What happens when exposing wrongdoing becomes a form of entertainment? In this Thinking Films episode, Dr Alex explores Primetime, starring Robert Pattinson as Chris Hansen. The film raises uncomfortable questions about To Catch a Predator, public humiliation, and the boundary between protecting people and creating a spectacle. When fame, status and ratings enter the picture, how can our motives change? In this episode we discuss: • Splitting and black and white thinking • How ambition and public approval can distort our priorities • Why moral certainty can make our own wrongdoing harder to recognise Where do you draw the line between accountability and entertainment? Share your thoughts in the comments. Presented by Dr. Alex Curmi. Dr. Alex is a consultant psychiatrist and a UKCP registered psychotherapist. Get in touch: https://alexcurmitherapy.com/contact/ Check out The Thinking Mind Substack: https://thinkingmindblog.substack.com/ Speaking inquiries: https://alexcurmitherapy.com/speaking/ Coaching: https://alexcurmitherapy.com/practice/ Alex is not currently taking on new psychotherapy clients, if you are interested in working with Alex for self-development coaching, you can email - alexcurmitherapy@gmail.com with "Coaching" in the subject line. Give feedback here - thinkingmindpodcast@gmail.com Follow us here: Twitter @thinkingmindpod Instagram @thinkingmindpodcast
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Are you sure your parents aren't home? I'm sure. Big night plan. Well, who are you? She has a seat right there. I'm Chris Hansen with Dayton NBC. What happens when exposing wrongdoing becomes a form of entertainment? Welcome back to Thinking Films, where we discuss films through a psychological lens. As we come to the end of 2026, I still can't believe it.
SPEAKER_00I hope everyone is doing well. Today we're discussing Primetime. Primetime is a psychological thriller inspired by true events surrounding Chris Hansen and the NBC show To Catch a Predator. It's a great film for discussing television, public humiliation, the pursuit of fame, and how to deal with evil. Robert Patterson plays Hansen, Lance Oppenheim directs with a screenplay by Agent Singh. The supporting cast includes Merritt Weaver, Skylar Gizondo, Phoebe Bridges, Matthew Maher, and Bookem Woodbine.
SPEAKER_00Patterson has made some great choices recently. He was in Batman in 2022, The Lighthouse in 2019. Of course, people loved his performance in The Odyssey. He was also in a film called Good Time, which I haven't watched yet, but this performance comes highly recommended. So let me let me know if you guys have watched that. The film is doing well so far. I mean it's only just out, still out in UK cinemas, but Rotten Tomatoes has given it an 86% positive reviews from 273 critics. So it's doing well. So what's the story of this film while leaving out spoilers?
SPEAKER_00So it's 2006, and NBC journalist Chris Hansen hosts this new show to Catch a Predator with Dateline NBC, and he's working with this vigilante group called Perverted Justice. And the program stages these sting operations targeting adults seeking sex with minors. The men arrive at houses expecting to meet children, and instead they encounter adult decoys pretending to be kids. And then they're confronted by Hansen and his camera crew, and usually the police arrest them.
SPEAKER_00And NBC boss Jeff Sucker, despite disliking the show, gives it the hailed prime time slot, allowing it to compete with the likes of huge shows at the time like Lost. I don't really like your show. But America loves it. So I need to move you to catch a predator. 9 p.m.
unknownPrimetime.
SPEAKER_00Gonna be bigger than lost. I'm gonna be bigger than lost. In the film, Hansen attempts to pursue greater and greater success, but then eventually a sting operation goes wrong in combination with difficulties unraveling in his personal life, and this all turns his ambition into a nightmare. Now, before going any further, I would like to say anything I comment, you know, about Chris Hansen is really about Chris Hansen, the character, how he's portrayed in this film.
SPEAKER_00I'm not making any psychological claims about the real Chris Hansen because I don't know anything about him. But I think this film raises some really interesting questions. So those are questions like: should criminal accountability become a public spectacle? You know, how can fame and status change someone's motives? What responsibilities do broadcasters have towards the people they expose, even if they are committing really serious crimes? And I think the deepest question this film is asking is how as a society should we deal with the problem of evil or badness?
SPEAKER_00How should we approach that? I think some really compelling questions raised by this film. Culturally, this film takes us back to the early 2000s and this now seemingly almost quaint world of television time slots. So for my younger listeners, back in the 2000s, the time slot of your show really mattered because generally people watched a program when it aired. And of course, the prime time slot, which was around 9 pm, meant the show had would have access to a much larger potential audience.
SPEAKER_00And broadcasters like NBC or CBS, they had to really be aware of what shows their shows were competing against in a given time slot. And this film talks about that, and I really appreciated that throwback. Of course, these time slot dynamics mean that shows really had to start competing, and that's how he got shows like To Catch a Predator, because they had to be even more sensationalist or even more controversial to attract as much of an audience as possible. And now it almost seems quaint because since that time, the the time restriction has now disappeared.
SPEAKER_00Time slots are no longer an issue. You can watch anything at any time, and there are less gatekeepers, there's less entities like MBC or CBS who can judge what should be a show on television because now it can all be available on platforms like YouTube. So all of this has only intensified. So it's a really nice cultural artifact you can see here in this film. And I'd like to talk a little bit about what I think this film shows us psychologically, of course. Before I do that, if you're enjoying this video so far, do like, subscribe, follow whatever you happen to be watching or listening, and do check out the description of the episode so you can see how you can support the show.
SPEAKER_00Psychologically, the first thing that stands out about this film to me is this idea of splitting. So, splitting for people who don't know is this defense mechanism when people are encountering difficulties. It's very common for people to split up the world into good people or bad people. And Chris Hansen, the protagonist, seems to have this very black and white view of morality. People are either good or bad. Again, as I said, I'm talking about the fictional version, not the real version necessarily.
SPEAKER_00But this black and white thinking makes sexual predators the perfect subject for him because their wrongdoing gives him this perfect foil that puts him in the clear position of being a good guy. He's a good guy because he's catching predators, and you see in the film that he's really relishing that. And I think that's how the audience often felt watching this show in real life, and we can all relate to that feeling of watching people having their downfall, watching people being caught doing really, really bad stuff. There's so much of this stuff in the news, even recently, in the past few weeks and months, and it can make us feel good about ourselves.
SPEAKER_00We don't have to think about the badness in us because we can see the badness out there and the things that some people do like child predation, they're so heinous and that it's easy to maintain this black and white picture. The problem with splitting is that it really leaves us in a very poorly equipped position to recognize and prevent and deal with our own moral failings. And that's what you see. Chris Hansen, too, has difficulty dealing with his moral failings. Early in the film, you see that he's coping with having an affair that's potentially going to be found out, found out by his wife and reported in the news.
SPEAKER_00And he's really struggling to deal with this. And this is something I can see, you know, from my experience working with people. If you have this very black and white view of morality, if you approach the world through this splitting lens, I think it actually makes it more likely that you're going to do stuff that's not ethically sound because the black and white lens makes it harder to question yourself. It makes it harder to self-examine. When you do make a mistake, it makes it much harder to accept that you've made a mistake and therefore course correct and do something, you know, a bit better in the future.
SPEAKER_00If you can't tolerate being a bad person at all on any level, how closely can you possibly examine what you do day to day? In psychoanalytic theory, one of the cooler aspects is they list all the different defense mechanisms and they can be divided into like less and more mature ones. And splitting is considered one of the immature defense mechanisms. And you know, we can see this in our lives. Often, you know, younger children they tend to divide the world into black and white, and even amongst people we know, often the less mature of us will see things through this very polarizing lens.
SPEAKER_00And recognizing that both good and bad can exist within any individual can be a really difficult thing to get your head around. There are some really interesting psychological theories which talk about how morality develops in humans. So you might look up people like Jean Piaget, who talked about how people develop their moral sensibilities. And in any theory of moral development, there'll usually be a stage where someone first comes to grips and learns the rules of society and follows them, you know, might follow them quite blindly, you know, without questioning too much.
SPEAKER_00And usually, as someone's moral development gets more sophisticated, they have to develop their own sense of morality. They have to learn when rules can be broken or when rules shouldn't be broken. And again, this is different from splitting where you kind of conform to rules quite rigidly, perhaps overly rigidly, without any kind of flexibility. The second thing which is psychologically interesting about this film is how Chris Hansen himself always appears to be acting. He never seems to be himself, and there are some really amazing montage sequences where you see him practicing what he's gonna say to people, both on the television show, but also in real life, and everything he's doing in his life seems intensely rehearsed.
SPEAKER_00And there's this lovely moment of irony where he gets frustrated at one point in the film and he says, Nothing I do is acting. But of course, this is very ironic because pretty much everything he does in the film, again, even talking to people in his personal life, seems like a total and utter performance. And to me, this inability to be authentic makes a person particularly vulnerable to status seeking and what Karen Horneye, the psychoanalyst, called this neurotic search for glory.
SPEAKER_00In other words, this search to fulfill our ambitions, not for their own sake or because it's a good thing to do, and but to get the glory, to allow us to feel good about ourselves and to look really good in front of other people. And I think this portrayal of Chris Hansen is an amazing illustration of what this search for glory can look like, this search to do something virtuous, but really to look virtuous in the eyes of other people rather than for its own sake. So much seems to depend on how he appears to other people.
SPEAKER_00If he can be this really good person who catches sexual repetitors, uh then people will love him and you see him, you know, really bathing in the admiration he gets from this. And that leads me to my third point. So once you have difficulty, you know, you have the black and white thinking, uh, and then you have difficulty being yourself, and as a result, you might seek status. Then once you get on the status strain and you start getting the money and the fame and the recognition, then that again serves to warp your incentives even more.
SPEAKER_00It seems as the film wears on, that protecting children becomes less and less of a priority for Chris Hansen, and actually the priority becomes creating the best possible spectacle. And this is illustrated by the fact that towards the end of the film they need to catch the whale. Predator has never earned the recognition that deserves.
unknownGet out of here.
SPEAKER_00I want something that matters. No more body tapers. I want a whale. Which is this really high-status potential sex offender rather than the more ordinary people they've been catching so far. And this the general confrontation, the humiliation of the people on the show and the audience response, they seem to become Chris Hansen's primary motives, the primary incentives, rather than, or of course, what should be the main priority, just protecting children.
SPEAKER_00I think the film does a really great job of deliberately creating these really uncomfortable feelings of moral ambiguity in us. We recognize the seriousness of the wrongdoing of these predators as they're being exposed and how heinous the crimes they're committing are. But at the same time, we're allowed to question the motives and the methods of the people making the TV show and people the people exposing these crimes. And I think this brings us back to the central question that I raised earlier.
SPEAKER_00So, how should we deal with evil in society, you know? And I think this is a great case study because childhood sexual abuse is about as close as we can get to an archetypal, unforgivable crime. So it's the perfect subject for this film. And this film does not shy away from these moral ambiguities, the moral ambiguities of a show like to catch a predator. To me, the film is clearly asking: is it okay to exploit someone's punishment? Indeed, is it okay to relish in someone's punishment because they've committed and maybe about to commit a really serious set of crimes?
SPEAKER_00And is it okay to subvert the norms of our legal system for the same reason? I think it's really worth noting that many of the cases actually brought to light um by To Catch a Predator in real life couldn't actually be prosecuted because of the way the show bypassed legal norms. And there's a really interesting documentary about this called Predators, which came out in 2025, which I would definitely recommend watching if you're interested in this subject. The other thing I saw in the documentary is that a lot of people involved in the real life making of the show to catch a predator really regretted being involved after the fact.
SPEAKER_00And you can see in the film, you can see many of the characters in the film being visibly affected by dealing with the dark realities of sexual predation and how they're approaching it. I can relate to that from my professional experiences. I previously worked on a forensic ward which dealt with people who committed really serious crimes like sexual predation, and it's very difficult to get your head around, and you can't help but feel psychologically impacted by working with individuals like this.
SPEAKER_00The notable exceptions in the film, at least to me, are Chris and his producer, uh, played really well by Merritt Weaver, and they seem really emotionally unaffected, and they seem really just again fixated on how can we make the best, how can we make this the best show possible, how can we get the most ratings, etc. etc. Uh, at times you almost feel in the film like Chris and his producer have become their predators of a different sort. You know, they're looking for this kind of situation which they can turn into a public spectacle.
SPEAKER_00Obviously, this doesn't equate their form of predation with sexual abuse, it's very different things we're dealing with, but I still think it's it poses an interesting question of how to treat people in our society when they do bad things. Meanwhile, I think the best character who is a kind of insert for the audience is Dekoy Dan, played by Skylar Gizondo. So he's like a young man who looks like much younger than he is, and therefore he can be used in this show as a decoy, playing a child to kind of lure the predators into the house where they're caught.
SPEAKER_00And we see him really struggling to deal with all of this stuff on the show, and I think he really represents the audience quite well because we are as an audience, we're also, I think, presented with a lot of moral ambiguity, as I mentioned earlier. The film you know made me think a lot about the legal safeguards uh in Western society, which we often take for granted. The presumption of innocence, the right to legal representation, the right to remain silent when caught, even something as basic as that.
SPEAKER_00The importance of examining someone's intent, their motivation, their circumstances, for example, how you might distinguish between murder and manslaughter, depending on someone's intention or their motivation, the importance of having a legal system which judges someone's actions, even when they're very serious and heinous, with a degree of detachment. You know, part of the value of these safeguards is that they restrain our impulses when our emotions run high. When someone's done something really terrible, we can feel completely justified in making really poor ethical decisions because they've done something so wrong.
SPEAKER_00And I think To Catch a Predator seems very much like a show designed to provoke our emotions and to provoke our sense of completely certain self-righteousness as strongly as possible, and therefore to justify any and all actions towards the person who has committed uh the crime. One of the criticisms that's been lobbied uh at the real life show to catch a predator is that it doesn't really try and help the audience understand the psychology of a predator, which could be really helpful to prevent, to you know, educate people meaningfully about how someone can take safeguards to protect their children.
SPEAKER_00That's been a big criticism of the show, and the film kind of portrays the show quite similarly. I think these tensions of how how do you deal with these despicable acts of predation is the most interesting part of the film and how this is you know personified by Robert Patterson's character in the form of Chris Hansen. There's a lot I really liked about how the film is made. Patterson's performance as someone who constantly needs to rehearse every aspect of his life I found really compelling.
SPEAKER_00I really like that the film didn't overexplain everything. There's a lot that's implied. There are a lot of layers to this film. I've only watched it once at the cinema a couple of days ago. I'm looking forward to re-watching it because I'm sure there's a lot I missed the first time. Uh, there's a lot you can spot in the background of scenes. There's a point where one of the characters goes to Subway and you see the image of Jared Spogel, who was a Subway spokesperson who was later convicted for child sex offenses, and that gives this appearance a kind of unsettling irony.
SPEAKER_00We get glimpses of the lead vigilante of perverted justice. We get glimpses of his apartment that really make us wonder about his own lifestyle and his own difficulties and potentially his own sexual habits. Again, without spelling everything out, looking forward to the rewatch to see what else I can spot. There's even a small scene involving Chris Hansen just dealing with a broken vending machine, and even just how he deals with this really mundane situation gives us a really cool glimpse of his character and like his moral uh sensibility.
SPEAKER_00There's a lot happening in the film textually but also subtextually. I love the use of colour and the inclusion of like a lot of montages that ramp up very quickly and uh a lot of seemingly nonsensical scenes that give the film the feeling of a fever dream, which, as far as I understand, was intentional on the part of the filmmakers. There is something about the film which I can't quite place, where I did feel it lost its momentum somewhere around two-thirds of the way through, and I'm not exactly sure why, because I have only watched it once, as I said.
SPEAKER_00But despite that loss of momentum, it does build towards, I think, a really impactful conclusion. I'm not gonna spoil it, but again, this is based on what happened in real life. I think, in terms of practical takeaways, the film really points towards the importance of developing our own moral principles, of course, while retaining some sense of mental flexibility, a code you can live by while at the same time still being able to admit it when you've made a mistake.
SPEAKER_00You need to be able to say, I believe this is right, while still asking, you know, could I be getting something wrong, or have I done something wrong, or how can I, you know, improve in the future? Again, this also speaks to the importance of being comfortable with yourself, of not like overly depending on moral virtue or status or fame or success to feel good about who you are. Of course, I've talked about this so much on the podcast: the importance of what you call a reasonable sense of self-esteem. Because if your self-worth rests on being seen as good by other people, not actually being good, but being seen as good, then admitting any kind of wrongdoing, even to yourself privately, can feel like a threat to your whole identity.
SPEAKER_00I think it's really important to examine yourself when you're at your most self-righteous, because I think this is often a point where we're avoiding something really important about ourselves, and it's often a point where, you know, caught up in the fever of self-righteousness, we could actually do something unethical ourselves. You know, a lot of unethical things have been done in history by people who felt they were very much 100% doing the right thing. So those are the kind of practical takeaways I got from the film psychologically.
SPEAKER_00What film would I recommend to watch as a double feature? Of course, this film makes me think of many others. I think about Network, which we've covered on the podcast. Network is an obvious choice because it similarly treats human distress uh as a commodity to be made into entertainment. As I mentioned earlier, the documentary Predators from 2025 would also make a really good back-to-back feature because it covers this stuff more from an angle of what actually happened in real life.
SPEAKER_00But I think the strongest pairing would have to be Nightcrawler, which we also covered on the podcast last year. Uh, for its again, exploration of ambition and media incentives, moral disengagement, all very similar to network, but then the protagonist played by Jake Gyllenhall in one of his best performances, similarly portraying someone who rehearses, who seems to rehearse and perform every aspect of his life. It would be really, really cool to line up Jake Gyllenhaal's performance with Robert Pattinson's performance and see how they compare to each other, I think.
SPEAKER_00Overall, I think Primetime was a great film. I'm looking forward to re-watching it. Possibly for me a career best from Robert Pattinson, in my opinion. You know, this film doesn't shy away from provocative questions, it has a really distinct aesthetic. It's blending reality television with a more conventional narrative film and really quite strange to watch at times, but quite wonderful to watch. You know, when it's when this film soars, it really soars. I'm excited to see what Lance Oppenheim does next.
SPEAKER_00I haven't really seen any of the other stuff he's done. I know he was involved with You Can See Everything, which is the documentary coming out soon about the whole Elizabeth Holmes controversy. That's not out yet in the UK, but I will be watching it and probably covering it on the podcast as soon as it comes out. The question I'm left with is this with regards to this film, which is when we feel certain we're confronting evil, what can we still be willing to examine about our own behavior?
SPEAKER_00If you enjoyed this video, do like, subscribe, follow wherever you happen to be listening or watching. If you have any feedback for us or you want to suggest a film for us to cover next, do leave us a comment on YouTube. Check out the description of the episode to see how you can support us. I use my psychiatry and psychotherapy background to coach people when they're stuck in life. That is usually with a career problem, a relationship problem, a personal fulfillment issue, self-sabotage addiction, that kind of thing. If you're interested in exploring how we could work together, again, check out the instructions in the description.
SPEAKER_00You can also check out our other thinking films, episodes on films like Nightcrawler, Network, The Wolf of Wall Street, The Truman Show, Obsession, and many others. We love to release episodes talking about great cinema in between our normal episodes where we discuss mental health, psychology, personal development, and related topics. Thank you so much for watching, and we'll see you here next time.
Could a psychedelic trip whose most intense effects fade within about 20 minutes help people with depression? In this episode, Dr Alex is joined by Dr Anya Borissova, an academic psychiatry registrar, to discuss a...
What happens when a psychiatrist has to put his own advice about facing fear into practice? In this episode, Dr Alex joins Dr Rosy Blunstone, a psychiatry and psychotherapy registrar, to discuss his experience of trying...
What can Netflix's Matthew Perry documentary teach us about the psychology of addiction? Matthew Perry achieved extraordinary fame and success, yet continued to struggle with addiction throughout his life. His story...
What happens when ordinary people are handed power over others, and how do they respond when that power is taken away? Do you have an inner monster waiting to be unleashed? In this episode, psychiatrist Dr Alex examines...
A major new government review has been published into mental health, ADHD and autism. Some headlines have framed it as a warning about ADHD and autism being overdiagnosed, but is that really what the report says? In...