Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Purpose Brief

The Purpose Brief artwork

Philanthropy, Identity, and the Role of Fundraisers with Professor Beth Breeze OBE

Feb 17, 202632 minAudio

In this episode of The Purpose Brief, James Johnston chats to Professor Beth Breeze OBE, and they explore how philanthropy really works and how it’s changing. Drawing on decades of research, Beth reflects on generosity among the wealthy, and why giving is rarely just about money. Instead, philanthropy often sits at the intersection of identity, influence, responsibility, and a desire to make a difference, sometimes in ways that can spark controversy and debate. The conversation explores what happens when wealth and goodwill meet in the real world, and how ideas of responsible business and responsible wealth are shaping modern philanthropy. They also touch upon the identity of donors, the critical role fundraisers play in building relationships and trust, and why public perception and collaboration matter for sustaining a healthy culture of giving. It’s a grounded, thoughtful conversation about philanthropy as a force for good and the responsibilities that come with it. LINKS Order 'Rich Expectations' Now from the Directory for Social Change More about Harris Manchester College: https://www.hmc.ox.ac.uk/ About Us: https://www.thepurposebrief.org.uk/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello and welcome back to the next edition of The Purpose Brief. In this episode, I'm joined by Professor Beth Breeze OBE. She's Principal at Knoxford College, Director of the Centre for Philanthropy in the University of Kent, and one of the world's leading experts on why people give to charity and participate in philanthropy. Beth's new book, Rich Expectations, with esteemed colleagues, lifts the lid on how wealthy donors

shape the world through their philanthropy. It explores what motivates them, how they choose causes, and what their giving reveals about power, privilege and purpose. So look, I checked my privilege on talking to her today. Beth's been around through my... fundraising career. So it's a real pleasure while she settles into life in Oxford to grab some time to have a discussion with her about this new book. Let's get started.

Beth, hello. It's really, really lovely to see you today. Thank you for joining us on this next episode of The Purpose Brief. Good to be here. Hello. And so I think it's safe to say for all our listeners that Beth is one of the kind of leading lights. if not the leading light in the UK on philanthropy and fundraising. And through my... time as a fundraiser was a bit of a north staff to go to around the frameworks and the thinking around philanthropy back in the in the

90s and the noughties when I was starting out as a fundraiser and that's how you started out Beth isn't it and have kind of gone on to different roles you've just become principal at Harris Manchester College in Oxford so congratulations and that gives you sort of a different focus and different purpose But let's start with that question and go into the deeper question around what do you think your purpose is through your work? Well, thanks for asking that. So I think that our lives do take coherence, but maybe only with hindsight. So I look back now and I don't

want to pretend it was all this tied up. from the beginning. But I look back now and I see my career in three parts. So really the first decade or so, I was on the frontline fundraising and I loved being a fundraiser. I don't come from a wealthy background. So if I could raise money, if I could raise a million pounds, that was the closest I was ever going to get to being a millionaire. And that felt really good because you're doing it for causes you believed in. But during that time of being a fundraiser, it just became very clear to me that the sector with which we charge to do some of the most difficult things and tackle the most intractable problems

that haven't yet been solved by government or business has got the least support so my friends from you know school and uni who'd gone into the business sector could you know do a degree in business and every university's got business school they could do an MBA there was loads of journals on business loads of research loads of data you know you were existing in a world with lots of information and then my friends and peers who went into government or politics again there was loads of support for that you chose to go into the third sector or the charity sector it was like well good luck on you go and There was nothing. There was no degrees, no higher

education. At that point, very little professional support. And it just struck me as really odd that the sector doing this most difficult work had the least support. So that's what led to my move from doing fundraising to studying fundraising. And then the middle bit of my career where I spent 20 years at the University of Kent, first of all, getting my PhD. So I had my training and then being in a position where I could do that research and set up the kind of courses that I wish I'd accepted. when I was a fundraiser. So the master's degree in philanthropy, then a PhD pathway, but also entry -level courses

that we had an online free course or have still available called How to Fundraise and the Fundraiser Apprenticeship. So really just trying to provide that suite of training programmes. And because there wasn't really anyone else doing the research, we were also writing the textbooks and doing the research that were taught on those courses. So I loved doing that as well and probably trained certainly a couple of hundred did the MA and many others did the other courses. But now this third act, which is quite nice, in your early 50s to do something else. I've moved on to work in an institution that is seeped in philanthropy.

So I'm now at Oxford University in Harris Manchester College, which is the only college for mature students. I'm teaching the same kind of people as I taught at Kent. But it's a university that has benefited a lot over eight centuries of people leaving money, leaving assets and making it be, you know, the successful institution that it is. You know, there's a reason why Oxford is the best university in the world, because it's... It's got a lot more resources and a lot more friends and a lot more support. So here I am running one of the colleges. So that's my sort of story. And I suppose running all through that

is that belief that there's more to the world than just business and states. You know, people see it as two sectors. If you've got a problem, can you sell me a solution or can I demand that government provide it? And sometimes those two solutions do work, but actually... Very often, it's the third sector that's there first tackling these issues or working alongside government or working alongside business and drawing attention to needs and meeting them more quickly, more innovatively. And so my purpose really is to draw attention to the importance of that sector,

which is often hidden in plain sight. We just don't see. I used to set my students a challenge. Can you get through a day without benefiting in some way from philanthropy? And I don't personally believe you can because, you know, the clean air around you, the health. the benefits your kids in a nursery your elder parents in an elder institution it's all around us so I want to draw attention to it to encourage it and to improve it that's my purpose I think that people forget that it is all around us and it is a theme that runs through everything we do and it touches every story that we certainly been uncovering

through the work that we do, is around a link back to somebody who just wanted to do good. They wanted to give back. And universities have that in droves. But as we know, there's been a big announcement this week around the Office for Impact from the government. And do you welcome that as an initiative to bring all that impact economy work together and philanthropy is included in that? I definitely welcome it. I mean, philanthropy needs friends and the charity sector needs friends. So if government wants to do more, and they've

always done a lot, we shouldn't underestimate, you know, even just the tax breaks for giving and the regulation of charities. You know, there's plenty of ways in which the state enables the third sector. So that's a good thing. Would I call it the impact economy? Probably not. I'm not sure that's a phrase that many... donors use, that many fundraisers use, but I'm not someone who gets tied up too much in terminology. I think it's basically a euphemism for charity and philanthropy. And for whatever reason, it was felt that those words were not very 2025. And we'll get used to it. It's not an unfair title. I mean, it does

have impact. It ought to have impact and positive impact. Let's see if it catches on. But no, I definitely welcome anything that... that enhances the strength of the relationship between government and charity. Because nothing important gets done with small amounts of money or small amounts of effort. It's always collaboration. So the more we can develop those strong relationships, the better. No, I totally agree. Let's just jump into Rich Expectations, which you've written with Rod Reid, Davies and Teresa Lloyd. So great

to see that. And always good to reassure ourselves that as fundraisers, we're looking at the same kind of motivations when we talk to donors. And over the years, I've talked to so many different types of donors about. what motivates them. And sometimes it's quite simple things. You know, it's not as complicated as you think. But just talk to me a little bit about why you think identity and giving for those donors that you interviewed has become so closely tied to identity. What is that link? And do you want to unpack that

a little bit more? Yeah, sure. So, I mean, this is a study that's now happened three times. It's three different books. But the basic methodology and goal of it is the same. We're trying to understand why rich people give. So the first iteration was done by Teresa Lloyd by herself in the early 2000s. And the book's just called Why Rich People Give. And then 10 years later, I worked with Teresa to revisit half that sample and to interview and survey a fresh half. And then this last one is Rodri joining the gang and going back to 44 of the people who were involved in one or both

of the first two editions and then 44 new donors. And I think it's important to refresh the pool because things change. There's a lot more women now whose name is on Flamsby. I think they were always there. They just didn't always get the credit. But there's other kinds of wealth. So it's important to refresh that pool. But it's also important. to try and track changes over time so having that consistency over time is helpful i sometimes describe it as a bit like the seven up tv program you know you keep going back to the same kids every seven years well hopefully this will carry on keeping on going back to philanthropists every 10 years and we'll have a really good longitudinal study so one

of the questions we ask them and the questions are pretty similar each year one of them we ask them is how important is philanthropy in your life and has it grown in importance and the good news is that they answer yes to both it's very important. And it's even more important now than the last time you asked me this question. So I think that that answers the first part of your question, that it really is part of people's identity. I'm not just someone who inherited a lot. I'm not just somebody who made a lot of money in business or won the lottery or had a big divorce settlement or whatever it might be. I guess I've accumulated wealth, but I'm also

distributing wealth. And that really matters for their sense of self. And we call the book Rich Expectations because what came through really loud and clear is that they have an expectation of themselves that they will use some of that wealth for good. And they actually hold it of their friends and colleagues. And sometimes they struggle to understand why people of similar wealth are not also giving that money away. And there's quite a funny combination of sort of judgment and pity because they say, well, we know how much they've got about the same money as us and they're not giving that's wrong but also they're missing out they don't know how

much fun it is they don't know how enriching to your life it is what interesting people you meet so it's quite and one went so far as to say I'm not really friends with the non -giving rich because I don't really you know I don't relate to them I don't understand where they're coming from so it definitely is very very important to their identity funnily enough though a lot of them don't like the word philanthropy they often reject that they think it sounds paternalistic Victorian or a bit self -aggrandizing and my best explanation for that is you don't tend to say you know my name's Beth and I'm really funny

you know it's for other people to say you're funny in the same way you don't say my name's Bob and I'm a philanthropist it's for other people to say that you're so I don't think they mind it so much if other people apply it to them but very few of them walk around saying hey I'm a philanthropist because it it doesn't sit well especially in Britain maybe maybe in America somewhere else but the funniest explanation I got from one guy who said oh yeah I don't mind the word philanthropist because you always get mixed opinions you know these are just people and they have different opinions so just as some don't like it some do and this man said oh yeah i have it in my linkedin profile that i'm a philanthropist

he said it's better than describing myself as a hedge funder which i thought was quite funny yeah i think it's i've had some really interesting conversations with donors over the years who i would In the negotiation and the discussion about things, we refer to their philanthropy or them being a regional philanthropist, particularly up north in Yorkshire, and they don't like it. It has sort of caveats, like almost calling them an influencer or something like that. So we've got to be careful. Is there a word that kind

of lands or a terminology that's landed through this study that creates a new terminology around this? Yeah, I don't know that they're close to damage. Certainly people talk about giving. sharing is quite nice and I like sharing because they know that the money alone can't do very much. You know, you need someone to spend the money. And I think there's so many myths and misunderstandings of philanthropy. And one of them is quite how much power you have when you have money. Of course, you've got some power. No one's going to pretend you haven't. But, you know, you can have all the money in the world, but if you can't find

a partner that you trust to spend that money well to achieve the thing you care about, it's highly unlikely that someone who's got the money can also, you know, do the science to find the cure to that illness or can run the project to, you know, end homelessness in that city. to find a partner to work with. And a lot of them do use that language of partnership. So I think sharing, generosity, caring, just being a good person, you know, sort of that's how they would see it as well, which again, I think speaks to how fundamental they see it. It's not really optional. Nobody wants to be a bad person. So

if being a good person means sharing some of your wealth, then you're going to do it. And do you think that there's an emerging role for philanthropists, let's call them, but people who want to donate? they have a more proactive role in shaping the solutions to the problems so it's not just about giving cash or giving a check they want to work as you say in partnership to solve the problems through other things that they can do through their networks through their businesses is it emerging into something more

embedded in terms of it's not just a transaction it's a it's an ethos it's let's work together on this Yeah, there's definitely some of that, but I think we have to always be careful of false binaries in philanthropy. It goes back to that thing about the misunderstandings and assumptions. One of them is, oh, in the past, people just used to sit in their armchair, you know, write a check, send it in and want nothing more to do with it. And there's really no historical evidence for that. You can look at Carnegie, who'd go in there and design his libraries, you know, decide what kind of motto should be on

the outside and what kind of stonework it should be and what books would be in it. You know, people always got very involved because that's half the fun of philanthropy is. getting involved with the project so I'm not sure that there was some sort of mythical armchair checkbooking check writing donor in the past but I think it's definitely true to say that the forms of engagement are getting possibly more um sophisticated or more personalized you know a good fundraiser will work out well what kind of engagement do they want some some want stories you know they want to be told about somebody got helped last week and how their life was turned around and obviously

anonymized if the beneficiaries are vulnerable but if they're not if it's a you know if it's a musician or a scholar then they'd like to meet them and have a relationship with them so there's that kind of very almost patronage type relationship which brings its own problems if both sides are not as comfortable meeting but in the ideal scenario they are other kinds of engagement might be becoming an expert on the topic you know it's there's something about getting to live another life you know you always fancied being i don't know an archaeology expert or a paleontologist But you chose to work in the city or you chose to

work in the family business. But by supporting that world, you can get involved and hang out with other paleontologists or, you know, harpists or whatever that might be. So there's that kind of engagement that's almost like having a second life at the same time. So it really depends. I say good fundraiser works out. Do they want to, you know, see all the Excel sheets of the data and what have you? Or do they more just want to be around the culture of this institution and have relationships with the people who are involved? So working out what kind of engagement is quite crucial to good major donor fundraising.

Is there something here about the purpose of a fundraiser and the role that they play in that? And any reflections on that from you as somebody who's been a fundraiser in the past, but more on an academic side? No, absolutely. I love that question because I think it's very easy to forget that the fundraiser is so crucial to all of this. And I love thinking about fundraisers. Being a fundraiser, I sometimes use the word we when I'm talking about them anyway, because I think it's a fascinating role to basically organise and choreograph generosity. You know, most gifts

are asked for before they're given. You know, I challenge people to give me many examples where the gift just came completely out of the blue. Even if it felt like that, there must have been some work done to make the donor aware that this charity existed and that would fall under the fundraising function. So I'm fascinated by fundraisers and what kind of people do this work. And one of the findings from research I've done into the fundraising profession is actually they share many of the same characteristics as the philanthropists, the donors that they're working with. They just have a smaller bank account. But in all other regards, they're very similar. They care passionately

about the cause. They want to make a difference in the world. They're fundamentally optimistic. They think a change can be made. They're often quite dynamic and energetic. They're learning new stuff. They're happy with every day being a bit different. So there's lots of, it's one of the reasons that relationships can be so much fun because you're actually talking about fairly similar people if you think of the caricature of a fundraiser. So I think we should never underestimate the role and the impact of fundraisers, even if they're a bit invisible. There's lots of blue plaques and naming of tributes to philanthropists,

but have you ever seen a blue plaque to a fundraiser? I mean, they're not thought of, they're not on the radar. But I remember some of the fundraisers I interviewed talked about that. quite explicitly and this is for research i did for a book called the new fundraisers and this particular guy had raised a lot of money for a medical research charity and he said one day there will be a cure for this illness he said and the scientists will get the nobel prize but we will sit here in our fundraising office in the basement and we will toast the success and we'll know the part we played in it and i always that always stayed

with me and he didn't say in any sort of pitying way he was just very happy to have played his part and he didn't need the public recognition and that's one of the reasons i love fundraising Yeah, that's a really good point. I think there's something there about the... Somebody said to me that they recently stepped into a different role, but they reflected a lot on their role as a fundraiser and how you give a lot of yourself over without thinking about it because it's your duty as a fundraiser to make this work. That amazing academic research matched up with a brilliant donor who just gets it. That synergy, if you

can create it, is so magical. But as a fundraiser, you are... you often have to take, stand back and take stock about the emotional energy imbued in that. But ultimately, I think there's a real privilege about being able to navigate those different worlds and be at the intersection of that space is quite a special thing as a professional. Yeah, no, you describe it beautifully. And I think the best word I can think of for what is

it actually fundraisers do is they look for alignment. And other people use this word as well. But it's not about persuasion. It's not about begging. It's not about getting someone to do something they don't want to do, because you can't actually do that, especially very powerful, very rich people. You can't get them to trick them into giving you a donation. people who don't understand fundraising often imagine is going on. You're looking to align somebody who wants to make a certain change in the world or who's worried about a certain cause or who wants to stop a change happening, whatever that might be, with an organisation that has the army on the ground,

the foot power to make that happen. And so you're looking for that alignment and it's bringing them together. And then, of course, you're building trust that actually this money will be spent well. And the trust should go both ways. The recipient charity needs to trust that this donor is going to act respectfully and going to acknowledge their expertise. expertise and give them the kind of funding they need which is the right amount you know don't give us too little and then have you know unrealistic expectations but also if you can give it unrestricted and give it over a longer period of time so again the reason we use the word expectations in the title of the book rich expectations is because there's

all these expectations that exist on all sides that the donors have of themselves that people have about rich people the expectations that the donors have about the charities they support and vice versa There's expectations that politicians and governments have about the role rich people will pay and again, vice versa. And most of these expectations are unstated, implicit. And I think when things go wrong, that's why. It's because people have made assumptions about motivation or how a charity should act. And I think if we could all just be a bit more explicit about what

we need and hope for, we can perhaps avoid some of those things going wrong. Could Brits, for instance, be better at asking and better at... discussing these issues? Because I think that's a really interesting space that we're in as a country, as we look at the role of the impact economy. Is there something that we can be better at in comparison to our friends across the pond? Because Americans are much better at this than us. Yeah, I mean, we've got a double problem. We don't like talking about money and we don't like talking about morals. And philanthropy exists

at the intersection of those two things. So it's really hard to talk about if you're a classic Brit. You've got to say not only have I got money or I've got views about how money is used, but I'm going to talk about the values that lie behind how I use this money. You know, I think it matters that people are, you know, have enough food or I think it matters that people have these kind of opportunities in life. So these are not easy things to say in a culture that doesn't really love sort of Pollyannas and do -gooders and tall poppies or whatever else you call them. It's actually weirdly easier to be sort of cynical

and, you know, not do good because you don't then set yourself up for sort of... criticism and ridicule. So I think that's all tied up in why people worry about. On the good news side, one of the questions we've asked across time in this study is, do you think sort of public understanding and the profile of philanthropy has increased? And it's slowly there. And people say, yeah, you know, certainly people talk about it and know about it. And they attribute it to things like more philanthropists being willing to tell their stories. And it's so simple. But

if nobody would ever share, you know, I gave a million pounds and this is why I did it. And this is what went well. And this is why I'm glad I did it. If no one ever told those stories, then you never get to establish norms. It seems very unusual then to do it. But if you've got lots of regular stories of people talking about their giving, then when somebody has got some money to spare, they've got lots of points of reference to refer to. And they might have even heard of some of those people. They might be in their social circle. So that's what people like us to do when we've made some money. So much as people tend to validate the anonymous

donor and say it's much better to give anonymously. And that's people's choice. In some religions, for example, that's the right way to give. But we do need a few donors to talk about it and to go public. And so it's quite reassuring to see that that was definitely having the positive effect that we hoped for. No, I agree. I think if every organisation who's actively fundraising took 10 stories a year and just pumped them out through social media and donors were happy to, you know... I suppose there's something here about leadership for leaders who are philanthropic

minded. So we want to see more of that. We need to see more of it. Switch the lights on on it. Is there something here about public trust as well? So, you know, we're in that world where there's a lot of chatter. There's a lot of negativity out there on social media, a lot of division. How do we build philanthropy into that space around public? Yeah, I think, I mean, this is something I think about and worry about quite a lot because I think a lot of the criticisms of philanthropy are not really about the giving

rich. They're about just the possession of wealth. You know, people worry understandably about the grown division between rich and poor, the extreme accumulation of wealth, especially in the US, but in other countries too. And so all of their concerns and worries about that get... targeted on philanthropy because they're the only rich they've ever heard of and so one of the things i've done when i've given talks is shown a picture of you know a bunch of billionaires who've all got whose surname begins with you know b and said which of them do you know and the only one they know is richard branson they don't know the other bees who are living quietly at home

with their fleet of vintage cars and their private jet and their you know 10 mansions so it's actually strategically not a great idea to be philanthropic if you care about your public reputation because you are setting yourself up for criticism and ridicule so And I think we, as a society, we need to ask ourselves, is that a sensible strategy to critique people who give, even if those critiques have got some... kernel of justification in them, because what's the end result? If you're a bit worried, well, they get to choose this cause and not that cause, well, that's fair enough.

But if you end up encouraging people to think, I'll just keep my head down, I'll just keep the money in the bank, I'll pass it on to my kids, because whatever I give to somebody is going to have an opinion that I shouldn't have given to that cause, I shouldn't have given that much or what have you. So I would much rather we lived in a society that best celebrated philanthropy, but at the very least didn't criticise it and realise that you don't encourage people to do things if you pick. pick away at it I think that's not helpful and you know I don't think those who already give are that affected by it I think that they understand they enjoy their philanthropy

they get to meet interesting people they feel their their life is being well lived so if you're already a philanthropist I think it's it's probably a bit annoying one of them said to me you know whatever you do they'll they'll criticize it's only when you're dead you get an obituary that says you know points out your philanthropy so which I thought was quite a quite a sad thing to say but you know nonetheless they sort of said it with a twinkle in their eye My worry is the people who haven't started giving yet, who haven't made a fortune in business, who haven't inherited, you know, who is just not on the radar. at the point at which they have that wealth in their possession, would they think, oh, I know,

I'll be a philanthropist because that goes down well, you know, because then people will think well of me. And it's not really a joke because there are people saying, I just, I don't want to risk my kids getting grief. I don't want people thinking I'm a tax dodger. I don't want people thinking I'm hugely egotistical. I just want to do good. But if I'm a philanthropist, I know I'm going to attract these comments. So that's why I talk a lot about us being, you know, encouraging and celebrating. all kinds of giving and maybe holding back on some of the criticisms that we think we want to make can you be a philanthropist

but not be wealthy of course oh my goodness i'm so glad you asked that because you know the trouble is i've studied major donor philanthropy and the new book is about rich donors so my kind of inclination is to talk about the richer donors but no absolutely the word philanthropist just means love of humankind so philo love of anthropos humankind you can love other people in so many ways with a smile by opening a door by being good company and by volunteering by you know offering expert help and by being giving moral

support there are so so many ways you can help other than giving money Interestingly, these things tend to go together. People who volunteer tend to also donate. People who give blood tend to also be sort of helpful financially. So these things do tend to go. Once you realize there's a world beyond your door and you've got agency to help, people tend to help in multiple ways. But no, I don't like the claiming of the word philanthropy just for elites. I would like to reclaim it for all of us. Yeah, no, I agree. And so the takeaways from the book for me are that donor profile is changing the demographics

are changing that's kind of interesting do you think about what future philanthropists might look like and the sorts of things there are the positives there in in the work and the research that you've done yeah sure so there's definitely the feminization of wealth which has been happening for you know a while and is now is affecting philanthropy so the first A set of interviewees in the early 2000s were predominantly male and were getting much closer now to 50 -50. I think that's partly women being more willing to stake

a claim and say, no, actually, this is our money, not just his money. So it's not necessarily that money is in different places. It's just being claimed more. But there's definitely more female entrepreneurs. So they're making more money through business. There's definitely changes in inheritance patterns where daughters are getting similar amounts to sons. So that changes some of these things. And then there's divorce settlements that are taking into account the role of the partner who maybe wasn't in the business, but certainly played a role in that wealth being created with Mackenzie Scott and Jeff Bezos being the most obvious example of that. And then Mackenzie

Scott has gone on to become quite a role model for giving in a different way, you know, getting the money out fast, giving it without strings attached, giving it unrestricted. So it's quite interesting to see not just the profiles of the donors changing, but how they give. There's a lot of talk about trust -based philanthropy, about participatory grant making. speaking so I think there's a real push towards doing it better and I'm definitely delighted to see that it's not just about larger and larger sums people can get very hung up on well how much was given and of course that matters you can do more with more money but it also matters how how it's given

and if it's given more strategically and also if it's given more thoughtfully you know with empathy what what what does this charity actually need how can I be a good funder how can I not cause them more stress and then that's a good thing as well and one of the reasons I think that's happened is the role of advisors and other kinds of intermediaries. So when we began the study, very, very few of our interviewees had had any sort of formal philanthropic advice or support. It just didn't really exist in the 2000s. By the 2010s, people were getting advice from

their banks. So Coots Bank were the first to offer philanthropy advice, and then all the other banks followed quite soon after. But in this latest iteration, 53 % had either taken philanthropy advice or were about to do so. That's about 10 % were about to. do so so it's now normal it's now normal to get advice whether that's from a non -profit provider like a community foundation or the Charities Aid Foundation or paying for it from an independent philanthropy advisor and of course if you pay for something you value it more so we found that of those who did take advice two -thirds said it had affected their giving and the way it affected it was either

more strategic or more sort of thoughtful and empathic so these are all real positives that happen in the world of philanthropy so I think we can hopefully all feel good about those. No, absolutely. And I think it's really great to be able to get into the detail of that and into the kind of weeds, if you must use that term, around the motivations. Because often we don't, as you say, we don't talk about it enough. And it's always a very personal thing. We need to be able to share and talk about why giving is such an important part of our lives. whoever

we are, whatever our background? Well, I hope that the study continues. I may or may not be involved in 10 years time. So, but I hope that somebody goes back and continues the study. I'd say the book ends with two chapters that are the kind of the so what chapters. So we've got, it begins with a very nice chapter written largely by Rodri about developments in the world of philanthropy in the broader context. That's really nice scene setting for all of us to bear in mind. I mean, a lot happened in the last 10 years, whether it was COVID lockdowns or political change or you know a lot's happened and philanthropy is

always a product of its time so that's a really useful kind of recap then there's all the data presentation you know how why do people give how do they give whose thoughts they're giving but I think I'd probably end by drawing attention to the last two chapters and the first of those was written mostly by Teresa Lloyd and that's the takeaways for fundraisers and charities you know what does all this mean how can you apply it in your in your efforts to you know recruit and retain donors and that's chapter nine and then chapter 10 is actually not written by any of us you may be surprised to hear it's written by a coalition of people who've drafted the national

draft national strategy on policy on philanthropy and really what we tried to what they've tried to do is pull together all the ideas all the different bodies have got about how you could strengthen philanthropy in the UK and instead of everybody having their own list that they're lobbying government for or that they're trying to persuade the public to do or that they're trying to get journalists to care about if you have 10 different voices you're always weaker so what's been wonderful the Charities Aid Foundation and Beacon Collaborative and a couple of others have said, let's just pull it together and have one set of recommendations, one plan for philanthropy.

And so we gave chapter 10 over to that document and said, here's what that collective group says. And one of the recommendations in that is to have a champion in government. So it looks like that strategy is working, having a shared approach to asking for a better, a more conducive environment for philanthropy. So I think the book contains an awful lot. within its two covers and I hope people find it useful and interesting. Thank you very much, Beth. It's wonderful to see you again. Congratulations on the new role. The book

is available through the Directory for Social Change, I think. Correct. That's right. Great publisher, DSC. They publish all kinds of other books as well. And they're a non -profit publisher. That was very important to us to publish with them. So do take a look at their website. Thank you. That's a call out for the readers and the listeners. Thank you very much, Beth. We'll catch up soon. Lovely. Good luck to everybody. Bye -bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. David Skaith: Building Healthier, Fairer Communities in York and North Yorkshire

    Oct 13, 202639 minAudio

    What does meaningful social impact look like when you're responsible for an entire region? How can local investment tackle poverty, improve men's mental health and create better opportunities for young people? David...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. "Find Out Who You Are and Do It on Purpose": Celebrating Give Like Dolly Day

    Sep 25, 202636 minAudio

    Most people know Dolly Parton for iconic hits like 9 to 5 or Islands in the Stream. Fewer realize that her proudest achievement, and the love letter to her father, was founding Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library. In...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What is ESG…. really?

    Sep 1, 202651 minAudio

    ESG (Environmental, Social and Governance) has become one of those business buzzwords that everyone uses, plenty of people argue about, and far too few people can explain without reaching for another acronym. So what...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Purpose behind a Yorkshire Vineyard: Sustainability, Family and the Future of English Wine

    Jul 28, 202656 minAudio

    England's wine industry is booming, and Yorkshire is proving it has a place on the map. In this episode of The Purpose Brief, James speaks to two brothers, Jack and Kit Fletcher, who are behind Ryedale Vineyards to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Community-Owned Businesses Keeping Rural Britain Alive

    Jul 6, 202658 minAudio

    What happens when a village refuses to lose its last shop or pub? This episode looks at how communities across the UK are creating and running businesses together for their own benefit, from village shops and pubs to...

    Credit the people on this episode