Verity is one of the biggest movies in the world right now, and as you’d expect from a blockbuster Colleen Hoover adaptation starring Anne Hathaway and Dakota Johnson, there is a lot to talk about. Laura and Em are giving you their completely unfiltered review of the movie - from the performances they couldn’t look away from and the twists that genuinely shocked them, to the darker moments Laura found particularly confronting. They unpack what worked, what absolutely didn’t, the choices they’re still trying to make sense of and whether the movie ultimately lives up to all that hype. And Em has come armed with receipts. Having read the original novel, she takes Laura through some of the biggest differences between the book and the movie, including the scenes and storylines she was stunned to see disappear, the changes that completely surprised her and whether Hollywood’s version of Verity actually improves on Colleen Hoover’s original story. Become a Mamamia subscriber and get an all-access pass to everything we make, including exclusive podcasts and early listening, subscriber-only articles, monthly giveaways and our home workout app, MOVE. Built to work around your real life, MOVE adapts to whatever season you're in. That's why we've created a brand new collection of feel-good weight workouts, designed for any body, anywhere. No hectic challenges or intimidating gym setups, just simple, easy-to-follow sessions, designed to help you build strength at your own pace. MOVE is feel-good fitness by Mamamia. For less than a coffee a week, get unlimited access to hundreds of workouts, ranging from five to 45 minutes. Plus, you get unlimited access to everything across Mamamia, including subscriber-exclusive podcast episodes, articles, discounts and giveaways. Get your MOVE goodness here. Get access to Very Peri, Mamamia's exclusive perimenopause series, for just $59. 25 world-leading experts, over 20 on-demand sessions, available now. We’ve sorted through the noise so you don't have to. Go to veryperi.com.au and join me today. You hot? Same. Buy today and save 40% THE END BITS Find and follow us on socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thespillpodcast/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thespillpod Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thespillpodcast/ Support independent women's media Want to join the conversation? Have feedback or a topic you want us to discuss? Send us a voice message or email us at thespill@mamamia.com.auand we’ll get back to you ASAP! Hosts: Laura Brodnik & Em Vernm Executive Producer: Monisha Iswaran Mamamia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1From Mamma Mia, welcome to The Spill, your daily pop culture fix. I'm Laura Brodnick.
Speaker 2And I'm Em Burnham.
Speaker 1And welcome to a very special Friday episode. We have been waiting all week since we went and saw this movie together to talk about it. Welcome to our brutally honest review of Verity. Verity. Verity. Verity. Ooh, it's creepy. No, it is creepy. Don't even get me started. We're about to get started.
Speaker 2Firstly, great name.
Speaker 1Verity.
Speaker 2I love the name Verity.
Speaker 1Really? Yeah. Oh, my God. Every time I called Verity in the movie, I was like, I hate that name. Sorry to any Verities out there who listen to The Spill. No, I don't hate it. It's an interesting name, but it doesn't roll off the tongue.
Speaker 2I think it's like a mixture of villain and purity.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2A pure villain.
Speaker 1Oh, is that why she called her that? No.
Speaker 2Oh, my God. I wish I thought of that, though.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's a very clever plot point. So, of course, talking about the new sexy psychological thriller movie with Anne Hathaway and Dakota Johnson based on the 2018 novel of the same name by Colleen Hoover, which, did you notice, it was originally self-published. It was one of those books that was self-published and it gained so much traction online with people loving it that it was picked up by a by like an offset, I think, of Hachette Books, which is obviously in the movie, and then became a bestseller.
Speaker 2Because I would argue this is her best book.
Speaker 1Really? How many Colleen Hoovers have you read? Two.
Speaker 2Okay. Including this one.
Speaker 1I mean, well, you would be the author. Why'd you call me out like that? Just let me have my opinion and ask no further questions. Can I say, I didn't know it was going to go that way. I thought you were going to be like, I've read about five and this is the best one. What's the one you.
Speaker 2I feel like I've read five.
Speaker 1Okay, then what's the worst Colin Hoover book since you've only read two? Um, the....
Speaker 2It ends with that.
Speaker 1Oh, okay, okay. And fair enough, fair enough. Well, get back to us when you read a third and we'll see how that... Maybe then I can.
Speaker 2Have my opinion.
Speaker 1How that tiebreaker works out. So, of course, with the Brutally Honest Review, we are talking about the entire movie all the way through from start to finish. There'll be so many spoilers just to be aware.
Speaker 2Yes, so, so many spoilers for both the movie and the book because I've also read the book. And I read the book like just before I watched the movie. So I'm sorry if I get my scenes mixed up and I end up still talking about the book instead of the movie. But you can call me out on that.
Speaker 1I'll call you on that. Oh boy, will I call you out on that. Yes, because I haven't read the book. In fact, I went into this movie cold. Like I had barely even watched a trailer. I knew the cast and that was about it. Because I wanted to, if I'm not going to read the book, I want to go and experience the movie with no prior knowledge. Because everyone kept, all I knew was like people like jump scares, twists and turns. And I was like, well, the best way to see a twisty thriller movie is to go in knowing nothing. And do I regret that decision? A little bit.
Speaker 2Oh, I just wish, like, I actually wish I read the book after watching the movie. Because I think I would have enjoyed the movie more. Because there are a lot of plot points that happen in the book that, that didn't happen in the movie. Like before we even went to watch the movie, I was telling you, I'm really scared because there are jump scares in the book that made me actually scared that weren't in the movie. So the book is, I feel the book is much more darker and scarier and the movie kind of hinted at some of those big scenes that we didn't really get.
Speaker 1Interesting. Yeah, because as we were walking into the premiere and I'm looking ahead and I'm seeing the bright lights of the premiere party and I'm seeing the little signature cocktails they have with the rosebloods with the rosebuds floating and I'm just like power walking towards that and then you're trailing behind me going oh the book was so scary so many jump scares and then well we're about to get into it all so obviously the movie starts off with Dakota Johnson's character Lowen Ashley quite a good name I think good name great names in this not me trashing Verity and saying Lowen's good Like, I'm just scared.
Speaker 1I'm scarred from the book, from the movie.
Speaker 2She has to have, like, an intriguing, unusual name.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2Because in the very, very first scene, which also happens in the book, she experiences someone dying in front of her.
Speaker 1Okay, so that was quite a crazy entry for me coming in, not knowing anything about it. So it's Dakota Johnson as Lohan, and she's looking like Dakota Johnson, you know? I was like, am I watching The Materialist for a second? Because she's got her perfect, perfect long hair. her perfect bangs, walking along a busy city street, not moving, which is a Dakota Johnson signature. She's standing on the edge of the street and the voiceover is her talking about how some people are meant to live in busy cities. She's got the headphones on. It's all very much like the
Speaker 1start of a dramatic story about a young woman moving to the city. So I'm kind of lost in that and I'm like, where is this going to go? And then the next second, bang, and she's covered in blood. That was almost for me the most graphic scene of the movie.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's exactly how the book starts off as well. And she's covered in blood and then a nice man approaches her and is like, are you okay? There's a cafe across the road. They have a bathroom. Let's go get you cleaned up. And then they're kind of They're strangers kind of just already talking about their past experiences. And very quickly as she's washing someone else's blood off of her, we find out that her mother had passed away last week. And we also find that the person who came to help her pulled his daughter's body out
Speaker 2of the lake a few months ago.
Speaker 1And they're literally in this coffee shop bathroom and she's rubbing all the blood off her. Her shirt is soaked with blood. He takes his shirt off to give to her. I have two questions for you in this moment. One is obviously this actor playing this mystery man who we're about to find out who he is, is played by Josh Hartnett. What's your relationship with Josh Hartnett?
Speaker 2I don't really have one.
Speaker 1Oh my gosh. Emily. Yes.
Speaker 2For me, um, was kind of like the hot guy that was always a little bit there that like my older cousins really loved. And I kind of just missed him.
Speaker 1Yeah. Okay. That's because I'm a bit older than you because when I was a teenager, he was like one of these.
Speaker 2He was a heartthrob.
Speaker 1He was a heartthrob. Yeah. He still is. No, he's still. Okay, you don't have to tell me twice.
Speaker 2He's still very good looking.
Speaker 1I was like, towards the end of the movie, I'm like, I do think that's a bad man, but a handsome one at that. No, and he's come back in a big way. He's got like a TV series coming out. He's been in a bunch of movies.
Speaker 2Has he played an evil character before?
Speaker 1Uh, yeah, there's a movie I could talk to you about called Trap. Yeah. But he has, no, he has played villains before, but like I kind of grew up with him.
Speaker 2He gives like villain energy.
Speaker 1Oh, really? I see. I grew up with him playing like a heartthrob, like a teen heartthrob or like he's super hot in Pearl Harbor. Oh. Yeah.
Speaker 2Not what that movie's known for, but I'm glad he's there.
Speaker 1No, that movie is known for that. Oh, fun times. So that was my first question I just wanted to sort of establish because I'm like, I'm a fangirl of his. I'm excited to see him. My second thought is I kept thinking that he was helping her clean up in the bathroom so they could go back together across the road and talk to the police. And then... And then she came out of the coffee shop and he's just gone. And then she just buttons her shirt and goes to a meeting. And I was like, sorry, did you guys just, you guys just witnessed, like you're at the scene of a crime. Yes. You didn't go and talk to the police?
Speaker 2She does talk to the police in the book.
Speaker 1Thank God. Yeah.
Speaker 2She goes back. She goes back.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2But he doesn't. And he, in the book, he doesn't witness it. He's like, she is in such shock that she just keeps going about her day. And then because they're in New York and so many people like see so many things, no one's really registering her. And he registers her and it's like, oh, that woman's covered in blood. I need to check if she's okay. So he actually, I don't think from memory, he doesn't experience what actually happens.
Speaker 1Okay. And I do understand that would have held the story up in a weird way. But as I just walked away, I was like, do you guys just walk away from a crime scene? You've got to go to jail for that. Not allowed. Don't recommend. If you guys see a crime, say something. Say something. So then she gets to the publisher's office, the Hachette offices, and goes into the meeting room. And who is there?
Speaker 2And he knows it's her because they introduced themselves to each other when they were in the bathroom. And he's like, Loewen's not a very common name. So I knew it was you. And what happens is they sit down with the lawyers. The lawyers tell Loewen and her publisher, her agent, Corey, that they have a very, very high profile client who's in the middle of writing a series of books and that client cannot continue writing those books. So they're looking for an author to help out. Please sign an NDA
Speaker 2before we give you any more information. And then it was uncovered that the client is in fact Verity and that they need, that she can no longer write the book. She's been in an accident and they need someone to write the books for a very, very high price. And Lohan's like, she's got a bit of tall poppy syndrome she's like i can't do that that's too her agent is like what agent's like wait can i please talk to this girl and then jeremy's like actually agent no i want to put the agent's name cory actually cory
Speaker 2i want to talk to you and they have a bit of back and forth he tells her that verity was in a car accident and is incapable of writing the books um he said that you're lowballing you should ask for half a million dollars instead And that there are some notes in her study. So if you do want to continue writing these books, you'll have to come live with me in a few days to go through all of her notes in her study because I don't understand them at all. So it's a big deal.
Speaker 1It's a lot to take in, especially as a young writer being told, you'll have to come live in my house. And obviously she doesn't know it. She knows the name Verity Crawford because she's a world-famous best-selling author, but everything about it is very mysterious. But she does need the money because she's getting evicted. So she jumps in her car and heads to– What could only be described as one of the most incredible houses I've ever seen.
Speaker 2Also in the book, it's made clear, which they kind of alluded at in the film, that her and Corey were in a previous relationship. And that she broke up with him and now he's dating someone else. But that's a more bigger deal in the book than they made in the movie.
Speaker 1I guess that is something like, I mean, obviously I haven't read the book, but I'd say if like as a reader, I'd be okay to kind of skip over that in the movie because they do have that scene on the couch in her apartment where They kind of like have a little bit of a moment together. And then she's like, who's this girl over Instagram? You should keep dating her kind of thing. So for me, that was enough. I was like, I don't need to know anymore.
Speaker 2Sorry, Corey.
Speaker 1You're not in this. I was like, we need to get to the mystery house.
Speaker 2Oh, how nice is this house? Yeah.
Speaker 1Can I just say, yes. Is she locked up with two potential serial killers? And which one is the, which one is the crazy one? We will never know. I think I'd pay that price to live in that house. To sleep in that bed and use that bathroom. The price of maybe dying. Yeah. The price of living with some crazy people. Hey, I've lived with worse. It's fine.
Speaker 2It's a beautiful, beautiful house. So in the book, the way she pulls up to the house and you get your first jump scare because crew like hits her window and she like screams and she's like, oh my God. And then it's like this little kid and she's like, oh, this must be crew because she's like looked up this family.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And then he's not talking to her, so he's, like, quite quiet. And then he then says hello, and then she follows him up into the house, and then he slams the door in her face. So then, like, the introduction is, like, she sees the kid walk in, and then she's like, oh, and then she knocks, and then Jeremy opens the door.
Speaker 1Okay, interesting. Yeah, so they set the scene a bit differently. So she pulls up to this beautiful house, and Jeremy's, like, being the perfect host of showing her around, and she wants to get straight to work. After she's shown to the master bedroom... which is, again, chic as hell. Really gorgeous.
Speaker 2And also exactly how I pictured it in my head when I was reading the book. It's beautiful, huge, and it has the infamous headboard with the teeth marks.
Speaker 1The teeth mark in it. Yeah, which was interesting at the premiere. We got a cup that looks like to take home in a gift bag. It looked like wood with teeth marks in it. And I was like, I don't know about that. I was excited until I watched the full movie. And then once I knew what the movie was about, I was like, I don't know if I want this cup at my home.
Speaker 2Because like those cups like they're takeaway mugs.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So it's like people are going to think I have like some crazy issues and I'm biting into this mug.
Speaker 1I'm going to take that mug downstairs and get them to put my coffee in the coffee shop and just see what they clock. Very cute. But yes, when I saw that bedroom, I'm like, holy shit, I'd have an affair too. Doesn't it make that room make you want to have an affair?
Speaker 2100%. Yeah.
Speaker 1That bedroom was not made for people who are in a monogamous relationship. Yeah, no, no, no.
Speaker 2That's why they had to move upstairs.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. Because they were like, we can't be here. Yeah, exactly. It's too much.
Speaker 2Loan, this is your room. And so Jeremy shows her the room. He's like, this is the master bedroom, but now we all live upstairs after Verity's accident because it's just easier. And also we also see the study, which does not look like what I pictured from the book.
Speaker 1Oh, really?
Speaker 2I thought the study would be a much more bigger open plan, very bright.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And very open with like these big, it's described as having like these big, big windows because a lot of the scenes that happen where she sees Verity outside, it's from the study.
Speaker 1Oh, okay. Yeah. Interesting. So this is, it's got like a sunken couch and like, it's very kind of like the, all the books on display. It's so funny that like, this is such a remote home. Like that's the whole thing. It's remote. It's on a lake. There's no one around. Yeah. And it's so big. But then when you go into Verity's study, like in the movie, it looks like a showroom almost. It doesn't look like a place that's designed for someone to hang out and be by themselves and ride. It looks like a showpiece, which is kind of interesting for a character who's meant to be like very private.
Speaker 1But then also like the more you learn about her. does her study look like that because it's a show for people. Yeah, that's so true. It looks like what a successful woman's office would look like, not where someone would actually sit to write, which is kind of interesting.
Speaker 2And this is when you start to try to figure out what kind of person Verity is. And then so Lohan meets Verity and then she sees how badly she was injured in that car accident. And she also meets the nurse who has like a bigger role in the book. But I kind of agree with the Corey's perspective. It's not as needed.
Speaker 1Yeah, but I am interested. We'll get to this at the end. But I am interested in like kind of like how much the nurse knew because they really make it look through the movie like she knows something. She's in on something. But as a moviegoer, you don't get any kind of like one day she just leaves and you never see her again. That's it.
Speaker 2Yeah, you don't really find out much in the book either.
Speaker 1No, I'm sure. But I was like that woman's in there. Like what we learn is that... What's happened to her after that car accident is so much worse than they let the publishers know, is that she's basically completely, she's had a brain injury. She's like catatonic, non-responsive. When Lohan goes to meet her, she's first of all really shocked, which is fair enough because... I think they kind of in the office led to believe that she might be able to have a conversation with her a little bit.
Speaker 2Yes, so that was made more obvious in the book. There's this scene, which I actually think was really important and I was sad they didn't include it in the movie, but there's a scene where– the nurse is having lunch with Verity and then the nurse is talking to Verity and then Loewen comes in and talks to the nurse and she's like, how long have you been here with Verity? Like, how are you doing? And then the nurse pulls Loewen aside and was like, can we talk in the next room? And the nurse tells Loewen, you don't know if the
Speaker 2patient can hear you or not. So we have to talk to them as if they're like still here with us. You have to include them in the conversation. And I thought that was really important.
Speaker 1That is really important because I guess that that is something that happens in the medical field. Sometimes when people have obviously different levels of like brain injuries and stuff, sometimes the doctors have said like, we don't know how much they're taking in, how much they can hear. Because there are people who have woken up from comas or things like that, and said that they could sometimes hear who was in the room.
Speaker 2Because I think then, like, in the book, it was kind of like Lohan was talking about Verity as if she wasn't in the room or as if she was dead. And then the nurse was like, she's not dead, so you have to include her and talk to her.
Speaker 1Like, she's still here.
Speaker 2Because she is.
Speaker 1Interesting. What did you think of that first scene where we have Lohan, so we have Dakota Johnson's character meet Anne Hathaway's character Verity for the first time?
Speaker 2Oh, God, Anne Hathaway's so scary.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, because it's not just that. That's an interesting performance from her because she's obviously playing someone who's completely unresponsive. But as an actress, she knows the bottom line of what's going to happen later. So she has to also play a little bit in that scene.
Speaker 2Yeah. What did you feel from that?
Speaker 1It's jarring. Because, again, I hadn't watched any of the trailers, so I wasn't sure. I knew there was something about her being, like, unresponsive or I thought she was actually just ill. So I didn't realise when you saw her and what the state she was going to be in and that blank look on Anne Hathaway's face as that character. And it is kind of like it is– the thing is it wouldn't be terrifying in real life, but because it's a thriller and everything's played as like, oh, what's going to happen now? What's going to happen now? It was like a little almost like a mini jump scare.
Speaker 2Yeah. I was– just because I read the book, when I saw that first scene of Anne Hathaway, I was immediately like, oh my God, this movie is going to scare the crap out of me. Oh, really? And I think what I was sad about, just speaking about the movie in general, was that there were so many intensely scary, jump scary scenes in the book that I think Anne Hathaway would have been so, so good at. And I'm really sad that we didn't get that.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm interested around and as we go through, please do bring those up. But I'm interested on that decision from the filmmakers because other things 100% you can't keep everything from a book. And also, I think it's more fun as someone who's read a book going to a movie. I want them to change a bit. So it's like if I read the whole book, I don't need a page by page retelling. Like I want them to make it their own. But I'm also interested why you would take out the jump scares when that seems like such an important part of the story.
Speaker 2I think it's also because in the book it's very much Verity is the main character. Like there's so much more detail in the memoir that we get that she's written about herself. I think they tried to do a montage in the movie where you just see some words pop up on the screen of what she's written. But the book goes into so much detail about Verity before her accident and as well as some of the things that she does in the house that she shouldn't be doing because she's not meant to. And I feel like
Speaker 2the movie tried to make Dakota Johnson the main person.
Speaker 1In the story. Yeah, I think they tried to make it Lohan's story.
Speaker 2Which I think was a mistake.
Speaker 1Interesting. Okay, because you're seeing everything through her eyes. So Lohan then starts delving more into Verity's work and that's when she comes across the memoir, right? Yes, so be it. So be it. Which, okay, this is the part of the book. So this is the part of the story that I wasn't across in any way, shape or form because I tried to like not see it. But as I said, I said to you as we walked in and I sat down with my three glasses of wine and I was like, okay, I'm so excited to watch like a sexy thriller and I hope it's scary. I want it to be scared. I wasn't prepared to be horrified.
Speaker 1There's some actually horrifying stuff in this movie. It's to do with the kids and it's just– I found it really confronting, actually. Yeah. I didn't find it thrilling. I found it really confronting, and I was like, I don't know if I want these two storylines in this movie.
Speaker 2There's actually, like, the book is actually, with the memoir, was way more confronting.
Speaker 1Really?
Speaker 2To the point where I was like, I actually didn't know how they would do some of those scenes, which they just didn't do it at all.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2So in the movie, Lohan finds the memoir... She reads the introduction, which is very much Verity saying to the reader, you will not like me after this. Like, so I'm going to be completely raw. And she says she does this thing about memoirs, which I actually think is true. Like if you're writing about yourself, you have to write your true self, which is what she says. So she's like preparing the reader, like you are going to hate me after this. And then she dives in to how she met Jeremy and her relationship with Jeremy. And then
Speaker 2Loewen says, I think is so confronted by what she says in the book that she tries to clarify with Jeremy going, maybe this is just like a random piece of fiction that she's written. And she asked Jeremy about like how they met and he kind of confirms exactly what Verity's written. So she goes into the memoir about how she was so obsessed with Jeremy. And in the book, Like the sex scenes from like this first initial part are insane.
Speaker 1Really? Like what? Paint us a little picture.
Speaker 2Like she's so, so obsessed with him. She does like sexual acts that she doesn't really like, but because she loves him so much, she wants to do it for him. She wants to perform for him. She wants to be the best person for him. She's so in love with him and she wants to be the only thing in his life. Right. And then when it ends with her going, but then he finds something better, which is the children, the way she describes her pregnancy in the book is Is so intense. So in the movie, they go into that she had two children, twins, Harper and Crew. In
Speaker 2the book, there's actually three children.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's wild to me when I heard that. Yes.
Speaker 2So she first gets pregnant with twins, Harper and Chasten. So she has twin girls and then Crew, the younger brother of the twin girls. And there are some, like, really intense scenes about her hating her pregnancy so much. She tried to do a self-abortion.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah.
Speaker 2With a coat hanger, which ends up scarring Chastin's face. Like she has a permanent scar on her face. which she lies to, obviously, Jeremy about. The scene where she tries to suffocate her.
Speaker 1I don't know if you looked over at me in the movies at that point, but I had to cover my face. I found that so confronting. That, to me, is the most horrific thing you can watch. I have a visceral reaction to the scenes like that in a movie, even though they're not real. The same way some people are like, I can't watch a dog die in a movie. Not that I like watching a dog die, but I can get through it. But I'm like stuff like that where she's like, I left them alone to cry and I went back to sleep. And I know that's the least thing she did to them, but even that made me feel sick. And when she walks in, Anne Hathaway's character Verity, when she walks into the room with the
Speaker 1pillow to put over her face, I nearly said to you, I need to go. I can't watch this.
Speaker 2So in the book, they framed it in a way where, so she hated both the twin girls from the get go. She hated them. But then in the book, which doesn't really make sense, or there's no like concluding point to this, which is why I'm glad I didn't really include it. In the book, she has like this visceral dream of Harper killing Chasten. So then Chasten, she starts to like her. And then she has like this deep fear that Harper's going to kill her, which is why she goes into the room to try to kill Harper.
Speaker 1Oh my God.
Speaker 2Which is very, very sad. And in the book, Chasten also dies. But she dies through anaphylaxis with peanut butter at a sleepover. So it's not really related to Verity and her vengeance against these kids at all. And she's quite sad about Chasten's death because she was the only kid that she really liked.
Speaker 1Oh. This to me, like I understand this is the plot and people love it. And I have spoken to heaps of other people who have read the book and saw the movie with us who loved the movie. So maybe this is just a me thing that I'm just not. But to me, this, that storyline wrapped with like the idea of like a sexy psychological thriller wrapped around it are two like storylines that almost shouldn't exist in the same place. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2Which is why I think they try to lean it into like two separate areas.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2With like Variety before, you're reading this separately to the main storyline that's happening with Loen, Dakota Johnson's character. I want to talk about some of the scenes. that Verity does in the book as someone who's not meant to be able to move or talk or anything. So were there any jump scares that you had in the movie?
Speaker 1Yeah. I don't know if there was for me, maybe because you had really built up being like, I'm going to be so scared. I mean, I've been to movies with you before where you've, movies that are not that scary, should I add? Yeah. Like Scream 5, whatever it was. Scream 5. You're on the floor shaking in a little ball.
Speaker 2I'm scared of jump scares.
Speaker 1Yeah. And so I think maybe because you had built up so much, there wasn't enough. I think one of the first jump scares, because I wasn't expecting it, is when Loen is like, it's like her first morning there and she's got a little cup of coffee and she's looking out where Verity's sitting in her wheelchair and all of a sudden she looks down again and Verity's just staring at her and she screams and drops the coffee cup and drops the floor. I think that's one of the first, it's also one of the first big jump scares because up until then she hasn't done anything.
Speaker 2Yeah, that is also in the book. It's very scary. But in the book they make her eyes follow Loen. Like Loen is in the study when that happens. That's why I expected there to be massive windows in the study because I thought that's where the scene would take place. So she's looking at Verity. Verity's being read to. And then the nurse goes away for a bit. And then she looks up again and Verity's staring at her. And then Loen, like, drops to the ground and tries to crawl away. And Verity's, like, following her with her eyes.
Speaker 1Oh, just you doing it then? That was so scary.
Speaker 2And then Loen, like, then, like, is, like, breathing. And then she looks again and then Verity's not looking at her.
Speaker 1Aww. It's weird what can be scary. That's such a simple thing, really.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1And just the way you just sit with your eyes in. Don't look at me for the rest of this pod accord.
Speaker 2Anne Hathaway would have nailed that scene.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Like her just like staring and like following but not moving her head.
Speaker 1Maybe. I mean, obviously some things sometimes come to life better in a book and then some things come to life better in a movie. Maybe they were trying to keep the reveal in the movie. Maybe they thought they did that in the movie. It would be too pointed of what was going to happen.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Although you kind of do almost know. Even I was watching it and I was like, I can see the pieces of the puzzle what's going to happen here.
Speaker 2Oh, my God. It's so good. There's also a big plot point in the book that Loen is a chronic sleepwalker.
Speaker 1Okay. You wouldn't want to be sleepwalking around that house.
Speaker 2No, to the point where it's quite scary. So she goes into her past where she's talking to a therapist and she says that the reason why she has such a taut relationship with her mum was because her mum was scared of her. Her mum was scared of her. Loan's mum was scared of Loan. Is it because she named her Loan?
Speaker 1Probably.
Speaker 2And I think one of the scenes that was like really scary that was so vivid in my head about the book, and I wish we saw it on screen, was Loan talks about this past moment where she was a child and she walks outside her house and stands up on a fence. And she's standing there for hours and she's not moving or swaying or going back and forth. She's just standing there completely still. And her mum sees that on a security camera and her mum gets so, so scared that she stops talking to her mum.
Speaker 1That's the thing. Everyone wants to have a kid, but they could be evil. You just never know. Well, here I am feeling sorry for this poor girl going to this creepy house with these creepy people. Like, one of them's definitely really messed up.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1We don't know which one, but, like, it kind of feels like maybe she went to the right place, right?
Speaker 2She went to the right place, but she's so scared of her sleepwalking habits that she asked Jeremy to put a lock on her bedroom door.
Speaker 1Oh, but also, if I was in that house, I would also want a lock on it. I know I said that room was.
Speaker 2But from the outside.
Speaker 1No, that's scary. That's getting the housemaid territory where they're like, oh, sorry, there's a deadbolt on the outside. Yeah, because as sexy as that room was, like I said, the bedroom she's in is a fair worthy, but also I would be scared sleeping in open space. Also, the bed's in the middle of the room, so someone can walk behind you. And if you're a scaredy cat sleeper, I'm a defensive sleeper. I have to sleep with my back to a wall. and like have two exits.
Speaker 2It's in the middle of the room. Firstly, such a rich flex.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 2No one's bedroom's big enough for that.
Speaker 1Well, in my new, well, my apartment I've been in for five years, I nearly didn't take even though it was my dream apartment because it's got like a wall of glass on one side with the balcony and then the bathroom and closet. So I have to have my bed in the middle. And obviously I grew up being terrified of that. And you know, there's like this one Halloween movie where the girl gets into bed and goes to sleep and she's been getting ready for ages. And as soon as she goes to sleep, Michael Myers, the killer and the master, sits up slowly next to her bed because he spent all night lying next to her bed and all day so that he can get her when she goes to sleep. So every night when I
Speaker 1go to sleep now, I have to look over the edge of my bed. You walk around your bed. I do. I look down and check for my... And I push my hand against the curtains because they push out. That's true.
Speaker 2That's a good hiding spot.
Speaker 1Yeah. And I check the closet. Not that anything can fit in there. Jesus. So anyway, when I saw her sleeping in the middle of the room with like that walk space behind her head and I was like, Lohan girl, get out of there.
Speaker 2Get out of there.
Speaker 1That's a murder bed. So she gets... Jeremy put a lock on her door.
Speaker 2Jeremy put a lock on her door in the book because there are two big sex scenes between Loan and Jeremy in the book. I think only one of them is in the movie. So the first time they have sex is in her bedroom. In her sexy bedroom. In her sexy bedroom. And I'm pretty sure I'm getting this right. I hope I'm not mixing them up.
Speaker 1That's right. I'm not going to fact check you. But when.
Speaker 2The next morning, because he doesn't want crew to find out, so he goes to leave and the door's locked. There's only a lock from the outside. And then he's like, oh, it must have been the wind. And she's like, I don't think it's the wind.
Speaker 1The wind pushed the lock and turned it.
Speaker 2So he breaks open a window from the bedroom, runs upstairs, and both Verity and crew are fast asleep.
Speaker 1I bet they are. But are they? Oh, my God. Does she sleepwalk around the house in the book?
Speaker 2Okay, so there's a scene where she sleepwalks and she wakes up in Verity's bed.
Speaker 1Oh, no, that's so scary.
Speaker 2With Verity just staring at her. And she screams and runs away. And then Jeremy's like, what happened? What happened? And she's like, I'm so sorry I sleepwalk. This is how they find out she sleepswalk. And I'm like, firstly, this is crazy. Imagine like a woman you invite to write a book is like in bed with your wife.
Speaker 1And also, I know a lot of people think Verity is a villain and maybe she is, but in that case, she's in the right. Imagine Verity being like watching her low and get into bed and sleep next to her. And in her head, she's like, yeah, I've murdered a bunch of people, but also... The audacity of this woman.
Speaker 2The audacity.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So then there's also a scene where Crew cuts his lip.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah, because that's in the movie.
Speaker 2Okay. This scene in the book is.
Speaker 1I love how you can't differentiate between the movie and the book.
Speaker 2It's so scary.
Speaker 1He bites on a knife, which is.
Speaker 2What happens is he cuts his lip. He's in Verity's room where he cuts his lip and no one else is there. And he just starts screaming and wailing. And Lohan runs up to Verity's room and Crew's on the ground with a knife on the ground. Verity's in bed. And, um, she picks up crew and she's like, what's happened? What's happened? And he's like, I cut my lip. And she takes him downstairs to, um, see, uh, Jeremy and Jeremy comes into the kitchen. He's like, what happened? What happened? And then, um, Lowen's like, he cut his lip. He was in Verity's room.
Speaker 2There was a knife. And then crew's like, no, there wasn't a knife. I just fell over and very, and Loan's like, no, you didn't. She goes back up to Verity's bedroom and there's no knife on the ground. So she looks under the bed and then as she's coming up, Verity's face is right in her face.
Speaker 1Oh, Evelyn, you keep freaking me out with that.
Speaker 2That's what I'm trying to tell you.
Speaker 1It's a scary book.
Speaker 2And they like missed out on all these scenes.
Speaker 1That would have actually sent me over the edge. Like her face with her eyes open.
Speaker 2Like she like leant over in bed and her eyes are open.
Speaker 1I mean, the thing is, obviously, Vary is not in the best situation because she's having to pretend. But part of her is having a bit of fun with this. She's having so much fun with this. She's like, this pretty author's come into my house. She's obviously macking on my husband. She's moving in on my kid. And look, did I kill my daughters? Yes. Yes. But I'm also, well, one. And that's, you know. But still, she had thoughts of killing them all. But she's like, I'm going to have some fun and mess with her. And that's not okay.
Speaker 2That's not okay. So now we're coming up to like Harper's death.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Which is the kids want to go in the canoe on the lake behind their house.
Speaker 1And this is going back, like in the movie, it's her, it's Lauren going back and reading that manuscript again.
Speaker 2So she keeps going back and forth with the manuscript. She keeps getting very, very upset, putting it away, but she can't stop reading it.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And then we get to Harper's death and they're in the canoe together. The kids wanted their dad to take him and he's like, no, your mom will take you. And she's like, no. this guy. I hate this guy.
Speaker 1I hate this guy. I hate these kids. I hate my beautiful house.
Speaker 2I hate my beautiful house. And I feel like Anne Hathaway's acting of like her annoyance whenever Jeremy is paying more attention to the kids over her is so good because that's exactly what's happening in the memoir with Verity. And she takes a canoe and she, in the memoir, she's like, I have this great idea to kill Harper. I'll just like tip over the canoe and And in the book, she tells Crew to hold his breath. So the canoe tips over. Crew holds his breath. She swims with him to the shore. She doesn't go looking for Harper.
Speaker 2And Crew's like begging her to go look for Harper.
Speaker 1Oh, I hate that.
Speaker 2I can't listen to it. And Verity's like, remember, I tried to look for your sister. I tried to look for her, but I couldn't find her. And crew's like, please look for her.
Speaker 1Oh, Em, no, I can't. I can't hear you. And then she just ends up convincing him. I know it's a fictional story, but it just upsets me so much. It's so upsetting. There's nothing more horrific in.
Speaker 2The world than that story. So I'm glad we didn't see that whole thing happen for me.
Speaker 1Yeah, no.
Speaker 2Because even I was like, I don't want to see this scene.
Speaker 1I want to see that. I just don't. And, like, also I think, again, it sometimes feels– That part of the story feels out of place with some of the other parts of like, look at this sexy, crazy, these three sexy, crazy adults in this house. I'm like, no, they can do whatever they want. But don't wrap a story around children being tortured and killed by their parents who they trust the most in the world. I can't be around that.
Speaker 2So then we come to the point where, so Cruz cut his lip and Jeremy has to take him to the hospital.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2And Lowen is going to be left alone with Verity in the house.
Speaker 1I would have gone straight to my room and locked, oh, you can't lock it from the inside. Lock it from the outside. I sit out in the car. And now a window's broken too in the book. Oh, no. I sit outside with that knife just till he comes home.
Speaker 2Would have gone with him. I'm like, I don't care.
Speaker 1I'll take him. Leave her here. What's she going to do? Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 2So she takes the baby monitor that she had. She places it in front of Verity and then she goes back to Verity's study and looks at the baby monitor to make sure she's not moving.
Speaker 1Okay. And in the movie, this is where I thought this is prime time for some jump scares. Because the thing about baby monitors is they're very helpful. But as someone who, me, weirdly, I babysit so many children. Children related to me and children not. I don't know how it happens. It happens all the time. And I'm always given a baby monitor when I'm watching kids overnight. And they're creepy. Because the kid is just this little, whenever you're watching them, this little shape moving around. And then every so often you look at the baby monitor and the kid's awake and it's looking at the baby monitor. And there are some baby monitors that pick up like
Speaker 1sounds from other places. That should be illegal. Yeah, that has happened to me. Come on.
Speaker 2We send people, we send to Katie Page Space and we can't figure out baby monitors?
Speaker 1I know. Katy Perry's floating around space holding a daisy and when I babysit my niece, the neighbor's radio is picked up on their baby monitor. It's too scary. I was like, I'm going to have to leave that baby. No, I would never. Yeah, so baby monitors are scary. Any kind of camera, like a back camera on a car, a security camera in an apartment building, because there's so many movie moments where it's such a prime setup where the protagonist looks at it, there's nothing there, they look away, they look back, face down.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 1And that's what I thought was going to happen.
Speaker 2Well, let me tell you what happens in the book.
Speaker 1Oh, okay. Can this pod just be maybe you telling me about the book? I know.
Speaker 2But what happens in the book, so Loen sets up the baby camera in Verity's room. She does it behind her, so Verity doesn't actually see the camera.
Speaker 1Oh, because that's interesting. Because in the movie, it looked like she was standing in front of her. I'm like, well, she knows it's there.
Speaker 2Yeah, she knows it's there.
Speaker 1She's not an idiot. She's been tricking everyone for months.
Speaker 2And then Loan goes back. I think at this point also Jeremy's come back with crew. And Loan's continuing reading the memoir, like getting very, very upset. And then the baby monitor makes a noise because it makes a noise when there's movement. So she looks at the monitor and Verity's on her hands and knees.
Speaker 1Oh!
Speaker 2With her head down, and then Lohan screams Jeremy and then Verity hears it. So then she tilts her head at the camera.
Speaker 1Emily, your face doing these movements as Verity is so scary.
Speaker 2Can you imagine how good Anne Hathaway would have been at this?
Speaker 1No, I know. And she was already pretty good just like in the way she was doing it.
Speaker 2And then she throws, I think she throws him on her.
Speaker 1Guys, if you're not watching this on YouTube or you can watch it on video on Spotify, Apple, Emily's face movements while she's pretending to be evil book Verity.
Speaker 2My imagination's crazy. So I was like picturing every scene in my head. You're so creepy right now. I'm so sorry. She screams Jeremy. Jeremy comes back, obviously.
Speaker 1And what does she scuttle on the floor, Verity? I can't remember.
Speaker 2I think she's just back in bed. But this is the point where Lohan discloses the... thing the memoir to jeremy he gets very upset he reads it very very fast and then he goes to verity's room and confronts her and lowen's there as well in the book but she's not there she's watching on the baby monitor yes in the movie.
Speaker 1But coming back so skipping because we've skipped a little head for the movie oh yes before we get to that point in the movie which is obviously the like one of the big climax moments yeah we have jeremy and lowen like slowly starting to sort of get to know each other more and when she let's slip in the movie that it's her birthday he was like well why don't we go out to dinner and have a sexy time and it's like of course why wouldn't you with your sick wife in the house with this with this girl who's about to leave so then she goes into Verity's closet to pick out and she sees the
Speaker 1red dress and there's this idea of like in the book in the memoir when she first meets Jeremy she's wearing a red dress so she puts that on So there's a point here I'm just like, wait, is she the evil one? Did she set this up?
Speaker 2Maybe.
Speaker 1What's happening here?
Speaker 2I don't remember that happening in the book.
Speaker 1Maybe that's for the movie. And again, I do like a movie that writes its own scenes. Because I was like, that's the whole point of it.
Speaker 2And that's a very visual thing that I feel like was important for the audience.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. Because I heard people around just going like, ooh, when she comes downstairs in the red dress.
Speaker 2Also, our cinema was very loud.
Speaker 1Yeah, it really was.
Speaker 2There were some big talkers in the cinema, which I'm not a fan of.
Speaker 1Oh, I wasn't a fan of it either.
Speaker 2Thank you. So some feedback. Stop talking in cinemas.
Speaker 1Oh, people who talk in cinemas, I can't. I can't. Laughing and chatting and having a fun time. I guess that's what happens when you go to a media screening and there's some influencer-y, famous-y people.
Speaker 2There's some people whose job isn't reliant on talking about the movie.
Speaker 1There's some people who just came for the photo op.
Speaker 2And we were there to work.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And you were interrupting our work.
Speaker 1Yeah, thank you. We're professionals. We're professionals. Me with my three drinks. And those little cookies that they had. Great. Loved it. Loved it every second. So then they go to a Bavarian restaurant. I just, before we go back to Verity getting, I thought this part was important because this is when we have the big kind of emotional moment between Lohan and Jeremy of them having this dinner and them talking together. And they, this I think is like the start of their like proper emotional affair. But there's a funny line in there where he says to
Speaker 1her as they're talking that you're not having fun. And she's like, yes, I am. He's like, no, but you don't look like, you look like this is torture for you. And Lohan goes, sorry, I have resting bored face.
Speaker 2I looked at you the minute she said that.
Speaker 1I looked at you too.
Speaker 2Because I had a hidden meaning.
Speaker 1I was like, is that, what did you say to me that night? You're like, is that ad-libbed from Dakota Johnson? Because the thing about Dakota Johnson, and she has said this herself, and I have spoken to her before, and she does, she has resting bored face. Can I tell you when I interviewed Dakota Johnson, I don't even know if she did it on purpose. It was on a Zoom. And so she came on the Zoom and I started talking. You know, I'm a talker. Yeah. Famously. And I'm like, I loved your movie. And it's my job to watch it. I did. I loved her movie. Splitsville. It's so good.
Speaker 1I love your movie. I said to her and I watch, it's my job to watch every movie. So when I say I loved your movie, I really mean it. Cause I've seen everything. And then I realized, oh my God, she's frozen. I was like, oh my God, the Zoom's not working. Cause Dakota Johnson's like on my screen, her face is just frozen. It's like really neutral position. And so I'm laying down, I'm trying to tap on the little thing. I tapped the help box. I nearly tapped the screen. I'm like, oh, this is so annoying. Can't believe it's frozen. When I'm interviewing Dakota Johnson, I'm looking up and she's not moving. And then all of a sudden she blinks and I was like, oh, she's not frozen.
Speaker 1She's just not responding.
Speaker 2She's just not responding. She had resting bored face. And I remember when I watched that interview that you did with her, I think my first question to you was like, what did you say to her?
Speaker 1Yeah, I loved your movie.
Speaker 2And I was like, well, she clearly hates you.
Speaker 1Yeah, she did hate me.
Speaker 2Like she hates you so much.
Speaker 1Yes. She did. No, the thing is, I have watched, people have, of Dakota Johnson, people have only watched her big TV interviews where she's been crazy and she knows the host. Like, she and Jimmy Fallon are next door neighbours. No one has done the legwork like I have and watched the thousand of smaller interviews that she does with other journalists. And that's how she acts. Dead behind the eyes.
Speaker 2Because she just hates nobodies.
Speaker 1She does. She hates nobodies. And look, fair enough. If I was a third generation of a Hollywood dynasty, I'd hate everyone too. But she has said in the press a few times she knows that she has a very neutral expression. So when they said that in the movie, I was like, is that a little nod to her?
Speaker 2Yeah, she just said unresponsive.
Speaker 1Yeah, unresponsive.
Speaker 2She was method acting for this.
Speaker 1She was deeply method acting. And I guess this is a good character for her to play because it's very kind of just like, neutral and like she has a few intense moments but half the time lowan's just looking around yeah and she's reacting to something she says at the window and she's react just but when i say reacting there's a slight twitch of her face yeah.
Speaker 2But lowan in the book as well is very bland.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah i think that's the point of her right because the whole the whole point of her is that she's she's a writer she's quiet you get the idea that she just only wants to be like in a solitary environment Um, and why she liked being in a big city was not because she wanted to be around people is that she felt like she got lost in the crowd and she wanted to be lost in the crowd. So I think that all fits with like who this woman is. Um, so that's super interesting. And also she's also writing dark little books, you know, in, in a, like a, in a room. So that's her whole vibe. Um, so they're having this dinner and then he lets slip
Speaker 1to Lohan, Jeremy, that he's Verity didn't read her book, Hurtful, as he first said. He read her book and loved it. And that's why he wanted her, because she wanted someone to tell her in person that her writing meant something to them. And in any other world, this is a beautiful rom-com moment. If you're not taking in all the other factors of the murdered children and the homicidal wife and the potentially homicidal and then actually homicidal husband.
Speaker 2And then you think about like, Yeah, you're right. In any other situation, this would be a rom-com.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2But this is not that situation.
Speaker 1No, no, no.
Speaker 2So what I'm seeing is a man lying to me that his wife loved my work and then he basically just wanted me to live in his house.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Which is really weird.
Speaker 1But Lauren's not saying that because she's all in with Jeremy at this stage. Yeah, and she's wearing that beautiful red dress. And, you know, we all know, why aren't you wearing a really good red dress? We all make crazy decisions.
Speaker 2Yes. And she also calls Variety the C word.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Because she's so upset that, like, Verity's being able to hide this state of hers, but she's kind of playing.
Speaker 1With Lohan with it. Yeah, and also fair enough.
Speaker 2Yeah, and Lohan's like, I'm going to steal your husband. I'm going to steal your house. I'm going to steal your life. You see you in tea.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. And before this, okay, this is the few infamous scenes that I'm sure people are going to be like, why didn't you talk about this? Is that the sex scenes peppered through? Is that one, obviously, we see this flashback of Verity Verity and Jeremy having sex and then Anne Hathaway bites the... Anne Hathaway doesn't. In fact, when Maddie on our team interviewed Anne Hathaway, we obviously already played that interview in The Spill, but she was asked about biting headboards and she was like, I don't mean to be a square, but I would never. She's like, that's a lot of dental work. It's hard. She's like,
Speaker 1I'd bite other things. I'm not a complete square.
Speaker 2I wouldn't bite a headboard either because it's like you're also moving.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And I'm like, maybe if you were still, you could bite a headboard.
Speaker 1At least the headboard was wood.
Speaker 2But I don't think you can be grinding while also trying because you're going to lose a tooth.
Speaker 1Well, that was Anne Hathaway's thought. She was like, that's a lot of dental work that you're going to rack up. But also, Verity's teeth, very strong. Very strong. Cut right through.
Speaker 2And then Lohan tried to do the same thing with Jeremy.
Speaker 1Yeah. It must be a move Jeremy has that makes women want to bite a headboard.
Speaker 2Well, Lohan wanted to bite the headboard because she wanted to have deeper marks than verity and oh.
Speaker 1Okay like claim her territory yeah yeah that's obviously a book thing i mean she obviously she uh lowen still bites the headboard in the book in the movie but obviously you can sort of interpret it in different ways and things of how that is but also we have that moment where um lowen's dreaming but she's also masturbating in the incredible bathtub That's like sunken into the stone.
Speaker 2I wouldn't waste that bathtub on a masturbation moment, honestly. I'd play mermaids.
Speaker 1Can I do that?
Speaker 2Like, I don't think she used that bathtub. Like, you're on like a beautiful, it's like a beautiful rocky bathtub.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2I'm like, pretend to be a mermaid.
Speaker 1Yeah, that beautiful sunken bath. Actually, it's more like a grotto. It's a grotto.
Speaker 2And it's got rocks around it.
Speaker 1Like, she should be Ariel. Yeah, she should be. And I'm like, you know what?
Speaker 2Spend all your time in that bathtub.
Speaker 1Forget about everything.
Speaker 2That's exactly what I would do. That's exactly what I would do.
Speaker 1And be like, where's Laura?
Speaker 2Jeremy's like, I'm paying you to write these books.
Speaker 1And I'm like.
Speaker 2Another bath?
Speaker 1I just imagine, like, Verity coming up the stairs to, like, kill Lohan. And she looks in and she's expecting her to be, like, wearing her clothes, having sex with her husband. And it's just her paddling around the bath. But also, all these, can I just say, all these people with all their drama, if you're in that house, what is there to fight about? Couldn't you all just live in that house happily and you can have a grotto bath each? Yeah. I don't see what the issue is. Rich people are always so miserable.
Speaker 2Rich people want too much and you should just be happy with what you have.
Speaker 1Exactly. I would have lived in that house happily for the rest of my life by myself. Exactly. Except in that bedroom, that murder bedroom with too many entrance points. I sleep in the bathtub in my little darkness. Yeah, we've seen too many horror movies. Yeah, that's the thing. Seeing too many horror movies spoils a lot for you. So something to think about there. But that's when there's the going back to the masturbation scene, which I agree wasn't the correct use of the bath. That's when she has the fantasy of going into their shared bedroom and having sex with Jeremy. But then the camera flips and it's Verity.
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 1And the biting of the lip and the blood. Yeah. What do we think that was about?
Speaker 2I think it was about.
Speaker 1Because that was the biggest part of the movie marketing. So that's why I went in thinking that I was going to see a different movie. Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. I think it shows like Lohan's like obsession with Verity. Like she wants to hate her so badly, but she really wants to be her more.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, exactly. And she wants to like almost like consume her in a way. And she kind of sees Verity as this like, Because in that scene, Anne Hathaway is so good in that scene because she just, when the camera cuts back and there's that blood across Anne Hathaway's face and she does that intense smile, I was just like, oh, she's very evil.
Speaker 2She's got it.
Speaker 1But yeah, I guess it's because Verity fears her but also wants to be, like finds her very enticing and exciting in a way. Or she did before she kind of gets to the root of what she thinks she's done. So yeah, that was a kind of interesting part. And I love how Dakota and Anne are like, we improvise that scene. I'm like, of course she did, gals. It's just a little kiss. That's fine. Okay, sexy dinner, getting back to that. Oh, yes. And then going back to the house. And now they're fully like almost like in hookup mode all the time.
Speaker 2Always in hookup mode. The scene where they're having like sex on the kitchen bench does kind of happen. It happens and then Verity in the book, like so in the movie, Verity literally like walks up to them.
Speaker 1That's crazy. And what, Jeremy doesn't see it?
Speaker 2Yeah, Jeremy doesn't see it.
Speaker 1Can I say, that man is just choosing not to see what's going on in his house at this stage.
Speaker 2I feel like he knows some things now.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And there's also the scene where she's, like, left in front of the TV to watch the TV. And I think, I don't know if this, I don't think this happens in the movie, but in the book, she mutes the TV.
Speaker 1No, that didn't happen in the movie. There's very, in the movie, there's actually very few moments where you kind of think there's something up with Verity. Yeah. Like there is that moment where the character is like about to have sex and they start hooking up and then there's that kind of vision of Verity walking, like stumbling down the hallway towards them and she's watching them and she looks really heartbroken. And then that's when Llewyn sees her and starts screaming. But somehow Verity, who we're led to believe can't move, because the thing is even if she's pretending, she's also like, she's not moving her body very much
Speaker 1and she was in a car accident. So you get the idea in the movie that, she can't move quickly.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1But I was like, she moved pretty quickly just then. Yeah. She scurried away before Jeremy could see her.
Speaker 2She does. She's a very fast runner.
Speaker 1How is she described in the book? Is she described the way they've made Anne Hathaway look like? Is she a tall woman? Is she brunette? Like what's the vibe?
Speaker 2No, she's blonde in the book.
Speaker 1Oh.
Speaker 2She's blonde in the book and she is like, but she is like Anne Hathaway in the sense where she's like greater than life and like.
Speaker 1She is like. Like a classic beauty.
Speaker 2Classic beauty. The most beautiful person in every room she walks into. Very charismatic. Very like everyone loves her. Like she has like. Millions and millions of fans who love her writing and love her and love that she's like the face of her books as well.
Speaker 1Yeah, because that's what you get because like a lot of throughout the movie is scattered. interviews with Verity and some big names they got in there. Like Gayle King does an interview with her. Like it's the real Gayle King playing herself. And then she goes on Call Her Daddy with Alex Cooper, which is obviously was filmed, like Alex Cooper filmed her scenes and then Anne Hathaway should actually go on Call Her Daddy. And then also Hot Ones.
Speaker 2Hot Ones with Sean Evans. And he like asked like still very deep questions. I'm like, I want to watch this.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, yeah. Release the full cut of Verity Crawford. On Hot Ones. So good. It's funny because Anne Hathaway said she was hoping to do Hot Ones for the actual press tour of the movie Verity. But she's very heavily pregnant now and her doctor said she couldn't because she might go into early labor because of how hot the ticket is.
Speaker 2That's so funny.
Speaker 1But yeah, that was interesting. You're like, oh, even on like Verity Crawford on Hot Ones is kind of interesting. I wonder if she ate all the hottest wings. Release the full cut of Verity Crawford on Hot Ones. Verity could.
Speaker 2Also Anne. And would be able to as well.
Speaker 1And like very just has no emotion in her face. I know. So you're watching her in all these interviews and like, yeah, she's so good at being public facing and like putting on an act and having all these little jokes, but she's so reserved the whole time. Yeah. So it's also, it makes the contrast when you see like Anne Hathaway as like the bedridden woman. unmovable Verity. It's more of a stark contrast because then you can see what she's like in her real life.
Speaker 2Yeah. And then so we get to like towards the end of the movie where Jeremy's read the memoir, he goes upstairs to confront Verity. And the exact same thing happens in the movie that happens in the book.
Speaker 1Josh Harnett is great in that scene because you can see when he looks up from the manuscript, just the absolute anguish and pain on his face. Obviously, we learn later on that There's two sides to that story because that's either the first time he's read it or it's not, depending on which side you believe. But he looks anguished in that scene, and I think that's probably true for the character because he's either hearing it for the first time so he's distraught or he's reliving it so he's distraught. So good acting from Josh is what I'll say about that.
Speaker 2Such good acting from Josh.
Speaker 1So he tears to the bedroom in the movie.
Speaker 2Tears to the bedroom. He starts screaming at her. He's like, if you don't tell me, I will take this to the police. And then she immediately caves. And she's like– No, no, no, no, no, please, please, please. And he doesn't let her explain and then he starts.
Speaker 1And that was such a good moment for Anne Hathaway. Because, I mean, you asked me for my jump scares, obviously the moment outside. But that too, because even though I knew, but I didn't know when she was going to break or what was going to happen. Because before that, Lawood had literally stuck pins in her hand.
Speaker 2Yes, ew.
Speaker 1And Verity had it moved. So she's like committed to the bit.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'd be scared of that nurse. I'd be like, why is her hand bleeding?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And I'd be like, I don't know.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. Yeah, did no one check that?
Speaker 2Did no one check that?
Speaker 1Let's look into the medical care she was getting. Because that woman was, she was either in on it or she was not across what was happening with her patient. Yeah. That scene in the movie where he's like, tell me. And she's like, let me explain. And everyone in the movie goes, ah!
Speaker 2Yeah. Oh, my God. So scary. And then Lohan comes in and she's like, you have to make it look like an accident.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah. Lohan with the inner darkness coming out.
Speaker 2And she learned that from the memoir from when Verity tried to kill Harper.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So Verity's kind of teaching her. And then what confused me, which I don't think happened in the book and it made more sense in the book. So they kill Verity and then it's like, They don't go into like the police investigation or anything because I think it was in the book it was quite probable that she could have died in that state. So the fact that they made her like actually wake up and then walk herself into the lake as the way she died that they told the police was very odd to me.
Speaker 1Oh, okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, yes, in the movie he suffocates her with Lohan giving instructions about how to make it look like Yeah, an accident, which is creepy. If anyone has that information, look at them twice. And then they take her body out with weights and throw it into the lake. And it's a very cinematic scene because you have Lohan's voiceover and then you have that shot of Verity's body going down into the water and it's so ghostly and creepy and you see her sink into the darkness. And that's very picturesque. But in my mind,
Speaker 1I was like, you go to all the trouble to kill this woman and make it not look like an accident and then you dump her in front of the house. That's bad murdering 101.
Speaker 2Bad murdering 101.
Speaker 1You don't put the body in front of the house. No. So then I think what happened, they didn't show the scene. I think what happened is they dumped her over the edge, like goodbye Verity.
Speaker 2Oh, shit.
Speaker 1Because we can't say we don't know. She's tied up. Go get her. Go get her. And she's waiting to go get down and get her and go again. Try something else. You can't have an accidental death when the person is weighted down. No. So then they, so yeah, that's not explained in the movie because then they tell the police that she walked off the end of the dock. Yeah. But did the police, when the police got down there and pulled the body out, did they not realize that she was tied to something?
Speaker 2And I'm like the police, and you can even see the police writing notes and he's literally like woke up from her state, walked into the lake.
Speaker 1Yeah. Like what? Yeah, it's bad. That's bad police work. But obviously he's a fan of the books. But also, if he's a fan of the books, shouldn't he be more interested in finding out how his favorite author died?
Speaker 2This should be a personal project for you.
Speaker 1Yeah, he should be like, I'm going to solve this murder. And it's, yeah.
Speaker 2And he's like, oh, as long as I'm getting another book, that's fine.
Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. They must have pulled the weights off her or something for her to, because she sank to the bottom, so she was weighted down by something. That's not an accident. Her guilt at killing her children. Yeah. Okay, so whatever the police did or didn't do, and it sounds like they didn't do a lot, whatever happened there, they get away with it. They get away with it. Jeremy and Lohan.
Speaker 2Yes, because we get the seven months later where Lohan is pregnant with Jeremy's baby and they're packing up the house because they're moving and Lohan finds a letter from that was hidden in the floorboards of Verity's room.
Speaker 1Yes, because Crew had gone up there. Also, Crew, what a cute little kid. I was so worried the whole time something was going to happen to him. He's gone through a lot. He's really bounced back.
Speaker 2The only one his mum was speaking to.
Speaker 1Yeah. I'm hiding a lot of secrets. Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 2Firstly, you kill my sister.
Speaker 1Yeah. And you lied to me. You made me do this. My dad's probably done some stuff. And the whole time. So he went back up to get his pictures, which was cute. I thought there was going to be something in that when he went back up and said, I've got to get my pictures, my pictures. I thought there's going to be something in the pictures. I like, are there pictures of him and Verity like doing evil stuff together? Like doing evil stuff. And then you're actually pulled out the letter from under the floorboards. Yes.
Speaker 2Oh my God. So, okay. So to explain the letter in the book, um, it, it, it, the book goes into like, that's the reason why she was on her hands and knees because she was putting the letter in the floorboards. So the letter being there explains a lot of the things, like that's why she hid the knife because she didn't want the floorboards to be seen. So that, a lot of the scary scenes were explained that way in the book.
Speaker 1Interesting. Okay.
Speaker 2Now coming to the letter, Verity in the movie goes through the whole like reasoning for her memoir. She's Basically saying that the reason why all this happens was because she was doing a writing task.
Speaker 1Yeah, that was a bit tenuous for me.
Speaker 2And I feel like as writers, I'm quite offended. I'm quite offended.
Speaker 1I can't say I've ever heard of that, but I mean, I have heard a very similar thing. So yes, her agent had said to her that as a writing exercise, you flip the story around and you write from the villain's perspective, right? To process the story. And in the letter, Verity says that that's what she was doing following Harper's death. And the words just started pouring out of her. So basically she was saying that was all made up, right? Yes.
Speaker 2Do you believe it?
Speaker 1Yeah. Okay. This is the interesting part. Well, the thing is, before the letter even came out, as we were reading it, I thought it was going to flip that. I was like, oh, is it the other way around? Because when they said flip the story and write from the other perspective, I thought it was going to come out that Jeremy had done all those things, that he was the one who didn't want the kids, that he felt that she had abandoned him for the kids, that he had treated them badly and that he had done something. That's how I thought it was going to go. But then I was like, oh, no, no, now they're saying it's more of like a made-up story.
Speaker 1And she's written this as like a way to kind of.
Speaker 2Like a trauma response.
Speaker 1Yeah, like a trauma response. Which.
Speaker 2To help her, I guess, with everything that's happened in her life.
Speaker 1And that she was horrified. Because obviously only in... I don't know about the book, but in the movie, it's only Harper who has died in that moment. And it was an accident. What do I believe? I've been thinking about this since we saw this movie. And I'm not sure... But I understand the twist. I understand they're trying to be like, oh, my God, like there's an option that she wasn't. But I don't know, and maybe this comes down to Colleen Hoover as a storyteller and maybe she hasn't laid enough, like, information around this for me to
Speaker 1believe this. I don't know if there's enough content in the story to back up this theory we're supposed to have about Verity, that that was all an act. Because... There's so much evidence to suggest that what she was writing was true. And also, like, I know that theory is that, like, he thought that she killed Harper. So he put her in the car and tried to kill her. And then the reason she's been in this pretend, like, catatonic state is that she was trying to get away
Speaker 1with Crute. Mm-hmm. But also that feels tenuous because she's had ample opportunity to get away with Cruz and she has so much money. And I mean, not that that's obviously easy, but then the part of me that makes it, I'm just going back and flip because I don't know. I don't really know what the answer is. But then the part of it that was kind of interesting is that when she started speaking to Cruz in the movie and he was so happy to be talking to her and he kept her secret and he felt so comfortable and safe with her and he had a fear that people would find out. I was like, well, if he has this relationship with his mother, then that makes me
Speaker 1think that her version of her being a good, loving mother was maybe the true one because you can't trick the kid. But also I don't actually think to be, not to call out Colleen Hoover, who's a very successful writer, but I don't think that she has put I'm creating those in my mind. I don't think she has put all those layers in there for us to find.
Speaker 2Reading the book, I was quite a bit disappointed with the ending because I felt very rushed with, like, our final goodbye to Verity and our final twist is just, like, a really short letter. Yeah. What was really funny in the book, though, was because– There are so many more sex scenes in the book than there is in the movie with Verity and Jeremy. And they're very intense. And you believe her obsession with him. Like, you genuinely believe that he was her whole life and nothing else matters. And in the letter, it was really funny, which is
Speaker 2why in the book, when I read the book, I kind of believed that Verity was telling the truth and it was like a writing exercise, even though I don't think that was the right way to go. But I do believe that she... like that whole thing was made up because in the letter there's a part where she says in the book, obviously this was a lie because women don't love sex that much.
Speaker 1Oh, I don't know if that's what you want to hook your claim on, Verity.
Speaker 2It was so funny though because I'm like, you know what? Because in some of the scenes, as I was explaining before, like they were like so outrageously out there where I'm like, I wouldn't even journal about this. Like it is so crazy.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And then when she says in the letter, like, women don't, like, love men that much and they don't love sex that much.
Speaker 1Oh, no. There's plenty of women who do. Not that way. Okay. And I was like, you know what? That's true. I believe you. I believe you, girl. Yeah. No, but also, like, it's not just the sex side of it. Like, from the movie side of it, at least, it's the idea of, like, wanting, like, a man to love you this much. And, like, people do fixate on other people to that extent.
Speaker 2I just couldn't believe that she would do this writing exercise a minute after Harper dies. If she was claiming it was.
Speaker 1A writing exercise.
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 1It's just, it wasn't enough. I love the, I don't mind the idea of like a inconclusive ending. And as an audience member, I never mind having to do like a little bit of work sometimes to think like, what do I think? What are the clues? But the issue that this didn't land as well for me, I like the idea of the ending, but I just don't know. Like, does Colleen Hoover know? Yeah.
Speaker 2No.
Speaker 1The thing is, like, for me to really believe it, I need to know that even if I as a reader or a movie watcher will never know the truth, I need to know that the characters who live inside this person's head, I need to know that they know the truth of what happened.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's what I wished when we were talking about the movie before we went to the premiere. I said to you... I wish they changed, I wish they will change the ending in the movie and they didn't. Yeah. Because I wanted it to be Jeremy. I wanted it to be Lohan. I wanted it to be a bigger twist than what it was.
Speaker 1Me too because I think it's a bigger twist if there's a bit more of a definitive or even a bit more reason for her to believe it. Make it the nurse.
Speaker 2Make it crew.
Speaker 1Yeah. The camera goes to crew and he's still holding the knife.
Speaker 2But I just felt like it had so much more potential to be, like, greater.
Speaker 1Yeah, it just felt like, and I know the ending is divisive for people, but I also, yeah, I wondered if maybe the movie should have taken a stand where the book had it or at least give us more information so it was a bit more of a plot twist. But I feel like because Lohan, in the movie, she moves on from it so quickly. Because she kind of has to just like wipe away tears, get in the car. I'm having this man's baby. I'm in it now is kind of her thinking. So you almost see her disregard it, which to me is kind of like, well, should the audience just disregard it? Yeah, which happens in the book
Speaker 1as well. It doesn't feel like as much of a plot twist because it's brushed aside.
Speaker 2Yeah, I agree. I completely agree. And that's like, I was just sad that I had that same like unfinished feeling in the movie that I did when I first ended the book yeah i'm like double unfinished.
Speaker 1Yeah because again a plot twist is incredible but a plot twist only works if like every piece of the puzzle is in place when the story starts and it comes across to you because there's there's so many little parts where you think but what about this and what about that and just yeah and like looking back at the way i guess like looking back at the kind of you see the way the kids treat her it's also like she's they're not acting like in the flashbacks which i know is from her perspective but they're not acting like kids who are brushed aside or unloved by their mother when you kind of see the flashbacks and he and Jeremy doesn't remember anything about that.
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 1Yeah. So that's why he's so shocked when he reads it because it doesn't match up with the life. And I know in the flashback, she's pretending to love the kids, but everything about it just seems like it wasn't quite placed properly. But it's a good, it's a great premise. The whole book is a movie is an incredible premise and there's truly terrifying scenes in it. And it's gorgeous to watch except for obvious. I mean, it's gorgeous visually to watch when the adults are on screen. None of the scenes with the kids. I hate those. I hate those. Oh, and that house and that grotto. And again, take us
Speaker 1to that house. Yeah. I mean, get Verity out of it. Or look, if she wants to hang there, that's fine. That's fine.
Speaker 2I'll be fine.
Speaker 1That woman wants to just hang out in the house and pretend to be catatonic. You go for your life, girl. Yeah. You know what? We both love movies where people don't talk. That's so true. In a way, Verity's like the ultimate movie buddy.
Speaker 2Yes. Oh, my God.
Speaker 1She might try to kill you, but she won't say a word when the movie's on.
Speaker 2Important so verity i actually do encourage because i wish i did this yeah if you haven't read the book but you've seen the movie still read the book it's so much more scarier i was getting scared reading it like the jump scares in the book is like way more.
Speaker 1Um i'm getting scared watching you watch it out every time you said to me then she does this and in this studio when you did the verity face following you i don't like emily don't I don't like it. When I go to bed tonight and I'm doing my bedroom checks for monsters and stuff, I'm picturing your face popping up from my bed. Scary! Oh, yuck!
Speaker 2Gross.
Speaker 1Okay, well, that was our brutally honest review of Verity. And as you're saying, I know so many people who loved it. So, like, you know, see it in the theatres, read the book.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Tell us what you think the ending is. I'm interested to know what people think.
Speaker 2Well, thank you so much for listening to this episode of The Spill. If you don't follow us on socials, please do. We put a lot of content on there. You can follow us on Instagram or TikTok. We'll put those links in our show notes and we will see you next week.
Six years after the most famous podcast breakup of all time, Sofia Franklyn has finally told her side of the Call Her Daddy story, and Alex Cooper hasn’t said a word. We’re unpacking Daddy Issues, the memoir that reads...
Read our entertainment editor Tina Burke's review of Sunrise On The Reaping here. Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription for Black Friday with code BLACK30. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends...
Khloe Kardashian hasn’t had sex in four years, and she’s officially over everyone asking why. We’re unpacking her candid chat with Goldie Hawn, the Lemme gummy that started it all, and a very unexpected list of men who...
This morning, Anne Hathaway becomes a mum of three, and Jeff Bezos makes a very interesting admission about the new James Bond. Plus, the Pretty Little Liars rumour that has every millennial texting their group chat. ☕...
After the longest casting saga in history, Robert Pattinson is officially the new James Bond. Here’s why we think it’s the wrong call, plus the Twilight fans who called it first and who we really wanted in the tux. Tina...