Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Tink Magic

Tink Magic artwork

What's IN & what's OUT for podcasts in 2026 | LIVE session replay with Arielle & Lauren

Jan 9, 202657 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

So…What’s In and What’s Out for Podcasting in 2026 (From two people who talk over each other, love podcasts maybe too much, and really don’t want you to waste your time) At the start of every year, all corners of the internet put out “ins and outs” lists. Fashion, media, sports… almost every industry participates. And we find these lists really fun to read! What would it look like for the podcast industry? A few years ago, we were sitting at our favorite restaurant (Màlá Project) - the kind of place we go to so often that showing up not together has raised questions among the staff who’ve come to know us - and we got started writing down our thoughts. This list has turned into an annual tradition. This is our fourth year doing it. And once again, we decided to talk it through live. This replay is full of us interrupting each other, changing our minds in real time, and sharing what we hope is actionable, tangible advice and things to think about for creators. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit podcastmarketingmagic.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01We are here today to discuss our podcasting, what's in and what's out for 2026 post that we just posted today. It is the fourth annual post. We have done this for the last four years, and it started because Lauren and I were at our favorite restaurant just a few years ago, and we go all the time, probably once a month. But we were there a few years ago when we were thinking about how all of these trending lists come out every so often around the new year. Ins and outs when it comes to media.

SPEAKER_01Ins and outs when it comes to etiquette. Ins and outs when it comes to whatever. And we were like, what would that look like for podcasting? And more specifically, what would it look like for podcast creators? So that is the origin of our podcast. article and we just put out our 2026 version of it. And we've got a lot to say and to dive into in more detail. And that's what we're planning to do today in this live chat. If you're just joining us, feel free to tell us who you are in the chat. What brings you here today? What is a podcast that you're listening to that is not your own?

SPEAKER_01But let's jump into it. Lauren, who are you? What is a podcast you're listening to that's not your own? And what are you excited about to discuss today?

SPEAKER_00Hmm. My name is Lauren Passell and I founded Tank Media and I am excited to, I guess, you know, like you and I haven't talked about this this much.

SPEAKER_01No, we wrote it asynchronously.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I guess the things that the things that you were the most excited about, do you know what I mean? Like we wrote together.

SPEAKER_01But I want to know the thing that you're like, this, this. Yeah, yeah. And I think what's also cool about this list is that From 2021 to 2023, Lauren, you and I worked together very closely on marketing campaigns. And for the last two years or so, we've been working in adjacent circles. And sometimes we help each other out with certain clients. But we've also been developing our own philosophies when it comes to marketing and growth and the changing times. So I'm curious about how some of our ideas have evolved

together and maybe separately.

SPEAKER_01And we probably have different experiences with clients. Wait, I just remembered, though, the other thing I'm really excited about.

SPEAKER_00What? Because we finally listen. We have a million projects going on all the time. And I'm always like, when are we going to get to do something together? Because we do stuff together all the time. But we don't do anything public-facing together, except for speak at conferences. It's like everything. But we don't have, well, for example, a newsletter or a podcast. And now we have a newsletter. We do. We do. Drop it.

SPEAKER_01Drop it in the chat. Drop it in the chat. We will. It's called Podcasts We Text About because we text about podcasts all the time. Sometimes it's nice and sometimes it's mean and sometimes it's just recommendations and sometimes it's... The host was weird on this episode and we want to talk about that. So we're going to dive into some of our text messages and the things that deserve a little bit more of a deeper dive. We're going to get into that. Hi, Elvin. Hi, everybody who's joining us. We're so excited that you're here.

SPEAKER_01We have 26 people live right now, which is awesome. And I realized I didn't introduce myself. My name's Arielle, and I write a bunch of things about the podcast industry right now. I am mostly focused on my always existing newsletter, Earbuds Podcast Collective, which is about to be nine years old. And anybody is welcome to curate a list for me. I also write more thoughts on the podcast industry in my newsletter called Podcast Plunge. But as Lauren mentioned, and she just dropped the link in the chat,

SPEAKER_01we started a newsletter together. And a lot of you are subscribing right now, so that's super cool. I'm getting notifications as we go. Today, though... We are discussing a list that we wrote, that we published today in Podcast Marketing Magic that we're going to get into some details on. And what we do in this issue of the newsletter, what we write about is what we think is in for the upcoming year and what we think is out. And it's predictions,

SPEAKER_01but it's also mixed with our hopes and dreams, also mixed with things that we just wish would stop. In order to end on a positive note, let's start with things that are out. How does that sound, Lauren?

SPEAKER_00Perfect. So we're not going to go through every single thing that is out and every single

SPEAKER_01thing that is in. Maybe what we'll do is we'll read each of them and we'll decide which ones we really want to get deeper into. I think, yeah, we can just take turns on the ones that we're like, this one cannot go unnoticed.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01I feel passionate about this one. So why don't we start with the first that is in our out list, the drop blasts. I feel, yeah, I feel passionate about this one because, so feed drops work or feed swaps work.

SPEAKER_00I mean, feed drops work also. You can buy a feed drop. You can pay someone to put an episode of your show onto their feed, or you can do a swap where you put each other's shows on each other's feeds, a swap. But I feel like every time I bring up the idea of a feed swap to one of my clients, they go, ugh, like everyone hates feed. them, but they were and they're good. So why is that? And it's because everyone does them wrong. Almost, almost, almost everyone does them wrong. They could be magical if you put a little bit of work in them.

SPEAKER_00So I won't name any names, but certain you'll you'll you see this if you follow a lot of podcasts. If there's a new show on the network, you see that first episode in every single feed that that network has access to at the same time with no editorial difference. With the same title. That makes people mad. It makes people, maybe I'm speaking for myself. People like K.A. Lauren and me. Everything. But okay, so I was talking to you.

SPEAKER_00The first person that I think started changing the game on this, and correct me if I'm wrong, was Roman Mars and 99% Invisible. He does feed drops that are editorialized. They're no longer feed drops. And I was talking to him about this later, recently, and I was like, he did this collaboration with Endless Thread, and he's just a very collaborative person with 99% Invisible and all the work that he does. He's like, well, ew. He's like, I don't call them feed drops. I call them features. Ew. Maybe he didn't say ew, but I could see it on his face.

SPEAKER_00Let's start. Maybe. I don't know what to do because it's like feature. Maybe I just need to get rid of the word. I didn't write. I love features. Features is a great way to put it. Okay. Let's right now you and me. No more using that word. And some people might be like, what? They might not get it, but we're going to shift. The tides will shift and everyone will soon know what a feature is. And a feature means there is a feed drop still, and that's bad. The new thing is the feature, which means you put the episode on, but you introduce it. You know, Question Everything did a really good job with this.

SPEAKER_00They featured an episode from another show. I can't remember. But they had this story at the beginning how one of the producers was like, you just really love this episode of this other show. Like, In a way, they could almost get more people interested than less. Instead of driving people away, it's actually like, wait a second, there's a story here. Feed drops can be so good. There's so much potential and they truly work. So. Out. Feed drops. Low features. And also, I would say one more thing.

SPEAKER_00And this is some of these things like feed into each other. Yes, a lot of it. So much about audience size. If you find the perfect audio match to do a feed swap with, don't worry if they are way smaller than you. Trust me, it's worth it. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Okay. I just want to add one thing to this, which I think we've been playing with the philosophy behind this for a while with if you find the right If you find the right partner, if you find the right, what do we say, play date for your podcast to be swapping with another podcast, it won't feel like you're shoehorning it in to a show that doesn't make sense. It's going to sound like really great complimentary podcast.

SPEAKER_01content. I'm going to use content, but probably media. It's going to sound like really complimentary storytelling, whatever it is, to that show's audience and to your audience. And because of that, your audience is going to think of you as a curator of great content that That brings them joy, that brings them education, that brings them whatever it is that they're looking for. So I love the idea of setting up features with other shows. And out for 2026 is Feed Drop Blasts. So we are, for the folks who are just joining us,

SPEAKER_01going through an article that we just published today. It's our ins and outs for podcasting trends for 2026. We're currently going through some of our outs. Some of these we're going to go in depth on. Some of them we're just going to say the thing and move on to the next. Let's go to number two, boring bonus content that isn't actually that much of a bonus, just clearly a place for you to put your leftover stuff. Lauren, would you like to say something about this?

SPEAKER_00I feel so strongly about this. Because I feel like this is coming because we're just seeing more and more shows relying on Patreon and stuff like that. And I think when this started happening, I'd talk to creators who were like, oh, I guess I'll just... Oh, my God. Like, give the Patreon subscribers, like, unedited audio or something. And it's like... That's, like, not a present. Or, like, I mean, in rare cases. But, like... Or they just have a casual conversation about something else.

SPEAKER_00But what I have started seeing and I want more of is real thought, like an entire other miniseries. Or what if the hosts are watching Breaking Bad? Why did I say this? I don't know. Something else together where it's real. Another investigation, if it's a true crime show or something like that, where... someone has actually put a lot into it. There is a real drive and strategy behind the bonus content, or it's completely different than what everyone else is doing

on bonus content.

SPEAKER_00It's not just a throwaway. It's really offering... Something that you could enjoy on its own. Anything else?

SPEAKER_01Yes, yes. I think there was a few years ago when subscriptions were introduced, there was a thought that was, you can't just take away ads. You need to give something to the people that are subscribing, that are paying money for subscriptions. you know, for your membership. And the easiest thing to do in that situation is to say, here's our unedited episodes. We are, you know, we're sharing the embarrassing stuff with you. We're sharing the things, the uncut, the raw, whatever. But I think that that is almost a disrespect in a lot of cases.

SPEAKER_01It does seem like a throwaway. So I think Lauren is spot on when she says we need to think of We need to think of complementary stories. We need to think of complementary concepts for episodes that are going to be exciting. And in our in section, which we'll get to in a bit, we share a few example ideas that you might be able to take on for this bonus content. So if anyone in the listening has an example of good bonus

content they'd have ever

SPEAKER_00experienced or done for their own show, I would love to hear it. That's something I want to start looking into this year. That's fine to keep track of people that are doing interesting things.

SPEAKER_01And that's a Lauren promise.

SPEAKER_00And also... Not Jennifer Marmers here. I feel like MaxFun does a really good job with bonus content. Maybe Jennifer... I think that's true. Yeah,

SPEAKER_01because they have such personality-driven shows that people have been, you know, glomming on to their love for those hosts for so long. But also, I have gotten... I've been like... I've been a supporter and I've actually... like been witness like been part of very creative part uh projects like on art projects with with uh supporters and stuff like that so anyway yeah the next sundrive it true well uh amazing yeah yeah yeah could give a master class on that

SPEAKER_00so i should just

SPEAKER_01For those who are just joining us, Lauren Passell, Ariel Nissenblatt. I'm Ariel. That's Lauren. We are here to discuss our article, which, Lauren, do you mind dropping it in the chat just for the folks who have joined us recently and for the folks who might be catching us later? Thank you for being here. We are discussing our article ins and outs for podcast. Sorry to interrupt.

SPEAKER_00I'm doing our newsletter again.

SPEAKER_01We also have a new newsletter and it's called Podcasts We Text About.

SPEAKER_00Do you have to tell them why we interrupt each other?

SPEAKER_01oh yes, we interrupt each other a lot. It's because we are passionate and sometimes we disagree and sometimes we agree. And one time we got yelled at for this and at first we were really embarrassed and we vowed to change and then we were like, you know what? This is who we are. So take it or leave it. So... We are discussing this article that we just put out. We're going through our outs first. There are a lot of overlaps between our ins and our outs, but we're now on to number three. And we may focus in depth on some of these, and some of them we're just going to skip over.

SPEAKER_01As always, keep the chat active. Let us know who you are, what brings you here. Write some stuff. Let us know that you love us, and let us know what podcast you're loving as well. We are desperate for love and attention. Not really, actually. We'll do this no matter what. Okay, next. Number three. Out. Giving up on promo swaps or other collabs because they didn't convert in huge numbers. Let's do this one quickly because I think we've mentioned a few of these principles.

SPEAKER_00Don't give up. Yeah. Don't give up. I feel like, how many times do I talk to someone and they're like, I did a promo swap.

SPEAKER_01It didn't work.

SPEAKER_00You have to test. It didn't work. Yeah, you're doing something else wrong. It's not the promo swaps, honey. It's you. Ask yourself. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So let me go to the next one. And I really do like this one. Number four, nonspecific ad slash promo copy out. Yeah. A lot of times when you're setting up a promo swap with someone or a feed swap or whatever, they're going to send you their talking points. And those are going to be the talking points that they send to a lot of different people. It's the easiest thing to do. But those are going to sound rote. They're going to sound memorized. It's going to sound like you're reading off of a script. So what we highly recommend doing is getting in touch with that show and what it actually means and how it makes sense for your potential.

SPEAKER_01So it's for your listeners who may or may not be interested in it. Why? What's the reason that this show is right for them? Why do you want this promo swap to be in your feed in the first place?

SPEAKER_00I would also say if you're sending copy to give a specific episode that those listeners, if you're sending copy for another podcast to read for a promo, send them an exact episode and make it different for every single one. And another thing we've been doing a lot, um, is instead of like promo swaps, like with a two minute promo or something, or a 30 second promo, doing more creative things, like maybe there is a promo, a 30 second promo. Maybe we're doing a trailer swap,

SPEAKER_00but we're trying to get the host to introduce the trailer or the promo. It's a combination. We used to just say, do you want to do host red or digital? Now we're like, can we do both? Because there's certain shows where you got to hear the audio, right? Like a beautiful show, you have to hear the audio. And there's certain shows where the host should really is very going to be very convincing to the audience. But if you can do both, sometimes the best of both worlds, if you can swing that is a really good idea.

SPEAKER_01Love that. Great addition to our out, which is that we're kind of sick of nonspecific ad slash promo copy. Get specific. And let's move on to the next one. I think we can do this one quickly because it's kind of like you either agree or you disagree with this. Out. Everyone thinking that they need a YouTube channel. And this goes both ways. Yeah. Everyone thinking they need video is one thing, but also YouTube is, it can be great. It's a great search tool.

SPEAKER_01It is a tool, it is a platform that gives you amazing analytics if you've got people actually coming and watching and or listening. But the number one thing that you can do today if you haven't already is you can submit your RSS feed to YouTube so that you do have a YouTube channel. You can create playlists for your podcast and they will stay audio only. There are, of course, some ways to add video and we will share a few more of those in the in section or you can talk to us about it later. There are definitely some ways to play around,

but there will always be people who love your audio only show and there is money in

SPEAKER_01the audio only stand. If you know what that's from, put it in the chat. Lauren, anything to add?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, just that, I mean, I think people, I have a lot of clients that are smaller, not even tiny shows, but that think they have to have video. And it's like, I guess you should have video if you want to be one of the bigot, like the very, very large podcasts should have video. But it's a show, it's a TV show. And I do think the gap is kind of widening between podcasts those shows, right? Like the one, like something that'd be going to Netflix and something that really, really needs high quality video and something that doesn't.

SPEAKER_00So anyway. I think we're going to see more and more creators in 2026 double down on I'm an audio only show. Me too. Oh, yes.

SPEAKER_01Number six, let's just do this one.

SPEAKER_00Bonus, because I don't even think that's written down in the post.

SPEAKER_01That was like... No, yeah. We're riffing here.

SPEAKER_00We're riffing.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Patrick Ellis. There's always money in the banana stand. All right, number six, AI. We joked about it. We fucked with it. We're tired of it. That's it. That's it. That's the out. Also out, obsessing over download numbers and not even considering other metrics. Lauren, quickly, what are some other metrics that people should obsess over? um how about time spent listening how about how about that i was just sorry i'm the derailer everyone that knows me knows this i was just listening to someone that i was talking about their news resolution they're a book editor

and they were like everyone in book because i used to work in book publishing how many books did you read this year how many books did you read this year and he was like actually i'm going for pages because i don't want to over like finishing the book and moving on

SPEAKER_00how much actual reading am i doing That makes so much sense to me. How much actual listening are you getting? How much time with you are your listeners spending? I said that sentence terribly, but that's one. The gist is there. What's another metric, Ariel?

SPEAKER_01Another metric that you might consider focusing on is... Maybe you've decided that you want to track comments on your Spotify episodes. Maybe you've decided that you are putting really valuable links in the show notes of your episode and you are upping your game when it comes to getting people to click on those. So how many people are actually clicking on those? Track those links. You can use a trackable link in order to do that. So just choose some other things to focus on. And try to make that a goal of yours for 2026. It's not how many downloads did I get on this episode,

but it's let me check in on these other metrics that I've set out for myself.

SPEAKER_00Or if you're setting goals for your show this year, like maybe like trying to get more people listening to the whole episode. See how the listen through rate goes. Let's skip ahead a little bit because I want to make sure we get to spend a lot of

SPEAKER_01time with our in section. For those who are just joining us, we're going through our article that we just published, our ins and outs for podcast marketing for 2026. I'm Arielle. That's Lauren. Let's move on a little bit in our out section. Out, treating your audience as viewers, not listeners, because people are still listening without watching. What does this mean, Lauren?

SPEAKER_00I'm starting to notice that podcasters are referencing where they are, like, look at this beautiful thing or using props or watching things on screens a lot that if I was watching, I'm sure I would know what they were talking about. But it's kind of insulting to the listeners. We've been here. We're still here. We've been here. We'll be here. We'll be here, but we don't know what you're talking about.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I'll say Amy Poehler, when she first started her podcast, Good Hang, was doing this a lot. She was referencing things that were happening in the scene a lot that obviously people who are watching would understand. And she has done such a great job naturally fixing that and now saying, listeners, for those who are not able to watch or who are not watching or who will never watch, here's what's happening in the scene. And at first I was like, wow, she did such a great job picking up on that. How is it possible to flip that quickly?

And then I'm like, oh, she's an amazing actor and takes direction really well.

SPEAKER_00So that's cool. In my favorite episode, the Philly Justice episode, she actually at one point says, you should probably not watch this. You should hear it with your ears first. Wow. Wow.

SPEAKER_01I believe in her. I believe in her. Do that. Let's hit on this one. Out. Faces on cover art, unless it really, really, really makes sense. This is something that has been on our list for a long time. What do we mean by this? I mean, I just think it's... Once again, Roman Myers calls them face casts.

SPEAKER_00It's like a... Where it almost, to me, now signals... That it's not about good storytelling. It's not about good audio. It's about someone with a microphone. Listen, I'm not saying that all podcasts with faces on them are bad, but I think it's kind of like ick now. It's not a good look, if you ask me. Ariel? It just should not be the default.

SPEAKER_01I think a lot of people tend to think... Oh, this is my podcast. Let me make it very clear that this is my podcast. Same with when people put a microphone. And do we have that on this list this time?

SPEAKER_00He's on the list again. And also, I would love a year where we don't have to tell people not to put microphones on their podcast.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. As Albin Brooks says, we don't put video equipment in film posters to show, to prove that this really is a movie.

SPEAKER_00Someday. Someday. Someday. I think that will be the longest remaining thing on our every single year we do this. Or the air horns.

SPEAKER_01We'll get there. We'll get there. Let's hit a few more of our outs before we go to our in section. Let's do this. I really like this one. Number 13 on our outs, bankrupting yourself or shortening your season because you spend a chunk of your budget on full scale video. So we talked a bit about video before. Let's get a little bit more into it now.

SPEAKER_00You go. Okay.

SPEAKER_01This is, yeah, this is big. I would much rather you have a 10 episode season of audio only, maybe with a few clips here and there, than a three episode season because you've decided that all of that budget needs to go into video. It's better for me as the listener, for all of your listeners who get to spend more time with you, but it's also better for you because you have way more time to market this show that lasts 10 weeks, for example, rather than three. Also, if you put all your money into video and it flops, You put all your money into video and it flopped.

SPEAKER_01Thoughts?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I couldn't agree more. Yeah, same, underline. And you can still incorporate video and visual elements without going all in on

SPEAKER_01renting a studio, getting some fancy lights, or even building a studio in your own place, or even recording remotely and still paying a video editor to make it look good and all that. You can, number one, have a newsletter where you share maybe videos, but also just visual elements of things that you talk about. You can have chapter artwork for the different things that you're talking about and then refer people in your audio-only voiceover to look at the chapter art so that they can have a visual reference there.

SPEAKER_01Those are just some quick ideas for creating a visual touch point with your listeners without needing to spend money on video. And again, all of our advice, all the things we're saying, they are not for every single person at every single stage of their production journey. Video could be right for you. We can talk about that, but it could also not be right for you. And I don't want anybody to feel pressured to spend a lot of money to get this thing out into the world that could get out into the world and beautifully if it's just audio only.

SPEAKER_00Also, I know I'm biased because I love marketing and I think marketing is important, but I can't tell you how many times I've talked to people that come to me in need of marketing and they have spent a lot of money in video and then they say, sorry, we don't have money to market it. And I'm like, man, like, I would spend my money. Tragedy. It's a tragedy.

SPEAKER_01Oh, my goodness. Yeah. Think about how many great stories are not getting out into the world because they didn't have enough of a runtime because they spent all the money that they had on video and on promotion within YouTube. Any hoodle. And yeah. Right. Don't say sorry. Derail.

SPEAKER_00Go. Derail. I mean, I also get a lot of clients that are like, okay, they freak out about video. I'm not making fun of anyone. It's just like, this is what happens. And this is what happened to me too. They freak out about video. They're like, I've been told I need video. Then they get video. And then they come to me and they're like, we got video. And it's like, okay, now what? Do you know how to make the video good? Do you know, is the video different than the audio or is it the same? Do you know how to promote anything on YouTube? Do you know how to use the video on social? Cause that's also different.

SPEAKER_00And do you know how to drive, if your goal is to get people listening, do you know how to drive people from the video to your, your podcast or the RSS or your, sorry, your newsletter, whatever. Like it, getting the actual video is only step one. Then you have an entire other mess to deal with. Not that I'm anti-video, some it's fine. Well, you know, anyway. It makes sense, yeah.

SPEAKER_01It makes sense for some. Okay, we're just about at the half hour mark. So Lauren, I'd love for us to move to our in section where we talk about the things that we either think are going to be in in the coming year, things that we wish we're in in the coming year, and things along those lines. Are you ready to move on?

SPEAKER_00I'm ready. Let's go. I think you start things off with pitching yourself to speak at events. OK, so a lot of people are looking for ways to grow their shows, but also to grow their overall

SPEAKER_01personal brand or even spread the message that their podcast is about. And one great way to do that is to be a speaker. Sometimes that is at live events where you fly and you go to a place and you schmooze with people and then you have some time on stage. Sometimes it's pitching yourself to be on somebody's Substack live or, you know, another type of opportunity that's virtual. And we want to talk a little bit now about pitching yourself to speak at events. Yes, you can pitch yourself to speak at podcast-related events because you have a

podcast and you've learned things about the journey of having this podcast. And you can come up with something really clever that is useful to a lot of

SPEAKER_01different people from your learnings. But you can also pitch yourself to events that are specific to your subject matter expertise. And I definitely recommend looking in that direction for speaking opportunities, especially if those subject matter conferences don't tend to have talks on podcasts because you could be the podcast person there. This year, every year for the past few years, Lauren and I have spoken at events both together and separately, but this year we pitched ourselves big time.

SPEAKER_01We, we, in our regular pitch to podcast movement we also in the notes section said what if you had us as keynote speakers and they said yes and we didn't have any special sauce behind this we just have been in it for a while we pitched something great We made the case for why this would be entertaining for folks. And we link to the keynote in our blog post that we're talking about here today. And we hope you check it out just as a way to see it all the

way through from all the work that we've been doing together to the pitching that we did for this,

SPEAKER_01all the way to how did it come out actually on stage? And then, you know, we can talk at another time about all the cool things that that has brought us so far.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, that's how the keynoting at Podcast Movement worked. And the On Air was a little different. We're going to be speaking together at On Air in New York. And that was a little different because we pitched an idea that was a little off the wall. And they called us and they said, OK, but it needs to be 20 times weirder. More off the wall. And I said, there's nothing that we won't do. And a dunk tank, the word dunk tank was. She did say dunk tank in this talk. Dunk tank. Anyway, so that was.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was how that. So just throw yourself out.

SPEAKER_01Put yourself out there. It can't hurt. It can't hurt. And let's go to another item on our in list for podcasting in 2026. Let's go to number three, capturing email subscribers, even if you don't start a newsletter. Why?

SPEAKER_00Because you don't have access to your Apple podcast listeners. You don't know. They really like they. could come and listen and go, and you'll never know that they were there. But having their email address, even if you don't have a strategy for your newsletter, no one is, almost no one, is like, why didn't I get an email today from my favorite podcast? People don't either notice or they get a lot of emails. It doesn't matter if you don't have one. Just get those emails. Be honest with your newsletter readers about how often it's going to be coming out. I think that's great. Even if you can do one a month, say, this is a monthly newsletter.

SPEAKER_00That's great. But just having... Having the email list is very, very important. That's an important asset. I have a few comments on this.

SPEAKER_01One, just because you start an email list and you place a subscriber capture form on your website doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to get tons of subscribers. That's work in and of itself. But it's worth having something on your website so that when people search your podcast or search you, they can opt in to receive correspondence from you. Some of the people that do that are going to be people who have never listened to your podcast. Some of them are going to be people that want more from you. And you can choose what you want to do within your newsletter. And like Lauren said, how often you put it out into the world.

But the most important thing is to have that so that people can opt in to be in

SPEAKER_01contact with you by way of this newsletter or Substack or whatever it is. And I differentiate newsletter and Substack because You can obviously send newsletters via Substack, but a lot of the infrastructure of Substack is meant to keep you on Substack. So that's why all of you right now who are watching have accounts onSubstack and might be following other people. And I wonder how many of you are consuming other things within Substack. That's a whole other discussion of the difference and everything like that. But... My point here, the action item that I have in this list is to find a platform

like Substack,

SPEAKER_01which is totally free, or Beehive or MailChimp or Ghost or tons of other email service providers that allow you to have a free plan up to a certain number of subscribers. Create the landing page and set up your subscriber capture form. Mention it in the next episode of your podcast. Put it in the show notes. Put it on social media and get people starting to subscribe. And don't worry too much about it. This can be a more passive thing.

SPEAKER_00I would also say newsletters have helped me grow podcasts immensely. I've started podcasts for nothing. I've helped market podcasts that are just starting that have a large newsletter and done promo swaps with the newsletter. So we'll say, we don't have any inventory on our fee. We don't have any download numbers. We'll put you on our large newsletter if you do a 30-second promo for us. So that's why it's another reason why it's an important asset. You can use it in these partnerships partner swaps, you're doing any, consider it a promo.

SPEAKER_00Impressions. It's just more impressions for you to leverage.

SPEAKER_01Let's go to number four. I know this is a big one. This is a new one this year. So I'm curious about how it came about, Lauren. It says, okay, hear us out. Season two is the new season one.

SPEAKER_00What do you mean? I'm obsessed with this. We say it here. Season two is the new season one because when I get a show that's a season one, I'm like, all right, let's go crazy with PR. Pitching to apps, pitching to get the host on other shows, pitching to editorial. PR people like something to be excited about and we can often make up things to be excited about or make things seem more exciting than they really are. However, if something's new, that's obvious new excitement. So season one, new show, that's a lot of excitement.

SPEAKER_00Um, but it, you know, I work in PR and marketing and sometimes they work together and sometimes they don't. And sometimes if a show is brand new, the marketing stuff isn't always there because there's no inventory on the feed. So you can't really do promo swaps. I can't do, there's only so much I can do with promo swaps and feed swaps because we don't, we haven't been here very long. We don't have much to offer unless we have a gigantic newsletter. Um, Season two, however, you get both the exciting flash flash of we're back. We're still pitching to the apps. We're still getting editorial features.

SPEAKER_00We're still pitching to get interviewed on other podcasts. But we have inventory this time, which means we can do literally everything.

SPEAKER_01We can do everything. You're very passionate about this. I love it. I'm going to take a moment now to make a plug for a newsletter that we just started, Lauren. For the folks who are joining us live, some of you have already subscribed. Thank you very much for doing that. For the folks who are watching this later or for you who are not convinced yet, Lauren and I are going to talk about these things and so much more by way of examples from the podcast that we're listening to in a new newsletter that we started called Podcasts We Text About. Lauren's going to drop the link in the chat now so that you can

subscribe there. We also are really making an effort in this new newsletter to make it a sustainable

SPEAKER_01endeavor for us. So if you want to subscribe, we're going to have cool bonus content that you can bet is actually going to be bonus content. Because if you read the article that we're discussing now, you'll know that we are no longer just offering uncut as bonus content. So Lauren, thank you for dropping the link in the notes there. And hopefully to our viewers, thank you for sharing. Thank you for subscribing. So I have another thank you.

SPEAKER_00Thank you to Will, who's literally like answering people's questions. Yeah, wow. High five Will. High five Will.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. And thank you, more thank yous, for asking questions and being active in the chat. That's our number one goal is like doing this is really fun. We love being active. We love doing this live. It is the best feeling when people are actually engaging. So if you have a question, if you just want to say hi, we will shout you out in the next few minutes of this because we've got about 20 minutes left of the live. So Lauren, let's go to another in for 2026. This is, you talked about this before, features instead of feed drops.

SPEAKER_01So we'll move on from there. Let's go to creative bonus content that is actually doing something bonusy, not just BTS, not just behind the scenes content, not just unedited interviews. But here are some ideas. We made reference to this in our out section. But Lauren, do you want to share one of the ideas that folks can try out if they're looking to do bonus content that is not just here's an unedited version of this episode?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, one of my favorite things is the reverse interview. And the first time I ever did this was I had a client who had a podcast who was she was interviewing other people. And we were like, well, how are we going to get her interviewed on their podcast when she her whole podcast is her interviewing other people? Well, she was a very good journalist. We went to these other podcasts and said, okay. I said, can my client be on your show if she's going to interview you? I know you're usually used to interviewing people on your show, but she's going to interview you.

SPEAKER_00So that kind of reverse content can be used in many ways. That could go on my client's feed or the other person's feed. So that's an example of... Just something actually different than, yeah, it's something that you don't get to hear very often.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Especially if this person is constantly interviewing other people, we don't get their perspective that much. So this gives your listeners a bit more insight into who you are. Another idea for bonus content that is actually bonusy, you can follow up with a guest from an earlier season for a where are they now type episode. I love this idea. I think it is something that you've already made the connection with this guest on. And a lot of your listeners might be curious how things turned out for this person. So I think that that can be a fun follow up.

SPEAKER_00They have a really good example of this. Alternate Realities was Zach Mack's podcast where he made this bet with his dad who was going down these rabbit hole, like conspiracy theory rabbit holes. That was at the beginning of 2025. And they just dropped an episode that was like, okay, it kind of, it's a very good series. The family kind of, the bet kind of destroys the family. And he's like, all right, well, where's my family now? I bet you're wondering. And I was really wondering. Yeah. Can you think of an example of bonus content?

SPEAKER_01Yes, yes. I feel like Heavyweight did this a lot between seasons. Yeah. Heavyweight is a great show and it relies heavily on people's stories. And also sometimes they don't Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And they call that like the happiest ending or something. It's always just the last scene. Whoa. So it's like, I think it's one of those things where I'm like, I just like it when people do something different. So it's like, remember that you can make up the rules for your own podcast and what the idea of bonus content even is. I'll also say some of these bonus content ideas are so specifically perfect for audio only.

SPEAKER_01Do you know what I mean? There's something creative that you can do with audio only that That comes so naturally to the podcast format, and I think that's a great example of it. I want to read this comment from Katie, who says, we call our bonus episodes our rabbit holes, things that we didn't have time to get to in the main episodes. Katie's podcast is great. Katie does great.

SPEAKER_00Katie's just instinctually.

SPEAKER_01Instinctually great at marketing.

SPEAKER_00Queen's podcast, look at everything Queen's is doing. Just do it.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. Yeah. Even just like literally the first 30 seconds of Queen's podcast. Listen to it and let us know what you think the marketing idea is there. I would love to get some folks in on this universe and also try it themselves. So come on back and tell us what you think. All right. Let's go to another in that we shared in our article. Let's talk about YouTube content that is completely separate from your audio feed. What do you mean by this?

SPEAKER_02You go first.

SPEAKER_01Okay. I love the idea of having a YouTube channel and not necessarily needing people to go to it for the sake of growing your podcast. What you're doing is creating an entire world, an entire show, and there's different entry points to this show. You might decide that you want to eventually grow the YouTube channel and not really care so much about the audio only feed. You might decide the opposite. But what you're doing is creating different ways for potential fans to find you.

And maybe you're just using YouTube as a way for people to search the keywords that

SPEAKER_01you want to pop up as. And that's a great way for them to be exposed to you and then decide where they want to check you out full time or where they really want to become your fan. Lauren, do you want to add something to that? A great idea of somebody who's an example of someone who's doing this is 20,000 Hertz.

SPEAKER_00Dallas Taylor is doing a really good job with this.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. So check out that show. Dallas Taylor has an entire YouTube channel that it's not that it has nothing to do with his podcast. It has a lot to do with his podcast. But it in and of itself is a great channel. And maybe it causes people to go check out the podcast, but maybe not. And that is OK.

SPEAKER_00And I think you're going to think about the whole video thing in general, because it just comes up all the time is like people are listening or watching videos. like they're going to and they are listening people do really want more ways to engage with you so if anyone's that too much you know like it's just if you do want to have something on video just think of it as an extra way to reach someone i think i hit on this every single time but i feel like it's a necessary framing for

SPEAKER_01people who are thinking about marketing for their own work How do you, viewer, listener, however you're consuming Lauren and I right now, how do you tend to find something to listen to or to watch? Try to keep track of the journey that you take from looking for something to finding that thing to becoming a fan of that thing. And think about how to put yourself in the shoes of somebody who might be doing that for your podcast. What are they searching for? What is going to hook them?

SPEAKER_01What Who are they and what do they want to do? Lauren gets excited when she has ideas and I can always tell because she starts looking down. Lauren, what would you like to add?

SPEAKER_00I made noise and I interrupted you and it's so rude. But we said the word the hook and this is kind of a derailed bit. But I do think Just, it's hard to, it's a lot of work to find new podcasts. Ariel and I know this. We work, we spend our whole lives doing this. We spend every living waking day moment of my day is spent trying to find new podcasts. So I know that it's a lot of work and not everyone has time to do that. Um, So listeners need to find shows. And then once they get there, they're like, well, where do I start?

I think a lot of people don't know where to start a show unless it's a series. So I think every podcaster should know what is the hook episode of my show? Know it off the top of your head so when you meet new people in your marketing,

SPEAKER_00you're like, this is the hook. What is the episode that you can send to someone and say, this is a great example of what my show is doing and it's doing a really good job accomplishing it? Love that.

SPEAKER_01I also, when I'm doing audits for podcasts, I ask the host of the show to send me two examples of episodes. One, an episode that they think does a really great job grabbing the essence of what they want to be doing with this show and one where they think they fall a little bit short. And I think if you can have the first one on hand, that is a great way to use that as a template for what you want to be doing in the future.

SPEAKER_00I like that asking both. But also, I feel like if you're... Because I ask people about this all the time, and it's like, if their hook episode is from 2017, that's bad.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, time to have another hook. Time to have another... Time to have not peaked almost 10 years ago. No. Time to peak again, and it is possible. Peak again. Peak again. Peak again, 2026. Yeah, yeah. Let's look at this comment from Danny Brown, the 5RQ companion. I love this because we are, parentheses, not contractually obligated to mention RePhonic every single time that we go live. We love RePhonic. To be clear, we're not contractually obligated,

but we love them very much.

SPEAKER_01We joke about getting Rephonic tattooed on our arm. Dani says the Rephonic listener profile is a great free resource to know your audience breakdown and then market to that. So Rephonic is Rephonic.com, and we're big fans of it, and Rephonic should be sponsoring us,

SPEAKER_00but here we are. I already used Rephonic.com slash graph in the chat as well.

SPEAKER_01So technically we already did mention it. That's great. All right. Let's go to a few more examples of in, we are discussing our article ins and outs for podcasting 2026. Let's just, let's skip ahead a bit because we're a little bit short on time. Talk to me about making money with the CPM model. As a reminder, this is a list, both of the things that we wish would be true and the things that we think are going to be true. So Lauren, how do you tell me what you were thinking when you wrote this one? Um, yeah,

SPEAKER_02I was thinking that this should be on the outlist. Oh, interesting.

SPEAKER_01We have found a mistake here. Have we? Well, what do you... Well, I was thinking that this is in because... Okay. Because a lot more hosting providers are making it possible for you to just turn on programmatic advertising, which may or may not be a good thing for you and your audience. Okay. So even though a lot of the rest of this list is things that we wish were true or hope are true or whatever, this one is something that I just think is going to be the case.

SPEAKER_00Okay. No, then maybe that is what I was thinking because just in general, it is getting easier for people to make money using the CPM model. Okay. But yeah, I also think the CPM model is not... the best usually no not only is it not the best but it's also especially if you're turning on these programmatic ads that are using the cpm model the you have to be really careful with what ads are being placed where so sometimes they might if you don't put markers properly in the middle of your show you might

have ads that are

SPEAKER_01just dropped at an arbitrary point in the middle of your show, that doesn't make sense. So just make sure that you look into the settings of your hosting provider if you do turn these on. I know I was also surprised when I was editing because Lauren and I wrote this asynchronously. So I was curious about this, but then I looked at it from the perspective of, yeah, I just think that this will be the case.

SPEAKER_00I think it belongs still, maybe we can write some a little bit, elaborate a little bit more because it is like people can use it.

SPEAKER_01People can, and maybe they should, maybe they shouldn't.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. All right, let's go. There's no one answer for anything. Always disclaiming that. I feel like you say this all the time. You're like, nothing is real.

SPEAKER_01You just say that. Nothing is real. Nothing is real, but also people are bullshitting all the time. And also you really have to be careful of like guru grifters on the internet who say that this is the one way that things work because there's not one way that things work. And I know that sounds like a cop out, but it's also the truest thing I've ever said. Okay. Okay. Ready? Okay. Let's go to number 17 on our ins list. And again, Lauren, do you mind just dropping in the chat this article one more

time because we're

SPEAKER_01coming to the end of our time? And then we're going to make one more plug for a cool thing for something that we just announced today. But first, let's go to 17. Always on content for podcasters who make highly produced, serialized shows that only put out like six episodes a year. I think it's going to be more and more important for you to come up with a creative way. to have content that is content, to have more episodes that are available to your listeners in between those more

SPEAKER_01intensively produced seasons. And there are a lot of ways to do this, a lot of reasons to do this. But Lauren, let's explain a little bit more about that.

SPEAKER_00Question, why are you shuddering when you use the word content?

SPEAKER_01I don't love the word content. I think it cheapens it to an extent because we're talking a lot more about maybe I'm trying to and listeners, viewers, let me know what you think about this word. But I think it's become ubiquitous to the point that like it does mean at this point the episodes that you're putting out. But I think it also means the clips that you're generating with AI that you're just throwing on social media in order to maybe drive people to something else that you're doing. And yeah, that's that's my idea. So sometimes I try to use media.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes I try to use episodes. Sometimes content does make sense. But yeah.

SPEAKER_00No, I wanted to hear you explain that. I get you. I just thought it was important. She gets me.

SPEAKER_01I get you. And this is definitely something that's resonating with the folks who are watching us live. Lauren, let's go back to the always-on question. So what do we mean by this?

SPEAKER_00I mean, in a way, it's... you can lose people. And it's funny because I used to be like, well, no one's going to care if your episode isn't there. They're not going to forget you, you know, if you don't, if you go silent. But one thing that can happen is, They get into a new habit because now they're listening to, they've replaced some other thing as their favorite thing to listen to on their commute or whatever. So I do think that it is important to have, to not just completely go away.

SPEAKER_00Ariel, what would you say is a healthy, but I also love a season break. take breaks take breaks take breaks um what were you gonna ask me healthy rested what is a number what a good what is a good amount of time between seasons for you or whatever like what what's the farthest the longest you would keep a feed empty dormant um i mean there's maybe a month and and what i'll say maybe two months what

SPEAKER_01i'll say there is I don't mean you need to always be producing your own stuff, even these shorter, not as labor-intensive episodes, but you can do a feed warmer campaign. We wrote an article a few years ago about a feed warmer campaign, which is the idea of reaching out to a bunch of other shows and setting up features, as we discussed today, with these other shows so that you can keep your feed warm between your episodes. But I also really like the idea of finding...

SPEAKER_01an always-on concept that is complementary to your show, that is exciting for your listeners, and that doesn't feel like you're just phoning it in in order to populate your feed.

SPEAKER_00I also think it is very important to be transparent with your listeners. Like tell them this is when I'm coming back or we're going to be having an episode every blah, blah, blah, blah. I think that's actually like important with everything. I think you can get away with a little bit more if you're honest and transparent with your listeners.

SPEAKER_01I agree. That's something that we've been pushing for a really long time is just explaining the why behind your decision is huge. People love the connections that they have with the podcast that they listen to, consume, whatever it is. And I think because of that, you are scoring points, I think, with your community, with your fans. If you tell them that you're a human, if you show them that you're a human. Let's go to our last item on our ins list. But before we do,

I'm going to make another plug for our newsletter podcast that we text about.

SPEAKER_01Lauren's going to put a link to it in the chat. And I will say that if you become a paid subscriber right now, not to sound like an infomercial, if you become a paid subscriber right now, I want to do something interesting with you, which is maybe what we'll do is run. Lauren, I have not run this by you. Maybe what we'll do is do like a live time podcast. study with you of like did what we put out this week was that enough for you to stay subscribed you know and I would love to report on that as we do it so it's a

very meta discussion of we're trying this out we're trying out this this paid tier

SPEAKER_01and we want to figure out In real time, what makes people want to actually pay for the content that could otherwise be free? What if, okay, did not clear this.

SPEAKER_00Riffing. Riffing. What if the people that are paying can do a live with us or not a live with us, but on anything they want? Interesting.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we're like in real time thinking about ideas that might hook you. Um, so yeah, I love that idea and we'll come up with more and we're also open to ideas. Also, we should have a number that people can text so they can text us about podcasts.

SPEAKER_00Cause we literally have the chat. We have the chat. That's true. Yeah. Um, cause I do know if I have to text, you don't guess you're the only one that I can text.

SPEAKER_01I guess monthly would be the best way to do this, Chad, because then you can be like, I'm out after two months when they didn't deliver or they did deliver. And then I choose to stick around up to you. Let's go to the last one and then we'll close things out. Investing in episodic artwork and even chapter artwork. Do you want me to hit this one? yes okay there is a lot you can do we talked about this a moment ago with audio only we still love audio only obviously you can do a lot with video too well we can talk about more on that in a in a future live here on Substack

but what i really like about audio only is that rss the technology behind what makes podcasts run is

SPEAKER_01always evolving danny brown who's uh watching us live now is a big uh advocate for this. But one of the things that you can do in most of your hosting providers is add episode artwork and add even chapter artwork. And that allows you to have a visual component to your podcast without having to go all in on video or even setting up an Instagram with constant visual needs. So I really like episode artwork i really love chapter artwork and i also really

just recommend everybody learn more about the technology that runs podcasting i did a live recently with the founder of rss.com he knows a lot about the technology he has a lot of cool ideas for how it can be implemented and i think that it is responsible for people that make podcasts to know as much as they can about this technology

SPEAKER_01I have a question. Yes. What would you say to someone that's like, why would I have show or like episodic artwork? Doesn't that hurt me when people are like searching on Spotify and they don't see

SPEAKER_00artwork that they recognize? You know, like that's sure something it's like straying away from the branding because I've got.

SPEAKER_01Well, I would make sure that it's within the branding. I think that there's ways for you to make sure that you stick to your color palette and to your fonts. And then maybe you have something that's always recognizable, but then also something that is specific to this episode.

SPEAKER_00And maybe if it's like, if you're making a really cool episodic and it's not in brand with your regular art, maybe that's a sign that your regular art needs to be changed.

SPEAKER_01Love that idea. Always a fan of changing things up. And again, being transparent about that thing. We are about to hit an hour. So let's wrap up, Lauren. Again, tell us where people can find this article, what we want them to do with it, and then who are you and where can people find you?

SPEAKER_00Um, I, I don't really, I'm not really on social media anymore. I lurk and read a lot, but, uh, go to tinkmedia.co if you need to find everything I do basically, or hear or podcast the newsletter. I write podcasts and newsletter. That's what I spend a lot of time doing. What about you, Ariel?

SPEAKER_01Ariel Nissenblatt.com is easiest. And I'm becoming more and more active on LinkedIn and threads. And I'm sharing a lot of things that I'm learning. So find me there.

SPEAKER_00We'll just drop something in the chat that is super important to know. And almost like not enough people know this. Apple doesn't want you to have text on your episode artwork. They'll be less likely to select your text. It's great. Yeah. That's a good data point. Yes, it's very good.

SPEAKER_01That's the that on that. Thank you, folks. We'll do this again.

SPEAKER_00Tell us what you want.

SPEAKER_01Tell us what you want. Tell us what you want us to talk about. Again, if you are a paid subscriber, we're really open to ideas. We're like silly putty. We'll try things out. We'll dance. We'll dance for money. Just kidding. We'll podcast dance for money. But we are also just hoping that this was helpful and that you will take something from this experience and apply it to your show and then send us that episode. And I think that'll wrap us up. Lauren?

parting words just give us something to text about yeah in our new newsletter

SPEAKER_02podcast we text about all right bye everyone

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Creating a Successful Pitch Deck w/ Danielle Bezalel

    Sep 2, 202634 minAudio

    On this live, talked about what it takes to create a successful pitch deck that makes sponsors and advertisers more likely to give you their money. The wonderful DB created a pitch deck to help you create your pitch...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Video's role in podcast growth w/ Annalise Nielsen

    Aug 13, 202637 minAudio

    Thank you to everyone who tuned into my live video with Annalise Nielsen of Lower Street! We talked about how to actually grow your podcast on YouTube and somewhere in there Annalise released a tension knot in my brain...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. A Chat w/ Most Interesting Person at Podcast Movement

    Aug 7, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit podcastmarketingmagic.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Being Funny on the Mic w/ That Aged Well

    Jul 16, 202640 minAudio

    Thank you to everyone who tuned into our live to talk about: * Being funny on the mic * Nurturing your podcast community * Making a podcast with your friend without tearing their head off! Watch out for my key takeaways...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. PMM Live with Wil & Lauren! ✨TRUE CRIME EDITION

    Apr 17, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit podcastmarketingmagic.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode