Will artificial intelligence transform economic growth - or are expectations running far ahead of reality? And what does the rise of AI mean for graduates, white-collar professionals and the future of work? In Part 2 of his conversation with Dr Alan O’Sullivan, renowned economist and Northwestern University professor Robert J. Gordon challenges predictions of limitless AI-driven growth. He explains why many human-centred and physical jobs remain difficult to automate, while roles involving computer-based tasks could face significant disruption. The discussion also examines the economics behind the AI investment boom: who will ultimately generate the revenue needed to justify enormous spending on data centres, chips and electricity? Professor Gordon considers the implications for productivity, education and independent thinking, drawing on his experience teaching university students. Turning to the longer-term outlook, Gordon identifies population ageing and declining fertility as central challenges to economic growth. He discusses retirement ages, immigration, inequality and why the labour market may increasingly favour skilled trades over traditional graduate careers. They close with a recommendation of Brad DeLong’s Slouching Towards Utopia and Gordon’s advice to young people planning a career in an AI-driven economy. Topics discussed AI, automation and the future of white-collar employment Productivity, technological progress and the return on AI investment University education, examinations and AI-generated coursework Demographics, fertility, retirement and long-term economic growth Immigration, income inequality and skilled-trades shortages Career advice and book recommendations Further viewing Robert Gordon TED Talk - The death of innovation, the end of growth https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYHd7rpOTe8&pp=0gcJCR0AztywvtLA Subscribe to The MOST Important Thing for conversations on economics, investing, wealth and the forces shaping our future. Disclaimer: This episode is for general information and discussion only and does not constitute financial or investment advice.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The idea that computer-driven artificial intelligence is going to take away all the human jobs and destroy all the jobs and give us somehow infinite output with nobody working is just a total myth. Who's going to pay for all these data centers, all this electricity, all this incredible investment that's going on? Who's actually paying the bill? We have a growing surplus of college graduates looking to be interns, to be middle management, to be tech workers. And we have a growing shortage of plumbers and roofers and construction workers.
SPEAKER_00And I just think we have too many people going to college.
SPEAKER_03So on last week's show, I had the great privilege of speaking with Professor Bob Gordon of Northwestern University. Bob Gordon is one of the foremost living economists in the world. His book, The Rise and Fall of U.S. Growth, is a bestseller. In the same year that his book was published, he was voted by Bloomberg as one of his most influential living economists. Last week's part one, we talked about the four headwinds debt, demographics, inequality, and education.
SPEAKER_03Professor Gordon also spoke about the three industrial revolutions. A lot of us remember just one, but there are in fact three. This part two now we focus in on artificial intelligence. And Bob Gordon has some good news for graduates, professionals, but also some sobering news at the end of this interview. So I hope you enjoy the fantastic Professor Robert Gordon of Northwestern University. When your book came out, um Professor Gordon in 2016, it was deemed to be a bit controversial at the time, you know, uh perhaps arguing against the steamroller that is US the US economy.
SPEAKER_03But this notion of perpetual growth, even that notion that we're always going to continue to grow in the context of 300,000 years where nothing happened until there was the Industrial Revolution, is that deeply flawed, this notion of perpetual growth in and itself?
SPEAKER_00Oh, it goes beyond that. I mean, the the current Economist magazine talks about infinitely exploding growth, growth going up not to from 1 to 2% to 20 and 30% a year. That's a total fantasy. And that brings up uh artificial intelligence, which we might as well talk about now. Uh the idea that computer-driven artificial intelligence is going to take away all the human jobs and mean that human-like uh computers are gonna do everything and destroy all the jobs and give us somehow infinite output with nobody working is just a total myth.
SPEAKER_00Artificial intelligence is nothing unless you're not sitting in front of a computer using it. But only about 30 percent of the employees, and I'll talk again about the United States, are have their jobs involved with staring at a computer. So the other 70% are not affected by artificial intelligence at all. They're engaged either with human-to-human jobs or human-to-material jobs, like construction, like mining, like manufacturing.
SPEAKER_00The the future uh like nurses in a hospital. I've spent some time in hospitals, and I can tell you there's almost nothing that the people in that hospital are doing that can be replaced by a robot except for transporting patients back and forth for tests. I mean, a robot could push me down the hall on a gurney. I I accept that. But almost everything that they do when they come in to your hospital room requires a human person with enough touching and feeling uh to help you with all the different aspects of your uh your personal life.
SPEAKER_00So you take all those different kinds of jobs and evolving person to person or person to materials. Uh and the the future doesn't depend on artificial intelligence at all for those jobs. It depends on the speed with which technology invents robots that are really human-like in their capabilities. And you know that we're way far away from that kind of robot. And just walk through your daily life and look at everybody who has a job and say, how likely is it that in the next 10 or 20 years that job is going to be replaced by a robot?
SPEAKER_00So I think that brings down the temperature on the infinite growth aspect of artificial intelligence. The real issue is what percent of tasks are going to be eliminated by uh replaced by artificial intelligence? How much is that gonna hollow out white-collar work? How much of that's gonna aggravate what I described earlier as the education crisis of college graduates coming out and not being able to uh to find jobs?
SPEAKER_00As the number of people working and being replaced by artificial intelligence uh grows, there will be a boost to productivity growth in that part of the economy that is centered around white-collar middle management uh kind of work. I imagine that to take a recent example, uh artificial intelligence could well take over pricing algorithms for airlines or airline scheduling and eliminate jobs of people who are now involved in doing that.
SPEAKER_00That's an industry I know a lot about. It's not gonna take away two pilots in the cockpit. It's not gonna take away flight attendants going up and down the aisles. Can you imagine a robot going up and down the aisles of an airplane trying to serve you? It just is isn't uh conceivable with today's technology of robots. So uh you asked about whether growth is gonna be continual or fade away. I think it's a contest. I think it's a contest between the obvious now apparent effect of AI on white-collar work, competing against all these headwinds, the growing burden of old people who are not working at all and not really affected by AI, except to the extent that if AI can create um better diagnosis of Alzheimer's or uh invent new drugs for dementia, then that can have a big effect on the elderly population.
SPEAKER_00But basically, we're we're talking about a growing share of elderly people who are not working, not affected by AI. And so that's the headwind aspect of growth, pushing against this growing ability of AI models to take over tasks that have traditionally been done by humans, like computer programming, software coding, uh, graphic design, designing book covers, making movies. I mean, every every night we watch a comedy show uh in the United States that starts out with a 45-second comedy video that's obviously been constructed by AI, with uh people talking in voices of other people and wearing uh clothing and being having bodies that are different from their heads and all sorts of stuff that is clearly being created by AI.
SPEAKER_00So a lot of this is not even uh job displacing. Uh it's uh just adding to the quality of the entertainment that's available.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, no, it's it's it's interesting. And uh from what from what I'm taking from what you're saying is, and it makes sense that you know the manual work, uh farming, mining, you know, uh other other other work like that is pretty safe nursing. But you would be kind of concerned if you if you have a grandson or granddaughter and you were uh they were going into accountancy or law school or looking to become a maybe a wealth manager like myself. Um we hear the line uh AI won't replace humans, but humans with AI will replace humans without.
SPEAKER_03I don't know. Is that like you you obviously have some concerns about white-collar uh jobs, but how quickly is this gonna happen, do you think?
SPEAKER_00I don't think that can be predicted. Ten years ago, we did not predict that the ability of these large language models would explode so quickly as it has in the last two or three years. Uh so um my gut feeling is that we've had this explosion in the last two or three years and it's gonna level off because these large language models have been built on scraping the internet of all this information. We're running out of information to scrape. You know, so we're gonna hit diminishing returns in the ability of these models to incrementally, they're gonna go from massive improvements in the ability to mimic humans.
SPEAKER_00They now can write little essays on any question you ask them. But they can already write a book. Uh so what's the next step of their ability to uh to do this kind of conversion of existing knowledge into answers to questions? It's a great convenience, all of a sudden, to be able to type into Google search some question instead of being sent to three or four different websites which might or might not have the answer, immediately within two seconds you get a paragraph answer through AI.
SPEAKER_00That's a great service, but it brings up the question I have: what's the underlying economics of AI? Who's gonna pay for all these data centers, all this electricity, all this incredible investment that's going on, that's allowing these millions of fancy computer chips to answer all these questions? Who's actually paying the bill? You know, we're getting this stuff for free from Google. Uh, who's gonna create the revenue to repay Microsoft and Meta and all these people for uh investing$500 billion in data centers?
SPEAKER_00Uh the story waits to be told.
SPEAKER_03I was looking at the Northwestern University website and your own. You you you still teach, you still teach uh economics and and and a couple of other modules. And I was looking at some of the notes, and it was interesting to see uh where you you don't allow laptops, computers uh in the um in the tutorial hall in the in the classroom. And I think that's wonderful. And so I I I have the same rule in my in my class because students are distracted, and um, but I mean, from your own perspective of having taught for decades and decades, I mean, how do you assess students in this environment?
SPEAKER_03How do we are we are we eliminating independent thought uh in this new generation? How do we how do we approach that?
SPEAKER_00It depends on the it depends on the class. I taught uh two classes, very different answers to your question. One class is a lecture course in intermediate macroeconomics. Uh that's where we we go beyond just the stories of elementary economics and teach models and graphs and definite specific answers to questions like to take the topic of the day, what's the effect of tariffs on the trade balance?
SPEAKER_00We have a model we show that uh the trade balance depends on the balance of saving and investment in the economy, and that is or is not affected by tariffs. So we have models to do that. Now, in a course like that, which I've taught for many years, um there's no problem about AI, there's no problem about cheating, uh, there's no problem about students learning, because in my class, 84% of the grade is based on closed book tests. They are sitting in a classroom with a paper exam, a combination of multiple choice questions and short-answer questions where they have to come up with uh exact answers for uh numerical questions.
SPEAKER_00And they're sitting there in a room with no notes, no laptops, no phones, no nothing. And they have to know in order to answer the questions. Um the role of AI actually has been present in my class for a while because 10% of the grade depends on doing electronic homework. And for each chapter, they're trained to do multiple choice questions. So they're trained to do what they later do in closed book form. But the tutorial that they go through, if they don't get the right answer, they don't get any points, and they're forced to stick with the same question until they get the right answer.
SPEAKER_00And the software jumps them into the textbook explaining what they just missed, if they missed the question. And they've got to slog through this until they get 100%. So they are actually being tutored in a sort of computer interface, but that's only 10%. And that allows them to do well on the closed book stuff where they have to actually remember it out of their heads. And I must say that the most recent class I taught in the winter of 2025, I've never had higher grades on these closed book uh things.
SPEAKER_00I'd like to think it's because I'm a brilliant lecturer, uh, but uh somehow the whole thing, the whole package uh came together. Now, what what you ask about AI being a threat to traditional education comes up in my other class, which is a freshman seminar called, Did Economics Win the Two World Wars? And it's about the politics and economics, and a little bit about the military aspects of the two world wars, and they write papers. And so the question is, how do I prevent them from just getting AI to write a paper?
SPEAKER_00Now, this has only really become a threat in the last two or three years, as you know, because of the large language models. At least so far I'm okay in that I truly believe that they are writing their own papers. Now, how do I know? It's because there are enough typical freshmen writing mistakes and poor writing style that I know this was not written by AI. I know what AI is like. And by the way, we now have AI detectors where you can put a student's paper into an AI filter and have it figure out if AI wrote it.
SPEAKER_00Uh so uh we're protected. So far in that class, uh, I believe they are actually writing the papers. Uh, and there are various ways I can tell.
SPEAKER_03I'd like to just finish up um on a question and then maybe just a couple of uh personal questions in relation to advice for students, which which is always very beneficial for somebody with your ex experience and expertise. In relation to your original thesis, well, let's say back 2016, uh, and I would strongly encourage anybody listening or viewing to watch uh the TED Talk and the rebuttal to the TED Talk from Professor Gordon, I'll put the link and additional uh information in the notes.
SPEAKER_03But in relation to where we stand today and those four headwinds, if you were to, and this is a difficult question I know, but if you were to pick and focus on one of them that is going to be the most uh crucial to study in terms of uh deflationary forces or our plateauing of growth, which which one would it be?
SPEAKER_00Demographics, the aging population. Um I just saw a graph that showed that um if fertility stays at its same level in the U.S., which is 1.6. Remember the 2.1 is fertility where each woman has two children, therefore the population is replaced. And with the 2.1 fertility, you have a steady population forever. Uh with 1.6, the population is going to peak and then decline forever until the human race is wiped out three or four hundred years from now.
SPEAKER_00Uh so demographics is clearly the big deal. And demographics means ever-rising burden of old people on uh the shrinking share of young people, leaving aside whether the young people are going to have jobs and the ability to uh to earn income. Uh one of the predictions about AI is that more and more money will go to the rich and to the owners of the AI companies, and less and less to the middle class that are being uh pushed out of jobs.
SPEAKER_00Uh so the only real solution to the demographic crisis is to raise retirement ages. And that's sort of easy to say for white-collar work. I mean, look, I'm 85 and I'm just uh retiring now, not at age 65. The French The French are fighting to keep their retirement age at 62, which is ridiculous. People are really healthy in their 60s. People are pretty healthy these days in their 70s.
SPEAKER_00Um and the problem with that is that life expectancy is not uniform across types of people. Uh people in the top 10% of the income distribution live about 10 or 15 years longer than people in the bottom 10%. People with manual jobs, really tough physical jobs. Uh, I think of the guy who takes care of our yard here, he's looks like he's getting on to age 70, and it's getting harder and harder for him to just do the bending and and physical work.
SPEAKER_00So that retirement age issue is really a hot one because you've got a sort of obvious case for forcing people to retire at yet older ages before they get their retirement benefits. But on the other hand, you have about a third of the population maybe that's doing physically taxing jobs that they have to retire to keep their uh physical health. So that's a really tough one. And I don't think any country has wrestled with the possibility of having different retirement ages for different types of people.
SPEAKER_03You've just raised something very, very interesting, and and it has been a common tread throughout all of my discussions, and that is the weak the failure of the political system to really address what's an obvious problem in terms of the entitlements, you might call it in the US, the unsustainable entitlements. Um because as politicians are voted, are their their number one aim is to get re-elected, and the system is not inducive to uh sustainable policies that are good for everyone, let's say.
SPEAKER_00Let's not forget, wait a minute, let's not forget the big policy failure besides the retirement age, and that is immigration. To have enough legal immigration to fulfill the needs of meatpacking plants and agriculture and construction, all these places where the currently illegal immigrants work, if we had just had a much more generous and open immigration policy that had channels not only for high-skilled tech workers, but also for agriculture workers, the things that business firms find very hard to fill the jobs.
SPEAKER_00We could have done that for the last 30 years, and we'd have this immigrant population now that wouldn't be deported because they'd all be legal. Uh now we have, if we have a threat to American economic growth now that the uh trade war seems to be subsiding, it's this merciless deportation of people, uh, stripping whole companies of all their workers. Uh and that's going to start to show up in job growth and economic growth over the next year if it continues, and I expect it will continue because uh Trump has not backed down on it.
SPEAKER_00So just to complete your idea of political failure, political failure to deal with aging and immigration are the twin failures. And I would uh add for the in the U.S. context also failure to offset rising inequality by putting up taxes on rich people. We could have a supertax on people with over$100 billion,$100 million a year. It wouldn't stop innovation, it wouldn't stop economic growth, despite all the uh you know what political group is is uh going to talk about that.
SPEAKER_03Listen, this is this has been absolutely uh wonderful, a real pleasure for me. Can I can I just finish up, please, uh Professor Gordon, by it's a couple of questions we ask every guest, and it's basically to give something. Back, there would be young people, uh, maybe career professionals listening to this. In terms of uh books uh that should influence you starting out even today, uh books that that that you would recommend for for students, for practitioners that uh would give them real insight.
SPEAKER_03Any any tips?
SPEAKER_00Um well my uh my focus is on on the US and and um the one I would point to that I would I I would read next if I was lining up the books that uh that I would want to read would be um Brad DeLong's book called Slouching Toward Utopia. That's also a history of the United States over the last hundred years, but it's a very different emphasis than mine.
SPEAKER_00It's not really about economic growth, it's about you know it's got brilliant chapters on the two world wars, on the depression, on uh just very aerodite but easy to read. And so if I can just suggest one one book, he'd probably be surprised to hear me recommending his book, uh, but that's the one I would say.
SPEAKER_03And and finally, that a little bit of advice for young students, uh, for graduates that are looking to that are living in this AI world now, okay? What kind of advice would you give them in terms of looking at a 30-40 year career? Is it to get in is it to just if you can't beat them, join them, or is it is there something else that you would advise uh young graduates, young students?
SPEAKER_00Uh I think we're we're entering a world in which we have a growing surplus of college graduates looking to be interns, to be middle management, to be tech workers, and we have a growing shortage of plumbers and roofers and construction workers. And I just think we have too many people going to college. That's not very helpful advice for the people who are in college and worried about getting uh jobs out of college.
SPEAKER_00Uh, but I think we have an imbalance in society. It's I think it's inevitable as we go forward with the effects of AI that we're gonna have a a growing share of these person-to-person and person-to-object jobs that are gonna be hard for robots to replace, and we're gonna have a shrinking share of the population doing white-collar work. And that's not what college graduates want to hear. So, my message is really for people coming out of high school: do you really think it's gonna be helpful to go to college, especially if you can't get into one of the top colleges?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's very honest advice and useful. And um listen, I just want to thank you very much, uh Professor Gordon. That was really, really interesting. Um, and I'm sure.
SPEAKER_00Send the questions, you really you really got it going.
SPEAKER_02But that's high praise and I really appreciate it. Well, that was truly fascinating and and fairly profound. Uh so what's the difference between growth and productivity?
SPEAKER_03That was one of the first questions I I asked um Professor Gordon. So growth really is what it says in the tin. You know, we've typically got averaged over in the US has around 2% growth. And that's kind of the natural rate of growth, you might say, because things generally have to grow in order for, you know, uh true innovation and entrepreneurship, that type of thing. Productivity is different. Productivity is the output. So if you've got growth, productivity brings in number of workers, okay? So output per hour. So then we're getting into demographics, Ivan, which he talks about, because you can have all this growth, but if it's concentrated in, say, an aging demographic, you're you've got to look at uh output.
SPEAKER_03What's your output going to look like into the future?
SPEAKER_02So then he talks about peak growth in the context of the United States economy. Because, you know, we've seen in other uh interviews that you've done as part of this series, people saying that maybe there was 80 years where America dominated the world economically and politically, even militarily, and that now we're entering into a phase of Asia leading the world and China. Uh, what does peak growth mean?
SPEAKER_03Peak growth has to be framed from the likes of Professor Gordon in terms of history, right? So it's interesting, he looked, he looked, he is a bit of a financial historian as well. He looked back at hundreds of years. And for millennia, we had no growth at all. Okay? Around the end of the 18th century, beginning of the 19th century, there was a a number of uh really consequential inventions. Okay, we had electricity, uh, we had light, we had uh what did electricity do?
SPEAKER_03It allowed for power tools, okay? So we became much more efficient, similar to AI today, you could argue, right? But what he calls, he talks about three industrial revolutions, not just the one we know about the late 19th century, but there was other industrial revolutions as well. And what his view is that we have peaked in terms of the US has definitely peaked in terms of peak growth for a number for because of those four reasons debt, demographics, uh, inequality, uh, and education.
SPEAKER_02And yet, maybe he's just an oxygenarian who's out of time, because a lot of people talk to me about the industrial revolution 4.0. And it started with the internet and it's developing not only through software, through artificial intelligence and so on, that that is actually a 4.0 industrial revolution. You know what I mean? Maybe because he's coming near the end of his era, he he is not aware of what comes next.
SPEAKER_03I mentioned Professor Gordon's TED Talk, right? But there was a rebuttal to his from a from a techno-optimist, and you can get the say you can get that TED talk as well, right? So they're back and forth. But you know, that's what this is debate. You're looking at different views, okay? So he talks uh your argument about 4.0, that's all fine. But what Gordon says is that you cannot look at just growth in isolation. You have to look at debt. Okay, so we have all okay, so is the AI revolution going to save us when we have when we the debt levels we have are completely different to where the growth period started 50, 60, 70 years ago?
SPEAKER_03You cannot separate the two because debt is going to diminish the level of growth you could have. There's going to be winners and losers with this.
SPEAKER_02We alluded at the outset to demographics and so on. Um, and is this an irreversible trend? Or is there like I remember when China had a one-baby policy, um, is there anything can be done to stimulate a reversal of this trend to encourage people to have more kids? Very, very difficult.
SPEAKER_03I know there's the Chinese, for example, uh it's it's it's particularly acute in Asia, okay? Japan, uh, China, other Asian countries, uh, Europe is is under pressure, Germany, for example, and we saw Merkel's policy with the migrants to should you know a lot of people thought that was very altruistic, but there was there was rationale from a demographics point of view there. You ask the question, what can Pit Buck can do? I mean, the size of China, how much would it cost to incentivize families to have more children? It just doesn't make sense economically.
SPEAKER_03Why are you gonna give$10,000,$20,000? Do the maths on that. So it's very difficult. Unfortunately, you're gonna see regions of the world like India become very attractive. The average age in India is something like 32 or 3. Compare that to late 50s and some in Asian countries. And what is productivity? It's number of workers per hour's worked.
SPEAKER_02Simple maths. Thank you, Alan. Well, that concludes this week's episode of The Most Important Thing with an interview uh with Professor uh Bob Gordon. I hope you enjoyed it. Now, if you'd like to learn more about this whole uh investing, financing, economics, education, uh please do access the Truth Series, which is in conjunction with this particular series, the most important thing. Thank you for joining us until the next time.
SPEAKER_02Looking forward to joining you again from Alan and me.
SPEAKER_01Thank you for listening to the most important thing. This podcast is for general information and educational purposes only. Nothing in this episode is financial, investment, tax, legal, or pension advice, and nothing said should be taken as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any investment, asset, or security. Any assets, stocks, or markets we discuss are for discussion and illustration only. The views expressed by our hosts and guests are their own, and they may hold positions in investments mentioned. Investing involves risk, the value of investments can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you invest.
SPEAKER_01Past performance is not a reliable guide to future performance. Before making any financial decision, please seek independent advice from a regulated financial advisor who understands your personal circumstances. Thanks again for listening, until next time.
Ivan & Alan are back this week. Do central banks really control the economy, or are the Federal Reserve and ECB reacting to forces beyond their control? In this episode of The Most Important Thing, Ivan Yates and Dr....
Are we heading towards a debt crisis, an earnings downturn and a major shift in the stock market? In Part Two of The MOST Important Thing, Dr. Alan O’Sullivan is joined by contrarian investor and former hedge fund...
Is the AI bubble about to burst? Contrarian investor Jesse Felder joins Dr. Alan O’Sullivan on The MOST Important Thing to examine NVIDIA, Big Tech’s AI spending boom, rising US Treasury yields, stubborn inflation, and...
Is the global economy entering a new inflationary era - and could rising government debt make the next downturn even harder to manage? In this conversation with Dr Lacy Hunt, Alan O’Sullivan examines the forces...
WARNING - This episode should be viewed given the educational content and graphs referred to during the episode. Anyone tells you they "know" what the market is going to do is as dangerous as a one-legged man in an...