Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Thinking Deeply about Primary Education

Thinking Deeply about Primary Education artwork

Writing First, Assessment Second: A Conversation with Chris Youles

Mar 30, 202545 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Episode 221: Writing First, Assessment Second - A Conversation with Chris Youles This week on Thinking Deeply about Primary Education, I’m joined by Chris Youles for a timely conversation about writing assessment - why it often feels so difficult, how we’ve arrived at this point, and what we can do to realign assessment with the true purpose of teaching writing. We explore: Why assessing writing has become disconnected from high-quality teaching. The unintended consequences of planning lessons around assessment strands. Whether great writing instruction makes formal assessment simpler - and what that looks like in practice. How schools can rebuild trust in teacher judgement and let go of overly complicated systems. If you’ve ever found yourself frustrated by writing assessment or unsure how to make it more meaningful, this episode is packed with clarity, insight, and practical advice. If you enjoy this episode, please support us by subscribing to our YouTube channel, leaving a review on Spotify or Apple Podcasts, or making a donation via www.ko-fi.com/tdape. Join our Discord community to share your thoughts and explore unseen questions.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to thinking deeply about primary education, the podcast, the next time space to think about pedagogy, teaching and learning, professional development. Anything of interest to time per but enthusiasm rich primary teachers. This week I'm joined by Chris Hughes. Hi, Chris, How are you? I'm very good. How are you? Yeah, fantastic, it said. This. The spring has sprung here. Don't know. Obviously you're part of the world. Perhaps less of a distinction between the the seasons. It's humid and nearly 30° here. All year round. Yeah, but no, it actually gets cold in the winter.

Everyone told me, but I didn't believe them. But it's true. And we're going to explore writing assessment, something that I think is really, really important for teachers. But I thought we'd start with a little bit about who you are or you're from because it's your first time on the podcast. Thank you. Yeah. So from Kent and spent most of my teaching career in Brighton and I've been moved over to Taiwan to Taipei in 2022. And I'm the assistant head teacher of a school called the Taipei European School, which is

where I'm currently working and sitting in my office here now I'm talking to you. Fantastic. I mean, I'm also in Kent. I mean, I don't want to dock myself by saying exactly where in Kent I am, but it's a. It's. A lovely part of the world, like I said, especially in the sunshine. Yeah, exactly. But don't remember that too much from England, but I think I remember that day in June the 18th, wasn't it? Yeah. The the, I mean, the first time I sort of came across your work, I think you published at least one book with John Katz. I mean, how many books have you written so far?

3 So I have my first book with John captures Sentence models for creative writing and then I've got a book with Bloomsby called Teaching Story Writing in Primary and I've got sentence models for non fiction writing just coming out in, I want to say April. I think it's April. Fantastic. Not not long at all then. No, it's creeping up a better start promoting. It's the bit I hate, I was gonna say. Yes, yeah, yeah, I mean, and it's really difficult with social media changing, you know, we don't really know what, uh, what what does get seen and what doesn't get seen.

I. Haven't got a clue. I don't no idea how the algorithms work. Well, I mean, The thing is, like I said when I first came across your work, I think you're saying very, very sensible and, and supportive things about the teaching of writing. And so I think listeners would be really interested to hear what you have to to say about assessment. And because when we changed key stage 1 assessment here, my advice was just to don't bother doing anything. And I think we're going to go a little bit further into I. Think that's excellent advice. That'd be better than what exists. So yeah, I'm for that.

Seconded. Writing assessment. I think we both agree we've made overly complicated. Why do we think we've managed to make assessment of writing feel so difficult and disconnected from actual teaching? Now I don't know if there was a sort of sort of golden days prior to the, the, the first national curriculum being written where I've almost been this fantastic write teaching and writing my experience. I started teaching, I've been teaching 20 years. So I came in with the, the national literacy hour at the time of the stopwatch and the making sure you're only talking for 5-10 minutes for your start

and what have you. Now I the reason I think fundamentally comes from is that if you give people a list, they're going to use it as a list rather than thinking about the aspects of what actually makes writing good. And then you get all sort of balmy ideas from that. For example, I remember going to work with a school that fronted adverbial poetry writing, not because that makes poetry good, but you probably guessed because they needed to take off funded adverbials in their teaching. So I think one of the things I

think there's been really lost or, or, or never was there. I, I don't know the answer to this is that the, the teachers subject knowledge. So the example I always use when I'm doing training or working with schools is that in one of the curricular or one of the assessment frameworks, there's something that says write an effective story. And then nothing unpicks the word effective. And actually, what makes an effective story is point of view and stakes and obstacles and character goals and all these things that come from the wider world of writing about story

writing or writing about writing. If you read Stephen King's On Writing, or you look at Pixar's advice or Dan Harmon's Story Circle, this stuff is widely known, but it's not in our curriculum and so therefore we don't teach it. So I think we've almost accidentally gone down the rabbit hole and flipped the world upside down. And instead of thinking about what makes great writing, what I'm going to teach to my students. To do that, we go to our curricular or assessment list and then we work through, OK, I

need to teach subordination. So therefore I'm going to ensure that in this story we have subordination. Whereas actually, I don't know about you, I've never recommended a book to a friend say, hey, this book's it's got the best subordination and I've ever read, right. We, we recommend books because of plot and characters and character change and all those other things to do. Why did the story? So I think everything is just accidentally slipped upside down. And perhaps that's something that in terms of the subject

knowledge that from my point of view, you have to have a real passion for writing and perhaps like build your own expertise in terms of what you mean, what you understand from that rather. So that that's why I feel like we've this disconnect has come from that's why it's quite difficult, I think for teachers. I mean, you would have been starting right as this was becoming a a phenomenon. What weren't you and with the that's been sort of the time when triple marking was being recommended and. Oh God, yeah, yeah, yeah, I've

got PTSD. I mean, it's actually what off state are trying to deny. I don't know if you listen to the off state episodes, but we but essentially they've got these pejorative terms that could be interpreted in many, many different ways and like nothing has really changed since since 2003 thousand 4. Hmm. Do you find these sort of shortcomings are exacerbated in the international sector or do you think they're much the same so you can assume that nothing has changed over the last 25 years in England? I must admit I've seen the

Ofsted episodes and I'm not listening to those at the moment because I'm enjoying the world without Ofsted and breathing down our neck. I guess what's different in the international world is that, for example, in my team, when I started in this school in, it starts in Year 5, and I said, we're going to write a, we're going to learn how to pace. This is what we're going to do. It's going to be the big idea in this unit. And then one of my colleagues said, I can't see that in the curriculum. I was like, yeah, I know, don't worry, we don't have Ofsted.

And actually pacing is one of the most important things in writing. It's the one of the things that students in story writing find the hardest thing to do because we don't teach them how to do it. And actually, there's some really simple tricks if you want to get really geeky, if you want to speed the pace up, you can write with action or you can switch to an omniscient narrator. It's great fun as a writer because you can just suddenly say 1,000,000 years later Bob. I don't know why students are obsessed with Bob as a character name. It drives me to mental. But or you know, one second later and you can, you can play

with time, slow it down, speed it up. And when you want to slow time down because I'm in pacing them. We're going to teach our students to add more description or use the senses or use introspection like thoughts and feelings. And that literally has the effect of slowing time down. You've probably recognised the opposite of that when students do too much of that. And you have 4 pages of the character Bob eating his cornflakes, getting ready for school. And, and I said, look, this is what we're going to teach. And my colleagues, if that's not in the curriculum map, we've got

to teach subordination and fronted variables. And actually we have more scope, I think in the international sector to say, look, well, we don't have the offset window, we're not in it. We can, we can do this, it's fine. And actually I'm the writing lead here. So we could just sort of do it anyway because I asked them to. And what they found actually was that teaching these really good things to do with writing came back to the effective part. And all of a sudden the story of writing was great. And I think this also works out this bizarre rabbit hole effect again, where teachers are

looking at writing and then getting a assessment frameworks out and then working out what do I think of this rate writing from the assessment framework. But the truth is, when you finish reading it, you've already made your judgement. Did you enjoy it? Was it a good piece of writing? Did it talk to you as a reader? Did it have a good effect to you as a reader? And then more commonly, you start to use an assessment framework because I'm not saying not to do that because it's part of the school systems or if you have to do it, but then you start to find the things in there that made it good. So I feel like we have a little

bit more wiggle room in in international teaching, but we should have that room in anywhere. I think we're teaching despite the Ofsted because yeah, that's what makes writing good. Can I share a funny example? I was working with a year two class and it was Samuel Peeps diary writing. And then it said the great Fire of London raged outside. It was a really good piece of writing. The the the flames were flicking at my walls. Worried something about his cheese in his garden or something that was writing about that obsessed with the cheese. And then he said as the as the

burning got closer, the heat, you know, the flames were licking at the window. I reached for my woolliest jumper, put it on and head outside. And I remember asking if you know the year 2 writing curriculum. I think when I've shared this in workshops, anyone who's worked in year 2 is like EST spellings, right? So at no point had the teachers thought this makes no sense in terms of cause and effect of a story. It just need a shoehornet in there so we can highlight it off or ticket or yeah. So I think that's where we've got to.

It's amazing. I mean, he was obsessed with wigs, wasn't he? And he was wondering what the impact of the plague would be on wigs. So to be the wiggiest. The wiggiest, Yeah. Reach my wiggiest wig? Yeah. I mean, what you're describing there is like, is like super effective subject leadership because I think that wiggle room should exist here. And it's almost like an element of cultural capital that really great subject leaders have is that they know that they, if they go to moderation where the construct is a bunch of, you know, do you have this? Do you have this three times? But actually, you know what, you

know what great writing is? Yeah, you can talk your way through that and say, actually, no, here's why this is at least the expected standard and perhaps performing, you know, beyond it. So I think there's a lot to take from that because you know the way you know, the piece is a great example because you need lots of other elements to get this, to get to that piece, don't you? And we all have children who all of a sudden this lunchtime in the last piece just drops off. And it was all a dream. I mean, that's about us. Do that too.

That's true, yeah, Yeah. You know some time totally with you because it is the having the conviction in your in your subject knowledge, in your pedagogical contact knowledge to say actually this is the this is the approach for us, the. The, and the weird thing is that, and I think this is where the, the disconnected idea from like you see that they're the anti grammar brigade. And I'm very programmer. I think grammar is a tool and understanding how to use it and having a shared metal language with the students is really effective. We know what it's called, so why not just called it the proper term?

And I think the anti grammar brigade, I don't know if they've actually got a union or, but you know, the people that moan about grammar and teaching, they've got what they're actually seeing is decontextualise or poor grammar teaching and they're not understanding the, the, the good effect you can have from that. So when it comes to the actual curriculum assessment framework, I actually agree with all the stuff that's in there, lots of it, you know, tense use, that's really important because you read and need to understand what you're writing and not get confused or have any ambiguities. And it needs to be cohesive. So all those things should be

taught through contextualised story writing or author effect. And you hear, I think the one that like the anti, I keep talking about the anti. I'll stop talking about the anti grammar, but you know, people put them not so keen on grammar, obsessed with fronted adverbials. And I I agree on the idea that fronted is crazy because they can sit anywhere in the sentence. But actually, if you teach it through the effect of so, like, you know, if you're doing this starting with lesson that, you know, in the summer, Mr. Ewes goes to the beach and now we're going to go on to write our science fiction writing, then of

course that makes no sense. But actually, if I was the the man walked through the desert and I wanted to have the effect that my reader, from his point of view, understood just how much more the stakes are raised or there's an obstacle here, then maybe I'm going to add like a prepositional phrase at the start under the midday sun or as the sun hit its highest peak. But I'm using it for an effect. So actually there's a lot of good stuff in the curriculum. I'm not saying to throw the, you know, burn it and ignore it. What I'm saying is just start

from the endpoint. What makes the writing good? It's the first thing I do when I'm looking at a rich text and try and work out what is the right of done here to make me enjoy this text. What did I pick? Why did I pick it in the first place? And then I'm going to backwards engineer it. I'm going to pick those elements out. I'm going to teach my students. I'm going to break it down into little mini lessons or full lessons, and then we're going to build it back up. Always thinking about my reader because that's the most important part of the deal with the reader. Like I I've been teaching a couple of years whenever the the sort of the new national curriculum committee. And I thought it was great because it was, it was, it was, there's almost like it was, it

was more concrete than when it existed previously, you know, and all of a sudden knew what it was because I didn't know what good writing was. You know, I had my own loquacious style, but I couldn't tell you what I was doing. And, and so we had to, we had to become sort of, we had to become more knowledgeable about the subject. And then I was talking to Julie rise up about disciplinary literacy and all how all that information feeds you're sort of academic, quote UN quote and style it at primary school and stuff. So.

So I think, yeah, I think, yeah, it's very much a baby in the bathwater situation. You know it doesn't have to be all or nothing with this. It just needs I think. I mean I don't know how many PD or insect days or not insect days. So, you know, after school PD sessions I've been to run by really well meaning like local councils and authorities and I've sat and said, this is a session here how to get great depth writers or how to, you know, to deliver improve your writing in your school. And I sit there and then the trainer would walk to the front

and say, right, well, I'm not going to tell you anything because you haven't come here to listen to me. Let's all share good practice here on the table. And then I think, OK, well, that's really nice, but come because you're the purported expert, that's going to improve my knowledge and my subject knowledge of how to teach writing. And actually, I end up talking to some school about what's your school like and what's your school like? And I often left those PD sessions with a couple of good recommendations for books maybe to use in class. But I left with no further knowledge of actually how to teach writing. And I used to find it incredibly frustrating.

So I think, yeah, there's another element now. I think my people and teachers can, I don't know, feel a bit lost in that or that disconnect of how do I actually do this? What do you think the consequences are on pupils development as writers? I mean the, the, the great example I have here and this is if we just pick one element of writing, which is story writing. And I, I was teaching many years ago and I had this group of students and this really keen

student in my class. And she said to me, we're teaching setting descriptions, which I think a lot of teachers fall back on setting descriptions and character descriptions because they're quite easy, right? I think you can, you can see what the author's done, imitate them. People Chuck out, you know, here's 15 character descriptions and now you write 1. And this student in Britain is pretty decent setting description. She said to me, I just wish I could write setting descriptions every day. And I was like, OK, well, you know, why is that? And he explained to me, he said, because I know what I'm doing. I write a second description. But as soon as I try and write a

story, I haven't got a clue what I'm doing. And it was like a light bulb moment. I was bore a sledgehammer to the head. Just thought, well, hey, that's my fault and let me go away and really think about what is an effective story and stop worrying about my curriculum aspects and teach you this. And actually I think that's what it's done to pupils is that either they, we're trying to get them to, for example, like write stories where we, we've never taught them the actual bare essentials or functions of how a story works. I don't know if you've used all your comparative judgement like

the normal marking website. I think it's great. I think it's really fantastic for moderation. But with that you read a lot of stories, a lot of stories from students one to years, one to six and endlessly I read the stories. I think this character has no goal. There is no aim for this character. So instantly this story is not going to work. And then I can start to pick apart, you know, the grammar or the punctuation, but essentially the story is not going to work. So why don't we teach that? Why don't we teach students what a goal is? And I've tested this out and it was, it was really fun because I

put up, I'm not a big Disney fan, but I just presume the students would know the Disney films. I put a big, you know, there's like montage of like 50 different Disney films. Is that OK? Right. Finding Nemo one I have seen. What's the character's goal? Well, he wants to find Nemo. That's the goal. And then we can talk about obstacles. All these things get in the way. And even students who maybe are not, you will find that all your students pretty much are sine literate or TV literate. And this story working works in the same way. And then you can start to pick it out and you guide it reading text. Then you hog cast reading texts

and say, what's the goal? What are the obstacles? What's the thing in the way? And even with my daughter, who was three at the time, we were reading Stick Man by Julia Donaldson. And I said, like, what does Stick Man want? What he wants to get back to the family tree. We know this. We actually. So you're not trying to teach them some, like really unusual knowledge because they do have the knowledge. They probably just didn't know. It's called a goal. And no one had explicitly told them. No teachers had told them. Your character has to have a goal and then stuff gets in

their way. So actually, again, it might not be in the curriculum, but they do know these things. We just need to make it more explicit for them. You mentioned Don Harmon's story circle. Would you use that kind of device with your students? Because I mean, I really like Don's work and I think he's, he explains how his process really, really well. I mean, yes, Trey Parker and Matt Stone do something similar, don't they? They've got I've talked about it in my book, actually, what was it is therefore because but or whatever it is and they they realize it was the key to story writing, right. So therefore it's like says the

cause and effect, which is part of story writing. If you've ever read and George Saunders book, oh what's it called? Something to do with the pond. That's a really good plug, isn't it? He's taken some of the most famous Russian short stories ever written and then picked it apart in terms of cause and effect. My example, I love showing this example, the year six class who had the writing like ghost stories and they said it was probably Bob. Even though I've banned Bob is my only condition.

Bob was walking down the street. He saw the haunted violin and picked it up. I think, Well, think about logic and cause and effect. If you saw a haunted violin, you're going to run away. You're not going to pick it up. But these little like pieces of the puzzle, like, you know, the trade park and that same one or Ben Harmon's story circle, anything really, I don't think it almost matters which one you use, as long as you're using it as a framework to explain to students how writing actually works. I mean, I even think it back to my own right and I used to write

like pages and pages and pages. But I'm pretty sure one of the one of the the feedback I would get was what is the what is the point of having all seven of these pages? Not much, Not much is happening here. There's a there's a series of fantastic lectures by an author called Justin Cronin. He's a sci-fi horror writer and he is also a lecturer in writing. And I've, I've watched them on YouTube and I've watched them and he said he'd written many short stories and several books before he understood what point of view was.

And all of them failed because he'd never actually picked the point of view. And again, this is something, it's probably the most fundamental choice in students writing. And there's so many stories that you read, for example, like when I'm reading on no more marking and I, I pick that one not for anything to no more marking. It's just because you read a lot like you read like 2448 stories in one session. You know, the stories often start George, Susan, Tom, Billy, Harry Kane and Pennywise the Clown. There's always like an inappropriate horror character walk into a cave and straight

away you think, well, whose story is this? Like, whose eyes are we seeing everything through? Whose ears are we hearing from? Whose thoughts and feelings we're going to experience? Because you can't write a setting description unless you understand what a point of view is. You can't write dialogue. You can't do everything else that you're teaching them. And again, it's just that little thing. It's not in our curriculum to teach points of view, but it's what makes an effective story. I keep coming up to that word effective. So I think it's, yeah, those little things that problems that students have with writing. And I think I've talked about story writing a lot, but all writing comes down to like the lack of subject knowledge,

perhaps from teachers, and it's not their fault. Yeah. And you can see how that would apply across. And because I think you almost got some sort of like, you know, the cognitive burden of trying to think about the the sort of act of writing, but also the the purpose and and the the general generation of ideas. I think that could be quite a lot, quite a big burden for pupils. And is that the kind of thing you can't alleviate against? Massive and if you think about the the compositional aspects in terms of our curriculum and our assessment frameworks is is very slim or is alluded to without

being unpicked. And then we have a lot of like the, you know, the automaticity or the transcription parts and which is great and they're equal is important because even if you know from, from, I'm a bit of, I, I worry about this. I go backwards and forwards with handwriting and I worry that I'm a bit of a, a Luddite, But I, I think handwriting is really important. And I, I will argue that for a bit. I know Neil Alman and as Neil Alman talks about it on your podcast, I think before. Yeah, he's done it a few times and obviously got a chapter in the research head book. Yeah, so and actually you can

write the best story in the world. If no one can read it, then you failed at your basic thing of communicating to your read on. I know it frees up a lot more common to train. So I think, yeah, completely teach all those things that would get to the point of automaticity or the understanding of tense so that you're not thinking about that. You can think about the compositional, compositional elements more. But for me, those two things aren't at odds with each other. They're not 2 separate things. They're things that we can teach at the same time if we do it in a contextualized way, thinking about our reader all the time. So they're equally important, but they're not at war with each other, which I think sometimes

people tend to give that opinion. I'm not sure. Yeah, I think it's it's potentially an underdeveloped aspect of the discourse of the discussion around this element. I mean, if we if we teach right and well and so contextually in sequence, then assessment will largely take care of itself. To what extent do you agree with this? Statement. I couldn't agree more and in fact, this is the message I give to my teachers all the time. And I've I've see not just in my school, but in many schools I've worked with.

So I used to be like this. God, what was it called? Basically, I'd go into schools and help them with their writing. Literacy had some ridiculous title that I would didn't actually like calling myself, but was. IT SLE specialist leader. That's it. That. Thank you. That's it. Yes. Yeah, Yeah, Yeah. I had the hat made in the badge. Yeah. Just to look like an absolute Wally when I walked in. And time and time again, you'd see them planning their writing from, you know, from the curricular or from the assessment framework. And I think it's really fascinating that what I always say is like, which I've

mentioned, you know, start with the text, work backwards, what made it good, break it down. And then when you go back to the map, you suddenly realise that you've actually covered most of these things or you're covering these things constantly. And if you have something specific that you need to teach the students, like relative clauses in Year 5, which personally I hate for all sorts of boring, geeky reasons. And actually you will cover it all through working in this way. And if you don't, then you can do a lesson if you want, or part of a lesson on a relative clause. And if the student chooses to apply it and use it, then they

can. But I'm not going to force it. I'm not going to make them use a relative clause. So I think that is something I think teachers panic about, but you're good writing will cover it. And then I think actually what you really need to do, which I think is much more important, is start to think about how you're sequencing your teaching of writing through your year group so that all this information that you're building with them fits together in a way that isn't just about those things and the the assessment framework. So for example, in Year 5, we started with pacing. So we made sure they understood how to slow down or speed up

depending on what they want to do as a writer. We moved through how to use dialogue to reveal exposition. We moved through to teaching them how to use introspection well, balancing it out with action. So it's a classic thing with emerging writers where you know, you get the and and and and and. There's furious paces, pace writing, which is partly in fault to the story Mountain, which I could probably round about for about 5 hours. How much I hate the story Mountain as the only planning

shape that we use in class and actually teaching those things and building together. And then at the end of the year, we'd have a unit that would put all those things together for the student to apply it. And you cover everything, evidence covered in your curriculum. And actually, you've got much richer, much more versatile writers, writers that are more able to independently write or think about the choices they make than you would have done if you're teaching the other end up and you're trying to linearly work your way through assessment criteria criterion.

How long did it take you to sort of map out what that journey might look like? I mean, was it like an extended process or was it trial and error over an extended period of time? Both, I think, yeah, both. And I think that and that's the beauty. If you start to get like a bit of a if you can step away from these things and think about what really matters, then these conversations get much richer. You can. And actually I think that that particular Year 5, like horizontally articulated map took a few years of revising and

playing and I'm, I've moved away out of class now I'm the assistant head teacher here. But if I still there, I'd know, I'd still be tinkering with it and thinking about that. And one way that helped me was, OK, we're going to teach all these other elements that are in there, but we're going to look through the vehicle of whatever genre we decided to write in. We're also going to have a big idea. So when I talked about the thing about pacing, yes, we're going to teach all this. But the big idea is we're going to teach students how to pace. Or the big idea is we're going to teach them how to use introspections for thoughts and

feelings to slow scenes down. Or the big idea is this. So I just started writing that. Well, we didn't have paper planning, but I would put that for the teachers on a slide. So this unit is all these elements, but the big idea that we wanted to understand is how to do this through these practical things. So I think I mentioned them earlier, this is how to slow the pace down. This is how to quicken up and This is why you would do it to having that I felt personally, I felt that really helped me sequence it. If there, if there are any sort of any like sort of new and sort of fresh English subject leaders

who may find themselves with this kind of responsibility, but not necessarily the depth of knowledge that is required to engage with it. I mean, what's the best way to try and draw that from your mind? Have you got it somewhere that they could find that? Or is it, is it getting in touch with you? They'll say, you know, visits to your school are going to be, you know, although they'll be fantastic, I think limited to most of our audience base. It's. Yeah, yes, exactly. I think this is where I can make a shameless plug. It's not shameless because I think this is this is genuinely stuff that people need to know about and would be really interested in.

So the the and the the sales have been sluggish. So this is this is great in terms of story writing. This is my book teaching Story writing in primary, which is actually, I think I've had lots of really nice feedback from secondary teachers saying this is really good stuff for secondary as well. But I've tried to really unpack all this. I have got sections in there which explain how you can sequence these ideas, the idea of big ideas how and lots of practical advice for that. Other than that, go to the same place I did grab Stephen Kings

on writing. Get get all those. There's a fantastic John York book, into the Woods that goes through how to plot and go to, if you know, if you go to Google and say what are the best books by writers on writing? That's the source material. And I, I also, as I alluded to earlier, I really like watching writers who work as creative writing work teachers and universities, and I watch a lot of their workshops that they deliver for their students. And as I'm sitting, I'm thinking, OK, this is obviously

goes to a far too deeper level for the students that I'm teaching, but how can I break this down and ensure that they can access this? So Brandon Sanderson, who's the fantasy author, has all his university lectures online or the different themes of them. And they're, they're a great watch. Fantastic. I mean, the whole way through this chat you've given lots of really great sources to go to. So I think I'll try and as a as a medicine, I'll try and collate them and then almost have it in the show notes. So anyone is interested in this can go. I think the, the thing for me

that, that I, I genuinely love. So there's a, a group of scholars in London that have been working with some of these ideas. And I saw, you know, I, I've taken these ideas from great authors. I've tried to put it in a format that I think is useful for teachers. And then I've seen teachers start to run with the ideas and change and innovate and I've seen some of the writing coming back. And even though this, as I mentioned, the sales have been sluggish, seeing students start to use the ideas, for example,

my student, my character's got a goal. And then there's an obstacle in this very short scene. And and then suddenly seeing it come to life, That's, that's the magic, that's the part that it's just so rewarding. And the hundred 200 plus hours I've sat at a coffee table and coffee shops working away and writing is suddenly worth it when you see the students using them. Yeah. Yeah, because the process itself allows you to think so deeply, but you have to really have to think about your practice, don't you? And yeah, that's a that's a win win for our students. And yeah, so I mean, I mean, the public service nice for those

give teachers is that books in the grand scheme of things are easy to get 3 head teachers desks. So, you know, I I'd be making an order form now and just sort of saying here, I want this book, this book, this book, this book. And you know, it's going to be way under what they're being expected to pay for, like their parent communication systems and that kind of thing. So anyone's listening, They want books. Don't buy them yourselves. Get your head teachers to buy them for you. Absolutely, yeah, I could think of a few. You could probably think of yourself a few great elephants that a lot of money has been spent on the sitting in stock cupboards gathering dust. Quisdom, did you do you ever

come across that like this interactive quiz system that was on like for multiple choice questions that was on these and it never worked. It just it sat on the desk. Yeah, I mean in the maths cupboard it's a trundle wheels because they once a year. I mean, they obviously are important, but I think they're better, you know, probably more cost effective ways to teach the concepts of measurement. You've proposed that we let go of overcomplicated assessment systems and return to the idea that writing is first and foremost about communication. I Can teachers in schools begin

to rebuild trust in their professional judgment when it comes to assessing writing. I think, I think you mentioned it earlier because I was a moderator for key stage 2 for, for years for two different authorities. And I've sat in those moderation meetings and, and I've been in moderating at school. And if, if a teacher knows their stuff, they'll talk you through that moderation process. Because that's normally the fear, isn't it? I'm worried about the grading or the assessment system, which in

we, we work, which is unavoidable. But if you've got someone that actually understands writing, has a good subject language, they'll talk you through why that writing's greater depth or not. And actually, the moderator is over the moon. I can trust me when you sit there and you have someone saying that this is greater depth because you think, well, fantastic. And I completely agree rather than, and I'll share this, but I won't say the poor panicky teacher said, but he must be greater depth. He comes from a long line of greater depth writers in his family. Oh, so actually I think that's

part of like where we can, if you, if your subject knowledge is good, then then you don't have to worry about that aspect. The thing I think that teachers most most worry about. And then actually in terms of like senior leadership teams or authorities or schools building trust, I guess it just comes back to the point I made earlier, which is that genuinely when you read the piece of writing, I think you've made your mind up whether or not that piece of writing works because you're the reader in that scenario.

And the reader is the most important part of the deal. It's the thing that writers where they fall in love with their own language and drift into purple prose, which is actually quite a natural stage of imitation for young writers. And then you can teach them how to edit and pare back. But actually good writing is good writing. And you get that gut feeling, the instinct, which is why actually why the normal marketing system works well, right? Because it's just that nice easy comparative judgement. And if you go from that point and your subject knowledge is good, then we don't have to worry about the trust because actually you'll know what you're

doing. Where it gets panicky, I think is where the subject knowledge is not as deep or slightly flaky. You're probably planning lessons like out fronted of verbals poetry, and then suddenly when it's under the magnifying glass of a moderation or a moderation team coming in, then it can lead to that feeling of distrust or worry about how they're teaching it. And yes, I just, I really honestly think better subject knowledge or really good advice, say here's the curriculum. But when we I keep saying it, but I'll keep banging on about

because this example is best when it says effective story. Look at Appendix 2 or look at this page. This is what it means that it has to have. And I feel if we get to that point, then actually we'll be in a much better place for our students, which is the most important thing, yeah. It's that specificity around the sort of component parts and like we say, you know those the sort of ill defined features. Yeah, I mean, because I remember like I also did the key stage to moderation process for a couple

of counties in this area and I remember talking to them about collocations because it's not something anyone ever mentions, but it's like the way words behave with each other. And I come across it through my language learning that. Then when it's obviously it's more jarring in another language whenever you use that. And it's almost like, like you say, I'll go into those sources that you've recommended. I'm going beyond what's specified because we've obviously got, like I said, got our grammatical content, but really an effective subject leader is developing almost like

an additional layer. Is that a, is that a fair characterization of what's sort of expecting teachers or certainly subject leaders to to do? It is. And I think that, I mean, I felt bad because I felt like there was that big quick review recently, but was known and I, I kept meaning to like I wanted to just pitch this idea, say like, you need to unpack this a bit for teachers. It's not, you don't have to necessarily get rid of the quick, just just unpick it. Give some examples, give some practical examples of how this actually works. You know, that was one of the

things in the E6 framework, like build atmosphere, but that's all it says. It doesn't really give you any more guidance on what it actually means or why you would use it. So I feel like that's something that in terms of, yeah, any sort of curriculum changes could we do with just some. This is what it really means, the specificity of it, right? The interesting thing, we keep calling it the new curriculum, don't we? What was it, 2014? And for me, I always bring

about, I know you're a maths expert and you you write about maths. The biggest change I found in my practice was 2014 curriculum I thought was so much better at teaching maths and I improved massively as a maths teacher because it was the first time actually I've thought about breaking it down and using the concrete attitude and all this stuff that come I guess was it from the Singaporean maths model. And I, I talk about this a lot, but I feel like 11 years on and I feel like maths teaching is so much better than the 10 years I was teaching prior to that.

Why would I was on primary? I've got to teach fractions tomorrow, God, I'll find something on primary resources and we'll play this game. And it was all disconnected and I didn't understand what I was doing. I still feel like that's needs to be a big scene change in where we go with writing. At some point we're going to really understand what this means, work out how we can break it down and stop leaving it to this sort of like the abstract, similar to maths. I quite often share the example of like how I teach long division now compared to how I

used to teach it. You know, I'll teach over 3 or 4 lessons breaking it down. And then I try and use that as analogy for if you just show them a story and it presumed by osmosis, they're going to absorb that and suddenly if it produces a really good story, it's not going to happen. And I feel like the excellent shift in maths teaching, in my opinion, that's happened since the New Quidcombe across schools in the UK still, we haven't really gone on that same journey in a granular way in writing. And that's why I'd really hope

it goes at some point. Yeah, I think, I think you're spot on and I tend to agree. I mean, obviously I spend a lot of time on this podcast complaining about the things that I would cut from the national curriculum. But All in all, I mean, you mentioned primary resources, stock Code UK. I mean, I used to spend so much time there in a Sunday and that was busy where my plan it was taken from because it was just a deal. It was up to you going ahead. And, and I think certainly genre dominated when I started teaching and I feel like it still does. So I think the fact that there seems to be mention that assessment systems may change in

writing and that it feels like comparative judgment might be the model that comes in. I don't know. That's just a vibe I got from the and there was like an interim report on the curriculum assessment. So it may be that that opens the door then, because if we're not tick listing what I think I. Hope so. I actually think that'd be much better model. It'd be more efficient. And, you know, I used to enjoy being a moderator and I feel sometimes that that system gets a bad rap. And I think actually I do, you

know, a lot of people think we got paid, which used to know exactly. Yeah. Those people that worked in would be passionate and are genuinely doing. I think for the for the love of writing. I'm trying to help. But yeah, so that's interesting. I I've got a funny example for genre that I remember in the Lipsi hour and the local authority said we've got this idea of this like intervention scheme for students that can't write. And what we're going to do is we're going to take a different genre and a different writing outcome. Every week and they're going to write 1:00 every single week. And then by the end of this like 8 week program that have caught

up and when it came I said, but you know X, let's call him Bob again. Bob can't write a sentence. He can't write a sentence for persuasive writing. He can't write a sentence for science fiction or anything. He can't write a sentence that he's got fragments and run ONS and lack of understanding. So yeah, the I I enjoy like varying the genres and that is something I think about in terms of my sequence and I like varying the different types of story shapes that we might come across. But essentially, if all you worry about is the genre, that's

not thinking about the other big compositional aspects to writing as well. Or one of my other favorite examples. If I asked, the teacher said, are you, you're doing first person writing this time? Why is that? And said, well, we've done a couple of Fair persons. We thought we'd do a first person. It's like, well, it isn't just a grammatical distinction, it's in a complete Switcher point of view and it comes with its own set of rules for writing. So actually again, subject knowledge, right, that people don't honestly understand that. Yeah. I mean, I think it'd be fantastic if that was the way

that the system was set up, you know, so that, you know, obviously to counter those sort of myth, I don't know, not over generalizations, but misinterpretations of what the what the purpose and what the point is. And high children get better at learning to write. I mean, incidentally, have you had a look at needles and sort of sentence level curriculum? At least you developed at step, or maybe I had gene in step developed I. Think it's on my desktop. I've had a little, I've had a little, I've had a little sneak and I, I think my point of view,

anyone who's trying to break it, what is incredibly hard being the students to master and learn down into steps and thinking about that. So Andrew Percival has been doing some workshops as well, how they're like trying to build it from a sentence level. I think they're doing, they're doing the right thing from a level format. I think that's that, that's my feeling is that's the right way to go. So I think it's fantastic anyone is thinking about it that deeply. Yeah, they'd be, they'd be the first two to come to mind. And there's actually been the keynote at our conference at the weekend. And although it'll be in there,

it'll be in the past whenever, by the time they say yeah, yeah, they do a lot of really deep thinking about things. And I think, you know, it's definitely 1, you know, people can visit. It definitely should. Just to share one thing that popped into my mind that always makes me laugh as well. When teachers decide actually, I'm going to teach in the first person, and then they spend all the time trying to drill the students out using the word, the pronoun I, It's like you fundamentally have to use the pro and I in the first person. You decided right in the first person, so deal with it. They've got to use I It's not a

bad thing. It's like yeah, using said. Yeah. What's the issue with Said? Yeah. And there's obviously there was the kind of revolution, wasn't there? They said it's not such a bad thing. Yes, exactly. Yeah, Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's bad one. I mean, I think about you. You're mentioning, you know, he comes from a long line of, I'm thinking like, you know, the Alfred the Great's line almost made it to, I don't know. And was it Edward who sort of started the whole thing about 1066, right. He was almost like, I think he might have been the last night

line. And just think of this child, unfortunately the one who paused this this cataclysmic moment in in British history. Exactly. Yeah. Yeah, it was. And so the greatest depth line ended this poor child in my motivation. Yeah, I can't. I think it might have given great depth just out of pity. I think I can't end that line. Yeah. I mean, what difference is going to make this secondary? School. Exactly. Yeah, they didn't pay any attention to it. Yeah, no, I mean, we have lots of very sensible secondary teachers who listen to this podcast, you know?

Completely agree. And I mean, it's, it's, it's been fantastic to chat about with you in this much depth and detail. And we'll definitely come back to that sentence almost sentence level, sentence composition element in the future. All I was there to do is say thank you very much for joining me. Thank you, I've thoroughly enjoyed it. The thing I enjoy most is when I talk to my wife around these things, I can see her eyes glaze over. So it's always nice to talk to someone who's not half falling asleep or just thinking shut up. Yeah, I mean, my wife hasn't

read either of my books. No, neither is mine. And the third one, she said. Have I got an acknowledgement? I said not until you read one will I say thanks for your support. And everyone at home, until next time, thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Guests

  • Chris Youles Guest Inferred

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can a Generalist Really Teach Every Subject Well?

    Nov 21, 202657 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Doing Less, Better: Maths Teaching and Lasting School Improvement | Samantha Patterson

    Nov 14, 202643 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Burnout, Boundaries and the Systems That Shape Teachers with Ruth Poulsen

    Nov 7, 202651 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Teaching the Child, Not Just the Lesson

    Oct 31, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Attention Comes Before Learning

    Oct 24, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Learn more about ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠The Story of Maths⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ACEL Pro ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠- ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠www.alta-education.com/tsom-overview⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode