Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Thinking Deeply about Primary Education

Thinking Deeply about Primary Education artwork

Season Two, Episode Four: Victoria Morris and Neil Almond (History)

May 8, 20211 hr 29 minAudioSeason 2, Episode 4
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week, I'm once again joined by Victoria Morris and Neil Almond as they very generously share their considerable expertise in the field of primary history. We discuss all things curriculum including content, sequencing, features of high quality practice, pitfalls to avoid and where to go when in search of knowledge and pedagogical inspiration. The second of two episodes featuring Victoria and Neil, this is possibly even better than the last. Which is no mean feat. Full video episodes with bonus tier list footage can be found a www.thinkingdeeply.info or the Thinking Deeply about Primary Mathematics YouTube channel.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Fakie, David by primary education, the podcast that gives you a peek Inside the Minds of some truly inspirational teachers. This week, I'm thrilled to welcome back both Victoria Morris. I'm Neil. Almond on to the podcast this time to talk about all things primary history. If you enjoyed their thoughts on primary geography, then you're going to love this one. So there's so much to take away that the hard part will be finding space for all of your notes before we get started. And once again like ask for a small favor because one of the ways to help ensure this podcast, reaches the many many teachers, not using social media. You is to leave a review

wherever you're listening. Should only take a second and it would mean so much to do these interviews were reaching those. They can help. And so thank you. One reviewer will be chosen at random during episode 8 of season 2 and receive sign copies of thinking, David by primary mathematics, the Art and Science of primary reading, 100 ideas for primary teachers maths, and the research Aid guide to curriculum. But without further Ado, let's spend some time thinking deeply about primary history education. Excellent. And so in a laboratory it's good to have you back. Good to see you again. It's be back. So think we can just jump

straight in. Now we're all familiar with and who everyone is and where we're coming from. And so, I think possibly, the only thing that you guys are more passionate and knowledgeable about than geography is history at primary level. So, tell me why is it important that our fears of schooling? So, I just litter their the preamble to the National curriculum. And there's an explanation of why history is important in there. So it says about understanding the complexity of people's

lives, a process of change, diversity of societies and relationships, as well as their own identity. So I think my I'm not going to try and restate that. I think that's a good explanation of why it's important. Yeah, similar to Victoria when I saw the question I Go back to the, you know, the purpose of studying, the national curriculum and all the reasons why history is important at primary level. Written down very well. I think in that Preamble again,

going back to her, as I said on the geography podcast, you know, young children are quite egotistical. They find it difficult to see things beyond the self. And so, I think, History is important that primary because it makes them understand how we got to the point where we can actually focus on the self thinking, particularly, you know, the transition from nomadic hunter-gatherers where,

you know, we were kind of living to survive. And, you know, it was the, the all about the tribe and the group mentality, as opposed to. Now, you know, when the side to develop Agriculture and irrigation, we went that transition between Survivor living to survive to thriving. And, you know, being able to give the humanity that greatest commodity of all things time to focus on the self.

And obviously, it's through that Society improved as well. But I think it's particularly powerful for children understanding how it is that we're lucky that we can even think about the self and not thinking about the tribe and maybe that's gone too far the other way. But that sir, - I think for for another time. Well, I was kind of thinking that house. How's the, how is this different from his compared to the geography history and I came up about a dinner with you think, fit meal, but I came up with geographies.

Basically understanding how does the world work? What is it? Like, and how does it work? And then histories why? Yeah, I love that distinction. That's gonna it's more of an element of story and Imagination in history. Where is Geography. This process, isn't it? Yeah, more to do with imagination in history and developing curious curiosity storytelling has the like geography process. It's a lot more kind of data, heavy kind of subject where

there are level of certainty is so much more sure. Let's do you know how we, the contents are the way that they are right now? Obviously, those things still change, but when it comes to history, Teaching history. As certainty has fact. Yes, there are some things that we can do and obviously 200 300 years from now. It'll be a lot easier because we've got a little cameras to document all of this stuff. But, you know, a lot of it is interpretations of what little there actually is there.

And so, as you say imagination, and that sense of uncertainty, I think is an incredibly important difference between the two subjects as well. It seems in my experience that history is probably the one that most teachers, understand the importance of a little bit more than geography say, and and it's probably very close to the core subjects in terms of people's passion for it. Do you think that's because of the sense of narrative and the fact that people can relate to

it, or do you think there are other factors that sort of give it that almost increased status among primary teachers? I think the narrative is more obvious in history stories about. Police violence and say, I a specific person and their story of, maybe it's more obvious. I think there is a sense of narrative in geography, but it might not jump out at you in the same way that you have. It has to be presented to you in a certain way for it to make sense. Yes. Yeah, I think it's just a more I think, really?

Because it is about fundamentally about people. It's just far more relatable. I think. We're as you say, geography is more those abstract processes, you know, of erosion, which for some people neither here nor there, but thinking of Guy Fawkes is, you know, everyone, I think can compare themselves in a way of, you know, Wanting a certain goal and finding a certain way of how to do it and all of that kind of thing. If you guys had to condense your

approach to history in a set of guiding principles, what would they be and are there any marked differences to those? We discussed in reference to geography, for Key Stage 2, there isn't For me that much difference. Obviously the curriculum itself is a little bit more it's a little bit more prescriptive I don't mean prescriptive there's more content gives you more contents to cover than the geography curriculum, for example. So there's more to go on for there.

So obviously you know, you look at the curriculum. As a school, you need to decide where things go and then needs to be logic behind those decisions. We don't give year for the Egyptians just because that's where it's always been. As I say I think prior to the new ofsted framework, the most political conversations, I think that happened in the staff room was who would get to teach the victorians or something like that? Because those who are you must be in your 5 because that A year

five, always done it which obviously is not a great reason for doing things. So, definitely curriculum decide on the outcome for Key Stage 2. You want to link appropriately to the second order concepts of History, quite fortunate. In that historians, there's a greater consensus as to what constitutes history. So the things like evidence significance change and continuity. Unity similarity and difference. We're quite kind of as a subject

discipline are quite content of. These are the things that we look at when we do our subject. Again you're mapping out that sequence. Find that endpoint decide what that's going to look like. You want to link them to the substantive Concepts and things like monarchy and pyre peasantry. All of those things that you can kind of sprinkle in as many units as possible because those are the nice links and the nice threads that you can get Between different units across the are groups or within the same year

group and where possible, you know, that's where you can get your meaningful cross, curricular stuff, done trade, for example, is a really great one that transcends history and it lends itself, so beautifully as well to geographies. There's that natural link there as to how all that was able to happen. And as saying, then you write version one and you walk away from Commit, you come back to it and make any changes you live it, you teach it, you change

your reflects on it and you change it. The key stage 1 and this is going back to something like kind of mentioned in when we did the quiz addition. I don't know if maybe Victoria actually knows that this is where my thinking is going, but I think I would if I was an academy and I had kind of complete curriculum control and I used those the powers of the government. Give me I would actually get rid of the history requirements for

Stage one, and I would make it all about story narrative. And so, actually, I would use that as a tool for my literacy writing. I'd find, you know, it's time for a read-aloud, right? Okay. We're going to read a historical nonfiction text maybe from the core knowledge website, about the Aztecs or whatever it might be. And so, actually throughout their throughout year, one and year two, they're hearing just lots and lots of different stories about different. Periods of history and not necessarily going to the depth

at the national curriculum. Kind of puts them in straightaway which I think there are merits to it. Absolutely. But I think Can I find full creative control? I think that's the way that I would quite like to quite like to look at it. It's interesting because I've written down like there's more of a choice than history because he said he feel like history's more. If you say histories more. What word is it fixed yet, is more pain, more content to cover. I feel like in the history,

curriculum than the geography. Curriculum. Yeah, I think there's more breadth of content, but then I feel like the geographies more concrete, I until she teach them about these things. And, obviously, this different context you can use for it, but the history, there's a lot more Choice isn't there? So it's making the right choices. This may be more important running a history. Curriculum then geography is more. Choosing the places that you're

going to focus on to teach certain things through and I think the difference In the history, the geography is more. You're either going to teach about a process or your teaching about a particular place, isn't it on the whole history? You've got that thing of deciding for you, teach it as an overview or a depth study. Like what, what over for you so you do and where do you make the depth studies? There's a lot more sort of freedom to choose where you do that rather than the geography of you get told what place is to

do on the whole, don't you? And their choices to make in between that you choose? Exact place in Europe, but you have to pick a region in Europe. So I think probably the maybe the history I don't know, is it harder to pin down? Exactly. What you're going to do. I just felt like, when I was thinking about it, it's harder to say for the history. The geography is teach this. Yeah. I think that's fair. I think that's probably my that what you were saying? Yeah, I don't like to use this about myself, my, maybe my

expert blindness coming in a little bit there too. Choices because it's a yeah you can get just says like the Romans and it gives you some non statutory guidance as to what to do but you know, okay, so the Romans in Britain as well. So you've only got about 500 years to play with but you know, condensing choosing 500 years to doing however, long you decided to give yourself for that is, yeah, quite a task. If you then don't know anything about much about the Romans, hence, why you get then? Get people making Roman Shields

and calling that history? Which I'm sure. Got 12 later on. Can I go here we go again to do you reckon? And because at the minute and there's quite a big conversation around what history and you know because obviously we've got the traditional Western ecology and do you guys find it more difficult because of that changing landscape or, you know, this is this is just my perception from outside that actually, if I were choosing content right now, I'd be a bit Worried and how does that come

into play at all? Or is that just me being overthinking things? It depends how it's done. Obviously, we do have a national curriculum, and if you're at a school, you have to teach the national curriculum. There's no way about it. And that is quite heavy on the history of the British Isles and kind of typical Western Civilization. There are choices that you can make. Within that kind of does get that diversity of approaches and the different regions thinking

specifically you have the choice to do the kingdom of Benin, for example, which was a an African Empire. So you obviously you can make the choice to do that. I think it's one. You need to be careful. And I always think I think my when I've asked and I kind of helped schools about this before we make it to tokenistic, I always say, right? Let's have a look at what we have here and what you're currently, what we need to do and how we're making sure that we're being representative in

that. So case in point is the Romans, If you're doing some lessons, obviously we only have to focus on Romans in Britain but it makes sense. I think to do a couple of lessons about the Roman Empire and how it all came to be and, you know, the Roman army. And for example, if you're only showing pictures of the Roman army as white men, that's problematic because the Roman Empire spanned into North Africa. And one of the things that you could earn Roman citizenship by

joining, the Roman army, I think was after 17 years, And you got your citizenship so there were plenty of people of North African origin in the Roman army and I think getting that across is incredibly important and I think gives it that diversification without it necessarily appearing to tokenistic. And I think we do need to let

you know. I don't I agree in teaching history, really, really well and that means, you know, warts and also if you're only telling yourself, you're only giving the benefits of the British Empire, then that is obviously problematic and you need to discuss and there's other what other people would say, you know, the atrocities of the Empire and quite rightly so he's probably subject knowledge issue. Isn't it? But you have to have really, really strong subject.

Knowledge to know where it's appropriate, T, what's appropriate to include? Where? Basically, I always used to think my history subject knowledge is quite strong, but actually it really isn't. I couldn't have given the example that you just gave, but I'd have to do a lot more research myself to be able to address that properly. I think. Yeah, I think is one another one clear example is, you know, WWII and India. They came to our rescue and then there's loads of information. There's loads I think on the in

the Imperial War Museum, you know, there's whole displays this whole page of information on the website about the contribution of India, particularly seeks as well to the war effort and obviously then you I don't think you can teach the world wars. Well, if you don't mention that and then also go into it as a result them and their assistants, you know, Independence followed several years afterwards. So as I think, the main place to

start is think about what you're teaching and where you can get that diversity where it's, so thoroughly deserved. Yeah, yeah, I think you're absolutely right Victoria in terms of the limitations of our subject knowledge the unknowns going to set out to give a sort of diminished or restricted view of of history. But I think you know, when your historical understanding is that Is the product of your own education, you know it's very easy for the VM sort of cycle to

continue. And as posing in your opinion what's the what's the single most important aspect of historic of history education? I was quite a tricky question actually. I thought I went for achieving a sense of a coherent narrative across like the whole school that. Yeah, I'm just going to repeat what I've what I mean. I'm just going to explain the same thing again. Coming up a bit my like over the chill, child's Journey Through the school, making sure that they've got that sense of a coherent narrative across all

the units, they've studied. So when you sit down and we may be jumping ahead to the curriculum later on and you've got your blank page in front of you. What is it? That helps you guide that narrative, you know, where do you, where do you start? When you're trying to pinpoint those important points on the journey me, I guess. It's logic just thinking that what makes sense coming before. But based on what came before and what's coming after and making sure that that you really think about what's come before when you plan what you're going

to teach next and just really having those links with prior learning making it explicit. So that the teachers always referring to what they learned and how it links and just really having that thorough knowledge of the before the child already knows. Yeah. I think I agree that Glory. I think that sense of that sense of chronology. He is quite important. I think I'm teaching dates. I think there is a place for that. Absolutely. But if they leave Primary School kind of understanding.

Okay? Right. So we started the Stone Age, then we went to I and then we went to Brahms and then it was the Roman's and we had that kind of same time that Vikings and the Anglo-Saxons and then they went away away. But and then 1066 and then the Norman started and all of that and then obviously there's a natural massive break for whatever reason in our kind of chronology of how we teach the history.

But then also understanding right, well, ancient Greece kind of fits in and that was happening at the same time at around this time and that's why those ideas are kind of all going around at the same time. So they get that sense of chronology. And when kind of these see Sighs ations starts to appear, I think that kind of puts them on a decent standpoint, then for when they go into secondary school, but I think also understanding, so understanding video history

is in history isn't just facts about the past though. Max are important to understanding history. It is the understand. It's asking those kind of big and answering those kind of big questions, you know, what powers this. Changed or how has the impact of this particular policy or event changed or continue to certain aspect or of life or you know, how was farming and agriculture similar. But also different in the

civilizations that cropped up, you know, near rivers and things like that. So understanding what it is a historian does and having a sense of chronology of kind of the big civilizations and Periods of English. History of British history I think is pretty important. Just going back to the narrative as well. I'm thinking, if you've learnt about significant figures and maybe not just in history, but other subjects as well. Actually understanding, where do they fit in in the chronology of

what's being taught? So I've ended up doing just incidentally with my class because we were listening to music and I trying to fit the composer's in with other people that they've learned about in history and that they know, actually, when that person wrote that bit of music, this was happening. At the same time. So my class of learn about parents Nightingale and Mary Seacole. Then we we cleaned everything back to what at what point in Florence Nightingale or Mary Seacole is life, was this piece of music written? And this one and the order, my class last year were really good

at all during various composers and Florence, Nightingale, Mary Seacole and like things around the Victorian period because we just kept, we kept coming up to and authors as well, we do poetry. Peace in reciting poems and so we 80 words were. So I've tried to sort of Link in but the classic poetry when when was that written and and sort of slotting in with some of the music, we listen to and things. And some of the books, we were reading as well, wear that more

classic text. So, the liner which in a wardrobe, Wind in the Willows, just like, when were they written? And they got quite hooked on actually, where does this fit in the sequence of all the different authors and composers? And We had and blinking it back to the history of. I think there's a danger of them just seeing this figure is some sort of it's just in a void, isn't it? That they've got nothing to link into and if you can get them to have that sort of coherent, understanding of how does everything fit together?

That's probably better for me. That's like the important thing is not just seeing things as always, learn a bit about that in a bit about that and they've got these sort of separate loves stuff. That's on another level. And have you blogged about that a written about that. Don't know if I've written about that specific thing. No I reckon definition because you've almost got this. Panorama that don't you of them? Yeah. And I'm really loving the idea of connecting those musicians

and their you know, because I've got a sketchy outline of maybe the last 300 years of classical music in my head but it takes a lot of reading. To get actually somewhere near what the reality is, you know, there's a big chunk that I think you know, from Mozart to like Mom or is a lot closer in my head that it is in real life and stuff, you know. And yeah and I think that meant something of immense value, you know, and if you know, I think I reckon if needle through in a

diagram and you threw in the word, so be the ultimate blog used to amaze me when I threw the names up. I used to keep a list and add names too. Ooh, it and I used to just throw the names up on the board and they could actually correctly, put them in chronological order. Whenever I came back to it, they can still do it and I know it's bad. That's just like a retrieval. It's not an in-depth understanding but they did genuinely understand the sequencing of when those things think together. Well, then that's really useful

because whenever I read any things, I enjoy reading around history. So, I'm reading Hamilton's biography, and it's just a useful thing to No. Around this time. These things were happening. I was reading something about. Mozart. Yes, they don't really know much about classical composers at all, but there was a date in there that I could easily associate with 1776. All right, so, we're around the

time of American independence, and all of that starting, and it just kind of say it stops, IT anchors. What you're learning about and kind of stops it from being out in The Ether. And something else, just out there. It's like, okay, I can kind of see how this kind of Mental timeline that I'm kind of building up how that all comes together which I think is really powerful. Yeah, Ivan, I benefit in a few quizzes when they've asked about Napoleon and certain things happening and I've obviously got this mental hook of the 1812

Overture and I'm all okay. It's not gonna be very far from that and then you know, get within 10 years and you know, haha, get the points that's awesome. And, and what is it? The schools. And Who provided a really Stellar history often do so well. So I think there is that narrative. There is that coherence between all the units that are there. I think that's It's not easy to do. I think it's easier to do that

for history than it might be for jog feed but that might just be a subject knowledge deficit so it's really kind of easy. I think I once you start looking at this civilization is that you have to teach. You can see all those really strong links that appear already, things like that moving from an Agricultural Society to an Agricultural Society and it's such a massive leak Deep in human development and how we got

here and it's kind of interesting to you notice, okay? So that all they mostly ancient civilizations were near rivers. Okay. So, why was that okay? Because, you know, they developed irrigation one, they develop, irrigation Oaks, they could start farming. Why did they Farm? Because they mean, they didn't have to spend all their time out hunting and Gathering their food, which meant that they had time to do interesting things. Thanks. And, you know, once you kind of get that and you see those similarities, you see grease and

go actually, you know, Greece wasn't exactly like that. They had some farming but it was more. Do we trade because they were right on the Mediterranean so they had, you know, plenty of fish. They'd go and Trace to various other countries within the Mediterranean as well. So, I think, It's quite an easy, one to find those natural links. And hooks. It's one of those ones where if you have a Knowledge explicit curriculum. It's easier for that year. Three teacher to go. Alright, okay.

That's why you're making me teach about trade because we're then going to understand that. When we're doing the Egyptians have cheap suits trade Mission down. The Red Sea was really important because then we can contrast that with when the Romans came to Britain. Opened up trade with the whole empire and how the building of Roads roads made trade so much easier, which meant that we started getting, you know, more things and you can go back and

you can get very nerdy about, you know, the beaker people, and how trade started there, and how actually, we were quite an egalitarian society. Until these people came around and said, haha, we have this skill, that none of you guys have what you're going to give us for it and how then you know capitalism you know, started to take over and Here we are today. So I think it's quite a few have the subject knowledge and you are nerdy enough like me. I think it's quite an easy one to make all of those links to. I think they focus on that

chronologies. They make sure that chronology is there and linking back to what Victoria said with the Composers and bringing in other aspects as well. There's a great company I think they're called timeline for schools and if you have a long wall, they will just put a timeline on whatever you want. You can go for as long as you want. If you have a really kind of knowledge explicit curriculum where you know, I'm going to be music, you're going to learn about Mozart's and Williams.

Whoever it is that you might want to do, you know, they can incorporate that on to that timeline. So, you know, it's there in front of the kids and, you know, as you're going past on assembly, you can say oh yeah, right let's go. Quick little bit retrieval, practice kids as we're on the way in and make use of all those kind of learning opportunities and because you know, you know, it's set, it makes it easier. I think for teachers to get on board and the students, as well as you know, what to expect things are created. And as you've said, are our

switch from Automatic people to an agrarian. People are those features that highly effective schools will always include? Or do they have a range of choice in terms of the sort of the big Concepts, the big picture they want to portray? I think there is a choice, but at the same time and perhaps, you know, your definition of what you think civilization Society is my impact that choice. But I think we'll kind of all agree or that think there's will probably be some sort of

Agreement, that unless you've developed an effective writing system, you're probably not quite there at the point of civilization. And so, obviously that's a wonderful thing to look at from a Sumerian cuneiform and how they started off and how that change through hieroglyphics various other logographs and you had the Rebus principle and how we started to stop using symbology for things because got a bit confusing and we We don't have enough space and mental

capacity to remember all these symbols until we get to some sort of Greek Latin alphabet. So and I think there are for me personally I think there are a core few that I think we can all agree on that. You know, civilization will have these things but then there are certainly other ones that Scholars regularly argue over and I think you know, Ben Tune what they're saying and I actually think.

It's probably less is more when it comes to that thing. I think I'd rather four or five Concepts that do kind of look into all those civilizations that students can come to the end of their schooling and be like, right, I understand the importance of trade, I understand the importance of literacy and writing systems and the use of tools because that enable us to do all that enabled this Society to do this civilization to do with ABC and they will that To do ABC, this

one didn't have it. They relied on someone else for it and so, actually, then this happened, see, I think less is more than that. And that makes a lot of sense. So it's driven by your definition of civilization and then you and then you run from there. Yeah. So I was thinking inquiry and I guess that goes back to the whole making things coherent as well. Do it really inquiry drive your units for you're not just teaching it. Look, disconnected, facts, that you've got that sort of inquiry

and really thinking about inquiry questions, which is quite hard. And I'm just picking a question for the sake of it by having really good purposeful enquiries to be something that probably a mark of the better history. Curriculum and making sure it's led by those Concepts that are in the preamble to the National curriculum. Rather again that you're not just teaching. Facts about it. But you really understand those

sort of different concepts and you're using them to drive the questions and also like the looking at the coverage and the breadth and depth of the curriculum that again, you haven't just selected something to meet bullet point on the national curriculum that you know, why have you made where they were choices, why have you chosen that particular thing? And that this really good reasoning behind and the choices that have been made, I'm just finding it really interesting. How comparing, what Neil's responses to line on this one.

I feel like around my knowledge of I think I've got much more of a narrow knowledge of History. So interesting, as being the difference between the way that I way I approach it because I don't think. I mean, I don't think I really understood those Concepts until quite recently, to be honest. I don't. And I thought I'd always been quite good at history and done quite a lot. History of school and I haven't really got that. It's only listening to a lot of My research had talks and people speaking and Christine Council mentions her history examples

and I'm like, oh my goodness, that's another one. I didn't know that. Write that down research, that I don't think if I think that's probably a mark of the better history. Curriculum is if you really have that understanding of those historical Concepts because otherwise it is just all this. This was an interesting period in history here. Some things that happened and that's it and it's no sort of Purpose behind it. Yeah, I think that's one of the reasons why it was absolutely essential that, you know, both of you were answering at the

same time because and, you know, there are a lot of ways to come at it. But actually in term, you know, you're both thinking really really deeply about and similar ideas but but almost all with different outcomes at the same time, you know? And yeah. So and you know, personally I'm again I think I like, Like, you know, I really like history and, but did I go half as far as you guys are discussing and probably not. And so it absolutely fascinates me.

Listen thinking, is this, this sounds absolutely wonderful, you know, I'd, I'd love to be a kid in one of those classes. Nevermind death a teacher and and so are the pitfalls again, like, geography sort of the opposite, or are there? Anything that's crucially him to avoid in terms of the provision of history, education? Pitfalls are similar to geography, isn't it? Make sure you're actually teaching history and history lessons, you'll know just doing some fun activities linked to that period of history or you're not just writing something set in a period but what your

teachings actually history and also about covering the national curriculum and making sure what you teach it might meal said earlier, you don't just teach something about the Romans but look at what it actually asks you to teach about the Romans in the National curriculum. And yeah, there are choices about how you can do that, but you can't just do a few things on mosaics and Roman fillers and the Army doesn't cover what it says about Roman Britain in the National curriculum.

So really referring back to that. So trying to sort of superficially say oh yeah, we've done something on the Romans. We've done something on the Egyptians, we've done something that's going to Bieber. Things to avoid. It's just try and really make sure it's all linked back to exactly what it says in the National curriculum and the same thing as well. I think about going too much into opinions or value judgments on was this, right? Word was the person right to do

this and that kind of thing. It's not really takes it too much into citizenship and pshe, it's not really about judging what happens. It's about looking at, why? Learning about what did happen and people's viewpoints on it. But it's not about the children giving their opinion of whether someone was right to do something. So I wrote what I've got is pretty similar to the geography. Certainly some similarities like not just facts about the past

history doesn't come from a topic title and your topic title. Also isn't a prodigiously silly thing that borrow from Horrible Histories because I think that the level of Give it to the poor Vikings with having a just Vikings given to them for so long where, you know, there was quite substantial about evidence. They weren't, you know, they were doing wrong. They did some very vicious things but, you know, make such a massive. Generalization, I think is not

helpful those things, but then there are few other things. I was thinking about that. I kind of History specific. One of them links from what kind of Victoria said about making sure it doesn't turn into a Use or ethics class and kind of linked from that. It's kind of tasks that we can, sometimes be asking children to do. It is not appropriate, I think to ask a year, five Charles to imagine that they are a slave on the slave ship and write a diary entry as if they were, you know, part of the the Atlantic

triangle and they're, you know, going on a journey from Iron, it's not appropriate. I'm a bit of a stickler for this one, but I think writing in role in history is a bit of a. No. Go for me. And it's not something I personally Advocates, because of the misconceptions that it can provide your average.

Roman soldier probably couldn't write and if he could Right. He's unlikely to be writing a diary entry there were some so you're saying there might be some space for it. Certainly the vindolanda. Scrolls for example are a letter from someone who was on the wall, Hadrian's Wall writing back to Rome. So if you are looking at specific person fine but to do it as a kind of generic know and

I'll imagine you've crossed you know into Scotland as a Roman soldier and now right back don't necessarily think it's appropriate and kind of my last one I would avoid is I just wrote this down very quickly and I kind of don't know if it's the official title for it's called but like an artifact first approach where you think? Oh, I have an amazing artifact here. And I'm going to kind of give children the time to explore that and history will kind of

come from that. I We used we need to, you do it the other way around where actually the artifact is used to strengthen our pastora condiment not as a starting point for history so there's would kind of be my no goes. I think point is well actually about trips if you're going to go on a trip, is actually often more useful to go on the trip

towards the end of the topic and the children. I know things about it already and same with artifacts actually, because I've been on a museum trip before where they were showing artifacts and asking the children to work out what they were and I didn't have a clue what they were so that it's not really helpful to do that. If you don't have sufficient knowledge, you can't work out what the things were for or you work out something that actually turns out to be wrong. So it's actually better to us.

If you've taught the children about those specific objects for and then you show them the real thing, they can recognize it and link it to what they've learned. But just giving a child an artifact and asking them to work out what it is. It's not you're just going to waste a lot of time, getting a lot of wrong guesses. I think, I think it's the same for anyone. The more we know about something, the more you appreciate it and yes, I think I think you hit the nail on the head and I'm sure everyone's got children to write and roll at some Careers.

And what the the argument against it is pretty strong and been particularly the examples, you've given nail and, you know, it doesn't make any sense at all really. Especially when there's so much Rich history to teach, you know, spending time that we don't have necessarily in a literacy lesson and a pearly advised literacy lesson Miss em. Yeah, I know, I can't see any way that I could justify it at all. It's actually incredibly hard to write accurately. About the past. It's so so hard there. So many details that if you,

when I I'm sure I have got children to do that in the past. When I've done it, you've been, you've been sort of get bogged down in as they're writing, their are asking you about all these little details or you read it. And you realize they put some totally historically here at the thing in there because they just don't know the amount of detail needed to properly. I just don't think that children can really have that. They can't have the depth of knowledge. Each of what? Well, it was like, at that time. So, I mean, it can be quite useful to explore, would they have had this or not?

But actually getting them to write it. You're going to end up getting a lot of piece of writing with this. Not, it's just not really accurate, right? Yeah. And I think that leads back to kind of a Changed, I think is maybe slowly happening, which is where the foundation subjects were traditionally, just seen as a way to get more extended writing from the the English side of things. So, whereas we weren't too fast, whether someone was writing the

story of a Remus and Romulus, but they then took out their iPad as long as they were using the right. Yeah. The literacy, the lip, the writing features Is that we wanted were in there now. So we could go to a moderator and be like, oh well look, you know they're using, you know, was that they got their skin. They got their subordinate clause with an admitted real relative pronoun in there. So yeah and I think the content has to come the content of the subject has to come first for me. I think you can.

I actually had this written down for the previous question. I didn't say, I think you can get really high quality writing from history, but it's just about the choice of Ask isn't it? It really good writing evidence in you expect from your history. If you're writing an essay at the end of your topic and it's like non-fiction writing a comparison. I ate. When I was in year six, I used to do a lot of comparison writing actually probably based on comparing books but it would work in history as well. And it used to be some of the

best evidence I had that wasn't actually written as a piece of writing. It was actually Based on something else. But just then if you've got the comparison then there's opportunities for really good sentence structures and conjunctions and all those features that you're looking for that, you can get evidence of those things and it's actually a purposeful piece of nonfiction writing is actually often better than those sort of writing enroll like tasks. Anyway, if you want narrative evidence, it's better to just focus on writing and really good

story and then the writing you get through the history. Make it non fiction writing using the content that they've learned and that's the really great getting writing fiction, isn't it between your writing about history versus writing stories, within a historical area? That there's some great stories that are written in based on historical period and it's actually us being able to work out. The accuracies versus the

authorial kind of flair that certain authors use to make their stories worthwhile. Yeah, I saw, I saw Andrew Percival talking about his school. Do an essay writing em on Twitter recently and I thought, honestly, this is a Direction. I want to know more about and I'm so just as you guys are talking about that to him. Yeah, I'm thinking. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. And I like, I think I've said before, I'm lucky enough to work with Jack Harker and see his plan and process and his, and

there, he has to cut a whole lot of what he wants to include in his Romans and Does this wonderful sequence Regals from Celtic Britain to the Romans and over the crossover? Maybe for the first 14 weeks of the 16 weeks of the year? And and if he were to he just never enough time for half the stuff he wants to have in there. If he were to spend his time doing right and lessons at the same time, you know, those children would be getting his hands, high quality, an opportunity, I send as they do the minute, you know, so I can

see where you're coming from and we do essays, we allocate a bit Of time in our English lessons to, right? Yes. They after they finish the history learning and I think people hear the word essay and do some sort of boring dry children. Actually love writing essays at my class. They're excited about writing the essay, they really want to write it. We got interrupted from writing one last year, have locked down and they were so upset that

because they know that they know the knowledge, I just really want to be able to do that. Piece of writing are so proud of themselves, because they've got so much to say, I think it is, if you can, you don't have to call it essays. But if you can do something similar to that, and really allocate that literacy time. So you get really good quality writing, you're using what they know. The children really love that. It's a beautiful form as well. You know, because I've been thinking about conversations, how we need about the ascent of man and how it's essentially

essay as TV. You know, where he's done, you know, quite a few consecutive races and they build up over time and stuff. And I think it's not only is a really useful skill but it's a really good form of expression. In terms of like you said, with history of being with the why you can express, what you think, the wires and stuff. Yeah, so that's really clear. And so, if anyone wants to improve their teaching of History, were they going to? You know, I think, obviously, your blogs and are probably the best starting point. Were they going?

There to sort of develop their knowledge of, and of their craft in this respect. So I go. So I think for me, it was quite difficult one because there are so many places where you you can go. So obviously, you know, and I'll talk about these later on. There is the history Association for the primary, which I think is particularly good. There are, there's a particular paper that I really like and I think it goes back to that idea of how Source sources is done in primary school, so it's called

primary sources in history. Breaking through the myths and it's written by someone called Keith Barton. Who is, I think he's Australian and he's a history educator out there any kind of goes through, actually, and what is elementary school's out there. You know, these are some bad uses of primary sources. And I think for teachers who aren't well versed in, we're not historians are not professional and stories, we don't necessarily know how to do this. Things properly. And, you know, we're not taught these things and it's not something that we should, you

know, we're expected to know. But I think it's kind of a useful. He provides a useful list of kind of do's and don'ts as to how we might kind of simplify this. And I know you talked to Secondary School teachers on Twitter. They'll actually tell us don't do any Source work because actually the amount of misconceptions that we do that we kind of inadvertently provide with regards to sourcing takes them a lot of time. To unpick and sort out later on. So I kind of think if there was one paper kind of just on

History, I'd want people to read. It would be this one. Breaking Through The Mists of primary sources in history. Just very quickly, just outlines the kind of the seven myths that there are, which are primary sources, are more reliable than secondary sources myth to primary sources. Can be read as arguments about the past myth 3. Use a sourcing heuristic to evaluate bias and reliability, which I know is the big one that the secondary school. Teachers really kind of get

upset about, because we always go, oh, who wrote it Goebbels? So therefore, it must be biased as I was not quite, as simple as that myth for using primary sources and engages students. In authentic historical, inquiries, that can again kind of goes back to what I said to me, over some bad teacher, history. Curriculum might do is there Use that primary sources away to think you know, right you're being a historian out which I think that's more damage than good myth 5. Was that students can build up

an understanding of the past just through primary resource sources and myth 6, right? There's only six of them. I'm sources can be classified as primary or secondary and he kind of looks very kind of carefully at what that means and how it all depends, whether you know, What the inquiry question might be, will depend whether a source is primary or secondary? Depending on the role that inquiry question takes quite

useless, then he then provides a list of some things that sources can be used for, which is to motivate historical inquiry to supply evidence for historical accounts, to convey information about the past and to provide insights into the thoughts and experiences of people in the past. So if I kind of thing, You are history coordinator. I think it's good to kind of Martin Luther and is nailing of the 95 Theses. You know, that's what you're going to nail up in front and the classrooms of all your

teachers. Say it is where this what Neil said. I think it for me if you can listen to Christine Council speak at all because she always we've seen historical examples even if it's even if the topic Of the talks, something else? Even if it's not practice specifically, history, Focus talk, I like the level and the depth of what she describes, just always blows my mind.

I'm always thinking, oh, my goodness, I didn't know any of this. I need to read everything I can about that now. So just, I mean, he's fantastic speaking about the curriculum in general, but for ideas about and I think she comes at Maybe a different way because because she's secondary base. But when I heard her talking about what she's doing with the primary curriculum and the ancient civilizations that's really changed, like, My way of thinking about it. I don't think I had a very

joined up way of looking at me, ancient civilizations before. So I'm listening to Christian counsel, speak about anything, be great. And I've had recommended to me, I won in the geography, podcast. I I mentioned the teaching primary geography book which I have read. I haven't actually got the product the history version, but I have had it recommended to me. That that's quite good as well. Say that that would be a good book T. Yeah, I'm definitely going to get that one.

Yeah, I think just lots of discussion on Twitter. I learned loads from discussing on Twitter. Yeah I think just like I realize I'm wrong when someone else starts saying oh I can't believe they're doing this and I think more I didn't know you weren't supposed to so I just think it's like having this much dialogue as he can. It's probably the case for any subject isn't it? Just trying to learn about things and then talking to people and realizing where because it's the same thing. We said in geography that you don't know what you don't know.

Sometimes to research it to you and you think you then when you think you know it Is the worst moment because that's the point where you need to be thinking of definitely more to this somewhere. Yeah that's why I'm Christine Council. Always makes me think of my goodness. You have got so much more to learn about this. I won't be able to start feeling. What's the word, like? I wouldn't be able to start developing any sort of arrogance about having mastered curriculum development because if I could

return any time I listen to her, I'm thinking, oh my goodness. I've I'm in my whole lifetime I couldn't get to this level that I do. It's just it's motivating listening to someone who's got that. Sort of depth of knowledge is hers. The opening chapter and the research Ed curriculum book, guide the curriculum. No she closes it closes it, then you should warn you anymore. And remember, being really interesting and really powerful and, and I think she speaks quite a lot of red and some of the Sort of more, it's bread,

likely Thorpe's, not kind of thing. And I kind of thinks you're speaking a recently. So, I think there are, there are quite often lots of opportunities to hear speak and the the method of use of Twitter sounds like a really healthy but not necessarily a common usage, you know where you're listening to other people's ideas, taking them on board and refine your practice and sometimes it feels as if the default is to You know, transmit rather than receive and I think as you describe the use of Twitter, that's definitely how to get the most out of it.

And you know, we have some great history based discussions on. It's often a lot of to paint. I think we often get Michael to get involved and then we can have these whole long discussions and it's leaf rake lessons. That's like my favorite thing about Twitter. I love that. Just a nice discussion about reasons and everyone listening to everyone. What about subject knowledge? What are your top three sources of Rich? Historical knowledge?

Okay, it's taking me a long time to see them, get my head round. Actually getting the words out today some reason. And now I think for me probably the main way that I probably the main thing that I've always done is visiting my historic buildings of museums and things like that. Maybe that's why my history subject knowledge isn't great because then it I'm just getting a snapshot of all the vocal stuff. I don't know though. Anything that's interesting near wherever I'm on holiday. That's what I'm going to find out about. So and definitely I think same as with the geography, knowledge

of local history in the areas, quite important for selecting those local history studies. So, I think visiting all museums and all the National, Trust cases in the area, that's going to be good. And I think when I visit places, I'm always thinking about I just read all the information and I'm thinking about how to link to the curriculum so that for me that's one of the main things. Don't know it just makes me want to learn more. That's one of the main things I do and reading children's books again just I read because it's

more accessible, isn't it? In an Ideal World? You might need all of the adult versions of the but TimeWise. You can't necessarily do that. So now if you're struggling for time, finding my, I loved it, Kay, I witnessed books, just really reading those and thinking before, starting to plan something, that's probably the main things that I do. And actually, I was going to say something about Twitter as well. Another thing on Twitter that's really good for history is if you follow history specific hashtags or accounts on Twitter

because there's things like Hill for Wednesday and it's just interesting anyway, actually I love that and then I follow lots of Romans are Count accounts now and I get all this stuff about, they've discovered me mosaics and there's just lots of interesting news articles if you start following some history stuff on there if they discover and that can be quite good to then use in the curriculum if there's been a new discovery and it links to what you're teaching as well. So it's worth looking at, I don't know how much she is for.

I've mainly done it for Romans and Prehistory. There's definitely lots of good stuff to eat follow one on Mason topics. What would you go to nil or what are your three sources of Rich, historical knowledge? Having it down to three ways difficult, so I'm going to not give you, three are going to give you more. First of all, your dad's to Me, podcast with Greg Jenna is

really really good. There's Greg a professional historian and a comedian as well. So it's quite Hearted, but you can get a lot out of it. And some years, some really interesting stuff on there and quite a few episodes are quite easy to relate to the National curriculum, as well. So that's a great way to go particularly for UK history and the history like the British

Isles. If your YouTube channel called 10-minute history's, kind of goes through certain periods or certain events. It's in ten minutes and I think I have spent a whole day just you know that auto play button was on and before you know it we had got up to so that resemble them something relatively modern day. Victoria made me think of this one. Actually, when she mentioned Michael tid, if you you Google, Michael did cheat sheets when the first curriculum.

First. We know where the 2014 curriculum, go in the first in its infancy, he Do things which are kind of a rough springboard starting point for where you want to go. I've mentioned the history Association, check the pricing on this one, it's 72 pound a year for primary school and that they've got some really good podcasts. They've got the mag of the primer. Magazine is really, really useful, plenty of articles in there.

And in the previous image of the episode, I talked about how Ow, some things can behind the second, the second repay wall, and I think a few primary colleagues who are as enthusiastic, shall we say about a primary history, particularly in a doing it. Well, at Key Stage 2, we threw a bit of a fuss about all the, what's the wisdom podcasts and series being behind the secondary pay wall, so they very

kindly enabled. Was open those up to those with the primary subscription as well. For those that are not sure. The what's the wisdom really looks at what those second-order concepts of History asked, if when we're talking about evidence change and continuity, if you're not sure what those are, there's articles about them and their, our podcasts with Christine Council, there just get yourself a membership that's really, really good. And then links to what Victoria said, I use the news app on my

iPhone and every now and then and you can search the categories that you're interested in. So obviously I've got a lot of history. History ones. So in my saved folder. I have article and ask for an article about various things to do with history that relates to the curriculum and relates to aspects of the history that my trust and teaches.

And so, I kind of keep those and I will screenshot them, print them out and either read them or, you know, kids can System as well and kind of an area of assessment that I'm kind of interested in. We look at history of how we can assess these kind of foundation. Subjects is kind of that really simple before. And after what you understand about this article that appears in the, you know, it's in the newspaper. It's not a necessarily, A

History magazine, but I know there's been quite a lot of talk about Stonehenge recently and how perhaps that it was Moved from Wales to where it is now. So I've got a few articles about that so actually right, if I if you I've taught you inh Stone Age. So the wrong way around stone age to the Iron Age. And I've now given you this newspaper article to read, you know, I'd like to think that your depth of understanding and the connections perhaps you're

making from, that is far more fruitful than it was before I taught you about that. So, I think there's quite a nice Way you can look at assessment through that as well. So I think what's really interesting is that whenever I wrote that question, none of the sources will expose aside from the historical Association, were ones that I would have thought of. So I think that's gonna be really useful because, you know, I think you've got some really unique and inspirational sort of sources of your own inspiration there, you know, and there's something that's really useful

and I think that in our discussion of what screws do really well. The features of a high-quality curriculum came across, and because they're essentially a large part of what they do really well. So you okay, if I move on to the next question, where are we? So and you know smaller schools who might not necessarily have the capacity or the time enjoyed by their larger counterparts you know what can they do with regards to curriculum design?

I said sorry for to you, okay? And I mean, I kind of I can say what we did in my school, she's the one form entry to create our curriculum. So basically you just gave over and this is the later phase. I didn't I wasn't involved in the early phases. When I joined the school there's already been a lot of work going on beforehand. When I joined, we were just in the process of creating our sort

of curriculum overview that is Say about the knowledge, we were teaching in each unit. So the way that we did that was to give over quite a lot of staff meeting time and a couple of insect days to many teachers, who are already taught those units summarize, what what did they teach? And I think it's good to start with teachers who have already taught it because you just have more depth of knowledge. If you had to teach it rather than one person having to come

at it and research all of that. If the teachers do this, right? The initial sort of Rights was by the teachers and then for each subject, one person, the subject lead, then to call if the plans for each year, group looked at the units and fitted them together and then maybe adapted. Little bit, if they weren't as coherent as they could have been adjusted. Some of the content or I just checked it, but it is, it is closely linked to the National

curriculum as possible. So, I did the history and geography, so I adjusted it a little bit, but it was mainly, what, what the teacher said written and then looked at the links between the units as well. So that was, we managed to do that in one Academic Year, and that says, a small stuff and I think I maybe had one, I might have one or two days out of class to do it, so it is, I think it is doable for a small

school to do something like that with all the teachers working together and then one person sort of overseeing their subject Nice. I think that's really powerful because you're not speaking hypothetically, you're speaking to your own experience and and you've been very, very with careful on smart with your time there you know and utilized your team. You know, which I'm 100% behind know, the experience of our, you know, armor wizened colleagues

on percent. And so, I think that will be really useful if you anything you want to die, then that wasn't my decision making. That was clear. Leading on that part. I just did the history. Geography overview. Yeah, I think I had something very similar which was dedicate. I think there are two options that you can go. Which is to do something as Victorious mentioned, where you kind of give off, give over lots of staff meeting time to kind of put these things into place.

Which absolutely right. I think that was well, for some subjects and some subjects. I think it probably doesn't need. Obviously, you can do it and it can work. Well, whether you need to do, that is another option, complete question completely, and I think certainly for some Leaders there kind of is a fetishization of the spoken asst and it's kind of this buzz word that gets thrown around for curriculum. Quite like it needs to be

bespoke to our school. I see no reason that you are not going to make a study of the mire bespoke to your school. If it is in central London, It's pointless. You might have a few this you might be able to get some things in there, some local link perhaps to some Romans, but the vast majority of that is not going to be bespoke.

You're not going to look at the Romans within a two-mile radius of your school and what happened around there for a whole sequence of learning. So I think Actually when it comes to history there is one curriculum objective where it talks about using yet the locality and of course you know that one has to be speed bespoke to your locality. Although you can get into a debate perhaps with the geographers about what locality means and how far you have to go

from where you are between before you go out of your locality and whether you agree with it or whether you don't agree. With their on a philosophical level. You know there are curricular out there that you can buy off the shelf. And as long as you kind of subscribe to even if you don't subscribe to the kind of pedagogy that kind of the school that develop that as you know, uses something particularly of reach Feldman here and their history booklets that they've

written, which are amazing, they're fantastic, like the it does 95% of the work for you. and I think there is, That fetishization of bespoke curricular where it has to be, you know, it has to be asked a on it and it needs to be us. And, you know, that actually the amount of time that that takes depending on where your staff are, what their subject knowledge are. You know, let's get real here. We're all specially now we're all busy, we're all tired, we've

all got lots of other things to worry about when we get back in, you know, kids are back, just buy it and use it. And then just concentrate your time on that one unit where it is about your locality and then obviously, you know, adapt it for that five percent where you might have a local link to something. But other than that, I think that's certainly something that I think, you know, if you're

small school and you're worried about that, don't worry about it too much. Just use what's there? And that's just one thing that you can. I'm sure there are others. I think Christine councils. I don't know they're available to buy, but I saw that, you know, Christine cancels written some curricular resources for. I think are engaging in or funders they met, they met They may be available to purchase at a later date so I'm not sure, but, you know, there are things out there and I think, yeah,

School leaders. Don't worry too much about that this Focus. I'm not sure where that's come from, to be honest. So to try and cut cover the look on my face when you're saying that II. Did I agree to a point that there's no point. Reinventing the wheel, I don't know if I can go quite as far as saying just, by it, personally, even house that he didn't write

everything from scratch, just sort of magic, any matching its magic in it up from our minds that we did draw on other resources. But there's no, you don't have to write everything yourself. Scrap it. There's no point during that definitely agree with that. I don't mean some resources, can be really good. We use some of the cgp history now should I really go? They've got really good sources in one eye piece. The prehistory one that was it was so helpful. And if you can save time like that without really high quality

resources, then definitely go for it. Yeah, stay too. I've got one down here they do I'm active. This is a it has one but they do do. Ya think they do activity books as well for schools? They are couple of quid. I think for the actual booklet and the activity books, you would maybe this is, you know, controversial cracks in here. But I think you know, there are probably schools who are doing, you could get these for the kids and you know, these are the workbooks for the kids. I think you know that might be

better, that might be a better offer than what some schools are doing by trying to do it alone. Lots of food for thought and do you think it's possible for a curriculum to be over ambitious in it? Seems yes. But I would rather start from a place where I've been too ambitious and have to turn it down than not be ambitious enough to begin with, and then have to ramp it up afterwards.

Is my kind of, when I thought about that and I think I've fallen definitely Fallen guilty of some of the curricula that I looked at. Again, it's that process of, you know, curriculum is never done, it's not just document that's finished. Once you know, you've put that last Full Stop in. I've looked back at some of the things that I thought, and I thought, probably, you know, would take that out now or, you know, I wouldn't be too, I wouldn't be upset in the slightest, if a teacher thought I don't need to worry about that bit too much, but I think it's

easier to Go too far and then cut back then to put a lot of work in and be like, yo, we didn't go far enough, so we need to ramp up with a pressure, a bit more. That's interesting. Actually, because I didn't initially think about being over, ambitious, as in putting too much content in by be definitely do. I'm sure I do but also I think you can when I want to revise things, it's because I haven't been ambitious enough in a way but not about the amount of content that I'm putting in, but just that maybe I think actually it's more about The disciplinary

knowledge for me. But I've learned something about those Concepts and I'm thinking about, actually, no, although they're learning about that. I didn't include the comparison that they could have been ride. Mr. Link between something. So, I think me if I was revising things, I'd probably be making it more ambitious, but that doesn't necessarily meeting mean adding more content in its just adjusting the way. It's taught to teach it better that see when I my enemies. Your thoughts about that was it can be too ambitious but I

sometimes I think maybe there's a people want to be ambitious and so you can put content in this just way above what you what the children can access without. And if that doesn't mean that they can't understand my complex content, but if you don't actually plan the curriculum to enable them to understand, It and you just say, oh look my my year 6 is so great, they're studying this as if just saying

the, the title of the topic. Like the content that they're learning makes it better somehow. And it's not sort of approaching it from a point of view of doing it to look impressive, but look at what. Yeah, yeah, six are learning, is that your curriculum is really supported their learning so that when they get to you see because they are really able to access and understand that content. So I thought I was kind of thinking yes and know that some

of the You can enable children to use of do really impressive things, but you have to have actually put the work in to get the children to that point. There's no point in trying to get them to do something. They don't really understand just to make it look ambitious. And then the other thing I thought of was also I think some people want to challenge their children to the extent that they start teaching things from the secondary curriculum, we're not likely to do as good. A job of teaching is that specialist teaching in And

what's the point of them? Jeep vacating things. I think there's a danger of that as well, that you have to really know what are they actually going to learn that secondary school subject and make sure that you don't encroach too far into that? Because, to be honest, like the bit of history that we have in primary, but so fixed, the we have to cover is the ancient history prehistory ancient history up to 1066. Well, I mean, there's so much in that you could. You could spend so long teaching that in primary and still not have to everything but you might

want them to know in that in that time period. So I don't know why you would then go into things that you know they're going to cover again in secondary. So that's really interesting because in a unit that we do we do the history of medicine which is taken like pretty much from I think I did it in gcses. I don't know if it's still in the GCSE. Did that in cases. Yeah, and so be interested if in whenever we eventually are year,

five year fours, to do that, whether that's going to be beneficial to them with the history teachers are going to be like all you know, this isn't helpful but just to let people know who are listening. The justification for that was because I like to use thinking about curriculum history, curriculum design. I like to use kind of thematic. Units to kind of go back and look at the period that they've already studied bad, kind of a new element to their schema.

So we do the history of medicine. I think towards the end of year for where we go back, we look at right actually medicine during the Stone Age. It was some herbes and like a witch doctor kind of thing and a bit of trepanning which is always an interesting one and then Go to the Romans and it's all about, you know, public health and things like that, which I think. And obviously, you can connect that and to the prior knowledge

of Stone Age, Romans etc, etc, etc. And I think that works quite well. I never kind of really gave it much thought about whether that's something to leave to GCSE and I'm kind of short and some things. Might be touched upon and some things won't be. So just from the my knowledge and we don't look at, we do look at Galen the four humors. We certainly don't go to let you know the role of the church in

like controlling medicine or anything like that. We look at now there were the other four humors when you know and they just thought if they were out of balance and they put a leech on you, they got they had more blood, you know, real kind of a simplistic. I don't think it's the Simplicity very kind of surface level, kind of idea. What stuff is and the hope is actually that they will remember or not necessary, remember it. But it'll kind of be there in thats kind of subconscious memory. And so when they come to do that, hopefully they take it at

GCSE and then they can go. Oh yeah, I remember when we did the ABCD and all those kinds of things so they are interested. I never really thought of it from that, we're, we're poach, I'm poaching too much into secondary territory there. I think, I mean, we do have to do though, somatic studies, and then go later. Right? That is part of the primary curriculum. Anyway, isn't it? I mean yeah, they restart element of going later than 1066 with the pneumatic study and develop in the sense of chronology and I suppose it

depends on. How does it fit into the history? Curriculum, is it as a whole? Doesn't it? If you do one thing that they might come back to later in secondary It's not really a big issue. Is it? That is quite good to prepare them for things. They're going to learn later. Anyway, that's probably one of the functions of what what we're trying to do, isn't it? Is to prepare them for what they're giving secondary. Well, if you maybe And I guess it might be Academy's that could potentially fall into this trap. If you want to use the not

having to follow the national curriculum and deviate from it a little bit, you could go too heavy on me after 1066 stuff. And then there's the danger that you're not actually teaching them the pretense 66. And then I just think that they're not going to get that again in secondary. And I know that I've seen some secondary seat teachers on Twitter saying that they having to add in extra ancient. Jury to their key stage. 3 already from the children don't have enough, knowledge of ancient Greece and Rome to be

able to access them later. What they've got planned for later. So they need to add that in, to make sure that they're ready for it. And then I just think, well if they're having to do that then But that's not right, really? Is it? They've got enough to do in Key Stage 3 as it is, without having to go back and reteach stuff in primary? So, I think I feel like we should try and focus more on that ancient prehistory and ancient history, because I know there's no way I was going to miss the ancient Greeks, even

though we've had to go and change the curriculum around a little bit because of lockdowns and things. That's the only time they're going to learn about ancient Greece and its really important. So, you have to really make sure that they've done that really well in primary. Because they know I'm going to get it again and if they go on to later classic study that I don't have, I didn't have a preconceived answer in mind, but I knew that asking you guys would be really interesting and it absolutely was. And I think what it did with a long was illuminated, the connections between the different decisions.

You're making, you know, almost semi-automatically at the minute. And so I think that's really interesting and is there any final piece of advice you could give to anyone you know like like last time they were feeling energized about Out there there, Geography, practice anyone who's buzzing to get in there with history. What would your final piece of advice? Be, I'm a very, very, very similar to what type of geography. I hope my passion for teaching history is kind of Crossing this and so I am exceptionally

willing to chat to anyone. Who wants to talk about primary history, curriculum whatsoever at any point. I really do enjoy it past the SLT for that membership. The AHA make sure you get those magazines. Listen to those webinars on. What's the wisdom? Just that reminder it's a marathon not a Sprint and curriculum is never done just because you've written your first one. It's far from over, you're not going to see the benefits of it until kind of that first year

that year, one of that first year of implementation, kind of get through to year 6 and all the time. They're there needs. To be that Amendment. If you are on Twitter then I certainly recommend you follow Christine Council. Michael forwarder might kill Stewart. Tiffany who is a primary history specialist and been Newmark all the others are secondary based but they've all been really, really helpful in my thinking

and I've always kind of been willing to help. Me out whenever I've asked questions. Yeah I mean the only thing I've probably had his the local thing again I kind of already mentioned it earlier but just trying to learn a lot about your local history, local to your school, try and visit all of the possible places. I've just really enjoyed learning, just really enjoy learning about history. Not just I think the more that you research things, the more interested you're going to

become so just really giving a little bit of time to developing your own subject knowledge. Make it more enjoyable although possibly more frustrating because there's so much stuff that I'm interested in. I want to teach all of it at the Children's bone but I'll end up getting frustrated that I can't do that thing. Ink. Just try and find those sort of Interest, make sure that you're really interested in, then the passion will come across in your teaching. Yeah, and I think if you're not interested, Fake that interest. I think you can become

interested. You don't you think you're not interested because you haven't found out the right things yet. It's what I think I used to, I, probably hadn't really thought about re at all until I became re subject Pete and I don't, I just didn't really, I didn't really know much about other religions at all and as soon as I started finding out more about, I just found it so interesting and I think you can, you can develop an interest in subjects yourself. By starting to research and looking for the things that are interesting. You maybe just haven't found out

the right things yet to interest you. Yeah, that's quite a common with maths. Teachers are or primary math specialist, you know, they'll often say, like, I know Lisa said, in, in her episode that then she was big into literature, which was younger, and then she doesn't seem a little romance and then, that was her gone. Now, she hasn't looked back together. I think that's him as hundreds of the way to go and I think if nearly just Tell everybody what your ring, you know, as you change books, you know, because I know that my understanding of antiquity and has improved just

by sort of following your recommendations not with knowledge is a wonderful fantastic book on History. If people want their and share a real kind of meaty history book to to read it. Some yeah it follows the story of galen's medical curriculum. Ptolemy is The Alchemist and Euclid working geometry in the Army. I had characters gone again the elements the elements.

Thank you very much and how kind of when they were written and how they might be lost and all the translations that they went through and it kind of follows them around 77 cities which yeah, it's, it's very good and clearly I need to go back and revisit and commit to it. More to my long-term memory. And there's a few things that I think Victoria, but almost quite important as well. Re and there's a very important

and very important that when we teach our re, we do stick to the religious element of re obviously, but we at the same time, there is a political element. Social me comes to Christianity and looking at processes and customs, and the Schism that happened there. So For example, we do teach the shooters in year 5 or year, 6, being an academy. And so I think for us, you know,

if you're doing that, you're using those freedoms where you can link your re to your history as well. So that, you know, right? If they're doing doing the tutors in the focusing on religious change, then you want them to be really secure in. Standing what the difference is between protestantism and Catholicism is because it just gives it something much more of a meaningful meeting. Just makes much more meaningful for them.

Likewise, I see some schools who do they focus like Guy Fawkes in year two, I think. And obviously you can do that and not saying don't do it in year two. But just think about, you know, anything about choice. Everything's a choice, there's an opportunity cost to everything, you know, if they have that understanding of the differences between Christian and between Catholicism and protestantism first, then, you know, I think it's going to they're going to get a lot more out of that.

I think so where you can see if you can get those links going together as well and it's been an absolute pleasure guys. And I think people will get so much from both episodes and I think also desist. Thank you very much and hopefully we'll see you again. Very, very Very soon.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Guests

  • Neil Almond Guest Inferred
  • Victoria Morris Guest Inferred

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can a Generalist Really Teach Every Subject Well?

    Nov 21, 202657 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Doing Less, Better: Maths Teaching and Lasting School Improvement | Samantha Patterson

    Nov 14, 202643 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Burnout, Boundaries and the Systems That Shape Teachers with Ruth Poulsen

    Nov 7, 202651 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Teaching the Child, Not Just the Lesson

    Oct 31, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Attention Comes Before Learning

    Oct 24, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode