For show notes, links, and a summary episode, sign up for the Hey! What You Reading For newsletter. Mondays at 7am BST - https://tdape.beehiiv.com/subscribe Click for tickets to TDaPE Conference Cymru https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-thinking-deeply-about-primary-education-conference-tickets-1295761139449 For maths curriculum questions contact us here or via support@alta-education.com Episode 246: This week Kieran is joined by John Jackson to get under the skin of McNeil, Jordan, Viegut and Ansari’s new paper "What the science of learning teaches us about arithmetic fluency". The conversation tests common claims, separates principle from preference, and turns the paper’s recommendations into classroom moves that travel from early number through to secondary. Expect a forthright look at conceptual grounding, timed practice, retrieval, task design, and the perennial anxiety debate, with an eye on what school leaders should adopt, adapt, or abandon.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to Thinking Deeply of our Primary Education, the podcast that makes time space to think about pedagogy, teaching and learning, professional development. Anything of interest to time for Enthusiasm rich primary teachers, This week I'm joined by John Jackson. So it's great to have you back. John, how are you? Yeah, good. Very well. Thanks. Karen, how are you doing? Yeah, not too bad. Busy, busy start to the year. But I suppose that's that's teaching for your education for you, isn't it? Yes, yeah, absolutely. Yeah. It's nice to kind of set aside a bit of time to talk about some some teaching, some maths that.
Well, that is the thing, yeah. Don't get to read. Like I say, I've always said this the whole way through our previous three episodes. Don't get, don't get enough opportunities to read the fun stuff. This is definitely one of those, I think. Yeah, We're going to focus our attention on a paper called What the Science of Learning Teaches Us about Arithmetic Fluency, and that's McNeil, Jordan Vegut and Ansari. Daniel Ansari is probably the one that most listeners will be familiar with because I think Daniel did like some sort of,
you know, we like, not the sabbatical, but we spend time in a visiting university. And I'm pretty sure he was in the UK for a while before he went back to Tennessee, Canada and or whatever, whichever part of the United States he might be from, I don't know, continental United States. Yeah, Yeah. I think, I think McNeil is involved in the FIFA AL paper that we talked about a while back about concreteness fading as well. So A. Nice bit, a nice bit of symmetry. What the science of learning teaches us about arithmetic fluency. What's the paper about, John, and why is it useful?
I think like the overall thrust of the papers, it like looks at kind of one of the the like core goals for early maths, like just sort of two to seven in that kind of view, I think, which is building arithmetic fluency that kind of like being able to use arithmetic. Basically. They're not saying this is all of early maths, but they're saying it's like a really crucial point of it, part of it. And they talk about like they recommend the mixed approach that like teachers should early maths should focus on like both
the kind of recall of facts, but also on meaning. And that's the kind of thing you hear quite a lot about. But I think what makes this this useful is that they actually make good recommendations around that. They give concrete descriptions of what that mixed approach might look like. They think about what teachers might do to like promote memorization and meaning and why they might do that as well. And then they also, and we might talk about this a bit later, that talk about potential pitfalls of those approaches. And it's quite chunky paper, but
I think it's worth worth being the size it is because it starts with sort of an overview into the research around learning and development, arithmetic fluency. And that means that not only their recommendations sort of evidence informed, but they like explain the reasons behind that. They sort of show they're working out basically, which would help people apply them like more flexibly rather than just sort of here's the rule I've got to follow. And then the thing I think that I find really interesting, like early maths obviously isn't my specialism as a, as a secondary teacher, I'm kind of focusing
much more on like that maintaining and developing that fluency as pupils are a bit older. But I found this useful because it shows you where that starts from. And while that might be like more familiar ground for like, primary teachers, I think there's also some really good things around, like, like what parents might do when they're working with children and like some really like simple kind of conversational things almost that parents can do and like look for in children. So yeah, I think, I think that's kind of a summary of why I think
it's really useful. You mentioned the fact that, you know, we're always hearing about the, you know, it's not one or the other. It's, it's a combination, you know, and basically everything we talk about, you know, it's that nuance, isn't it? But there's a quote from the the NCTM, not to be confused with the NCTM and who, you know, I'm not going to say they're bad faith actors, but there's very little to convince me that they're actually good faith actors because everything they publish is behind the pay wall, which is annoying. And and they're also making
these scandalous and statements like they're opposed to the memorization of arithmetic facts and the use of timed practice, you know, and as recently as 2023. And then when I, when I saw that, I was like, Oh, my goodness, you know, you this, you know, you don't think this should be necessary, but there's clearly a substantial amount of people who are going about their daily business believing that memorization and timed, you know, practice are a bad thing. And so why is this paper useful? I think it makes a really good
outline of why the NCTM, you know, the NCTM is, is wrong. Yeah. Please don't. The National Center of Accents and Teaching Mathematics. Please don't. I think I'm, I'm aiming this at you guys. But yeah, you know, like I said, don't say they're bad faith actors, but it's not, it's not good faith they're acting in here, is it? Yeah, it seems, it seems like, I mean, obviously we're both based in the UK, but it seems like the position is much more polarized in in the US And I think where everyone over here will try and
look for kind of common ground and like, OK, well, there might be different positions and things like there's bits around like how memory works. And like the importance of like having stuff that you can recall from long term memory easily is like is really well established by kind of everyone over here. Like. And there might be like differences of opinion about exactly how you get there or what the research is saying about how you get there. But that importance of like knowing those facts is I think
just much better agreed upon. And I think it's yeah, it's kind of interesting to see it set out in the in the paper in terms of how how different that that piece is. Because I think and what I think is really good about the papers, it talks a bit about how you might get there because like that statement, like you need to memorize some facts is just doesn't have any context, right? It doesn't tell you like, OK, well, is it just recall without anything else? Or is it like that just happens organically?
And actually what the paper sort of takes you through is like what you need those conversations and those representations and so on with meaning. And you also need to like explicitly practice it and like with things like retrieval and things like that. And I think that's where it's kind of apart from those. Like often you hear that kind of you need a middle ground, but doesn't say, well, a middle ground is. And this kind of sets out quite clearly and bases it in like cognitive science and like educational research. Really strange too, given that most of this research has been
conducted in the United States of America or certainly North America in general. You know, I suppose that goes, that's the scene for cognitive science in general, isn't it? You know, the New York's get more a lot more respect over here than they perhaps do in their in their own backyard. How do the authors describe arithmetic fluency and what are the main recommendations? They, they kind of they, and this is the thing I like, they, they like set out the position nicely. They don't just like use the word and don't fail to define it. They sort of say like arithmetic fluency is like efficient,
accurate and relatively effortless mental production of sums and products of the numbers 0 through 10 and their inverses, which is a kind of slightly like very precise, but like slightly clumsy way of saying like knowing your times tables in addition to subtraction facts. But they're explicit about like has to include meaning. And it's not just like constantly quizzing people's on just like just solving, solving the same sort of questions again and again and again. And then they talk about approaching that and like kind
of building that fluency in sort of four main ways, really like the importance of having like a really enriching early environment for like almost before people, before children are in school. Then explicit instruction about like around arithmetic. And that's again, both like what the facts are and like making meaning out of them and well structured retrieval and then sort of appropriately using time
constraints. The last one's probably the most like most unusual, sort of, well, not unusual, but I think the others are kind of fairly obvious, although they explain them really well, but maybe we'll kind of talk about them sort of in general. I think they're like enriching early environment piece. It's just it sort of explains what the early most of the papers around explaining what the kind of early development of like like mathematical thinking
and numeracy is involved, sort of like sabetizing and conceptual sabetizing and things like that. And the kind of different principles around like counting, which I think are things that would be really, really familiar to like primary school teachers, less so to secondary school teachers, I think. But it makes the point really well that like that stuff that happens before kids arrive in school matters. And particularly like just things like you can, that parents at home can be like
constantly trying to count things or like explaining what the, what the maths they're sort of using is in sort of everyday life. And yeah, saying, OK, if I've got, if I, if I've got 2 and I want 3, how many more do I need? And that, that kind of that kind of thing. And I think what I liked about that was it's sort of, it's quite reassuring, I think. It's not like if you, if you were presented with that as a parent, it's not Oh my God, I need to learn a whole new, whole new way of thinking or I need to be doing like maths practice every day.
All I need to do is a bit of counting, like counting and just think about it and listen to what my child is saying and like what that might be telling me about what they, what they understand. So I thought that was kind of nice, nice, kind of clear, clear point. But that's one of the things you quickly realize when you join an earlier set in or a primary school is that the children who are spoken to from a young age are the children who excel, you know, and quite often it's the children of teachers who excel the most because they're having those really rich conversations, You know, board games, you know, we mentioned, you know, the, you
know, bringing that mathematics into the, into your daily life, you know, the only small tweaks to board games, you know, I want you to, I don't want you to count the, the number of pips on the dice, rather, or I want you to touch the pips as you count them. You know, I remember doing this with my kids, but mostly during the pandemic because that's when they were sort of at that stage. And but it's just like small tweaks to things that we hopefully already be doing. You know, I know board games aren't as popular as they used to be, but they definitely should be because it's a game changer socially, you know, and then those are the kids who are
advantaged. I think, you know, I was experientially privileged as I, as I described it when they went to school, because then they're the kids. You're 18 months ahead of the the kids who aren't. Yeah, for sure. And you get all that like turn taking socializing as well at the same time. Yeah, it's quite it's like I started, I think I was going to train sort of a week or so after I'd read this paper the first time in the like a family playing a board game on the on the train. Your kind of attention is drawn to it because that's what you've just read and you're kind of
listening out and you're hearing them like count out the steps. Oh, yeah. OK. I can really see how that how this is. Yeah. Going to really help their sort of development, things like that. Yeah. So that's the kind of initial recommendation. And then they talk quite a lot about that explicit instruction and like really breaking down the elements of arithmetic fluency. So like providing models and practice and particularly around that is sort of like using more efficient strategies for
calculation, which again, like stuff that primary school teachers like really know. But I like the kind of like systematic approach to this and, and just I guess reinforce, it's always quite nice as a teacher to like hear reinforced like something that what you think is good practice is actually also reinforced by the kind of empirical evidence as well. So they talk about things like using 10 as a reference point for calculating 9 + 5. So you might calculate 10 + 5 and subtract 1 or right, 9 + 5 is 9 + 1 + 4 or all these kind
of different things. And similarly for multiplication when they come and get a bit older, like 9 * 5 is like 5 less than 10 * 5. And because they kind of, they cite research that shows that like some pupils will figure out those alternative strategies and efficient strategies, but like, but many don't and we'll just carry on relying on the same things again, like relying on counting on or. And I definitely see this latter one, like at secondary school, like imagining the column method in your head rather than kind of
having that like that practice over time at the different ways of solving, like solving mental calculation problems. It breaks that down really nicely. Again, it's like stuff that primary school teachers know, but like reinforcing it and emphasizing it's part of like connected understanding is not just like, OK, we're going to learn this method right now. Practice doing all these questions using this method or whatever it is. And that doing that well is likely to involve some like
pictorial or concrete representations, like things like, yeah, particularly that kind of bridging 10 or yeah, where you've got, you're comparing to 10, lots of something when you've got multiplication, that understanding is so much clearer when and so much more flexible when, when you've got those representations that definitely, I mean, I'm sure this happens at primary school as well. And like where kids have got the kind of they can relate that concept that they can then like extend it so they can think
about like 9 adding or subtracting 99 and 999 and so on. And the ones who've just kind of like tried to memorize strategy and isolation are kind of stuck on just that, that one point. Is that almost like when they describe the input and the output? Because obviously they're at its most fundamental that output of those known facts are those common facts. But there was, there was a discussion of the input element to where actually that's what takes us beyond the mere recitation of facts towards development of, you know, they,
they use numeracy, they use number sense. They said there are lots of ways that academics have tried to describe the same fundamental ideas. Just understanding this, these these sort of connections really, really well. And is is that sort of what you see those inputs leading to or are is that what they are? Yeah, I think so. I think they talked about this idea a couple of different places, didn't they? So they talked about, yeah, that even if your goal might be to be
able to like, yeah, add, add 9 to a bunch of numbers or something like that, but actually you can't just skip straight to that or you're going to get very like shallow understanding if you skip straight to that. And there's like understanding what's going on sort of acts as the bridge and reinforces those connections. And it makes it easier to like get that recall really well cemented because there's like there's a kind of meaningful sort of network of knowledge in your head rather than rather
than you're just trying to like search for like the always nines. Like what do I do with nines? Like you've kind of got the the kind of greater reliant different bits of cues and so on there. I can't remember this is the point exactly they made in there, but it's sort of a related idea they talked about, which I think is kind of nice in maths is that you quite often start off with learning about a concept as a process. So that and then it becomes like an object.
So like addition to begin with is kind of about the process of counting on and then like addition is a separate thing or, and the first time I ever came across this was around like fractions like initially like 1/2 or 1/4 or what, or three quarters or whatever. It's always like half of something or 1/4 of something or 3/4. Whereas and then eventually those things become numbers and then you can operate on them as numbers. And it's the same way even way up to like a level maths because you have like like differentiation as part of
calculus is initially like a thing you do and at like 2 something and then it becomes like the derivative that like is a thing you can operate on and do stuff with. It's quite like a powerful way of just thinking about knowledge and maths. And I suppose that's sort of what's happening with that unders going from the process to the outcome as well. What might the the risks of focusing arithmetic fluency be? There's quite a there's quite a
few risks and I think this is perhaps where the like let me get the right acronym, the NCTM, the American NCTM are are kind of approaching this from in the. You might, you might end up with just that focus on like, yeah, like factual recall without meaning and taken to kind of, it's not even taken to its extreme. But like when you when you have pupils that have just learned like maths in a really isolated
and disconnected way, it just becomes so hard for them to kind of select the right bit at the right time and to kind of hold it, hold it all in their heads. And it's, I mean, it's the kind of thing that gets picked up in sort of curriculum reviews and like reviews and maths teaching and like has been for my entire like teaching career of like 15 years and has been for like probably 30-50 years before that as well. And I think the, the paper does a good job of like tackling that
head on because they're like sort of big, one of the big recommendations is around having well, like what they call well structured retrieval practice. So having people continue to like practice recalling things they've learned from memory over time. And like, so like, for example, it might carry on practicing addition facts all the way through primary and probably on to secondary school as well. And they give a whole range of different ways that might happen. So like free quizzes and things like that with the focus being like, as we kind of know about
retrieval and like your listeners will be really familiar with this, like, like recalling from memory, like with like with as little scaffolding as possible. And we know that that with that works really well over time, particularly when spaced out like much better than kind of restudying or repeating the information. But they talk about like that being much more impactful when it's well structured. So and there's a bunch of different ways that you can do that. And I think they're trying to get at two different things.
They're trying to get at having a systematic approach. So you're not you're not missing stuff out. And also like leveraging those questions to sort of help build meaning and look for patterns. So whereas because you could do retrieval with things like dice games to like practice like addition packs or something like that, but they can be a bit like they can be really engaging. They've definitely got place, but they can be really haphazard. You might never come across a fact or like you might have your
peoples who need the most practice with, I don't know. So you use them for multiplication. They learn to practice with their three times table and it keeps giving them seven times table questions and it's not really helping. They suggest a few different ways of structuring it like they talked about, like starting with the easier ones. So like multiplication, you must start with multiples of two and then 10 and so on. Gain like confidence and momentum or starting with the hardest things. So you start with the things that are like 6 * 8 and 5 * 7. The thinking being that then you
get the most practice of the hardest ones. It's interesting. It's kind of counterintuitive to sort of maybe how you might approach it or like working with things that are foundational and then like getting derived like derived facts from them. So again, if you start with sort of twos and like if you start with like twos and threes, you can only get your 6 times table and things like that. And you can make make those links and make those connections. But I think and then they talk
quite a bit in terms of like potential risks. So I think the kind of two that really like, I think they really stress are like only focusing on that product, that outcome that we talked about earlier. So yeah, lots and lots of kind of like quizzing, but they're not not making those links what the maths is behind it in this kind of structure. And then the second thing is around the importance of
people's achieving success. So introducing that retrieval too early before they've really established that kind of knowledge. Like sets would risk setting people's up to like fail or, or even like keep recalling the wrong fact and sort of cement the like wrong the wrong thing into their, into their memory. Which I think is something that sort of that kind of introducing that retrieval at the right time is something that kind of links to one of their other
recommendations around time constraints. And they can't, they again provide like quite nice specific recommendations about what they like about how to avoid introducing retrieval too early. They talk about like only introducing like 3 or 4 new facts at a time, and then only once they've got those, like going on some more. And then once they've got 2 sort of sets, then you can sort of start mixing them up and like really gradually building that
in. So you're talking like a few minutes a day, not like chunks of like 20 minutes like once a week or anything like that. Yeah. So I think there are those kind of risks and pitfalls and I think that's like what people worry about when they hear kind of like retrieval and memorization and things like that. But they give you some quite, they're kind of aware of those and suggest some quite like concrete ways of avoiding them. I imagine probably when we get onto time constraints we'll talk about sort of the risk of maths
anxiety and things like that as well. Call them risks, but it's just things you should really be looking out for as a teacher anyway, you know, because like they're called desirable difficulties for a reason, you know, and I think what's really good is they explain how to make them desirable, like you said, by bringing in those smaller effects at a time and rotating the mountain back in, you know, but when I think about, you know, things like, you know, if if pupils are misapplying strategies, you know, haphazardly, that's just the same as looking like from over
generalizations in the classroom that a teacher we're doing. So, you know, I think possibly, you know, they want to be helpful in supporting people in sort of may taking the next step towards this kind of behavior in the classroom, but also maybe just felt like I needed because the discourse, like you said, was so polarized in their neck of the woods. You know, I we often find these with these kind of papers, any people in the in the maths education field sphere. And is that overcompensation, you know, just to almost delay
the fears of those who are perhaps aren't, you know, because I don't, I don't see anything on, you know, like I said, I've got 9 things that I thought, you know, potentially worth worth watching out for that some of them they had mentioned. And it's, it's stuff you're, you're looking out for as a teacher anyway, I think, you know, and so, you know, I, I don't think it could be LED at, you know, at the door of arithmetic fluency. And because from what I could see, they've outlined this really effective way or it feels like a really effective way of
getting pupils to the point where they're like you say, confident with the mathematics, You know, anything like John Starr, Riddle Johnson, you know, what you were describing was adaptive expertise. You know, and you do, you know, in the same way the teachers don't become experts and you know, in in a, in a sort of linear, seamless fashion seem for the pupils too, But you want them to struggle. I mean, I agree. We don't want them to embed misconceptions, but they've got to see why things don't work as much as why they do work. You know, and quite often in
math, that's actually, that took a whole lot longer than I should have taken. If I just then, you know, if I'd added 10 and subtracted 1, you know, that kind of thing, you can think, oh look, I've got all this free time to do other stuff. Yeah, you kind of create the create the motivation for it almost by yeah, no, I totally agree with that. I think. Yeah, you part of it is like, Oh yeah, you've got to create the kind of worth the need for it, I suppose. Yeah, I think that kind of bit about struggling is quite nice in terms of they talk about like not restricting those question
sets too much as well. So not having, I don't know if you're suppose you're learning some multiplication packs in the like 3 times table or something and not having them as all is like 3 * 3 three times four 3 * 5 mixing them. So they're like something equals 3 * 5 or even like 3 times something equals 15. And so you know, they're seeing all those different formats. And I guess there's also like the related sort of division facts in there, which again is like what we know is really good teaching.
But often, I guess often like resources don't support is with that. And my teachers are really time poor. It can be, it can be really like you don't really have time to kind of notice it, let alone like act on it as well. But that kind of. So hopefully this is a bit of a sort of, I guess a call to answer talk policy and textbooks, textbook makers, makers as well. So the authors talk about space
drills and this is the bit, the dent dent in the micro, the pantomime body. What other low resource approaches might we use? Yeah, I suppose before maybe before we just do that like let's just like one of the things they do talk about is time practice. And and this was something I wasn't quite so aware of the like research around. Actually, it was quite nice to nice to read that there's like some evidence that kind of those
time constraints help improve performance sort of there because your, your brain sort of like tries to meet the goal of doing things quicker and sort of works a bit harder. So for example, if you if you kind of know how to count, like to add 9 and five by counting on and you also know, but maybe you're not quite so like it's not your natural go to to like add 1 and then add 4 to do the same problem. The time constraint can push you towards using that more
efficient strategy. But like they're they're really clear that this you only want the time constraints when people are really like pretty fluent at it like and pretty pretty solid. Because again, like things like mass anxiety, that little bit of time when you're quite good at something, a little bit of time constraint can create a tiny bit of like again, a push to improve your performance. But if if you're not any good to start with, it's going to be really stressful, it's going to make things worse. It's going to make you worry
about your math math lesson. So it's definitely not like every math lesson should have some time practice. It's definitely not like do time practice from the start or every day or anything like that. But like it kind of makes the case that it's quite, quite a powerful thing to do in short, short kind of doses. And we're not talking about unrealistic time constraints either, like kind of reasonable and crucially, not comparing, not giving pupils the opportunity to compare their performance between each other.
Because then that sort of reinforces like, I guess when we go back to what you talked about earlier with the, the pupils who get off to the best start are probably going to be in the best position to have that like to do that time practice even quicker. And then you do you kind of you're setting up on fair comparisons. It's not kind of humans. We love, love comparing ourselves to each other, even if it's not necessarily good for us. But yeah, the kind of question you asked was more about what else might we use? And I think like elaboration is
probably a really important one. So getting, and that's a really good way of getting back to that kind of meaning making, which you'll probably do it more at the start, the kind of instruction and then people's practice or whatever. But getting them to like explain why our strategies worked or explain why it's not like why it's not worked. Or it's kind of linked to that other paper we talked about a while ago, the ritual Johnson's paper where it's comparing different methods like or why, why is this people done it this
way and this people done it that way. And get like getting them to think and discuss and talk about what they're doing is really powerful for sort of improving that practice and, and requires them to sort of like retrieve from memory and things. And then I think we've already talked about the kind of varied practice. They're not all, they're not drills in all the same format. So you can, you can vary that much more than that kind of what I talked about with just the movement of the position of the
unknown and kind of the multiplication problem. And then I guess like practice that supports connections like probably what you describe as variation theory. So I don't know, like looking at a bunch of questions where you're adding nine to different numbers and then, OK, what do you notice about the number you started with and the number you finished with or those those kind of things can just make it a little bit more interesting. I think kind of what Craig Barton often describes as sort of a purposeful practice, like
there's something else there as well as the sort of truancy building I. Don't know if you, if you've heard the episodes with, with Dan Fromm who works in Cologne and when he was talking about the, a bunch of the names, the sparks and Fogel stress paper. But like raised cortisol levels and during the encoding and the retrieval processes and you know, and like, so it, it showed that actually a little bit, you know, slightly raised cortisol levels were actually beneficial
for the, for the learning process to take place. You know, so like any, you know, I've often found any arguments against time practice to be ideological in nature. You know, won't obviously go near anybody name anyone who's researcher quote, UN quote, research suggests that because they can be quite litigious. And but, and you know, if we, if we, if we think about that element, I think, you know, that it's, it's not even mathematics, it's, it's the natural sciences, you know, it's how your body reacts.
And so it's, it's a pretty good place, you know, so if you happen to be under the people, I'll send it across to you because it's meant to be semi not fail and not pretend to be a biologist in any shape or form. But it's it's really accessible elaboration you described there, I think can often be something that gets missed. Like if if we have a really good think per share routine that works in tandem with our what if you want to call your my turn, your turn, our turn, You know, I do we do whatever. If you have the those two
routines in place in a classroom. So you've got that back and forth between teacher and student, but also you've got every student in the class, no understanding the expectation that they're going to do a little bit of elaboration, at least a little bit. And if that gets built from when the children enter the school, like when they enter reception, when they're nursery, you know, and they know what's expected by the time they're, you know, as they go through the school, you can tell the difference between students who are used to that kind of articulation and that
kind of elaboration because it comes naturally to them. Whereas when you're just learning, you're leaning on the memory grade of the teacher a little bit more, just like you would be during the my, my, my turn, your turn sort of phase. So whenever you mentioned that, that's what came to mind was like thinking about as a subject leader and listening to this conversation and thinking, OK, what I should be trying to do is trying to tie all those different pieces together so that teachers know that they have all these different options. You know, because you're not going to have, you know, that purposeful practice in every
lesson because sometimes it's just going to be blocked. Like you said before, lock practice at the start. Let's get really good at doing this thing and then we can maybe think about it later on. And so that I'm almost in the back of my mind trying to paste these things together saying how do we structure that? What do we call that? Or maybe someone already has, I don't know. I mean, it would not be similar in your, if you're thinking about your classroom and your department, say your head of department, those are the kind of things you're thinking your teachers are thinking about as well. The idea of like those core routines really enabling things
is really powerful and a nice kind of link link back that you don't really need very many of them. There's a paper. There's a really good teacher education paper around kind of like a modular approach, being quite powerful in terms of like unders, like thinking about teacher, you can think about like, well, if I can introduce like an idea, that's an important thing to be able to do as a teacher. Like I'm, I do, we do if I can give them some practice, that's a really important thing to do as a teacher. And if I can get some kind of
discussion, that's also a really important thing to do as a teacher. And I might do them introduce the idea, discuss it, provide like practice, but I could also sometimes play around and go hang on. Well, they know quite a lot about this and give us to have a go at. Then I'm going to get a bit of discussion, then I'm going to teach them something about it. And then I'm going to like and play around with those different things. And if you've got those kind of initial routines really solid, that really sort of enables that. I think I am thinking about that. We are, I am thinking about that secondary like you are, you are trying to get the same, the same
things. I think as a, as a maths teacher, I think you want those kind of like building blocks that are like, I don't know, yeah, you can introduce some ideas, you can give some practice, you can check for understanding and some techniques within that that you'll use. But then you want some kind of like overall principles that you also like can hang your decisions off as well. And then if you've got all of those things, then you can make, you can make decisions in the classroom and you can like plan and then adapt, adapt what
you're doing. So I think it definitely kind of applies over a secondary as well. Because if you're a teacher reading this, I think it can be really, really useful because there's lots of really clear guidance on on different just on the background itself and then find the ways that we might behave in the classroom. But I think what's clear sort of having this conversation huge on is that when you're supported by systems in school, like say that for instance, the curriculum being really explicit and
specific about which mental methods we're going to focus on, I think then you're almost in an advantageous position relative to your peers here. They've sort of got the standard calculation policy, but actually it's the same one that we had in 2000. And it's not really that explicit, you know, just mentions the, the grid method and I can't think. And, and so I'm thinking that they're, they're almost layers to this, you know, as a, as a teacher, you're reading this, you're thinking, well, if this support isn't here or if this isn't the way we do things in school, and maybe think of it where I'm going to buy my trade
in the future. And then that'll be something I'll look out for. But if I'm a, if I'm a leader, I'm thinking, OK, how can I help my teachers make this the reality for my pupils as much, as as much as possible? Because. Maybe. Yeah. Because if you think about, you know, what other approaches, you know, that I think it's, it's everything in in tandem. And it's and it's the relationship between curriculum and professional development and and almost ask ourselves what the pupil experience is and then working from there, I think. I think it is quite rich kind of
almost the more the more senior you are in this, in the kind of like like from an audience point of view. I think as a yeah, as a school leader, you can think as a head of department or kind of head like maths lead or something. You can think a lot about the kind of curriculum and like how you can support that and like, and then so OK, what like also what kind of like knowledge about learning do people need as well? And like how might that help help them make better decisions and kind of how does that feed
into professional development? I think my kind of sense reading it was probably if you're a primary school teacher reading this and you've thought a bit about math teaching, then it's probably like little snippets you're picking. I think, OK, well, I hadn't really quite thought about that that way. That's a new like a slightly different thing. But I knew this and I knew that and I knew that. Whereas I think actually for like if you're a school leader and you're trying to support parents, I definitely had conversations with like friends who say like there's so much on phonics. I get so much support with like supporting children, how to how
to read. I know what to do with that, but I don't really know what I can do to support them with maths and actually like school leaders sort of saying what, what kind of say to parents and support them with early maths. And actually there's some really like small things here that you can say like you're, you're probably doing this already. Just do a bit more or OK, they can count 12345, but do they know at the end when they've counted the 6th one? Do they know it's just do they know that six like, and if not, just start saying 123456. I've got 6 things like really
like simple stuff that it's probably really obvious to like not particularly early years, I guess, teachers, but actually maybe a kind of like more senior level or like policy makers and things like that. And certainly for secondary school teachers, I think there's a lot that's quite, quite new in there. And yeah, thinking about where that's come from and where the gaps might be. And then also the kind of like the parallels I think is really really useful. Maybe I'll make the topic guide
for parents and I'll run a passage on see if that it matches up with what you have in in mind. You know, I like that idea that it's it gets more and more rich for the reader depend on what level of the sort of school ecosystem they're they're operating within. You know, I think, you know, I've got 2025 and brackets on mine. Is this this like this is like February time? Was it or there there are bikes? I know something. Like that? Yeah, it's definitely this year, yeah. So it's like, you know, it's a, you know, it's, it's hot off the press, but it's accessible. It is full to the brim.
I mean, I've got 48 pH version. Not all 48 pages have got and sort of probes and on on them. But you know, it's one that, you know, if you spent the term reading it, I think it'd be a lot of benefits. Obviously, I'll make sure all the links are shared and you know, this, it seemed to be freely accessible, which is always a bonus with the with research to this magnitude. And so, yeah, so I think definitely worth reading. And we've only really touched the the surface in the in this chat.
And, but also to say thank you very much for joining me, John. It's been an absolute pleasure, as always. OK. Thanks for having me here. It's been great. Great to talk about it. And everyone at home, until next time, thanks for listening.
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...