In this second installment of The Virtues of Disagreement, Kyle and Chris discuss humility and how it can be cultivated in and through disagreement. But humility has got a lot of doppelgängers. Like a soft form of narcissism with a fake ID, and a false modesty that tries to wear humility's hat. Both are posers. If you're looking for the true manifestation of humility, besides Jesus, look no further than John the Baptist. He gets it. "Mission over Me" is the motto. Join Chris and Kyle as they discuss humility in this sixth episode of Two Pour Spirits. Support the show https://www.projectneighbor.org/ | https://x.com/proneighbor |
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, friends, and welcome to the podcast Two Poor Spirits, a conversation about cocktails, communion, and the church. I'm Chris Simmarelli. And I'm Kyle Bennett. And we are the co-founders of Project Neighbor, a think tank and training ground for spiritual formation and the common good. Visit Projectneighbor.org to learn more.
SPEAKER_02We are in a series entitled Long Disagreement in the Same Direction. Tonight or this episode, we're recording this evening, and this is the second episode of four in the series. But we took a break last time with an impromptu episode in light of recent events in which we discussed disagreement and dignity. And we're jumping back into the series tonight, long disagreement in the same direction.
SPEAKER_02And just a reminder: this series, the essence of this series is to look at the ways in which, you know, conflictual conversation and difficult dialogue, not just disagreement, but any sort of uh difficulty in dialogue or um conflict in conversation, um, you know, difficult conversations, that if we stick them out, they truly could be virtuous, they truly could have something to offer and be fruitful.
SPEAKER_02Um and before our impromptu episode this last time, we looked at patience and how patience is cultivated in and through disagreement. This episode we'll be looking at humility. And what is humility? There's a lot of false notions or incorrect or misguided understandings of humility. What is it and how might disagreement cultivate it? But as always, before we dive in, Chris, I need you to inform me of what this spirit is that is poured in my glass.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Kyle. And it's uh I'm happy to be back podcasting with this important series on long disagreement. Um, tonight's drink, the cocktail that we've selected, is really a a riff on a Kentucky mule. Right? So uh a bourbon base, uh strong bourbon, um high-proof bourbon, uh, two ounces of that uh for each person, plus one ounce of the spiced cointreau, which we've used several times.
SPEAKER_01That stuff. Yeah, again, just uh you know, Thai and red chili pepper flakes steeped in cointreau and liquid gold. Yeah, it's it's really nice. Um those elements poured into a cocktail shaker and shaken with ice, uh, poured over a cocktail glass full of ice, um, and then we added in uh ginger beer, a nice spicy one, along with uh a torched orange peel, which was expressed a little bit, wiped around the glass, then torched and thrown in there as garnish.
SPEAKER_01Um cleansing fire. Yeah. Is that is that spiced ginger beer the cue? It is cute ginger beer. It's a good one. Uh and then there was an additional garnish, uh, really two. It was a little slice of orange to put on the edge of the glass, as well as a cocktail cherry.
SPEAKER_02Do you know what I love though? I'm and I'm seeing a pattern with a handful of these cocktails that you're making that I love is as you're putting the cherry in, there's just a little lather, a layer of the cherry juice. I mean, and and it like it changes the viscosity of the drink and the and the the layering of the drink. Uh and you would think that it would you would think that it would temper. I might have said this before, I'm having like a deja vu.
SPEAKER_02It it might you might you might think that it tempers the ginger beer, but it actually accentuates it. Yeah, like the spice comes out more, I think. Um, I mean that could be assisted by the bourbon too, but it's yeah.
SPEAKER_01The and you know, the the cocktail cherries it they're kind of sh shipped over from Italy. So I think the juice is a high quality, you know, it's it's not this overly sugary, artificial, syrupy type of thing. So I th I do think it accentuates it. So thank you. Great job. Thank you. Hey, absolutely. Cheers, brother. Cheers. Two poor spirits, two poor spirits. So, how should we, how ought we to dive into humility?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think we should start with you, with the fact that you received my compliment and said thanks as if you deserved it. And how humble of you to acknowledge praise.
SPEAKER_01I'm puffed up right now.
SPEAKER_02When I when I I think I remember Bernard of Clairvaux saying that the humble person will be though the one who flees from praise. So let's just jump into like you and how you're not a humble person, and then let's start to pull that. No, I'm just kidding. Yeah, I mean, let's start with what is humility. Um, I think there are some erroneous and false notions of what humility is. And maybe let's just start with some of those and tease it, you know, let's identify the obvious and what would resonate with many of us, and then let's pull that apart and see kind of what the skeleton and sh and structure that we um could begin to intuit in sense that, yeah, that sounds a lot like humility to me and not something else.
SPEAKER_02I would say that if I if I can just propose you know a couple what non non-humility or you know, non-humble person is, um one who doesn't have um you know a healthy sense of confidence, or one who has a very low uh low self-confidence in that they're kind of say, like, I suck, I'm terrible, I'm not a great person, I guess I just have to deal with this. Right.
SPEAKER_02You know, nature made me this way, I'm not a strong person, uh, I'm not in I'm not intelligent like everyone else. Uh I'll never make it. Like they're just exceptional and they have good looks. And um, and maybe it's somebody may maybe you know, taking that a little further, maybe that's you know, they're identifying one thing that they prize or value and reducing themselves to it. That's a whole different conversation. But maybe that's what's occurring in the low self-confidence person, they identify a few things.
SPEAKER_02Um, but I wouldn't say that that's a humble person, the person who just you know looks at something and says, I'm not very good at that, or I'll, you know, I wasn't made like that. And so I suck, I'm terrible, and I don't have much to offer. So I would say that's not humility, that's a not even a false sense of humility. I I wouldn't say. I think that's just it's it's it's damaging.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02You know, I mean it's it's um it's destructive, and humility is not destructive, it's upbuilding. Um so you can't be a humble person if you're someone with low self-confidence in that manner. Right. You know, I also don't think, and this is probably where people get more easily confused. I also think a person who has self-contempt is not a humble person.
SPEAKER_02Someone who's constantly looking at their faults and mistakes and shortcomings and saying, yeah, like oh, you know, um, I I despise myself for not being this kind of person. You know, um they're constantly cutting themselves down. And and I I mean I I think I I'll get to that in a second after you know, a third um non a third person who isn't humble.
SPEAKER_02Um but the but the self the person who engages in self-contempt is so self-focused and you know so destructive um that it it's it's not it's not this pure upbuilding sense of humility.
SPEAKER_01Can I can I interject for a second? Yeah. So it's it's fascinating to me because years ago in in our well, when we were colleagues together at the same institution, um I gave a little talk on called the United States of Narcissism.
SPEAKER_02I think I remember that one.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and when I was doing research for that talk, um what I what I found fascinating was that there are multiple kinds of narcissism. There's your more like stereotypical, like I'm the best at everything, look at me, I can't do wrong, I'm all puffed up. But then there's also the uh a darker, like twisted type of narcissism where you know it's more of self-contempt and loathing, and but it's it's so egocentric. To get attention, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's like you're still the center of the universe, yeah, but in a suffering type of mindset. It's like so just because you you're negative towards yourself doesn't you know do away with being egocentric or totally focused on the self. I think maybe we'll we'll see through our conversation today about maybe it's about being decentered a bit.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that that's fascinating. I do want to I'm gonna register that here um because I do think I wonder if that flows two different ways. It flows in sort of not not like a sadistic way of not in a sadistic way, but in a uh I'm drawing attention to myself for myself, and it can flow in another way of look at me, poor and suffering, everybody else look at me, right? Seems to me like you can have two different kinds of movements there.
SPEAKER_02One that it they're both self-centered, right? But one is self-centered, self-centered, and one is self-centered for others to recognize, right? Yeah, yeah. Uh interesting. Okay, yeah, let's come back to that. I think that's fascinating. So um low self-confidence, self-contempt. We're not, you know, we're distinguishing these from humility, but but as of yet, not defining the features of humility. And finally, I would say, like, and this is what this is the one that I've I've heard um um, I've heard most misrepresented, um, and misrepresented with respect to humility in particular, but this false sense of modesty, you know, um, in which it's it's akin to I know that I'm like God's gift to the world, but I'm not gonna act like it.
SPEAKER_02You know, I I I know, oh shucks, you know, you're too kind, you know, but there's a deep pride and arrogance, arrogance that underlies that, that still hasn't been attended to. I would say that that's still not the humble person. That's not persons that that's not a person who has the virtue of humility, they're just for social reasons and perhaps for their own guilt, are suppressing the praise.
SPEAKER_02Um, but they aren't truly humble. They don't have the virtue of humility. And so, I mean, we typically say a false sense of modesty, but I think modesty in and of itself, even when it's innocent, cannot be humility. The the recognition, the awareness, the decentering that we'll get into, it hasn't really registered or taken root in the modest person. Um the modest person may perhaps hasn't acknowledged for themselves the state in which they are or they should be, but they're still seeing themselves in with reference to others and then telling others to shh quiet down, you know, don't boost my ego because it's already too huge, you know, possibly, you know.
SPEAKER_02Um so I would say that those are three different kinds of peoples, different kinds of people or characters that um some people might confuse with the humble person, but aren't yeah you have any thoughts?
SPEAKER_01Well, I do, because the this is really interesting to to consider. You know, I oftentimes as we're talking, I feel like I'm drawn to my childhood, you know, thinking about what what was my first impression of some of these ideas? How was I raised to kind of view these? And you know, growing up, I definitely think the the false modesty idea came up uh quite a bit. It's pretty prevalent, you know.
SPEAKER_01Uh just downplay, any praise that's heaped upon you, or something like that. Um but but I also, you know, being someone who's really interested in sports, sometimes way too interested in sports. It's a little bit of a vice. Um, you know, I was always drawn to the athletes that didn't make a big deal about how great they were. You know, and I think it's really hard to parse and to discern and to say, because we can't get inside their brains, right? Are they deflecting attention or you know, pointing elsewhere because that's what they really feel, you know, especially if it's a team sport, or are they doing it because it plays well, it it's what's expected, you know, that kind of a thing.
SPEAKER_01I I don't know. But so that type of a, you know, well, you know, I just gotta thank my teammates, um, you know, being in a position to do well and my coaches and this and that. I mean, in a sense, it's kind of like a false modesty because there are times where people are truly excellent in their craft and employing and manifesting their gifts in a way that nobody else can do. Right. And they they might say, Well, you know, I always think about like if if you know Michael Jordan or LeBron James was like, Well, you know, I'm I'm okay at basketball.
SPEAKER_01You know, that that's certainly not uh respectful of the truth. Yeah, like so obviously it can't be something that is disingenuous or betrays the truth. That's not what true humility is. Um but uh but I definitely, you know, growing up, false modesty comes to mind or downplaying praise heaped upon you, and then certainly the way that those who are publicly uh lauded uh that comes to mind as well. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So we we can come back to this, yeah. Uh, but I want to throw this out there, I want to pin it. It that is a great example, athletes being interviewed after games.
SPEAKER_01Okay, except for boxing. Nobody wants to hear a boxer interviewed after the match.
SPEAKER_02I just straight up knocked him out. He deserved it. Yeah. Um it so this is what I'm thinking of. There seems to me to be uh a different a different phenomenon going on between the ascription, you know, the the the stellar athlete and their ascription of the um outcome of the game to their teammates, yeah, which you've identified as false modesty.
SPEAKER_02It depends, it depends.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So what what I think is on the other side with you know the the reference to or direction to God. I just want to thank my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ for all of the gifts and talents that he has bestowed upon me. I wouldn't have been able to do this without him.
SPEAKER_01But that's better than acting as if my Lord and Savior has dictated the terms of this game.
SPEAKER_02I I just want to thank my Lord and Savior for choosing me to win this game for my team.
SPEAKER_01It was very important in heaven for this result to occur.
SPEAKER_02But you you know, I I think I have been in rooms, living rooms, in which people observe, perceive that as humility. Okay, you know, not modesty, right? So that that's what I'm trying to identify is with respect to teammates, there's modesty.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02With respect to your Lord and Savior and God, um it it's it's viewed as some sense of humility. What's so what's going on there, you know? And I so I I I want to pen that. And I mean, we can we can come back to that and we can come back to narcissism too, but I think that's a thing. That that that is a phenomenon, and it's interesting to think about. So, I mean, maybe let's start biblically. Okay, we can jump theologically and philosophically.
SPEAKER_02When I was thinking about humility, uh, and it doesn't re directly relate to disagreement, although there are some instances in which it might. But, you know, a model figure for me biblically who exemplifies humility might be John the Baptist.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Tell me more.
SPEAKER_02Because I think uh it you know, the short answer is Jesus comes on the scene and John's gotta be like, okay, cool. You're here. We were waiting for you. Um and and he doesn't he's got this ministry, he's got these followers, and he is the forerunner. Now that's that's built into his identity his identity, right?
SPEAKER_02But still, like he he didn't have to respond that way. Uh he didn't have to receive the arrival of Jesus in that way. But he but i it it he he in he encapsulates and captures the the the kind of responses and attitudes of a humble person. Yep, this is who I am. Yep, this is my purpose, yep, I got a contribution to make, and I'm not gonna compare myself to others.
SPEAKER_02I shouldn't be the savior. Um yes, you are my disciples, but this is what you've been waiting for. You know, he he knows his place, he knows who he is, he knows the length of his ministry and and what he's here for. And so he doesn't he doesn't have low self-confidence. There's no self-contempt, there's no comparison, there's no comparison game.
SPEAKER_02You perform miracles, I'll perform miracles, and it's better to eat beetles and you know, whatever, than it is to eat, you know, manna, and there's none of that going on. And I I think just the way that he the way that he is able to say I must decrease and he must increase is not like self self-loathing or uh self or even self-resignation.
SPEAKER_02He accepts what is what is real and true about himself. His place in the order of the cosmos as a you know, as a creature, um he understands his ministry and the purpose of his ministry as something that initiates and and filters into the whole point. You know, and I I think this he he he just encapsulates and captures like the total orientation and attitude of the humble person.
SPEAKER_02That they recognize these things about themselves, they recognize who they are, why they're here, what their purpose is, their status in the in the order of things, and they accept it. And even they they even accept it with joy, which is probably the most difficult part of humility, you know, and recognizing these things about you and and your contribution, which may not be the ultimate uh most uh celebratory and you know, celebrity act and you know, and and contribution.
SPEAKER_02You you accept these things for for what they are and your your purpose, you know.
SPEAKER_01I don't know, do you well yeah, I mean it's I like the way that you're introducing this topic, and John the Baptist is a fascinating figure and crucial figure for understanding the ministry of Jesus. And what you're saying kind of resonates because you know he was an extraordinarily popular figure. I mean, if if you look at the way some historians of the ancient world um treat him, I mean, by by many accounts, for a large part of the first century, the movement that he inspired was just as popular, if not more popular, than early Christianity.
SPEAKER_01But the movement that he inspired um fostered disciples that eventually, many of whom went went to Christianity, right? And it seems to me, you know, if we're looking at the biblical character, this is a person who is so focused on the Lord, so committed to the mission, to the ministry, that despite any greatness or ability to draw crowds and gather disciples, he is able to just focus so much on the truth and what is demanded of him in a moment that yeah, he he's able to just work with it's about mission and not me.
SPEAKER_01Yes, exactly. Yeah, and and he paid the price for it. And if you consider him as a character in you know the gospels, he is an example to Jesus, uh a revelation, if you will, of of what the stakes truly are as he as he carries out his ministry and has to discern, and even to the to the point of you know the agony in the garden, right? You have to Jesus learned so much from John the Baptist, you know, a relative.
SPEAKER_01So this type of thing, I I really feel like what a what a great figure, person, character to look to to think about humility. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I mean I would say that's great. I I would say um, I think that there is, you know, drawing, extra extrapolating from his story, you know, some themes or principles. I think it's I the person who accepts who they are as a creature and their purpose and calling in their lifetime and the truth and reality of it, regardless. I may not like who I am, I may not like who I'm called to be in the church or my family or society is telling me you ought to be this person because these are your gifts and talents and whatnot.
SPEAKER_02You don't deny that, you don't reject it, you receive it. Um you you take reality and the truthfulness of it and you accept it, and you accept those limitation any limitations or abilities. Um not everybody can be Michael Jordan, not everybody can be Kobe Bryant or LeBron James, right? Um and I mean pin this too. We've got narcissism to talk about, and we've got um uh out, you know, uh athletes after sports games to talk about.
SPEAKER_02Um talk about uh oh, I just lost my thought.
SPEAKER_03Oh, you got it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I got it. Talk about um, you know, in America, the maxim, you know, be all you can be, and you can do anything you set your mind to. Yeah. Right now, now we're instilling uh the uh humility is obsolete. Why would I be why would I need why would I need humility? How could humility ever be a virtue if I could be anything I want to be that I could set my mind to?
SPEAKER_02Right. Pen it. No, no, I know I know you want to bite on that. Don't bite on that just yet. Don't bite. We st we still gotta define what humility is.
SPEAKER_01Let's do it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Um, you know, so I think I think, and and most of us probably intuit this, but we intuit it the wrong way. I mean, we we revert back to humility is a tearing down. Like the humble person is someone who rolls around in sackcloth, you know, rolls around in the mud, um, eats beetles, you know, and and is never willing to accept credit.
SPEAKER_02Um and they're constantly self-deprecating. And and that's not biblically and uh uh historically in the Christian tradition, that's not what humility means. Um, but humility does involve, you know, it humility is the seeing of things correctly in their order and how they've been ordained and and whatnot, and receiving that and accepting that. And we'll get to this with with other centered, but you know a leave uh uh elevating and appreciating the contributions of others, yeah, right, and not not so self-focused, but I do think there is some truth to that area where we typically confuse humility with other things, that humility is a bringing low.
SPEAKER_02You know, humility is tied, etymologically tied to earth and the ground, and there is something about being low that is that is essential to humility, but it's it's essential to humility because we tend to want to fly. Right, we tend to want to fly up and say, hey, everybody, look at me, look at what I can do, so on and so forth. And so I think you know, humility does involve a bringing low, but that's because we promote ourselves so much through arrogance and pride and vanity that we are in a constant state of finding our place back down a little bit.
SPEAKER_02Um not all the way down to bury ourselves, you know, not all not all the way down to be dead, but just because our inclination, I I think our inclination as creatures who have fallen into sin, our inclination is to try to rise up ourselves, point to ourselves, you know, distinguish ourselves from others, that the practice of humility is a constant pulling back down.
SPEAKER_02You're not an angel, stop trying to fly. You know, you're you're you're not you're not a spiritual creature who's meant to be in heaven, you know, like come back down, come back down, come back down. So I do think that there is a layer of humility, uh there is a layer there to humility in which it is a um a living within something that is lowering because we're constantly trying to get elevated and higher than where we should be.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I uh I'm I'm I'm not speechless because I'm about to speak. Uh I didn't I didn't leave you breathless. No, no. So the the etymological kind of significance or signification, you know, humility having to do with earth, it's just so perfect for you know the types of things we've been talking about for a long time. You know, when we talk about Project Neighbor, we talk about you know living in this rich kind of relational logic and and and a relational type of being and belonging that fosters kind of communion.
SPEAKER_01You know, I think about the line that we've used before, uh from soil to sky. Yeah. But I think when when you say humble and but there's something that if you embrace your origin and you embrace that which you truly are, that we are made of the earth. Yep. When you and we are made by God and we are made with others for communion. If you embrace that, despite being tied to the earth, it it allows for a transcendence and for new possibilities that could not have been imagined prior, right?
SPEAKER_01So um I'm I'm really kind of consumed with this at the moment. This idea that's a good connection.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you're right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so that it's not about being held down and being pushed, your face pushed into the muck or the mud. Right. You know, it's recognizing our origins and when you truly embrace it, it it changes your destiny. Yeah, I really believe that.
SPEAKER_02Dust with breath in it, you know. I mean, yeah, yeah, you're right. Like that's yeah, I didn't even make that connection.
SPEAKER_01Well, I appreciate that uh you helped draw it out.
SPEAKER_02Tag teams back again. Um, well, I mean, do we wanna before we go into how humility can be cultivated in through disagreement, do we want to just maybe for a few minutes attend to um narcissism and or the outcome of the game with athletes and modesty versus humility? What's what's your gut telling you?
SPEAKER_01I mean, they're they're both valuable uh pathways here before us. Um let's let's let's talk about narcissism.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And what what about that? When I mentioned it, what about it appealed to you, at least for this conversation?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, I think I mean I I think one one feature of um one feature of humility that I think we both agree on, that we've intimated a few times, but haven't really drawn out and accentuated is that humility, when you get down to it, humility isn't self-centered or self-focused. It is it is there there is an element to it in which you're trying to find your place. This is who I mean, this is who God says I am.
SPEAKER_02I am a finite creature, I'm a worshiper, I was made to worship. I'm made of dust with the ruach, you know, breathed into my nostrils. I have to own and find my place which is related to humility. I am not God. I'm I'm I'm you know, made a little lower than the angels, and I have to accept that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And there's something about obviously narcissism connects with arrogance and pride and vanity, you know, and so forth. But I think that there's an there's a um uh fine-tuned uh distinction that fascinates me about what you said with respect to narcissism, that you you can have people who seem to be humble, and maybe this is related to the outcome of the game for the athlete, that they seem to be humble, humble, um, but they're so self-focused, yeah.
SPEAKER_02And and and it seems to me that narcissism, like you could have the narcissist who just re in kind of like the masochist or the sadist, who kind of just revels in the pleasure of being self-focused, yeah. You know, yeah and you know, typical narcissism, we might, you know, say is the other way. Typical narcissism is hey everybody, look at me, I'm the best, you know, right.
SPEAKER_02But that there's something here with just as we're talking about false modesty, as we're talking about being confused and and um conflating or confusing humility with other things, there's something here about that sense of self-focused narcissism in which I'm merely getting pleasure from focusing on myself and identifying things in myself, drawing tens drawing attention to myself for myself, if that if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_02Like you know, and I I think there there are there are people and and and I think I can relate to this because perhaps one you know, times in my life I have I have displayed false humility, if we could just shorthand it. I've displayed false humility and felt good about it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_02So like there's something there that's connecting for me, that's resonating for me with this self-focused narcissism and the satisfaction of drawing attention to yourself for yourself that relates to a false sense of humility, in which you're yeah, there's others who you're displaying that false humility to, but you're you it's really about you feeling good about yourself for displaying that false humility.
SPEAKER_02Does that make sense?
SPEAKER_01It does, yeah. I I so you know, you think about your stereotypical narcissist, and we think about narcissism kind of mythologically, stemming from the idea of being consumed with your own image, right, to the point where you die, you know, because you won't even take care of yourself because you're just staring at yourself.
SPEAKER_02And and this is typically a vice of swimmers, right?
SPEAKER_01Because they're always looking at the Yes, yeah, certainly swimmers. Um, yeah, so that we think about the uh a narcissist as someone who a lot of times is, you know, out there, sometimes charismatic. Um people flock to them, but the people that end up being associated with the narcissist ends up getting used and abused, exploited because they only exist to serve, to enhance the image of the narcissist, right? So even people that are in intimate relationships or close relationships, friendships with narcissists, it's like, oh, it's fantastic until you realize it's not, and I've just I've just been fodder for their own ego.
SPEAKER_01Right? Bridges get burned, um things turn sour very quickly, and this happens over and over and over again. But with um this other type of narcissism, and I think it's probably something that you know adolescent men sometimes go through quite a bit. Um, sometimes it's when you, you know, are still so focused on the image of yourself that you've created, and sometimes the failure of that image to manifest, uh more of a withdrawn type of narcissism where the entire world exists in relationship to your own ego.
SPEAKER_01So you've made yourself the center of the universe. Everything else is in reference to that. And if you're not dating the person you want to date or you don't have the social life that you want, everything everybody else is to blame, right? Um, and you are the kind of uh imaginary hero of your own stories. Yeah, you envision yourself in these intricate plots where you know uh you're the best and everybody else is either to blame or might recognize your greatness, you know.
SPEAKER_01So it's like there's this, there are different types of narcissism, but in either case, you are the center of the universe. Yep. Okay. And it it leads to some tragic consequences, you know, and when I think about the possible connection to a false modesty in sports or elsewhere, you know, in a sense, if someone is deflecting praise and pointing to teammates, but they're doing it only because they know it enhances their image of self with a certain subset.
SPEAKER_01I mean, that's devious in a sense, like that's twisted, you know. Um, so so I think it kind of relates to this idea of everything's in reference to the image that I see of myself. And that's what's going on.
SPEAKER_02You know, you know, it's just making me think of too is like there's something I I don't know if I would juxtapose in a direct line narcissism and humility. Um obviously they're antithetical.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02There's something about reception and receiving a gift. Receive receiving reality in the world for what it is, and I want to construct and control the world. There's something in hospit there's something hospitable about humility and something incredibly inhospitable about narcissism. You know, there there's there's something about a welcoming and a hosting of things related to humility, whereas narcissism makes enemies of everyone.
SPEAKER_02You know. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So all right. So let's take a step back here.
SPEAKER_02I we we should do we we we should do an episode on narcissism at some point.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm down for that. It's it's one of those subjects that like rises up to the surface and now it's gotta continue to be its own thing.
SPEAKER_02And I'm I'm thinking like it would be great, uh it would also be great, and we don't have to we don't have to thematize it in this way, but we should talk about narcissism and arrogance, and like it seems to me that there's some different subtle movements there, but but they're they're running on a parallel track.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's an interesting way to put it, but but hopefully a productive one. All right, so why don't we continue here with our exploration of humility?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so all right, let's talk about how cuility is cultivated in and through disagreement. I mean, I can think of some very obvious ones. Um, you know, when you're when you're in this course and path of disagreement, at some point you're gonna realize that others have very good arguments, uh, and they have you know strong convictions that um you know they can defend and uphold. And it's like there is this moment in which you realize like, like this is stronger than I thought it was.
SPEAKER_02Um their arguments are persuasive, their arguments are coherent. I vehemently disagree with them, but man, they're strong. Right? And so I think that that recognition, that acknowledgement does something to you that lends itself to humility. Wow. Maybe I'm not the guy who holds the whole truth and nothing but the truth. Maybe I'm not the guy with the strongest arguments.
SPEAKER_02Uh maybe possibly I could learn something from others, you know, and that would be that would that would be another element that um leads towards humility is I don't have all the answers. You mean I can actually learn something from you know from others? Um you know, uh and and they could provide. Information that I didn't know.
SPEAKER_02And you know, when you're in those moments, like, haha, well, Kyle, obviously you haven't read the news today. Right. And it's like it causes you to, you know, step back on your heels and you you you sense some not inferiority, but some a deficiency. Wait, I didn't have it all together. I shouldn't be so quick to assert without inquiring. You know, and that that that's sort of softening the spirit.
SPEAKER_02That's soften softening the spirit so that humility can can sprout. Um I think one more, you know, one of the more obvious ones related to not being informed is if you are truly going to disagree, if you are truly going to stick it out and engage with this, you've got to ask questions. And your questions have to be sincere, you know, not leading questions.
SPEAKER_02There's got to be a point in this process of disagreement in which you don't know something. Even if it's not material or the content, like, oh, I, you know, I didn't know dinosaurs had six legs. You know, not something like that, but just like, why do you keep saying the word ethos? Like, what why why is that such an important word for you, right? You don't know that. And that's why you're asking. It's a sincere question, you know, and I think that that is also softening your spirit to um to lend yourself to humility and you know, the growth of humility throughout this conversation.
SPEAKER_02You become the kind of person who sincerely asks questions, who believes with their whole heart and with conviction that they don't know everything, that they're willing to listen for you know, for the sake of truth, they're willing to listen to uh viewpoints and to possibly entertain them and argue with them from people that they just flat out, just to be honest, they don't like. You know, these sorts of postures and positions are feeding into and and you know, soiling the ground and spreading seeds for humility to to emerge and sprout.
SPEAKER_02What do you think about that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I I really like that imagery that you just left us with, with spreading seeds and and the possibilities for humility sprouting and growing. You know, it brings me back to some of our earlier conversations um in the recent episodes about listening and asking, right? Uh and how valuable these types of practices are. You know, what when it comes to um other people, right? And other what we would say, other images of God, uh, you you quickly realize that yeah, you don't control everything and you don't share agreement about everything.
SPEAKER_01You know, I mean, even if you are in a relationship with with a spouse and you've you've been together for a long time, um, you know, we've both have our marriages which have you know different years, but it it's pretty long at this point, I would say, you know, enduring marriages. You know, you can know a person like the back of your hand, as uh an Augustinian priest and mentor of mine at Villanova said. You can know them like the back of your hand and yet still say, like, ah, I'll just never understand them.
SPEAKER_01You know, yeah. Um, because there's such a depth to each person. And, you know, and and to your point, like people oftentimes have good reasons for disagreement. But even if you are not willing to grant that it's a good reason, right? You you also come across something that you realize you don't have the same shared experiences. That that person, despite the fact that we're ad you know, advocating not being self-centered, but that person has a whole host of experiences and a history that has informed what for them are deeply held principles, like first principles, things that they're taking into, all of their views, that can only come about through our conversations and sometimes through our disagreement.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Right. So they they emerge, and and as you recognize them, you realize, wow, like I okay, if you're actually listening and asking, you realize that people come from different vantage points and that they have authenticity based upon those experiences, right? Um, and they they bring them to every conversation. Uh, and and we all know, I mean, one of the great mysteries and and the great, you know, I would say one of the strangest things about humanity is that we can rationalize almost anything.
SPEAKER_01Right? We can we make snap judgments and then rationalize why it makes sense afterward. But a lot of times it's because of these experiences and as they help to form our deeply held principles that we're not always aware of. But if you're a conversation partner, if you're an interlocutor and you're listening and you're asking questions, you start to realize oh, we're approaching something from completely different vantage points.
SPEAKER_01Hopefully, if you're listening and asking, you will start to realize that maybe you're not the center and this person has validity in what where they're coming from. This should engender humility, I would hope. Yeah. At least that's one way I would respond.
SPEAKER_02Well, yeah, I mean, that's fantastic. It also makes me think, like negatively, you know, even on the even on the bad side of things, the selfish person will still come to greater knowledge for themselves of their convictions and presuppositions and holes and deficiencies in their arguments. They will benefit from disagreement. Yes. Even if they're looking for all the wrong things.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Which is fascinating. I never thought about that. Here's something else I just thought of too. Um to your point about spouses, you know, and this is just a footnote like that. I was just thinking about. You know, Adam says about Eve, uh, you know, flesh of my flesh, blood of my blood, but not brain of my brain. Yeah. And I I think that's provocative to think about too.
SPEAKER_02Like um some of the in in related to the church too, insofar as the Son of Man and you know, Christ is the head of the church. That uh even with our spiritual brothers and sisters, we will not always agree with them. We we are in a sense, in a in a mystical and theological sense, in in you know, the mystical union that's in the church, that we are, you know, um flesh of my flesh, blood of my blood, and we partake of the Lord's Supper together, the Eucharist, but yet we're not going to always agree on everything because we're not brain of my brain.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I think that's provocative to think about.
SPEAKER_01It is. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um all right. You have any concluding thoughts about humility and disagreement. I see that we're we're hitting the mark.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we're we're really close to where we usually wrap things up.
SPEAKER_02Which is like two hours or 17 minutes, which one?
SPEAKER_01We're we're about 51 minutes in.
SPEAKER_02All right, that's good. So, I mean, let's do an episode on narcissism and and possibly arrogance. Um any concluding thoughts about humility?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, okay, yeah. I mean, uh, and I'm sure you'll have some some thoughts as well. I would I would say to people, you know, if you have a copy of C.S. Lewis's screw tape letters.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, you didn't read any of those exercises.
SPEAKER_01I didn't read them, but I have them. But I would say um letter 14 from the screw tape letters. Do you do you want me to read a couple of things?
SPEAKER_02I want you to read that at least that pericope of paragraphs.
SPEAKER_01All right, so uh I have uh just a few selections, but you know, I'm sure if you're listening to this, you might have an awareness of the screw tape letters by C.S. Lewis, but you know, deeply Christian man, but writing a book from the perspective of demons to really highlight aspects of the spiritual life. So incredibly valuable. And this is letter 14. And we the demon says, I see only one thing to do at the moment.
SPEAKER_01Your patient, the human, has become humble. Have you drawn his attention to the fact all virtues are less formidable to us once the man is aware that he has them? But this is specially true of humility. Catch him at the moment when he is really poor in spirit, and smuggle into his mind the gratifying reflection, by Jove, on being humble, and almost immediately pride, pride at his own humility, will appear.
SPEAKER_01But there are other profitable ways of fixing his attention on the virtue of humility. By this virtue, as by all the others, our enemy wants to turn the man's attention away from self to him, that is, to God, and to the man's neighbors. You must therefore conceal from the patient the true end of humility. Let him think of it not as self-forgetfulness, but as a certain kind of opinion, namely a low opinion of his own talents and character.
SPEAKER_02I feel like that's a gospel reading. We should say amen at the end of it.
SPEAKER_01That's right.
SPEAKER_02That's fantastic.
SPEAKER_01Just a couple of thoughts from C.S. Lewis, letter 14, screw tape letters.
SPEAKER_02Great. Thank you for sharing, Chris.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, my concluding thoughts would be just remember that conversation in disagreement andor agreement is a process, and it's a process in pursuit of the of the truth. And the truth is much bigger than us. And um, you know, inquiring and understanding and even opening our mouths has a greater purpose than our own benefit. It's more than it's more than about being right.
SPEAKER_02And remember that. So this week, as you speak to your kids, or you order a coffee and engage with the barista, um, or you speak to your students, remember that it's not just about knowing and and having the answers and specifically being right. It's about understanding. It's about growing into the truth and the way and the life.
SPEAKER_02Next time we'll continue our series of long disagreement in the same direction by looking at how disagreement can cultivate courage and confidence. See you next time.
A wise man once said, “Clothes are never just clothes; they are arguments stitched in fabric, parables worn in public, small acts of cultural exegesis.” That wise man is Rev. Dr. Robert Covolo - Executive Director of...
Can you sit still for more than an hour or do you get antsy? When your boss interrupts you, does it make you want to rip out your hair? Do you ever have the unction to whimsically take an alternative route home after...
Do you hate it when they leave splattered marinara sauce in the microwave? Do you hesitate to pass the ball to them because you don’t believe they’ll make the shot? How many times did you draft that email response to...
Do you dream of becoming a Wolf on Wall Street? Is having a library dedicated to you on your bucket list? Are you prepping all your kids to become President because you never could? In America today, we generally...
You excoriated a colleague. You locked in but left the faucet on for a week. You were on full grindset but forgot to pay the bills. Have you ever made a mistake at work? Or failed? Maybe so. But can you really call an...