This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the thirty-seventh installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to the 1920s and the moment Franklin Delano Roosevelt contracted polio. We look at how the disease terrified the American public, how FDR contracted it, and how it shaped his public and private life throughout his three terms as president. Thanks to all of you who are paying subsc…
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01There is no disabilities movement, right, yet. There is no sort of accommodations that are happening for families. And so if your child survives, but they still are paralyzed or they still have a disability, there's not a lot in society that's being done to sort of aid or assist the way your child can live a full life.
SPEAKER_02It seems like, Kelly, too, is it right that the response to these polio outbreaks, I mean, we think we saw the public or government response to something like COVID. It seems like the response to polio outbreaks was pretty strict.
SPEAKER_01Oh, absolutely. I mean, they were basically changing rules that basically said children can't go into movie theaters, children can't be in crowded spaces, children can't be at beaches. They were like... trying to figure out if you were trying to leave the city, you had to prove that you had a clean bill of health if you were trying to get out to the suburbs or if you felt like you were trying to escape with the disease and infect other people, you know, they wanted to quarantine you as much as they could. So there's a lot of this like, I'd say like witch hunt in terms of like how children are surveilled and
SPEAKER_01who allows them to go where and that sort of freedom that you think of childhood was just not there for a lot of people.
SPEAKER_00I mean, in 1916, there's a wave that hits New York City. And I think that's the peak of just this witch hunt or just deep fear and paranoia. But like there's police posted at the cities at like railroad stations and roads and rivers. Basically checking papers and checking health certificates and turning kids away. And then there's reports that like kids would sneak out and escape to the suburbs. And then people, cops and officials would go through the suburbs and find truant kids from the city
SPEAKER_00and ship them back.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, man, what a scene. I mean, we've also talked about this a lot too, like how diseases... easily become racialized. And so like the immigrant community, the Italian immigrant community really gets targeted. People start to villainize them and, you know, pinpoint them as being part of the problem or cause of the problem. And so you've got Italian immigrants that are being beaten up and that are being sort of ostracized as well. And so that fear mongering really does a lot to communities,
SPEAKER_01especially communities that are being targeted as the problem. Yeah, you can imagine this rolling into the 1920s.
SPEAKER_02immigration restrictions. Yes. This fear that immigrants are carriers of disease that are killing your children.
SPEAKER_00Well, David Oshinsky, who's a great author and historical writer, has written about polio. He has this just incredible sort of paints a picture of later in the 50s. But, you know, it's worth pointing out this is basically, you know, a phenomenon that Americans are living with from The teens, the mid-teens, all the way up until the 50s. But he says, you know, about what it was like to live in the polio era. He says, quote, each summer polio would come like the plague. Beaches and pools would close because at first the fear was that the polio was waterborne.
SPEAKER_00Children had to stay away from crowds, so they were often banned from movie theaters, bowling alleys, and the like. And he points out that in a 1953 survey of what frightened Americans the most, polio was in second place just below nuclear annihilation. And those two actually sort of like the kind of fear seem similar to me. This unknown, unspoken, silent, perplexing, it could strike at any moment kind of pervasive fear.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, this external enemy feels very familiar.
SPEAKER_00So that's the background of kind of what polio is and how it was just sort of pervaded American life in the middle years of the first half of the 19th century. Let's now switch gears and talk about Franklin Delano Roosevelt. So I think listeners, you know that we're not going to do the full sweep of FDR, certainly not the full political sweep of FDR, but this is more about, I'd say, how his personal life intersected with his political life. So who is FDR? Where does he come from? And then we'll trace a little bit of his early life and then how he got polio.
SPEAKER_02FDR is a fascinating figure in U.S. history. He comes from a very wealthy New York family in the old Hudson Valley. For those of you who have been to, I guess I call it upstate New York because I'm so city oriented. Hudson Valley. Hudson Valley.
SPEAKER_00For some of us, upstate starts when you cross 125th Street.
SPEAKER_02That's right. Yes. Anyway, if you go up to the Hudson Valley and you go to Hyde Park, the family property is still there in Eleanor Roosevelt's cottage, and it is just this beautiful area of land, but it's also where all of the old robber barons of the late 19th century have erected their mansions, and the Roosevelt's kind of fit in with that. A very famous political family as well. People will know FDR's famous cousins,
SPEAKER_02including Theodore Roosevelt and, weirdly, Eleanor Roosevelt. They weren't first cousins, but, you know, they were. It's wild, too.
SPEAKER_01First cousins?
SPEAKER_02I can see third or fourth. First cousins? They're not first cousins. I think that they are further removed. But there is something, like, slightly monarchical about keeping it all in the family. Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_00So they are. They're not that far removed from those days. Yeah. No, not really.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. But it's this very WASP-ish way of living. Anyway, gets a law degree, but he is very much inspired by his cousin Teddy Roosevelt, and he moves into public service, and he basically takes the same path that Teddy Roosevelt takes. He wins election to the New York State Senate, then he becomes Assistant Secretary of the Navy during World War I, which is the exact position that his cousin had held. He becomes eventually a boss, I won't get into that yet. And then in 1920, he becomes the Democratic candidate for the vice presidency.
SPEAKER_02So picture this, right? This is a handsome, wealthy, well-connected, six-foot-tall man who has just shot up through the ranks, much like his cousin. And there is an aura of kind of destiny around him. Okay, hold on.
SPEAKER_01Can I just say, listeners, you have to Google a picture of FDI
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the thirtieth installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to summer of 1925 and an explosive trial over teaching...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the twenty-ninth installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to 1969 and the United States victory in the race to the...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the twenty-eighth installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to 1948 and the moment that Harry Truman issued an...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com Hey all. This week, as we head to the 4th of July weekend, we are bringing you a really special two-part episode that provides a...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit thisdaypod.substack.com For the twenty-fifth installment of “50 Weeks That Shaped America” we go to June 1969, and New York City’s Greenwich Village. Police...