On January 26th, 1977, twenty-four year old Melanie Flynn walked out from her Lexington, Kentucky job, climbed into her red, Ford Elite and drove off into the unknown. She has never been seen again. Immediately in the aftermath of her disappearance her father, former state senator Bobby Flynn, reached out a friend and police officer for help. He didn't expect the response he received. The Police weren't all that interested or concerned. They brushed aside the family's worries and assured them that Melanie had likely gone off with friends and would come back sometime soon. It wasn't until ten days later, when the missing woman's car was found, that a detective was finally assigned to the case. The initial investigation was described as poorly conducted and carried out by detectives who seemed indifferent to the plight of the Flynn's. When they received tips that the missing woman was seen in Florida they took that statements at face value and announced the case was closed. It remained that way until a cop, the very one Bobby had reached out to, sat for a controversial interview where he blasted the victim, called her a slew of insults and then issued his belief that she'd run off on her own and didn't need to be found. This interview would unlock a door that revealed the dark indications of a grander conspiracy in which Melanie may have found herself caught. Part 2 will be releasing Friday, June 5th, 2026. FollowTEPod.com Follow Trace Evidence on Social Media Twitter --- Instagram --- TikTok --- YouTube --- Like Facebook Page --- Join Facebook Group --- Threads --- Like MeWe Page --- Join MeWe Group --- Bluesky Suppport Trace Evidence Patreon --- Paypal --- Cash App --- Buy Me A Coffee Trace Evidence Merch Shops TeePublic --- ShopTEPod --- Spreadshop All Other Links Official Trace Evidence Website --- LinkTree Music Courtesy of: "Lost Time" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ "Chasing Time" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ "Galactic Rap" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ #truecrimepodcast #unsolvedmysteries #coldcase #coldcaseinvestigation #murder #murdermystery #missingperson #missingpersons #truecrimecommunity #mysterypodcast #truecrime #coldcasefiles #truecrimestories #crimelovers #truecrimeaddict #truecrimejunkie #crimescene #justiceforall #missing #crimesquad #podcastcommunity #sleuthsunite #darkhistories #criminalmindset #detective #detectivediaries #forensics #forensicfiles #crimestories #crimepodcast #traceevidence #traceevidencepodcast #criminalinvestigation #justiceforvictims #detectivework #truecrimediscussion #podcastfamily #listenandsolve #crimefans #listentotraceevidence #uncoverthetruth #podcastrecommendations #podcastlove #podcastlife #truecrimeobsessed #followtheclues #cluefinders #podcastaddict #unsolvedmurders #unsolveddisappearances #detectiveatheart #jointheinvestigation #disappearance #vanishing #abduction #gonemissing #upandvanished #pacheco #stevenpacheco #podcasting #crimetalk #crimeanalysis #theories #melanieflynn #bobbyflynn #dougflynn #billcanan #henryvance #drewthornton #cocainebear #cocaine #trafficking #escobar #medellin #lexington #kentucky #kentuckyunsolved Sources Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/trace-evidence--3207798/support.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1This episode is dedicated to my brother Daniel, who celebrates his fiftieth birthday this week. Happy Birthday, bro. Twenty four year old Melanie Flynn was well known throughout Lexington and the greater part of Central Kentucky. Daughter of a former senator with a talent for singing and an eye for horses, she was, by many descriptions, an insightful, intelligent, and talented woman.
Speaker 1She was vibrant and beautiful with a long line of suitors, but none could tame her wild heart. Melanie played by her own rules, and when she wanted something, she chased it down until it was hers. She was a fixture of the community, known by day for her kind endeavors and deep involvement with the rich horse breeding aristocracy, while by night she was a firecracker of a woman who lit up local bars and clubs with her amazing singing voice, undeniable charm, and limitless charisma. Melanie loved to be the
Speaker 1center of attention, so when she mysteriously vanished one night in January of nineteen seventy seven, people noticed. There were no easy answers or plausible explanations, and while her family fought for her, disappearance to be handled with seriousness and professionalism. They were met instead with indifferent investigators and a seemingly cold and detached police department. In time, it would be revealed that perhaps some of what directed investigators to turn a blind eye to the obviousness of the truth may
Speaker 1well have been in pursuit of their own self preservation. It would eventually become obvious, despite efforts to obfuse, skate and conceal the depths of police corruption infecting the ranks of the Lexington Police Department, that for some officers it may have been more advantageous for them where Melanie never found at all. Left with few options and even fewer people they could trust, the Flynn family had no choice but to sort through the wreckage on their own, while battling against a consortium of actors doing their best to
Speaker 1silence their cries for help and revelations of crooked and illegal acts carried out by the very people charged with enforcing the law. Local journalists, police figures, and elite figures of high society made it their duty to stamp down on any accusations of impropriety, while bending over backwards to blame Melanie's disappearance on the victim herself until the leaks began spreading and eventually the whole dam burst, exposing a massive conspiracy which reached all the way from the local
Speaker 1department to several federal agencies, with crimes revolving around extortion, drug trafficking, and murder. This is episode two fifty six, The Vanishing of Melanie Flynn, Part one. Welcome to Trace Evidence. I'm your host Stephen Pacheco. In today's episode, we examine the case of Melanie Flynn, who vanished out of Lexington, Kentucky,
Speaker 1in January of nineteen seventy seven. What initially begins as a so called run of the mill missing persons investigation will eventually spiral out into a massive conspiracy involving dozens of people spread across multiple federal agencies and police departments. It's a twisted story that ties into some other cases previously covered on the show, such as those of Norman Ladner and Chuck Morgan. It also involves cases we haven't covered but that you likely know, like those of Barry
Speaker 1Seal and Don Henry and Kevin Ives the Boys on the Tracks. The Octopus, as it is known, has many tentacles and the connection to Melanie Flynn may be one of the most overlooked, So without further do this is episode two fifty six, The Vanishing of Melanie Flynn. Melanie D. Flynn was born on Monday, November twenty fourth, nineteen fifty two,
Speaker 1at the Good Samaritan Hospital in Lexington, Fayette County, Kentucky, to parents Robert and Ella Flynn. Melanie was the Flynn's second of three children, born between an older brother, Doug and a younger brother Brad. Being the only daughter, Melanie received a lot of attention, and her parents doted on her a bit more than her two brothers. Friends and family described the young Melanie as a bright, intelligent, and fun loving girl who had a deep fondness for spending time with her family, swimming and enjoying long, hot summer
Speaker 1days in the sun. The love of Melanie's life was a debatable topic, with equal support going to one of two different categories, singing or horses. According to her f Bobby, horses were always in the lead, with him later telling the Cincinnati Post that his daughter's first real ambition was to be a jockey. She was a skilled rider, that was for sure. And newspaper articles speculated about her obtaining her athletic prowess from her father, who had played both
Speaker 1baseball and basketball for the University of Dayton before he was signed to a pro season with the Brooklyn Dodgers the very same year his daughter was born. She was also a talented singer who used every opportunity to carry a tune, whether carrying out chores around the house, hanging out with her friends, or participating in concerts in choir at school. There was no denying that she had a lovely voice. How far that voice could take her would be another question, and if you asked her father sincerely,
Speaker 1he'd have replied that she was an amazing singer, but her ability with horses was vastly superior. So talented was she that men from the Kentucky Training Center came to the family home asking for Melanie to work on their horses, noting that she had remarkably good hands. Unfortunately, it would be Melanie's love of horses that eventually led to a life changing injury that is debated by some nearly five decades later, may have played a role in her disappearance.
Speaker 1On Sunday, March twelfth, nineteen seventy two. The nineteen year old was working at doctor Arnold Pessen's training center when one of the workers there requested for Melanie to take one last run on a newly broken colt. Mel took on the challenge and ended up being thrown from the horse while it was in the midst of a full on run. She flew through the air and landed hard, receiving a ten inch gash from her eyebrow to the back of her head. Investigation of the incident never led
Speaker 1to any answers. Some believe that a strap broke, allowing her to be thrown, whereas others believed she had been a little careless and merely lost control. Being flung from the equine unconscious, Melanie was rushed to Saint Hubert's hospital, where she didn't wake up until two days later. When she did finally regain consciousness, she struggled with memory issues and reported that she had completely lost her senses of smell and taste. She never got them back. Ultimately, she
Speaker 1was kept in the hospital for three and a half months, not being released until nearly the end of June. Things with Melanie were never quite the same after the accident. Parts of her personality shifted. She became a little less agreeable and a little more impulsive. The accident also coincided with the year she turned twenty, and so a lot of those typical desires to take charge of one's own life and to do as she pleased may have been heightened from that head trauma. She started seeing a psychiatrist
Speaker 1to deal with some of the confusion in her mind and mixed up memories, but this approach didn't appear to address all of her concerns. No one can say with any certainty when, but eventually, she began using drugs to self medicate. It's worth noting that this was the mid seventies, and so a lot of people were experimenting with marijuana and other recreational drugs. Melanie wasn't all that different from the thousands of other twenty somethings who enjoyed going out to the bar, taking a few hits off a joint,
Speaker 1and maybe even chipping a little coke, which was growing in popularity. At some point, though, things clearly progressed beyond just having a good time, and it was clear to some that if not properly managed, this could become a major problem for the young woman. Whether or not any of her close friends or even family members were fully aware of the issue was unknown. Melanie, it was said, was an open book for the most part, but if she wanted to keep something hidden, she was quite good at it. Not long after leaving the hospital in June
Speaker 1of nineteen seventy two, Melanie's impulsiveness was on full display when she, seemingly on a whim, broke up with her fiance, University of Kentucky basketball star Ken Hollenbach. She'd met a new man, eighteen year old Stephen Snyder, the son of a rich Lexington horse breeder, just three weeks after meeting. On Friday, July seventh, the couple ignored the requests of their families to take things slow and ran off together to Jellico, Tennessee, where they were married. The marriage didn't
Speaker 1last long. On New Year's Eve, the couple attended a party in Aiken, South Carolina. At one point, Snyder knelt down to tie his shoe, and as he stood up, the back of his head clocked Melanie on the jaw. She was immediately knocked senseless and became dizzy and confused. From there, things continued to decline, with Snyder later telling the post quote after that everything starts going haywire. She was complaining about dizziness and really feeling weak, feeling bad.
Speaker 1She didn't get out of bed for about three days, and when she did, the first thing she did was call her mom. Really it was a homesick feeling. Ella planned to fly down to South Carolina to see her daughter, but before she could even book the flight, Melanie arrived home in Lexington on her own. While there, she met with a lawyer and filed for divorce, never seeing Snyder again. The next few years were somewhat of a struggle for the young woman, Coming to terms with the reality that
Speaker 1her dream of being a jockey was probably dead. In its place, she began putting more effort and energy into her singing. In the summer of seventy five, she moved to Cincinnati, where a promoter named Don Sheets got her a few gigs and auditions. For the most part, she set country, rock and show tunes. She performed under the stage name Melanie O'Hara and was a feature at both the Mediterranean Supper Club and one of the Ramada Inns. Less than a year later, she'd returned to Lexington, feeling
Speaker 1somewhat depressed. Her singing career wasn't exactly going the way she'd hoped, and though she had talent, she may not have had enough to catapult her into a major record deal. Back home, she tried once more, performing an audition for the Mark Davis Trio, who were booked at the then Continental Inn. She told her parents that they were wowed by her singing and hired her, but when their previous singer came back, they hired her in place of Melanie. Mark Davis, the leader of the band, later refuted the
Speaker 1entire story, saying they had never hired Melanie at all. The band ended up hiring another singer, Susie Carr, and despite the competition for that same spot, Melanie and Susie became good friends and would remain that way until the day she disappeared. According to friends and family, Melanie treated Susie's apartment, which she shared with her brother Tom, like a second home, and she was free to come and go as she pleased. In June of seventy six, Melanie
Speaker 1seemed to close the door on her dreams of being a singer, at least temporarily. She took a job offered to her by her father, working as a secretary at the Kentucky High School Athletic Association. It wasn't exactly the glitz and glamour of singing in clubs, but it paid well and she liked the people she worked with. Her night life was another story. Melanie earned a reputation as somewhat of a party girl, always enjoying making the scene and being the center of attention. She loved bars, clubs, discos,
Speaker 1and any place that was flushed with people laughing and having a good time into the late night hours. Some of her favorite haunts, little more than memories to the older crowd these days, were some of nineteen seventy's Lexington's Hottest Spots, the Library, Nellie Kelly's The Upstart Crow and Melanie made a lot of friends and acquaintances along the way, including a long line of suitors who found themselves drawn to her vibrant blonde hair, bubbly smile, and that always
Speaker 1impulsive attitude despite multiple attempts. Melanie was an independent woman who liked doing things her own way, and whether it was her parents or a potential boyfriend, she didn't like being told what she should do, even if it was the right advice at the time. Simultaneously, she lived at her parents' McKenna court home, and when the night kept her out too late, she'd just crashed elsewhere to avoid a potential lecture about her nocturnal partying. Regardless of the situation,
Speaker 1one thing was sure. Melanie was extremely close with her mother and shared everything with her. She had no qualms about telling the whole story, and whether her mother liked it or reprimanded her for it, she had no hesitance at all. Even when she'd lived in Cincinnati or during an ill fated excursion to Aspen, Colorado, she never went more than two days without calling home to speak with Ella. Melanie's younger brother, Brad, confirmed this, telling the Mayfield Messenger quote,
Speaker 1My sister was very friendly. She got along with everybody and would do anything for her family. She told Mom everything she did, the good and the bad. Debate rages about what was going on in Melanie's private life between taking the job with the Athletic Association in June of seventy six and her disappearance just seven months later. Anita Madden, wife of millionaire horse breeder Preston Madden, was a dear friend of Melanie's, at whose home she spent a great deal of time, and their closeness was shown through the
Speaker 1bond mel developed with Anita's young son. They lived at the time on a two thousand acre thoroughbred farm called Hamburg Place. The couple acquired a reputation for throwing lavish parties, but none topped their annual Derby Day gathering, where hundreds, if not thousands, of rich horse society folks would gather and party into the early morning hours. Anita claimed that Melanie was single, and though she had suitors, none had managed to captivate the young woman enough to warrant a relationship. Anita,
Speaker 1it's worth noting, would later deny having any closeness to Melanie after her disappearance, despite gobs of evidence to the contrary. Other friends and even some family members disagreed with Anita's revisionist history, noting that Melanie was not single at the time of her disappearance. In fact, she was involved with a local man to the degree that friend said she bluntly had told them she'd fallen head over heels for him. There was, of course, at least one problem. He was married,
Speaker 1and while Melanie told everyone who would listen that their relationship was serious, even saying they'd discuss getting married themselves. Friends warned her not to get too close. He was nearly ten years older than Melanie, already had a family, and despite what sweet words he might whisper in her ear, he was unlikely to leave his wife when it came down to it. His name was Bill Canan, and he was at that time a narcotics officer working for the Lexington Police Department. He also may be one of the
Speaker 1last people to have seen Melanie alive, and following her disappearance, will become an extremely prominent figure in both the investigation and the chaotic quagmire into which the search for truth became stifled. According to Bobby and Ella, something changed in their daughter in the weeks leading up to her disappearance. Throughout much of December and all of January, she grew a little more quiet, anxious, and paranoid. At the time, they thought it might just be emotions from the holiday
Speaker 1season catching up with her, or maybe a little bit of depression about her singing career. In the two weeks preceding her disappearance, that behavior became more erratic, Bobby Flynn, discussing that time, told the Post quote, she was just real upset and nervous all the time, and she couldn't sit still. Just for the last week or two, I noticed that her personality was changing. That brings us to the last week of January nineteen seventy seven and the last day that twenty four year old Melanie Flynn was
Speaker 1ever seen alive. The morning of Wednesday, January twenty sixth was a cold one in Lexington, with temperatures barely swinging from the mid twenties to the low thirties. Thick gray clouds hovered over the city throughout the day, with chilly winds sweeping in early and gaining strength in the hours after sunrise. For most people that day, it was coat weather, to be sure, and Melanie was no different. Arriving at work that morning at the Kentucky Athletic Association on Cooper Drive,
Speaker 1she climbed out from the driver's seat of her red Ford Elite and braced herself against the cold, pulling the belt tighter on her red leather jacket, which almost appeared as a matching accessory to the vehicle. Always fashion forward, friends had often joked that Melanie had only bought the coat because it matched her car, something she playfully denied. Although we know that Melanie arrived at work that morning without issue, no specific accounting has ever been given for how her time was spent and when she arrived. Regardless,
Speaker 1interviews with coworkers would reveal nothing out of the ordinary or remarkable about the early part of the day. At approximately four PM, Melanie received a call from her father. Bobby was at his insurance office and needed a favor. He asked if Melanie could send him a copy of the Little Red Book, which listed state high schools and their coaches. Bobby, always deeply connected to local and state athletics, served as a part time referee in his spare time. He noted it wasn't a rush and she could simply
Speaker 1mail it, but Melanie replied quote, Oh, I'll be coming home tonight. I can just bring it to you. I love you, daddy. Shortly after this call, Melanie picked up the phone and dialed her mother. During the conversation, mel asked what they were having for dinner and got really excited when Ella said they'd be doing a full turkey dinner with mashed potatoes and all the trimmings. Then, though, Melanie remembered she had an appointment with her psychiatrist after work at five point thirty and she wouldn't be able
Speaker 1to get home until after that, but her mother told her not to worry. They'd wait the extra time so they could all sit down and eat together. Elated by that response, Melanie told her mother that she loved her and she'd see her in an hour or two. Initial reports would later note that at five pm, Melanie stood up, covered her typewriter and pulled on her coat. Grabbing her purse, she turned to coworker Gene Batzel, saying see you tomorrow, before walking out of the building. Witnesses later reported seeing
Speaker 1a twenty four year old driving west along Cooper Drive before turning right heading north on South Limestone Street in the direction of her psychiatrist's office. Melanie never made it to her appointment, nor did she arrive back at her parents' home. She has never been seen alive again. Bobby and Ella waited for their daughter as they promised to, but she never showed up. They listened intently for the sound of her Ford Elite reving in the driveway, but were only met with the silence of an eerie stillness. Eventually,
Speaker 1the couple had their meal and assumed that Melanie was running later than she'd planned, or perhaps she'd gone off to do something else without calling. She could be impulsive in that way, and while no one thought lesser of her for it, you never really knew whether or not plans were officially locked in until Melanie actually showed up. People speculated whether or not that was a result of her head trauma, but others thought Melanie was just capricious. Suffice it to say, those close to her were used to it, and as a result, neither of her parents
Speaker 1were very concerned when she not only missed dinner but didn't come home at all that night. While that might seem concerning to an outsider, to the Flynn family, it was just another day in the life of Melanie. Over the course of the next few days, no one saw or interacted with Melanie, as far as is known. Several friends called the Flynn family home looking for her, but no one expressed any concerns, and they figured they'd catch up with her eventually. The first indication that something might be wrong came on the afternoon of Friday, January twenty eighth,
Speaker 1three days after Melanie had last been seen. That day, the phone at the Flynn home rang, and when answered, it was Melanie's boss. She hadn't been into work for days and hadn't called out six, so they wanted to make sure she was all right. Armed with that new information, Bobby and Ellis started making calls and driving around town looking for any sign of their daughter or anyone who might have some insight into her location, but they came up empty. In desperation, Bobby reached out to Lexington police
Speaker 1officer Bill Canan for assistance. Canan, as you may recall, was the man Melanie had told all of her friends she was in a serious relationship with. Canan had other connections to the Flynn family as well. He had previously been friends with Melanie's older brother, Doug. He'd been around the home before and had developed a relationship with Bobby too. The former senator asked the officer if there was anything he could do, and Canan said he'd look into it. Not to worry in all that more than likely Melanie
Speaker 1had simply gone off without telling anyone, as she was sometimes apt to do. Bobby tried to accept that, but impressed upon Canan that something felt different this time and he was very concerned. Canan, though failed to come up with any leads or information. In fact, Bobby felt like the officer was dismissive of Melanie's situation, and later noted that Canan acted as though he barely knew the missing woman. Bobby, feeling ignored by the copy he thought he could trust, on Saturday the twenty ninth, contacted the Lexington Police Department
Speaker 1and officially reported his daughter missing. Four days had passed by that time. Unfortunately, while the Lexington Police did take the report, several more days passed before detectives were actually assigned to the case. Initial interviews focused on coworkers who had seen Melanie in the hours leading up to her disappearance. At least one of those spoken with provided an interesting scenario. Reportedly, Melanie was last seen speaking to the occupants of a
Speaker 1dark colored vehicle on Cooper Drive. Neither the people in the vehicle nor the vehicle itself were identified by the witness, but it was noted that after speak seaking to them, Melanie got into her car and turned onto South Limestone Street. She was alone, and the witness didn't notice whether or not the dark colored vehicle followed her. Police later confirmed that when leaving work that night, Melanie had only twelve dollars cash on her, no checks, and no credit cards. Now, interestingly,
Speaker 1one might assume that being the daughter of a former senator might have afforded Melanie's disappearance some extra ink and coverage in the media, but the opposite is actually true. From the moment Melanie was reported missing, there was only a handful of small blurbs about her with little to no details. There were no interviews with friends or family, no full page stories or even photographs of the missing twenty four year old. In fact, nearly fifty years later, there are still only a handful of photos of Melanie
Speaker 1publicly available, and they're not in the greatest condition. Some would later argue that they felt from the beginning that this case was ignored, while others went further, claiming that the investigation was purposefully sidelined. The goal, it was argued, was not to find and recover the missing woman, but possibly to obfuse, skate, and confuse the details of the case until it could not be properly investigated, so that anyone or a group of people with power and prominence in the community might be shielded from having their own
Speaker 1illegal parallel activities exposed. The early stages of the investigation was primarily limited to interviews conducted by patrol officers, coworkers, friends, family, and anyone else they could find who may have had some insight into Melanie's location were also questioned. Despite the concerns of her family, Even a week after she vanished, Melanie's case was being handled as though she'd run off on an impromptu trip and simply had forgotten to tell anyone. Part of this, it seems, was due to Bobby Flynn's
Speaker 1open and honest discussions with the media. Bobby noted that his daughter had previously suffered head trauma, and it was possible she was having memory issues or even full blown amnesia, and didn't know who she was or even that she was missing. The argument would later be made, however, that investigators utilized this information more as an excuse for a half assed investigation that resembled little of what a missing person's case should actually be. Then, ten long days after
Speaker 1Melanie was last seen, a patrol officer made a discovery which threw a major wrench into any claims that the twenty four year old had left of her own accord. On Sunday, February sixth, Melanie's red nineteen seventy five fort Elite was spotted at approximately eight pm in the parking lot of the La Chateau apartments, located at five point thirty four Hollow Creek Road, less than five miles northeast from where Melanie had last been seen. The vehicle was in operable condition and didn't appear to have any damage
Speaker 1or indications of a struggle inside. Police noted the finding of several items. These included a suitcase and a garment bag with clothing inside, as well as the red leather jacket Melanie had worn the day of her disappearance. The only items reported as missing from the vehicle were Melanie's purse and keys. The jacket being left behind grabbed attention because it had been so cold that day it didn't make sense for her not to wear it. Bobby would later comment on the jacket and the car, telling the
Speaker 1Courier Journal quote her pocketbook and keys were gone. The fact that her winter coat was still in the car indicates to me that she had to either get into a car of somebody that she knew or else she was going to someone's apartment at Hollow Creek. The Lexington Police towed the vehicle so that they could conduct further analysis of both the interior and exterior, as well as to conduct an inventory of items found. Officers at the scene were directed to canvas the apartment complex and surrounding
Speaker 1home so they might discover when the vehicle had been left behind, and maybe, if they were really lucky, a description or identification of who had been driving it if it wasn't Melanie herself. It was presumed at the time that mel had probably been the driver, and why that the case, she had likely gone to the complex to visit someone. Initial interviews, though, failed to make those connections. Melanie's best friend told police that she didn't know anyone in the complex. No one there had seen the driver,
Speaker 1nor could they remember exactly when the car had shown up. One particular witness said he believed the car had been there about ten days, which would mean it was there from the very moment of Melanie's disappearance, but this couldn't be entirely confirmed. While they couldn't find anyone at the complex who would admit to knowing Melanie, there was one direct connection that the police initially missed. Melanie had previously lived at that complex. Whether or not this gave further fuel to the idea that she might be having some
Speaker 1kind of memory or mental health issue is unknown. Beyond that, the only detailed police made about the complex itself was that it was located in an area known for illegal drugs. At the time, this didn't mean much to the family or investigators, but keep it in the back of your mind because that detail will become very relevant later on. Back at the garage, police went through the vehicle but came up with little to offer insight. Both the suitcase and the garment bag contained clothing that the twenty four
Speaker 1year old had taken with her on a trip to Louisville a little over a week before she disappeared. Her leather jacket was recovered, but nothing about it was remarkable. There's no accounting for whether or not the police dusted for prints in or on the car, but I'd presume they did not, since there's never been any mention of Prince being found. When the vehicle was released into Bobby Flynn's custody, he noted that the driver's seat was pushed nearly all the way forward, which was consistent with his daughter's driving style. She was only five feet tall and
Speaker 1required the seat to be all the way forward. He wondered if his daughter had perhaps been lured or tricked into going to the complex, but no one could say that for certain. At the time, the Lexington Police announced that although they had found the car, they still hadn't come across any evidence that Melanie was the victim of foul play. Despite this statement, issued within hours of the discovery, two detectives were finally assigned full time to the case the next day, Monday, February seventh. Detectives John Bisick and
Speaker 1Al Bourne inherited an already flawed investigation that was nearly two weeks behind the eight ball. The detectives began by going through all of the notes and reports that were gathered. According to Bisick, they had a highly detailed timeline which established everywhere Melanie had gone and every person she'd spoken with or seen in the week leading up to disappearance, but they had very little information about what happened after, with Bisic telling the Lexington Herald quote on the twenty sixth, at five pm, we know Melanie turned right off Cooper
Speaker 1Drive on the South Limestone. From there, all we know is that ten days later we found her car on Hollow Creek. We have no direct evidence to indicate that Melanie Flynn has been an object of foul play, but we do have investigative findings that will not allow us, at this point in the investigation to treat this as a simple missing person's report. For the next few weeks, Bisick and Born worked the case in earnest, hoping to find something to lead them to the missing woman. They went through her bank in charge accounts but found nothing compelling.
Speaker 1All cab companies in the area had their records examined, wondering if mel could have taken a cab from the complex, but there was nothing there either. They started visiting stores, businesses, and nightclubs that Melanie was known to frequent, but they found no trace of the twenty four year old. Wednesday, March second, marked the thirty fifth day since Melanie vanished, but Bisic and Born were reaching the ends of their ropes. In the previous month, they conducted two hundred and eighty two interviews, not counting the more than two hundred people
Speaker 1who were spoken to during the canvassing of the apartment complex. Based on interviews in tips, they had acquired one hundred and sixteen investigative leads that they now needed to follow. Given how well traveled Melanie was, she had a history in several different states, Lexington Police notified law enforcement in Louisville, Cincinnati, Ohio, and Miami, Florida. Melanie had previously lived in Cincinnati, and her brother, Doug, was at the time an active member of the Red's Major League baseball team and also lived
Speaker 1in the city. To further spread word of the case, the teletype was eventually used to send out information to all law enforcement agencies in the Countryive Bhisick noted that while they were getting bits and pieces of information, they found themselves quote unquote, fighting our own investigation. The detective explained that people interviewed in the beginning of the case had spoken to other potential witnesses, some who had already been spoken to and some who hadn't yet. A lot
Speaker 1of rumors were drummed up, and one person's statements began to impact another's, and then things started getting blown out of proportion. One example given by Bisick, multiple people told police that a local man had seen and spoken with Melanie in the weeks after her disappearance. After taking two days to track this man down, they learned not only had he not spoken to Melanie, he didn't even know her. Bisick made a request through the Herald that if anyone
Speaker 1were calling with information, they'd be preferred if it was first hand and not something they'd heard second or third party. The passage of time, though, Well was putting the case more into perspective, with detective Physics saying, quote, she's twenty four, an adult independent. To have her disappear for a weekend as nothing but thirty four days is an absurdity. Up until a week ago, we thought she might be off on a lark. Now all of that has changed. Additional
Speaker 1and follow up interviews with friends and family revealed little. Friends were clear Melanie was loyal, very close to her family, and though she could sometimes choose to travel spur of the moment, she always told someone, usually her mother. None of them believed she would have run off for any reason, and even if she had, she wouldn't have stayed out of contact for that long. This belief was reinforced by her family, who pointed out that she didn't have a car, or clothes or makeup, which she didn't go anywhere without.
Speaker 1In addition, she'd recently received a tax refund checked from the IRS, but it had also been left behind. The Flim family were growing more frustrated, feeling that police weren't giving them any information, with Bobby telling the Herald quote, we haven't heard a thing. It seems like everything is a stone wall. One person interviewed by police was Melanie's dear friend, Anita Madden. However, Madden not only denied that the two were close, she even denied they were friends, referring to the missing woman as merely an acquaintance. She
Speaker 1was extremely resistant to the police, not allowing them to search her home and refusing to supply them with the contact information of Sonny Collins, a professional football player with the Atlanta Falcons. Collins knew Melanie, and the two had met through Madden, and police wanted to ask him about the missing woman and whether or not he'd had any contact with her in the previous months. When they finally did find him, he denied any knowledge, which led investigators to wonder why Madden had been so opposed to even
Speaker 1turning over his phone number. While some believe that perhaps Madden had something to hide. Others felt that Millionaire's wives simply wished to avoid any whiff of a scandal, and that desire for self protection led her to turn her back on her friend. Madden would later be arrested and charged with conspiracy, theft, and obstruction of justice in a case revolving around stolen grand jury materials and a drug trafficker with whom Anita allegedly had connections through a local nightclub.
Speaker 1A jury would find her not guilty of those charges. Whether or not she knew anything about Melanie's disappearance has never been revealed. At the end of March, it was announced that the Cincinnati Police were joining the investigation. A year earlier, Melanie had lived in Cincinnati, where she had worked as a singer in several clubs. Unfortunately, the investigation was already hitting the Rocks, as detective Bhusic and Born confirmed they hadn't found much of anything new and the passing of time was complicating their sins. Church Bisic stated quote,
Speaker 1as time goes by, it's harder to find someone who might have seen her the day after she disappeared, or it's difficult for them to put when they saw her into perspective, the case began to stall out, and for nearly the next two months it remained paralyzed by a lack of solid leads and information. The last week of May marked four months since Melanie disappeared, and police were no closer to finding her nor figuring out what exactly had happened. Detective Physic showed the Winchester Sun Melanie's file,
Speaker 1now six inches thick, but noted that he and Bourne hadn't added anything to the file since late March. Bisic went on to note that they had conducted much of the investigation through interviews, and that those interviews, totally more than four hundred by that time, were directly selected by combing through two of Melanie's personal notebooks, which were utilized as address books. Biz equipped that the missing woman kept track of people, even new acquaintances, saying quote, Melanie was
Speaker 1the type that if she met you tonight, she'd have your name in that book. Melanie's six inch case file had its status changed to filed pending, which meant that in less new information was found, there was really no further investigation which could be carried out. They needed more information and specifically actionable information to move forward, and they were hitting a lot of dead ends. Even Melanie's close friends, who initially expressed great concern and frustration, had begun closing doors and not answering calls, something Bisic attributed to an
Speaker 1emotional burnout on the topic of Melanie altogether. He played down the urgency others felt, noting again that they hadn't found any evidence of foul play, and as far as he was concerned, Melanie had probably elected to leave of her own volition and merely had chosen not to notify friends and family, He explained to the Winchester Son, saying, quote, she's an adult. She doesn't have to tell anyone where she's going, and normally we don't look for missing adults unless there's some evidence of foul play. Less than one
Speaker 1month later, in mid June, five months after Melanie's disappearance, detectives received a tip which not only revitalized the case but completely shifted the direction of the investigation. Detective Bhisick received word that Melanie had been spotted down in Daytona Beach, Florida, some eight hundred miles away. Two men from Kentucky claimed that three months earlier in March, they had run into Melanie and a group of young women in Florida, and that Melanie directly identified herself as Melanie Flynn. According to
Speaker 1the men, The women with Melanie confirmed that they were all from Kentucky, and through conversation, went on to discover some mutual connections with those men. Bhisic, learning of this, believe that only the real Melanie could have known who some of the people being discussed were. In hopes of finding Melanie herself, detectives Busic and Born were sent down to Florida to pursue that lead, seek out additional witnesses, and to make contact with local police departments in Florida to get their assistance. Bisick arrived in Daytona Beach on Thursday,
Speaker 1June sixteenth and began following up on the information. It didn't take long for him to arrive at the Texan Hotel. At the time, an extremely popular hotel in Daytona. Seven oh one South, a legendary nightclub known as one of the hottest spots in town, was owned by and part of the Texan Hotel. It was there that Bisic encountered two musicians who stated that they'd met Melanie and were able to identify her from color photographs. Bisic had Brawn with him, unaware of where Melanie might be. The two
Speaker 1men notified Bisick that she'd made mention of plans to leave Florida for a trip to Knoxville, Tennisee d Armed with what he considered case breaking information, Bisic went on to find no less than seven other witnesses who also claimed to have encountered Melanie between March and June. Among these additional witnesses was a female who worked as a hospital administrator in an emergency room who said Melanie had come in for treatment with an allergy problem, which Bisic considered reliable since Melanie did have some allergy issues and
Speaker 1was on medications. Two clerks working at a hotel also id'd the missing woman from photos, as well as a third clerk from a different hotel. A woman club owner also claimed to have seen Melanie in recent weeks. Bisic would write in his report that they had found nearly fifty people who allegedly met Melanie, but that not all of their information could be considered reliable, so he'd only really pursued the seven. Although he never saw Melanie nor
Speaker 1found any actual evidence of her presence in Florida, returned to Kentucky completely convinced that the twenty four year old was alive and well, partying in the clubs and on the beaches of Daytona. Bizick noted that they hadn't merely relied on photo identification, but also corroborated details like what type of jewelry she was wearing, her activities, and physical descriptions as a result of this visit. On Monday, June twentieth, just four days later, Detective John Bisick declared the case closed in a statement addressing that Bisick wrote, in part quote,
Speaker 1Flynn was identified by several witnesses as being in Daytona Beach during a period that extends from March to June of nineteen seventy seven. Facts learned through the investigation allowed detectives to identify Flynn through photographs, personal belongings, activities, and associations with certain witnesses. The possibility of foul play as being part of her disappearance has been eliminated, and due to that elimination, the investigation has ceased. While that evidence
Speaker 1may have sufficed for Bisick and the Lexington Police, it did little to move Melanie's family. Bobby Flynn came out strongly opposed to the closing of the case, noting that absolutely no evidence had been produced to show that Melanie had actually been to Florida, not to mention, there were other inconsistencies which didn't sit right with the family. Bobby explained to The Herald, saying quote, we just don't think it's Melanie. I think it's someone who looks like Melanie. There are many conflicting stories in the things Busick told us.
Speaker 1There were two or three things that just don't sound right. If she were going down to Daytona Beach, we can't understand why she would go down without any money, without any bathing suit, without her car. She didn't take anything. Reportedly, Busick could not find any evidence of Melanie Flynn being registered at any of the Daytona area hotels, leading him to believe that she was using a false name, but her father found that to be rather contradictory as well, wondering quote, if she was trying to hide or get away,
Speaker 1she wouldn't tell complete strangers that she was Melanie Flynn from Kentucky. Hard to argue with that logic. The family also struggled to accept that hotel employees and musicians in Daytona Beach would truly be able to differentiate their daughter from the countless thousands of other young women flocking there for spring break. For Bobby Flynn, it was a matter of a positive identification, one which he wouldn't feel secure in until it came from someone who actually knew Melanie.
Speaker 1According to the family, while Melanie could certainly be impulsive, she never went anywhere without notifying someone of her plans, and generally speaking, it was her mother that she would tell. In Bobby's opinion, the police couldn't break the case and ultimately decided to use the Florida statements as an excuse to shut down the whole investigation so they could just move on. There was, of course, another interesting reason for the family's doubts. Back in March when the first sightings began,
Speaker 1Melanie's younger brother, Brad, and her mother were on vacation in Daytona Beach and were staying at the Texan Hotel. They never saw the missing woman, nor anyone who they thought even looked like her. In addition, the family called Bhysic's description of the identifications into question, noting that multiple people had identified the jewelry Melanie was known to have been wearing, but not the person who was actually wearing it. Some witnesses described Melanie inaccurately getting details like height, weight,
Speaker 1and hair color wrong, while others reportedly acknowledged that they couldn't be certain that the woman they had met and the woman in the photos were one and the same. In those instances, they claimed, Bisicks still reported them as matches. Bobby Flynn noted that he'd been trying to get the FBI involved in the case, subtly calling in to question the reliability of bysics reporting. Bizic countered, stating that they had conducted an extremely thorough and reliable investigation. He noted that in the months leading up to the Florida discovery,
Speaker 1they had interviewed more than six hundred people, utilized Army National Guard helicopters to search for shallow graves near to where her car had been found, covering an area of thirty five square miles. They'd spoken to psychics in both Paduca and Lexington, and they'd followed up every lead obtained for Melanie's friends, no matter how vague or gossipy it had sounded learning that Melanie was in Florida was in some attempt to shut down the investigation, but instead the very conclusion to which the investigation had naturally led, according
Speaker 1to the detective, Regardless of how the family felt, the case remained closed and the investigation ceased until a newspaper interview with another police office entirely turned the case on its head. By August of seventy seven, much of the fanfare surrounding Melanie's disappearance had died down, from Detective Physic announcing that the case was closed based on his own belief that the missing woman was alive and well in Florida despite never actually finding her, to Melanie's own family, who,
Speaker 1out of frustration in feeling that their words were being twisted by the media, stopped granting interviews or even given quotes at all. Her name fell out of the headlines, and as far as much of the general population were concerned, she was somewhere on a sunny beach, completely unaware of all the strife and pain stirred up by her absence. That sentiment, though, was completely shattered when the Lexington Herald Leader published a lengthy, detailed and controversial interview with Lexington Metro Police Officer Bill Canan. Officer Canan, as you'll recall,
Speaker 1was a friend of the Flynn family and the first member of law enforcement that Bobby reached out to when he couldn't find it daughter, also the man that friends claimed Melanie had been in a deep relationship with. Canan was made aware of Melanie's disappearance within two days. Over the course of the next one hundred and sixty seven days, he had nothing to say to her family or to investigators. Then, all of a sudden, on Friday, August twelfth, the interview dropped and all hell broke loose. Canan spent the majority
Speaker 1of the interview doing his best work to cast Melanie Flynn as a drug addicted, alcoholic, compulsive liar flake who couldn't be trusted or relied upon for anything of importance. Simultaneously, he details his relationship with her, which he describes as purely business, claiming that Melanie had been working as a confidential informant for him for some time prior to her disappearance, specifically in terms of helping him make major drug arrests. Oddly, he never addresses the disparity of using someone he describes
Speaker 1as a compulsive liar as a reliable source for building cases or arrests. According to Canan, he first met Melanie shortly after she was divorced, which could be any time after January of seventy three. Canan says that he helped Melanie move into a new apartment and eventually built a case against her for possession of marijuana. Instead of arresting her, they worked out a deal where she would introduce him to people in the drug scene so that he could build cases against them. At the time, Canan was working
Speaker 1in the Lexington PDS Tactical Unit, which was disbanded prior to Melanie's disappearance. Canan says that between late seventy four and early seventy five, he would go out with her twice a week to parties and other social gatherings where drug activity was taking place. Canan used the cover name Reynolds, and Melanie introduced him to people as her partner, sometimes saying boyfriend, other times saying fiancee. Canan claimed this was always the cover story and that they had never had a personal relationship. To further support that, Canan stated that
Speaker 1there was no room for impropriety on either of their parts, as he and Melanie were never alone because he always had someone with her for backup. Contrarily, Melanie's family have stated that the two had a relationship which went way beyond professional work, and that mel herself had told them that she was in a romantic relationship with the cop. Canan says he made approximately twenty arrests as a result of working with Melanie, and that eventually the scope broadened, with mel providing him with information about crimes unrelated to
Speaker 1drugs as well. Reportedly, she had a lot of connections in the horse industry, entertainment industry, and with big time gamblers who lived in or just passed through the area. Canan also said that in addition to working off her potential charges, Melanie had in the past brought problems to him so that he could fix them for her. This, he claimed, included traffic tickets and even in one instance, a charge of drunken driving. Canan also claimed that despite being forced into the job, Melanie found the undercover work
Speaker 1glamorous and exciting. He also claimed that Melanie's family were fully aware of her being an informant, saying quote it didn't seem to bother them that was a statement everyone in the family strongly denied, later saying they had absolutely no idea Melanie was working for Canan, with others saying not only were they unaware of it, they didn't believe a word Canan was saying. Though Canan claimed her disappearance had nothing to do with their work together, he also pointed out that her car was found in an area
Speaker 1known for drugs that he had previously targeted through his work with Melanie. In a thinly veiled attempt to depict Melanie as a member of those same criminal communities and to give her a negative look, Canan told the Herald Leader quote, she was known to deal with black drug dealers. The last time I saw her, she was drinking and taking pills. She was having a hard time coping with something. In addition to these statements, Canan told the press that Melanie was under psychiatric care and that it wasn't out
Speaker 1of the ordinary for her to simply disappear on a whim. Canan further described mel as quote an attractive playgirl who was very self destructive. He claimed that she had previously lived on a commune and at one time had ridden along with a dangerous motorcycle gang. At the same time, he noted she had a tendency to exaggerate, saying that with mel a claim about a pound of cocaine usually turned out to be less than an ounce. Canan added quote, she was the type of person who wouldn't let you
Speaker 1help her. She always sought escape. It was a downward spiral, according to Canan. When the missing person's case was officially filed, he turned over a list of people who could have been involved due to their previous work together. That list was delivered to Detective Bhisic, and Canan claimed there was at least one name that got investigated closely. That name belonged to Mario Crespo, a horseman and movie producer. Detectives never managed to tie him to Mell's disappearance. However, asked
Speaker 1about the family's denials of his claims and their belief that police hadn't done enough to find her, Canan dismissively replied, quote, they have to look at this through emotionally tinted eyes, while the police do not. This interview seemed to backfire on Canan. Rather than dismissing Melanie away entirely, it lit a new fire and the headlines were once again splashed, with the story then either done intentionally by someone with an ax to grind or through one of the most
Speaker 1astonishing coincidences in Kentucky law enforcement history. Six months after Melanie's car was found, and just two days after Canan's interview was published, new pieces of physical evidence mysteriously appeared. The waters of the Kentucky River flow into a marina located at Camp Nelson, approximately twenty miles south of Lexington. There, floating in the water in a debris field between two docked boats was Melanie's missing purse. The discovery was made
Speaker 1at approximately eleven thirty am by Grace Proctor, an administrator with the University of Kentucky's Medical Center who also runs a woodworking shop in Camp Nelson. Proctor said the purse appeared to be expensive, describing it as eight inches by eleven possibly made of burlap, with a leather lining and shoulder strap. Upon opening the purse, Proctor found two prescription medicine bottles, a tube of lipstick, and a perfume atomizer. One prescription bottle was ineligible and contained what appeared to
Speaker 1be the remnants of decomposing pills. The other was clearly labeled prescription number seven sixty one Dash nine three five Melanie Flynn Pbzsr one hundre milligrams filled eleven twenty six seventy six by doctor Mayer. These pills were later identified as Melanie's allergy prescription. Proctor called local authorities and the person contents were taken into custody by Jessamine County Sheriff Gene Goldie, who then turned the evidence over to the
Speaker 1Lexington Police. Lexington PD stated they would analyze the contents and then write up a list of information they'd like the lab in Frankfort to determine for them. Among their list of questions would be how long had the purse been in the water, which they hoped to determine by figuring out how long it would take the prescription pills to reach the powdery level of decomposition they were found in. Bobby and Ella Flynn learned about this discovery through the local media and quickly became frustrated that they hadn't been
Speaker 1contacted by authorities. When they were able to examine the purse, they couldn't say with one hundred percent certainty that they recognized it as Melanie's though Ella pointed out the twenty four year old had just purchased it three weeks before she vanished. At the same time, they felt their identification didn't matter since the purse contained Melanie's prescription medication. Lexington Police claimed that they had tried to notify the family earlier in the day but couldn't and assume no one
Speaker 1was home because their calls had gone unanswered. Bobby and Ella denied that claim, noting that they had been home the entire day and hadn't received any calls from the police. Ella said they had been contacted by multiple reporters that day because they were in fact home, and it was ultimately one of those journalists who convinced the police to notify the family, which they finally did ten hours after the discovery at nine thirty pm. Ella was able to
Speaker 1identify the prescription, noting it as being pyra benzanine, an antihistamine prescribed by Melanie's longtime doctor, Lloyd Mayer. The prescription was filled at the former will Done Drug Company, then located at two ninety South Limestone Street. Despite the finding of the purse and prescription bottles and the need to analyze the evidence, Lexington Police maintained that the case remained closed. Ten days later, Melanie's older brother, baseball star Doug Flynn, sat for an interview with the Lexington Herald, who Canan
Speaker 1had previously spoken with, and completely dismantled the officer's statements, going directly on to accuse the officer of flat out lying. According to Doug, he and Canan had previously been friends for several years, spent a lot of time together, and the officer had become very close with the family. He stated that Canan was involved in a relationship with his sister and that was why she had worked with him, not because she was involved with drugs herself. He stated, quote,
Speaker 1all of a sudden, he comes out and says he didn't know Melanie very well and he was only doing it because he was helping her get off of a marijuana charge, that he was letting her work for the police. That's a lie. That's an outright lie. In Doug's mind, the only reason for Canan to create such a patchwork of lies was to cover up something bigger, telling the paper quote, the only thing that makes sense to me is that it looks like somebody down at the police department. Somebody down there got caught. Something's happened, and I can't
Speaker 1believe that the FBI won't come in and help. On Friday August twenty sixth, two weeks after Canan's interview in the discovery of Melanie's purse, a press conference was held by Lexington Mayor Fred Pettitt and Metro Police Chief Nolan Freeman. Freeman stated emphatically that the case had never been closed, making a fiery though semantic argument that cases are never closed. They're either cleared or pending. Asked about detective physics highly
Speaker 1publicized statements that the case was closed, Freeman replied that that was just the detective's personal terminology. Apparently Chief Freeman didn't think this was important enough to make that distinction two months earlier, when the Flynn family were raising hell about the case being closed and every headline ran with the quote unquote personal terminology of the detective. Chief Freeman concluded the press conference saying, quote we will continue to review, evaluate,
Speaker 1and if necessary, investigate any new information in this and all other police investigations. Well, I'm sure that went a long way to convince the people of Lexington of their police Department's ethics and drive but I digress. Four days later, on Tuesday, August thirtieth, it was announced that both Detective's bhusic end Born would be returning to Florida to try and locate Melanie Flynn while her person and its contents were delivered to the FBI Crime Lab Washington for a thorough examination. The Florida trip was supposedly to track down
Speaker 1the original witnesses and to find new ones to corroborate their story and hopefully to locate Melanie herself. While this was happening, Chief Freeman issued an amendment notifying all officers that, moving forward, they were not allowed to reveal the identity of any former or current confidential informants. In what the media called a direct and highly public rebuke of Officer Bill Canan's interview on the Florida side of things, Detective Bhisics stated that they were looking for a Miami based
Speaker 1man who worked in real estate because he allegedly spoke to Melanie two weeks before her disappearance. Bisick believed speaking to the man might help establish that the missing woman planned to disappear. Detectives found the man's name scrawled in one of Mel's notebooks and said that he was the primary reason for their return to Florida. Initially, they tracked down some of their previous witnesses, but reported the media coverage had complicated things, as now everyone thought they had seen Melanie. That in and of itself was odd because
Speaker 1there was vastly more media coverage leading up to their first trip, but Bisick felt no concern at that time that media coverage had impacted those witness statements. On Wednesday, August thirty first, Bisic and Born left Daytona Beach, traveling two hundred and seventy miles before stopping in Fort Lauderdale. Along the way, they handed out flyers with information to police departments in Fort Pierce, Pompino Beach, and the Cocoa Beach Cape Canaveral area. They arrived in Fort Lauderdale at
Speaker 1approximately eleven PM, where they made plans to visit several area nightclubs that Melanie was theorized to have previously visited. What that theory was based on is hard to say, since it was never revealed. Then, the officers made their way further south, arriving in Miami, where they found at least one new witness. According to Bisick, a bar maid working at what a local Miami cop called the most popular disco tech in town, claimed to have encountered Melanie back in May, nearly four months earlier. Many people questioned
Speaker 1her statement, wondering how someone would remember a fleeting encounter with one woman mixed in with thousands of others several months earlier. Bisick also claimed to have found two playboy bunnies who also said they had seen Melanie. Investigators did manage to track down the Miami real estate man, though they did not disclose his name. According to their interview with him, he'd met Melanie and Miami during a visit several weeks prior to her disappearance. He confirmed speaking to the missing woman on the phone weeks before she went
Speaker 1missing and discussed a potential move to southern Florida, but that was where their contact had ended, with the man saying he hadn't heard from mel since some days prior to her disappearance, and if she had moved to Florida, she had done so without his help. Joorne claimed they had obtained information showing that Melanie had traveled to Miami with Tom Henry, a liberty business consultant and cattle breeder. Henry, who local papers claimed had previously traveled with mel during her time in Cincinnati, was alleged to have put Melanie
Speaker 1up in a luxury resort with another person, an unidentified female, in the first week of January, three weeks before her vanishing. Upon issuance of this report, several local papers wrote articles detailing that Henry partied with Melanie, was involved in the drug scene, and also claimed that he had been photographed with Melanie less than two weeks before she disappeared. Henry denied all allegations and demanded retractions from the Kentucky papers. He noted that he hadn't lived in Cincinnati for four years,
Speaker 1leaving back in nineteen seventy three, which would completely throw off the timeline as the report claimed he was there in seventy five alongside Melanie. Henry also pointed it out that yes, he was in Florida with Melanie and another woman, who he identified as singer Susie Carr. However, it was well known by police and Mel's family that she returned from Florida on January tenth, while Henry stayed in the Sunshine State, making it impossible for him to have been photographed with her back in Kentucky. According to Henry, he
Speaker 1last saw Melanie during that Florida trip and he'd had no contact with her since. Although the detectives in local papers made a lot of claims about Henry, nothing ever came from them, and after he denied any involvement and threatened legal action for defamation, his name was never mentioned again. While in Miami, Born in Bisick checked with the Florida Racing Commission authorities at Calder and hihale Erase Tracks, under the idea that the missing woman might need to satiate her interest in horses. At Calder, the detective spoke with
Speaker 1a security guard who noted that he thought he'd Melanie in the area since May, which experienced investigators Busic and Born considered a convincing enough statement for the security guard to be written into the report as another direct, confirmed witness. They met with the local police and asked for assistance in searching through both police and public records for any trace of Melanie. Became up empty. They were fairly certain that she had been living down there, as they had been since their first visit, but they could find no
Speaker 1proof rather than confronting the possibility that they had been wrong and Melanie was not in fact living it up in Florida without any money, or her clothes, or her car or anything but the shirt on her back, they suggested that she might be using her old singer names Melanie d or Melanie O'Hara, or perhaps a new pseudonym. Detective Bhisick, pressed about this by the Herald Leader, stuck to his guns, saying quote, there was not a trace of miss Flynn in the records, but that doesn't mean
Speaker 1she couldn't have been here since then, or that she couldn't be here now. Bisick, however, fails to note that none of what he reported means that she couldn't still be in Kentucky or any other place in the world either. Bisic and Born returned to Lexington empty handed. Not only had they found no tangible evidence of Melanie being in Florida at any time after her return on January tenth, they couldn't verify any witnesses from the first trip, and though they acquired new ones, they were seen as dubious
Speaker 1by both Mel's family and the local media, who were starting to ask more questions. Finally, for months, Kentucky journalists appeared to be playing softball with the police, but as more time passed and the demand for answers continued to grow, they started asking more frequent and more pointed questions. Captain Robert Duncan of the Lexington Police Department spoke with the Career journal about the investigation and for the most part, stood behind the work of Busyes and Born, noting that
Speaker 1the department believed the Florida witnesses and that Melanie was somewhere in the Daytona area. Asked about Bisic previously calling the case closed, Duncan noted that that merely meant they had run out of leads, which is difficult to swallow since no experienced detective would refer to a lack of leads as a closed case, especially not while being interviewed by the media. Duncan stated that they were and had been doing everything they could to find Melanie because the community had been very loud about it. But it's worth
Speaker 1noting that if it was Chief Freeman who ordered the investigation to continue, not Duncan who had allowed Physic to close it. Following the Florida trip, Busic and Born were put on a tight leash, at least when it came to speaking to the media. Both men were told in no uncertain terms that they were no longer authorized to discuss Melanie's case with anyone outside of the department, and that all media inquiries were to be directed to their supervisor, Ergent Drexel Neil. Sergeant Neil told reporters they were hoping
Speaker 1to get some response from the flyers they'd handed out in Florida, and that he thought their new witnesses were likely more reliable than the previous witnesses. For the most part, though, the case grew quiet again. Then a few months later, in November, ten months after the disappearance, lab results returned from the FBI's analysis of the purse found with Melanie's medications inside. The FBI confirmed the purse was the expensive Christian Deor purse Melanie purchase prior to her disappearance. They
Speaker 1also confirmed the medicines were those prescribed to Melanie, but they were unable to determine how long the purse had been in the water. They inventoried the purse's contests as being two tubes of lipstick, two bottles of prescription medication, one for an infection, another for asthma. The purse was tested for fingerprints, but those results were not released. However, I did say that they had found some quote unquote trace evidence which they could use to identify a suspect,
Speaker 1but they didn't say what exactly that evidence was. Neither could they say whether it had come from a person or an object. Following the release of the lab report, the Lexington Police confirmed that after finding the purse, they had had teams of officers combing the riverbanks, docks, bridges and spillways nearest to the scene and up to thirty five miles away. Officers searched through the water for any additional items that could be found, including any signs of Melanie's body. They followed the Kentucky River from Camp Nelson,
Speaker 1six miles south of Nicholsville, heading northeast until they reached the area of Clay's Ferry. Despite extensive searching throughout the area, they recovered nothing besides Melanie's purse, and at no point have they ever determined how or by what method her purse ended up in a river more than twenty miles from where she had last been seen, Seemingly another area of interest that led only to a dead end. January of nineteen seventy eight would mark one full year since
Speaker 1Melanie vanished, and police had said little in the previous months. Detective Bisick, asked by The Herald Leader, replied only with I'm not going to reveal my personal feelings about it. While Bisick and the folks most closely work in the case weren't talking, a familiar cop still had a lot to say. Officer Bill Cannan, who had previously described Melanie as a former confidential informan and troubled drug addicted party girl in what many have called a blatant attempt to dissuade interest in her disappearance, wasn't quite finished yet. He
Speaker 1went on to tell the media that not only had Melanie been a CI for him, something her whole family denied, but she had also been working for three or four other detectives of the Metro Police Department, as well as law enforcement officers in other states. Apparently he forgot to mention her extensive work with other police officers during his first interview, almost as if he hadn't quite distanced himself enough from the missing woman. Then off the cuff, Canan revealed that while he had ceased officially working with Melanie
Speaker 1two years before she vanished, He'd also forgotten to mention that he did run into her just two days before she went missing. Present was twenty five year old Thomas Carr. Carr met Melanie through his sister, Susie, a nightclub singer, and they became friends in the month prior to the disappearance. Melanie had been staying at Tom's place, located at the Harrodsburg Square apartment complex, less than two miles from where she worked. According to Tom, it wasn't uncommon for Melanie
Speaker 1to crash at his place if the night got a little too late, or on occasions where she wasn't getting along with her folks. According to Tom, on Monday, January twenty fourth, two days before the disappearance, he was alone at the apartment when the phone rang between four and five pm. He answered and was asked by an unidentified caller if Bill Canan or Melanie Flynn were there. Carr said no, and noted later that he hadn't previously met Canan through Melanie, but she had mentioned him. Approximately five
Speaker 1minutes later, the door swung open and Melanie strode in with Canan by her side. The two sat on the couch in the living room and began talking quietly. Tom felt they were trying to avoid him overhearing anything, because they whispered more quietly whenever he entered the room, and so he decided to leave the apartment for a while, saying they clearly wanted to be alone. According to Tom, when he returned a few hours later, he found Melanie in rough shape. She was lying on the couch and
Speaker 1seemed dazed and out of it. Tom tried to chat with her, but she couldn't keep up. Her eyelids were heavy and she kept dozing off. Finally Tom decided to let her sleep and went to bed. The next morning, she was doing well, and Tom didn't ask any questions about Canan nor what had happened, feeling that something was surely strange, but it wasn't really his business. That morning, he helped mel carry some clothes out to her car, and when she drove off, he was under the assumption she'd be returning to her parents' home. According to Tom,
Speaker 1Melanie came and when as she pleased at the apartment, and so he figured he'd see her a few days later. The last time Tom spoke to Melanie was the day of her disappearance, Wednesday, January twenty sixth. The two chatted on the phone when she rang up the apartment. Tom later stated she sounded fine and said nothing about any concerns or worries. The conversation was short, with her telling Tom that she needed to swing by after work to pick up an address book she'd left behind, but she never showed up. When he couldn't get in touch with her,
Speaker 1he made several calls to her office, to her parents, and finally to Officer Canan. Tom felt that Canan was annoyed by his call, telling the Herald Leader quote he acted real, cold, callous and withdrawn from it all. He said, I could file a missing person's report if I wanted. Tom found the interaction strange because Melanie had told him on numerous occasions that Canan always knew where she was and what she was doing. Canan later said the phone
Speaker 1call Tom had answered had come from an undercover officer, Drew Thornton, his partner. According to Canan, he was there seeing Melanie on official business, contradicting his previous claim that they had stopped working together for years. A friend of Tom's, who was also a cop, allegedly told him a different story, claiming that Melanie had called Canan to the apartment because she needed a traffic ticket fixed. Asked about their time together that night, Canan had no explanation from Melanie condition
Speaker 1when Tom returned. According to the officer, the two left the apartment after Tom had left and went to grab drinks at a local bar. Canan claimed that Melanie gave him some information about drugs and other crime related information, but no cases developed from it. Canan, who by nineteen seventy eight was working in the police department's training unit, was at the time of the disappearance, working in an administrative position, but was also still doing undercover narcotics work for both the Metro Police and federal authorities. The Lexington
Speaker 1Police stated that through the investigation, they'd already ruled out Mel's alleged work as a CI as being connected to her disappearance. Detective Bhisic strangely included that they knew who Melanie spent the night with before she disappeared, but that they would not be revealing that name. Both Tom and Susie Carr expressed concern about Melanie's disappearance, with both noting their inability to accept that she could have just run off. Susie stated that mel craved attention and it wouldn't make
Speaker 1sense for her to withdraw from everyone that gave it to her. In her mind, there was something sinister with her, saying quote, I think she got knocked off because she was involved in some kind of a dope deal. Tom agreed with his sister for the most part, especially about Mel's need for attention, saying quote, Melanie had to be the center of attention wherever she was. She had it and she flaunted it. It seems hard to believe she would just drop out of society like this. Susie, for
Speaker 1her part, suggested that perhaps Melanie had been killed and that the local police were involved in a cover up, though she couldn't explain why that would be the case. She wondered aloud why the police hadn't used the lie detector to weed out some people, and why all more than four months later, they still hadn't dragged the area of the Kentucky River where the purse was found. So Lexington police, asked about these details, deny to cover up and stated that they had done everything they could to that point. Even consulting with psychics, they confirmed that they
Speaker 1hadn't polygraphed anyone during the investigation, and in regard to the river, said they didn't have a specific location where the purse entered the water, so they didn't have a pinpointed area to do any kind of dragging at. For the remainder of nineteen seventy eight, nothing much is done with Melanie's case. Any new information and leads received or tracked supposedly, but nothing develops. The family remains steadfast in their focus on trying to keep Melanie's name in the headlines,
Speaker 1but local media begins turning away, and what were once front page stories become backpage blurbs with little or no meat on the bone. For the most part, Melanie begins to be forgotten, at least in the minds of the public. The new cycle moves quickly. Different atrocities rise to the surface, and reporters grow weary of writing stories without new details or more accurately, without something to hook a larger audience. Journalism is, at the end of the day, a for profit enterprise for the newspapers, and people aren't putting down
Speaker 1any extra money to read the same story with the same details time and time again. Things were finally settling down, and for those that allegedly wanted the story to disappear, much like Melanie herself, they shielded themselves beneath the blanket of that silence. While Melanie's name began to fade. There's at least one person associated with her case who proves himself not only to be a very controversial figure, but also a shining example of how to disenfranchise and alienate
Speaker 1so many of your coworkers that even those who previously defended your position choose to turn their backs on you once again. It's our old friend, Officer Bill Kanan, who can't seem to keep his foot out of his mouth nor display e in a shred of the honor and dignity that one might expect of a man who swore an oath to protect and defend. Canan in nineteen seventy nine is one of the most recognizable figures in the Lexington Police Department. Local papers write about him as though
Speaker 1he's a blend of an honorable Kentucky cop cross with James Bond. We'll get into that later, and trust me, it would be funny if it wasn't so sad well. Nineteen seventy nine becomes a major turning point for Canan when he finally runs into a brick wall that even his status as the president of the Fraternal Order of Police cannot break through. Canan, for some reason, starts making accusations that local police, some of whom work for his own department four years earlier in nineteen seventy five, were
Speaker 1all involved in a break in and an advertising agency, which they then covered up. Rather than bringing this to his superiors or filing an official complaint, Canan chooses to air his grievances in the local papers, who are always more than happy to write up little puff pieces for him. During a discussion of these claims that the department, Canan apparently grew extremely angry and began shouting obscenities at Chief Freeman when he demanded to be put in charge of the investigation, and Freeman denied that request. At that point,
Speaker 1Freeman informed Canan that he was suspended without pay, and the officer responded by throwing his keys at the chief and ultimately having to be restrained by Captain James Matthias when he reared back as though he was going to take a swing at the chief. This temper tantrum lit the fuse that would ultimately lead to Canan being permanently relieved of duty. At a disciplinary hearing, three people testified that Canan's conduct was undermining their department and that his poor behavior and bad attitude had been negatively influencing the
Speaker 1department for some time. The Urban County Council was reviewing the testimony and claims, which came from a local reporter, Rick Willinzick of WBLG Radio, as well as two top names in the department, Chief Freeman and Assistant Chief Frank Freiman. Yes, Freeman and Freeman. I know it sounds like a bad joke, but it's strangely true. Full charges against Canan included, but were not limited to, insubordination, incompetence, disobeying orders, and violating
Speaker 1police policies by making unauthorized statements to the press. Chief Freeman stated that Canan's public accusations against several local officials quote severely handicapped the division of police. Assistant Chief Freeman, who had previously awarded Canan a commendation back in nineteen seventy one, said Canan's behavior resulted not just in a loss of confidence for the department, but a complete loss of confidence in Canan himself. Freiman said they now needed to question his abilities as an officer, and he could
Speaker 1not be relied upon to handle things in the appropriate way. Chief Freeman added that a prime example, noting that Canan's interviews in nineteen seventy seven regarding Melanie Flynn had severely hindered their ability to conduct a full and thorough investigation previously, Freeman had to issue a new order that officers are never to reveal the identity of a confidential informant, no matter how much time had passed. Furthermore, Canan was accused of publicly and unfairly criticizing the department's training program, policies,
Speaker 1and communications equipment. In the end, the board sided with police officials and approved Canan's termination from the department. Canan, in response, went scorched earth on the department in new interviews and later launched his first of several lawsuits, all of which would be fruitless efforts to recapture his job. At this point, the case takes on a major shift. While Melanie's disappearance continues to be investigated, the woman herself seems to fall between the cracks instead. Over the course
Speaker 1of the next fifteen years, throughout all of the nineteen eighties and well into the nineteen nineties, the focus turns from a single missing woman to an examination of multiple disappearances and murders, all of which are allegedly tied together. For you, dear listener, what that means is that, as we conclude Part one, Part two, we'll see our primary focus shift from the disappearance of Melanie Flynn to her likely connection and possible murder at the hands of a group of people actively participating in a wide swathe of
Speaker 1illegal crimes known throughout Kentucky as the Bluegrass Conspiracy. In Part two of The Vanishing of Melanie Flynn, we will dig deep into the so called Bluegrass Conspiracy as we follow former officer Bill Canhan and a notorious group of
Speaker 1friends and co conspirators as they engage in a wide array of crimes, including but not limited to, witness intimidation, planting evidence, drug trafficking, and murder. The players involved will run the gamut from low level police and former police, to federal agents and even members of the Lexington Legislature. It's a wild story that only gets darker the deeper you plunge, and it becomes highly evident that this is but one previously ignored tentacle of a grander conspiracy known
Speaker 1as the Octopus, and Melanie Flynn may be one of its earliest victims. One day, I've really got to dig deep into the octopus. Is that something you'd be interested in hearing? Make sure you let me know see you in Part two,
On the evening of Saturday, March 22nd, 1975, thirty-two year old John Harden arrived at his Claremont, FL home after a work call with his wife and young son. John went upstairs to clean up when, a short time later, he...
In September of 2012, nineteen year old Faith Hedgepeth was brutally murdered in her Chapel Hill apartment by an unknown individual. A thorough examination of the scene and evidence told a disturbing story of the young...
In September of 1982, seven people in the Chicago area died after ingesting over-the-counter Tylenol capsules that had been laced with lethal doses of potassium cyanide before being placed on store shelves. Although...
In October of 2003, twenty year old Brandon Rumbaugh and his girlfriend, nineteen year old Lisa Gurrieri wanted to find a special way to celebrate their one year anniversary. When a trip to Disneyland was too costly,...
Jerry Wolking was worried, but nobody knew why. He was fidgety, pacing and didn't want to talk about what was on his mind. Days later, her mysteriously disappeared after leaving his girlfriend's house. He has never been...