Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The MOST Important Thing

The MOST Important Thing artwork

Ivan Yates & Alan O Sullivan | Central Banks Inflation & AI Bubble

Nov 20, 202617 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Ivan & Alan are back this week. Do central banks really control the economy, or are the Federal Reserve and ECB reacting to forces beyond their control? In this episode of The Most Important Thing, Ivan Yates and Dr. Alan O’Sullivan examine the real influence of central banks on interest rates, inflation, economic growth and financial markets. They unpack the role of the Federal Reserve (Fed), European Central Bank (ECB) and Bank of England, and ask whether monetary policy works as effectively as investors assume. Why can borrowing rates rise while savings and deposit rates fall? Did quantitative easing (QE) and money printing cause the 2022 inflation surge, or were energy prices, COVID-era supply shocks and government spending more important? And how could financial repression and negative real interest rates help governments manage rising debt? The conversation also turns to market risk: are AI stocks, NVIDIA, Bitcoin and property in a bubble? What happens to consumer spending when stock-market wealth falls? The episode revisits expert perspectives from David Kelly, Russell Napier and Edward Chancellor on central-bank power, financial repression and the unintended consequences of ultra-low interest rates. Subscribe to The Most Important Thing for more expert conversations on macroeconomics, investment markets and the global economy. CHAPTERS • TIMESTAMPS The MOST Important Thing - Central Banks 00:27 - Do Central Banks Really Control the Economy? Why Banks Benefit from Higher Interest Rates Mario Draghi, QE and the Limits of Monetary Policy How Negative Interest Rates Distorted Investment Incentives David Kelly: Are Central Banks Losing Their Influence? The 2022 Inflation Shock: What Really Caused It? Financial Repression: How Governments Reduce Their Debt Burden Lessons from Ireland's Banking and Property Crash Are We Living Through Another Financial Bubble? Nvidia, China and the AI Valuation Debate The Hidden Risk to American Household Wealth #CentralBanks #Inflation #Economy

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Long and Short, part of the most important thing. Join Ivan Yeats and Dr. Alan O'Sullivan as they take on the major issues shaping markets, economics, politics, and geopolitics, from interest rates, investment trends, and government policy to elections, global conflicts, and shifting economic power. They break down what's happening, why it matters, and where they agree or disagree.

SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome to another episode of The Most Important Thing with me, Ivan Yates and Alan O'Sullivan. And what we're going to do in the next few episodes is we're going to reprise the distillation, the crystallization of what we learned from more than 20 interviews with really acknowledged experts and all the different elements of financial, fiscal markets, central banking, and so on, macroeconomics. So today we're going to dig a little deeper into the nuggets that came in relation to the role of central banks in the macroeconomy.

SPEAKER_01And I suppose the frame for today's discussion is and this started the whole podcast series, do central banks actually control the economy? Or are they reacting to forces bigger than themselves? So it's a rhetorical question in one way, Alan, but I think the perceived wisdom is is that take the ECB in the context of Europe, the Fed Reserve, uh the Bank of England, and so on, that they do have a certain economic power.

SPEAKER_01I suppose the first question I'd ask you about this is, are all central banks the same? Would maybe one central bank, uh say the Bank of England, have more role in in the British economy than a huge sort of 37 nations in the EU, uh, some of which are in the euro and some of which aren't. There are some general

unknowncharacteristics

SPEAKER_01in terms of the mandate. Like what's the role of

SPEAKER_02a central bank? So maintain price stability is a common theme. Uh

SPEAKER_01low inflation. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02In English, keep inflation

SPEAKER_01under control,

SPEAKER_02uh, and also promote long-term sustainable employment. And, you know, the the the the logic there is you've got the two most important uh variables, economic growth and inflation. And how they do that traditionally is interest rate policy. Uh, you know, controlling the short-term interest rate, interest rate. And typically, and this is where we probably go with this, uh, typically, if you want to slow down an economy, you increase rates because that makes existing uh borrowing uh more expensive uh for car loans,

SPEAKER_01for house purchases, and it slows demand. And if you want to stimulate demand, you will cut interest rates at a very simple level. Okay. Riddle me this because it's a particular conundrum that I have personal interaction with. So I invested on a deposit account and it was four year, but not west it was, four, four percent a year, right? And uh it was a five-year thing, but they had an option to cancel it after three years if the market had moved against it. And every day I hear how the ECB are going to raise rates and rates are generally going to inch upwards, right?

SPEAKER_01Uh borrowing rates, right? And yet deposit rates have gone down to 2.4%. How can it be that interest rates to borrow are rising and deposit rates are falling? Well, that's the great mystery of the commercial enterprise that is banks. I mean, whereas governments may mandate and central banks may

SPEAKER_02may uh lower and raise interest rates, there's no precise requirement on banks to pass that on, as you know. Um I mean

SPEAKER_01So are they increasing their margins?

SPEAKER_02They're absolutely increasing their margins, and that's why there's a

SPEAKER_01So they're fleecing us. There's

SPEAKER_02a very

SPEAKER_01they've always done that. They've always done that right.

SPEAKER_02There's a variable the net interest margin. So generally, in a rising interest rate environment, banks will do well. Big financials will do well because obviously they're getting returns on their book, their assets, and mortgage repayments as well. So what's on a bank's balance sheet? Assets and liabilities. And people, a lot of people miss this. Like people think uh a bank's assets is is deposits. That's that's liabilities. Banks' assets are loans. So, you know, still people still need to borrow. Bottom line is there's a shortage in Ireland of housing. So people will still need to borrow.

SPEAKER_02So the margins are there, and they're not paying out as much then. So that differential is how they make margin.

SPEAKER_01So the other sort of generally understood thing about um central banks is is they can be counter-cyclical insofar as after the crash, Draghi was in charge of the ECB, and he did round after round of quantitative easing to push out money to try and get uh restoration of growth, restoration of asset values, and so on. Surely that's that's valid.

SPEAKER_02There's been a lot of paper written about uh how successful was was QE? Was it a good transmission mechanism? There's a lot of criticism of it in that yes, uh the banks were wash with cash, but did they lend? Think about it. When you go through a recession, there isn't really an appetite for borrowing. People have been hammered. So it's not as simple as saying, let's recapitalize the banks and they'll automatically lend it. There's a bit of a lead time there. So it's not all the banks' fault, but there is definitely evidence that banks were not lending and and perhaps the economy didn't see the recovery.

SPEAKER_02Uh like you mean in terms of distortions, Ivan, you mentioned QE, negative interest rates, like rates turned negative in Europe, and that had a huge distortion effect to asset prices. You had uh property prices. Look at Ireland. You have pensioners, savers cannot get a return on their deposits through 2011, 12, uh 12, 13, 14, 15. They were buying property and competing with young families to buy property. So so there was a distortion going on there.

SPEAKER_01Okay, let's let's go back to some of the content we have, and I want to focus on David Kelly, um, who told you that central banks don't control the economy the way we think they do. After 30 plus interviews, do you agree with him?

SPEAKER_02So David was the first person we interviewed for the series, and he recognized the power of central banks. But what he also recognized is that they're not as influential as people think. Like 30 years ago, we didn't really know who the governor of the of the Bank of England was or who the central bank chairman was. Now they're like rock stars. The the markets and the hang on every word that they say. Why is that? That's a consequence of the huge fallout of 2008 financial crisis when central banks uh were so pivotal in the so-called uh recovery.

SPEAKER_02But what David Kelly, who has an economic model for the last 30 years, found evidence was that in the 1990s it started to change, whereby uh interest US, the US economy particularly became less interest rate sensitive. Why? Because the US started to move towards fixed rate mortgages, locking in fixed rates, and also transition from a heavy-duty manufacturing industrial economy to a more services-type economy. So the that kind of makes sense.

SPEAKER_01But uh he does make a valid point. If you take the inflation spike in 2022, this really was to February 22, the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Um that was really about oil, wasn't it?

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_01And Iran again, it's a it's about oil, isn't it? Energy costs are a critical factor more than interest rates to inflation.

SPEAKER_02It's all it's it's all relevant. I mean, if you talk about 2022, it was really a supply shock. Uh you're right, gas. Like Europe was completely overly reliant on Russian gas. And uh when the invasion happened, uh we saw gas prices going through the roof, natural gas prices, uh, there there needed to be resupply of energy. And and energy actually became a national security issue for a lot of European European countries. But it was a bit more than that.

SPEAKER_02When you mandate citizens to stay at home, you you you basically prevent all that purchasing capacity and you store it up. Supply chains are shut down for 12 months plus, and then when you reopened, prices were naturally going to go up. The other factor is governments around the world

SPEAKER_01that was COVID-related.

SPEAKER_02That was COVID-related. Uh but then but COVID

SPEAKER_01that was 2020.

SPEAKER_02That was 2020, but there was a long lag from COVID and the Russian invasion of Ukraine definitely um added to that uh supply chain uh inflationary pressure, added to that factor then. So there's those three features there. It was the fiscal support governments give to individuals. If if you deposit money in somebody's account who lives paycheck to paycheck, they're gonna, surprise, surprise, they're gonna spend it. So increased spending on services after the reopening, uh fuel prices because of the Russian invasion.

SPEAKER_02So it was kind of a perfect storm for inflation. Pent up demand. But but David Kelly said that this uh central banks didn't cause that inflation. A lot of people say, oh, well, the central banks, all that printing of money caused inflation. No. If if printing of money caused inflation, it would have happened a lot earlier than 2020.

SPEAKER_01What is, as as Russell Napier referred to, what is financial repression?

SPEAKER_02Okay, so financial repression is really a situation where the government won't say it publicly, but we're we're we're out of ammunition here. What is their menu of solutions here? They can introduce austerity. We saw it in Ireland, it doesn't work uh because it kills growth. They can uh default uh on the debt, they can do that, but they'll they'll play a future premium for future borrowing. Ask Argentina, they'll tell you. Um, they can hope for growth.

SPEAKER_02That's wishful thinking if you're in a recessionary environment, uh, or they can print money. They printed money, they took the easy option, okay? But what happens in an inflationary regime is interest rates have to rise. And what happens if you have borrowed excessive amounts of debt, the interest payment on that debt restricts what you can do at a certain period. So we're at that juncture now. Look at the US, and a large portion of its uh income tax receipts is paid on servicing the debt.

SPEAKER_02It ha it it's it's in a corner. So what financial repression, and sorry for that long, but it's important to explain the context, what financial repression says is is that we're gonna have a situation of negative real interest rates. Okay, and this is where it gets interesting, where the government mandates its private citizens to purchase government debt. And you say, Well, I'm not buying government debt, that's what Johnny on the street says. But how do they do it?

SPEAKER_02Very subtle. You've got money on deposit in banks. Maybe they make regulation where banks have to invest in Irish government bonds, in German government bonds. Maybe pension funds have to are regulated to hold a certain percentage of government bonds. If lots of these big institutions are buying, are it's bringing down the yield, and if inflation is running at 4%, it's inflating the debt away.

SPEAKER_01But in terms of central banks, uh when people look back at the crash, and you know, there was Patrick Neary, the financial regulator, the the pr the the distilled wisdom of the crash is there was a lending bubble that drove property prices. They halved, they crashed. The government uh so then the banks crashed after the assets crashed, and then in bailing out with the government guarantee, the government crashed and the Troika came in. So we had a kind of triple whammy.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_01But all of that came from a bubble of lending whereby uh they were getting this sort of money from Germany or or whatever, and they were throwing it out. It wasn't linked to the real world. So, you know, the price of uh assets was crazy. The question I want to ask you now, as as a potential client of yours, is are we in the middle of a bubble now? Are we in the middle of an AI bubble? Are we in the middle of a you know, look at house prices? A million won't get you very much in Dublin. Are we in the middle of another property bubble?

SPEAKER_01Are we in the middle of a Bitcoin bubble? So where where do you stand right now in 2026 on bubbles?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, bubbles are tricky because bubbles can last a lot longer than fellows like me think. And you know, people are very quick to say, well, Al O'Sullivan was talking about a bubble two years ago, and I was. Because it made sense that there was a bubble even two years ago.

SPEAKER_01The bubbles got bigger. The

SPEAKER_02bubbles got bigger. The bubble's been blown bigger. And like if it made sense, if you could rationalise that there was a bubble in certain equities, Bitcoin, uh, a couple of years ago, you have to kind of m rationalise that it still makes sense. Why is there a bubble though? Back to interest rates.

SPEAKER_01So on the binary question, is there a bubble or isn't there a bubble?

SPEAKER_02Well, I think my own view is that there is a bubble in the AI hyperscalers.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_02And you say, well, why the important question, why? Because price determines uh future returns. The price is what you pay, value is what you get.

SPEAKER_01So if So if you buy NVIDIA stock, what are you saying?

SPEAKER_02So if you're buying NVIDIA, you're assuming that that company's revenue future revenues is going to be in the trillions and trillions. It's a blue sky scenario, it's not stress tested to what happens in China. China could bring out a model tomorrow. No, the reason NVIDIA is is doing

SPEAKER_01deep seek

SPEAKER_02part two.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_02Uh and and and and you know, there's a lot of talk that China's working on that just to disrupt the whole business model for AI. Um,

SPEAKER_01but I actually thought that one of the the lessons of the last crash was that capital adequacy ratios and the rules of banking changed so that it could never happen again. So, whatever about a stock market bubble, there won't be a banking

SPEAKER_02banks are fully capped, banks are a wash with cash. So it we're not worried about the banks, we're worried about the private domestic uh like here's a statistic for you. In 1982, uh the share of uh US personal holdings of wealth was around 10%. Okay. So 10% of that person's wealth was built up in the stock market. Do you know what it is today? So what that means is that individuals in the US, people in the United States, for example, if I pick on the US, if there's a wobble in the AI market, they're gonna have a crushing blow to their wealth.

SPEAKER_02So that's a negative pension effect. Not just their personal money, their pension funds, so they're not saving. There's a there's the there's evidence from the Bank of International Sentence that the US, uh the normal punter that has done really well in the stock market's wealth effect has increased dramatically. But it's notional, it's stock market wealth. So there's this kind of substitution for saving. And what happens then, if that hasn't been the case traditionally, a wobble means that consumption will slow down, and that is the thing nobody's talking about.

SPEAKER_01Alright, uh some salutary warnings there from Alan, as always. So I hope you uh found that beneficial, informative, a deep probe into uh what impact central banks actually have, and what are the key factors in the underlying macroeconomics? Uh that's another uh section of uh most important thing. I hope you enjoyed it. Dude, join us again where we'll take more detailed analysis of the various uh 30 odd entities that I've conducted.

SPEAKER_01So from us, for now, thank you for joining us and goodbye.

SPEAKER_03Thank you for listening to the most important thing. This podcast is for general information and educational purposes only. Nothing in this episode is financial, investment, tax, legal, or pension advice, and nothing said should be taken as a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any investment, asset, or security. Any assets, stocks, or markets we discuss are for discussion and illustration only. The views expressed by our hosts and guests are their own, and they may hold positions in investments mentioned. Investing involves risk.

SPEAKER_03The value of investments can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you invest. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future performance. Before making any financial decision, please seek independent advice from a regulated financial advisor who understands your personal circumstances. Thanks again for listening. Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Jesse Felder| Are We Heading for a Debt Crisis? Felder on Diversification & Investing (Part 2)

    Nov 17, 202632 minAudio

    Are we heading towards a debt crisis, an earnings downturn and a major shift in the stock market? In Part Two of The MOST Important Thing, Dr. Alan O’Sullivan is joined by contrarian investor and former hedge fund...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Is the AI Bubble About to Burst? NVIDIA, Interest rates & Energy | Jesse Felder (Part 1)

    Nov 13, 202643 minAudio

    Is the AI bubble about to burst? Contrarian investor Jesse Felder joins Dr. Alan O’Sullivan on The MOST Important Thing to examine NVIDIA, Big Tech’s AI spending boom, rising US Treasury yields, stubborn inflation, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Inflation Era: Dr Lacy Hunt on the Keynesian Endgame

    Nov 10, 202647 minAudio

    Is the global economy entering a new inflationary era - and could rising government debt make the next downturn even harder to manage? In this conversation with Dr Lacy Hunt, Alan O’Sullivan examines the forces...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Most Important Thing - In Focus - Bubble-enomics!

    Nov 6, 202617 minAudio

    WARNING - This episode should be viewed given the educational content and graphs referred to during the episode. Anyone tells you they "know" what the market is going to do is as dangerous as a one-legged man in an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Is the 60/40 Portfolio Broken? AI, Hedge Funds & the Future of Investing | Dr. Philip Seager (Part 2)

    Oct 28, 202629 minAudio

    Is the traditional 60/40 portfolio still fit for purpose? What should investors look for in a systematic fund manager? And how is AI changing the careers of people working in finance? In Part 2 of The Most Important...

    Credit the people on this episode