Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and https://www.acel.pro For maths curriculum questions contact us here or via support@alta-education.com Get your tickets for the TDaPE Conference Edinburgh Maths PD Dublin, Belfast, Glasgow - https://alta-education.com/cpd-tour-26-27/ For show notes, links, and a summary episode, sign up for the Hey! What You Reading For newsletter. Mondays at 7am BST - https://tdape.beehiiv.com/subscribe AI For Teachers newsletter Episode 319: Primary teachers are expected to teach across a breadth of subjects, each with its own body of knowledge, disciplinary practices and traditions. But is the generalist model compatible with teaching every subject well? In the first episode of a new mini-series exploring subject specialism in a generalist profession, I'm joined by Emma Turner and Neil Almond to consider what it means to develop expertise as a primary teacher, the extent to which pedagogical knowledge transfers between subjects and what we can reasonably expect of individual teachers. We explore four key questions: Is the generalist primary model compatible with teaching every subject well, or are we asking teachers to do something impossible? Which aspects of effective teaching transfer across subjects, and which are inherently disciplinary? What should curriculum resources, subject leaders and professional development provide, and what must remain a matter of professional judgement? How can teachers recognise the limitations of their own subject knowledge? Whether you're a classroom teacher, subject leader, school leader or someone involved in the development of teachers, there's plenty to think about in this episode.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Emma needless. Fantastic to see how you guys. Very well, thank you. It's lovely to be here. Yeah, doing very well. Thank you. Very excited to kick off this sort of curriculum miniseries on thinking of our primary education. But I thought maybe refresh listeners. I mean, Emma, they're all going to know who you are, but it's your first time in the podcast. I want to just talk a little bit about who you are and how you got here today. Uh, right. So this is my 29th year in primary. Uh, so I've got to stop lying and telling people I'm 45 because it doesn't add up anymore. Uh, but I've been teacher for many, many years, class teacher, assistant head, deputy head head
teacher, deputy direct for education, advisor for a MAT for Matt, advisor for a local authority and currently work as a school improvement associate advisor for Nottinghamshire for part of the week. And then the rest of the week do lots of work up and down the country on teaching, learning and curriculum design. And the series editor for this, in which we're going to maybe explore as part of this chat as well. I mean, how was that experience, Emma? I learned absolutely loads. It was a real privilege because you think you know stuff and then you speak to an absolute cast.
I an expert in that subject and you suddenly realise that there are loads and those are things that you hadn't considered or areas that they've explored, explored in so much depth. So it was a real privilege to read everything that those that deep specialism from individuals in those individual subjects. And then it was really great to pull out the kind of commonality bits and say, you know, this is what great primary looks like, but this is what this subject looks like. So it's been brilliant to edit it, brilliant to work with the people. And I really hope that anyone who reads it feels exactly the same way.
Yeah. Definitely. I mean, I had to very quickly read mine as I prepared for these podcast episodes, but they were very, I'm looking forward to getting hard copies and actually going through them in in depth, especially the early years, because I think it challenged some of my preconceptions about the the face. So interesting to to see Neil. I mean, obviously longtime listeners will be very familiar with your sort of your sort of background story and stuff. And you've got a little bit of an exciting adventure on the horizons. All right. Well, exciting midlife crisis. See, I'm not sure. So for the past 34 years I've worked for a teaching school hub
and that's been really successful, really sort of enjoyed all that work of some work with ECTS and PQS. But from January, I'm going to have a bit of a break from that and try and sort of go it alone and sort of look at a bit of education consultancy, but also kind of thinking about behaviour change more sort of widely support for the really lovely aspect of my role that I've done previously is getting EC, TS and mentors to sort of change their behaviour. And so it's kind of thinking about can we apply that to other workplace? Because obviously learning
doesn't just happen in school. There'll be organisations up and down the country as well that will be improving providing PD for their workers. And I think, you know, they need to make sure they're getting a good deal as well. So hopefully, yeah, some behavior change work in the corporate world as well. Fantastic. And you're here as our as our on call curriculum expert because I mean, the great thing about having teachers as authors is that you get on the grind at the chalk face, but during their half term, they don't necessarily want to come and sit in the basement in London do this, which is fair enough.
Horses for courses. So in this episode, we're going to start with considerations of generalism because with, you know, most countries, most nations, most jurisdictions, you're going to have roughly 10 to 13 subjects expected for primary partitions to cover. Is the generalist primary model actually compatible with teaching every subject well, or we're asking teachers to do something impossible? And I don't know if you want to kick us off on that one. It's an interesting one because I think of it through the kind
of primary phase lens and I sort of think that is it important to have real specificity very, very early on, or is it more important to get children to become really adept at being great learners in the classroom? So it's thinking about that tension between great overall primary practice and inducting children into formal, formal education alongside A gradual
shift into that potentially more specific aspect of individual subjects. So they'll be the big ones to start with, you know, English, maths, personal development, all of those things need to be quick off the quick off the bat basically. But then potentially some of the individual subject specialisms may need to start being more specific later. So I think yes, there's a, there needs to be a really good appreciation of subject
specificity, but I also think it needs to sit alongside a really good understanding of generalist practice and the need and the differences in seeing how a primary day is structured. So I think there needs to be definitely subject specialism in the school, but how that translates into the enacted teaching in the classroom might not look the same throughout the full bandwidth of each year group in the school. So I think it's perfectly possible to teach subjects well
if there is support from subject specialists or specialist resources, but I don't necessarily think that teaching individual subjects really specifically from the word go is is the most important thing. Where would you draw the the line? Where would you start? I don't think there is a line. I think it's more of an ombre. I think it's more of a gradual shift from a generalist approach into subject specificity. And as the children become more
adept at understanding key concepts within the subjects, as their general knowledge increases, as their understanding of the of the world increases, then that subject specificity takes on more importance. But I generally do think it's an ombre. I don't think there's a hard stop that. It's got to be in this year group or that year group. I think by the end of the primary phase, yes, you need to have understood the individual subjects, but when and how and with whom you introduced That is a gradual shift from generalism
to specialism in my mind. Do you reckon context, maybe school size plays a role in that? What? Do you think sometimes, I mean I'd support schools, Some of my schools that I support have got 23 pupils in in total. So one of my schools has got a class, has got nursery reception year one year 2 in one class and 3456 in another class. So that's going to be a very different set up from some of my other schools that I support that I've got 1500 children in on our Junior School in a big urban setting. So I think context is important.
I think the end goal of what you want for all children by the end of primary is important one to keep in mind. But I think the journey through to getting there is going to need to be more context specific based on the knowledge and understanding in the context of the children, but also the logistics of the organization as well. And also little things like where you are in the country. When I support a school in Bournemouth with geography and we're doing coastlines, it's very difficult, very different, sorry, from teaching that in Leicestershire where we are the furthest point from the sea, you know.
So there, context is always important, both for subject knowledge and what you might be teaching and what children bring to their understanding of that. But also context in terms of the professional agility of the organization, the knowledge base that's in the school. The smaller the school, the fewer specialists you're likely to have because you've got a smaller staff base. But I think that as long as you've all got a shared endpoint and understanding of what children should be able to do by the time they leave primary, the route through to that may, may look and probably should look different. Yeah, almost all sounds to me
Libya. Thoughts. Yes, I do, which is good. I think if you want to just sort of distill the question into a, a clear answer, I think it's yes, it is compatible, but there are sort of lots of ifs and buts needed for that. And I think what you said, I'm around sort of keeping in mind what the end result, the end of year 6 looks like is really important. Because throughout all of this, I just feel really sort of whenever I've worked on curriculum, I just feel sorry for the poor year 6 teacher who's got the most complicated bit of art drawing that they need to sort somehow model the
most complicated bit of modern foreign language that they need to work on. That's not to say that anything else, you know, isn't complicated or difficult, but I do feel for that year 6 teacher who has the the most sort of right, the most sort of subject specialism. And let's be honest, usually sometimes those teachers are in year 6 because the Sats are a thing and we know that that's sort of wave effects of impacts practice. So I think it's a really good ambition to have that generalist primary teaching model can work for everyone and work for every
subject as long as I think you are really clear about what that boundary conditions is for what is that we want to achieve by the end of year 6 for MFL and all those sort of subject disciplines and being, you know, there's being ambitious absolutely, and then there's being realistic. And it's trying to find that that fine balance between the both keeping that poor year 6 teacher in mind particularly. And as we know in primary, you know, you could be teaching year six one year and then boom, you're back down to early years, then the next year after. And so how are you then supporting that years, that early years teacher who's doing
all that really important foundational stuff to all of a sudden having to be semi fluent in French and really understand multiple perspective points when they're modelling in art, etcetera, etcetera, when that's not been what they've been thinking about? So my sort of big but around this is that it requires sort of a lot of investment. And I think there are, you know, political choices to where you put that investment. Do you want to make teacher training sort of a five year endeavour where you actually make sure and you practice these things and actually there is almost like a French word Spanish one O 1 sort of course
within that process. Now pros and cons to all of that, obviously, are we going to go on strike at some point to make sure that we get 20% PPA instead of the current sort of 10% that we have? Or, you know, is there some sort of hybrid model where actually we have that as our endpoint, but we do do something like the the Singapore model, which always gets spoken about in terms of this high quality mass teaching. But you know, the third sector does a lot of work there in terms of the afternoon and supporting with the more artistic sort of subjects where
that subject specificity isn't there because they are working so hard on being incredible mass teachers. So that I think there is sort of, I think it is possible, but I think basically there needs to be a lot of political will from politicians I think to make it really work, I think. I wish I could remember. There's a piece of research I saw and it was getting on for about 20 years ago where it said the knowledge equivalent to be a teacher of year 6 to teach to age-related expectations for year 6 was the equivalent knowledge equivalent of 10A levels.
Wow. And that's a good bit of research. I can't find it. It was in a, it was in a broadsheet newspaper and I, it resonated at the time because I was in my seventh straight year in year 6. It's like once you get in, you're never let out again. Oh. It's not California. Once you're in, you're never leaving. But you're right in that there's a massive amount of knowledge, part of it accumulated over time if you end up staying in year 6 for a long time. But there is that fear as well, so that you often hear me, it goes, don't put me in year 6 because there's a fear of
there's that much knowledge. Ultimately, it isn't hugely difficult knowledge because the children are only 11. It's not like a PhD in astrophysics, but there's so much of it to actually have to get your head round as the year 6 teacher. If you're going to teach history to your highest attaining child in history and your art, like you said to your highest attaining child in art, it's a massive pressure. So there is a need for specialist knowledge or specialist resource in in school. And it's how you get that
balance and how you put those things around that member of staff in your six so that professionally they don't get trapped in there either and they don't and that they potentially lose that overview of the rest of the the school as well. Yeah, I mean, the most challenging thing I ever saw was there was this Year 5 program study, can't remember which one it was, but it was asking the pupils and the teachers to use the technique Da Vinci had used in painting the Mona Lisa. I can't remember exactly what that technique is, but like, wow, I can barely draw with perspective, never mind that
level of depth of expertise. I. Think as well that bit of research probably before the new, old, new. I don't know what we're going to call it. I still call it the new. I still call it the new National Creek. And despite the fact that it's the 2014 one where, you know, throughout my schooling showing my age here, I wasn't taught grammar explicitly. And all of a sudden I was teaching what a modal verb wasn't. A subjunctive mood wasn't. Yeah, yeah, I was a child of the 80s. Well, as in I was in primary school in the 80s where we taught maths through little work cards that you just took out a box.
SMP. SMP and KMP. Yeah, you put your little headphones on. If it was a headphones lesson like we've got today and you're off, you'd toddle into the corner by yourself and then look at the answers on the back of the sheet. Really first intelligent sheet. They're spoken about so fondly. I was at BCME 10 yeah in October and they they always talk about the cards so fondly as if it was this great way to. William loves them. Loved. Them to engage in this individual. I didn't realize the answers were on the back and the system. If the answers weren't on the back of the card, you could go into the box and there was like a little pamphlet at the back.
You just get it out right on the right and sister. High trust environment saying wouldn't, wouldn't, wouldn't trust kids these days. So, I mean, I, I, yeah, I'm definitely willing to subscribe to the idea that at some point we're transitioning, but there are a lot of factors. Are there any bits of like what we would call quote, UN quote, good teaching that transfer across subjects and which kinds of knowledge or ways of thinking are inherently disciplinary? I think what what when I work with teachers on curriculum is
lost the time teachers get stuck or ravelled up on the detail of what they're teaching rather than the underlying concept of what they're what it is they're trying to teach. So if you're teaching history and the topic, for want of a better word changes, the bit that worries colleagues that I work with is what's the detail of this I need to teach rather than, OK, well, we were going to teach sources and evidence you in this unit, but actually now we're going to use sources of evidence in this unit and not recognizing that similarity between the underlying aspect of it and getting worried about the
details. So I think one of the best things when I work with schools or when schools have got this really nailed is that teachers really understand what the core concepts of each subject are and teach those well rather than getting ravelled up with the detail of it. So I think once there's a clarity about what is it, what is it that I'm actually teaching in this lesson session, whatever. And it goes a little bit back to the secondary thing, because every child that arrives in Key Stage 3 is not going to have had the same national curriculum
experience because there's choice at the moment that you might teach choose to teach Vikings in Year 3, that other school might teach Vikings when the children are in Essex. And so they're going to come up with a detail, a level of detail of knowledge that's different in Key Stage 3. What they shouldn't come up with the differences in is understanding those core concepts that underpin the subject. So I think that things that translate well are when teachers understand what concepts they're trying to teach and highlight those in their teaching and, and link those together really well. So there's a coherence through
each subject that they teach, and that approach about thinking about concepts rather than the detail of content is where in every subject that for me that works when they know what it is that they're actually trying to teach rather than getting revelled up with the detail. Because we think about Tom's ideas on hinterland, yeah, I've known like medieval scholars who teach in year 4, teaching the Anglo Saxons. And they, they want to go so deep into the hinterland that actually they lose sight of, of what the purpose of that unit is like, as you say. So yeah.
So each of us brings our own passions and enthusiasms, you know, I mean, like if we were doing like Tudor and Stuart history, it's probably going to be some quite slim in terms of content for me. But again, if it's Vikings fully into it. When I work with schools on designing their curriculum, they say, oh, but we don't want to change the I'm not suggesting they do. But if there's a conversation in the room where somebody suggests, let's, let's look at the Life and Times of Ernie Shackleton rather than Florence Nightingale. And people say, but I don't know anything about Ernie Shackleton. That's not the issue. You're still going to teach the
same things. You're still going to teach about historical significance and cause and effect. You're going to teach the detail, a different set of details, not the underlying concepts. And that's where I think people get a little bit ravelled up in terms of how do I have to teach this subject? Not actually thinking about how do I have to teach her thinking what's the detail you want me to teach? And that's two different things. So I think really understanding the concepts that underpin each subject. And that's why these books work so well because they've they all outline. That is where great teaching
stems from. It stems from a real understanding of the structure of the subject rather than the detail of the subject. And I think first for me as well, I agree. I think maybe I would also say that that content I think is really important and absolutely agree. We need to find decide what those concepts are. And that in itself is a massive intellectual endeavour because subject communities themselves think apart from history, don't really know what their own concepts are in their own sort of subject. And so as primary generalists, that in itself can you know.
But I feel like as teachers, we love a list and we love a single source of truth. And I think the history that is sort of there, but the other subjects, maybe maths is the other exception. We need to sort of do that intellectual thinking as a school, thinking about what disarg and what concepts really sort of suit our community to make sure that it reflects sort of the voice, that mirror and window. Sort of thinking about it as well. In terms of then all that teaching stuff, for me it always comes back to the model of learning as well. Like I do think there are some general sort of pedagogies that would work from, and maybe this
is my sort of primary bias coming in, but as long as you're thinking about, right, how am I getting their attention? Yes, what that looks like in EYFS might look a little bit more different to what it looks like in year 2 to what happens then in Key Stage 2. But I'm pretty certain I could go to a year eight class and still sort of get their attention. And if I was having to teach any sort of the subject or if I'm thinking about checking for understanding, you know, how I write a high quality question, yes, I need that sort of subject content knowledge to be able to write a good question. But I know now is a good time to
check that question. I know I want to gather as many sorts of sources of data as I can. I know I want to make sure that I really sort of limit the cheating aspects so that results I'm getting are valid. You know, I think there are sort of quite some sort of general thinking if we come back to the decisions that we make as teachers, coming back to that sort of model of learning, that lovely diagram that it surprised me EC TS still haven't. I'm sick and tired of talking about it to be honest, but still sort of see EC TS in the country that haven't seen the Willingham simple model of memory through their ITT, but that's a separate
discussion. It's not, not just EC TS, they do a lot of work and it's, although there's been a big trickle down, I think nationally there are lots of teachers who they, they work within it without knowing what it is. They do great work in classrooms. But haven't had the opportunity to engage with that model in depth. But I think that once teachers do see that, then that's it. That's a framework to hang their decision, which then overall improves what you're teaching,
regardless what you're teaching. So, I mean, you're going to, Neil said that the there was no consensus across many of the subjects you were going to jump. In I was going to say a stupid joke and say the general consensus is because I do a lot of work with schools on developing their history, geography and science curriculums. And I always make the joke that if you want to define the concepts in history, put 2 historians in a room, they'll fight to the death and come up with three answers should be. But it is that important point of there needs to be a consensus somewhere. So regardless of what you call
it in your school or how you group those concepts in your school, there needs to be a shared underpinning framework of when we talk about geography, is our geography geography ish enough? Is our science science ish enough? Or have we got a collection of nice things for children to do under the banner of this subject? Or is our thinking actually underpinned by the rigour of what this subject is about? Or have we called it science? But we just do lots of nice, lovely things. Not that I don't like doing lovely things in primary school. Part of coming to primary school is doing lovely things, but it's not just about lovely things.
Yeah, I mean, more than once I've made colour and in jokes in front of geography teachers who I didn't realize were geography teachers. So my apologies to all for those jokes. Of the territory, I'm sure. But yeah, because I mean 2018 sort of Ofsted framework, we sort of saw lots of statements on websites and that I think was replacing the kind of thinking that you're describing there. I'm almost like on a senior level within the school. What is it we, what's our aspiration for every child and their experience as they go through the seven, five years, whatever it might be, and it manifested as lists, when really
it should manifest as where we put in our plant, our flag in terms of the subject. I love an intent document that runs to 7 pages. I really enjoy those when I get sent those. Like why question mark I? Mean I'm not even reading my own documents that are 7 pages long I'm. Producing those documents versus actually doing the heavy sort of intellectual, fun, intellectual work of having those conversations with your staff around what do we look on, how do we make sure DT is DT and not junk modelling like you know? Yeah.
And and it's really interesting when I do work with schools on that, that's the bit they actually really like. That's they've kind of the meaty interesting stuff. It's not about creating some kind of PR marketing strap line. It's actually, well, what does this look like when it's enacted in the classroom? What does this feel like? What will they be doing? What will the children be thinking? What should be we be exemplifying? What should we be highlighting not? Can we put it together in a nice banner that we can hang on the gate? What we're going to do? How does this underpin what I'm doing on Tuesday? Exactly, Yeah. I think as as middle leaders, as subject leaders, you're going to
get increasingly less opportunity within the school's timetable to go and support your colleagues. So you've really got to want to drive that subject forward and you've really got to believe in that vision. I think because you're going to be using your time in the staff room, you're going to be using your sort of your after school time, you know that four to five window maybe when there's no staff meeting and. It is interesting in as primary school when you get bequeathed a subject, you don't necessarily get a choice about it. You say hey, you are now, you are the RE lead, now you are the art lead and you're going great. Just got me around maths, but thanks for that.
Oh, you are the leader of, I think I was the leader of 6 subjects at one point and the head teacher and having a baby and moving house. Not my finest hour. But you have to then be the advocate for the subject and that point of contact for the subject. You need to get yourself up to speed quickly. But I don't think you can be the specialist in the school. But I think you've met that's when the networks model needs to come in, where if you haven't got that specialism in your in yourself or within your staff, you've got to be able to tap
into some kind of local network group of schools hub, whatever that may be to give you that shape and help you to clarify your own thinking around that. If you've been given a subject, gifted a subject. Yeah, my my second year I was given RE. So I became organising Christmas and Special People Day was essentially the the leadership that I listen. You don't know about. Oh, which songs you want to sing? That's an important distinction to make around how inconsistent the middle leader role is up and down the country.
I'm sure you've got managers of subjects, IE often doing IE. So I've got to make sure their nativity goes on right. And actually very little thinking around what's being taught because the RA is a bit of a special case because of the local authority, because you've until maybe the new national curriculum comes in, you've got to use whatever, I will say, wild, wacky local authority scheme that local authority have put together versus an actual leader of that subject as well. And he's sort of making sure there is that clarity between those roles and what subject leader should actually be doing,
you know, rather than the subject manager. I think it's a really important distinction to make and. I think as well, sometimes in a primary school, because of the size of the staffing body, you often meet a middle leadership responsibility very early in your career. Oh I've worked with ECT's who've got through the door and it's like we need someone to do an art and or it's usually I'll be honest or ET. The other systems thing that needs to sit up alongside that is then that development and clarity around what we mean by subject leader role. What do they do? What do they not do?
What do they need to have an overview of an oversight of what is the, what are the limits and parameters of that? And what is the expectation in this school of what a subject leader will be doing? And is their support around people who are early in their both their teaching career and their leadership career, that they've got the structures and the systems and the support to be able to do that role well, rather than every single subject leader going away and inventing their own way of doing subject leadership? There will be subject specific aspects to it.
Like some subjects have statutory external tests that are going to be externally marked. So you can have a data set. Some schools don't have a data set for, sorry, some subjects don't have a data set for certain subjects. But there needs to be clarity in the school around the role, the remit and the reach of the subject leader in order to be able to to lead those subjects really well. Yeah. Definitely. I think that leads really nicely into my, my third, third question. And what sort of curriculum, resources, professional development opportunities should we provide for possibly our
subject leaders, but also our teachers and, and how much of it needs to be professional judgement on the on their part rather than, you know, for instance, there was something a programme of study or scheme which gives to them. I could talk about this for about 3 to 5 minutes. I think there's a tension between if there's too much prescription, then it doesn't give enough time for people to respond to context and it can become overwhelming very quickly. And I also think that a lot of
externally produced resources don't have enough wriggle room in them. And by that means, by that I mean amount enough time, there's too much in them even to to get through once then then to revisit and go over and develop that mastery of that subject that you really want. And if they become so prescriptive, some of the ones that I've seen that people have to read 7 pages of a plan to teach a one hour lesson. And it's almost like they've become unsupportive by being trying to be too supportive
because they're too, they're too dense in their structure. So I think there's a sweet spot, sweet spot where a concept is outlined, the point of the unit is outlined. The this is the steps in learning that you might take through this because this would be a, this would be a logical sequence to go through the content in order to understand it. There's a clarity around what the unit's actually trying to achieve in terms of children understanding, but that there isn't right. Here's lesson 1. Here's everything you need. Here's lesson 2, Here's everything you need because that takes away the professional judgement.
And also teachers are really hard working, biddable people. They want to do the right thing. And if somebody gives them a resource, a lot of them will think I've got to do this as it is because I want to do the right thing. So a lot of teachers haven't been given permission to say here's our externally produced scheme, whatever that may be or the one that we've done in school. It's a framework, it's not Magna Carta. You can, as long as you get the kids the way they need to be at the end, do as you see fit in your classroom, as long as they can do this by the end. So I think that sometimes
there's a danger of over scaffolding the resource so that the teachers don't engage with it on that detailed level of thinking. What do my children need? And they worry more about getting through the resource than actually thinking hard about the content. The flip side of that is you don't want to give something that's so loose and woolly and lacking in structure that people can think I'm just going to do whatever I like about this topic. I'm really interested. You talk about the Anglo Saxe. I'm really interested about this
niche thing that I understand. I'm going to do that. And so I think there's a, there's a, it's both A crutch and something that can get in the way sometimes overly scaffolded resources for people. And when I work with curriculum design, I will say it is like a crutch. Like sometimes you need everything and you need to lean on it to start with. But after a while, once you get going bit like when you've been on crutches for a while, in the end, that crutch gets in the way and you kind of need to get rid of it because you can do it yourself now. So I think there's a tension and a danger sometimes about overly
structuring resources to support teachers. Yeah, it's a fine balance that agency autonomy and when do you release and and who is our own ward and what the what because everyone's common at different. Points in their career but if somebody gives me a maths plan and goes teach that I'll be like ha no ha ha no but if somebody says can you go and teach year one music or year 6 detail like what you got give me give me everything give me everything you've got and the. Issue is, is that that's different for every single person. Yeah, it's definitely not viable to create 5 different versions of each thing of being like,
you're in this lane for this subject so you get everything, but you want to be in that lane for math. So yeah, as long as you get on with what you need to do, then that's year 6 ISM of like I'm going to put you in year 6. I'm going to close the door because I know whatever you do, we'll get them together by Yeah, you'll get into that endpoint, we'll leave you alone, just do what you need to do. But it is such a hard tension and I think something that I'd say talking to BC TS who kind of work in schools where it is very much here, here it is given to you. And then they say, you know, they still, despite all of that,
they still work long hours. The expectation's still really, really high. And then you have to say, well, if you have that autonomy, that's not going to give you fewer hours. You're going to be working more because you've got less to go on. So finding that, and I think that kind of comes down to re sort of being really clear around what do we expect a teacher to be able to do. And sometimes schools don't help themselves because it's like you have to fill out this 20 PowerPoint slide for the lesson. Don't. Say PowerPoint to me. And it has and it has to be on
our branding and it has to have, you must ask the hinge question in this particular way or something like that, which is bonkers conkers. But it is difficult to find that balance. And as I say, I've done a lot of internal work with the schools that the teachers will have a part of in terms of rolling out sort of curriculum. And yeah, I'm not sure we, we thought we found a good middle ground. And then the feedback was, no, we want more. This is still too much work. So it's like, OK, back to the drawing board. What do you want? What's going to be useful?
And I'm sure some people think, yeah, this is the right balance. I'm like, this is still not enough. Give me the lesson slides. I'm still working 60 hours a week potentially and some I'm sure I'd like to know I can just maybe loosey goosey and I'll get them where they need to be and don't worry about it. It's so hard. You just made me think about something yourself. The when you've got something that's been produced elsewhere, be that within a trust, within a commercially produced package, whatever that is, that person can never assume what you've got in your classroom other than potentially A photocopier, a
data projector and you know, something to write on. So very often the pedagogy suggested within or the activities or the technique, whatever you're doing in that can be very narrow that you can get lots of lessons that look and feel and the same or start in the same way because people can't assume what you've got in your classroom. So the way that you teach that becomes potentially quite formulaic because the resources that go with that scheme or approach, I can't say that actually you are, I want to
teach you like this. Like I'm just thinking about some externally produced schemes that don't reflect the fact that lots of schools and hundreds of schools that I work with, especially in the Midlands, do a continuous provision model to the end of Key Stage 1. So you won't need to start with a digitally projected set of slides, but that's what it comes with. And so then the teachers are saying, well, actually, I've got to teach it like this now. So they stop doing what they're doing and they come and then teach in the way that the resource has provided the resources. And it, there's a gradual
erosion of the richness and the breadth of the way that you teach in that classroom. And then it, that's potentially one of the reasons why we end up with, with colleagues saying, I have, I haven't got any slides for that lesson. I need the slides for that lesson. I was like, no, a lesson isn't slides. It isn't that, but it can become that because when people write resources for somebody else, they can assume you've got that, but they can't assume that you've got XYZ other ways to teach. So I do think there's a a danger in that externally produced resources bit in that trust
based ones or commercially produced ones can accidentally erode teacher practice in the classroom as well because of the things that they have in them. I think it comes from the top is I'm listening to you guys talk because essentially there are there are things in ways you want your teachers behaving, things you want them thinking about, things they need to consider before they even go near the classroom. But if they don't have the time and the space, you're talking about 6070 hour weeks. You know, one of our things is teaching can be a 45 hour week job if we reduce all of the needless bureaucracy from it. And so anyone listen thinking
actually, I'm going to speak to my most senior leaders if we're not in those conditions, but if a senior leaders listen, they're thinking actually, well, how can I you know, school improvement needs to be as a reductive or subtractive process where you text stuff one of my willing to make sure is my priority. And so that's one might. So if we use maths as an example, rather than like you described, I'm a thrown loads of spaghetti. The ones that hear all the possible manipulatives and representations of an idea. What's my key metaphor and as a teacher understanding, I'm going to try and get the majority of my classic over the line with this idea, with this one metaphor, but knowing that I've
got two or three as backup just in case that doesn't land because it not everything lands with everybody. And I think that probably transfers across also just thinking OK, in terms of what do I really need to spend my attention on because it's finite and I need my most senior leader support because if I'm being expected to six data drops a year like we used to for every subject you. Know. The red, the sort of rag rated forms that we just make up in real time because there was no, you know, there's just the one of those was the old national
curriculums targets with that they were called, you know, and just sort of yeah, Facebook. What is 81? A nice make 2 sub levels worth of progress guys. Otherwise, what they're doing. Yeah, even if the subject is cumulative and not linear. We did gymnastics that term, we've done football this term, and you must have made progress from gymnastics to football. What somehow? Yeah. I think just to come back to one of the points that I said about sort of slides and stuff, I think you're absolutely right. But I also think that can happen
also even if you're not using external schemes. Yeah, I think I've seen, I've been certainly told about, you know, PPA sessions where the year group team are just sitting in silence and it's just like you're going to do English, I'll do maths and I'll do the slides. And actually PPA is about that rich conversation around and the decision making of. I'm asking this question then because that I'm using this model because I want them to know this and it's going to come up later on. And I think that our of conversation around planning is eroding because of the pressures
around sort of time and and things like that. And it's just not giving teachers that empowerment to have those conversations around that planning process, which is a process not focusing on this with the artifacts of that planning process, which is here's the finished slides, here's the worksheet. They're saving this folder. Where are they for English? Great, lovely. I'll let you know if you're lucky, how it goes and whether anything needs adapting. And half the time that doesn't even happen. And so it's, I lost art, I
potentially in my experience anyway, that sort of lost art around. And I think the difficulty, the other difficulty that comes with that is obviously wanting to make teaching a profession in which, you know, we can have those sort of workplace flexibilities. If you can take PPA from home, absolutely there are absolute benefits to doing that. But equally, it can potentially also erode sort of that joint sort of planning process as well and finding A framework, mechanisms by which teachers can
still work from home. But you know what, just have that 10 minute conversation with your colleague. You know, I believe you're having PPA from home. You should be doing some sort of PPA, yes, in a private appointment amongst what stuff if you can, but there should be sort of some sort of conversation that you can have with your year group partner if you're lucky to have one around what that planning has been like the. Middle P, the middle P of PPA, that preparation bit, the too often Ppas focusing on the first P, writing a plan or producing a thing and not actually preparing, rehearsing
explanations, talking about modelling, thinking about how you're going to discuss this potential misconception. And schools have they spend all their time on that first P and not the middle P, either because they're plowing through an overly dense existing resource and they're having to try and make sense of that. Or they haven't got enough there and they're having to spend the whole time Googling for a map of Sparta that they can possibly use. What you need is the artifacts and the things ready there to
teach that lesson. And then that PPA time to really focus on the middle P. There shouldn't actually be a massive amount of that first sort of P to do because the the medium term plans should be there. They should be ready to go sequenced really well. And So what needs to happen in in the PPA is that middle P right? Prepare to teach this medium term plan. And that's what doesn't happen a lot of the time. And the, the conversation bits interesting because very often in a small school you're having
a conversation with yourself. It's just me then. Or a lot of schools have got odd mixes. So they'll have a year 2A, year three and a mix 2/3. And that person that is potentially on their own, but actually they, they need to have two conversations. And the other thing that bothers me a lot of the time is like you were saying, I'll do the English and you do the maths. Well, if you don't have that conversation, how do you know what the story of that sequence is? How do you end up two slides ahead of the children?
When you're kind of trying to work out the story of this lesson as you go in along. And I do think that schools need to, when you talk about investing your time, Kieran, invest that time in making sure that their initial medium term plans provide the scaffolding and structure and have done some of the donkey work in terms of finding really great resources that demonstrate things. So people aren't trying to find an image that shows a tropical island that hasn't got a stamp through it so that people can actually use that time either to think and prepare and get ready to teach that lesson or talk
about the common problems across the year group, team that you can overcome, overcome together. But that middle P is I totally agree. It's a lost art. And I talk a lot about the lost art of planning. And because it's not that it's not the planning that's the lost art, it's the preparation. And I talk a lot about the fact that practising explaining, which comes back to your are there great examples that go across subject? Yeah, you need to have practised how you're going to explain something. The first time you explain a concept shouldn't be to the children, should they shouldn't
be your dress rehearsal where you've got a double back on yourself and go over thing. I'm going to mean no, I didn't mean that. And one of the things I talk about with schools a lot of the time is make you slides, do slides. Just don't show them to the kids. Just have them if you need it as a aid memoir, because it's hard work to teach 12 subjects, especially if you're doing to a particular level, and just show them to yourself. And that gives you the freedom then to do different sorts of modelling or different ways of structure in the lesson. But you've got that sequence structure there for you. Just because you made it doesn't mean the children have to see it. And if sometimes I feel like I've revealed the sequence of
the universe, I don't have to show it. No, you don't. Just because you made it doesn't need you, doesn't mean you need to show it. Absolutely. Maybe we should campaign for the preparation to be the first P Yeah, preparation planning an. Assessment If ever anybody ever hears me speak or works and they they will hear me say absolutely. Years. The middle P is the most important one, and it's the one that's constantly overlooked because people are too busy making the bits and bobs and the nuts and bolts of the lesson rather than thinking how am I going to prepare to understand this concept well myself, teach
it well? And how will I be checking that the children are actually with me whilst I'm doing this? And have I rehearsed it well enough before it hits the ground in the classroom? Which? In primaries hard because you only have one stab at it, don't you really? In secondary, if your first year 7 lesson photosynthesis doesn't go well, you have six more other the same lessons that you can go, right. So that first lot get a bad deal, but by the time you've done that less than six times, didn't your 7 cohort on the same day within sort of two or three days of each other? Which goes back to your consistent metaphors thing.
If you've established those across the subject that you're going to be teaching across the year, you can consistently come back to something that you're adept at explaining or adept at using or adept at modelling with so that you can make those connections for yourself and your teaching as well as the children are in front of you. Yeah, I mean, I often think one of my schools, for cover reasons, asks me to do the same 50 minute session three times. I wonder who gets the best version of it. Isn't the ones you get at 9:00 in the morning or is it? They want to get the third version at 1:00, but it's also after lunch. So I'm always thinking who's getting the best day in here?
Probably the middle group, but. It's interesting because I was just thinking when you're talking about there's a lesson that I thought on introduction to ratio, which I was used to do in mixed year 56, about the 7th time I've taught that. Oh God, I was amazing that I could do it off the top of my head, I could do it in my sleep. And I'm thinking those poor people that were my first year round teaching this really that was really complicated way of explaining that. But the seventh time through. But that's why that middle P conversation is so important because if you're in a team and you've got an experienced teacher that's taught this
multiple times, they can talk colleagues through. This is the best way to explain it. So if you don't call about that time for that middle P, then that professional system doesn't get shared either when people are busy tapping into a laptop. And you've spent a lot of time thinking about flexible working energy. And so I don't have a source, but my understanding is that sort of new teachers, new sort of young people come into the workforce because of the effect of the pandemic. They expect a bit more flexibility in their working lives, no matter what sector they're in.
Is there any way we can marry almost the expectations because we we're talking about perhaps people who are working full time here. But if if people are job sharing or if them there are schools where people are only in maybe three of the five days and things are there extra consideration. I mean, whenever you think about your the sort of advice you give people on flexible, where, where do those two sort of ideas, Mario? Ideally, if you've got a job share, you've got a some form of crossover somewhere. So the easiest way to do it is to give both people PPA at the same time so that they're
somebody has it just before they come in and somebody has it just as they're finishing that bit. That would be the ideal because not only can you say this is where I've got to, this is where you're going to pick up and it's seamless, but it also gives that chance for that conversation about how well the unit's going, what's what children need to have more time on, less time on. So whenever work on flexible working, it's always about what works best for for learning in the school. And it may well be that you need to learn more heavily on that
initial medium term plan that they need to be absolutely bolt on and crystal clear so that people can see exactly where they're up to in that unit of work as well. But it's factoring in time when you know, everybody's going to be in to ring fence space to have those conversations. And the worst case scenario is where teachers pass like ships in the night over lunchtime and the, you know, the the 2 1/2 day person has finished and the the other two and 1/2 day person is picking up and they have a horrid conversation. One person's bustling things into the bag to get out the door
and the other one just skipped in like Tigger because they've left up for three days. Reflects on my own practice walking in on a Wednesday, don't we? Everyone is like crawling through the stuff, but it is that crossover is absolutely important to factor in. And any decent leader who's working with colleagues who are working flexibly, either in a job share or in a standalone role that doesn't have another half, because that's the other thing. Sometimes you're employed to do a body of work that's over a certain Andre.
You don't have another person to go with. It is recognising that crossover, be it a leadership crossover, be it a classroom teacher crossover, be IT support staff crossover. There has to be that professional dialogue and recognising that and factoring that into your flexible working model is absolutely fundamental. Otherwise you're just doing a quick bat on bat on pass and it's very easily dropped, very easily dropped. Then you can imagine, yeah, I need to find out what that source was, but I know there's certain there's like a Guardian article the other day I was saying about how teaching should become a four day profession, pupils going for five, but
teachers do 4. So it's it's certainly something that seems to be on people's minds. It's the availability to work 195 days at the moment that the change is coming into, I believe. But again, that's quite sad because there's a lot of teachers who've deliberately gone to .8 to try and get a sense of balance in their own lives who it'd be interesting to see how it comes out in the wash in terms of what that actually looks like. The new proposal and how that affects people have already gone to .8 and and how that affects people who are currently full time but want to look at maybe
condensed hours, something like that, Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think that's a lot of policy that we're getting at the moment, seems to be a wait and see kind of situation. I don't know, I don't want to be overly critical of the current sort of department, but that's just where we are, isn't it? I mean, like last couple of weeks, last couple of guests have been talking about having the safety to admit that they're struggling with something or they don't know something. If I'm a teacher and I, I know that there are, there are real shortcomings in my own subject
knowledge. How do I go about eh, approaching my sort of those who are supposed to support me, but also bringing myself up to the point where I can effectively teach to the, you know, almost to my own internal standards? I think first of all, you have to recognise that you were saying right at the beginning, Neil, there's a massive amount of knowledge that you do need to know and nobody expects you to know it on day one when you walk into the profession. And also if you've not got the breadth of experience about teaching across the whole bandwidth or you've not taught
the full curriculum because you might have initially been employed to teach just English and maths or you might have come in as a support stuff. Sorry, a support teacher for a particular area of the curriculum is recognising your own experience and your own subject knowledge. And there is no shame in saying I haven't done geography since I was 16. You know, I need to know what is it I need to know in order to teach this well. And again, I keep coming back to this meet this idea of the medium term plan and the subject leader. That should be absolutely crystal clear because what you need to know for that unit of work and how you understand the
shape of the subject in your school should be really easy to see in the codification of the school's curriculum. They should be able to see that at a glance. Too often you have to go through so many different documents and so many different resources to actually understand and get some clarity around the teaching in terms of your own subject knowledge. If you're teaching 7 year olds and you teach them history, the actual depth of history that you personally need to know isn't massive, but you do need to have an idea of how what you're teaching fits in with everything
else they'll have done to date and everything else you tee in them up for. And that's why it comes back to that. This idea of your codification in school should have real clarity. If that's not there in the documentation, that's the first question to say, how do I get clarity around what this curriculum actually looks and feels like for this school? Who can talk me through that and who can walk me through that? But you know, you don't have to suddenly become an expert in the Shang dynasty just because you've moved into EFI if you know, it's OK to say, I don't know much about this. But what I do know, what I should be good at is
understanding all those underpinning concepts again. So you're saying like, what does this concept look like in this year group? And what's the detail I also need to know in order to be able to hang back on in this year of work. But there's just shouldn't be any shame in saying, I don't understand. I haven't taught this subject since I was X years old or, you know, I haven't taught in this year group in this subject. What, what does, what can I look at to help exemplify what this looks like and support me? I think it'd be a bit more of a difficult conversation if you worked in secondary and you were the head of science and you went, do you know what?
I've really struggled with this whole chemistry thing. I think that's a, that's a different conversation. But I think you have to also recognise that as a generalist, you, you can't have that completely broad set of knowledge at your fingertips, especially at the beginning of your career. It's just not feasible. I mean, my understanding is that there is a real reluctance to teach the very like furthest elements of mathematics. Like you're further in your A level maths. There's a very small group of teachers who actually fall in that window of really wanting to to go there.
It's interesting because when I speak to people who work in the secondary, a lot of them absolutely love that because they get to, to sit with the intricacies and the, the, the kind of the magic of their subject that they really love. And what some teachers feel is they don't want to talk. They don't want to teach key stage 3 or further down because they don't get to really get into the complexity. So I think that's probably a personality person by person thing. Some people love inducting children into the wonder of their subject, regardless of age. Some colleagues really love
working within their discipline because they love their discipline and want children to go as deep as they possibly can with that. So it's it's an interesting one, although I will say that I did a skit course the other day and there were 4 trainee physics teachers on it. You do realise I've got 4 unicorns in this room? Yeah, they've got a lot of purchasing power, they do. They're walking in like super, super confident.
I think a couple of things. One sort of big highlight here is sort of, I think this is a good sort of proxy around sort of what the culture of your school is like. Like hopefully you are in an environment and a culture within that school has been developed where like it's perfectly fine for you to first of all, say, do you know what guys don't know? I've known many schools where unfortunately that culture, you know, either doesn't sort of exist or there's just that assumption. Well, you know, you're the you're the teacher, so you just got to know it, sort of get on with it. So hopefully there is that
culture where you can go, I'm not sure what to do this. And then either a leader can point you in the right direction of a resource or they might just say, oh, so and so taught that unit last year when they were in year 6, like go and have a chat with them. And I'm sure that they've got some sort of help and support for you there as well. I do think, and I don't know whether this could just be a sort of a me ISM, but I am a big sort of believer in like professional development, but sort of autonomous professional development. So if you do realise, or if you are being have been told that, you know, subject knowledge or
subject specific pedagogy might be something we need to sort of help and develop. Like there should be a some sort of CPD library available where you can go. This is the Shameless book plug the an action series. You see that, But that's what I wanted it to be, you know, that's what I want, you know, for the non specialist, I wanted them to have a safe book to pick up, to note. You know what, there's a lot of wisdom in here and this is what this subject is about in primary. So you can read that and kind of get to grips with it and get your head around it as a primary teacher who may be a non
specialist, but with enough kind of meat in there still for the, you know, the specialists of their subjects to reflect on what they're doing as well. But that's exactly why these books were written or joking aside, that it was for that read and that conversation to say, do you know what? I'm a bit shaky on RE. I'm a bit shaky on geography, but I don't want to read a secondary school book on this because it's not the right content for the children or the right pedagogy potentially. But what? Where do I go? Yeah.
And that's where and again, the subject was like, you know, there's there's little short history of guides that I strongly believe. You know, there's they have them for every subject in terms of the sort of history, like definitely I think there's a yeah, I'm pulling out all the sort of plugs. But I think there's also a couple of episodes where we've done around our sort of our favourites sort of subject specific resources and stuff like that. We've mentioned some of these books. Yeah. I think you should have a book available around the Shang dynasty that's almost scholarly lights with your teacher who's
teaching that after the Christmas holidays wants to take that and read it over there to broaden their own knowledge around the subject and hinterland. And that's how that they can then find those little bits of interesting bits and bring their own sort of personality to it whilst maintaining a sort of strict call. Absolutely, you should be able to do that. So I think there are a couple of elements that one around sort of school culture, resourcing, and then the sort of the feedback loops that leaders are putting in to make sure that teachers are actually engaging with that. How do you know, How do you know and potentially that that is, you know, having an impact and
it is being used? Hats off as well to John Hutchinson at Meno Academy. I did those little history short films and my goodness me they are. Yeah, and then he obviously he's he was the series editor on the hard elite. It's series, but I think put the two together. Yeah, like the company of a perfect combination. No, but who am I to say? I mean, I think yeah, those were the subject knowledge compendia that we did. But Chris such Kai Bosch just said, I don't have anything to put for series episode 3 of this because we we said it every every Christmas to round off the
year, we'd say, right, OK, here, all the things places we're going, like you mentioned in Chinese history, there's a really good podcast on like the covers the whole of it. But you realize how little you know when you've got this little tiny piece and you're thinking, Oh my God, this is like 4567000 years of history, even even the bits that are just documented. So you know, it's the realizing you don't know what you don't know, the known unknowns kind of thing. Yeah. So I mean, I think it's been really interesting chatting about the, the generalist
specialist sort of not dichotomy, but the the tension between the two and and where we sit in schools. And all I said to do is say, thank you very much for joining me before next time, we're going to explore the word curriculum and its many uses and how it moves beyond the the list of topics. So all I said to just say thank you very much for joining me. Thank. You very much, Amber. Thank you. Thank you, Neil. Thank you so much.
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...
Learn more about The Story of Maths and ACEL Pro - www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview and...