Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Spill

The Spill artwork

Apparently Taylor Swift and Karlie Kloss Are BFFs Again & Why Noah Wyle’s The Pitt Is Being Sued

Nov 10, 202643 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Taylor Swift brought an unexpected guest to the Chiefs box, and fans are calling it the most surprising friendship reunion of the decade. Plus, a Knicks player has dragged Taylor into a ‘fake fan’ storm, and the backlash is getting messy. McKenna Grace is turning The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping press tour into a full fandom fever dream. We’re unpacking her most iconic tribute looks and asking the big question: when does method dressing go too far? Finally, The Pitt is facing a legal battle that just got very real, with claims it’s an unauthorised reworking of ER. We’re deep diving into the lawsuit, the eerie similarities, and what it means for season three. Take our three minute survey for a chance to win a $1,000 gift voucher AND help shape what we do here at Mamamia. Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription for Black Friday with code BLACK30. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends November 30. Become a Mamamia subscriber and get an all-access pass to everything we make, including exclusive podcasts and early listening, subscriber-only articles, monthly giveaways and our home workout app, MOVE. Built to work around your real life, MOVE adapts to whatever season you're in. That's why we've created a brand new collection of feel-good weight workouts, designed for any body, anywhere. No hectic challenges or intimidating gym setups, just simple, easy-to-follow sessions, designed to help you build strength at your own pace. MOVE is feel-good fitness by Mamamia. For less than a coffee a week, get unlimited access to hundreds of workouts, ranging from five to 45 minutes. Plus, you get unlimited access to everything across Mamamia, including subscriber-exclusive podcast episodes, articles, discounts and giveaways. Get your MOVE goodness here. Get access to Very Peri, Mamamia's exclusive perimenopause series, for just $59. 25 world-leading experts, over 20 on-demand sessions, available now. We’ve sorted through the noise so you don't have to. Go to veryperi.com.au and join me today. You hot? Same. Buy today and save 40% THE END BITS Find and follow us on socials: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thespillpodcast/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thespillpod Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/thespillpodcast/ Support independent women's media Want to join the conversation? Have feedback or a topic you want us to discuss? Send us a voice message or email us at thespill@mamamia.com.auand we’ll get back to you ASAP! Executive Producer: Monisha Iswaran Mamamia acknowledges the traditional owners of the land on which we have recorded this podcast. Become a Mamamia subscriber: https://www.mamamia.com.au/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1From Mamma Mia, welcome to The Spill, your daily pop culture fix. I'm Tina Burke. And I'm Brie Player. And we have a very exciting show for you guys today. We're going to be talking about McKenna Grace's red carpet looks for The Hunger Games, Sunrise on the Reaping, and we're going to be getting into method dressing as a whole and where we are at with it as a fandom and as a general society. I love that. Huge thoughts and takes. It's a hot topic. I've got a lot of thoughts and takes. I'm excited to talk about that with you. I'm excited. And then we also have something that you are uniquely qualified to discuss, which is.

Speaker 2Like, kind of. You make it sound like I have legal standing on this.

Speaker 1I don't. Whatever. You are the number one fan. You've got the T-shirt. You've got the feelings. True.

Speaker 2Which is the ER pit legal drama that is happening. I do have the T-shirt, which regular fillers will know.

Speaker 1Which she's not wearing today.

Speaker 2I'm unfortunately not wearing it today. I'm really disappointed because I do like wearing that T-shirt on the pod, so I've got a reason to put it on my– ATO as a tax write-off.

Speaker 1Yeah, perfect. Amazing. I'm sure the accountants love that one. This is my Noah Wiley t-shirt, obviously, that I'm talking about. Obviously. Yes. But first, we're going to get into a couple of things surrounding our favorite pop girlie, Taylor Ellison Swift. Yes, making headlines as per usual. And some of them were not even her fault, which is also as per usual. As per usual. But one thing she has done is very much her decision, which was to bring Karlie Kloss with her to the Chiefs game yesterday. Yes, Karlie Kloss, fantastic. Former friend, renewed friend and model. Yeah. So, yeah, I

Speaker 1was surprised. Where were you when you found out the news? Well, I was in bed.

Speaker 2Oh, okay, boring. So, yeah, I was surprised to see the pictures as they emerged and they always do whenever Taylor attends a Chiefs game. And she's there in that, like, box which looks a bit like a fishbowl of her and whoever she's chosen to bring with her at that time. They go everywhere. We've seen her with so many different combinations of friends and sometimes with just one, sometimes with family members. But, yeah, Carly Kloss was in there with her today. And I really, like, if I think back, like, this time a year ago, If I had been told

Speaker 2that she would be sitting there at a Chiefs game with Kylie Kloss next to her and that never again would we see Blake Lively in there with her, I would not have believed it.

Speaker 1I hate it. I hate it a lot. Tell me how you really feel. Like, genuinely, I was like, she's doing what with who? Like, ugh, ugh, ugh is my feeling. I saw a tweet that was like, this must be how Jesus' disciples felt when he forgave Judas. I do specifically find this very interesting because obviously Taylor and Blake were like the best friends, the closest ones. And then ever since that friendship sort of like soured. And at

Speaker 1the same time, her friendship with like Kaylee Teller also seemed too sour or to disappear. Yeah. She's been hanging out a lot more with her other friends who've always been lifelong friends, like Dakota Johnson, the Heim sisters, Selena Gomez. But Carly and her had just not really hung out publicly together in a very, very long time. Carly went to the Heiress tour and everyone was like, did she buy her own tickets because she wasn't in the VIP tent? She wasn't.

Speaker 2And she wasn't even in the assigned seats for Taylor friends and family.

Speaker 1No, she was in the bleachers. And I know that. Because that night I.

Speaker 2Was there in the assigned seats that were for Taylor's friends and family. I'm neither of which, but I was obviously invited as media.

Speaker 1Yeah. But I was like, I've got better seats than Kylie Kloss. Yeah. Way better. She was up in the nosebleeds. Yeah.

Speaker 2And, yeah, so that was kind of the first time we saw any kind of interaction with them, which was her attending. Yeah. And that was in August 2024. They had obviously met when Taylor was doing the Victoria's Secret show as the singer. They became fast friends. They were besties. They did that amazing Vogue cover shoot together. It was really fun. It was like a besties road trip vibe.

Speaker 1Yeah. There was a line about a getaway car on the spread.

Speaker 2Yes.

Speaker 1Everyone took that to mean that the song Getaway Car later would be about Carly. It wasn't. Oh, that's so funny. Oh. Oh. Oh, the gay lores.

Speaker 2Oh, yes.

Speaker 1Yes. Maybe having a good day, I guess. I reckon they're having a great time. I don't think anyone's having a better day than Jennifer Lawrence. Like, I think she's the most excited about this because she's been intrigued for years. She has.

Speaker 2Publicly so. She's also close friends with Taylor. She can just ask her questions that we can't.

Speaker 1I don't know that J-Law and Taylor are that close. I reckon Emma Stone's the bridge and J-Law's become closer since she was first curious about Carly and Taylor. But do you think she would ask her about it?

Speaker 2Yes!

Speaker 1I don't know if they're close enough that she can send her a text. She's so rogue, though. She is, but I actually think.

Speaker 2Oh, and a couple of drinks and a dinner. They're at the corner store, like a very cool restaurant in New.

Speaker 1York, as if she wouldn't. Yeah, I don't know. You know, she's rogue. Yeah.

Speaker 2But, yes, of course, then Carly attended the wedding, which already surprised everyone.

Speaker 1Yeah. Incredibly strange. And then Carly went on like the Today Show and got asked about it and she was like, I don't talk about my friends' lives. I don't share their personal lives, but they're a lovely couple. And I'm like, how would you know? Where have you been? But allegedly very close now. Okay.

Speaker 2But also, funnily enough, one of the things that people believe caused the original rift between Taylor and Carly was that Carly was talking about Taylor.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And that Taylor set up like rumours about And this is all alleged.

Speaker 1Like, we don't actually know.

Speaker 2But that was how Taylor found out that Carly was kind of blabbing about her.

Speaker 1Yeah, and it was all tied to Scooter Braun and Katy Perry as well, obviously. And that's when people really knew that something was afoot between Carly and Taylor, when Carly was pictured on. Lyrics attributed to that. Yeah, yeah, of course. And, I mean, a lot of people think Closure is about Carly Kloss. Yes. And there's a lot of songs that people think are about that friendship. What is it that you.

Speaker 2Really don't like about seeing a reunited friendship between them?

Speaker 1Yeah. Well, first of all, I have my own opinions on Karlie Kloss that we don't have time to discuss and her husband and his extended family. That's fair. If anyone doesn't know, Karlie Kloss is married to Joshua Kushner, whose brother is Jared Kushner, who is married to Ivanka Trump. Jared Kushner currently, I don't know, maybe just Google Jared Kushner legal troubles. Things will come up. You'll see. And Karlie Kloss, I'm not saying she's involved in that. I'm just saying a bit messy. Yeah. Not who I'd want

Speaker 1to spend a Sunday with. Not who I want to go to a barbecue with. Nah. But also, I just don't love this era that Taylor seems to be in currently in her personal life with these weird people. Because I'm like, that girl was real mean to you. Why are you hanging out with her? But also, I don't know you and that's your choice. Yeah, true. I don't know.

Speaker 2I mean, I guess it's just that typical thing where we never really know and that fans think they know a lot more than they do. And then something like this will happen. You go, okay, well, Whatever she did, obviously, and whatever caused the feud between them, obviously Taylor decided it was not something she wasn't willing to move past. Yeah.

Speaker 1And I guess when you need someone to bring with you to the Chiefs game. She seems free and available. I don't think she was struggling. She went down her list of friends. She's like Dakota's with MGK. She's busy. Dakota's so busy.

Speaker 2Like mum's getting a head start on putting up the tree. She can't make it. You know, oh, the Haim sisters, they're cutting a new album.

Speaker 1They're busy. Booked and busy. Gigi's exhausted. She walked the runway recently. Oh, I know. Here's Carly. Yeah. But that's nice for them. Good stuff. So the other reason that Taylor is making headlines this weekend is that she, along with ruining football, is now ruining basketball as well. Oh, God, is there a sports ball that girl can't ruin? And I know I'm kind of thinking, like, what could she do next? I'm thinking golf. It's quite boring. Oh, too boring, I think, maybe. Yeah, OK. I think she could get in there and really, like, rustle some feathers. She could

Speaker 1ruin hockey. She could. No. A lot of attention on hockey right now. Nothing could take down hockey right now. Not in the year of heated rivalry and off-campus. How dare you? Unlike the times when she has gone to a game or, like, just been friends with somebody, the reason that she is now allegedly ruining basketball is because she's being accused of being a fake fan. This obviously already happened when she went to the Knicks game with the Haim sisters and Mariska Hargitay for the sort of lead-up to the finals. She didn't go to the actual last game, but she went to the second last. And she...

Speaker 1rocked up in her blue t-shirt. She was having a great time and cheering. And at the time, people accused her of being a fake fan because they thought she was. I don't know. Who cares? And because she'd been to a Cavs game with Travis Kelsey before that. But the thing is, she went to the Cavs game because he went as like a Cleveland boy and she didn't wear merch. She wasn't cheering for the team. There's actually photos of her laughing at Travis when he's upset. But people saw those pictures and were like, she's a fake fan. And my one thought on that is who cares? But now we've got actual Knicks players saying that she's a fake fan.

Speaker 1So there was a live stream and Knicks players Miles McBride and Tyler Kolek were asked about performative fans. And they weren't specifically, like, asked, like, please tell us which female celebrity is a fake fan, but they really did. Which blonde A-list, you know. It was definitely, like, leading the horses to water.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1For sure. Yeah. And they said Taylor Swift. And Tyler said, I'm going to get some hate. I guess she's got a lot going on. She can't come all the time, but it's a little performative. And Miles was like, yeah, the Swifties are going to hate you, but I would agree with you on that. So they do this. It starts blowing up. I first saw it and I went, I don't care and I don't have the bandwidth for this conversation.

Speaker 2Yeah, and, like, she's covered this before with the football thing and when people have complained about her ruining football by being in the audience and the whole fake fan thing.

Speaker 1Yeah. She doesn't care. She doesn't care. And she wasn't involved in this conversation. But then obviously it really blew up to the point where the Knicks came out and released a statement saying, we love Taylor Swift. Thank you for your continued support. We love how much you've supported Madison Square Garden. You've been a fan for years. Basically defending. her.

Speaker 2Famous wedding venue, Madison Square Garden, where she allows the Knicks to play their games.

Speaker 1But also where she has attended many Knicks games. She performed there as a teenager. She was... wearing the number 13 jersey before Tyler Kolek ever did. Yeah. And she was in the crowd watching those games when she was in her 20s living in New York all the time. And see, this is the thing about Swifties. They're smart and they have long memories. And they have long memories. But it's true.

Speaker 2She has like a long history of supporting the Knicks.

Speaker 1And what I would say about his comment that, you know, he doesn't see her there often is like you don't see her anywhere often anymore. No. She's far superseded the level of fame she used to be at when she just used to go enjoy her life. In fact, she has several albums talking about how she can't enjoy her life anymore.

Speaker 2She's one of the, like, actual few celebrities in the world where it is genuinely not really possible for her to just walk down the street.

Speaker 1And I think you just need to look at the ruckus caused by her going to that Knicks game and her being singled out here. He didn't say the Haim sisters are the most performative fans. Or Mariska. No. Well, he wouldn't say Mariska because of her close personal friendship with Jalen Bronson. But it's just interesting to me. And I was kind of like, I don't really give a shit about this. Who cares? But then, you know that tweet that's like... When you're at the function trying to have fun, but then you remember how misogynist, like, in everything. And I was like, yeah, because why'd you say that?

Speaker 1And you know what?

Speaker 2To take it further, it pissed me off when they talked about celebrities that were real fans and all the ones they mentioned were men.

Speaker 1Yeah. Of course. Which just felt so typical. Yeah. And I think obviously like no one's saying Taylor Swift's like a bigger fan than Ben Stiller or Timothee Chalamet. Who honestly cares? But what I find interesting is obviously the Knicks gave the statement, now Tyler is being posted on Instagram singing Taylor Swift songs with his teammates. And they're like, relax Swifties. And he's captioned an Instagram post, Tyler's version. What's pissing me off is all the men in the comments going like, yeah, get her. Oh my God, she deserved that. She's so fake. And then all these also

Speaker 1men thinking that him singing the song is him apologizing, going, no, you really showed her. You should keep it up. She's not even in the conversation. And it's so stupid to me that like men continue to do this. There was kind of, we had a brief respite in like 2022, 2023 when people liked her again and They weren't really like using her name to just start beef. And like, I do think I don't really want to be back in that point in time. I'd love us to just go back. Unless, unless. What?

Speaker 2Dragging her back to that time makes the climate right for a reputation drop.

Speaker 1So true. Yeah. Everyone like, cause there are obviously I've said it a million times. There are reasons I critique Taylor Swift. Being a sports fan is like the stupidest among them. Who cares? Also, who cares about getting on a bandwagon? Don't they want more fans? Yeah. Let people be part of the fun. Let New Yorkers be part of the fun. Yeah. I think it's just classic misogyny and I'm not enjoying the fake apology tour that he's doing at the minute. So the biggest press tour of the moment that I know you're really loving and I am definitely really loving is for The Hunger Games' Sunrise

Speaker 1on the Reaping, which is the latest movie in The Hunger Games franchise. Replayer, are you a big Hunger Games fan? You absolutely know that I am. For anyone not watching.

Speaker 2I am doing the salute to Pan Am right now. And I know that you are too, despite the fact that you still have not read this book.

Speaker 1I don't want to cry. I've cried enough. I'll just watch the movie and cry then. I just, I can't. I actually can't do it. I love The Hunger Games. I watch the whole franchise multiple times a year. Have you read the other books? No, I didn't read the other books either. I missed that train. And then I thought, I love the movie so much. Should I go back and read them? And it's been on the list. But God, you know how much other stuff I got to read? I had to read all of ACOTAR. I had to read all the things. I've been busy. I get that. But Spillers, I want you to help me bully Tina. They bully me enough. It's fine.

Speaker 2I want you to help me bully Tina into reading these books because it will enrich and enhance your life.

Speaker 1I believe you. I believe you. So for anyone who's not sure, hit us with like what sunrise on the reaping is real quick.

Speaker 2So Sunrise on the Reaping is a prequel. Last time we had the Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, which was earlier years before that.

Speaker 1This was Haymitch's game. So the second quarter quell. Yeah.

Speaker 2So it means the 50th annual Hunger Games. It has been referenced in the books and films before. Obviously, Haymitch is a key player, but the games itself have been. So every time there was a quarter quell, something new happened with the game, like something... even more like messed up than usual. And in this particular case, they doubled the number of tributes from each district. So that meant four tributes going in, which means way more children getting slaughtered.

Speaker 1Yeah. Horrific stuff. Horrific stuff. And the cast is like excellent and brilliant and beautiful. Oh, stacked. Every time someone was announced, we would text each other and get so excited about it.

Speaker 2They didn't pick a wrong choice with any single casting on this movie.

Speaker 1So we've got Australian actor Joseph Zada playing Haymitch. Young Haymitch. Yes, young Haymitch. We've got Whitney Peake playing Lenora Dove. We've got McKenna Grace as Maisley Donner. Maisley Donner and also her twin sister. And her first look photos of on set got some weird responses from fans. I saw that and I thought that was strange because she's meant to look that way, right? Yes. She's really into her little looks and her fashions and stuff. Sort of like when people thought, like Lucy looked a little strange in Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. It's like, but it's the character. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1It's the character.

Speaker 2And the Donner twins are like the wealthier girls in town. Their father's like the mayor or the equivalent. And they own like a sweet shop. And so they've got like little trinkets and things that they use to enhance their looks. And, you know, because they're obviously in District 12, which is, the poorest district, but they're like in the upper crust of District 12. And then obviously like inspired casting, Elle Fanning is young Effie Trinker, which everyone wanted and everyone got and they were thrilled by. We've got Kieran Culkin

Speaker 2playing young Cesar Flickerman, which raised an eyebrow or two, but I think it's interesting.

Speaker 1Oh, no, no, no, spot on, spot on. Yeah, and I think the actual very best young casting. I know who you're going to say. Who am I going to say? You're going to talk about young Plutarch.

Speaker 2Oh, my God.

Speaker 1It's beautiful. It's incredible. Young Plutarch Heavensby. So obviously played by Philip Seymour Hoffman in The Hunger Games franchise and now being played by Jesse Plemons, who is also an incredible actor and also looks exactly like him. It's astounding. Yeah, it's incredible. And then Ralph Fiennes, President Snow, which is medium. But I'm excited. It's fine. He'll be amazing. Yeah. Yeah. He'll be amazing. How did we get from Tom Blythe to Donald Sutherland and Ralph Fiennes was in between? I don't know. No one knows, but it doesn't matter. No one knows. But, yeah. It's okay. So, obviously, those are

Speaker 1our key players. We're very excited about it. But no one is more excited. No one is more excited than McKenna Grace. No. I was going to say she is really the one, like, making headlines at the minute with her outfit. And her, like, face. Being a fan of this. Yeah, she's such a lifelong fan.

Speaker 2Yeah, it is absolutely like, you know, from the start she's been a huge fan. And when they were on set. She was the one kind of delivering great TikToks and pieces of content on set with, like, roping in all the others and, like, showing what a fan she was right from the start.

Speaker 1Yeah, agreed. And she also, I would say it's been called method dressing. I would say she's wearing costumes all over the red carpet. I don't think it's method dressing. I mean, I guess that's the thing, though.

Speaker 2Like, it is method dressing, but because of the Hunger Games and what it is and the sort of capital cornice of it all, it is very costumey.

Speaker 1Yeah. So I would say what Elle Fanning is doing is method dressing. Yes. So Elle is obviously playing Effie. She's done a lot of, like, very, like, extremely tailored suiting looks. Like, she's done a lot of interesting headpieces. She's playing into, like, the capital and, like, the sort of vibe of Effie Trinket when she was younger and what she was doing. Whereas McKenna has recreated some, like, really beautiful outfits. Do we want to run through a couple of Effie's very quickly? So she wore... Most recently, a recreation of the Girl on Fire dress. Absolutely incredible.

Speaker 1So that is the dress, obviously, that Katniss Everdeen wears when she's in the Little Chariot and then it sets on fire as she goes past President Snow. So McKenna had a custom version made, obviously, and was like throwing it in the air so that the dress looked like it was flames and it was on fire. That was designed by Kongtree. It was pretty cool. Yeah, it was amazing. That, I would say, is my second favourite that she's done. Okay. Yeah. She also wore the wedding dress that Katniss wears in the second film when she's allegedly getting married to Peter.

Speaker 1What about the baby? And she wore like a white silver embellished gown by Monique Lillier and it was like a recreation of the exact same look and she did the same makeup, same hair, everything. She looked so much like her as well in that moment. Very interesting. She also wore like an archival Gucci kind of like clown-esque glittering suit that sort of looked a bit Caesar Flickerman-y. Yes. From the new film. Yeah, see, this is the thing.

Speaker 2She's not just recreating looks that Katniss Everdeen wore.

Speaker 1She's recreated a whole lot of different other characters. Yeah, different things. She wore a Betsy Johnson outfit that paid tribute to Rue with little puffed sleeves.

Speaker 2That one was absolutely incredible and just like tugged on the heartstrings immediately.

Speaker 1Yeah. At the UK photo call, she wore a Gucci Fall 2016 gown and it was a little bit of a duo tribute. So it was a tribute to Lucy Greybeard in Songbird, but it was also a dress that Elle Fanning had wore on the cover of a W magazine in like 2016. That was incredible. Which was just beautiful and colorful and amazing. But I'm going to guess your favorite. Yes. Is the Hunger Games arena dress. Yes. So she wore a couture hand beaded crystal dress with like 3D floral applique. And at first glance, it almost

Speaker 1like was like a Van Gogh painting. Like it was really beautiful. And you're like, what's going on? And then you looked at it and it was the still that we've all seen from like the trailer of the Hunger Games arena, like across her body.

Speaker 2Because you won't know this because you won't read the book, but this arena is incredibly beautiful. It's like known for being the most beautiful arena that there ever, ever, ever has been.

Speaker 1It's like rolling hills and flowers.

Speaker 2Yeah, rolling hills of flowers, butterflies, like a babbling brook sort of cutting through the rolling hills is visually really, really, really stunning. And then Haymitch and Maisley and the other tributes learn very quickly that no matter how beautiful everything looks, it's like every single element is designed to kill them.

Speaker 1Yeah. And it was an incredible dress. And even if you haven't obviously read the book, if you've seen the trailer, you would have put it together eventually. Yeah. It was stunning. And she's also dressed as Jennifer Lawrence twice. Yeah.

Speaker 2She wore a dress that was reminiscent of the red Calvin Klein that Jennifer Lawrence wore to her first Academy Awards when she was nominated for her role on Winter's Bone.

Speaker 1Yeah. And then she also wore like a recreation of the Golden Globes dress Jennifer Lawrence wore earlier this year. She also wore like a red carpet look dress. that Jenna Malone had worn once for a red carpet for the Hunger Games. So she's really like digging into old photos of the press tours as well as the film to like pull her looks together. And then she did that really funny video where she was being finicky. Very cute. But what I would say is she has come out and obviously spoken about it because she's been asked a lot by people. Yes. And she had this to say. She was like, fashion's been weird and hard for me

Speaker 1to figure out. So being able to play around in this way has been really fun. it makes me feel it's in a way healing that now I have fun with fashion versus it being something of anxiety. Because obviously McKenna Grace has been like a child star. Oh, yeah. She was in literally everything. She played every young version of every actress in a movie you've seen from like Margot Robbie to Kiernan Shipka. She was also like in that beautiful movie with Chris Evans where she was just like a really smart kid and he was her like uncle. Loved it. But she has been in the public eye for a really long time and now that she's a

Speaker 1young adult, she's also obviously like experimenting more with fashion and like what that feels like to her. And so she kind of said that going this more like costume tribute route has just helped her feel a bit more confident in promoing the movie. But it also gives her a chance to lean into the fandom side. I think so.

Speaker 2And the fans love her so much. So the response has been really, really overwhelmingly positive.

Speaker 1I would say.

Speaker 2I have seen just recently in the last couple of days, a couple of people starting to niggle at it and say that they're a bit over the method dressing thing. And I wanted to chat to you about that because I know that it was something that we were all starting to feel when Lily Reinhart was doing her press tour for The Love Hypothesis. And I have to say, like, I am loving McKenna's like outfits. I'm loving the method dressing. I can't get enough. Like I want to see more, more, more, more, more. But Lily's did great on me after a while.

Speaker 1She looked incredible. She looked great in every single thing she wore.

Speaker 2But I started to get a bit tired of it and like the stuntness of it.

Speaker 1I would say with Lily's, because obviously she recreated outfits from like Miss Congeniality, Atonement, Ever After, just How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days, a bunch of films. And her whole thing with her stylist was like, I'm recreating iconic rom-com and romance looks to pay tribute to the concept of romance. But then her other press tool looks I thought were much better. Same. Quote unquote method dressing to play a rom-com lead. Like she wore a lot of like couture 2000s Ellie Saab and like really sparkling gowns and really cute kind of 90s, 2000s rom-com

Speaker 1vibes that really like brought the feeling of what she was going for without her having to essentially wear costumes for movies that weren't related to her movie.

Speaker 2No.

Speaker 1I think that was why that might have graded on some people.

Speaker 2I think as well, I also just felt like the project didn't warrant it.

Speaker 1Yeah. And I do think a lot of the time this works the most when you are in a blockbuster franchise. That's where we've seen it be at, like, some of its most powerful. Obviously, Margot Robbie did it a lot for Barbie. Again, I'm not saying it cost you me in a bad way. It's, like, almost Met Gala in a way. No, I mean, it worked so well for Barbie. She's dressing it as a Barbie.

Speaker 2And it's these concepts that have a huge history, right? Whereas Lily and her team were manufacturing that history by calling in on other well-known.

Speaker 1Other well-known films that aren't actually related to what you're doing. Whereas, like, McKenna's specifically channeling Hunger Games. Like, Halle Bailey with the Little Mermaid, she wore a lot of like silhouettes and like a lot of shell patterns, a lot of beading, a lot of colors that really worked for being a mermaid. And obviously there's like the more subtle things like Timothee Chalamet in a like purple suit for Wonka. We've obviously got like Cynthia and Ariana doing really dramatic pink and green and like Elphaba and Glinda coated looks without wearing costumes. But the history is there. And I think I mean, Timmy,

Speaker 1you do what you want. Timmy, do what you want. But, like, you know, there's a level of dressing to match your movie. Yes. Then there's method dressing and then there's, I think, what McKenna and Margot did. Yeah. And obviously, like, the queen of method dressing has always been Zendaya. But I think what's missing there as well is, like, the history and understanding of fashion sometimes when people do it and when it grates on people. Because, like, Zendaya and Law have spoken at length about how, like, They go into like, his whole thing is like, we don't borrow, we buy. Like he goes into stores, he buys the stuff. They go to like vintage and like archive stores. They work

Speaker 1with designers. They have a list of designers they refuse to work with who didn't dress Zendaya when she was younger. And I love that. I love that a lot. I like his level of pettiness. I love it. And it's very valid. Yeah. But he also used to like, I know you would know this. He used to put her deliberately in clothes that had already been worn by other celebrities. So she would end up on the Who Wore It Better pages. And that was, like, a tactic he did. That was so clever. Because also she always looked so good. And she always looked better. Like, no one ever looks better than Santana in a dress. No, and that was a tactic they took to, like, build up her as, like, a luxury fashion girl. And even as far back as

Speaker 1her being in, like, the Space Jam movie, the first Spider-Man, they were already method dressing. Yeah. They've always done it. It's been, like, a slow burn for them. He's so clever with the way he works with her. And it's often, like, obviously there's, like, her in a robot suit. for June, but a lot of the time it's more subtle than that. It's not necessarily this sort of stunt dressing that we're seeing with McKenna. And I have space on like both of them, but I think the common thread is these are blockbuster, huge, huge, huge films. And then as well, like you said, it's the understanding of like the history and the reasoning behind it. Yeah. That maybe people like

Speaker 1enjoy these, but don't enjoy it on others.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Look, I agree.

Speaker 2And I think that that's really what it comes down to is that history and also just the, like the existing fan base already being hungry for it.

Speaker 1Yeah, and I know you said, like, McKenna was really inspired by Elle Fanning. Yes. Yeah. Oh, my God, she did.

Speaker 2She was asked about how much fun she's having with her method dressing and what looks she's looked in the past. And she referenced Lily Reinhart's love hypothesis and talked about how much she enjoyed watching that.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2But she also specifically called out Elle Fanning, who wore– the most, like one of my favorite, favorite, favorite gowns ever, which was for the Maleficent press run. And she wore a custom Gucci gown that Alessandro McCarley was the creative director there at the time. And it had the little droplets of blood down, like from her pricked finger, like, and it was at finger length for her.

Speaker 1Yeah. trailing down the skirt of the dress and it was unbelievable yeah the detail again in all those looks was spectacular and also like subtle enough that the fans would see it but that if you didn't you just thought oh a beautiful gown but it was all very intentional like for the first round for Maleficent she wore all these like pinks and blues her first event she went to in like a green mini dress and then her heels had aurora on them and the hair like went up the like pointed toe pump it was really cute but then obviously she got more elevated especially as like the second movie came around I have a Pinterest

Speaker 1board of, like, red carpet looks I would wear if I was famous because I have, like, a rich and storied, like, interior life. Of course. Where I'm a star. Yeah, me too. Yeah, of course. And the Gucci dresses on it, but also this, like, white dress that she wore to the Tokyo premiere. It was Alexander McQueen and it had, like, stars and moons and, like, a feather trim and it just was so perfect. Every single look she did was really capturing the, like, dreaminess she's.

Speaker 2Such a fashion girly as well exactly yeah she looks beautiful I love I I think I can't think of a time where I've not liked something Elle Fanning's worn on a red carpet yeah and I think.

Speaker 1We're both enjoying this so much because we love the Hunger Games and we like that McKenna's a fangirl like she used to run fan edit accounts she was like begging to be in this movie she's.

Speaker 2Really in the way of sunshine as well she's a really just like bright bubbly great gal yeah Also, I want to shout out her stylist, Molly Dixon, who's done an incredible job.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And then Glenn Coco, who does her hair, who has been putting the braids through, which of course Katniss is known for her braids, but Maisley always had like a thin braid as well. So she's been rocking those looks thanks to her team.

Speaker 1Yeah. And I also think you said something interesting before of like a lot of these method dressing moments, it has to live up, like the movie has to live up to the hype you're creating. Yeah. There has been a little pushback on McKenna from a few fashion mags in the last couple of days kind of going, oh, is this the end of classic red carpets? Why is everyone messing with the dressing when they don't need to? I like McKenna's looks. I'm enjoying it. But I also think the movie is going to back it up. Oh, for sure.

Speaker 2For sure.

Speaker 1Like she's creating buzz for something that is going to work. Yes, live up to the hype. Yeah, absolutely.

Speaker 2So, Tina, while Laura's away, we will talk about The Pit.

Speaker 1Amazing. And look, you and I, we both love The Pit. Yeah. We're both big Pit heads. We love this show.

Speaker 2I am sad I'm not wearing my Noah Wiley shirt.

Speaker 1I'm sad for you.

Speaker 2To tell this story. But the show has had an incredible run. We are two seasons in. They're currently filming their third season. Noah Wiley in particular, star of the show who plays Dr. Michael Rabinovich, Robbie for short, has had– such a career high since this show aired. He has won the Emmy back-to-back for Best Actor in a Drama and the show itself has won Best Drama. He was also recently named Sexiest Man Alive by People magazine, something

Speaker 2that you're shaking your head about. I still very, very strongly support. However, it hasn't been all sunshine and rainbows for Noah with this show because there has been a bit of a legal drama kind of holding over them ever since the first episode, well, even before the first episode aired. So what has happened is now this, like, hugely successful medical drama is being accused of being an unauthorised reworking of ER, which is the show that, of course,

Speaker 2made Noah Wiley famous in the first place, playing Dr John Carter.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2The studio is disputing that and, like, okay, for anyone who didn't grow up watching ER because it old.

Speaker 1I mean, I personally didn't grow up watching it. I didn't watch it. I remember being intrigued why Noah and George Clooney got such big cheers on Friends because they did like a crossover appearance as like doctors. Yes, they did. And I was like, who are these clowns? Apparently very famous men. Who are these clowns? Who are these gorgeous, gorgeous men? And they were famous and they were on a show about medicine. Yes.

Speaker 2So ER was a hospital drama set in Chicago. The name gives away which part of the hospital it is set in. The emergency room, obviously.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And it ran from 1994 through to 2009. Noah started off the show as like in that sort of young intern role and worked his way up through the show. And it was created by a man called Michael Crichton.

Speaker 1Yeah. Who also wrote Jurassic Park. Yeah. Yeah, he did. I'm aware.

Speaker 2Now, he passed away in 2008, but his widow, Sherry Crichton, controls the company that holds the contractual rights to ER.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2And so when he originally made his deal with Warner Brothers, which is the network that have ER and now have the pit.

Speaker 1Yes, due to the merger that has happened in the middle of this lawsuit. Due to the merger that's happened in the middle of this, yep. He negotiated a very valuable provision, which is that follow-ups to ER required his agreement.

Speaker 2Yep.

Speaker 1And that right survived him. Yep.

Speaker 2So basically, like, any kind of, like, spin-off, sequel, remake, or any other, like, derivative work of ER had to be approved by.

Speaker 1Him, but they're now his estate. Yeah.

Speaker 2And Warner Brothers acquired the ER copyright that made that contractual promise thanks to, obviously, the merger. Now, this is where it gets really interesting because there were discussions about bringing ER back and they negotiated with Sherry, Michael's widow, but the talks ended without an agreement. And then came the pit with Noah Wiley and some of the producers.

Speaker 1Yep.

Speaker 2So the issue here is that Roadrunner, which is the company bringing the case, alleges the revival development began in 2020. Sherry was approached about the approval roughly two years later and the company sued in August 2024 before the pit even aired. The company holding Crichton's rights alleged that they went ahead with a reworked version of that revival, so that potential ER revival that was nixed.

Speaker 1Mm-hmm.

Speaker 2And Warner Brothers says that these people have created an original show. So last week, This is all heated up again last week because an appeals court ruled that the case against the studio can continue.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Although it has directed that, like, Noah Wiley specifically and other defendants are dismissed from it.

Speaker 1Yeah. Okay. But the names.

Speaker 2Here, aside from Noah, who is obviously the most famous name attached to the case and the face of it inadvertently because every time there's a story written about this, his face is front and centre and all of the.

Speaker 1Yeah. And I mean, well, even without knowing any of this, it was always like when the pit started advertising, it was like, oh, it's like if he stayed on his job after ER and like everyone drew the link themselves. Of course.

Speaker 2So the other parties involved is John Wells, who's a major producer and showrunner on ER.

Speaker 1Yeah. And also is the showrunner and producer on the pit. Yeah. R.

Speaker 2Scott Gemmel, who worked on ER and created the pit. And then, of course, Wiley, who was... starring in both and an executive producer. So all three of them were among the original defendants. That has been dismissed though. But what they have actually compared is the pilot scripts and episodes of both shows in front of them and what they've decided to take this forward is that there is enough crossover between between both shows that it is worth

Speaker 2actually considering.

Speaker 1Okay. That, like, the lawsuit can go ahead. Yes. Yeah.

Speaker 2So here are the things that they say. It's actually quite ridiculous.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Here are the things that they say there are similarities in. So this says that there are similarities that they're both set in an emergency department and both depict difficult working conditions and comment on the healthcare system.

Speaker 1Mm-hmm.

Speaker 2They also both have patients arriving in overlapping sequences and that staff leave one case to handle another and that the crises build on top of each other at a very fast pace. There's medical shorthand.

Speaker 1Yep.

Speaker 2Graphic injuries, exhausted doctors and nurses, and emotional outbursts. And that both pilots have an experienced young doctor fresh from medical school who struggles with the job.

Speaker 1Right. So basically. They're like identical. But basically a description of any possible medical drama. Yeah. Ever. Grey's Anatomy starts exactly the same way. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Her name is Meredith Grey. She's just come to the hospital. Yeah. Now it's moving quick. Oh my God, there's a crazy case on the first day. But you know, like the thing is why they all start that way?

Speaker 2Because that's the reality of what an ER is actually like.

Speaker 1Yeah. And also that's good TV. It is good TV. Yeah. Okay. So they say those things have crossed over, so that's why there's enough. That's why there's enough. Is it not a commentary on the case itself, but just specifically if you were to compare the two things? There's enough crossover of these things. So now it's up to both legal teams to decide how to explain that. Yeah.

Speaker 2And so Warner Brothers are saying, look, like obviously they're just familiar features of emergency room dramas. Like nobody can own the idea of overworked doctors dealing with emergencies.

Speaker 1Yeah. That is literally the reality of every single hospital out there.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Do we know when they approached Sherry? Yes. Do we know if it was in the hour format that it is now? No, it wasn't. Okay. No. So what they approached her with was the revival of AR. Yes.

Speaker 2And then that was set aside. They weren't interested. It didn't move ahead. And then The Pit, of course, which for anyone who doesn't know, each season is 15 episodes and the episodes and season occurs over one whole day. So each episode constitutes an hour and it's an hour of that very same day. So from 7 a.m. clocking on for day shift through to 9 p.m., although season three starts at 6 a.m.

Speaker 1I saw it on the board. I saw it on the board in the trailer. Oh, my God, how exciting. What a time. One more hour of Sean Hattersey. One more hour of Sean Hattersey. That is, yeah, I mean, that's why everyone was like, I'm clocking in for a shift at the pit during the first season because it does, you watch it and you feel like you've lived an hour of real-time experience in an ER. My brother-in-law is an emergency doctor, right?

Speaker 2He is like the equivalent of a Robbie at the hospital he works at. He can't watch it because he said coming home and watching that is just like living another hour of work.

Speaker 1It's the one like medical show that medical professionals have been like, this is the most realistic portrayal of like our shifts or our working life that I've ever seen. Yeah. Which is not really what people said about ER or Grey's Anatomy. No, it's not.

Speaker 2And this is the thing, there's a lot of kissing that goes on on Grey's Anatomy in ER and there is zero on The Pit.

Speaker 1In fact, Amy Pollard called that out. In fact, everyone's shipping two people who've like barely even spoken. Barely even interact.

Speaker 2Yeah. But everyone's just gagging for some romance and they're not going to get it.

Speaker 1No, because that's not the point. It's not what the show's about. Maybe in 17 seasons time. Especially because some of the people, like you're like, they've probably barely worked together. Yeah. Okay. Obviously, like how many times do you reckon you've rewatched The Pit? Yeah. I know the answer to that. Oh, you know? Okay, hit us. I've watched it five times. I feel like it's more than that. No, I've watched it five times. Okay, that's actually quite okay. I thought you had watched it like 70 because every time I speak to you in our lives, you're watching the bit. No, because I've been

Speaker 1watching Animal Kingdom a lot. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. She knew Sean had to see shows. Yeah, and there's a lot more seasons of that. Yeah. And it was also back when they did longer seasons. I think five is like quite a nice amount of rewatches.

Speaker 2I have also downloaded– I'm going on a flight later this week. I have downloaded both seasons to watch it on the plane.

Speaker 1Yeah, I watched it on the plane once and then I felt bad about it because everyone– was in the medical cases with me on the plane. Too bad. Like, they're, like, really intensely grotesque medical cases in the pit. They are. You know. Yeah. But have you seen a bit of ER? Because I, like, have gone back and watched parts of it over time. And, like, I remember it was definitely not the Noah seasons because it was far gone. But I remember watching parts of it on free-to-air when I was younger. Yeah, right. And I feel like, personally, I think there's quite a tone difference in the kinds of shows they are. What do you think as, like, a pit girl?

Speaker 2I see huge tone difference. I think that ER feels almost... And I think it definitely got this way, but almost soapy. In the same way that Grey's Anatomy got soapy, which eventually happens when you've got a series that runs for so, so, so long. You run out of people to date. You run out of medical cases. It's going to go that way. But I think from the start, the time was very different. I think you can have... Like me aside, because like I do realize it's not normal to watch The Pit

Speaker 2as often as I do, but I think that you can have a good time watching AR. I don't think watching The Pit for most people is necessarily a good time. I think it's just brilliant television. But yeah, as you say, it's pretty harrowing. I think like the experience of watching it is a very different experience. It's like addictive television because it's so good and the performances are so incredible. And it is that slice of real life that You know, if you're lucky, you never get to go inside the emergency room of a hospital. But anyone who does is

Speaker 2probably pretty shocked by what is going on around them.

Speaker 1Yeah. And it does depict that. Yeah. No, I mean, I think The Pit is phenomenal television. Yeah. But I guess we'll see. So, like, what's the next step? Now it's allowed to proceed. Yeah, now it's allowed to proceed.

Speaker 2What I do think is interesting is if The Pit had not been the roaring success that it is, if they would have cared.

Speaker 1Yeah, okay. And the answer's probably no. I mean, they'd filed before the pic came out, right? Yeah. But do you think because of the buzz?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1There was a hell of a lot of buzz around the pic.

Speaker 2Yeah, a hell of a lot of buzz and then obviously worth pursuing because it has just surpassed expectations. Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 1I mean, I guess we'll see. Yeah. Yeah. I'm intrigued.

Speaker 2I'm intrigued too. But we are getting season three is underway right now. They have recently last week been over filming outdoor scenes in Pittsburgh. So locals have been out and about spotting them and taking photos. And I've seen many a blurry, blurry pic of Noah and Sean together on set. Can't wait for that scene. and some, like, hot spots in Pittsburgh being filmed in, like, bars and things like that. So we will get season three in January, regardless of.

Speaker 1What happens in this legal drama. Yeah, love it.

Speaker 2Thank you so much for listening to us on The Spill today. If you aren't following us, we are on Instagram and TikTok. We are going to pop up some of our favourite looks of McKenna Grace's method dressing from her sunrise on The Reaping Tour, and we will be back in your feed early tomorrow morning with Morning Tea.

Speaker 1Thanks, bye. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Brutally Honest Review Of The Call Her Daddy Tell-All

    Nov 20, 202659 minAudio

    Six years after the most famous podcast breakup of all time, Sofia Franklyn has finally told her side of the Call Her Daddy story, and Alex Cooper hasn’t said a word. We’re unpacking Daddy Issues, the memoir that reads...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Weekend Watch: The Most Brutal Hunger Games Yet & Jared Padalecki’s Netflix Christmas Rom-Com

    Nov 19, 202634 minAudio

    Read our entertainment editor Tina Burke's review of Sunrise On The Reaping here. Subscribe here for 30% off your annual Mamamia subscription for Black Friday with code BLACK30. Code applied at the checkout. Offer ends...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Real Problem Behind Florence Pugh’s Viral Statement & We Support Khloé Kardashian’s No Sex Stance

    Nov 19, 202644 minAudio

    Khloe Kardashian hasn’t had sex in four years, and she’s officially over everyone asking why. We’re unpacking her candid chat with Goldie Hawn, the Lemme gummy that started it all, and a very unexpected list of men who...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. MORNING TEA: Pretty Little Liars Is Coming Back…Maybe? & Anne Hathaway’s Baby News

    Nov 18, 202611 minAudio

    This morning, Anne Hathaway becomes a mum of three, and Jeff Bezos makes a very interesting admission about the new James Bond. Plus, the Pretty Little Liars rumour that has every millennial texting their group chat. ☕...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Robert Pattinson Shouldn’t Be James Bond & The TV Show That Changed Our Minds About Dating

    Nov 18, 202643 minAudio

    After the longest casting saga in history, Robert Pattinson is officially the new James Bond. Here’s why we think it’s the wrong call, plus the Twilight fans who called it first and who we really wanted in the tux. Tina...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode