Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Spill

The Spill artwork

A Brutally Honest Review Of The Call Her Daddy Tell-All

Nov 20, 202659 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Six years after the most famous podcast breakup of all time, Sofia Franklyn has finally told her side of the Call Her Daddy story, and Alex Cooper hasn’t said a word. We’re unpacking Daddy Issues, the memoir that reads less like a glossy celeb tell-all and more like a tragedy. There’s a blackout Christmas party that three different people remember three different ways, a secret pay rise that changed everything, and a safe word that was meant to keep two best friends together. We get into the Barstool women who say this isn’t what happened, why the internet’s most hated man of 2020 has been quietly rewritten, and the one part of this saga where someone has to be lying. Plus, we’re conflicted about that happy ending. It’s messy, it’s juicy and nobody comes out looking good. Daddy Issues is out now. Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription for Black Friday with code BLACK30. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends November 30. Become a Mamamia subscriber and get an all-access pass to everything we make, including exclusive podcasts and early listening, subscriber-only articles, monthly giveaways and our home workout app, MOVE. Built to work around your real life, MOVE adapts to whatever season you're in. That's why we've created a brand new collection of feel-good weight workouts, designed for any body, anywhere. No hectic challenges or intimidating gym setups, just simple, easy-to-follow sessions, designed to help you build strength at your own pace. MOVE is feel-good fitness by Mamamia. For less than a coffee a week, get unlimited access to hundreds of workouts, ranging from five to 45 minutes. Plus, you get unlimited access to everything across Mamamia, including subscriber-exclusive podcast episodes, articles, discounts and giveaways. Get your MOVE goodness here. Get access to Very Peri, Mamamia's exclusive perimenopause series, for just $59. 25 world-leading experts, over 20 on-demand sessions, available now. We’ve sorted through the noise so you don't have to. Go to veryperi.com.au and join me today. You hot? Same. Buy today and save 40% THE END BITS Find and follow us on socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thespillpodcast/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thespillpod Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thespillpodcast/ Support independent women's media Want to join the conversation? Have feedback or a topic you want us to discuss? Send us a voice message or email us at thespill@mamamia.com.auand we’ll get back to you ASAP! Executive Producer: Monisha Iswaran Mamamia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1From Mamma Mia, welcome to The Spill, your daily pop culture fix. I'm Laura Brodnick.

Speaker 2And I'm Liv James.

Speaker 1Now, Liv James, you are the perfect person to be here for this episode that we have been talking about for over a year since this book was announced.

Speaker 2Yes. This is, I feel like I know too much about it. I feel like I am only seeing content around it. I just saw photos of Sophia and Alex Earle at the Bumble event.

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 2And everyone is saying they have the opportunity to do the funniest thing ever, and that is start their own podcast. And I honestly think they might.

Speaker 1I don't think they will, but it's a funny thought. I don't think either of them have quite the vibe for that. They're all more about a photo than a long-term revenge. But, of course, we're talking about the, when I say you're across this, I mean the story that started back in 2018, which is the Call Her Daddy podcast, which we've talked about a lot on this show. with the breakup between Alex Cooper and Sophia Franklin, the founders of that. And a while ago, Sophia Franklin announced that she was releasing her own memoir. I have my well-thumbed copy in front of me. I've gone through this bad

Speaker 1boy a few times. her memoir, Daddy Issues, which is finally telling her side of the call, her daddy drama. So I'm glad you're here for this because I know you've been in the weeds of this for many years. So with a brutally honest review, they're usually for movies or TV shows, but we're doing a book this time just because I feel like our audience is very hungry for this. But I will say if you're out there and you're like, Laura, I don't know who the Call Her Daddy girls are. I don't know much about Alex Cooper. I don't know Sophia Franklin. And to that I say, that's so fine. Yeah. Buckle up because we're going to tell this story.

Speaker 2Indeed, buckle up. This story is about betrayal. It's about friendship. It's about sisterhood. It's about business. Yes.

Speaker 1It's about dating. So there's something for everyone.

Speaker 2I think it will get made into a TV show one day. I think it will be.

Speaker 1Too.

Speaker 2Exactly. I think that's very much the vibe. We're getting ahead of everything. We're making sure everyone's in the know. Yes, because we're going through spoilers of the book. But as I said, if you're not across the story, don't worry, we're going to hold your hand. Yes.

Speaker 1So Daddy Issues starts with Sophia Franklin. Again, podcast host of Call Her Daddy. Then she was ousted, started her own podcast, now has written this memoir. But it starts with her childhood, which is something she has talked about, but went a bit more in depth with this novel.

Speaker 2Absolutely. And she had a very interesting childhood. She had a few arrests for underage drinking. And what people have really clung on to and what's made it into the headlines is that she accidentally smoked meth thinking it was cocaine.

Speaker 1Yeah, if I had a dollar, hey.

Speaker 2I mean, look, we all do wild things in our youth.

Speaker 1I think a lot of things.

Speaker 2Were known about her. Liv's gone already. We're two minutes into this.

Speaker 1A lot of things were known about her like crazy, like teenage years and early adulthood because that went on to be the basis of Call Her Daddy, like her telling these wild stories. And she even sold like sweatshirts, like they sold them through Call Her Daddy with her mugshot on it. Exactly. But I thought it also showed a different kind of the, I guess, more sensitive, not as fun, crazy side of like growing up with a single mother, her mom falling in love and like her like kind of like quote unquote stepfather, kind of like his impact. And also how, yeah, she did discover drugs

Speaker 1and partying and was just feeling really lost and was so desperate to get out of Utah and move to New York.

Speaker 2Yeah, and she discovered them at the most extreme level, I would say. But she did end up going to New York. She worked in a finance firm, which is quite interesting, before she did Call Her Daddy.

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 2Do you know how she met Alex?

Speaker 1Oh, so I had heard bits and pieces. Were you an original Call Her Daddy listener when it came out in 2018?

Speaker 2I was a little tiny bit bit. I would say, well, actually I was 18. So maybe, I guess I just.

Speaker 1You're too innocent for that world.

Speaker 2I wasn't in the know, but when the Gluck Gluck episode came out. Oh, that really skyrocketed them. It went viral for listeners that don't know about that.

Speaker 1Yeah, tell us Liv.

Speaker 2Yeah. Sorry, mum. That episode is a.

Speaker 1Full- Don't listen, Liv's mum. Or do listen.

Speaker 2I don't know.

Speaker 1Maybe you're very sex positive. Yeah.

Speaker 2That is a full deep dive episode where the girls, Alex and Sophia, give you a how-to on how to perform the perfect oral sex. And it went completely viral. That's how people found out about the podcast, I feel like, in a mainstream way. Oh, absolutely.

Speaker 1That was kind of like the real height of their fame. Yes. So Sophia's in a rough situation. She's in a domestic violence situation. And she's able, through the company she's working for, and this is what she writes in the book, because we're kind of following through her young adult years, she's able to move to New York. She moves in with her aunt. So these are the kind of little tidbits of her story that I didn't know. But reading the book, I was like, it's really shaping her as a full person. And so she moves in with her aunt who's living in a tiny New York apartment. And her aunt says, you're welcome to stay, but your bags are not. Yeah.

Speaker 1And I was like, Aunt Fabiana, I think her name is.

Speaker 2You're like, hello? I was like, what?

Speaker 1You can't, like, push it.

Speaker 2There shouldn't be terms and conditions. But you know what?

Speaker 1A New York apartment, it was probably a one-bedroom. She's probably sleeping on the couch or something like that. And, yeah, you can't have bags in that apartment.

Speaker 2But, like, still just make it work a little bit.

Speaker 1I know, but she has to go rent a tiny little storage unit across the road from the apartment. And she treats– I would just put everything in there and just– not use it. I was thinking as I was reading, like thumbing through this book like crazy. But she goes across every morning to get dressed in the storage shed.

Speaker 2It's so funny.

Speaker 1And get her stuff out.

Speaker 2It is the perfect setting for a TV show. You can imagine that they're going to do it. But yeah, so she's living in this apartment and she's obviously trying to figure out what she's going to do. And probably is thinking, I can't stay here and live like this for a bit longer.

Speaker 1Exactly.

Speaker 2And then she gets into an Uber pool.

Speaker 1Yes, or a via, as we say. Well, the step between that is she does get her own apartment. And I can really relate to this, and maybe you can too, as someone who has moved to a lot of different cities and that intense loneliness.

Speaker 2I've never lived in another city, LB. Yeah. Only Sydney.

Speaker 1Oh, no, but you moved to Sydney from a different town, right?

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1Well, I've had that thing where I've moved to so many different cities and lived alone. And it's such an intense loneliness because living alone, let me tell you, it is the best thing ever when you have options to leave and be with other people. Living alone when you don't have any friends or you're in a new city is.

Speaker 2Lonely.

Speaker 1Really.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And that's what we see Sophia because she has her aunt, but she doesn't obviously go hang out with her. She's going to work. She's getting sexually harassed at work and she doesn't got any friends and she's just living in this apartment that she can't afford. And so she's kind of like putting all the pieces together of how this story fell in her lap. And then she gets in a VR, which I wasn't super across, but I do remember it being mentioned.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1It's like an Uber pool.

Speaker 2It's like an, like, does it still exist? I'm not sure. I don't think so. I don't know.

Speaker 1Well, if it's not very widely used. Yeah. Basically, it's like a whole bunch of, you can book it and a whole bunch of strangers get in and get dropped off like an Uber pool.

Speaker 2Yeah, exactly like an Uber pool. She gets into the Uber pool and she like sparks up a conversation with whoever's in the car with her.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And she goes. Another drunk girl called Taylor.

Speaker 1Oh.

Speaker 2There we go. Extreme details. I love that, LB. And then she says, I have nowhere to live. And then Taylor, I guess, goes, well, I know someone. And that someone is Alex Cooper. Yeah, it's... Well, again, I really related to Sophia in this moment of.

Speaker 1Because, again, when I've moved to new cities and I don't know anyone, you start... Like, people think you would fantasize about, like, meeting a love interest or something.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1But you're so desperate for friends.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1And just someone who doesn't want to have sex with you because you want companionship and friendship. And that term that you start... Unconditional, too.

Speaker 2You start seeing people walking past you and you're like, maybe she'd be my friend. Maybe she.

Speaker 1And you start having fantasies about, like, a girl stopping and talking to you.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1So... Um, Sophia said she's in the back of this VR, she's hung over, she's going into this job she hates and this girl in front of her turns around and apparently she's like gorgeous. And she's like, oh, I'm so hung over. And at first I'm like, is that Alex Cooper in my head? I'm like, is she meeting Alex Cooper? But she's meeting, um, Taylor and they go back and forth about how hung over they are. Yeah. They meet for happy hour drinks later that day.

Speaker 2Oh, I didn't realize that happened.

Speaker 1Yeah. Do we read the same book? Yeah.

Speaker 2So this is a really annoying thing about me.

Speaker 1Liv, you'll notice we do podcasts. I don't mean to, but I have like a photographic memory.

Speaker 2I'm like, LB's retaining a lot of stuff. And I'm like, geez. Okay, here we go.

Speaker 1Some would say too much.

Speaker 2I know.

Speaker 1I wish I remembered other more important things of life.

Speaker 2But that's like a beautiful meet cute, isn't it? It's like they almost fall in love. Exactly.

Speaker 1They have that kind of, I mean, Taylor is 45 minutes to meet her after work. That's okay.

Speaker 2Taylor's hungover. She's got a lot of stuff going on. It doesn't count when it's a friend.

Speaker 1And then she messages her later and is like, oh, my friend Alex. is looking for another roommate so they can get a three-bedroom with her and her best friend, Lauren. Do you still hate your apartment? And Sophia's like, absolutely, yes. And she's trying to not come across as too needy. And then what I thought what Taylor said was interesting is she's like, oh, just so you know, she's a bit famous. Well, I think at the time she was a bit well-known because the thing is she did have.

Speaker 2A YouTube channel.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Do you know what I liken her to? She's a local celebrity. Yeah. So we all grew up, obviously, with people that you probably went to high school with and maybe were a few years older than you. And I have a few where I'm like, that is my local celebrity.

Speaker 1That's your local celebrity, yeah.

Speaker 2And I walk around and if I see them, I know I'm like, oh, my God, that's that person. And I know probably 15 other people would say that too. Yeah, yeah. I feel like Alex Cooper was famous in that way.

Speaker 1She was famous in that way. She had been on like bar stools, like smoke show thing before. But I think mostly because she was dating Noah Syndergaard. A name I've never heard before, but a very famous athlete apparently. I just don't know athletes. It's not for me to know, but because she was dating him and they'd been seen out publicly and she had an online following. Yes. So she and Sophia go and start, Alex and Sophia meet for the first time when they're looking for apartments. Yes.

Speaker 2And they just hit it off, right? They do. But I would say you're in a vulnerable position there, right? You are almost going to force yourself to hit it off with whoever's in front of you when you are desperate to get out of your living situation. So I'm not surprised that they got along so well. Like that's the only option she had. Yeah.

Speaker 1Again, I really relate to kind of like when Sophia's talking about like feeling nervous about moving with two best friends, just wanting to make it work and just wanting to get out of that apartment. So they end up getting a three-bedroom. Lauren, who is now a producer with Alex Cooper on Call Her Daddy, which was only added during Alex Cooper's documentary, Call Her Alex.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1She'd been doing it for years and they had kept it secret.

Speaker 2Which is weird. I don't get it. But that's my first bomb drop.

Speaker 1What's your bomb drop?

Speaker 2Do you want to do a sound effect? Boom. Boom. She's been waiting to do that, everyone. Lauren told Sophia that Alex uses you because you're hot and then she'll toss you to the side, which I thought was incredibly interesting. Yes.

Speaker 1And.

Speaker 2I think about this because I wonder if Lauren got jealous about the friendship that Sophia and Alex were having as well. Like I think there would have been multiple emotions going into play. Oh, absolutely.

Speaker 1Yeah, that's interesting because that happens when the three of them are living together. But Sophia, and we will get into this more later, but like obviously we're taking Sophia as an unreliable narrator.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1The same way I take Alex Cooper as an unreliable narrator. Exactly. Um, and a lot of people only because like everyone's very fixed that their story is true, but all their stories are different. So someone's not saying the right thing.

Speaker 2It's the very famous quote. There's your story, their story and the truth. Exactly. And that has never been more true than right now.

Speaker 1But in Sophia's version of events, there's one night where Alex is away and she's not normally away because she keeps always going, Alex doesn't want to be near her family. Alex doesn't want to like visit her family. which is very telling because Alex Cooper's family become bigger parts of her story later on.

Speaker 2They do.

Speaker 1But there's one night where Lauren comes home and she and Sophia are sitting on the couch.

Speaker 2Lauren's drunk. And, yes, you're right, she's telling her, like, you can't trust Alex. But they never speak of it again. It's so weird. Do you think that that maybe has, like, because obviously Lauren is still very much involved in Alex's life.

Speaker 1Oh, yeah, they're still the best of friends.

Speaker 2I wonder if that's kind of put a wedge in between them a little bit. I don't know.

Speaker 1I just think there would be so much more to that story. And I think if Lauren's been her best friend through high school, which is what it looks like it is, has been her best friend through all of this, all of the Call Her Daddy drama. She now works at the Unwell Network, is the producer on Call Her Daddy. Alex Cooper's husband, Matt and Alex Cooper, like furnished her apartment for her. When she moved, yeah, like really, like she's in the throes of that. So I would say that she's seen more than anyone else.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1So I don't know if that, reading that in the book, would have done anything to their friend. It's so hard to know because obviously Alex Cooper, when Daddy Issues came out, it has been like a kind of, it has just been all over the internet. And Sophia Franklin has gone on the biggest podcast Press tour for it. She's been on every TV show, morning show, panel show. She's on every podcast. Lena Dunham interviewed her for her newsletter.

Speaker 2Like she's, you know what I mean?

Speaker 1She's had all different types and vibes of media. Everyone's been sharing the book. Everyone's talking about the book. Again, that's why we wanted to do a whole episode on it because it's just like, it's been saturation.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1So through it all, Alex Cooper has said not a word and she won't say a word because that's her playbook.

Speaker 2You don't think she'll say anything? No.

Speaker 1This is her playbook with controversy. She says nothing. And she obviously is on maternity leave as well, so I wouldn't expect her to, so she's home with her baby. But also this is what she does when there's any kind of controversy. The Alex Earle thing where she posts that video and said, if you want to say something, say something, was out of character for the new Alex Cooper.

Speaker 2Yeah, interesting.

Speaker 1The one she had become when she evolved into like this generation's Oprah kind of girl boss vogue, girl boss vibe.

Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely. Interesting.

Speaker 1Okay.

Speaker 2Yeah, because then what I also found quite interesting is that the show didn't run for a very long time.

Speaker 1It's so crazy because this is kind of like the Spice Girls. The Spice Girls made such a big impact, but they were only really a band for a couple of years.

Speaker 2That blows my mind. What?

Speaker 1Yeah, they were only together for like three or four years. Something really before Jerry left.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1And then they were together a bit longer, but... I always count it from when they released their first album and, like, started touring, so when they became a band, to when Jerry left the band. And it's literally, like, two years. Wow. Or, like, some short amount of time. But the impact lasts for generations. And Call Her Daddy is the same because it was founded in 2018. Yep.

Speaker 2And then in 2020 is when Alex....

Speaker 1Took it from Sophia or Sophia let it go, depending on who you ask.

Speaker 2Yes, exactly.

Speaker 1So two years.

Speaker 2Two years.

Speaker 1And yet six years later, it's still the biggest talking point.

Speaker 2Absolutely. And it all began, and now correct me with your photographic memory, they were out and about, like drinking at the bars and having the time of their life.

Speaker 1And.

Speaker 2I think the story is, is that the two girls were telling a story and there was just a crowd of people around them. Yeah.

Speaker 1That was kind of like here, how this kind of the idea, how they realized how they could put on a show. Exactly. Because you've got, and again, this is again, something that happens in your twenties, especially for women, which is really beautiful, but also can be all consuming and sometimes toxic is when you meet a new friend.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1And especially if you're in a new city or you've just grown up or something like that, and they become your everything, your lifeline, your companion, your roommate, your best friend, your therapist, everything. And that's what Sophia and Alex became to each other because they were living in this apartment together. Lauren was never there. Obviously, Sophia's mother was like a plane flight away. Alex didn't really go and see her family in Pennsylvania much. They're each other's person. They spent every night together, every weekend together. It was like they were in a relationship.

Speaker 2It really is.

Speaker 1And they even talk about the fact where anytime they tried to add a new friend into the mix, it didn't work. So they were always a duo. They were never part of a group. According to Sophia, Alex obviously, we'll get to, has had a different story over the years. So yeah, they realize that they're very entertaining together.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1And then Alex loses her job at a magazine she was working at. She's trying to be a YouTuber. She's trying to make that happen. Which is not funny.

Speaker 2That's actually beautiful and it really worked out for her, I guess. I don't know. It's really beautiful. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm always like when someone says they want to be a YouTuber, it reminds me of like kids that are like they don't want to be firefighters anymore. They want to be YouTubers.

Speaker 1Literally kids only want to be YouTubers.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's so funny.

Speaker 1Literally one of my nephews is obsessed with me and not just because I'm the world's best auntie because I am, but he's newly obsessed with me because he found out the spills on YouTube. Exactly.

Speaker 2He's like, that's my in. Oh my God.

Speaker 1Well... And him and all his friends, they just want to be YouTubers. It's so crazy.

Speaker 2Yeah, exactly. So Alex Cooper was starting that. Yeah, that's so funny. So then she lost her job. Yeah. And then she was like, well, we could do this.

Speaker 1And then she met this guy who was like, I'm starting a media company.

Speaker 2I want to start a podcast.

Speaker 1And Alex was like, well, I need a podcast host, which is how she and Sophia started doing demos.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1For this smaller media company, posted a few clips, and that's when, enter Dave Portnoy. I know so much more about this man. He is my guilty pleasure, LB. Hey, he's everyone's guilty pleasure. Well, at least a lot of people. And, like, it's hard because he's so awful. He's so awful. But he's entertaining sometimes.

Speaker 2He's disgusting.

Speaker 1But he's also disgusting.

Speaker 2And yes, but he, like he himself had a podcast for a very long time where he just rinsed the shit out of celebrities. Yeah. And gossip about them. Well, that's the thing. Like I do sometimes, especially like I have been kind of interested in his take on this because he was there.

Speaker 1Yes. But I'm always like, I do feel dirty watching what he says and listening to him. So Dave Pointnoy is the founder of Barstool Sports, which is a huge media, mostly podcast, but also YouTube company that was founded in New York. And he had known Alex a bit through her being like, A YouTuber. And dating sports stars.

Speaker 2Sports dudes. And I think that he had already followed her. So he was seeing these clips come through of the girls and he slid into her DMs.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And was like, what is this? And he described it as female locker room talk. Yes. Something he had never seen before. Yeah, it was two girls, me and Sexy. Yeah.

Speaker 1So Alex and Sophia signed then to Barstool Sports and they start Call Her Daddy. Yes. Now, their interpretation of Barstool sports culture is interesting because if you're reading Sophia Franklin's memoir, Daddy Issues, Barstool sports comes across, it's full of men, but like, grunting sports, like angry, dirty men.

Speaker 2Yeah. And they're all, and everyone just, it's like a content farm.

Speaker 1Yeah. I kind of think it's like how those hype, you know how like Hype Houses.

Speaker 2Hype Houses. It was, it kind of was an OG Hype House.

Speaker 1It was the OG Hype House, yeah.

Speaker 2But also there's vlogs that you can watch of Barstool when the girls were there.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And they go for 40 minutes. They're really entertaining. It's not, I mean, it's full of men. Yeah. It is, but it's not this like grungy, like there's massive windows. There's heaps of nice light.

Speaker 1Maybe it was their move to say, new office because they moved to an old office they moved to a new office but yeah they were like they when Sophia and Alex went to Barstool they felt again Sophia's take on it was like fish out of water everyone wanting us to perform cameras in our faces all the time and she kept saying like there's really no women there there's no women there's no women and talks about the culture Yeah. Which is kind of interesting because do you listen to Chicks in the Office podcast?

Speaker 2I do a little bit. I see their clips a lot. Yes.

Speaker 1So hosted by two very entertaining women called Fran and Ria.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1They were at Barstool already when Alex and Sophia started Call Her Daddy. I had no idea.

Speaker 2So they were already there.

Speaker 1It's so, on a recent episode, they do their response to daddy issues. You need to go listen to it. It's so funny. That would be so funny. I think that we have in this story, we have your version, your version, the truth and Fran and Ria's truth. And I quite think I believe them because, you know, I always believe the person who's just in the background.

Speaker 2What did they say? Give me, whose side are they on?

Speaker 1Neither. They don't like either of them. Because they said that when Sophia and Alex first came to Barstool, they treated them quite badly. yeah and they don't like the way that the story is kind of portrayed in the book because they're like there was no women here they're like we were right here yeah they're like they're like once again one of the I think it was Rio she was you know we were just gum under their shoe then and we still and we still.

Speaker 2Are because I saw that they had.

Speaker 1Dave on Oh yeah, because they still, so they have their podcast still with Barstool Sports, but it kind of operates independent within that. So they also were like, we know what Dave's like. We don't trust every single thing he says, but they were telling it from their perspective.

Speaker 2Interesting. I'm definitely going to go listen.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's a really interesting listen because they said that when Sophia and Alex started, they acted like they were better than them. They didn't really come near them. They then, like, they're pretty fair about it. They weren't being toxic at all. I'm probably painting them in a bad light. Because they were like, we can also see, like, what a horrible thing to happen to Sophia. And it is a hard industry. And, like, Alex is a really good businesswoman. But they're just like, reading this book is. It's just like reading fiction because we were there and we saw that and this is not what happened. And they're mentioned really briefly in Sophia's book, you know, when

Speaker 1Alex and Sophia go in with Erica.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah. They hate Erica.

Speaker 1RIP Erica after that. I think she's still alive.

Speaker 2No, she is.

Speaker 1She is. Who's one of their like CEOs at Barstool and one of the few women who's in like kind of in the senior leadership team.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1They mentioned the book really briefly when Sophia and Alex come out of their first performance review. And they say the cameras are in their face. And they're like, how's your performance review? Maria and Fran are really upset. And Maria and Fran were like, that's us. And also, we've never been upset after a performance review because our podcast has only gone up and up and up and up. Because now they get big celeb guests. They do live tours and stuff like that. And then Rhea was also like... And no one calls me Maria. No one's ever called me Maria in this office, which means she had to

Speaker 1Google what our names were. And she saw her, when she obviously saw her full name Maria listed in Google.

Speaker 2Yeah, put it in the book.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's just important. It doesn't mean that Sophia's like, there isn't real.

Speaker 2No.

Speaker 1But it is an important reminder that everyone's version.

Speaker 2Of events is different. Not necessarily like Bible truth. Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 1So then they start building the podcast and it becomes very successful.

Speaker 2It's so interesting because the initial deal that they had with Barstool was a three-year deal and they were getting paid 75K a year. Yeah. That's US. That's okay.

Speaker 1Can I just say a few things? I try not to let my own personal experience come into this book. Yeah. But everyone's like, oh, that was a bit hard. They're only getting 75K.

Speaker 2That's a lot of money.

Speaker 1I was like, you got a full-time podcasting job in 2018. That's crazy. I can't imagine.

Speaker 2And the podcast was your, I know it's two episodes a week.

Speaker 1That's your entire job.

Speaker 2And they barely went into the office.

Speaker 1Barely.

Speaker 2Yeah. And I know that like we really edited it. We did this and we did that.

Speaker 1We did our socials and I get that. But as people who've had to do six episodes a week of a podcast on top of our full-time jobs, I was like, you girls had a beautiful deal. It is a beautiful deal. No, I just didn't think, especially because podcasts were very new at that time. I don't think anyone had a full-time podcasting job.

Speaker 2No, I don't think so. I think it was like, it was, well, I think that they set the like kind of standard, I would say, especially for women.

Speaker 1Yeah. But.

Speaker 2The 75K has always been under a lot of scrutiny because they were saying that's not a lot of money. It was initially, but what made it not enough is that the show within its 18 months, two years of existing generated $ 11 million for Barstool. Yes.

Speaker 1And so I do, they've been labeled as greedy and stuff over the years.

Speaker 2And look. I do see their point. Yes.

Speaker 1And the thing is there's parts of this story that Alex and Sophia agree on.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And this is one of the small sections of this like torrid history between them where they do agree that they realize that they were making so much money. They were getting bonuses in cash. Yeah. It's not like their apartment would fill with cash.

Speaker 2Yeah. It's so weird. It's just like the whole thing is so weird. It's like, of course, a man like Dave Portnoy is running this and making these decisions. Yeah, yeah. But the fact that they were generating that much money for the company and they were only getting 75k, I'd be pissed about that.

Speaker 1Exactly. So they start to renegotiate. Before they do that, cracks start to appear in their friendship. And that is the Christmas party.

Speaker 2The Christmas party. That is crazy.

Speaker 1A lot of people who were at that Christmas party have commented about it.

Speaker 2Oh my gosh, all the photos that came out about it.

Speaker 1Yeah, because it's a very infamous moment in the book. So the way Sophia writes it is they get to the Christmas party. She says as soon as they get into the room, there's cameras everywhere in their faces. Alex runs off to talk to Dave. She gets left alone. She's trying not to say anything for the camera's They're following her everywhere.

Speaker 2Because she's already had been drinking. Yeah.

Speaker 1She talks about being in a spiral of like alcoholism and drug abuse prior to this. Yes. And feels that she needs to perform, but she's like also their lifestyle and everything. So she's really open about that.

Speaker 2Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 1And so she says that she meets up with two guys called Spider and Robb. And they drink more and she wakes up the next day at home, no memory of how she got there, no memory of what happened, but with a sinking feeling.

Speaker 2And she's also realized she's missed the podcast record. And then Alex storms in and kind of berates her. And then later we find out that Alex was basically saying, this is so embarrassing. Like Dave's like already thinking that he wants to fire you.

Speaker 1Everyone was saying to me, what's wrong with you? So that's Sophia's version of events. I've never heard Alex Cooper talk about that particular moment. Except I think she does say in one of her videos afterwards that, like, she got messy at the Christmas party. Yeah.

Speaker 2But, okay, Maria and Fran's version is that... Oh, this is so interesting. I'll be excited. They're like, there was no cameras at that party.

Speaker 1They're like, if there were videos and footage, if there was, like, a vlog of that night, don't you think it would be everywhere by now? Yeah.

Speaker 2And so they said that, like, their memory of the Christmas party is very different.

Speaker 1They're like, we saw Sophia. Yeah, she was a bit, like... out of it, but we didn't see her scream at anyone. And then Dave Portnoy went on the Toast podcast. I hate even quoting that man, but I'm just telling you what's out in the world.

Speaker 2No, no, no, this is interesting.

Speaker 1Dave Portnoy went on the Toast podcast and talked about a lot of stuff, but he really went in on the Christmas party. And he said.

Speaker 2Well, I guess because that has to do with him and he could get in a lot of trouble.

Speaker 1So he's like, it's a classy event. He's like, we don't have cameras anyway. He's like, there's one photo booth, which is what Fran and Rhi said too. There's one photo booth. There's no cameras because we let employees like... have their, you know, night off. Yeah. He's like, we don't have anyone called Rob. Although, Sophia does say at the start of the book that she changed some people's names. So maybe that's it. She talks about really liking Spider. He's like, Spider hates her. I was like, okay, Dave. Dave, Spider's still there. Where is Spider in all this?

Speaker 2I want to hear his take. Dave is so mean.

Speaker 1And he also says that he was not upset that, at Sophia for getting blackout drunk.

Speaker 2Exactly.

Speaker 1His exact quote at one stage was, hey, even at the office during the day, people do drugs and that's fine. He's like, we don't care. He's like, sometimes I'm like, I rather you wouldn't, but you're allowed to do that. And I was like, well, that gives you a lot of insight.

Speaker 2What this leads into, though, is a big bomb drop in the whole story. Oh, another bomb drop. Okay, go on. We're doing a bomb drop, everyone. So basically, Alex goes to Dave and goes, if I need to put up with her, apparently, you need to pay me more money. And she also says that she's doing more work because she's apparently editing the podcast and producing it. So that leads to Alex getting an extra $ 20, 000. And Sophia does not know about that 20K until her lawyer tells her about it when they're doing the negotiations for the final deal.

Speaker 1And that, yeah, post-Christmas party sets off a few things. So the way Dave tells it is he said that Alex came to him the next day, but she was in tears and she was like, I don't.

Speaker 2Know what to do.

Speaker 1She's out of control. I'm doing all the work, but also I can't help her. So he tells her like that. Alex says that she went in calmly to have a conversation and said, I do all the editing. I do the marketing.

Speaker 2Can I have some money?

Speaker 1Extra money and she got it and she decided not to tell Sophia because she said Sophia was funny about it. So fear's version is you've really got to, I feel like we need a big board with string and like highlighters and stuff. So fear's version is that she thinks that David and Erica weren't upset about her getting black out at the Christmas party, that Alex told her that to scare her because then she goes to a therapist and she goes on medication to stop her drinking and that Alex did that as a cover to get more money and lied to her. So that's like the, and that becomes the catalyst for all of the fallout later on.

Speaker 2Yeah. It's so interesting too. I do believe Alex just made the wrong move there. She should have told Sophia straight up.

Speaker 1She should have just.

Speaker 2Been like, I'm going to ask her.

Speaker 1It has undermined her story going forward because there's a lot of stuff between these two women. And again, the reason people have latched onto this is because The same way we watch a Dave Portnoy video is that it's a bit scandalous and dirty and like it's a bit intense. At the end of the day, we all love a bit of scandal.

Speaker 2Yes, we do. In particular between young pretty women. I also believe that Alex Cooper has gotten the same edit as Blake Lively. Like the internet has the same energy around her or at least developing the same energy where you like to hear about her being torn down a little bit. Yeah.

Speaker 1We love a popular girl being torn down. And for a long time there, she was a very popular... She still is, but she had a... very heightened popularity for a while then. But the other reason, apart from the scandalous, dirty side of it, which no judgment, we all got involved in this. But the other side is it does bring up a lot of universal themes of friendship breakup, business breakups, all that sort of stuff. But yeah, Alex Cooper not telling Sophia that she got the extra pay rise has haunted her since then. Because now every time

Speaker 1like something about her story gets thrown up everyone's like but then why didn't you tell her.

Speaker 2Exactly and then also Alex has not been immune to drama outside of this story either oh absolutely so it's kind of like and i feel like it's she's done this book at the perfect time sort of thing where there's been enough issues about alex's business and her husband for people to believe this book even more not that she's lying but you know three sides to the truth.

Speaker 1Well, no, I do think she would have been a lot harder to do. I think this book's been in the works for a long time, but I think it would have been a lot harder to do when Alex was at the height, height of her fame and she felt untouchable and everyone loved her. But again, there's been like the Alex Earl scandal. There's been like they were fighting back and forth. But also that big investigation into the Unwell Network and allegations against Matt Kaplan, who is her husband, and a few other different mean girl allegations. So we have this. And for a while, it seems

Speaker 1to be after the Christmas party, they seem to get back on the right track. Sophia doesn't know. Alex has a pay rise. She stops drinking.

Speaker 2Alex comes in with a new Chanel bag. Oh, yeah. No, she doesn't. She doesn't.

Speaker 1No, but it's one of those things like you wouldn't know there'd be signs if I won the lottery. It's like all of a sudden she's getting a.

Speaker 2Limo to work.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. Well, they do move into a fancier apartment. It's just the two of them.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1And again, they're even more intertwined because they spend all day working together, all night going out. And it's the two of them, this apartment, Sophia and Alex. This is when they really realize how much the podcast is making, how much they're not. It also coincides with Sophia meeting someone who was very famous in pop culture at the height of the Call Her Daddy breakdown in 2020. And that is Peter Nelson, a.k.a.

Speaker 2Soup Man. Soup Man.

Speaker 1Soup Man.

Speaker 2I found out a lot of people online thought it's Soup Man. Why would they think that? Heaps of people. So he wears a suit. Yeah, when this story went viral, everyone was like, I always thought it was Soup Man.

Speaker 1That's crazy.

Speaker 2He's Soup Man, though, because he's a massive executive for HBO. So she started dating him and then he goes, hey, guys. you're stupid. You should be making way more money from this show.

Speaker 1He was an executive at a big TV network. And also the suit, when you're in a creative industry, the suits is always used like a derogatory term, like the people who move the money around, who do all this sort of stuff. So Sophia meets Peter Nelson. They swipe on each other on Raya. It's actually her mom. Also a moment for Sophia's mom through all of this. Every time Sophia's like, oh, I've got no money or like I'm doing this or I just went into this. I met these like rich men who want to take me on a plane. Her mom's like, Sophia, no.

Speaker 2Don't do it. Just make sure the podcast isn't available in Utah.

Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. Block everyone in Utah. Yeah. It's like, okay, well, um, her mom's voice, her mom's a massive fixture in her life and she really permeates the book, but I just, I have a real soft spot for that woman. I know Sophia writes, but she made mistakes and stuff.

Speaker 2Everyone does.

Speaker 1We're all here. But I just think of the phone calls that woman was getting all the time from her daughter in New York.

Speaker 2And it was just like, what the hell is going on?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2It's so crazy. But basically, Suitman is the one that encourages them to renegotiate a deal.

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 2And that's where everything flips upside down. Yes, yes.

Speaker 1So in the online world at the time, Suitman became very, very demonized to the point where at one stage, Barstool Sorts was selling, like, fuck Suitman, T-shirts and sweatshirts. And they sold out. Like, they were crazy.

Speaker 2So crazy, isn't it?

Speaker 1So Sophia and Alex... decide to stop recording Call Her Daddy because they are just like, it's the only way to make a statement. Around the same time, I'd never heard this story before. I don't think they have ever told it because obviously their breakup happened just after and they never recorded together again. They went on a founder's retreat to an Airbnb out of town. Yeah. Cool.

Speaker 2What's your vibe on that? Well, I thought that was very interesting because, well, basically the deal that they were asking for, they wanted a million dollars US each and then they also wanted a 50-50 revenue split on everything else that was like merch, et cetera, et cetera. And then Dave was like, get lost yeah I just flipped my um you're allowed to.

Speaker 1Do that little am I allowed to do that here little mini Dave Portnoy over here yeah Dave Portnoy.

Speaker 2Was like get a life keep dreaming yeah um and then they were like okay well let's go on this retreat together and they both decided together that if the deal really doesn't go through they will start a new show because the issue was that Barstool owned the IP.

Speaker 1Exactly they couldn't have the name or any of the sayings or anything like that and the This is kind of where I do think everyone's in agreement of Pina Nelson's influence in it is that he was like, founders need to stick together. Yeah. Because founders apparently have a bigger divorce rate than like marriage.

Speaker 2Like they, it's in the book. Oh my God.

Speaker 1It's okay. You were skipping ahead to the next juicy part. And so, yeah, which I do believe, like a lot of founders who get together, like it's such an intense thing, break up.

Speaker 2Just with everything.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. And also mixing work and friendship is very hard. Money rips everything apart. Money. And so Peter Nelson was like, if you guys are going to like take on Barcelona and get this podcast going again, you need to be on the same page. They go with these like workbooks and packets of like exercises to work through. And they get very vulnerable and they share things they've never shared before. And not the 20K though. No.

Speaker 2Would have been nice, Alex Cooper.

Speaker 1Which actually is one of the most like kind of haunting parts from Sophia's perspective is that they, obviously they lived together and they made the podcast together. Yeah. But then they went on this retreat and they had this full weekend of just sharing the deepest parts of their soul.

Speaker 2That would wreck me.

Speaker 1Also, Sophia thought only to find out that whole thing was a lie because Alex hadn't told her the truth. And also, they leave it with a safe word.

Speaker 2Yeah. Remember that?

Speaker 1Their safe word is Crompton.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And so they remind each other of anything.

Speaker 2It's so weird.

Speaker 1If business ever gets too intense, they'll just say to each other, Crompton. And it's meant to say like reminding each other, remember this moment, it's the two of us against the world.

Speaker 2Like I do wonder if someone was in Alex's ear. I think people were in all of their ears. We've got to remember that these girls are very young at the time. They were really young. They're only in their 20s.

Speaker 1I can't even imagine how I would behave if something like this happened to me in my 20s. They're all of a sudden crazy famous.

Speaker 2Yeah. And they're trying to make this huge deal. Yeah.

Speaker 1And so then what happens is they keep sort of negotiating with barstools.

Speaker 2But they also decided that they could go and make a podcast outside of Barstool and call it The Fathers.

Speaker 1That was their kind of plan if they couldn't get the IP off Barstool.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1Which Dave has said that I would have sued the hell out of them.

Speaker 2They can't do that. Okay, Dave.

Speaker 1It's neither here nor there.

Speaker 2Sit down, Dave.

Speaker 1Okay. He literally sat down. Dave's been talking about this for six years. He's in the weeds about it.

Speaker 2I know. He's just obsessed.

Speaker 1But I guess also, like, not to defend that man, but I guess he was at the forefront of it. Like, he was the one having the conversations with them and everything.

Speaker 2So I do understand.

Speaker 1But so this is when... negotiations really start to fall apart between Sophia and Alex because the way Sophia writes in the book, and obviously all the points we bring up here are from Sophia's book, and I'm just interjecting what other people have said to try and give a layer.

Speaker 2I love it. I love the interjection. I like the other perspective of the two girls. That's incredible.

Speaker 1Oh, yeah, definitely go listen to them, such chicks in the office, and also go listen to Dave on the toast because the toast girls really push back against him in a really interesting way.

Speaker 2I love it. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1It's good getting everyone's perspective. So really, there's so much back and forth. But really what ends up happening is that from Sophia's perspective, she thinks they're in it together. And then the lawyer calls, who Suitman set them up with. The lawyer calls and says, Alex doesn't want me to represent her anymore. And then he calls her back and says, oh, Sophia, I thought you guys said you had the same contract. Why is Alex getting paid so much more than you?

Speaker 2She's getting an extra allegedly 20K, which is so insane.

Speaker 1I think it was even more than that at that stage. And that's when, yeah, yeah, yeah. And this is when Alex and Sophia's relationship like completely breaks down. And again, there's very... Because the thing is, after this all happened and then Alex Cooper retained Call Her Daddy for herself, she put out a lot of like long YouTube videos, like the truth about Call Her Daddy, the funeral, where she really gave her perspective of how those few weeks panned out. And this book, Daddy Issues, is the first time we've had Sophia Franklin's version. She did talk about

Speaker 1it on her own podcast, but this is the first time we've had her like real intense version.

Speaker 2Alex basically rang Dave and said... Sophia doesn't want to keep going. I want to though.

Speaker 1This is the only part of the story. This is the only part of the Call Her Daddy saga where we have never gotten a clear answer. Because everyone has a very different version of events. And this is the only part of the Call Her Daddy saga where someone is definitely lying. Because every other part, I can be like, that.

Speaker 2Was a different interpretation. It's a different memory.

Speaker 1But someone's lying in this situation because the two girls go to dave's rooftop that was a very famous part.

Speaker 2Of all this and that's also a bomb drop where sophia says that they walked into the apartment and i do think this is such a push like i when i was like come on girl she goes we walked into the apartment and alex just seemed to know her way around yeah and she thought to herself have they slept together?

Speaker 1Yeah. That's a crazy thing to put in there.

Speaker 2I was like that. You are jumping ahead majorly. Like, cut on.

Speaker 1That allegation has been out there for a while about Alex Cooper and Dave Portnoy. They've both always denied it.

Speaker 2Denied it, yeah.

Speaker 1But, yeah, it was a wild thing to be like, I think Alex has been sleeping with them because she feels like she's been in this apartment before.

Speaker 2Yeah. So they've denied it.

Speaker 1But, yeah, that's crazy. They go to the rooftop. Dave offers them a deal. Speeding ahead here because there's so much in this. And they go kind of back and forth and then– So fear's perspective is that she gets pushed out.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1Of the deal, that Alex tells her that she's taking it, she's being argumentative. and she's like, well, don't I do more work? I do more work. That's why I deserve the money.

Speaker 2Exactly. And then. And gets the call from the lawyer. And then suddenly she's like, okay, we're at odds now too.

Speaker 1And Alex's version is that she, Sophia was just never going to sign the deal. And so she had to move on without her and she tried to get her to sign it, but she wouldn't. which is also kind of Dave's story. His story is that he called Sophia and then said to her, like, Alex is doing the deal. We want you to do it too. And then he says that he also offered Sophia her own podcast and didn't hear from her.

Speaker 2He offered it for like, didn't they?

Speaker 1The same money, he says.

Speaker 2Yeah. Okay, interesting.

Speaker 1He offered the same money. So everyone's story is slightly different. So someone's lying because it's such a big thing. It felt like this deal just, it felt like the end of Call Her Daddy just fell through the cracks. Yeah. Because Sophia's saying, I'm here saying.

Speaker 2I'll do it.

Speaker 1I'll do it.

Speaker 2I'll roll over on the points.

Speaker 1I just want to do it.

Speaker 2She did initially at some point be like, we should shop around. Yes, yes.

Speaker 1But when it came down to the crunch, Sophia writes in her book of messaging Alex and saying like, let's do this together. And then she was like, I just want to say this, Crompton.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1This is back when Sophia's in Utah with her mom, her and Peter Nelson. Also, Peter Nelson's a very tragic figure in this book. Loses his job, gets cheated on. He's crying all the time.

Speaker 2I know.

Speaker 1I think it's very intentional the way she's written him because he was always posed as this like super villain.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1But the way Sophia writes about him in the book is almost like a very kind of sad background figure. Yeah.

Speaker 2I guess you would be though. Like you would not have been prepared for what this was about to be and how you were about to be spun. Exactly. Like no one could have predicted this, especially if you're just a guy that's dating a girl that has a podcast and you go, you should probably try and get more money from that seeing that you're making $ 11 million and getting $ 75, 000. Like let's try and up this. I mean they did up it to half a million eventually, but still let's try and get you more. And then suddenly people are selling T-shirts of you and making you the villain.

Speaker 1It's just a bit weird. Yeah. And this is a messy time because this is when Alex takes control of Call Her Daddy. Whether it was correct or not, there's different versions of that. Sophia writes about having to go back to Utah. COVID's like, deep COVID throws. Her and Peter Nelson are living in the basement of her mom's house. And when she writes about this in the book of being rock bottom, I was like, I believe it. Because you had one of the biggest podcasts in the world. You were on the brink of like, True, proper fame.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And then all of a sudden you're back in your mom's basement and you're seeing the person that you thought was not only a business partner, but a family. It's so funny. On the Toast podcast, the girls, when they were talking to Dave about it, the hosts, they were like, the biggest issue here is they both had different interpretations of the friendships.

Speaker 2Sophia was like, this is my sister and my best friend. And Alex was like, and this is my crackhead roommate.

Speaker 1Yeah. They obviously had very different interpretations.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Alex Krupa has said, like, we weren't that good of friends. And Sophia writes in the book about them. their sisterhood and like each other's person.

Speaker 2But I don't believe Alex. I don't believe.

Speaker 1In this case, I do more believe Sophia. I believe that for a while there they were, whether it was like completely real or not, but you do get, you can fall into an intense friendship the way you fall into an intense romance.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1It's so hard and fast and like it just becomes everything.

Speaker 2And then we're working together everything and like it just would be impossible for Alex not to be slightly I don't know. I actually don't know. I'm like she– I think she manipulated the story to be like what was beneficial for her in the moment.

Speaker 1Oh, I think both Alex and Sophia have presented their version of the story and they're very different. Yeah. So Sophia's back in Utah. She's living in a basement and she cannot– she knows she has to make a move and really start a podcast because that's all she knows how to do but she can't really get it together. At the same time, she's seeing Alex's fame. She sees Alex make all these videos where she really passionately talks to camera and and really paints Sophia and Snoop Man as their villain. She then builds the show. It gets bigger and bigger. She moves from the network. She gets

Speaker 1millions of dollars. She starts booking celebrity guests. And on the other side, Sophia's trying to get her podcast off the ground, Sophia with an F, with Muji, who was a big character in the book, Alex's childhood friend who was also part of Call Her Daddy and who Sophia alleges wrote all of Alex Cooper's material. Yes. But then was fired by the girls and then rehired and then fired.

Speaker 2Yeah, which is so interesting too. And then Alex goes on to make it like a production company that is called Unwell. And Unwell was a term that Sophia came up with on the podcast because when she had her corporate job before the pod- she wanted to go to Coachella and she said that her excuse to get the time off was that she was just unwell.

Speaker 1She was like, hello, I won't be into work today.

Speaker 2I am unwell. Yeah, and that became a huge inside joke and then Alex named her whole company off it.

Speaker 1And her drink that Sophia finds when she's been throwing up and she goes into the shop to get like a Gatorade and she sees the unwell drink and she was like, I have vomit in my hair. Again, literally, she paints a really intense, tragic, like that's the thing. There's nothing about this book that feels like, a glossy celeb memoir. It reads like a tragedy, even with Sophia, like even when they're at the height of their fame. And I was like, I know what your life was like on the surface, at least at this time. The parties, the events, the red carpets, having this big podcast, being adored.

Speaker 1But from her... What she writes in the book from her perspective is always this crippling self-doubt, darkness. It was always like being in Barstool was hard. Getting the pod together was difficult. It's all darkness.

Speaker 2It is.

Speaker 1It's just very tragic. And I don't know if she's written it that way to shape herself as a tragic figure because no one saw her as a tragic figure or was that really what it was like?

Speaker 2I mean, it's quite interesting. Maybe a bit of both, hey?

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And I do think that she was always the one that was coming second, I guess, in that trio.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Oh, in that, what is it?

Speaker 1Duo.

Speaker 2In that duo. And I definitely think that, you know, she would always come back to the thing that Lauren told her too. You're just getting used because you're pretty.

Speaker 1And that's what Muji said too. And then obviously when she hired Muji to fly to Utah to make the podcast together, but they just all got drunk. all the time. And I kind of almost get what, because that's the thing. A lot of people, when Sophia has said that she was the brains and the comedy and the creativity behind Call Her Daddy and that Alex was the production, a lot of people discounted her story because they're like, well, then if you were all the creativity, then why did your podcast not take off in the same way?

Speaker 2Why couldn't you do it?

Speaker 1And in the book, Sophia talks about that for the first time where she was like, She's no longer an entertaining, interesting person because she's in the depths of despair and she has to, like, drug herself and drink alcohol to feel like she can perform. So she can't be this witty, funny person she once was. And I was like, that actually makes a lot of sense.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's hard.

Speaker 1It'd be hard just to be sassy and cool and be this person that– people loved you in the original Call Her Daddy when you're at rock bottom.

Speaker 2And to be devil's advocate for Alex Cooper, I mean, it's the classic thing of, like, you can have all the talent but not work hard. Or you can work hard and, you know, beat the person with all the talent.

Speaker 1Well, that's what a lot of people have said. If Alex Cooper wasn't the talent, then why does she have this big booming business?

Speaker 2And I do think she is smart and hardworking. I think she's smart and hardworking.

Speaker 1And I wouldn't say she's not talented. I would say she's talented in a different way than what people thought because the thing is, Call Her Daddy wouldn't be an interesting podcast.

Speaker 2It was just her. Yes. And I think she knows that.

Speaker 1And I think she did try for a while there to sort of just it be her or she brought like her friends on and her mum on and stuff. And people were so hungry for more details of the scandal. They really listened to it.

Speaker 2Yeah. And the thing is, every so.

Speaker 1Often she's on a solo episode. She is a good storyteller.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1But. Her pivot to being a celebrity interview podcast was very strategic.

Speaker 2Yes, absolutely.

Speaker 1And that is what has made her so successful is the guests she gets.

Speaker 2I don't think not her. Do you think she's going to be able to come back from this? Yes.

Speaker 1You do? I don't think there's that much to come back from, to be honest.

Speaker 2Really?

Speaker 1Because I think she's taken a few hits, but I think... her popularity is at a place now where it would have to be. And also a lot of people believe Sophia in a way they didn't before, but I don't think it's enough to sort of take anything away from her. If the allegations against her and her husband for their workplace, if that didn't like do anything. That's so true. And I don't think it has changed their podcast downloads or anything.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1I wonder if maybe a few guests, if their values don't align with like things she's been accused of, a few guests might say no. But I think a lot of the time, then I don't think it's going to.

Speaker 2Affect her at all.

Speaker 1True.

Speaker 2And I guess the things that she's been accused of aren't as bad as the workplace drama accusations.

Speaker 1Exactly.

Speaker 2And that all came out and they were like very intense against mostly her husband. Yeah.

Speaker 1Allegations, which they have always set her on true. If that didn't touch her. But I also think she... It's hard to think of this now because the tables have turned and a few more people are demonizing Alex Cooper and then a lot of people are on Team Sophia, like Sophia's side. But at the time in 2020 when this all happened, Alex Cooper felt like a phoenix who had risen from the dead. from the ashes of like the patriarchy kind of thing. Because Sophia really came across as like this greedy, ungrateful, spoiled friend. And the Barstool

Speaker 1had come across as like this company of men who had tried to keep Alex Cooper down. And she was really, and she positioned herself and people believed her. as like the champion who had risen above it. And when she got that massive podcast deal for millions of dollars and moved to LA and started booking all these big celeb guests, people were like, I don't know if you remember this, people were like cheering her on like, girl boss, this is what women can do when they work hard. And it felt very unifying, which brought in all the celeb guests. And now she's almost like so many rungs up. She's a little bit untouchable.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's so interesting. I guess it does. It also reminds me of the fact that when this, I don't know, you know, the summer house drama. Yeah, I do. And then, yeah, you obviously do. Yeah. um I do feel like there was a point where Sierra was going too hard where people started turning on her it happens I do wonder if that is a potential with this.

Speaker 1Which I think that's all Alex has tried. Well, the thing is she's tried to distance herself, but then she named her company and her drink Unwell, so you didn't try.

Speaker 2But more so with Sophia. If Sophia keeps going and going and going, will people go, hey, and flip on her? It's so freaky. Potentially.

Speaker 1Like it's a very fickle situation because people are wanting to support Sophia Franklin now, not just because they believe she's a wronged figure, although I'm sure parts of her story really make her look like that. They want to support her because they want to take down Alex Cooper. Yeah. That's the thing because she got too popular. And, look, maybe she's a terrible person.

Speaker 2I don't know.

Speaker 1But it gets to the point where, like, a woman gets so popular that everyone wants to bring her down.

Speaker 2Which I feel like happened with Blake Lively.

Speaker 1Yeah, it's a lot. There's nothing society loves more than a golden girl involved in scandal. Yeah. And for a while there she kind of was a golden girl. Yeah.

Speaker 2With the celebs and everything.

Speaker 1So Sophia writes a lot about that in her book about what it was like to watch Alex soar and herself kind of falter. She cheats on Peter Nelson. Yeah.

Speaker 2R.I.P. He's still alive.

Speaker 1He's just crying. He's crying. He cries a lot.

Speaker 2And again, I'm not making him up.

Speaker 1I'm not making fun of him for that.

Speaker 2Sometimes when I'm on a first date, I'll ask a man when the last time he cried was.

Speaker 1Oh, and do you get a good reaction to that often?

Speaker 2It's just good to see how they react. Yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, I cry too. He goes to go to Utah to live in his kind of half-mother-in-law's basement. The whole internet is after him. People are wearing We Hate Suit Man merch. It's crazy.

Speaker 2He loses his job in COVID. Yeah.

Speaker 1And then his girlfriend starts cheating on him. That is kind of interesting how Sophia Franklin writes about that.

Speaker 2In the book. Because.

Speaker 1She both throughout the book shares her kind of darkest moments and she also shares a lot of times where she makes a bad decision or she does the wrong thing to someone. It's very strategic. I think that's important because it makes you believe her more.

Speaker 2Absolutely.

Speaker 1But there's also times where she writes about things like she's like when she has an affair and Peter calls her and says, we can stay together, we can do couples counselling. And she says, Peter's in a rough spot. He's also living in her mum's house.

Speaker 2He's like, what do I do?

Speaker 1Also, Peter's been through the wringer. I'm not apologizing.

Speaker 2It's so funny.

Speaker 1I don't know that man at all, but it's just so funny how he was such a demon publicly online in 2020. And in this book, he's a real tragic figure from her perspective.

Speaker 2Yeah. Justice for Peter.

Speaker 1Oh my God. You want to wear that in a t-shirt? Justice for suit man. You'd be a lone wolf doing that.

Speaker 2Oh my God.

Speaker 1But also when Sophia talks about saying to him, like, he's like, we can do couples counseling. We can get through you cheating on me. And she writes like, I just found myself saying yes. I found myself agreeing, even though I didn't want to do that. And I do find that something that's how she writes a lot in this book is often she portrays herself as as like just a leaf getting.

Speaker 2Blown in the wind.

Speaker 1Just someone who's going along and she's like, then I found this happened, then I found this happened, then this happened. And when celebrity memoirs go down that path, I kind of find them a bit, that's when I find them an unreliable narrator. It's like Demi Moore's memoir where she writes about the fact that all her daughters stopped speaking to her And all her family stopped speaking to her and her, like, ex-husband and everything. And she was just always like, but I was always so puzzled. I was so baffled. Why would they do this?

Speaker 2It came out of nowhere.

Speaker 1I'm like, girl, obviously it didn't come out of nowhere.

Speaker 2Something happened.

Speaker 1Something happened, but you're not telling us.

Speaker 2Something happened, Demi. Yeah.

Speaker 1And something happened, Sophia. Yeah. And then the book, I kind of find it interesting how it ends. Mm. Because you're getting to the end of the book. So I'm like, I've got a few pages left. And I was like, we're still in dire straits here.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1And I just know this book is going to have a hopeful ending.

Speaker 2It has to.

Speaker 1That's how books get sold. And so her podcast isn't taking off because she can't like, it goes really well when she puts out her first episode.

Speaker 2She should have called it Daddy Issues, number one, not Sophia with an F.

Speaker 1Oh, the podcast Daddy Issues.

Speaker 2I know she wasn't ready for that yet. Oh, come on, Sophia. Anyway, yeah.

Speaker 1Daddy Issues is a good title. Also, because as she said, Daddy Issues isn't just about the Call Her Daddy podcast. It's about her dad, like her biological dad who she meets twice, not wanting to see her.

Speaker 2It's about her like.

Speaker 1Mom's boyfriend who's her stepdad, like, abandoning them. It's about, like, men like Dave treating her badly.

Speaker 2Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 1Soup man who's in his 40s when this is all happening and she's in her 20s. She probably will start a podcast called Daddy Issues. Oh, yeah. I feel like that's the thing. And then also the Call Her Daddy drama. So Alex is, like, kind of, like, she talks about Alex, like, flying in life. She's got this big production company. She's always looking so beautiful. Her house is beautiful. She had a beautiful wedding. Like, she's just become this picture of a perfect life. And Sophia said she's, like, she's struggling. Her podcast came off.

Speaker 2She's drinking. Yeah.

Speaker 1She feels a lot of shame of getting an abortion at 30 because she feels like she should have a life together. And then the book kind of skips ahead quite quickly where she does find resolution. And it ends on a, I don't know how I feel about this. You tell me, because it ends with her falling in love for the first time. And we know she married that man.

Speaker 2Yeah, we know she married that man. I don't know. I think that she is in a very, very unique situation where she will always be chasing something that maybe she won't be able to catch because I don't think there can be anyone else like Alex Cooper and I don't think she'll ever be satisfied unless she is either, like unless she's like theoretically beating Alex.

Speaker 1Do you know what I mean?

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah. I think the book is proof of that. So it's just a very, I think landing it on Alex ending it on being in love may be one of the only ways that she could have felt okay with it. Do you know what I mean?

Speaker 1Yeah, it's kind of interesting because I feel like it's kind of like in just like that, the Sex and the City reboot where Carrie writes her memoir after Big's death. Sorry, spoiler alert for like five years ago. Writes her memoir and she takes it to her publisher and her publisher's like, okay. It's so beautiful and it's like your darkest moments and I was crying everywhere.

Speaker 2But also it needs to end on a hopeful note.

Speaker 1And that's why she tells Carrie she has to go out and go on a date.

Speaker 2Just go on a date. So you think that happened?

Speaker 1Well, I don't think she... Well, she met him through a matchmaker. I don't think she met him... I don't think she went to a matchmaker and met this man and married him so that she could have an end of her book. Although that's brilliant planning.

Speaker 2But do you reckon the end was that? Or do you think they've shoved it in? I think that a lot of people have said she.

Speaker 1tried to like time her book around like Alex's like downfall but I think this started long ago the same way people think Alex timed her pregnancy around Sophia's book and I'm like these things are very hard to line up yeah I don't think I think a lot of this just happened because that's the way things happen but I think one of the reasons she felt confident to write the book is that because she is like well I'm sure she's happy but like her public persona is now like I'm also a happily married woman.

Speaker 2I found my prince charming.

Speaker 1I had a lavish Italian wedding and a lavish proposal in France and we're so happy. And I think that both she and the publisher wanted to end on a good note.

Speaker 2Something of feeling equal to Alex. Yeah. And so.

Speaker 1Even the saddest of books, they know audiences want a happy ending. But I kind of feel a bit conflicted that her happy ending had to be for a girl that had always based all her worth on how her fathers treated her, how men treated her, how her friends, how Alex Cooper treated her, how listeners treated her, how the audience.

Speaker 2Or is it kind of perfect in that way? Does it really align with the title?

Speaker 1Well, kind of, but I mean, I know she talks about, she has, she's done so many interviews and I've watched all of them. She does talk about feeling like better in herself, but I don't know if that's an on paper answer because I do think this is the end of the day. It's a tragic story about a girl who was looking for approval, got caught up and spat out so many times. And her story ends with the ultimate public approval, which is getting married. Yeah.

Speaker 2And it will always be hard if your success is also reliant on someone else's demise. Yes. I don't know if you can ever be fulfilled with that.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. But God, it's an interesting read. And I do think it is her truth in a lot of ways. It's her and she's been waiting to put it out there. And I hope it gets turned into a TV series.

Speaker 2Yeah, and I hope she made a whole lot of money. Yeah, she did. She did.

Speaker 1This book is a bestseller.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's cool.

Speaker 1And she's been on a huge press tour. She's being embraced by, like, people in the industry she hasn't been embraced from. People who were never Team Sophia are Team Sophia. So ultimately, it's actually kind of nice that she and Anx Cooper are kind of both winners. Yeah. And also both losers because I do think at their core they're both not good people.

Speaker 2Yes, I agree.

Speaker 1Podcasts and entertainment are made up of not good people.

Speaker 2Yeah. Speak for yourself, Ellie. I know.

Speaker 1I know it's true.

Speaker 2But yeah, it is very interesting. And I do think that it solidified that they're both selfish. They really are. But you know what?

Speaker 1Those are kind of, it makes for a good story.

Speaker 2Yeah. And this story, whether you think you're above this story or not, the truth is this story is a compelling one. It is so compelling.

Speaker 1Because of all the reasons we've said about friendship and sisterhood and business breakdowns, but also just because of the scandal.

Speaker 2Yeah. And I think it will be made into a TV show one day. And we will do a brilliant review on that.

Speaker 1Thank you.

Speaker 2Thank you so much for listening to The Spill today. If you're loving us, come say hi to us on socials. We're at The Spill Pod on TikTok and The Spill Podcast on Instagram. We'll see you next time.

Speaker 1Bye.

Speaker 2Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Weekend Watch: The Most Brutal Hunger Games Yet & Jared Padalecki’s Netflix Christmas Rom-Com

    Nov 19, 202634 minAudio

    Read our entertainment editor Tina Burke's review of Sunrise On The Reaping here. Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription for Black Friday with code BLACK30. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Real Problem Behind Florence Pugh’s Viral Statement & We Support Khloé Kardashian’s No Sex Stance

    Nov 19, 202644 minAudio

    Khloe Kardashian hasn’t had sex in four years, and she’s officially over everyone asking why. We’re unpacking her candid chat with Goldie Hawn, the Lemme gummy that started it all, and a very unexpected list of men who...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. MORNING TEA: Pretty Little Liars Is Coming Back…Maybe? & Anne Hathaway’s Baby News

    Nov 18, 202611 minAudio

    This morning, Anne Hathaway becomes a mum of three, and Jeff Bezos makes a very interesting admission about the new James Bond. Plus, the Pretty Little Liars rumour that has every millennial texting their group chat. ☕...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Why Robert Pattinson Shouldn’t Be James Bond & The TV Show That Changed Our Minds About Dating

    Nov 18, 202643 minAudio

    After the longest casting saga in history, Robert Pattinson is officially the new James Bond. Here’s why we think it’s the wrong call, plus the Twilight fans who called it first and who we really wanted in the tux. Tina...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. MORNING TEA: Batman Is The New 007 & An Update On Russell Brand's Prison Message

    Nov 17, 20269 minAudio

    This morning, Robert Pattinson is officially the new James Bond, and he’s already got the royal seal of approval. Plus, the 2027 Grammy nominations are out with women dominating the big categories and one very famous...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode