Where were you when AMERICA DECIDED? Were you watching our livestream? Were you at the super-exclusive party that, as of this writing, is still raging on? Were you injecting Substack’s election hub straight into your veins? If so, you’ll have no need for this audio-only selection of the best conversations from the evening. For the rest of you, enjoy! You’ll hear not only from Matt, Michael, and Kmele, but from Mary Katharine Ham, Marc Caputo, Ben Dreyfuss, Greg Lukianoff, David A. Graham, Josh Barro, Eliana Johnson, Jamie Kirchick, Megan McArdle, Nick Gillespie, and Ruy Teixeira!If these two hours aren’t enough for you, feel free to relive the evening in all its audiovisual glory over on The Fifth Column’s YouTube channel. The Fifth Column (A Podcast) is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Come see The Fifth in Connecticut!: https://quickcenter.fairfield.edu/2026-27-season-calendar/lectures/the-fifth-column-podcast.html Follow The Fifth Column YouTube: @wethefifthInstagram: @we.the.fifthX: @wethefifthTikTok: @wethefifthFacebook: @thefifthcolumn This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.wethefifth.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Producer Jason Mojica here, coming to you not from our fancy studio, but from the streets of Brooklyn where I am currently walking my dog with a hangover. I have the hangover, not the dog, on Wednesday, November 4th. The reason? Because our social producer, Charlie, has been up all night pulling together the best bits and bobs from our epic four-hour midterm madness livestream. So in case you didn't feel like showing up, and yes, that is a ministry reference, here it is.
SPEAKER_03The best of The Fifth Column's Midterm Madness 2026.
SPEAKER_01We know of new methods of attack.
SPEAKER_02The Trojan Horse, The Fifth Column.
SPEAKER_01Mary Katherine Hamm, to start the night, we've got a million guests, but we always save the best for first. Mary Katherine Hamm. Thank you very much. Of the podcast Getting Hammered, former CNN contributor until they ran you out, and Mark Caputo is joining us from Florida. Let's talk about Ron DeSantis, I assume.
SPEAKER_00Let's do it.
SPEAKER_01Let's do it, because that's when I met you. You were giving him a piggyback or something. I saw you with Ron DeSantis. He came out, he's the first one who comes out swinging, right? I mean, Donald Trump is, you know, he's gaslighting you if he says it's not the Iran War. He's doing the thing. I mean, we've seen him do this before when he was running against Trump. What do you make of the new DeSantis? And I suspect we're going to see a lot of DeSantis's coming in the next couple of weeks, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So today he like suddenly pops up on Stephen A. Smith's podcast. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Right. As you do. I would never turn that on. That's true. Right. And so he slowly like you can never really tell with Ron. Like so if you listen to the people who sort of know his thinking and Ron is not known for having a lot of friends because he's that kind of guy. And, you know, he just has it. He's not an easy guy to hug. And so he has a lot of staff turnover, doesn't have a lot of advisory to stick with him.
SPEAKER_00But his staff has generally known that he's sort of like Ron Burgundy, right? If you put a script in front of him, he's going to read it. If you put like a podcast mic in front of DeSantis, he's going to start shitting on Trump. He doesn't want to really shit on Trump, but he's going to shit on Trump. And so that's kind of what he did today. Now, he made sure not to say Trump and not, you know, pretend he was shitting on him, but he was shitting on him. And that's just Ron. Like if you get him, if you get him in front of a mic, he's going to do it. I'm not sure there's any sort of strategy that's going on here. This is where it's hardest.
SPEAKER_00It is. Well, there's a number of reporters who wanted to interview DeSantis and get him on. And his staff was telling people he's not doing any political interviews. And the reason they were saying that is because they know if he was doing a political interview, he'd start to be like, look, you're gaslighting people. You can't say that gas doesn't matter, that the Iran war didn't cause it. So if they didn't put him in front of a You know, camera, he wouldn't do it. Well, he got in front of a camera. Here we are.
SPEAKER_02We see already that John Ossoff has been declared or our next Democratic presidential nominee.
SPEAKER_00I mean, that should surprise no one. If you saw the debates between him and Mike Collins, it kind of looked like it was like the debate equivalent of watching a butcher render meat. Like I've never seen, never seen like. Because Ossoff used to present as very beta. I think he's been hitting the juice. The gym was the best thing that ever happened to that dude.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yes.
SPEAKER_00And I think he had the testosterone flowing. He goes on stage. He starts pointing at Mike Collins. He says, I challenge Mike Collins not to have anyone in his family member send out white supremacist literature for the next three weeks. And then Collins stammered like, look, he can't even do that. I mean, it was just really a beatdown. Like, what?
SPEAKER_02Mayor Catherine, do we have comments about Ossoff's ass? We were talking about that before.
SPEAKER_03But since we are discussing assets, his would certainly be in the pantheon, I think, of politicians. I don't know if we actually were discussing assets.
SPEAKER_01I think you were discussing assets, which is totally fine.
SPEAKER_03It's the closing argument of the Trump administration is asses. So that it was.
SPEAKER_00Hold on. I've got a counterintuitive take, which is the Trump position. They are saying that this was a stroke of genius, that thanks to Donald Trump, People no longer perceive John Husted in, Senator Husted in Ohio as boring. People start to talk about him positively as having a great
SPEAKER_02ass. We have some Trump video closing argument stuff I think we should tee up and respond to. The reflecting pool? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Are we going to tee that up? In the meantime, before we tee that up, how about we do this? Byron Donaldson. Donaldson. Donaldson. Donaldson. He also... Donaldson. I used to live in Sweden. Biron Donaldson. He... DeSantis also shit on him today, too. Why not? Why not? When Alina Haber took a swing at her and said, you know, I mean, this is a bad deal, right? I mean, she's getting $50 million from her Turkish husband who's in his 70s and,
SPEAKER_01you know, whatever. Or she's in her 70s. And he's like 25. But what did you make of that?
SPEAKER_00I think she's 42 and he's 29.
SPEAKER_01But wasn't there some reporting he might be younger than that? He might be 25. He might be 25. So I want to be accurate about this.
SPEAKER_00There's a bunch of weird shit going on over there.
SPEAKER_01I don't know what's happening. Talk to us about our Swedish potential governor.
SPEAKER_00Well, he's going to be the first, not just the first black governor of the Deep South, but the first black Swedish governor.
SPEAKER_01Yes, which is rare even in Sweden.
SPEAKER_00And I think he's the first black Republican governor in the nation, or he will be, assuming the trends hold. Yes. I mean, what's interesting about Donald's is he went sort of everywhere and did everything. Like today he appeared on The Breakfast Club and got in an argument with Angela Fry, who accused him of having kind of an anti-black agenda. And he just went at it with her. Like, most guys don't go into hostile territory on Election Day and get
SPEAKER_00in an argument with the host. But Donald's did. Like, I mean, Donald's has a lot of swagger. And now he is underperforming Moody statewide in Florida. But, you know, that's not a surprise. A lot of Republicans were worried in the state. That what are commonly called the George Wallace counties. That's right. In 1968, George Wallace won 44 of 67 counties in Florida that it would cost him. Now, there is a little erosion in his margins, but nevertheless,
SPEAKER_00the Republican Party on whole, Republican and Republican leaning voters on the whole were not held back by that. And it looks like it's Again, it looks like he's going to make history. And one of the things that Donald didn't do was talk about actually sort of downplayed a little how he'd be the first black governor of the Deep South, certainly the first black governor of Florida.
SPEAKER_02Let's let's play some Trump closing arguments material.
SPEAKER_01Massive piece of piece of pool. There's never been anything like when you look at the side. It's the biggest anywhere in the world by far. Now we're giving serious Thought to changing the name to the Trump Reflecting Pool. Despite all that we went through, the Reflecting Pool right now looks better than it ever looked. The pool is now better and more beautiful than it's ever been before. We went through a lot with vandalism.
SPEAKER_01The vandalism was unprecedented. People don't like talking about it.
SPEAKER_03Even the DOJ that you asked to go after that guy, and then they had to, we don't want to talk about it.
SPEAKER_02No, thank you. You covered your White House correspondent now. Yeah. We heard from a guest last week, from Edward Luce from the Financial Times, great writer, that basically Trump's not taking any phone calls anymore. He's kind of had a bad couple of months and is not feeling very expansive. What do you- I don't know if that's true. Okay. So what's your sense of how he is taking this and how he is taking his final lap here before the elections?
SPEAKER_00Well, he's not sort of taking blame for what happened, even though, I mean, If you boil down the election results and the problems that they've had, it's inflation and the Iran War. But, you know, he's, in the words of the White House, he's left it and laid it all on the field when he did, I don't know, 28 rallies in, you know, 30 days or something like that. So his attitude is, look, I did everything possible. I did my part. If everyone else loses, that's on them. It's not my fault.
SPEAKER_00And that's the story he's taking to it.
SPEAKER_01I mean, the idea that Trump wanted was it would be a referendum on me if he's going to go out there.
SPEAKER_03Never mind. Yeah, never mind.
SPEAKER_01I mean, this seems like a rather risky strategy, Mark.
SPEAKER_00I mean, it makes sense to the degree of it's always a referendum on the president. So the idea was on paper. So Trump's going to go out there and make the case. And then when Trump goes out there and makes the case, he jokes about a guy's ass and he says all the things that come into his head because Trump Remember the fundamental thing about Donald Trump is that he's a performer when he gives these rallies. These aren't so much political rallies as sort of stand-up acts and sort of an ability for Donald Trump to entertain the crowd. And every Donald Trump speech is two speeches in one. It's a speech that's written as he says, he'll say it there.
SPEAKER_00There's the speech that my advisors want me to give and then there's me going off script and that's what you want. Everyone's like yeah. And that's where the fun and the magic happens. Now in the Trump White House and Trump political operations view, All of those digressions, as it were, or the weave, as he likes to call it, don't really matter. What really matters is getting the clips that they need where he's on message and it works. I'm not sure they're correct about that, but they're certainly going to point to Florida as being one of their bright spots because it might be one of the few bright spots. Were there points where he was on message?
SPEAKER_00There probably were. It's just statistically impossible not to happen. He talks for two hours, right?
SPEAKER_01That's true. Well, one last thing for you, Mark, is, you know, you're the White House correspondent now. You know a lot of people in Trump's orbit. There's a lot of knees knocking and gnashing of teeth of what the administration will do and how they will respond. If this is a very bad night for them, right? The New York Times had, I thought, a partially bullshit story a week and a half ago about, oh, they're already trying to dispute the results of the election in Alaska
SPEAKER_01in burying nine paragraphs in. That it was the 1948 Joe Kennedy get the guy with the same name thing. So I think there's some kind of overheated rhetoric on this. But what do you suspect that the administration will do and how will they respond if all the last polls like these New York Times Siena polls turn out to be right?
SPEAKER_00I mean, if there's an opportunity for the White House, for the Trump directed Republican Party to object and find a way to force something to a recount, get a court to declare voters ineligible, change the results, they're going to do it. So what I don't have a read on is what sort of opportunities there are. At the very least in Alaska, the Department of Justice filing that lawsuit in the short term was a way to sort of draw attention to the case and to have voters say, oh, this is a dirty trick.
SPEAKER_00Look, the Justice Department is there. Now, I would never presume to say that the Justice Department won't follow through with that and do more. But, you know, Donald Trump is the, this is the Trump show. And one of the things about the Trump show is it keeps you watching. So we have to stay tuned.
SPEAKER_01Mark Caputo. Mark, can I ask you a question?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_01Is your dad Philip Caputo?
SPEAKER_00Yes. Okay. That's all I want to know. He passed in May, by the way.
SPEAKER_01Oh, sorry. We're sorry to hear that. If you don't know, absolutely brilliant man. Fantastic writer. Mark Caputo, thank you so much for joining us, not from Florida, but from D.C., because he's gotten a raise in the world. I'll be back.
SPEAKER_00I got my Miami Hurricanes hat on still.
SPEAKER_01If Angie Nixon wins, you're not allowed back. That's what you texted me earlier. Thank you, Mark. Appreciate it, buddy. Have a good one. We got our favorite one-eyed jack, as I call him, Ben Dreyfuss. You know, I got a bone to pick with you. Is it the eye? It is. It is. The fact that every time I look at your very funny Twitter feed, you're always complaining that you're not invited on the show anymore. You're like, well, I don't go on the show.
SPEAKER_02I mean, sorry, sorry. It sounds like you're looking at your notifications. If you see my other tweets, there's actually, they're constantly various and sundry.
SPEAKER_01I only just search for my name, and you are invited on the show, but thank you for coming. Where do you live now, Ben? I live in Sun Valley, Idaho. That's why you don't come on the show. It's a ski resort surrounded by Nazis. It's a bit of a, it's William Pierce lived in Idaho, didn't he? I have no idea. He wrote the Turner Diaries, which I don't know why Hollywood hasn't made into a film.
SPEAKER_02Look, we can probably find some Jews willing to do that.
SPEAKER_01Well, yes, they all vote for Syed. Can you grab me one of those drinks? Yeah. I don't know. I took the Beau French 75. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I had the, I had the beau, the beau, the beau French 75, and I thought it was great.
SPEAKER_03What would you like? Can I get you one of these two choices?
SPEAKER_02I want the one.
SPEAKER_01Guys, you understand that we have four hours of this, so we're going to just keep drinking, and you can watch, and this is like Anderson Cooper on New Year's Eve. Exactly. Coming down the fire pole. Yeah. Yeah, that's the name of the show. We're down the fire pole. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Have I ever gone down Anderson's Fireball?
SPEAKER_01No, no. I believe in all kinds. Jamie's coming on soon. We'll talk about it. Are you paying attention to this at all? Do you care when you're in Sun Valley, Idaho?
SPEAKER_00The what?
SPEAKER_01The election. No, of course I care.
SPEAKER_02I only moved to Sun Valley after a couple of... I lived in New York for a long time. I'm Jewish. Of course I care about the election.
SPEAKER_01What is the most Jewish part of this election?
SPEAKER_02Oh, I thought you were going to say Sun Valley.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. The money. I was going to say it's you, but
SPEAKER_02okay. The most Jewish part of this election is probably not Michigan. It might be Democrats winning. Democrats love Jews, even though, again, not in Michigan. But yeah, I think... Did the DSA love Jews? Well, the DSA, no, no. The DSA doesn't seem to love Jews very much. Yeah. But, you know, there's just a couple of those people. Yeah, they're right. We got 13 million Jews in America, all right?
SPEAKER_01Two percent. Yeah, we are the two percent. Yeah, nice job. They're probably more Sikhs. Yeah, yeah, they're probably more Sikhs, yeah. But there's not a lot of Sikhs in Hollywood. Yeah, no, not yet. Yeah, not yet. They're all being played by Ben King.
SPEAKER_02We want to ask Ben Dreyfus, since he is the most Democrat, probably, of this table at the moment, what do you think Dems are going to do? Like, just not what you want. What do you think that they're going to do? Because, I mean, we had We had a situation after 2010 where the Tea Party came in and they suddenly, there's a Republican House and going against a president from the opposite party, and they kind of did stuff. They were part of politics. It didn't last, but like the whole- Sorry, sorry.
SPEAKER_02What did the Tea Party do in the first- We had sequestration cuts of defense in 2013 based on hard-ass Tea Party negotiations. It didn't last because- Long story, but basically Republicans won both House of Congress and they stopped caring about that stuff, Paul Ryan and Mitch McConnell, whatever. But those weirdos for a while held Obama's feet to the fire on spending and kind of like we our national politics was all about like long term fiscal problems
SPEAKER_02for about two years because of that. So they they did stuff. They were able to do stuff. What do you think the Democrats are going to tangibly do? With a president who's old and weird and is signing more executive orders than any president since FDR and bragging about it. Like, what do you think is going to happen?
SPEAKER_01Do you mean in the next two years or do you mean- Two years. Next two years. Nothing.
SPEAKER_02Literally nothing.
SPEAKER_01I mean, there might be this permitting bill reform that's going to be in the lame duck, right? And they won't confirm any judges, you know, if they get the Senate as well. And they'll investigate some things and there'll be some oversight.
SPEAKER_02But no, of course, they're not going to do any. Do you mean laws? Yeah. I mean. Investigating an oversight is part of it. That's part of it, sure.
SPEAKER_03A lot of people are- But I do like your low expectations. We're on the same page. No, I mean, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01What do you think they would do? Do they even have, have they said they're going to do anything? Has anyone, do they print out? Is it like Jerry Maguire?
SPEAKER_02And like mission statements? Do they have one? There's a piece of the New York Times about a week ago or less that said that the things that people agreed on in the incoming class were they wanted to Um, vote against the Iran war and try to reassert congressional, like actually having a vote on these things. Similarly tariffs. This was the surprise to me. We're talking about this before we started taping. Um, like according to the times, uh, they're universally agreed that they want to block They want to block
SPEAKER_02the president's authority on tariffs and also to reduce the tariffs. Well, sure. Well, sure. Democrats, well, sure.
SPEAKER_00They can't do that. He'll veto those bills.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, but what a beautiful thing to have them negatively polarized into free trade.
SPEAKER_02I do agree with that.
SPEAKER_03I'm here for this.
SPEAKER_01I've been fighting the fight against the protectionist wacky, that part of the Democratic Party for a long time. It's like, I totally am with you on it.
SPEAKER_03Wait, see, we're coming together. See what's happening here?
SPEAKER_02All right. I want to give thanks to our American girlfriend. Thank you so much. Mary Catherine.
SPEAKER_03Can I give you one quote to prove myself right for 2025 real quick before I leave the set?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_033-11-25. Biden's vice was government spending. Trump's vice's tariffs both rationalized them with magical thinking, and Trump can definitely sink his whole presidency within a couple months if he gives into it just as Biden did and then tells people that they're not struggling.
SPEAKER_01Yes. That's what Ron DeSantis said today, by the way. Yeah. Same thing. Already fighting. Mary Catherine Hamm. Thanks for having me. Thank you so much. Go to the party. Have some drinks. I will. I mean, I'm already having one, so. Yeah, I mean, that Mallard drilled a hole in me. Lord, I've got more hours of this. I can't do that.
SPEAKER_02Thinking about those times early last year, it's funny to look back on because there's a lot of enthusiasm from various crowds about how MAGA was never going to die. Do you remember the story where they hired the guy in Doge? They were like, look, these Democrats, they think this isn't going to work. They're doubting us. This kid we hired, he solved the riddle of Mount Zesuvius. If you can solve a riddle of Matt Vesuvius, we can solve anything. And I wonder where that kid is right now at the office just being like...
SPEAKER_01I think Big Balls is probably back working at Twitter. One of the people we're going to bring on now is our dear friend. Somebody whose work we big up all the time and support. Whose conference we're going to be speaking at within a matter of hours.
SPEAKER_02Is that true?
SPEAKER_01I don't want to tell you the bad news, but yeah, 72. I don't have a secretary. No one tells me this. But Greg Lukianoff is... What do they call them? The Dear Leader. Grant Poobah. Grant Poobah, Dear Leader of FIRE, our friends over at FIRE, the foundation for... I was going to like... Do you know what FIRE stands for? That's not going to give you the answers. You don't have to put that in.
SPEAKER_02Foundation for Individual Rights and Enterprise?
SPEAKER_01Expression. Expression. Expression. Not bad. Let's get Greg in here. Greg Lukianov, welcome to the show. We have you because you're our dear friend.
SPEAKER_03So, you know, I think that we're probably heading into the worst of both worlds. Oh. I think that Trump is going to feel utterly unshackled, and I think he's going to do a lot of the things he's been threatening to do. You know, he's already leaned into the FCC to use it against media like crazy. You know, he's also been routinely saying he's going to arrest people from The New York Times. And when it comes to the more DSA-influenced, you know, Democratic Party, So I just I think they're going to lean into every civil rights kind
SPEAKER_03of option they have. They're probably going to turn Title VI on its head on campuses going after Islamophobia.
SPEAKER_01Explain Title VI as we all know Title IX. Yes. What is Title VI?
SPEAKER_03So Title IX has just been insanely abused for more than my entire career.
SPEAKER_01I thought this was about ladies playing soccer.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's what a lot of people thought. But then unfortunately, as of 1980, it became much more about hostile environments.
SPEAKER_01I realized they weren't very good at soccer.
SPEAKER_03And then in the 1980s, started out with the first generation of modern speech codes. And those were all justified as harassment codes. And this got incorporated in the Department of Education. And I've been screaming at the top of my head. So is fire, you know, try to explain. It's like, no, they've been using this. They call it harassment. It's just a speech code. It's the same as the codes in the 1980s. But the more recent administrations moved to Title VI, which is more ethnicity and national origin as a way of going
SPEAKER_03after the genuine problem, to be clear, of antisemitism on campus. But as we warned for 10 years now and got a lot of Jewish donors got very mad at us, but we were saying, like, listen, First of all, if you really lean into punishing people for speech that's critical of Israel, that's going to have horrible backlash. And I think we've been proven right on that. But also, if you lean into Title VI, the left is just going to turn around and go, oh, you mean you want to ban Islamophobia?
SPEAKER_03And that's the way they're going to use that.
SPEAKER_01So everybody wants to ban the thing that they're against.
SPEAKER_03Well, and the worst part of it is there used to be A civil libertarian aspect of the left, and a more libertarian aspect of the right, and both of those forces have been badly marginalized. Oh, I'm Greg, by the way.
SPEAKER_01I don't think we've met. We've been on the internet. We have been on the internet. Yeah, it's Ben Dreyfus. I'm hurt.
SPEAKER_03Holy Ben Dreyfus.
SPEAKER_01You said it. It's a real life moment where people are having a connection.
SPEAKER_03You're very funny.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. You're very smart. And I agree with you about speech.
SPEAKER_02Fire's a great word. What about Hanson? Yeah. Well, you're very smart. Yeah. I want to ask you a question about Trump. Yeah, yeah. What do you want? Let's have some of that. So Trump has been, I think, in all of our conceptions, very awful on free speech. Oh, yeah. If predictably awful, although there is some contingent. Even awful-er than predicted. Yes. Awful-er. And Brennan Carr, the FCC commissioner, has been awful-er than predicted by a lot.
SPEAKER_02What do you make of the argument that, yes, he's been awful-er, But it's also been targeted. It's been targeted at the New York Times. It's been targeted at corporations, law firms, which we talked about with you on this program before. Whereas the Biden administration is much more broad. Like we want to like go after social media and like stop individuals from doing this. Whereas Trump hasn't really affected individuals. How do you measure those things in terms of the awfulness and the reach
SPEAKER_02Of the awfulness, comparing the two as best as you can, knowing that we all hate comparisons on some level.
SPEAKER_03I mean, Trump has really focused on sort of like bastions of liberal or left-leaning power. So he's really gone after law firms. Media and higher education. But he's also done things that have serious ramifications on regular people as well. I mean, he send DHS officers to people's door if they're critical of ICE. I mean, like there's been a lot. Trump has kept fire busy all the time. And it's honestly this past year is the worst I've ever seen. I've seen some of the worst cases of my entire career in the past year.
SPEAKER_03But what the old Biden version of the Democratic Party wanted. You know, was essentially to create an oligopoly of AI companies. They wanted, you know, greater, not necessarily control over social media, but they liked it when their buddies are the people sympathetic to them are the ones, you know, in charge. I think that what we're going to see, but all the Democrats have to do to a degree, though, is, you know, haul everybody into, bring everybody before Congress and say,
SPEAKER_03well, you ban all this stuff in Europe. Why don't you ban it here? So I actually think that how bad censorship has gotten, arresting thousands of people a year in the UK for one, is what they're going to do is they're going to get out of the way of a lot of the activity that's going on in Europe and kind of like let them kind of like do the dirty work. And then, of course, with the more DSA-influenced Democrats, I think they're really going to lean into all the levers of control that they have
SPEAKER_03over campus, which did recede a little bit. They got a little spooked by what the Trump administration could do to it. But those shackles, I think, are going to be off.
SPEAKER_02Talk a bit more about the DSA aspect of it as someone who is half Russian and hates communism for the fire of a thousand suns.
SPEAKER_01They weren't great on free speech.
SPEAKER_02The Irish half is fine with it though. Both like broadly and then like practically of what you can imagine a new democratic Congress with potentially a small You know, DSA friendly block that tries to become the new Freedom Caucus.
SPEAKER_03Well, yeah, I mean, we can expect some help from DSA types for, you know, bans on protest and these kinds of things. But otherwise, I mean, it's always important to remember that Karl Marx himself said, Really good things about freedom of speech, particularly freedom of the press. And then there's not a single Marxist institution out there that is actually good on the press, or country at least. The spiked people would probably disagree with me on that. But as far as countries, it's always against freedom of speech.
SPEAKER_03And centralization of power is always against freedom of speech. And as far as how many taboos There are within the harder left and how many of those get treated like blasphemy if you offend against them, whether it's trans issues, whether it's questioning or saying there wasn't a genocide. There are so many different ways to commit crimes against ruling class morality.
SPEAKER_03Uh, that I think all of that stuff is going to get worse as well. So I, I, you know, we're, we're going into the FIRE conference tomorrow that you guys are going to be at, and I, I'm going in. Thankfully, I, I got, uh, slapped in the face metaphorically by Nadine Strawson. Cause I, I did this talk with her, the former head of the ACLU and works at FIRE, which just kind of blows me away. And I was giving a talk at Oakland University and whenever I feel, whenever I'm on stage with Nadine, I always feel like the grizzled cop who's just two days from retiring, who's just like, ah, I'm too old for this shit. And weirdly, she's 24 years older than me,
SPEAKER_03but she always seems like the bright-eyed rookie who's just kind of like, things are going to be better. But that positivity comes from having been there for the worst. And I realized that growing up in the 80s, freedom of speech always seemed to be getting better every decade for a while there. Whereas her perspective is, listen, it's only ever been a tiny number of people who genuinely care about free speech as a principle, not as a tactic.
SPEAKER_02May I derail? Quickly, quickly derail it. Love it. When you talk about, like, I also have this tendency to wear, look at the world to rose-colored glasses. Yeah. And say, like, everything will be fine, you know? And one of the things, as you describe it, sounds awful. I should blow my brains out.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But when I then see good spots here, Trump and all of these other leftist cranks who want to stop you from saying anything bad or anything at all, the court seems quite good on speech right now, right? For my lifetime, it seems like the court right now is sort of like the most like, all right, we're going to...
SPEAKER_03The court is a real bright spot. And it's funny because it's like definitely on the left and I live in kind of like left-leaning bubbles all the time. That there's this kind of like, oh, they're totally dominated by MAGA. And I'm like, no, they're not. They don't rule them all the time. Are they more conservative? Yeah, of course they're more conservative. But as far as showing integrity, I really think they have shown integrity. So yeah, I agree with you on the courts. All right, good.
SPEAKER_01We have David Graham.
SPEAKER_03We have David Graham right here.
SPEAKER_01Is David Graham from the Atlantic here?
SPEAKER_02From the Atlantic is calling from North Carolina as far as we understand.
SPEAKER_01He is calling from North Carolina.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we're not going anywhere.
SPEAKER_01David Graham, are you there with us? Thank you for putting up with listening to us. I'm sorry, buddy. I appreciate it. This is great. Roy Cooper, look at what is happening in North Carolina. Obviously, you live there, or you just borrowed somebody's house with bookshelves. Presumably, you're living there, David. I am. Give us a sense of what's happening in North Carolina. We watched a bit of Roy Cooper's speech. What do you make of it?
SPEAKER_02I mean, I think the result is pretty much what we expected. Cooper has been way ahead for a long time, but I think it's a sign of where the state is, and it's a sign of how disorganized Republicans were in North Carolina this cycle. They ran Michael Watley, who was a Trump guy, and I think by the time he got into the race, he was basically a sacrificial lamb. Republicans had kind of decided they weren't really going to compete. They were going to put up somebody who they liked okay, and they were going to kind of cede the seat to Cooper or hope
SPEAKER_02that maybe something would come through for them. And it just never did. When did North Carolina become a kind of place that Republicans would just kind of cede? That seems recent. I think it would only happen against Roy Cooper. Cooper is just a singular politician in the state. I think he has a credibility with voters across the aisle today. And if some other Democrat had won, I think they would have fought it really hard. And with Cooper, they kind of they saw the writing on the wall. He's just really popular. He has been with a brief break in office here for since basically time immemorial.
SPEAKER_02And so, you know, Whatley tried to run this playbook of sort of telling people, you had Republicans saying, you know, you can't convince people they don't like Roy Cooper. You have to convince them that he's going to vote for a Democratic agenda that is bad. But if you tell him that he's not a good guy and they don't like him, they're going to know that's not true. And I think that's kind of what Whatley tried to do and it didn't work for him. Josh Barrow, you just sat in with us. Do you have a question for David Graham? I want to put you on the spot. Yeah, I mean, the question I have for David is, you know, as I look at some of these house races on the polymarket odds,
SPEAKER_02some of these house races in North Carolina that were sort of not on the radar at all, The betters think Dems are favored to win in those. Now, you know, it's always challenging looking at the partial returns in and trying to figure out, you know, is what's outstanding way more Republican than what's been counted so far? But am I right in understanding that Dems may pick up some seats here that no one was really even talking about a couple of weeks ago?
SPEAKER_01It looks that way.
SPEAKER_02I mean, it seems to me like a potential dummy mander situation. And this state was already pretty gerrymandered. Republicans came in and tried to squeeze more out of it. And you can only split your voters so far. And I think they were also working on 2024 models and assuming that kind of electorate. In a 2026 electorate, they're really thin. And so I think some of these they may pull out and some of them they may lose, but they'll be close either way. And North Carolina also has one of the weakest governors He's like weirdly smart. Shouldn't he be on TV or something right now?
SPEAKER_01Isn't this TV? No, it's not. This is dumb people drinking.
SPEAKER_02Josh, you know more about North Carolina than I do.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. By the way, I know that you're in Bushwick. It's fine. We trace the IP address. I just want to get a small update. With this kind of space? Yeah, well, you've got a lot of money. The Atlantic pays well. A million-plus subscribers in the Atlantic. The Ohio governor race, I want to go back to.
SPEAKER_00Oh, God, you're just waiting.
SPEAKER_01This is the one that I am desperate to watch Vivek Ramaswamy lose.
SPEAKER_02I have something to say about Vivek. Go ahead. Because when he was running for president and annoying the shit out of everyone a few years ago, I wrote this piece where I talked about how he's too annoying to get elected to anything. So first of all, I'm glad that that proved true. But I went to college with him. Yeah. And what I wrote about was that he's this, like, awful Harvard archetype of, like, the know-it-all kid in the section. Section guy is what people called it. And section guy can be a woman, but on average, section guy's a man, and, like, Vivek, sort of, like, a prime example of, like, who, like...
SPEAKER_02And the thing is that most of them, you know, like we were all 19 when we were in college, but most of us mature and change. And it seems like he's the same kid. And so when I wrote about this, I wrote that I'd never met him in college. And then someone emailed me with a clip from the Harvard Crimson reflecting that I had participated. Participated in a debate about social security reform that Vivek moderated. And so I guess I did meet him. But again, Harvard was full of kids like this. So he wasn't that unique a figure. But most of them, as they mature into adulthood,
SPEAKER_02they change a little bit where it's like the pure college Republican shithead. Like somehow... Like fully formed, came in to be the nominee for governor in Ohio. And I don't know if you saw the, there was an ad from one of the outside spending committees like shitting on him that included like his favorite sport is tennis. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. He posts videos of himself playing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And it's just videos of him playing tennis and him like failing to pick up that kid who was way too big.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Like, it's like, don't pick up the kid who weighs 110 pounds. We might be showing some video. We might show a video.
SPEAKER_01I think that he was actually 25 years old and just quite short.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_01We love David Graham. He's fantastic. See him at the Atlantic. He is not going to tell a story that ultimately is a way of him saying you went to Harvard. Did you know I went to Harvard? Did David go to Harvard?
SPEAKER_02I went to school with Stephen Miller. It's much worse.
SPEAKER_01You see Santa Barbara? He went to Duke. High school or college. You went to Duke. You went to Duke. Yeah. Thank you so much for joining us. Really appreciate it. Thank you guys. I'm going to have to get my liquor now. Yeah. Unfortunately, I've had way too much already.
SPEAKER_02Megan McArdle. Yeah. Megan McArdle, who's never been on this podcast.
SPEAKER_01I know because you don't love me and it makes me sad. It's not you. We don't like women. It's a sexist podcast. We have been accused. That's fair.
SPEAKER_03I don't care for them either if I'm honest.
SPEAKER_02Do you think any of the factions who are involved in the succession battle of who gets to inherit MAGA are going to look back and say, yeah, you know what? We did this one wrong. We did this one policy wrong.
SPEAKER_03Um, I mean, this one. So, look, I think you've got the faction that kind of liked the tariffs and didn't like the Iran War. You've got the factions, the faction that liked the Iran War and didn't like the tariffs. And all of those guys are going to be trying to point the figure at each other. But, like, ultimately, I think what this really reveals is the futility of attempting to, like, grab the mantle of Maa This is like trying to grab
SPEAKER_03the poisoned chalice that the president has just poisoned the entire party with, and they're all lying on the ground. It is like Jonestown, but for Republicans. And you're like, I want that Kool-Aid. Give me the chalice, right? Because this is the end of MAGA. We are witnessing- Do you think? I don't think that we are witnessing- MAGA's over by tomorrow? No. Well, fine, the beginning of the end of MAGA.
SPEAKER_02And also MAGA, MAGA, have we decided? No.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, okay. We don't care.
SPEAKER_03I don't know. It depends on whether you're from Massachusetts or not. MAGA. But look, these guys have spent 10 years, first of all, trying to resist him. That didn't work. And then they just, either they bent the knee or they got out. And then they were replaced by people who thought, I am going to be the next Donald Trump. I'm going to copy everything he does. They're like the mini-me's. And Vivek Ramaswamy is where that ends up. He's like, look, I don't like Donald Trump.
SPEAKER_03I think I've made that pretty clear. But his talents are that he had high name recognition. He was a celebrity, but he's also incredibly good on camera. He's funny. He always knows where the camera is, how his lighting's working. He just pops off a screen. He has what they call in Hollywood, it. Just that thing where you get two equally good looking people and one of them looks amazing on screen and you can't take your eyes off of them. The other one's like, who was that waiter carrying the drinks around? And he just has that. And without that, all of the rest of it,
SPEAKER_03the lack of ability to do policy or legislate or build coalitions or be a decent human being, Right. Like all of that is a liability. And when you don't have the offsetting, like I am basically the Brad Pitt of like elderly politicians. It's a low bar, but then like all you have is Vivek Ramaswamy. All you have is being stupid in public and saying dumb things and making dumb decisions that cause you to lose races. And that is where the Republican Party is now.
SPEAKER_03And they're all tomorrow. Going to be looking at that and saying, like, the people who just went along are going to be like, what was I doing? This did not work.
SPEAKER_02Do you think they'll actually say that, though, if they stayed, if they didn't leave?
SPEAKER_03The great Yuval Levin. I had a discussion with him on my other podcast, which isn't Central Air. I have too many podcasts. But The Washington Post, it's a great podcast. Everyone should listen. Reasonably optimistic. Anyway, Yuval Levin came on and we talked about what the Republican Party looks like after Trump. And one thing that he said that I think is really deeply true and perceptive is that no one ever apologizes. One of the examples he gave was FDR.
SPEAKER_03Everyone thought he overstayed his welcome, that letting him have four terms was a bad idea. I totally agree. He died during that. Yeah, but very quickly after he dies, they pass an amendment so that that can't happen again. But the Democrats never come out and are like, yeah, we shouldn't have done that. What were we thinking? That was gross. That was a violation of American civic norms. They just... Pass the constitutional amendment. And I think that's what MAGA is going to do.
SPEAKER_03They're not no one's ever going to come out and be like, you know what? I was a craven fool to go along with this for as long as I did. And I did a disservice to my country. What they are going to do is I think you're going to probably see some moves to rein in corruption of the way like of the style in the style of Donald Trump.
SPEAKER_02Which DeSantis was not today. He was pretty strong on that.
SPEAKER_03You're going to see moves, I think, to rate in the pardon power, which a bipartisan issue, so glad to see it. I think that you will see the GOP, but mostly I think you're going to see them backing away. They're not going to go along with his dumber and grosser ideas, and they're just going to slowly back away.
SPEAKER_01How publicly do you expect them to back away? Especially. I mean, DeSantis is something different, right? I mean, the Tom Tillis types are you're leaving and that's going to be Roy Cooper, right? Ossoff's about to talk a minute. I don't really care. He's good at talking. We know.
SPEAKER_02Ricardo's talking now.
SPEAKER_01Ricardo's talking now, which is more important. But there have been so many people, the Ben Sasse of the world, Jeff Flakes of the world, and when it becomes safe for them, when they're safely back in their districts and not in power, do you suspect that if this goes the way it looks like it's going to go, That there are going to be a bunch of Republicans who have, look, you guys, unless you're in D.C., you talk to Republicans. I talked to one Republican who's running tonight and looks like he's going to win or has won and got the bear hug from Donald Trump when he was running and then said
SPEAKER_01to me, I now have to run away from this man as fast as possible. He's going to win. He's going to do that publicly. Do these people do this publicly? Because that's how you kind of shift the idea of what it means to be a Republican and a conservative. I don't suspect that.
SPEAKER_03I don't think they're going to do the like, I hate Donald Trump. I've made a ruinous mistake. What I do think they're going to do. Is that they're going to run away from him on individual issues.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And overall, it's going to be kind of like, you know, like that awful boyfriend you had, but you were going to graduate in six months and you were like, I could stage a dramatic and horrible breakup now, but also I
SPEAKER_01could just move to Finland in six months. I've done that like seven times in my life as an adult, not in college. Let it fade away. But the thing is, what does Trump do in response, I'm asking to be sort of Rasputin on this one, is that he is going to be very angry. He is going to be very angry about it. So how does that manifest itself of an angry Donald Trump, angry Democrats we know, he's going to abuse the DOJ, he's going to go after them in a million ways. How does he do that in his own party when they're not actually
SPEAKER_03Look, I mean, he can throw a fit in two years and try to like support primary challenges to them. But I also think here's the other thing that really makes this different is voters don't like losers. It was always the case that he was going to have less power as soon as there was another nominee. Because like, look, he's got a hard base. He's got the people who are like MAGA forever and they won't vote unless it's for him. But he also has these people who were just like when he won the primary, they thought, well, I'm a loyal Republican
SPEAKER_03and these dumb never Trumpers should be loyal Republicans too. And they got mad about that. And they were like, you have to stand behind him because he's our nominee and he's on our team. But the minute there's a new nominee, if he tries to mess with that nominee, those people are going to get upset because that's our nominee and that's our team and you're not being a good team player. He is just not going to have the king making power. People are looking at the wreckage of what's happened here. No one in the establishment wants to give him that power, but a lot of Republican voters who are going to be mad at this loss
SPEAKER_03in the same way they got mad at George W. Bush. They were all loyal Republicans, loyal soldiers, and then he just destroyed the party. And I like George W. Bush a lot more than I like Donald Trump. And I think, well, he made a lot of errors. They were better intentioned than Donald Trump's errors, which you get partial credit. Um, and like, I think that, that, that issue, he can rail all he wants on Twitter, but if the voters, if he doesn't have the threat of the voters,
SPEAKER_03the threat of the primary people who are going to unseat you, then he doesn't have the power that he has wielded over these guys for the last 10 years. Josh Barrow, Democrats.
SPEAKER_01Yes. If we take those last New York Times, Santa Poles, and let's imagine that it looks like it's going in a particular direction, that all of that stuff bears fruit. What do you see them doing that is going to be horribly stupid and wrong? Is it a feint towards DSA stuff? Is it going to be like, okay, we need Medicare for all, and that's going to be a very complicated thing to actually do? Produce. I mean, where do you see the Democrats if they come out of this in the way
SPEAKER_01that we suspect they might?
SPEAKER_02Well, so I mean, the question is, who is they, right? Because, you know, I mean, one benefit of winning huge like this is, you know, I mean, you know, the one prediction market estimate I saw was the Democrats might come close to 260 seats in the House, given the strength of this wave. You know, that's an enormous majority. And so if you have a few DSA aligned members of the House who Don't want to vote for Hakeem Jeffries as speaker or want to make certain demands. They can sort of just be ignored. Weirdly, a bigger win for Democrats actually makes it easier to stiff arm
SPEAKER_02the left wing of the party. So I think for the next two years, the ideal... The political goal for Democrats is to just criticize Republicans for being terrible without advancing as much of their own legislative agenda that can end up being divisive. Certainly, I would not expect them to take votes on Medicare for All in this next Congress, and I don't think anyone will be able to make Hakeem Jeffries do that. I love how Josh just wants Democrats not to actually do anything, and yet he's still a Democrat. We're not. Often, the thing to do in opposition,
SPEAKER_02never get in the way of your opponent when he's making a mistake. That is true. There's also, of course, going to be a presidential election. And so, you know, I think a lot of Democrats have been afraid of a repeat of the 2019 experience of, you know, the quote unquote ideas primary. That didn't work out. No, it was not. I mean, literally it laid the breadcrumbs for the most devastating out of the 2024 campaign with Kamala Harris at some point. It wasn't an ACLU event. She'd filled out the ACLU questionnaire. But anyway, she's going on about the need for sex changes for prisoners.
SPEAKER_02And then in the questionnaire, it's also about even immigration detainees.
SPEAKER_01Josh Barrow, thank you very much. Thank you very much. The smartest guy in the business. We knew that before. It's a bit disconcerting, the hair.
SPEAKER_02I don't, you know, I, I just, I always wanted to be blonde and now it's like it took 10 IQ points off. Yeah. I feel in your 40s.
SPEAKER_01You can't do that when you're 50. I'm not 50. Yes, you are. I'm 42. Okay. Well, my.
SPEAKER_03He is not having a midlife crisis.
SPEAKER_01My information, but the big board had it wrong. I said, he, they said he's 50. He's very 50. Wow.
SPEAKER_02Uh, thank you, Josh. We appreciate it. Eliana Johnson. We do have Eliana Johnson.
SPEAKER_01You know what? We have Eliana for, beyond the fact that she is hilarious and great. And I love her so much. Eliana Johnson, editor in chief of the free beacon. One of my favorite people. She comes from Minnesota. Don't you come from
SPEAKER_03Minnesota? I do come from Minnesota.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for joining us, Eliana. Thanks for having me. What's going on? What are you thinking about? Tell me what is coursing through your veins right now watching these results. What are you thinking?
SPEAKER_03I'm thinking about a bloodbath.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I'm thinking about a bloodbath. I mean, geez. And my takeaway so far, look, we don't know the results in Michigan, which I think may change my interpretation, but so far it appears to me If you could turn yourself into, if you could either really be or turn yourself into a generic, unobjectionable Democrat, the country was swinging 20 to 30 points in your direction from where it was. In 2024, which is remarkable.
SPEAKER_03And I say that because Angie Nixon did not prevail in Florida. Yeah. But it is amazing. But not by much, by the way. Not by much. It is amazing that a DSA-backed woman who owns a cafe resistance with a shrine in it to convicted cop killers came within... 2.53 points of winning a United States Senate seat in what is a very red state. I think that speaks to... The massive shift that has taken place that we're watching in the country, Kansas,
SPEAKER_03Florida, South Carolina, Iowa, Texas, Ohio, these places are just seeing enormous shifts. And I think it owes to the unpopularity of the Iran War, which made gas prices shoot up and the tariffs. Yeah. Both are things which were in the president's control. I was supportive of the Iran war when it launched, but much of this falls at the president's feet.
SPEAKER_01Eliana, you saw Ron DeSantis today, right? Taking the first swing that, you know, saying that Donald Trump, if he's saying that it's Ukraine, if it's this, that, and the other that are raising gas prices, not Ron, he's gaslighting us. He was doing the thing. He was coming out and saying, here are all the, I mean, didn't totally surprise me. Do you expect a lot of Republicans to be coming out in the days following the results once they've all been counted? Alaska will probably be three weeks from now. But that will come out and say this president has made things worse and we have
SPEAKER_01to keep an arm's length.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I do think more Republicans will come out and start to say that because I think they're going to fear for their own political lives. I think the results of this election will have showed them that fealty to Donald Trump will not have made them safe. And Trump is a lame duck. The next two years are going to be impeachment, impeachment, impeachment. And he's exiting stage left. And I think the results tonight are also bad for J.D. Vance. He's going to have to account for them and struggle to do so, I anticipate.
SPEAKER_01That's good for America, right, if it's bad for J.D. Vance? I would assume so. I think that's good for America, Matt Wells. Mccarl do you think that's good for america I think
SPEAKER_03it's actually might be good for jd vance if it spurs him to reform his soul wow are you kidding me I look I found jesus I believe in he found jesus and I believe in the possibility of redemption all right he's the he's
SPEAKER_01beau french to his own wife he's I think I think, you know, life is long.
SPEAKER_03Too soon. The years are many. There is much time for him.
SPEAKER_01Wow. You are like the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi right now. Eliana, I want to tell you something that we have somebody who's just joined the panel who I know is a pal of yours and a pal of ours. We replaced one homosexual with another. Josh Bearer was out. Jamie Kerchick is in. Oh, hey, Kerchick. Hi, Jamie Kerchick. Hi, Mike. He's on the set there, too. He's on the set. He came. We couldn't get you.
SPEAKER_00Eliana and I were the same class at Yale together. Oh, gosh. 20 years ago.
SPEAKER_01Oh, everybody's in that seat. We just had our 20 years to go to school. Josh Barrow is talking about going to Harvard.
SPEAKER_00I've actually known Josh since we were 13 years old.
SPEAKER_01Wow. Did you guys come out together?
SPEAKER_00No, we were in some... You were like, what is happening? We were in some summer program. Some summer program. I know that sounds really cryptic.
SPEAKER_03It was run by the CIA.
SPEAKER_02Do we have video producer Jason of Donald Trump making some very new ideas about aid to Israel?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, why don't we get, we should get to that. Do we have that clip? Let's see. Well, Donald Trump thought, by the way, that if he blamed the Ukrainians for their own invasion, then maybe diesel prices would come down. That didn't happen. So he put his finger up to the wind and he said, oh, I'm surrounded by a bunch of anti-Semites. Maybe we can pull back aid from Israel. We'll say that Glenn Greenwald responded to this today and said, well, that's not all of it.
SPEAKER_01That's only the baseline amount. So there will be more and they'll find ways.
SPEAKER_00Well, Glenn won't be satisfied until the United States actually does nuke Israel.
SPEAKER_01And then he'll be satisfied. Let's play the clip of Donald Trump talking about aid to-
SPEAKER_00Trump says he's cutting off billions in U.S. military aid to Israel, and he claims that Netanyahu is also on board. Now, the United States gives Israel $3.8
SPEAKER_01billion a year to buy American weapons. That's a 10-year agreement that was supposed to end in 2028. But then Trump dropped this in a phone interview with Fox News.
SPEAKER_00It's a bad talking point because you say, why don't we give everybody $4 billion? Israel's our number one. We give them more than anybody else, and they no longer need it.
SPEAKER_01We give him four, he said four billion because Jamie couldn't hear. They no longer need it. By the way, Netanyahu prepared everybody for this a few days ago by saying something very similar. Jamie, Eliana, I mean, look, we just had our friend Jake Siegel on the show. He's been making a similar case with Leal Leibovitz. He wrote a very interesting piece about this probably a year.
SPEAKER_02I wrote it fascinating. It was a couple years ago.
SPEAKER_01A couple years ago, they wrote for Tablet. What do you think, Jamie? Let's start with you. Is this smart politics? Is this good policy? What do you think?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think Israel has been prepared for this for a while. I think it's actually the United States that would be losing out because then they would be losing out to kind of preferential access to Israeli military technology that they kind of already now have proprietary access to because of these military aid system that they have. But if that's what the two countries agree to, I mean, the case that Jake and Liel made is that Israel should have more freedom of action, right? And if it's not dependent on the U.S. in the way that it has been, Then they can sell to red China.
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, it won't have to listen to a future American president who says, don't go into RAFA or whatever, right? And so they can be more independent that way. But I think it's important to note, what I note is that- I thought they called the shots, Jamie. Well, that's, yes. And this is really what I'm about to say. I don't think that this happening will have one iota of difference in the anti-Israel left and right and their sort of attack on Israel. Because for years it was always, you know, why are you picking on this one country to the exclusion of every other country that receives American aid? It's because, well, Israel receives the most military aid of any other country.
SPEAKER_00I don't think that you're going to see that. Well, now it's Egypt and Jordan. By the way, Egypt was never far behind. Egypt was two billion, Israel was three. You never heard anyone talk about Taking the Egypt money away. So I don't I don't think that this is going to have any sort of effect on the Israel debate in American politics. I don't know if Eliana. What do you think?
SPEAKER_03I totally agree with Jamie. I think there will be a shifting of the goalposts. I mean, this supposedly is what the left has wanted. And I think there will be a shift to, OK, we don't give the aid to Israel, but there needs to be an arms embargo. And you're already hearing, you mentioned Glenn Greenwald, but there will be many others. Abdul El-Sayed, I predict, and all the others on the far left flank of the Democratic Party will say, this isn't good enough. We need an arms embargo. We can't sell any of our weapons to Israel because they are a genocide-er.
SPEAKER_03And so I don't think it's bad politics. I think it would be good for Israel. I think BB agrees with that. And I didn't disagree with the Jake Siegel, Leah Leibovitz piece. I have no problem if the U.S. and Israel go their own ways. And I agree with Jamie that it hurts America. This aid is money that we give to Israel to then in turn buy American weapons. So it's American weapons manufacturers and American companies that are whose bottom lines are hurt by this.
SPEAKER_01But I think that's an important thing to point out, right? I mean, the more extremes on this, and this would be the Abdul al-Sayed's of the world, and probably Daria Liza Chevalier, those people. It's the arms embargo is not American aid to Israel. It's American sales of anything to Israel, full stop, right? I mean, that's something that I don't think in this conversation is often highlighted.
SPEAKER_00No, that's the goal. And I think Israel has learned in the past three years that they need to build up their own domestic arms industry to prepare for such an eventuality. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_03I also think given that the relationship, the U.S.-Israel relationship has become such a partisan issue, The relationship itself has become less stable and more dependent on who the president is. When you can go from Barack Obama on the one hand to then Donald Trump on the other, such a contrast to what used to be a bipartisan consensus in American foreign policy that provided some stability to the relationship, that there was a realization on the Israeli part that the relationship can fluctuate
SPEAKER_03and change so much depending on which party controls the White House that something had to change here.
SPEAKER_01Eliana, tell us why Michigan is important. I mean, we have right now about 18% reporting with Abdul El-Sayed up about 100,000 votes. You know, we have it up in the big board here, 52, 45 more or less. I mean, it's early, but I assume that this is a race you're paying attention to. I know what you think about it. So why don't you just tell me why do you think that Abdul El-Sayed would be
SPEAKER_01a net negative for America and for the people of Michigan?
SPEAKER_03Sure. I mean, I think this is the marquee Senate race of the cycle. It's the only one, honestly, that I really deeply care about. I've said I would rather Republicans lose the Senate and Abdul El-Sayed go down in Michigan than vice versa. I think that he will be, if he wins, hands down the most radical candidate ever elected to the United States Senate ever. I think it's not about his anti-Israel view.
SPEAKER_03It's about his anti-American views. And the fundamental thing that I think came through in every interview he gave, in every campaign stop he made, was that he ran this campaign to Not running a primary and pivoting to the center, but making clear that he would not give an inch on any of his radical views to make a point to other Democrats that you don't need to cede an inch on any of your radical views. In order to win a statewide election in a purple state.
SPEAKER_03And this race is not just about Michigan. It is about a transformation of the Democratic Party. And he has said as much. He said, if I get elected, the next thing I'm going to do is try to take out John Fetterman. I want that ogre's head on a pike. And so I think for Democrats and for America, this is not just about the state of Michigan. It's about the entire trajectory of the Democratic Party over the next six years while he's in office.
SPEAKER_02How do you weigh that against the sort of Tucker Carlson, Groyper-ish right that's happening now, the horseshoe on this specific issue?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's a great question. I think what we've seen are on in the Democratic Party, these people running for office and winning and getting elected. Whereas on the Republican side, you have Tucker Carlson endorsing Abdul El-Sayed, but Tucker Carlson saying, I'm no longer a Republican. And being somewhat exiled from, well, self-exiling from the Republican Party and others who share his views, Thomas Massey defeated in a primary, Marjorie Taylor Greene out of Congress. And so I see Democratic leaders doing nothing.
SPEAKER_03In fact, Chuck Schumer... Denounced Haley Stevens for endorsing Mike Rogers. He's standing arm in arm with these folks as they increasingly take up more and more space in the party. While in the Republican Party, while there are certainly folks who espouse the same views, they remain on the fringes. They're not running and winning Senate seats and House seats in the same way.
SPEAKER_00Can I say one thing about the Haley Stevens reaction? Sure. Yes. I think this is a major moment for Jews in American politics because we have a candidate who is an Islamist or an Islamist fellow traveler. I think it's fair to say you look at all the Muslim Brotherhood connections, not just his family, but the funding that has come from care, people related to care.
SPEAKER_03He himself wrote a letter.
SPEAKER_00He signed a letter that was a pro-Muslim Brotherhood letter. He refuses to condemn the Ayatollah because his supporters will be upset about it. He refused to condemn the IRGC. This guy is a clear, you know, and the most heinous thing he said, of course, was after the synagogue was attacked. Hurt people hurt people. Which, by the way, was your best tweet of the past 20 years. Have you been tweeting for 20 years? Well, I said, this gets me to Haley Stevens. I said, when she decided to support Rogers, I tweeted, hurt people hurt people. And I thought what was very interesting with the response to her, not interesting,
SPEAKER_00just kind of horrifying, actually. I think it's I totally get why Democrats are upset with her. We live in a two-party system. It's partisan. You support whoever it is. Almost all the time, you support who your guy is, right? If it's a dog, you know, the yellow dog, you vote for them. What they didn't even show a scintilla of, why couldn't they have said to Haley Stevens, why couldn't they have treated her objections, which were not just her objections, the objections of a lot of Jewish people, Jewish Democrats in that state and around the country, were serious objections to him about antisemitism.
SPEAKER_00Why couldn't Chuck Schumer, of all people, have said, you know what? We recognize what you say, Haley. We agree that these are legitimate concerns you have with this candidate. We think Donald Trump is an existential threat to the country. And so we're going to support Syed. We're disappointed that you made this step. You're probably throwing your political career away, but we respect your decision. No, it was you are a crazy woman who needs to be checked into a mental hospital. You're being manipulated by your Jewish Zionist boyfriend. The New York Times thought it was necessary to insert in that story
SPEAKER_00that she's considering converting to Judaism. All these insinuations about her. And I think a lot of Jews were looking at this and saying, you really don't give a fuck about us. Really, you don't.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'll tell you, Jamie, you're missing something very important. A lot of Jews supported El Syed, included Jack Mioff. Yes. Yeah. If anyone has not seen the New York Times. The New York Times. Yeah. I thought it was Jack Abramoff. No. It was actually his cousin, Jack Mioff, who supported him. So we're very proud of the New York Times reporting that. We got a couple. We have a quickly... A flip. And I swear on my life, if Democrats run this table,
SPEAKER_01I am going to be under the table because Darlene Graham... Has lost her race for the Senate. Annie Andrews has, that is the winner, called by everyone at this point. You will have to finish your previous shots. She can't do that. She sipped. She smelt it. I'm going to keep going. She can go in the other room. She has no excuse. I don't drink. Yeah. Darlene Graham, her brother passes away, and then Donald Trump throws his support behind her when there's a lot of other capable candidates.
SPEAKER_01This is not only a repudiation of Trump when it comes to his policies, right? When it comes to the fact that everything costs more, whether that's because of tariffs, because of the Iran war, whatever. It's decisions that he's made which are going to echo for the next couple of years, at the very least, from Cornyn on. Everyone, I throw it to the table. What the ever-loving fuck was this man? This is the problem is that I think you were saying, somebody was saying, Josh Barrow saying, he's very good on the stump, he's comedian-like,
SPEAKER_01I think it was you. And yes, he's incredibly funny, but his political instincts when he's losing and when his, and you pointed this out on the show the other day, when his record is Is the one being prosecuted. He's absolutely terrible.
SPEAKER_02Political factions prove themselves. They identify themselves. They reveal themselves.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Wow. Yeah. Reveal themselves. We've been drinking a lot. We've been drinking and we're like holding off. It's a lot. About what races they're willing to lose. Trump was willing to lose Texas because he wanted to make his own party more Trumpy. That's it. The Tea Party was willing to lose Christine O'Donnell's seat. The DSA was willing to lose Florida. They could have won Florida today. They really could.
SPEAKER_00You think with a normal Democrat, what's his name, Vindman, you think he would have won? I don't know if he's normal. The Vindman family.
SPEAKER_02Very good on Kirby and Booth. It was the other one. It was him. It was him. So they fell on themselves. And Trump has repeatedly over the last 10 years, but more recently, more strongly, just said, look, it's more important for me that the party becomes more Trumpy than it is that the party wins. And as a result, what is the party now? The Republican Party. Some of you might have voted for the Republican Party in the past more often than I have. It ain't what you started to vote for at all.
SPEAKER_03Who isn't really a party, right? Like a party implies that there is some organization and some point to it larger than the guy at the top. It's just Trump. There is no Republican Party. There is no Trumpism beyond Trump. And everyone has been seeking this for 10 years. And there is nothing. There is just Donald Trump, the sucking vacuum that is going to pull everything in his orbit into its increasingly hungry maw until it is all destroyed.
SPEAKER_03And I don't know why Republicans-
SPEAKER_02Word like fingers.
SPEAKER_01By the way, it sounds a lot like those Nick Fontes videos that get served to me all the time. He's very angry about this. Jamie and then Eliana, and we'll let you guys all go. Jamie, the party now, what is it? Is there this husk of a Republican party that believes in nothing as far as we can see? How does it go forward from here? Come on.
SPEAKER_00I think there's going to be a lot of competition within the party. You're going to see these next generation of leaders. J.D. Vance, Marco Rubio, Tom Cotton.
SPEAKER_01Does it set Vance back significantly? Say that again? Does it set Vance back significantly?
SPEAKER_00I can't talk. I think it does set him back. Certainly, absolutely. It'll be interesting to see how he and his supporters spin this. You might see them saying, well, it's because of the Iran War, which J.D. opposed all the time. In which case, he served in the administration and he supported the policy, right? So it's going to be very hard for him to-
SPEAKER_01Probably defended it, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's going to be hard for him to weasel his way out of that. But I think it's, you're right, it's hard to think of another situation where a political party in my lifetime has been this sort of, It's just an open playing field here to construct a new vision of what the Republican Party should be. And I think we will see different types of ideas and ideologies. There is going to be a Tucker faction. There is going to be the old, maybe the kind of pre-Trump
SPEAKER_00I don't know how to say George W. Bush or H.W. Bush or Reagan. No, you think that's totally done? I don't know.
SPEAKER_02Both of those people will definitely be fighting for power.
SPEAKER_00Meaning that there's not many left.
SPEAKER_01Eliana, last word to you. What is that? You know, it's a very serious question. It's the last question of all time. We're going to shut the whole operation down after this. What has the party become? I mean, this is going to be a battle for the soul of the party. Where do you think it's going to go? We don't know.
SPEAKER_03Don't know, but the race for 2028 starts tomorrow. Good news, guys. And it is an open race on both sides. And I think it's going to be hotly contested on the Republican side. The bad news, I think, for the Democrats is that the far left did not get a real check in this election. And so it is going to be A vicious race on the Democratic side as well. But 2028 will be fascinating because it is a wide open. I mean, when's the last time we had an open race on the Republican and the Democratic side?
SPEAKER_03And I think it will do a lot to define the future of the Republican Party.
SPEAKER_01Eliana Johnson. Wow. Yeah. We just want to say her name. Let's say it again. We'll do it like we're in the whiff and poofs or something. In unison, Eliana Johnson, Editor-in-Chief, Rand Poobah of the Washington Free Beacon, who has done so much to get L-Side elected. Thank you. It didn't work. I'm sorry. We'll see. Jamie Kerchick. I don't even know what to say. You're everywhere. I'm an author. You're an author. You're an author. Pretentious asshole.
SPEAKER_01Megan McArdle, Washington Post, two podcasts. Guys, thank you so much for joining us. Appreciate it.
SPEAKER_02Let's reset here on this here podcast as we shuffle people out and in. We just brought the biggest purveyor of hate in modern American life, Nick Gillespie. What did you do today in the state of New York, Nick Gillespie? Well, I voted on Saturday. Okay. So I did a lot of work and I interviewed John Stallionno about, you know, why do some people prefer butts? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01You saw this election, Nick, which is the most important election of our lifetime, and you said, what does the butt man think about this? What did the butt man say? What did you take away from that conversation
SPEAKER_02with the great John Saliano, and this was maybe a first, but in that story, which is up at Reason.com. Hold on. Let's just one.
SPEAKER_01And then we're going to go right back to that because it's relevant.
SPEAKER_00Please come up, John. This is after John Gruden told me about him. So he's over here, I'm over here. And I'm studying his body. I've never studied the body of a man before. It's not my thing. Nothing wrong with it, of course. Nothing wrong with it. I always proceeded by saying, nothing wrong. But it's never been my thing, to be honest with you.
SPEAKER_02But it is now.
SPEAKER_00But I looked at his ass.
SPEAKER_02Yes, you did.
SPEAKER_00And then I looked at his legs and I said, his ass is like, it's like a pile of muscle.
SPEAKER_01Then I looked at his legs and I said, man, his feet are big. Then I looked at his shoulders and I tapped him on the shoulder and it actually hurt my hand. It was like a piece of steel. And he said, this guy's a monster.
SPEAKER_00And John Gooden told me that he was a violent tackler or this, that. But he never talked about it. He was an all-American football player. And by the time I finished with that story, he went from being 10 points down to being two points today. A poll came out. He's two points up.
SPEAKER_02Wow. You know, I just want to point out the Trump rallies, that two-drink minimum. That's the only laughter for the drunks in the crowd.
SPEAKER_01Jared Brown, by the way, I want to point out that a listener got very upset with you.
SPEAKER_02With me?
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes. I never said a goddamn thing about Sherrod Brown. You did, but you said Sherrod. Oh. And someone pointed, I said, oh, he's pronouncing it the black way. That was literally what was said. No, he's pronouncing it the Pink
SPEAKER_02Floyd way. Tell us more about the Buttman. So, well, okay, two things. One, He talked about, you know, when he started out in porn, he was drawn, he was attracted to butts. And then, you know, hence the Buttman series and everything. But he, and I've had other conversations like this where he said, like, it's just, you know, I was pre-programmed that he said that way, and the body doesn't lie.
SPEAKER_02So, and then he was saying, you know, like, whatever consenting adults is good. Do you know what he said? He's breaking radically with Russell Brand in that statement that he's sending adults.
SPEAKER_01It is 1036. I think that I can reasonably say that there are no children watching this, I hope. If you have children, take them away. There's only the bad ones. Yeah, well, take them away. But he said, John said this very famously to Martin Amos. Oh, yeah. And he opened his piece with a quote from John Saliano that we're going to bleep this. He said, pussies are bullshit. And then he goes and explains that the raw emotion is something else.
SPEAKER_01I don't know why we're talking about this. Donald Trump made us talk about this, but it's because of John Saliano. But that piece by Martin Amos is one of my favorite pieces of journalism when he goes to L.A. to investigate the porn industry and ends up with our
SPEAKER_02Our friend and pal and listener. Who is, you know, who is the Fellini of fetish. Yes. His four-hour fashionistas is the kind of—if Hollywood had followed, you know, kind of Last Tango in Paris and gone in that direction, it would have ended up in fashionistas. I don't want to overcook it too much. But the other thing, and this is more apropos of election night, John lives in California, his house burned down in the Pacific Palisades fire.
SPEAKER_02He's having a lot of trouble rebuilding because Karen Bass is terrible and Gavin Newsom and all the Democratic supermajority in California is terrible. And I said, what would make you leave California for a place like Texas or Florida where people are going? And he did not say ass. Yeah, which is what I would guess. Likes the quality of life he has in California and that the things he prefers there have not become so onerous that he would leave.
SPEAKER_02And it was kind of interesting. And then I said, well, who do you vote? Who are you going to vote for? And he's like, I don't know. I just vote for the libertarian. And it's not worth my time to learn anything about the other candidates.
SPEAKER_01I think there's some wisdom.
SPEAKER_02And it's kind of an interesting, you know, relationship to freedom because he has money, but he also has, you know, social acceptance, tolerance, etc. But, you know, and he hates regulation. He hates government in general, but he's happy in California.
SPEAKER_01Well, let's tie that to this race. We asked Greg Lukianoff this question about speech. About tolerance, government regulation, intrusion to our lives. I mean, we constantly hearing about things like flock cameras now. Is there anything, whether these are state ballot measures or just a shift in the balance of power in the Senate and in the House. That worries you or, you know, something that maybe is the opposite direction says, oh, this is actually better.
SPEAKER_02So two things. One is the ballot measure to reprohibit marijuana in Massachusetts is a bit troubling. It is The complete astroturf attempt to solve a problem that nobody really thinks is a problem. I don't think it's going to pass, but if it passes, that worries me because we're in the wave of an anti-drug legalization, kind of a soft pushback against it.
SPEAKER_01I know somebody who's a libertarian-ish guy. I wouldn't say he's publicly so, but you know him well, and I won't name him. Why not? But I asked him because he might hunt me down. Okay. But I asked him one night, this is about six months ago, and I said, what have you changed your mind on? What is the thing that you, you know, were ardently for, publicly for, that maybe now you've taken a few steps back from? And that was the one that he mentioned. And I'll tell you who he was afterwards, but he said, legalization, I thought,
SPEAKER_01would, yeah, of course he does. Um, I thought would be fine. It turned out not to be.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. It's just, you know, completely. And, and again, you know, I, I dabble a lot of drug policy and the sample. One thing though about it is that everywhere and including, you know, the federal government surveys show that like in places where weed is legal, teen use has declined, which was the big fear. You know, like once you make it legal, it's going to be like alcohol or cigarettes or something, which are also going down.
SPEAKER_02You know, it's like legal weed is not a problem. And people especially come to New York and say, you know, the real problem is the smell. Yeah, yeah, yeah. This fucking city smells like, you know, a fucking sewer. You know, and then people are like, oh, but you know, that weed smell.
SPEAKER_01New York Magazine used to have the smelliest block. And it was very rare. It was in China.
SPEAKER_02I think I live on it. Yeah, yeah. But so there was the Massachusetts thing. But then this larger thing about like, say, OK, Democrats take over. One thing I worry about has to do with tech policy because, you know, the AI guy. The Silicon Valley guys who know everything and should be running everything because democracy is bullshit and these guys are so smart all went in hard on Trump and Trump and MAGA is now getting its ass kicked. Democrats are going and AI and data centers are very unpopular.
SPEAKER_02I think there is going to be a lot of blood extracted out of AI and I think it's going to spill over to other types of digital technology. In a way that is going to be very troubling, ultimately for free speech and free expression.
SPEAKER_01Well, Nick, let's go big here. Let's go big because we have a flip. We have a flip.
SPEAKER_02Fill your fucking glass.
SPEAKER_01Fill your glass. You don't drink anymore. Fill with Diet Coke. First time since 1988 when Lloyd Benson won.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, yeah. So Tallarico wins it.
SPEAKER_01The Decision Desk has called it for Tallarico in Texas. That, ladies and gentlemen, is a very, very big call.
SPEAKER_02Now barbecue is banned. The barbecue is banned. Are you going to actually drink? I mean, this is the same one.
SPEAKER_01The meal will. Are you kidding me? I just refilled this. No, this is Hispanics being a block of voters, which is a meaningless designation, that went for Trump. And now we see he couldn't keep that coalition, right? Is that kind of, I mean, we don't know this yet, but I think that's probably right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I mean, this is what's frustrating is, you know, whatever was good about Trump. And I think in 2016, I think it was, was it in Chicago or Michigan or something where at some point, you know, in his smooth way, he was addressing a black audience and he was like, you people, Like the Democrats haven't helped you people, meaning blacks, right? Urban blacks in the industrial Midwest. You might as well try us. And he's good on school choice. He's good on a couple other things. He was able to ultimately, by not being such a horrible human being.
SPEAKER_02Get a fair number of Hispanic, particularly men and Black men, you know, this last time around. And he coughed that up because of the Heritage American crap, because everything he has done is to make life more miserable for people who don't look American. And he's, you know, he's helped destroy the economy. I mean, what... If you wanted to fuck the economy more, what would you do besides not just trade tariffs but then flip them
SPEAKER_02on and off every once in a while? That doesn't make any sense. Immigration, it's one thing to secure the border. It's another thing to start dragging people out into vans and whatnot. He's reaping what he sowed. Um, we have, uh, we have, speaking of. Somebody who knows this stuff very well. Trump. We have Rui Teixeira. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Do we have Rui Teixeira? My God. Oh, my God.
SPEAKER_02He's heavy on the very purple way. The colloidal silver. Yeah. It's very blue. Two of the four of us are just drunk and a third is getting there and the other one's a quitter.
SPEAKER_01Rui, the coming Democratic majority is coming right now.
SPEAKER_02Texas flipped
SPEAKER_01for, I mean, look, this is the first Democratic senator in blue South Carolina. What do you make of what you've seen so far, Rui Teixeira?
SPEAKER_00Well, boringly enough, I see this as a thermostatic reaction against the incumbent administration and Trump. I mean, the two big issues here are opposition to Trump and a sense the cost of living is not under control. And as Trump promised, in fact, out of control. So this is basically a huge rejection of Trump and everything he's done and stands for. That's really what it's about. It's not an embrace of the Democrats. Now I love the Democrats. They'll be my party forever. I understand what they want to do with the country and I love it.
SPEAKER_00It's more like let's get rid of these people. So I think that's really what it's about.
SPEAKER_01But really, is there a gap that is large enough that will make you say, actually, this is about a little bit more than Trump? Or do you think that this is just a rejection? I mean, we see this every time a president comes up against a midterm. Is there some kind of, I mean, I'm seeing some stuff that is, you know, look, there are polls that predict this stuff. I don't know how much stock to put in them, but they're pretty surprising.
SPEAKER_00Well, in terms of the results, of course, they're very surprising. I mean, this has been a In off-year election where you would have thought the Democrats would do well, but not this well, and in the states that they're doing, the Democrats generally also have an advantage in terms of the kind of coalition that shows up in these elections. They tend to be more educated. Democrats benefit from that. In fact, if you look at the exit polls, at least as far as we can see so far,
SPEAKER_00education polarization actually increased in this election. In a sense that college-educated voters moved even more. Toward the Democrats than non-college educated voters did. So continuing a pattern of many years. But yeah, no, I think it's fundamentally about disliking the incumbent party and what they've done, not just in the economy, but in corruption, immigration, and lots of other things, the tariffs I think you guys were just talking about. Basically, the concept in the mind of the media
SPEAKER_00and voter is these guys don't know what the hell they're doing. They're screwing things up. They thought they'd make things better. They're only making things worse. So, you know, why should I vote for members of his party? I will not. Tell us a little.
SPEAKER_02Do you think he didn't go hard enough on Houston's ass?
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, that's just part of the package, man. I mean, it's like.
SPEAKER_02Really? Seriously?
SPEAKER_00It's gone from charming to extremely just weird, you know? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's the quote of the night. It's gone from charming to weird. That's right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Okay. So also the thing, the long discussion with before and after pictures of the reflection.
SPEAKER_01We played a clip of that earlier. This is his final push is talking about the pipes in the reflecting pool.
SPEAKER_02Matt Welch, sorry. Just to say, what do you see early if we can see anything about the change in sentiment among the so-called Latino vote so far?
SPEAKER_00Well, we see, as far as I've been able to determine, the Latino vote has swung significantly back toward the Democrats, kind of like everybody else, but maybe more so, and particularly in a place like Texas, where it looks like there was a huge shift. I've got to dig into the data a little bit more, but yes, they swung extremely hard toward Trump in 2024. That was one of the big salient facts about that election, and now basically, Trump has given all those gains back. I mean, Trump assembled kind of a really interesting coalition, if you think about it.
SPEAKER_00Remember, people talked about the multiracial working class coalition, populist coalition that Trump had put together and essentially has blown it up in the course of two years. Now, again, I don't think those voters will necessarily stick with the Democrats because I don't think they love them. I think they just wanted to get out of out of dodge, so to speak. And we see actually there's some interesting data that suggests that Democrats are going to see this big victory as essentially a license to run even more. And more progressive candidates, which is not maybe the right lesson here.
SPEAKER_00If you want to keep these voters down on the farm, you should run hard at convincing them. You're really share their values. You're just aiming toward the center of the country. You just want things to get back to normal. You won't have any heroic plans to remake the entire country. You just want to make the country work well, govern well, make the economy work well. I mean, if it's the blowout that it looks like it's going to be, how do Republicans reposition themselves? The MAGA message is not working because MAGA is not working.
SPEAKER_01I mean, do we see something that is more of a pushback to, you know, sort of AEI Cato politics of 10 years ago? I mean, what what is it that that Republicans have to do to get these voters back on board?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, that's an excellent question. I've talked about it a lot with many people, including some of my colleagues at AEI, because you mentioned AEI. Yeah. I think, of course, in their heart of hearts, I think not everyone, but I think significant numbers of people at AEI would just love it if you could turn the clock back 20 years. And re-implement that kind of politics within the Republican Party. That kind of politics, can you be specific?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, because 20 years ago was George W. Bush who sucked and who got pounded in his second term. Well, I think they mean it in terms of more.
SPEAKER_00More economic kinds of issues. Back to Paul Ryan, not necessarily George W. Bush. Paul Ryan. And ideally even all the way back to Ronald Reagan. But that kind of small government, low tax, modest ambitions, decent governance kind of party. Now, you could argue that maybe they're being a bit too nostalgic about it, but it wasn't actually that great. But I think they would like to see the populism sort of burned out of the party. And I just don't think that's going to work because the party is so different now.
SPEAKER_00The base of the party is so different. The faith in limited government and low taxes and all that as an economic program is not high at this point. So to reimplement the Paul Ryan plan, I think it's probably not in the cards.
SPEAKER_02Is there any way the Democratic Party does something like that? If the Republican Party is now the Populist Party and it's just the party of handouts and entitlement and resentment, is there any way in which the Democratic Party, which is now more educated, becomes a globalist party of limited government, of free trade, of immigration, kind of regulated immigration, And laissez faire lifestyle. Certainly an opportunity.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, I'd be a little skeptical of that because I just don't think that corresponds to the mood of the rising forces in the party. And even on something like free trade, which has had a rebirth a bit among Democrats, but that's mostly in opposition to Trump's tariffs, not because I think they have a tremendously principled position on it. So I would be skeptical about Democrats, in a sense, changing places with the Republicans of many years ago and embracing that kind of program. I think that they themselves will have a populist Uh,
SPEAKER_00slant to what a lot of what they do in the near future, but I don't think it'll, it'll be, it'll be populism, just a different kind of populism than what Trump tended to practice.
SPEAKER_02But it does feel like there's, there's at least an opportunity for Democrats to do that. And I mean, there's a lot of enthusiasm around a candidate like John Ossoff, for example, and not even a candidate, a Senator who has again, won reelection and who's, who's governed as a moderate. And part of the reason for his prominence now Is because he resisted the urge to join a very popular rising wave with all of the woke one insanity. It's entirely possible that he moderates, that he sees the opportunity and the very clear lane to move towards a more moderate, sane, Constrained,
SPEAKER_02economically responsible type of governance and that even the party itself doesn't lurch at the opportunity simply to be punitive, to go after Republicans and collect scalps, but perhaps lays out a legislative agenda that even if they can't get it passed now could serve as the roadmap for a potential Ossoff presidency. I can at least hope for an outcome like that, that there can be room for meaningful moderation.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think it's the least possible. I mean, I think my moderate friends in the party really hope that that's the road that the Democrats go down, that they do use what power they now have to pass some responsible bills that would put their legislative agenda. In front of people, they would not sort of have a lot of show votes on very progressive pieces of legislation like Medicare for All. They would more like try to focus people like this is a modest thing we want to have done. And the only reason we can't get it done is because Trump just vetoed it.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, John Ossoff would be the bearer or maybe Josh Shapiro of that kind of politics. I just think that that will be very difficult in the context of the way the Democratic Party is likely to evolve in the next two years. I think the progressives are going to feel like they have the wind at their back, even if time is fully justified by the election results. And I think they will not, in fact, want to moderate particularly, certainly not in cultural issues and not really in economic issues either. So I think there'll be a real struggle. Between the two wings of the party,
SPEAKER_00and I predicted that my sense is that struggle will probably lean more toward the left than toward whatever passes for the center now in the Democratic Party. If someone like Ossoff, once he's in the context of a Democratic primary struggle, is Ossoff really going to lay down the law about how, you know, I think a lot of what my other Democratic friends stand for is completely ridiculous and stupid, and I'm totally opposed to it. I think it will be under enormous pressure. To actually take on board a lot of the things that that wing of the party says
SPEAKER_00and just try to titrate a bit of moderation into it. He's a good campaigner. He's charismatic. People like him, blah, blah, blah, and hope that's enough to get him the nomination and then general. But I don't see him being the guy who's going to Lay down the law about being a different kind of Democrat.
SPEAKER_02I mean, he did it once. He did it once. I mean, during the racial reckoning, he was one of the lone voices of reason. Very lonely position to strike out, to stake out as a Democrat. I think doing it here is certainly less expensive.
SPEAKER_00Right, right. Well, you know, we shall see. I wish him well.
SPEAKER_02I'm trying to speak this into existence. You got
SPEAKER_00If you wish hard enough, it will happen. Fingers crossed. I know that. Rui, one final thing.
SPEAKER_01We're going to keep hope alive. That's what Jesse Jackson said. Keep hope alive. Yeah. Keep hope alive. Is that his name? Is that Roy? Rui, before we call the Ohio governor's race, we've been paying a lot of attention to, it's behind us. I'm sorry to say that Girl Swing lost. I'm very happy to say that. But one final thing for you is we're talking about DSA type candidates.
SPEAKER_01A lot of them that we've talked a lot about on this show, the Daria, Lisa, Chevalier types will take their congressional seats because there's no opposition. It's in New York. It's in Hamilton Heights. It's in Washington Heights. The statewide version of that Is Abdul El-Sayed. We don't know which direction that's going. It's looking good at the moment for El-Sayed. So what does that mean for democratic politics if you have a guy like El-Sayed who said, I'm a capitalist, right?
SPEAKER_01I didn't believe him when he said it. And he said, I'm not a member of the DSA, you know, in name only. But if I win a statewide election that Donald Trump and his state that Donald Trump wins, what message do you think Democrats will take from that? And will they maybe lurch in a particular direction that I suspect you would think would be the wrong message?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I think moderates will basically try to point out he underperformed the ticket. I mean, he ran behind the governor, the editorial candidate, which is probably true, but it won't be that by that much, actually, it looks like. But I think the left of the party, as AOC famously said it, if Abdul can win here, we can win anywhere. And I think actually what would have been ideal for the Democrats is for the Democrats to run in these really red states with less flamboyant candidates and for Al-Sayed to have lost Because even though they would have lost a seat,
SPEAKER_00they more than would have gained it back with their other victories. And then they would have taken a talking point away from the left, which is going to figure to a large extent in the way they attempt to frame the election.
SPEAKER_01Rui Teixeira. Thanks. And all of your blue and purple glory, thank you for joining us at this. You look like a supervillain, but we talked about it to make you feel, yeah. Thank you, really appreciate it.
SPEAKER_00I'm going to go back to my layer and figure out how to think about it.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, Rui. Appreciate it. The great Rui Teixeira, we are looking at the outside election. 25% reporting. It is too early to call, way too early to call.
SPEAKER_02But it's close. And all those votes on the Edmund Fitzgerald. I'm worried when they're going to turn up. It is the gales of November right now.
SPEAKER_01Yes, the wreck of Edmund Fitzgerald.
SPEAKER_02But we have the race to call. We've got some news to spread. And is it sad news?
SPEAKER_01No, it's great news.
SPEAKER_02No, it's kind of great news.
SPEAKER_01It's the Ohio governor's race where Nick Lesby once lived. Yeah, for 20 years.
SPEAKER_0220 years. The Associated Press calls to governorship in Ohio for Amy Acton, which means that it's time to say goodbye to Vivek. Ramaswamy.
SPEAKER_01Good. Bye bye Vivek Ramaswamy, former guest on The Fifth Column. Yeah, that's what happened. We have a clip of Donald Trump that Matt called. What was this clip?
SPEAKER_02This is Trump pre-describing his loss.
SPEAKER_00The president always loses for whatever reason, the midterms, whoever it is, Republican, Democrat,
SPEAKER_01great president, lousy president. For some reason, I guess they've won two out of 25. I don't know. Oz, is there a reason you can think of medically? Why do people vote? There should be no reason. In fact, you'd think it would be an asset, not a liability. But presidents that go in, good ones, bad ones, Republicans, Democrats, they tend to lose the midterms. We'll see what happens. I do say this. When I was on the ticket, when I ran, we won everything.
SPEAKER_01We won everything.
SPEAKER_02So this means we're not getting the $5,000 check,
SPEAKER_01I guess, right? That's right. It doesn't make any sense to him that a person governing would get shellacked after two years of governing poorly. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Is that, is that, am I reading that wrong? But it is true that the second, the midterm of a two-term president, like the last, typically the party in power loses a lot. Mm-hmm. It's not always a wipeout, but it's typically— Clinton is the only exception, and that's because of the impeachment. The impeachment.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. But there's the interregnum, too. Right. You would imagine, from his perspective, that the— Well,
SPEAKER_02Grover Cleveland in his second term got shellacked in the midterm.
SPEAKER_01But you would imagine that in this case that Biden was such an— He was just a crappy president almost every way. Look, there's COVID. But the border stuff, which of course is Trump's strongest thing coming into this second term, becomes what? I mean, where are we ranking that on his I do this well? It's incredibly low because people do care about how you do things, even if it has the right—
SPEAKER_02Well, the border is one thing, but then interior— Correct.
SPEAKER_01There's that conflation of the fact that sealing the border was what everybody wanted. And Democrats wanted that too. And then the enforcement of people in the country then being performatively sent to third countries.
SPEAKER_02And no means of legal immigration. So we all have been part of this conversation where people are like, well, I... Love immigrants, but I love legal immigrants. And the idea is that when you seal the border, then you start the legal process by which people can show up and trumpet every knob he can turn to make it harder. White South Africans. Yeah, that's true. And they go right to Disneyland and they got a Space Mountain without waiting.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. No, but that, you know, and that thing, I'm forgetting the exact, I know you've covered this a lot, Matt, there were no, like, Christian refugees brought into the country like in the last year except for Africans. Yeah. I mean, and it's kind of like, wow, you're, you know, like you, you're supposed to be Christian, you know, Trump, you're, you represent Christians and stuff. You're not allowing anybody other than Africa. In 2015, when, uh, were you there too at, uh, at the Freedom Fest, uh, Donald Trump speech?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Um, In which I bravely wrote a headline of the Idiocracy Candidate. I think it was the first person to identify him with Idiocracy. It was only the third week of his candidacy at the time. And I say bravely, it was a shitty column with some funny lines and getting the whole country wrong in the process. But one of the things that he said there, he was bemoaning the fact that We are not accepting refugees,
SPEAKER_02Christian refugees from Middle Eastern countries right now. And it's like, that's a bad thing. And firstly, the reason why we weren't at that time accepting Christian refugees from Syria was that it takes a while in the process to vet everyone. And if you're like taking a while to vet everyone and not having everyone come in, Then it's just the minority who is Christian is just not going to get in. But then also second of all, and I pointed this out at the time, if you then do the policies that he's advocating as part of this,
SPEAKER_02which is shut off immigration from shithole countries, do a Muslim ban altogether, you're going to get zero. It's going to go from 111 to just zero. And that's exactly what has happened. And that line of argument has been dropped because people stopped caring about it and being able to use it as a bludgeon. But that's the natural state of being. And for me, there's many things to lament about the policies that have come about.
SPEAKER_02Bipartisan in the last 12 years, but among the top three is that we just stopped being a country that accepts refugees. We were always, always the country that accepts refugees, particularly if we have any hand in what happened in the creation of those refugees as we do with Vietnam, with Cuba and other places. Those people are like fantastic Americans when they come here. Like we've all lived around those places.
SPEAKER_02Like go to Westminster, California, which is a place at some point in the 1970s and early 1980s, like, oh my God, we can't assimilate these Vietnamese immigrants. They come from a shithole country, a lot of communists. They're not going to, it's not going to work out. And what do they become? Like the most like insanely.
SPEAKER_01I went to a John McCain election party on election 1916. I was in Arizona and I walked in there and I was like, is this a faux restaurant? Everyone was Vietnamese. They were all very pro-John McCain. Look, I think the thing that you can, so we're going to get into this recrimination phase pretty soon of what you take away from this, right? What does this take away from the mood and the politics of America?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I think one of the things that you can say is about immigration was that seal the border, the way this is happening is bad. I think that's a pretty basic thing. The poll numbers show that. These election results show that.
SPEAKER_02Maybe not the sealing of the porter, but the, like, grabbing of the wives of the military servicemen. Correct.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I mean, and then— Although, you know, as somebody who's only been to the airport in Minneapolis, like, do we care that they were shooting people in the face of their, like, nurses, male nurses who, you know, something suspicious. Who was the short Franco guy? Gregory Bovino. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Ashamed to be Italian.
SPEAKER_01Who showed up, like, it's funny, I don't know if you're actually just saying that, but the guy, he showed up at some far-right rally in Spain. Oh, really? Yeah, absolutely true. You can look this up.
SPEAKER_02This is probably in his Himmler duster that he was wearing. This actually, to go to fears of outcomes of this, is that there is a non-trivial part of the Republican, like the J.D. Vance world, that is Francoist. I mean, they are—and this is something that is, you know, co-equal with National Review being a place of fusionism and— Well, National Review is also a place of Francoism.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And it's like, I think the Francoist threat is real, where, you know, just people who don't care about the economy, and this is J.D. Vance, right? They don't care about the economy. We can, you know, we should be paying $60 for toasters, you know, made by prisoners in Louisiana, right? And I also don't believe the Pope. The Pope in Rome is a fraud type of thing. I actually worry about that because the Republican Party, and this was certainly true under Reagan, at least rhetorically, was a party that was open.
SPEAKER_02He has that famous talk of how you can live for a thousand years in France and not be French, but you can be here 15 minutes and be an American. That is, you know, we didn't know it at the time. That was the last gasp of that vision of America and of Republicanism of like, you know what, everybody, you know, as long as you, you know, work hard and follow the rules and don't bother people too much, you can be whatever you want. It's good America. And that's gone from the Republican Party.
SPEAKER_01Is it gone? I think it's gone.
SPEAKER_02Is this not a repudiation of this? No, I think, so this is what I'm saying.
SPEAKER_01I think that The repudiation, there's a couple of ideological elements to it. And I think the immigration one is pretty straightforward. But I think by and large, I mean, we've had conversations with a number of people tonight About will there be a snapback? I mean, Democrats saying, I care about tariffs now. This is bad as an anti-Trump point. We're going to move as an anti-Trump point. The party's not been there. Keeping in mind that the first version of this, when Joe Biden came into power in 2021, they kept all of Trump's It was like,
SPEAKER_01this is great. This is what we do. It's fine. And is the party doing this in an ideological way? Or is it doing it in a way that is just kind of for the moment and of the politics of the moment? I don't see too many things because there is such a narrowing of the gap between when it comes to like economic policy, right? The J.D. Vance gave you called who? Texas A.B. Calls. Okay. So Abbott is gone. Wow. And down the hill going too fast, trying to pull the brakes.
SPEAKER_01It's a whatever happened to baby Jane scenario.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. We also have Decision Desk Calls Kansas for Adam Hamilton.
SPEAKER_01Wow. Is that right?
SPEAKER_02We have a double flip. Is that true? Adam Hamilton is like the name of the hero of a late 50s Western show. Wow. Absolutely right. And also Ohio Senate, Sherrod Brown.
SPEAKER_01Sherrod Brown, Adam Hamilton, which is the one that I thought Roger Marshall, who is the incumbent here. These two guys. Who is a, like they are interchangeable in their utter tediousness and boringness.
SPEAKER_02Only one of them did the ad saying, Well, I only, like, put my patients into bankruptcy court. Yeah, that was great. That's a good one.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and he was like, but I treated people for free, but it's just required that we report them. We sue, like, 20% of them. Roger Marshall is somebody who, if it wasn't for this election, nobody would know he existed.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01He was a non-existent senator. We have a video of— Let's play the Roger Marshall ad. Let's watch Roger Marshall.
SPEAKER_00When I practiced as a small-town OB doctor, often serving
SPEAKER_03as the only OB in the middle of 40,000 people, my wife and I decided to take care of everyone, regardless of their ability to pay. We wrote off hundreds of bills monthly, and one of every five patients received free care. Now, to ensure that 40,000 Kansans would still have access to care, we did have to keep the lights on, so we occasionally handed some accounts over to a collection agency,
SPEAKER_00just like nearly every private medical practice does.
SPEAKER_01Bad ad. This guy's like, I'm going to look at your vagina and I might report you. I'm not sure, but like, here's my pitch. I was looking at money up there. I was looking up there and said, there's an old credit card. It was expired.
SPEAKER_02So I had to report them. He really should have gone with the other version where it was just talking about delivering kittens.
SPEAKER_01Oh my God. The best thing, that ad would have been perfect if at the end of it he had him like left-handed swinging a bat, like somebody who had some sort of congenital disease. Are you fucking kidding me?
SPEAKER_02I'll tell you what, obviously- At that point you wanted to pull back and he's on cantilevered legs.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. By the way, this is a big victory. We can look across the map of Kansas.
SPEAKER_02So this is like Alf Landon? This is Alf Landon. No, this is like how many years back do you go to get a Democratic senator?
SPEAKER_01In Kansas, I think it's the 30s or 40s. Look up last time. A Democrat won the Senate in Kansas. But you see, obviously, these blue bits here are, oh, we're having a low battery. The blue bits are, you know, college towns, et cetera. But Kansas also, you see some of these shaded bits here. This is a place, because Donald Trump sees tariffs in one direction. Is that it'll bring manufacturing back. These people in Kansas are selling things abroad, farmers are, to companies,
SPEAKER_01to countries who are then putting up tariffs where they can't sell their products. This is an own goal of own goals. Kansas lost.
SPEAKER_02Since 1932.
SPEAKER_0132. I said 30s or 40s. I wasn't.
SPEAKER_02Who was it? Who was it? Oh, really? It was Roger Marshall. Producer Jason says decision desk. Who's a little bit early.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Says what?
SPEAKER_02Dems have flipped the Senate.
SPEAKER_01Wow. There you go. That seems likely. Yeah. No, I don't. I truly don't see this as an ideological wing for Democrats.
SPEAKER_02Well, they're going to screw it up, too, right? Because as Rui Teixeira was suggesting, they're going to see it as—I mean, and this happens every two years. They see it as a mandate for whatever it is they think they believe. I don't know if most Democrats, certainly the leadership of the party— I think most of them appreciate that having the Michigan race center on a candidate who isn't actually a great candidate is probably a bad look for them.
SPEAKER_02Republicans would love for him to be the standard bearer for the party. I don't think they actually want that. I think there's a real possibility that it goes in a different direction. There's at least an opportunity for him.
SPEAKER_01I mean, Mike Rogers is up in Michigan now with only 31% reporting. The other thing, good lord, what is wrong with us? Abrogation of our responsibilities for not putting up the main race, 41% reporting. Susan Collins beating ahead against the non-Nazi Troy Jackson.
SPEAKER_02So 41%.
SPEAKER_01But we haven't seen the tattoos on its inner thigh.
SPEAKER_02It's the rising sun, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02She's the Yamamoto of, I'm running. You know, by the way, she's not that old. I mean, she seems like a thousand years old. She's like 71, maybe, maybe 72. Nick, you're getting a bit older, and so 71. John Saliano is 74. He's doing more dance classes now than a decade ago. I'm always groggy during that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that the Republicans are likely to have a more difficult time like holding together their party and staying on message as opposed to kind of descending in chaotic infighting that I suspect Democrats are going for. Well, the White House- That is my bold prediction, but I am also a little drunk.
SPEAKER_01But think of this, the White House in the first term- I've had two of them.
SPEAKER_02This is third. I know, but we have like three flips. We have to drink up. We have to drink up. Nick, I don't want to- You don't try to tempt him to drink. It'd be great if he went off the wagon tonight. Nick is strong.
SPEAKER_01As a celebration of America. This is it.
SPEAKER_02No, this is bad. My glasses are followed up. I can't read anything or see much.
SPEAKER_01No, I just want to finish this point before. I just want to finish him. This, by the way, is going to be the Foster Brooks
SPEAKER_02bit of the evening where I'm like, I don't know. But what's it he originally, like Huntley Brinkley reported? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Also, not a drinker. Foster Brooks did not drink. Was he like a medieval scholar?
SPEAKER_02Dean Martin, I've heard, was faking it. Yeah. I'm also faking it. What was his real name? Oh, God. What is Dean Martin's real name? It's an Italian name. He's from Steubenville, Ohio. God, I can't remember his name, but he changed it.
SPEAKER_01Again, this is why you tune in to this broadcast. I, Harry is a friend of mine. I love Harry.
SPEAKER_02Not his real name.
SPEAKER_01And I want to say this about Harry Enten. Is it the first time I saw him? And you're the only one that would appreciate this. I said to him, you look like an old ball player. He looks like a ball player from the 40, you know, with the, with the, hanging off the unathletic frame, but is hitting like 340. He was like Tris Speaker of CNN. But no, we have this. This is the race to watch.
SPEAKER_02More important, my favorite Italian who hid his Italianess was the actor John Saxon. John Saxon? I don't know. He was in Enter the Dragon. He gets beat up by Bruce Lee and Kareem Abdul-Jabbar. Played an Arab in Dynasty. Black Christmas,
SPEAKER_01Jason says. Producer Jason.
SPEAKER_02Just Google who John Saxon's real name. He never played an Italian. He played every ethnicity and probably a couple of outer space aliens. And his actual name again is like googly googly. Incredible. He died not too long ago.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, rest on me. I wish he could have been here to see these folks. Nick Gillespie, thank you for joining us. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Love to have you. So Rogers is up. We're close.
SPEAKER_01Rogers is up right now. On the big board behind us, Jamie Kirchhoff.
SPEAKER_00Where's Anna, whatever her fucking name is. Kasparian. She put her there. You see her today. What'd she do?
SPEAKER_01I want to talk about the real issues.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Anna Kasparin today has started her Tucker path.
SPEAKER_00Oh.
SPEAKER_01She said she now believes in Jesus Christ or cares about Jesus Christ.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01No. Yeah, no, no. It's on the party cam. Can we get the party cam up there? I think she's here.
SPEAKER_00Is she? I doubt it. No, I don't. She was on the show recently.
SPEAKER_01She was on the show recently. Not that recently.
SPEAKER_00A couple months ago, right? January. No? Oh, January. Never mind. No, January. Never mind.
SPEAKER_01And she made a little turn after that. She came on the show and she was like.
SPEAKER_00But she had done the before. You asked her about it. And she was pretending that she didn't know what it was.
SPEAKER_01No, she had no idea. She was like that. Yeah. That's just when you have to warm your hands when it's cold.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01And you're Jewish. Jamie the Jew? Jews are bad.
SPEAKER_00Well, the fact that the Islamist candidate, who would be the first Islamist elected to...
SPEAKER_01Oh, we didn't look at... Yeah, that's what we're talking about, aren't we?
SPEAKER_00No, well... You're talking about John Rosenthal, Texas Railroad? No, no, no. Sorry, I haven't been following that race so closely.
SPEAKER_01No, we didn't look at New Jersey.
SPEAKER_00Oh, Adam Hamawi. Well, there's no—well, he's the— No, there's no— I mean, I think they're both Islamists, and I've gotten a lot of grief for saying that, but— Oh, yeah. Do you want to talk about that? No, not really.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_00But, oh, if you want to talk about why they're Islamists, then absolutely. I mean, Hamawi more so than— Grief. Hamawi actually has worked for—well, first of all, he was a character witness for the Blind Sheikh, who was the guy who planned the first World Trade Center book. Yeah. Character witness for a master terrorist. Yeah. If you play in a bombing, does that mean you have no character?
SPEAKER_02If we're fair.
SPEAKER_00It wasn't just a bomb in the tower. They were going to bomb the Holland Tunnel, I believe. It was a whole citywide. No, they were very... It was like Bane. It was like Bane. Very ambitious.
SPEAKER_01It was like the ambition of that attack. Particularly when you're blind. You have to admire it. Yeah, he's like blind and shake. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, that's hard work is an American value.
SPEAKER_01Then Tryphus on earlier. Yeah. We almost had our former-
SPEAKER_02Dan Crenshaw, if he would ever show up to the- Dan Crenshaw.
SPEAKER_01We should have then done, these were one eyes, we should have done a blind shake afterwards. Oh my God. Great. That's it. Adam is running against Greg Melli. Yeah. That's a check mark. He's a perennial candidate. Yeah, so 70%. Right.
SPEAKER_00And then he worked, and then in the Balkans, he worked for a Muslim Brotherhood front group. Yes. And then in Gaza, he was working at the Hamad. And in Gaza he was working at a hospital.
SPEAKER_02And he refuses to answer any questions about his past. There will be people who say that the DSA squad in Congress only increased from two to eight.
SPEAKER_00Well, I'm actually, I think it's actually really good that the Dems got so many House seats because it means that they're not going to be beholden to the Hamas caucus. The James Carville point, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Right. It was also, somebody else made that point tonight, maybe it was Caputo. Marc Caputo, I think. Somebody else said that. We've been doing this for an hour. I don't know. I've been drinking for hours.
SPEAKER_02But also, there are much more than the six people who will adhere to the DSA, who are in the DSA. Yes. Yes. But it's like what? Twelve? Well, we're not really sure. How do you count people? Like Ilhan Omar is not in the DSA. Well, she's part of that conference. She's not. Part of that caucus.
SPEAKER_00Brad Lander is part of that caucus.
SPEAKER_02But are these people more or less influential in the party than they were, say, four years ago? Much more. Ilhan Omar? Maybe not in her particular. Not her in particular.
SPEAKER_00I will say the fact that her party is rallying around her, despite all this mishigas that she's going through. And I use that word deliberately. I don't know what that means. I don't see it.
SPEAKER_02Is there really a constituency within the Democratic Party, in the actual congressional delegation that is enthusiastically behind the idea of like an AOC presidency? Yes. Within the Congress. Within the Congress.
SPEAKER_00Oh, absolutely.
SPEAKER_02Really?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I don't know the numbers. Is it a meaningful percentage?
SPEAKER_01I know, but it's, again, not an ideological thing. They think she's a good politician. They think she presents well. They don't really care about that stuff. It's directionally close enough to them. But I wanted to point out something here. This is the Nebraska Senate race that I was talking to you about earlier. And 52% reporting, close enough not to call, but Pete Ricketts, who's the incumbent. And the weird thing about it, he has Ricketts.
SPEAKER_01What are they? British sailors get them. That is a shingles. Shingles, yeah. It's like a shingles kind of thing. But he is at 45 in Nebraska.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Good Lord. It's amazing he managed to win any office.
SPEAKER_00Dan Osborne is, I believe, a Morris Katz candidate. He is. He's a non-aligned. He's independent. Yes. But he was recruited, I think, by this Morris Katz candidate.
SPEAKER_02Morris Katz is vocal fry Graham Plattner. Yes.
SPEAKER_01Now let's check in again with Maine, 46.
SPEAKER_00This is the other race I was really enthused about now that I'm seeing this.
SPEAKER_01So let's talk about Maine. We have like, we're running out the clock at this point, 20 minutes. Maine, Susan Collins, who
SPEAKER_02votes with Trump
SPEAKER_0175%. And that's the lowest. Of all the Republicans. All the Republicans. The lowest loyalty. Lowest of them. And you see her in this map behind me, upstate as you get to Canada. It's very much her. The blue is a bunch of people from Massachusetts. Portland and people who moved to Portland, many of whom I know from Massachusetts. Troy Jackson is a fantastically bad candidate.
SPEAKER_01Like our friend Graham Plattner, who's behind us here, Where's the knot? Well, he got moved out, so I didn't put the swastika on his forehead. But old Totenkopf here. A bad candidate in a different way. When Troy Jackson was asked about Gaza. And he said, and somebody said to him, you know, well, when the Egyptians ran Gaza and he was like, what are you talking about? This is unfamiliar to me.
SPEAKER_01This was the version. It's like, you're not somebody's deceased person's sister, which is like what I expect in South Carolina. Right. He didn't know. And this is a Senate candidate. You're supposed to know.
SPEAKER_00I'm not surprised at all. Well, I'm not surprised either. Egypt occupied the Gaza Strip from 48 to 67.
SPEAKER_01It's like the same when you talk to somebody outside who has a sign. They don't know from what river to what sea. But he is not a skilled politician. The thing about Susan Collins, If you listen to her talk, she's been on every committee under the sun. She's very able. She's very smart about policy and about politics. You can dislike the positions she takes, fine, but she is not somebody that needs about four of those six years to figure it out. There's actually like she's fought Trump on certain things.
SPEAKER_00This race I care about for, I think, three reasons. One, Michael's from Massachusetts. We're both massholes. Susan Collins, she has been for several years. She is the last Republican federally elected official from New England. She is the last remnant of that New England liberal Republican tradition that you can really trace. They used to have it. All the way back. I think that's important. I think it's good for the Republican Party that they have a moderating influence like Susan Collins. I like the moderating info. She gave one of the greatest speeches in recent Senate history
SPEAKER_00on the Brett Kavanaugh confirmation vote. Go back and watch that speech. She was talking about due process and the presumption of innocence.
SPEAKER_01Which, by the way, she's been hit on endlessly. She destroyed her on this.
SPEAKER_00You go back and watch that speech. There's an anthology of great Senate speeches from the 21st century. That should be in it. Second of all, the Democratic Party in Maine deserves an effing fist in the face for nominating that piece of shit over there. What's wrong with him? Let me count the ways.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So the races that I care about most personally was Maine, Michigan, and Ohio, where I really wanted Ramaswamy to lose. Yes, which he did.
SPEAKER_01He is a piece of trash and he's gone.
SPEAKER_00What was the aspect of Vivek that you thought was the most? The advertisement that he... I mean, I found him just... I mean, Josh put it, you know, put it the best. He's the kid in section. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's like the most obnoxious person in your class. I mean, that was a very good description of him. Josh is very smart. He is very smart. I didn't know he was that smart. Let's not have him on the podcast again. Oh, we don't have him. We should have him. Never again. Because he really showed us up.
SPEAKER_01But he was like, you're pronouncing that wrong. And I was like, okay, cop. He's a narc.
SPEAKER_00He's a pronunciation narc. I think smarmy is the word I would use to describe the event. For Josh? No, for the event. Because it could go either way. I would pick smarmy because I think he's just a really smarmy individual. And he's just an oleagonist. Can I use that word, oleagonist?
SPEAKER_02Neil was mumbling defenses. I want to hear them. No, I just said I didn't always have a low opinion of him.
SPEAKER_01I liked him at first. But that was because he was, there's an, I think that, and it's hard to judge these things, The original Vivek, when he was like the, you know, Silicon Valley guy, he writes the book. And as we pointed out in the show a number of times, we had him on the show, is that he backed away from about a dozen things that when you flip through the book and pointed, he then no longer had those views because he was sucking up to the Trump people. And this is a great repudiation of people who sucked up to Trump for so long.
SPEAKER_01And I think there's a lot of people that They became brave when they were going to lose. Tom Tillis is a great version of that. And they lost that fucking seat to a Democrat by an enormously wide margin. Like we have 100% reporting there. What is the Cooper margin? It's fucking huge.
SPEAKER_00He's also a very conservative Democrat.
SPEAKER_01He's a conservative Democrat, but like you lost that fucking seat. Yeah. And because like, who else, Ben Sasse, Jeff Flake, the people we talk about quite frequently, is that those guys stood up in a time when it mattered and they're gone. Now, I am going to see, we're going to see, and we're going to keep track of this, of the people who do the DeSantis thing today. And DeSantis came out today and he hit, uh, Hubba, the fraud. Uh byron donalds uh who's oh what's happened
SPEAKER_01with that right do we do we actually have uh
SPEAKER_02those desantis clips so we have I heard that we had desantis
SPEAKER_00clips let's governor florida governor yeah bring him bring my dollars one wow david jolly lost we're
SPEAKER_02making who are uh in the administration uh trump was it through criticizing alina haba she's working for doj and she gets a 10 million And then the guy that gave it to her got a presidential pardon somehow. So I think we have to be the party that's saying, you know what? Our founding fathers believed you could have the best constitution in the world, the Declaration of Independence, if the people in office don't display some civic virtue about public service as a sacrifice. It's not to use the public office for private gain.
SPEAKER_02And we see so much of that in D.C. right now. We're seeing it at the White House. And I think when you look at if the democrats you know look I hope we keep the congress I mean I'm looking at the writing on the wall hope we do but wow I mean honestly
SPEAKER_01yes thank you because that's right good for him and we can't I can't say that he's a sleazy kind of guy who kind of does
SPEAKER_00meatball think meatball ron
SPEAKER_01Big fat bastard. I mean, Paul Ron is right, that guinea fuck. That's right. At the end of the night, we can call him a guinea bastard. He's right about that. He's right about all the other stuff he said, too, because he went after Byron. He went after...
SPEAKER_02He went after the gas... Republicans are saying, oh, well, the gas, don't worry, you know, it's not a big deal. Like, they're trying to blame Biden for it. no, no, listen, we just got to be honest. Gas is higher. It hurts people, working class people, and it's higher because of this conflict. That's just a fact. If you can't admit that to voters, then you're gaslighting them, and they're not going to listen to you on other things. So I think what's... Can we give him credit though?
SPEAKER_01Yes, he's right. But he's late as fuck. This was true a month ago. It was true two months ago. Look, here's the thing is that they're never going to fucking do this stuff on time. Tills is going to do it when he's not running for re-election, right? Yeah. He hasn't been running for real. We have given credit to people who have said things when they have decided they're going to vacate their seat. And we've always done that with an asterisk. We can do it with an asterisk. But he has not been running. It's important now that somebody fucking says it. Not only saying that, okay, your gas prices are higher, clearly it's because of Donald Trump.
SPEAKER_01And if we look at what Trump did in this last bit, was to blame it on the fucking Ukrainians. They're blowing up refineries in Russia. That's why diesel prices are so high. Therefore, the deliveries of Amazon are going to be no longer covered by Prime, whatever the goddamn argument was. It was a desperate last ditch thing. It did nothing. It did nothing that hurt the Ukrainians for a number of days, by the way, where people died because Elon, the sycophantic idiot that he is, goes and like,
SPEAKER_01well, we're going to slow down They're Starlink connections. So those drones don't work. They have to work at a certain speed. They don't work. People are dying because of it. These motherfuckers are killing. They killed Ukrainians doing this. And I'm not going to get into the idea of USAID and all that stuff. I think these are sort of overblown numbers. But they're doing things in political ways that have direct harm to people. If you do it now, it's better than not doing it at all. And we can asterisk and say, okay, you should have fucking done this last week.
SPEAKER_01Of course, I agree. He should have done this a year ago. But what that says to me is the party is changing because they finally are this iron grip of this halfwit. Who has done things that are so unbelievably stupid from tariffs. Like this is that these are not Republican policies. They're not free trade policies, not free market policies, right? How many companies do we own now? A share of them. 34. 34. And the Tea Party went to the ramparts over the cash for clunkers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. As they should have. They should have. They were right to do that. We were talking about this the other day. The Swedish government refused, with Bhaskar, refused to bail out Saab. They said, no, go away. Saab then became a Dutch company and a Chinese company. We don't do that. The socialist government didn't do that. But this is the beginning of snapping back to policies that are halfway sensible.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's not going to snap back, dude.
SPEAKER_01I don't, with Republicans, if this is the result and this is the way that you lose, maybe this will say, you know, we need different candidates. We don't need bad performative Vivek candidates. He's a performer and he's a fucking moron. He's a smart guy, but he's a moron politically.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Because he's like, I'm going to just do, I'm going to do my Trump impression. I'm going to try to be tough and I'm going to, you know, insult people on the stump. There's one person that can do that effectively. It's Donald Trump. All of these cover bands, they can't do it. Maybe.
SPEAKER_02Which was a point.
SPEAKER_01These are bad cases. People are losing our bad fucking Canada.
SPEAKER_02But also maybe Trump is like a one in a million. Yes, he's sui generis. Yes, of course. And so everyone's been trying to backfill him. And like DeSantis said this in his interview, in a few interviews he's given over the last 24 hours of like everyone projects their feelings on Trump. And those feelings are divergent. They don't match up. And, and so people in his wake are like, okay, well,
SPEAKER_02I understand what Trumpism means or MAGA means and it's this. And like, you're just making that up. And it actually, it's not, it can't be true. It actually can't be true because it is the magnetism of this performer who has a preexisting relationship with the public that can't be replicated.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02J.D. Vance doesn't have that magic wand. And so there's a part of me, and I will confess to this, that looks forward to the humiliation that J.D. Vance is going to experience over the next two years.
SPEAKER_01Why do you not want to admit that? I'm going to sleep so well tonight knowing that he has a little bit of humiliation.
SPEAKER_00Uh-oh, bad news from Michigan.
SPEAKER_01Uh, this, okay. So like, before we get out of here, we're not going to get, uh, Alaska mission is going to be a long night. Uh, the same thing with Maine. They're slow. We have Fox saying that I'm flipping. That is, I think we're there now. We are also at 1% battery. Yeah, so we have L-side at 50, my card is 47, that's 43% reporting. This is a toss-up at the moment, but Senate looks like it's going to be in the hands of Democrats,
SPEAKER_01House in the hands of Democrats.
SPEAKER_02True tests for polymarket there.
SPEAKER_01We will see races that we want to look at and then we'll look at these. Uh, next time we sit down here, Asian LA mayor race. Yeah. Well, Asians, number one, uh, that might be LA, uh, uh, Colorado, uh, with this idiot DSA lady, Colorado. It's going to be what we expect. Um, Alaska will be the big one. That's going to be the one Trump hones in on. Right. Because of some shitty politics.
SPEAKER_00What's been, do we have any, there's not even exit polling yet?
SPEAKER_02The Dan's solving, but like the, the, the ranked choice voting is going to. Oh, there, they don't, they don't.
SPEAKER_01There's no, no.
SPEAKER_02Fox News right now is projecting that Democrats will win at least 51. Okay. We have 50 already. 51.
SPEAKER_01But we have 50 right now, 50 now in the House, um, called already 145 to Republican 99. I'll tell you what, this is going to be my final, I'm going to sign off on this. Um, perhaps this will be a wake up call for a party That decided to behave, act, and be ideologically aligned with the party they're trying to defeat tonight. And that is with tariffs, that is with bad economic policy, that is with a rump of the party that thinks of American foreign policy
SPEAKER_01in the same way that Abdul Al-Sayed does. If you want that party back, this is the beginning of it. Tonight, any semblance of that party back The party that lost tonight is the party of Donald Trump. And the party of Donald Trump came into this second 2.0 with a mandate that they thought was the mandate for everything. And they staffed it with all of the psychopaths and sociopaths they could find. There were no H.R. McMasters. There were no people checks on this stuff.
SPEAKER_01And this was the result. Exactly when you came, you governed for two years, and this is what you got. You lost the House. You lost the Senate. Greg Abbott, by the way, I talk about bad candidates. Greg Abbott's not a bad candidate. He's a decent guy, done decent things. People like him. But the absolute rejection of what this party has become is full. It is complete. And that is the lesson tonight. I want to thank everyone for joining us tonight.
SPEAKER_01There were a lot of stupid live streams, but none of them were as stupid as this one. Not as dumb. No, that's where I was going. If you thought you were fucking with me, that's literally what I was going to say. We drank a bottle of the Lord and many... How the fuck did we do that?
SPEAKER_02I mean, by you not fucking draining that glass.
SPEAKER_01No, Malort was drained. This is our sponsor, Macklo. You have a sponsor now. We have a sponsor now. Fairfield University, we're going to be there. Go to the website wethefifth.com or wethefifth.substack.com with our special guest, Yemisey. And you know what? The confidence. Because if you can't pronounce her last name, she's Prince. She's Yemite. Who went in hard on Abdul Al-Sayed.
SPEAKER_01And all the people on her own side fucking hate her. She'll be joining us. Maybe we'll get protested. We hope so. So we'll see you in Fairfield. Thank you guys for joining us tonight. This was a marathon.
SPEAKER_02Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_01Very, very late marathon. We've got a bunch of races to call and we'll be back with you very soon to talk about those races. So to Jamie Kerchick, Camille Foster, Matt Walsh, what's your name, Matt Walsh? You fucking went there. Matt Walsh, who's going to figure it out. Don't laugh. Don't you fucking laugh. Watch his film on YouTube. What is a woman? I heard Charles de Gaulle over there fucking laughing. Why white is all right. Jamie doesn't know the answer to that question, neither does Matt.
SPEAKER_01Definitely do not. Bye, bye, bye.
SPEAKER_02We know of new methods of attack. [music]
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.wethefifth.com The most energetic man at CNN has the habits of an 87-year-old Jewish grandfather -Harry’s enormous wallet of $2 bills -Neil Sedaka’s nepo...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.wethefifth.com/subscribe -The United States is falling apart at the infrastructural seams -Is...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.wethefifth.com A YUGE thanks and our sincere gratitude to Fairfield University for hosting us, and to the students and faculty who joined us for the...
This is an audio excerpt from The Fifth Column live in Philly. You can watch video of the full event at wethefifth.comArt historian Erika López Prater joins The Fifth Column live at FIRE's Soapbox conference to explain...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.wethefifth.com/subscribe You have one last chance to go to Connecticut and see the guys, LIVE, on...