna get to them, who's really gonna, you know, smack them on the backside of the head, and then they'll wake up from their dogmatic and unethical slumbers and start living the good life.
SPEAKER_02And yeah, I'm also thinking about parents who just don't want to put in that work, and so they send them to a Christian school. You know, your your teachers will do that moral formation for you for you, right? Or spend more time at youth group or go to the, you know, go to church more often, and then you know, you'll be morally formed, and I don't have to put in the work as your parent. I think there's different manifestations of this. There are. But I think we shirk on our responsibilities when we outsource that moral and spiritual formation to others that can be helpful, can reinforce, and be assistance, but but the task is for the parents.
SPEAKER_02There's a reason that, you know, blood of your blood, you are able to have an effect on your children that strangers are not able to.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And so, you know, God, you there's a natural affection there. And it might be difficult to tap into it depending on how many years you don't tap into it, but but God designed things in such a way that your children are naturally going to have more affection for you and be more attentive to listening to you and learning from you and growing with you than they are a complete stranger. God designed it that way.
SPEAKER_02And so, as parents, we do have this very particular and singular calling and commandment and commission to instruct our children in the way that they should go, in the nurture and admonition of the Lord. And that's our responsibility. And if we're failing at that or they're not grasping and getting at it, getting it, then I think there are moments, there not all moments, but there are moments in which we should say, Am I doing this correctly?
SPEAKER_02Have I given it my all?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Is there more to be done?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I have an example that comes readily to my mind. That's great. And so my wife and I, we we both work full-time and very busy, and as you know, you well know, that can create a type of exhaustion. Yeah. And you just struggle to get through one day. But we do have our kids in Christian school.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_01Right? And then we come home together as a family and we have these moments together, and we share stories. But there are times in which stories are shared by the children, and you need to make a decision while the story is being shared to ask follow-up questions, to muster up the energy to say, Well, wait a minute. What what do you mean by that? What exactly happened?
SPEAKER_02Instead of uh-huh, uh-huh. Uh-huh. Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_01Or just keep going. You have to actually engage and follow it up because you know the child. You have an experience that the teachers don't have. You know them better than anyone else. And there might be something there that that precipitates a moment of instruction, even though it's uncomfortable for everyone. We've had this moment in my family, and I'm thinking about my son in particular. Just what happened? What are you talking about?
SPEAKER_01Like, how did that eraser end up from the board on the floor? Please tell us a little bit more about this. Oh, wait, you're saying this? That doesn't make any sense. Clarify that for us.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then all of a sudden, there are moments now for instruction and maybe punishments that are intended to facilitate better judgment, better behavior. So, but when you're tired at the end of a long day, you've both been working, it's easy sometimes to be like, okay, great.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But you've got to make the decision. No, it's my responsibility. I've been tasked with this. I've got to figure out what's going on here.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there is a difference that that um there's a difference between raising your children and letting them grow up. And we've uh in previous episodes, we've we've hinted and intimated and and signaled this. It's easy, it's so easy, especially when you've got working parents and uh, you know, the hustle and bustle of life, to um, yeah, that you know, tonight I'm just not gonna get I'm not gonna engage. Like just go to bed.
SPEAKER_02All right, just go to bed. But but there's still formation happening throughout the whole day, and even in the just go to bed. That's formative for children. We're always making formative decisions, and uh man, it's hard to be a parent. It is precisely because you are responsible for forming the next generation um of image bearers and citizens of his kingdom and fit for society and seekers of the common good, and it is so living your life and working your jobs and being faithful and obedient and doing that while also trying to train and teach someone else, a little neighbor, how to do that is incredibly difficult, but we can't shirk on that.
SPEAKER_02Um, we can't just let them grow into adulthood because the kind of moral being and the kind of ethical person and um you know citizen that we will see in the future will not be something that we want to see.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and put our fingers on and poke you know some issues that I I have heard and I've owned, you know, I've dealt with in my own um in my own family as well as in the in Christian circles about um disciplining with pain. You know, like we distinguish between discipline and punishment. And discipline is the goal for the Christian to correct and to instruct to steer.
SPEAKER_02And with that with that steering metaphor, you know, it it does, you know, it makes me think of driving like you're trying to drive your children to the right end and to the right goal. And for anyone who has who has driven a car or uh a U-Haul truck or a semi, there are times in which you have to jerk the wheel. And I'm thinking of that in a comparable way to to disciplining. There are times, it seems to me, in which you have to inflict pain because pain is a motivator, and I just want to talk a little bit about those feelings of pain, the infliction of pain and the feeling of pain, right?
SPEAKER_02And I'm not just talking about spanking, because obviously that's physical pain. But there also might be the pain of embarrassment. You call out behavior in public among friends so that they experience the pain. I'm just identifying, I'm not, you know, normalizing or uh, you know, uh recommending or I'm just I'm just yeah, here's the lay of the land, right?
SPEAKER_02There's physical pain of spanking. There might be some psychological pain of embarrassment. There might be some emotional pain when a child is being yelled at. Right? There's different so so um you know, spanking, embarrassing, yelling. What do we how is we how do we as Christians think about these things?
SPEAKER_02Now, when I when I was growing up, last um tail end of the comment here, and then I want to hear what you um when I was growing up, I got spanked. And when I was growing up, which is totally uncommon, it seems to Me these days, I can remember saying words I shouldn't have said, and I had to eat some soap. You know, clean out my mouth.
SPEAKER_02I gagged and I suspect that nowadays, first of all, eating soap, I haven't heard of that, you know, in Christian circles in decades, right? Spanking, I think Christians are still dealing with. Like, what do we do with that? And you know, you you reference Proverbs and sparing the rod. What do we do with that? But I would like to, I mean, I if if we want to single, if we if we want to single out one of those or home in on one of those, I'm totally cool with that.
SPEAKER_02But I guess I'm just I what I want to attack, and just to put my cards on the table, what I want to attack is what seems to be nowadays the fear in the church of inflicting any pain whatsoever. Any pain. Yeah. Don't yell at your kids, don't spank them, don't, you know. Um, and there's something about that that doesn't seem right to me, but also on the other side, mere turning to pain because it's easy to do is also wrong.
SPEAKER_02Right, right. Just yelling because you know it works instead of working through it is wrong. Mere spanking because it's just the first thing you want to do because you're angry is wrong. Right. So let's let's break that down. What do you think?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think right off the bat, I want to say I don't think we get off easy. There's not one simple solution. We can't just give in to the desire the desire to punish someone for not adhering to what our expectations are. But at the same time, we don't also get off the hook with our parental responsibilities. So I think you've brought up something fascinating here.
SPEAKER_01And you know, we think about Proverbs chapter 13, verse 24. We think about, you know, whoever spares the rod hurts the child. Well, I I think we we can admit that there are various ways to interpret this passage. It it need not be corporal punishment necessarily for some people. That that certainly is not our cup of tea. It's not something we've done, although some of our close um friends, our Christian families, they do elect to to use like spanking and these types of things.
SPEAKER_01But the the truth is that we need to instruct our children, we need to find out what it is that is causing the problems in instruction and behavior, and we need to kind of address those in meaningful ways that cause some sort of problems for for for those children. So I would say that yeah, like it might be, well, you've lost screen time or you've lost this or you've lost that.
SPEAKER_01And in a sense, it involves knowing the child and attempting on the basis of your knowledge and that relationship of enacting some sort of a consequence that is going to be meaningful to them, hopefully to instruct them. So, whatever the intention is, whatever the goal is, needs to be kept in mind. And it's not a matter of just kind of falling into a knee-jerk reaction because they're not obeying me.
SPEAKER_01I think it needs to be more than that. Um, and I don't think it needs to be a bodily form of punishment, although I do know some people that that engage in that type of a punishment. Um, yeah, so that's kind of my first initial response.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it does seem like you could have some, and I've seen this and experienced this with some Christians who would uh subscribe to the difference between discipline and punishment.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And reject punishment. But yet in action, their discipline is an act of punishment because they react to a situation. They react out of anger, and and their their so-called discipline is an act of punishment. I'm gonna spank you immediately, you know, immediately. I'm gonna, you know, walk you to the bathroom and you're gonna eat soap for the curse word you said, you know.
SPEAKER_02It it it's a response of retribution that isn't well thought out for to what end? How effective is this gonna be? How effective is this going to work? You know, I can imagine Christians who spank to sit down with their child and say, I don't want to do this, but here's what you did wrong. Do you understand why you did it? And and you know, there might be some reconciliation after and hugging and and all of those things that isn't primarily or manifestly experienced as a response or reaction or a reaction and a punishment.
SPEAKER_02And I mean, I I I also want to say there probably are some Christians who are quite okay with rejecting spanking and accepting yelling. I'm not sure that that that absolves you, right? I think in the same way that somebody could grab their kid and spank them out of anger, could yell at their kid out of anger, and it's it's the same sin or it's the same vice you're engaging.
SPEAKER_02You're just you, you know, on the one hand, you're using an instrument or your hand to cause pain. In the other instance, you're using your voice to cause pain. Right. Right? Yeah. And so there's something across the line operative that's problematic. When, and and they're both, perhaps, you know, to not fully circle back to what something that we said, but there's something about reacting in the moment that steals the discipline that it becomes punishment.
SPEAKER_02You're so focused on the moment and responding to the moment and making them feel pain in the moment that you've lost sight of what are you supposed to be doing in the long term, in the long run? You're supposed to be guiding them towards the right behavior. And if all you're doing is just lashing out, are you truly educating them and forming them for the right behavior, or are you just karate chopping the bad behavior?
SPEAKER_01Does that make sense? It it does, and it also to me it highlights something that I've become more and more aware of over time, which is that it's very easy for me to get angry. And there are times where I have to interrupt that. You don't want to see me when I'm angry, pretty much. But but in a sense, it's very easy to get to that place of anger. It's much harder to kind of search the anger and to also recognize that I am not God.
SPEAKER_01And there are times where I'm reacting out of my own hangups, my own insufficiencies, my own spiritual battles. And I'm trying to kind of convey the things that I've won through effort in my own spiritual life to my children who have not yet experienced the same things that I've experienced. And I'm in a sense trying to force it on them. And this precipitates a problem for me at this kind of like phenomenological or experiential level.
SPEAKER_01Like they also have to have their journey of faith.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That said, there are times where they are just willfully disobedient and they need instruction. So I think it's important for the Christian to search their intentions, to kind of take a step back, maybe even take a breath, a moment to kind of collect before you you enact some sort of a repercussion or a punishment. Because ultimately we're hoping to instruct the children.
SPEAKER_01And I I would caution against doing so overly quickly or or in some sort sort of you know sense that's not premeditated, because we ourselves are caught up in sin and disillusionment and false impressions. So with our children, if we are acting as a form of authority, I think we have an even greater responsibility.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's great. I mean, you so you just presented an angle for me that I wasn't even thinking about at all. And it's it's great, it's brilliant. Our children, we we're not only in the process of teaching them to do the right thing, generally, and in that particular situation with that with whatever misconduct they've done. We're also displaying and demonstrating for them what we do as parents when we've had a long day and we have to respond to conflict.
SPEAKER_02You know what I mean? Like we're also teaching them and training them, not just in that particular behavior, but how a person, how a parent deals with a situation with a child after a nine to twelve hour workday.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And they're seeing that, they're observing that. Um and and that's a that's an additional dimension that we have to consider. I I think I think parents, I think parents, when when you know, when you first get married and you start start having kids, all of the parenting habits and practices that you experienced as a kid, you have to wrestle with.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Was that the right thing to do? Should we parent that way, and so on and so forth? That's because children are watching, observing, learning. So I don't think we can lose sight of that other dimension. While we're teaching and training our children to live a good life and to not do particular, singular, concrete misconducts that we're constantly correcting.
SPEAKER_02We also have to pay attention to: am I displaying and showing forth the right kind of person in this moment, in this stage of life, for when they get there because they'll remember it. And so it is we're trying to steer them in the in principle in the right way that they should go, but we're also constantly exemplifying and presenting how they ought to be a parent and discipline and disciple their children when they are our age.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Questions, comments, concerns, fears, frustrations, deep sighs.
SPEAKER_01Can I say all of the above? No. That sounds great. No, this a lot of food for thought here. And for those that have children, a lot to relate to and to reflect on because it's it's a daily occurrence to deal with young children who are emerging to their own, going through things that we sometimes remember vividly or we have forgotten. And going through this with our children, it's an astonishing process.
SPEAKER_01And we don't always know that we're doing the right thing, right? Sometimes we're confused. Did I did I overreact? Did I really convey what I wanted to convey to my children? So I think we've got a lot of food for thought here. Maybe we need to kind of be intentional about what are our intentions.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And what's the goal?
SPEAKER_01What's the goal of everything that we're doing? Yep. And to recognize that, yeah, what we do is going to directly relate to what they do.
SPEAKER_02We'll continue in our series on parenting to conclude season two. Next time, let's look at tiffs between siblings and timeouts and uh friends and and and any kind of you know, just disputes between friends and how to handle it. Um, thanks as always for listening to Two Poor Spirits. Until next time, I would recommend, I don't know how you feel about this, Chris, but I would recommend don't shirk on your parental responsibilities with charity, steer and guide your kids, and don't feed them soap.
A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...
Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...
Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...
Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...
You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...