This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com Hey all. This week, as we head to the 4th of July weekend, we are bringing you a really special two-part episode that provides a capstone for our month-long collaboration with Random House about the books that have shaped American history. Over almost two hours, we took a 250-year-tour of the books that shaped this country’s history. Niki, Kellie and I w…
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01And then along the way we will also keep track of what has aged well and what hasn't aged well and at the end I will ask which of these works you would save in a fire that's like pretty I don't know with books I don't like that scenario but basically you're not a fan
SPEAKER_03of book burning yeah I was gonna say because there's always an audio book or
SPEAKER_01an ebook fair enough but basically which one has had a biggest impact on the US or on you and which is the sort of one you want to shout out so got the ground rules everyone yep Agreed. All right. I think we have to start with Tocqueville or de Tocqueville. What do you say? Do you say de Tocqueville? Oh, you dropped the de?
SPEAKER_00You dropped the de.
SPEAKER_01Disagreement right off the bat. I like it.
SPEAKER_00You've already learned something.
SPEAKER_01You've earned your pay, everybody. Alexis de Tocqueville writes Democracy in America, 1835-1840. John, I would say that this is obviously an incredibly impactful book, but to what you were saying earlier, it's a chronicle of America in the middle of the 19th century, but it also, I think, injects some really key ideas about what America is through the act of the book itself.
SPEAKER_00It does. It's also much more quoted than read, which is, I think, an important element in almost all of these topics, right? But he was there in the age of Jackson. One of the insights that I sort of always sticks in my head is his noting how political a people we were. That every crossroads, every cracker barrel was consumed by political conversation, which means that as pervasive as cable news seems today,
SPEAKER_00politics has always been and would be in a democracy obviously top of mind.
SPEAKER_02And I think that's an important thing for people to understand as we get into this is, you know, sometimes you hear this complaint that everything is politics now. All anyone can talk about is politics and it's crowded out everything else. And there's something to talk about there, but it's also creating this imagined past where people were just disconnected from politics. But of course, it's always been sort of the water in which Americans swim.
SPEAKER_03I also think it's interesting that he is looking at the United States the lens of incarceration, interviewing prisoners, interviewing people that would be experiencing the least democracy offers to say. I think that that tells something about like, okay, if this is how democracy functions, how is the bottom experiencing that? What does that look like? And how are people talking about their experiences in prison? It's quite illuminating when you think about what prisons were, especially in the 19th century, to sort of give us that lens to talk about America in general.
SPEAKER_01Well I've always sort of this has always struck me about him is that to your point john as much as he gets flattened into a few core ideas and notions about you know the american character the book itself and he's a sociologist i mean he does the work like he goes to a prison and interviews every single prisoner he travels around the states and talks to people up and down the social ladder and you know i guess this is an obvious thing to say but it's like A lot of the books that really matter are the ones where the people are extremely rigorous in their approach. And I think people sometimes forget that because he has that sort of like log line
SPEAKER_01through history.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's become a coffee mug guy, you know, and that's always tricky. Although it's also not a terrible thing, right? I mean, I remember President Obama was always contemptuous of soundbites. I always thought, well, you know, the Sermon on the Mount was full of soundbites. There's nothing actually the capacity to distill what one sees as a large truth into a phrase is a great gift. And you're exactly right about it. Think about Francis Trollope. All that travel literature in the late 18th and 19th century is uneven as all literature is.
SPEAKER_00They were reporters and as sometimes we, I don't know about you all, but sometimes I'm so desperate to think in some grand terms that I forget that often what endures is the fact you can put in the bloodstream as much as the idea.
SPEAKER_02Although I also think that in the case of Tocqueville, those ideas are one of the reasons why he's so quotable, right? He's writing about the thing that Americans continue to be obsessed with, which is democracy and democracy's limits. And his fears, even in the 1830s, and again, this is going to sound very contemporary, but this... This concern that there's something about a democratic society that's been unleashed from some of the traditional hierarchies that held European societies together,
SPEAKER_02that there was a danger of atomization and there was a danger of You know, people only being bound together by their passions being whipped up and that democracy would both sort of ironically be the tyranny of the majority, but also it wouldn't have any center to hold it together. I think that's something we think about a lot today. And while his solution was maybe bring some of those hierarchies back, not on board with that, but we are sort of still in search of what are the things that can hold us together
SPEAKER_02and bind us together. Now I think our question is how do we do that without those hierarchies?
SPEAKER_01I mean even just injecting this basic idea that there is a unique American character that we need to wrestle with and examine and sort of go back to over time. I mean yeah I don't know if that I mean the founders obviously thought about that too but I feel like he's you know responsible in many ways for just injecting that basic idea and as we'll go through this list a lot of the books that we're going to talk about are sort of in conversation with that are wrestling with that are trying to get at that same central question of what is the unique American character.
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the thirty-seventh installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to the 1920s and the moment Franklin Delano Roosevelt...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the thirtieth installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to summer of 1925 and an explosive trial over teaching...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the twenty-ninth installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to 1969 and the United States victory in the race to the...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the twenty-eighth installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to 1948 and the moment that Harry Truman issued an...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the twenty-fifth installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to June 1969, and New York City’s Greenwich Village. Police...