Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Thinking Mind: Mental Health & Personal Growth

The Thinking Mind: Mental Health & Personal Growth artwork

E193 | A Psychiatrist Tries Stand-up Comedy: What I Learned About Fear

Nov 6, 202659 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What happens when a psychiatrist has to put his own advice about facing fear into practice? In this episode, Dr Alex joins Dr Rosy Blunstone, a psychiatry and psychotherapy registrar, to discuss his experience of trying stand-up comedy for the first time. From anxious rehearsals to jokes that didn’t land, Alex shares what helped him handle self-doubt, embarrassment and the vulnerability of being a beginner. Together, they explore: • Responding to the inner critic • Focusing on the process rather than the outcome • How perfectionism can stop us from starting something new • Why trying something scary is easier with a community • Making room for hobbies, play and enjoyment without needing to excel • Challenging limiting beliefs If there’s something you’ve always wanted to try but fear has held you back, this conversation is for you. What’s something you’d love to try - and what’s stopping you? Let us know in the comments. Presented by Dr. Alex Curmi with Dr. Rosy Blunstone. Dr. Alex is a consultant psychiatrist and a UKCP registered psychotherapist. Dr. Blunstone is a psychiatry and psychotherapy registrar. Get in touch: https://alexcurmitherapy.com/contact/ Check out The Thinking Mind Substack: https://thinkingmindblog.substack.com/ Speaking inquiries: https://alexcurmitherapy.com/speaking/ Coaching: https://alexcurmitherapy.com/practice/ Alex is not currently taking on new psychotherapy clients, if you are interested in working with Alex for self-development coaching, you can email - alexcurmitherapy@gmail.com with "Coaching" in the subject line. Give feedback here - thinkingmindpodcast@gmail.com Follow us here: Twitter @thinkingmindpod Instagram @thinkingmindpodcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back everyone. Today is a special episode for me. This is a podcast for someone who's always had something that they've wanted to try, something they've wanted to do, but fear has held them back. Maybe they feel they have to stick to their comfort zone. This is a podcast about getting out of your comfort zone. As regular listeners will know, one of the main thrusts of this podcast is self-development. So this is going to be one of those episodes. Something that I've been feeling for a while is it's had been a while since I walked the walk of getting out of your comfort zone rather than just talking the talk.

SPEAKER_00Obviously, for me, this podcast was a huge step outside my comfort zone when we started and the first years. But as it's grown to be like a regular part of my life, uh it's become a little bit routine. So I was feeling like I needed something new. I needed to try something new and you know, get out of my comfort zone again. By total chance, I came across this really interesting organization called Ultra Comedy. And what they do is they do free in-person training to help people do stand-up comedy for the first time.

SPEAKER_00So it's for people who have always wanted to try stand-up comedy but have never quite worked up the courage to do it. And at the end of this free eight weeks, you get to do a showcase in front of friends and family. Comedy is something I've always loved, I've always wanted to try stand-up comedy. And so, despite the fact that I was in an incredibly busy period of my life, I decided to do it. Thank you. Thank you so much. Thank you. And I have to say, it was amazing.

SPEAKER_00It was one of the most uh interesting, like psychologically interesting, but also fun experiences I've ever had. And one of the interesting things about it is it brought up like really old familiar feelings from years and years ago about you know how it feels to do something scary, to do something a bit challenging. And so I thought it would be amazing for to talk about for listeners, because we can talk about like specific psychological principles I used to help me to get through something like this.

SPEAKER_00These are similar principles thought I might use in therapy or with my coaching clients. So, again, this podcast is for you if you have something you've always wanted to try, but you've been held back by fear or perhaps shame or something like that. And this is going to be one of the most personal podcasts I've ever recorded. With me to discuss this is Dr. Rosie Bluntstone, a psychiatry and psychotherapy registrar. Rosie, thanks so much for coming on.

SPEAKER_01Oh, thanks for having me, Alex, and what an amazing introduction. Um, yeah, so you have become a stand-up comedian. Is that that's where we're up to here?

SPEAKER_00I wouldn't, I wouldn't go so far. I'd say I've tried stand-up comedy. So as of now, I've been on stage three times. So very much like at the very, very beginning. And it's so fun to be at the beginning of something, you know, because there's a few different things I do where I've done them for quite a few years, and there's there's such a magic, right? To being at the very start of something. I don't know what we're we'll talk about, you know, the future later, but um, it's it's been a lot of fun.

SPEAKER_01That's great. I'm so interested to hear about the process you went through in identifying that you felt like there was something new you wanted to do and that this could be it. Um, but one of the things I wanted to pick up on that you mentioned in your intro was despite it being a busy time in your life, you still decided that this would be a good point to pursue this opportunity. And I wonder, was there a tipping point or anything particularly that made you think I'm gonna do this now, even though it's not the right time?

SPEAKER_00I think a lot of it was just like logisticals. So this company, uh Ultra Comedy, shout out to Ultra Comedy, by the way. I think they're a great organization, and and I should say that it's also for charity. So you you do the eight weeks of comedy and you raise money for charity at the same time. Uh, and they only run a couple of events a year in London, and so it would either have been when I did it, which was between April and June, or I'd have had to wait another six months, and so there's parts of me that was a little bit impatient, like might as well do it now.

SPEAKER_00Um, it's something comedy is something I've always wanted to try, but it's so intimidating. I guess if you don't do something like ultra comedy, what you have to do is kind of write your material by yourself, show up to some random open mic night in some random bar, some random part of London, and just go for it not necessarily with a community or anyone around you who's helping you, and that is a very intimidating process. Where there's something about I think ultra comedy have really good marketing and they they they frame it as they're gonna walk you step by step through that process, and so even though I was quite busy, the fact that they're able to convincingly say, you know, it's gonna be much easier than it would otherwise be for you.

SPEAKER_00I think that's what tipped me over. And to be completely fair, they did deliver on that promise. So it wasn't just marketing, it was actually a really good service that they provided. Politeness goes out the window. Please and thank you. Gone. Someone says, Have a nice day at the coffee shop. I don't say have a nice day back.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's great, but I think as well, there's just something in that about there so infrequently is a right time to do things, and it can end up being a really um good barrier to us doing things that scare us, things that are new and different. And actually, sometimes it is just a case of knowing in your um in your own mind there there probably isn't going to be a perfect time, but likewise, um logistically, this is the best it's gonna get.

SPEAKER_01Um, and for all of the reasons you've listed, um, this opportunity may not present itself at a different time. So so you kind of had just had to crack on and just do it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it's also it speaks to being humble about what you're trying to achieve when you're doing something new. So in my mind, it was okay if the showcase didn't work out so well. In my mind, it was okay if I didn't wasn't as funny as I thought I was gonna be, or didn't give as good as a performance as I thought I could. The only thing that mattered is can I devote, you know, I thought about it quite practically, you know, can I devote the what I estimate it would be three or four hours a week? That's what it would require of me.

SPEAKER_00And once I figured out yes, I I think I can check that box, I can devote the more or less four hours that it needs, then the decision is straightforward. Whereas I think, and we'll talk, we can get into this a bit later, but I think if you're really um not clear on what you want to get out of something, you can your goals can be a little bit inflated. Maybe you think I have to be really amazing at this, and therefore that might require many more than four hours, and then it might seem totally unrealistic. Again, the analogy I always use is you know, you want to learn how to play piano and you expect to be playing Beethoven in a month.

SPEAKER_00Like it doesn't work like that. So immediately I'm being quite humble about what I'm trying to achieve. And my goal was literally to do it. So the goal is to try, and we'll, you know, you know, what happens happens, and that helps helps me make the decision as well.

SPEAKER_01Okay. And I was gonna ask you if you would share what your goal was. So I'm I'm glad you did that unprompted. But I guess out of interest, did you ever have any moments of thinking I'm not going to be able to do this, or even I regret saying I'll do this? And how did you overcome that if you did?

SPEAKER_00Yes, actually. So I had I decided over a couple of days, and I really wasn't sure because I have been dealing with a very, very intense work schedule. I'll be releasing an episode about this actually soon, but I've been dealing with a very intense work schedule for years. And so part of me was like, is this really helping me kind of manage work-life bands better? Because it is work, let's be clear, it's fun and creative, but it's also is work. So I was hesitant initially, then I signed up, and then about halfway through, maybe four or five weeks through, you know, things were pretty pretty busy, and I gave myself permission to quit.

SPEAKER_00You know, I said, I'm not sure if I'm gonna quit. Um, and it's not quitting because of fear exactly, or not being good enough, it's just pure logistics, it's just pure time, mental energy, and effort. And because that was quite high at a point midway through the training, I did say, you know, if it gets too much, you can quit. And how I sort of worked through was just go to the next training. So there's a training session every Sunday for this program. So I'm like, just go to the next training and see how it goes and what happens, happens. And if you quit, you know, no big deal because it's not quitting again out of fear necessarily, it's just quitting out because of logistics and time demands, and giving myself the permission actually allowed me to relax.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because I knew I I don't think quitting is always a bad idea. Sometimes you need to quit, you know. I I do believe in the occasional tactical retreat, and giving myself that permission allowed me to kind of actually persist ultimately and and and really enjoy it. I work as a therapist. This was not a good moment of my career, you know. My clients are amazing, but I was losing it.

SPEAKER_01I was yeah, I I I can totally recognize, even in myself, of of there being times of being very honest and upfront about, as you say, it wasn't a fear-based need to quit. Although I am interested how you knew that.

SPEAKER_00I think that um how did I know that? I think I'm I think I am capable of being uh honest enough with myself that this isn't if I did quit, it wasn't because I'm overwhelmed by feelings of fear and anxiety. It's because of the raw time constraints on my schedule and the raw time uh input that I know something requires.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there can totally be a difference, I think, in like the cadence, I suppose, of your like your thoughts and your feelings and how intense it may or may not be. And I think you can know in yourself if if decisions are being made from an anxious um avoidance type of a place to to completely sort of bodge that reference. But I think you can know that um and uh versus like you say, just the practicality of I'm not giving this what it needs at the minute because there's so many pulls, and and that's just a very honest self-reflection, isn't it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it speaks it speaks to the what the value of emotional literacy. And I would say some people are in a like a better position than others. You know, if you've done a lot of therapy or a lot of introspection, any introspective activity, you can recognize okay, it's this emotion is dominating. And for me, it wasn't fear, it wasn't really fear of what other people think, fear of being on stage or fear of not being good enough. It was like, wow, my time is being pulled in lots of the it was more overwhelmed, my time is pulled in lots of the different directions.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and sometimes having lots of different things going on, like you say, can actually be quite motivating, but there are times where it just starts to become overwhelming and and giving yourself the out can just kind of relieve you a little bit um and let you go back to then enjoying it. But I'm interested as well, then, because you did say just in your intro about some old familiar feelings that were brought up doing this, and I wondered if you could talk a bit more about that and what they were.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I think super important to clarify when I say I didn't give myself permission to quit because of feelings of fear, I'm not saying I didn't feel fear, I fent I felt plenty of fear and plenty of fear of like screwing up in front of people, and there were lots of times in the training where it resurfaces all feelings of um self-consciousness, anxiety, maybe some degree of shame, feeling of real um vulnerability and exposure.

SPEAKER_00There's something I think uniquely exposing about stand-up comedy. It's kind of just you and the mic, there's no one you can put the blame on if it doesn't go well, and I think there's something really uniquely exposing about trying to make a joke, you know, even in your personal interactions, you know, if you make a joke and it doesn't go down well, it doesn't feel good because people really value humour and they really devalue when someone attempts to be funny but it doesn't quite land. Um, so so one phrase I like to use to capture this is mental noise.

SPEAKER_00I think when you do something unusual that puts you out of your comfort zone, your brain responds with a lot of mental noise and cognitive behavior therapy. This is called negative automatic thoughts. In something like Gestalt psychotherapy, they may call that an interject, like an unhelpful message from the past, which you may have internalized. Um, and they're just all these really, really unhelpful thoughts. So thoughts like that might sound like, who do you think you are?

SPEAKER_00This is stupid, you're gonna make a fool of yourself, you know, people are gonna think badly of you. And those thoughts, I was, you know, they're they're thoughts that I might have now and again, but I was surprised at how intensely they came up, you know, going to the trainings, trying out my jokes with my classmates in my training and the run-up to the showcase, they definitely came out in full force. And again, I'm just lucky that I have the kind of psychological training that I can kind of recognize what's happening. So my brain is generating thoughts which I feel are unhelpful, and then I have an idea of how to respond to them.

SPEAKER_00And this is something I would do if I was coaching someone, I would try and elicit these thoughts, like if they're happening, of course, uh, and help the person identify them and respond to them.

SPEAKER_01And did you find then that that was helpful for you in your specific um background in this training? And likewise, was there a difference then with other people? Because I'm assuming the other people that were going to the training didn't have your background in psychiatry and and psychotherapy. Did you find that there was a real difference in how you were communicating these these fears and thoughts, or or did you keep them to yourself anyway?

SPEAKER_00So I think I kept a lot, I kept them to myself, but my so the training just helps because I'm just aware, okay, this is something the brain does and this is how I'm gonna respond. Obviously, my classmates mostly aren't from psychology, but they you could see them kind of figuring out as well. So there, you can see them, you know, everyone's anxious. I wasn't, I think I don't think I was any less anxious than anyone else, but you can see the other people also kind of figuring out more as they go along, realizing okay, I'm feeling fear, my brain is telling me stuff that's really unhelpful.

SPEAKER_00Um, and you could see them saying out loud, you know, the kind of positive affirmations I might do internally that I just know how to do. So the positive affirmations might look like something like who would have the courage to do this, this is good just because I'm doing it, it doesn't matter what the end result is, I'm learning all these really cool new skills, I'm meeting all these new people, the fact that I'm willing to fail is a really cool thing. And you could see them coming, realizing that and starting to say it to it to themselves and each other.

SPEAKER_00And so, one other huge principle that you might use when you're doing something scary, in addition to kind of recognizing mental noise and and responding with more positive affirmations, is community, like doing it something with a bunch of other people is so it's like a hundred X easier. Uh, which is you know why this training was so attractive. Because for most people, stand-up is a very lone wolf. People often do it alone, especially in the beginning. And having people around, it means you don't necessarily need to go to a therapist, you know, or a coach because everyone's kind of coaching each other with positive the vibe was really, really positive.

SPEAKER_00Uh, and and so it's just it really for me highlighted the value of having a group of people around you all helping each other.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think I think you're so right in the level of accountability, maybe, because you're all putting yourselves through this together, so you turn up for each other, and that that is a principle around lots of sports, and the reason why these you the the commitment to uh another community or or a team can be really good for getting you out to do things you might not do for yourself. I've got to ask, you've said then that there were lots of positive affirmations around it's okay if I fail.

SPEAKER_01So, did you have any moments of uh kind of tumbleweed where jokes didn't land? And I guess how are you picking yourself back up after that if it happened?

SPEAKER_00So the showcase went really well. I have no complaints about the showcase, and one thing you want to understand about stand-up comedy before you start is you've got warmer audiences and cold audiences. So, something like the showcase, you know, our our instructor. So we had an instructor who is a legit comedian. Shout out to Tom Short, he's done fringe shows and stuff like that. He's opened for like huge comedians across the UK and he teaches, he taught our course. Um, and he said the the showcase is kind of like the Disneyland of comedy gigs because it's the vibe is positive, it's for charity, people know it's for charity, it's a lot of family and friends in the audience, and so you're gonna get on average a better response than you might get at your standard uh open mic night at the local pub.

SPEAKER_00And for me, you know, the for most of us, the showcase went really, really well. And but I've been on stage twice since then at more regular open mic nights, and it's you know, it's a bit more touch-and-go in terms of how certain jokes land or the response that you get. And the first time you kind of stell a joke in front of a group of people on stage and it doesn't land, it's kind of like getting punched in the face a little bit, you know, emotional, it's kind of like a little bit of an emotional punch in the face, and uh it's it's it hurts, it doesn't feel good, but then the cool thing is the next time it happens, it's kind of not as bad, and the time after that it's not as bad, and then you you know you land the joke and it's it does well.

SPEAKER_00So so what one of the deepest principles I might use for something like this is a principle from Eastern philosophy, which is attachment to process, not to outcome. So I'm not trying to get every laugh for every joke, I'm trying to become the best at comedy within reasonable constraints that I can at that time. I'm just trying to deliver the best performance I can at any given time, and there's obviously some similarities between those two, but there's some important differences.

SPEAKER_00You're not seeking the audience's approval, you're not, you're trying to construct and perform the best joke possible, and if the audience likes it, that's great, and if they don't, so be it. That's how well you did that time. And I kind of again, because I kind of have an understanding of this, especially from podcasting where we're like almost 200 episodes deep. I had an understanding that very, very early. Two gigs, three gigs is like nothing, it's like going to the gym two or three times. It's it's a it's such it's so early in the in the journey of anything to do it two or three times, and that helps me give perspective that's not a big deal.

SPEAKER_00It's not a big deal if the joke doesn't land because it's like it's like a grain of sand ultimately in what someone's journey with this thing could become. So I I think having that perspective, even though it still hurts, especially the first couple of times, is really helpful. So if anyone is like trying something new and they're in the early stages, it's okay. Recognize you're in the early stages. Failure is normal, failure makes it more exciting, can actually get a bit boring sometimes when you're deep into something and you can just reliably do it well.

SPEAKER_00You know, if I I do a podcast and I kind of know I can reliably do a podcast well, it's still fun, but it's not quite as exciting as those touch and go, touch-and-go days where like anything could happen, you know?

SPEAKER_01I do, and I think that again, it's a really interesting observation about how frequently, though, we can accept that as a safe space, your comfort zone, um, and kind of why would I do anything to mess this up? And something like the stand-up comedy is really, you've already said it's really exposing. And um it couldn't I I mean I just don't think it could be further from the sort of perception of a psychiatrist and psychotherapist standing up there and making people laugh.

SPEAKER_00So the Nazis can I sell it on social charity, okay?

SPEAKER_01Because so much of what we do in our day-to-day is is not about humour, really, um, although it is about observation. And I wonder that um there is something in the skill set of people who work in our fields, so particularly around supportive people with mental health, that observation and listening and picking up on cues might have been helpful.

SPEAKER_00I think someone's intuition might be like the best person at stand-up comedy would be a natural extrovert. And I think there's truth in that, like extroverts probably have advantages. A lot of psychologists and psychiatrists were more introverts. We don't express ourselves as much. We tend to receive. We receive other people, we kind of dive into their worlds. But I think a lot of great stand up comedians are actually introverts by nature because introverts spend a lot of time in their own heads. Thinking about things, um, thinking about other people, observing other people, as you've said, and trying to find the and uh and I think introverts are a bit more accustomed to weirdness and some of the strange aspects of living which might not occur as much to an extrovert.

SPEAKER_00Obviously, there's actually other personality traits which we would have to account for, but still extroverts they're often in the external world, they're talking to people. Introverts are often doing that deep level thinking, especially on one-on-one relationships, and there's a lot of like weird stuff there, you know, and and also weirdness about oneself. I think introverts are a bit more familiar with their own weirdness, which can then be really awesome material.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I think that's true, and I I I definitely think um the process by which you're putting together material, if you are okay a little bit with your weirdness and you're okay with the possibility that your weirdness is going to come through a bit more, then you can hopefully just explore those corners of your mind that are likely to be able to evoke the most response, whether or not it's positive, other people find it funny, at least you're willing to go there.

SPEAKER_01Because presumably you're when you're putting the all the material together, you there's a seeking out of a limit to which you can reach so that it's surprising, unusual, and the um and the and then funny versus keeping it safe because if it's too safe, it won't entertain and it won't be funny.

SPEAKER_00No, you can't obviously the intention all jokes are trying to provoke in some way, obviously, many different levels as to how someone can provoke. But every joke is like a little bit of a provocation. And I would also say, just on the personality point, I think the the trait that's probably undeniably most useful for comedy is trait openness to experience in the big five. So I think I wouldn't say introverts or extroverts are better at comedy, one over the other, but I think being relatively high in openness to experience is very advantageous because that's about exploring ideas in a new way, thinking about things differently, and also seeking novelty and new experiences.

SPEAKER_00And many psychiatrists, psychologists are tend to be high in openness to experience. And I I think that's a trait that is super, super advantageous for comedy.

SPEAKER_01I was interested because we just started talking a little bit about the process of building material, and I cannot stop thinking about you telling me that certain words are funnier than others, and that you had learned this through doing your training. Um, and so something I was just interested in is about how about the process of developing material, but also how do you know when you're done? Like how did you how did you know this was the final act?

SPEAKER_01I'm not going to tinker with that anymore. Tell me about that.

SPEAKER_00That's that's a really good question. So so one thing, so one of the most basic, basic principles I use when doing something, when changing behavior, doing something new is you have to grade it. Take the big scary thing, in this case, it's stand-up comedy, and you grade it. And this is the value of doing a course. So if you're wanting to try something and there is a course available, whatever the thing is, you should probably do it because the nice thing about courses is they grade it for you. You don't have to think about it.

SPEAKER_00Um, some courses are better than at doing this than others. This particular course, Ultra Comedy, was really good at grading. So, again, the teacher, uh Tom Short, I think we did three training sessions before we even got to writing jokes. The first three sessions were being comfortable standing up in front of people, being relaxed standing in front of people, because of relaxation is so important and conducive to comedy, whereas like being really anxious, unless you're being anxious performatively, which is different, but being anxious in inherently is so uh antithetical to comedy, and then just talking, talking and and talking and acting and walking around the stage in a relaxed way, and what you what you find out is that when you do that, kind of you're creating a space for natural comedic things to emerge.

SPEAKER_00So, one of the exercises we might do in those first three sessions is maybe just repeat the same word over and over again. Uh an exercise I get to repeat the same word over and over again. And what you see is once the person saying the words gets relaxed and the audience gets relaxed, funny funniness emerges. Funniness is kind of like this emergence property which just comes out. So that's just before you even get to all of that happens before you even get to joke writing. When it comes to actual material, the process is basically you're gonna write your best guess as what you think is funny, and that could be a really conventional joke with a very conventional premise setup punchline, or it might be a story, or it might be like a fantasy, could be basically anything that you think it's your best guess.

SPEAKER_00And then the process of comedy is you perform it, you get feedback, like what's working, what's not working, you kind of dissect the performance, verbal, non-verbal. Is it the joke itself? Is it how it's written, it's how I'm delivering it, is it all of it, and then go back, rewrite, edit, test again. So this is what professional comedians do. They will they they don't start out with their hour of really funny material, they'll go on stage in little clubs, like little clubs around London, for example, they'll do 15 minutes of a time at a time and they're testing.

SPEAKER_00So often when people watch comedy and like, oh, Jimmy Carr is in the club for like and does 15 minutes, they're really unimpressed because they're like, I saw Jimmy Carr do his hour show, and that was incredible, and then he did 15 minutes at the comedy store, and it was like really mediocre. But what you don't understand is that's how comedy gets made is people are testing out their jokes in front of the audience. So the the big secret is you don't know what's funny as much as you think you do. You write something and you think, Wow, this is super funny, and then you test it, and for whatever reason it doesn't work, then you can either tweak it and make it work, or very, very often you just scrap it entirely and write something new, and obviously you get better with time, and hopefully, your intuitions that as to what you think is funny gets better, I'm sure it does.

SPEAKER_00But super relentlessly important is testing, feedback, and then editing based on the feedback. So, one thing I knew to do again, because I know about psychology, is I recorded all of my practice sets, so all the sets I did in front of my classmates, um, I recorded all of them. So I knew what joke was working to a T and what wasn't working, so I could edit. And then, in terms of your other question, like when do you when are you done? I think the truth is you're never done. So even the five minutes that I did in my showcase that worked really well and still works well, could still be improved, I'm sure, in many ways.

SPEAKER_00But you kind of have to at some point just be okay with it and be like, this is the best I've done so far. And and but it is kind of a living, breathing thing, and I, you know, you could continue to tinker with it. I don't think there's like a you don't know it's done per se, but this is the best I can do right now, and you kind of have to accept that. And then I think there's a value to moving on doing something that's entirely different, just like you know, if I was coaching, if I were coaching an artist, I would say, you know, at some point just be done with that painting, move on to a different painting because you learn a lot more if you do 50 paintings in a year than if you spend one year trying to perfect a single painting.

SPEAKER_00And I there are some studies which justify that approach.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm interested that you use the the P-word perfect. And I think again, when we're thinking about sort of the barriers that can keep um somebody from trying something new, perfectionism actually can be one of them, right? Because that sense of just not being able to get out and do the thing because it doesn't feel perfect yet, and I'll know when it's perfect, but until it's perfect, I'm not going to do it. And actually, that can become a real reason that you don't just give it a go and learn that good enough is usually is good enough and and and get going.

SPEAKER_00I I think comedy is amazing because it's anti-perfectionistic. You basically can't be a comedian if you're too perfectionistic. Um, every show is different. People who do plays, I'm sure, will tell you the material is exactly the same in a play, it's very standardized, every performance is different, and that's even more true in stand-up. What you're really creating is you're creating that special kind of interaction between you and the audience on that night, and you could deliver the same routine, pitch perfect, and it could do much better or much worse.

SPEAKER_00And actually, what you shouldn't be doing is trying to, I don't think my conclusion from doing this training, and again, I'm not an expert, an actual comedian could correct me, but my conclusion is you shouldn't really try and think of it as like delivering standard material to a different audience. You should think, okay, I have this material and I'm going to interact with the audience one line, one line at a time. You're giving them something, and they're giving you something back in terms of how they receive it, and that'll that could and should, I think, influence how you then deliver the next thing, and then then you might do something you've never done before.

SPEAKER_00If something funny occurs to you in the moment, you might do something new. So I think it's generally better to think of it as a much more organic thing that night's particular thing as it happens. It was very strange. I thought about it, and then I realized what it was. There's too much happening right now in the modern world, it's crazy. We've got Bitcoin, AI, Ukraine, the economy, no one could buy a house. We have all these things happening and all these ways of finding out how it's happening, but we don't know how it's gonna end. World War II was the worst thing that could have happened, but we know how it ends.

SPEAKER_00Like, think how bad World War II was. In World War II, this country was at such great risk of Nazi invasion and takeover that the then Prime Minister Winston Churchill had to go on the radio, and for the Gen Z members of the audience, the radio is like a podcast. So Churchill went on a huge podcast.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and there, but there's a real bravery to that then. And and you've mentioned about um there being an intuition about the audience. Um, is that something you have? Do you develop that? Because in my mind, this is a room full of strangers, and you've spoken about what it's like to make people laugh, but they're your friends or your family, and then it not landing and it being frankly mortifying. Um but you can generally gauge that based on who you're talking to.

SPEAKER_01You know what they might or might not find funny, and so a joke might occur to you when you say it. But when it's a room full of strangers, where does that intuition about um how to gauge it come from? Is it learned or do you just have it?

SPEAKER_00I think I'm probably too early to speak intelligently about it. As I said, I've done this three times. So far, my experience is you just get you're taking in all of this information, you're taking in people's facial expressions, those that you can see, you're taking in the laughter, the lack of the laughter, or someone might like gasp, or someone in the back might cackle, or someone might heckle. You have all of these data points, and I think there's just this feeling of the what the vibe in the room is, and you're kind of responding to that.

SPEAKER_00And when it's going well, um, you might be like, Oh wow, they're liking it even more than expected, and then that's gonna lead me to use these two lines that I had kind of in reserve that I wasn't sure I was gonna use, but I'll use them now, and this happened in the showcase. Um, but if it goes the opposite, obviously the natural human tendency is to withdraw, and in comedy, you kind of have to fight that tendency, and you actually have to. I think it's crucial to maintain the conviction you have around your jokes, which doesn't mean being super serious, but it does mean continuing to deliver your jokes congruently, as in I think this is really funny, and I'm gonna perform it as well as I can, even if the last joke didn't land, and that's like you know, I'm sure part of the skill set of every new comedian is to maintain that congruence and confidence, even when you feel at a gut level, I'd say it's a gut feeling, um, it is in that it's going super well.

SPEAKER_01And and I wonder as well, about you've already spoken that there's a lot of prep and a lot of training that goes into this. And again, we can sometimes fall into the trap of assuming that the the first time we encounter somebody doing something is their first time at this. For instance, you spoke about the showcase. Um, it would be uh a relatively normal assumption to think, oh, this guy's just stood up there and he's just funny. And actually, I think what you've done is explain that there's a there's a lot of work that goes into getting to that point.

SPEAKER_01Um, and you are being quite spontaneous in the moment and and moving through the paces and responding, but responding based on probably some learned cues from all that training that you did beforehand.

SPEAKER_00Yes, and I I think part of the goal is to make it look effortless because effortlessness again is relaxing. The audience are taking their cues from you as to how relaxed to be, and so part of the performance is to be relaxed in your delivery, and again, unless you're doing something performatively, like you could be performatively angry or performatively anxious, but like at a deeper level, the audience intuits that you're actually quite relaxed and this feels super effortless, and that is part of the performance.

SPEAKER_00But for anyone who doesn't know, and some people still don't really understand, for the most part, stand-up is a very prepared performance, especially at a professional level. If you're watching an hour of stand-up on TV or someone, a professional comedian doing like a formal show, not an open mic night at a club. A ton of work has gone into that, and that's usually a combination of literally writing in a room by yourself and then testing out your material in different contexts. So the material I did in the showcase, I had tested at least three different times and like training sessions.

SPEAKER_00I had like recorded it, I'd gone over the recordings, I wrote by myself, I tested with friends, I rewrote with friends. So so probably five minutes, this is five minutes of material we're talking about, probably took about five or six hours of work, in addition to just the other training sessions and the other stuff I did. But just for those five minutes, six hours of work. So you get you get to understand the ratio is quite intense.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And and when you've got a short period of time to deliver that material, you've got to make sure that each bit counts, I suppose, because there's probably lots of other stuff you could have put in, but you're trying to make sure that the bits you put in are the are the the main things.

SPEAKER_00And that's that's why I think it's really good. One of the other reasons I want to do it is to help me as a public speaker and a podcaster. And one of the huge uh not flaws, but maybe vulnerabilities of being a podcaster is it's super easy to waffle on and on and not actually say anything or value. Whereas stand-up really taught me, you know, you have 30 seconds to deliver this idea and this setup premise, punchline, whatever. And it really teaches you that you can be much more uh you can have much more economy of words even in podcasting, and you should, because you know, you don't want to waste people's time.

SPEAKER_01Well, frankly, Alex, I don't know what you mean about waffle. Um I was just gonna ask you, because this is actually almost like a complete contradiction of what I just said, but I I in addition to there being a lot of work that goes into doing a performance like you were doing in stand-up comedy, I also think that there is something really interesting about how enjoyable it is to make people laugh, and that it feels like a really sort of human thing. And I wondered if you'd had any thoughts in the process or or afterwards about that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, my my main feeling is it was just super fun, it was the best, it was a really nice, you know, a lot of my work obviously is about people's difficulties and suffering that we all go through. And I find that work very valuable and in many ways enjoyable, but it was really nice, it was a really nice counterbalance to do something where just like the goal is to have fun, and even though it requires work, almost every stage of it was a lot of fun. Um, it was really nice to be in a room with lots of different people from all walks of life, so many differences you could point out between all of us, but we are uh unified by this very, very like niche goal of we just want to get up in front of people we don't know and tell really funny jokes, and uh it sounds corny, but it was just very it was very enriching.

SPEAKER_00It was like a very enriching uh experience to have such a simple goal, very, very the simplicity of it was very uh refreshing.

SPEAKER_01And I suppose you've mentioned then about the goal that was simple, which you've achieved, and yet you're still going. So have the goals changed, or has some something new come through or new motives that you're aware of for keeping going? Can you talk about that?

SPEAKER_00So, because I I have a lot of different work things going on, you know, a lot's going on behind the scenes uh at the podcast and the other uh kinds of work that I do, I am deliberately keeping my goals uh around comedy super small and humble, and really I'm kind of just doing it every now and again for fun, and fun is really the goal, and not pressuring, putting much pressure on myself again, still may could that change in the future?

SPEAKER_00Maybe, um, but I have way too much other stuff going on right now to be super serious. So, my current goal is to maybe go on stage, and and London's like one of the best places in the world to do stand-up because it all there are so many stages. But my goal is to go on stage, you know, once a week, maybe once every two or three weeks, to you know, write a little bit of material here and there and to have fun, so it's kind of in the hobby category right now. So I'm being very intentional about that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that's great. I think it's great to have goals around um things being fun, and it's actually something that comes up quite a lot in therapy is trying to help people to identify ways in which they can do things for themselves that is completely for self-enjoyment alone, um, and and leads back to this idea about play and how important it is for both adults and children to play. Um, and a lot of the time, what you're trying to do is to encourage people to stretch their imagination, to um try things that they're less comfortable with but giving it a go regardless, and to understand where rules are that need to be observed and where they're not, and that communication and interaction and collaboration, all these skills um actually all develop through through play and having fun.

SPEAKER_01Um, and sometimes it's so uh enriching um to explore the possibilities without it being something that you have to uh win at um or in some ways kind of progress with. It just literally can be for fun's sake. Um, and I think that's really refreshing, actually.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think you hit the nail on the head. You don't have to win. Stand up is a bit of an uncomfortable thing because you feel like if you don't win, it can be quite embarrassing. I think once you get used to it, that's not a huge issue. But whatever it is, you it might be for the person listening, something where you don't have to win. Life can get so you know, life gets serious.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I'm in my mid-30s, life gets very serious, and it feels like I think there's this unconscious idea that you can't play or you shouldn't be having fun, and then what having fun looks like is okay, going out for dinner for like the thousandth time, or like having adult fun, but something that's really playful, where you can break rules. He's looking down at me. I'm looking up at bread, it's like, sorry, I'm late. And I'm like, no, monsieur, Pete, you're just in time.

SPEAKER_00Where you can, you know, be yourself, where you don't have to conform to certain like boundaries and restrictions. I think definitely for people who work in serious professions like ours is a really nice tonic for that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, agreed. And I think also just going back to the idea that um none of us are um experts in everything, and one of the nicest things that um I've really got out of being a mum is I watch my toddler learn new ways of doing things. And actually, I think I spoke to you about this um a little while ago, but actually, one of the things she loves to do is to make people laugh. And that was why I was asking you before about do you think it's something that's just a human thing?

SPEAKER_01And and I wonder that there is something about that connection that she gets from making us laugh with her at her, with her. But it feels like something that's really important to and she really enjoys it. And I like then that she's enjoying it. But likewise, um as we as she explores her world with us and also independently, the play aspect and the fun aspect becomes the way in which she learns the next rule of the next game with the older kids, etc.

SPEAKER_01etc. Um, and there's there's no better way for people to be learning, I think. And you know, as the research has upheld too, but as you say, we lose it as we get older and it starts to feel like we have to justify it. If it feels fun and it's enjoyable, it feels like something we have to justify. And actually, I think from what you're saying, that doing something that's scary and out of your comfort zone, meaningful but fun, is a great way to um be exploring new ways of uh of adulthood and this sort of this chapter of um of your life, really.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think if we if we want to get nerdy about it, humor has all sorts of important functions. It helps us deal with darkness, difficulty. Humour is in psychoanalytic thoughts regarded as one of the mature defense mechanisms. So a really immature defense mechanism might be something like denial, you know, pretending something is unreal, or splitting, you know, saying things are either all good or all bad. But humour is regarded as a mature defense mechanism because it's something a joke or a humorous way of seeing something kind of is is a way of acknowledging the difficult reality of something while also getting a bit of relief and release and a bit of a laugh out of it as well.

SPEAKER_00And the other thing you picked up on, I think, watching your your toddler, is that humor is a way of trying to figure out the boundaries, like what's acceptable versus what's not acceptable. And a great joke lands right on the borderline between acceptable and not acceptable, or it takes something unacceptable and makes it more acceptable, or sometimes it takes something acceptable and makes it slightly more shocking and less acceptable. So jokes are always not always, but jokes are often playing on this line: what can we tolerate in our culture and our society, and what can't we?

SPEAKER_00And that's why I think comedians and jokes in general have such a huge importance in terms of political satire, you know, scrutinizing the status quo, helping minority voices speak louder. So, I mean, there's all sorts of things you could say, and you also use the word meaningful, and I think that's very important as well. So, definitely in this episode, we're not advocating doing something scary, just something scary, but the sweet spot is something that's scary but meaningful to you specifically as an individual.

SPEAKER_00So if you uh are really scared of rock climbing, but you have no interest in going rock climbing, don't go rock climbing because it's just you're just gonna have a bad time, right? But if you've always wanted to do salsa dancing, always wants to do somehow in your heart of hearts, but you're afraid of it, then that's the thing. That's the sweet spot where I think something really rich can come about.

SPEAKER_01That's a very important nuance and why it's so important uh to have a thought about what are the goals for doing something, and that goals have to be individual. And I think sometimes when you're starting a on a therapeutic journey, for instance, and people ask you about your goals, it can feel like sort of uh a somewhat pointless task, perhaps about well, my goal is just to feel better. Um and for most people, of course, that's true. But what you're also trying to say is, shall we identify some things that you you haven't been able to do before that you would like to do and work towards them together?

SPEAKER_01And they are completely individual because, as you say, it one person's goal is is terrifying and pointless to somebody else, and this it would not be motivating in the least. Um, I'm neither a rock climber nor a salsa dancer. Um, and you know, and so we're on different journeys, and that's okay. Um, but in order to make the therapeutic relationship um productive and um collaborative, you what you're trying to do is to find something that for that person um is individual and not just, I suppose, not just a therapeutic um relationship, but that was just the one that when you talk about goals as a C therapist, that's the one that pops into it speaks my language.

SPEAKER_00Um and if you're not sure, if you're not sure about what the goal might be for you or what the thing might be for you that you want to try, then I would just say experiment. So try lots of different things and then watch your own reaction. Does the thing make me feel excited? Does it make me feel fascinated? Or does it make me feel bored or just pure fear without any kind of intrigue? So the goal might be to figure out what the goal is, and that's okay as well. And then you just want to get a ton of experience with different things to find out what it is that seems to um resonate with you.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and figure out the feelings too, because you were very insightful about uh it not being a fear-based decision to perhaps not go along with it. But again, that that that takes a level of um self-knowledge and um insight that we don't all have. And but you get it from trying and understanding, and maybe something's like you say from quitting, and then saying, Gah, I think I'm I think I made a fear-based decision there. Perhaps not in that language, but um uh and I'm reflecting on it and doing it differently next time.

SPEAKER_01But the point is not to not to not do it, the point is to give it a go.

SPEAKER_00One of one of the maybe strongest themes which I'm trying to promote on the podcast is self-knowledge shouldn't be like even though it sounds like it is, it's not an intellectual activity primarily. I think you get a ton of self-knowledge from propelling yourself into the world and trying like a bunch of stuff and seeing what happens. And you learn about the world when you do that, but you also learn about yourself, and that was one of the big things we discussed with the existential psychotherapist Amy Van Diersen, and she's huge on that. And she herself is a shining example of that.

SPEAKER_00She's tried so many things in her life. It's like you you really, if you're not in the world enough, you need to get in the world that will, if you do that intelligently and reflect, you'll just learn a ton about your yourself doing that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and the fundamentals of CBT is um exactly that is experimenting and and and recording the outcomes of those experiments. But fundamentally, the idea is that you're going to learn that your assumptions about the world, which may well have been framed by a negative mindset, actually are not upheld. So the idea that you'll won't be able to cope if something bad happens is usually not upheld. Fundamentally, most people do cope and cope well, and the outcome is generally not as bad as you thought it was going to be.

SPEAKER_01But you've got to try, and that's where the learning happens. Um, because the assumption otherwise the assumptions are all you're going to know, and that you don't give an opportunity to do things differently.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely.

SPEAKER_01We have covered all from personality traits to um some existential um psychiatry and a bit about the fundamental human uh skill of humour. Was there anything else that you thought was a real kind of I cannot leave um this podcast or miss this opportunity without um discussing or reflecting on?

SPEAKER_00So maybe just a couple more things. Again, if you're early on in something, a trap that people fall into is they overcomplicate it. So maybe you're learning piano and you think I have to learn how to read sheet music, I need to learn my rhythm, I need to learn the timing, I need to learn like every aspect all at the same time. And usually the cool thing about being at the beginning of something is there's probably two or three things you need to focus on and don't overcomplicate it with too much. So if you're new to comedy, you basically all you have to do is write jokes, go on stage as much as possible and tell tell them, record them, go over them, and then use that to edit and rewrite.

SPEAKER_00And that's all you need to do. You just need to do that, and that could probably get you through five years of getting better at this. There are like some fundamental things, and so if you're starting something and you kind of just recognize what are these five most highest leverage things that I need to do. Like if you're starting a podcast, you need to be on the microphone often, coming up with ideas, record them, listen to it, edit it, put it out, get as much audience feedback as you possibly can. Repeat, repeat, repeat.

SPEAKER_00More sophisticated, nuanced stuff can come in later. So if you're at the beginning, your mind will try and overcomplicate it, it will. Time blocking. Decide when am I gonna work? So for me, I you know, the training sessions for this were on Sunday. So I said Sunday morning, I'm gonna write and edit, and then Sunday afternoon I have the training session, so I knew when I was gonna work on it, and that relaxed me as well.

SPEAKER_00I don't have to think how am I gonna balance it with everything else. Anything creative, you want to have idea capture. So this is a very fancy word, which just means when an idea randomly occurs to you on the tube or in the shower, quickly go and have a thing where you put all your random ideas. The the some of the most successful jokes that ended up in my five minutes occurred to me on the train, going to and from the training sessions, just me thinking about it spontaneously, not even actively working.

SPEAKER_00It wasn't my active writing and editing time, but the idea occurred to me, and I put it in my phone, and then I looked at it when I was actually writing, and I put it in the five minutes, and it's like we will find them on the beaches, and we will find them on the hills and in the landing grounds and in the streets, and we will never surrender. Can you imagine Keir Starman? Sorry, did I say Keir Stalman? I meant instead prime minister of the month. Can you believe that prime minister in this country has fallen to the prestige level of substitute teacher?

SPEAKER_00That's kind of the right thing. So creativity will occur to you when it happens. Often it's when we're not like actively brainstorming, and so idea capture, just a simple notes app on your phone, Google Docs, something you can access at all times. I think the last the last thing I definitely want to mention is I uh this thing of allowing for identity level change, allow for your identity to be flexible. Um you might, if you're an accountant and you want to try stand-up comedy, part of your brain might go, Oh, I can't do comedy.

SPEAKER_00Why? Because I'm an accountant. Try to be more flexible about your identity. Um, we are we're humans are very complicated and we can be lots of different things. Well, the makes one of the things that makes humans humans is our adaptability when we put ourselves in a new situation. We kind of become something else, especially if we do it for a long time and we really engage and try our best. So don't let like identity constraints uh constrain you too much and allow for that kind of flexibility. I think those those are the most, those are the key things I really wanted to mention today.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that's fascinating. And I think it leads back to a lot of the things that we often talk about when I talk, for instance, about my daughter and watching her explore and evolve. And and I think you're right in that we we get to phases of our lives where we start to feel like this is just who I am, uh, and rightly or wrongly um we lean into all the ideas and expectations that go with that, um, and that there can be such a freedom in just saying, well, who decides?

SPEAKER_01I decide. Yeah. And go doing something that that that you want to explore. And then it can also be a facet uh of the your identity, um, which is actually really exciting and something that it feels like um could be very useful across the board, not just with work, but in in lots of other in lots of other areas too.

SPEAKER_00100%. So I have a question for you, Rosie. So my question for you is my question for you is what is what is if you're comfortable sharing, what is your thing that you are I've always wanted to try, or you have an intuition you want to try, but maybe fear has hold held you back.

SPEAKER_01Oh my god. Oh okay. I I can be I'll be honest and say that I think the biggest thing is probably writing. So I've always felt that I'd have quite liked to have written a book. Um and actually, this feels like a bit of a cheat, but it's not. Um actually, one of the reasons why we said I asked about setting up the blog was to identify that one of the things that I needed to do to work towards that goal was to actually do some writing.

SPEAKER_01Um so, in all honesty, that's probably it. Um, and um starting the blog was a way of trying to get a sense of who would I be as a writer, how do I like to write, and what would it be like to write. Um, but I don't know that I've taken it any further than that. No, nor do I know if I will.

SPEAKER_00But it's fair enough. And guys, we don't have to be all optimizing at all times. It's all good. It's all good.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's true. It could just be for fun.

SPEAKER_00It could just be for fun. Thanks uh uh so much for listening. If you're interested in comment, especially comment on YouTube, what is the thing that you're thinking about doing? Uh, if you're on YouTube, like and subscribe. If you're not on YouTube, consider watching us on YouTube. But if you prefer to remain on Spotify or Apple, just uh comment, subscribe. Uh any feedback or reviews would be super helpful. Rosie, thanks so much for talking with me today.

SPEAKER_01Thanks, Alex.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. E195 | Can a 20-Minute Psychedelic Trip Treat Depression? (New 5-MEO DMT Study)

    Nov 20, 202634 minAudio

    Could a psychedelic trip whose most intense effects fade within about 20 minutes help people with depression? In this episode, Dr Alex is joined by Dr Anya Borissova, an academic psychiatry registrar, to discuss a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. E194 | Thinking Films: Primetime (2026)

    Nov 13, 202624 minAudio

    What happens when exposing wrongdoing becomes a form of entertainment? In this Thinking Films episode, Dr Alex explores Primetime, starring Robert Pattinson as Chris Hansen. The film raises uncomfortable questions about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. E192 | What Matthew Perry's Story Reveals About the Psychology of Addiction

    Oct 30, 202618 minAudio

    What can Netflix's Matthew Perry documentary teach us about the psychology of addiction? Matthew Perry achieved extraordinary fame and success, yet continued to struggle with addiction throughout his life. His story...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. E191 | Netflix’s Stanford Prison Experiment: The Danger of Unearned Power

    Oct 22, 202623 minAudio

    What happens when ordinary people are handed power over others, and how do they respond when that power is taken away? Do you have an inner monster waiting to be unleashed? In this episode, psychiatrist Dr Alex examines...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. E190 | New ADHD/Autism Review Set to Dramatically Change UK Mental Health Services

    Oct 15, 202620 minAudio

    A major new government review has been published into mental health, ADHD and autism. Some headlines have framed it as a warning about ADHD and autism being overdiagnosed, but is that really what the report says? In...

    Credit the people on this episode