Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Thinking Class

Thinking Class artwork

#153 - Oliver Bennett & Morgan Watkins - England Is 1,100 Years Old But The English Have Forgotten Who They Are

Nov 19, 20261 hr 46 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Oliver Bennett and Morgan Watkins are the co-founders of The Base and RADA-trained actors with nearly twenty years of experience in British film, television, and theatre. They join me to trace the English from their origins on the North Sea coast, through Alfred and the Danes, the Norman yoke, and 1,100 years of continuous nationhood to becoming a people who built a civilisation that conquered the world but can’t define themselves without embarrassment. In this conversation, we think out loud about: * The MacFarlane-Hume challenge: do the English have a national character? * Anglo-Saxon origins and the peoples of the North Sea coast * Alfred, Guthrum, and how the English became one nation under external threat * 1,100 years of continuous nationhood - longer than any European country * Why the English subsumed themselves into the British identity after 1707 * Class and identity - why working-class English people know who they are and the middle classes don’t * Orwell’s paradox: “It is your civilisation. It is you.” * Assimilation, its limits, and what happens when hospitality has no expectations * The Norman yoke, linguistic apartheid, and Chaucer’s revolution * The cow-beef divide: how the English language still carries the scars of conquest * The medieval Englishman vs the stiff upper lip - and what changed * Enchantment, disenchantment, and the pagan-Christian tension in English literature * What happens when civilisational difference meets democratic settlement? * What the English owe each other - and whether noblesse oblige can be recovered * Kundera’s warning: the struggle of memory against forgetting Guest links: - Website: https://www.thebasecreates.co.uk - X: https://x.com/thebasecreates - Substack: https://open.substack.com/pub/thebase Related episodes: The Call of England Episode 1 Alan Macfarlane and the origins of English individualism Carl Trueman's Lament For England Peter Hitchens on How Britain Witnessed A Moral And Cultural Revolution This episode is sponsored by Aquinas Tuition. https://aquinastuition.co.uk/ Thinking Class is a long-form interview podcast on the cultural, historical and civilisational forces shaping England, Britain, the Anglosphere and the wider West. Hosted by John Gillam. ▶ YouTube ✍ Substack 🎧 Spotify 🍎 Apple 🐦 X New episodes every Thursday at 3pm.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello, classmates, and welcome to Thinking Class. I'm John Gillam, and today I am joined by Oliver Bennett and Morgan Watkins from The Base, which exists to renew the dramatic arts by returning to the great works and asking what they mean now. This is the first episode in a new series that we are calling England, our England. And in this conversation, the three of us think out loud about who the English actually are, how a group of peoples from the shores of the North Sea became the oldest nation in Europe, the holy island of Lindisfarne and the Venerable Bede, King Alfred and the fight for survival against the Danes, the Norman Conquest and the 333 Years Without an English-speaking king, the passage from Walter Scott's Ivanhoe that every English person should read, George Orwell's Line and the Unicorn, and what Ernst Junger meant when he called the English the most formidable and the most chivalrous people.

SPEAKER_00This episode is brought to you by Aquinas Tuition, which provides bespoke academic tutoring informed by classical liberal arts principles. Whether your child needs support with GTSEs, A levels, or university entrance, Aquinas will pair every student with a tutor who cares about formation and not only grades, but they do care about grades too. Visit AquinasTuition.co.uk. I'm also the founder of the Albion Institute, an institution for the formation of nationally minded leaders and an informed public through the preservation, transmission, and renewal of the intellectual and cultural inheritance of the English-speaking peoples.

SPEAKER_00Lord Nigel Bigger joins Albion as the advisory board chair, and if you would like to learn more, register your interest, or indeed become a founding patron, we're looking for our first 50, please visit AlbionInstitute.org. And if you haven't already, go and watch The Call of England, my six-part documentary series following HV Morton's 1927 journey through England. The link is in the description, and in the meantime, enjoy the show, classmates, and now Oliver Bennett and Morgan Watkins.

SPEAKER_00It's 2026, and the debate about identity rages throughout all of the West. We sit here in modern Britain, made up, as we know, of England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, and yet who we are seems to be a question that won't go away. Perhaps previously it seems to be obvious, but it doesn't seem obvious to other people. There seem to be paradoxes within our identities. For some who have clear boundaries as to what they are, the English in particular don't seem to.

SPEAKER_00Is that always been the case? Or is that a more recent development? Today, joining me are friends, colleagues, Morgan Watkins, Ollie Bennett from The Base. Thanks very much for joining me again, chap.

SPEAKER_01Pleasure, John.

SPEAKER_02Thanks, John.

SPEAKER_00We're here as three Englishmen, albeit with uh uh uh influence genetically from the Celtic fringe to try to understand ourselves. And this conversation, which will be a series of conversations, came out the back of one we held in real life uh uh about six weeks ago. And Ollie, it was actually as we were talking about some of the conversations I've had on thinking class, and one of them was with the great British anthropologist Alan McFarland, professor emeritus of anthropology at Cambridge, and he is famous for his work on the anthropology of the English specifically, and he's a man who is mostly Welsh and Scottish, but has has studied and researched about the uniqueness of the English people and their literature, their politics, their laws, and we'll get to all of that.

SPEAKER_00But within one of those conversations, he said the thing the other thing that's unique about the English is that despite being unique, they don't actually have a national character. And you found that to be somewhat um uh triggering to use modern parlance. Why was that?

SPEAKER_01I knew I knew the word triggering was coming there. Um yeah, no, it was I mean, I wasn't um I didn't lose sleep over it, but uh I think he was quoting David Hume, right, who says the thing about the English they they don't have a national character. Um and it did well I I took it to be the biggest challenge to a kind of conservatism or a kind of um anyone who tries to think in not necessarily essentialist terms, but in an attempt to actually conceive of ourselves as a as a as a people, which a lot of our conversations have been about.

SPEAKER_01So I thought this is a challenge that needs to be tackled head on. Like, is is Hume and is McFarlane right about that? And so yeah, that got me thinking, that got me going back to English literature, to the the the long history of English literature, to see are there consistent strains here? Um, are there are there threads that carry on through? I think as you say, there's paradoxes which we will get into, but I think there are dominant strains that we would uh that I would I would raise uh as evidence uh in repost to McFarlane and Hume.

SPEAKER_00Morgan, in that same conversation, you you you told us, look, I'm I'm half Welsh, and yet I feel drawn toward stepping in the ring with the English at this moment in history. And and specifically this was because of the the nature of the changes in the country and indeed all of this argumentation about English identity. What wh why is it that as as a man with a Welsh dad, proudly Welsh dad, wants to step in the ring with the English don't know?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Because I love England and I love the English people, and it's I I sort of have a sense of justice in in my heart and I feel the need to to to to fight with the people of my land. And I live here, I've grown up in England. I still live in London, and I've yeah, I feel kind of woven into this country too. I I'm very proud of my of my Welsh side.

SPEAKER_02I I think just to kind of immediately get into some of the debates about the identity and ethnicity and this sort of stuff, which I think is unavoidable with this, is you know, my dad would never, ever have thought of himself as an Englishman. And and that's so obvious to him that he wasn't English, you know, and that was kind of the idea that he was English because he just lived in England was absurd.

SPEAKER_00Uh

SPEAKER_02and we we knew that. And I've I've I find some of this this debate quite tedious. I do understand some of the complexities actually to it, but it's just so obvious to me what it all is. I I also just feel protective over the country because it's been governed so badly by completely out-of-touch elites for what, 30, 40 years now? And we, you know, the the the country's under attack. It's it's under attack, its culture's under attack, it's degraded itself as well.

SPEAKER_02I think we should we should be honest that it's not that every English person is some amazing person. I think English people themselves have have have lowered their own culture as well. There it there this is a complex issue. It's not just, you know, it's not just immigrants doing that or whatever, you know, whatever whatever it would be. It's a complex discussion. But there has been huge problems with like mass immigration and complete kind of no democratic mandate for that. And I've it's just wrong. It's wrong. Uh and it's wrong that you that you're doing this.

SPEAKER_02You're giving people this sort of thing called democracy, and and you're what they seem to be doing is kind of piling, having uncontrolled mass migration without any discussion properly on how complex that is. If there's ever been any pushback to that, it's been just described as racism, which is the worst thing you can say to white people. And then at the same time as that, at the same time as doing something very uh uh incredibly unfair, without any mandate, they uh uh they have and very dangerous, reckless policy.

SPEAKER_02They have been somehow kind of um incubating a culture which is anti-English and anti-Western at the same time. So people coming here have nothing to assimilate to.

SPEAKER_00So

SPEAKER_02th these two things are just terrible together. And yeah, we I I just feel that that that's probably why I feel to fight for England. But I love England, I love England, I love all the I love the I love the the the woodland, I love the beaches, I love I love this country, I love the language, I love the history, I love Wales too, but we have to we have to fight for it.

SPEAKER_00Well, I I think I think added to all of that, it's fair to say that we think most things now are constructions in some way, uh, whether it's our identity, whether it's our gender, uh everything can be built and selected from a menu. But the notion that nations are modern constructions is one that I used to believe in, but no longer do. I think it's it's it's been comprehensively challenged, and you can see that there isn't there is an ethnic core, you can't get away from that.

SPEAKER_00Um, you know, the shared name, ancestry, there's myths, there's historical memories, we've got distinctive culture. So that's that's one element of it. There's a there's a symbolism of the the majority ethnicity within nations, uh, as true for Scotland as it is England, um, and and both of those nations have been made up from a a synthesis of either closely related peoples or or or different peoples too. But there was a lot of conflict in in the middle of that. I also feel compelled to do this because, as you just described, Morgan, it's a time of of crisis in many ways, a crisis of meaning.

SPEAKER_00And it almost feels like what we need to do is to go and revisit uh our roots to pull something back for us to actually hold on to. So we can understand ourselves again. Because actually, the other thing about not understanding the story of who we are, which is always contested, but there's usually a pool of memories to hold on to, uh, and we can all argue about the meaning of them, is that they seem to have been fundamentally erased or or or suppressed to the point that I think most of us are going on like these rootless, atomized individuals.

SPEAKER_00And I know having lived that journey for all of my twenties before really starting to understand even my own family background, ancestral background, before understanding my regional and national backgrounds, that once I understood those things, I felt much more rooted and sure of myself in the world, rather than feeling like I wasn't a part of anything. Um, so I think there is something that we need to do there where if there's a nationalism within this, there's definitely a cultural nationalism for the renewal of whatever this is. I I think also that the point you make about mass immigration, it's not actually just all about immigrants, it's it's ourselves too.

SPEAKER_00And it's true that those arriving in diaspora groups have their own clearly delineated ethnic boundaries. They know what they are, they know what their historical memories are, they know what their symbolism is. Uh, we need that too. And the thing is, is people can choose to come and join that team and they can come and choose your symbols and they can come and take part in your memories, and they can choose to be with you. And I think unless this process is done, and I don't think the nation is going to get all of this from this podcast, but they they should.

SPEAKER_00But unless we all go on this, uh, I think we we will just continue to have these totally fruitless conversations about who it is that we are. And and not only that, I think we we we ought to understand the fruits of our civilization. Because as you chaps know, as people uh both in the literary and theatrical world, is there are a great many fruits of our civilization. Um

SPEAKER_01just to add to that as well, John, I think it's important to say that the fact that there have been a few different people that have gone into the construction of the nation. Well, I've used the word construction, but the making of the nation,

SPEAKER_00right?

SPEAKER_01The fact that that is historically the case uh is used to justify any and anything being done in terms of people added and everything like that. If you you hear leftists in arguments all the time, they will say, you know, there is no national um core, original, national thing, and therefore we can just add to anyone.

SPEAKER_00So

SPEAKER_01Britain is seen as this universal um global community because of this of this history, but actually that history is not properly understood, and so that's one of the reasons that we're doing this as well. So there is a kind of firm foundation to push back against that argument.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and can I just also throw in a provocation early on? Perhaps the reason that you you know the the we the the the the Alan McFarlane comment and Ollie's response to it perhaps the reason there isn't a strong identity in some ways, but if if that could is true, is basically because it is the central it's the centrality of all we know. And and we it's the centrality of everything, our language, our thoughts, our history, our philosophy, our everything is is the theory of mind is an English one. So you live in that naturally, so it's very hard to to see that.

SPEAKER_02Uh yeah.

SPEAKER_00I think I think you're right. I also think besides us inhabiting this very part of the world with all of those cultural artifacts around us that you know we're we're we're fish, so I don't realise we're swimming in water, basically. We've got no idea what what's around us.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But but not not only that, it goes further than that, doesn't it? Because um as MacFarlane himself says in his work back in 1250, England wasn't like the peasant societies of France or Italy or the rest of Europe. This is a quote, it was already a mobile, market-oriented, individualistic society in which the weights of lordship and community bore relatively lightly on the individual. There was no great transition from a peasant to a market economy, as far back as the records go, England was already capitalist. The reason why I bring that up is that's what was then transported, transmitted to the rest of the world.

SPEAKER_01You know,

SPEAKER_00we we live in an unbelievably mobile time, everything's market-oriented, even people from clannish societies that were unlike the English are now becoming more individualistic. And so our assumptions, which the US did such a great job of then projecting even further than the British Empire, are now taken up by almost everyone else as something to aspire to. So it it makes us even blind to some of our cultural particularities because they became universals in some way.

SPEAKER_00Uh what do you think what do you think uh is the layman's way to start this?

SPEAKER_02Well, okay, girls.

SPEAKER_01Uh well I think there could I think there's uh Morgan and I were discussing earlier on, there's a there's some basic history that we literally were not taught in school when we went to okay schools. Um and so I do think and I've just been refreshing you know.

SPEAKER_02Ollie, when you say okay schools, I think we should be specific, right? Because that we went to state schools, me and Ollie. We went to like oak okay state schools. So I think you mean.

SPEAKER_01I mean decent comprehensive schools.

SPEAKER_02Decent comprehensive schools, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Uh and so and yeah, even even still it was not was not taught. Um so I do think some kind of recap of the basic stages of those uh uh of the early formation of England as a unified state um would would be useful. And I'm looking at you, John, and you can't tell. Uh, to guide us through.

SPEAKER_02Also, I'm looking the reason I say when you say it okay, because you've said that before, and it always sounds like you're saying uh we didn't go to Ethan, but we went to Open. So I just thought it would be sort of

SPEAKER_01a mid-range private school.

SPEAKER_02No, and I think yeah, yeah. Even

SPEAKER_01the difference of going to a comprehensive at and a and a grammar school is different, is massive. So I was a comprehensive up until GCSEs and then went to a grammar school for A-level, and it was just clear there was so much general knowledge that I didn't have. And I, you know, was always feeling like I was catching up, and then went to university where there's kids who've been to private schools, and you're like, oh, these these guys have even more sort of broad range. Uh I'm sure people dispute that who've been to those schools, but it it was a a real thing. Like, even though you went to a good area, decent area, decent comprehensive, some lovely teachers, there was not the foundational knowledge.

SPEAKER_02No, no.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I know I certainly know that feeling. I had to do lots of self-taught stuff. Again, northeast of England, nice part of Northumberland's state school, good reputation, always rated very well. And uh, I mean, saying that, I don't want to blame the school, I was a total tear away, and so I wasn't actually listening the whole time. Uh, but it is true, and actually, some of the things you touched on is also a very English thing, right? Is Morgan jumped in just to just say, just be clear about your class bona fides here.

SPEAKER_02Yeah,

SPEAKER_00because

SPEAKER_01yes, yes.

SPEAKER_00Because everyone in England is very, very alive to that. And and I get it all the time. Just because I wear a tie, people say, Oh, here he is talking about this, uh, such a public schoolboy thing to say. It's like, no, I don't, I didn't. I I never went, but it's only because I I dress smartly, and so that itself becomes coded as being like an upper class thing to do, um, which is which is interesting. We will certainly get to class, but so I am no historian by trade, but here's here's the the broad view of the English people from um where they originated from before they stepped foot here on Albion uh and changed the course of of the Isles.

SPEAKER_00So um what's interesting about McFarlane talking about uh an individualistic society as far back as records go is he himself even nods back to the idea that these cultural traits can be found within writings from the Anglo-Saxon period. And I think it's we should go a little bit further back than the Anglo-Saxons because they themselves were um uh synthesis, but of very closely related peoples. So effectively there were um uh uh several groups of peoples that lived across the the shoreline of the the North Sea and what is the Elba Weser Triangle, a couple of rivers that are in are now in modern Germany and some of the Low Countries.

SPEAKER_00And he had Frisians and Jutes, he had Saxons, he had Angles, and effectively um these people were exhibiting those traits that McFarlane was writing about in the 13th century, according to uh Roman historians um and commentators of the time, Tacitus being the most famous one, where he wrote about this um this uh tall, domineering, individualistic um uh people who were who were concerned with utility.

SPEAKER_00So the things that worked for them that made their lives easier, and they couldn't suffer tyrants, they lived in a a freer, a freer way naturally, without having had all of the fruits of s civilization, you know, from the Mediterranean to sit and pick over. That this is just the way they were uh as people, closely related peoples, they spoke mutually intelligible languages. Um and they were largely brought part part of the same ethnic group, really, uh at least at the genus level. Anyway, they all came over, fall of the Roman Empire.

SPEAKER_00Uh there was a there was a Romano, a British elite. So when I say that

SPEAKER_02John, what what you what what the what year is it? What sort of rough year is this all happening in?

SPEAKER_00This starts to happen in the late um 5th century, is when you start seeing people coming over, and they start coming over because you have the withdrawal of the Romans in the 430s, roughly, from Britain. Um and then the the British elites, so those who were um what we would refer to now as Celtic stock, really, uh the original inhabitants of of the of the Isles, not not strictly the original inhabitants, but we won't go there. Um, is they um they the elites were had become romanized, and so they had villas and they lived for good lives.

SPEAKER_00And basically upon the withdrawal of the Romans, they thought, bloody hell, all this is gonna go up in up in smoke, but because we're gonna have all of our fellow natives coming for us. They're gonna come and take us out of our fancy uh fancy villas. So they basically put a clarion call, a clarion cry out there, a rallying cry even to to the continent, um, to some the mercenaries on the North Sea coast. Um uh and famously Hengiston Horser, the two brothers were the first who arrived on the shores of East Anglia to support shoring up the authority of the Romano-British elite.

SPEAKER_00Turns out that many more came over to help with this, but in the end they realized that they could, you know, it authority was there for the taking. And so they themselves uh began to create their own polities. They became the rulers in various places, and largely this was in the south and east of England, though there was um a transplant up on the the northeast coast, which became the Kingdom of Northumbria, which is very important. But effectively you had the heptarchy, different ruling kingdoms.

SPEAKER_00So there wasn't one English king. Uh there were there were there were there were several. Um you had Mercy here in Essex and Wessex, Northumbria, East Anglia, and am I missing another? Polly? I feel like sounds good. Sounds good. Anyway, they often fought with each other for supremacy. And it was um and and they also fought with the the Celtic fringe. So the the Britons who we spoke about, that Romano-British where the Romano-British elite came from, they were typically in the south and west, sorry, the west of the country and the southwest of the country.

SPEAKER_00Well, they were everywhere, but they kind of got pushed out uh to these what is now Wales and Cornwall ultimately. And some decided they're not having this anymore, and they jumped on their boats and went over to Brittany because they didn't they couldn't stand the English or the people that became the integrated English. Um, and then you had those in in Scotland who were also uh Scotland wasn't a thing at the time, hadn't even been colonised by the people that became the Scots. Uh they were they were they were a mixture of Britons and Picts, and um, and we'll get to the Scottish later, I'm sure.

SPEAKER_00But um basically the English managed to become the English and have one king and become one nation in response to external threats. That external threat being the arrival of who we call the Danes, but they were you know from some of them from the west coast of Norway and some from what is now modern-day Denmark, and ultimately they started um uh r raping and pillaging their way through the the the northeast coast of the Western. And what year and

SPEAKER_02what year is this, John?

SPEAKER_00So the first the first um I think landing of the Danes, I think was um off the south coast, and that was in the 780s, but it wasn't recorded in the same way as the most famous landing, which is 793, and that was on what is the holy island of Lindisfarne, off the the coast of what is modern-day Northumberland, but it was a pretty central point in the Kingdom of Northumbria, which at that point was where the main power was in uh in the island of Britain. Uh, the Kingdom of Northumbria was an early seat of Christendom, it had um some of the most important um writings that were read um across um Northern Europe um and uh made famous by the scholar the Venerable Bede, uh, who is a monk.

SPEAKER_00And he he wrote the first history of um of the English people, the ecclesiastical history of the English people. But he he wrote of the different peoples that populated the uh the isles. Um

SPEAKER_01five nations, yeah.

SPEAKER_00The the five nations, yes. Um but effectively what what he wrote about at that time was that there was this providential history of of the English peoples, um, and that they were destined to be one nation, and they would be one nation under the Christian God. And and actually, uh whilst people often talk about the English being these you know terrible, rapacious colonizers, which of course that there was definitely that those examples, it was also true that there was um there was actually some more benevolent exchange between the English and the surrounding peoples.

SPEAKER_00So the beat bead, for example, said the English should be forever indebted to the Irish, because the Irish, um referring to those on the the northwest coast of of the island of Hibernia, brought us Christianity. Uh, they ri they they brought us out of our pagan ways. Now, he knows that St. Augustine came from Rome to come and preach to the Kingdom of Kent um and to start converting down there, but it also came in the other direction. It was a very different kind of Christianity. Um, and so he said the English should be forever thankful to the Irish people for that that very thing.

SPEAKER_00Um, but anyway, it took a while uh in response to the the Danish uh who initially started to um to rape and to pillage their way in, they realized that actually this is a pretty peaceable society. Um they're not prepared for us, and it's so agriculturally rich. We're we're running out of of farm arable lands in you know cold uh Scandinavia. Let's go over here where farming is just absolutely brilliant, and we'll just you know, we'll just hack our way to supremacy. And so so the English-speaking peoples themselves look like they've been reduced to this this rump, they're basically on the way to just becoming this now outpost of of the the Norse and Danish peoples.

SPEAKER_00Um, and so it was it was the Kingdom of Wessex led by the great King Alfred, um, who who

SPEAKER_02so John, just just I just want to go back over a couple of points here, just because I I'm thinking about someone who might be watching or listening, some of the people we work with at the base who who will not know these dates. So just to kind of mark this clearly in people's heads, we're kind of we're talking about the English now, the English, the Anglo-Saxons, or this com this combination of tribes you've you've you've described in the sort of northern parts of Germany. Prior to that, you've got the the Britons or well, maybe what we might might might know of as Welsh and Cornish now. So this is but that's a you're you're saying that they they come over about about f 500 AD.

SPEAKER_02So about two about an one and a half thousand years ago, and they're sort of building up across what we we now think of as England, and then we've the Danes or the maybe the Vikings start to come in the late 700s.

SPEAKER_00Yep.

SPEAKER_02And then now we we're sort of Alfred is this kind of huge figure of English history, yes, maybe the first king. I know some people debate that, and we are now in 800s. I

SPEAKER_01think it's the 10th century, it's unified now.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So we we we end up as a unified nation in the 10th century. Um but um the uh the the the bat the great battle that Alfred had to fight uh against the great heathen army that was led by the warlords uh Guthrum, the Danish warlord Guthrum, was in it was in the late 800s. So um uh and also the the yeah, Battle of Eddington, um and that was because for decades after the those landings at Lindisfarne, because the Danes and the Norse kept on coming over, they'd established an area under their own laws, the Dane law, um, that didn't have Anglo-Saxon influence.

SPEAKER_00There were Anglo-Saxons that lived in it, but they they they led the way and uh and they'd brought their own language, they they worshipped the pagan gods still. Um, and so th Alfred's victory led to the turning of the tide. So Guthrum, having been defeated at the Battle of Eddington, um Alfred, instead of trying to vanquish them all, knew it wouldn't be totally possible, but did have the supremacy, said, if you're to stay, Guthrum, you're you're you need to convert, first of all, uh to the Christian God.

SPEAKER_00And secondly, all of those people that you have with you, they they don't they don't live under any other flag but this flag. Um, you know, this is what it's about. No, the St. George's flag wasn't around, but it was basically saying, You you're you you have to be part of this now. This is the that that's the rules. And basically that the England wasn't unified until his grandson Athelstan. So there were basically a couple of uh here's the House of Wessex over three generations of kings consolidated that victory at Eddington until effectively what they managed to get was fealty pledged to them by the other kings that were around England, uh or what became England, so English the English people, um, and say, look, we'll we'll give up being kings, and you are the one king.

SPEAKER_00And that that all happened um uh almost 1100 years ago. So next year is the 11th, 1100th anniversary of England, uh once Athelstan was actually recognised as King of the English, and that was uh that was in North West England that took place.

SPEAKER_01So so the thing that strikes me about that is that we have been a unified nation for 1100 years, which is almost unheard of. And and that's longer than any other European country.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Uh and partly because it's being an island as well. You know, those those borderlines, obviously they're internal things, but those borderlines are pretty pretty secure because they're literally geographical things. Um and so, yeah, that's that's very, very clarifying and and important to realise how how long we have been a unified nation for. But why why are we singularly uncomfortable and unable to think of ourselves as a unified nation or a continuous nation?

SPEAKER_01Because that's the paradox that you we sort of start that you kind of started with and that we're kind of exploring here. There seems to be something inherent in some ways in the English condition that's that's uncomfortable with an essentialist argument about our our identity, and yet we do have the longest continuous identity in Europe.

SPEAKER_00It's a great question. I I I think we didn't always have the identity crisis. Um what I mean by that is that it's very, very clear throughout history, effectively up until the Act of Union in 1707, um uh that which is when Britain became a unified polity between the Scottish and the English. That the Welsh had already been defeated and and had become a principality and and became part of England itself, um, though obviously maintained its distinct uh identity, and then that the unifying of uh Ireland came later on.

SPEAKER_00But James VI of Scotland, who became James I of England of the the House of Stuart, he he spoke about how um all the peoples of the Isles would be his wife. Uh was one of his speeches. He's basically saying, you know, I'm king of Britain and we are now one nation. But the English and the Scottish did not like this at all. The Scot the where where the in Edinburgh, where the um where the where the union was, where the union of the crowns, a 100 years-ish prior to the the act of political union in 1707, was signed with James VI and James I it had to be done in a really discreet location because only about one in ten Scots actually wanted this union.

SPEAKER_00They basically hated the English. Um uh and and that obviously still rears its head today, and there's always talk about the union. The English didn't really want it either. Um, the only it was only really the mercantile classes of the Scottish cities and the English cities that wanted it because they were sick of having to deal with the constant fighting, and they just wanted to like, could we just get law and order and all be part of the same union so we can trade freely? And in the end, actually, you know, the Scots accepted the union, and they even had place names showing up and street names showing up with various things that had uh a British civic identity, and the English did too, obviously.

SPEAKER_00But effectively, what I think happened at that point was the English subsumed themselves to the British identity, and as as I think you can see it in conversation with people, is like the English will often sub in I'm British, I'm British, I'm British, in a way that the Scottish and the Welsh uh and the Northern Irish, maybe less them, wouldn't. Um so I I think I think the I th but I think you were touching on it, uh Ollie, that there's perhaps something about the English character which makes us less essentialist.

SPEAKER_00So now that civic identity has kind of been established at the political level, and there's been centuries of that. Uh it's very hard to give up because of the way that we think.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Oh, and there's a different there's different ethnic identities related to class as well. Because you think of I I'm just thinking of school, lots of the English kids who were working class English kids, they would always identify themselves as English, right? We in my school was very multi-ethnic, and we spent all our time just basically cutting each other over our countries, right? You know, whatever it we know, but honestly, if you were like half Moroccan, half Spanish, half Welsh, it was English. The whole thing was we all knew exactly which country everyone's mums and dads were from, right?

SPEAKER_02But but the middle class English kids they don't express that. They've got there's a different identity attached to that Englishness there. So already we're in a complex area here, and then possibly like as you go up the class ladder, that it kind of flips around, and the higher class people do once again have

SPEAKER_00a

SPEAKER_02proud English identity. That's a simplification, but it's possible.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I do buy it. That's definitely true, our experience. Um, and I recognise that as well, that it is a kind of middle class. Maybe

SPEAKER_02I'm thinking Ollie more of a bohemian middle class in London, actually. So maybe that's slightly enough. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But I would throw in, I do think there is something um in English thinking that is suspicious of essentialism and that is suspicious of um that is suspicious of systems. Right. Um They that we we very much like the grand sis I was looking through like the history of English poetry and then looking at the there's quite a few grand system projects like Chaucer's Canterbury Tales and Wordsworth's The Prelude that remain unfinished.

SPEAKER_01And there's there is something uniquely English about that. Um Lord Salisbury says there is no way, there is no better way for a man to become a fool than by a system. And we've always had that kind of empirical distrust of this kind of grand design, and we we kind of prefer to like muddle through and and have a much more practical approach and sort of non-continental approach to these things. More more kind of, I suppose it would be more individualistic and more kind of character-based approach.

SPEAKER_01And I do think that that very strong strain of English thinking is has contributed to us being slightly uncomfortable with with defining ourselves.

SPEAKER_00Like

SPEAKER_01that, and also having the the power and dominance to not need to. Um, and and because being an island, you're not really kind of forced to, you know, the lines aren't being moved around all the time like they are in Europe in the 20th century. So I think Yeah, I do I do think the paradox like it goes quite deep, actually.

SPEAKER_02It does go deep, and isn't isn't that a middle class thing you're saying there, Ollie? Because it's so when you say uh even this the framing of our discussion here is is is actually quite middle class framing, most English working class people they wouldn't even be having this discussion, they know exactly who they are.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Do do you not think so?

SPEAKER_01I I mean I recognise that as um you know anecdotally true, but um yeah, you've got David Hume saying that in the whatever, the 18th century. Um you've got you know, so eve even someone like Chaucer is or even some of the Anglo-Saxon, they're they're not they're not fully English nationalistic in the way that we would imagine that they might be.

SPEAKER_01They they have a very there's a very like plural attitude to the world, I would say. Um if you take like someone like Chaucer, Dickens, Shakespeare, these kind of great English figures, they do have a very like plural way of looking at things and a kind of non-essentialist way of looking at things. So I think that strain is is is deep in our character as well. Um I mean maybe you could argue, and I've thought about this as certain times that it is part of the English character to actually pretend that we don't have a national character in order to like for political purposes, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I I I wonder if in some ways when you talk about the the national character question, all the points you just raised, Dolly, you can see how that becomes a topic of discussion. Well, how do you actually delineate that? What's the boundary? Whereas actually, Morgan, what you're talking about as well, is that for those the work for the working class English, and I suppose for for for most of us who've just grown up in you know normal places, um, and and um is that they also understand ethnic identity, right?

SPEAKER_00As you as you just talked about there, um Morgan, you went to a multi-ethnic school, you had English kids, and you had kids from everywhere all over the place, and you would have obviously had kids that were the result of mixed marriages and whatever. Um but everyone would have worn their identity. So um, yeah, there would have been some cross-pollination or whatever, but you would have the English would have known what team they were on. They would have known that who their ancestors were, the wars that were fought, and this, that, and the other, they would have known that part.

SPEAKER_00And then those who are from a different lineage would have known that wasn't necessarily their history. So I think there's some of those things that you're right, is that most people, um, particularly uh in kind of the non-middle classes, chattering classes, will just know who they are. They don't really need to have the chat about national character. But part of the reason why we do it or why we're doing it is because those who are running our educational institutions, they're running our media institutions, they will not only say that the English ethnic identity as a construction doesn't exist, but they'll say that we don't have a character either.

SPEAKER_00When both of those things are untrue, even if the character question itself is more of a moving target in some way, because of that non-essentialist um streak, which, as you've pointed out, Ollie, as someone who's been a literary scholar, it seems to show up throughout history. But the ethnic identity people just know it's there uh intrinsically, unless you've been conditioned to say that it's not.

SPEAKER_01Or it's one of these things that when you're forced to define it, it is it is very, very difficult to define, right? You would uh uh you're saying the working class kind of they just know it. And I feel like the kind of continuity of identity that we're talking about is something that is felt and known rather than intellectualized. As soon as you start to intellectualize it, it runs into potential difficulties.

SPEAKER_02Well, yeah, and we're sort of here we are intellectualizing it in a podcast. So we sort of Well, my

SPEAKER_01attempt would be to find an intellectual ballast to it.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, it's it's good. It's it's it's challenging, actually, it's challenging stuff, isn't it, as you start to think about it. I I think one of the reasons I have been uh defensive or in in my heart defensive over the the working class English is because they were the people who were having to integrate with other ethnic groups more than other other uh parts of the class structure. And they were the ones who were struggling with it. Also, by the way, mixing with it more, you know, because there'd be many sort of mixed marriages, mixed children in those in those communities, middle class tended to stay white, right?

SPEAKER_02And yet they so they were kind of, they would, they were given all of this, they didn't have a say over it, then they're called racist if they say, I don't quite like this, or if they, you

unknownknow,

SPEAKER_02you

unknownknow,

SPEAKER_02you go to Dagenham, that woman who said my high streets changed, and she basically got told off by the the Labour politician or whatever it was. They've had to deal with these problems, and they've actually lived amongst these people and generally probably get on better with them, and yet have been called you know, racist, this and that. And I feel very I just think that's just wrong.

SPEAKER_01I could completely I completely agree. And I suppose what we're trying to do is to fashion an a kind of new elite that are able to give ballast to her instinctive that that that woman's instinctive position.

SPEAKER_02Yes, yes, yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01We are a continuous people.

SPEAKER_02No bless or blige a bit, isn't it? You know, I mean but it's slightly kind of maybe promoting ourselves to some. Yeah, yeah, yeah. That

SPEAKER_01might be a bit aggrandizing for

SPEAKER_02sure.

SPEAKER_01But

SPEAKER_02if some but there is something. But if the people will it,

SPEAKER_00if the people will it, then who are we to deny

SPEAKER_02them? Just to say if we get

SPEAKER_01over a thousand likes, that's uh that's a mad.

SPEAKER_02Well, no, it's true. But no, but it is something like no bless or bleach. It's a sense of we understand there's a class structure, we understand there's differences here, and we might have different tastes, and there might be some vulgarity to these tastes, and some over, you know, I get that, and we can critique the English working class. I'm up for doing that as well, right? I'm up for kind of going at everyone and myself here in this in this. I really I think we should. I think this is interesting stuff, but I think that sense of but we are that there's a no some sort of English noblesse the police where you have an uh an obligation to the country, even understanding its complexities and the differences.

SPEAKER_02And that is what I'm railing against, is going, even even though I might not feel like my mates who are white working English class people, I wasn't the same as them in some ways. I was half Welsh, my mum's from the her father was in the navy, you know, is it a different kind of backgrounds, right? But I still felt I still felt this, I've always had the sense that I do love this country and I love these people. It's it's yeah. So

SPEAKER_01the reason that the reason those people are getting buggered, excuse me, pardon my French or Norman French, um, is because of uh because of an elite uh that has been uh that has uh malicious intents or has been badly educated or is or is uh stupidly ideological, right? So we have to create a new elite, which is kind of what we're trying to do, um, or put um intellectual or ideological pressure into the mix.

SPEAKER_00To

SPEAKER_01try and to try and r reinstate that noblesse bleach.

SPEAKER_02Yes, indeed.

SPEAKER_00As you were talking there about how hard it is to essentialize the character and the civilization, and um it is also true that even those people who are sure of the identity will end up betraying that English mindset you talked about, Ollie, of that empirical mindset. And I've got a quote here from Orwell. Um George Orwell, he wrote a pamphlet called The Lion and the Unicorn. And uh there's a great um there's a great quote here.

SPEAKER_00Oh, you're getting it out yourself, we'll show that on screen.

SPEAKER_02Great book.

SPEAKER_00It is a great book. The the quote is Yes, there is something distinctive and recognizable in English civilization. It is a culture as individual as that of Spain. It is somehow bound up with solid breakfasts and gloomy Sundays, smoky towns and winding roads, green fields and red pillar boxes. It has a flavour of its own. Moreover, it is continuous. It stretches into the future and the past. There is something in it that persists, as in a living creature.

SPEAKER_00What can the England of nineteen forty have in common with the England of eighteen forty? But then what have you in common with the child of five whose photograph your mother keeps on the mantelpiece? Nothing except that you happen to be the same person. And above all, it is your civilization. It is you. However much you hate it or laugh at it, you will never be happy away from it for any length of time. The suet puddings and the red pillar boxes have entered into your soul, good or evil, it is yours.

SPEAKER_00You belong to it, and this side of the grave, you will never get away from the marks that is left upon you. I I think we can recognise that some of the things like suet puddings may have gone out of fashion, though I still am into the jam rolly-polies for sure. But but but it it but but that does ring true. It's something that you can you can you can feel and you can kind of sense just from your own experience, which again is seems to be a very English philosophy. And and there's almost nothing systematising about that, like those foolhardy French that we've uh fought so so often.

SPEAKER_00And it's true, there is a total difference in the English philosophical approach to life, whether it's on the street or in the elite, compared to the continentals who've who have tended to systematise.

SPEAKER_02And w when we get this all sorted, we we we will invade France again. But

SPEAKER_00yeah.

SPEAKER_01It will happen.

SPEAKER_02I just

SPEAKER_00I do hope so.

SPEAKER_01To push back on Orwell there, um that's deliberately a non-ethnic definition of Englishness. Right. That's the as you say, experiential idea.

SPEAKER_02He doesn't need to do it at this point, does he?

SPEAKER_01Probably no, probably not. He's right that 1940, I think, isn't it?

SPEAKER_02It's like br i England is 99.9% white at this point.

SPEAKER_01But the the the the potential downfall of that is that you can use exactly what Orwell said and say that somebody from a totally different ethnicity could grow up in England and be and have everything that Orwell describes there.

SPEAKER_00Perhaps. Although you could you could argue there is an implicit suggesti uh suggestion of a continuity of a people, because he uses the metaphor of you as the child of five on the mantelpiece, and then he uses the metaphor of what can the England of 1940 have in common with 1840, uh basically saying there is a continuity, you're the same person. And I think within that it is implied that whilst he wouldn't say it himself, um is that that means we do just go all the way back, and to go all the way back, you need to be part of the chain.

SPEAKER_00Um but but yes, at that point, he doesn't probably need to make it any more explicit because of where of of where he is, you know, demographics, um but at that but at that point England is bent on modernisation as well, and it is losing a sense of itself, and writers are writing about that saying, Oh, for this great rush toward progress, and we're gonna lose all the stuff that we love about the country, and he's he's going against it in some way.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. It is complex here. So to go back on my earlier point, if you you think of someone who's come here and is completely assimilated and is kind of very well spoken, very charming, and then you see like a uh who isn't white, let's just say, and then you see a crackhead on the corner who's you know on smack, stealing things, nicking your Amazon deliveries from your door, and and you and you do think you are challenged to say, oh, but this person's English, this crackhead's English, and this kind of completely assimilated English anglophile loving kind of character is not.

SPEAKER_02That is complex. And I I I think the problem is when you have a hundred people and you take five people into that a hundred, right? Add five hundred or add five on to a hundred, you can assimilate people, right? And and the reason this debate has become so intense now is because they have just been piling in people without any kind of plan at all at all. No plan at all. They don't even have the Blairite plan anyway, that sense of like Britishness, that is even gone now.

SPEAKER_02It's just they're hanging on to sort of hangover of Blair Blair Blair's Blair's ideas, but they don't, they're not convincing in it. And and then they're just piling in the numbers, piling in the numbers, piling in the numbers, no assimilation plan, and it's it's chaos. And you look at it and it's it's sort of terror. Um but I but I I do think there is probably like an argument to say when you when you're assimilating small amounts of people, you can assimilate people into a culture and no one really cares.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely.

SPEAKER_00I I think it also depends on who it is that's arriving and the culture from which they arrive and their own circumstances. Because again, in many ways, the mass migration thing, whilst it's being so unbelievably loose, it's also so you could broadly say kind of uh non-systematic, that seems to be a very English thing, but at the same token, it's been systematic in just importation of people because people are just fungible units of production and it kind of doesn't really matter, and we can maybe just get as long as people broadly go by fair play intolerance, then we'll be alright.

SPEAKER_00Um, but but interestingly, I think the the other thing about the English and even just the British peoples more broadly is that it has been remarked upon throughout history, uh, merchants from Venice in the the um not not long uh into the 1400s that uh and even people earlier than that, and uh that the the British peoples are a friendly people. The English people are friendly people because they're an island nation and they they've always had this commercial contact, and so they're kind of free and easy, they can be outward looking.

SPEAKER_00Um and so probably why England has managed to actually go along with this for so long, because there is actually just a you know a sense of uh of trust and transactional way of doing business, and that actually if people just play by the rules would be okay. Um but I've also got an example within my own family of someone who is from um you know subcontinental India, but a totally different part of the rest of India. So, you know, Gowan, Catholic, lots of experience, outward-looking, effectively um uh seafaring, island-style people in many ways, um, lots of commercial context, had been Europeanized centuries before, and also had the same root faith as the Latin West, um, and was also someone who was the son of a civil servant in the British Empire in East Africa and had worked amongst the British, believed in the British Empire, liked the British people, and when you look at the race of assimilation amongst the Goans, they literally all married into the tribes of the island, so to speak.

SPEAKER_00Whereas lots of other peoples from the subcontinent are just more clannish, both through their um religions and just their own their own tribal natures. So there's just much less osmosis going on between them when they come over in diasporas, and so they just maintain the ways of back home uh in a way that others don't. And so, yeah, I think yes, small numbers can be assimilated because but but it also depends on the mindset of the person arriving and their own historical context, because to think, again, that small numbers might always assimilate, not always true.

SPEAKER_00I mean, look at Roman Egypties, for example, and have been in the on the streets of Europe for like a thousand odd years and have not assimilated in any way, shape, or form. Um so so I think that's that that's that's the other that's the other thing to think about.

SPEAKER_02Very, very based, very based, John. Um

SPEAKER_01you're saying about the the the friendliness, I suppose that's what I was sort of getting at with the you know, to look at Chaucer, Shakespeare, and Dickens as these big, big figures from medieval, early modern, nineteenth century. Um they do have like they are very tolerant writers, right? They are they are really open, they like to, they don't judge, they see, they don't it's very difficult to work out what their opinions are. They have that very wide panoptic view um of of the whole of humanity.

SPEAKER_01And so that is a strain of of the English system as well, I think. Uh not the English system, but there's uh that that is a strain of the English view of the world, as you say, like uh open and and transactional, but you know, we're now in a situation where that is being very, very challenged and and threatened. Um just just on assimilation as well, from a linguistic point of view, when I was researching for this, I was I was struck and surprised by how um there are very, very strong linguistic arguments that um Anglo-Saxon as a language would have developed in exactly the same way it did with or without Norman French influence.

SPEAKER_01Um that's the kind of uh there's a scholar called R. W. Birchfield, who wrote his book The English Language, which which argues precisely this that there is supreme continuity with Anglo-Saxon, and even though the Norman French come over and occupy elite positions for literally hundreds of years, it doesn't actually have much effect on the language as of as a core language. We we uh the Anglo-Saxon language essentially incorporates Latin French romance words, but actually it doesn't affect the structure of the language, which uh uh uh helps us kind of argue this this continuity for eleven thousand years argument, right?

SPEAKER_01Even even longer than that, like back to fourth century. Um, that that our language is still structurally Anglo-Saxon. I'm not sure of the latest scholarly debate on that, but I know that that that has been a r recently um and strongly argued.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, but very interesting. Also, I I I I don't want to come across as like woke or I'm not obviously at all, right?

SPEAKER_01Definitely not.

SPEAKER_02Uh

SPEAKER_00explain that pink hair then, Morgan.

SPEAKER_02But I'm I'm also interested in trying here in this kind of journey to be honest and and and look at the complexities, and I think try and be open and say, well, this is this that isn't that simple, that bit.

SPEAKER_00Yeah,

SPEAKER_01I think it's important and important to to to tackle that. And that's the virtue of tackling McVal and Hume like head on.

SPEAKER_00I I um I th just because you brought it up, I think we should perhaps talk a little bit about the language and and you know the Norman invasion, 1066, successful conquest. You then effectively had a French-speaking, Latin documenting elite for the best part of three centuries before they themselves adopted the English language as the language of government. And Geoffrey Chaucer was really the first the first person to bring this newly modified English with some of these loan words from Norman French and and Latin into it and turn it into a literary language, and effectively set in train the English fying of government once more, after having the Norman yoke be, you know, nothing but really a Norman yoke, just this this imposition on top of um what were the English people.

SPEAKER_00Um not just the English people, I suppose the English people plus the Danes who had arrived and who had briefly for a time also held the throne here and subsumed England into a kind of North Sea Empire, or a kind of day North Danish Empire, uh linked to to Denmark and modern-day Norway and what have you, before the Normans came and and took over.

SPEAKER_02And and John, just to be very basic, I do I promise you I do know some of this history, but I just want to go over it in case that people don't. There's some bits I won't know, and I'll be honest about that. But the the Nor Normans, 1066, is the date that everyone can remember. There's William the Conqueror comes in,

SPEAKER_00yeah,

SPEAKER_02and lots of our kind of rulers that we have, it will start, you know, the the the king, the monarchy, the monarch's rulers, they will tend to start from William the Conqueror. And I think it's quite an interesting distinction, actually, because there's something more potent before that in terms of this English question, I think, actually, that you've been going through in your brilliant uh history early on. And just worth noting that that we sort of almost I I think lots of people th think of the beginning of this country's kind of uh hi history in some ways, some people think of 1066, because they know the kings from there on in.

SPEAKER_00But I

SPEAKER_02think when you go back to Alfred and you start going through all of that stuff, you get really into the kind of the f the flesh and bones of of the English story.

SPEAKER_01Well, I I didn't realise, again, doing research for this, how um like the Anglo-Saxons were culturally much superior to the Norman French.

SPEAKER_02Were they?

SPEAKER_01Well, it's widely accepted. Um dispute in the in the comments, but they were much more culturally advanced and no less a figure than Wittgenstein. I teased you with the Wittgenstein quote before we started recording. Um Wittgenstein said uh a famous quote of Wittgenstein, William the Conqueror got himself a very good bargain because the Anglo-Saxons were were superior.

SPEAKER_02Ah, I didn't know that. I always thought the Normans were slightly posher because the Norman surnames are much posher, aren't they? Like Granville and and uh as opposed to Smith.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well they they basically they themselves were though this has been come under debate recently, but let's not go there right now. It is broadly accepted that the Normans are effectively a Scandinavian and a Norse people. So they uh similar to what happened when there was the conquest here in England, similar uh uh conquests of the Nort men were taking place on continental Europe and beyond. And the Parisians, the Franks, were just absolutely sick of these Northmen um coming and bombarding Paris.

SPEAKER_00So they said, you know what, go and have your own douche over here. You you can be a Duke Rollo, he was called Groulf, and off he went in what is now Normandy, uh, because it was the for the Northmen, they the Normans came from the Northmen, but within a matter of three generations, they'd become utterly Frenchified. Uh, they'd basically given up, apart from their marital rituals, um, and there were one or two other cultural um artifacts of where they came from that they kept, they just went all in on the Frenchification of society.

SPEAKER_00And so they just you know gave up their native language and uh took on the kind of the Franks finery and way of um uh the kind of monarchical approach to things. Um so yes, uh then they they uh in many ways you could see that the the impact of the North men on England has been huge, right? From the Dane law, which was successfully repelled for a while before then used you ended up with chaps from that part of the world becoming the kings, um, like King Canute, for example, was one of the he was the first Danish king of England.

SPEAKER_00So even having gotten rid of the Dane law, the Danes still ended up with their hand their hands on the levers of power, um, even if they weren't a demographic majority in the nation. Um and then it happened again under the Normans, but they were just, you know, Scandinavians speaking French, really.

SPEAKER_01And those Normans they kept elite positions for for a long time, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I can't remember exactly what date it was, but was it which which which Henry was it that was the first to actually speak English as his mother tongue? I I can't

SPEAKER_02know that, but I don't

SPEAKER_01know. I don't know. Um

SPEAKER_00Well Henry

SPEAKER_02II.

SPEAKER_00I think you might be right with Henry II. And

SPEAKER_02Henry II is the one who k who has who kills um Thomas Beckett. Thomas Beckett, which I went to see the play recently, The Murder in the Cathedral. With David Suchet playing Thomas Beckett.

SPEAKER_01He was

SPEAKER_02very good.

SPEAKER_01He

SPEAKER_02was very good.

SPEAKER_00Um

SPEAKER_01you'd have a couple of centuries after that where there's not much literature written in English because um Yeah,

SPEAKER_00it was a linguistic apartheid, basically. Um so so yes, um Henry the Fourth, Henry Bolingbrook, first plantagenic king to speak English as his native language. So that was in that was in four that was he reigned from thirteen ninety-nine to fourteen thirteen. So basically from ten sixty-six for three hundred and thirty-three years, not a single king spoke English as their uh as their the normal daily language.

SPEAKER_01Interesting. But he is such a key figure for for Shakespeare as well in the history plays.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, because he's when

SPEAKER_01he starts with Richard the second way starts with um King John earlier, but then then there's a gap, and then uh he his history plays chronologically would start with like Richard the Second and then Henry Bolinbrook, Henry the Fifth, Henry the Sixth, and Henry the Eighth.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, but yeah, King John's uh uh w would what about 12-1215.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Th this might be just some some trivia, but I actually think it's quite uh important because it it laps on maps onto the the class conversation we've had, which I think really came out of what was inter-ethnic rivalry um in those few centuries after the conquest. So um in in the English language, the words we use for um animals and their meat are split basically between English and Norman French. So cow, sheep, and pig were all derived from the Anglo-Saxon words, whereas beef, mutton, and pork, you know, the meat that has been slaughtered and then prepared and ready on a plate to be eaten by the lords in the manors um use that language themselves.

SPEAKER_00Yes, I'll have beef and mutton and pork, please, because it was for them. Whereas it was the farmers who were the Saxons ultimately. And what's quite interesting, you can see this drawn out by a Scott, Walter Scott, um, in Ivanhoe, one of his great um his his great works. And uh I will I'll I'll I'll do a poor Lowland Scott accent just for the the fun of it, whilst I read this out. Swine is good Saxon, said the Jester. I'm making him sound like a Glaswegian, but I'll go with it.

SPEAKER_01He's

SPEAKER_02a Ouija.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's a Ouija. Um Swine is good Saxon, said the Jester. But how call you the sow when she is flayed and drawn and quartered and hung up by the heels like a traitor? Pork, answered the swineherd. I'm very glad every fool knows that too, said Wamba, and Pork, I think, is good Norman French. And so when the brute lives and is in the charge of a Saxon slave, she goes by her Saxon name, but becomes a Norman and is called Pork when she is carried to the castle hall to feast among the nobles.

SPEAKER_00What dost thou think of this friend Gerth? Huh? Thank you.

SPEAKER_02You should have gone for Arder.

SPEAKER_00Just to protect myself from any rabid Scotsman in the comments, just so you know I'm quarter Scots, my dad is half Scots, I'm uh, you know, proud of it too, so um this was not mockery. That was that was um that was actually cultural appropriation of the most flattering kind.

SPEAKER_02We've got it covered, haven't we, everywhere. I I said to a student the other day, I said, I I blame my Welsh side on like my lack when I sometimes things I struggle to put timings together, right? And she got really offended because she was Welsh. And I said, I can I can say this because I'm half Welsh, but she still wasn't she didn't she didn't take it, which is quite a Welsh thing to do, to to continue being offended, you know, that sort of which I also have. I also have that kind of passion uh we've

SPEAKER_01actually all we're all uh uh part English and part region.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_01Like all of us, part English, part Welsh, uh John, part English, part Scottish, and me, part English, part Northern Irish. So we've got we've got the whole United Kingdom government.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I would be keen. I never do.

SPEAKER_01Some of the key uh English figures are that actually.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_01Northern Irish and English, like so so many of the of the most English kind of people are uh are a combination of of those two temperaments. C. S Lewis talks about this in his autobiography, actually, surprised by joy. He says, I have this kind of Northern Irish uh Celtic uh blood in me, I can feel that very emotional. Side and I can feel a more English rational empirical side as well. And I'm a product of the two things. And yeah, I do think you get the most sort of quintessential English people in history are a combination of those two things.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's exactly that. You feel this mix. Even King Arthur, it seems to be sort of this character that they battle people battle over where he's where he's from. Is it is he sort of West Country, Cornwall? Is he Welsh? I'd have to say he's definitely Welsh. You know, uh yeah. Uh the that's because I f I I I follow these books by Alan Wilson, but I won't get into that. And then um Henry VII, who comes in in the late uh 1400s, he is very much kind of interested in this kind of idea of unifying England and Wales, and he calls his first son Arthur, in in kind of and in in that's this idea of Arthur almost being this kind of figure of unifying the very thing you're talking about, Ollie.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And I think hen another Henry, Henry V is a key figure here, which kind of brings in a lot of different aspects of the conversation because it brings in Shakespeare as well. The way that Shakespeare portrays Henry V and the Battle of Ashincourt. Um for this English expedition, the the regions are necessary, right? And if people know the play, they'll know there's this subplot with uh Flew Ellen, the Welsh character, um another character's name I can't remember at the moment, is Irish. Um

SPEAKER_00Mac Morris is the Irishman,

SPEAKER_01uh

SPEAKER_00and Jamie is the Scotsman, and Gower is the Englishman.

SPEAKER_01And there's another Englishman, Pistol, who's actually quite nasty, and he's uh Pistol is bullying Flew Ellen, the the Welsh character, and they they have a fight, and but you see them, Shakespeare portrays it the moment of battle. Through this military campaign, all those forces are united by the again empirical, rational, um, almost Machiavellian, who's known

unknownas

SPEAKER_01like the white Machiavelli, like the good Machiavellian character of Henry V himself. Um he he is standing there together as the sovereign with uh who's able to utilize the the the regions basically and use their different characteristics. He uses the Welsh's stubbornness, uses the the the the Irish um you know uh uh passion or whatever. Like um so yeah, that's that that's a kind of defining English feature.

SPEAKER_02I I I agree, but I can I can also hear like an Anglo-Saxon purist at this point not not enjoying this, it almost sounds like a bit of a work discussion. It is actually a mixture of all these things, and uh it I it is right, but then I can uh I'm happy also to kind of take the separation as well to say I I think really the problems we're in really really and truly everyone is gonna have to work together. So

SPEAKER_01I

SPEAKER_02don't I don't think if if you want to deport me to Wales, uh I'll I'll I'll go actually because I've got to

SPEAKER_00be.

SPEAKER_02back over

SPEAKER_00Offers Dyke. That's what we dug it up.

SPEAKER_01But we need you for the future Battle of Ashencourt. That's what Shakespeare is is giving us. Come back for

SPEAKER_02that. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Get it Seth Ford and we'll we'll we'll we'll sail down to

SPEAKER_00for those who don't get that reference and why that was pointed at Morgan specifically. Uh I'll include a link in the show notes here to Morgan delivering many of the famous lines from Henry V and incredibly passionately. And actually, we should I I want to reverse back to the bit about the the the the differences in the national temperament of those people of the home nations, the English, the Welsh, Scots, the Irish, because we talked about ourselves when the three of us together in London about six weeks ago, where and you could see it, you could see you could basically see it.

SPEAKER_00We we spoke about the the the the Donish um Englishman, which Ollie was basically being that archetype, and then the passionate Welshman of Morgan who who um was was finding um sticks to go running after and was like, yeah, like this is really doing my head in, and and you know, just spoke from the heart. And um, I I found that quite interesting that uh we were displaying some of those national characters.

SPEAKER_02But

SPEAKER_00uh one thing I do want to throw a bone out to uh postmodernists and and and woke people in some ways, because but at the same token it also bolsters the separation, is that I think it is true that you can so you can both draw boundaries around your identity. So whilst each one of us has the genetic influence, like Morgan's half Welsh, I'm quarter Scottish, very, very, very proudly derived from the people who were from basically the northwest of Ireland who ended up colonising and creating a kingdom of Dalreata, which straddled the Western Isles, so like Mole and Iona and then South West Scotland, its own very influential kingdom, um Iona at the centre, which actually had a transplant of a monastery over into the Kingdom of Northumbria, which made that part of England very Christian, the same one I was talking about earlier.

SPEAKER_00Well, it was it was pre-England, but it brought the religion to the English. I'm very proudly part of that people. But at the same token, when it comes to boundaries, I sit behind the English boundary. A Scotsman is not going to accept me as a Scotsman. It doesn't matter that my name should be Scottish, um, they're not going to accept me as one. And I couldn't see myself as one because I I conduct myself like an Englishman. Though I do say, as someone who's grown up in the northeast of England, not far from the border with Scotland, is I've whilst I've always spotted the difference between me and the Scotsman, even if they're lowland Scots from 30 miles away over the border, I've always felt more culturally aligned with them than people from Southeast England.

SPEAKER_01I I sort of

SPEAKER_00I

SPEAKER_01sort of felt that. Well, I feel like what it in bearing our kind of um regional credentials, are we not kind of No, are we not sort of falling? Because I remember at school it was like you weren't cool unless you were beefing up your I would sort of increase. Maybe I'm not even a quarter northern eye, maybe a half if I want to seem really cool, right? Um and that was such a thing at school. And even now I can feel it, you want to make yourself interesting, you sort of dial up one's regional credentials. But why is that? Like, why isn't it enough to say, like, oh no, I'm English?

SPEAKER_01Like this we need to kind of re-enchant that sense of Englishness, so that is as as cool as having a having a Celtic and regional side.

SPEAKER_02I think I think we we should. And I I listen, I will also say my mum is English, right? And she is incredibly passionate and emotional as a character. So I think we've sort of stereotyped the English as being a bit too empirical and sensible here. And I think there are, and I've just to to put up a relatively controversial order author, I think, is the Ernst Junge, the Storm of Steel, right? Which the but he says in this, and he's talking about World War I, he says, of all the troops who were opposed to the Germans on the great battlefields, the English were not only the most formidable, but the manliest and the most chivalrous.

SPEAKER_02And I I just I just love that description. It's very moving because I unfortunately our elites and the regime, all the people they present to you are pathetic, right? All of the men, and I think a lot of these men that he's talking about, I think they were killed in World War I and World War II, right? So I think that's a genuine problem. But actually, I want to I want to encourage the strength in English people again and make that part of the identity. Because if you think of all the big media figures on the podcasts and the you know the just I'm not gonna say names, but just think of the really successful politics and entertainment podcasts, I think of all the TV, the BBC shows, just think of all those people.

SPEAKER_02They're pathetic, they're weak, weak men. And they are kind of emboldening a sense of kind of patheticness, with which is almost oxymoronic in some ways, but they are within the English people,

SPEAKER_00and

SPEAKER_02I hate that. I hate when I see um people talk about how pathetic they are. Uh I really don't like it when like dads say, Oh, I can only do one press up. I think, come on, man. You know,

SPEAKER_01so

SPEAKER_02is that Welsh or is that English? You know, am I being Welsh or English?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's not that's that's not that that's like

SPEAKER_00it is. And there's

SPEAKER_01people I went to univers, I always say this, but the people I went to university with, they gave up on life 15 years ago and just consented to being pathetic. And men are really scared, like Englishmen are really, really scared to assert themselves now. I was with some uh you know, a bunch of actors the other day, and I was like, God, you guys are terrified of saying anything

SPEAKER_00for

SPEAKER_01fear of I don't know, whatever. And yeah, the that that is not English. That is not English. We have always been an anarchic and a and a boisterous, if melancholy, occasionally people.

SPEAKER_00And totally

SPEAKER_02tough, tough people.

SPEAKER_00The the well, and that uh so you made a very good point, a good pushback, Morgan, and actually it was something that I clocked as we were preparing for this, is there was something in my mind about how the Englishman had actually changed through the ages. So the one that we see today, and which Ollie and I began by presenting as, which is you know the Donish empirical type stiff upper lip, is that actually hasn't always been the case, and literature shows that. So the medieval Englishman was known across Europe for being passionate, fiery, uproarious, and that's total opposite to the stiff upper lip.

SPEAKER_00And you can see this in two that I pulled out two examples, one from Henry IV, um, Shakespeare, and the other from a poem by Rudyard Kipling titled If. And and whilst the archetype of the Englishman is clearly changed here, is what they both carry is the passionate intense well, an intensity and a toughness that you were just talking about, Morgan. So, first, this is this is hot spur, Henry the IV. By heaven, methinks it were an easy leap to pluck bright honour from the pale-faced moon, or dive into the bottom of the deep where fathom line could never touch the ground, and pluck up, drowned, honoured by the locks, so he that doth redeem her thence might wear without Corval all her dignities.

SPEAKER_00So that's about the passionate side. And then Rudyard Kipling uh this is the kind of British imperial side. If you can keep your head when all about you are losing theirs and blaming it on you, if you can trust yourself when all men doubt you, but make allowance for their doubting too, if you can wait and not be tired by waiting or being lied about, don't deal in lies, or being hated, don't give way to hating, and yet don't look too good, nor talk too wise. Both of those are about some kind of resolve in many ways, one passionate and one stiff upper lip,

SPEAKER_01but

SPEAKER_00the resolution's there. And I think you're right, Ollie, is actually when you look around and and Morgan, when you look around the modern nation, uh there are far too many who are supine now.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Just to be fair to all i i everyone, or just to be honest, I think there's an emasculation everywhere, like in so many Western countries. So I think this probably isn't just a strictly English problem. It's definitely connected to the kind of the destruction of the English identity.

SPEAKER_00But

SPEAKER_02you you probably get these you do. We know you get these similar characters in in Ireland, in Scotland, in France, in Spain. You you we might call them cucks, you know, that's the kind of that's the modern cultural term for them. But there is the sort of cuckification of of men uh spiritually, uh, you know, there is everywhere. And we and and when you said we need to we we can't have that, we're not gonna survive with that.

SPEAKER_01And if we yeah, if you look if you look at it from a literature point, I'd say you probably could find, yeah, you're always gonna find evidence that they would stiff up a lip before uh before Kipling and and and all of that, right? Um but there is a there is a sense of strong resolve. I mean Hotspur, who you quoted, is a notorious he's a hothead. That's that's the point of him. Um but

SPEAKER_00good Northumbrian man. Good Northumbrian man.

SPEAKER_01Um I mean supposedly the answer to where the stiffer pilip came from, I don't know if this is just like comic book history, but supposedly it's the French Revolution. It's like the English seeing the excesses of the French Revolution um and and um that coming out of romanticism, the age of sensibility, as Jane Austen calls it, sense and sensibility, and a very a very emotional kind of movement. Um, you know, Wordsworth and Coleridge were obsessed with the French Revolution, had had high hopes for it.

SPEAKER_01Uh seeing what happened with that and the English reaction to, oh, we're going to actually take the Duke of Wellington route,

SPEAKER_00um,

SPEAKER_01and and that supposedly spread. That I've always heard that that was the origin story of the stiff upper lip. I'm sure that is debated. Um but yeah, I mean, even in in Shakespeare's time, I think it's true that um the English were regarded as quite demonstrative and and very open and hearty and um physically demonstrative in the way that we might think that the Italians are physically demonstrative now. Um so yeah, there definitely has been a slow, a slow cucking uh of the Englishman.

SPEAKER_01And it's if you look at um the change in how I've

SPEAKER_02lowered both of you, I've I've dragged you into low-level cultural chat, haven't I, Lan? No, but you look

SPEAKER_01at the way scholars use it. You mentioned Donish, right? If you compare this a scholar like uh Dr. Faustus in both the Marlet play and the Goethe play, the scholar is viewed as a really dangerous, vital, almost uh satanic kind of figure.

SPEAKER_00Um

SPEAKER_01and then you look at how scholars are treated in a 19th-century novel, like Middlemarch or something, as like a sexless, boring, dead kind of figure. Um that that is a huge change. And and yeah, I don't I I I don't know enough to to track that kind of change.

SPEAKER_00But

SPEAKER_01both the Englishman and the scholar have been sort of denuded from the from the 16th century to the 19th.

SPEAKER_00Well, I I think we go with the blame on the French answer, personally. What more what more English answer could we come up with? So it feels feels convincing to me. Um although uh just as a as an aside, so the romantic period's quite interesting insofar as yeah, it's a couple of centuries on from um two and a half centuries on from the reformation. And uh Ian McGillchrist, who I know you've interviewed uh as well as I have, author of The Master and His Emissary and The Matter with Things.

SPEAKER_00Um has uh a section really uh uh within one of his big chapters in The Master and His Emissary, where he talks about the Reformation, its impacts, but the response to it in culture. And his by his telling the romantic period, uh besides being a reaction to the French Revolution, which as you say, some of the romantics had high hopes, and then they were, they were, they were shattered, and so they actually just became more rooted in their own national identity, um, uh, and uh, and also a more a prelapsarian world that they were looking at really um uh or hoping to bring into being because they thought things were being lost in this kind of this world, is McGilchrist's telling was they were actually yearning after the the the Catholic worldview, which used to be so prevalent, and indeed was prevalent right through even the Shakespeare period, even though even though England and Scotland were becoming Protestant by this point, is that there was a folk memory of what that world was once like.

SPEAKER_00And indeed, they all still lived under the same assumptions in many ways. It was just they're starting to identify differently, and there was these that there was there was effectively a civil war had been brewing and and and what have you. Um so it's quite interesting that our identity, it's influenced um by even events that have been in the days gone by. So so besides you know external forces like the Danes invading or the French having a revolution, it's also the things that people have fought and died over and lost battles on, ideological and otherwise, centuries before.

SPEAKER_00And I suppose in many ways, is this not even what we're trying to do? We're trying we're looking at the echoes of the past to try to restore something because we think something's been lost.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely.

SPEAKER_02I think just to say that even on this sort of on this episode, just going through all these figures and these characters and these moments in history, and it it's it's unbelievably rich and brilliant history, and there's just so many characters. So the idea that this doesn't exist is just beyond absurd. It it exists more than any, as Ollie said earlier on, it exists more than any other history of any other place, anywhere ever in the history of human existence, which is all that we know.

SPEAKER_02And I think the simple study of history for people is a really powerful way to sort of actually bring up morale and just bring people together again around some sense of who they are, because it you should you should go away, or you should be following this episode with your ruler out, you know, your king's ruler, or your books, or something, and or just just look into it, look into the history. Lots of people listening to the show might well know all this stuff, John, particularly your side of the audience. But if I'm thinking about some of the younger students that me and Ollie encounter and work with, you know, that would be one of my big bits of advice is is just get go uh go through the history, just uh just look through the things that John's mentioning, look into the Anglo-Saxons, the the Vikings, the Normans, the Kings we're talking about.

SPEAKER_02Just start to get that in your head. And that will that will start to concretize an identity.

SPEAKER_00Go on, Ollie.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, just when you were you were talking about the in a way the disenchantment of Protestantism. And um I think that I think that is important because there is something more enchanting about the Catholic worldview in some way, more magical, right? Um and then perhaps there's something even more or equally as enchanting about a pre-Christian pagan worldview as well. And I think that this is a this is a strong strain of of English literature and history actually.

SPEAKER_01Um this um in a way, kind of shedding of this previous more enchanting thing. This is this is quite speculative, right? But I again to go back to Henry V, the more the more I think about it is quite such a pivotal English figure. And if people know the Henry the Fourth Shakespeare plays, you've got um Henry V as a young man, and he's a very, very um dissolute character. He's just like drinking in bars and hanging out with this character Falstaff, who's a much more enchanting, a very emblematic English character, right?

SPEAKER_01Hard drinking, uh vaguely criminal, um, disreputable knight, right? Um and Henry the Fourth, uh sorry, Henry the Henry V has to get rid of that of that character in order to go go forward and become Henry V. So in my again, a slight flight of fancy from me, but there's some sort of strain that comes back in English literature, the shedding of the more enchanting sort of pagan past. Um I I think we see we can see this strain like recurring in English literature.

SPEAKER_01You see the the key figures of of English literature are quite pagan figures like Gandalf, Prospero, Falstaff, like Merlin. These are these are these feel like quite pagan figures to me,

SPEAKER_02but

SPEAKER_01chanting figures. And so there's a there's a wrestling with that within the English soul, I feel.

SPEAKER_00And

SPEAKER_02and and uh just to just to once again play the idiot historian, the the the word Catholic, it's w the English kings you're talking about, Oli, would they would would you think of them as as as Catholic kings? Or at that point you don't need to because there's no separation.

SPEAKER_01Well, up to the Reformation, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, up to the Reformation. So it just sort of worth saying, I know it sounds stupid, is the Reformation happens in the 1500s under the Henry VIII, but before that, so Shakespeare's from a Catholic family, but before that it's kind of all of it is tied to Rome. Yeah, and I i I I am studying this when I can. The I think understanding Europe, understanding this schism, this this this tension between these in Christianity is one of the most important ways to study Europe.

SPEAKER_01And you've got the schism before that between Catholicism and Orthodox Christianity as well.

SPEAKER_02Across Europe.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um it's complicated. I just sort of sense this because even the oldest English poem that we have, Beowulf, is a Christianization of a pagan story. Um so you've this tension is is core to English literature, right?

SPEAKER_00And that's that's actually quite a natural thing for universal evangelizing religions to do. So um whether it's Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, you can actually find this synthesizing of the previous cultures and gods. Um, and and you know, we can even see it within between Christian peoples. So I I've I've used Holy Island of Lindisfarne as an example a few times. It's famous for the Lindisfarne Gospels.

SPEAKER_00Which is one of the glories of English civilization. Now in the British Library in London, you can go and see it, and you should. It is a wonderful piece of work. And these monks in a scriptorium quite literally wrote out the gospels in pen, um, quill and ink in the most fantastic colours, um and would have spent an awfully long time on it, and they would have been the most expensive materials possibly available.

SPEAKER_00But the the uh calligraphy that was used was heavily influenced by those Irish peoples I spoke about earlier. So those people from Dalreata, Saint Columba was the man who had left the northwest coast of Ireland, um, who then founded the monastery on Iona, St. Aidan, who was actually a Scot ethnically, so not a Gael, like Columba, then was the one who transplanted the Iona monastic order over on the Holy Island of Lindisfarne.

SPEAKER_00And he and um and Columba's ways, and then Cuthbert, who was a s who was an uh an Angle, an Anglo-Saxon we'd now call him, uh, was also part of this. He became a disciple of Aidan's and took all of this on and was hybridizing the I the Celtic Christian culture with the the newly founded English Christian culture, whilst there's all the Latin influence as well, because they're writing the Gospels in Latin. So, but yet it became such an English thing. But it's it's quite similar to the Book of Kells, which sits in the the the the Trinity College in Dublin, which is the kind of Irish version done on Hibernia.

SPEAKER_00So it just shows this example of this synthesizing that even though it's very English, it's taken Irish influence, but it's still an English possession.

SPEAKER_01But there are things to maybe draw this into the present more or or to may actually to get more cultural,

SPEAKER_00right?

SPEAKER_01We're talking about the synthesis of pagan and Christian

SPEAKER_00um

SPEAKER_01worldview. Like maybe to speak more frankly, like the background of this conversation is that we are saying that some things do have a continuity and can be synthesized. But I think we're also saying that some things can't be synthesized. Right? I mean can Islam be synthesized? Like we'll because I suppose the woke or one of the left wings or even a liberal position would be look, you've seen pagan be synthesized with Christian and all these different things be incorporated, German, um uh French, all the rest of it, uh why not Islam as well?

SPEAKER_01Right? Why not? Why not anything? And I suppose the b background idea that we've been saying is no no, these these things are can be seen as part of a whole in the way that not anything goes. Right? Um but maybe we could be more explicit about that. I don't know how implicit we want to get with it. Like

SPEAKER_02Do you want to get explicit?

SPEAKER_01Well, I sort of want us to think about is is that what we're saying?

SPEAKER_00Well, I I I I I'll put my neck on the line and say yes. I I think ultimately um when we talk about Western civilization, it has its own distinct components. So we've talked about some of them today. Two closely related European peoples of the English and the French have very distinct approaches to philosophy and governance and all the rest of it, but also have relied upon the same reference points to build their civilization, Greco-Roman, biblical, all that kind of stuff.

SPEAKER_00Islamic civilization is its whole other thing. Uh, it's uh it's got its own lineage, its own history. It itself wouldn't want to be synthesized. Um and um uh and indeed, you know, Islamic nations, um uh they they can allow for other um other faiths to live among them. So for instance, the Malaysians are quite good at this. They basically say, look, we have a culture here, it's Islamic, and everything is going to be largely Islamic, but you're allowed you're allowed to practice over here, but we don't want you basically making that part of the furniture.

SPEAKER_00So, but you're allowed to do it because frankly, this is how we want to live. And they they basically learned that from funnily enough, the the British Empire um and and the colonial governors that were over there, and they kind of continued that going, and the nation actually pretty much works, but it wouldn't want to synthesize with any of the minority faiths. Um, and I suppose what what we're probably saying when we're talking about is there a threat to the way of life? Well, certainly not when there's small numbers, but I suppose what you can see throughout history and English history as well, right?

SPEAKER_00Let's think about the Britons, the Romano-British that were here, who invited a few people over to shore up their support, and instead a demographic tidal wave came over, which ended up leading to the country of England, which was a totally alien civilization compared to what was already there. And people used to write it about it in their books, saying, Oh my god, these people have literally, it's either, it's either get we've we're gonna run into their sword or we're gonna run into the sea. Um, they didn't want it. Um, they knew that they were losing something. And so the English having us now being descended from these people, this nation was formed through that.

SPEAKER_00You know, that's happened already, and our ancestors caused that kind of submersion and change and might have synthesized some things around the edges but imposed something else on top. I suppose the conversations we're having about in the modern day is, you know, what happens when you have two civilizations run up against each other and demographics get to the point that it's not about synthesis but it's about imposition. Um so yes, I don't think either Christianity really would want to be synthesized to the point where it it gave itself up to another faith regardless of what it is, and I don't and Islam wouldn't want to do that either, and and neither would the adherence.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, well, I mean, I just that's it, John. You just explained it brilliantly far more eloquently than I would have done. But yeah, I don't think it I don't think it can, I don't think it would want to be. And I can think of people I know who are from that background, they would they wouldn't, you know, they they wouldn't respect me if I said, oh yes, they don't want that. People just people just don't want that. Uh can we live together in a country and can we kind of live side by side and get on with each other? Possibly. You know, it it it it feels that as these numbers go up and tensions rise, these things are just gonna get even more difficult to deal with.

SPEAKER_02But it yes, completely different history, completely different people. It's just no. There'll be some people probably from those backgrounds who might be anglophiles, but it's very rare, isn't it? It's very rare with people from those backgrounds to be like, oh yeah, I really love England. I want to be they they're also what is there for them to love anymore? You know, this is the just to c come back to the sort of thing I said very at the beginning of this discussion. What is there for them to love about England? We know what there is, right, us three, but in some ways, I can see that they look at our culture and they think, you are degraded degenerates.

SPEAKER_02They see Bonnie Blue is is is this white blonde woman with lines of men, you know, uh uh going in to have sex with her. We've got pornography everywhere, you know, uh cocaine all over the country, run by mainly Albanians, but it's lots of people who aren't Albanian doing the drugs, right? They see this culture we've got. Why on earth would they want to be part of it anyway, in lots of ways, right? They they see it's we have to attack our own culture as well in in in order in to deal with this because we the English culture, a lot large parts of it have become completely cultureless, um uneducated people, uh, and degenerate there's a degenerate culture.

SPEAKER_02And and so there's my there's me kicking the English uh in in this episode because you you can't you're not gonna I always say to my friends, I'm like, you're not gonna beat Sharia law with um brassing and cocaine.

SPEAKER_01I mean you see it uh you know on the on the on the coast as well, which is where I where I've moved, you really see the the generations of broken and deprived uh white working class, right? And you can see it etched in into the people's faces. Um and it's very sad, it's been quite confronting to actually live around that now. Um and I kind of fall around, this sounds very patrician and and patronizing, but I walk around and I'm like, what can we give to these people? But you

unknownknow,

SPEAKER_01their their culture's been so hollowed out, and uh not that I've become the saviour of the coastal coastal towns. Um yes, exactly. That's

SPEAKER_02Oli Oli, the road to

SPEAKER_01Hastings. Um but no, I but I I I I go on my my runs and I see these people, you know. I'm sounding more patronizing by the second, but I think like no AI revolution is going to help these people.

SPEAKER_00No.

SPEAKER_01Right? And you know, maybe there could be some kind of rejuvenation of of the military and the state that could employ these people because that's formerly what and lots of my personal ancestors and people in my family would have done. Um, but I don't know what it is, but I feel the need to I don't, I'm not gonna use the word help, but like re-enchant these people and and ballast up the culture that previously sustained them.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I don't think there's anything wrong. I know we you're probably reticent to use the word help because then it conjures up images of the white saviour who goes off to a third world countries to show themselves nailing in a bit of wood into a ramshackle school they're building and say, have their selfie with everyone from this country, and then they come back on their flight and they're like, Oh, I had such a great gap year.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's

SPEAKER_00brilliant. But the the reality

SPEAKER_01works for Shakespeare and a working class guy technically.

SPEAKER_00But but as Morgan said earlier, um no noblesse oblige than the notion that actually so people rail against just to bring modern politics into it, they rail against one nation Tories now in Britain as being wet people who are just open to the world and they're kind of they're liberals, you know, they're Whigs. That's what the Tory party's become. But actually back then, one nation Tories really did mean that patrician angle to it. You know, that they were actually quite deeply influenced by, you know, at least Benjamin Disraeli was, about the idea that, you know, there were people who were deeply affected by the Industrial Revolution because they all once had their own lands, Land and Closure Act came along, then everyone's out into the factories, they're at the behest of the o, you know, the factory owners, capital owners, all the rest of it.

SPEAKER_00And actually, yeah, those people who were the haves did have to help the have nots that actually had to govern in a just and merciful way, and you had to try and find a way in which to educate and to elucidate the best in people. Now, that's not to say the class distinction didn't exist. It did, and there's loads of examples of that kind of hoity-toity um uh attitude toward people who were getting above their station. But I don't think there's anything wrong with the Blessed Legion patrician values, because you don't actually see that now.

SPEAKER_00What if you get paternalism, it's insofar as, oh, let's just shut down political debate online in our in our various legal acts,

SPEAKER_02rather

SPEAKER_00than rather than how is it that we um prevent people from being drowned under this tsunami of a technological revolution? Or how is it that we're going to unpick the really bad decisions that have been made where, you know, whilst it could have made sense at various geopolitical times to um change the regulations of the nation, to basically just sell off all our industry and close them down, having literally spent a couple of centuries allowing whole communities to build and cities to to take root around an industry, but they had all built their own um their own lives.

SPEAKER_00There was a spiritual core to it, whether they were uh high Tory Anglicans or whether they were dissenters and non-conformists, uh they they had a a civic life and it was literally all taken away from them. Um and then we put everyone on welfare. So, but but the one thing I do want to say uh to take on Morgan's point, and and this is I say this is a man who's been on housing benefit. Like I was out of work for a few months and had to be on housing benefit. I felt bloody dreadful. I felt so low, as low as I'd ever been. I had no A levels, no nothing.

SPEAKER_00I left school early. Um, I'd been working for six or seven years in retail, quit my job because I was so bad at it. And I thought it'd be better to just use those 40 hours a week instead of doing door-to-door sales, trying to get a proper job. And I was on three months on benefits, felt dreadful. But I guess the point I'm trying to make is that um we do need to somehow get agency back in people's lives and try and find a way that people do try to lift themselves up, that some people do try to give people the tools to lift themselves up because too many people have entered the Faustian bargain that our captains of industry did with we can just sell everything off and and live this easy globalized life, and we can just import this and import that and forget about all these hoi poloy in the in the seaside towns.

SPEAKER_00But those people in the seaside towns have also taken the Faustian bargain where they've gone, oh well, actually, this is okay. I

SPEAKER_01don't

SPEAKER_00have to do anything with it. And then it's just been generations of dependence, and that's the kind of people that you're seeing, Ollie. And again, I don't want to kick anyone while they're down, but it's also true that people do have the agency and the free will to be able to change things. And I don't know how we change that mindset, but we need to because because we've got too many people who want to outsource responsibility for everything to government and corporations, and we've got government that are quite happy to have people outsource their responsibility to them because it keeps them in a job and they'll create more jobs and they'll just tax more people to create more jobs, and they'll just keep their dependence.

SPEAKER_02But if if they stri if they if they strip you of a people, how can you care for the people? This is why this is where we're in such a confusing state now, because yeah, you can have a have a love for these people, or only you can see these people and go, I I sort of recognise they're broken and destitute, and they're but they're kind of vulgar and disgusting. But you're are you allowed to say, Well, these are still my people and I need to help them somehow.

SPEAKER_01Alienation has got so intense what you're describing, Don, is it is a big supreme like alienation uh and atomization. It's so intense, it seems to be only getting more intense uh with technology and global situation, whatever. When you are very alienated and lost, you need to know who you are, you need to connect to something in space and in time. Uh like you know, I'm sure a psychotherapist would say that that as well, when people are very depressed and isolated, situating yourself, being somewhere in time and in space, being connected to a history, a lineage is very, very important.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So that it is important that people have that culturally and do not just have the idea that oh, you're you have no history. This is literally, I mean, uh these the recent years have been has been the idea that we have no history.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01It's so

SPEAKER_02it's so cruel, isn't it?

SPEAKER_01Use literature and art to to remind people that there is history and you are connected to something in time.

SPEAKER_00Well, I I I think that's what the purpose of all of these conversations is going to be. And we're focusing on the English now, but I think we probably do need to go out to the other peoples of of Britain because there are just as many rich inheritance as there. But we'll we'll stick with the English for the time being. Uh and perhaps we can tee ourselves up for the next one where we actually explore more than the breadcrumbs we've dropped today about the inheritance that we've received and that have been produced by the people who came before us.

SPEAKER_00Uh, because I think what we've been getting to today as well is that they're um when we've been talking about cultural amnesia and an erasure and then a forgetting um is this is something that we need to try to push back on and and and drop those breadcrumbs for people to pick up and go and follow themselves through this to this dark wood, Hansel and Gretel, like just hopefully they don't get put in an oven by a big scary woman. But um perhaps to finish on on a on a quotation from Milan Kandera, who uh a Czech writer uh in a book called The The Book of Laughter and Forgetting, because I think this is this is how serious the situation is when you look at the state of education and what we are served up when it comes to national identity and history.

SPEAKER_00Uh and I hope that people can recognise that they see this if they if they can't really understand themselves as a people. So Kondera writes, the first step in liquidating a people is to erase its memory, destroy its books, its culture, its history, then have somebody write new books, manufacture a new culture, invent a new history. Before long, that nation will begin to forget what it is and what it was. The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting.

SPEAKER_00So, chaps, here's to memory. No more forgetting.

SPEAKER_01Amen.

SPEAKER_00Amen.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. #152 - Carl Trueman - Why An Englishman In America Laments What The Mother Country Has Become

    Nov 12, 202657 minAudio

    Carl Trueman, professor at Grove City College and author of The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self, returns to Thinking Class to talk about what he felt when he came back to the mother country this summer. In this...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. #151 - Paul Morland & Philip Pilkington - Britain Is Going Bankrupt And Nobody Will Say Why

    Nov 5, 202656 minAudio

    Britain's economy is a demographic Ponzi scheme. The models don't work. The Treasury knows it. And nobody will say it out loud. Paul Morland and Philip Pilkington are the authors of Bust: The Economics of Population...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. #150 - David McGrogan - The British State Is Not Broken And The System Is Working Exactly As It Was Designed

    Oct 29, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    David McGrogan is a legal scholar at Northumbria University and the author of the Substack News from Uncibal. In this conversation, we think out loud about: • Why the intelligentsia wanted to show mercy to the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. #149 - Bella d'Abrera - How Australia Became A Warning For Every Western Democracy

    Oct 22, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Bella d'Abrera is the former Director of the Foundations of Western Civilisation Programme at the Institute of Public Affairs in Australia and the author of Mindless. In this conversation, we think out loud about: • How...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. #148 - Marie Kawthar Daouda - They Told Her She Was A Victim Of The West. She Became Its Greatest Defender.

    Oct 15, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Dr Marie Kawthar Daouda is a French-Moroccan scholar at the University of Oxford and the author of Not Your Victim. In this conversation we think out loud about: Why a French-Moroccan Oxford scholar wrote a love letter...

    Credit the people on this episode