Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Trace Evidence

Trace Evidence artwork

SOLVED - The Murder of Jennifer Persia [Ep 153]

Apr 14, 202626 minAudio

Sixteen year old Jennifer Persia had everything going for her. She played saxophone in the school band, was on the color guard and was becoming a breakout athlete. As a freshman, she was on the varsity track team and medaled in a competition against mostly seniors. Then one quiet, Monday night, someone stole away everything she hoped to be, shattered a family and rocked a small town. On April 4th, 1994, an unknown killer, or killers, entered Jennifer's home and brutally murdered the sixteen year old over a matter of just $200. UPDATE After more than 30 years, DNA has conclusively identified Jennifer's killer. Not only has her case been solved through the use of genetic genealogy, but it was also discovered that Jennifer was not the monster's only victim. Twenty-four year old Marebeth Welsh, murdered five months before Jennifer, has also been identified as the victim of thirty-nine year old Francis Schooley. Submit a Tip - https://camdencountypros.org/unit/49 Use promo code "Trace" to save 10% on your pass at CrimeCon.com FollowTEPod.com Follow Trace Evidence on Social Media Twitter --- Instagram --- TikTok --- YouTube --- Like Facebook Page --- Join Facebook Group --- Threads --- Like MeWe Page --- Join MeWe Group --- Bluesky Suppport Trace Evidence Patreon --- Paypal --- Cash App --- Buy Me A Coffee Trace Evidence Merch Shops TeePublic --- ShopTEPod --- Spreadshop All Other Links Official Trace Evidence Website --- LinkTree Music Courtesy of: "Lost Time" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ "Chasing Time" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ "Galactic Rap" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ #truecrimepodcast #unsolvedmysteries #coldcase #coldcaseinvestigation #murder #murdermystery #missingperson #missingpersons #truecrimecommunity #mysterypodcast #truecrime #coldcasefiles #truecrimestories #crimelovers #truecrimeaddict #truecrimejunkie #crimescene #justiceforall #missing #crimesquad #podcastcommunity #sleuthsunite #darkhistories #criminalmindset #detective #detectivediaries #forensics #forensicfiles #crimestories #crimepodcast #traceevidence #traceevidencepodcast #criminalinvestigation #justiceforvictims #detectivework #truecrimediscussion #podcastfamily #listenandsolve #crimefans #listentotraceevidence #uncoverthetruth #podcastrecommendations #podcastlove #podcastlife #truecrimeobsessed #followtheclues #cluefinders #podcastaddict #unsolvedmurders #unsolveddisappearances #detectiveatheart #jointheinvestigation #disappearance #vanishing #abduction #gonemissing #upandvanished #pacheco #stevenpacheco #podcasting #crimetalk #crimeanalysis #theories #jenniferpersia #persia #magnolia #nj #newjersey #marebethwelsh #welsh #schooley #solved #DNA Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/trace-evidence--3207798/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1In episode one point fifty three, the Murder of Jennifer Persia, we detailed the hideous crime which left the bright, talented and caring sixteen year old dead on the floor of her family's home in Magnolia.

Speaker 2New Jersey.

Speaker 1Despite the hard work and dedication of detectives and of family, which refused to allow the case to grow silent, the search for Jennifer's killer was constantly leading to a dead end. The crime shocked Magnolia and left residence stunned by the brutal nature of the murder of a young teenager who had her whole life in front of her. Eventually, despite the acquisition of DNA evidence collected at the scene, investigators could not connect that DNA to any known person of interest or suspect. There were no matches in the system,

Speaker 1and given that it was the early nineties, technology had not yet reached the point at which the killer could be tracked from only that sample. Now, however, things have progressed far enough that investigators conclusively linked that male DNA to the man believed to have killed Jennifer, identified as thirty nine year old Francis Schooley. Not only will we dig into this new information, but also the revelation that Jennifer was not Schooley's only victim. New Jersey authorities have

Speaker 1announced that Schooley has been identified as the killer in another unsolved homicide. This is a special update episode the murder of Jennifer Persia Solved. Welcome to Trace Evidence. I'm your host Steven Pacheco. In today's special update episode, we delve into all of the newly released information about the closing of Jennifer's case, as well as her killer being

Speaker 1linked to a second previously unsolved homicide. Before diving in, though, just a quick reminder that this year, Crime Con will be returning to Las Vegas for the weekend of May twenty ninth through thirty first, and I'll be there on podcast row representing Trace Evidence. Every year, attending Crime Con is such a blast and I'd love getting a chance to meet all of you amazing folks. So if you're planning to attend but haven't yet purchased your past you can save ten percent by using promo code trace. That's

Speaker 1Crimecon dot Com promo code trace.

Speaker 2I really can't wait to see all of you there.

Speaker 1Originally I'd plan to put this episode out later in the week, but I've received such an overwhelming amount of emails and messages from people telling me about the break and also requesting more information, so I've decided to flip the schedule. Episode two fifty six, which is in the final edit now, will release in just a few days, and for now now you will get this update episode. So without further ado, let's get right into the update.

Speaker 1Sixteen year old Jennifer Persia of Magnolia, New Jersey had everything going for her and the world at her fingertips. She played saxophone in the school band, was on the color guard, and was proving herself as a talented breakout athlete. When she had been a freshman, she'd easily made the varsity track team and meddled in a competition made up primarily of seniors, cementing her place as an up and coming high achiever and a force to be reckoned with. Tragically,

Speaker 1her bright future was violently and viciously stolen away from her on a quiet Monday in nineteen ninety four, when an unknown intruder entered the family home and murdered the kind and compassionate teen in what was then theorized to have been a robbery gone long. The price extracted for the intelligent woman's young life a few boxes of coins, totally no more than three hundred dollars.

Speaker 2On the last morning of her.

Speaker 1Life, Monday, April fourth, Jennifer awoke early to get over to a practice which began at nine am. She was then attending Sterling High School, located just over a mile away from her home in the one hundred block of Jefferson Street. For Jennifer, a quick job would easily cover that distance in less than fifteen minutes. According to her coach and teammates, practice went off without any issues, and Jennifer seemed to be in good spirits. While no one seems to have accounted for exactly how long practice lasted,

Speaker 1it has been stated that Jennifer was done and back home on Jefferson Avenue by twelve pm. Over the course of the next few hours, Jennifer hung out around the house, but for her parents, Georgia and Mickey, it was an exciting day that was to be the beginning of a new adventure. Georgia was working as a bartender at the time, while Mickey ran a body shop. However, over all the years he'd run that business he'd always rented out space. That Monday, he was set to buy his own building

Speaker 1to house the operation in nearby Lawnside. In their excitement, the couple called home to Jennifer several times that day. As Mickey later told reporters, they were as elated as kids. On Christmas morning, at approximately three pm, Georgia called home and spoke to Jennifer. The two chatted for a short period of time as she checked in on how her daughter's day had been while updating her on progress with the body shop business. Forty five minutes later, Georgia called home again. This time it was to make dinner plans,

Speaker 1where she asked Jennifer to pull the meat from the freezer and drop it in the sink to the frost. Jennifer agreed and filled a pot with water, throwing it on the stove, setting it to boy. By the time her parents got home, mother and daughter exchanged I Love yous, not knowing that that would be the last time they would ever speak. The call ended at approximately four fifteen according to the official timeline. Jennifer next spoke to a friend from school. That call began at approximately five point thirty,

Speaker 1and it was during this call that there came the first indication that something strange might be going on. According to the Philadelphia Daily News, Jennifer's friend, who has never been identified, explained that while they were chatting on the phone, there was a knock at the door. Reportedly, it was a man who said that he was looking for Georgia and Mickey. After telling the man that neither was home, Jennifer went back to her conversation, but after several minutes noticed the man walking past her house again. It didn't

Speaker 1make sense. They lived near the end of a cul de sac, so the man shouldn't have still been in the area. His eye identity has never been determined, or at least if it has been, it's not been revealed publicly, but it is believed that this band was likely involved in the crime. The final sighting of Jennifer occurred approximately an hour later, sometime between six and six thirty PM, a neighbor glanced out the window and noticed Jennifer sitting on her front steps. Sometime over the course of the

Speaker 1next two hours, Georgia left work at the bar and drove over to the new garage Mickey had purchased from the garage. She called home planning to let Jennifer know what time they would be there, but this time the call went unanswered. Not thinking it was anything to worry about, the couple watched as electricians flipped on power to the building before closing up for the night to head home and celebrate. That night, however, their lives would be forever transformed, and what should have been the start of something great

Speaker 1became the first sleepless night in a life wrought with them. Arriving home at approximately eight thirty PM, Georgia and Mickey found the home completely dark. This was somewhat unusual, as Jennifer always turned on the lights when the sun went down. Together, the couple approached the back door and entered through the kitchen. It was here that Mickey caught sight of a shape he couldn't define, and upon turning on the lights, he saw Jennifer, his stepdaughter, lying on the living room carpet

Speaker 1in a pool of blood. When Mickey discovered Jennifer's body cold, he knew she was gone, and he would later tell the Philadelphia Inquirer quote, she was cold. It didn't just happen. At eight thirty pm, I literally put my arms around Georgia.

Speaker 2And dragged her out of the house. She was hysterical.

Speaker 1Neighbors responded to the sound of Georgia's screaming, and police were immediately called. Upon their arrival, investigators began examining both the scene and the body. While right off the bat they couldn't necessarily determine a cause of death. Camden County Prosecutor Edward Borden spoke to the media, noting that there were multiple incidents of trauma, saying, quote, I can only say that there was no gunshot wound. We've been sifting through the evidence. The investigation is proceeding. According to investigators,

Speaker 1there were no signs of forced entry, which left them with two possibilities. Either Jennifer had left the front door open it was a warm afternoon, allowing the intruder to enter without a struggle, or perhaps Jennifer may have let the killer in with it possibly being someone she knew or recognized. While there was no sign the home had been broken into inside, there were multiple indications that a massive struggle had ensued. Based on blood trails and broken glass. It appeared that the struggle had moved through the kitchen,

Speaker 1living room and ultimately ended near the base of the stairs leading up to the second floor. A heavy glass mug was shattered near Jennifer, and investigators believe she likely struck her attacker with it. Considering what appeared to be defensive wounds on Jennifer's arms and hands, police believed she fought viciously for her life. As Borden would later tell the Courier Post Quote, she put up a heck of a fight and her assailant had to suffer some bruises impossible cuts during the scuffle. At the very least, the

Speaker 1assailant had to be covered with blood when fleeing the house. Word was transmitted to investigators and local law enforcement, as well as hospitals and the media to be on the lookout for anyone who might have unexplained scratches or bruises. Also, considering the amount of blood at the scene, police believed there was a good chance someone would have seen the suspect fleeing in the area covered in blood. Trying to determine a motive for the crime proved to be trickier, at least at first examination of the house didn't show

Speaker 1any signs of robbery. There were credit cards, cards, and jewelry out in the open, but no attempt had been made to take them. No drawers had been opened, there was no sign the killer had been searching for anything of value. The autopsy would later confirm that Jennifer had not been sexually assaulted, and so what exactly had caused this atrocious crime to occur wasn't very clear. However, when Mickey was brought into the home to speak with investigators and have a look around, he quickly noted that something

Speaker 1was missing. On a shelf in the master bedroom closet, there had been four large, five pound containers filled with coins. The vast majority of the coins were Susan B. Anthony's silver dollars, though there were also some two and five dollars certificates. All told, the value was estimated to have been between two hundred and three hundred dollars. For the next thirty two years, Jennifer's case would ebb and flow

Speaker 1from actively investigator to cold and awaiting further information. For three decades, detectives and Jennifer's family worked hard to try and uncover the truth of not only why Jennifer had been killed, but who might be responsible. Now, a breakthrough DNA analysis has revealed not only the person responsible for Jennifer's murder, but also for the unsolved homicide of twenty four year old Mary Beth Welsh.

Speaker 2Case update.

Speaker 1In August of twenty twenty five, investigators attempting to solve a different homicide submitted key pieces of evidence from the crime scene to the New Jersey State Police Office of Forensic Sciences. The victim in that case was twenty four year old Mary Beth Welsh, who is discovered dead on a sidewalk along the three hundred block of Jackson Street in the city of Camden, approximately ten miles north of Magnolia. Sh'S body was discovered by the Camden Police Department at

Speaker 1approximately four to twenty four am on the morning of Sunday, November fourteenth, nineteen ninety three, five months prior to Jennifer's murder. According to investigators, Welsh was found with blood coming from her nose. She wasn't wearing shoes and had a sock on only her right foot, despite the fact that it had been raining earlier ending around three point thirty in the morning. Welsh's clothing was dry, suggesting that she may have been dumped close to the time at which she was found. An examination of the location appeared to confirm this,

Speaker 1as investigators did not find evidence of the murder at the site where the body was located, leading them to believe well sh had been killed elsewhere and then left at that location by the killer. Following an autopsy, it was determined that well Sho had been the victim of a homicide via strangulation. It was also learned that she had been sexually assaulted by her killer prior to the murder. Following the initial investigation, during which time law enforcement were unable to identify a probable suspect. A forensic examination of

Speaker 1Welsh's paid dividends when DNA belonging to a yet unidentified male was found on both her shirt and underwear. This sample matched up with one which had been acquired back at Welsh's home the actual crime scene. That DNA sample was obtained from blood which was found on the comforter of her bed. While the sample was identified as male, it didn't match anyone in the system, and so while it could be used to rule a suspect in or out.

Speaker 1When they took samples from men in her life, they couldn't find a match anywhere and eventually ran out of people to test it against. Five months later, Jennifer Persia was murdered in her home.

Speaker 2Her death was ruled a homicide, with the.

Speaker 1Cause of death being multiple insized wounds to the neck and chest, as well as ligature strangulation. The medical examiner also found several wounds described as both sharp and blunt. At the scene, investigators found blood evidence on Jennifer's socks, the lower level door towards the rear of the home, and inside of the master bedroom closet where the coins had been kept. A DNA sample belonging to an unidentified

Speaker 1male was found following analysis of that blood evidence. Again, like in Welsh's case, when the DNA was put in the system, it failed to deliver a match, and despite testing of men in Jennifer's life, the DNA hadn't matched any of them either. Both cases began growing cold, and at the time investigators didn't believe them to be linked, as they had no solid evidence connecting the two seemingly unrelated murders. In August of twenty twenty five, prosecutors decided

Speaker 1to reset submit Welsh's shirt and underwear to the New Jersey State Police Office of Forensic Sciences. Advancements in technology allowed a stronger profile to be developed, and when put into the system, it immediately came back as a perfect match to the male DNA found at the scene of Jennifer's murder. Still not knowing the suspect's name at that time, the decision was made to pursue investigative genetic genealogy in addition to new interviews with both new and previously interviewed sources.

Speaker 1Through this combination of investigative techniques, detectives were able to make a preliminary identification of a man named Francis Thomas Scooley, though at the time not yet confirmed. Investigator's next needed to obtain a sample from Schooley, but they hit a major roadblock. Schooley had been dead since the year two thousand. Reportedly, he had died by his own hand, and few details about him or his life have yet come to the surface.

Speaker 1In the absence of the suspect himself, investigators met with one of his parents and as sibling, at which time they were granted permission to gather a DNA sample from cheek swabs in early March of this year. Those samples conclusively link Schoolees DNA to both crime scenes, and the Camden County Prosecutor's Office Slash Cold Case Unit determined that there were sufficient probable cause to show that Schooley thirty nine at the time of his death, was the source

Speaker 1of the unknown male DNA discovered at both scenes. In the probable cause statement, it was noted quote the kinship analysis showed that it was four point eight million times more likely that the source of the DNA profile was a child of Schooli's parent than if the source of the DNA profile and Schooli's parent were unrelated. Unfortunately, with the killer himself dead, he would never face justice, and

Speaker 1while investigators had hoped to figure out his link to both victims, that work would be a little more challenging. Through additional interviews, it was learned that in the months leading up to Jennifer's murder, Schooley had been connected to her stepfather. Schooley had performed construction work at the Persia's home as well as at the Sterling Auto body shop, which was partially owned by her stepfather. In fact, it was learned Schooley was part owner of a mini race car which was sponsored by Sterling Auto Shop. Apparently that

Speaker 1loose connection was enough for Schooley to have either had a direct motive in targeting Jennifer or perhaps to have targeted the home, with Jennifer's murder being a secondary action. Nonetheless, the link to Mary Beth Welsh was somewhat weaker, though it was corroborated according to one Schooly's siblings. After being shown a foldo of Welsh, the twenty four year old was identified as a woman who had previously been seen in Schooley's company on multiple occasions. Ultimately, it was confirmed

Speaker 1that worst Schooly still alive today, he would have been arrested and charged with both murders, leading investigators to conclude that both cases have officially been solved, even if detectives and the families were robbed of seeing Schoolly charged, tried, and jailed for his horrendous actions. Whether or not Schoolly may have been involved in other crimes or murders remains unknown, but detectives are working to see if he can be tied to any other unsolved cases. Last week, on Thursday,

Speaker 1April ninth, a press conference was held addressing the closing of both cases. Detectives wore purple ribbons along with the victims' families in honor of mary Beth and Jennifer. Present at the press conference were Mark Persia, Jennifer's father, and Melody Beth Welsh, mary Beth's daughter, who had been less than one year old when her mother was brutally murdered and dumped on the sidewalk. It was a bittersweet moment for Melody, who told News twelve quote, it was very unexpected,

Speaker 1but I'm grateful for all their hard work. There's some closure, I guess it's the best word for it, the details of how her body was found. It's just kind of feels like she was alone, and I don't think anyone should feel that way. According to one investigator, had the technology of today been available in the early nineties, neither of these cases would have grown cold, and there's a chance that Schooley would have been caught after killing Mary Beth and before he could have gotten to Jennifer.

Speaker 2Prosecutor Grace C.

Speaker 1McCauley led the conference and credited investigators for never giving up dedicating years of service to trying to solve these cases. Macaulay said, quote, these cases never left the minds of our investigators, even as years passed. We must commend Sergeant Dennis Convrey and Detective Daniel Crawford for their unwavering commitment to the truth. No matter how much time passes, we will continue to pursue justice for every victim. In a

Speaker 1quiet magnolia park sits a beautiful gazebo which was erected in Jennifer's memory. The gazebo is surrounded by a small garden of flowers and adorned with a plaque that reads Jennifer Lynn Persia in the arms of God and in peace with the Angels. Her love and energy touched many people. May the happiness Jen shared always be with us and make us realize how precious life is. Sadly, while Schooley

Speaker 1managed to escape from facing justice, both cases have now been closed, and perhaps Marry Beth and Jennifer's families can get some semblance of peace or some assistance in moving towards closure, though in all reality, the wound from losing a loved one never fully heals. The road, though, may be slightly less bumpy as they no longer have to wonder if the killer is still walking free and perhaps targeting new victims. Much of the life and behaviors of

Speaker 1Francis Schooley remain a mystery. If you have any information about Francis Schooley which may be helpful towards adding additional context to the murders of Mary Beth and Jennifer, or perhaps which may link him to other crimes which have yet to be solved, please contact the Camden County Prosecutor's Office Homicide Unit SLASH Cold Case Unit by calling eight five six two two five eight four zero zero. You

Speaker 1can also submit tips online on their website at Camden Coountypros dot org Slash Unit SLASH forty nine. These links, as always, will be provided in.

Speaker 2The show notes. For now.

Speaker 1This concludes this special update episode. Jennifer's case was a frustrating one to cover, as it always felt like all the pieces necessary to solve that were there, but the links simply couldn't be made. Although it took more than three decades, I'm glad to see answers delivered to her family, even if justice could not fully be served. Although I had not previously covered Mary Beth Welsh's case, it's excellent news that her case has also been solved, and while it may provide little comfort now she was never forgotten.

Speaker 1Whether or not Schooly may be tied to other crimes remains to be seen, but he's certainly someone who's past is worth digging into. As always, I'll keep my eyes on what happens from here forward, and should there be additional updates necessary, I'll put an episode together. Just one quick reminder, Episode two fifty six will be out a little later this week, and trust me, this one's a doozy. What I originally understood to be a fairly typical missing person's case quickly exploded into one involving massive police corruption

Speaker 1as well as the involvement and corruption of multiple three letter agencies, namely the FBI and DEA.

Speaker 2You won't want to miss it.

Speaker 1So I want to thank you all for listening to this update, and I hope you'll join me later in the week for another unsolved case on the next episode of Trace Evidence. So far, this is our first case

Speaker 1update of twenty twenty six, and I'm certainly hoping this is going to be a year where I've got a lot more updates to cover.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 259 - The Ambush Murder of John Harden

    Nov 13, 20262 hr 44 minAudio

    On the evening of Saturday, March 22nd, 1975, thirty-two year old John Harden arrived at his Claremont, FL home after a work call with his wife and young son. John went upstairs to clean up when, a short time later, he...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. UPDATE - Faith Hedgepeth - Killer Found Guilty

    Oct 27, 202624 minAudio

    In September of 2012, nineteen year old Faith Hedgepeth was brutally murdered in her Chapel Hill apartment by an unknown individual. A thorough examination of the scene and evidence told a disturbing story of the young...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. UPDATE - The Tylenol Murders

    Sep 29, 202625 minAudio

    In September of 1982, seven people in the Chicago area died after ingesting over-the-counter Tylenol capsules that had been laced with lethal doses of potassium cyanide before being placed on store shelves. Although...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 258 - Bumble Bee Murders - Brandon Rumbaugh & Lisa Gurrieri

    Sep 19, 20261 hr 34 minAudio

    In October of 2003, twenty year old Brandon Rumbaugh and his girlfriend, nineteen year old Lisa Gurrieri wanted to find a special way to celebrate their one year anniversary. When a trip to Disneyland was too costly,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 257 - The Disappearance of Jerry Wolking

    Jul 23, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    Jerry Wolking was worried, but nobody knew why. He was fidgety, pacing and didn't want to talk about what was on his mind. Days later, her mysteriously disappeared after leaving his girlfriend's house. He has never been...

    Credit the people on this episode