This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit podcastmarketingmagic.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to another podcast, Marketing Magic Live. Our edition today is coming a little bit later in the day, and Lauren is going to be joining us sometime during the stream. We've been talking a lot about two different true crime podcasts that are very buzzy right now in very different ways, and we have some thoughts. I would love, as anybody is joining us, As always, if you've been loving anything recently,
please put it in the chat.
SPEAKER_01Reminder that also if you have any questions for us, whether it's about podcast marketing, podcasting, or just, I guess, questions in general, please leave those in the chat too. And we'll see when Lauren shows up. I know she's on a meeting. That's going a little bit over, but that's fine. So right now you are catching me as I am halfway into the most recent edition of episode, not edition, of The Worst of All Possible Worlds.
SPEAKER_01This podcast is so good. This is one that Lauren recommended to tank, but then also to me specifically was like, you need to listen to that. You do. And then when this last episode came out, because I've been a little bit delinquent, am I listening? I'm not going to lie. She was like, you need to listen to this episode specifically. And I was like, yeah, what's it on? And she was like, American Psycho and the guest is JP Brammer. And I was like, you're right. You're right. I do need to listen to that immediately.
SPEAKER_01That's everything that I love. I love American Psycho. I've never read the book. I really need to. Brett Easton Ellis is crazy. So I'm like a little bit hesitant, even though I know it's going to be good. But I love the movie and this episode is so good. It's so fun. But I want to talk a little bit about like how I think about marketing when it comes to true crime and what I like to see and what I really do.
SPEAKER_01don't like to see. Also, you might think that I have painted nails. No. This is what happens when you dye your hair very, very, very black and then rinse it out. This is from last night. The nails, they're just going to be kind of purple. So, When I think of true crime and how I like it to be marketed and how I don't like it to be marketed, obviously this is going to come so much from the content itself.
SPEAKER_01I am very true crime picky when it comes to what I think is good. When it comes to what I listen to, Whether or not it's good, I'm not going to lie. Ever since COVID specifically, I've gotten a lot less picky on what I will listen to, and I will in fact listen to absolute garbage. Do I enjoy it?
SPEAKER_01Yes. Do I hate myself while I enjoy it? Yes. Also, yes. I mean, if you have recommendations for true crime, whether it's garbage or actually genuinely very good, leave that in the chat too. I'm always, I'll be very curious because I want to ask Lauren which true crime podcast she thinks do it really right. And I know we're going to have some of the same answers. I think it would be ludicrous for any list about true crime
done right to not
SPEAKER_01include in the dark. This used to be an APM podcast was then picked up by the new yorker is this right was it picked up by the new yorker or the times hold on hold on um in the dark podcast i always get this mixed up i'm pretty sure it's the new yorker um it is the new yorker that makes sense because it's good um oh my god there is my tab uncover yes katie uncover is so good and
SPEAKER_01I think I can. I think I can share this. I just got a press release for their upcoming season. Let me go ahead and see if I can find. I just shared this with Tank, actually. Yes. Uncover the expert witness. I think. I think I could share this. I wasn't told it was embargoed. I think I could share this. Do you guys want to see a one-pager? A press one-pager?
SPEAKER_01I'm putting it in the chat. It looks so good. I'm going to read off some of it. In Akron, Ohio, murder cases that went cold for years are suddenly being solved. But defense attorney Don Malaric, I believe, isn't celebrating. He is alarmed. The key evidence in these cases is coming from a mysterious AI tool called CyberCheck, a system so secretive that its founder refuses to explain the details of how the
SPEAKER_01technology actually works. Terrifying! Terrifying! I can't wait. Uncover is so spectacular. Everything that the CBC puts out, I think, is pretty... Pretty beautiful. Yes, Sam Mullins. Yes, yes, yes. Truly one of the best. When I think of good true crime, and I feel like he doesn't quite fit this, I have a very love-hate relationship with Dan Taberski's work.
SPEAKER_01And he's in that space where it's true crime, but it's not true crime, except my favorite Dan Taberski works by... a mile a mile are um running from cops which is a deep dive um hi everybody joining us in the chat by the way lauren will be joining us soon we're talking about true crime that does it right um we'll probably talk about true crime that doesn't do very right soon too because we have some thoughts um and i do
have some thoughts
SPEAKER_01about the marketing um So Dan Taberski's, oh my God, no worries, Anne. Anne is apologizing for keeping Lauren too long. It's okay. It's okay. So Running From Cops, Dan Taberski, is a statistical analysis of the TV show Cops and what it says about law enforcement in America. And also, all of those are like real arrests that you see. And there is statistical analysis on like, how often were these people given their Miranda rights?
SPEAKER_01Because it's not a lot. Because it's not a lot. How often are the people in the show black? Much more often than they are white. Unless we're talking about the cops. My other favorite from Dan Taberski is The Line. This is one of the most, like, excruciating podcasts I've ever listened to. It really makes me think of In the Dark season, their previous season podcast. about American war crimes the line is also about American war
crimes and the two those two shows go together so well um but like because they are about literally American war crimes in the Middle East um obviously be very careful walking into both of those shows they are both harrowing but that's the kind of work that I
SPEAKER_01think is really like kind of hard to say isn't perfect hi lauren hello what did i miss i'm sorry i'm late no you're fine we're talking about um true crime that i think does it well so gimme gimme obviously up in the dark um also talking about dan taberski's running from cops and the line
so good so good the line i feel like people didn't listen to it did you already say that no no people didn't people straight up didn't listen to it and it's like one of the most impactful things i've ever listened to he's so he's so unbelievably hit or miss for me because i katie rat katie listened to it katie clark gray oh my god
SPEAKER_01i can say words i'm so glad katie was it not like So important. Yeah, it's incredible. It's incredible. Super underrated. Truly a harrowing experience. Truly an excruciating lesson, but so important. Lauren, what else do you think is doing it really right when it comes to true crime? And I do want to talk about how we go about marketing these shows, too, because it's so tricky.
SPEAKER_00What do you think? Gosh, gosh, gosh. Okay. Honestly, I feel like, oh, my God, I could go on and on about this. But I think New Hampshire Public Radio, I really like how they do, too, currently.
SPEAKER_01Yes, absolutely. We just helped with a season called Operation Nightcat over on Outside In and Document. Operation Night Cat is a limited series, and it's so good. And it basically looks into this, like, illegal poaching ring and figures out who the people in it are. And it's very much like, oh, if these people are willing to abuse animals, what are they doing in the rest of their life?
SPEAKER_01And surprise, surprise, it doesn't stop with animals. It's a really spectacular thing. little self-contained i think three episode season highly recommend and they also had another one called something about sergeant tibbs i can't yes the final days of sergeant tibbs these are sergeant tibbs which and it also you know i see this on reddit a lot people being like i am grossed out by murder but i like true crime
SPEAKER_00what non-murder true crime is there and they're kind of as a murder in Sgt. Tibbs, maybe. But like, you know, it's the death of a cat. A cat does play in the story. It's very sad. But it's more about what happens to the neighborhood and it's more about people and community and people showing the bad sides of themselves. But so I think I also just like true crime that isn't just straight up about someone getting murdered.
SPEAKER_00Oh, my God. So many things I want to talk to you about this. I think, oh, did you listen? Did you listen? I don't think so. No, I just asked you the other day. One day, I doubt in less than 24 hours, you listened to Blood Memory in the relevant years.
SPEAKER_01Not yet. I want to.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Oh, someone just said non, we should talk about some non-murder.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Love and Radio, I will just say quickly, did a really interesting, I think it was kind of pitched as like the first of its kind. There wasn't really a narrator. It was kind of like you are thrown into the story hearing voices talking about this person and then you start hearing him talk and you're just kind of led by him. And he ends up being a criminal. And you're kind of like, I think I said this when I was talking to you, well, like, it's like Nick Vanderkalt doesn't lead you to anything.
He kind of lets the characters reveal themselves and the stories reveal themselves
SPEAKER_00unless you make up your own mind. And that might frustrate people that want to come in and hear Like, what happened? What do I think? What did the facts say? That is not what love and radio did. And I think that's what people that love love and radio love about love and radio. And I would recommend this just as an experience of something different because I always also love anything that sounds different. I was talking to some people that disagreed with me because, you know, as I mentioned, the person, the criminal is really talking a lot.
SPEAKER_00And they said it was way too much of him talking and that it was non-journalistic to let this person talk so much.
SPEAKER_01And we'll- Talking about this. In my opinion, oftentimes the best journalism is asking a question and letting your subject talk for way too long. Terry Gross, actually thinking about it, A million years ago at a podcast movement, I want to say this was like 2017, 2018, she keynoted. And she was talking about how a lot of her job is just asking a question and letting people talk for as long as they will talk and listening
and not tuning it
SPEAKER_01out. Because more than once, she's had an interview guest on. She asks a question. She lets them keep talking. She doesn't interrupt them. She keeps open air. They keep talking and they say something crazy. And then she has to be and then she'll come in and be like, say more about that. And then they do like that is often how good journalism happens. I feel like a lot of the time, the more an interviewer interjects,
the less the
SPEAKER_01The less honest the responses are, I feel like when we just let people keep talking with no guidance... they will keep talking and well this is how they're gonna get me this is how they're gonna get me because so me me too i'm one of those you are you and i are both in this i'm one of those people that someone's not talking i'm like what's wrong i better say something and it ends up getting bad like i once this is a bad situation for me but we all relate in an elevator because i'm
like oh i have like five seconds like it's like do i and i was in an elevator with my boss when i was
SPEAKER_00working at barnes and noble And I said something. He wasn't known for having the whitest teeth. And I happened to make a comment about teeth whitening. And it was just like, why, Lauren? Why? Like, why?
SPEAKER_01Because you had to see people, right?
SPEAKER_00You couldn't just not see people. But that's like, it's so normal, though.
SPEAKER_01Like, this is why. This is why you give the open spaces. Because people will say things.
SPEAKER_00And guess what? In blood and blood memory, this guy said stuff. And my position was I hadn't even thought about what Will said about like journalistically. Yes. But like also like the jinx, you know, like that's what we got in the jinx. But I think that I don't care if they did. And I don't care if what he's lying. He's a criminal. He's lying about stuff. I don't care. I'm in for the story. He had a very interesting story to tell. Whether it was true or not, I cannot confirm. I love Bible stories.
SPEAKER_00They're not true at all. They're pretty interesting. So anyway, I wonder if... Oh, Jeff is here. We were also... No, not everyone has to hear this, but Will and I were also talking about Jeff that same call. We were talking about blood memory because... we were talking about how I literally had a client. We introduced this client to Jeff and they basically came to us and said, we need to find another Jeff.
And then we're talking about Jeff so much that it was getting somewhat awkward.
SPEAKER_00So anyway, Jeff is the best. I'm wondering if Stephanie is interested in non, okay. Cause there's like non-murder true crime.
SPEAKER_01I would say.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Non-violent. I think there's like several levels.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because, like, when I think, like Stephanie is saying, non-murder true crime, I think of scammer shows, absolutely. One of the two that we have to talk about today that I want to focus on is a scammer show. I also, I mean, there are, the other one I'm thinking of does have crimes. They're not murder, but they're not, like, good.
SPEAKER_00It's dark.
SPEAKER_01It's dark. And then I also think, like, we could get into, like, the S-Town of it. Y'all probably know I'm not an S-Town guy. I did not like S-Town. But there's also, let's see, there's Beth's Dead, which I would, I guess I would put as a scammer show. There's Believe in Magic, scammer show. Yeah. What's the one? Caitlin's Baby? Caitlin's Baby.
SPEAKER_01Scammer Show. Let's see.
SPEAKER_00I mean, there's definitely a lot of Munchausen by Coxy.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Scamfluencer's so good.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Oh, Scamfluencer's is so good. Yeah. That's the one I see on Reddit. Everyone loves Scamfluencer's, by the way. They're all talking about it on Reddit. Yes. What else was I going to say about, oh, wait, can I take this into a wild area, Stephanie? Yes. You're unfortunate for Stephanie that we are picking on you. But there's also some ones that are kind of funny and not. Like the one I'm thinking of is who shot on the floor at my wedding. Stephanie, have you heard of it?
SPEAKER_00It is. Two women got married, and they discovered that someone sat on the floor at their wedding, and they spent a serious investigation trying to figure out who did it. And it's now turned into a mini—like, now they're doing miniseries that are so well-reported. They're so, so, so funny. They aren't all about shit. But oddly, a high number of them are. But they'll do things like—I'm allowed to talk about this here, right? Yeah. Stephanie's like, please stop.
SPEAKER_00It's called who shot on the floor at my wedding. But now I think all the series when the clock say yes, we say no. Cause what the point is, if the cops are like, I would never investigate that. They're like, we're going to investigate it. So for example, one woman, there was one series where a woman had a friend, some friends spend the night, a grown woman. And she woke up and someone had shit in her dishwasher. And they have to find out who. And they're literally, if you go on her Instagram or see pictures of this, the two hosts go to an appliance store to find the model of the
dishwasher and
SPEAKER_00figure out what position you would have to be in in a dishwasher. Like, they go to such great lengths to figure out nonsense. And sometimes I really enjoy. And there's this also, like, There's kind of a classic called Mystery Show, which is people still talk about Mystery Show as being maybe one of the greatest shows ever made. And no one dies in Mystery Show as far as I know. But, like, one of the mysteries is this author who wrote this book that no
one had ever read
SPEAKER_00gets Britney Spears back in Britney Spears' heyday. That's great. carrying the book and this author's numbers soar and host starly kind goes to great lengths to meet britney spears and ask her how she got the book like that kind of thing where it's like the stakes are the stakes are this high the trouble that the person went to to solve the crime is this high i love those kinds of true crime shifts
SPEAKER_01There's also, up that same alley, there is the very silly, very stupid Joanna McNally Investigates series. She did the one who replaced Avril Lavigne. And then she also did Furby's Spy on Us. These are through the BBC series. um let's see i'll pull up some links as we're talking so let's before we give more recommendations let's start talking about the other two shows that i really want to
focus on today because there's two true crimes that i think are very different oh my god and thank you you're a hero um and putting links in the chat hero truly
SPEAKER_01constantly um so two shows going on right now very fuzzy and i feel like they're doing things like radically differently um first is adults in the room i haven't finished it by the way i haven't either um because i thought i thought they were done but i think they just dropped another episode and then the other one straight up i can never remember okay the other one
SPEAKER_01Long title, Love Trapped, Owens v. Etchard. And this one is about, it's another crazy pregnancy scammer who was going after the worst bachelor. So I'm going to pull up these last few podcasts we recommended.
SPEAKER_00That's so Anne to have already done that. I know.
SPEAKER_01And then let's see. Come on. There we go. Lauren, if you could quick. McNally, give like a little brief overview of.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Trapped. So there was this. I don't listen. I don't know any. I have not seen a single. So you do not have to. more about the bachelor or the bachelorette or a single reality tv show but i guess this bachelor um he was on the bachelor but kind of like not making a lot of money kind of struggling he hooked up with he had a one night stand or something with this woman but he did not have sex with her but he found out she contacted him
later she seemed rather obsessed with him and found out later that she was pregnant
SPEAKER_00she was like i'm pregnant and had like a like sonogram and like you know all this like evidence i get like pictures of her belly and it turns out i mean spoiler alert she was not pregnant and she tried to trick the bachelor and then it turns out this wasn't the first person she did this to and so it's really interesting lawsuit and this woman it's a really wild story it's a wild story i have to say i didn't think
SPEAKER_00I'm just going to say, I don't speak poorly of podcasts often. I didn't think it was well made at all. But when you got a story like that, I don't care.
SPEAKER_01That's the thing. It's like, I'm going to keep listening to it. But it is kind of almost exactly, other than the fact that it's not about a grisly murder, I think that it's kind of exactly what I don't want. From the production and execution of true crime. And a lot of that plays into the marketing for me. Because I'm looking at the cover art. Things like that. And like.
SPEAKER_01Excuse me. It's very like flashy. So looking at the cover art. It's like. Half. half of the image is this bachelor's face in black and white looking serious. There's a line down the middle. And then on the other side, it's their text exchanges, which are crazy over some, like, it looks like red rose petals out because of bachelor, but like, it kind of looks like a blood splatter almost. And then it's like big yellow text impact font.
SPEAKER_01And I think it's tacky. I think it's really tacky. Yeah. I don't like seeing people's faces. I don't care that he's The Bachelor and that he's handsome. I think the colors are all very garish. And the yellow is so obnoxious. And I think it looks very not cohesive. It looks cheap to me.
SPEAKER_00I have two follow-up questions.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00First of all, my first, this, I think this is a fun exercise, but what would you have done for the cover? But also how would you have, cause getting this to make a podcast on the story seems to me like a gift. I would also love, I don't even, I don't even know if, um, Katie's still here, but I would love to hear how Katie would have made that show. But like, how would you have made the show?
SPEAKER_01Okay. First things first, that host, she's not it.
SPEAKER_00No, she's not it.
SPEAKER_01Um, Much to my fellow Arizonians, but she has a very casual, friendly relationship with the subject. It is very clear as you listen that they have become friends and like will go to conferences together and things like this. And I don't necessarily have anything wrong with the host being part of the story, which is what we'll talk about with adults in the room, which I think is so good.
SPEAKER_01But I think that it comes across as like a little glaringly biased. Yeah, her commentary is very funny sometimes. That's very true. And I can be okay with that in some moments of the show. But I think that she... Let's use impact as a font. Sentences never said before. Good graphic designer decision. Yeah, clearly. It's not exactly impact, but, like, it is very close.
SPEAKER_01See, okay. Stephanie is asking... Oh, that's a good idea too. That's important. So Stephanie says, Oh, interesting. I have my face on my artwork. It's more an illustration, but it's still a person was suggested to do this as a POC. So folks will see that when selecting shows. That's important. First off, illustrations, I do like. And I would say for the show, for the cover art.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01Yes. I could vibe with an illustration. I could vibe with a rose. But I think it needs way fewer elements. And I think they need to be executed more clearly. And the fact that as a POC signaling to other POC that your show is bi and for folks who aren't just white, I think that is super important and totally worth bringing up.
SPEAKER_00Also, her artwork is a gorgeous AF, I must say. And this episodic artwork, too. Anyway, sorry, I interrupted. Did you look at it? Oh, good.
SPEAKER_01No, I need to. I need to. Yeah, I think that those are important things to take into consideration. Almost always I want an illustration, though. There's something about a photograph that is just very... low effort to me and most of the time when i see a photograph of a person um it is like a very normal looking uh white person a white cis person
on a business podcast who's telling me how to do my business good who is holding a microphone and if i see one more microphone we don't need to see a microphone on a podcast art we know
SPEAKER_00it's a podcast because we know whoa We're listening to it. You don't see like film projectors on movie trailers, posters. Anyway, wow. Don't get me started. Stephanie, your artwork is awesome. It truly is. It's gorgeous. There's nothing. There's almost zero overlap with this. But anyway, keep on going. Well, what would you have done for the artwork and how would you have done a show differently for...
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think definitely illustrated cover art. I think that you could maybe have an illustration of his face, but I don't even need that. I would focus on a rose for sure, signaling bachelor, and maybe like something to do with the sonogram. I think that can be a little bit sketchy, but something just much simpler. There's so many elements in that cover art. And I would go for
SPEAKER_01And I'm usually not this kind of person. I think that I would go for a much more, like, scripty font playing up, like, the bachelor romanciness of it, you know, to have that subverted. I think that the huge yellow text that is very... Huge yellow sans-serif text is almost always signaling to me, this is a true crime, you know? And, like, I just... We don't have to live like that. We don't have to we don't have to do that. You know, I get that it's wise for marketing.
SPEAKER_01If it's like immediate recognition, it's wise for mass marketing, but it's not wise for marketing to people who are actually going to listen and stick around. But I guess they don't need that because. the story is good enough that they don't really need to worry about the podcast itself interesting case in them doing like everything wrong and we still like are spending so much time thinking and talking about the show i have sent it to i've been texting it to my friends that don't love podcasts because i'm always trying to convince them i'm like yeah this would be a good on-ramp well yeah
SPEAKER_01other than the 5 million billion iHeart ads every four seconds, which I think are a huge turnoff for new listeners.
SPEAKER_00That's true.
SPEAKER_01And then when it comes... Okay, this is something else that we talked about briefly. When it comes to the way that the show is written, it's written so strangely. Like, the actual script written so strangely. It feels to me... There's so much repetition. Like, literally clips repeated. It made me think of what we've heard coming out of Netflix, where it's like we have to reiterate what's going on in the show every five minutes because people are watching this while they're doing other
things and they're not
SPEAKER_01paying attention. So it's repeated over and over. Another thing that I noticed is, and it happens twice in the first episode, I was going to go back and count. And then I realized I don't want to listen to this from the beginning again. But at least once per episode and at least twice for the first one, we get something to the effect of, and that's when everything changed. Or, and that's what changed everything.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_01Twice in the first episode. Twice in the first episode. And I remember it happening.
SPEAKER_00Well, you got to admit, stuff be being changed on the podcast. What else are you going to do? Stuff be being changed. Stuff be being changed is really true. It could be made in the context of Stuff Be Being Changed. In fact, if they had called it Stuff Be Being Changed, that could be like a series, right? Like, it's the next one of Stuff Be Being Changed.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm sure they're going to go for whatever they can find up next for Love Trapped, which is so broad. That could be anything. Yeah, I... I don't think this show is good, but I sure am enjoying it. And I think that that's all they wanted. And I guess that's fine. I guess that's fine. It kind of hurts my soul as somebody who's in this for like the craft.
SPEAKER_00I feel like we need to mix it. I appreciate it all. You know, I feel like we need to mix it. It's like, you know, sometimes you really kind of just want something crappy to listen to while you're like changing the litter box. You know what I mean? It's fine.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I was talking about how I was like pretty staunchly true crime other than things like in the dark, which again, just like feels like doesn't even, it's like on another level. Until COVID.
SPEAKER_00Okay, go keep on going. I have a comment. Go first.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. During COVID, my brain broke. I completely, like, pretty much for the entirety of lockdown and a while after, like, lost the ability to pay attention to fiction, which was my first original love. It's come back now, but it took a long time. And all I could listen to was, like, episodic deep dives a la You're Wrong About. Or true crime. And honestly, like the trashier, the better because my brain was broken.
And ever since I've had much more of an appreciation for true crime that is done right. And I'm much more open to the idea of true crime being done right as even like a possibility.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You know? I feel like a lot of the things that when I like true crime, if I think about it deeper, it really would be considered investigative journalism. Yes. Yes. Also, I feel like there's some that go... Oh, wait. I have a big tip for you, Stephanie. Oh, my goodness. There is a podcast called Crime Writers On.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yes. Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.
SPEAKER_00It is hosted by Rebecca Lavoie, who... Well, there's four hosts. But Rebecca Lavoie is actually make stuff at New Hampshire public radio, which we were mentioning earlier, which is strange. So she and her co-hosts, this is a great chat show. They have great chat vibes, but they're all crime writers and they talk about true crime, but not just podcasts. So it's like, uh, TV and movies. So they view it. And there's not a lot of people critiquing audio out there. Um, other than me and will on this here, sub side chat.
SPEAKER_00Um, You really critique it. And they will tell you, they always say on every single episode, go to the last 10 minutes if you don't want spoilers and you just want to know if you think this is worth your time. And a lot of times I'll listen and listen to the last 10 minutes and find out if I should even listen to it or not. And I think they have, but then you got to listen to that episode because it's just interesting to hear four of them kind of disagree and agree and...
SPEAKER_01Yes. You know what's funny? While we were at the TED conference, one of the things that I would do, that was when I was... I hadn't listened to Crime Arch on in a long time.
SPEAKER_00Will and I were at the TED conference.
SPEAKER_01We were. We were. Actually, yeah, I've got my little, let's see, my little TED badge up here. Oh my goodness. And my Resonate badge.
SPEAKER_00We went to Resonate. Will and I just had a little room under... very heavy weighted blankets eating snacks the entire tech conference but anyway it was wonderful um i was doing my deep dive into crime writers on while we were at that conference and i would like in the morning while i was getting breakfast or like walking around i'd be listening to an episode of crime writers on and then after the conference um i would go back to the hotel room and crash while watching
SPEAKER_01whatever documentary they just talked about um which was very Fun and crazy. They have great recommendations. They also do their best ofs for the year, every year. And I would highly recommend like going back through those archives. And it's just a great way to find things that you might not have found otherwise.
SPEAKER_00Highly recommend.
SPEAKER_01What would you have done different also?
SPEAKER_00I like the idea of like a rose and like blank, like something just... Not as busy and more minimalist and maybe... You know what I was actually picturing was like something Wisecrack-ish. Wisecrack. Oh, speaking of one you might like, Stephanie.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Wisecrack.
SPEAKER_00Wisecrack just won a bunch of awards. It was very good. First episode, very, very, very good first episode. But I switched on some issues with this one, but I think overall it stands up pretty well. Yeah. But how I would have done the podcast differently, I think, I don't know, I don't know how to make podcasts. But like, just writing better, better writing. The writing is really... A real journal in a journalistic way.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's it. Actually, I just fixed it. There we go.
SPEAKER_01Do it better.
SPEAKER_00We can better.
SPEAKER_01Just like do it better pretty much. Let's talk about adults in the room. So this is on, I have to look up the feed. I know. Hi, Mozzarella. I'm going to see if I can pick up this little baby here. But this is on the Focus feed, which is an NPR K-U-O-W and the Seattle Times. And adults in the room is fascinating. You could do a rose stylized as a sonogram. Jeff, that's brilliant.
SPEAKER_00That's brilliant.
SPEAKER_01Come here, baby. I'm here, baby. Hello, everybody. This is mozzarella. He's the dumbest boy alive.
SPEAKER_00We were also talking about clavicular on that call. God.
SPEAKER_01My God. I lied. He's not the dumbest boy alive. He's second. Yeah. adults in the room is fascinating so this is by a journalist and her co-host kind of um is a public defender and both of them were journalists for their high school newspaper but this wasn't just like new snacks in the vending machine it was like they were like breaking actual stories this was like a legit newsroom at this very
SPEAKER_01like fancy cool hip artsy high school um that like cool people come from um and at that school there was this big like the teachers treat you like adult people and they're cool too and uh yeah love a cool teacher uh-huh the thing about cool teachers is that so i have a degree in education i have taught high schoolers um cool teachers are
SPEAKER_01That is like a colossal red flag. If you want your students to think that you're cool, I don't trust you. I don't trust you. You should not be worried about whether or not a 15-year-old thinks that you, an adult person, are cool. If they do think you're cool, that's awesome. You should not be trying to make them think that you're cool. They're not your friends. They're not your friends. And... Basically, they're looking back about some allegations that came out while
they were in high
SPEAKER_01school. They broke the story in the newspaper and essentially got blamed for quite a lot of what happened to that teacher in the aftermath. This is... I mean, the allegations are rough. And what happens is rough. But now, as an adult... They're looking back on that and reinvestigating and finding out, like, were we wrong? Like, was that?
SPEAKER_01Did we do something wrong here? Were we right? And they wind up finding a whole lot more. It's a crazy lesson. So this one obviously has, like, quite a lot of presence from the host. But I think not only does it work, I think that it's why the show is so good.
SPEAKER_00I think, yeah, and I think it's necessary. The difference is, like, they're not reporting on it. They're part of the story. It's like they're asking themselves questions. It's, like, two totally different, yeah. And also, like, because they're going back on their own memories, part of it is their memories and their experiences. I think it's really necessary. And, yeah, and also, like, another problem that I have with true crime is, that it's like we have like different kinds of hosts and it's
like the adults in the room hosts that are like super invested it is their story that they are telling they are so invested it's so personal then there's the other one where it's like why are you so invested this is actually isn't about you love trapped it's like girl this isn't about you why are you i'm just gonna say it flirting with a
SPEAKER_00bachelor right
SPEAKER_01It sounds like she's flirting and like she's about to get married.
SPEAKER_00He's something like thinking, wanting someone to think you're cool. I think she wants him to think she's cool. And it's funny because it's something that I used to notice on laundry shows a long time ago. where I know that Wondry was only scripted at one point. And so they would hire hosts to read a script that they did not have anything to do with. And you could just tell it was like complete... They wouldn't have been able to riff on the subject or anything. But sometimes that kind of sneaks in.
Sometimes where the host is just basically reporting and has no investment.
SPEAKER_00It didn't do the reporting.
SPEAKER_01That used to be really common. Do you remember that? It did. And I think this is part of why... Because before COVID, when I thought of true crime, I associated it with Wondery and kind of with I Heart. I don't feel like I Heart had really dived in or like with My Favorite Murder. And when it comes to like Wondery, My Favorite Murder.
SPEAKER_00But you just named the other kind, which is two chicks reading Wikipedia. That's the other category.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Wow. Wow. But I remember,
SPEAKER_00I almost feel like it was with you, Will, because this is, like, who I talked to about this stuff. Me, like, talking to Will, I mean, like, Will, am I crazy? Or is Wondery, like, doing a great job with True Crime?
SPEAKER_01It was like, wait a second. Somehow it got good. I don't know what happened. Somehow Wondery shows got good.
SPEAKER_00And then they did. Then they went away.
SPEAKER_01That's right.
SPEAKER_00What a rollercoaster, Wondery. Yeah. Wait, I thought of another category. There's... Oh, wait, I wanted to ask you about something. So, so far, we're covering all the categories of true crime.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So, I'm straight from adults in the room. I'm putting that one in the chat. Don't even worry about it. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_00How do you feel about last podcast on the left? Is that true crime? What is it? I don't know.
SPEAKER_01I don't know. I don't care. I've listened... I've listened to maybe like five total episodes of Last Pod. And I've listened to a million clips of Last Pod. This is, I'm putting in the chat belts in the room. And I do really love also the cover art here, which I think is really interesting. It feels, it's got photograph and it has a lot of elements, but it just feels a little bit more considered and more elegant and more cohesive.
like amazing what just like colored reading will get you last pod I just like last pod and chopo trap house and like all of those like they all have the same energy to me and it's like that dirtbag leftist like I'm okay I'm good it is yeah even if
SPEAKER_00they're not screaming yeah I usually don't have the thought like, oh, me and this host would be friends in real life.
SPEAKER_01Like, that's not the kind of person I am. But when I listen to those shows, I do think if I was at a party and these people were here, I would leave. Like, they seem exhausting and so annoying. And like, they would try to correct me on things that I know more about them on. That's, that's how it makes me feel.
SPEAKER_00Also, one of them got, I mean, it's a little crack in the system. One of them, I forget, had to leave for really bad allegations of like abuse. Do you know about this?
SPEAKER_01Right. That's right. That's right.
SPEAKER_00It's kind of a, like, bad sign for the i i have uh enjoyed the last podcast and loved episodes and i like their theme song i'll say it um i like their series on the men and his brothers and that was but that was like a long time ago i but anyway um i know that it's like i know some people that really really really love it and that seems to be the other it's like people looking at wikipedia articles or people doing deep dives where it's mostly about themselves and their comedy maybe i don't
know now we're just
SPEAKER_00naming all the
SPEAKER_01Yeah. How do you feel about Adults in the Room, though? How are you liking it?
SPEAKER_00Whoa. I'm loving it. I mean, it feels really special because it seems like this kind of stuff isn't being made anymore.
SPEAKER_01Yes, it does. It feels like a dying breed. And I feel like I've been saying that about, like, specific single-season investigative reporting. But I have seen. I mean, I think that we are getting it. It's just that the quality... I don't know if we're getting... I'm sure we're getting less of it than we used to. But I think that also part of it is that there's so much else in this space that acts like it's doing this investigative reporting style of true
crime that is just
SPEAKER_01so bad and so low quality.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I feel like what we need is funding for people to do this because it's so expensive. It's like... Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. It's ludicrous.
SPEAKER_00Newsrooms need to be supporting this stuff. I don't know. There are a couple news... And this is a newsroom. This is a... Right? Like, I feel like that's where we have to look to for true crime.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. This is with, again, like NPR, K-U-O-W. Which makes total sense. And of course, like, you know, we're currently going through an administration that has no interest in funding journalism that they can't immediately control. So no surprise there. But I also think outside of that and outside of like traditional publications,
SPEAKER_01I do think that a lot of networks like iHeart, Like Wondery, they have the assets to be funding these things. And I think that they are spending those resources on. This is so obvious. Like, I know I know how corporations work. They're spending these resources on shows like Love Trapped that are not high quality. but we'll get listeners and we'll get ads listened to. That's what they care about.
And because of that, the money is going there and not to like another in the dark, you know?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Sorry. I was just looking up to see what other, cause like there's some of the tip of my tongue, like that have done investigative really well. Yeah. Cause I also almost feel like, like when you hear the story, you're like, what are the chances that these two women are... First of all, they're journalists. They were journalists on their school paper. They're basically journalists. Well, one of them was a...
A public defender is a journalist pointed in another direction.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you're right. But that they come together and can get all these people's contacts and get all these people to talk again. It's almost like, what are the chances? Also, in fact... they went to the same high school as Lindy West and Megan Hatcher, who were hosts of one of my favorite podcasts, Text Me Back, and they went during the same time. So this was Lindy and Megan's teacher as well.
SPEAKER_01I'm scrolling through Crime Writers On's episodes to find, like, what I... Because it's just, like, such a great feed of true crime titles. But also while I was doing that, I really, like... It's, like, getting a little bit ridiculous how prominent my brand is. Like, I get it. You're a goth and you like purple. Jeez. That's good. Thank you. Thank you.
You know who else does... Well, I haven't loved all of them, but The Observer and Tortoise.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Not all of them. They just did a... They did Sweet Bobby, which... talk about a good scam one i don't know if you listen to sweet bobby but um they just did one what was it now i can't even remember um anyway on the observe the same and the observer tortoise just bought the observer which seems crazy to me but they do pretty good well done true crime like real investigative observer yeah
SPEAKER_01isn't insane that's crazy what That's supposed to go in the opposite direction.
SPEAKER_00I know. I can't believe I haven't brought up two of my favorite non-murder true crime shows. So the first, this is one that I talked about back when I was on forums like Best of the Year.
SPEAKER_01Fur and Loathing. This is by Brazen.
SPEAKER_00And Brazen is so good.
SPEAKER_01Brazen does incredible work. It's so artfully made. Like, the journalism is great. This is about the largest domestic chemical attack, which... you would think would be a huge news story, but it wasn't because it happened at a furry convention. So most people wrote it off as a joke. But the thing about furries is, one, that's human people. They're alive. And two,
SPEAKER_01most furries are queer and neurodivergent, which means, hey, so this was probably a hate crime, right? This was probably a hate crime, right? And the investigation is fascinating and all of the subjects are treated with a great deal of respect. And then to that same end, I got to talk about one that is much more investigative, much more up the mystery show is Everybody Knows That. Everybody Knows That, the search for ulterior motives.
SPEAKER_00I'm thinking about this show this morning.
SPEAKER_01Right, Stephanie, nobody knows about this happening. Nobody knows about it. And it's huge. Fern living amazing. Everyone knows that is an investigation into finding a piece of lost media that people have been searching for, for like pretty much as long as the internet has been around. And not only was it found in this podcast, they talked to the musicians of the song.
SPEAKER_00I'm going to tell a little bit of story because Josh is the host of it. And we know, well, we know Josh now because we didn't know him at the time. He emailed us and said, hey, I've been working on this podcast for a long time about this piece of media, this song that no one can find. And it's so rare these days to have anything that you can't find online. So we were like, okay, we gave him some advice. You're like, maybe we'll talk. And then we got this frantic email from him saying they found the song. I got to make this podcast now.
SPEAKER_00And so we made it really, really fast. And it's so good. We won't say where they found it, but it's very good. I also want to say two shows that I got from crime writers on. Did you listen to Hush? That was... Hush was really good. It had two seasons. Incredible. And I feel like no one was talking about Hush. And then also Bone Valley.
SPEAKER_00Do you like Bone Valley?
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. So I only listened to the first season of Bone Valley. I haven't listened to the second. But the first season also... Bone Valley is the one where it's the reporter and his producer kind of intern. And there's a moment where she's in a car and scared. And they're having conversations about it. Really, really good. And another one where the reporter presence in that is important. I was just going to say, it's pretty rare that I remember so clearly moments in a
podcast that
SPEAKER_00And that one, I can remember, there was a moment in, they got to find the elements that were found with the woman who was murdered. And like, hearing her just choking up, like, yeah, she was a powerful part of the story. It was incredible.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah, it's... I'm very glad that I am now in a stage of my life where I can accept that some true crime is good. Sometimes it does things that are good. For instance, get photographic evidence of American war crimes declassified. I think that's very good. I think that's very important.
SPEAKER_00These all cases, they free people, you know?
SPEAKER_01They do. They do. They do. And I think, ultimately, what it almost always comes down to for me is who is good? Who is the antagonist of the podcast? So for Love Trapped, the antagonist is this scammer, this woman who's a scammer, right? For In the Dark, the antagonist is the American criminal justice system and the
American military
SPEAKER_01system. And I think that that's always the more... responsible respectful and sophisticated answer for love trapped i would love because there's references to like this woman is going through something this woman is not well yeah why is that not the antagonist i get that she did things that were crazy and said things that were crazy i i get that but like how did how did she get
SPEAKER_01here and what what can we do about that there's no less questions that's not fun that's not well not juicy so that's and we can't that doesn't entertain us yeah you're that's not big yellow font it's not very big yellow font this kind of reminds me that just has to be said a lot of true crime these days is they should rename the category true crime police incompetence they
SPEAKER_00could just rename Because basically every single true crime is like, what were the police doing? What the fuck were the police doing? You know, like a quiz. Like, could every true, could the true crimes we've been talking about now? It could love trap be considered. I don't think so. I think the police actually did their best. Yeah, it's true.
SPEAKER_01But I think like, I guess structural incompetence is the thing here. um hans oh my god weird this is weird because on that same call we were talking about how should we love hans that's weird yes we actually were just talking about you hans this is going to be such a silly compliment but your reply um to the obit project is like one of the best like replies after a connection email i've ever read i showed it off in the tink sack so i was like look at the
beautiful email a
SPEAKER_01lot And also, somebody... We were also talking about you because someone responded to my email.
SPEAKER_00We were talking about your new show, Maddie and the Homefront. Did I say... Maddie and the Homefront. I'll link it. Yep. And someone responded saying thank you for opening Maddie and the Homefront to me in my newsletter. So we were just talking about that. Really lovely show. Really lovely. This person specifically said... The reason they listened to it was because they thought you were a genius and would listen to anything you did. But then they're really glad they found it.
SPEAKER_01And that's correct. That's correct. Real ones know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Hans says, I was there for the first season of In the Dark. And the secret to their success is that they had an excellent question. There was a bonkers story about how their question saved them. Yes. Yes.
SPEAKER_00Wait a second. You need a question.
SPEAKER_01You need an explanation. i'm getting things mixed up because it was the first one the boy in the bicycle or was the second one the boy in the bicycle the first one was the one where the guy got oh i'm looking i'm looking first one was the boy in the bicycle let's see i think you're right abduction of jacob letterling okay yeah yeah yeah yeah oh wow
SPEAKER_00hans was there jeez
SPEAKER_01I know. Okay. We have one minute left, but Han says, okay, so, and I am waiting.
SPEAKER_00Two weeks before they were supposed to launch,
SPEAKER_01the cops caught the guy who killed the boy on the bike. Wow. Whoa. That timing is crazy.
SPEAKER_00That timing is crazy. I want, and I have to think that that helped, like that helped that the podcast did it. Right.
SPEAKER_01Do people know this? Yeah. The question had been, who did it? They had no show. But that wasn't the question.
SPEAKER_00Huns, this is gold. This is better than everything Will and I have said for 50 years. Wow. Maybe Hans wants to be a special guest next time. My God.
SPEAKER_01Hans, come be on a live. It was, why did it take 27 years for them to catch him? That's it. That's it. And that's what it comes to with the structural incompetence. That's what true crime should be focused on, is how did every system fail this bad for this long?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Wow. That was good. What a way to go out. Hans, thank you. I don't think people know that. I don't think people know that. That's great. Well, this has been really fun.
SPEAKER_01This has been so fun. If y'all have things like topics that you'd like us to talk about on our next live, we do these every two weeks. I am always thrilled to talk about shows that I think are doing well. Hans says they did an amazing talk about the importance of a good question at Third Coast the year after. Ooh. Ooh. Okay. Hans says he's sure there's tape of it. We'll try to go find that because that sounds amazing.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Okay, y'all. We will see you again in two weeks. Thank you so much for joining us. This was so fun. And I can't wait for our next talk.
SPEAKER_00I'll be here next week. This was too fun. Okay. Bye, guys. Happy Friday.
On this live, talked about what it takes to create a successful pitch deck that makes sponsors and advertisers more likely to give you their money. The wonderful DB created a pitch deck to help you create your pitch...
Thank you to everyone who tuned into my live video with Annalise Nielsen of Lower Street! We talked about how to actually grow your podcast on YouTube and somewhere in there Annalise released a tension knot in my brain...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit podcastmarketingmagic.substack.com/subscribe
Thank you to everyone who tuned into our live to talk about: * Being funny on the mic * Nurturing your podcast community * Making a podcast with your friend without tearing their head off! Watch out for my key takeaways...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit podcastmarketingmagic.substack.com/subscribe