Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Thinking Class

Thinking Class artwork

#152 - Carl Trueman - Why An Englishman In America Laments What The Mother Country Has Become

Nov 12, 202657 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Carl Trueman, professor at Grove City College and author of The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self, returns to Thinking Class to talk about what he felt when he came back to the mother country this summer. In this conversation, we discuss: • The cold beer sign and the death of English pub culture • Keeping his British passport after a Dutch politician was refused entry for quoting his work • The dining room that architects no longer build - and why it matters • Whether Britain and America are still the same civilisation • Why the post-religious right is no more human than the post-religious left • Foucault on his deathbed: "I thought there would be something to say. There was nothing." • Psalm 115 and what happens when a people worships nothing • Why liberal democracy cannot survive without a Christian anthropology • The second technological revolution - when we transform ourselves • Where to find refuge: build a home Guest links: Carl Trueman - First Things columnist: firstthings.com The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self (2020): https://link.amazon/B00PMVL2m Strange New World (2022): https://link.amazon/B04wdSO8V Grove City College: https://www.gcc.edu/Home/Staff-Directory/Staff-Detail/carl-r-trueman This episode is sponsored by Aquinas Tuition. https://aquinastuition.co.uk/ And if you haven’t already, go and watch The Call of England - my six-part documentary series following H.V. Morton’s 1927 journey through England: https://youtu.be/muBQWIP6ZQQ The Albion Institute - launching 2027. Recovering the inheritance of the English-speaking peoples: https://albioninstitute.org Thinking Class is a long-form interview podcast on the cultural, historical and civilisational forces shaping England, Britain, the Anglosphere and the wider West. Hosted by John Gillam. ▶ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ThinkingClass ✍ Substack: https://thinkingclass.substack.com/ 🎧 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/37vvzrlxpo8eORDoTDRtbH 🍎 Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/thinking-class/id1717021615 🐦 X: https://x.com/thinkingclasses New episodes every Thursday at 3pm.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello, classmates, and welcome to Thinking Class. I'm John Gillam, and today I'm speaking to you Carl Truman. Carl is a professor of biblical and religious studies at Grove City College in Pennsylvania, a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Centre, and a regular columnist for First Things. He is the author of The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self, amongst many other works. And this is Carl's fourth appearance on Thinking Class. In this conversation, Carl and I think out loud about what he found when he came home to England this summer, why he kept his British passport after becoming an American citizen, the dining rooms at new houses no longer have, whether Britain and America are still the same civilization, Michel Foucault and his dying in a Paris hospital with nothing to say, what happens when a people worships nothingness, and why liberal democracy may not survive without the Christian metaphysics that made it possible.

SPEAKER_01This episode is brought to you by Aquinas Tuition, which provides bespoke academic tutoring informed by classical liberal arts principles. Whether your child needs support with GCSEs, A levels, or university entrance, Aquinas will pair every student with a tutor who cares about formation and not just grades, but they care about grades too. Visit AquinasTuition.co.uk. I am also the founder of the Albion Institute. This is an institution for the formation of nationally minded leaders and an informed public through the preservation, transmission, and renewal of the intellectual and cultural inheritance of the English speaking peoples.

SPEAKER_01Lord Nigel Bigger has joined Albion as advisory board chair, and if you would like to learn more or register your interest, visit Albion Institute.org. And if you haven't already, go and watch The Call of England, my six-part documentary series following H. V. Morton's 1927 journey through England. The link is in the description. In the meantime, enjoy the show, classmates. And now, Carl Truman. My guest today was the last boy in his school to learn Latin.

SPEAKER_01He grew up in England, the era of the grammar schools. He learned personal restraint, the age-old fair play virtue. And then he left for the United States. He's returned every year since he went, and something seems to have changed this summer upon visiting his home country. And he wrote four words in a recent article. The England that I knew is gone. Today Carl Truman joins me to talk about what he felt when he came back to the mother country and his observations about where the country may be headed.

SPEAKER_01And Carl, it is a delight to welcome you back, I think, for the fourth time on Thinking Class. Thanks so much for joining me. Great to be here, John. Always lovely to chat to you. Likewise. So your trip back to England this summer, you I don't want to put words in your mouth, but you seem to suggest that the present day England had started to feel increasingly foreign. I don't think you were just talking about demographic change, you were talking about cultural mores as much as anything, and perhaps even uh the spirit of the place.

SPEAKER_01Perhaps you could talk us through what you felt upon arrival and during your time in summer and and w what is the um the the the sentiment that you feel because I sensed mourning in some of the articles that you've been writing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's it's an interesting question. I I I probably need to sort of back up and and set a bit of context. I uh you know, I I emigrated to the United States 25 years ago uh for job reasons. And I think that the it's the experience of immigrants that you particularly if you emigrate in your your early thirties as I did, you end up with this odd situation that you never quite understand the country you've moved to because you're pretty fixed by the time you get there. But the chur the country you've left continues to move forward or move culturally.

SPEAKER_00So you end up never quite fitting in the country that you return to each year. You you end up not, you know, to say a stateless person would over-dramatize it, but you end up not quite fitting in uh anywhere. So I've been aware for some years going back to the UK, you know, I I have no right to expect the UK to be the same as it was in the 1980s when I was being formed. I'm also aware that there's a a natural tendency as you get older to be nostalgic about childhood and youth.

SPEAKER_00You you look back and you think of the the hopes and the opportunities that were there and you realize, you know, you've not you've not been able to take advantage of them all as a tendency to to construct a kind of golden age to one's own childhood. So all of that is to say that I'm I I I try to be self-critical when I reflect upon my home country, but I was very struck by a few things this year. First of all, I was struck by the amount of what I would call public loutishness I encountered.

SPEAKER_00And that's down to people, you know, people watching videos on their phone without wearing headphones. You know, you might see it's a small thing, but I would say it's actually reflective of how we think about our relationship to other people around us. When it becomes acceptable for me to do what I want in a way that inconveniences others, when that becomes normative, something's going on. Uh I've been struck at how members of my own family have become you know, radicalized might be too strong a word, but have certain come to feel that their voices are not hurt, particularly on the immigration issue.

SPEAKER_00Uh you know, I have a sister who says, you know, if you know if I want to raise a serious question about immigration, I'm just dismissed as a racist these days. Well, you know, that's that's a recipe for strong political polarisation. Thirdly, I was struck at the amount of nonsense that's pouring from the political establishment at this point. Uh this notion, you know, diversity is England's strength. No, that's an empty concept. That's a piece of rhetoric that sounds cool, but it doesn't mean anything at all.

SPEAKER_00No nation's strength lies in its, if you like, inability to provide a coherent account of itself, which is what I think is being is being said there. And then I I I felt was a general a general unease or lack of confidence that was shaping the culture. Okay, London taxi drivers, not necessarily a cross section of the population, but I had some interesting conversations with London taxi drivers who were not only lamenting the fact that they could no longer live in London, had to commute into work, but also uh lamenting the fact that their own communities were being disrupted and transformed by the imposition of immigrant caps.

SPEAKER_00Now, again, you might say, well, it's terribly racist to raise it. Well, that of course that's part of the problem. If you can't uh raise a question about who is being allowed into your community without being dismissed as a racist, then there's something very serious going on in your culture. So it was a host of things. Um most trivial of all, I walked past a sign in London that said uh fully air-conditioned, uh uh cold beer served. And I said to my wife, that's a sign that the England that I grew up in is gone.

SPEAKER_00No pub would ever have been air conditioned, and no beer would ever have been served at anything but room temperature when I was growing up.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, without warm bitter, this country has lost its soul. Yes. I actually would like to touch a little bit on what this means for you and your relationship with the the mother country. You're you're a US citizen now, you've been there for two and a half decades. Um clearly you still have referred to home as the mother country, and I'm just wondering whether it now feels like you're not really able to do the Homeric thing on the Odyssey and go back, that there is nowhere to go back.

SPEAKER_01Do you feel as though the cord has been cut in some way and that you you uh the the country that you are from no longer exists, and so your your eggs are all in the the the US basket alone now?

SPEAKER_00No not not at all. I think uh first of all I have two I have both passports, and I'll I'll talk about the reason why I'm gonna keep both passports uh in in a minute. Um my family uh live in a a rural village in Gloucestershire, and to be honest, very little changes there. So when I go back to visit my my mother, uh really it's you know it it's the land that that time forgot.

SPEAKER_00So I can go back there and I can walk the lanes and I can look at the horizon and I can see the faces in the street and it's it's like travelling back in time. Um so I don't feel that my my links to England have been have been broken entirely at all. And I s I've I've tried to articulate to Americans who seem to think that this renders me a traitor to their country. I say, you know, I I I don't believe in America to to quote that beginning of Godfather movie, you know, I believe in America.

SPEAKER_00Uh I love America, I'm very happy living here. But my heart really belongs to to England. And it's really the England of the 1980s. Uh it's not uh it's not the England of today, I suppose. Now I have both passports, and one reason I've decided to keep both passports is this. Uh earlier this year, I think it was uh uh a young Dutch politician, Eva Vlatingerbrug, was refused entry to the United Kingdom. Now I to be honest, I'd never heard of her until my sister alerted me to her.

SPEAKER_00My sister did a search on some AI engine online to ask, you know, why has this this young woman been refused an entry visa to the United Kingdom? And among the things that it listed as her having done that rendered her an undesirable in the United Kingdom was that she'd quoted my work on transgenderism in public speeches. Now, I have an elderly mother in in Gloucestershire. I've at least got to keep coming back while my mother's still alive.

SPEAKER_00And I remember saying to my wife at the time, wow, uh, you know, we'd we'd been thinking about should, you know, do we do we need British passports anymore? And I remember saying to her, I think I need my British passport at this point, because I'm not going to be asking the government for permission to go and visit my mother. And some algorithm throwing up the fact that I wrote uh a book on transgenderism that doesn't happen to fit with the governing ideology of the British civil service or whatever. I want to be able to go back and visit my mother as and when I wish.

SPEAKER_00So that was my first, I suppose, you know, going back to your first question, John, I guess that was the first sign to me that things are really changing. We have all kinds of crazy people in England, but you can't be a legitimate Dutch politician and be guaranteed entry. And when I wrote one of my articles, uh the first article, the sort of Lament for Britain, um, I had some somebody I didn't know emailed me and said, you know, you need to get out a bit more, you need to go to a pub.

SPEAKER_00And my thought was, yeah, I'd love to go to a pub. I'd love to go to a boat pub with Ava Vladigerbrook and talk to her about her politics. But unfortunately, I can't do that in England anymore. I would have been able to do it 30 years ago when, hey, everybody believed that men were men and women were women, and her views would not have been considered uh of a type to render her undesirable in England. She would have been typical. Uh so yeah, going to a pub makes me look around and see, well, who isn't there?

SPEAKER_00Who isn't allowed to be there? Eva Vladingerbrook isn't allowed to be there. Uh Pavy Raisen from Finland, uh former cabinet minister from the Finnish. She's not allowed to be there. What is happening to a country who you know so say our strength is our diversity? Well, actually, it's diversity pretty narrowly defined by uh a progressive cast of leaders, I think.

SPEAKER_01Yes, I think the the the the decency of the British people has been weaponised uh against us. Yeah um and the the state uh uh um through its imposition of these speech codes through uh borders, but only for the people who disagree with its worldview.

SPEAKER_00Um uh fact only for people following the law, one might say. You know, legal immigrations are all problems, say it's the same here. Borders only apply to those who actually respect the law.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And and and and the the point the point is ultimately being conceded by the fact they have to have all of these impositions in the first place. Uh th thinking oh well, and furthermore, about the pub, not only that, but if you go to a pub in an ice, leafy part of England, you might find a Labour minister talking about it as being a fantasy that never existed and only existed in the heads of far-right people. Um uh quite quite unbelievable. Uh just just how year zero uh some politicians really are trying to go as though those of us who've actually grown up in the country uh uh are not going to be able to recognise that as a as a barefaced lie.

SPEAKER_01Um I was also interested to hear you uh talk a little bit about and just diverging a bit onto the the um the the Anglo-American relationship. Often our country's referred to as Anglo-America as well. Uh ultimately it was a uh a transplant of Albion seed, as you know, I'm into talking about this. And right up until I I don't know, John Quincy Adams, who made the break saying we're no longer Englishmen, we're Americans, um, up until that point, everyone pretty much thought of themselves as Englishmen in America.

SPEAKER_01Um and a lot of the the colonists, I think you can find uh people writing about the homesickness for generations, um, generations after their ancestors had arrived, they they they longed for the mother country, but it was a long blummin' boat ride away. I suppose obviously it's easier now to get back and forth. And I I know I know your wife and I met her in in the summer um from the Hebrides has spoken about how it's when she goes back that she knows she's she's home. Do you do you think your your sons born in uh America feel that longing for the mother country?

SPEAKER_01Or are they are they American as apple pie?

SPEAKER_00Well, they were actually born in the United Kingdom. So uh one of them is one of them is the one who's married to an American and has an American daughter is actually the only one of us who doesn't have an American passport at this point. Really? But they were they were born in in Nottingham, uh, where I was teaching at Nottingham University at the time. Uh I think that if you ask them who they are, they'd say they're they're British. But I don't think they really, you know, if they came home to Britain, they would they would be foreigners in in Britain.

SPEAKER_00I mean, if I find Britain a somewhat perplexing place these days, they're really, I would say, intuitively American in the way they think about a lot of things.

SPEAKER_01Interesting. I I interviewed a chap recently, he's the author of a book called The Scramble for America. He he's he's a br he's a Brit living in Switzerland, and uh the subtitle is How the United States Conquered a Cont Continent. And um I I saw him post recently that the notion that th we are the same civilization, just something that I d believe, he believes to be false, that actually there has been a divergence ultimately between the United States and the Europeans who initially populated it.

SPEAKER_01What do you make of that? Do you think we're the same civilization or are we different now?

SPEAKER_00I I think there's a number of things one could one could offer in response. I mean, first of all, of course, I think the idea of European civilization is something of a generalization. You know, it's very clear that you know to grow up in France or to grow up in England is to grow up in in two you know not unrelated but quite distinct cultures. Absolutely. Uh and I think the same would go for you know Germany or Italy or or Spain. Um the Italians always strike me as having so much more fun.

SPEAKER_00You know, when I when I visit Italy, it's a it's they they just seem happier and certainly better dressed people than than than many many of the rest of us. But uh I I think that what we're seeing here at the moment is that certainly politics in America has taken a very different path for a variety of reasons. I was teaching just yesterday in class on the First World War in my sort of modern age course. I and I made the point that the experience of the First and Second World Wars really shaped Europe in a way that America was somewhat immune to because no battles took place on American soil.

SPEAKER_00Uh the and certainly in the First World War, the the catastrophic levels of death that the the British, the French, the Germans experienced among a pretty narrow demographic of sort of 18 to 25-year-old men, it has no analogue in the United States. And I think that certainly shapes cultural attitudes in profound ways. America has been, historically, I think, a more optimistic culture up until probably 9-11 was the watershed.

SPEAKER_00I I emigrated three weeks before 9-11. So I've had a ringside seat in watching the what I would describe as the crisis of American confidence unfolding uh in front of me. So you know, we can talk about Anglo-American culture, and often I think that we we certainly share many foundational texts of our culture the same, many of our traditions are the same. Uh, but the narrative of America and the narrative of European countries is distinctively different and does give uh uh our respective countries a very, very different character.

SPEAKER_00You know, guns might be the most obvious thing that come to it to the British uh uh imagination. I think I'm I could be the only unarmed man within a 50-mile radius. I I live deep in the heart of Western Pennsylvania, upper Appalachia, gun territory. I don't own one. Uh because guns mean something different to me than they mean to an American, they're a symbol of personal freedom and a symbol of the limitation of government power. To me, I just can't get my head around that.

SPEAKER_00I'm not saying my American friends are wrong at all. I'm just saying the cultural logic that they are schooled in and the cultural logic that I've been schooled in, they're different. They're incommensurable. Yes.

SPEAKER_01Well, if you'd like, I'll cut that out for your own safety so no one targets you, Carl.

SPEAKER_00I'm English, you know. If if I'm in trouble, I'm gonna call for help.

SPEAKER_01I'll be fine, you know.

SPEAKER_00Well, having I was actually held at gunpoint for 15 minutes in Texas once by uh a member of a Nigerian organized crime group, would you believe threatening to blow my brains out? And I live to tell the tale. I I actually I I had students say to me, Dr. Truman, this is why you need to carry a gun. And I said to them, you know, if I'd been carrying a gun that night, I think he'd have shot me on the spot. Because he would not have wanted to take the risk of me drawing my gun, and you can bet your bottom dollar, he's better at shooting people than I am.

SPEAKER_00So I would have been an absolute goner. Blow me.

SPEAKER_01And only that, that is that is shocking. And laughing laughing about it as well. Although I I do something similar. I was held up at knife point in Colombia and find myself chuckling about the story when I tell it. I think it's the uh the only possible response, and perhaps very interesting. It's a great two.

SPEAKER_00It is a yeah, it is, it's a great self-deprecating story.

SPEAKER_01Indeed. Uh well, after after after a um uh a detour over the Atlantic, we'll bring it back to Blighty and uh and specifically the pub culture. So we've we've joked about the warm beers and how that's a thing of the past, but there was also something else going on within pub culture which you described um very warmly, uh like the beer in one of your articles, which is that the the the going to the pub and having a pint wasn't just a s a social habit, it was uh it was actually bonds of mutual obligation, like buying rounds.

SPEAKER_01It was the way that m men typically express community uh uh amongst one another. Uh on your observations, coming back all these years, and and the the the pub culture is now being hollowed out, and I think those bonds of mutual obligation are are weakening. What do you think has replaced it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's it's yeah there are there are various reasons for the decline of the pub, but I think um tax is one, but tax on beer and on small businesses. But i it would be unfair to blame you know we we love in Britain to blame the government for everything. It'd be unfair to blame The government solely for the decline of the English pub. I think we're seeing, we've seen over the last hundred years major cultural and social shifts.

SPEAKER_00I think the advent of the television, for example, provides a focal point in the home that is isolated in many ways. When you think of the old, oh, you know, my mother lives in an old weaver's cottage, and there's the old fireplace there. And you can imagine the family, the focal point of the room is the fireplace, because that's where the warmth came from. And everyone sit around the fireplace and be drawn into each other's company. Today, the focal point of many, many houses is the television.

SPEAKER_00And people sit, and the television's the focal point, but it doesn't draw people together, it actually individually entertains them. So they don't have to talk to each other. That problem, I think, has been exacerbated with the advent of smartphones and small screens, that we're now able to literally entertain ourselves without any contact with other people. So I think that the the dynamics of of free time, for want of a better term, uh the geography of free time has has uh has uh been transformed.

SPEAKER_00And we see that not simply in pure, but even in the architecture of houses. I I don't know if this applies to the United Kingdom, but I taught a course last year on the transformation of thinking about what it means to be human in the modern world. And one of my students was an architecture student. And I asked him at some point in the course, I said, you know, the houses that you m architects now design, what do they do with the dining room? And his answer was many houses these days are not built with dining rooms.

SPEAKER_00It's considered to be a waste of space. You know, just think about that. Okay, on one hand it makes sense, you know, you've got this room that maybe you only use on Sundays, or like my grandmother's front room, only use it when you know posh guests come or something like that. Otherwise it's not used. On the other hand, on the occasions you do use it, it's very important because you sit around a table, you share food, you you enjoy each other's company. Um my wife and I, we have a dining room in our house, and we okay, we don't use it very often when we're just by ourselves.

SPEAKER_00We eat at the kitchen table. We still sit at a table and eat. Um we use it for guests when they come. And that room is is key because it reflects an attitude to how we think of ourselves, how we think about food, and how we think about friends and community. Um and you know, uh I I think the loss of the dining room is analogous to the change of the pub. And when you think of your local pubs now, when I was growing up, pubs were just places you went to drink with friends.

SPEAKER_00Um today they have TV screens, so you go there to watch the TV.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Watch Sky Sports News on on repeat. The point you were making about architecture, the removal of the dining room, seen as a waste of space, that whole utilitarian worldview. Um it rings very true to me. Uh uh and and and I talk about this in my documentary series, The Call of England, specifically as I'm coming out of London and I'm going through a part of London which has transformed magnificently in the last 30, 40, 50 years.

SPEAKER_01The the buildings are all streets in the sky, the glass and steel structures, the boxy apartments. And one thing that I've noticed, and this is the way I lived as a younger man too, uh, and the older I've gotten, um, have started to live differently, and my my wife certainly adds to that, is that you'd live without with a lack of ornamentation. The walls were bare, there wasn't a lot of colour, there was nothing really suggesting uh any depth, both to yourself, but also um any connection to the story of your community, region, faith, nation.

SPEAKER_01And and when my wife and I were looking for houses, we were looking in various parts of the country, deciding what where to be, near family and whatever, what have you. And there was one house we we went to view that was right next to an 11th-century church, and it it dawned on me as I was there, viewing this house that had been um vacated by uh a woman who was in her 90s, her husband had passed away a couple of decades before, and the place, the moment you felt walked in, felt like home.

SPEAKER_01There was uh evidence of being lived in and loved everywhere, from everything on the walls, you know, and also things like of the national identity, you know, uh um images of the Battle of Trafalgar, uh, there were uh crocheted um psalms that she'd perhaps done at church group on the wall. Um there were prayer books by her side, there was um the history of World War II or uh Winston's Churchill's History of the English Speaking Peoples, a set a connection to a people and not just herself.

SPEAKER_01And yet, if you see some of the the billionaire tech bros, you know, Sam Altman you'll see doing interviews in his kitchen, the whole thing's bare. Everything's just really smooth, and there's there's almost no depth there. And that's that, and perhaps this is a tenuous link, but I do think this is that this age of expressive individualism, as you call it, where people are quite literally just looking for pleasure and for their own comfort above all else, has actually stripped away um anything that might suggest a depth to them.

SPEAKER_01That the expressive individualism is just this empty nuss, this this fountain which has nothing really to water anything around it. There's nothing to work with. Um and and I I my my question to you actually, whilst we're on expressive individualism, is sometimes it's it's thought that we we can blame the left for a killing of the decent habits and restraints and reflexes, but you've also made the point that the right could be accused of um being marked by expressive individualism as much as them.

SPEAKER_01Could you describe why that is?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I again I think there are various reasons. Um one would be, of course, that yeah I I think the the the a radical free market philosophy is corrosive of traditional ties. You know, I I don't often quote Marx positively, but I I think his description of what industrialization is doing in in England in the 19th century, when he talks about, you know, all that is sacred is profane, all that is solid melts into air. I I think that captures something of what the market does.

SPEAKER_00It transforms us into consumers. And that means that, you know, we don't buy paintings because they capture something of who we are. We buy paintings as an investment or as a way of displaying our status to to other people. So I think there's there's you know, this was the genius, I suppose, looking in retrospect at Mrs. Thatcher. She was able to, on the one hand, have the free market philosophy and at the same time play to traditional tropes of traditional England.

SPEAKER_00She was both establishments and anti-establishments in this fascinating uh combination. Uh but I also think that the you know th the right, certainly the radical right as it's developed in the United States, is so contemptuous of traditional institutions and so contemptuous of the wisdom of the past that it too is is very similar to progressivism in a lot of ways.

SPEAKER_00It's iconoclastic at its core. And that to me is is very shocking, but also very disturbing. I don't think that the post-religious right is any more friendly to what it truly means to be human than the post-religious left will be.

SPEAKER_01Well, on post-religion, that that is a very good segue towards uh the the um the nature of religion here in Britain, which I know you have remarked upon of late. So there have been a few news stories which have piqued people's interests, but only a few people, which probably speaks to how post-religious we have become, because there really hasn't been too much of a a response to this on a wide scale. One of them is that Andy Burnham, Catholic Prime Minister, he's proposed legislation to let Catholics and Jews be able to appoint uh Church of England bishops and the Archbishop of Canterbury.

SPEAKER_01Um, this is something that has typically been um uh forbidden in the past. Um and then on top of that, uh St. Paul's Cathedral has um signed a deal with Fabric, which is a nightclub venue. Uh this was uh then um advertised with glee by the Muslim mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, these two iconic venues joining forces to provide an experience you'd never forget. Uh and then we've also had the Archbishop as the third story uh uh uh give out an interfaith award, then subsequently rescinded, to a man who had praised bin Laden.

SPEAKER_01Um some people have argued this surely is the end of the Reformation, but you've said nope, the the horse has bolted on that front. So my question to you is, is this the end of the Church of England?

SPEAKER_00That's uh yeah, I I I've been thinking all my life that you know the Church of England my of almost my entire life has just been one public relations disaster after another, and the sort of so the you know, will it come to an end? Who knows? But I certainly think the Church of England as as any kind of authoritative moral body or religious body, that's that's done at this point. Um the church is you know it's it's the punchline of a of a million bad jokes.

SPEAKER_00You know, the malale you know to to to give the the current Archbishop of Canterbury credit, I think she's she she proved pretty solid on the assisted dying stuff, in a way that more orthodox predecessors had had really been rather disastrous on that. But on this appoint this award to the the Muslim cleric, even uh a 30-second Google search should have revealed that there's a problem here. Even if you're into interfaith stuff, which I'm not, but even if you are, uh the PR problem should have been absolutely uh obvious.

SPEAKER_00And I think the award was given on 9-11. Was that was that? I mean, yeah, it's hard to believe that you're dealing with intelligent human beings when when so many I mean, we can all do stupid stuff, and I've done it myself. But there are moments when you think, wow, that that takes stupidity to the next level on a whole number of fronts. So um I I I think the Church of England has had an unenviable task over the centuries because it's in some ways it's an adjunct of the state, and that leaves it in an invidious position.

SPEAKER_00You know, there's always going to be a you know, is it faithful to the gospel or is it faithful to the state? Sometimes you can do both, uh, but often you can't, and that leaves you with a uh sort of an unenviable choice, and I think the church has made the wrong choice so many times that it's now uh undermined. As for the St. Paul's debacle, you know, the the group that St. Paul signed a contract with, again, a Google Yeah, I just when I heard about this, first thing I did was I Googled this company, and what do I see?

SPEAKER_00Stories about drug busts, deaths, etc. etc. Gosh, what you know I don't approve of churches signing deals with nightclubs anyway, but what a nightclub to choose. Um it's not just immoral, it's stupid.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And it also the tacit approval, uh in fact the explicit approval to dance on the graves of some of the most august people in English history. Uh that St. Paul's is a tomb as much as a place of worship, and uh it is uh But that this this this goes to show how nihilism really has in many ways crept in because uh well it's either that or the deluge of unbelievable information and news that we are hit with every day means that people can't respond to this.

SPEAKER_01And I don't know what to choose at this point because yes, the likes of you and I will go, what on earth is going on? This is crazy. Lots of people don't hear about it, but then those that do, it's almost like the shock factor is quite low now. And um, and perhaps it's also because they just don't value it. I mean, the amount of people that actually go to Church of England services is very few, and people generally visit perhaps as a tourist rather than a pilgrim or a worshiper. Um and I and and actually let's try to draw out for those people, and I don't know how many of those kind of people will be watching, uh having gotten this far, but let's try and draw out those people who see the kind of world that we are decrying the loss of as one that actually needed to be transgressed, that was stuffy and traditionalist, and one that was focused on power, ones that are people that might be um drawn to the ideas of Michel Foucault, who you've written lots about.

SPEAKER_01And he um wrote so much about transgression and domination, and he he wrote a lot about death too. Um and yet you have talked about his his life as um almost a uh a moral warning, which is you do become like the work that you do. And you invoke Psalm 115, where you say, Those who make them will be like them, and this is with regards to making idols.

SPEAKER_01I'm going to let you do the job of articulating what you mean by that as the warning, not to go down the Foucaultian worldview by talking about him and his ideas.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, but first of all, I mean Michel Foucault, for for any watchers uh who aren't familiar with him, he was born in 1926 in France. He died in 1984. Uh he's what we call a post-structuralist theorist. Uh he is he is one, if not the one of, if not the most cited man scholars in the humanities today. You know, over 40 years after his death, he revolutionized thinking about the humanities. And what he did was really he drew upon the thinking of Nietzsche, uh the 19th-century German philosopher, and used it as a way of of critiquing, you might say, the whole of culture.

SPEAKER_00You know, Nietzsche, in in his uh work, The Genealogy of Morals, says, you know, the the question of morality, we shouldn't be asking what is moral. We should be asking who is moral or who is considered moral. And Nietzsche's point there is that he he doesn't want to get at the content of morality, he wants to get at what morality does in society. And Nietzsche's answer is really it's it's all about power and manipulation. And Foucault picks up that mantle in the 20th century and uses it as a way of dismantling really all transcendent meaning.

SPEAKER_00You know, he'll even make dramatic statements. I think a statement like, you know, human nature is invented in the 18th century. And what he's trying to get at there is that the concepts we have are, you know, they emerge at points in history, they organize their thought, and they serve the they're in the service of power, those who have power, in order to sort of manipulate others. So Foucault is uh, yeah, I I think to describe him as a nihilist is is quite legitimate because he has you know for Foucault, everything's about everything can be reduced to questions of power.

SPEAKER_00He's not interested in truth, he's not interested in a hierarchy of truth, he can give no account of things getting better or worse. Uh perhaps his most notorious example of this is his uh book translated into English as Discipline and Punish, which begins with this horrific account of the the literally the tearing apart of this man who tried to assassinate the French king. Well, he then goes on to talk about how categories of justice, punishment, discipline, etc.

SPEAKER_00being used to shape and manipulate populations over time. But he treats the narrative as one as where it just changes. It doesn't get better, it just changes. So the idea that you know if I try to assassinate the president and I get sent to prison for the rest of my life, that's no better than me being torn to pieces by horses in a public execution. And I want to say to you, no, given the choice of prison for life or being, you know, quartered, uh I'm gonna choose the life sentence, actually.

SPEAKER_00But um so Foucault can give no gives no account of truth, be you know categories like beauty, they all have to be reduced to power, uh power plays. The tragedy of of Foucault's grip on the academic imagination, of course, is that I don't think you can explain life in purely Foucauldian categories. Towards the end of his life, when Foucault is dying of AIDS, uh accounts indicate that he really came to appreciate and value friends.

SPEAKER_00Well, on a Foucauldian account, you know, what is friendship? It can it can only be manipulative. Well, no, he his own life belied his theory at that point. And in the article I wrote, I quote from uh uh uh a famous French novel. Here it is, uh Hervé Guibert's to the friend who did not save my life, which was it was presented as a novel about the the friendship between the author and somebody dying of AIDS. In actual fact, it's a very thinly disguised account of Guybert's friendship with Foucault during Foucault's last last months as he's dying of uh of AIDS in a in a prison hospital.

SPEAKER_00And when Guibert meets Foucault for the for one of the last times, he goes into his his room in the hospital and Foucault's sitting in a chair staring out of the window, and Guybert asks him, you know, what's the matter? And and the Fouca Foucault says, I always thought that, you know, faced with something like this, you know, death, there'd be something to say. In fact, there is nothing to say at all. And that, I said in the article, reminded me of Psalm 115, that we become what we worship.

SPEAKER_00If you worship nothingness, you become nothing. And it connects to, you know, we're both Christians, you and I, John, it connects to the uh the idea of human beings made in the image of God. We worship God, and that's what makes us alive. If we worship stone or wood or nothing, we come to adopt the characteristics of that which we worship. If you like, we become the image of that which we worship, and that's why it's important to worship the living God and not some dead alternative.

SPEAKER_01Well, on the on the Imago Dei, the the the the the notion that we are made in the image of God, uh I know you've written uh a little on this of late, where you've argued that liberal democracy requires a specific metaphysics. Uh and th that specific metaphysics of the Imago Day uh is really seen as quaint superstition, I would say, amongst Britain British institutions and also just the general public. I've seen people criticising Danny Krueger of Reform UK for making reference to, in a recent conference speech, the Christian roots of the British nation.

SPEAKER_01And um, I suppose my question to you is given that lots of people have abandoned this ideal, even those who are sick of the progressive leaning of the institutions, do you think that liberal democracy can survive without the anthropology that had created it? And indeed our nations that were so wrapped up in it too, both the US and the United Kingdom?

SPEAKER_00I I I think I make a distinction between theory and practice here. I think practically, people can live very inconsistently. So it's possible that liberal democracy will survive even after abandoning its its anthropological roots in Christianity, because people are just inconsistent. I do think that uh on the theoretical level, though, no. A the a political theory of liberal democracy. Democracy requires an understanding of of what it means to be human, that we are free, responsible agents, and that we are interconnected because we share this thing called human nature.

SPEAKER_00That requires a metaphysics. And I I as I see it, the dominant metaphysics in the West has been a Christian metaphysics. Maybe uh atheist colleagues can find something that comes in to replace it. There's no evidence of that at the moment. And indeed we're seeing people like Richard Dawkins sort of thrashing around for something and having to go back to this cultural Christianity, which sounds to me like uh believing the best bits are true, even though you believe the metaphysical foundations are fundamentally false.

SPEAKER_00So I would I would char I I think as Christians we need to we need to go on the offensive a bit here and say, okay, if you want to build a world where human beings are respected, where uh the elderly are cared for, uh where young people are protected from themselves and from others, uh, you have to come up with a a coherent and stable understanding of what it means to be human. Where are you going to go for that? And what seems to me to be happening, of course, at the moment is we've lost our metaphysical grounding of what it means to be human.

SPEAKER_00We're seeing the emergence of this radical identitarian politics, uh both right and left. On the right we see it constructed in in sort of nationalist, ethnic, perhaps racial ways, and the left has its own uh equivalents of those in terms of sexuality, gender, and indeed when you think back to critical race theory, racial categories as well. I'm just reading a fascinating book at the moment that makes the case that the racial theories of the right and the racial theories of the left actually have a a considerable amount in common, uh precisely because they use the category of race as a way of cultivating a certain kind of elitism within our culture.

SPEAKER_01Well, we've talked quite a bit about the the dissolution of social norms uh that have been driven by uh many things from policy choices of successive governments to uh the swelling of this progressive worldview that has come to conquer all in many ways, and the anthropology that we had uh or the theological anthropology that we'd previously been moored to, uh has now been shifted.

SPEAKER_01One other method uh by which we are well what method but one other means by which there has been a dissolution has also been um the rise of uh technological um tools, those which uh immediate all aspects of our lives. So it began with the television, which we've talked about, the thing that can distract you from whoever you're in front of, entertain yourself or amuse ourselves to death, as Neil Postman put it in the 80s. And you could do that now on steroids with our own personal phones, as we've talked about.

SPEAKER_01Now, one thing I wanted to bring up, and to again link this to this Anglo inheritance, which uh when you look at the anthropology of the peoples who who live in the English-speaking world, there's always been a reliance on technology in which to be able to bring nature to bear. Things that could be useful to you. There are there are not that many of you, so what can you use to make your job easier? And obviously, that has now been turns towards just a Faustian technological development, which has led to a dissolving of our communitarian bonds that did exist.

SPEAKER_01So my question to you is the Anglo inheritance is necessarily technological, but is this genius for invention also our undoing? Is it destroying the conditions for our own human personhood?

SPEAKER_00Yes, great question, John. I think the simple answer is yes, it could be. And I think we need to, you know, there's some distinctions we need to make about technology here. Yeah, uh you know, a hammer is good for one thing, hammering in a nail. A smartphone can mediate the whole of life. Uh plus we can add to the technological developments. Uh we're now at the beginning, or we're now in the middle of, perhaps, what the German philosopher Hans Jonas identifies as the second technological revolution.

SPEAKER_00The first technological revolution, we might say, you know, the most dramatic example of is the industrial revolution. It it provides machines and tools that allow us to manipulate the world in dramatic ways previously unimaginable. Fundamentally changes our relationship to the things we make, changes our relationship to the world around us. The second technological revolution allows us to transform ourselves at an essential level.

SPEAKER_00Most obvious examples would be uh genetic engineering, for example, but they're not exclusively tied to that. Forms of reproduction uh would be another one. Um I would throw into the mix uh artificial intelligence, which is you know not simply a a tool. You know, most people when they think of artificial intelligence these days, they think of large language models and they use artificial intelligence as I use it, and that's as a kind of powerful and very efficient search engine.

SPEAKER_00You know, I I needed to find a quotation this morning. Do I look through all my books or do I just quickly type it into Chat GPT? I need the answer quick. But artificial intelligence also has this there called agentic artificial intelligence, where it's it's taking over human agency in powerful and profound ways. So I think we we stand, we face technological challenges on a whole heap of fronts at the moment that don't simply touch on our relationship to the world around us, but touch deeply on how we understand ourselves to be at our essential core and potentially deliver great power to manipulate and change that.

SPEAKER_00And so I think we are uh we're at a point where that question, what does it mean to be human, is taking on new and complicated dimensions.

SPEAKER_01I was going to ask the last question linked to your articles on England, uh, but I wonder if I should tie it into what you just talked about here, which is what we're facing into with this this technologically uh advancing era. And the question was centered around is there a refuge? And I was going to ask you whether America has been a refuge for you in some way for a changing England. And now talking about all of the things that we're facing, just broadly as a civilization, that you we we've got serious questions to ask about our own agency and how we live.

SPEAKER_01I suppose my question to you is is anywhere a refuge and where can people find refuge?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, certainly America is not a refuge. We have our own set of problems over here. Um I think I think the advantage America has over Britain is America's just a lot bigger. And it's easier to find those lands that time forgot, of the kind that my mum lives in in Gloucestershire. It's easier to find them over here. I live in the in the wilds of western Pennsylvania. Uh I remember during COVID, people were asking, you know, how you cope with lockdown. It was lockdown, you know, it's it was that kind of thing.

SPEAKER_00So America's a much bigger country and harder to police from that perspective. But it has its own problems. Um race runs like a it's like a running sore in American culture. I've seen articles recently about saying, you know, the French riots could come to America. But then I saw my friend Mary Harrington wrote an article saying, hang on a minute. It's actually the American riots going to France. You know, you had all these in 2020. And I think she she lands a good punch there that America is not a society at ease with itself.

SPEAKER_00So America's not a refuge. I think if there is a refuge, we find it in our in the rebuilding of our own homes. Uh you know, as a simple thing. Uh I I did, by the way, I didn't come to America to flee Britain. I came to America because I made a good job of her. Uh it was as crude as that, I'm afraid. Um one thing my wife and I did from the moment we arrived in America was we we tried to watch British TV uh as a shelter from American TV.

SPEAKER_00In those days you had to buy DVDs. We've got all of Father Ted on DVD. These days we stream it through Britbox. Uh trivial thing, but we try to make our home a place where, okay, at night we put our phones down, we talk to each other. Uh we have dinner around the table. We when our boys and and our family are in town, we have proper family sit-down dinners. We we don't mediate our lives through phones. Uh we'll sit and talk, we don't watch the TV all the time.

SPEAKER_00So I think we need to, you know, if if you're watching this and you're thinking, well, where can I flee? Where can I find start by building a home. And you don't have to be married to do that. You can you can make your home a place of hospitality even if even if you're not married. So I would say intentional reflection on your own life and your own space. That's the place to begin the resistance to what's going on. We don't have to make our own homes and our own families uh places of fear or cynicism, which is what the wider world is pushing us towards at this point.

SPEAKER_01Well, that seems like as good a place as any to wrap up on that that rousing call to arms, at least spiritual arms. Uh Carl, I won't ask you the boilerplate question that I've probably asked you three times already, uh, because I'm always asking you whether you've changed your mind on anything. And you can venture. You you you you you you can venture it if you wish. But I know you're generally usually pretty busy working on something. You are producing books left, right, and centre. You're being trotted out across many different continents to do talks.

SPEAKER_01Where can people find your work and what can we expect from you next?

SPEAKER_00Most of my regular work comes out at firstthings.com online. It's uh a publication of the Institute for Religion and Public Life. I have a column that I write there every two weeks. So that's where to go. And I'm continuing to think about anthropology, thinking about the issue of virtue, how we cultivate virtue in uh in a culture at this particular point in time. And also thinking about the the role of of technology and how that is transforming things. I have the great privilege in two weeks from now, actually just over yeah, two weeks from now of doing a double header with uh Paul Kingsnorth.

SPEAKER_00Oh yes, I saw that. That looks amazing. Um I I'm looking for we will I will be square. He's much cooler than me. He has more hair than me, which isn't difficult, of course. Uh but I'm very much looking forward to to spending time interacting with Paul Kingsnorth because I think he's I don't agree with it with everything he says, but I think he's really putting his finger on a lot of of issues. So hope I imagine those lectures will be put online at some point. So you can you can find me pontificating online also.

SPEAKER_01Hmm. That will be fascinating. I did see that come into my inbox. Remind me, who's the which organization's putting that on? It's a church in Atlanta.

SPEAKER_00Wow. Um I think Riverside Church. I think I can't remember the name of the church. I live 24 hours in advance, so I haven't thought that far ahead in detail. But it's uh it's somewhere just outside Atlanta.

SPEAKER_01Well, that'll be a lot of fun. I'll see if I can find a link which people might be able to follow for the YouTube when it comes out at some point. I'm sure Paul Paul definitely put something on an email, but I'll see. But yes, people should tune into that. I'm uh two two great minds. Carl, it's been an absolute pleasure, as always. I'll leave you to get on to your next engagement. Look forward to the fifth visit and keep fighting the good fight. Great. Thanks, John.

SPEAKER_00Lovely to chat to you as always.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. #153 - Oliver Bennett & Morgan Watkins - England Is 1,100 Years Old But The English Have Forgotten Who They Are

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 46 minAudio

    Oliver Bennett and Morgan Watkins are the co-founders of The Base and RADA-trained actors with nearly twenty years of experience in British film, television, and theatre. They join me to trace the English from their...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. #151 - Paul Morland & Philip Pilkington - Britain Is Going Bankrupt And Nobody Will Say Why

    Nov 5, 202656 minAudio

    Britain's economy is a demographic Ponzi scheme. The models don't work. The Treasury knows it. And nobody will say it out loud. Paul Morland and Philip Pilkington are the authors of Bust: The Economics of Population...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. #150 - David McGrogan - The British State Is Not Broken And The System Is Working Exactly As It Was Designed

    Oct 29, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    David McGrogan is a legal scholar at Northumbria University and the author of the Substack News from Uncibal. In this conversation, we think out loud about: • Why the intelligentsia wanted to show mercy to the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. #149 - Bella d'Abrera - How Australia Became A Warning For Every Western Democracy

    Oct 22, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Bella d'Abrera is the former Director of the Foundations of Western Civilisation Programme at the Institute of Public Affairs in Australia and the author of Mindless. In this conversation, we think out loud about: • How...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. #148 - Marie Kawthar Daouda - They Told Her She Was A Victim Of The West. She Became Its Greatest Defender.

    Oct 15, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Dr Marie Kawthar Daouda is a French-Moroccan scholar at the University of Oxford and the author of Not Your Victim. In this conversation we think out loud about: Why a French-Moroccan Oxford scholar wrote a love letter...

    Credit the people on this episode