Send us Fan Mail Hardcore got bigger. Somewhere along the way, it also got more expensive, more curated, and a whole lot easier to sell. Patrick digs into the tension between growth and the underground, participation and consumption, and what happens when a scene starts looking a little too much like an industry. VIP tickets. Festival bullshit. Merch lines. Bigger rooms. Better opportunities. More money. Some of that is good. Some of it feels corny as fuck.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00This episode has been sitting in my head for a while. Because the more I thought about it, the less simple it got. There are things in hardcore right now that I genuinely love. And then there's some shit that feels completely backwards. Money, branding, bigger shows, packaged experiences. People participate in the culture in totally different ways. And somewhere in the middle of all that is the question I keep coming back to.
SPEAKER_00What happens when something built as an underground culture gets big enough that people outside of it start seeing it as an industry? That's what we're getting into today. Loud music, louder opinions. Let's go.
SPEAKER_00There. That's the episode. Except it isn't. Because the second I say that out loud, I have to explain what the fuck I mean. I don't mean hardcore sucks now. I don't mean that everybody under 30 is doing it wrong. I don't mean we need to drag 1995 out of the grave, put everybody back in a VFW hall, turn the lights off, and let somebody get kicked down a flight of stairs for authenticity. And when I say hardcore here, I mean the whole neighborhood.
SPEAKER_00Hardcore, punk, metal, and all the adjacent shit that overlaps with them. This isn't one scene with one culture. Half these little subcultures can barely agree on what hardcore even is. Boston isn't New York, a punk house show isn't a death metal show, a thousand person room isn't somebody's living room. Those differences matter. What I mean is there's a version of hardcore right now that feels less like a scene and more like a curated hardcore themed experience.
SPEAKER_00Big bills, branded festivals with Roman numerals, dramatic lineup reveals, merch drops,$60 tickets,$6 waters, an hour-long line to buy a shirt that already costs too much because apparently everybody between the band and your torso needs their fucking blood tithes. And somehow we've reached a point where hardcore can occasionally feel like spring break with breakdowns. Beach balls, crowdsurf selfies, manufactured crazy moments, everybody filming everybody else, proving that everybody had a fucking amazing time.
SPEAKER_00I don't need a beach ball. I need the band to be good. And VIP hardcore might be the funniest contradiction of all. A culture built around participation, community, and flattening the difference between band and crowd somehow figured out a way to sell hierarchy back to us? And nothing screams punk like paying extra money so you can be more important than the other people at the show. And I know how this sounds. Old guy yells at the cloud.
SPEAKER_00Back in my day, Flyer was photocopied crooked and the half the bands didn't even show up. That's not what I'm trying to do here. Because I don't think there's one version of hardcore happening right now. There are a bunch of them happening at the same time. There's the underground, house shows, basements, VFW halls, little clubs, local promoters, local bands, and touring bands that nobody outside the room gives a shit about yet.
SPEAKER_00Somebody dragging a PA into a room. Somebody selling records off a folding table. Somebody trying to make enough money to get the touring band to the next city. That still feels like a scene. Then there's the other version. Big room, packaged, commercialized hardcore. Live nation type shit. Pedestrian concert festival vibe bullshit. Everything branded, everything rolled out like it's a product launch.
SPEAKER_00You buy the ticket, you buy the parking, you buy the water, you stand in the merch line, you buy the shirt, you take the photo, you post the clip, you prove that you were there. Then you go home. One asks you to participate, the other can start to feel like you bought admission to somebody else's version of it. But even that's too neat. I've said before that I don't like big room hardcore.
SPEAKER_00I was wrong about that. Or at least that's way too simplistic. It's not about room size. It's about orientation and experience. A thousand people in a room can still feel like hardcore. A hundred people in a room can feel completely dead. Capacity isn't culture. What is the whole thing built around? The band, the people, participation, community? Or moving customers through an event?
SPEAKER_00Maybe I don't hate what hardcore became. Maybe I hate one version of what hardcore became. And here's where this thing gets annoying, because hardcore got better in a lot of ways. Safer rooms are better. More inclusive scenes are better. More awareness around consent is better. Less tolerance for predatory behavior is better. More women, queer people, younger people, and people who used to get pushed to the margins being able to participate is better.
SPEAKER_00Better organization is good. Better sound is good. Easier access is good. Bands being able to reach people outside their town is good. I don't miss people getting their teeth knocked out. I miss the feeling that nobody knew exactly what was gonna happen. Those aren't the same thing. Hardcore becoming less hostile is good. Hardcore becoming less weird is not. We figured out that you don't need to be an asshole to be hardcore.
SPEAKER_00Great. But did we accidentally decide you also have to be wholesome? And all of that can be true at once. Safer versus sterile, inclusive versus sanitized, community versus branding, dangerous energy versus actual harm, growth versus professionalization, visibility versus underground identity. How do you make hardcore safer without making it sterile?
SPEAKER_00How do you let it grow without optimizing the fucking life out of it? Because I'm not mourning the violence, the exclusion, or the dysfunction. I'm talking about the unpredictability, the weirdness, the local character, the imperfection, the feeling that nobody completely controlled the experience. Hardcore's become better at being a community and worse at feeling like an underground.
SPEAKER_00It sounds contradictory. I don't think it is. A community wants people to find it. An underground, almost by definition, isn't completely legible to everybody. A community wants access. An underground has friction, local language, and some things you can only learn by showing up. Those things pull against each other. Money's where this argument gets stupid fast.
SPEAKER_00Money is not automatically anti hardcore. Hardcore is always sold shit. Records, demos, shirts, tickets, zines, whatever. Buying something from a band, especially some unknown touring band that needs gas, food, or enough money to reach their next city can be one of the most direct forms of support there is. Bands making money from their art is good.
SPEAKER_00I want bands to eat. I want them to pay rent. I want them to tour without coming home buried in debt. If somebody can actually make a living doing this, good for them. The question isn't whether money belongs in hardcore. The question is what money starts doing. Money keeping bands alive is one thing. Money recognizing the culture around extraction is another. The problem isn't just that hardcore got bigger.
SPEAKER_00It's that once it got big enough, people outside the scene started seeing a revenue stream. Once there's real money there, people who never gave a shit about the scene suddenly care a lot about the audience. As customers, percentages, ticket demand, and merch cuts. Growth brought opportunity. It also brought extraction. The bigger hardcore gets, the more people outside hardcore start asking what they can sell to it.
SPEAKER_00That's where I get uncomfortable. Not because the band is successful. Not because the room is big. Not because people are making money. But because the culture can start bending around money instead of money supporting the culture. And maybe this is the part that pisses me off the most. Hardcore's lame as fuck for doing all the things it used to say it was too punk for, right up until there was money in it. That's harsh, but come on.
SPEAKER_00There was a time when being too polished was suspicious. Too branded was suspicious. Too corporate was suspicious. Too slick was suspicious. Too interested in the industry was definitely fucking suspicious. Then enough money showed up, and suddenly a lot of that shit became normal. Not all at once, not everywhere, and not always for bad reasons.
SPEAKER_00Some of it's bands getting older, some of its people wanting to actually survive, some of its musicians realizing that sleeping on floors for ten years is not a retirement plan. Fair enough. That isn't the problem. The problem is when the things hardcore used to treat like compromises suddenly stop being compromises because now there's a check attached. But then we have to ask whether the values actually changed or whether the price just got high enough.
SPEAKER_00Hardcore has always loved telling itself that it operates by a different set of rules. DIY, community, anti corporate, anti-mainstream, do it yourself, support the bands, support the scene. Okay. So what happens when somebody outside the culture shows up with enough money? What happens when the venue deal sucks but the room is bigger? When the merch cut is bullshit but the exposure is good?
SPEAKER_00When the ticket price feels insane, but the show sells out anyway. That's where the argument gets interesting. Because maybe some of those old values were always easier to defend when there wasn't much money at stake. It's easy to say you're above something when nobody is offering it to you. It gets a lot harder when somebody puts a number on the table. And again, I don't think the answer is purity. Purity's bullshit. Hardcore has never been pure.
SPEAKER_00There's always been money. There's always been ambition. There's always been people trying to make something bigger. But there's still a difference between making money inside a culture and letting money decide what the culture becomes. Maybe there isn't one clean line. Maybe it moves. If hardcore starts doing everything it once claimed to reject, I think we're allowed to ask what changed? Did we grow up?
SPEAKER_00Did the culture evolve? Did we realize some of those old ideas were stupid? Or did we just realize that our principles had a price? Then there's a visibility problem. Hardcore's become incredibly aware of what hardcore is supposed to look like. The clothes, the stage dives, the merch, the poses, the fucking facial expressions. At some point, the camera stops documenting the night and starts changing the night.
SPEAKER_00The camera stops recording the moment. The moment starts happening for the camera. Show becomes content. Tours become content, breakdowns become content. Crowds become content. And suddenly you've got an economy of proof. Proof the show is insane. Proof the band is blowing up. Proof the fest mattered. Proof you were there. Hardcore starts performing hardcore.
SPEAKER_00And that's where I start wondering if some of the corniness is really just self-consciousness. A culture that used to feel like it didn't give a fuck now spends a lot of time proving how hard it doesn't give a fuck. That's funny. And kind of sad. At some point, everybody stopped being in hardcore and started having a hardcore career. Yeah, that's exaggerated, but you know what I mean. Band becomes brand, tour becomes campaign, shirt becomes merch drop, show becomes experience.
SPEAKER_00Scene participation becomes audience engagement. And corporate doesn't always mean some giant corporation. Sometimes it's just the mindset. Optimize it, scale it, brand it, repeat. Maybe some things stop being underground the moment we optimize them. Not because underground has to mean shitty sound, unsafe rooms, broken toilets, and getting paid twenty three dollars in gas money.
SPEAKER_00That's nostalgia bullshit, because underground culture usually has some friction built into it. You have to take a chance on something you don't really understand. The modern commercial instinct is to remove friction. Make it easy, seamless, convenient. Put everything in one place. Give you the lineup, the clips, the playlist, the merch, the discourse. The fucking recap video before you've even processed what happened.
SPEAKER_00And I'm not gonna pretend convenience is evil. Finding a band in 30 seconds instead of hunting six months for a demo is not a cultural tragedy. But some of that friction created context. A lot of the information used to travel through people, and because it traveled through people, it came attached to culture. Now you can get all the information with none of the context. You can know every band, fest lineup, viral clip, and merch drop, and still have no fucking clue what is happening ten miles from your house.
SPEAKER_00And that's just fucking weird to me. Hardcore can feel enormous and tiny at the exact same time. More bands, more access, more shows, more participation. And somehow everybody's still talking about the same twenty things. That's the one giant internet scene. It connects everything. It can also flatten everything. Boston felt like Boston.
SPEAKER_00New York felt like New York. DC felt like DC. Cleveland felt like Cleveland. That local weirdness mattered. Different rooms, different sounds, different personalities, different rules. You could feel where you were. Scale can connect all of that. It can also sand some of it down until every scene starts speaking the same visual language. Now everybody can see everybody else all the time.
SPEAKER_00And once everybody can see everybody else, everybody can start adjusting towards what gets rewarded. What gets clicks, what gets reposted, what gets booked, what photographs well, what looks like hardcore. That last one is the part that gets me. Because when everybody knows the visual language, it gets easier to reproduce the visual language without necessarily reproducing the culture underneath it.
SPEAKER_00And this is where I keep coming back to experience. Knowing about hardcore and knowing how to participate in hardcore are not the same thing. An audience knows what is happening. A scene makes something happen. And if the curated version is the loudest, most visible version, then that becomes the template. That is what the next wave gets taught hardcore is supposed to look like. So the question is not just what are we selling now.
SPEAKER_00It's what are we teaching people to expect when they finally walk into the room? You see that difference when people walk into the same room expecting two completely different things. Banana Gate is useful here. Not because the guy in a banana suit is some historically important hardcore moment. That sentence is fucking ridiculous on its face. But the reaction exposed two totally different ideas of what hardcore show is supposed to be.
SPEAKER_00One version says, This is a hardcore show. It has its own history, physicality, etiquette, humor, confrontation, assumed risks, and unwritten rules. You're entering something that existed before you bought the ticket. The other version approaches it more like a conventional entertainment event. I paid to get in, I should be able to occupy the space however I want.
SPEAKER_00The environment should adopt to my expectations. And no, buying a ticket does not mean you consent to getting your head kicked in. And hardcore is dangerous, is not a blank check for being an asshole. But the other extreme is pretending a hardcore show should work like every other entertainment space. I don't think that works either. Hardcore is participatory. The crowd affects the band, the band affects the crowd. People move, pile on, dive, grab the mic, scream lyrics in somebody else's face.
SPEAKER_00And that context is exactly what gets lost when the experience has already been shaped for you. You can watch 10,000 clips of moshing, know the bands, the lyrics, the shirts, every fest announcement, every stupid internet argument, and still not understand the room. Everybody should be welcome in hardcore. That doesn't mean hardcore has to become whatever every person walking through the door already expects it to be.
SPEAKER_00Inclusivity means you get to enter the culture. It doesn't necessarily mean the culture gets rewritten around you the second you arrive. We already did the gatekeeping episode, so I'm not beating that to death. Pardon the pun. You can be deeply informed and culturally inexperienced at the same time. Put that person next to somebody who's been doing this for 25 years? They can love the same band and have completely different ideas about what happens when the band starts playing.
SPEAKER_00That's the clash. Not old versus young, not real versus fake. Two different ways of learning the culture. The underground teaches you hardcore by making you part of it. The commercial version gives you a role inside an experience that's already been designed. You can still move, yell, dance, buy the shirt, post the clip, feel like you're shaping the night, but the boundaries of that participation were mostly set before you walked in.
SPEAKER_00And inside that system, our participation is measured in tickets, drinks, merch, clicks, and views. Our participation is measured in dollars. We want hardcore to grow. We want people to come. We want bands to succeed. We promote the shit out of it. And then when somebody shows up without understanding the culture, we ask, who invited this fucking guy?
SPEAKER_00Well, apparently we did. And here's the other problem with pretending these are two separate worlds. They're not. They overlap all the time. Bands move between them, fans move between them. I move between them. Sometimes reluctantly. There are shows where I look at the venue, ticket price, fees, merch situation, the whole polished concert festival thing, and think.
SPEAKER_00Fuck this. And then I buy the ticket anyway, because I want to see the band. Sometimes the only way to see a band you actually give a shit about is to buy into an experience you don't give a shit about. I can hate the packaging and still want to see the fucking band. And now the argument gets messier. Because I'm participating too. Paying the 60 bucks, buying the$6 water, standing in the stupid line, walking into the exact environment I'm complaining about.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't have to convince me it's better. It just has to have enough things I care about on the side of the ticket. The economics change. Big rooms are not the problem. Again, orientation and experience. I went to the palladium in Worcester the other night, and the whole night basically proved this back to me. Saying Guisa Kebab, dying fetus, crowbar, left to suffer, and deterioration.
SPEAKER_00Some of those bands absolutely fucking own that big room. Others not so much. So again, the room isn't the problem. Meanwhile, the merch line was fucking absolutely ridiculous and basically never ended. People waited for hours. And that reluctant participation gets normal pretty fast. You complain about the ticket price, the venue, the fees, the merch cut, and then you go anyway because you still want to see the band.
SPEAKER_00After a while, the shit that used to feel ridiculous just becomes the price of admission, financially and culturally. At what point does the version we tolerate become the version everybody assumes is normal? Maybe that's how cultures really change. Maybe that's what I'm actually afraid of losing. Not basements, not shitty sound, not bad bathrooms, not some imaginary golden age where everybody was tougher and everything was real.
SPEAKER_00I'm talking about the possibility of the unrepeatable moment. That thing that happens when a room tips into something nobody planned. It's hot, it's crowded, people are dancing, shoving, laughing, yelling. Half the room looks completely out of control. And somehow everybody's having the time of their life. For a minute, it feels perfect. Not polished.
SPEAKER_00Perfect. There's a difference. And you can't schedule that. You can't put it in a promotional copy. You can't guarantee it with a bigger lineup. You can't manufacture it by throwing a beach ball into the crowd and telling everybody to lose their fucking minds. It either happens or it doesn't. That's what the managed version can't guarantee. It can reproduce the bands, the stage dives, the lights, the crowd, the merch, and the pictures afterward.
SPEAKER_00The experience wasn't good despite being messy. The mess was part of what made it good. Some moments only work because nobody completely controls them. And once you felt that, you know when something else doesn't have it. Does it still feel alive? You can measure ticket sales, streams, followers, views, merch, and engagement. You can't measure the second a whole room loses its fucking mind together.
SPEAKER_00And maybe that's exactly why it matters. Then every once in a while, something happens that makes me think maybe I'm completely full of shit. I recently saw a flyer for a benefit house show, and I got genuinely excited about it. Not ironically, not because it was cute. I saw it and thought, it looked really fucking fun. No giant production, no manufactured good vibes, no stage spectacle, just a house full of people making something happen.
SPEAKER_00Maybe hardcore didn't disappear. Maybe I just stopped getting the flyer. Maybe the underground is doing just fine without asking me to approve the branding. And that complicates the whole complaint. Of course the commercial version is easiest to see. It has the machine and the money to make sure you see it. Maybe visibility is the trap. The most visible version is not necessarily the whole culture. Maybe hardcore became many things at once, and some of them I probably don't even know exist yet.
SPEAKER_00Alright, time for the repeat offender. This week. Something new from an underrated band out of the Bay Area Bad World. Three tracks Maker of Rules, Last of Me, and a cover of Only Living Witnesses, Ninove. That's it. No filler, no fucking around. Badworld hits that crossover sweet spot. Fast, heavy and nasty, but still punk enough that it doesn't just turn into a pile of riffs.
SPEAKER_00I was gonna pick just one song, but forget about it. It's three tracks. Play the whole fucking thing. Deal with it. So what am I actually saying here? Because at this point, I've complained about ticket prices, merch cuts, festival bullshit, algorithms, pedestrians, big rooms, little rooms, and probably six other things. And all of that can start sounding like one giant complaint.
SPEAKER_00Is hardcore actually losing something? Or are we just watching it change? I think the answer is both. A lot of the changes I've been talking about are good. I'm not interested in pretending inconvenience was some sacred fucking virtue. But something can get better and still lose something. Hardcore can get safer and lose some unpredictability, more inclusive and more self-conscious, more accessible and less local, more successful and more attractive to people who see revenue before culture.
SPEAKER_00That contradiction is the whole episode. Hardcore has become better at being a community and worse at feeling like an underground. So what do I actually want to survive? I don't want to preserve dysfunction just because it used to be ours. What I want to preserve is the possibility that something can still happen that nobody planned. That a room can still have its own personality, that a local scene can still feel local, that a weird band can still come out of nowhere and completely change the night, that people can still participate instead of just observe.
SPEAKER_00That it still has enough rough edges to surprise you, enough friction to force people into actual contact. Enough weirdness to resist becoming completely standardized. Enough room for the night to become more than whatever was advertised on the flyer. That's what I mean when I say I don't want it cleaned up too much. The electricity.
SPEAKER_00Maybe that sounds romantic as fuck. Fine. I'm talking about hardcore. I'm allowed one fucking romantic thought. So I don't think the answer is drag hardcore backward. I don't think the answer is purity. I don't think it's telling younger people they're doing it wrong. And money, growth, organization, success, none of that is automatically corrupting. The question is what survives them? What survives when everything is easier to document, measure, promote, monetize?
SPEAKER_00What survives when the room gets bigger, the money gets better, the culture gets more visible? That's what I care about. And younger people are gonna make this into something that doesn't look exactly like what I inherited. They should. The question is what gets lost along the way, and whether anybody notices before it's gone. And maybe the real responsibility is making sure there's still room for the version nobody has figured out how to package yet.
Send us Fan Mail Episode 16 Open This Pit Up… or Don’t When does hardcore stop feeling dangerous and start feeling like somebody trying way too hard to look dangerous? This one gets into fake toughness, real intensity,...
Send us Fan Mail After a two-week break, Two Mics, No Masters is back with six releases from the first half of 2026 that refused to leave the rotation. This isn’t a ranking, a midyear awards show, or an attempt to tell...
Send us Fan Mail Some bands become legends. Others quietly change the course of hardcore and never get the credit they deserve. In Volume II of The Unsung Architects, Patrick explores five bands that challenged...
Send us Fan Mail The Unsung Architects - Volume I: Six Bands That Deserve Another Conversation Some bands become legends. Others quietly change the course of heavy music without ever getting the recognition they...
Send us Fan Mail Patrick and Andy sit down with Sam from Massachusetts grindcore band Entropy and his son Isaac, who plays bass and drums in the current Massachusetts heavy scene, including SoundOutTheBraille. Patrick,...