Spitballing, here, but perhaps leisure is a factor in the instigation and perpetuation of mental illness. Perhaps our experience of entertainment, in which we passively enjoy or amuse ourselves to death, is decapitating our attention. Maybe concerts, movies, competitions, travel, and literature are full of sneaky and sinister sins and the screens we hold have our souls in their hands. Just spitballing. In this episode, Chris and Kyle tackle entertainment in the family - basement, living room, and bedroom. They take stock of what we are feeding our feeds and why we are willingly walking in various wastelands. Perhaps we as parents want to get away from our kids, so we intentionally throw them into “techno-hypnosis.” Also, Kierkegaard was wrong: boredom isn't the root of all evil; negligence is. + + Welcome to another episode of Two Pour Spirits. + + Two Pour Spirits is a podcast of Project: Neighbor. Project: Neighbor is a theological think tank and spiritual training ground for the Church and the common good. We think theologically about everything from soil to sky, and disciple believers from crib to casket. We draw widely from the catholic Christian tradition, are ecumenically-oriented, and practically-minded. Project: Neighbor is co-directed by Kyle David Bennett and Christopher Cimorelli. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a think tank and training ground for spiritual formation and the common good. Visit Projectneighbor.org to learn more.
SPEAKER_02Greetings to our two poor spirits listeners. We are back. We are in the midst. Well, we're on the tail end of season two, in which we've been focusing on the family and the common good. Thanks for listening. We have two episodes left as we reflect on the ways the family as an institution contributes to the fecundity and the furtherance of society. In these last two episodes, we'll be focusing, as we have in the past three, on raising kids.
SPEAKER_02And in particular, we want to look at entertainment and leisure in this episode. What do we as a family do on, I don't know, Friday nights, Saturday nights? Hopefully we're going to church on Sunday mornings. Um but what do we do in our leisure time? Um what activities, what entertainment do we engage in? Before we dive in, which is, or before we nerd out, Chris, let's let's well, let me qualify. Before we nerd out on the content of this episode, let's nerd out on the beverage that you have concocted for us.
SPEAKER_02There's always a tablespoon of titillation in these spirits that you pour for us. They're always catching me by surprise and distracting me, but also delighting me. So what majestic pile of angelic spirits have you dumped into my glass this time, my friend?
SPEAKER_01I never expected angelic and dump to appear in the same sentence. But uh we have a a drink that I think we've used a riff on in the past. This is slightly different because of one of the ingredients. So the Boulevard Deer or Boulevard DA, I don't know how to exactly pronounce that, but this drink is a riff on the Negroni, and it involves uh whiskey. Um, so that that's right off the bat.
SPEAKER_01That's kind of like that's the base. That's the base. Yeah. So in this particular cocktail, uh, we basically put into a cocktail shaker with ice uh equal parts of strong.
SPEAKER_02I'm sorry to interrupt.
SPEAKER_01What is the whiskey you use? I used makers mark cask strength. Yeah, that's so it's it's holds up even when you put it in with ice. So uh makers mark cask strength, one ounce. Um we did one ounce of the Jesus juice, but this is the the so uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_02I love that you've gotten used to that, man.
SPEAKER_01I'm not really comfortable.
SPEAKER_02You got listen, when God created Adam, he said, name the animals. You have to name the Jesus juice.
SPEAKER_01So this this one is the augmented version of that with that was steeped with both uh chili pepper flakes and with cinnamon sticks before being smoked with Palo Alto wood. So it's a little bit more complex, a little bit spicier, but it's got that cinnamon kind of savoriness to it as well. So that's the other, so one ounce of the of the bourbon, one ounce of the spiced smoked cointreau, and we also did one ounce of Aperol.
SPEAKER_01So uh this Aperol or Campari is more of a standard ingredient in your Negroni. But in this drink, uh, of course, we have whiskey and Aperol, and now the spiced cointreau. So we put that together in the shaker 10-20 seconds until the uh shaker got frosty. And then we had a cocktail tumbler with a large cube, uh, Agnostora bitters, a couple dashes of that on there, and then poured the poured the concoction into that glass and garnished with a cocktail cherry with a few drops of juice.
SPEAKER_02I think I think the Aperol was the right choice. You think so? I mean, if you would have put Kampari in here, it would have clouded and overshadowed um and um tempered the spice in all the wrong ways. I think the citrus of the Aperol accentuates the spice. I mean, we were joking about a name for this. I don't know if you're even getting there, but it's like this drink is kind of like a Trojan horse.
SPEAKER_02That's we should go with that. You you know, you like you like see the Trojan horse coming, which is the spice. But then when the Trojan horse gets through the gate, it's like all spice.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02There's more horses coming out of the Trojan horse. Um, there is so much spice, there's a hint of it in the foretaste, but there is a plethora of it in the aftertaste, but it's not overbearing. I think that the the the citrus of the Aperol massages it. I think the Angostura bitters kind of heighten. I wouldn't, I don't know if it accentuates it, but but it it it definitely heightens it a little bit, and the cast strength is almost it's almost lost in in the right way.
SPEAKER_02You know, it's like the Holy Spirit working beside the behind the scenes, you know, like it's such a great blend. And I would I would also note that you know we're we're often commenting on when to partake of this in season and out of season. Like this is you know, we're here we are drinking it in the middle of February, but I could totally be on a beach sipping this in August. Like this is a great drink that's both refreshing and um and you know heat you up when you're sitting by the fireside.
SPEAKER_02So well done, my friend. This is great. What do you think?
SPEAKER_01I really like it, and I'm I'm happy you're here to kind of give expression to what I'm feeling.
SPEAKER_02I'm glad I could be your mouthpiece.
SPEAKER_01Which is that I I felt that there were three moments in the drink, and I couldn't actually express what that meant. So in a sense, there was a little bit of spice at the forefront of it. Then the flavors kind of come together, and then it finishes with more spice. Yeah, which is fascinating to me. But yeah, I I I agree that this could be used in different seasons. But we have to remember this for when the summertime comes. True. We've got to do it again. Um, because right now it's really cold, yeah, and I'm enjoying the heat from the drink.
SPEAKER_01Right, yeah. But I'll enjoy the refreshment of it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I as you're as you um as you said the word expression, it makes me uh realize that there is um the viscosity of it changes too. What you know, when it when it first hits your palate, it's thin. But by the but when that when all that spice, when when there's that fusion and that waterfall of spice at the tail end of it, it widens and thickens.
SPEAKER_02Like I feel it on the side of my cheeks, uh, and in you know, inside my mouth. It like lathers at the last moment. And I that's fascinating too. Yeah, like it's almost like the makers, you know, is soft and quiet, and then it's shouting and yelling at the tail end. Uh, so that that that is fascinating too, just how it's not just the flavor, but how the substance of it is taken in. It's it it's really, I mean, Trojan horse might work, but there's like there's layers of hiddenness.
SPEAKER_02You know, it's like it's I don't know, purgatory abyss or something, you know. It's got layers and layers of of hiddenness and and and revelation.
SPEAKER_01Awesome.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, thanks for making this, brother. You got it. All right, so let's jump into this. What do we do? You know, we're talking about the family, we're talking about family life, we're talking about raising Christians, uh, we're talking about being deliberate about the things we do, thinking Christianly about all aspects of our lives.
SPEAKER_02We've talked about artwork on our walls, we've talked about decks and and um front yards and backyards and all of the things. And in this episode, let's talk about our downtime. Let's talk about our detox and our Friday nights, and uh in particular, because I think that most people, most of our listeners, in their time of rest, in their time of leisure or detox, uh, they're engaging in entertainment.
SPEAKER_02Um, and so I kind of want to um just thrust us into entering the terrain of entertainment, our experience of entertainment. And I was recounting to you earlier, um, you know, when I watch movies, and that's probably my go-to. Like I do sit around and listen to vinyl and and invite the kids into that in our reading room that we have upstairs. But most of my Friday nights or my Saturday nights are downstairs in the basement watching a movie with the kids.
SPEAKER_02That's how I let my hair down, so to speak. That's that's when I liege. That's when I um I rest. Um and and I typically take a notebook with me and and a pen or a pencil, and I just jot down thoughts or or quotes that I could use in writing or remember for a sermon, for a lecture, something of that nature. And there's been countless times that I've looked to my right.
SPEAKER_02I'm typically all the way on the on the left side of the couch. I look to my right, and they're my youngest boys are sitting there with their jaws dropped, gawking, you know, eyes, you know, open wide, maybe bloodshot, just because they've you know, they're they're just so intense. Yeah. Um, and it it strikes me that they are passively intaking. Maybe not, I'm not inside of their head. I don't know if they're thinking critically about this, like I am, you know, like, oh, that's a good quote.
SPEAKER_02Oh, they're wrestling with the concept of freedom and these sorts of things. I'm trying to think critically as I am taking things in. It doesn't seem like they are, and I think for most people, like that is the purpose of entertainment. The purpose of entertainment is to not have to think. The purpose of entertainment is to enjoy being titillated, enjoy being stimulated, enjoy being amused, and to not really think about it and not to really think through it.
SPEAKER_02And so while we might appreciate things and delight things, whether it's a movie or it's a concert or it's a uh you know, basketball game or a competition, I think it seems like for most people, entertainment is to let one's is a is a a moment, an event, an activity of letting s letting yourself go, to just be entirely passive and to not have to put up anything, including thinking or feeling, so that really when we're reading a good novel or we're watching a sports team, we just want enjoyment and amusement, and we don't want to have to think through things or to feel things, maybe like negative feelings, you know.
SPEAKER_02We just just feed me, just make me feel good. Would you say that in in your experience in our assessment of of culture and society, that there is this there is this sense of passivity to entertainment? Because I think that matters for how we think Christianly and constructively about entertainment.
SPEAKER_01I think that notion of passivity might be key here. And I think it's commendable that you have a notebook. So good job. There are times, and I think a lot of people can empathize here, where you get to the end of a long week if you have a family and you're working. There are times you just are desperate to rest and to veg out on the couch just to absorb and be passive in a sense.
SPEAKER_02But I also think you're on assuming you've been active all week. Assuming you've been active all week. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But at the same time, we might be missing a really important opportunity, or at least a part of the call that we have. And I don't think we're supposed to just be passive when it comes to the things that we are imbibing or uh allowing to affect our imaginations. I think back to when I was in middle school, and it's ironic and kind of funny now, but I had friends with whom I disagreed vehemently about things.
SPEAKER_01My non-denominational, more I would call them my fundy friends.
SPEAKER_02Emphasis not on fun.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But then again, there was this practice of, well, how does this movie or how does this thing that we've watched relate to Jesus? And in retrospect, many years later, I I'm more appreciative of that type of of idea or practice. Because there is something about passivity, right, that that doesn't make sense for for the Christian. And I'm thinking also about how strange it is looking at the gospels, looking at Jesus' life and ministry.
SPEAKER_01He calls people that are unremarkable to be the bearers and the witnesses of this revelation.
SPEAKER_02Fishermen. Come on, man.
SPEAKER_01You could do better than that. But he doesn't allow them to be passive. He's inviting them to be active and charging them, commissioning them.
SPEAKER_02Like when he tells them to pray, but they fall asleep.
SPEAKER_01Yes. They they might want to veg out. So I do think there's something about this idea of passivity. And I I think we should kind of play around with that idea here. Because even in when I was taking a look at an article that we had at the institute where I work, and a scholar talked about this recently, which was the difference between just watching something on a screen and reading something, and how the brain is involved with having to reproduce an image or create an image of what's being encountered in order to make sense of it versus just kind of glazed eyes receiving something.
SPEAKER_01Now, I don't want to just like crap on this idea of why I love watching good movies, good shows. I remember as a young person how amazing it was to view movies, films, like all these different uh types of shows that kind of challenged me. But there was certainly a component of I need to think seriously about this, negotiate it, weigh it against what I know and and what I'm hoping for.
SPEAKER_01Maybe I don't do that as much now as a parent, and I'm more guilty of this idea of passivity. So I don't know if there's a way to kind of inculcate habits, develop habits toward uh the the things we watch on screens. But there might be a distinction between the different types of entertainment that we're kind of exposed to or taking in.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. There's something there too that I find fascinating with. I think you're absolutely right. Um I I think we ought to critique passivity. I and I I think so, um let me let me say something theological and and then something philosophical. Theological, like if if entertainment and leisure is supposed to map onto, let's say, like Sabbath rest, uh, the weekend.
SPEAKER_02Uh mind you, Christians are supposed to, if we're going to be biblical, Christians are supposed to work six days, not five, and rest one. But my but still, if the weekend is rest, then for the Christian, the weekend is a day of looking upon things and seeing that they're very good and enjoying them. And that's different than just feed me images or feed my ears with good sounds so that I can fall asleep and not think about things.
SPEAKER_02Um so that's very I I think there's something going on there that theologically we ought to resist the passivity. Something else you said that I that find fascinating philosophically, in that there is this, there is this layer of experience in which you can be watching, and I'm thinking mainly of watching something, it could be applied to hearing, uh listening to music, but watching something in which you're being fed all of the images, and you can't keep up.
SPEAKER_02They're like a movie, right? They're sequences of images. You could pause it, whatever, you know, but that's not going to make for a very good movie of entertainment. But you're being fed all of the images and swallowing them in your brain, and that's shaping your imagination. And there's a different layer of experience going on when you have to recollect, recollect, or remember, remember images by say reading a novel.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Or it's not remembering, it's membering. You're you're being given an image, and you have to put the puzzle pieces together of the image when it comes to a novel. Now, all I want to note is that's different, but I also I would I would also suggest that that is they're they're going to shape the imagination differently. One's gonna be pretty weak. I mean, we remember movies from a scene, but when we insert ourselves into a story and try to piece the puzzle together of the story, that sticks because we're invested.
SPEAKER_02That's that's what I'm trying to get at here. Like when reading a novel, you're so invested because you have to do some work. When you're watching a movie, unless you associate with the character in the movie and place yourself in the movie, it's not gonna stick emotionally, memorably, it's not gonna stick in the way that in you you're forced to do in a novel.
SPEAKER_02Now, to be honest with you, I love movies more than I love novels. But that's kind of that's kind of why I have the notebook and the writing utensil, because like I not only want to remember things, but like I want to put myself in those situations or or um take something from the words that they say that's applicable to my life because I want it to stick. And so there's something about there's something about entertainment and leisure that that that as Christians I think we have to lean into investment like not critical thinking but thoughtfulness in not only what we're doing but being thoughtful in what we're doing that we can't just be passive.
SPEAKER_02I also think too related to the word entertainment there is there is this uh root or uh etymological element of holding one's attention and oftentimes our entertainment is holding our attention but we have to raise the question of like is is that why like what are we subjecting our attention to yeah you know are we are we subjecting our attention to things that uh can hold our attention for that long how long should we subject ourselves to them very practically like should we watch multiple movies on Friday night?
SPEAKER_02Should we start at 530 eating pizza and watch movies until 1030 like should your attention be held that long in this way for this amount of time you know can you be so sorry that this point I'm I'm I'm just kind of like meta thinking about attention and how much investment we can have in our entertainment and leisure you know like does it get to a point in which this is hazardous and dangerous for us to be entertained this long or does there come a point in which you know I'm either going to go to bed or I'm gonna go do some pushups and cut some wood you know what I mean like should we be entertained for that long?
SPEAKER_02Which might also this is my last thought which may also raise the question of like should we not associate rest with entertainment because if entertainment is we're passively receiving things and having things capture our attention and we're subjecting ourselves to uh atten the you know what's capturing our attention passively should that not be should we not associate that with rest and the Sabbath and looking out on the things that we have done or that God has done and saying this is really good.
SPEAKER_01Let me enjoy this I that's a provocative question.
SPEAKER_02It's not one that I I really thought too much about before this evening but it's worth considering and just kind of immediate reactions I don't know if there's a way to apply a certain standard to our entertainment or our habits around entertainment but considering what we've been about with Project Neighbor would our engagement or experience of entertainment does it help us to be conscious of and to love God and to love neighbor are we neighboring better as a result of our entertainment are you calling into question my enjoyment of like I don't know Hannibal and you know peaky blinders and is this helping me be love my neighbor is that what you're calling into question here Kyle fraternal correction is a part of scripture so no but in all seriousness here I raise this point because I actually don't know if I agree with someone like Augustine with St.
SPEAKER_01Augustine about he marveled at the way people would take in the theater back in the day. Yeah performances where all kinds of terrible things are happening to people and the Christian ought not to derive pleasure from things that are really well stemming from evil or a non-virtuous behavior. So Augustine spent a little bit of time thinking about that how he used to enjoy certain things but then after his conversion he didn't but I'm not I'm not sure I agree completely and maybe I'm wrong I mean this is a saint a doctor of the church and all this so um but I'm thinking about the the types of shows that do contain a lot of things that are certainly unchristian a lot of activities or behaviors that I'm not sure they should be coloring our imagination.
SPEAKER_01Yeah but maybe there's a way an intentional way to go about watching viewing these types of things being more active in the engagement with them why am I so invested in this show? What about it is speaking to me about the human condition and then doing work to kind of receive it in a way that can then is filtered through our beliefs. I don't know if that's possible but we the amount of time to to your point about you know 530 to 1030 it's it's hard to say it's really hard to say what's what's too much uh so but but yeah I think we ought to really think about what we're taking in what we're engaging and maybe some practices that will ensure that we're we're not affected or imaginations aren't influenced to the point where it's affecting our ability to neighbor well.
SPEAKER_01So what do you think about that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah no I think those are some great observation great observations it also makes me think um you know we're we're talking about I so I I'm I'm still hearkening back to the influence and the impact that a novel will have on you versus the image of a movie. Yeah you can't unsee images you know like I can think of some great movies that the first time I watched them uh I can't unsee it and two immediately come to mind American History X and seven yeah those are two I would have picked too I remember watching those for the first time and being like I I mean I I saw those as a freshman in college and I still remember them vividly now you know reading about David and Goliath or hearing the story when I was a kid I put things together and I sort of remember them but not the way that I remember those images.
SPEAKER_02So I think we just have to take stock of that like there is a difference there and they have different import they have different influence and impact given the kind of media that we're receiving whether it's passive or active I'm also thinking too about social media and I pick up a book to read because I want to read it and I turn on a movie I want to watch because I want to watch it but when I get on social media recommendations pop up and some of them are disturbing and strange and wild and weird you know like just all all of the recommendations or all of the infomercials or whatever it might be whether it's on Facebook or Instagram or Twitter or TikTok whatever I'm also being fed things that I wouldn't click on.
SPEAKER_02And I think that also it's complicating this conversation because it's not merely how should Christians think about mediums or media like movies or novels. And in the past we had Christians thinking critically about those things constructive constructively about things when you're watching this movie they will say this word four times and here's you know here's the moral of the story and here's what you can talk to your kids about now we're in an era in which you don't know what you're gonna encounter on Facebook you don't know what you're gonna encounter on Twitter TikTok Instagram etc like you're go you are going to see things that you don't want to see perhaps and you're gonna you're gonna see or hear things that you didn't intend to receive now that also affects our kids right as they're growing up in this era of social media now the bridge between those two developments is also takes take for example something like Netflix to some degree you can control what ads pop up on Netflix but there's another degree in which you can't so things are going to be shot at you that you do not intend to receive or your children to receive and so I just think that that's also something to think critically about like what do we do with streaming platforms and social media as as we might have the right mindset about entertainment and rest.
SPEAKER_02Let's say we distinguish between them like good Christians perhaps and say okay yeah um we don't want to be passive we want to be invested and we're only going to do a little bit of entertainment and we're also going to do some rest and whatnot. But let's say that our little bit of entertainment is on Netflix we've got other problems that we encounter I did not want to see that and I did not want my kids to see that. So what do we do about that as Christians do we entirely dismiss you know the promotions and and the the propaganda and all of the things that we know we will encounter on social media how do we navigate through that and that not that's not a direct question to you but I think that that is a it it it complicates and muddies the waters of how do we do this in a social media streaming epoch it's insidious that's this problem.
SPEAKER_01But yeah I want to answer that or at least I want to start to talk about that more first just hearkening back to what we were talking about one thing that is very important is self-knowledge or self-awareness or even kind of a familial knowledge in a sense about the types of things the type of media that affect us and I've come to realize this too with people in my immediate family as well that some people are much more affected by the visual than others.
SPEAKER_01And so you have to be aware of this and you have to be aware of what you are susceptible to what you're influenced by in how you take things in and engage them. And and this strikes me you know my son is not ready to see certain things that I thought I was ready at his age. Maybe I was wrong back then but he's not ready and he has no inclination to do that and the effects in his imagination would be poor. But coming back to the social media thing I think most people can probably relate to what you're talking about.
SPEAKER_01I remember it's almost a decade ago now where I decided to just basically go dormant on Facebook. And there's this there was a sense at the time that I was so disheartened by certain things and I would stop and look at them. Almost like people passing by a car wreck or you know a train wreck. Yeah and my attention would linger on certain things I'd click on certain things and very quickly I realized that well if if my attention at all focuses on these things then the algorithm is going to make sure I keep seeing them.
SPEAKER_01And that was the first kind of realization for me that this isn't healthy. I I need to step back from this but we need to be sober about the fact that so many of the things that we utilize are operating with algorithms they're tracking our movements what things we watch how long we spend do we finish something do we you know abruptly leave something and this all goes into what's recommended or suggested and some of these things are are okay for us and some of them aren't yeah and how do we discern amid the algorithm yeah right and I do think yeah I I don't I don't I I wholeheartedly agree with you.
SPEAKER_02I also think though there is there's the algorithm but there's also advertisement which just I think is also not neutral. Absolutely yeah the the the advertisement is not neutral and um the algorithm is also not neutral but but for us it's it's been catered and and curated for us.
SPEAKER_02But you know there's things that you know so so I think I think the advertisement and I'm sp I'm using that broadly construed like when I pop on Facebook and there's a bunch of reels it's like a shark attacking a polar bear which I've never searched for in my life so that's not an algorithm I don't even know what that is or there's a street fight or there's like you know eating the most hot dog man eats 131 hot dogs.
SPEAKER_02It's the fantastical the eccentric the thing that's gonna draw you in is what's being advertised you know and and it's just it who's ever behind the scenes is trying to is trying to lure our attention to nonsense or you know fantasy so not not fantasy because I think that is a good word but the fantastical yeah in or or the sensational just to grab our attention just to pull us in.
SPEAKER_02And it's like to be honest with you there have been reels that you only see like three seconds it only shows you like three seconds or on Instagram there's threads that'll pop up and it's just a few words but it's like I wish I would not have seen that because that's evoking certain things for me.
SPEAKER_01And you know there really is a question of like how how close or tight are the walls going to come in that I that I'm gonna be forced to watch things or see things or hear things that I never wanted to see or hear or watch and I certainly don't want as soon as I press the power button I don't want my kids to see right um or I don't want my kids to hear an advertisement on YouTube or something you know we go we go to watch the Jesus storybook Bible and there's promotions and it's like I do not want you to hear this right skip skip skip oh but you gotta wait 11 seconds before you can skip that ad you know what I mean like the walls are coming the the walls are tightening and the corridors are getting thinner and it's almost like a cloister and I think there are probably some listeners out there and some parents who um I and I'm I'm starting to raise it myself like what are the mediums what are the media that I use to entertain because I still have freedom for what I see what I hear and what are the ones that are just increasingly um uh putting me in chains and and are those still redeemable and are these ones the wisest and prudential you know yeah yeah that's that's it's evoking a lot for me the this idea of kind of the walls closing in I don't know if there's uh some way to apply this imagery from the death of Ivan Ilyich and as death approaches it's just kind of everything's closing in on him you know what remind me it reminded me of um what's oh the maze that's what I was thinking of the the movie the maze when it's like you've got a certain amount of time to get out yeah you know but it's fascinating because I I think there's a lot going on here and unless we are going to be Luddites if we're engaged at all it it there's almost this sense of an an increasing kind of predominance of this phenomena that you're identifying no matter what I'm choosing to engage or what platforms uh what apps I'm using that somebody is watching and the advertisements are coming through we're forced to kind of receive little bits here and there and how is this constructing us?
SPEAKER_01How is this influencing us shaping us as we mature and grow and try to navigate life. Yeah and I think that's a real dilemma here because again if unless you're going to completely retreat you're you're part of it and it's hard to break free and if we keep accepting this I accept the 15 seconds I have to watch this I accept this.
SPEAKER_02Yeah um my email gets this now because I've watched this they have my email which they sell and somebody sends me this how how many times can we accept it before we no longer are free right yeah yeah no I I think that's that's absolutely spot on I there there's a step back to for me there's a step back to from uh even my own situation of watching a movie with a notebook and a and a pen that I and and within within the cr the more Protestant evangelical my Protestant evangelical upbringing of like critical worldview thinking that the focus is on okay like always be critical how do we think about this Christianly that's great I think that's great.
SPEAKER_02Your focus is on though on moral formation spiritual formation like okay let me be okay so how is this shaping my character etc etc but I even want to take a step back maybe several steps back in in which it's not just moral formation it's not just what I prize and what I value it's also what I notice and what I pay attention to and if I had to like um if I had to take the example to its absurd extreme and get get slightly uncomfortable just for for one second.
SPEAKER_02If you're watching porn all the time we all know what that does it shapes the way that You see the opposite sex. It not only shapes your character and your moral formation, it shapes the things that you pay attention to. You start to look for the girls in short skirts, or you start to look at the mannequin with the lingerie on it.
SPEAKER_02Like your very attention in walking through the mall is shaped in a different direction. And like I don't think that we really take stock of that, that this is not only, you know, over over time, even though it's 15 seconds or 11 seconds or whatever it is, the frequency over time is shaping what we count as normal.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And what our attention, you know, it it only takes our attention, it only captures our attention for 11 seconds, but then it shapes the way that we look at things for 11 years. And I we have to be more thoughtful about that.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02What are we subjecting ourselves to that in this moment is only 11 seconds, but over the course of 11 years of those 11 seconds will shape the kind of the kind of things we pay attention to for 22 years.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. That that's yeah, you that's struck me right now thinking about that. And the idea of normalizing something. And also if something is normalized, it's much more likely to be planted or take root in you. You might not even be aware of this. And so things that are kind of planted into your imagination or even in your heart more more troublingly, that this becomes normal.
SPEAKER_01It may be something that attracts you or pulls your attention, and it develops into something that leads you away from the love of God and love of neighbor. And it might seriously impact or undermine your ability to realize communion and support the common good. And so I think I think we really need to grapple with this. And again, I think it's also difficult to navigate this because if you're talking about family life, certain people are affected differently by the things we encounter.
SPEAKER_01And so it takes kind of a commitment, a work on the part of parents with children to kind of know who who each other is and are. Yeah, to discern about the types of things that we're we're engaging. Because, yeah, this idea, 11 seconds, but then 11 years. So who knows? Because certain things, as you said in your youth, struck you, they stick with you even from early college. Movies that you saw, the scenes that just are seared into your imagination.
SPEAKER_01And I I can I can empathize with that.
SPEAKER_02Um I think I think the fear of boredom is tyrannizing culture, society, our neighbors, ourselves, the church. We are this this is part of the problem of of it seems to me, part of the problem of parents subjecting their children to just anything because they want to avoid boredom. They're not stimulated, they're not titillated, they're not amused, they're not amused, and so you know, I'm bored, I'm bored, I'm bored.
SPEAKER_02And the response by the parent is go watch TV. Yeah. I've got stuff to do, I've got work to do. Now, there's a different, there's layers there. There's layers of yes, you have responsibilities, you have duties, you have a job, and you you're having to parent in this moment. All of that is layered and there's dynamics there. But I want to press in on why are you afraid of your child being bored? Now, I I can this isn't this is way too ivory tower, I think, for for the the typical parent.
SPEAKER_02They're not thinking this thought. But it does remind me of um one of the pseudonyms in Kierkegaard's either or Johannes, who's this seducer, you know, and and um Kierkegaard's really trying to portray this aesthetic person who is is always involved in pleasure and everything has to be novel and beautiful and just always stimulating.
SPEAKER_02That in the in the um in the course of his reflections says that banality or boredom is the root of all evil. And so he he um Kierkegaard's weaving this within the character that the character of Johannes, that maybe Adam and Eve didn't fall from pride, didn't fall because of pride. They didn't they didn't see themselves as I should I should be God.
SPEAKER_02God told me not to eat of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. Good and evil, good and evil, sorry. Um, but they actually were just bored, they had nothing to do, they were twiddling their thumbs, and so that's why they ate, you know. So he's I think you know, he's trying to be provocative, but there's something there that lands for me with parents. They're worried that their kids will get into trouble if they're bored. Now that could be the case, there could be instances of that, but it also you're also uh taking that worry and conflating it with boredom is evil.
SPEAKER_02And maybe that this is the point I want to push, maybe boredom is actually something really, really good for your kids. And maybe boredom is something really good for your family, and maybe you should invite your kids to be bored. I mean, I tell my kids, not to virtue signal or anything like that, but like I'm I'm pretty passionate about that. Like, I tell my kids it's okay to be bored, get used to it. There will be plenty plenty of times in your life in which you're bored.
SPEAKER_02But maybe boredom leads to other goods. Maybe being passive and being distracted and being stimulated all the time is actually prohibiting and inhibiting good things that could come to life or light. What do you think about that?
SPEAKER_01I'm very much in agreement here, just that boredom can be a good. On the one hand, I'm I'm kind of brought to my family, and this is a lesson we do try to tell our kids that boredom is okay. As a matter of fact, when children are bored and they get frustrated with the boredom, oftentimes what they try to do is to immediately fill that with something else, which may or not be good for them, or to have somebody else entertain them.
SPEAKER_01Just keep entertaining me, keep entertaining me. So, in a sense, it kind of undermines communal life if they can't deal with boredom. But boredom can also be a vehicle towards greater imagination and the use of our faculties to find a new way to relate to reality. So boredom is is really important, I think, for children. And I also think it's important for adults to recognize the value or just the commonplace of boredom.
SPEAKER_01Because I I worry for as for parents as well as for children about and more for parents, but if you allow boredom to move you away from what it is you're called to do in a moment, or maybe you're called to be attentive to your children, but that's so boring, it's so mundane. It's like, do I want to hear about this stupid show again?
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But so just sit in front of TV so I can do something more exciting. But boredom, in a sense, we need to re we need to grapple with it because there's something there for the spiritual life, for a fulfilling life. And if I I think if we can wrestle with it and come out on the right side of it, it builds up families, it builds up communion, because we won't overlook our responsibilities or our duties or the things that are just every day constant, right?
SPEAKER_01Uh so I think there's a value of boredom both for children who sometimes ought to be challenged, to not have other people just can constantly entertain them, and also for parents who get frustrated with the day-to-day grind. And that might tempt you to seek excitement somewhere else in a way that might not be helpful. Right? It's it we we in some ways working hard, taking care of your family, and doing that for a long time, it's in a sense what we're called to do.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it may not be uh you know, Game of Thrones or it may not be some sort of dramatic enterprise.
SPEAKER_02Right. Yeah. That that raises a um a question, a provocative question and a thought. The provocative question is insofar as we continue to indulge our children and entertainment and stimulation, what are we doing to ourselves, our family, and to them? With the constant demand and acquiescence to the demand, how's that how is that rearranging the family?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02The the um the thought is it it does strike me that it's almost as if God has provided naturally everything you need for entertainment. I mean, I I don't want to be a Luddite as you noted earlier. I don't want to do that because I love technology. I love technology. I love technology, right? We're using technology right now, right? But your your comments reminded me of, you know, John Calvin said creation is the theater of God's glory.
SPEAKER_02There is a theater every time you open your eyes in everything. Everything that's before you physically, there are things moving and acting. The trees are growing, they're raising their hands in worship, the rocks are crying out as the ocean waves, you know, clap on them. There's a theater before your eyes, and you can appreciate it, you can be entertained by it.
SPEAKER_02You don't need the artificial, man-made entertainment that's passive, demanding, force-fed. There is something about we're trying to be entertained in a different way, and with almost a layer of additional fog that hides and prevents actual actual entertainment of reality.
SPEAKER_02And and our our children need to be raised up to see that first.
SPEAKER_01I mean, we were raised before technology, in a sense, yeah, compared to what we have now, right?
SPEAKER_02I mean, like, I don't remember when Macintosh computers were coming out and I was aware of those, but it was certainly not when I was born or I was an adolescent, probably a teenager's teenager. Um, but our children are growing up with screens, and yet there is a horizon that's before them as soon as they open their eyes, and they too need to be taught and trained to appreciate the theater of that of God's glory, the theater of reality before them that's constantly moving and acting that He made before we subject them to the screens that we have made.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, and and it somebody said, and it's this is an original thought, but when we were growing up, and all of a sudden more video game systems and computers were coming out, those were kind of the escape from reality. Right, yep. But now our children are growing up and they're constantly with technology and in the screens. And we need to kind of remind them of the larger world, the the theater that is out there.
SPEAKER_02That's fascinating. It's almost like, I'm sorry to interrupt you, it's almost like for us, given that we were inculcated or immersed in the reality, the natural reality, that technology became the escape. But it seems like for our kids, because they've grown up with the screens, uh, it's not it, that is their engagement with reality.
SPEAKER_01Right. Which is just fundamentally different.
SPEAKER_02It's entirely seeing it backwards.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And there are indications of this all over with the behavior of kids and you know spending 12 hours in a room just on their phones. Whereas when we were growing up, maybe you'd be outside or you know, and then eventually you'd come back and play Nintendo or something like that. That's right. So uh different realities, but we have to be alive to that, I think.
SPEAKER_02Wise words, my friend. Well, I think that concludes our episode here. Next time, in our final episode of season two, we're gonna discuss the value and utility of a family rule of life. How can and should we sanctify our schedules in such a speedy society? What values, things, and activities should we prioritize as families?
SPEAKER_02How do we slow our small people down, our kids and kiddos? Thanks as always for listening to Two Poor Spirits. Until next time, let's put a pause on those pixels, maybe stow those screens and keep beating down boredom.
A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...
Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...
Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...
Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...
You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...