Send us Fan Mail In this episode of Two Mics, No Masters, Patrick and Andy dig into The Gatekeeper Paradox: can a scene survive without gatekeeping, or does gatekeeping eventually kill the thing it claims to protect? Hardcore, punk, and metal have always lived on a tension between openness and standards. Everyone wants the scene to grow, but nobody wants it watered down. Everyone hates elitism, but most people still have a line where something stops feeling real. So who gets to decide what belongs? The old heads? The kids keeping shows alive now? The bands? The pit? The algorithm? Patrick and Andy talk through the difference between protecting a scene’s values and just being a bitter cop at the door. Along the way, they ask whether hardcore can be truly inclusive without becoming meaningless - and whether every generation has to destroy part of the past to keep the music alive. Loud music. Louder opinions. No masters.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Like I'm not hardcore enough because I don't want to smell people's farts. Like you know what I mean? Like it's don't let me see you cover your face again. Like I I can see why you're standing by yourself, bro. With that with that attitude, it's terrible. I'm gonna go back over here with my friends.
SPEAKER_00Welcome back to Two of Mike's Dill Masters. This is Andy.
SPEAKER_01And I'm Patrick. Uh today we are going to talk about the gatekeeper paradox.
SPEAKER_00To me, gatekeeping is uh shutting people out because of how they look, dress, or even dance. I don't think I was personally ever gatekept, but I definitely knew where I did not belong, that's for sure. I actually have a story. Like I said, I've never been gatekeeped personally, but I have a firsthand experience of seeing it happen in real time. Uh so my first experience with gatekeeping was at a show where these two dudes walked in, and just right away you could tell this was their first time at something like this.
SPEAKER_00I could see right away though that they were being targeted by other people who didn't want them there. And getting they were getting physical with them to the point where they were in like serious danger. I tried to be really kind of like slick about it and kind of walked up to him and was like, hey, you guys need to leave like now. And the guy kind of looked at me like, what the hell are you talking about? He's kind of mad at me. I'm like, oh I I want you here, man. Like it's fine, you're here, obviously, but I'm trying to warn you you're about to get hurt. Both of you. And he was kind of like, that's stupid, whatever.
SPEAKER_00I'm like, okay, just walk away. Then I'm gonna save myself because if you see me talking to you, like I'm gonna get hurt too. Yeah, that that was my first introduction, I guess, to it, from what I can remember.
SPEAKER_01I don't I can't ever recall a time being gay-kept myself, but it's it's more along the lines of what you said, you know where you're not welcome. Yeah, sometimes it's subtle, right? Sometimes it's not so subtle. And it could be things like people don't won't tell you about a band or because they don't think you're cool enough, you don't have enough cred to know about it. There's silly stuff like that, and then there's you know, you don't have the right, you know, your pants aren't big enough, or your pants aren't small enough.
SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? There's that that sort of stuff. I we did touch on some of this in a previous episode, but uh, you know, I thought, given some of the conversations we've had recently, that it would be we we could dive a little deeper into it. I think it's relevant, especially with um everybody having such you know, uh in in the hardcore hardcore universe, people seem to have uh such strong opinions about everything, and this is really just our experience and our perspective. Like I said, you know, I've been through situations where you just know, you know, it's you can feel it.
SPEAKER_01You can feel it. Yeah, yeah, yeah. You can you can you can sense it even if you're not totally aware of what the deal what the deal is.
SPEAKER_00I think I was lucky too. Like I've gone to some shows with some pretty um uh some people that knew other people that were gonna be at the shows and they vouch for me, like, hey, hey, he's with me. Oh, okay, cool, cool. You know, where you could tell, like if it was just me, probably. Like they I don't know, you could probably tell like I wasn't possibly the typical hardcore dude, like as I say in every episode probably for some reason, but uh I was like the I was the metal guy. So I was always like wearing probably some metal shirt at like uh you know a blood for blood show or something.
SPEAKER_00But because of who I was with, I was it they didn't bother me. I I was like, oh, he's fine, he's cool. So I was lucky enough for that.
SPEAKER_01The band shirt phenomenon is I think it's less of an issue now. I think people are more like I see more diverse. There was a time where like you know, there was certain things like you couldn't, you know, wearing a Nirvana shirt to a hardcore show is like oh yeah, no, right, it's a no-go, you know.
SPEAKER_00Even me, it's like we both listen to extreme music styles of music, but to me it's like I'd be at like you know, uh a whatever show, like a hardcore show wearing like a Brutal Truth shirt, and it's like it's just cool to wear. I'm like looking at around like, well, it's just this is who I am, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you know, a lot of diverse music tastes, but I think there's less stigma for wearing something that's outside of the the uniform because I think what you touched upon is what people are they notice what people wear and and will judge for what people are wearing, and I think that's become less of an issue.
SPEAKER_00I think so too.
SPEAKER_01A lot more um accepting. Yes. I mean, there's still obviously a unit there's some uniformity to it.
SPEAKER_00I think I saw a video on Instagram the other day where someone was filming like a show and they were going around just like shifting the camera, and it was like there's so many like camo pants. Camo shorts, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Same, I saw that same one. It's hilarious. It's hilarious because it's it it's it's truthful. Yeah. I mean, there's a lot of camo shorts, it's you know, it's a uniform. Uh so there is some of that. Um, so it is a bit silly to judge someone for not wearing that uniform. It's like have you ever get gay kept someone else?
SPEAKER_00Uh no. I actually uh used to bring people to their to shows for their first time, did that quite a bit. Kind of like, hey, come check this out. If you don't like it, obviously this could be your last show too. But you know, people one one of the one of the uh people I did bring ended up going to shows for a long time.
SPEAKER_01So same. I like anyone who shows interest, if they want to learn about it, yeah, and I'll give them the you know my my experience with it and you know what I what I know about it. I love I love it, especially music. I love to share. Like I'll you know, I'll I'll recommend a bunch of stuff, or I'll even, you know, I like to make mix mix, yeah. I like to make you know playlists for people. So yeah, I I I encourage it and I also wanna, you know, I mentioned before about you know older people mentoring some younger folks, and I I I think there's some truth in that.
SPEAKER_01You gotta you know, you if you want people to know the rules and to understand, you gotta allow them the opportunity to learn, I think. And if you shut them out right at the beginning because they didn't know, seems uh a bit un unfair.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because how how would yeah, how would any of us know unless we went to shows?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's like arresting someone for breaking a law they were totally unaware of. Right. You're like, well, you should have known. You're like, well, how how the hell am I supposed to know? Makes no sense. Some obscure. And there's all these these nuances and subtleties to it, but I don't I can't remember at least intentionally gatekeeping someone. It's it's it's pretty much the opposite. And um I was introduced to hardcore shows through a f friend at the time, a dude named Ryan, who's who sadly has passed away, but he you know shared what he knew to me.
SPEAKER_01And you know, so I like to also pass it along. If someone's honestly, if someone's genuinely interested, I'll give them the time.
SPEAKER_01But you can also tell when people are just I don't know, you don't really know people's intentions, but you know, sometimes people just don't belong. Right. But you you you don't want to make any assumptions either, you know. Did they wander in off the street? Right.
SPEAKER_00Did they just like sometimes that happens, I think, I think, you know? You see like someone's like, oh, what's going on here?
SPEAKER_01Like Yeah, it's natural, I think it's natural to be curious.
SPEAKER_00But I think it's also pretty gutsy to just go into something like that. Like, what's going on here? Like, oh, this show's happening. Like, okay, I'll check it out. Yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_01And if it was my say it was someone I cared about, family member, friend, and they wandered in and wanted to check it out, I wouldn't want them to be like afraid or assaulted. Or harassed by harassed, exactly. You know what I mean? Because they wanted to check something out. I think that's totally reasonable. But also it's good to know when you shouldn't be somewhere, you know, right? Not every situation is safe. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, I always think too, like, I think a big deal too is like when you walk into a new situation you know nothing about, you should just observe. Be in the back, observe what's going on, yeah. You know, instead of trying to run stuff.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I think that's good advice spoken from someone who has some experience, you know. Yeah, for sure. Years to live, and just we have we have the benefit of hindsight. We can look back on our experience and be like, yeah, we we know about this stuff, but we had to learn, like we said in an earlier episode. There's no manual. You can read Vinny Stigma's book, yeah. You know, you can this there's no written rule book. So you know, you gotta learn.
SPEAKER_01But I also understand gatekeeping because you want to you wanna pr pr protect, you know, you want to protect the things that are important.
SPEAKER_00Well, it has to be real too. You just can't let people in that don't value it or don't take it serious enough. And yeah, because for for I know for us and everyone we know that used to go to shows, it's serious. It's like a real thing that people take with them forever, and it's like it means a lot. So it's not just like this whatever thing, it became like a a a lifestyle. You know, so you just can't let anybody in that's just gonna disrespect that.
SPEAKER_01So I think that's quite natural for people. You know, it is important to people, and you don't want it to to feel like it's being devalued or whatever, ch cheapened by someone else's presence.
SPEAKER_00Yep, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. There are people come through that, you know, are just there to sightsee and then they move on. That's cool. Right. Just like I said, I think I said this before, there's no harm in that, really.
SPEAKER_00I mean when you really get into it, you have to understand the history of it, where it came from, the foundation of it, what it means to the current people that are in this thing. Yeah, and to me, you ha i it this isn't just heavy music, but it's you have to respect whatever the thing is that you're trying to incorporate yourself into. You're just not gonna join a softball league and be on the team and be a total, you know, douche about it. You you have to respect what's gonna already happen.
SPEAKER_00If you get in if you get like someone asks you to be part of this and you just act like a total jerk, you know, you that's you can't disrespect something. That means something to other people. Period.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I agree, it's like that for anything. Right. Who gets to decide? You know, I so let me back up. I I think we again we wanna we wanna protect the thing that's so meaningful to us, and we wanna part of that is understanding history. But I think we both agree I don't think I know that we both agree that things change, right? And so they can't stay the same forever because that's not good either.
SPEAKER_01That's not a positive thing either. Thing things we get older, we get wiser, we learn, and some things are just not they don't they're not okay anymore, they're just not acceptable, you know. We we know better.
SPEAKER_00I know I think I think it's up to uh like each in each individual scene because it's all different. Like there's there's so many different styles of heavy music, so like some are well some are accepting and s just some aren't.
SPEAKER_01No, I think that's true too. That's uh you actually make a good point.
SPEAKER_00So it depends on what scene you're walking into.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And even what what city or state. Like you can be in a hardcore, you can go to Boston, go to a show and go to New York, it's gonna be different. You you you have to act different.
SPEAKER_01Valid. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And even people that it's not about gatekeeping either. It's about if you and I go to a show in New York, we're not in the Boston Worcester area anymore. We're outsiders. We gotta respect the New York scene. So it's it just is different. Even from people that have been at going to shows for 30 plus years, you still have to know where where you are.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. How to act. This is a great point. And it's an inter what I what I'm what it what it got me thinking about is how do you learn? If say it's your first time, say you're from Boston, or say you're from the Midwest scene, right? And you you come to like Boston or New York.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um or any any scene to scene. Right. It doesn't matter. Yep. And if these rules are unwritten, and there's it's also a tale of caution where you're like where you're saying, well, you you it's it's good to know, you know, the customs of the place you're going. But how do you know that if you've never been there?
SPEAKER_00So I think you're always safe with kind of, like I said earlier, kind of staying in the back, minding your own business, and just observing. If you're gonna continue to go to that certain scene, like say you did move, you know, just keep going to shows, they'll see your face and they can see you're respecting the scene. And once you kind of see even who kind of is more like a bigger person, uh a notable name, maybe in the scene, you can just tell how people treat that person.
SPEAKER_00I mean, maybe go up to somebody and say, hey, I'm a person that's going to shows from Southern California for the past couple decades. I just moved here. You know, what's what's up with the scene? I I want to become like to me that they they recognize that stuff and they'll be like, Oh, cool, yeah, come on, man. Like, come on in here, we'll you know, kind of show you the ropes of how things run in the New York scene or something, you know.
SPEAKER_01So be respectful. Yeah. Especially if you're you're away from home, be respectful.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And another thing too, I always thought of is going. I always use New York as an example because we've been doing a bunch of shows there too. But it's like if I'm not around people that is kind of my friends and crew, well, not that I would act stupid anyway, but I'm I'm certainly gonna like act correct. Being somewhere where I'd have nobody.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00And they can tell usually like if if like if you and I show up somewhere else now, we've got like we look older. So it's like these guys are private around the block, so they probably know.
SPEAKER_01We yes, we do look a bit seasoned. Yeah. So we usually I mean I don't have a whole lot I I don't usually have any problems. So you're right.
SPEAKER_00Get get to learn and Yeah, and again, everyone gets excited and eager. I like I love this culture, I just want to jump in the pit. It's like, don't do that. Don't do that. Especially if you're if you literally have nobody, it's just you like at this thing. I wouldn't recommend it. Just kinda ease into it. Let people know who you are for a while. They they'll they'll notice you, they might not say anything or introduce themselves or whatever, but they'll they'll see you. If you keep coming and they can see you're being respectful and you maybe you're checking out merch or whatever, cool.
SPEAKER_01If you've been to a bunch of shows in your local area, say even within your own state, within say a fifty hundred mile radius of your home, and you go to another place and you think you're a hot shot because you've been to a bunch a bunch of shows, and you go in there and you start acting like a big deal and being disrespectful, chances are you're gonna get a not so great response from people. And it's just it's like go it's like traveling anywhere.
SPEAKER_01It's no different. It's good to know the social norms and customs of the place you're at.
SPEAKER_00I mean you're essentially in someone else's home. That's correct. We should all act correct in someone else's house. Yes. And it sounds a bit territorial, and I g I guess it is. It is, but with I think with every right too, because if if you've been if if if a certain group of people have been going to this one area for a long time, going to shows there, it of course it's territorial. They're gonna have respect for their um their area. Yes. You can't just waltz in and be like, hey yeah, I'm the big dog now. It's like, yeah, that's not you're gonna get a welcome, but I think I'm gonna be a happy one.
SPEAKER_01So you protect it like you would want to protect your home, you know, exactly. It's an extension of your home.
SPEAKER_00Just have respect, that's all.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Just have respect.
SPEAKER_00Pretty simple.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's simple, it's hard for some people.
SPEAKER_00And I and I get it too, because I remember uh my first show. I I I I don't honestly remember if I did get in the pit, but I remember it was difficult not to. Because I remember I immediately it didn't take long, probably for you too, where you're like, yeah, I belong here. Oh my god, this is like I love this. This experience, the live show, the bands, and I had a ton of friends at my first show, so I felt I definitely felt pretty safe, you know. And I say that, and then I know one of the people I went with got literally knocked out cold. But anyway, regardless, uh, it was safe, and I because I knew a ton of people, and you know nothing was gonna go down.
SPEAKER_00It was just it was a cool show. And and that's another different thing, too, if you go with a bunch of people. I'm not saying go with a bunch of people and act disrespectful because you can now, because you have a crew, it's like don't do that either. I'm just saying there's different situations, so know the situation you're in, know the circumstances, and just regardless, have respect and act act the way you should, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, don't be a dick. Yeah, my first show. I don't remember if I got in the pit either. But there are pictures of me shortly thereafter at a quicksand show, like running across the stage. So on my way to stage dive. So I'm assuming I had already advanced in levels.
SPEAKER_00I I think I remember thinking to myself, what do I do? How do I do this? Yeah. I think maybe kind of realizing like, oh, maybe everyone's got their own kind of thing, their signature to their dance moves. You just learn from doing and you guys get better at it, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I've seen videos and pictures of myself, and they're not they're they're not attractive. Yeah. Um but I wasn't concerned with how I looked, really.
SPEAKER_00I was just which was actually the best part.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00Because it you know no one else did either.
SPEAKER_01And and as far as developing style, you walk, you learn, yeah, and then you you develop your own style, you put your own spin on it, you know, very similar to skateboarding. I I think for a long time hardcore has got away from that where it was just like straight kicking and punching violence, and not a whole lot of style behind it, but now lately, I've been seeing more more style, more, less, same, same. Everybody's just kind of doing the same thing and which which makes no sense because music hits everyone different.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00So how could you do the same move? It doesn't make sense.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You gotta have the same you gotta have the core moves.
SPEAKER_00Right, you know, right, right.
SPEAKER_01You know, you gotta have those in your repertoire, but you gotta, you know.
SPEAKER_00You can still pick up change, but you have to have your own.
SPEAKER_01Start the lawnmower.
SPEAKER_00Right, exactly.
SPEAKER_01Make it some pizza, like there's all kinds of variations. And market basket, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I I know for me personally, like and another thing is too, if like back in the day, seeing Overcast, I would dance a certain way. Yes. But then seeing, say, Older Living Witness, I dance different.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Because they're not the same band, how could you feel the s I I don't feel the same? I go off differently. You know, my body moves differently.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you don't do the same d dance steps to every song. That's lame. Different I mean they hit they they they hit you in a different way. They feel a different way, as you just said. Yeah, you know, and I responded differently depending on the the band, uh, the situation, you know, the where I was. There's a lot of factors, you know, but it wasn't also a room of everybody just swinging around like windmills.
SPEAKER_00See, I imagine though we're telling these stories now because it was a huge part of our life, still is. Imagine if we were gay kept, we wouldn't we wouldn't have this whole experience. Exactly. Yes. You know, so it kind of brings it back to our up the point of this episode. You might be gatekeeping somebody that truly doesn't belong. I don't know. Hate to use that that language. I don't like shutting people out of anything. It's just it's life, whatever. People can experience whatever they want. But I just think if we were gay kept and we never were able to experience going to shows for all these decades, we wouldn't be sitting here for one thing.
SPEAKER_00We probably wouldn't know each other actually at all. And our lives would be totally different, you know?
SPEAKER_01And I don't expect every live show to be a hardcore show. No. That's what sort of what I meant when I mean when I tell people to read the room, like what environment are you are you in?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean I saw uh if uh people remember the band Seamless, uh, you know, members of like Jesse from Kill Switch was a singer and a bunch of different band members, but I've seen them, then they're they're like a rock and roll slash kind of stoner. So you're not pitting for that. It's like, you know, I mean, it's just you it's a vibe band. You chill out, you know, some headbang going on, some grooving, and you know, drink a beer kind of band. They were playing, and we're a few were just standing there watching them play, and people are trying to get like crazy. And I remember just looking at the guy, you know, I don't like telling people what to do because people do whatever the hell they want.
SPEAKER_00I don't care. Remember grabbing the guy on the shoulder, like, dude, no, just no, this is not. I think I pointed to other people, like, everyone just chilling and having a good time, man. This is not the situation for this, it's not the right place or vibe or band. And you kind of look at me like, oh, like, you know, like, dude, it's just not. I don't know. How'd you tell you?
SPEAKER_01And how did they how did the person respond?
SPEAKER_00Wasn't excited. Yeah, I think you kind of got though after a minute, like kind of looking around, like, oh yeah, I just you know, there's like you know, myself, my buddy, uh, we knew a bunch of other people, like, you know, women stand there. It's like most people would hold in a beer because they'll say that's kind of band it is, you know. And it's like, what are you gonna knock everyone's beer out of their hands and these women down? Like, yeah, we'll just watch some rock and roll.
SPEAKER_01And that's that that's a good example of time and place, you know, like being aware of where you are, and oh, okay, you you want you want to dance hard and throw around, throw and right, and who am I? A couple of spin kicks to tell this guy how he feels it. Right. But if the rest of the room is saying this is not the place for it. Right. That's true too. But is it not is it truly not the place, or is it the other people? You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think too, it's like yeah, I if if he did start like actually smashing at people, it'd be like you're gonna ruin a lot of people's nights, probably. Yeah. Because the setting here right now, and the vibe you're getting from the band is guys just like roove out with us and just have a good time. And don't worry about getting hit.
SPEAKER_01That's the vibe. Seamless has hardcore roots, but they're not necessarily a hardcore band. Right. So people who go to hardcore shows expect a certain experience or want a certain experience, and that's fine. That's totally fine. But again, read the room, man. It's not the time or place. You know, this time, you just hold that shit back, man, and save it. Right. Save it for the next one, you know, the the next real hardcore show or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Who knows? The guy might have this been his first time seeing Seamless. Totally. And he might have been like, This is Jesse from Kill Switch. Yeah, yeah. So he he's already got that mentality, but it's like, or it's like, you know, Pete was in Overcast and like the members of Unearth or something. But it's like, I no. Totally. It's not those bands, though.
SPEAKER_01It's not that it's not metal, it's not hardcore, it's you know, it's it's chilled, it's not, it's still heavy, but it's not, you know, like if you mention Stone and Rock, it's more that's that's a good example because it's not necessarily gatekeeping, it's more just social regulation, it's just people saying, Look, this sort of behavior at this particular time is not okay or welcome or appropriate.
SPEAKER_00I was trying to protect other people. Yeah. Because I'm like, hey I'm kind of pointing like, well, there's there's ladies standing right here, you know, and there's other people I don't want to get hit.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So And there have been other times where I've been in a room and people are flying everywhere and you look around and everybody's swinging. Yes. And that's the time for that. Exactly. You know what I mean? Time it time in a place. But I think people try too hard to force what they want on everyone else.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I want to be like, I want you to have a good time, but I don't want it at everyone else's expense.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, so I mean I feel bad. Like if I was going crazy, I did back then I felt bad when I hit somebody, but yeah, I like now. I don't like yeah, I've got if you if you don't feel bad about it, then like I I No, I never want to hurt anybody. No, like I would have some questions about your exactly. I mean, whatever. So who gets to decide though? Like who decides who and what belongs?
SPEAKER_00I just think there's unwritten rules for each scene.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Is it a collective is it a collective scene decision?
SPEAKER_00So So, okay. Actually, we I have an experience that we probably both were a part of. At 490, when that person came in during, I believe, Only Living Witness. Yes. Off the street. Oh, yeah, this is a great example, actually. Off the street, some Rando walks down the stairs and just starts railing people in the face.
SPEAKER_01Yes. And as a I was actually one of the people that got hit and I was pressed into a corner. Wow, okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that person, the whole collective scene, made a decision to uh end the problem, I should say. Yes. And remove that person. Yes, they were removed with force. Yes.
SPEAKER_01I was gonna say with prejudice, but with force. With force, with extreme force.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. But they were exited from the place, and uh it's like, and that is exactly what I mentioned a few times, I think, today, is like don't go into a situation acting like you own the place. That's what happens to you. Whether it's right or wrong, what happens to do it, that's going to happen. Because people are gonna be like, no, this is our place. It's not how things go.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that that's a great example of collective decision. They decided that they were gonna take out the trash, so to speak, you know, metaphorically. And and they did that, and they acted spontaneously, right? Uh that's a great example of that.
SPEAKER_00Um it could have gone totally different. The guy could have come in and possibly even could have went very different. He could have actually come in and still got in the pit and just jumped around with everyone, and probably would have been fine, actually. Yeah, but once you start just like it's like because that dude had no idea, guess what? Everyone's friends.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You just hit someone's like quote unquote brother or sister, because they're everyone's friends and family.
SPEAKER_01And also that guy, uh uh, this is a part of the story that gets left out. So that guy, when he was coming down the stairs, was talking about how he was gonna like mess everybody up and you know, look at all the freaks, and uh, you know, like so he came in with an agenda of causing problems, and he did. And that was a mess around and find out moment.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it it it and it was like almost like okay, you hit one person, maybe he doesn't know. Yes, and then it's like, oh no, another person, okay. Guess what? Yeah, now this is happening.
SPEAKER_01It was like a swarm of bees. Yeah, that was insane. That's I think that goes beyond gatekeeping. That's really just that's a matter of protection and defense and also setting boundaries for people who aren't respecting even even if they're unwritten boundaries, like they're they're sort of social boundaries. Um and when you cross it, there there's a consequence for that, and I think that's a that's a a good example.
SPEAKER_01But but things like you know how people people dress, or you know, this notion that we talked about earlier of can of getting consent. Everyone must give consent anytime they're touched, you know, and how how realistic it is that. There's all these nuances to it. Is it is it gatekeeping or is it just trying to protect a value that people hold dear? Right.
SPEAKER_01And and want to keep that from being diluted or changed, especially if that what's being asked doesn't make sense. Right. I don't have I don't have an answer for it. I'm just you know I'm I'm trying to come at it from these different perspectives, you know, sort of based on you know what I've experienced.
SPEAKER_00And I I think of too uh uh a funny, kind of a funny one is Barney from Napalm Death, he looks ridiculous on stage. I'm not being mean, but he had the way his like stage he looks like a spastic like lunatic. Yes, he has he's just no rhythm, he's just all like, but that's rhythm to him, obviously. But the way he moves, you wouldn't think he sings for a grind corps band. He looks so out of place to me. But he he's a legend, he's one of the literally probably the greatest grind corps band of all time. And it's like if he was gay kid, like, oh you you don't have the right stage presence for this band.
SPEAKER_00Or the right look. Yeah, exactly. The right look, exactly. He's up there wearing like suspenders and like but he's in like Napalm Death. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I saw him recently and he had the the classic suspenders look that he had, you know, with the black pants, totally t-shirt tucked in with the suspenders on, which is his classic look, you know. I'm sure he knows how he looks when he dances around at this point. But you're right. But he doesn't care. You yes, and you don't expect because when you hear the music, that's not what you're expecting.
SPEAKER_00You pictured like some long-haired, like big dude. He's actually a pretty tiny guy and short hair and just looks like he should be uh in a suit or something, you know?
SPEAKER_01It's funny. And you bring up a good point. I think sometimes with with we're quick to dismiss people or push people away too quick. I think we're too quick sometimes. Oh yeah, for sure. You know, before people can even, you know, they're just kind of poking their head and like, what's going on, guys? And we're like, fuck it, beat it. Screw you guy.
SPEAKER_00Out of here. Yeah, right. Get out of here. I mean, if I was gatekeeped for every stupid thing I ever said, as in like first impression, like you just get nervous and say something dumb, I wouldn't probably know anybody.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. If we're always pushing people out and we never let new people in, scene's gonna die. Yeah, it's gonna die. We gotta be mindful that we're not our gatekeeping isn't fueled by one nostalgia.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, because nostalgia feels good. Yeah. That's right. You think about something and it brings back a great memory. Yeah. So it's like, oh, that's the way it should be. That's that that's that's the correct way. That's the way it should be. Exactly. My point. Yeah, well said, dude. But then the person standing next to us doesn't have that nostalgic feeling, so it's like doesn't mean anything to them. So they, you know, they like a newer band that you go, well, I don't like them because they don't make me feel like this. Yeah. But it makes them feel like that. Yes. So and and they might be a newer band that is going to keep a scene growing and going on.
SPEAKER_01So there are a lot of those bands, and and some of them I don't care for.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01And some I do.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01But I'm not I don't perpetually live in 1995.
SPEAKER_00Unfortunately.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And and that's a danger too, because then you start keeping people out because you feel like they don't represent this this thing that you're nostalgic for. Exactly. When in really this new person's experience is already different than yours.
SPEAKER_00So is there actual harm though, you think, to letting just anyone into the scene, or is it or is gatekeeping necessary?
SPEAKER_01Yes. I think there is a harm. I think it's necessary because I think there's a harm for letting just anybody in. It's it's that old saying, you know, the one bad apple. Um, and it's sort of that thing. You want to welcome new ideas and new people, and you want to welcome positive change while also keeping out the things that you're that as a matter of personal principle just aren't acceptable anyway.
SPEAKER_01So there's always that balance. And not everybody sees eye to eye on every particular issue, but there's there's a lot of commonalities there, which is what unify I help I think helps unify this scene. So when somebody comes in and starts I'm trying to get away from sounding so defensive about it, like, oh, you know, you gotta pay your dues.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Because it's not so much as that it it it is that, but it's not that simple. I don't think it's that simple at all. You also don't want people to come in and start telling you that everything you do is wrong and this is the way they want it, and you know what I mean? And I think that happens too with I think there's some generational differences that can clash, to be honest.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_01Who's right? You know, we're back to the who makes the rules. I'd r I think I'd rather take the time to try to tell somebody, you know, you can't do that with everybody. I mean, like, can we try to talk to every person on your show? Give them like critique on like their clipboard. Yeah, be like, uh, so sneakers, check, uh, shirt, uh, one size too small, so you we're gonna one one notch down for that. Um, yeah. So I I watched your spin kick, that was kind of weak.
SPEAKER_01Uh, but your two-step was spot on. Uh great rhythm, great technique. Um, overall, you get a B. Your friend, however, oof, we're gonna ask him to go outside. There is a tutor waiting for him. Um, after he receives proper education and instruction, he will be given the opportunity to return. At which time he will be re-evaluated.
SPEAKER_00That's funny.
SPEAKER_01It is funny. So, and we can make fun of it because in the end it's not that it's serious and it's important, but it's not that serious, man. Like bro, like bro, bro, chill. So I I think it can be harmful and it can be helpful.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I I feel like we're constantly riding that line. Some people are blatantly like just gatekeepers.
SPEAKER_00Some people are even like that with music, like if it's if it's past this year, I don't want to hear it. Yeah, that's old. Like you're missing like tons of great music.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And we'll talk about it on which is a great point because you know, there's a lot of stuff from last year that I'm just now discovering. And had I known about it last year, it would have got a lot of listens. So I the fact that it's last year's is I'm more interested in the fact that it's great music.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's all I care about. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I don't care what year it's from. Really. I like to discover new stuff. And there's not that the demo core where they're like, oh, I only like their demo. No, you don't, dude. Nobody likes that demo. Right. It sounds terrible. It sounds terrible. Nobody likes it. Stop. They made that in your mom's kitchen. Right. I was there. Your mom made brownies after.
SPEAKER_00It was delicious.
SPEAKER_01It was delicious. Yeah. Like they're there. She made them nut free.
SPEAKER_00Try to consider it over there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because like Clarence has a fucking nut allergy. So Clarence. He's our he's the guitar tech.
Send us Fan Mail Hardcore got bigger. Somewhere along the way, it also got more expensive, more curated, and a whole lot easier to sell. Patrick digs into the tension between growth and the underground, participation...
Send us Fan Mail Episode 16 Open This Pit Up… or Don’t When does hardcore stop feeling dangerous and start feeling like somebody trying way too hard to look dangerous? This one gets into fake toughness, real intensity,...
Send us Fan Mail After a two-week break, Two Mics, No Masters is back with six releases from the first half of 2026 that refused to leave the rotation. This isn’t a ranking, a midyear awards show, or an attempt to tell...
Send us Fan Mail Some bands become legends. Others quietly change the course of hardcore and never get the credit they deserve. In Volume II of The Unsung Architects, Patrick explores five bands that challenged...
Send us Fan Mail The Unsung Architects - Volume I: Six Bands That Deserve Another Conversation Some bands become legends. Others quietly change the course of heavy music without ever getting the recognition they...