Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Trace Evidence

Trace Evidence artwork

258 - Bumble Bee Murders - Brandon Rumbaugh & Lisa Gurrieri

Sep 19, 20261 hr 34 minAudio

In October of 2003, twenty year old Brandon Rumbaugh and his girlfriend, nineteen year old Lisa Gurrieri wanted to find a special way to celebrate their one year anniversary. When a trip to Disneyland was too costly, they decided to stay close to home. The couple decided to camp out beneath the stars in a small area north of Scottsdale, Arizona called Bumble Bee. Tucked into the Bradshaw mountains and just a few miles off I-17, it was the perfect spot to spend a romantic night. When the couple failed to return, their families grew panicked. After more than thirty hours of silence, Brandon and Lisa were found dead, the victim of a grisly double homicide. According to police, it appeared as though someone walked up on the scene, found the couple sleeping in their sleeping bags, and opened fired with a .25 caliber pistol at close range. The killer, nor their motive, have ever been discovered. However, new breakthroughs in DNA technology are paving a pathway forward and, according to the most recent statements from investigators, they may well be on the trail of identifying the illusive killer..... Last Photos of Brandon and Lisa || The Unknown Photo || Example of a 25 caliber handgun FollowTEPod.com Follow Trace Evidence on Social Media Twitter --- Instagram --- TikTok --- YouTube --- Like Facebook Page --- Join Facebook Group --- Threads --- Like MeWe Page --- Join MeWe Group --- Bluesky Suppport Trace Evidence Patreon --- Paypal --- Cash App --- Buy Me A Coffee Trace Evidence Merch Shops TeePublic --- ShopTEPod --- Spreadshop All Other Links Official Trace Evidence Website --- LinkTree Music Courtesy of: "Lost Time" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ "Echoes of Time" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ "Galactic Rap" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ #truecrimepodcast #unsolvedmysteries #coldcase #coldcaseinvestigation #murder #murdermystery #missingperson #missingpersons #truecrimecommunity #mysterypodcast #truecrime #coldcasefiles #truecrimestories #crimelovers #truecrimeaddict #truecrimejunkie #crimescene #justiceforall #missing #crimesquad #podcastcommunity #sleuthsunite #darkhistories #criminalmindset #detective #detectivediaries #forensics #forensicfiles #crimestories #crimepodcast #traceevidence #traceevidencepodcast #criminalinvestigation #justiceforvictims #detectivework #truecrimediscussion #podcastfamily #listenandsolve #crimefans #listentotraceevidence #uncoverthetruth #podcastrecommendations #podcastlove #podcastlife #truecrimeobsessed #followtheclues #cluefinders #podcastaddict #unsolvedmurders #unsolveddisappearances #detectiveatheart #jointheinvestigation #disappearance #vanishing #abduction #gonemissing #upandvanished #pacheco #stevenpacheco #podcasting #crimetalk #crimeanalysis #theories #gurrieri #rumbaugh #lisagurrieri #brandonrumbaugh #bumblebee #arizona #scottsdale #doublemurder #zodiac #yavapai #yavapaicounty Sources Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/trace-evidence--3207798/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerreri were excited to celebrate their first anniversary together. From the moment they'd met, friends had described them as nearly inseparable. Their relationship had developed quickly, and within a year, they were already discussing the possibility of marriage. In fact, Lisa's mother had heard the term engaged thrown about a time or two, but she hadn't seen a ring yet. Originally hoping to spend their anniversary together in the happiest place on earth, California's Disneyland, they

Speaker 1were forced to change plans when the cost for tickets, travel, and lodging turned out to be way beyond their budget. So the couple pivoted to a less expensive and more romantic idea. They would mark the occasion by revisiting the site of their first date, a remote campsite in Arizona's Sonoran Desert. After borrowing a truck from Lisa's mother, the couple headed off with sleeping bags in tow to spend the night laying together in the bed of the truck beneath the stars. However, when they failed to return home

Speaker 1the next morning, friends and family grew worried. After searching for two days, friends found the truck parked just off the Bumblebee exit in a dirt lot not far from Sunset Point. Everything appeared normal, until the friends approached and made a grisly discovery. Brandon and Lisa were lying in the bed of the truck, still tucked into their sleeping bags, but there was no movement, no sound. A closer inspection would find that the couple were dead, each having been

Speaker 1the victim of multiple gunshot wounds apparently fired while they had slept. Nearly a thousand campers had been in the area that night, but not one of them had seen or heard This is Trace Evidence, Episode 258, The Bumblebee Murders of Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerrero. Welcome to Trace Evidence.

Speaker 1I'm your host, Steven Pacheco. In today's episode, we turn our attention towards Arizona and the 2003 unsolved double homicide of Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerreri, a case that seems to teeter on a knife's edge, on the verge of either being solved or growing even colder. Perhaps we can help give justice a little nudge today. This is episode 258, The Bumblebee Murders of Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerreri. Brandon

Speaker 1Keith Rumbaugh was born on Saturday, May 7, 1983, in Phoenix, Arizona, to parents Robert and Desiree. Brandon was the couple's first and only son, and his birth was followed a few years later by a sister, Jessica, rounding out their family. For the most part, the Rumbaugh's would live in and around Scottsdale, which has described itself as a vibrant resort city located in the gorgeous Sonoran Desert. Brandon has been described by friends and family as a fun-loving, active, and

Speaker 1talented young man who enjoyed being out beneath the sun, exploring, and playing. In his obituary, it was noted that Brandon would always be remembered for his infectious humor, spontaneous goofiness, and the joy that he brought to everyone in his life. Whether family or friend, or even a complete stranger, Brandon had a way about him that made him exude a warmth that others described as inviting and disarming. One term which came up a lot when discussing Brandon was optimism,

Speaker 1with many saying the young man was an eternal optimist, always focused on the bright side of things and forever seeing the world as a glass half full. Regardless of what challenges or difficulties might lie before him, Brandon came at his goals head on, and when he met a new barrier, he developed a different method by which to continue on in his pursuits. From a young age, Brandon had shown both an interest and an innate talent when it came to music and dance. He loved to hit the dance floor and, when young, often partnered up with

Speaker 1his mother, who did her best to support his abilities and encourage a further exploration of them. His mother, Desiree, later explained, quote, He's my favorite dance partner.

Speaker 2In the whole world.

Speaker 1Brandon went on to attend Scottsdale's Coronado High School, where he was a dancer in multiple school productions, often the only male involved. He ran the gamut from classical to Latin and swing dancing, at which he excelled. He also honed his ability at playing music, taking on the drums, trumpet, trombone, and saxophone. His talents were not just limited to music, though, with Brandon also showing exceptional artistic ability, specifically with the mediums of sculpting and painting. He was an all-around talent,

Speaker 1able to move others with his body or his creations. There was no denying that there was certainly a bright future ahead there. Brandon graduated from Coronado High in the spring of 2001, just a few months after his 18th birthday. Focused on the future with a sharp determination, Brandon, who had always viewed himself as an ardent patriot, turned his attention towards the military, specifically the Marine Corps, In July of 2001, he officially enlisted in the Marine Corps Reserves,

Speaker 1but he wouldn't last that long, as he would ultimately receive an honorable discharge due to knee problems, which derailed a potential military future. Though disappointed by that turn of events, Brandon wasn't one to give up, and so he decided to turn a negative into a positive. Since his body had cost him that pursuit, he set.

Speaker 2His mind to strengthening it.

Speaker 1He started reading fitness books and magazines, learning about workout routines and different ways to shore up his frame. This would lead to a new pursuit, one which would lead him down a path towards the gym. Enrolling at Arizona State University, Brandon again got himself involved in music and dance interests, but his academic calendar was filled up with a regimen focused on physical fitness. On top of hitting the gym and learning how to develop his body, the teen also began looking into martial arts classes. Brandon was

Speaker 1a believer that when you committed to something, you should give everything you had, and so if working in the gym was going to help him, certainly the stringent training offered through combat sports would be a perfect complement. Though developing himself into a broader, thicker, and stronger man, which was difficult to miss when seeing him in person, this did nothing to alter his personality, which remained that of a fun, loving, kind, and caring young man with a big heart. He was the kind of guy who would do anything to help a person in need, and he

Speaker 1wouldn't want anything in return. He just wanted to be the best person he could. Brandon's dedication to his body and physical fitness ultimately led him to be hired on as a personal trainer at Fitness Works, then a gym located on East Brown Road in Mesa, less than 10 miles southeast of Scottsdale. The young trainer made quite an impression. Starting with just a few clients, he quickly became one of the most popular employees at the gym, with both patrons and co-workers alike. Brandon was described as being a

Speaker 1beacon of light there, helping others and always finding a way to smile and laugh no matter the challenge. This was a trait which made him extremely patient with new clients, helping them to feel at ease and capable of achieving their goals. The more Brandon worked at the gym, the more he fell in love with his career, and it wasn't long before he started mentioning bigger plans for his future, namely, opening.

Speaker 2His own gym.

Speaker 1It was a beautiful dream he would no doubt have attained, had his life not been cut short in a brutal and senseless crime. While Brandon had set the course for everything and was putting all of his energy into the grind in pursuit of his dreams, fate decided to intervene, and in the fall of 2002, while out clubbing with some friends, he stumbled upon the woman he would go on to describe as the great love of his life, 18-year-old Lisa Guerreri. Lisa Marie Guerreri was born on Saturday,

Speaker 1July 14th, 1984, to parents John and Paula in what has been described as America's largest suburb, Mesa, Arizona. Lisa was Paula and John's only daughter, and she would go on to have two half-brothers. She was described from a young age as always smiling, laughing, and full of love. Friends and family say that Lisa was the kind of person you just wanted to be around. Whether it was playing and giggling as children or hanging out and chatting as adults, she always brought a level of fun and excitement.

Speaker 1She was an engaging young woman who had a natural ability to read into others. She was empathic and desired to make others feel loved and happy, a personality trait that she'd also find later in Brandon. Lisa also had musical talent, specifically as a singer, where her voice has been described as incredibly beautiful and moving. Raised Christian, Lisa attended Christ the King Catholic Church where she participated in the choir and church band. She also sang in the

Speaker 1school choir and really anywhere she could get her hands on a microphone with people willing to listen, or even if she was alone. She would go on to attend Mesa High School where she excelled academically, performing extremely well and getting involved with multiple groups and organizations. Lisa was described at this time in her life as full of joy and with gigantic dreams.

Speaker 2She was determined to capture.

Speaker 1Although initially she had been on a different trajectory, in 2001, after seeing the Jennifer Lopez movie The Wedding Planner, Lisa decided that was exactly what she wanted to do with her life. Finishing up at Mesa High, she moved on to Mesa Community College where she majored in business management. Around this time, she began working as a secretary at SRT, the Salt River Project, a local non-profit public utility that helps deliver water and electricity to central Arizona in and

Speaker 1around the city of Mesa. Coworkers described Lisa as always positive, supportive, and smiling. In fact, She smiled so much that it actually became a running joke in the office that with such a constant lovely smile, it's a wonder her face could frown at all. She always burst into the room calling out good morning, regardless of how she felt because in her mind, you were what you put your mind towards. If that was any measure, then it was clear to all that Lisa was vibrant and filled with energy, alive

Speaker 1and ready to tackle the world. Sadly, Tragedy would strike in May of 2002 when Lisa's father, John, passed away after a difficult battle with cancer. He was just 48 years old. This was obviously a devastating blow to Lisa, who adored the father who had always called her his little princess. As John lied dying, he turned to his brother, Mike, with a final request, to please look after and take care of his little girl when he was gone. Mike

Speaker 1agreed and and dedicated all the time and attention he could on his niece. Asked about her later, Mike would reply, quote, She always had a smile on her face. As a matter of fact, she sang at my wedding. I always thought of Lisa as my own. Just five months later, while Lisa was just beginning to throw off the shroud of grief which had enveloped her, fate got involved. Seeking a desperate night out to have fun with her friends and forget about the world for a little while, she went clubbing, and in October of 2002, the final piece

Speaker 1of her life seemed to appear, dropping right into place when Brandon walked in the room. The couple fell for one another instantly in what few have dared to call love at first sight. From that night until their last night on this earth, they became nearly inseparable. Lisa's mother, Paula, described the couple's dynamic from her daughter's point of view, telling the Arizona Republic, quote, She was beautiful, both inside and out. She had a fantastic personality. Brandon was a great kid. He treated her like a queen. He was

Speaker 1just wonderful to her. The sun set and rose on Brandon. They would play a lot and tickle each other. He constantly had his arm around her or holding her hand. Over the course of the next year, the couple continued spending as much time together as possible, developing and evolving their relationship. While the couple's parents might have felt that things were moving a little quickly, no one really complained or called anything into question because they both just seemed so happy together. Not just happy. But they complemented each

Speaker 1other's lives and offered up so much support and encouragement that they weren't just good for each other as a couple. They were actively involved in making each other better people, and their evolution was exciting and fun to watch. In August of 2003, after 10 months together, the couple decided it was time to move things forward. That month, Brandon packed up his belongings and moved into Lisa's apartment at the Scottsdale Greens Apartments. then located at 7791 East Osborne Road. Today,

Speaker 1the complex, which is still there, appears to now be called Denham-Scottsdale. The relationship had gotten quite serious, and with each new step the couple took, the happier they were with the results. According to friends and family, there had been talk of marriage, but nothing was officially set. Reportedly, the couple wanted to finish college before they started planning for a wedding, joking that maybe their own wedding could be Lisa's trial run with her career. Paula, Lisa's mother, would later tell reporters that although she had never seen

Speaker 1a ring, her daughter had told her more than once that the couple were engaged. Perhaps it was something they were keeping quiet for a while, at least until they got a ring and were ready to go public. Tragically though, That opportunity would be stolen away from them, along with all of their hopes and dreams, in a quick hail of gunfire in the vast emptiness of the desert. By October of 2003, Brandon and Lisa had been together for nearly a year, and the relationship was exactly what they

Speaker 1wanted it to be. They were happy, truly happy, spending all of their free time together and dividing their lives between school, work, and family. Brandon's family welcomed Lisa with open arms, and Lisa's family viewed Brandon as a good man who took care of their little girl. With their first anniversary rapidly approaching, the couple wanted to do something special to celebrate. Initially, they planned to make a drive west into California, where they could visit Disneyland for the weekend, but that was quickly ruled out as way too expensive.

Speaker 1Not just for access to the park, but travel expenses, getting a hotel, and all of that just made it unattainable, so they had to pivot. Always the kind of people to make the best of any situation, they came up with an even better plan, one which would keep them close to home and cost them little more than a few bucks for gas and snacks. On one of their first dates, they had gone down into the Sonoran Desert to gaze at the stars, and they thought it might be fun to recreate that night, except this time they'd stay.

Speaker 1At first, they planned to grab a tent and set camp, but looking to save time and money, they had a better idea. Lisa asked her mother if she could borrow her truck, a white Ford F-150 extended cab. She and Brandon explained that they would drive the truck to the desert, bringing along some sleeping bags, and then they would camp out in the bed of the truck together beneath the stars. Paula was slightly hesitant, both because her truck needed an oil change and because camping out in the desert like that could be dangerous. But Lisa and Brandon assured her

Speaker 1they would take every precaution. However, Lisa did have one request. She asked her mother not to tell her Uncle Mike about the trip. He was a worrier and could be a little overprotective, especially since he had sworn to his brother that he would always look out for her daughter. Lisa figured there was no way her uncle would be cool with the plan and at best he would try and talk them out of it and at worst, he might show up and the romantic couple's night would turn into a babysitting adventure. Ultimately, Paula acquiesced. It was a

Speaker 1decision she would later regret and one which continues to haunt Mike to this day as he will forever wonder how differently things might have gone had he been aware of those plans. Either way, the plan was set. On Friday, October 17, 2003, the couple would come to Paula's home and borrow her truck. At that time, they explained that they would drive approximately 70 miles north along Interstate 17 through Black Canyon City into the area of Bumblebee, a

Speaker 1small ghost town located in the Yavapai County's Bradshaw Mountains, a popular site for campers and RVs throughout the fall and winter. They did not give a specific area, noting only that it was around Bumblebee, and although it can be a very secluded spot at that time of year, there would normally be hundreds of campers scattered across a several mile stretch. The couple planned to return the next morning as Brandon was scheduled to work the afternoon of Saturday the 18th. When the couple arrived to pick up

Speaker 1the truck, Paula was still somewhat concerned, but Lisa and Brandon did a good job of assuring her that they would be perfectly safe. Brandon had been camping down in that area several times before and was familiar with it. Paula hugged both of them and told them to stay safe, keep in touch, and encouraged them to take extra blankets and not to hesitate to call if they needed anything. Calls might not be likely. given the remote nature of the campsite and the conditions of what cell networks were like in 2003, but for the most part, text messages

Speaker 1could get through, even if they might take a while. Not long after the couple drove off, Paula later admitted that she'd felt a pang of worry, like something terrible was coming, but she couldn't quite define it. Less than 24 hours later, the true horror of that feeling would be understood. The last time Paula communicated with Lisa was in the late afternoon of Friday the 17th. Paula, still worried, had been holding off on texting, not wanting to smother

Speaker 1her daughter, but she finally gave in and sent one asking if they'd arrived and settled in yet. Paula would later tell ABC News, quote, She said, No, we're not there yet, Mom. We still got so many miles to go. I said, Okay, just be careful. That was the last conversation we had. Lisa grew quiet after that message, and as they continued deeper and deeper into the isolated area, their phones became less responsive. While we have this report

Speaker 1of Paula reaching out, there's never been any information delivered, if known at all, whether or not Brandon spoke to or texted with anyone during or after the drive. Following the text message reply from Lisa, it becomes difficult to know with any certainty when and what exactly happened. We do know that the first indication of her problem came when on the afternoon of Saturday the 18th, Brandon didn't show up for work.

Speaker 2He didn't call or text.

Speaker 1Not only was it highly unlike him to miss a day of work, he certainly never did that without notifying someone in advance. While at the time this wasn't viewed as a massive red flag, it was enough to cause concern for Brandon's parents, who felt this was extremely out of character for him. Paula was already getting worried, mostly because she hadn't heard from Lisa, and by mid-afternoon they should have returned the truck, or at least called to explain why they were late. At the time, she hoped that it was something small like an issue with the

Speaker 1truck or their phones had died, but deep in her core she knew it wasn't going to be that simple. There was some consideration given by Paula as well as Brandon's father, Rob, that maybe the couple would have run off to Las Vegas to elope, but ultimately they ruled that out since they'd expressed their desire to have their families together and with them when they eventually married. The more time passed without contact, the more concerned everyone became. Soon, Paula was calling and speaking with Brandon's parents, and all

Speaker 1three were in turn calling friends and co-workers of the couple. who were then calling everyone they could think of to try and track them down. Everyone kept coming up empty, and all calls made to Brandon and Lisa's cell phones were going straight to a message informing the caller that the phones had no service. By that evening, search parties were already being organized while the couple had been reported missing to the Scottsdale and Mesa Police Departments as well as the deputies of the Yavapai County Sheriff's Office. Upon

Speaker 1taking the missing persons report, the Mesa police issued a statewide alert to be on the lookout for Brandon, Lisa, and Paula's white Ford F-150. That Saturday night saw several people traveling up Interstate 17 and into the canyons and curves of the Bradshaw Mountains in search of the couple. Among the initial searchers were Brandon's father, one of Lisa's brothers, and a group of several friends. No one knew with exact certainty where the couple had planned to camp, and so they drove along the interstate and took each exit

Speaker 1in the area, driving through different camping locations. Paula would later note, quote, They were going down each and every little road that they could find. That first night was unsuccessful, and no one had found any trace of the couple or the truck. What had begun as concerning became frightening, and it didn't take long for that fear to transform into panic. everyone regrouped and reached out to get more people together. The plan was, as soon as the sun came up on the morning of Sunday the 19th, they'd

Speaker 1get as many folks as they could up there combing through those mountain passes. Hoping to ensure that they had checked out every possibility, the families worked to coordinate with the police. On a whim, Rob Rumbaugh accessed his son's bank account and looked it over. There hadn't been any activity since Friday the 17th, which only made things more worrisome. That morning, several different groups moved up I-17 in search of Brandon and Lisa. One of them was a friend of Brandon's who had reportedly camped with the missing man

Speaker 1in and around that area before. Believing that Brandon may have returned to their spot, the friend set off to search on his own. Traveling down the interstate, he took exit 248, the exit towards Bumblebee. Not long after leaving the highway... he drove into a camping area described as little more than a vacant dirt lot. There, he found Paula's missing truck and the aftermath of a grisly double murder that left two beautiful souls dead for no damn

Speaker 1good reason. According to reports out of the Yavapai County Sheriff's Office, the Arizona State Police received a call through dispatch at approximately 3.30 p.m. on Sunday the 19th from a male who reported the discovery of two bodies at an isolated campsite just off the Bumblebee Road exit. The caller notified officers that, after finding the bodies, he had traveled approximately five miles north to the Sunset Point rest area where he knew a phone would be available. Upon arrival,

Speaker 1a highway patrol officer quickly looked over the scene before radioing in and requesting the presence of sheriff's deputies as he reported what appeared to be a double homicide. Deputies arriving on the scene found three men present, all of whom would later be reported as friends trying to help track down the couple. Deputies later described the scene as being located approximately two miles into a slightly wooded area off I-17. Paula's white Ford F-150 was parked in a

Speaker 1vacant dirt lot which was frequently used by campers and RVs. Approaching the vehicle, investigators found the bodies of Brandon and Lisa laying in the bed of the truck. Both were still inside of their sleeping bags, leading detectives to believe that the murders had likely taken place during the night, probably while they were asleep. Brandon and Lisa had both been shot five times, with the majority of those rounds being fired into their heads. Given that belief, they speculated

Speaker 1that the victims had likely been killed sometime between Friday evening and Saturday morning, though they would need information from the medical examiner to confirm any timelines. By the time crime scene investigators and supervisors had arrived on scene to get the ball rolling, the sun was already nearing the horizon. A decision had to be made in that moment. Set up lights and equipment and process the scene in the dark, possibly risking the destruction of more difficult-to-notice evidence like footprints or tire marks, or preserve and protect the scene and

Speaker 1wait until the morning, when a thorough and more detail-oriented examination could be conducted under the light of the sun. Ultimately, it was decided to process the scene to the best of their abilities that night, a decision that years later, an investigator would look back upon and say they might have destroyed potential evidence. The scene was processed for several hours, but little was discovered. Detectives at the time said they had to move slow, so as not to disturb footprints,

Speaker 1tire marks, or other pieces of evidence. However, they would reveal that they didn't discover a great deal of evidence at the scene, There were no suspicious tire tracks or footprints found, nor did they collect any shell casings or firearms. They initially reported that there was no sign of robbery, nor any indication that drugs or alcohol played a role. For the most part, they were stumped. Answering questions from the media, they repeatedly inquired as to whether or not this had been a targeted attack, or if there might

Speaker 1be a killer hunting those remote campgrounds. For the time being, Law enforcement couldn't say either way. Lieutenant Steve Francis replied to one reporter saying, Without much to work with, investigators turned to the public for help. This was a popular camping area, and it was believed that there had been hundreds of other campers within.

Speaker 2A mile or two of the murder scene.

Speaker 1Law enforcement requested that anyone who had been in the area that weekend reach out to them, with Lieutenant Francis noting, quote, Because this is such a popular weekend area and so many come here, we want the public's help. If they were up here camping and saw anything at all, we're ruling it's suspicious at the moment.

Speaker 2It's kind of early to tell.

Speaker 1A massive canvassing effort was undertaken after examination of the scene, with deputies, officers, and even park police involved with traveling to the different camping areas in the Bumblebee area, looking for anyone who may have heard or seen anything. At least ten shots had been fired that night. Surely someone had at least heard the most remote popping or even firecracker-like sounds. During the course of their canvassing, the Yavapai County Sheriff's Office determined that there were approximately 1,000 people

Speaker 1camping within a few miles of the murder scene. One witness did report noticing the couple's truck, saying he had spotted it in the location where it was later found on Saturday afternoon, though he had not approached nor seen the bodies. This fit in with the temporary timeline, suggesting that Brandon and Lisa had probably been killed Friday night. The problem was, investigators didn't arrive on the scene until approximately 30 or so hours after the murders and by then, a large majority of the campers who had been there

Speaker 1Friday or Saturday were already gone and couldn't be interviewed. When it comes to evidence and witnesses in the case, it always appears to be feast or famine here. After making statements to the media, investigators received several other calls from witnesses who had seen the truck, but who were unable to offer up any other helpful information. While investigators worked to try and find information about the crime, motive, or suspect, the families were delivered the devastating news that Lisa and Brandon had been killed. Paula was beside herself,

Speaker 1later telling the Republic, even after they said they had found them, I still couldn't believe it was them. Until I saw my truck.

Speaker 2And then I knew.

Speaker 1She was just a great person. She didn't have any enemies. She didn't dislike anybody. She loved everybody. Inside of the first week, little progress was made. Police continued working to find potential witnesses, but they had little evidence to work with and even less when it came to motive. They still weren't able to state whether or not the crime had been random or if either or both of the victims had been directly targeted. The release of the autopsy reports did shine a little light on the case, but

Speaker 1not a great deal. The autopsies confirmed that both victims had been shot five times, and while the official statement always says the five shots were to their heads, subsequent reports have called that into question. According to investigators, it appeared that Brandon had been killed first. And although they have never specified exactly what leads them to believe this, they have vaguely noted that there was some indication that Lisa may have been awakened by the shots and attempted to exit her sleeping bag before the gun turned on her.

Speaker 1By Wednesday, October 22nd, just five days after the murder, the Yavapai County Sheriff's Office announced that their investigation was quote-unquote in a holding pattern. Though they were able to learn a few new details of the crime, they were still lacking most of what they would need to provide real answers. Investigators reported later that they had spoken with a group of campers who had been staying at a site less than 100 yards from the crime scene, but none of those present heard or saw anything suspicious. How

Speaker 1exactly 10 gunshots didn't garner any attention at all was a different question entirely, and one which to this day has never been thoroughly answered. While the sheriff's office reported that the investigation was stagnating, there was suddenly a lot of activity. On Thursday, October 23rd, detectives were contacted by multiple people who reported that 34-year-old Michael Villers of Phoenix was in the area of the crime the night of the murders. Investigators described Villers as a lead, not a suspect,

Speaker 1and stated that they were very interested in speaking with him. They spent much of Thursday trying to track him down, even going so far as to alert the public of his description and the fact that he may be driving a black Ford F-150 extended cab pickup truck with a camper shell and the Arizona license plate 201HDL.

Speaker 2Detectives at the.

Speaker 1Time reported they were working on four to five other leads and that they were meeting with Brandon and Lisa's families to update them on the case and the status of the investigation. According to the families, they weren't given much information early on and were left mostly in the dark. Brandon's mother, Desiree, told the East Valley Tribune that they were less concerned about the motive and much more interested in seeing a suspect arrested. She told the Tribune, quote, We're all just holding to it's a random act of violence.

Speaker 1Mostly what I'm focused on is moving forward and keeping his spirit with me. Susan Quayle, a spokesperson for the Sheriff's Office, stated the next day that investigators had managed to track down Michael Villers. Detectives traveled to the metro area where they talked with Villers, who they reported as being helpful and cooperative. No solid information was given about who exactly had reported seeing him at the crime scene, nor how those people had known for sure. For the

Speaker 1most part, Villers was questioned and essentially cleared, with his name never coming up again. Whether there was legitimate reason to consider Villers a potential suspect or if his name just got caught up in the dragnet has never been clarified or addressed. While investigators were trying to put the pieces together, friends and family were mourning, planning funerals and working hard to try and organize searches and events to raise awareness and funds for a reward. Funeral services for

Speaker 1Brandon took place at 7 p.m. on Saturday, October 25th in the chapel of Scottsdale Bible Church. Fitness Works, where Brandon had been employed, organized a memorial fundraiser and established an annual college scholarship to be awarded in his honor. Lisa's funeral was scheduled for Monday, October 27th at Christ the King Catholic Church in Mesa, where she used to sing. Lisa was laid to rest in Queen of Heaven Catholic Cemetery in close by to where her father had been

Speaker 1buried just a year and a half earlier. Lisa's friends organized several fundraising events, including a local car wash to try and raise money for funeral expenses and to contribute towards a reward. By the end of October, the scene had been cleaned up, Paula's truck had been processed and released back to her, and both families had partaken in memorial and funeral services to honor their lost children and siblings. The case, though, seemed to be frozen. Following the pursuit

Speaker 1of Michael Villers, though investigators assured the family they were chasing down other leads, everything began to grow quiet. Then, in early November, sheriff's office detectives reported new information about a person of interest they needed help tracking down, identifying, and questioning. On Monday, November 10th, Susan Quayle stated during a press conference that detectives were hoping to speak with an unidentified man who had been seen at Lisa and Brandon's apartment sometime in the 48 hours prior to their murders.

Speaker 1The unknown man was allegedly involved in a loud argument in the doorway of the apartment at approximately 10pm on either Thursday the 16th or Wednesday the 15th. No one knows for certain what the argument was about, but given how close it came to the time of the crime, police were very interested in finding out more. They issued a description of the suspect, describing him as a white male, tall and husky, possibly in his 40s and wearing a white t-shirt and blue jeans. Quayle was not able to

Speaker 1provide a lot of context, telling the media quote, they're looking for information either from this person or about this person. there was an argument that took place. I don't know if they're looking for them as a suspect or an investigative lead. For the families, there was a growing frustration. While they appreciated the efforts of investigators, a month had gone by and they had learned very little about the crime and essentially nothing about the killer. They became reliant

Speaker 1on the public, believing that someone out there had knowledge of the crime, even if they weren't fully aware of the context. For them, it became a desperate act to keep the story in the headlines in hopes that the details would eventually reach someone who'd remember something. They did, however, contend with the possibility that there were people with knowledge who were actively avoiding coming forward. Paula would later comment to the Republic saying, quote, Somebody maybe is human enough and has a conscience and will come in and confess

Speaker 1the crime. Both of them just loved each other so, so much. Paula would later comment that in desperation, they had consulted with more than one psychic. Whether or not Brandon's family were involved is not made clear, and whatever information the psychic delivered has not been revealed, thankfully. However, in the article during which Paula is being interviewed about the psychics, there's a line which reads, That sentence sticks out, but there's no follow-up or context provided. Does Lisa's family

Speaker 1feel that way, or does Brandon's too? And do they have someone in mind, or is this merely speculation? Although we will never get a full answer, a partial one will come years later. A few days after police requested information about the unknown man arguing with Brandon at the apartment, Lisa's family announced that they had managed to raise $ 10, 000 to provide as a reward for information. According to Paula, that would have never been possible without generous members of

Speaker 1the community who wanted to pitch in in whatever way they could. Talking to the Tribune, Paula praised the community, saying, It's just unbelievable, the outpouring of love and affection. I just want this solved. Knowing this person is walking the streets and my daughter isn't, it's difficult. In hopes of making some connection, investigators began looking into other unsolved homicides in the area and across the state, which might fit into the same type of crime as the double homicide,

Speaker 1usually involving a firearm and in an isolated or out-of-the-way place. There were three cases examined initially, but no links were ever found. Ultimately, despite the media blitz and the efforts of both families... the case began fading out from the newspapers. November and December would pass, and the families faced their first holiday seasons without Brandon and Lisa. They knew things would never be the same, but no one could have prepared them for just how much energy and hope the

Speaker 1murders could suck out from their lives. Regardless, though, they were determined to push forward, to seek justice and to stand up for their lost children. On Friday, January 2nd, 2004, the East Valley Tribune released a comprehensive article entitled, Case of Slain Scottsdale Couple Frustrated Family. In it, the journalist Brian Wells discusses the passage of time and the failure of law enforcement to make advances in the case. Wells

Speaker 1sat down to talk with Paula, and during this interview, she revealed the calls from the Yavapai County Sheriff's Office were becoming shorter and less frequent. Mostly just check-ins, a reminder that they're working on the case but haven't.

Speaker 2Found anything new.

Speaker 1There would be vague discussions of leads being pursued or new people interviewed, but there was never much detail accompanying those reports. Paula stated, quote, It's been over two months now. You don't want to think of it going for years. You hear of all these cases that go for 10 years, that go for 20 years.

Speaker 2I hope that doesn't happen.

Speaker 1Discussing the case going cold and the possibility that the files could sit in a drawer for years before new information arrived, Paula resisted the idea and noted that the sheriff's office had promised her they would not give it up and file it away. She said, quote, We've been assured that this will not happen. Whether they will work on it exclusively at this point, I don't think so. I think they're working on other cases as well. This information was confirmed through spokesperson Susan Quayle, who told reporters, quote,

Speaker 1By no means is it a cold case.

Speaker 2It's very active.

Speaker 1While the case may have been active, reporting on it began fading a few weeks into the new year, and by February, things were very quiet. No interviews, no police bulletins, just periodic reminders in small blurbs in the local papers. Two months, no answers. Four months, leads drying up. Seven months, police remain baffled. Then, in August of 2004, ten months after the murders, the Sheriff's Office decided to try something new to drum up calls and tips and, at a minimum,

Speaker 1keep the story alive. Both for their own analysis and to potentially help someone remember something they may have seen or heard, the Yavapai County Sheriff's Office, in conjunction with Silent Witness... would produce, film, and release a videotape showing an accurate as possible reenactment of the double murder. Silent Witness, much like Crime Stoppers, is a non-profit organization that works with law enforcement to help solve crimes. Sheriff Sergeant David Rhodes noted their belief that the answers were out there,

Speaker 1and some people might just need more encouragement. He explained, quote, we have some idea that there are some witnesses out there still. I can't go into why we feel that way right now, but we are hoping that by releasing this silent witness reenactment, we may be able to get some of these people to come forward. Interestingly, around this same time, it's noted that detectives were still looking to find the man seen arguing at the apartment with Brandon in the days leading up to the murders, but there

Speaker 1was a note that police had adjusted their description of this unknown man. there's no information on what the adjustment was. To date, all sources continue to refer to him just as they did at the start, as a white male, tall and husky, possibly in his 40s and wearing a white t-shirt and blue jeans. I've searched everywhere I can, and I can find no other descriptions or variations of this description in any official documents or posts. Sergeant Rhodes,

Speaker 1continuing to discuss the case, noted that they had run down more than 150 tips to date and that that had kept them busy, and while information was slowing down, they were still receiving some tips. He was optimistic that the case would be solved, though when asked about potential suspects, he declined to comment, not even so much as to confirm whether or not they had any suspects. Lieutenant James Jarrell, stepping in for Rhodes, simply replied, quote, Whatever those leads were,

Speaker 1they apparently didn't pan out, as there would be little newsworthy of publication over the course of the next 15 years. Given this massive gap and the few minor newsworthy items to come out during that span, we'll hit a few of the broader points before jumping ahead. In June of 2011, an article in the Scottsdale Times included an interview with Sarah Clemens, Lisa's best friend. She expressed the same frustration as the families, not understanding how someone could murder such

Speaker 1a sweet and kind person for seemingly no reason and then just go back to their lives like nothing ever happened. Although the interview did not lead to any revelations, the article itself did include new details. Namely, that nothing appeared to be taken from the crime scene, money and valuables had been left behind, and neither a victim was assaulted by the killer. He appears to have simply come upon them sleeping and opened fire, or he perhaps came there specifically for that purpose. A motive is still unknown. In

Speaker 1late April of 2013, a news report from Channel 3 KTVK announced that Silent Witness was offering a $ 10, 000 reward for information about the murders and the person responsible for them. Sergeant Darren Birch sat for an interview to discuss the crime and revealed a few new details. Birch noted, at that time, it looks like Brandon was shot first.

Speaker 2It looked like he was sleeping.

Speaker 1Lisa might have awakened but did not really move to a great deal from the area of the bed of that pickup truck when she was shot. This statement from Birch seems to confirm that there was some indication at the scene of Lisa's awareness and I assume when found she did not appear to have been sleeping but maybe had been attempting to get out of her sleeping bag but that's merely my speculation. It's never been clarified. Now, interestingly, Sergeant Birch contradicts information in the 2011 report, where he

Speaker 1notes that some items were in fact taken from the crime scene. While some items of value were left behind, others were missing, and it was presumed that the killer had taken them before or after murdering Brandon and Lisa. For a time, there was a theory that this may have all been a robbery gone wrong, but evidence at the scene called that into question. Namely, there was no indication that Brandon had awakened at all, and Lisa awakening appears to be a direct response to the gunshots already being fired. The article includes another contradiction as well, this

Speaker 1one coming from Detective Mike Seches. In all of the initial reporting, and for years afterwards, it's reported that no shell casings were recovered from the scene. This had led many people to presume that the killer had either collected the shells, perhaps suggesting he had some kind of experience or had planned this, or maybe he'd used a revolver, which doesn't eject shells when fired like a semi-automatic does. All of those theories went out the window, however, when the detective stated, bullet casings were recovered from the scene

Speaker 1and submitted for testing, but we have not had any successful matches, so we're just looking for any leads whatsoever that may help us solve this tragic murder. The detective doesn't expound on the lack of matches, but I couldn't help but wondering if he meant they hadn't matched the shells to any other crimes or suspects or they hadn't been able to match them to a specific firearm, whether it's in the system or not. October of 2017 marked 14 years since the double murder and there were still

Speaker 1no breaks, solid leads, named suspects, or persons of interest. What had started as frustration for the families was breaking down into something more like hopelessness, a warming to the idea that they may never find the truth, at least in this life. For some of them, that meant trying to bury the pain, to move forward and remember the good times. For others, it meant clamping down harder and pushing even more furiously to find and bring the killer to justice. Paula expressed some of her frustrations to the Republic, saying, quote,

Speaker 1Everybody that met her loved her. Absolutely loved her. She didn't know an enemy. She didn't have one. That's why it makes it even harder. As much as she was loved, why would somebody do this to her? It just doesn't make sense. There's no reason why these two kids that were loved by so many should be where they are. These kids are no longer breathing. They're in the ground somewhere. And the person that did this is out there breathing every single day.

Speaker 2It's not fair. It's just not fair.

Speaker 1Paula went on to note that while she had received her truck back, the one in which Lisa was killed, she wasn't allowed to take any of her daughter's possessions found at the scene. She said detectives told her they could only release those items after 25 years or if the case is solved. Feeling less than optimistic about it, Paula commented, I just hope that this is solved before I go, before I die.

Speaker 2I want to know who did it.

Speaker 1But it could be that it's not going to happen because Lisa doesn't want me to know who did it. Two years later, in November of 2019, a new investigator took on the case and in doing so, stirred up a lot of attention and most importantly, began revealing vital information which had never been given to the public before. including the identification of the murder weapon and the discovery of a camera housing the last photos Brandon and Lisa had ever taken in the very spot where they would

Speaker 1be killed just hours later. Lieutenant Frank Barbaro sat down with Channel 4. 3 KTVK for an interview and much of what he had to say put a somewhat different spin on the scenario and opened some new doors while closing others. According to Barbaro, there was a lot of evidence recovered at the scene which included trash and items strewn about at common campsites. However, there was one piece of evidence which stood out above the rest, a disposable camera.

Speaker 1The camera was located approximately 100 feet from the truck lying in a pile of rocks. At the time, investigators couldn't determine if the killer had taken the camera and then dropped it or if it was purposefully moved. It didn't make a whole lot of sense. Perhaps they thought he'd grabbed it in a rush and then, while leaving, noticed it was a cheap camera with no resale value. Barbaro himself theorized that the camera had been thrown away from the area of the truck, though he couldn't say why. It was possible it was an attempt to destroy evidence,

Speaker 1but again, nobody knew for sure. Barbaro, who 16 years earlier had been the lieutenant at that crime scene, noted that even though the camera had been broken, they were able to recover three photos from it. The last three on the roll, all of which were released to the public for the first time. The three pictures, which I'll link to in the show notes, are as follows. There's a picture of Brandon posing with his legs open and arms crossed in jeans and a t-shirt sitting in the

Speaker 1bed of the truck. It appears the picture was taken by someone sitting across from him, likely Lisa. He is sitting on his sleeping bag and kind of making a tough guy face with a slightly clenched jaw and crossed arms. The second picture is of Lisa. She is sitting in the same spot where Brandon previously was, leaning back against the wall of the bed of the truck with her arms resting on the walls to either side of her. She has a big smile on her face and is

Speaker 1wearing jeans and a dark colored tank top. This photo appears to be taken from the same position as the one that was taken of Brandon, and so presumably he is now taking this picture of her. The third picture is somewhat more difficult to discuss. It appears altered due to some kind of issue with the film, damage to the camera, or a double or over exposure. There's a bright white distortion running from the middle of the photo all the way to the right edge, obscuring nearly half of it, while a black distortion on the left does similar.

Speaker 1There is a thin strip of image running between the two areas of distortion, showing what appears to be a ceiling light or hanging lamp with an illuminated bulb. some kind of hanging vine-like plant, part of a ceiling, the corner of what might be a window, and some kind of a basket or rack. Again, take a look for yourselves, it's quite easy to get lost in trying to figure out what exactly you're seeing, and your eyes try to define everything, even if it doesn't make sense. This third

Speaker 1photograph has kicked off a firestorm of debate and controversy online. countless online detectives, Photoshop experts, photographers, and everything in between have given their opinions and analyses of the photo. Suffice it to say that after reading a great many posts about the photo, all I walked away believing was that if we had the kind of dedication to solving this crime as we did to unraveling the mystery of the photo, this probably wouldn't be a cold case today. Either way,

Speaker 1I've seen this photo considering everything from a grisly peek into the killer's home to a mysterious building the couple may have accidentally stumbled upon leading to their murders. The answer is a lot more simple and a lot less scintillating, but we'll get to that a little later. Another piece of information revealed by Lt. Barbaro was that the disposable camera wasn't the only one on site, at least before the murders. Lisa and Brandon borrowed a somewhat expensive video

Speaker 1camera from Paula before they left that Friday, and while the case was recovered in the truck, the camera itself has never been found. Police continue to keep an eye out for it and even know the serial number, which has been added to their system should it ever turn up at a pawn shop, but to date, it has never surfaced. Asked whether or not he believed the killer had stolen that camera, Barbaro replied, absolutely A major detail finally revealed was the murder weapon. Although they hadn't recovered

Speaker 1it at the scene and to date have never located the murder gun, it's a rather rare find. The weapon was described as being a 25 caliber handgun. This is a small gun, the kind where the entire thing can nearly fit in the palm of your hand. Though not quite as small, looking up images of these guns makes them appear somewhat like a modern derringer. The kind of gun you could easily conceal in your palm, back pocket, or even a small purse. Certainly not the kind of weapon you'd expect an experienced killer to be using. If

Speaker 1you've ever seen one of those small novelty lighters that looks like a gun, they're not much bigger than that. I'll include an image of one in the show notes. Most gun sites and forums treat. 25 calibers as old, outdated, and more of a novelty than anything else. Reportedly, the guns had some popularity due to the time in which they were released. Invented in 1905, it was a popular caliber because at the time it was more reliable than a.

Speaker 222, but also less effective.

Speaker 1Advancements in design and metallurgy led to them mostly being phased out. You can still buy one, used and new, from brands like Beretta. They generally offer the same model in. 22 as well. It's a strange choice for a double murder, considering the. 25 caliber has approximately 20% of the energy produced from a 9mm, which is more widely and easily available. When testing for penetration, the FBI found that the. 25 caliber frequently failed to even penetrate the ballistic gelatin to

Speaker 1the minimum depth of 12 inches. Suffice it to say, while both victims were shot five times, what had originally been seen as an indication of rage leading to overkill, the sick truth might actually be this was more about practicality. Even at close range, the 25 may not be guaranteed to kill with a headshot or even two. Given all of that information, there's been three diverging theories which have developed out of this. One is that the killer was

Speaker 1inexperienced and used what he had available to him, possibly an older gun he'd gotten on the cheap or which came from a family member or collection he had access to. Others thought this might be indicative of the killer's gender. The. 25, while fully usable by all, is described by a lot of people as a woman's gun. The kind you would give to your daughter or a relative going on a first date or moving somewhere on their own and they want something to feel a little safer. It's smaller than a taser and may have more stopping power depending on

Speaker 1the assailant. Its petite design makes it fit more comfortably in the hand of someone with a smaller palm and slender fingers, such as a woman, although there are plenty of men with smaller hands. Then there are still others who believe that this gun was purposefully chosen by the killer because it wouldn't produce very loud shots that night, making it less likely that anyone in the area would hear, and because, especially if it's an older gun, it would prove extremely difficult to track down, which, all these years later,

Speaker 1certainly seems to have proven true. So Lieutenant Barbaro expressed his belief that this was likely a targeted crime, with either Brandon or Lisa being the primary focus. Whether this was about jealousy or robbery or something else, he couldn't say for sure, but he noted, quote, Normally, people are killed by somebody they know. Now, a lot of people have noted that Brandon and Lisa didn't tell anyone exactly where they were going that night, so it would have

Speaker 1been difficult for someone they knew to track them down. And while that's true, it doesn't account for the fact that one of them may have given a specific location to a third party that we simply don't know about, or if they had been very open about their plans leading up to that weekend, someone could have followed them. Remember, they were found by friends who had been in that area before and had camped with Brandon previously. If it could be done on Sunday morning, it could certainly be done on Friday night. That, however, raised an interesting question,

Speaker 1specifically about the unnamed people who had initially found the bodies. How thoroughly had they been questioned? Not thoroughly enough, if Lisa's Uncle Mike is to be believed. Mike Guerrero hadn't spoken much publicly about the case, but after nearly 20 years, it was hard to bite his tongue. He'd had suspicions since the early days, but no one appeared to be pursuing them. Talking to the media, Mike shared his thoughts about the people who found Brandon and Lisa, saying, quote, According to Mike, he went to speak to one of

Speaker 1the individuals who'd found them after the murder. alleging this man had had a thing for his niece. Mike explained, quote, he wanted Lisa. He wanted Lisa bad to be with her. I was on my way. I was in my truck headed to the freeway. I got a phone call saying he wasn't there. The place had been wiped out clean. Mike went on to say that he felt the entire case hinged on this one person, who has never been named, but apparently was one of the three who helped locate the crime scene that Sunday morning. Mike urged the sheriff's office to dig deep into this man. to investigate him,

Speaker 1but he feels like for the most part, they didn't take the claim seriously and in his words, that is where they botched the investigation. Reportedly, Sheriff's investigators did contact the individual. He was interviewed, questioned, and apparently agreed to sit for a polygraph examination, which he passed. That was enough for the Sheriff's office to clear him, and then, within a few weeks of the murders, he skipped town, moving to Washington State. Although the man had supposedly been cleared,

Speaker 1Lieutenant Barbaro disagreed, saying, quote, Them being the original investigators. Barbaro admitted the investigation hadn't been perfect, none of them ever are, but as far as he was concerned, no one had been cleared and everybody was subject to being re-questioned and re-evaluated as dictated by the evidence. Barbaro did

Speaker 1not spare himself some criticism either. Discussing the initial search of the crime scene, he brought up the choice that had to be made, to search at night or to wait until the morning. With nearly two decades of retrospect, he flatly stated, quote, Deborah West, a volunteer cold case investigator, has been working closely with Barbaro to try and help find and identify the killer. While the lieutenant believes there

Speaker 1is a personal connection, West does not, thinking this is more likely a random crime or perhaps a robbery gone wrong. She explains, saying, quote, I'm leaning more towards a random. The purpose was to break into the truck, steal the truck, and then they were surprised by the people in the back. West made direct reference to another double homicide which had occurred just six months after the murder of Brandon and Lisa and which had ultimately led to the suspect's death without any answers ever being supplied. On Monday, May 3rd, 2004,

Speaker 1the bodies of Omar Lee Casey, 74, of Somerton, and William Ray Middaw, 70, of Yuma, were discovered near Crown King in the Prescott National Forest approximately 30 miles southeast of Prescott and 25 miles from where Brandon and Lisa were killed. Casey and Middaw had gone up there to camp and ride their ATVs and according to investigators, it appeared both had been shot and killed by someone who wanted to steal those ATVs and perhaps other items. Investigators

Speaker 1quickly learned that 21-year-old Rusty Rankin of Phoenix had been camping in the area at the time of the murders and his vehicle was found within close proximity to the crime scene. An arrest warrant was issued for Rankin, the son of a Phoenix police officer, and local newspapers speculated that he might have used his father's service revolver in the murders. Officer Rankin noted that after being informed about the crime and the arrest warrant, he discovered that his service weapon was missing. Outside of sheer robbery, there did

Speaker 1not appear to be any real motive for the crime, and police did not believe that Rankin actually knew either victim. After the murders, Rankin fled the area and traveled into Colorado, where he checked into a Super 8 motel on Arrow Plaza Drive in Colorado Springs. On the night of Tuesday, May 4th, police tracked him to that location and surrounded the building, ordering him to come out and turn himself in. After a three-hour standoff, Rankin agreed to surrender, but then stopped communicating, so SWAT raided the room. They found him deceased,

Speaker 1having turned the gun on himself. Ultimately, four firearms were recovered, including Rankin's father's duty pistol. Rankin's death essentially closed that double murder investigation, but there are some who believe he could have been involved in Brandon and Lisa's murders, despite investigators at the time saying there were no connections. With the inability to question Rankin, we may never know for sure. Although there were some similarities, there were also a lot of differences. At least in regard to knowing their killer,

Speaker 1no one could establish any connection between Rankin and Lisa or Brandon, and although police have examined the possibility, they've never confirmed or established any solid link between the two crimes, nor have any details ever been discussed about Rankin camping near to where Brandon and Lisa were or really being anywhere near Bumblebee that October night in 2003. But given the way he exited from this world, there will always be questions lingering unless the truth is finally found. For

Speaker 1his part, Barbaro finds the coincidence hard to dismiss, noting, quote, Six months later, we have the same type of crime. Two people shot for their vehicles to be stolen. It's very unusual. It never happens here. We don't have any physical proof of it yet, but it really surprises me that these would be completely unrelated. According to Deborah West, the focus of the investigation was shifting away from theories and interviews and back towards the cold, hard evidence. Items

Speaker 1from the scene were being submitted for DNA testing for the first time now that new technologies made it possible. Some of the items being tested included Brandon's jeans, as it was theorized that the killer likely reached into his pockets after the murders looking for his wallet or cash. According to Barbaro, they were looking to track down a few people to conduct new interviews with, see if they can glean any new information, and of course, to make sure people's stories hadn't changed. It was the most they

Speaker 1could really do without any solid leads or at least the evidence necessary to properly pursue anyone. Over the course of the next few years, it was announced that the Yavapai County Sheriff's Office was relying on even more advancements in technology to test for DNA on key pieces of evidence, with Lt. Tom Boltz noting, they had more options in 2019 than they had in 2015, and way more than they had in 2003. With each breakthrough, there is new potential for cases like Brandon and Lisa's. Two years later,

Speaker 1in 2021... Deborah West confirmed to ABC News that there was a new detective on the case, and they were focused on re-interviewing everyone from the original investigation. During this interview, it was noted by Lt. Boltz that while no arrests had been made, there are still persons of interest. Who these people are has never been confirmed, but it is the first time an official source has said there were any persons of interest at all. Just last year, in May of 2025, Nearly 22 years after the double murder,

Speaker 1the Irish Mirror, of all places, released a fairly in-depth article about Brandon, Lisa, the murders, and the status of the case. This includes some of the most recent news about the investigation, revealing some new details. Lieutenant Bolts, now Commander Bolts, confirmed that a video camera was missing from the scene and for the first time, noted that Lisa's keys also appeared to have been taken by the killer, as they have never been found. Bolts also stated that they had managed to track down surveillance video from the

Speaker 1afternoon of Friday, October 17th, which showed Brandon and Lisa together in a Scottsdale area grocery store, purchasing, among other items, the disposable camera that was found 100 feet from the truck. Addressing the photographs themselves, police haven't said much about the images of Lisa and Brandon, nor has anyone officially connected to the case outside of Paula. In her opinion, her daughter doesn't look right in the picture, and she thinks it may have been taken by the killer at gunpoint.

Speaker 1She explained, saying, quote, It wasn't her smile. It was like she was scared and she was smiling. Paula believes that Brandon and Lisa were aware they were in mortal danger when those pictures were taken. I never knew Brandon or Lisa, so it's difficult to speculate, but to me, there's nothing about the photographs that stands out or appears odd at all. I think given the proximity of the time the photos were taken and the double murder, it's just easy to see something darker in those photos, whether

Speaker 1it's really there or not. As for the third photo, the overexposure that everyone's been going crazy trying to solve, well, the debate about that image continues to this very day, but law enforcement have almost entirely dismissed it. According to Commander Bolts, investigators believe the photo was taken some hours before the murders at a local restaurant which operated in Bumblebee back in 2003. The restaurant, which is no longer in operation, was one of multiple businesses which had operated

Speaker 1out of the building over the years. Police believe, based on information about the interior of that restaurant and some photos they have seen in the years since, that the couple likely snapped the picture while eating dinner hours before their murders. When the camera was thrown or dropped, police believe the jarring caused the film to slip and perhaps a picture slipped. snapped in the darkness overexposing the restaurant photo. But in all reality, no one can say for certainty where it was taken or how it happened. However, one

Speaker 1thing is for sure, the answers to this crime do not reside within the frame of that photo. According to Boltz, after more than 20 years of investigation, they theorized that Lisa and Brandon were either asleep or laying down preparing to sleep when the assailant attacked. While he didn't specify, he did confirm there's evidence that Lisa likely woke up during the attack. Whether this was a robbery gone wrong or always meant as a double murder remains to be determined. Given the mention some years back of persons of interest...

Speaker 1Commander Boltz was asked about that, and replied, quote, There are still persons of interest. There are a lot of people we've interviewed, a lot of people that we've investigated. We can't say any of them are no longer persons of interest, but it's, uh, yeah, the nature of these things is... You start big and get small, and we're still in that medium phase where a lot of people are still on the radar.

Speaker 2We're just waiting for something to break.

Speaker 1Somebody to come forward and tell us something, or DNA, or some other test that may be coming down the pike. As for the case itself, Boltz noted that a new detective had been working it for the last few years, and he was being assisted by several cold case volunteers. He then made a comment which, pardon my speculation, seems to suggest that they might be in possession of some partial DNA from the killer. Bolt said, quote, Right now, we're in the phase where we're working with genealogy, trying

Speaker 1to get some identification from some of the DNA that was at the scene so that we can generate some leads and hopefully find out who did this. It's difficult to work with genealogy if you don't have a genetic marker for who you're pursuing. So they may indeed have finally pulled some valuable DNA off the evidence, but as of this time, nothing has been confirmed. This was the last real update in this case. But there is some optimism to be found in that as recently as last year,

Speaker 1they're still finding new evidence and may even be closing in on identifying a suspect or perhaps a family member through whom they might begin digging. Genetic genealogy has solved many cases once believed impossible to conclude. We can only hope Brandon and Lisa's case will be added to that list. Lisa's mother, Paula, always believed that her daughter had likely been killed by someone the couple knew. She found it difficult to dismiss the possibility, believing that it may have

Speaker 1come down to jealousy, someone who wanted Lisa but couldn't have her. This is certainly how her uncle Mike feels, and he's been very vocal about it. Paula Guerreri hoped and prayed for an answer, telling ABC News, quote, I just hope to God they find what happened or who did it. Even if the person is dead, I want to know. Tragically, Paula Lee Hussey Guerreri passed away on Friday, November 29th, 2024.

Speaker 2At the age of 71.

Speaker 1Never learning the truth of her daughter's fate, nor to see justice delivered to her killer. However, for Paula's family, they believe she and Lisa have reunited in heaven, just as the grieving mother dreamed of for so many years. Brandon's family have, for the most part, kept things to themselves. Though they've spoken about the great pain and tragedy of their loss, they don't wish to live it out on the front pages. Some people have it in them to

Speaker 1get down in the trenches and battle with a hellacious fury. and others must do what is necessary to go on, to live their lives in the way they believe their loved ones would have wanted. Brandon's mother Desiree explained it best, saying quote, I've been tested to a point that a human almost cannot bear. That kind of pain changes you. When something hurts that deep within you, you ultimately come to two choices. You succumb to the pain, or you come out with more expansiveness inside. Brandon Keith Rumbaugh and

Speaker 1Lisa Marie Guerreri were last confirmed to be alive on the evening of Friday, October 17, 2003. They were captured on surveillance video in a Scottsdale grocery store buying supplies and a disposable camera. Lisa's mother, Paula, exchanged a last text message with her daughter in the early evening hours followed by 30 hours of silence until their bodies were found. Both were shot five times with a. 25 caliber handgun while laying in sleeping bags in the bed of Paula's

Speaker 1white Ford F-150, parked in a dirt camping lot near to Bumblebee and just off Interstate 17. Several items were missing from the scene, though other items of value were left behind. Investigators are actively pursuing all leads in this case. A $ 10, 000 reward is available for any information which leads to an arrest. Surely, there is someone out there who knows the truth, or at least, enough to get the ball rolling. All it takes is one little email, one

Speaker 1short phone call, one anonymous message, to help alleviate so much grief and pain for two broken families. Asked about the loss of her daughter, and the pain of never knowing the truth, Lisa Guerrero bluntly poured out her raw heart, saying, quote, it was hard.

Speaker 2I lost my daughter.

Speaker 1And I lost my best friend at the same time. When I go into a store and see something Lisa would have liked, I have to leave. They were my kids. I don't want a memory of a gun. I want to remember my daughter. I want her back so badly. The double homicide of Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerrero is a disturbing case to examine. From the sheer panic of being targeted in such an isolated spot, to the terror

Speaker 1one can only imagine racing through Lisa's mind as gunshots jolted her out of her sleep before she too was killed. We can only hope that she didn't have to see what happened, nor suffer long, but the imagery it evokes is haunting to say the least. Although initially inundated with media coverage, things have been pretty quiet for the last 15 years or so. Yes, we've gotten new updates about the DNA evidence and genealogy, which I personally think means they're well on the trail of a suspect whose DNA they recovered, but there hasn't been much beyond clearing up

Speaker 1some confusion and setting the record straight about what was and was not found, what the crime scene offered, and what it did not. When it comes down to the meat and bones of the case, the actual whodunit, so to speak, there hasn't been a lot of leeway made. If you really think about it, we don't even know for certain whether this was a crime perpetrated by one individual or if others were involved and present that night. Ultimately, the theories tend to split into two distinct categories. Those who believe this was a random crime or robbery gone

Speaker 1wrong scenario... and others who think this had to have been committed by someone who knew one or both of the victims, with jealousy likely being a driving factor. So we'll start with the random aspect and work our way towards something planned out and more sinister. The idea that someone may have come upon Paula's Ford F-150 parked in that dirt lot without any apparent sign of the owners would certainly lay the groundwork for a scenario by which this person thought they could steal from the truck, or perhaps take the truck entirely, while the campers who had

Speaker 1driven it there were otherwise occupied or asleep. This theory follows through with the idea that the killer or killers approached the truck and possibly began rummaging through it, not realizing that anybody was asleep in the back, and then just by sheer accident or by someone waking up and moving, they realized that the owners of the truck weren't far away, they were right there. In that moment, it would seem a decision was instantly made to shoot and kill Brandon and Lisa back to back with little to no delay

Speaker 1other than perhaps reloading. A. 25 caliber typically holds between 6 and 9 rounds, so for 10 shots we would need at least one reload or perhaps a model that holds more rounds, making it probably less common. Now, I don't think this can be entirely ruled out. While it seems like a dramatic overreaction to straighten up and fire ten shots murdering two people who may or may not have woken up and found you trying to steal a camera and random items whose value doesn't add up to a whole lot, sadly, we live in a world where

Speaker 1people have been murdered for a hell of a lot less. Perhaps it wasn't meant so much as a double execution, but it's hard to imagine it any other way. I mean, what's the scenario there? Brandon starts to move and startles the killer who, in shock and fear, quickly fires five shots into the man's head. I just can't imagine any circumstances under which the crime occurred in that way. One or two shots, not specifically to the head, and definitely not while they're sleeping, I could at least make an argument that things got out of control. However, in this instance,

Speaker 1it absolutely feels like this person or persons wanted to execute Brandon and Lisa. That doesn't necessarily mean that they knew them, though. Just because someone is sick and twisted enough to pull off a hideous crime such as this doesn't have to be any direct connections or emotional ties. I know we often get caught up in the idea that when people are killed, it's usually by someone they know, and firing five shots into both victims feels angry and temperamental. and full of hatred, but there are enough evil people out there who don't need any encouragement or assistance when

Speaker 1it comes to killing for no reason. Even if you do follow the statistics, according to the FBI, 70-80% of victims knew their killers. While that's a pretty definitive stat, it leaves out one key detail. This does not include any data on any of the thousands and thousands of unsolved homicides. I would agree that there's usually a connection, but we also know that random murders occur and they are notoriously difficult to solve. One thing to turn attention

Speaker 1to for the time was the area itself. Bumblebee is described as a ghost town in the Sonoran Desert. According to all available data, Bumblebee is home to approximately 15 residents who, following the murders, told reporters that their quiet little town was slowly becoming more dangerous. There'd been an uptick in minor crimes like vandalism, and that was followed by the drug scene. At the time, authorities hadn't fully wrapped their heads around it, likely because the small population didn't often encounter issues.

Speaker 2But there was no.

Speaker 1Denying that a drug problem was growing. Today, Bumblebee is part of a large area designated by the state of Arizona as a high-density drug trafficking area. The Avapai County authorities secured that designation in order to try and combat the heavy flow of illegal drugs moving through their county. Bumblebee, located just off I-17, makes it a valuable spot for traffickers. I-17 is the primary highway connecting Phoenix to northern Arizona, and the desert and isolated areas up through that region

Speaker 1provide a lot of cover for the concealed trafficking of narcotics and the establishment of hiding and even grow operations. According to the DEA and local law enforcement, the Sinaloa cartel mostly operates through this area, with Phoenix serving as a massive transshipment hub with illicit supplies run through northern Navapai County. The Sinaloa cartel began operating in the late 1980s, so it isn't difficult to imagine that by 2003, they may have been more heavily involved in rural areas such

Speaker 1as Bumblebee, especially since local authorities didn't achieve the high-density drug trafficking area designations until 2020. So, while initial investigators said they had found no links between the murders and drugs, that isn't necessarily true. Just because Brandon and Lisa weren't drug users doesn't mean they couldn't have parked in an area frequented by traffickers, users, or even cartel members who might be inclined to kill the nice, clean-cut kids to help send a message for others to stay the hell

Speaker 1out of that area. Now, obviously, this is all speculative, but what in this case isn't? So, I don't think it's insane to assume that this crime could have been random and maybe, in some way, connected to drug trafficking. Now, a cartel member I could absolutely see murdering two people over a camera. Those guys have no qualms about killing anyone for any reason. For me, however, the sticking point is the weapon. I just can't imagine a lot of cartel guys running around with. 25 caliber handguns, but stranger

Speaker 1things have happened. Investigators did look into the possibility of this being random as well. In fact, they consulted with police in different states, comparing similar crimes and looking for any potential connections. We're aware of the Rusty Rankin search, but regardless of Lieutenant Barbaro's opinion, there's never been anything connecting the two cases. But then, there was a double homicide in California in August of 2004, which turned some heads. Lindsay Cutshaw, 23, and her fiancé Jason Allen, 26, were

Speaker 1found dead in sleeping bags on Fish Head Beach on Wednesday, August 18th in Jenner, California. Each had been shot in the head while sleeping with a. 45 caliber rifle, and there were no signs of assault or robbery. It was ultimately determined that they'd been killed four days earlier. Although this was closely looked at, with investigators wondering if there could be a connection, the crime was solved in 2017 when authorities arrested 38-year-old Sean Gallen of Forestville, California. Gallin

Speaker 1had been a person of interest from the beginning, and there was no evidence that he'd ever spent time in Arizona, let alone in such an out-of-the-way spot as Bumblebee. In June of 2019, Gallin entered a no-contest pleas and admitted guilt in the crimes. He received three consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole, plus another 94 years in state prison. In addition, he'd also murdered his own brother, Seamus. and had attempted to murder another man in 2004 with a package bomb. While the solving of the crime was

Speaker 1fantastic news, it only went further to show there was no link between that crime and the murder of Lisa and Brandon. So, if it wasn't random, or completely off the cuff, could this crime have been committed by someone the couple knew?

Speaker 2Well, certainly.

Speaker 1There was a lot of talk of people being jealous, either of Brandon having Lisa or of Lisa having Brandon. Both were apparently popular with the opposite sexes, and that can sometimes breed contempt, even between friends. Mike Guerrero hasn't been shy about the fact that he believes one of the men who found their bodies that morning was directly involved. In his opinion, that man had a major crush on Lisa and was full of anger about the fact that he couldn't have her. That certainly sounds like a potential motive, romantic entanglements frequently being a precursor to horrible crimes. According

Speaker 1to Mike, he went to talk to this guy, only to find that he'd cleared out his place and moved to Washington State, where police later went to question him and administer a polygraph, which he apparently passed. None of that's exactly overwhelming evidence of guilt, but I could certainly see thinking the whole situation was a bit odd. Now, to be the devil's advocate for a minute, we don't know anything about this guy, his life, his connections to Brandon and Lisa, nor his reasons for moving. Generally speaking, one doesn't move in a matter of a week or two. Usually,

Speaker 1there's some planning, both for the state you're leaving and the one you're arriving in. Do we know if this guy had been planning this move prior to the murders, or was it spur of the moment afterwards? Also, while one could say he moved because he wanted to get away from the heat of law enforcement, one could also speculate that if he did have a huge crush on Lisa, he may have wanted to get away from everything that reminded him of that horrible loss. One detail I found interesting, and this may just be a rabbit hole that I

Speaker 1am indulging in, but give me a moment. Some years after the murders, in hopes of freeing herself from the daily traumatic reminders of the Arizona desert, Paula moved to Washington State. She lived there for several years before returning to Arizona, where she eventually passed away. Now, I don't think there's any connection there, but I do find it a little fascinating that both this suspect and Paula moved to Washington. And I kind of wonder if maybe she might have been keeping tabs on him. But that's just

Speaker 1my speculation. Obviously, there could be other people too. Ones who we haven't heard about. Friends who had crushes on Lisa. Friends who had crushes on Brandon. Friends or acquaintances who weren't interested in either of them, but just couldn't deal with seeing other people who were happily in love while their own lives weren't going according to plan. It doesn't take a whole lot, it seems, to move someone from distaste to hate. from jealousy to violence. We see it all the time. Surely that could have happened here. Maybe

Speaker 1Lisa or Brandon gave someone more specific information about where they were going, or perhaps they were followed. I guess the one stumbling block I frequently hit is why this person so enraged about this relationship would wait nearly a year before acting. No one tries anything when they first get together, or when they move in. They wait until this one year anniversary to do it, and sure, Maybe the anniversary was an antecedent for this person. It really got the fire going in their gut. But you plan out a double murder with a. 25 caliber handgun?

Speaker 2Seriously?

Speaker 1Now, keep in mind, as I mentioned during the evidence section, it's entirely possible the suspect could be female as well as male. This is why ballistics and other details from the murders would be helpful. Was the gun held against their heads or fired from a distance? What was the angle of entry and does it suggest an approximate height or stance of the killer? The police clearly have a lot more information than they have shared with us, but it would be helpful to learn a little more. Like that silent witness reenactment they did? Despite my sincerest efforts,

Speaker 1I couldn't find more than a two-second clip of it from a news broadcast. You would think if you go through the trouble of making something like that, you'd have it readily available, but I digress. At the end of the day, we simply don't know. I could easily accept either argument should additional information be presented to fortify the position of random versus targeted or vice versa. I think investigators have more of an idea, and while they say they have persons of interest, I think more likely they've got one or two people they've been keeping an eye

Speaker 1on from the beginning. Of course, now, we wait for the incredible work that all of these labs like Othram are doing, tracking down killers from the slightest slivers of DNA. I think, in this instance, it's only a matter of time before the killer is identified, and when that happens, it will certainly be fascinating to see who's left holding the bag.

Speaker 2For now.

Speaker 1this is where the case remains. Active, but waiting. Not quite cold, but not exactly sizzling. Someone out there knows the truth, and has the ability to solve this case right now, or at least to push it in the right direction. There's a good chance that person is listening right now. and we can only hope that they possess enough humanity to do what is right, even if only for the $ 10, 000 check they'd cash upon prosecution. Unless someone comes forward, new evidence is found, or DNA eventually leads

Speaker 1to this killer, the murders of Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerrero will remain open, unsolved, and tepidly warm. If you're looking for more information about the murders of Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerrero, there are many forums and newspapers detailing the examination of the crime. For this episode, the East Valley Tribune and Arizona Republic were the most helpful. There

Speaker 1are also other podcasts who have covered this case, and if you're interested in it, you should definitely seek them out. If you have any information about the murders of Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerrero, please contact the Yavapai County Sheriff's Office at 928-771-3260. You can also submit information, even anonymously, through Silent Witness by calling 1-800-932-7000.

Speaker 2What do you believe happened? Tweet me at TracevPod.

Speaker 1Email me at traceevidencepod at gmail.com or contact me by any social media, all of which can be easily found by visiting followtepod.com. That's followtepod.com. For more information about this case and all others previously covered, please visit our website at trace-evidence.com. There you can find write-ups on all cases, links to sources, updates, connections to social media, as well

Speaker 1as all the different ways you can support the show. We have multiple merchandise shops set up and are on Buy Me a Coffee and Patreon. The show also produces videos which are posted on YouTube and Rumble, so make sure to like and subscribe if you haven't already. Now it's time to take a moment to thank our amazing Patreon producers. So a very special thank you to... Thank

Speaker 1you all so much for your amazing support of Trace Evidence. Without you, this show would not be possible. If you'd like to support the show, visit patreon.com slash traceevidence, where you can listen to all episodes completely ad-free. And for those of you who hate the background music, I even post new episodes there without any music. So for as little as $ 3 a month, you can have access. So don't miss out. This concludes our look into the Bumblebee

Speaker 1murders of Brandon Rumbaugh and Lisa Guerrero, an extremely solvable case that just needs that one break. Personally, I think I'll be updating this case by the end of 2027, but maybe that's just my own optimism.

Speaker 2Either way.

Speaker 1I want to thank you for listening to this episode, and I hope you'll join me next time when we're going to dive deep into a case we previously covered where newly obtained police files tell a very, very different story. Thanks again for listening, and make sure to visit FollowTEPod.com and follow Trace Evidence on all your social media. This

Speaker 1episode is copyright 2026 by Stephen Pacheco, All Rights Reserved.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 259 - The Ambush Murder of John Harden

    Nov 13, 20262 hr 44 minAudio

    On the evening of Saturday, March 22nd, 1975, thirty-two year old John Harden arrived at his Claremont, FL home after a work call with his wife and young son. John went upstairs to clean up when, a short time later, he...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. UPDATE - Faith Hedgepeth - Killer Found Guilty

    Oct 27, 202624 minAudio

    In September of 2012, nineteen year old Faith Hedgepeth was brutally murdered in her Chapel Hill apartment by an unknown individual. A thorough examination of the scene and evidence told a disturbing story of the young...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. UPDATE - The Tylenol Murders

    Sep 29, 202625 minAudio

    In September of 1982, seven people in the Chicago area died after ingesting over-the-counter Tylenol capsules that had been laced with lethal doses of potassium cyanide before being placed on store shelves. Although...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 257 - The Disappearance of Jerry Wolking

    Jul 23, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    Jerry Wolking was worried, but nobody knew why. He was fidgety, pacing and didn't want to talk about what was on his mind. Days later, her mysteriously disappeared after leaving his girlfriend's house. He has never been...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. UPDATE - The Sundrop Murders - Arrest Made [Ep 114]

    Jun 9, 202623 minAudio

    On Friday, June 13th, 2008, just before 10 AM, an unknown assailant entered the Sundrop Bottling Company building in Concord, North Carolina. Inside were three employees including office manager Donna Barnhardt as well...

    Credit the people on this episode