In part 2 we examine the greater conspiracy surrounding the Vanishing of Melanie Flynn. Lexington Police Officer Bill Canan, who claimed to be using Melanie as a confidential informant for his undercover work in the drug scene is fired from his job for a multitude of reasons related to insubordination. Canan denies any involvement in Melanie’s disappearance or in any illegal activities. However, his partner, Drew Thornton, dies while flying a plane carrying two hundred pounds of cocaine into the United States from Columbia. In the early 1990’s, former reporter Sally Denton releases a book entitled “The Bluegrass Conspiracy.” The book goes on to expose a massive drug and arm trafficking operation being carried out between South America and the US with local police as well as several federal agents working hand-in-hand with Pablo Escobar’s Medellin cartel. In addition to trafficking, there are cases of witness intimidation, theft, assault and even murder. Canan is eventually arrested, charged and convicted of cocaine trafficking. During his trial, several witnesses claim he was directly responsible for Melanie’s disappearance and murder. FollowTEPod.com Follow Trace Evidence on Social Media Twitter --- Instagram --- TikTok --- YouTube --- Like Facebook Page --- Join Facebook Group --- Threads --- Like MeWe Page --- Join MeWe Group --- Bluesky Suppport Trace Evidence Patreon --- Paypal --- Cash App --- Buy Me A Coffee Trace Evidence Merch Shops TeePublic --- ShopTEPod --- Spreadshop All Other Links Official Trace Evidence Website --- LinkTree Music Courtesy of: "Lost Time" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ "Chasing Time" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ "Galactic Rap" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ #truecrimepodcast #unsolvedmysteries #coldcase #coldcaseinvestigation #murder #murdermystery #missingperson #missingpersons #truecrimecommunity #mysterypodcast #truecrime #coldcasefiles #truecrimestories #crimelovers #truecrimeaddict #truecrimejunkie #crimescene #justiceforall #missing #crimesquad #podcastcommunity #sleuthsunite #darkhistories #criminalmindset #detective #detectivediaries #forensics #forensicfiles #crimestories #crimepodcast #traceevidence #traceevidencepodcast #criminalinvestigation #justiceforvictims #detectivework #truecrimediscussion #podcastfamily #listenandsolve #crimefans #listentotraceevidence #uncoverthetruth #podcastrecommendations #podcastlove #podcastlife #truecrimeobsessed #followtheclues #cluefinders #podcastaddict #unsolvedmurders #unsolveddisappearances #detectiveatheart #jointheinvestigation #disappearance #vanishing #abduction #gonemissing #upandvanished #pacheco #stevenpacheco #podcasting #crimetalk #crimeanalysis #theories #melanieflynn #bobbyflynn #dougflynn #billcanan #henryvance #drewthornton #cocainebear #cocaine #trafficking #escobar #medellin #lexington #kentucky #kentuckyunsolved Sources Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/trace-evidence--3207798/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Wednesday, September eleventh, nineteen eighty five, a twin engine Cessna four H four Titan takes off from Columbia loaded with approximately two hundred pounds of cocaine. The drugs are supplied by Pablo Escobar's Metaean cartel and are meant for delivery through a corridor which stretches up from the Gulf into Louisiana and further north through where the Central and Eastern States meet. The pilot, Drew Thornton, was unaware that the FBI had been on to his drug smuggling for a while,
Speaker 1and this entire flight was being tracked. This didn't stop him from getting hinky, however, and as his plane sailed over Georgia, he suddenly realized that the FEDS were on his tail, and having previously been popped for flying nearly half a ton of marijuana into the country, he wasn't looking to get caught up again. In a last ditch effort to save the product and himself, he began dumping duffel bags full of coke out of the plane, with them soaring down into the Chattahoochee National Forest with the
Speaker 1autopilot engaged, Thornton had all the time he needed to dump the cargo in an area where it could later be retrieved. In desperation, he pulled on a parachute and strapped some cocaine to his own body before diving out himself, leaving the plane to continue onward without a pilot until it eventually crashed approximately sixty miles away in western North Carolina. No one can say for sure what was going through Thornton's mind, because within moments of dropping out of the plane,
Speaker 1he discovered that his parachute wasn't functioning properly, and he continued onward, plummeting thousands of feet until he slammed down on a random driveway in Nashville, Tennessee. When police arrived at the scene, they found a real mess. Thornton was mostly unready recognizable. On what remained of his body, police found a bulletproof vest, a pair of high dollar Gucci shoes, two loaded guns, several knives, night vision goggles, several thousand
Speaker 1dollars in cash, and thirty five kilos of cocaine in duffel bag strapped to his body, which comes out to about seventy seven pounds. His legs were wrapped up in the remnants of his chute, but the investigation never determined why it had failed. While Drew Thornton's days of running drugs were over, there was still one victim left to be claimed. Miles away, all the way back at the Chattahoochee National Forest, a one hundred and seventy five pound
Speaker 1female black bear came upon some of Thornton's dumped product and immediately indulged. The bear ripped open multiple containers and began ingesting enough cocaine too well to kill a bear, And that's exactly what happened. Three months later, on Monday, December twenty third, Georgia Bureau of Investigation agents came upon the decomposing remnants of a black bear with its stomach stuffed full of cocaine. Not far from the animal, they found forty containers which had held seventy five pounds of coke,
Speaker 1completely torn open. You might know this story through a highly fictionalized account in the movie Cocaine Bear, but that's not the point of this story. The point is Drew Thornton, the former Lexington Police officer who was both before and after his official service, a longtime partner of key figure in the disappearance of Melanie Flynn former Officer Bill Canan. This is Trace Evidence, Episode two fifty six, The Vanishing
Speaker 1of Melanie Flynn, Part two. Welcome to Trace Evidence. I'm your host, Stephen Pacheco. Today we jump right back into the action, picking up where we left off in episode one, in hot pursuit of a multitude of corrupt and criminal figures involved in what has been called the Bluegrass Conspiracy. It's through the exposing of this conspiracy that Melanie Flynn's
Speaker 1case comes into sharp focused, and it's theorized that she may have been one of their earliest and least recognized victims. This is The Vanishing of Melanie Flynn, Part two. On Saturday, January sixteenth, nineteen eighty two, Florida Prosecutor Eugene Berry stood from his couch and walked to the front door of his Port Charlotte home in response to the doorbell. Upon
Speaker 1opening the door, Barry stood face to face with an unknown female dressed in a blue jogging suit. Berry asked the woman what she needed, and without answering, she produced a thirty revolver and fired three shots from point blank range, hitting Berry with all of them. The shooter took off running as forty six year old Berry collapsed, later succumbing to his injuries. The shooter would be identified as Bonnie Kelly, the wife of Mike Kelly, who Berry had recently prosecuted for his involvement in drug trafficking. Mike Kelly was sentenced
Speaker 1to forty five years in prison. Barry had made a name for himself as a fearless and fierce prosecutor who pushed forward regardless of the numerous death threats he received each week. This time, though, the threat turned out to be real, and Barry's life was needlessly taken in a split second assassination. According to Berry's widow, Trudy, they never believed the threats would turn into anything real. They'd heard many, and in the weeks leading up to the murder, they'd been informed by the FBI that Barry's photo was being
Speaker 1shopped around in Columbia as they were looking for an assassin willing to take the jail. Bonnie Kelly, the shooter, later admitted that she had performed the execution with the assistance of Henry Vance, a friend of the Kellys and also a powerful man in Kentucky. He had previously been a legislative aid to Governor Julian Carroll, as well as a deputy sheriff in Fayette County. Vance was being surveilled as federal and state authorities believed he had played a role in the murder of Barry. Ultimately, Vance was charged
Speaker 1with supplying and trafficking the revolver, which Kelly used to kill him. During Vance's trial, Bonnie Kelly confirmed she'd received the weapon from Vance, though she took credit for the planning and execution herself. Barry's widow, Trudy, later stated her belief that Vance had been the brains behind the entire operation, but had that been the case, Kelly had chosen not to reveal his full scope of involvement. Vance received a fifteen year sentence for his role in the crime, though
Speaker 1he'd ultimately served less than ten. Bonnie Kelly got a life sentence in Florida, and, in a bitter twist of irony for her, her husband Mike, was later released from prison on a technicality and walked free while she served life. Gee. What a shame. One of the people involved in surveilling Vance was Ralph Ross, a twenty six year veteran of the Kentucky State Police. At the time, he was the chief of the state Police's Organized Crime and Intelligence Unit.
Speaker 1He too, would find himself facing charges when it was alleged that he'd utilized an illegal wire tap to listen in on Vance's phone calls, something for which he did not have a warrant or any illegal authority. The prosecution's chief witness against Ross was Sergeant Terry Barnes, his own partner. Ross argued that it was actually Barnes who had been behind the illegal wire tap, but the prosecution had already chosen a side, and they pushed hard to get a conviction against Ross, in a prosecution that the accused would
Speaker 1later describe as another corrupt act from a representative of the justice system. In order to aid a larger cover up, Ross had been working with a woman named Betty Gee, who fed him a great deal of tips and information not just about Vance, but a wider network of smugglers, killers, and criminals hiding behind a badge. Betty Gee directed Ross to a Jessamine County farm where they found guns previously used in crimes which had been hidden. One of the
Speaker 1weapons was a machine gun, which it was claimed was utilized by both Vance and some of his closer associates. Ghee also told Ross that she could lead him to the burial site of Melanie Flynn, but Ross never had time to do that search before he was arrested. Interestingly, Betty Gee was no ordinary citizen, but in fact the sister of convicted killer Bonnie Kelly, which may be how she came into possession of so much inside information. According
Speaker 1to Ross, this was not a crime syndicate limited to Vance, nor simply to Kentucky or Florida. Ross claimed that in addition to the legislative aid, there were at least three members of the Lexington Metro Police Department involved in the drug trade, as well as crimes peripheral to it. Ross named these men as officers Stephen Oliver, Andrew Thornton and his partner Bill Canan. Ross further alleged that these men had formed a group which they referred to as the Company or sometimes the Preppie Mafia, but regardless of title,
Speaker 1they all fell under the banner of the Bluegrass Conspiracy. For the most part, claims about this grand conspiracy were dismissed not just by local and federal law enforcement, but even by the public and members of the media. A lot of articles were written throughout the eighties combating the claims while attempting to hold up officers like Bill Canan as these hard working policemen who had been unfairly maligned by corrupt cop Ralph Ross. That was still the approach when in nineteen ninety, former television news reporter Sally Denton
Speaker 1broke the story writing a book she simply titled The Bluegrass Conspiracy. In the book, she detailed the acts and crimes of a group of men, most of them former Lexington Police officers, who she described as now being involved in drug smuggling, arms trafficking, intimidation and assault, and, when it was necessary, murder. Among those directly named were Officer Bill Canan, the man who had once been hailed as a reliable and dedicated cop with an impressive record of narcotic busts. As it turns out, many of those busts
Speaker 1may have been less about getting drugs off the street and more about eliminating the competition for him and his friends. Then there was Andrew Thornton, Bill's narcotics partner, who carved his name into history by committing one of the dumbest acts imagine when in nineteen eighty five, he died trying to parachute in a Knoxville, Tennessee, with fifteen million dollars worth of cocaine strapped to his body. Famously, a black bear came upon the site and, after ingesting a large quantity of cocaine, collapsed dead of a massive overdose. This
Speaker 1story would eventually be spun into the movie Cocaine Bear, though highly altered and dramatized and with no mention of Melanie Flynn. Other names in the book included Bradley Bryant, a drug smuggler, and convicted weapons dealer Henry Vance. The legislative aid we previously discussed Harold Brown, a former DEA regional director in Louisville. Brown resigned just nine months before he was set to receive his full federal pension after the DEA informed him that he was under investigation for
Speaker 1suspected involvement in narcotics trafficking. Brown, rather than waiting around to face charges, used a gun to alleviate the world of his presence at his own home in March of nineteen eight. That crime was initially examined as a possible murder given the long list of people who didn't want Brown to see the inside of a courtroom, but police never found any solid proof to put the gun in anyone else's hands but Brown. Then there was Jimmy Lambert, a big time drug supplier utilized by Kentucky's high society
Speaker 1to provide favors for their luxurious parties. Lambert, as it turned out, was a close friend of the former governor John Brown Junior, leading many to wonder just how high up the ladder all of the trafficking and corruption truly went. For the book, Denton was given information from several different people, but her primary source was former state investigator Ralph Ross. Ross's career had ended unceremoniously following his conviction for the illegal wiretap back in nineteen eighty two, for which he
Speaker 1was given a five year suspended sentence. He continues to maintain his innocence. In the book, Denton and Rassus claimed that this group of men played major roles in the international narcotics trade and along the way, corrupted top officials of the Kentucky state government, as well as federal and state law enforcement officers. The group had access to military installations, traffic sophisticated arms to Central America as well as Libya, and had shadowy connections to the CIA and DEA. This
Speaker 1group allegedly took part in training a private army on the same Jessamine County farm where Vance had hidden his firearms. In addition to all of that, they were also alleged to have committed multiple murders targeting the competition associates that they worked with and their own drug couriers, in addition to two women, Rebecca Moore and Melanie Flynn. Denton and Ross did not spare former Governor Brown, however, claiming that he had to have been involved in the conspiracy. At most,
Speaker 1They argued he was an active participant in both the crimes and the cover up a bare minimum. They believed he was involved in protecting some of the conspirators and using his power and authority to interfere with law enforcement officers trying to break the case, such as former Chief Ralph Ross himself. To them, it appeared clear Brown had major aspirations of becoming president, and that can oftentimes attract darker entities who were willing to provide the backing needed in exchange for cover. Following the release of the book.
Speaker 1There were a lot of articles written about the claims, but for the most part, the so called cover up continued. Journalists reviewed the book as a poor attempt at stirring up controversy, accusing Denton of doing her best to lodge false claims against prominent figures of the community in an attempt to sell more copies. All of that, however, would change just a few years later in April of nineteen ninety three, when former Lexington super cop Bill Canan was arrested by federal agents and charged with possession of cocaine
Speaker 1and intimidating a witness in effect federal trial, following an investigation which had spanned nearly two years, almost to the day of Denton's book release. Although locals weren't taking it too seriously, federal investigators had. On Friday, April ninth, Canan was taken into custody and held without bail pending a detention hearing scheduled for the next week. The affidavit leading to his arrest had been written by FBI agent William Walsh,
Speaker 1claiming that in January of nineteen ninety one, he debriefed a cooperating witness who claimed to have provided Canan with twenty four ounces of cocaine at a Lexington area holiday inn sometime between December of eighty nine and January of ninety. Wells stated that a second cooperator claimed he had received cocaine from Canan around that same time in that same parking lot. The second person, later identified as Robert V. Scott, was arrested for possession and at the time alleged he'd
Speaker 1received the drugs from Canan, and after working on the details, he made a deal with the FEDS. Scott told the FBI that Canan had threatened him, saying he'd kill him and his family if he dared to cooperate with investigators or testify against him. David Cole, FBI Special Agent in charge, said the charges against Canan would be presented to a federal grand jury. The arrest came, he acknowledged, after a joint operation consisting of the FBI, the US Attorney for
Speaker 1the Eastern District of Kentucky, and Canan's former employer, the Lexington Police Department. Canan had worked for the Metro Police for eight years before being publicly fired in nineteen seventy nine. Though he fought tooth and nail to get his job back, taking it all the way to the Kentucky Supreme Court. They ultimately upheld his dismissal. According to Lexington Police Chief Larry Walsh, it was a step in the right direction and to clean up the mess of the past, telling
Speaker 1the Courier Journal quote, this case started some time ago. It's been a considerable concern to me and others. This is something we've been needing around here for a long time. Then, forty six years old, Canan was arrested in the parking lot of his apartment complex. At the time of his arrest, he had two loaded handguns on him, which the FEDS took into their possession. Inside of his apartment was a strange scene for investigators, who described it as filled with weapons,
Speaker 1bizarre pictures, and eerie warnings. One item which stood out was a large poster board on which Canan had written Canan's Alley. The board contained photos of multiple local officials and police officers. There was a bullseye drawn on the pictures of former Commonwealth's Attorney Larry Roberts, as well as a bullet hole scribbled on his forehead. Interestingly, in the early nineteen eighties, Larry Roberts told a report with The Herald Leader that Melanie Flynn had been murdered and that
Speaker 1he knew who was responsible for the crime, but that there was insufficient evidence to file charges. Perhaps some speculated this is what had earned his way onto Canan's so called hit list. There were two other photos with Bull's eyes on them, those being Lexington police officers Frank Freeman and the man who had headed up the investigation into Melanie's case, Detective John Bisick. Others targeted on the Canan's alley included former mayor James Amatto and Fayette County Clerk
Speaker 1Donald Blevins. There was also a photo copy of Robert Scott's inmate profile, an internal document that Canan shouldn't have had access to. That copy was traced to a computer at the Federal Medical Center near Lexington. The FBI later learned that the paper was printed out at one twenty seven am on Monday, March fifteenth, nineteen ninety three. Canan's brother Ke was one of only two people who had access to the computer terminal at that time. Agent Welsh
Speaker 1noted that they launched a new investigation after searching the apartment. When they found multiple notes which suggested that Canan was currently under contract to kill someone's wife and make it look like an accident. They also recovered a bag of cocaine, a police badge, two hundred dollars in cash, and hundreds of cassette tapes. In addition to a large arsenal of weapons, investigators also found books on how to convert semi automatic weapons to full auto, how to make homemade silencers, how
Speaker 1to create and use explosives, as well as one on how to transform a shotgun into a grenade launcher. Whether or not Canan had been planning something major, or if his posters and weapons were some personal fantasy, no one could say with any certainty. However, the more investigators looked into Canan and the more one name kept resurfacing. Melanie Flynn. George Umstead, a former Lexington police officer who was serving
Speaker 1thirty six months on a federal drug conviction, testified that Andrew Thornton, the cocaine bear skydiver and former partner of Bill Canan, told him in eighty four that Canan had murdered Melanie because he loved her. According to Umstad, six years later, following the publication of Denton's The Bluegrass Conspiracy. He directly asked Canan who killed Melanie. Umstead said that Canan just smiled in response. Pushing more, Umstead asked Canan
Speaker 1if he had killed her, and quote, he just kind of shook his head and nodded as if he were saying yes. During that same conversation, though Canan described the book as being filled with quote all fabricated lies, former officer Umstead ed was not the only person to mention Canan in connection with Melanie. Bonnie Kelly, serving her life sentence for the murder of Eugene Berry, told FBI agent James Huggins that she once overheard a conversation between Canan
Speaker 1and Thornton about Melanie. According to Kelly, the two men were discussing her disappearance and noted that they weren't too concerned about the investigation because quote, they will never find her. Umsted also claimed to have been threatened by Canan, allegedly through a third party who delivered a message from the former cop saying simply, quote, people have a way of disappearing. Robert Scott, the other man threatened, told FEDS that Canan broke into his home one night while his wife and
Speaker 1children were asleep in the next room. Canan allegedly told Scott quote, I'm not scared of dying, and I'm not scared of you or George Umstead. Both Scott and Msted later testified that Canan had previously sold them cocaine. On Tuesday, April thirteenth, six witnesses testified against Canan, painting what the media at the time called a chilling portrait of a former cop with a chip on his shoulder and a desire for revenge. A former colleague testified that Canan admitted
Speaker 1to killing Melanie. George Umsted testified that he bought coke from Canan for a Kentucky derby party in nineteen eighty four. FBI agent Welsh testified that twenty to twenty five weapons were found in Canan's apartment, including a variety of loaded guns and rifles, several small spiked throwing stars, a blow gun with steel tipped darts, and stiletto knives. Ralph Ross, who had investigated Canan along with the others before he was fired for a crime he claims was a setup,
Speaker 1told The Courier Journal that, based on his investigation, Canan and his partner Thornton were likely involved in the murder of Melanie Flynn, but that the local police were too afraid of both men and chose not to target them in the investigation. Canan was dangerous and he had powerful connections, including to several federal investigators with whom he had worked under cover previously. Ross stated that there were three people he was in hot pursuit of when he was arrested, and those men were Bill Canan, Drew Thornton, and former
Speaker 1legislative aide Henry Vance. According to Ross, while the local police were afraid to move against the men, he frequently received calls while working for the State Police where Lexington detectives would ask him to investigate the men to help them avoid blowback for doing so. On Wednesday, April twenty first, a judge denied bail for Bill Canan following a thirteen count indictment on weapon and drug charges. US Magistrate Judge James Cook ruled that based on the evidence, Canan was
Speaker 1a danger to the community with enough connections and heavy charges to likely jump bail, and therefore he would remain in jail until the trial place. Seven of the thirteen counts alleged that Canan possessed or distributed upwards of thirteen pounds of cocaine between nineteen eighty eight and nineteen ninety in and around Fayette County. He was also charged with one count of carrying a firearm while committing a drug offense, one count of possessing false identification of a special Agent of the DEA, two counts of threatening and intimidating federal witnesses,
Speaker 1and two counts of possessing unregistered firearms, those being a three eighty caliber semi automatic pistol and a twenty two caliber derringer. Karen Caldwell, US attorney for the Eastern District of Kentucky, stated after the hearing that additional charges might be filed as investigations were continuing. Facing such a hefty set of charges, former officer Kanan knew that where he found guilty, those charges carried a potential maximum sentence of more than one hundred years in prison and seven point
Speaker 1four million dollars in fines. Bill Canan's trial took place in October, six months after he was officially charged and held. In addition to previously mentioned witnesses and statements, came the damning testimony of Susan Griffin, the former Fayette County deputy clerk. According to Griffin, she played the middleman between Canan and her former boyfriend Don Kimbler, a Florida drug runner. Griffin claimed that Kimbler, formerly of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco
Speaker 1and Firearms, used to bring her freezer bags filled with cocaine, which she then passed on to Canan for sale and distribution. Griffin, who had known Canan for twenty years, said that when her boyfriend propositioned her with the cocaine sale idea, it was Canan who immediately came to mind because quote, he was the only person I knew to trust to do anything like that. Reportedly, she approached Canan with the deal in March of nineteen eighty eight, at which time he
Speaker 1agreed and Kimbler assigned him the code name Big Kentucky. Kimbler died from liver cancer in May, just five months before the trial, but prosecutors did manage to get him on video delivering testimony about the case. Kimbler said that after Griffin and he broke up and she left the business, he would deal with Canan directly. Kimbler was fired from the atf in nineteen eighty four, after fifteen years of service for leaking information about a confidential drug informant and
Speaker 1then lying to cover it up. US attorney Mark Wolander stated that testimony from Canan's former associates, combined with phone records, journals from drug runners, and numerous other documents, would show beyond the shadow of the down that Canan was majorly involved in the drug scene. Following a trial which lasted just eight days, Bill Canan was found guilty by a jury on five of the thirteen charges, all of them drug related. His sentencing was scheduled to take place three
Speaker 1months later in January of nineteen ninety four. On Friday the fourteenth, Canan was sentenced to seventeen years and eight months in prison. By order of the court, Canan must have served at least eighty five percent of his sentence, which totals out to a little more than fifteen years. The judge also ordered Canan to be evaluated at a Butler, North Carolina medical Center, where he could continue receiving mental health care. Prosecutor Wolander was disappointed in the sentence, urging
Speaker 1the judge for the maximum as he argued that Canan was the leader of a drug organization, but the judge disagreed, noting that testimony had shown that Canaan was an equal within the syndicate, but not the one in charge. The judge also chose not to issue any fines against Canan, stating that the defendant wouldn't be able to pay for them anyway. For Melanie's family, it was a positive step towards dealing with all of the corruption in the Lexington Police Department, but they also acknowledged it did little to
Speaker 1advance their search for justice for their daughter. Melanie's mother, Ella, who had been present in the courtroom every day of the trial, told the Courier Journal quote, it doesn't answer any questions for my family about our daughter, but I feel like we do have some good people working on it now. And even if we never find out what happened to Melanie, we will find out that there was corruption in local government seventeen years ago, and I think part of it still exists, and I think we'll see some things out now. I've always felt that Melanie was
Speaker 1kidnapped and murdered, and I think certain people in the Metro Police Department had something to do with it. While Bill Canan found himself blasted back into the headlines, perhaps much to his chagrin. With him came the name Melanie Flynn, the missing woman from whom he has been inexorably attached since the very day she vanished and her family came to him for help. Canan had gone out of his way in interviews to distance himself from Melanie, besmirching her character, labeling her as an unrepentant drug addict, in some effort
Speaker 1to diminish the value of her life and the tragedy surrounding her unknown end in perhaps a perfect example of the Streisand effect, even if predating the term by decades, the more Canand talked about Melanie, the more people believed he had a deeper connection to the missing woman and likely knew more than he was saying about her disappearance. In early nineteen ninety one, Larry Walsh became the chief of the Lexington Police Department, and on the list of accomplishments he hoped to achieve was clearing Melanie's case. Walsh
Speaker 1had heard all of the rumors and experienced firsthand some of the corruption which had tainted the department decades earlier. He wanted to bury the odious actions of former officers like Bill Caanan by digging up all of the skeletons. The problem was, even if you're doing your best to avoid it, some of that dirt is going to end up on people referral to the crime who hold seats of power and who believe what's best for the county is not worthwhile if it doesn't also align with what's best for them. Corruption is rarely wiped away with ease,
Speaker 1and the pillars of power can be shaken by even the most narrow of excavations. Chief Walsh noted that testimony in Canan's case, which alleged his involvement in the presumed murder, would surely result in the case taking on a new intensity, although he did not name the person. Walsh also stated that at least one detective at Lexington PD had never given up and had managed to build a massive case file through what Walsh called a world of effort. There was a lot to work with, and yes there were
Speaker 1even some liege which were still worth pursuing. For the Flynn family, this was good news, but they were still bitter about the way things had been handled two decades earlier. For all those years they'd waited for answers that never came, and rather than finding humfort and support in the local media, instead they had found only antagonism and cruel hearted mocking. Melanie's brother, Doug was still guarded, telling a reporter inquiring of their thoughts on Canaan quote, We're not going to say anything for several reasons. We don't want to come
Speaker 1out for the sake of saying something emotionally, just to make a story. Just days after Canan was arrested in April of ninety three, for the first time in more than sixteen years, Ella Flynn publicly discussed the case with Chief Walsh during a live call in radio show when she shocked the host by calling in unprompted. The Jack Patty Show then aired on WVLKAM radio and Chief Walsh was the announced guest. Walsh spoke very positively about Melanie's case, and,
Speaker 1in the opinion of some, perhaps when a little overboard, patting himself on the back about how much work he had put into the case. This ruffled Ellis Feathers and she immediately picked up the phone. Ella came out of the gate hot addressing Walsh's claims that the case had been worked hard for the previous two or three years. She noted, quote, I'm really shocked to hear that this has been stepped up in the investigation. For the last two or three years. No one has ever talked to me. I knew Melanie better than anybody. Chief Walsh replied that
Speaker 1they had interviewed her husband and sons during the initial investigation, but she interjected, saying, quote, my sons and my husband did not know Melanie like I know her, and they'd be the first to tell you that they didn't know her friends like I do. But nobody bothered to ask me. Ellen next stated that she felt investigators had ignored her from the get go, and that rumors suggested that parts of the case file may have been purposefully removed by bad actors, saying, quote, I have given John Bisick and
Speaker 1many of your police officers' names, dates, addresses, and events that nobody seems to care about. I was told that all of the records were stolen several years ago. It puzzles me. If these records were stolen from the police department, why I've never been questioned. Walsh replied that that was the first he had ever heard of stolen files, assuring Ella that the case file was thick and intact as far as he knew. At that point, the show host turned back to Chief Walsh and simply asked, why hasn't
Speaker 1this case been solved after sixteen years? Surely there must be some new information, some nuggative truth that managed to make its way to the surface. For Walsh, it was a fine line to walk, noting the obvious links between his department and multiple corrupt officers and officials, while also claiming that a ton of work had been done and yet not enough work had been done. He explained, quote, I think there's a lot of people who need to answer that question. I'm not going to name any names,
Speaker 1because I've been asked asking that question for fifteen years or more. I'm not the first guy who's known about all this stuff. I think I've paid a bigger price for it than anybody I know. I can tell you right now that there has not been enough action on it. Frustrated with the public nature of the forum and believing they could more easily come to terms and work together to advance the case through more private means, Ella invited Chief Walsh to come to the Flynn family home to discuss the details with her and other family members. Chief
Speaker 1Walsh agreed, and the two met on Monday, April nineteenth. Neither Chief Walsh nor any member of the Flynn family would reveal what exactly they had discussed, but Ella was impressed enough to have changed her tune from the contentious radio show call in to telling the Herald Leaders simply quote, we have a lot of faith in Chief Walsh. Four months later, in August, WKYTTV released a five part series on Melanie's disappearance. Tips called into the station in response
Speaker 1would be routed to reporters, who would then decide whether or not to give them on to the police. This strange caveat came from the direct request of Melanie's mother, who expressed concerns about trusting the police to decide what did or did not have merit. Chief Walsh clearly wasn't too pleased with the arrangement, but declined to make any public comments when asked about it. Though controversial, the series dug deep into the case and interviewed a wide array of people connected to it, both law enforcement and civilian alike.
Speaker 1Several new details were revealed through the show. One episode of the series played a tape recorded all the way back in nineteen seventy nine, two years after Melanie vanished, where reporter Wayne Bowman was interviewing an FBI informant named j. R. Dunham. During the interview, Dunham directly stated that Bill Canan was involved in Melanie's disap appearance, and he laid out several shady connections between Canan and the missing woman. There doesn't
Speaker 1appear to be any evidence that this lead was ever properly followed, nor is it stated if Dunham was ever directly interviewed by law enforcement in regard to Melanie's disappearance or Canan's extracurricular activities. There were also new details about the night of the disappearance, specifically witness statements about possible suspects, which for some reason had never been revealed before. At approximately five pm on Wednesday, January twenty sixth, nineteen seventy seven, a witness claimed to have seen Melanie talking to someone
Speaker 1behind the wheel of a blue van near the intersection of Cooper Drive in Limestone Street, less than five hundred feet from the building she worked in. Another witness, in a shocking statement claimed to have seen Melanie hours after her disappearance at a local restaurant and bar Nellie Kelly's. The witness stated that Melanie was sitting and talking with an unidentified male with a pock marked face and brown hair parted down the middle. This is the first and only report ever revealed where someone claims to have seen
Speaker 1Melanie after she left work. According to FBI agent James Huggins, the Kentucky State Police had been previously notified that Melanie had been seen talking to two men outside of her job the evening of her disappearance, and at least one witness identified those men as Bill Canan and Drew Thornton. For their part, Ella and Bobby Flynn spoke highly of their daughter, and it was clear to everyone involved that despite the passage of nearly two decades, the wound was
Speaker 1still raw. They continued to maintain Melanie's bedroom in their home just the way she had left it. Ella was very upfront about the fact that they were extremely unhappy with how police had handled the investigation, especially in the first months. They had remained quiet for years, avoiding the media altogether due to feeling betrayed and having their pain used against them. They chose to speak out sixteen years later, in what Ella called a culmination of frustration and with
Speaker 1the hope that they could bring new attention to the case. Ella also stated emphatically that she believed her daughter had been murdered and that someone or more than one person working at the Lexington Police Department was involved or at least helped cover it up. She explained, saying, quote, we think information was suppressed. We don't know why. We tried to work within the system all these years, and we were told that if we spoke out, we would hurt the investigation, and I just felt like it was the
Speaker 1time that we told our side of it. I think they were involved in her disappearance and probably in her murder. Ella went hard at Detective Physic, the original investigator assigned to the case. It was Bisic who had been dismissive of the family's concerns, and it was also Bisic who'd returned from Florida claiming Melanie was alive and well in Daytona Beach despite never seeing her. Bisick had also been the one who had claimed that the case was closed at that point, which later had to be reversed by
Speaker 1the Chief of Police asked her thoughts about Bhysic's claims of Melanie's escape to Florida, she merely replied, I thought that was a joke, a sentiment which even at the time most people agreed with. Unfortunately, from this point forward there are few, if any developments in the case. We'll move forward at a more rapid pace as we addressed the few and far between news items which have come out since the early nineties. In June of two thousand
Speaker 1and six, the Lexington Police received a grant in the amount of one hundred and twelve five hundred dollars for the express purpose of investigating cold cases more thoroughly. At the time of that announcement, Melanie's case was heralded as one they hoped to break with that assistance. On Wednesday, Step twe three, two thousand and eight, at the age of sixty three, Bill Canan was released from prison after serving fifteen years, and Revance, the former legislative aid, was released years earlier after a nine year stint. For the
Speaker 1most part, both men kept themselves out of the news afterwards. Vance returned to his family home before moving to Frankfort and addressed media inquiries for stories about Melanie by asking them why he would bother speaking to a journalist. Canan also managed to avoid doing the interview circuit, which I imagine was difficult for someone who seemed to love the limelight so much. Eleven years later, in July of twenty nineteen, some forty two years after Melanie mysteriously vanished, there was
Speaker 1a flurry of police activity which led to a renewed look at the case and the first searches for Melanie's body in many years. Lieutenant Albert Johnson, then head of the Lexington PDS Homicide Unit, expressed his own frustration with the lack of movement on the case. Asked about potential suspects, he wouldn't give any names, but he did tell the Herald Leader quote the people thought to be involved had influence, they were powerful, and there was money. On Friday, July twelfth,
Speaker 1Lexington and Kentucky State Police were at Murphy's Landing in Mercer County, approximately eight miles as the Crow Flies downriver from where Melanie's purse was found back in August of seventy seven. The search was brought on by an unnamed elderly man who went to police five months earlier in February and told investigators that a key figure in the case had told him the whereabouts of Melanie's body. This source allegedly told the elderly man that Melanie had been taken to the area of Murphy's Landing and her remains
Speaker 1had been forced into what he referred to as a septic whole. After doing the best they could to verify the information, the Lexington Police next asked the US Department of Agricultures to supply them with aerial maps so they could begin making plans for when to dig and in how many locations. Though they'd received the maps and reviewed them for reasons which were not explained, they chose not to dig. However. A few months later, in late June, the State Police told Lexington Police that they'd received another
Speaker 1tip from an elderly man which corroborated the earlier tip, though no names were given. The State Police said this tip came from a male who was on his deathbed and wanted to clear his conscience. The State Police, it was announced, had already been digging in that area based off their tip, and were hoping that the Lexington Police would join in with them. Lieutenant Johnson noted that though the purse had been found upstream from the Murphy's Landing area, they had enough information to believe it was possible that
Speaker 1Melanie's remains were located somewhere around there. Johnson didn't want to commit to a major dig operation at the time, but did say they were planning to take some instruments in technology to the area in hopes of pinpointing a more precise location. Johnson did confirm that they had brought police dogs up to that area, though he did not state whether or not they had indicated anything now. While Lieutenant Johnson wouldn't name any specific person as being a suspect, he did confirm that they had recently gone back and
Speaker 1interviewed Billkanan about the search for Melanie's body. According to Johnson, they left that interview quote believing that he did not know the location of her body. It should be noted, though, that Canan was in poor health at the time, so some wondered if Canan truly didn't know the location, or if his health had deteriorated to such a point that his memory was no longer functioning in a way that could provide assistance to the police. Lieutenant Johnson also stated that they had been in touch with Melanie's younger brother, Brad,
Speaker 1who had done some of his own searching for his sister's body. Brad told Johnson that he was glad to know his sister hadn't been forgotten and he was sincerely hopeful that they would find her. In early August, doctor George Cruthers, an anthropologist and the director of the University of Kentucky's william S. Webb Museum of Anthropology, said he had on two occasions taken equipment to Murphy's Landing to help police search for Melanie's remains. According to Cruthers, they
Speaker 1utilized ground penetrating radar to try and narrow down a dig location, telling the Messenger inquirer quote, we were primarily trying to see where the structures stood out there and what else might be buried, like utility lines or a septic system. Cruthers went on to say that they did find something that might be related to a septic system, but that they would need to narrow it down further since so much had changed in the area in the nearly fifty years since Melanie vanished. Lexington Police issued a
Speaker 1request for any photos or maps of the area dating back to the late seventies that might be in the possession of locals and could possibly help with the search. Unfortunately, it seems the search failed to turn up anything helpful and Melanie's body was not recovered. Although the police said they would return to dig more should they develop information that could narrow down the area, it doesn't look like that has ever happened. In their stead. Brad Flynn has searched through the area multiple times, but a series of
Speaker 1dangerous mind shafts, some of which have been covered by large steel seals, has made it difficult for him to truly excavate much of that location. Seven months later, and yet another strange twist of fate, both Henry Vance and Bill Canan died within days of one another and ended up laid out at the very same funeral parlor. Both men dying when they did raised eyebrows in regard to the information about Melanie's location. Was it possible that one
Speaker 1or both of those men had made deathbed confessions about the murder and burial. Likely Canan couldn't have provided much information if police said they didn't believe he knew the location. Therefore, many believed that after all those years, Henry Vance might have wanted to get it off his chest, but no one can say so with any certainty at this time. Ultimately, Canan was buried at Camp Nelson National Cemetery, less than a mile from where Melanie's purse was found. On Thursday,
Speaker 1September twenty second, twenty twenty two, Melanie's father, former Senator Bobby Flynn, passed away at the age of ninety five. Following his time in the Senate from nineteen sixty eight to nineteen seventy two, he went on to serve twelve years with the Urban County Council, and he worked for thirty years selling insurance. Three months later, almost to the day, on Wednesday, December twenty first, Ella Flynn, passed away, also at the age of ninety five. Bobby and Ella had
Speaker 1been married for seventy six years and were truly devoted to one another. Both had sincerely wished to learn the truth of their daughter's fate before they moved on from this world, but their family can only hope that they have found peace in the answers, answers they so desperately sought in the great beyond Melanie D. Flynn was last confirmed to be alive at approximately five pm on Wednesday, January twenty sixth, nineteen seventy seven. At the time, she
Speaker 1got behind the wheel of her red nineteen seventy five Ford Elite, turned right off Cooper Drive onto South Limestone Street and disappeared into the unknown. Melanie is believed to have had no more than twelve dollars cash on her She was supposed to be going to see her psychiatrist, but never arrived for her appointment, nor did she show up at her parents' home where she was supposed to have dinner. Melanie has been described as a white female with strawberry blonde hair and brown eye, standing five feet
Speaker 1tall and weighing approximately one hundred and ten pounds. She may go by other names such as Melanie D or Melanie O'Hara. Her nickname was d D, but that was mostly reserved for family and close friends. Melanie's teeth have some gaps between them, and she still had all of her wisdom teeth. Her right eye tooth was recessive, and she had a nervous habit of rubbing the tips of her fingers rapidly against the tips of her thumbs. Melanie has no sense of taste or smell. She often colored
Speaker 1her hair and wore it in every shade between blonde and black. Both of her ears are pierced. She is believed to have been wearing a yellow jacket, a sweater, blue jeans, and furry hiking boots. She also wore a silver colored Pulsar digital watch and a diamond cluster ring. Melanie suffered from allergies and took prescription annie histamines, which she left behind. She was also seeing a psychiatrist at the time and may have been struggling with drugs and alcohol. She suffered a severe head injury years earlier and may
Speaker 1have experienced memory issues or possibly amnesia. At the time of her disappearance, Melanie was twenty four, and if alive today, she'd be seventy three. This year marks forty nine years since Melanie Flynn mysteriously vanished on a random Wednesday night in January of seventy seven. All semblance of this being a normal missing person's investigation, whatever that is, went out the window when it became clear that the missing woman was tied to several questionable figures, ranging from drug smugglers
Speaker 1and dealers to corrupt cops and murderers. What Melanie knew about their activities and what knowledge she had about the drug operation itself have never been revealed, but many assume her disappearance is directly linked to the crime syndicate described in the Bluegrass Conspiracy. Over the course of the last half century, the Lexington Police Department has worked hard to change not just the culture within their ranks, but also the public perception of their officers and leaders. They've stepped
Speaker 1up and tried to distance themselves from a past filled with corruption and criminals hiding behind badges. Progress is a good thing, but the truth remains that until Melanie Flynn is found and her case properly investigated, the specter of that corruption will continue to hang heavy over the department and Lexington as a whole. Many who were involved, and many who knew and loved Melanie are gone now, but the truth endures, and it is out there somewhere, buried
Speaker 1alongside a young woman who found herself caught between drug runners and corrupt cops, so deeply entangled in the shady enterprise that even the mighty reach of a former governor couldn't pull her out from that darkness. Sunlight, though, remains the best disinfectant, and Melanie Flynn needs to be found or home and laid to rest beside a mother and father who never forgot and never gave up. On the surface,
Speaker 1the vanishing of Melanie Flynn has a lot of hallmarks of what have been referred to as regular or normal missing persons cases. Now we know there isn't really any disappearance that is so called run of the mill, but there are procedures that are generally followed until additional information changes the perspective and gives you an area to focus on. In this case, you're looking for a young woman who is known to come and go as she pleases, does a bit of couch surfing here and there depending on her mood and activities, and whose own parents acknowledge it
Speaker 1wasn't uncommon for her to disappear for a few days. These details, combined with the attitude we've seen amongst many police officers in the seventies and eighties when it comes to a missing person, can create some chaos. They approach the case calmly and casually, with more of an idea that surely nothing criminal has happened and everything's gonna work out. They perform the bare minimum talk with a few people, ask a few questions, get a broad overview, and then just kind of shrug with a well, I'm sure everything
Speaker 1will be fine attitude. She's an adult, she can go and do whatever she wants. We don't have any evidence of a crime here. That's pretty much what happened, and frankly, I find it really surprising given the nature of this case. You've got a former state senator, popular and well liked, and his only daughter goes missing. Today. That would be coast to coast headlines. There'd be dedicated hours on all the cable news networks. There'd be live streamers going to town breaking down every detail on YouTube and all the
Speaker 1other sites. I mean, just look at the Nancy Guthrie case and all of the attention that's grabbed and continues to hold on to. Instead, we pretty much see indications that something's wrong with the investigation from the start. Anyone who knows anything about missing persons is aware that the first few days are the most important. That's when everything's still fresh, people's memories aren't fading or flawed, and you've got the best opportunity to track down some leads. Bobby Flynn reached out to Officer Canan, someone he knew and trusted,
Speaker 1someone who had been around the home, spent time with his son, and was in a relationship with his daughter. Canan reacts with such a nonchalant attitude and cold disconnection that Bobby's actually taken aback. He turns to the department and files a missing persons report, and they don't seem to take it seriously. The department sends a few patrol men out to conduct half assed interviews. They don't assign detectives or bring the family in for a deeper discussion. They don't even put out any bulletins in the local papers.
Speaker 1That all comes later. The media themselves show a lack of interest as well, writing just a few short sentences and leaving out all of the pertinent details, you know, silly things like a physical description of the missing person and the vehicle that she drives. It's not until ten days later, when her car is randomly found, that detectives are finally assigned, and outside of canvassing the area around that complex, they really don't do a whole hell of a lot. Their biggest lead comes with the tips from Florida,
Speaker 1which when placed under the microscope, falls severely short of what anyone would consider solid evidence. Half the witnesses that they hang their hat on directly acknowledged that they can't even be sure that Melanie's the person they actually saw, and yet that was enough for Detective Bhisic to report that she's in Florida. We know it for sure, she's alive and well. Case closed. Chief Freeman would later argue that Busic didn't literally mean closed when he said closed, but we can all see what was happening there. Freeman
Speaker 1himself didn't find it necessary to even get yet involved until after Melanie's purse was found, because now he had to get involved. If that purse had never been found, you probably wouldn't know the name of Melanie Flynn because this would be a case that was closed in nineteen seventy seven. And I don't care what kind of semantic games they want to play about closed versus cleared versus pending that discovery of her purse occurs less than forty eight hours after Canan does his character assassination interview, during which he does his very best to bury Melanie for
Speaker 1likely the second time. Although figuratively in this instance, by describing her as some out of control drug addict, liar, manipulative person whose borderline insane and disappears for weeks all the time. The reporter chooses not to push back, probably because Canan was a real media whore and was always leaking out information to a degree that local papers wrote about this guy in the same style you'd describe an adult romance novel. He was tough and strong, reliable and resilient model of what you'd want a local cop to be,
Speaker 1until it turned out he never had been. As it turned out, Canan wasn't ever a good cop. He was partnered up with criminal officers from the beginning, including his partner Drew Thornton. As it would eventually be revealed, Canan was but one of many local police officers operating out of Lexington who was more interested in stuffing his own pockets rather than enforcing the law. You've got local cops, FBI, DEA, ATF and more all working together to transport drugs from South America into the United States in part to fund
Speaker 1a revolution in Nicaragua, but overall it was more about acquiring power, money, and influence. They grew greedy, and when they learned they can make a lot more money using their badges as bulldozers, they can't help but start taking control of the streets, arresting or murdering the competition and flooding the area with their own drugs. They even go far enough to set up frame and tear down good cops who might dare to look into them. Half of these guys worked narcotics for the Lexington Police, so they
Speaker 1all knew the players involved had unsupervised access to street level dealers and carried out a reign of terror which allowed them to strong arm people into their employ and should anyone get in the way, it wasn't a problem to put them in the ground. Is that what happened to Melanie? Given her personality issues with memory and poor impulse control, Melanie Flynn wouldn't exactly be an ideal candidate to bring on for heavy involvement in a multinational drug smuggling operation. Where her value came in was in her connections,
Speaker 1and that's what Bill Canan was really drawn to. All of his stories about working with Melanie as an undercover detective, where she'd bring him to parties, introduce him under a false name and get him hooked into the scene. Sure sounds like the legitimate efforts of a dedicated cop. You got to keep in mind his original target was Melanie's older brother, Doug, famous baseball player, talented guy, probably goes to a lot of parties. Perhaps he thought he could use Doug to get into the scene that way, But when Doug goes to Cincinnati and joins the Reds, he
Speaker 1turns his attention to Melanie, who still has all of those connections. The problem is, all of those efforts that would be made by a dedicated cop are also the same activities that would be made of someone heavily involved in the drug trade who's looking to make the right connections to keep the product flowing. Was Canan using Melanie to bust dealers and users or was he using her to develop those same people into his own little network. I mean, if he weren't above using a marijuana possession charge to manipulate Melanie into working for him, what might
Speaker 1he be willing to do to a cocaine dealer with a lot of customers who wants a higher percentage of the cut. Today it doesn't sound all that surprising, but back in nineteen seventy seven, this was still somewhat of a new approach. So you've got all these corrupt and Feds and hundreds of pounds of cocaine flying in on a monthly, if not a weekly basis. You've got drugs being air dropped out of planes all up the middle of the country, through Louisiana, Mississippi, Arkansas, Tennessee, Kentucky and beyond.
Speaker 1There's been quite a few movies made about this operation and just how large and extensive it was. From Tom Cruise, who portrayed Barry Seal, an American maid, to Johnny Depp, who played George Young in the film Blow, and a million others in between. It's always the same story. Pilots and or people with access to private planes travel down to South America where they hook up with Pablo Escobar and others. They load up their planes in the United States with firearms and cash, take them down into South
Speaker 1America and unload the arms and money, replacing them with duffel bags filled to the brim with some of the strongest and purest cocaine developed to that time, and then they fly it right back here. They would examine maps of the states and like the most isolated areas to utilize as drop zones. They'd load up the planes, which then fly low and slow to avoid being detected by radar and to keep themselves out of commercial air space where they could be spotted or possibly cause an accident. Once the plane gets into the right area, other people
Speaker 1on the ground would activate radios and handheld transceivers to alert the pilot that yes, you're in the right area to start the cargo drop. While the pilot guides the plane according to the directions from someone on the ground, someone else begins to drop and everything is coordinated down to within inches. These guys didn't screw around, and they didn't play games. If someone stumbled upon the operation or started asking questions, they were eliminated. Look at Norman Ladner as well as Don Henry and Kevin Ives. There's a
Speaker 1great deal of evidence and speculation to suggest that their deaths were specifically related to these drug drop operations. Hell Henry and Ives were to the airport in Mina, Arkansas, which was a major outlet for these acts. Barry Seal was a commercial airline pilot before he got involved. He was running guns south and drugs north, all while operating alongside a CIA handler who later burned him and left him to be murdered by contract killers working for the cartels.
Speaker 1Now some people will look at Barry Seal and dismiss his story. He was just some looney guy with a wild tail drug runner, and I'd be inclined to agree if there wasn't so much evidence to the contrary. Hell, in twenty twenty, the FBI released a memo which confirmed that Barry Seal had been using the Mina Airport to smuggle in drugs from nineteen eighty through nineteen eighty four, two years before he was killed. Suffice it to say, if you dig in deep enough, you'll find that Barry
Speaker 1Seal wasn't an outlier or a rare instance. He was one of dozens, if not hundreds, of people who were being utilized for the same operation. It was done with intelligence and planning. Everything waspartmentalized to the point that most of these pilots thought they were the only ones involved, not realizing that they were entirely expendable. And it wasn't just this operation. You can look into others. For instance, Air America Drew Thornton was one of them. Canan's former partner.
Speaker 1This guy had been flying drugs in from South America for years and he was making major cash. He started out in the military as a paratrooper, moved on to the Lexington Police and eventually opened his own law firm through which he continued to operate his illegal enterprise. Bill Canan wasn't the brains behind the operation. Frankly, I don't think he was the brains behind much, nor was he the driving force. It started before him and continued well after his dismissal from the police force, which devalued him to the drug traffickers in his group. This may be
Speaker 1why he was forced to pivot, working with Don Kimbler through his surrogate Susan Griffin, to run bags of cocaine brought up from Florida. The operation ties into a lot of different areas and certainly leads towards what has been referred to as the Octopus. For a quick summary for those of you who aren't familiar with it, The octopus, as it's been called, was a term developed by journalist Danny Cassilero, which suggested that there was a secretive, interconnected network of intelligence agents, government officials, organized crime figures, and
Speaker 1corrupt law enforcement agents working together in a highly compartmentalized cabal which had its tentacles tied into a bunch of different illegal schemes, from drug running to arms races, to real estate scams, the theft and back dooring of the promised software, and even direct links to the Iran contra affair. No one can say with any certainty just how far and extensive the network was and or likely still is, as most people who ask too many questions either found
Speaker 1themselves thrown in jail for crimes they claim they never committed, or, in most instances, they simply were killed or disappeared. Denny Cassillaro is perhaps one of the most famous names, alleged to have been killed by members of the Octopus when he got too close. Chuck Morgan, previously featured on this show, is thought to have been connected to some of those land scams going on. There are, of course, countless others whose stories have only been partially told, if ever told. Suffice it to say the Octopus is the evil syndicate
Speaker 1operating at the center of your favorite spy thriller slash noir story. Except and more frighteningly, it was real and it's the only one we know about. Surely there were others. By now the names have changed, and with the advent of technology and the Internet, much of it has gone digital. But there's no doubt there are currently people from the United States in intelligence as well as other country secret services, who are still doing tasks like this every day. One day,
Speaker 1I'd really love to dig into the octopus, and if that's something you'd be interested in, please let me know. Netflix released a series about it called American Conspiracy The Octopus Murders, but frankly, it was so poorly executed, which such shallow dives into the information that I'm almost of the belief that the documentary itself is part of the overall cover up. But I digress. Turning our attention back to Lexington, I don't believe it's even remotely controversial to note that Melanie Flynn, consciously or not, was directly connected
Speaker 1to and spending time with multiple people who were later confirmed to have been involved in drug smuggling, intimidation, assault, robbery, and murder. Whether or not she knew how dangerous it all was is another question. Entirely, Generally, people don't realize they've really stepped into a bad place until they try and step out of it, and there's some belief that that is what might have happened here. Melanie's brother, Brad kind of hinted at this when he was doing an interview about his sister. As I noted previously, Melanie was
Speaker 1a very independent person and didn't like being told what to do. Now, whether or not Canan was actually coercing her into working for him as a CI because of a marijuana possession charge, I can't say for sure, although it doesn't sound all that reliable to me, But if he did have some way of controlling her, that would only last for so long. Eventually, as Brad suggested, She's going to say she wants out, and if that declaration were met with threats or attempts to keep her quiet, she might have been willing to say, I'll go to
Speaker 1the police, or perhaps I'm going to tell my father everything. A quick statement like that, made in the heat of the moment would certainly be enough to have signed her death warrant. Even if Canan didn't want to do it, he'd have known that if those above him found out, they wouldn't hesitate to put him in the same shallow grave with her. So for me, I think it's more than likely that Melanie was killed, probably by Canan Thornton or both, due to her involvement in their illegal scheme and perhaps her own plans to get out from under
Speaker 1their thumbs. Maybe by turning state's evidence. You're talking a group of people who didn't think it was aligned too far to murderer or federal prosecutor. They certainly wouldn't have had any second thoughts about sweet little Melanie Flynn. I guess the question you have to ask yourself is just how many people tied into that corruption are still around today, seated in positions of power they earned through their criminal activities, and just how far they're willing to go to keep this story as quiet as it has been for the last few decades. We know the FEDS and Lexington law
Speaker 1enforcement were involved, as well as probably some politicians, as we saw in other states when similar conspiracies were exposed. Are there other possibilities here? Surely Melanie's previous hen injury made her prone to memory issues impossible amnesia, so it's not entirely out of the question that she could have lost her memory or become confused and wandered off, fell into a river, merged into the homeless population, or merely when elsewhere, and started life anew without any knowledge of
Speaker 1her previous role. But it's unlikely. While it took time for her story to break through it into national headlines, it eventually did, and despite notifications sent to police departments all over the country, there was never a confirmed sighting of the twenty four year old. And you're never going to convince me that any of those people in Florida actually saw Melanie herself unless you've got more evidence than some vague statements to me. At least outside of the Melanie being yet another victim of the Bluegrass conspiracy. The
Speaker 1only other possibility that I think holds some merit is the idea that she was killed by someone she had helped canand bust. We know there were a few busts made, certainly not enough to justify carrying out this undercover operation for several years, but apparently enough to keep Canan's bosses off his back, assuming all of them weren't involved too. Some of those I alluded to earlier were likely done more so to eliminate the competition as opposed to enforcing the law and keeping drugs out of the community. It
Speaker 1isn't impossible that one or more of those people that Melanie helped betray may have wanted some revenge. I mean, look at Bonnie Kelly. She murdered a prosecutor for throwing her husband in jail for his role in drug trafficking. It isn't wild speculation to imagine someone may have sought a similar justice against Melanie. At the same time, I tend to be of the belief that Canan was involved somehow. Even if Melanie had been taken by people who wanted revenge, it wouldn't surprise me in the lease for Canan to have manipulated the situation so that he could lead Melanie
Speaker 1right into that ambush. Why get his own hands dirty when he could use other folks to carry out the crime. Surely that's a possibility, but I'm still inclined to believe that Canan was the one who pulled the trigger. He doesn't strike me as the type who would trust someone else to carry out an execution for him. And if indeed he was as close to Melanie as others have claimed, he may have seen it as his own duty to eliminate her at the same time, if everyone was doing enough coke, Melanie could have been killed for simply looking at someone the wrong way. You really never know what's
Speaker 1going to happen when you mix high end cocaine with power hungry people who have access to an arsenal of weapons and who feel that there is no authority to control them besides their own desires. More than likely, Melanie is somewhat not too far from the Kentucky River, perhaps up in clays Ferry, buried in a former septic hole or one of the dozens of caverns and mines there. Maybe she's closer to Camp Nelson, not far from where her purse was found and Canan himself was later laid to rest. Or perhaps she is somewhere no one has
Speaker 1yet thought of, disposed of in a way that couldn't be tracked. These guys had access to planes and ran and drugs frequently. Who's to say Melanie wasn't taken up on a flight and pushed out when they were somewhere over the ocean or the jungles of South America. Truly, it's difficult to say. But if I had to put my hard earned money down on one idea. It would be that whatever happened to Melanie, and wherever she was buried, it's some place that Canan could get to. He seems the type who'd want to keep his victim nearby where
Speaker 1he could visit and relive the twisted thrill he had felt. He'd also be dumb enough to leave evidence in a place where someone else could find it. What really is messed up at the end of all things is that Canan probably wasn't even half as bad as a lot of the other guys he worked with, And we don't even know all of their names, and probably never will, at least not the major ones. Forty nine years ago, twenty four year old Melanie Flynn mysteriously vanished after leaving
Speaker 1her job and heading towards her psychiatrist's office. In the nearly five decades since, a great deal of information has come out which clearly shows that the young woman was smack dab in the middle of a pit of vipers, perhaps completely unaware that her life could be extinguished at a moment's notice. Was she the victim of revenge for someone wanting to punish her for bringing an undercover cop into their midst Did her previous head injury result in some kind of a fugue state from which she never recovered, or was the man she told everyone that she was
Speaker 1completely head over heels for ultimately the hand by which her young life was taken. Unless someone comes forward and tells the whole story, her body is found, or new evidence is brought to light, it appears that the vanishing of Melanie Flynn will remain open, unsolved, and growing cold. If you're looking for more information about the vanishing of
Speaker 1Melanie Flynn are many newspapers and forums discussing her case. For this episode, the Lexington Herald Leader and Courier Journal were the most informative. I would also highly recommend Sally Denton's book The Bluegrass Conspiracy, which you can find on Amazon and wherever you buy your books. It's a fascinating read which gives you a fairly decent overview of what exactly was going on in Lexington, Kentucky in the late seventies through the eighties. Also, I know Robin has covered
Speaker 1this case on The Trail Went Cold, so make sure you give that one a listen. If you have any information about the vanishing of Melanie Flynn, please contact the Lexington Police Department at eight five nine two five eight three six zero zero. Her case is number zero one three one seven seven zero four eight. You can also reach out to the Kentucky Forensic Lab in Frankfurt at
Speaker 1five zero two five six four five two three zero. And finally, you can contact the FBI Field office in Louisville at five zero two two six three six thousand. What do you believe happened? Tweet me at trace f Pod, email me at trace Evidencepod at gmail dot com, comment in the Facebook group, or reach out through any of our social media accounts, all of which can be found
Speaker 1in the show notes and at follow tepod dot com. Now, I'd like to take a moment to shout out and thank our amazing Patreon producers, without whom this show would not be possible. So a very special thank you to Ann m Bertram, Crystal Jay, Denise Dingsdale, Dianni Dyson, Jennifer Winkler, Caar Morland, Christine Greco, Lisa Hopson, Nick Mohar, Sures, Roberta Jansen,
Speaker 1Shauna Stacy Finnegan, Tom Radford, and Whitney Welp. For now, this concludes our look into the Vanishing of Melanie Flynn a truly disturbing and fascinating case which breaks through the glossy veneer of seventies police action and reveals a truly sick and twisted criminal enterprise hiding beneath the badge. I truly hope that eventually we find Melanie so that she can be brought home and laid to rest beside her parents.
Speaker 1Surely there is someone out there who knows enough to make that a reality. As a quick heads up, I just wanted to let you know I'm going to be releasing an update episode in the next few days, and then it's on to our next case. So thank you all again for listening, and I hope you'll join me next time for another unsolved case on the next episode of Trace Evidence.
On the evening of Saturday, March 22nd, 1975, thirty-two year old John Harden arrived at his Claremont, FL home after a work call with his wife and young son. John went upstairs to clean up when, a short time later, he...
In September of 2012, nineteen year old Faith Hedgepeth was brutally murdered in her Chapel Hill apartment by an unknown individual. A thorough examination of the scene and evidence told a disturbing story of the young...
In September of 1982, seven people in the Chicago area died after ingesting over-the-counter Tylenol capsules that had been laced with lethal doses of potassium cyanide before being placed on store shelves. Although...
In October of 2003, twenty year old Brandon Rumbaugh and his girlfriend, nineteen year old Lisa Gurrieri wanted to find a special way to celebrate their one year anniversary. When a trip to Disneyland was too costly,...
Jerry Wolking was worried, but nobody knew why. He was fidgety, pacing and didn't want to talk about what was on his mind. Days later, her mysteriously disappeared after leaving his girlfriend's house. He has never been...