ESG (Environmental, Social and Governance) has become one of those business buzzwords that everyone uses, plenty of people argue about, and far too few people can explain without reaching for another acronym. So what does it actually mean when it leaves the strategy document and lands in the real world? James is joined by Justine MacArthur, an independent consultant working across people, culture and HR, and Dane Wadsworth from JZ Flowers, to look at what responsible business looks like in practice. There are no neat answers here. Instead, there are real examples: choosing between air and sea freight, measuring social impact, persuading people across an organisation to get on board and tracing the journey of flowers from more than 1,600 growers. The conversation also challenges some familiar assumptions. People don't necessarily dislike change, they deeply resentment change done to them. Sustainability isn't just about spreadsheets, initialisms and reporting. It needs to become part of how a business operates. ESG can feel like a minefield of frameworks, regulations and competing demands. This episode cuts through some of that noise and asks a more useful question: how do you build a business that is resilient, responsible and fit for the future without losing sight of the people who make it work? In this episode Why ESG has become so loaded and why stripping away the jargon matters How purpose, leadership, HR and sustainability connect What JZ Flowers' approach to sourcing, carbon, traceability and operational efficiency looks like in practice How to communicate sustainability without drowning people in jargon The tension between carbon reduction, cost, waste, freight and supply-chain realities Why traceability and fair-trade premiums matter to customers The challenges charities face when funding rules restrict what “social value” can mean Why governance matters, and what happens when sustainability depends on the people at the top LINKS Justine: https://www.linkedin.com/in/justine-macarthur/ Dane: https://www.linkedin.com/in/dane-wadsworth-thurnham-mchem-hons-276b01103/ About us: https://www.thepurposebrief.org.uk/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello and welcome to The Purpose Brief. I'm James Johnston and today we're asking a deceptively simple question. What on earth is ESG? Environmental, social and governance has become part of the language of business and investment and public policy, but it is also surrounded by jargon, misinformation and political pushback. People don't like change is something that I hear quite a lot and I think it's codswallop. Because change is happening all around us. What people don't like change being done to them. People feel like
they haven't got a say in something or it's just been thrust upon them and they don't agree with the outcome. It is about giving people the bigger picture, not patronising folk. Essentially, you're constantly trying to sell an idea. And that idea needs to be flushed out. You need to be passionate about it because I think passion creates passion. If I'm going to be talking to you about something and I'm like, OK, yeah, green agenda is great. Like, you're not going to be bought in. I swing from one side to another between being really hopeful that things are going well and that we
have enough passionate, knowledgeable people to be able to make a change. And then... It's usually after I've watched the news. Slight sense of despair. I'm hearing a lot around hope at the moment. And I'm hearing it all over the place. And I don't know whether that's my reticular activated system. Like, I've heard hope. And now it's like, I'm always hearing hope. Yeah, but I love it. I love it. And I think we should embrace it. If you don't have hope, how can you do anything? It's not just wishful thinking. It's taking that into action. There have been
decades of debate. and endless flip -flopping around the impacts that humans are having on our environment. But the climate crisis is here right now in front of us. We live in a country which has been built for a climate that no longer exists. That is the stark conclusion of a recent climate change committee which says we must prepare for the extreme weather associated with at least two degrees of global warming by 2050. We have broached the planetary boundaries. We're already
seeing what that could mean, more intense heat, drought, flooding, wildfires and growing pressure on our water, food, infrastructure and public services. And everybody is starting to notice it. This isn't simply an environmental issue. It's about people, places, leadership and whether organisations are prepared for the risks ahead. So is ESG still useful? And what does responsible business actually look like in practice? To help make sense of this, I'm joined by Justine MacArthur,
an independent consultant who helps SMEs and not -for -profit organisations develop their people, culture and HR, and Dane Wadsworth from Jay -Z Flowers. The three of us met... earlier this year as part of a brilliant group of humans brought together through a programme at Hull University Business School. So together we explored how responsible businesses of all different sorts can improve productivity, resilience and sustainability. At its heart is a simple idea, doing good shouldn't
be an optional extra or a charitable add -on, it should be part of the business model. And today we'll strip away the jargon, share some lived examples and explore how ESG can help organisations understand their impact, earn the trust of their consumers, their customers and contribute to prosperous places and thriving communities. Justine and Dane. Welcome. Thank you. Hello there. Tell me about your areas of work. What does ESG mean to you? So I'm going to start with purpose. When
I decided to work for myself, I was quite clear in my mission, which it doesn't translate very easily, outwardly, I'll be honest, but is I want to help people to help people to help improve the world. So if I can help managers. be better managers, be better leaders, them as individuals and their teams can then go out and do great things that I can't do. I don't have the skills and capacity to do, but I can help enable them to be able to improve the world. So if it's environmental,
you know, if they're conservation or they're working in sustainability, or if it's social, so, you know, like you're looking after, say, people who are marginalised, international social issues, social justice issues, and then governance, you know, it's not the sexy part of it, but it is the important part of it. that is what makes the business tick tell us about jc flowers your work there yeah so i've been at jc flowers for coming up to a year now and them as an organization
jc flowers are they wanted to become front runners in sustainability they've been around since i believe sort of early 90s they're now part of the dutch flower group that has i think 25 percent global market share on flowers So only a small operation. But yeah, Jay -Z Flowers themselves tend to show a lot of stewardship within the DFG itself, not just from a human rights perspective, but also from a sustainability perspective for
carbon, so the environmental side. And it's all about what we're trying to do at Jay -Z Flowers is... almost standardise the approach to make sure that we can compare apples to apples when it comes to other big players, sort of, you know, your apples, your Microsofts, etc. And linking back to purpose, I suppose, when I applied for university, I naively put whatever I want to do, I want to have an impact in terms of the world. And this is long before I had any visibility
of sustainability, climate change, etc. And through a series of sales roles and then falling into sustainability i can now see that coming to fruition in terms of you know reducing carbon improving efficiencies and sort of trying to ensure that when we're communicating about sustainability it's not always a cost it can be an efficiency improvement and actually generate revenue so for me the purpose is saving the planet but pragmatically
one step at a time as well as not having it cost the earth as well. We went on a bit of a journey with the course at Hull, a positive one, because we were immersed in sort of the theory and the science and the challenges, but then the practical applications. What are your takeaways from... From the course and what were your learnings? The course itself. I loved that the people who were running the course, the tutors that we had, we had a mixture of tutors for a start and that
they all had, you know, relatable experience, either directly in industry or supporting industry. And that made it really relatable. The organisations that I'm supporting at the moment are in the smaller end of the spectrum. still again trying to make that relatable for them is a challenge just because of people can see from from health and safety like that social aspect of like looking after your people health and safety like we've got that in this country we we know that we people
don't question health and safety so much and we're moving like HR and the way that we treat people with the benefits employment laws that's pretty ingrained as well. And I think it's just, it's like that we're on a tipping point. And I really felt that. And I think through things like the Carbon Literacy Project, so we're all carbon literate after that course, that is how we're going to sort of start moving that needle, I think, for the environmental side of things. And it was a real eye -opener, that and the planetary boundaries. For me, definitely opened my eyes
up to more than just the environmental side. So my specialism was... more looking at carbon and for me I went in thinking okay I just want to get a qualification to prove my experience whereas the course opened my eyes up to more of the social and governance aspects and made me really appreciate the nuances within the governance of how an organisation can be structured and how that impacts senior management. middle management
and then your you know sort of your operatives and that sort of thing so and also the communication side of how top to bottom and bottom to top communicate to each other and then communicate outwardly to the general public so that when it comes to things like recruitment etc why aren't you talking about your social social benefits because this is how great you're doing it's almost like we're scared to to say anything because We don't know whether it's going to make our competition think,
oh, we'll do that as well. And then you're kind of blinkering yourself to not be able to recruit the talent that you want based on the inputs that you've had, the investments you've made with the social aspects that you've implemented. There's a really interesting thread that runs through a lot of that, the work and experience of those people that we talked to and worked with around leadership and how. A lot of this gets handed to doers who are really operationally delivering and then the lessons of leaders in
that space because they need the doers to understand operationally. I suppose my view has always been that leaders have a lot on their plate in businesses and can probably do more in this space. Is there any kind of reflections more broadly from you about different organizations you've worked with and why this is? is landing now. So taking the first aspect of that about leadership and to make the change, I think, you know, it's kind of common knowledge that you have to have a tipping
point of what percentage of people in any sort of situation can make it something normal. And I think that's what we're feeling the uptick at the moment of ESG becoming more normalised. It's coming into conversation and the aspects of ESG. So people might not be saying ESG, but they might be talking about the different areas of it. We're coming up to that and we haven't reached that tipping point yet. You know, I'm a firm believer in hope and we're all doing things
to make this happen. Like there are individuals like us doing things to make that happen and things like having a podcast on this to demystify and is only ever going to help that. And the leadership within an organisation, the leaders, as in the people at the top in the hierarchical sense, if they're passionate about making that change, then they can use their influence throughout. But let's not forget, like people at any part in an organisation can make change in an organisation, you know, through their passion, through being
able to educate people and removing barriers, removing these things that people think, oh, well, we can't do that because it's a huge challenge for people. But it is possible and I'm really hopeful. and you can give your honest view of this from an HR perspective, but people don't like change. I think that's a bit frail. One of the challenges really is how do you, and you might want to say something like Jay -Z and the work there, but how do you take people on a journey either up the kind of management scale or people
who are operationally delivering on the ground? So it's interesting because people don't like change is something that I hear quite a lot. And I think it's codswallop, to be honest, because it's happening all the time. We're always changing. It's a good Yorkshire phrase. Good Yorkshire phrase. I was thinking, how am I going to say that? Yeah, codswallop. Because change is happening all around us. People don't like change being done to them. It's an agency, isn't it? Nuanced, isn't it? It's not change in general. I think it is when people feel like they haven't got a say in something or it's just been thrust upon
them and they don't agree with the outcome. If they like the outcome, if it's like, oh, what we're going to do is we're now going to have a swimming pool in the office and you get an hour a day to go swimming, we'll pay you, then they will love that change. But yes, I think people... It is about communication, and Dane mentioned that, and you've touched upon it. It is about giving people the bigger picture, not patronising folk like people want to know. In terms of from a business perspective, when you're arguing the figures of savings, presumably that's
half the battle. I sort of managed the way I approach the whole communication piece. So I think this is where my sales background helps me a little bit because. essentially you're constantly trying to sell an idea and that idea needs to be flushed out. You need to be passionate about it because I think passion creates passion. If I'm going to be talking to you about something and I'm like, okay, yeah, green agenda is great. Like you're not going to be bought in, but if
you can bring some enthusiasm about it and have it be relatable and talk the person's language, not your own jargon, the whole point in this podcast. helps people get on that journey. And I tend to find that management like to talk numbers and savings. And luckily, in the carbon space, a lot of efficiencies are synergistic with carbon
reduction. On the flip side, things like due diligence, human rights, remuneration, that sort of thing, tends to add additional costs. So it's trying to You have to pick your battles and then you have to give the overall long -term picture. Obviously, a lot of this is you invest now and you'll get the return investment in X amount of years. But yeah, in terms of the leadership and communication piece, it's very much you've got to tailor it and you've got to make sure that you use simple things like we were delivering
some workshops or I've been delivering some workshops within the Newport site that we have. Straight away, I wasn't presenting to them. I was making it interactive. I was asking them questions. And if they participated, you get a chocolate thrown at you. But that's the thing, isn't it? It's sometimes you have to take it really simple, not just the content, but how you approach it as well. Is it easier when people see that the prime minister bans barbecues to stop wildfires when people can't get? And there's summer holiday because of wildfires in Europe. Do you think
that helps in a way? Does it tip the balance? It depends on the individuals, really, because a lot of the political side is, it depends who you speak to in the office. Some people are really tuned into politics. Others are just like, I just like my family, my work. That's my bubble. When there's big legislative changes that impact. a person's work that's when they start to dive into a bit more of a political sphere i .e okay why is this happening what's the the reasoning
behind it but i think things like that little steps to show that oh we can get quick wins and then you can use that yourself as an analogy for your own quick wins it's interesting i think with any topic People like to be right and they look for things that reinforce that they're right. So the company in this room, we believe that climate change is man -made. We believe that this summer that we're having, oh, it started in spring, didn't it? So I thought to some people, oh, it's an El Nino, isn't it? Yeah. Oh, well,
it's nothing to do with climate change. Or yes, the earth's getting hotter, but it's natural. It's a natural occurrence. It's nothing to do with us. And sometimes you can forget that. there are because we surround ourselves with people who think like us and that's that's human nature so we are not in an echo chamber justine do not say that no i think there's something about different kind of siloed thinking that you've got to everybody's at different stages around this we can't you can't deny the facts and i think that in the
work that we do with different organizations i can see that sort of division across you know working with trustees in a charity or an operational team versus you know a leadership team you see there are different points and that's uh yeah that misinformation part around it can create kind of extremes around the views it certainly can yeah and that's that's that's where a lot of tension comes from in in organizations and particularly around this which i suppose if you think about what's happening in the states where there's a rollback on asg We're in a space at
the moment in the UK where we're sort of pushing forward. But there's a lot that depends on the decisions that get made at the top. Shall we look at the E, S and G separately? I'm not sure, but we'll meander around on this sort of topic. Tell me about, you know, we've got... Orcas coming to Scarborough, climate change. We've got vineyards in Yorkshire. So climate change has some benefits. But that aside, what are your thoughts about
how you're working on this? And I'm particularly looking at you, Dane, you're really in the thick of it in the work that you do because you are importing things that grow. You're importing plants. You are distributing them. Tell me about that because it's quite a phenomenal story about that company. Yeah, so for us, the carbon question or the E, should I say the environmental question, is really hot topic for our MD because she wants to be able to make sourcing decisions based on
not just cost, not just availability, but also environmental. environmental impact as well so one of the quantifiers is the carbon number so what we've done is we've included within our scope of our assessment transport and distribution as well as purchase goods and services now the transport and distribution side basically looks at each product we have by country of origin and how we source it do we source it by air freight or is it by sea freight and so we use defra or
desnes i think is now emission factors and the air emissions or air freight emissions are significantly higher than sea emissions so you'd think i'm going to opt for c but there's a little bit more nuance because i found out through you know just asking people on the shop floor the technical and quality team the um the production team could we just transition straight blankets to sea freight and they're like well we have to purchase more volume because there's a higher percentage of waste so it's like okay so i now have to balance
an increase in cost and output for extra volume but we're saving a bit on the sea freight but obviously as well you've got straits being closed here there and everywhere so routes aren't as direct as they once were so there's a geopolitics side there's a an actual product element as well. So I think that the whole point for me for the environmental side, particularly carbon, is asking questions and understanding how everything knits
together and trying to find a pragmatic approach and to be able to have plan B's and C's as well as your option A for each decision that you make. Obviously, you don't want to bombard people with options or else it's just like, I don't know what to choose. But I think that... approach that jz flowers has taken is i think it's it's at least sector leading because it's giving individuals the buying team the the know -how to be able to leverage certain growers and certain producers
where we source from how much it costs and how it's getting to us so that for us is is a key metric and your business is is often around fair trade agreements as well. Yes, absolutely. And that's another thing, traceability. We have to basically do both internal audits and have external audits on the fair trade remuneration. So where does that money actually go? Because our customers are very... They pay a premium, essentially,
as does the end consumer. So they want to see that that money is going towards something that has... real value. And it's not just going into, say, shareholders' pockets, etc. There's a real push for traceability of virtually every single stem from every single country. And we source from the likes of India, Ethiopia, right the way to Portugal. And it must be 1 ,600 plus different growers, over a billion stems a year. From 1
,600 growers, that traceability is going to be really difficult. But somehow, some way, we find that ability, which is, I think, when it came into the organisation, I was like, this is a well -knit together thing. This gives me that context and springboard to be able to map all the things on top of it. Do you see that there's going to be a change in the kind of flowers available because of the changing climate across the globe and just that? Growing certain breeds are going
to be really hard to do and impossible from a carbon footprint. Absolutely. So not just from a carbon perspective. So we've found that, you know, the, I think we call it the greenery. So you know how you have like bunches of flowers and there's like, I think we call it pistache. It's sourced from Spain and it's basically how it's sourced is people that live in a local area just go wild harvesting. and then sell that to a local distributor and they give them money. Recently, there's been legislation change where
all of those people that are cutting back the wild harvest, they have to have a license. And these people that are doing the harvesting are living from day to day. So there's been massive pushback and then an increase in cost of sourcing. wild harvest passage which is like say that green that adds to your bunches so that availability suddenly squeezed because everyone was like oh i don't want to have this extra cost and it's
a massive up taking chain making everything more traceable because and as i say and like you mentioned about the availability of flowers We are looking at, or at least some of the growers that we work with, are looking at hybridising certain traits within different flowers so that they can withstand sea freight better. So looking at that wastage figure again, it all sort of loops back into, but yeah. And that's a really good example of
when someone's rushing to the shop, to Sainsbury's or wherever, to get grandma's carnations. for Mother's Day, that there's a whole supply chain of things. There's a journey that it's taken. Yeah, there's a journey, yeah. And it's been aware, isn't it, as a consumer on that. Yeah, I'm surprised to hear that even in the UK we're getting stems from India. Yep, roses particularly. Yeah, interesting. Yeah, the English rose, not
so English. I mean, volumes are just there, but the thing that... India have and Kenya and Ethiopia, they have so much land that they can have these huge monoculture farms that they are able to grow at such scale. I mean, you say the word monoculture and straight away you're like, oh, well, that's not a good idea, is it? Exactly, exactly. Do you want to unpack that a little
bit? Well, do you know, actually, I was just reading. that globally since the 70s, like biodiversity has gone down approximately 73 % since the 70s. That's a huge amount. You know, there's a lot of people on the planet to feed. There's a lot of people who, you know, buy roses and other products and things that we, especially in the global north, sort of take for granted that we can just get something seasonally. It's not seasonal anymore. Any time of year. and we can just buy
it from a supermarket. That's had a big impact on the rest of the world, you know, our expectations on things. We want it now. I know, I know. And I'm such a tinker for that too. Thank you. It's quite nice to see things like there are some, particularly around these parts in East and North Yorkshire, around kind of flat farmers who are growing wildflowers and selling them and creating a kind of visitor destination. So there's a bit of a shift around. locally sourced I think that's
really interesting I picked up a fact which you might not have agreed with but around the kind of daffodil sort of industry and I think that was my take on the supply chain behind that and how that's grown over you know British sourced daffodils and how do we do that because we want them at a certain point in february march and there's a whole sort of thing there about consumer demand and how that marries with the seasons i mean deaths i've recently been on a call with um a colleague that is she daffodils is like
her thing and we were basically looking at a nice call exactly exactly we were looking at traceability so we were just tinkering with our transport and distribution data looking at the sourcing distances and she said Oh, what year are you looking at? Oh, we're doing reporting year 2025. So she was like, oh, 24, 25 season. We were like, yes. And she was like, oh, yeah, that's when we were good with DAFs. So I'm like, what do you mean? So she was like, next year, as in your next reporting year, DAF deals just
dropped off the planet because we were too wet in winter. And then this summer is just absolutely, they need about three seasons to get a strong culture. and that's just not... So if you want daffodils, get them now because they're not going to be as available next year. Let's not start panic buying. Yeah. Sorry, sorry. Plant your own. Yeah, exactly, exactly. Plant your own. There's only takes on that because this thing about climate resilience, which is a term that's
come in a lot more recently, nature resilience, should I say, but, you know, the role of... biodiversity for a business like you it's it's about the place isn't it and it's the same for things like farmers big processing engineering related businesses there's a knock -on effect on on kind of water catchment all that that kind of thing how do you see that as a way to build that buy -in organization
should be thinking about we do this this is our business and actually that will have a knock -on effect. I often think haulage and logistics are really interesting. I know there's some innovative work in that space with different companies like Clipper. For us, biodiversity hits home and abroad. So when we are at our sites, if we want to expand or build upon the current site that we have, we have to basically ensure that we meet... biodiversity
net gain requirements which is plus 10 each council may add an extra two percent or whatever but essentially for our local operations we have to increase biodiversity through whether it's um how we discharge our our flower food and water or replanting rewilding etc but we're trying to get a grasp of that specifically in 2027 whereby we're doing something called a supply chain biodiversity footprint which is essentially looking at it
uses a very crude metric on spend but it also looks at your country of origin and the impact that has per what product you're sourcing and then we can give metrics on that and add that as another variable when it comes to sourcing decisions and use it as a way to not go, we're not going to buy from you, but we'll buy from you, but to help steer the reds into the ambers or the ambers into the greens. So I think these metrics, we don't want to use them as exclusivity,
but we do want to use them as something that can help guide them into the right direction. Yeah, and it's interesting that influence from a large organisation along your supply chain, because that's similar to like with carbon counting in that it's that influencing through either end of your supply chain, isn't it? That asking that question and keep asking those questions. And again, it's kind of like normalising. You've got to keep track of this. You've got to be able to be prepared if you can't. give a robust answer
that you might lose our business absolutely yeah let's move on to the social perspective of this and there's a big thing about social value at the moment with again announcements from the government building that sort of skills side into contracts public procurement but there's also a big part here about being diverse as a As an organisation, I started off life in a university background, so I always think we were very good in that sector around that. James, obviously
you work in the charity sector and the third sector as well. But yeah, I've been having quite a few conversations recently with founders and CEOs of charities about what social value means to them and what they... When they're talking to funders, what do funders mean? And do those two things align? And sometimes they don't. So, yeah, talking to a CEO of a local charity, CIC, sorry, the funders want to know the direct impact
of what that pound per person helped. For them, they want to be able to do maintenance on their properties and they want to be able to. So they're like, we really want, so unrestricted funding is like a godsend, obviously. And I think that's any organisation, that unrestricted funding. But particularly because there are some things that they know that they could do to their properties that they use that would reduce their impact on the environment. You know, they could get
better insulation. They could swap out something as simple as swapping out light bulbs. But because of the way that the funding is and they have to say exactly what that money went to and how many people they helped, they can't demonstrate that with doing wider environmental -based initiatives. And that got me really thinking because we're thinking, well, I hadn't even considered that. That organisation's already... niche but they're being they can't look a bit further on because
it's not in their charitable aims but yeah there's i mean and and social value is obviously there is a definition but actually when you talk to people and you say social value that's a really subjective area for people because they they they have a an idea of their own in their own mind about what that is um not necessarily like with the procurement side of things um where it's very distinct questions like eight ten questions this kpi this metric is yeah yeah but when you
talk to we've talked to people who aren't in that kind of role and in that industry they're like oh well actually yeah it is we had this amount of headcount at our event and it's more than last year but we didn't spend as much as last year or we spent similar to last year you know so that's that's how People kind of see it in that respect. Reporting can be a big challenge for a small organisation. I totally agree with what you're saying. I'm hearing the same thing,
that funders, particularly big funders, are being really restrictive around the make -up of boards for a governance board. They want to see that kind of impact down the supply chain. But often a lot of this, as you know, comes... back to how do I measure this? This came up a lot in the work that we've done. How do we measure this in the different things, whether I'm running a broadband provider or a manufacturer? How do you measure all this stuff? There's metrics within
metrics, I guess. How my work's assessed is in terms of the reporting. is for instance the workshops that i recently did so i did departmental workshops so for each department i did um basically a knowledge checker quiz at the start and it was right no laptops no phones fill this in i'll give you your score and then after you'll repeat the same thing but all the answers they are within this presentation or this this workshop and i had
an average score of 7 .6 Across the board for the pre -session quiz, the post -session quiz, 12 .7. So I saw that straightaway an uptick in terms of knowledge building. But from more of a CSR and CSRD perspective, the reporting element is really crucial and it can be a little bit gung -ho. So what I did was I used two international standards without getting too technical. greenhouse
gas protocol and an iso 14064 standard merge those two together so that the people that understand a little bit of sustainability so the greenhouse gases scope one two three they could also have that mapped onto a standard that is within quality security and technical so that they can see that it has a set out structure, set out methodology, and it's clear, complete and transparent. My
biggest bugbear for reporting is, look how great we are. And there's no bad bits. Whereas with the report that I've put together is it's transparent. It is. We know that this isn't the best data set in the world. And this is how we're going to improve moving forward. So it's warts and all. In terms of a reportability perspective, I think if you can standardise the approach and also justify it with complete and accurate data, that's how you can quantify. And presumably you
will need to have those allies across the organisation that are going to give you the data because the data will be all over the shop or not even there. And one of the things that I really wanted to pick up on in this podcast was there are so many advertisements out there. Because I'm in sustainability, my LinkedIn is, it's just got sustainability plastered all over it. I'm connected to every single sustainability person ever. You were a hub. Constantly marketed to, don't ever have to ask about sustainability data again. Have AI do it. I think we're missing a trick with
that is. Asking the question makes you understand a person, understand what their drivers are, but also helps you interrogate the answers that they give and can give you insight into what can be practical steps for reduction as well as how can I help this person sell their idea to management. So if you get AI to do it, it's sort of faceless, nameless, and it's just numbers at the end of the day. Humans are good, then.
Yeah. That's good to hear, reassuring. But I think a lot of it's about relationships, isn't it? And that kind of goes back into the social side of things, about how you embed this in organisations. Yeah. And so, like, if you look at the HR... What is now modern HR and where it used to be as personnel, where it was just literally doing the payroll and a couple of very transactional things, you know, back in the 50s and 60s and its transition over the years to become businesses,
all businesses have, large organisations have a HR officer or an equivalent of that. And the, you know, the responsibilities are now... with managers to do some of the things that maybe 30 years ago was you'd send somebody off to HR because they were poorly or they had a performance issue well we're realizing those relationships should be with the people who are closest to them so the manager should be having that chat and say oh you've been poorly are you okay and then that it hits a compliance tick because you
may be getting a return to work conversation you may be getting a self -certification form out of somebody so that's the compliance side of things but it's also that actually are you okay should you be back at work it's a what what happened like is there anything i can do to help and they don't have to be separate things and and i think that's that's what dane's saying as well about that communication yes you might be in your in your world you might be looking for data and figures and But in other worlds, you know, those relationships are there and I
see that's what sustainability is doing as an industry, is it's moved from just a compliance, I'm going to build a spreadsheet and I'm going to give you some facts and figures into this integrated part of a business. But if you're looking at like a company, I think it's 99 % of organisations in the UK are SMEs and then you've got... Out of those 99%, 80 % of those have got less than 50 employees. So to me, my passion is with these folks, these smaller organisations and how they get the data because they don't
have to do relations across functional stuff because there is... It's a small organisation. It's in some ways easier to make a difference. Yeah, it can be. Just a resource and maybe knowledge issue, isn't it? Yeah, but again, they've got so many different demands on them as well as the carbon counting. So, you know, obviously employment law is constantly changing and rightly so want to be. creating more diversity, that EDI aspect within organisations. But it's upskilling
the people to know that and to know where they stand with the law as well. So, like, sexual harassment has just... The laws in there are becoming so much more stricter about, you know, taking reasonable actions to prevent sexual harassment. And these are all things that managing directors and owners, founders of small businesses, just like, well, what does that mean? So... In each area of ESG, we could do a separate podcast on it. Yeah, no, that dawned on me actually when
I was having this conversation. It tips into governance. This is the thing. Before we go into that quickly, I just wanted to go back to that industry standards piece. There's lots of frameworks that have been brought in over the past 40, 50 years to help. There's lots of different things. I'm kind of amazed at the depth that some teams are going into to sort of deliver that, and it's across all different areas of a business, operating business. Do you want to say a little bit about
what they mean? Because some organisations, particularly SMEs, might not have kind of considered that. Yeah, I mean, a lot of the standards or the frameworks or the reporting bodies that organisations have to report to, There are usually criteria that is the same across most of them. So it's usually based on balance sheets, assets, as well as number
of full -time employed staff. So the usual is, you know, if you're looking at 249 plus employees, then there's mandated. environmental reporting that you have to do so particularly CSRD there is the SECR so that's a streamlined energy carbon reporting that's majority of the UK and also it depends on what products you import export so there's recently the carbon border adjustment mechanism that's there's an EU version a UK version
and then there's going to be a US version so and that's to do with specific whether it's for fertiliser, cement, aluminium, et cetera, that you import, export, and there's a carbon tax on that. To be able to have that carbon tax, you need to know what the carbon impact is of your product that you're sourcing. So it can be quite... It's really dependent on your size of your organisation and where you start to meet those criteria, keeping a handle on that, so
with HR records as well as your finance records. but also just keeping your finger on the pulse. But it's so difficult to, I'm all good with health and safety. Okay, now employment law, oh, that's changing again. Oh, sustainability has changed again. It is a bit of a minefield. So I think that's where consultancy is a real help because you can onboard a specialist that can say. This is my particular niche. I know that I've got
the finger on the pulse with this. I've looked at what your business is doing. You ought to be doing X, Y, Z. So I think that in terms of standards and frameworks, it is ever -changing, but I can see a slight shift in terms of they are all starting to coalesce. And I was going to ask you about that because in SRS regulations coming in January for the PLCs and then obviously the year after that, starting on the reporting
for the, again, plus 250 or 249 employers. Do you think that it's going to simplify things? Because I think it's going to really have a knock -on effect. This is where we're going to see that trickle -down effect to the wider, smaller companies. reporting and having to get things out. So the simpler it is for them, the better. So do you think that's going to happen? I think it really depends on who's at the top of the organisation. It's their driver. Are they in
it just for legacy and ego or are they wanting to actually make a difference? are keeping abreast of what is happening in terms of changes in standards and legislation and frameworks. So I think it will in the organisations that want it, but I think those organisations that are just existing just to make the money, which obviously is usually a main driver. It's usually the only reason an organisation exists. But I think it will make it simpler, long story short. so governance as
a foundation for long -term success particularly important for big companies is why we see these shifts in the investment that they're putting into place and sustainability equality diversity inclusion programs but for smaller businesses that's that's still a big challenge and i think a lot of them will be holding their hand up and saying or actually i'm not sure whether this is right for us some organizations if you've got 40 staff and you've got 40 plumbers and they're going to look sort of a feel a sort of homogenized
group of people how do you argue the case for them or is it about adapting to make it a better experience to work there and a business that's responding to these bigger pressures. When you say EDI, there tends to be a specific... Another acronym. It's another acronym. I apologise. Yeah, yeah. It's Equality, Diversity and Inclusion. Of course, this is layered. So I use Babushka Doll as an example. So, like, you've got the outer layer. So you have the EDI stuff that people...
out of the nine protected characteristics in the UK, there are some of them you can probably go, oh, well, for me, as an example, white female, 40. So I'm like, I aren't quite in an age discrimination bracket quite yet. I mean, you know, depending, I suppose, on who you're asking. And that's like, whites, that's, you know, your most privileged. Female. Second most privileged. But then there's
all the other layers underneath it. You don't know from somebody from just a glance. And so your plumbers, your 49 plumbers and a managing director, you might think that they're a homogenised group. But when you apply the layers, that managing director might be making reasonable adjustments for some of his team that he doesn't even call it reasonable adjustments. It's just a bit like that. So we do it this way for them. And I think sometimes all the acronyms and all the laws around things can make it feel harder work than it is.
And they are all there trying to make money. We all go to work to make money. We all have to feed and house ourselves and feed and house other people. It's about leadership culture. How are you? behave ethically as a business how you train your staff them being aware and and also i think with anybody in in life it's about how you check your own privilege on on things and understand that nobody's really like you everybody's coming at life from different angles
and you've got to be kind of curious about that rather than pigeonhole people which is a big part of the checking privileges it's a painful thing yeah we're coming to the end but let's just have some sort of reflections and the challenge ahead how are you feeling about it can i say that i swing from one side to another between being really hopeful that things are going well and that we we have enough passionate knowledgeable people to be able to make a change and then It's usually after I've watched the news. Slight sense
of despair. I'm hearing a lot around hope at the moment. There's a lot of, as you two know and the listeners know, I'm a member of the Friends of the Earth and I volunteer for them. They have a hope strategy. I'm reading a book called Hope is a Strategy by a great guy called Ian Pettigrew. And I'm hearing it all over the place. And I don't know whether that's my reticular activated system. Like I've heard hope and then now it's like, I'm always hearing hope. Yeah, but I love it. I love it. And I think we should embrace it because if you don't have hope, how can you
do anything? Like it's not just wishful thinking, it's taking that into action. I resonate with your swinging from one side to the other because... Although I'm really passionate about what we do, the effects are very clear from just our doorstep. And you sometimes get the sense of, OK, we're past the point of no return. But are we? Is there a technology that's currently being developed? But for me, it's about mitigation,
adaptation, as well as doing what we can to protect what little we have left. So for me, my reflection is I'm hopeful, hope again, but I'm also finding that with each individual conversation I'm having, whether it be out and about or within work, if you can resonate with one person on a particular thing that is sustainable, it could be sustainability adjacent. you've touched someone and you've inspired
someone that then could then inspire and it becomes a domino effect. And I think that's what sustainability is slowly doing. It's going from this corporate thing that then the bubble burst to this more ground up. actual thinkers and doers are driving this and are helping planting these seeds pardon the pun about flowers and plants it's allowed i think that's really nice but that there's a duty and a purpose to the work that people are
doing in this space and like you say if you put humans together around a problem they'll generally work it out i'm kind of radically optimistic about what that means for this space but also we just touched on an introductory chat to it so there's more to come i would say in future episodes justine you wanted to come in as we came in where we're recording this they're going to be doing a showing of the national emergency briefing the people's emergency briefing and we've got two in beverly so this is august september
they're showing and they're popping up all over the place so we're in in this in our region North Lincolnshire, East Yorkshire, Hull, we've been really slow on the uptake for that, but the momentum's getting going and it's really good to see. Every time I look at the map, I'm like, ooh, there's another little pin in there. There's another community place that is going to be showing that. And I think the general public understanding that this isn't just a tree -hugging issue. Actually, this is a national security issue. This is a national health issue. Food availability. Food
availability, yeah. We're only going to see more wars, and we do all have to do something. More angry, it's all interlinked. Yeah, that's really good. And for listeners, we are in Pocklington Arts Centre in the East Riding of Yorkshire, which is a really lovely venue, so do please check that out as well. Thank you both for coming today. We could have many more discussions on this and we will catch up with our pals from Hull University Business School at some stage, I'm sure. But thank you so much for joining us
and we'll put your details to connect in the show notes. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Thank you for joining us today on The Purpose Brief. If you want to connect with us, details in the show notes, follow or subscribe wherever you're listening to this podcast. We'll speak to you next time.
What does meaningful social impact look like when you're responsible for an entire region? How can local investment tackle poverty, improve men's mental health and create better opportunities for young people? David...
Most people know Dolly Parton for iconic hits like 9 to 5 or Islands in the Stream. Fewer realize that her proudest achievement, and the love letter to her father, was founding Dolly Parton’s Imagination Library. In...
England's wine industry is booming, and Yorkshire is proving it has a place on the map. In this episode of The Purpose Brief, James speaks to two brothers, Jack and Kit Fletcher, who are behind Ryedale Vineyards to...
What happens when a village refuses to lose its last shop or pub? This episode looks at how communities across the UK are creating and running businesses together for their own benefit, from village shops and pubs to...
James sits down with Matty Lewis, a social entrepreneur and founder of Menfulness, to explore how mindfulness, community, and purpose-driven leadership can create meaningful impact. Focused on tackling the stark...