Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Fifth Column

The Fifth Column artwork

How to Save the Media (While Drinking Heavily) w/ Hamish McKenzie #584

Nov 18, 20261 hr 16 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.wethefifth.com/subscribe -The United States is falling apart at the infrastructural seams -Is something sinister behind all these technology breakdowns? -Hamish’s complicated relationship with Elon Musk -“A total piece of shit” -Why Hamish started Substack and turned down $150 million -Substack’s early existential crisis: Nazis, censorship, and angry writers -Richard Hanania -Can Subs…

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Elon? Elon. I think the full quote was, no one should trust Hamish Oathbreaker McKenzie. He grossly and deliberately violated his Tesla NDA. He's a total piece of shit.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Wow. We know of new methods of attack. [music] grave. Oh, do we not pay you enough as it is? Yeah. That's a sponsorship man. Man! We're going to get that percentage down by the end of this recording. Okay, let's work on that.

SPEAKER_02We actually, Hamish McKenzie, brought you here for a serious reason, and the smile's going to go away from your face. Oh, no. I imagine. This is based on your book, How to Save the Media, and a deep reading of it. You need an intervention. I do. You do. You drink all through this book, Seymour Hersh gives you like a- 12-year. Macaulay Culkey. Yeah, you're like a 12-year Macaulay Culkey. You're like at a TED Talk.

SPEAKER_02That sounds very weird.

SPEAKER_03He did not give you a 12-year-old Macaulay Culkey. That was Michael Jackson.

SPEAKER_02Your hands were shaking, obviously, before a TED Talk. Yes. And you're like, all right, who else is drinking? Everyone's like, no, I'm doing a TED Talk. But you can go ahead and you just drink your face off.

SPEAKER_03Defend your alcoholism in this book. Thank you. You know, you don't have to tell people that.

SPEAKER_01No. Well, I was trying to appeal to writers and I know the culture. Well, cheers. This blackcurrant juice is going to go down beautifully. You know what, though? I had more booze in the book, and one of my friends who read it said, you know, some booze is good, but maybe this is a little bit too much booze. And so I very artfully excised those sections.

SPEAKER_03I felt that it was very much in knowing you, that it's kind of the you that I know. That's concerning. Because the last time I saw you, You happened to be taking a table. Do you remember? I put my hand in the drink. I need to stop drinking. You were taking a table that I was vacating. Yeah, at finales. Yeah, yeah. You had seen a better evening. In recent times. Thank you. Yeah. I appreciate that. But you looked like you were having a lot of fun. I was. And you said, I had a book coming out and I was like, what? Yeah.

SPEAKER_03What language is he speaking?

SPEAKER_01You were like, we must get him on the show. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And then I tried to move us back to Patreon that night.

SPEAKER_01Did you? Yeah.

SPEAKER_03It just made it, it was hard. Yeah. I'm glad that the typical barriers were immense. We've done a good job of that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we've done a good job of that. Yeah, well, I do spend a lot of time having drinks with writers and creators and media people. It's important to my job. It just helps make the conversation a little bit easier sometimes for them. Obviously, for that. But as I have moved further into my life, I'm trying to moderate this a little bit as I moderated it with my editing of the book in response to my friend's demands. Trying is doing a lot of work in that sentence.

SPEAKER_03Trying. I did say before we started.

SPEAKER_02The book was to show the books as producer. Did you show the cover? Yeah, yeah. How to save the media.

SPEAKER_01Just show it on the inside because then people can see there's words in there.

SPEAKER_02They're like in 38-point type here. Yes. We had to spread it out. Yeah, that's fine. Hamish McCants.

SPEAKER_03No, I did say I wasn't going to drink.

SPEAKER_02You did say that.

SPEAKER_03And I said the same thing last night. Yeah. And the peer pressure, I am so susceptible to peer pressure. So now this would be my third straight day. And it's Tuesday. It's Tuesday. Sunday and Monday. Last night I was like, I'm fine. I got on the train and I was like, I don't feel great.

SPEAKER_01I made it, and I'm here, and I'm drinking again. What were the nationalities of the people who were forcing you to drink last night?

SPEAKER_03They were all English. Yeah, I think that's a factor. Every single one of them was English. Yes. And they actually stopped. But once I'm going, I'm like, nobody else? I was getting the final round. I was like, oh, we're good. And I was like, that's fucking dumb. And I kept going. And then they left. Well, it's impressive to see you here at the early hour of 5 p.m., Yeah, yeah. So can we talk about a couple things in the news before we get to your book?

SPEAKER_02Because then he can explain those things. Yeah. I can say how to save it.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, because everything seems to be under attack, Hamish McKenzie. Every time I turn on the TV, as Norm MacDonald would say. Another thing in NSA today, their internal network, which, wait a second, how are they getting to the internal network? And as our friend Jonathan said, this is the secret organization. How do we know about this? What are you talking about? You didn't see this? Oh, my God. Yeah. The first thing to save the media is to start reading it. That's the first thing. I've been busy. Number one.

SPEAKER_01I've been doing meetings.

SPEAKER_03No, all of these things, the plane groundings because of supposedly a router, banks offline. So it was like Chase, I think, in Wells Fargo. NSA's internal network. United Airlines. United Airlines, another second grounding. But the NSA responded and said in the Washington Post reported this, we were just applying an Scheduled routine maintenance is the phrase they use. And it's like maybe you should fire some people because if you have scheduled maintenance and it's already at CNN and you work

SPEAKER_03at the NSA, something is going wrong.

SPEAKER_00My suspicion, strong suspicion, is that there is just a hysteria at the moment and everyone is panicked and is looking for these things and someone mentioned, oh, look, there's the down detector website. We can just go there and find things and...

SPEAKER_03Well, can I tell you another reason why there's hysteria? Can we grab this clip here of the great Mark Wayne Mullen? One word. One word, Mark Wayne Mullen, who is- Mark Wayne. I just want to say is a genius. Yeah. And this was him last night addressing this issue- Soothing the nerves of the nation. With the guy who throws the footballs. Yeah. Well, I said, I said, what could be causing all these separate allergies? And he says, I believe that it's the SI. He said, because these programs aren't designed to work as fast as SI is.

SPEAKER_03And so when they contribute, or when they put in a program that's able to write codes and it goes in, it self-fixes itself. As it starts to self-fix itself, it's like doing a change order on a house. When you change one thing in a house, everything else starts changing. That's a ripple effect.

SPEAKER_00And it causes these systems to be overran that weren't designed to run as fast as the SI technology is today. That was the conversation I had today. That kind of makes sense to me because...

SPEAKER_03Does that make sense to anyone else? It was overran that itself fixes itself.

SPEAKER_02And we missed the three seconds where we said, I was talking to a guy.

SPEAKER_03I was talking to a guy. The guy was like a tech guy and he's like,

SPEAKER_00Secretary of Homeland Security goes on national television and starts speculating wildly about AI being responsible.

SPEAKER_03No, S.I. S.I.

SPEAKER_02I mean, why do you think that he's speculating? I mean, he has more knowledge than we do. He's got the computers right there. No, obviously he does. He's got them. He's got them. He's got the clearance at one point? I think so. He was Joe the Plumber in his previous... Let's not denigrate plumbers.

SPEAKER_00No, no, but I don't... Not every plumber goes on to become Secretary of Homeland Security.

SPEAKER_03No, but do you want the guy who's trying to... Assuage our fears about an Iranian attack saying, you know, it's like the house. When you change something in the house, all the other shit has to change. It's like, what are you talking about?

SPEAKER_01When the house can self-improve. Yeah, because it can self-fix itself.

SPEAKER_03And SI, I was like, okay, I had no idea what they were talking about.

SPEAKER_01SI.

SPEAKER_03Super intelligent. Super intelligent.

SPEAKER_02Oh, so you've bent the knee, sir.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, of course I'm from Silicon Valley. I have to. Which is a little north of the Gulf of America. It is. But I love that this administration and these utter incompetent boobs that populate it are so obsessed with language. And I saw a previous clip of him when somebody said AI and he said, this is in a news conference, and he's like, we call it SI. And it's like, I'm glad this important matter.

SPEAKER_02They're doing the pronouns. Yes. They're literally fucking doing the pronouns.

SPEAKER_03The they, thems of the SI.

SPEAKER_02What has Substack done to harden itself against these outages? Language.

SPEAKER_01Oh, with language? No. What has Substack done? We've done, I'm sure that the engineers are self -segregated on all sorts of things. He goes to house and change the pipes.

SPEAKER_03And now my second question, do you actually work in Substack? Substack, I'm vaguely aware of that. He's writing a book.

SPEAKER_02If you've read the last chapter, it's like... Yeah, so sure! He can walk with me. Thank you for making it to the last chapter.

SPEAKER_01Maybe Substack is blogspot. The engineers are always in there with the code, you know, Switching one foundation for another, putting in new beams. And so far, we hardly ever break things. When things do break, it does make us look bad. But they're mostly on top of that.

SPEAKER_03Well, I want to follow this up with what Donald Trump said. And here is the most interesting thing about this. This was posted by the White House. The White House, okay. This is a 10-second clip. It was posted by the White House today.

SPEAKER_00Are you concerned about all these outages? Microsoft, FAA, United, the cheese thing?

SPEAKER_03It's like when you're big and powerful and you have all the money. Things like that happen is fine. Posted by the White House.

SPEAKER_01Impressive.

SPEAKER_00Camille approved. That's actually it. That's a great, when you're big and you're powerful and you have all the money and things like that happen, it's fine.

SPEAKER_03Mr. President, go out and sue their jangled nerves. I am going to say that all the time from now on.

SPEAKER_01That does seem aligned with your theory of like this is just normal business.

SPEAKER_00In general, it seems that way. Yeah. There's no evidence that there's anything else going on.

SPEAKER_02Not a little piece of you is sort of suspicious. Of what? Of like the weird things seem to be happening a lot with computer systems of large things causing stuff to happen that almost never happens.

SPEAKER_00We're paying special attention to it at the moment. There does not appear to be an actual unusual trend here apart from the fact that the media is reporting on outages that last maybe a couple of hours.

SPEAKER_01Well, there are three things and as soon as three things happen, that trend.

SPEAKER_03Second grounding of planes, or the third, since 9-11. It's not like this kind of thing happens often. And they were like, oh, it was a router in Alabama. And it's like, even if that's true, that's a big problem. That we have an old Atari 2600 in the woods in Alabama that's running all this stuff. And Mark Van Mullen, that cannot inspire confidence. These are the people, and if anything... Is this not inspiring a group of, like, bored North Koreans to be like, these are the guys.

SPEAKER_03This is easy. That's the guy.

SPEAKER_00This is what happens when you lose Elon. He's no longer a doge. Oh, because he did so much good.

SPEAKER_01He was doing all the security patching before these guys.

SPEAKER_02How was your relationship?

SPEAKER_03Sorry, who are you talking about again? What did he call you, the underachiever? The underachiever? Yeah, what was the name he called you? Oathbreaker. Oh fuck no! I call you The Underacheriever. What did you do to Elon?

SPEAKER_01I did nothing to Elon except I tried to write a book 10 years ago that was about how Tesla was catalyzing the electric car revolution. And my initial plan was to- It seems like a good thing.

SPEAKER_00It was, yeah,

SPEAKER_01even- Even its worst-for-him version of it was going to be great for him. Yeah, but my initial plan was to write this story about how Tesla is changing the world based on, in part, on my experience at the company because I used to work there. And he didn't like that bit. And so I had to end up writing that book as if I never worked at the company. Yes. And he's still upset about it. The oath is what? The oath was... In India. I shouldn't... That's what he... Yeah, so there's... Contestable claims about the very existence of an NDA.

SPEAKER_01But I didn't break anything, but he's using that as his control.

SPEAKER_03But you didn't actually have an NDA.

SPEAKER_01I think I should be careful about how much you say on the record. Sorry, he doesn't have a lot of money. I very confidently say I didn't break it in the air. He's like, very cool. He's the earthbreaker. Yeah, he is the best. So my name... Yeah, my name is Hamish Oathbreaker McKenzie now, and I will only respond to such.

SPEAKER_03Okay, so listeners, viewers, you have a choice of two nicknames for Hamish. I added a third, the underachiever. Underachiever is interesting. And then the other one, which is more of a sentence, but Vanity Fair, he said, what about you?

SPEAKER_01Elon? Elon. Oh, yeah, sorry. Okay, the other thing. So I think the full quote was, no one should trust Hamish Oathbreaker McKenzie. He grossly and deliberately violated his Tesla NDA. He's a total piece of shit.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Wow.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00That has not been my experience. Total piece of shit. Really? Yeah. Just partial?

SPEAKER_03Not most of the time. But there were threats, lawsuit threats.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, when I was trying to write that book in the first place 10 years ago about how Tesla is changing the world for the better, Elon responded by getting his lawyers on to me. They're the same lawyers who had previously defeated Enron. And I was an individual writer by myself, paying a lawyer I couldn't afford. That was $430 an hour. And so I could resist up to a point. But your public defender was not confident that you were going to get through this. No, my lawyer wanted me to keep going.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, sure. And I thought, well, I also got dropped immediately by my publisher at the time who got scared by the cease and desist letter that the Enron defeating lawyers wrote to them, painting me as a fraud who stole secrets from the company. Who was the publisher? Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.

SPEAKER_03Wow, you don't mind throwing them up.

SPEAKER_01I put it in the book because I don't like how they backed off.

SPEAKER_03Wow. They literally dropped the book.

SPEAKER_01Immediately, yeah. They didn't ask me to explain myself. They immediately just got the cease and desist letter and they're like, all right, we will cease and we will desist. They did, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Did you have to pay the advance back?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Really? So you get paid in advance in four stages. The first one I was living off, but then they demanded it back. And so my agent and I sort of worked out a plan to pay them back in installments, and it ended up being contingent on how much the book ultimately sold. If I earned out the advance, I'd get to keep some of that. So it wasn't quite the full amount in total, but they fought for it to get back.

SPEAKER_03I would have said, fuck you.

SPEAKER_01I wanted to say that too.

SPEAKER_03But your $420 full stop lawyer, I don't think it was an hour. An hour. I don't think it was an hour. I was able to pay for one hour. Some guy lurching through the tenderloin. He was like, I can do it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, he's better than that. Yeah, but he was an employment lawyer rather than a free speech lawyer. And if I got to do that over again, but he's the lawyer I knew at the time. I wasn't deeply connected or anything. And eventually I just wanted to get the book out and not be dissuaded by the legal threats. And so I wrote a different book that made the same points, told a similar story, just pretended as if I'd never worked at the company.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. But now we know. Now you know. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I can tell you guys everything now.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So like you didn't literally pretend you never worked there. You just didn't.

SPEAKER_01I mentioned that I worked there, but yeah, but I wrote it as if I was a reporter with a distant perspective.

SPEAKER_03So it was a deeply dishonest book. No, it was a very honest book.

SPEAKER_01It was less juicy than it otherwise would have been.

SPEAKER_03And then you said, hey, I need to save the media.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that was my next statement.

SPEAKER_03That was your next step. What year is that?

SPEAKER_01So I finished writing the book just before Chris and I started Substack together and convinced Jaraj, the third co-founder, to join us as soon as he could. So 2017. And yeah, I thought I'm never going to have to talk to Elon Musk again or hear from him again after this kind of two years of trauma. And then he turned out and bought Twitter and tried to acquire us. And we said no. So he declared war on us instead and started blocking Substack links everywhere. Which still exists, right? You cannot...

SPEAKER_01No, it's got better actually. Nikita Beer came in and fixed a bunch of things. And I think we've moved down Elon's kill list. So yeah, he's focusing on other enemies at the moment.

SPEAKER_02What was the high water mark on the Musk offer? Because you were offered to, Twitter wanted to buy you before that as well. So talk through those numbers so everyone can salivate.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, so early 2021, I think Twitter offered $150 million to buy Substack and We said, no, it's not. We weren't interested in sort of. How much of that would have just ended up in your pockets

SPEAKER_02at that time? Like if you had to do the calculation ever thinking about real estate.

SPEAKER_01Double digits millions. Double digit millions could have been in your pocket right away. Yeah. I think it would technically go to a bank account. That's too much for the pockets. Your MC Hammer pants full of cash. So Yeah, so that was a tempting thing. And, you know, there are lots of synergies between Twitter and Substack, especially in those days. And there are arguments for making it work. But ultimately, it's built on a model that we're trying to provide a counterexample to. So it didn't make sense for us.

SPEAKER_02Explain that because that's a key theme of the book and a key theme of kind of your existence in some way, the difference between an advertising algorithm model between subscriptions. Why does that mean so much to you?

SPEAKER_01We started Substack in 2017 out of frustration with the state of the discourse, the state of the media economy and the culture because of the incentive system of social media, which is the dominant media structure of today and of then. And Our approach was, well, the media isn't going to get better. The media economy is not going to get better if you just change which billionaire owns which publication or platform. And it's not going to get better from just tweaking an algorithm or passing

SPEAKER_01the perfect regulation. The only way to address this is to create a different system with a different set of rules that... Delivers rewards with different types of behavior and content than the social media platforms do. And so that is why we started Substack and the idea was initially framed around the idea of make the audience the customer instead of the customer being the advertiser or a social media platforms algorithm. And so if we were going to join forces with Twitter, we would be essentially succumbing to the model that we're trying to create

SPEAKER_01a successor to.

SPEAKER_03But it was $150 million.

SPEAKER_01It was $150 million, yeah.

SPEAKER_03I would succumb to any model. You would? Yeah. I love succumbing to models, but that model would be one that I would succumb to. Their model, yeah. I could give a shit about the discourse if you put that check in front of me.

SPEAKER_01Right. Well, you know, we're foolish and idealistic. Yeah, yeah. And we've always seen Substack as a cultural mission, not a business mission. But the business piece is really important to support the cultural mission. And so... Having a business model from day one is based around direct subscriptions where the audiences could support the people they love the most. The Fifth Column could be propped up by its subscribers. And so nailing that from day one is actually fundamental to the whole Substack ecosystem. It means the core Substack product is not an app or the publishing tools.

SPEAKER_01It's the business model itself.

SPEAKER_03But you do something really interesting at the time because if you look at the top 50 political subsects right now, there's maybe two or three that I would identify as conservative. And even those are a bit wobbly, right? I mean, our old friend Andrew Sullivan, I don't know what he believes, depending on how many bong hits he did that morning. He has sort of ever-shifting kind of views of things, hates Trump, et cetera. You start this...

SPEAKER_03And timing-wise, it's like a refuge for a lot of people who cannot survive and are getting kicked out of sort of the mainstream media at the time, right? This is like 2018, 19, 20, around that.

SPEAKER_01You know, that was one period of time. It was one period of time.

SPEAKER_03And you mention Alex Berenson in the book, and there's a lot of people who find not only homes, but they find, like, very good salaries there. And then the media response to that... Which I'm sure you remember, is this is a haven for right wing cranks and Nazis and the rest of it. Because unlike Patreon, another platform most listeners and viewers will be familiar with.

SPEAKER_02We used to be on.

SPEAKER_03We used to be on. And that was a place that had some kind of language codes Things that if you said, you could get kicked off. You guys didn't do that. You went the opposite way. It was the unfettered, what was it in the New York Times? Unfettered speech. Unfettered speech, and that was a pejorative, right? That wasn't a positive thing. So these articles come out, and it basically says Substack is where all the right-wing cranks go, right? How do you change that narrative?

SPEAKER_03I mean, because that is not what I see when I look at the most popular Substacks. Not today. Not today. Not today.

SPEAKER_01We don't actively try to change the narrative. We just stay true to the principles of the platform.

SPEAKER_03But you must have tried to push back on that when you said, no, this is for everybody.

SPEAKER_01Well, you know, it didn't really matter if we pushed back on it. Occasionally, people would make this claim of, like, Substack is the haven of the right-wing crazies or something like that. Substack has a Nazi problem. Some people have said words along those lines. Yeah. And... Often we'd say, look at the number one revenue earner on the platform. It's Heather Cox Richardson. She's from the tribe that you affiliate with. She is a Joe Biden Democrat. And people would just sort of wave that off and look down at number two or three

SPEAKER_01or some other category. And another thing about Substack is a lot of people like us, we get fixated on who's at the top of the politics board or who are the media figures who we already know who are doing well on the platform. But Substack is like an index fund of culture. There are people writing about cooking and fashion and food. I guess that's the same. Those are the three categories. Cooking. Fashion, Finance, you know, everything's represented on Substack. And so the people in the media world, New York media in particular, get overwhelmed on the axle of like,

SPEAKER_01who are the media figures or who are the controversial political figures on the platform?

SPEAKER_00But can you talk about how you navigated that situation? Because I remember us having conversations around that time.

SPEAKER_01What was my emotional state like at that time?

SPEAKER_00How nervous were you, Hamish, that this might actually be an existential problem for you guys? Just the perception. And also your fault in particular.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, you know, I did say a lot of things that didn't make the situation better, I think. What was the worst one you said? Let's revisit it. There's nothing that I deeply regret in terms of the position that we're taking. But there was a statement I put out at the time after people were demanding we say something about why we aren't kicking off extremists. And I said something like, in my statement, I came across as a little bit flip. I think I said, we don't like Nazis either.

SPEAKER_03But you shouldn't have written it in German. It was a strange move at the time.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I look back at things like that and I just think, well, there probably were better ways to articulate it in the hot moments like that. But I don't regret the positions we took. And I've forgotten what you guys said before that. What was your mindset at the time? Did we worry that it was going to destroy the platform? I felt the emotional effect of it as much as the business anxiety. There is a chance that there's enough of those people that they can start a bit of a trend or a run on the bank and maybe you lose out with that particular tribe.

SPEAKER_01Overall I felt like there were more voices actually that were supporting the Substack approach to content moderation and they were less noisy but they were an incredibly important bulwark for the platform. So I was not super worried about the business implications but the emotional part of it sucks. A lot of these writers I personally helped and I want to see them thriving independent of their ideology. And when they turn against us and when they turn against me in particular,

SPEAKER_01that bit was hard to deal with.

SPEAKER_03People who had been on Substack, people that then turned on you and said, you have to get rid of these bad people.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's a lot of social pressure from writers on Substack. There was a campaign from a couple of hundred writers or a couple of hundred people signed this letter against us to pressure us to get rid of these voices that

SPEAKER_03And they were naming names. They said, this is our list of people.

SPEAKER_01There were versions of that. The first time we went through a controversy like that was objection to Substack harboring anti-trans voices. And their first definition of who counted as anti-trans was- Jesse Single. Including people, Jesse Single, Andrew Sullivan, Matt Taibbi, Freddie DeBoer, somehow just- Four for four. A grab bag of people whose politics they strongly disagreed with for whatever reason. Mm-hmm. And so that was the first go around with the pressure campaigns.

SPEAKER_03You know, we've all worked in these places at that time. The anti-trans places. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I started one. It folded very quickly. You know, these places that have a lot of young employees who have a very different view of free speech and what the media should be. Did you get the internal pressure? I mean, you're in a pretty progressive place. I mean, you guys are based in San Francisco. In the tech industry. And the tech industry. But was there some push internally?

SPEAKER_01Not really, actually. We were pretty lucky, and partly because Substack was born After some of those other companies that already had huge employee bases and before they knew to be careful on the questions of free speech and censorship when they're hiring for their companies. And so we were able to make sure that people who are joining Substack, for the most part, were very aligned with the Substack values and the kind of liberal project of Substack. And so when it came to it and when we kept on holding strong to the mast,

SPEAKER_01It didn't result in that much pressure from inside the company. Of course, there are people with different views, but none were ever able to overwhelm the core principles.

SPEAKER_00Can you talk about that a little bit? Because obviously we've had a relationship with Substack for a long time, but when I was in San Francisco, I'd be at the offices a bunch, and I met a lot of the people on your team. And I have told you before in private, and then we'll say again here, that you guys have one of the Most interesting and I think healthy corporate cultures I've ever been around. In general, there is actually a real meaningful ideological diversity amongst the people who work there. But in general, you could have us come in and do a podcast as we did live from the offices.

SPEAKER_00And we could do all of our stuff with no breaks. And it didn't create any sort of firestorm. Everyone there really does seem to be on the same page. And this was at a time... When that was not the case. Yeah. Across most of. During the cultural wars. Yeah. Like how, how did you guys manage to do that?

SPEAKER_01Well, we write about our values in public. And so early on, before the hugest pressure from cancel culture came on board, we put out a statement saying we believe in free speech. We believe in a hands-off approach to content moderation. We think the other social media companies that were doing this were doing it wrong. And that the problem is at the root level. It's at the system. It's what do your incentives encourage? And not... Can we build an ever more sophisticated content moderation apparatus? Can we improve on what Facebook and Twitter have done and sunk billions of dollars into?

SPEAKER_01So the public statements, the filtering at the interview level, like why are you coming to self-stack? What do you want to do? What do you want to work here for? What's your view on free speech? That was a genuine question.

SPEAKER_02Do you start doing the Jimmy Chase Richard Pryor thing?

SPEAKER_03I don't know what that is. Yeah, he's going to pretend he doesn't know what that is. It's a very naughty word in that.

SPEAKER_02Word associations. Word associations.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I'm not sure, but I don't remember doing a lot of word association play in the interview process.

SPEAKER_03But you have, and you say in the book, I mean, Cambridge Analytica, that's like front of mind because Facebook and a lot of these companies are trying to kind of, you know, backfill things and kind of run backwards after... I mean, the Cambridge analytical thing was bullshit in about a million ways. But that became a narrative. It became a dumb narrative that Facebook was swaying the election because of Russian politics.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think people were upset that Trump got elected. And fingers went in search of where to be pointed, and a lot of them ended up on Facebook. And Facebook, you've got to take more responsibility for what your algorithms are promoting. And I think Facebook really did feel the heat. And then, of course, they had tens of thousands of employees who shared those politics. So Mark Zuckerberg was in a really difficult position.

SPEAKER_02And his actions in that time hollowed out the new media infrastructure, which is, I think, a super fascinating and underappreciated story, right?

SPEAKER_00I suppose there's also a weird incentive where you don't want to be the one to say, well, look, we weren't really that influential, obviously. Yeah. So it's a little complicated.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think they were trapped by their business model, which hurt the business models of these hopeful new media startups in the 2010s, which I think you're just alluding to, and resulted in putting more pressure, like fear that they face pressure and scrutiny about what their algorithms promote, et cetera. But also, I think, is an artifact of this developmental time in the media system writ large, where For the last 10 years in particular, we've sort of had social media as the only successful business model with nothing

SPEAKER_01to counter it or nothing as an alternative because traditional media exists but it's small and downstream of the social media system. And Substack is the first viable kind of counter to it where there's a place to go to have quality discourse and quality media experiences that are based around a different model that make you less vulnerable to the incentive system of social media.

SPEAKER_03All right, we're going to take a quick break. And if you don't want to hear this break, go over to wethefifth.com and subscribe. But right now, here's a message from our sponsor. Apparently, the holidays are right around the corner. I mean, I like this. I'm very happy about this. The Vince Guaraldi, the drinking, the fighting with people in my family. But I got to buy some gifts. And the same old gift guides are boring. Uncommon Goods makes holiday shopping genuinely fun with thousands of one-of-a-kind gifts for everyone on your list and all in one place.

SPEAKER_03From moms and dads to kids and teens, from book lovers, history buffs, and diehard football fans to foodies, mixologists, and avid gardeners, you'll find thousands of new gift ideas that you won't find anywhere else. When you shop at Uncommon Goods, you're supporting all Artists and small and independent businesses. Many of their handcrafted products are made in small batches, making every gift feel meaningful and truly one -of -a -kind. And with every purchase you make at Uncommon Goods, they'll give back $1 to a non -profit partner of your choice. They've donated more than 3 .1 million dollars to date.

SPEAKER_03So don't wait cross those names off your list before the rush to get 15 % off your next gift go to uncommongoods .com slash fifth that's uncommon goods dot com slash fifth for fifteen percent off Uncommon Goods we're all out of the

SPEAKER_02ordinary Let's talk more about your failures. No,

SPEAKER_03he's got somewhere to be. That's true.

SPEAKER_02One of the media storms that came up, I think this was before the Substack has a Nazi problem headline, which... Please keep saying that. It's a good headline. It sort of sticks. We talked about it a lot on this podcast at the time and wrote about it a lot, about how ridiculous it was. And it's just transparently ridiculous, especially when you drill down into the particulars of it.

SPEAKER_03No, I think we were. I think you were. Are you sure? Yeah, we're self -destructing. Moynihan might not have been aware.

SPEAKER_00I was in the corner sweating. You don't remember they were paying us off the whole time. Yeah, that's right. That was a lot of blood money.

SPEAKER_02We'll get back to the blood money in a second. But before that, just before that, you interviewed Richard Hanania on your podcast. And a lot of people came at you and said, why are you Platforming a guy who has a history of being a racist troll. Was that a mistake to interview him in retrospect?

SPEAKER_01I don't know, probably.

SPEAKER_03Well he changed his mind. Maybe it was you.

SPEAKER_01Well, now he's already becoming much more interesting as a critic of the right at that time. But he had a reputation among people from the left as being something completely different from that. That interview was actually what's He set Jonathan Katz off. And Jonathan Katz went off to try and find how many extremists he could dig up from across the Substack ecosystem, scratched a few together, wrote a story that he got published in the Ideas section, the Opinion section of The Atlantic, which became the story of the headline that I can't remember that you were mentioning before.

SPEAKER_01And they created all this problem in the first place.

SPEAKER_03Hamish thinks of a Holocaust didn't happen, right? That was something like that. I think that was a lead.

SPEAKER_01Hanania was emerging. He's a good social media user. He is doing interesting stuff on Substack and saying things like, the mainstream media is good, actually, which is a strange position for a Trump-loving conservative to take at that time. He trolls in every direction.

SPEAKER_02He trolls in every direction.

SPEAKER_01And I had this podcast and I hadn't had anyone who... Openly supported Trump on the interview, on the podcast, and thought that was an omission because lots of the country really did support Trump. And then it came out afterwards. After I'd done the interview, someone went and did, another Jonathan Katz friend actually did an investigative piece for the Huffington Post and found that Hanania had a history of posting white supremacist stuff on forums 15 or 20 years prior.

SPEAKER_01Maybe it's 10 or 15 years prior. 15 or 20 months prior. Wasn't that long. At nine. Yeah, which create more heat and raise more questions about whether or not I should have done that interview in the first place.

SPEAKER_02But do you have those questions yourself now is the question.

SPEAKER_01Which questions?

SPEAKER_02Like raise more questions about whether you should have done the interview in the first place. Do you have that question yourself now? I'm just curious about you.

SPEAKER_01Let's put it like this. If I hadn't done that interview, I think a lot of the Animating force of what became that controversy wouldn't have happened.

SPEAKER_02Although one could counter-argue that there was a lot of cultural energy like amassed against the signatories of the Harper's letter, right? It had to go somewhere. And I'm looking at Camille because he's the guy who signs petitions in this group. No one petitioned signer. Including like to defend Substack. And an open letter is not quite a petition. But whatever. I don't sign group things whenever possible. But that energy was going to express regardless of whether you ever had Richard Anani on.

SPEAKER_03It's also I think the thing is it's a defense in a way of the kind of Substack worldview is that there are a number of people from that universe. Richard Anani is one of them. There's a guy named Pedro Gonzalez. You know this guy you write for Chronicles. And he's gone – Absolutely the opposite direction. I'm sure he would disavow things he wrote three years ago. You can go down the list of these people. And I think the number of those people who got to those places is because there were debates. There were conversations about things.

SPEAKER_03He saw this stuff happening in real time. And there's a number of examples. I spoke about one when we were at Fairfield. No, it was in Philly at the fire thing of people who are confronted by better ideas and change their mind. And I think that there's something to it. And I think at that time, There was something interesting about Richard Anani in particular because he was a torchbearer for Trump and he was like, wait a second. Hold on. And he has become much more interesting, stuck to it,

SPEAKER_03and I mean become pretty liberal on certain issues too. So I think it's worth engaging people like that. You put them – We see this, you know, we've spoken about this a million times, in the cordon sanitaire of the far right, or whatever you want to call them, in Europe, is that you don't get to be in our newspapers. You don't get to form coalition governments with us. And those people dig in deeper and deeper, and they have no interaction except they're in their own universes. And that's not been a good thing there, and it's usually not a good thing. I mean, where the fuck did people think they were going to go?

SPEAKER_03We're going to kick all the bad people off of X, Twitter. They're going to stop talking. They're gonna stop posting online. It's their life's blood. It's the only thing they care about. It's a thing that gives them meaning. They will find a different platform to do so, and there's not—I mean, there's endless limitless numbers of platforms that can accommodate them when Trump starts his own, Right. Which is, as far as I can tell, just him. The very best of them all. Yeah, the very best of them. The best. Hamish knows that, like, you can't kick people out of society in the internet age.

SPEAKER_03And that was the stupidest of many of the stupid things that were hitting people in the mainstream media in that time of, like, 2016 to, let's say, end of the pandemic.

SPEAKER_0122, 23, I think. Yeah. At the very least, I think you could say that it was ineffective. It did not achieve the ends that the people who were carrying out those strategies hoped to achieve. No, the opposite.

SPEAKER_03I mean, it's the thing that helped Trump, I think, more than anything in 2024. It's still some residual culture war stuff, particularly the trans stuff and the famous ad that we've all spoken about a million times, the VEVEM ad. And, you know, people thought that mugshot was gonna be the kill shot. And it was the kill shot of them. It was the great thing. People, I went to a Trump rally after that and was shooting there. And the number of people that had that on a shirt as a point of pride, I'm like, you guys don't get this movement at all.

SPEAKER_00I wonder, Hamish, if you could talk a little bit about, like, how to save the media broadly. Like, we can talk specifically about the problem. He wrote a book about it. I know, but I want to talk about the progress you're making with respect to this project. Do you feel like you're being successful? What exactly is the mechanism that Substack is using to rehabilitate the media, to reinvent the media?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I will say, if you read the book, I don't expect anyone to do so. I'm not really making the case that Substack is going to save the media. But I'm using Substack as an example. Of how to save the media. How to save the media? Subtle. Just to say you can't do it all on your own. Right. Well, how this different type of model for the media can actually work and thrive. And this model is counter to the social media and center system where you can have direct relationships where the publishers own their relationships

SPEAKER_01with their audiences and own all their content. And the audiences can have agency to support the voices that they value the most. And you can get network effects with that. That was what was missing from the traditional media ecosystem. And the first network effects business that got successful with media in the internet age was the Facebook model, the social media model. And so I'm not saying that we need to destroy social media or that traditional media was bad and a huge failure.

SPEAKER_01I'm saying that there's new infrastructure now and a new incentive system to fit the infrastructure that can make this direct relationships model thrive, which allows more voices in, which gives the audiences more agency and can lead to the birth of entirely new types of institutions.

SPEAKER_00So why doesn't that just result in a kind of siloing? And why isn't it just audience capture all the way down?

SPEAKER_01Because there's not that, there will be some, every incentive system has pros and cons, and there will be some charlatans who can succeed with this model. You don't have to look very far enough to find them. But there, but on, yeah, well, yeah, you know, any other direct relationships platform. But it's also a model that can reward integrity and reputation and where people's memories aren't as short as 20 seconds as they are on a Twitter timeline, for example.

SPEAKER_01And in aggregate, you're going to get more of the good than you do with the bad. And I think it's evident in the Substack ecosystem. If you hang out in the app, if you spend time looking for things to subscribe to, it's a totally different experience than what your experience on social media might look like.

SPEAKER_03I mean, audience capture is as old as time, right? It's just spread out now. I mean, more people can do it and become an influencer. They have access to audience capture. They have access to audience capture. You can have the audience catch a dream too. Yeah. Well, there's always these stories. I saw one yesterday from some kind of lefty website. It might have even been that Midas Touch website about these influencers being paid. Oh, yeah. Of like tracing these shortened links that go through this. And it's like, oh, yeah. There's nothing that surprises anyone about that.

SPEAKER_03It's kind of writ large now. But you've mentioned social media issues. And in fairness, Substack does a lot of that. It has its own internal kind of social media system. When you looked at that at the time and you look at it now and you say, this is the problem, right? This is where I see something that has to turn. What are those stories? What is the thing that you say, is it, it can't even be an instinct. There's too much kind of Nick Fuentes, you know, Post-Nazi stuff out there,

SPEAKER_03or it can be Russiagate, whatever it is. There's a lot of these that made people go to people in Substack because they said, I trust this less. What were those for you?

SPEAKER_01Because I trust this less. I trust the media less.

SPEAKER_03This ecosystem that we were all, that was our only option, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so, um... On social media, especially Twitter, TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, it's the performative outrage and the... Anger farming and the sensationalism, all of which can be part of a delightful experience. And you can get some good entertaining stuff on those platforms. But those platforms don't serve the trust and understanding piece that media is supposed to build. And their business models don't care about that.

SPEAKER_01But again, I don't necessarily think this is an act of evil by the social media companies. They shouldn't be the only force in media. And so people get tired of that stuff. They're tired of being anxious. They're tired of being angry. They're tired of the shallowness of it because all of this stuff is reactive on a timeline with quick little reactions to things. And they want to go deep on stuff. They want to be in a... Podcast episode for 90 minutes and read a long piece.

SPEAKER_02What about individual categories of stories like COVID, for example, like drove a lot of people like, I don't feel like I'm getting.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there was like, so both in the mainstream media and in the big platforms, Spotify, YouTube, Twitter, there were pending labels about what is good and what is bad, basically. And people, for good reasons, were skeptical about the official voices in that era. And Didn't feel like they were hearing the full story. And so if you're shutting voices out through censorship, you're only going to stoke that feeling of skepticism that you're missing out

SPEAKER_01on the full story, that the real truth tellers are being suppressed. And a better approach is, as America has figured out over the course of hundreds of years. I want to point something out here.

SPEAKER_03This is from yesterday. This is how it kind of ricochets back because there is obviously, you know, audience capture and desire to fan those flames within mainstream media too. This is yesterday in the New York Post. And if you're looking at this on your screen, which you should be doing, you'll see Stephen Hawking. On a bed with a drink in his hand. Well, I guess she's holding it.

SPEAKER_02She's helping. He's not really holding anything.

SPEAKER_03What? It's Steve Malkering, right? And this is the New York Post, and there's two bikini-clad ladies next to him, and this is the headline, Black Hole of a Man. Interesting. That's a pretty good headline. Can we say that's a good headline? The dark side of Stephen Hawking, strip clubs, Epstein Island, and wife who felt like, quote, a prisoner. What's the dark side? It sounds fucking great to me. But I looked at that photo and I was like, hang on, right? Blacked out faces in bikinis.

SPEAKER_03Drinks, very suggestive, right? And then you have Epstein Island in the headline. This is the kind of stuff that has been on social media and the Epstein files, quote unquote, story, which is his emails, has been one bit of bullshit on top of another in a lot of ways. And a lot of people don't want to talk about it, but it gets from social media into politicians, particularly Tom Massey and Marjorie Taylor Greene and stuff like that. That photo is available, right? In the Wayback Machine. The real photo. This is the real photo. Same photo. And let's look at this photo.

SPEAKER_03This is from 2008. Oh, wow. Right? Wheelchair accessible hotels. The U.S. leads the way. Wow, that's quite different. It's quite different. It's the same photo. Their faces are not obscured. Not blanked out. And you'll notice why. Because in that first paragraph, it is written by one of the women. The two women are Stephen Hawking's carers.

SPEAKER_01And she wrote a thing about- Their responsibility is to feed him Long Island ICS.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, that- You had to turn to page eight for that one. But that was at not Epstein Island. That was at a hotel, I think, the Ritz-Carlton in Florida. And she's writing this thing about how great it was that Stephen Hawking had wheelchair accessibility, which he doesn't have in so many European countries in 2008. That image is in the quote-unquote Epstein files. It has been recycled by people on social media endlessly because it's women in bikinis with their faces blacked out.

SPEAKER_03And that is the stuff That was driving the social media story about Epstein. And I did a couple of things, episodes, a couple of clips. And it was unbelievable, the response. The response was like, you pedophile, you this. And it just exists on social media. But I saw this last night and I was like, oh, yeah. Then it migrates into the ordinary media because they want the clicks too. It's not just a social media problem. It's laundered through there. So I thought that was... An amazing quote unquote story from the New York Times.

SPEAKER_01They missed a headline opportunity with G-string theory.

SPEAKER_03Oh, wow. That's what you were thinking the whole time. It took me a long time to come up there.

SPEAKER_00That was pretty good. Bill Blaise Joust. Optimize for a healthier kind of engagement. How does that work exactly? Because on social media, and you talk about this in the book, you've got the previous paradigm, advertiser-driven model that is dead. You've got the new model on social media where they're kind of optimizing for perhaps engagement, but oftentimes this is like outrage engagement. What are you guys doing differently?

SPEAKER_00Is it just a matter of having the long form content being produced on Substack alongside these tools that you guys have developed?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I do think it's important to have long form in the same place as the discovery system so that the discovery system leads people into the deepest stuff. But I think the crucial thing is what game are you asking people to play? And if you're a writer trying to build a following, are you asked to capture attention for a moment in a noisy attention marketplace on a feed or That is ultimately controlled by an all-seeing ruler. Or are you asked to win the trust and respect the attention of an audience

SPEAKER_01over time, over a relationship? So in that way, the subscriptions are the best kind of proxy for a trust relationship. When that guides the whole system, then you're just going to get different cultural outcomes. And so while we have algorithms that sort content, et cetera, in the Substack app, Those algorithms are asking, we're asking those algorithms to drive people into those deeper relationships, into the trust relationships, because that's how we make money. We only make money by taking a 10% cut of the Fifth Column's revenue. So we want the Fifth Column.

SPEAKER_01We have questions about that 10%.

SPEAKER_02Is this the proper venue for it? This is absolutely the venue.

SPEAKER_03You understand that there are no film in these cameras, and this is an intervention,

SPEAKER_02and we want a lower rate. Sorry.

SPEAKER_03This is the Truman Show?

SPEAKER_02There's a whole section here. There's a whole like section here. Is there alcohol in this Manhattan?

SPEAKER_01About how far you - Oh no, there's a lot.

SPEAKER_02Bent over backwards for the fucking free press. Oh, right. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03That's the chapter that you mention us in. Right. And it starts with Barry- You have one chapter.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. One chapter. You mentioned me last, which is very painful. I asked him about that and he said, it's because you're black. I keep telling him this wrong.

SPEAKER_02So let's do a reading here. This From How to Save the Media by Hamish McKenzie. It's the best part. On Substack, The Fifth Column, started by journalists Matt Welch, Michael Moynihan, and Camille Foster, last, transcends partisan politics and convenes a fervent community that gathers That's one way of putting it. Online and in bars that Hamish wants to drink in. He's an alcoholic. That's where my mind is.

SPEAKER_02To chinwag with a host. That's pretty good for chinwag. Chinwag? Chinwag with a host. Chinwag?

SPEAKER_01Do Americans say that? Yeah. We do now.

SPEAKER_02I just, which is a fine sentence. Yeah, fine sentence. The next sentence. What? Oh, no. And political commentary outlet, The Bulwark. No. Why are we in the same breath? dot, dot, dot, dot. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You're welcome.

SPEAKER_02Dude, we have to put the bullwark right next to The Fifth Column? That's fine.

SPEAKER_03I think Claude did that. No, I think Claude did that. It's called the book. What is the Claude thing? By the way, Claude, I always instruct, do not write for me. Never do that. But I will take Claude for, like, this is a guy at the Wall Street Journal I met over at Gnomes. He was like, oh, do it for all your errant commas and bad punctuation. I have to give it his instructions. And then if it ever writes for you, it just constantly calls things load-bearing.

SPEAKER_03Have you noticed this? Yeah, load-bearing. It's constant load-bearing. Yeah. Load -bearing. It's constant load bearing! And so I've seen it in print and I'm like load bear. It's a quiet confidence. Oh is that quiet for confidence?

SPEAKER_01Just quiet And quietly, there's something about these phrases.

SPEAKER_00I think doing work is another phrase that I encounter a bunch.

SPEAKER_01Doing real work. Doing real work.

SPEAKER_03So you used it for editing, but not for writing.

SPEAKER_02Do you want to talk about that?

SPEAKER_01I used it for a bunch of research, actually. The Google AI overview search tool is incredible because it actually links you to the original sources. That's true. And so you can speed through the research in a much greater clip than it would. Last time I wrote a book, I had to read a bunch of books and compile the notes and put them in Google Docs and then learn stuff, yeah, things. This I can just, yeah, in one ear, out the other ear, but it's done for three months. Good.

SPEAKER_03No, you did reference something, I was saying this to Matt, you referenced something and I was like, didn't that just happen? The, uh, the, um, thing at the- The Chelsea Hirsch Chelsea. Yeah, the Seymour Hirsch party. Yeah, that was like a couple of weeks ago.

SPEAKER_01That's February, Yeah. I was grateful for that party because I was like, oh, here's my first chapter. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And you're very generous to Cy Hirsch, who you say is a journalistic hero of yours, and he had some very heroic moments in his past. But you don't point out. I'm not going to bring up something he didn t write about. He wrote about it. The Ukraine pipeline story was wrong. Every part of it was wrong. And that's why Cy Hirsch has a very difficult time publishing in The New Yorker these days. They kind of get an LRB a little bit there. And then they were like, oh, he's just a crazy old coot at this point.

SPEAKER_03You should have pointed out that that story was wrong.

SPEAKER_01I think I did qualify that sentence. Qualified? Qualified? I think, well, I can't remember exactly what I said. Go to the sentence and it'll be like, but there's some contesting theories in all this. Contesting them. So you're betting on the other theory.

SPEAKER_03It wasn't contested. It was wrong. There's people on trial for it now in Germany.

SPEAKER_01Sure.

SPEAKER_03Deep state that. Oh, my God. This is a concession. We're going to be at 11% by the end of this podcast.

SPEAKER_00But you bring up an interesting point. And I'm curious if this is something you guys talk about internally. You're looking for healthy engagement. You want people to have these relationships with the publication. Yeah. If you're able to actually create that, does that also produce better quality, more accurate content? Sometimes.

SPEAKER_01Not all the time. It's a system that can reward quality better than social media can reward it and better than traditional media in some cases because traditional media is struggling to survive on a business model level. But an important thing is, You don't have to completely believe Seymour Hersh. You might go over to the Moynihan Report, find out what he has to say about that. And you can traverse the network in a way that exposes you to people's ideas where they make their case at length and with nuance and with detail.

SPEAKER_01And they have to keep making their case in quality ways to be rewarded enough by the audience to keep on doing the work and make money to survive. So how do we survive? I don't understand how we're making any money. It is kind of a curious question. You're looking around.

SPEAKER_03Do you have a group of people who just look at this all the time like, we don't understand it. We just don't get why they survive.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's a high concentration around this table.

SPEAKER_03Of bullshit. So what happens next? How to save the media?

SPEAKER_02There's the weird lengthy chapter about some cult incident. Very funny, entertaining. I had no idea what the fuck was going on. It spoke to that maybe you guys are thinking about how to apply this into more explicitly audiovisual aspects. You also, I mean, you did start Substack Notes, which is pretty social media-y for a anti-social media company. Anti the incentive system of social media.

SPEAKER_02It's a lot of hyphens. A lot of fucking hyphens. Yeah. And you're like tiptoeing into advertisements too, right?

SPEAKER_01With sponsorships, yes. Sponsorships. Yeah. So, I mean, a lot of this is in the detail. And when people apply the blunt filter of it looks like social media is so much salable, the problems of social media, then it happens. It can cause them to fail to appreciate the beauty of Substack. But there's a difference. Let me go back to saying the core thing is the direct relationships model. And it applies whether it's With advertising or subscriptions, if you own your relationship with your audience and the audience has agency

SPEAKER_01and being able to vote for the culture that they want to thrive. And the producers have the agency because they actually do own those contacts and can leave in a second. Exactly. It forces us as a platform to be in service of you. So we want you to have... Ways to make money in the ways that you see fit. And we'll try and take the grunt work out of it and share in the upside, share in the growth with you.

SPEAKER_02I want you to just like think about those words in terms of us at all times.

SPEAKER_01Well, we do. I'm pleased to report. What was the other thing I was going to say? Can you remember? Yeah. Networking, the social network piece.

SPEAKER_02Just the what comes next. Oh, the TV piece.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so the direct relationships model, I think, is one of the great modern media models. Whether Substack is part of it or not, it just happens that we are. And I don't think it's fully realized or given birth to yet, even. There's the platform relationship model where you subscribe to Spotify and Netflix, they decide who wins and loses. There's the algorithmic relationships model, like a YouTube or a TikTok, where the algorithm determines your life or death. And then there's this direct relationships model that Substack's shown can work, at least for blogging and podcasts.

SPEAKER_01But I think the direct relationships model can actually work for television and film as well. And in this chapter, I talk about BritBox, which is subscribe to this smorgasbord of British dramas for $10 a month, and then you can get stuff that you wouldn't find on ordinary television in your local market. I think that a lot more brickboxes can exist in the world. And there's the audiences that are willing to support them with $10 a month. And there is some ecosystem maturity that has to happen before that sort

SPEAKER_01of thing is fully realized. But I don't see anything in the laws of physics necessarily. That would prevent that kind of model working for the right content rights holders.

SPEAKER_03The one problem, and it's the problem we come up against, is those people who email and say, you know, we do a, somebody who does a month on, month off kind of thing. We're going to do something that I like next month that's similar to you and then cancel it and then go back. Because there's a point, you know, this is what happened with obviously cord cutting, BritBox, which I do subscribe to. You do? Oh, yeah. Gartner's World is not free, my friend. Oh, respect. BritBox, the Criterion Collection, things like that that are sort of more niche.

SPEAKER_03But there's a point in which you look at your bill at the end of the month.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03This is the biggest problem you have to face, right? I mean, people are not going to buy $150 worth of Substacks. I know some people do. I know people that do. But that's a small number of people. I mean, the Netflix-type models, it's like, Trust us, but it's one place for $10. That seems better. Isn't that the kind of big problem that you have of like getting people? Because then all of a sudden you have a magazine, right? You have a newspaper. You have a TV network because it's going to be one charge for a lot of content.

SPEAKER_01Well, I don't think the Netflix thing is going to go away. I think Netflix is going to be there. YouTube is going to be there. And then something direct relationships is going to be there as well.

SPEAKER_00But are you guys averse to trying that?

SPEAKER_01Well, bundling, no, we're not averse to training. In fact, we're starting to do little explorations on there so you can subscribe to an anchor publication and then it starts a bunch of satellite publications and instead of paying for each one individually, you can get them all for a bundled deal.

SPEAKER_02That sounds interesting.

SPEAKER_01We have just started to experiment with these tools or ship these tools. And in the future, all sorts of other bundling things make themselves possible in a way that can Be a win-win-win for the platform, for the publisher, and for the audiences. And the position that Substack's in is a kind of powerful position for helping realize that, make that happen. But I don't want to overpromise too soon because we've only talked about that stuff. We haven't started building for that. But the first thing where the media owners can create their own bundles

SPEAKER_01That is actually real and starting to exist in Substack.

SPEAKER_03Do you have any of those? I'm trying to think. People who, I mean, I know so many big names. This is the most impressive thing about Substack.

SPEAKER_01I was going to say this is impressive about you. You know so many big people.

SPEAKER_03I know a lot of big names. I've heard of them. And some of them blurb your book. Kareem.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_03I mean, people like that. Yeah. Tina Brown, who's one of my favorite writers.

SPEAKER_02This is an absolute, like, you have the easiest blurring. Yeah, I do. I don't know, I just own the platform and like who?

SPEAKER_03Didn't even ask for it. Kareem was like, who's Zuma?

SPEAKER_01Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, yeah, he is. But you have- Jumped eagerly into the opportunity.

SPEAKER_03You have all these big people, I mean, these individuals. And I was saying to you earlier, Tina Brown, the best thing about Substack is that you could, once in a while, Tina would write somewhere, right? And then previous iterations of her life, she was just an editor, right? I worked for her when she was doing Daily Beast and Newsweek and then Vanity Fair and The New Yorker. But now she writes consistently every week, and the stuff is absolutely dynamite. If you haven't subscribed, you should pay for it, but even the freebie is absolutely phenomenal. Fresh Hell, it's called, which is a perfectly Tina name.

SPEAKER_03But do you have, like, are bigger places that were established long before Substack coming to Substack now? I'm trying to think of their examples.

SPEAKER_01Well, The Economist, FT Alphaville, New Yorker's got a presence, Paris View's got a presence. These places exist. Most of them are characterized as in the dabbling phase. They're trying to figure out how this could work for them. But, you know, Der Spiegel in Germany is doing it as well. There are plenty of people. But what is the purpose there?

SPEAKER_03Der Stürmer in Germany? But that was 2019. What is the purpose there? Is that more kind of audience interaction? Is that the idea? Right.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think they can build a new type of audience and reach people that they're otherwise not reaching because these are some of the most thoughtful and smart readers on the internet hanging out on a Substack app.

SPEAKER_02And it can also be a publication that lets one of your stars out there kind of shine a little bit brighter. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so. Well, the Daily Beast is actually doing really interesting things like that. Michael Wolff and Tom Sykes and Kevin Fallon each have their own independent paid subscription newsletters on Substack, but the Daily Beast supports it with infrastructure and legal support and editing, et cetera. And that's a really cool model. But yeah, the general point is it's new land to build on. Some people are experimenting with, like, you know, can I build a little shack over here or can I build a tower over here? And I think those existing media companies can participate in that new building rush.

SPEAKER_01And some of them are going to be people who are more native to the platform and are growing with the platform.

SPEAKER_00What are you guys doing and how are you thinking about AI? And Slop in particular, letting people create content with AI, people creating bots that just go on, create their own substack. Are you guys concerned about that? Are you excited?

SPEAKER_01I know you're A little bit concerned. There's a risk that the feed gets overtaken with slop like LinkedIn has. We have an integration with something called Pangram, which detects whether or not a piece has been AI-assisted. And the most important part of that integration is that we created the opportunity for the writer to disclose how they're using AI. So it's not to say AI good or AI bad, but we're increasing the transparency because this is about trust relationships so that the subscribers have the full information before they make their decision.

SPEAKER_01So someone might be a finance writer on Substack, this happens. Where they are using AI to generate all of the text. But the people are not showing up for the quality of the writing. They're showing up for the insights that the writer is standing behind. And then there's a community that gathers around those insights as well that has its own kind of value. And so if the writer is saying, I'm using AI, but it's just to produce the written stuff at the end because I'm not a great writer, but the insights are what you're here for and that's what I stand behind, we think that's a completely legitimate use of Substack and people are going

SPEAKER_01to get great experiences on the platform because of that. But we think that transparency piece so that the subscriber is armed with the information they need to make their decision is the most important thing.

SPEAKER_03Am I wrong in... Remembering that there's an AI detector button before you publish something?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so you can check whether your own thing was written by AI. Yeah, I'm kind of confused by that.

SPEAKER_03Like, but that's what that's for? I don't know exactly what the thinking was going on there.

SPEAKER_01Well, because, I mean, I just published a piece today. Again, do you work at Substack? Occasionally, yeah.

SPEAKER_03But there's that AI thing, but do you label it if it's AI?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think some people do use AI in the research process and editing process and probably want to make sure that they're coming across as fully human and check themselves and so they can go in and root out the weeds once they, just before publication. It's depressing, but...

SPEAKER_03No, because we had this conversation with Ben Smith on the show because we had him on and that was the day that there was the finance guy who wrote the piece for Wall Street Journal. And he was like, no, of course. I'm a finance guy. I don't know how to write. I gave it my thoughts and it crafted them. And Ben Smith, very surprisingly, was like, yeah, it's fine.

SPEAKER_01No problem.

SPEAKER_03He thought it was totally fine. Do you miss being a journalist?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Writing the book was a good exercise in remembering what it was like to be a journalist. So you don't want to go back? I want to do more writing. I don't know exactly what form that's going to take in my life.

SPEAKER_03You know you can get a Substack.

SPEAKER_01I've got a Substack, yeah. I don't pay much attention to it. That's not real Substack. It's not really.

SPEAKER_03You're not writing for your

SPEAKER_01Substack? I've written a couple of things. And in fact, I started a Substack for this book, which is called How to Save the Media, published by Authors' Equity, out today. Authors' Equity?

SPEAKER_03That sounds very communist.

SPEAKER_01It is. It's give the writers ownership. And it's very ethos-aligned with Substack. That's why I went with them. So the lion's share of the revenue goes to the writers. It's a 70-30 split, which is unheard of in book publishing.

SPEAKER_03But no advance.

SPEAKER_01No advance, yeah. That's one of the tweaks. And then you own the license from the outset. You'd never give up the license to the publisher as the writer. And then you get all the traditional support you'd get from a publisher.

SPEAKER_02Really? What support are you getting from the publisher asking for a friend?

SPEAKER_01They printed that thing. Madeline McIntosh is a great editor, former CEO of US Penguin Random House, edited it. There's a publicity team behind it. Really?

SPEAKER_02So it's not just like, it's not just paid?

SPEAKER_01It's not premium self-publishing. It's an actual publisher with a different model.

SPEAKER_03Interesting. Mm. Yeah, don't go back to journalism. Yeah, why not? It's a mugs game. Who wants to do journalism these days? This is what we do. We talk to journalism students, which we did last week, and I didn't get to the point. Did you tell them it's a mugs game? I usually do. I'm just like, what advice do you give to people wanting to go into journalism? And I usually just say don't. What is the point? I don't say don't. I always say do it.

SPEAKER_02Really? No, it's great. It's a wonderful vocation. It's a great way to spend your life. Just don't count on it to necessarily make you rich, unless you're Hamish McKenzie. Yeah. So that was $150 million, just to be clear. That was the 2020, 2021 offer. 2021-ish, yeah. Yeah. So Musk came in and offered- Even though you were already, what was the word again? The Oathbreaker? I was already the Oathbreaker. You were already an Oathbreaker. He gets Chris Best to come into the office, right?

SPEAKER_02And imagine being the CEO of Twitter. It was a real live thing in 2023. Was there a price tag on that one? No, it didn't reach that point. But if you had to imagine what that was. Probably $7 billion, something in $7 billion. You guys evaluated more than $1 billion?

SPEAKER_01We're $1.1 billion. Not that you're counting. No. The .1 is obviously not important. It's only $100 million. That's my fee, actually. If Proposition 40 would have passed, let's say, I'd be in Nevada. Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_03Fair enough. All right, so you didn't... But I just want to say one final thing. It is actually, and this sounds like we're trying to get that rate down a few percentage points. Definitely not.

SPEAKER_01Talk to my people. You don't have people. I know, that's why

SPEAKER_03I say that. The woman you came with didn't even know your name. She said Steve. I was like, I think it's Hamish. But no, it is true that you used to say, you're not going to get rich off this. That is no longer true because of Substack. I'm trying to think of prior to that, you could be one of those breakout stars. And that was big advances on books, right? If you were a Fareed Zakaria, you got a TV show.

SPEAKER_02And maybe a Conde Nast sinecure. Yeah, and those sinecures were disappearing.

SPEAKER_03When Tina bought a very unwise decision that Tina made to buy Newsweek, We had, like, two people from the old days that had the sinecures. And one, and he's since passed away, great writer Chris Dickey, who was based in Paris. And I remember Tina complaining, but he had, like, an apartment and, you know... Paid for by Newsweek? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Oh, wow.

SPEAKER_03Huge expense account, could take anybody out to dinner. Like, that was the way it was at a certain point. But that died a long time before Substack. And the only way of doing it was being the one kind of famous person In the business, right? There are a few people. And talk about a bad incentive structure is how do you get famous? You know, you're an Ann Coulter. You're a Rush Limbaugh. Mostly you're on TV.

SPEAKER_02Mostly you're on TV or on radio.

SPEAKER_03And now there are people that make very, very good livings Having a low number of subscribers, and that's the important thing that people don't realize. You have 500, 1,000 subscribers, 2,000 subscribers, and you are doing extremely well in journalism, and particularly you can narrow cast. You can be somebody, I write only about film, and then all of a sudden, I mean, that's the great encouragement.

SPEAKER_01There's a guy who makes a living writing only about old Bob Dylan concerts on Substack.

SPEAKER_03I think I follow him. Yeah. There's a what uh what's his name do you remember no

SPEAKER_02it's in the book How many Substack millionaires are there now?

SPEAKER_01More than 50 because that was the last public number we shared. That's why I asked you, I can't. Yeah, but it is kind of amazing.

SPEAKER_03Why won't you share that?

SPEAKER_01It's encouraging. Well, I think we just have to, Piper, my comms person over here, we probably have to go back and update the number and then everyone gives an opinion about whether or not it's safe to share that and then we share it. Yeah, it's also like, and it's not just about millionaires.

SPEAKER_02I remember seeing Guided by Voices play about 15 years ago in LA at a festival and the dude, Bob, what's his name?

SPEAKER_03Bob.

SPEAKER_02I forget his name. But he said this great thing like, I want to thank the 10,000 of you Who buy every one of our records no matter what happens. You have allowed me to make a good living. Bob Pollard, by the way. Great minor league pitcher or at least a college pitcher or something. Multi-talented. Probably more talented at baseball than at music. There's a wisdom in that. Like if you have 10,000 incredibly core fans, that's pretty close to a number of paid subscribers if I'm thinking

SPEAKER_02about that out loud, then that's an incredibly good thing to have as someone who's creating content.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, Kevin Kelly laid that out with a thousand true fans theory in 2008. And now it's come to life in the Substack world or Patreon before that too. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Kevin Kelly sees far.

SPEAKER_03Do you want to comment on Jensen Hong?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'd love to. What controversy will take do you want?

SPEAKER_03Should he be reinstated? Yeah, you saw he tweeted today. I did see that, yeah. And his tweet was like, you know, if you want me back, it was like literally every conversation I've ever had with a girlfriend who broke up with me was like, if you want me back, I'm still here. Wait, they said that to you or you said that to them? No, I said that to them. Yeah, and they were like, fuck you, which is not necessarily what the NVIDIA board would say. And he obviously sees himself in this moment where people are, you know, getting a bit paranoid about a lot of the stuff that's happening and saying, yeah, maybe I can take advantage of it.

SPEAKER_03MAGA types are saying, maybe she's not a spy. It's not a big deal. You're a tech guy. You're in San Francisco. You've written about tech. What do you make of Jensen?

SPEAKER_01I mostly experience it. Jensen's Johnson. I experience it as a fascinating story. I don't know enough. I think people don't say this enough. I don't know enough of what's going on inside the deep state, inside NVIDIA, inside his private life. I can't make an educated comment. What do you know about it?

SPEAKER_03So then I can ask you about it. What do I know about what? What do you know about? Just in general.

SPEAKER_01Oh, no, I don't know very much at all. I only know how to save the media. That's it.

SPEAKER_03I've got 150 pages on that, and then I'm done. All right. Well, if you're saying like maybe you knew a lot about handball or cross or something.

SPEAKER_01New Zealand culture I can tell you about. But the way to ask the question is to say. Best band from New Zealand.

SPEAKER_02Best band from New Zealand.

SPEAKER_01Best band from New Zealand. Well, I think Aldous Harding is currently the best artist from New Zealand. Current. Not a band. Yeah, she's current.

SPEAKER_03Okay. What about in the past 50 years? There's no bands in New Zealand, are there?

SPEAKER_01Okay, you want a band. I like the Phoenix Foundation, which is not big enough to rise onto the radar of most Americans. But look up the Phoenix Foundation from Wellington, New Zealand.

SPEAKER_03That's wrong. There were two answers. It was either the bats or the clean.

SPEAKER_01The bats or the clean are great fucking answers. Thank you.

SPEAKER_03Flying on records, the best thing that ever came out of New Zealand other than Hamish McKenzie and his plan to save the media. Right?

SPEAKER_01Accurate.

SPEAKER_03You got a party to go to.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. We didn't get you too drunk. You didn't. You got me perfectly drunk. Yeah. Thank you. Thanks, guys. Yeah, really appreciate it. Yeah, man. Thank you.

SPEAKER_03Bye. Bye. We know our new method of attack. [music]

SPEAKER_03up as never before against those who would cast a smoke stream across our vision. [music] you next time. [music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Harry Enten Experience (w/ Harry Enten) MO #355

    Nov 20, 202613 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.wethefifth.com The most energetic man at CNN has the habits of an 87-year-old Jewish grandfather -Harry’s enormous wallet of $2 bills -Neil Sedaka’s nepo...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Fifth Column Live at Fairfield University (w/ Yemisi Egbewole) MO #354

    Nov 16, 202615 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.wethefifth.com A YUGE thanks and our sincere gratitude to Fairfield University for hosting us, and to the students and faculty who joined us for the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. She Showed a Painting of Muhammad. Then She Lost Her Job (Audio Excerpt from The Fifth Live in Philly)

    Nov 16, 202622 minAudio

    This is an audio excerpt from The Fifth Column live in Philly. You can watch video of the full event at wethefifth.comArt historian Erika López Prater joins The Fifth Column live at FIRE's Soapbox conference to explain...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Socialists Go to Washington, Trump Goes to Hell (w/ Michael Powell) #583

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 47 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.wethefifth.com/subscribe You have one last chance to go to Connecticut and see the guys, LIVE, on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Jared of Arabia (w/ Matthew Cole) - Members Only #353

    Nov 6, 202632 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.wethefifth.com The guys are joined by investigative journalist Matthew Cole, author of Princes and Thieves: Jared Kushner and Mohamed bin Zayed's Secret...

    Credit the people on this episode